A Blueprint for Thriving
or what I’ve learned from the “Great by Choice” book by Jim Collins and Morten T. Hansen
In a world marked by constant disruption, economic volatility, and rapid technological change, why do some companies rise to greatness while others crumble? This is the central question that Jim Collins and Morten T. Hansen seek to answer in their groundbreaking book “Great by Choice”. Unlike traditional business books that attribute success to vision, innovation, or luck, this one reveals that what truly sets high-performing companies apart is their ability to navigate uncertainty with discipline, consistency, and strategic foresight. Based on a nine-year research study, it examines companies that outperformed their industry peers by at least ten times — the so-called “10Xers”. Through detailed comparisons with similar but less successful companies, the authors uncover a pattern of behaviors and decision-making strategies that consistently lead to extraordinary results, even in the most chaotic environments.
This article is not a verbatim retelling of all the chapters of the book but is a subjective overview of the key points that I highlighted in the margins of the book while reading it.
About the authors
Jim Collins is a renowned business researcher, author, and speaker, best known for his work on what makes companies great and sustainable over the long term. He began his career at Stanford Graduate School of Business, where he received the Distinguished Teaching Award. Collins later founded a management research lab in Boulder, Colorado. He is the author or co-author of several bestsellers, including “Built to Last”, “Good to Great”, “How the Mighty Fall”, and “Great by Choice”. Collins’ work is known for its data-driven, empirical approach to business success, and his books have sold millions of copies worldwide.
Morten T. Hansen is a management professor at the University of California, Berkeley, and a faculty member at INSEAD, one of the world’s leading business schools. He previously worked as a professor at Harvard Business School and as a consultant at the Boston Consulting Group. Hansen is also the author of “Collaboration” and “Great at Work”. His research focuses on leadership, high performance, and organizational behavior. He has been recognized for both academic excellence and his ability to translate complex research into actionable insights.
A blueprint for thriving
In this book, Jim Collins and Morten T. Hansen explore why some companies achieve exceptional success — outperforming their industry peers by at least tenfold — in unpredictable and turbulent environments. These “10X companies” are not luckier or more visionary than others. Instead, they succeed through a unique combination of fanatic discipline, empirical creativity, and productive paranoia. These three traits, found in what the authors call “10Xers”, empower leaders to make bold yet calculated decisions, stay consistent in execution, and always prepare for worst-case scenarios. Through extensive research, the book proves that these behaviors, not circumstance or luck, drive long-term performance.
The authors illustrate how successful companies implement these principles through concepts like the 20 Mile March — a self-imposed performance discipline where companies make steady, measured progress regardless of market highs or lows. Another key principle, “Fire bullets, then cannonballs”, emphasizes starting with small experiments (bullets) before scaling up to major investments (cannonballs), reducing risk and increasing the likelihood of success. The concept of Leading above the Death Line reminds leaders to prepare for disasters by maintaining resources, backup plans, and strategic restraint, ensuring the organization can survive unpredictable shocks.
Get Felix Davidenko’s stories in your inbox
Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.
Finally, the book emphasizes that luck is not the deciding factor in achieving greatness. Both successful and failed companies encounter good and bad luck. What differentiates the great companies is their return on luck — how they respond to luck events, capitalize on opportunities, and mitigate risks. By adhering to a Specific, Methodical, and Consistent (SMaC) recipe, 10X companies navigate uncertainty with clarity and confidence. This book teaches that greatness is not accidental or reactive, but the result of conscious, disciplined choices made in the face of chaos and change.
How does it work in real life
A compelling example from this book is the story of Southwest Airlines, which illustrates how applying the core principles — fanatic discipline, empirical creativity, and productive paranoia — helped the company thrive while competitors failed. The context is that in an industry known for volatility, low margins, and frequent bankruptcies, Southwest Airlines became one of the few U.S. carriers to remain consistently profitable over decades — even during oil crises, recessions, and 9/11.
- Fanatic Discipline — The “20 Mile March”. Southwest was committed to a self-imposed performance target: achieving profitability every single year, regardless of external conditions. While other airlines rapidly expanded during boom times, Southwest grew slowly and steadily, resisting pressure to chase risky opportunities. For example, during airline deregulation in the 1980s, many airlines aggressively expanded into new markets. Southwest expanded only when it made operational sense, sticking to short-haul, low-cost routes and avoiding the temptation to overreach.
- Empirical Creativity — Testing Before Scaling. Rather than blindly copying competitors or chasing fads, Southwest relied on real-world testing and data. They discovered through experimentation that using a single type of aircraft (the Boeing 737) dramatically reduced maintenance costs and turnaround time. While this seemed counterintuitive at the time (other airlines used multiple aircraft types for flexibility), it gave them a huge operational advantage and became a cornerstone of their SMaC recipe.
- Productive Paranoia — Preparing for Downturns. Herb Kelleher and his team always assumed bad times were coming — and prepared accordingly. They kept cash reserves, avoided taking on excessive debt, and didn’t rely heavily on fuel hedging or unpredictable revenue streams. As a result, while competitors were grounded during crises, Southwest remained operational and often gained market share.
By following these principles, Southwest outperformed its comparison company, PSA Airlines, which also started as a low-cost carrier but expanded recklessly and ultimately failed. While PSA was acquired and disappeared, Southwest went on to become one of the most admired and successful airlines in the world. This example powerfully illustrates how the deliberate and disciplined application of the book’s core ideas leads not only to survival but to long-term greatness.
Three pieces of advice
- Create Your Own “20 Mile March”. Set a clear, consistent, self-imposed goal that you commit to achieving every day or every week — regardless of external circumstances (good or bad). Choose a realistic but meaningful target — e.g., “write 500 words a day”, “reach out to 3 new clients per week”, or “exercise for 30 minutes daily”. Stick to it no matter what — don’t do more on good days or less on bad days. It builds discipline and long-term momentum. You build consistency and avoid burnout or erratic behavior. Over time, this steady progress leads to big results.
- Fire Bullets, Then Cannonballs. Test new ideas on a small scale before going all-in. Only invest heavily once you’ve seen clear signs of success. Want to launch a new project or business? Start with a small version — a test product, a pilot client, or a short campaign. Gather data, learn what works, and only then scale up with time, money, or full commitment. You avoid wasting time and resources on unproven ideas and build confidence based on evidence, not guesswork.
- Be Productively Paranoid. Always be aware that something could go wrong — and prepare for it in advance. Save a personal “buffer” fund or keep extra time in your schedule for the unexpected. Ask yourself regularly: “What’s the worst that could happen — and how would I handle it?” Use checklists, backups, and contingency plans to reduce risk exposure in your work and life. It doesn’t mean being fearful — it means being ready. You’re less likely to be blindsided and more likely to bounce back quickly.
Conclusion
So, what I’ve learned from the “Great by Choice” book is that it offers a powerful and practical blueprint for thriving in an unpredictable world. Through disciplined research and compelling case studies, Jim Collins and Morten T. Hansen show that greatness is not reserved for the lucky or the most innovative, but for those who make deliberate, consistent, and strategic choices — especially in the face of chaos.
The companies that outperformed their peers tenfold weren’t reckless or driven by ambition alone. Instead, they marched steadily toward their goals, tested ideas carefully before scaling, and constantly prepared for potential threats. These behaviors — embodied in the principles of fanatic discipline, empirical creativity, and productive paranoia — are not just corporate strategies, but are life lessons.
Author — Felix Davidenko
Join me on LinkedIn
