THE WORLD IS WATCHING:
SOUTH KOREA’S MOST CONTROVERSIAL CUISINE
Reported and Written by: Adam Chen
Videography by: Aimé Majeau Beauchamp, contributions from Declan Keogh
Video editing by: Aimé Majeau Beauchamp, contributions from Martin-André Young
Translation by: Soomin An
Graphics by: John Vilmor Sicat
Event Photography by: Tiffany Lam
LAND ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
JOURNALIST:
Walk onto stage into spotlight.
Toronto is in the Dish with One Spoon Territory. The Dish with One Spoon is a treaty between the Anishnabe, Mississaugas, and Haudeosaunee that bound them to share the territory and protect the land. Subsequent Indigenous Nations and peoples, Europeans, and all newcomers have been invited into this treaty in the spirit of peace, friendship, and respect.
1. LEAD SCENE: The Final Stretch
The journalist stands to the side of the stage, holding a notebook.
JOURNALIST:
(Speaking over the video 0:00–1:41) One good thing about driving to the Toronto Pearson Airport on a Sunday night is there isn’t any traffic.
I’m in good company with Steve Dombey, a retiree volunteering for the non-profit Free Korean Dogs.
We pull into the cargo terminal, where we’ll go through a meticulous customs process that lasts three hours.
Once everything is cleared, four crates with newly arrived dogs from South Korea are placed before us. They’ve just completed a 30 hour journey.There’s silence in the back seat as we begin the final leg of their journey, to the Free Korean Dog headquarters in downtown Toronto.
This trip to and from the airport is not an easy one for Steve to make, taking him about 7 hours each time. Like the many other volunteers across the world who run this complex international dog adoption network, Steve continues to dedicate countless hours to the cause. What keeps them going?
2. CONTEXTUAL SET UP + THEME STATEMENT: A State of Changing Tastes
The journalist takes a look at the audience. Find someone smiling at the photographs, and speak to them.
JOURNALIST:
(Directed at the audience)
It’s true, you’re smiling aren’t you?
So I have just a couple of questions for you.
If you’re a dog owner, please raise your hand.
(pause)
What about if you’re a dog lover?
(pause)
Now raise your hand if, given the chance, you would be willing to try eating dog-meat?
Journalist looks around at audience. Respond accordingly.
JOURNALIST:
Free Korean Dogs is one of multiple Canadian organizations working to end South Korea’s dog-meat farming industry, through which an estimated 1 million dogs are consumed every year.
Since 2015, Humanitarian Society International, or HSI, has closed several of these places, flying nearly 1,800 of the rescued dogs to be adopted abroad.
Carol McDowell is a certified master behavioral therapist who’s trained close to 1,100 dogs across Canada, many brought in from overseas. She said dogs raised in these facilities are often traumatized, and difficult to train. But her main objection to this type of adoption had to do more with her personal ethics.
JOURNALIST
*Pause* I have another question for you. If you could vote to end the global dog meat industry, would you?
This is a hypothetical question, move onto the next question after a short pause.
To be completely honest with you, I’ve been a vegetarian for over 12 years. I love dogs. But I decided early on that this story wouldn’t be about sharing what I believe. It’s would be about what people living in South Korea think about all of this.
And numbers show that behaviors and thoughts on this subject are rapidly changing.
In 2008, an estimated 2 million dogs were consumed in South Korea per year. In 2019, it was less than half of that.
A 2006 survey found 84% of South Korean didn’t think killing dogs for food should be
forbidden. In addition, 70% said there was nothing wrong with eating dog.
Meanwhile, a 2018 survey estimated that only 51.5% of South Koreans are against the idea of banning dog meat, a significant reduction.
Dogs are not officially designated as livestock, although they were for a brief period between 1975 and 1978. Since then, there are conflicting documents on dog breeding versus dog slaughter, leading to a legal gray area.
This lack of clarity allows the industry to exist generally unregulated.
In 1991, South Korea adopted its first animal protection law. That piece of legislation defines ethical practices for animal slaughter. But because dogs aren’t on that livestock list, it’s not clear if it’s legal to raise and kill them for consumption, however, the law prohibits inhumane animal slaughter.
In 2018, however, two landmark decisions were made:
For the first time, a municipal court convicted and fined a farmer for killing dogs for dog meat in June.
The farmer was based in Bucheon, a city close to Seoul, and was charged with “killing animals without proper reasons” and “violating building and hygiene regulations.”
This was followed by the government closure of Taepyeong-Dong dog meat complex, the country’s largest dog meat market. It housed at least six slaughterhouses, each holding several hundred animals at a time.
Then, in early 2019, a scandal came to light.
Park So-yeon is the Executive Director of the Coexistence of Animal Rights on Earth, or CARE, an animal shelter. CARE gained national attention in 2017 for facilitating the adoption of President Moon Jae-in’s “first dog”, Tory.
In mid-January, a whistleblower from CARE went public with some big news. Over the past three years, the shelter had quietly euthanized more than 230 dogs.
The employee posted an invoice from an animal carcass collection company, allegedly billing CARE for the collection of 5.7 tons of carcasses. At a press conference in January 2018, So-Yeon confirmed the accusations as being true, saying the killings were done out of mercy for animals who were too sick or aggressive to be kept at their facilities.
Although more than 1,000 CARE sponsors have since withdrawn their support, Park has pledged not to resign. The media has since given her the name, “the Queen of Rescues.”
Pause to sink in.
As you can see, the issue of dog consumption in South Korea is a complex one. But it’s rapid decline in popularity and size is unquestionable.
So why the sudden decline? One thing I can tell you for certain — it’s not just because dogs look cute in a bowtie.
Answering this question requires first learning about how it all started. Why did people even think of eating dogs in the first place?
Journalist pauses.
I’m asking you.
Journalist starts staring at a single member of the audience, waving.
I’m talking to you. Yeah, you. You’re South Korean right?
Sue is in the audience, taken by surprise and nervous.
SUE:
Yeah.
Journalist signals Sue to come onto the stage.
JOURNALIST:
Great! Can you come onto the stage please?
Sue is flustered.
SUE: Um… okay?
Journalist speaks to the audience sarcastically as Sue hesitantly walks onto the stage.
JOURNALIST:
(smugly speaking to audience) It’s always good to ask a local.
So what’s your name?
SUE:
I’m Sue.
JOURNALIST:
Sue, great to meet you. We’re wondering about the South Korean culture of eating dog meat.
Sue speaks nervously
SUE:
Okay?
JOURNALIST:
Mind if I ask you a couple of questions about it?
SUE:
(Take a moment to contemplate, followed by a heavy sigh)
Okay fine. Just one second.
Sue grabs a sign that says “Race Ambassador”, and puts it around her neck, and clears her throat.
SUE:
Welcome to the world of Korean dog meat!
(AUDIO: KOREAN TRADITIONAL MUSIC)
3. HISTORY OF THE SUBJECT: The World of Korean Dogmeat
Sue speaks with an exaggerated smile, outgoing and friendly like a tour guide.
SUE:
So what would you like to know?
JOURNALIST:
Great! Okay! (Rub hands together) So… When did your country start eating dog meat?
SUE:
We started using animals as livestock differently in the east than in the west.
In the west, dogs were used for herding sheep and hunting. They were more valuable as companions than food.
In some eastern countries like Korea and China, cows were an important tool for farming. We couldn’t imagine killing them off for food.
Once slaughtered, cows were too large to easily store. Dogs are smaller, so they could be shared with neighbours and easily consumed. They also survive during times of famine. We had to eat them before they ate all our food.
JOURNALIST:
How interesting! So have you always eaten dogs in Korea?
SUE:
It’s hard to say. Korea has a long history of eating dog meat, that began in the Samkug era of 57 BC to 676 AD. Dynasty that spans several thousands of years. It reduced in popularity as Buddhism grew, but when Confucianism became the state ideology during the Chosen dynasty in the 14th century, became commonplace once more.
JOURNALIST:
So is this an everyday kind of food, or only for special occasions?
SUE:
The industry is mostly seasonal. Dog meat is popular during the summer months. Boknal is what they call the three hottest days of the year, and it takes place on July 16th, 26th, and August 15th. Many celebrate boknal by eating dog meat soup, and it’s during then that the majority of the country’s dog meat consumption takes place.
JOURNALIST:
I see. So are there any health benefits to eating dog meat?
SUE:
We believe Boshintang, or dog meat soup, is good for your health and vitality, especially when you’re sick. Many men also use it when they are having…
Glances over at the Journalist
… performance issues.
JOURNALIST:
Oh really? (Confused, then looks back and it clicks, then looks flustered)
I’ll… keep that in mind. But people have pet dogs right? How can people eat their pets?
SUE:
It’s important to understand that in Korean, there are two different types of dogs.
SUE:
Directing to the word on the right
The term Gyeon is used for dogs that we keep as pets, for military service.
Directing towards the word on the left
The term Goo means dogs raised for livestock and food. It’s similar to how you distinguish between pet fish, and seafood.
JOURNALIST:
Okay, I understand. So one final question. Why are people suddenly starting to eat less of it?
SUE: Well, I can’t really speak for all Koreans.
Take off race ambassador sign.
We’re all different, you know. Maybe it’d be better if you went there and found out for yourself.
Get Adam Chen’s stories in your inbox
Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.
JOURNALIST: Go where? …South Korea?
4. SCENE 2: Wave of Liberation
JOURNALIST:
This place is Gwanghwamun Plaza, a popular protest spot. In 2016, almost two million peaceful protesters gathered here to call for the impeachment of former president Park Geun-hye, leading a few western media outlets to come up with some provocative headlines.
Animal Liberation Wave, the group behind the event you just saw, led a protest against the dog meat industry here as well. They gathered in silence holding plates of dead dogs.
They worked alongside Last Chance for Animals in Los Angeles, with some recognizable faces in attendance.
Animal Liberation Wave founder Jiyen Lee invited me into their headquarters to offer her perspective on the impact that animal rights advocacy has had in South Korea.
JOURNALIST:
(Speak during pause in video from 0:38–0:45)
She cautioned that while pressure from international organizations had been helpful, it could also backfire.
5. INFO BLOCK: Olympic Games
JOURNALIST:
(Speaking over video) It’s the summer of 1988, and South Korea is the first Asian city to host the Olympics since Japan in 1964. After decades of civil war and centuries of colonization, South Korea was finally getting ready to emerge onto the world stage.
A flock of doves were released into the stadium during the opening ceremony. Billions watched as the torches lit the Olympic cauldron, scorching several dozen unfortunate peace bearers to death in the process.
(video ends)
JOURNALIST:
This unflattering event took place at the same time South Koreans began facing mounting criticism by international media for their treatment of another kind of animal prized in west.
Kim Hakmin, a cultural historian, described how this unwanted attention impacted South Koreans and their relationship with dog meat.
JOURNALIST:
In 2018, South Korea was once again hosting the Olympics, this time in the city Peong Chang. There were no torched doves, but the international pressure to ban the dog meat industry certainly was.
News sites were flooded with stories of western athletes looking to play their part.
Some South Koreans voiced their opposition to this.
6. EXAMPLE: The National Image Strategy
JOURNALIST:
(Speaking during video from 0:50–1:10) This is not a farm. This is a shelter. Jonga Choi, who prefers to go by Mimi, is the executive director of Korea Animal Protection Society, or KAPS. She works overtime to take care of the shelter’s 120 cats and 20 dogs. And she doesn’t receive a salary. When I asked her about why attitudes towards dogs are changing, she brought up the term “national image strategy,” which she explained is when activists shame South Koreans to change based on how they are being perceived abroad.
(Video ends)
JOURNALIST:
Anti-dog meat campaigns are easily visible to foreign audiences, but we don’t often see those protesting on the other side. They speak out on behalf of dog meat farmers, saying that everyone has a right to earn a living and that singling out dogs over other animals is hypocritical.
Contacting this side of the movement was difficult. Every attempt I made to reach out to their representatives failed. One restaurant owner we spoke to told us they changed their location and name in order to evade harassment from activist groups. They had agreed to speak with us for an interview, but pulled out shorty after.
It wasn’t until we travelled south to the more traditionally conservative city of Daegu that we met someone willing to speak to us on the record at the Chilseong Farmers Market.
7. EXAMPLE 2: All Five Senses
JOURNALIST:
(Journalist speaks over video from 0:00–0:40) This is the Four Seasons and Five Senses restaurant. The owner, Kang Soon-Yeong, has had this restaurant for over forty years. She hesitantly agrees to let us interview her, as long as we don’t show her face.
The restaurant is open every day, allowing Soon-Yeong only two days off a month. She’s never had a chance to visit her daughter and grandchild since they moved away to Vancouver over 10 years ago.
She said her many of her customers cultivated a taste for the cuisine as they’ve aged. And although she said business had slowed over the past five years, she recalls a time when she saw a dramatic spike in business.
8. EXAMPLE 3: The Doctor’s Opinion
JOURNALIST:
This period not only lead to an increased demand for dog meat, it also led to the creation of its most infamous spokesperson.
JOURNALIST:
Ahn Yong Geun is a retired professor of food and nutrition. He wrote this song to spread a positive message about dog meat culture across the world. His son, a music composer, helped put the song together. Professor Ahn had to sing the song himself. No other singers would agree to do it for him.
JOURNALIST:
(Speak over video from. 0:23–0:41) Professor Ahn wholeheartedly embraces the name “Dr. Dogmeat,” once given to him by an international reporter. His conviction for the movement partly comes from a belief that animal rights groups are corrupt, saying they are motivated by financial gain.
JOURNALIST:
Are these groups motivated by money? At a protest in the Chilseong farmers market, we decided to speak with a group of anti-dog meat protestors to ask for ourselves.
9. CLIMAX: Picket politics
JOURNALIST:
(Speak during pause in video at 0:23–045) Before they began their protest of the market, I interviewed the groups leader, Oh Wee-Sook. The South Korean reporter assisting me said Wee-Sook kept going off topic and evaded answering our questions. We didn’t find out why until later on.
Instead, we spoke with Cho Sung-Li, another dedicated member of the team. Sung-Li explained to us how protesting is definitely not making him any money.
AIME:
(Speak over video: 2:48–3:10) When Adam left, the protesters started pointing at things and speaking to me in Korean. Then I started hearing the sound of dogs barking.
I thought this was a recording, like they had in the last protest. All of the sudden, I realised there were actually dogs. All around me, hidden behind the garage doors.
But they weren’t just hidden in garages.
(Video shows the dogs in the cages)
The protesters chanting woke the dogs up, while everything else remained quiet.
JOURNALIST:
(Speak over video paused at 4:10) Back in front of the Four Seasons and Five Senses, I caught up with Ms. Kang. She was standing outside the restaurant, and appeared very upset.
JOURNALIST:
Remember that interaction with the head of the animal rights protest group from earlier? The following day she sent me a text message. She wanted to explain why she wasn’t making a lot of sense during our interview.
(AUDIO: Adamreadtext)
REPORTER LOOKS AT TEXTS, AS A RECORDING OF HIS VOICE READS THEM OUT LOUD)
JOURNALIST:
“Please tell this story to those journalists you were with. I wanted to tell them this during the interview, but I was afraid I’d burst out in tears. I’ve never shared this with anyone before.
When I was 30, I had a dog. It saved my life.
But one day, my husband took my dog to the slaughter house, to be served at a feast honoring the elderly in my neighbourhood. But when I found my puppy, it had already been killed. I cried for days. You can’t imagine how much I cried over this. Since then, I’ve lived to atone for this as an animal rights activist, participating in protests to abolish our dog farms. I’ve always been afraid to share the emotional scars I carry from this event, but I want those from abroad to know about this. My heart is breaking even now while I text you.
During the 70’s, every household raised dogs and sold them as meat, but this generation has changed and we must change with it. In this modern materialistic society, we see animals as money, not living beings. Our National Assembly’s weak animal welfare system allows dog slaughterers to do whatever they want, while animal welfare organizations are only concerned with raising money. The real victims are the individual animal rights activists, using our own money to rescue dogs and hosting protests. People in the world are standing up to voice their support to stopping this practice. I agonize over this, and yearn for the year 1988. I pray to Buddha for the day we stop eating dog meat, like in 1988 when we established a dog meat prohibition.
I know this message is long and unorganized, but I believe you’ll read this. Have a great night.”
Pause for effect.
I had no way to corroborate her story. After that message, I sent her numerous texts. She never responded.
10. Post Climax: Bardot Soup
JOURNALIST:
In 1957, Brigitte Bardot burst onto the international stage for her role in “…And God Created Woman”. Stirring up controversy and renown as a sex symbol through the 50s and 60s, she was France’s response to Marilyn Monroe. In 1973 she left the entertainment industry, giving up her acting career in pursuit of a new passion.
JOURNALIST:
Bardot’s legacy as an animal rights activist has left a bad taste in the mouth of many. In 1977, she flew to Canada to protest the seal trade. Her convoy proposed to Fisheries Minister Romeo LeBlanc that they create a fake fur plant in Newfoundland. His response?
“Canada refuses to be intimidated by pressures from abroad.”
Bardot’s intervention was met with resistance from Canadians. In Kamouraska, Quebec, the Cote Est Cafe made headlines by naming its seal-burger the “Phoque Bardot Burger”. In case you’re wondering, Phoque means Seal in French.
JOURNALIST:
Leading up to the 2002 World Cup in Seoul, South Korea once against found itself under the global spotlight.
(IMAGES FADE DOWN)
Brigitte Bardot enters on stage left, and Son enters on stage right
Brigitte Bardot had a memorable interview with South Korea’s most famous journalist, Son Seok Hee, which led to some in South Korea renaming the dish “Bardot Soup.”
(Sohn Seok Hee and Brigitte Bardot perform the following during 0:00–0:45)
SOHN SEOK HEE:
Hello, Ms. Brigitte Bardot
브리짓 바르도씨 안녕하십니까?
BRIGITTE:
Hello, Hello, Eating dog meat can’t be considered a country’s culture. It‘s just barbaric behaviour.
Bonjour, bonjour, manger du chien ne peut pas être réduite et excusé comme une pratique culturelle. C’est simplement être barbares!
SOHN SEOK HEE:
Speaking curiously and calm
If you don’t mind me asking, how much do you know about Korean history and culture?
브리짓 바르도씨는 한국 역사라던가 문화에
대해서 얼만큼 많이 알고 계신지 궁금한데요?
BRIGITTE:
Speaking defensively
I actually read a Korean fairytale book translated into French before.
Il s’avère que j’ai déjà lu un conte de fées coréen traduit en français par le passé.
SOHN SEOK HEE:
I know a few French people who started eating dog meat when they came to Korea. Some Germans and Americans started eating dog meat when they came to Korea as well, and they continue to eat it to this day. This is the truth.
제가 아는 프랑스 사람들은 한국에 온 뒤로 개고기를 먹기 시작했습니다. 독일사람이나 미국사람들도 역시 지금도 개고기를 먹고 있고요. 이것은 사실입니다.
BRIGITTE:
That can’t be true. French, Germans, and Americans would never eat dog meat. Maybe someone tricked them into thinking they were eating pork or beef. I do not want to do this interview anymore, bye.
C’est impossible. Les Francais, Allemands et Américains ne mangeraient jamais de chien. Peut-être quelqu’un les a manipulés en leur disant qu’il s’agissait de porc ou de boeuf. Je n’ai plus envie de répondre à vos questions. Bye.
11. CONCLUSION: In case you were wondering
JOURNALIST:
I figured you might have been wondering.
You want to know how it was, right?
It’s funny. I did feel a bit sick, but I think that’s how you expect to feel after not eating meat for 12 years.
I felt guilty, when I thought about a black lab named panther.
But the feeling that stayed, was more paranoia.
About how you’d react.
Because I’ve seen you posing with your dog on my instagram.
Or walking them in the park.
Anytime I see a dog — I’m convinced they know.
When people ask about the trip, I’m not sure if I should tell them the truth or not.
Many people love dogs. They think of them as family.
What would they think of me, eating their family?
When people protest the South Korean Dog meat trade, I’ve heard them say “the world is watching.”
I wonder who they mean when they say “the world.”
Because… we’re all a part of it, aren’t we?
12: LIVE COMMENT SECTION
JOURNALIST:
(While video plays in background) Thank you everyone for coming tonight. Now, we have the portion of the event called “The live comment section.”
We would like to make ourselves available to you to answer any questions, or share any opinions you have about the topic being covered. Around you, we have plated some traditional Korean side-dishes and drinks for you to enjoy. Feel free to go to any table, take a seat, try some food. We have some cards with some questions, if you’d like to discuss. Otherwise, enjoy your night.
Thank you!
Script + Fact Checking:
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1Mu_3UrPiiBOsjriSDhDKBSsdUsbKdNnxbeS0UYFH2ds/edit?usp=sharing
Reflective Essay:
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1g9mlOWg0GQRprd1mhrm45EP5h0YF_tVym8F2D76YCs0/edit?usp=sharing






