Somebody Hated My Book. That’s the Job.
Somebody hated my book.
Not “it wasn’t for me” hated it. Picked it apart, piece by piece, and closed it out with “I’ll never read anything from this author again.”
I read the whole review. Twice. That’s probably the first mistake. But I’m going to be honest with you: it stung.
This is my first book as a romance author. My first time putting a love story out into the world and letting strangers decide what they think of it. So yeah, this one landed.
Here’s the thing about being an indie author. There is no team between you and the reader. No editor to take the hit. No publicist to spin it. No marketing department to tell you it’s just numbers. It’s you, your laptop, and a stranger on the internet telling you your work wasn’t worth their time.
And the hard part is, they’re not wrong. Not really. A book is a promise. If the story didn’t give them what they wanted, that’s a fair thing to say. They paid for it. They get to have an opinion.
So what do you do with that?
You don’t respond.
Not to defend yourself. Not to explain what they missed. Not to argue in the comments. The review isn’t a conversation, and the moment you treat it like one, you’ve already lost. The reader said their piece. Let them have it.
You sit with it, then you put it down.
Read it once. Feel it. Then close the tab. If there’s a real craft note buried under the anger, keep that one piece. The rest of it, the tone, the final verdict, the “never again,” that’s not yours to carry. Throw it out.
Get Corey L. Johnson’s stories in your inbox
Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.
You remember the other voices.
One loud voice is not the whole room. For every reader who hated it, there’s somebody who stayed up too late finishing it, somebody who messaged a friend about it, somebody who saw themselves in it for the first time. Those people are quieter. That doesn’t make them less real.
You keep writing.
This is the part that matters most. The next book is the answer. Not a rebuttal, not a correction. Just the next story, written better because you kept going.
I’m not pretending this book is perfect. It’s my first. My vow is to keep getting better, book by book. The people who stick with me will see that growth. That’s the deal I’m making, with them and with myself.
Why some people love a story others hate
Here’s what I’ve come to believe. Readers don’t walk into a book empty. They bring their own hunger with them.
Somebody wants a fast plot. Somebody else wants a slow burn. Somebody wants characters who talk like real people. Somebody else wants them to talk like a movie. The same scene can feel honest to one reader and boring to another, and neither one of them is wrong.
Timing matters too. The same book hits different on a hard week than it does on a good one. Sometimes a reader just isn’t in the place to receive what you wrote, and that’s not the book’s fault or theirs.
And a story that takes a risk will always split the room. The safe book gets three stars from everybody. The risky one gets five stars and one star. I’d rather write the risky one.
For me, writing Black romance, there’s one more layer. Some readers have been waiting their whole lives to see themselves loved on the page like this. They feel things other readers won’t even notice. That connection is real, and it’s worth more than any single review.
So yeah. Somebody hated my book. They said they’d never read me again.
I’m still here. I’m still writing. The next one’s coming, and it’ll be better than the last.
