The Immigrant Paradox: Decoding the Success of Immigrant Children in America
Let’s take a trip back to the late 20th century, a time marked by unprecedented Central American migration to the United States.
From the twelve-year civil war in El Salvador to the tragic displacement caused by Hurricane Mitch in Honduras and Nicaragua, hundreds of thousands of migrants desperately fled north, seeking refuge from war, natural disasters, and economic devastation. By 2000, the Central American-born population in the U.S. skyrocketed from about 354,000 in 1980 to about 2,026,000.
Now, we fast forward to the next generation—the American-born children of these brave migrants. Given the socioeconomic challenges often faced by immigrants, one might anticipate that their children would achieve only modest socioeconomic advancements. But quite the opposite is true.
These American-born children are increasingly more likely to enroll in college, pursue employment or further education, and demonstrate lower rates of criminal activity compared to children of nonimmigrants. Nearly a third of students in higher education now are either immigrants themselves or children of immigrants. Among this group, Hispanics constituted approximately 20% of the student population as of 2020, with approximately 13.6% being of immigrant origin.
When many of these children experience lower familial resources, cultural disparities, and an increased likelihood of grappling with mental health challenges, how is this possible? This puzzling nature is what we call the Immigrant Paradox.
Amidst the backdrop of the Immigrant Paradox, we’ll delve into the stories of individuals who exemplify this phenomenon. We aim to unravel the intricate interplay between expectations and success and understand the nuanced complexities accompanying their success.
The Faces of the Paradox
In the heart of New Jersey, Ashley stands as an embodiment of the Immigrant Paradox.
Ashley garnered offers from several esteemed universities, including several Ivy League institutions, and has decided to attend Duke University on a full scholarship. She plans to become an immigration lawyer, significantly influenced by her parents’ background as Honduran immigrants and the recent immigration climate in the United States.
From a young age, my goal has been to become a lawyer. I became fixated on becoming an immigration lawyer as my parents became more open about our family’s struggles immigrating to the U.S. and seeing the extent of racism towards Hispanics in this country.
Years into practicing law, she hopes to establish her own law firm and inspire other Hispanic students to pursue careers in law.
Shifting our focus from the northeast to the south, Natalia is another meritorious high school senior from Austin, TX, with Mexican and Guatemalan roots. She will be attending Texas A&M University to pursue a degree in neuroscience, with aspirations to go to medical school and become a pediatric neurologist.
Some of the obstacles she faced early in her academic journey shaped her professional goals.
I started high school off on a really challenging note. My classes were completely virtual because of COVID, and during this time, I was diagnosed with migraines and Alice in Wonderland syndrome.
At the intersection of her struggles with these conditions and her desire to support others, Natalia developed a deep-seated interest in helping those facing similar neurological disorders. Despite the challenges placed upon her, she is on track to pursue the career she desires.
Pivoting our focus to a professional who has completed her educational endeavors, Vanesas is a Houstonian of Guatemalan and Salvadoran heritage. She is currently working in public accounting after a highly accomplished academic career. She attained her master’s degree from the University of Houston and completed her undergraduate studies in accounting at Texas A&M University.
With my social skills and having seen my dad run his own business, I always knew that business was the path for me. My love for math and desire to apply it to business led me to ultimately choose accounting.
With the stage now set for each of our interviewees, we embark on a journey to explore their insights and experiences within the dynamics of the Immigrant Paradox.
The Weight of Expectations
A closer look at the Immigrant Paradox reveals a vital commonality in the stories of immigrant children: parental expectations. This is the key ingredient, the driving force.
Ashley reflects on the influence of parental expectations in her academic journey.
My parents always told me that I could do whatever I dreamed of. Yet, the three career paths they often hoped I would pursue were law, the medical field, or engineering. They subconsciously put these jobs on me, and not going to college was never an option. Luckily, my interests fell into one of the career paths they wanted for me.
There was always a lot of pressure to do well in school. They would often ask me, “Why did you get an A- in this course and not an A+?” Constantly hearing this after beating myself up for finishing the marking period with a B made me feel like I wasn’t doing enough. This was often overwhelming. But I’m also thankful; it helped me aspire for more.
Natalia notes having similar experiences to Ashely.
My mother always wanted me to be a doctor, and even though I did too, not going to college wasn’t an option.
But for Natalia, the journey of pursuing her dreams was fraught with limiting beliefs imposed by her family, which often caused her to doubt her career choices.
My family often suggested pursuing a career path that wouldn’t take so long. They suggested I become a teacher or something like that so I could make money quickly. I sometimes felt this hindered my ability to pursue a career in the medical field since it would take about eight years.
Then, there were times when my family told me that Hispanics, let alone women, couldn’t become doctors. I understand they want what’s best for me and may have very limiting beliefs because of their background. But it’s sometimes challenging to tune out the discouraging voices. I’ve had to learn not to listen to everything they say.
Though expectations were still present, Natalia’s experience showcases a unique pressure that children of immigrants can often encounter: the need for expedient, seamless results. Coming from economically desperate situations, their parents often hope their children succeed quickly, meaning making money rapidly.
Economic desperation is a reality that Vanesas is no stranger to.
There were times when our electricity was cut, and we had to use candles for light. Other times, our gas supply was cut. At one point, we didn’t even have a car, and my dad had to drop me off at school on a bike. I remember telling him to drop me off a few blocks from the school so I could walk the rest.
Seeing this and knowing their undocumented status in the country at the time, going to school was something I just always knew I had to do. It was the least I could do.
In each of their stories, we find the presence of expectations in some form or another. These expectations, held by immigrants for their children, translate into relentless grit.
While the outcomes for our interviewees can speak for themselves, we find that their success stories are often intertwined with formidable challenges.
Navigating Cultural Disparities
On the journey to success, immigrant and first-generation children often experience feelings of alienation. This arises from navigating a culture vastly different from the one they grew up with at home, a contrast frequently underscored by factors such as physical appearance. As they ascend the social ladder, they may lack a direct connection to society at large, creating feelings of isolation or not belonging.
Both Ashley and Natalia experienced feelings of alienation that led to the repression of their cultural identities.
Get Irvin Ventura’s stories in your inbox
Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.
Ashley:
I started school in a predominantly white area, and the concept of racism never occurred to me. Kids in class often treated me differently. This led me to subconsciously wish I was white. I often wished my hair was straight and my skin tone was lighter.
It wasn’t until my sophomore year of high school, when I began to see other kids who looked like me, that I started appreciating my Hispanic heritage and embracing my ethnicity and features. I felt confident with my curly hair and skin tone, and I was no longer embarrassed when people asked if I spoke Spanish.
Natalia:
For the first 2–3 years of high school, I felt embarrassed to tell people I was Guatemalan. I noticed other students made fun of Guatemalans, purposely mispronouncing their last names and making fun of them. I even hid that I had another last name, Caxaj because I didn’t want people to know. It wasn’t until I found someone from the same culture in school that I felt more comfortable embracing it.
A critical commonality in Ashley and Natalia’s experiences is that they only felt comfortable embracing their heritage when they found others who shared their background. Unfortunately, this can become less common as these individuals ascend the social ladder. Vanesas reflects on this idea from her college experiences.
I remember the day I was sitting in my first undergrad accounting class. I was surrounded by all white men. I was in shock. There were moments I really felt the differences—like when I would work on group projects and didn’t understand any of the pop culture references my group members would make.
Then, when I would hear about my classmates' struggles, they were so different from mine. I would hear them complain about their parents lowering their allowance or something like that. This took some getting used to.
But I also knew that they weren't any better than me because I was sitting right there in the same classroom as them. I constantly reminded myself of this, and that’s how I empowered myself.
Cultural integration and assimilation are critical indicators of economic success. When individuals can build networks, establish relationships, and access resources, they are more likely to have better job prospects, higher wages, and overall economic stability.
In order to attain a certain level of economic success, immigrant and first-generation children inherently have to blend their cultural background with the customs and practices of their new host culture. Navigating this process can be emotionally overwhelming.
Such a process often entails letting go of parts of one’s identity, whether partially or entirely, to achieve success that serves the best interests of oneself and one’s family. They often have to make conscious or unconscious choices about what values and customs to preserve, which to modify, or outright abandon.
With the backdrop of expectations and cultural disparities, one might ponder the impact that these experiences have on the mental health of immigrant and first-generation children.
The Hidden Struggles of the Paradox
Though they achieve such success, a closer look at the Immigrant Paradox reveals that children of immigrants tend to show higher rates of psychological distress than those of their first-generation immigrant parents. But what drives this outcome? Each of our interviewees had their own insights.
Ashley:
Throughout high school, I struggled a lot with my mental health. Whether it was because of my grades, appearance, relationships, or I was worn out. I always felt like I had no real reason to be upset. My parents sacrificed everything for me, yet sometimes, I just wanted to stay home from school, be by myself, and deal with my emotions.
I’ve often felt that my feelings are invalid and that I shouldn’t dwell on situations that hurt me. This makes it hard for me to express how I feel because I fear being perceived as ungrateful or bratty.
Natalia:
Freshman year was the hardest, mainly due to my health. Dealing with school, caring for my siblings, and my health was a big challenge. I became extremely stressed because of the pressures for success that were placed upon me. My grades began to slip. I became very depressed. I didn’t know what to do. Based on my grades that year, I didn’t think I would ever succeed. I failed two classes, with my highest grade being a 70.
Vanesas:
In my professional career, mental health continues to be my biggest challenge. A lot of this comes from a lack of support I often feel at work.
There have been numerous times when I was given a task with vague instructions and a short deadline. When I cannot complete something successfully, I am often told things like ‘I don’t need people like you on my team’ or have been threatened with being taken off a project. The mentorship and guidance I need aren’t there. And the culture isn’t very forgiving.
I’ve cried so many times, which was especially hard for my parents because they had no idea how to help me. But it has also brought us closer together.
They are beside me, navigating this challenging new chapter of my life. We are taking it one day, one experience at a time, and growing from it together. As they sacrificed so much for me, there are some sacrifices I have to make for future generations.
As Vanesas points out, many of the challenges faced by children of immigrants are exacerbated by the fact that they don’t have parents who understand the challenges they are facing. They are often the first in their family to go to college or work a white-collar job, lacking a strong support system or generational context.
As Natalia pointed out, they often hold multifaceted identities. They often have to play the roles of caretaker, employee, student, and cultural/language broker all at once. This abundance of responsibilities can result in neglect of personal well-being, leading to feelings of hopelessness, depression, and/or anxiety with no end in sight.
The expectation to remain emotionally intact while fulfilling these various roles places endless demands on them as functional members of society.
And as Ashley points out, many children of immigrants believe that their mental health struggles are trivial compared to what their parents went through. This makes it difficult for them to seek help, and by the time (if) they do, there’s a chance their mental health issues have escalated significantly.
The cumulative impact of these challenges creates a complex and emotionally strenuous experience for children of immigrants.
But as we observe this phenomenon further, we unravel another truth. The children of the Immigrant Paradox withstand many pressures and experience moments of deep discomfort and even pain, but through this, they are the pioneers of something beautiful.
Retaking a trip to the past, just one generation ago, the parents of these children found themselves trapped in deep tragedy. In seemingly hopeless situations, they found the strength to endure the traumas that influenced their migration and to abandon everything they knew and loved.
As we witness the generation that blossomed from this pain and sacrifice, we meet children freeing their families from the strains of poverty, navigating a deeply perplexing experience, and changing the course for future generations. To be the first in their bloodline to be a doctor, lawyer, or accountant is quite literally changing what’s possible.
Understanding their impact can be elusive for these individuals. The burdens of pressure, stress, depression, anxiety, and fatigue can distort their self-perception; it can be difficult for them to see the transformative powers they embody.
The immigrant spirit holds remarkable beauty, even when accompanied by relentless pain. Even if the overwhelming parental expectations placed upon these children can have adverse side effects, a profoundly intricate truth of the human condition is that no life worth living and crafting comes without difficulties, pain, and tears.
In the words of Elisabeth Kübler-Ross, “The most beautiful people we have known are those who have known defeat, known suffering, known struggle, known loss, and have found their way out of the depths.”
The children of the Immigrant Paradox epitomize this sentiment. They embody humanity’s capacity for growth, compassion, and love.
Pondering the Paradox’s Influence on Future Dynamics
The stories of our interviewees and the Immigrant Paradox at large raise intriguing questions about the potential impact children of immigrants will have on the workforce, mainly in white-collar professions.
As individuals like Ashely, Natalia, and Vanesas enter white-collar occupations and infuse their beliefs, ideas, experiences, and moral attitudes into their work, it raises compelling questions: How will this impact workforces?
As these individuals become managers, directors, and partners at scale, will this transform workplace norms? Could they bring new perspectives and better practices into these spaces? How does this change the collective consciousness of a region?
When we hear about issues like discrimination, work-life balance, and poor leadership in professional occupations, one might ask: Could the children of immigrants be the answer to many of these issues?
Ultimately, the answer to these questions could shape the future landscape of the workforce, offering either an optimistic vision of progress where certain unhealthy practices are eradicated or a more pessimistic outlook characterized by entrenched conformity and suppression of their cultural identities.
While there are certainly external factors that could inhibit the positive trends we are seeing, mainly the rising cost of colleges and universities, recent changes to the Free Application for Federal Student Aid (FAFSA) that primarily benefit low-income students support an optimistic vision.
With the resilience shown thus far by individuals like Ashley, Natalia, and Vanesas, we can remain hopeful that workforces will continue to become more diverse, inclusive, and equitable.
They may not be able to do it alone, but as we continue to see children of immigrants go to college and enter professional occupations, collectively, they will inevitably bring their diverse perspectives, cultural intelligence, and compassion.
And if you’re reading this, and you’re the child of an immigrant, I’m talking to you too.
With their futures in your hands, cultivating optimism becomes less daunting.
I hope you enjoyed this piece as much as I enjoyed writing it (especially interviewing these awesome people). 🙂
If you want to fund my caffeine addiction so I can continue to write, consider buying me a coffee. ☕
Thanks always for your continued support.
