The Front Door
It is late morning, just got off the crowded subway and the security person at China’s Ministry of Education told me they close at 11:30 for lunch. It was already past 11 and I had been trying to get into this building for three weeks.
He asked if I wanted to wait until after lunch or go now. I chose the latter. He then asked if I needed help finding the right office. I said yes, and boy, am I glad I did, because we went down passages and alleyways I would never have found on my own, past maintenance doors and service corridors, until we reached the letters office.
You see, I am an American, with no Chinese ancestry, and I was standing inside a Chinese government ministry, about to hand over a strategic plan I had spent months building. Two staff members were in the room. I explained what I was delivering. They took it, walked it to a supervisor, and came back with a message. The ministry would receive it, and if they had questions, they would contact me by phone or WeChat, even if I left the country.
They were perplexed. Not suspicious, but genuinely confused. They asked me three separate times why I was giving the strategic plan away for free.
I told them I valued China, and I wanted to help rural communities meet global English standards, and I considered the end product to be too valuable to charge for rural China. This is a Chinese concept of Guanxi, basically the concept of mutually beneficial relationships.
Three Weeks of Closed Doors
Getting to that room took longer than building the plan.
My first stop was the government affairs office. I went five times and by the end, the staff knew me by name. They wanted to help, and they tried. But they had no direct line to the Ministry of Education and no way to put me in front of anyone who mattered. Each visit, they sent me back to the same person at the startup alliance.
The startup alliance founder. He was polite and connected in his own world, but his world did not touch the ministry’s decision makers. He could not open the door, and after a few attempts it was clear this path too, was closed.
I asked AI how to get in. It told me, in plain terms, that walking through the front door was not possible. That I needed to go through proper channels. That unsolicited submissions are not accepted and I would be turned away.
So, now what. I have a vision, I have the plan, but no way to execute it in a foreign country. This was what I faced for three straight weeks, door after door, being closed. However, AI got it wrong on multiple fronts.
Get James Keogh’s stories in your inbox
Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.
By the time I gave up on the indirect routes, I had one asset. A direct phone number to the chief of foreign talent, earned by showing up in person enough times that someone finally decided I was serious. That number did not get me a meeting either. But it told me the building was real, and it was reachable, and I was going to find the way in.
What the Plan Actually Was
I am not going to describe the strategic plan in detail. Some of it is still live, and I have no interest in undermining work that might still be useful.
What I will say is this. It was built for the Ministry of Education’s own stated priorities, expanding English education and reducing inequality between urban and rural schools. The core was a classroom level approach to closing that gap, and the market analysis pegged the value of the work in the hundreds of millions of yuan.
I built it on my own. I built it because I believed it was worth building, and I believed I was supposed to build it.
What I Learned
Three things.
The first is that China’s government is not the monolith Western media sells. The people I dealt with, the security guard, the government affairs staff, the ministry employees, were patient, curious, and generous with their time. They had jobs to do and rules to follow, and within those limits they went out of their way to help a foreigner who showed up unannounced and asked for a door.
The second is that the front door is almost always the answer. Every intermediary I tried was a filter, and filters kill unsolicited work. The ministry did not need a broker. It needed a person standing in the right hallway at the right time.
The third is that not everything valuable has a price attached. When the ministry staff asked me three times why I was giving the plan away, I gave them an answer about rural schools and global standards. That answer was true. But the deeper truth is that I had been told to give it away, and I obeyed, even when it meant walking out of that building with nothing but a handshake and a promise to be contacted if they had questions.
I have no idea whether the plan will ever be used. I got no name card, no email, no confirmation number. I walked back to my hotel with nothing I could point to.
What I do have is the memory of a security guard who could have pointed me to the lobby and instead walked me through the back hallways of a government ministry to make sure I found the right office.
That is the China I know.
