Why You Should Stop Making Birthday Wishes (And Start Receiving Them)

I have learned the hard way to tread lightly around the modern Western birthday ritual (cake, candles, “Happy Birthday to You,” wish, blow, clap, woohoo et al.). For some reason, when I ask people whether they feel it’s actually meaningful to them or just a rote habitual reenactment of a culturally mandated script, they get defensive.

But fear not, People. You can safely read on. What I humbly (debatable) suggest here will not take away what you love so dearly; it will only enhance and elevate it. And to those of us who crave something different but don’t know where to start, this is for you, too.

At the risk of alienating almost everyone, I will first go on record: I don’t like pretending to be surprised that a candlelit dessert has appeared when we all 100% know it’s coming, I don’t like the melody of “Happy Birthday” or the way everyone transforms into a choir of gummy zombies to sing it, I don’t like the pressure of people waiting for me to make a wish or the collective agreement that six seconds (apparently the sheer outer limit of our patience for silence) is enough time to locate your deepest desire and say it to a cake — come to think of it I don’t really like the concept of “wishing,” too noncommittal — I don’t like the metaphor of blowing out a candle on a day supposedly celebrating life, and, perhaps worst of all, I don’t like dessert, and I especially don’t like cake.

But I digress.

Here’s one simple tweak to make birthday candles a more meaningful collective moment.

Reverse the roles

Normally, the birthday person makes the wish while everyone watches. Here, the guests wish and the birthday person receives.

1. Hand out candles. Everyone gets one except the birthday person.
2. Light and pass. Light your own, then use it to light your neighbor’s, until every candle is burning.
3. Make a wish. Everyone silently thinks of a wish for the birthday person.
4. Blow together. On three, everyone blows out their candles in one final dramatic flourish.

Optional: if “wish” feels a little too disposable for you (read: me), invite people to offer a blessing, hope, prayer, desire, or intention instead.

Get Ezra Bookman | Ritualist’s stories in your inbox

Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.

Remember me for faster sign in

My friend Hannah did this for her birthday four years ago. It wasn’t planned, just a playful spark in the moment that everyone went along with. A Hanukkah menorah got used for some reason I can’t explain or remember. But I do remember how good it felt to be part of it, seeing Hannah’s shoulders relax and her face light up in the glow of all that love she was receiving at once. Without us having to say anything, she felt it.

Hannah’s role reversal birthday candle lighting with an anachronistic menorah, 2022

Five Reasons This Works

1. Everyone contributes. No one is a passive bystander; no one is on autopilot.
2. It looks awesome. A room of scattered, candlelit faces is quietly beautiful (dim the lights if you can, obviously).
3. It’s a gift to receive. Feeling a whole room of people bless you at once is like a hot bubble bath for the soul.
4. It’s low-risk. No one is put on the spot to have to say something profound, which means your friend’s +1 whom you’ve never met can participate without feeling awkward.
5. It’s simple and familiar. Because it’s remixing a ritual people already know, it barely requires any instruction and has built-in social permission.

Four Helpful Tips

1. Manage the wax. Wrapping tinfoil around the bottom of the candle works, though it adds a step. Tea lights work too, but the wax can easily spill after you blow them out. I’m sure you’ll figure something out.
2. Fill the silence. Sing or play music while everyone is lighting the candles, especially if it’s a big party (Happy Birthday, if you must, though I’m a fan of this sweet call and response jingle).
3. Allow the silence. Don’t blow too quickly. Once everyone’s candle is lit, allow some space for people to really reflect.
4. Delegate. You can facilitate this yourself, but it’s better to ask a friend to run it for you. Here’s a sample script for them:

“Hey everybody, we’re gonna do birthday candles a little differently, and we need your help to pull it off. Come grab a candle, light it, then use it to light your neighbor’s. Once we’re all lit, we’ll all think of a wish for [name], a blessing or hope you have for them this coming year. [Name], your only job is to sit there and take it in. Then I’ll count to three, and we’ll all blow them out together.”

I will admit this fixes only a few of my many complaints. I still don’t have a good solution to the birthday song. But there’s a moment in this ritual when the room goes quiet and every face and heart gets aimed toward one person, and — listen I know you’re going to think what I’m about to say is just poetic hyperbole in a last-ditch effort to end this piece with emotional gravitas, and honestly if I were in your shoes I’d probably think the same thing, but I swear I mean this — it feels like the gravity in the room shifts. Suddenly the whole reason why we go to all the trouble of gathering people to celebrate birthdays in the first place makes sense to me. I’d put up with a lot for that moment.

Except for the cake. Never the cake.