Confessions of a Creative Fraud: The Audacity to Continue
Two years, countless ideas, and one very persistent impostor syndrome later.
Two years ago, I wrote an article confessing to being a creative fraud. It was a rather dramatic admission, if you ask me. There I was, a grown man with a functioning brain, a keyboard, and a reasonable command of the English language, publicly declaring that I might have fooled everyone into believing I was creative.
I wrote about the sleepless nights, the blank screens, the frustrating search for ideas, and that annoying little voice that always seemed to know exactly when to remind me that I wasn’t as good as I thought I was.
I ended that article on a rather hopeful note. Something about trusting the process, embracing the journey, and continuing to write. Beautiful stuff, really.
You would think that after two years, several more briefs, countless words, and a few more battles with the blinking cursor, I’d have finally made peace with that voice.
Well, dear reader, I have some unfortunate news. The fraud is still here!! Except, lately, I’ve been wondering whether I’ve been accusing the wrong person of the wrong crime.
Perhaps I was never a fraud. Perhaps I was just afraid. And perhaps, for reasons I am only beginning to understand, I found it easier to question my talent than to confront my fear.
The Curious Case of the Creative Who Doesn’t Believe He’s Creative
There’s something rather peculiar about being a creative. You can spend years learning your craft, working on briefs, writing lines, developing concepts, and occasionally producing something that makes you sit back and think, “Ei, so I actually wrote this?”
Yet, somehow, all that evidence can disappear the moment you’re confronted with a new challenge. A blank page has an extraordinary ability to humble a person. It doesn’t care about your previous work. It doesn’t care about the ideas that received applause, the campaigns that went live, or the compliments you’ve carefully stored somewhere in your memory for emergencies.
It simply sits there. Blank. Waiting…
And suddenly, you’re questioning whether everything you’ve ever written was an elaborate accident. I used to think this feeling meant I wasn’t good enough. That perhaps the people who genuinely belonged in this industry approached every brief with the confidence of a prophet receiving divine revelation.
Surely, the great creatives didn’t struggle like this. Surely, their ideas arrived fully formed, dressed in beautiful language, ready to be presented to clients who immediately fell in love with them. Then I began to realise something. Maybe the people I admired were just as uncertain as I was.
Maybe the difference wasn’t that they had conquered fear, but that they had learned to create in its presence. And perhaps I’d spent too much time measuring my abilities against an imaginary version of other people’s creative processes.
An imaginary version in which everyone was brilliant, everyone was confident, and nobody ever spent forty-five minutes trying to write a headline that didn’t sound like something they’d seen on a billboard in 2013.
Maybe It Was Never About Talent.
I’ve been thinking about the word fraud lately. It’s a rather serious accusation, isn’t it? A fraud is someone who deliberately deceives others. Someone who knowingly presents themselves as something they’re not.
But what exactly was my deception? Was it accepting a creative brief despite not knowing immediately how to solve it? Was it presenting an idea while secretly wondering whether it was good enough? Was it calling myself a writer even though there were days when writing felt about as enjoyable as trying to open a stubborn sachet of water with wet hands?
If those are the qualifications for fraudulence, then the creative industry must be one very elaborate criminal enterprise. The more I think about it, the more I suspect that what I called impostor syndrome was sometimes simply fear wearing an unnecessarily expensive suit.
Fear of being judged. Fear of disappointing people who believe in my abilities. Fear of discovering that the brilliant idea I was so excited about was, in fact, not particularly brilliant. And perhaps most uncomfortable of all, the fear of trying my absolute best and finding out that my best wasn’t enough.
There’s a certain protection in convincing yourself that you’re not particularly talented. Think about it.
If you already believe you’re a fraud, rejection becomes confirmation rather than surprise. A failed idea doesn’t challenge your understanding of yourself. It simply reinforces what you’ve been telling yourself all along.
But believing that you might actually be good at something?
Now, that’s terrifying. Because it means allowing yourself to care about the outcome. It means accepting that your work deserves to be seen, challenged, celebrated, or rejected on its own merits. It means giving yourself permission to succeed without first preparing an elaborate explanation for why you don’t deserve it.
Get Jeffrey Fosu Addae’s stories in your inbox
Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.
And, for someone who has become rather comfortable with self-doubt, that can feel like an outrageous amount of responsibility.
The Strange Comfort of Self-Doubt
I think there’s a point where self-doubt stops being an occasional visitor and becomes a rather comfortable roommate. You get used to its presence.
You know exactly what it’s going to say when you start a new project. You can almost predict its commentary when you see someone else’s brilliant work.
“Why didn’t you think of that?”
“Are you sure you’re cut out for this?”
“Maybe you’ve finally run out of ideas.”
At some point, the voice becomes so familiar that you stop questioning whether it’s telling the truth. You simply accept it as part of your personality. I wonder how many opportunities I’ve approached with that voice already narrating the ending.
How many ideas I’ve abandoned before giving them a proper chance. How many times I’ve mistaken an imperfect first attempt for evidence of a fundamental lack of ability. And how often I’ve disguised fear as humility. Because there’s a difference between knowing you have room to improve and believing that you have no business being in the room in the first place. One encourages growth. The other makes you apologise for existing. I’ve spent a considerable amount of time confusing the two.
The Audacity to Believe You Belong
There’s a particular kind of courage required to create something and put it into the world. Not the dramatic, cinematic kind of courage that comes with a stirring soundtrack and a slow-motion walk into the sunset. I’m talking about the ordinary, unglamorous courage of submitting an idea you’re not entirely sure about.
Of sharing a piece of writing that reveals a little too much of yourself. Of presenting work to people whose opinions matter to you, knowing perfectly well that they might not like it. Of beginning again after something you’ve poured yourself into doesn’t work.
For a long time, I thought confidence was supposed to come before all of that. That one day, after enough experience and enough validation, I’d finally arrive at some magical level of creative certainty.
I would wake up, open my laptop, and the ideas would simply flow. No hesitation. No comparison. No internal tribunal questioning my qualifications. Just me and my extraordinary genius. A lovely fantasy.
Unfortunately, reality has refused to cooperate. What I’m beginning to understand is that perhaps confidence isn’t always something you acquire before taking action. Sometimes, it is something you build by acting despite its absence.
And sometimes, you don’t even become particularly confident. You simply become less willing to let fear make all your decisions. I still don’t know whether every idea I develop will work. I still have moments when another creative’s brilliance makes me question whether I accidentally wandered into the wrong profession.
But I’m learning that someone else’s talent is not evidence of my inadequacy. That a rejected idea is not a rejected identity. And that struggling to create something worthwhile doesn’t automatically mean I lack the ability to create it.
These sound like fairly obvious conclusions, I know. But there’s a remarkable distance between understanding something intellectually and actually believing it when you’re staring at a brief with a deadline that is approaching at an unnecessarily aggressive speed.
So, Was I Ever Really a Fraud?
I wish I could tell you that I’ve reached a grand conclusion. That after two years of reflection, I’ve finally silenced the voice in my head and emerged as a fearless creative who approaches every challenge with unwavering confidence.
I haven’t. The voice still shows up. Sometimes at 1 a.m., just as it did two years ago. Sometimes in the middle of a perfectly ordinary working day. Sometimes immediately after I’ve done something I’m genuinely proud of. But I’ve started asking it a different question.
Instead of asking, “What if they’re right and I’m not good enough?” I’m learning to ask, “What if I’m simply afraid of finding out how good I could become?”
It’s a small shift, but an important one. Because the first question assumes that the verdict has already been delivered. The second leaves room for possibility. And perhaps that’s what I’ve been missing all this time.
Not talent. Not ideas. Not some secret creative formula that everyone else received during orientation while I was apparently absent. Just the willingness to give myself a chance without demanding absolute certainty that I’ll succeed.
Two years ago, I confessed to being a creative fraud. Today, I’m beginning to suspect that I may have been a little too quick to convict myself. Maybe I wasn’t pretending to be a creative. Maybe I was simply a creative who was terrified of not being a good one. And maybe the real audacity isn’t continuing despite believing you’re a fraud. Maybe it’s daring to believe that you never were one.
I don’t know if I’ve completely arrived at that belief yet. But I’m willing to find out. And for now, that seems like a good enough reason to keep writing.
