The Monster Hunters Journal Chapter Four: Before You Hunt Anything
Alexandra did not open the first entry right away. She sat in the worn leather chair before the fire with Ben Carter’s journal across her lap, her fingers resting on the closed cover as though the leather had a pulse beneath it. Outside, the afternoon had gone dim and iron gray, the kind of light that made the forest look older than it was. Wind combed through the pines beyond the cabin, pulling dry leaves across the porch in soft scraping whispers. The season had turned its face toward winter. The last of fall clung stubbornly to the land, but frost had already begun claiming the mornings, silvering the grass, hardening the mud, and making every shadow seem colder.
The cabin held warmth better than it held silence. Firelight moved across the walls and made the shelves glow amber. The tall bookcases stood like witnesses, packed with weathered volumes, hand copied notes, old maps, jars of dried roots, and objects Alexandra still did not have names for. Her guitar leaned beside the shelves where she had returned it after playing Ben’s old tune. The blue mug that had been his sat empty on the small table near her chair. Her own mug rested on the arm of the chair, the last of the cocoa cooled to a dark skin. She had meant to drink it, but grief and dread had a way of making ordinary things wait.
The first letter had changed the room. Not visibly. The fire burned as it had burned before. The furniture stayed where it belonged. The windows still looked out onto the same clearing and the same thick woods. But something had shifted. The cabin no longer felt like a place Alexandra had inherited from a dead man. It felt like a place that had been waiting for her to admit what the inheritance really was.
She opened the journal again.
The page after Ben’s letter was thicker than the others, as if he had pasted it in later from another notebook. The edges were browned with age. The ink had faded in some places and darkened in others where his pen had pressed hard. At the top, in large uneven letters, he had written:
Before You Hunt Anything
Alexandra drew one knee up beneath the blanket draped over her lap and leaned closer. The title was not dramatic. That made it worse. Ben had not written like a man trying to impress anyone. He wrote like a man making sure the next person did not die stupidly.
Beneath the title, the first line began.
There are rules no hunter should break, whether he tracks wolves, men, or worse things. I did not learn these rules in books, though books helped me understand some of what I had already survived. I learned them by mud, blood, broken bones, bad guesses, and funerals that could have been avoided. Every rule here cost somebody something. Sometimes it was me. Sometimes it was a friend. Sometimes it was a stranger who laughed until the dark laughed back.
Alexandra felt her fingers tighten slightly against the page. There was Ben in every word. Practical. Grim. Angrier at foolishness than fear. She could almost hear him at the table, tapping ash from his pipe into an old tin, eyes fixed not on her but on the window, as if the real listener stood somewhere outside.
The first rule sat beneath the introduction.
One. Never go alone if you can help it. Even bad company is better than no witness at all. A witness matters. A witness remembers the trail, the sound, the smell, the hour, the mistake. If you die in the dark with no one to drag your body out, your story dies too, and whatever killed you gets to remain a rumor. Monsters survive on silence almost as well as they survive on blood. I broke this rule more than once. I am not proud of it. I lived because luck has a cruel sense of humor, not because I was right.
Alexandra breathed out slowly. The creature in the barn flashed through her mind. Yellow eyes. A rusted bell. Paul Rusk hanging limp from one clawed hand. If Sheriff Hale had not come through the barn door when he did, she might have become exactly what Ben described. A body in the dark. A story swallowed by panic and official lies.
Two. Never enter a place the locals fear without first asking why. Fools mock superstition. Fools are buried early. I spent half my youth thinking old women and drunk men exaggerated everything. Then I learned that exaggeration often grows around a hard little seed of truth. If a whole town refuses a road after sunset, ask what happened there. If children are forbidden from a creek, ask who drowned, and then ask whether the body was found. If hunters will not follow game across a ridge, do not cross it smiling. Fear passed down through generations may lose its reason, but not always its accuracy.
Three. If animals refuse a place, pay attention. Horses know. Dogs know. Birds know. Men are usually last to know. A horse that will not step forward is not being difficult. A dog that whines at an empty doorway is not being dramatic. Birds going quiet all at once may be the first honest warning you get. Once, in 1968, I watched every crow leave a churchyard within the same breath. I stayed anyway. That was the night I learned the dead do not always sleep under their own names.
Alexandra paused over the year. 1968. She stared at it longer than necessary. The ink there looked older somehow, though that was impossible. Ben had written these rules after the fact, likely much later, but the date carried weight. It placed his beginning farther back than she had allowed herself to imagine. Old Ben had not stumbled into monsters as an aging eccentric. His fascination, his research, his obsession, whatever name was safest for it, had started decades ago, somewhere between the late 1960s and early 1970s, when the world outside Briar County was changing fast and he was in the woods learning that some things had not changed at all.
She turned her eyes back to the page.
Four. Carry more than one light. Fire fails. Oil runs out. Batteries die. Matches get wet. Wicks snap. Darkness does not grow tired. It does not forgive the unprepared. Carry one light for seeing and another for surviving when the first goes out. If you are forced underground, carry three if you can. I once crawled out of a limestone sink with one hand burned and no lantern because I trusted a single flame. That was in 1971. I still hear what followed me in the dark when I sleep too deeply.
Five. Rope saves more lives than bullets. A bullet may stop a thing coming at you. Rope may keep you from falling into a place you cannot climb out of. Rope may pull a man from mud, water, roots, wells, cellars, and holes that should not be there. Rope may bind a door shut when prayer does not. Learn knots. Learn them until your hands can tie them in rain, cold, fear, and blood.
Six. Salt, iron, and silver have each earned their place for a reason. Not all things fear them, but enough do. Salt marks a boundary and spoils certain hungers. Iron is old, stubborn, and disliked by things that do not belong near honest earth. Silver is not magic the way fools think magic works, but it carries a purity of bite against several kinds of corruption. Do not wave any of these around like a charm and expect salvation. Tools require sense. A fool with silver is still a fool.
Seven. A sound in the dark is not always a warning. Sometimes it is bait. Crying, tapping, singing, knocking, bells, lost children, your mother calling from the trees, your own voice speaking from a place you have not reached yet. All bait. If the sound wants you to hurry, slow down. If it wants you to answer, keep your mouth shut. If it sounds hurt, remember that pain can be imitated. That is a hard rule. It may be the hardest.
Alexandra swallowed. She thought of the bell at the edge of the clearing. She thought of the voice in the dark.
Carter.
Eight. If something calls your name where no man stands, do not answer. Names matter. I have spent forty years trying to understand why, and I still only know enough to be afraid. A name spoken by the wrong mouth may be invitation, claim, mockery, or hook. Do not give the dark the courtesy of conversation.
Nine. If you feel watched, you probably are. The body notices more than the mind admits. Hair rising on your neck, skin tightening, sudden cold in the hands, the urge to turn around. Pay attention. That feeling kept me alive in 1973 near Blackwater Ridge when a thing in the laurel waited for me to step beneath it. I looked up because my skin told me to. My mind was busy being stupid.
Ten. Pride gets hunters killed faster than monsters do. Remember this when you think one successful hunt has made you special. Remember it when someone calls you brave. Remember it when fear embarrasses you. There is no shame in retreat. There is no glory in dying because you wanted a story told about you. The work is not to look fearless. The work is to come home alive.
Alexandra read the last rule twice. Then again.
The work is to come home alive.
Ben had written the same thought in his letter. She could feel how deeply it had lived in him. Survival was not cowardice to him. It was duty. It was discipline. It was the point of everything. All those years he had seemed hard, grim, and unreachable, he had been building a religion out of coming home with enough breath left to warn someone else.
The next page carried another heading.
Basic Pack List
No hunter should travel without these unless he plans on dying badly. That may sound harsh. Good. Harsh words weigh less than a coffin.
Alexandra almost smiled despite herself.
A good knife. Not pretty. Good. A knife that holds an edge and sits where your hand can find it without thought. A longer blade if you can carry one, because reach matters when teeth are involved. Lantern. Matches sealed against damp. Oil cloth, because rain ruins more plans than enemies do. Rope, at least fifty feet, and better if you can carry more without slowing
yourself. Iron nails, plain and clean. A small bag of salt, dry and kept close. Silver coin or silver blade if possible. A flask of clean water. Bandages. Needle and thread. Chalk for marks, signs, and finding your way back when a place starts lying about its own shape. Journal and pencil, because memory bends under fear. A second source of light. A bell, but only if entering underground places, and never the old red tied bells unless you know who hung them there. A pocket Bible if it steadies your hands. Any scripture, charm, keepsake, or song may serve the same purpose if it keeps panic from eating your sense. A steady horse, if one will go near the place at all.
At the bottom, Ben had added in heavier ink:
Do not carry so much that you cannot run. Dying well equipped is still dying.
Alexandra lowered the book slightly and glanced toward the corner near the door where Ben’s old field pack hung from a peg. She had passed it a hundred times since moving in, but now it seemed different, as though the worn canvas had been waiting for context. She could picture him packing by this list. Knife. Lantern. Salt. Rope. Journal. She could see those large rough hands fastening buckles, checking weight, touching each item once not because he forgot what he packed, but because ritual settled the mind.
The third page was marked with a smear of something pale across the upper corner, maybe ash, maybe old mud.
Signs a Place Has Gone Wrong
A place goes bad before most men notice. Land has habits. Houses have moods. Water has memory. People pretend only living things can change their minds, but any hunter who has lasted more than a season knows better. Watch the small things. By the time blood is on the floor, the warning signs have usually been there for weeks.
Milk sours too quickly. Dogs bark and then refuse the doorway. Birdsong stops all at once, not fading but cut clean as a snapped string. Windows frost from the inside in warm weather. Tools go missing and turn up in strange places, especially sharp tools, keys, mirrors, and things that belonged to the dead. There is knocking in walls with no one inside them. Water stands still when it should move, or ripples though no wind has touched it. Shadows look deeper than they ought to and keep their shape after the light changes. People begin speaking low without knowing why. The old folk suddenly stop joking.
Alexandra felt that last line settle over her.
The old folk suddenly stop joking.
She thought of Paul Rusk’s pale face. Sheriff Hale’s careful voice. Mrs. Bell at the general store looking out the window when Alexandra bought coffee and candles the week before, saying nothing about the dead livestock though everyone was saying something. Fear did not always shout. Sometimes it simply lowered every voice in town.
Ben’s note continued below the list.
If three or more of these happen together, leave before nightfall. If you cannot leave, prepare the place as if for siege. Fire first. Exits second. Windows third. Then count every living soul inside and make sure the number stays the same. If children are present, keep them away from doors, mirrors, wells, fireplaces gone cold, and any voice asking them to come closer. Children hear what adults explain away. That makes them useful and vulnerable, which is an ugly combination.
Alexandra sat very still. The cabin was warm, but the page chilled her. Ben’s knowledge had not come from one strange night. It had layered over decades. He had seen enough to make categories. Enough to make rules. Enough to know which objects went missing before trouble started and which voices children should not answer.
The fourth page was written in a different mood. The letters were sharper, more compressed, the lines crowded close together as if Ben had been annoyed by the limits of paper.
Classification of Threats
Get Odette’s stories in your inbox
Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.
Rough notes only. To be revised if I live long enough.
Alexandra closed her eyes briefly. He had not revised it. Or perhaps he had, in later volumes. She opened them and read on.
I resisted classifying these things for years because names can trick a man into thinking he understands what he has only labeled. Still, no hunter can carry every story loose in his head. Categories help. They are not cages. A thing may belong partly to one type and partly to another. A beast may be corrupted. A spirit may mimic. A feeder may wear a dead man’s face. Never let the classification make you lazy.
Type One: Beasts. These are things with flesh, blood, teeth, track marks, habits, dens, hunger, mating seasons, wounds, and patterns that can be learned. They may be natural creatures mistaken for monsters, old species that should have died out, or things the modern world calls cryptids because it likes fancy words better than old warnings. Some can be trapped. Some can be shot. Some can be poisoned, burned, or driven from territory. Do not underestimate them because they bleed. A bear bleeds too, and that will not save you if you meet it badly.
Alexandra lingered on the word cryptids. Ben had underlined it once, then written in the margin:
Started hearing this word more in the 1970s. New name. Old tracks.
She could almost hear the disdain in it.
Type Two: Restless Dead. Things that should be buried and remain so, but do not. This includes revenants, haunts with flesh, grave bound walkers, and the rare dead thing that remembers enough of life to be dangerous with intent. The restless dead are not all evil. Some are trapped. Some are hungry. Some are angry. Some are only repeating the last terrible thing that happened to them. Pity them if you must, but pity from a safe distance.
Type Three: Spirits. Things not fully made of flesh, often tied to place, memory, oath, guilt, murder, grief, or unfinished harm. They may not leave marks in mud, but they leave marks on people. Cold rooms, recurring dreams, voices in empty halls, objects moved with purpose, animals refusing entry, and the same death echoing in different forms over years. Spirits require patience. Bullets make people feel better and usually do nothing else.
Type Four: Feeders. Things that drain blood, breath, warmth, memory, luck, youth, fear, or something less easily named. Some look human. Some never did. Some kill quickly. Others ruin a person over weeks until the victim cannot remember when they began dying. Watch for exhaustion without illness, children aging in the eyes, rooms that feel hungry, and survivors who cannot describe what was taken from them. Fire sometimes helps. So does distance. So does not inviting strangers across a threshold because they smiled kindly.
Alexandra shifted in the chair, uncomfortable in a way she could not blame on bruised ribs.
Type Five: Mimics. Things that deceive by voice, face, shape, scent, memory, or trust. This is one of the cruelest types because it turns love into a weapon. A mimic may sound like a lost child, a dead wife, a brother calling from the creek, a friend outside the door, or your own voice begging you to hurry. If you must test one, ask something only the true person would know, but do not trust the first correct answer. Some things steal memories the way foxes steal hens.
The bell at the edge of the clearing returned to Alexandra’s mind. The creature had said her name. Not with Ben’s voice. Not yet. But Ben’s warning had not been casual. If it knew her name, it had known his first.
Type Six: Corruptions. Things made wrong through ritual, curse, desecration, bad ground, poisoned faith, or man’s own arrogance. I dislike this category most because men often stand at the beginning of it. A natural beast becomes worse after feeding where it should not. A house becomes wrong after enough blood is hidden in its walls. A person bargains, digs, burns, prays, or cuts where he was told not to, and then acts surprised when something answers. Corruptions can sometimes be undone. More often, they must be ended.
Type Seven: Unknown. The worst kind. Do not be ashamed of writing unknown. Unknown is honest. Unknown keeps you careful. Every other category began here.
The final line on the page was written smaller.
I have survived more unknowns than I have solved.
Alexandra stared at that sentence for a long time.
The journal had not given her comfort. It had given her structure, which might have been more useful. Ben’s world was not chaos, not entirely. It had rules, patterns, tools, warnings, and classifications written by a man who had spent decades crawling through error toward understanding. He had been young once, sometime in the late 1960s, fascinated by strange tracks, missing animals, whispered stories, and those blurry newspaper clippings about wild men in forests and impossible creatures seen beside lonely roads. Then fascination had become research. Research had become field work. Field work had become survival. Survival had become duty.
The old journals had carried all of that. They were not merely records. They were the bones of Ben Carter’s life.
Alexandra turned back to the beginning of the rules and ran her fingertips over the date written faintly at the bottom of the first page.
Compiled from notes spanning 1966 to 1998. Revised after too many mistakes.
Thirty two years of mistakes, she thought.
And this was only the entrance.
She looked across the room at the shelves, the ladder, the jars, the maps, the guitar, the kitchen she had rearranged to suit her own hands. Ben had built a life around what he had seen and survived. He had followed tracks through mud, creeks, mines, churchyards, pastures, abandoned houses, and whatever else waited in the pages ahead. He had lived long enough to become old, but not long enough to finish the work. Now the rules sat in Alexandra’s lap like a door key.
Outside, the wind quieted.
That silence was sudden enough for her to notice.
Alexandra lifted her head.
The fire
still burned. The cabin still breathed its small wooden sounds. But beyond the windows, the forest had gone flat and still. No birds. No leaf chatter. No branch creak.
She did not move toward the shotgun at once. She listened first, because Ben’s first pages had already begun rearranging her instincts. If animals refused a place, pay attention. If the sound in the dark wants you to hurry, slow down. If you feel watched, you probably are.
There was no bell this time.
Only the sense of something at the edge of the clearing, beyond sight, beyond proof, waiting.
Alexandra looked down at the classification page. Type One: Beasts. Type Five: Mimics. Type Six: Corruptions. Type Seven: Unknown. The creature from the barn could have belonged to any of them, or to several. Flesh, blood, teeth, and tracks like a beast. A voice that knew her name like a mimic. A rusted bell tied in red like a corruption. A hunger old enough to stand outside every category Ben had dared write.
She closed the journal carefully, keeping one finger between the pages so she would not lose her place. Then she stood, carried the book to the maple table, and set it down beside her cooling cocoa.
Her fear had not lessened. That would have been too easy. But it had changed shape. It no longer filled the room like fog. It had edges now. Names. Rules. Warnings. Tools. Fear with a handle could be carried.
Alexandra crossed to Ben’s field pack by the door and took it down from the peg. Dust rose from the canvas. The leather straps were cracked but strong. She laid it on the table beside the open journal and began emptying its old contents one by one. A coil of rope. A rusted tin of matches wrapped in waxed cloth. A small pouch of salt. Three iron nails bound with red thread. Chalk. Bandages gone yellow at the edges. A folding knife. A stub of pencil. A tiny silver coin wrapped in cloth.
At the bottom was a bell.
Not rusted. Not tied with red ribbon. Plain brass, small enough to close inside her fist.
Alexandra held it without ringing it.
For underground places, Ben had written.
She set it down gently.
The silence outside broke at last. A crow called from somewhere beyond the trees, harsh and ordinary and welcome. Alexandra let out a breath she had not realized she had been holding.
She looked back at the first journal.
The next page would begin Ben’s journey. Not the rules, not the pack list, not the warning signs or categories, but the first true account. The beginning of whatever had taken a curious young man in the 1960s and shaped him into Old Ben Carter, monster hunter, recluse, uncle, teacher, and the only man she knew who could make a cup of cocoa feel like a survival lesson.
Alexandra touched the cover once.
“Tomorrow,” she said.
But she knew better.
Night was coming. Something had already found the edge of the clearing. Ben’s rules were no longer history. They were instruction.
And somewhere in the woods, old hunger was learning how close it could come.
