The Notebook
It all began in 5th standard, that tender age when children first start to feel the stirrings of innocent crushes, swept up in daydreams they barely understand. I was no different. One afternoon, my computer teacher handed me a notebook and asked if I could return it to its owner, a girl named Annie. I didn’t think much of it at the time, though I accepted the mission — partly because the teacher was attractive, and really, who could say no to her?
Carrying that notebook, I navigated through the concrete maze of the school, climbing the familiar stairs to the top floor where Annie’s class was. I paused at the door, hesitated, and then called out, “Annie!” To my surprise, a voice behind me answered.
I turned, and there she was — her cheeks flushed, a sheen of sweat glistening on her forehead as if she had been running. She wore the standard school uniform — a skirt reaching just past her knees, her hair tied in two uneven ponytails. My first thought was, Eww, is this Annie? It was such a strange reaction, and yet that dismissive phrase kept playing on a loop in my head long after I handed her the notebook and returned to my class. It echoed all through the day and even followed me home.
She didn’t strike me as beautiful then, but something about her lingered in my thoughts, uninvited. I found myself wandering past her classroom at recess, telling myself it was just a coincidence, even as my eyes searched for her. My mind insisted she wasn’t that special, yet my heart — and my eyes — refused to listen. Her name, Annie, whispered through my mind, refusing to leave me in peace.
The following Sunday, as was my routine, I went to church with my family. Children stood at the front during mass, and after the service, we gathered for Sunday school. As I was walking to my class, I spotted her — Annie, in a long floral dress, standing just ahead of me. At that moment, something shifted. The world around her blurred, and she became the most beautiful sight I had ever seen.
She didn’t notice me, but that didn’t matter. I followed her into the assembly, where we stood for prayers. She was three people ahead of me, and in that brief moment, standing near her felt like the best thing that had ever happened to me. Sunday school, usually a tedious affair, felt like a dream because she was there, in the same room, within reach.
After the assembly, we parted ways, but fate had other plans. As we were leaving the church, my family climbed into the van owned by my dad’s friend, Daniel uncle. On the way, he casually mentioned he had to drop off some books at a house nearby — a new family that had recently joined the church. When we stopped at the house, a man named Santosh Gorge greeted us. His wife joined him, and as they chatted with my mother, they mentioned they had a daughter who went to school. My mom told me to look out for her, but I was too distracted by my thoughts of Annie to pay much attention.
The next week passed in a blur. I searched for her at recess, during lunch breaks, but she was nowhere to be found. Then, on Sunday, there she was again, at church. My heart raced as I realized that Santosh Gorge’s daughter — Annie — was the very girl who had unknowingly taken over my thoughts. Destiny? Coincidence? It felt like both.
As our school’s annual day approached, I finally understood why I hadn’t seen her — she had been busy with dance practice. She was partnered with Ajith, a boy popular among the girls. Around the same time, my close friend Piyush confided in me that he had a crush on Annie.
One afternoon, during recess, Piyush pulled me aside, his face flushed and eyes wide with excitement. He held out a neatly wrapped bar of chocolate, the kind we both knew was Annie’s favorite.
“Can you give this to her?” he asked, his voice trembling with hope. My heart sank a little as I looked at the chocolate. I knew how much Piyush liked her, and I wanted to be a good friend, but something inside me hesitated. The thought of handing her this small token — something that wasn’t from me but from him — felt wrong.
“I don’t know, Piyush…” I mumbled, scratching the back of my head. “Maybe you should give it to her yourself.”
Piyush’s face fell, disappointment flickering in his eyes. “Come on, man. It’s just a chocolate. You’ve already talked to her a bunch of times, and I — I don’t think I can do it. I get too nervous.” He thrust the chocolate into my hand, his voice almost pleading.
I looked down at it, feeling a knot form in my chest. My mind raced with conflicting thoughts. Part of me didn’t want to be the middleman, to watch this small gesture bring them closer while I stood on the sidelines. Yet, I couldn’t bear to let my friend down.
I shook my head, trying to push away the jealousy. “I’m sorry, Piyush. I just — ” I trailed off, handing the chocolate back to him.
Piyush’s face hardened with resolve. “Fine. If you won’t do it, I’ll do it myself.” His voice was sharp, and something about the way he said it stung. It was as though he was challenging me, forcing me to acknowledge the reality of the situation. He was willing to face his fear, and there I was, letting mine control me.
Suddenly, the thought of Piyush standing in front of Annie, offering her the chocolate himself, made my chest tighten. I imagined the two of them sharing a moment, something that had been mine, slipping away. Before I knew what I was doing, I blurted out, “No, wait. I’ll give it to her.”
He looked at me, surprised. “You sure?”
I nodded, even though every part of me felt conflicted. “Yeah, I’ll do it. Don’t worry.”
Relief washed over his face, and he handed me the chocolate again. “Thanks, man. You’re the best.”
But as I took the chocolate and walked toward Annie’s classroom, I couldn’t shake the feeling that I had just made a decision that would change everything.
Day after day, I delivered Piyush’s chocolates to Annie. She would tease me about blaming it on Piyush, but I kept handing them over. Yet, something shifted between Annie and me. We started talking more, and a fragile friendship began to blossom. I was over the moon, even if it was Piyush’s chocolates that had started it all.
Then, one day, I stayed home sick and missed school. The next morning, I found Piyush sitting alone, his face streaked with tears and his hands trembling as he held a crumpled chocolate wrapper. My heart sank at the sight of him. His normally lively face was replaced with a hollow look of despair.
“She rejected me,” Piyush whispered, his voice barely audible. “She told me to stop bringing her chocolates and that she… didn’t want them anymore.”
Get Akhilmathai’s stories in your inbox
Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.
The shock of his words hit me hard, but underneath it, I felt something else — an anger I couldn’t fully understand. How could Annie have been so cold to him? Piyush had been nothing but kind, and now here he was, heartbroken.
Without thinking, I marched through the schoolyard, my mind racing, determined to get answers. I spotted Annie talking with her friends, unaware of the storm I was bringing with me.
“Annie, we need to talk,” I said, my voice sharper than I intended.
Her smile faded as she saw my expression. “What’s going on?” she asked, her eyes searching mine.
I pulled her aside, away from the others. The moment felt heavy, charged with the weight of all the unsaid things between us. I didn’t waste any time.
“Why did you reject Piyush like that?” I demanded. “He’s devastated. He liked you, and you just crushed him.”
Annie looked down, guilt flashing in her eyes. She hesitated for a moment before speaking. “I didn’t mean to hurt him,” she said softly. “But I had to be honest. I couldn’t let him keep bringing me chocolates when I didn’t feel the same way.”
Her words stung, but they weren’t enough to cool the anger still bubbling inside me. “You could’ve told him earlier,” I argued. “You didn’t have to wait until he got his hopes up.”
Annie looked up, meeting my gaze with a mix of frustration and sadness. “Do you think it was easy for me?” she said, her voice shaking slightly. “I never asked for those chocolates. I never wanted them. The truth is… I thought they were from you.”
Her words hit me like a punch to the gut. “From me?” I echoed, my heart suddenly pounding.
She nodded, biting her lip. “Ever since that day, you returned my notebook… I’ve had feelings for you. I thought there was something between us. But then you started giving me chocolates from Piyush, and I didn’t understand why. I thought you liked me, too. But yesterday, when you weren’t here and Piyush showed up instead, I realized I’d been wrong.”
For a moment, I stood there, speechless. All this time, I had been torn between my feelings for her and my loyalty to Piyush, and now I found out she had been waiting for me all along. The weight of my silence, my hesitation, crushed me.
“I didn’t know,” I said, my voice low, almost apologetic. “I… I couldn’t tell you how I felt because of Piyush. He’s my friend, and I didn’t want to hurt him.”
Annie’s face softened, but a sadness in her eyes told me she already knew how this would end. “I understand,” she whispered. “But it doesn’t change the fact that I liked you. I kept hoping you’d feel the same, that you’d say something. But you never did.”
I swallowed hard, realizing just how much I had let slip away. There had been moments — countless moments — when I could have said something, done something. But I had chosen silence.
“I’m sorry,” I whispered, my voice barely holding together.
Annie smiled sadly, wiping a tear from her cheek. “It’s okay,” she said, though I knew it wasn’t. “I guess some things just aren’t meant to happen.”
I wanted to tell her how much she meant to me, how I had spent so many nights thinking about her, replaying every interaction in my mind. But the words never came. I had made my choice, and now it was too late.
For a moment, we stood there in silence, two people who had once been so close but were now worlds apart. Then, with a heavy sigh, Annie turned and walked away, leaving me standing there, frozen in the moment, watching her fade from my life.
After that day, we didn’t speak again. Not as friends, not as enemies. We simply drifted apart, two people who shared a connection that was never fully realized. Fourteen years passed without a word exchanged between us. Some connections are meant to remain untouched, preserved in their quiet beauty, existing only in the space between what was felt and what could never be said. It’s as if the universe gives us glimpses of people who are destined to stir our souls, but not our lives, reminding us that not everything needs to be acted upon.
There’s a unique kind of peace in admiring from afar, knowing that the bond exists but understanding that stepping closer might break the delicate balance. It’s the acceptance that some things are meant to be appreciated in their own silence, untouched by the complexities of what could follow.
Sometimes, the universe teaches us that love or connection doesn’t always need action to have meaning. The distance, the silence, the unspoken moments — they become a story all on their own. And maybe that’s how this one was always meant to be — a quiet, distant admiration, deeply felt but never disrupted.
But even now, I wonder if she remembers. I wonder if she ever knew how I felt back then, how every word left unsaid still lingers in the back of my mind.
Maybe she does
The End… but can be continued.
