When “Try Everything” Becomes the Problem
It’s Tuesday night. You’re sitting at your desk with eight browser tabs open. One tab has a YouTube video explaining TikTok growth strategies. Another has a blog post about SEO keyword research. The third is a webinar registration page for email funnel optimization.
You’ve bookmarked 47 articles titled “How I Made $X Doing Y.” You’ve started and abandoned three different content calendars this month. You’ve signed up for five free trials of tools you’re not sure you need.
And despite all of this learning, all of this trying, all of this effort — you’re not measurably closer to consistent income than you were three months ago.
If anything, you’re more confused now than when you started.
The Exhaustion Nobody Talks About
There’s a specific type of tiredness that comes from trying too many things at once.
It’s not physical exhaustion — though that’s there too. It’s a deeper, heavier tiredness. The kind that makes you question whether you’re cut out for this at all.
Not because you’re lazy. Not because you lack ideas or ambition.
But because you’ve been running in twelve different directions, and none of them have led anywhere specific.
Rachel knows this feeling intimately. She started her online business 18 months ago with a clear goal: replace her part-time income so she could work from home more.
Since then, she’s tried:
- Blogging with SEO optimization
- YouTube with faceless videos
- Pinterest with affiliate pins
- Email marketing with a 12-part automation sequence
- Instagram with daily stories
- A podcast (lasted four episodes)
- Webinars (got three attendees)
- Twitter threads (went nowhere)
Each time, she followed the advice. Showed up consistently — for a while. Then, when results didn’t come quickly enough, moved to the next promising strategy.
Now she’s 18 months in and feels more scattered than ever.
The problem isn’t lack of effort. It’s that effort spread across twelve directions feels the same as no effort at all.
When Every Expert Says Something Different
Here’s what makes this worse: every strategy you try comes with its own expert promising it’s “the one that actually works.”
One person swears SEO is the only sustainable traffic source. Another says email is dead and it’s all about short-form video now. Someone else insists that you need a personal brand on social media before anything else matters.
And they’re all successful. They all have proof. They all make compelling cases.
So you try each one. Not superficially — you actually commit. You learn the platform. You create content. You follow the frameworks.
But here’s what nobody tells you: these strategies work for people who’ve built them on top of something stable. They didn’t start with Instagram and affiliate links — they started with a clear message, a defined audience, and a core offer. Then they added Instagram.
You’re trying to skip to the tactics without the foundation. And tactics without foundation look like results when they’re someone else’s case study, but feel like chaos when they’re your reality.
The Self-Doubt That Creeps In
After trying everything and seeing nothing work consistently, you start to wonder if the problem is you.
Maybe you’re not built for online business. Maybe you don’t have the personality for it. Maybe you’re missing some fundamental skill that everyone else has but no one talks about.
Maybe you’re just not good enough.
This is what happens when effort doesn’t translate to results. You start questioning yourself instead of questioning the approach.
Rachel sits at her desk some nights and thinks: Everyone else seems to figure this out. What’s wrong with me?
But here’s what she’s not seeing: most people trying to build online businesses are experiencing the exact same thing. The difference is, the ones who seem successful aren’t talking about the six strategies that didn’t work before they found the one that did.
They’re sharing the victory, not the graveyard of abandoned tactics that came before it.
Rachel’s problem isn’t that she’s not capable. It’s that she’s trying to be good at everything instead of great at something specific.
When Information Becomes Noise
There’s a tipping point where learning stops helping and starts confusing.
Get Suzaan Sayed’s stories in your inbox
Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.
You watch a video about email sequences. Makes sense. You start building one. Halfway through, you see another video explaining why long sequences don’t work anymore and you should use short, punchy emails instead.
You switch approaches.
Then you read an article about how email is becoming less effective and you should focus on community building instead.
So you start a community.
But then someone in that community mentions they’re having success with SEO and affiliate content, so you pivot back to blogging.
Every new piece of information feels like the answer. And every answer contradicts the last one.
You’re not learning anymore. You’re just collecting conflicting advice and exhausting yourself trying to implement it all.
The Uncomfortable Truth About “Try Everything”
Here’s the thing nobody says out loud: “try everything” is terrible advice for someone who’s already overwhelmed.
It sounds proactive. It sounds like resilience and grit. But what it actually creates is diffusion.
Your energy gets spread so thin across so many directions that nothing gets the focused attention it needs to actually work.
You’re not failing because you picked the wrong strategy. You’re failing because you’re trying to execute six strategies simultaneously with the time and energy that one strategy actually requires.
Rachel has 30 half-finished blog posts, 12 abandoned YouTube scripts, 200 unused Pinterest pins, and an email sequence that stops abruptly after email seven because she pivoted to something else.
None of these things failed. They were never given a real chance to succeed.
What Happens When You Can’t Tell Anymore
After months of trying everything, you lose the ability to assess what’s actually working.
Is your blog traffic growing? You’re not sure — you stopped checking consistently when you pivoted to video.
Are your emails getting better open rates? Hard to say — you changed your approach three times and didn’t track the differences.
Is your audience growing? Maybe, but across six platforms, it’s impossible to know what’s meaningful growth versus just noise.
You have data everywhere and insight nowhere.
And when you can’t tell what’s working, you can’t double down on it. You can’t refine it. You can’t build on it.
You just keep adding new things, hoping eventually something clicks.
The Breaking Point
There’s a specific moment when “try everything” stops feeling like hustle and starts feeling like desperation.
For Rachel, it was when she realized she’d spent an entire weekend learning about a new platform she didn’t even want to use. She wasn’t interested in it. She didn’t enjoy the content style. She just felt like she should be trying it because someone said it was working for them.
That was the moment it hit her: she wasn’t building a business anymore. She was just reacting. Chasing. Grasping.
She’d become so focused on finding “what works” that she’d stopped thinking about what works for her.
What fits her strengths. What aligns with how she actually wants to spend her time. What feels sustainable, not just potentially profitable.
She was trying everything except the one thing that might actually help: stopping, observing, and understanding what’s already happening in the small corner of the internet she’s actually built.
The Weight of Unfinished Things
There’s a psychological cost to having dozens of unfinished projects.
Every abandoned blog post, every half-built funnel, every platform you tried and quit — they sit in the back of your mind as evidence that you can’t finish things. That you don’t follow through.
Even though the real problem wasn’t your follow-through. It was that you were trying to follow through on too many things at once.
But your brain doesn’t make that distinction. It just sees: started, didn’t finish. Started, didn’t finish. Started, didn’t finish.
And slowly, quietly, you start to believe that you’re someone who doesn’t finish things.
The exhaustion isn’t just from working hard. It’s from carrying the weight of all these unfinished attempts and internalizing them as personal failure.
When You’ve Forgotten What You’re Even Trying
Rachel was in the middle of setting up yet another automation when she stopped and asked herself: What am I actually trying to do here?
Not in the big, abstract sense — she knew she wanted to make money online. But specifically. Right now. With this particular action.
She realized she couldn’t answer. She was setting up the automation because someone said it worked for them. Not because it fit into a larger strategy she’d thought through.
She was executing tactics without strategy. Following advice without context. Trying everything without knowing what success would actually look like if she got it.
That’s when the trying becomes the problem. When you’re so busy doing things that might work that you’ve stopped asking whether they’re the right things for you to be doing at all.
What if the issue isn’t that you haven’t tried enough things — but that you’ve tried too many, and none of them have gotten the focus they needed to actually tell you anything useful?
