The Rigorous Dream
This is a letter to be read first or last — by the very young, by the very old, and by everyone standing in between.
A fire was built a long time ago. Everything warm since has come from that fire, carried hand to hand, never once made new.
I want to tell you why I am doing this.
Here is the fact underneath all the others: every machine ever built by a human being has been built by another machine, in a chain that runs backward, without exception, to this one planet. No tool has ever made a second tool from nothing but rock and light. Life solved that problem before industry existed — a seed makes a tree, a tree makes seeds, an egg makes a bird that lays an egg — and industry has never once caught up. That gap has a name now. I call it heritable thermodynamic agency, and humanity’s score on it, past the atmosphere, is exactly zero. Every gram of hardware operating in space was manufactured on Earth and shipped there. There has never been an exception.
That absence is the reason scarcity has outlived every other institution we have tried to replace it with. Not because there is too little matter or energy — there is a single body drifting between Mars and Jupiter carrying more metal than the whole of human industry has ever touched, and a star nearby pouring out, every second, more power than our species has used in six hundred thousand years of trying — but because nothing we have built can go get it and then build more of itself once it arrives. Abundance has been sitting in plain sight this entire time. We have simply never had hands long enough to reach it twice.
For many years I have worked on this single issue at a bench in Chicago, since I think it is the real turning point — the fact which determines whether the coming hundred years will seem like an expedition or like a lineage. An expedition comes to an end when the ships cease to arrive, whereas a lineage does not. This distinction cannot be decided by how much energy we are able to produce or how far we can go; it will depend on whether we teach industry the one thing that life learned before industry ever existed — that is, how to make more of itself.
I want to be honest about the difficulty here, in the one part of this whole project that isn’t trying to persuade you of anything. The material we would still need to import to close the loop is light in mass and enormous in the energy locked inside it. Full closure — a system needing nothing at all from home, ever again — is a problem for generations after mine, and I don’t expect to see it finished. But the loop does not have to close for this to matter. It only has to start. The day something we sent out there manufactures its first useful part from the ground under it — a beam, a mount, a piece of shielding, not shipped, not carried, made there — the arithmetic of everything after that day changes. Not because the system is finished. Because it has begun; that is the day I am actually working toward. Not the whole lineage grown. Just the first birth.
Get Antonio’s stories in your inbox
Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.
But the future is not yet written. Somebody is going to write it whether or not this succeeds, and I would rather it be written by people who tried.
So here is what I am actually asking, underneath the essays and the ledgers and the years — not that you believe this will work. Only that you understand why it has to be attempted, and by whom.
To the child: the reason grown-ups argue over who gets what is not because people are unkind. It is because, for the whole of human history, there has only ever been one planet’s worth of things to go around. I am trying to make that stop being true.
As a young adult, you’ll be told that the frontier has been closed and that the major problems already have people in charge. Ask about things which still read zero. Heredity beyond the atmosphere is still at zero. Very few people are working on it. That isn’t a career opportunity; it’s the real extent of the gap between an expedition and a civilization.
As for those who are still going ahead with the project, I am not asking anybody to slow down the ships, the rockets, or the rate at which they are launched. That kind of work is genuine and essential, and nothing here would achieve any result without it. All I am saying is that it is not enough. Access without heredity is still just an expedition. The next stage after access is the one that very few people have even begun.
To the eldest among us: I would like you to see the first part made off-world before you go. Not the whole floor risen — the first proof that it can. That, I think, I can promise. I can promise, too, that I spent the years I had on it honestly, at a bench, with the numbers checked twice.
Not conquest. Not a valuation. Just more places in this solar system where a person can wake up in the morning and not have to think about whether there is enough.
Tend the fire. Hand it on brighter.
— Antonio
