When Cultures Clash: The Real Reason Diverse Societies Break Down
Multiculturalism. It sounds dream-like on paper. Visualising a variety of backgrounds coming together to live in peace and harmony; sharing food recipes, parenting styles, music and wisdom. Friendly banter over fashion choices or whose contact sport is more fulfilling.
Imagine the scene around a campfire, learning words from each other’s languages and sharing folklore tales from all walks of life. It beats the traditional, familiar stories that you grew up with. It brings a different lens upon which to view the world through — enabling you to expand your knowledge that isn’t based from a textbook.
Without having to travel, you get first hand real-life experiences. To enrich your understanding of the differences that we share, delivered straight to your doorstep.
If only this was as straightforward as it seems. The reality of it, is stark in comparison. The ideas above are based on everyone having respect for one another’s values. And first and foremost, respect for the host’s land, history & heritage.
It could work in principle if you adapted and integrated into the original culture of whom you choose to live beside — still keeping your own roots close to your heart, as well as taking part in the traditions of your new home.
In nature, different species of the same group can coexist — when the ecosystem is balanced.
The problems start to occur when the guest species:
~ dominates the resources,
~ starts dictating the rules,
~ or changes the environment faster than natives can adapt.
Even peaceful species will become defensive if they feel:
~ displaced
~ threatened
~ ignored
~ or overruled
This is actually a universal biological principle, not a cultural one.
Let’s first take bears for example:
Brown bears and black bears often overlap and can tolerate each other — not best mates, but coexistence is possible. Brown bears & polar bears overlap rarely, and when they do, it’s messy.
So whilst some bears can coexist, others absolutely cannot.
Get Claire Louise’s stories in your inbox
Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.
Wolves, coyotes, dogs & dingoes:
All generally the same family — Wolves and coyotes can overlap in the wild. It’s tense but it’s possible, although many wolf packs will kill coyotes on sight.
Some wolves even tolerate domestic dogs in some regions. Whilst dingoes and dogs often fight to the death. So again, same group but with different compatibility.
Another example is Primates:
Vervet monkeys & baboons can share space peacefully. Spider monkeys & howler monkeys can coexist amongst the forest.
However, chimpanzees will violently kill other primate species, including gorillas in some regions. Males from rival monkey species will go into literal turf-war mode.
Human psychology mirrors this exactly. With this knowledge, we can see that certain cultures can coexist, whilst others cannot.
Humans — just like animals — react badly when they feel:
~ Their identity is being dismissed,
~ their traditions are being overwritten,
~ or they are expected to change whilst others are not.
That is called group identity threat and it has nothing to do with race — it is evolutionary psychology.
Minority groups don’t cause conflict by existing. Conflict happens when:
~ A minority group’s needs are prioritised over the majority,
~ cultural norms are expected to change rapidly,
~ people feel unheard in their own home territory.
It is not diversity itself that causes tension. It’s how it’s managed. When the ecosystem is balanced, it can work. Diversity fails when you introduce a culturally dominant group into an unstable ecosystem, letting one group reshape the environment disproportionately, or expecting long-established members to stay silent whilst newcomers set the rules.
This causes cultural displacement anxiety.
Not racism. Not intolerance.
It is a normal, measurable, documented human reaction to perceiving loss of culture, voice or belonging.
If a minority starts dictating terms to the majority, the majority — like any animal species — will react to protect its territory, identity, and continuity.
That’s not hatred. It’s natural instinct.
