Your 4-year-old Isn’t Ignoring You
Your 4-year-old’s Brain Can’t Hold What You’re Shouting
One-Sentence Summary: When a three-to-five-year-old seems to ignore an instruction, the cause is usually a mind that can only carry a small amount at once, and an old narration about a distracted boy in Madinah points to the same calm, brief response that child development research supports.
It’s a Saturday, and the plan for the morning was simple enough to say in one breath. “Brush your teeth, put your shoes on, and wait by the car.”
Ten minutes later your daughter is still at the bathroom sink. The toothbrush is in her hand, paused somewhere near her chin, and she is studying the foam as it slides toward the plughole. She hasn’t touched a shoe. When you call her name, she looks up as if you’ve arrived from another country.
Most of us have a word ready for that look, and the word is usually “ignoring.” It comes quickly, and it brings a hot feeling with it. The second request is sharper than the first, and by the third there’s an edge in the voice that we recognise later, after bedtime, with a small knot of regret.
I’ve come to think that word is wrong far more often than it’s right. Not every time, but often enough that it’s worth questioning before the voice rises. What a preschooler does with an instruction depends heavily on what her brain can hold, and between three and five, that is less than we tend to assume.
A capacity still under construction
Researchers use the term executive function for the set of mental abilities a child draws on to keep an instruction in mind, move her attention from one thing to another, and hold back an impulse. [1] None of these arrive fully formed. They grow fast in the preschool years and are still developing in the teenage years and beyond, according to Harvard’s Center on the Developing Child. [1]
Children also differ. Some pick up these skills sooner, some later, and preschoolers who are further behind tend to show more of the behaviour adults find difficult. [2] That finding explains a pattern many families know well: a child who is settled and cooperative during a quiet afternoon at home can come undone in a crowded room full of relatives.
Now consider that Saturday instruction again. It contained three separate tasks, delivered in one sentence to a child whose attention was already half on the foam. Attention develops at different rates, and instructions with several steps are hard for most children this age to keep hold of. [3,1] By the time she registered “teeth,” the rest had slipped away.
Saying it louder doesn’t give her more room to store it. Tiredness and overwhelm leave even less room, which is when a young child most needs an adult’s steadiness to lean on.
A useful check before speaking, then, is whether the request would fit on a sticky note. “Teeth now” fits. So does “shoes next.” The Saturday sentence, with its three tasks and a waiting instruction on the end, would need the whole pad. Breaking it up feels slower in the moment, yet in practice it tends to get everyone to the car sooner, because each piece lands.
An errand, a street game, and a smile
The story that keeps returning to me whenever I think about this comes from Sahih Muslim. [4]
Anas ibn Malik served the Prophet ﷺ when he was a boy. One day he was sent on an errand, and his first reply was a flat refusal: “By Allah, I will not go.” Inwardly he meant to go all the same. On his way he passed some children playing in the street, and the errand went clean out of his head.
The Prophet ﷺ came up behind him and took hold of the back of his neck. Anas turned, and found him smiling. “Unays, did you go where I told you to go?” Anas replied that he was going. [4]
What stands out is everything the narration leaves out. There is no record of a scolding for the refusal, and nothing about the game being treated as disobedience. The opening is familiar, too: a flat “I won’t” followed by quiet compliance is a pattern any parent of a four-year-old will recognise, and the story treats the refusal as something that didn’t need a reply. A boy got distracted; the narration shows him being called by a softened form of his own name and asked one question that turned him back toward the task.
That is also, almost exactly, the response the research points toward for young children: a warm tone and one short cue about what comes next, rather than a lecture. [1,5] It’s rare to find a fourteen-century-old account that lines up this neatly with modern developmental science, and I find it reassuring.
What harsher correction costs
If short and warm works better, the obvious question is what happens when correction goes the other way.
The largest answer we have comes from a 2016 meta-analysis by Elizabeth Gershoff and Andrew Grogan-Kaylor, which pooled data on 160,927 children. Spanking was linked to a higher risk of harm in 13 of the 17 outcomes they examined, and it wasn’t linked to children becoming more compliant. [6] In other words, it tended to cost something while delivering none of the obedience parents hoped for.
The American Academy of Pediatrics recommends that parents not use physical punishment at all. [7] There is also a quieter cost that anyone who has been frightened of an adult will understand: a child who fears a parent finds it harder to accept that parent’s guidance. [5]
Warm, responsive parenting, together with plenty of positive attention for the behaviour a family wants to see, does better than harsh approaches. [7,8]
Reading the behaviour by what the child is missing
Once the “ignoring” label is set aside, a lot of preschool behaviour starts to make sense as a child running short of something. Sometimes it’s words. Sometimes it’s time to shift gears. Sometimes it’s experience.
Short on words
A four-year-old in the middle of a tantrum is often a child whose feelings have outrun her vocabulary. Paying attention to what she feels, and learning which situations tend to set her off, both help. [5] For most children, tantrums usually ease off after the fourth birthday. [3] While one is happening, a low voice and a patient wait usually do more than any argument. If a parent’s own temper starts to climb, stepping away for a moment and turning inwardly to Allah before speaking can change what comes out.
Fear sits close by. Worry about the dark, or about being separated from a parent, is common between three and five. A worried child may hold on tightly or need to be told again and again that all is well, and a few start steering clear of places that scare them. [3] Naming the fear plainly (“the dark feels scary right now”) without dismissing it, then encouraging small brave steps and noticing each one, is the approach child guidance specialists describe. [5]
Bedtime offers a natural place to bring Allah into those fears. A du’a for protection, said aloud in words the child can follow, lets her hear that frightening things are something a family brings to Allah together. When fears start to shrink a child’s everyday world, a doctor is the right next call.
A child who is being picked on at preschool is short on something too: confidence. Extra warmth at home helps, as does a conversation with staff about what they can do. So does hearing a parent say clearly that they will act to stop it. [5] At home, a parent can explain that teasing people and calling them names is wrong whoever is doing it, and that going to a trusted adult is the right thing to do.
Want to implement this, not just read it?
Everything above comes with a free Companion Pack — a printable that turns what you have just read into something you can do with your child this week. It costs nothing.
Short on time to switch
Young children tend to have energy left over at the end of almost any day, and sitting still for a long time is hard for them. [3] A child who is asked to sit calmly through a late-running appointment is being asked for something her body doesn’t yet have in reserve. Letting her run outside beforehand, and bringing a quiet activity, makes the wait easier on everyone. The same planning helps at the masjid, where sitting toward the back allows a restless child to step out without disturbing others.
Focus works on the same clock. One step at a time, with a pause in between, suits a preschool mind: socks first, then shoes once the socks are on. Longer or harder activities go better with short breaks built in. [3,1]
Transitions deserve their own mention. A child absorbed in play copes better when the change is signposted in advance, first with “we’ll be leaving soon,” then with a concrete count such as “two more turns on the swing.” [5] Two acceptable choices at that point (“walk to the car, or hop like a rabbit?”) give her some say while the adult keeps the decision that matters. [5]
If a child’s energy seems out of step with her age, or keeps her from joining in learning and play, it’s worth raising with a doctor.
Short on experience
Preschoolers ask questions constantly. A trip to the letterbox can stretch to twenty minutes because a snail has to be examined, and the questions (“Do worms have mouths? Why is the sky dark at night?”) pile up by lunchtime. [3] This curiosity is how young children work out what the world is.
Get GrowDeen Education’s stories in your inbox
Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.
Islam has a gentle precedent for using questions to teach. Sahih al-Bukhari records that fresh dates were brought to the Prophet ﷺ, and he told the people with him that among trees there is one that resembles a Muslim. Abdullah ibn Umar, the youngest person there, thought of the date palm but said nothing, because he was the youngest. The Prophet ﷺ then named it himself: the date palm. [9]
I like how ordinary that moment is. A question went round a gathering, and a boy was quietly working on the answer alongside grown men. Children’s questions can be given that same room. When a parent doesn’t know, “let’s find out together” is a fine answer, and questions about animals or the sky are an easy doorway to talking about the One who made them.
Shyness belongs here too, because it often comes from limited experience of new people. Many preschoolers warm up slowly, so staying close during the first visits to a new place helps. Praising small brave moments with people, like answering a new adult or returning a salam, and practising greetings through play at home also help. [5] Ibn Umar’s silence in that gathering is a reminder that holding back in front of older people is a very old feeling. The goal isn’t to turn a reserved child into a loud one. It’s to help her feel secure enough to say salam and take part when she’s ready.
Early lying is another sign of a mind gaining experience. First lies commonly appear at about three, and the behaviour is tied to growing thinking skills, such as realising that another person can hold a belief that isn’t true. [10] A calm response that keeps attention on honesty works better than alarm. Children also watch closely whether adults keep their word, so a promised game after Dhuhr is worth keeping.
That same growing mind wants to do things alone. Preschoolers grow in confidence when adults pay them kind attention and let them attempt things themselves, again and again. [3,5] So a plate carried to the table after Bismillah still counts even if a few peas fall, and a small prayer mat laid out at a slight angle beside a parent’s is still a prayer mat.
Habits such as thumb-sucking or nail-biting are usually no cause for alarm. They often comfort children, and most disappear with time. [3] If one does become a concern, a doctor can advise.
Finally, experience with other children takes time to accumulate. Arguments between young children are ordinary, and their frequency is shaped by temperament, setting, age and social skill. [11,5] Even shares of treats and a predictable order of turns prevent many of them, and giving a child a ready phrase (“May I have it after you?”) helps with the rest.
The longer view is reassuring. For most children, hitting and pushing reach their highest point in the toddler years and then drop away as the preschool years go on, and kind, helpful behaviour becomes more common. [11] Time at preschool and with cousins lets children rehearse sharing and waiting, and get used to following rules set by adults other than their parents, which helps later in school. [5] Some children need several weeks before a new class feels comfortable. Persisting is usually worthwhile, a word with the teacher helps if settling drags on, and a du’a made together on the way can make mornings feel steadier.
Home and masjid add their own practice. A small sadaqah jar by the door turns the idea of giving into something a child can do with her own hand, and a weekend Qur’an class for young children is, among other things, an hour of waiting for one’s turn to recite.
Small practices that make gentleness easier
Gentleness still takes effort, and it goes better with tools sized to a young child’s mind.
Family rules work best when they describe what to do. “In our house, Bismillah comes before food” and “gentle hands with the baby” are easier for a young child to follow than a list of prohibitions. [5] Routines do similar work by making the next step predictable and assigning jobs clearly. [5,8] For Muslim families, the prayer times supply a ready structure: tidying after Maghrib, teeth and du’a after Isha. Wudu can join that rhythm long before a child prays, simply by letting her wash her hands and face beside a parent at the sink.
Specific praise tells a child exactly what to repeat. “You shared your crayons with your cousin. That was kind, masha’Allah” carries far more information than “good girl.” [8] Small changes to the surroundings, such as moving a block tower away from a crawling baby, prevent many conflicts before they start. [5] The same thinking applies to screens, where choosing Islamically suitable, music-free, parent-approved content shapes what a child takes in.
When rules and reminders fall short, a mild consequence that clearly follows from the behaviour can help. If blocks are thrown, the blocks are put away for a while. Consequences land best in a home where a child mostly hears warmth and notices from her parents. [5,7]
And for instructions themselves, the practice is almost embarrassingly simple: crouch until your eyes meet hers, use her name, and ask for a single thing. [5]
The parent in the room
Guiding a preschooler is tiring, and some days leave nothing in the tank. Saying calmly how you feel, beginning with “I,” helps on those days: “I’m getting frustrated because it’s very noisy and I can’t hear the phone.” The child learns that her actions affect other people and has room to adjust, and she picks up words for feelings along the way. [5]
Patience is easier to find when a parent’s own needs are met. That sounds obvious, yet it is the first thing to slip in a busy week, and a parent running on four hours of sleep and a skipped lunch has far less to give at 6pm. The basics matter here: eating properly, moving, resting when possible, and speaking to oneself with the same kindness offered to the child. Children also do better when parents support each other. Research on co-parenting links stronger teamwork between parents with better emotion regulation and more helping behaviour in children. [12]
Talking openly with a spouse or close friend helps, and a trained counsellor is another good option. Du’a helps as well, made in one’s own words, as often as the heart reaches for it.
When it may be more than a phase
A doctor is worth consulting if worries or fears keep a child from ordinary daily life, if energy or attention difficulties make learning or play with others very hard, if tantrums become more frequent after age four instead of settling, or if a parent feels angry or stressed about how the child behaves on most days. This essay doesn’t replace medical advice, and a doctor’s guidance for a particular child comes first.
Back at the sink
The girl with the toothbrush was four, her mind had room for one thing, and the foam got there first.
Anas, distracted by a game in the street, was met with a smile and a single question. Most of us won’t manage that every Saturday. But knowing what a young child can carry makes it easier to try, and easier to forgive ourselves on the mornings we don’t.
May Allah grant every parent patience that grows with each of these small moments.
If this essay was useful, follow me here on Medium for more reflections on raising young children with research and the Qur’an and Sunnah in view.
References
[1] Center on the Developing Child at Harvard University. (2011). Building the brain’s “air traffic control” system: How early experiences shape the development of executive function (Working Paper №11).
[2] Kuhn, M., Boise, C., Marvin, C. A., & Knoche, L. L. (2021). Challenging behaviors and executive function in preschool-aged children: Relationships and implications for practice. Infants and Young Children, 34(1), 46–65.
[3] Sharma, A., Cockerill, H., & Sanctuary, L. (2021). Mary Sheridan’s from birth to five years: Children’s developmental progress (5th ed.). Routledge.
[4] Sahih Muslim 2310a, The Book of Virtues, narrated by Anas ibn Malik. Graded: Sahih.
[5] Porter, L. (2016). Young children’s behaviour: Guidance approaches for early childhood educators (4th ed.). Allen & Unwin.
[6] Gershoff, E. T., & Grogan-Kaylor, A. (2016). Spanking and child outcomes: Old controversies and new meta-analyses. Journal of Family Psychology, 30(4), 453–469.
[7] Sege, R. D., & Siegel, B. S. (2018). Effective discipline to raise healthy children. Pediatrics, 142(6), e20183112. American Academy of Pediatrics.
[8] Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Positive parenting tips: Preschoolers (3–5 years).
[9] Sahih al-Bukhari 72, Book of Knowledge, narrated by Abdullah ibn Umar. Graded: Sahih.
[10] Talwar, V., & Lee, K. (2008). Social and cognitive correlates of children’s lying behavior. Child Development, 79(4), 866–881.
[11] Jambon, M., Madigan, S., Plamondon, A., & Jenkins, J. M. (2019). Developmental trajectories of physical aggression and prosocial behavior in early childhood: Family antecedents and psychological correlates. Developmental Psychology, 55(6), 1211–1225.
[12] Pan, B., Wang, Y., Zhang, J., Wang, J., Xiao, B., & Li, Y. (2025). Parental co-parenting quality, children’s emotion regulation abilities, and prosocial behavior. BMC Psychology, 13(1), Article 635.
We combine scientific research with Qur’an and authentic Sunnah, and we cite our sources. Even so, this is general guidance and no substitute for a doctor who can examine your child.
