Building Legacy
How Do We Fix the Individual Leaders Within Our Formations?
This post if from 2LT Robert Williams, a U.S. Army officer. The views expressed here are the author’s alone and do not reflect those of the U.S. Army or the Department of Defense
Consider this, you are currently enrolled in college as a big bright eyed freshman, and you see young men and women running around campus dressed in military fatigues. At first, you are unsure what to make of it; however, your curiosity gets the best of you when a well spoken campus recruiter gets you to attend physical training a couple mornings a week and you get to go do fun things at Leadership Labs once a week. Bam, you are hooked. You get offered a scholarship, and swear into a life (well at least 4 years) of service for this Nation’s great military. Then what?
Many Commissioning programs around the country produce quality leaders within our current ranks; however, I believe most programs fail to embed a certain quality within future leaders of our organization. Legacy (I believe it is called “Stewarding the Profession” in ROTC). I remember my days as an ROTC Cadet where I was completely concerned with my individual performance as a third year student. I was preparing for my summer evaluation (I understand Cadet Summer Training has since changed) with an active duty career in mind. Then one day I had a Major and Sergeant First Class bring me and my battle buddy into the office to talk about the future of the program. Before I dive into the importance of legacy I want to discuss how upbringings can impact the way we view legacy. Myself and the other individual I mention above had both participated in college athletics (I was a graduate student having already completed my career while he was an older undergrad participating in wrestling at our school) which had given us the right background to understand the necessity to better the organization. I came from a below average college baseball program where we had never been expected to win much. However, one day my freshman year our class gathered together for a night of team bonding activities, and we began to discuss what we wanted to accomplish during our 4 years here. It was a mature step for 18 year old kids to take; however, we were forced into the void created by a lack of senior leadership and experience. What was the most shocking from that night was the common goal we all had; leave the program in better shape than how we found it.
Legacy is defined by Merriam-Webster Dictionary as “a gift by will especially of money or other personal property.” Not exactly what I think of when I hear legacy; however, if you look at the term program and the impact of athletics on taking ownership of an organization then the definition of legacy fits quite perfectly. My college baseball program was something I was going to be proud of; something I would tell my kids about on how it made me into the man I am today. During my tenure, I owned that program. It belonged to me and my teammates. I was fortunate; we won our first conference championship in over 60 years. However, the championship was not the thing that made me the most proud. I was most proud of the fact that I left the program in a better place. We had won more games in 4 years than any other group of alumni, re-wrote the record book in almost every category, and had rebuilt the image of the program. I had found something in a lesser state, put hard work into it, and then handed it over to the next generation. It does not matter what they did with it, but rather the fact that my group took the pride to better the organization. We rallied around a common cause that was bigger than any individual. After a collective effort we left it in a better state than how we found it. Now we must return to ROTC programs around the country on how to focus on building leaders to be successful in our organization. We must build leaders to take pride in the organization, and focus on bettering it in any way possible.
The military trains their Officers to be the best you possibly can be; however, the massive failure in this method comes from not teaching the individuals how to direct their best efforts. The military is a massive machine that always runs. Certain days it may run smoother than others; however, if you remove a piece of the machine it continues to survive and produce every single day. Military leaders must not focus on just becoming the best individually but more importantly on how to better the organization. This is how you truly display your ability as a leader within the military. We return to the conversation between two cadre members, my best friend, and me. SFC G and MAJ A were two of the most influential mentors I have had the privilege of learning from, and during that meeting I will remember when it clicked for me as a Cadet. They sat down, and began to discuss the direction of our third year class. At first, the two of us were rather surprised about our involvement in the conversation but then the SFC hit us with a line of responsibility. He told us the military is not about being the best individually; it is about being the best team on the planet. As a Platoon Leader, you are not evaluated how well you do, but rather how well your element does. This is good training for you two. At that point, we instantly knew what had to be done. We had to find a way to improve our class as a whole rather than just our own individual skills.
This translated into our senior year where we had monumental turnover in cadre including our second Professor of Military Science in as many years. We took ownership of the program, and began to develop a program that would set up future Cadets for success. It took a tremendous amount of work, and we encountered many obstacles, but the payoff was tremendous. We ran major training events as a Cadet Battalion flawlessly. Our Cadets balanced heavy school loads, college sports, and social lives to dedicate time towards the betterment of our battalion. We were fortunate for the ability to band together for the betterment of the program. We received push back from different Cadets, some of whom did not even commission, about banding together to bettering our program. That did not matter to those of us committed for the betterment of our program. It was our duty to produce the most capable and ready leaders for the Army. So the biggest question is how do we promote legacy; better yet, how do we teach college students how to care more for the collective good rather than individual goals?
Our problem stems from ROTC having to be inherently competitive to determine who gets active duty, and who gets involuntarily selected for reserve duty. Cadet Command determined the easiest way for this to be done is to create a formula that produces an Order of Merit List (OML) ranking Cadets from first to last. This system is a typical staple within the Army. We use these lists to determine who is better, and typically reward them for such action. However, I raise the question is individual competition the best way to promote the development of Commissioned Officers within our ranks? So we reward the Officers who perform at the highest individual level possible, but possibly fail as a member of a team. Teamwork drives our organization, and I believe we are failing the next generation of leaders within our formations by molding them early during their careers on how to be the most successful individual. We never transform them until they reach their units, and NCOs began the long and tedious development of Lieutenants. This process does not have to be as difficult as it needs to be. Now no problem is worth bringing up unless there is some sort of thought towards how to correct the deficiency.
Get Robert Williams’s stories in your inbox
Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.
Teach Legacy, Value the Collective
We need to stop teaching and promoting individual excellence above all else. I am not saying that individually we should not strive to be the best, but rather individually we should strive to be the best member or leader of a team we possibly can be. Cadre at the respective programs must teach Cadets how to take pride in the organization, thus fostering commitment to bettering the organization. We must teach future leaders within our formations to understand the single most important element within the Army is teamwork. If we can build that pride of leaving behind a legacy in our junior leaders we can begin to reshape the force, and develop pride within the Army formations. I have had multiple conversations within my Battalion with other LTs, and you can see the difference in upbringings from the different programs. Some of them understand that this is a team effort, and when the team succeeds the individual succeeds as well. Others do everything possible to keep great products to themselves in an attempt to score some extra points with their Senior Rater. I think this attitude stems from the upbringing in the individual’s commissioning source. We can fix this.
The biggest problem lying ahead is how to fix this problem. Cadet Command is attempting to fix this problem by revamping the way Cadets are evaluated placing a greater emphasis on the on-campus portion, and limiting the evaluation portion during Cadet Summer Training. Cadet Command is on the right track to addressing some of the LDAC evaluation bias (spotlight rangers for 28 days); however, there needs to be a collective assessment involved somewhere in this portion. The program needs to get evaluated at the Cadet level. Cadets must be encouraged to take ownership of the program, and learn how to fail in a controlled training environment. Your time during the senior year as a member of a Cadet Battalion Staff can provide some crucial development in a young Officer’s career. Staff work is something that is thankless within our organization; however, it is also one of the most crucial parts of military operations. Teaching young Cadets how to take pride in products they produce will make your time in S3 much more productive and rewarding. Staff is the ultimate team game, and if Cadets fail to learn how to put the organization first, their time on staff will be wasted and often upsetting. If we do not fix this issue we can expect Cadets to continue to value their individual placement over learning how to work together to accomplish a greater task.
Place an Emphasis on Mentoring and Networking
The Army is very similar to a large corporation in the private sector to an extent. In fact, I was taking a graduate psychology class on Motivation from an Industry perspective, and my professor was fascinated with my involvement with the military. He always spoke how the private sector can learn from how the Armed Forces breed legacy, and culture within the organizations. Basic training is meant to break all your bad habits, and rebuild you with the skill set you need to succeed as a Soldier. Some Cadets do experience Basic Training; some do not; however, the single most impactful person in a Soldier’s young career is his/her Drill Sergeant. Cadets need the same type of figure in their early careers. Mentors can make or break a young Officer. We need the help and guidance of individuals who have been down the road before us. More importantly, we need a mentor who wants to be there; who wants to better the organization. I know Senior Captains often volunteer for ROTC assignments in order to create a little stability in their lives, especially following the last 14 years of deployment tempo; but, Cadet Command must ensure these individuals are selected using strict criteria similar to Drill Sergeants throughout the Army. Cadet instructors can have a tremendous impact on young Officers. We must avoid sending individuals into these positions who do not want to mentor and develop young Cadets. Captains who have served as Commanders must use that experience to develop future Platoon Leaders, Company Executive Officers, and Company Commanders.
We must teach Cadets the importance of networking early in your career by having them interact with other Cadet Battalions within your Brigade as well as fostering joint projects and inspiring creative training for younger Cadets. Individual driven OMLs lead to individual driven training. The Army does not run on independent individual performances. The Army runs on team performances driven by individual participants working towards a collective task. Let us not stray from this early in the development of future leaders of our organization. Instead, we should create an environment encouraging Cadets to interact with individuals and other professionals within the organization. Programs should have extensive alumni networks, and encourage Cadets to reach out to current Officers. The Army’s culture of brotherhood must be handed down from generation to generation; with each outgoing member teaching a new member how to do the job better. This is a selfless organization, and being an Officer is a selfless job.
If ROTC programs around the country build this network of professionals, and encourage Cadets to reach out to build professional relationships early we can begin to curb the individualism. We can begin to train Officers to become successful leaders and teammates in the organization. We must mentor the future leaders of our organization using the most professional manner possible. It is time to seize this moment and stop failing the next generation of leaders.
The Time is Now
ROTC programs around the country must begin to, or continue to, construct the legacies of their programs. They must seize the initiative to develop leaders who know how to work as a team, excel collectively, and share the knowledge within the organization. We must not fail the future of our organization by promoting individual excellence, while ignoring how to build a team. Officers are responsible in the Army. When the unit fails, we are directly responsible for the failure of our element. Individual ideologies do not prevail here. So rather than waiting to root this problem out through failure, we must inspire our Cadets to build their legacies before even getting to their respective units. It is true no one really cares about what you did during your Commissioning program; however, the work you put in becomes clearly evident during your first year in the unit. Build your program, build your skill set, and you will set yourself up for success as a leader within our formations. Do not fall prey to the idea that you can succeed individually. Build your legacy as an individual who performed at the highest level to better the team.






