Beyonce — 16 Carriages | Analyrical Content
Below you will find the complete lyrics to the song 16 Carriages. Then I will post an image. After the image will be an analytical lyrical (analyrical) analysis of the song with some additional commentary. Her lyrics will be in bold in the second section, and the commentary will look like this.
Lyrics:
Sixteen carriages drivin’ away
While I watch them ride with my dreams away
To the summer sunset on a holy night
On a long black road, all the tears I fight
Sixteen carriages drivin’ away
While I watch them ride with my dreams away
To the summer sunset on a holy night
On a long black road, all the tears I fight
At fifteen, the innocence was gone astray
Had to leave my home at an early age
I saw Mama prayin’, I saw Daddy grind
All my tender problems, had to leave behind
It’s been umpteen summers and I’m not in my bed
On the back of the bus and a bunk with the band
Goin’ so hard, gotta choose myself
Underpaid and overwhelmed
I might cook, clean, but still won’t fold
Still workin’ on my life, you know
Only God knows, only God knows
Only God knows
Sixteen carriages drivin’ away
While I watch them ride with my fears away
To the summer sunset on a holy night
On a long back road, all the tears I fight
Sixteen carriages drivin’ away
While I watch them ride with my fears away
To the summer sunset on a holy night
On a long back road, all the tears I fight
Sixteen dollars, workin’ all day
Ain’t got time to waste, I got art to make
I got love to create on this holy night
They won’t dim my light, all these years I fight
It’s been thirty-eight summers and I’m not in my bed
On the back of the bus and a bunk with the band
Goin’ so hard, now I miss my kids
Overworked and overwhelmed
I might cook, clean, but still won’t fold
Still workin’ on my life, you know
Only God knows, only God knows
Only God knows
Sixteen carriages driving away
While I watch them ride with my fears away
To the summer sunset on a holy night
On a long back road, all the tears I fight
Sixteen carriages driving away
While I watch them ride with my fears away
To the summer sunset on a holy night
On a long back road, all these tears I fight
Ooh, ooh
Ooh
At fifteen, the innocence was gone astray
Had to take care of home at an early age
I saw Mama cryin’, I saw Daddy lyin’
Had to sacrifice and leave my fears behind
The legacy, if it’s the last thing I do
You’ll remember me ’cause we got somethin’ to prove
In your memory, on a highway to truth
Still see our faces when you close your eyes
Sixteen carriages drivin’ away
While I watch them ride with my dreams away
Sixteen carriages drivin’ away
While I watch them ride with my dreams away
To the summer sunset on a holy night
On a long black road, all the tears I fight (x2)
I believe that carriages symbolize years. She opens the songs talking about how life was on that “holy night” at age 16. And at this point she watched her 16 years of dreams drive away on a long black road.
In the second line, she has nice internal rhyming with the “i” sound and some alliteration with the “w’s”.
She uses a lot of “distant” language by repeating “away” twice and using the word “long” to depict a journey. And she ends by saying she’s fighting her tears meaning she’s not showing them or letting them fall. She’s persisting.
At fifteen, the innocence was gone astray
Had to leave my home at an early age
I saw Mama prayin’, I saw Daddy grind
All my tender problems, had to leave behind
She goes back to the year before at age 15. And this was before her dreams went away, at this age her innocence left. Also, she is heading into the past tense with the word “was”. Everything else was written in the present tense, giving the listener more background information.
She compares her parents' reaction to life, mom prays and dad grinds.
Nice oxymoron in the last sentence to show some contrast. She calls her problems tender because in hindsight they weren’t that big of a deal. And she left these problems behind not knowing there would be bigger problems coming.
It’s been umpteen summers and I’m not in my bed
On the back of the bus and a bunk with the band
Goin’ so hard, gotta choose myself
Underpaid and overwhelmed
I might cook, clean, but still won’t fold
Still workin’ on my life, you know
Only God knows, only God knows
Only God knows
We’re now 4 stanzas deep into the song and she’s keeping this theme of “years”: Sixteen carriages, at 15, and an uncountable amount of summers. This is why I believe the carriages are literal and symbolic at the same time.
The next line has nice alliteration with the letter “b” as in “Beyonce”.
Next 2 lines: She’s going hard and is underpaid. She is overwhelmed because she's not choosing herself. But her husband is a billionaire. She’s a millionaire. How is she underpaid?
In comparison to the amount of work she puts in and how hard she performs, she doesn’t get as much as other people remaining underpaid in compliments/acknowledments but also money.
In the 5th line. Fold has a double meaning, as in laundry, or fold as in crumble or compromise morals. But I’m led to think it's a moral thing because she mentions god right after.
In the following line she says “you know” as in “you can understand me”, but only god knows me. What we see from Beyonce is a hard-working woman, but only god knows what her life is like and the ways she has had to maintain her morals and not “fold”.
Sixteen carriages drivin’ away
While I watch them ride with my fears away
To the summer sunset on a holy night
On a long back road, all the tears I fight
Sixteen carriages drivin’ away
While I watch them ride with my fears away
To the summer sunset on a holy night
On a long back road, all the tears I fight
This is what I got when I asked ChatGPT how old was beyonce when she joined Destiny’s Child and what she was doing in 1997.
“They were signed to Columbia Records in 1997 as Destiny’s Child. In 1997, Beyoncé Giselle Knowles-Carter was 16 years old. During that pivotal year, she and her fellow bandmates released their debut self-titled album as Destiny’s Child, which marked the beginning of their journey to recognition in the music industry”.
So this pushes me to believe that the carriages also represent years.
Next line. She switches out fears with dreams. Both of them heading in the same direction and being taken away from her. One of the things that happens when you grow up is to show less fear, especially when you’re in an industry as a black woman in the 90’s.
Sixteen dollars, workin’ all day
Ain’t got time to waste, I got art to make
I got love to create on this holy night
They won’t dim my light, all these years I fight
$16 aint shit. But she’s willing to work hard all day to make art, even for this little amount of money. Hinting at the fact that money isn’t a motivating factor for her.
She makes art. She’s an artist. A very interesting word choice to compare what she does to other people. She is a great artist, which needs vision & creativity.
Get Keván the Copywriter’s stories in your inbox
Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.
3rd line. This could mean many things. But I think she’s comparing art to love. The nights that she spends in her creative moments are holy nights. And for Beyonce art = love.
Last line. The haters won't dim her light. But neither will the competition because they can’t keep up. Likely she is referring to her competition because of the word “fight” at the end here. She also switches out “tears” with “years” now and she’s fighting or persisting.
*** This has been added post-upload. It has been brought to my attention by my partner that Beyonce’s competition knows that they can’t compete with Beyonce. Example. Doja Cat, Taylor Swift, Drake, Justin Beiber etc. None of them can compete with Beyonce and they know it. So Beyonce’s competition that she is fighting would not be people, but rather a “system” that already exists that she is trying to break. When you Google top artists, Beyonce who is a complete artist in all ways doesn’t appear to be number one in a lot of spaces where she clearly deserves to be number one. Especially as a performer. No one performs like her.
It’s been thirty-eight summers and I’m not in my bed
On the back of the bus and a bunk with the band
Goin’ so hard, now I miss my kids
Overworked and overwhelmed
I might cook, clean, but still won’t fold
Still workin’ on my life, you know
Only God knows, only God knows
This first line could be a hyperbole. But also I’m leaning to think it’s a literal 38 years that she has been working (since the age of 4). Throughout the song, she highlights her past and hasn’t exaggerated once which leads me to think that since the age of 4, she has been working. Hence the “overworked” line.
Next line. She spends her life on the road traveling. Never at home. Beyonce has no home and hasn’t had one since she was young because she chose to pursue art. Which is really sad.
Next two lines. Her desire to create art is so strong that she’s been putting it ahead of her family to the point where she misses her kids and perhaps feels a little regret because she’s overworked. So she’s overworking herself and willing to miss out on her kids' lives or stating that someone is overworking her and she’s upset that she’s missing out on her kids’ lives because of them.
Next line. Working on her “life” kind of changes meanings now. I believe this also refers to art because art is her life. It’s how she spends her time and what gives her life.
Sixteen carriages driving away
While I watch them ride with my fears away
To the summer sunset on a holy night
On a long back road, all the tears I fight
Sixteen carriages driving away
While I watch them ride with my fears away
To the summer sunset on a holy night
On a long back road, all these tears I fight
This is a repeat. So let's jump to the last word “fight”. After getting to the end of the song, this may also mean she’s fighting back tears of joy. Because maybe she feels like she hasn’t made it yet, and she’s waiting for this final moment to be able to cry and say “I did it”. The tears could come from a lot of different places because she mentions a lot of emotionally heavy things in this song, but seeing that the theme is her career I believe these tears are related to her success in some way.
At fifteen, the innocence was gone astray
Had to take care of home at an early age
I saw Mama cryin’, I saw Daddy lyin’
Had to sacrifice and leave my fears behind
The legacy, if it’s the last thing I do
You’ll remember me ’cause we got somethin’ to prove
In your memory, on a highway to truth
Still see our faces when you close your eyes
I’m not sure what “innocence” means here for her but it’s safe to say it includes all childlike mentalities or naiveness.
Home = Family. Parents and Solange, and at age 15 she had to take on emotional responsibilities. Assuming her dad cheated on her mom and broke the family unit apart
This line could play into how the parents got along together and how they responded to each other. This could be interpreted as how mom & dad react to life. Or how they interact with each other. The mom may naturally cry or just cry when her husband lies to her. Or the dad could naturally lie or lie when he sees his wife crying.
Next line. What did she sacrifice? Well, she did just state that she misses her kids so that could be one thing. The fear of “not being a good and active mom” was a fear that she was willing to leave behind. She sacrificed having a normal life because she is now Beyonce, no one treats her like a regular person. But this is also what she wanted.
Next line. The most important thing to her is her legacy. This is evident in this song and in her actions as an artist. And she will pursue it until her death. She wants to go down in history as one of the greatest.
Next line. Interesting switch from “me” to “we”. This “we” could mean the black community or it could refer to the immediate community that has supported her through her entire journey like her family. She makes a lot of music for black people and makes a lot of music including her family and extended family. So it really could be both. But I’m leaning more towards family based on how she ends this verse.
Next line. There is a quote here. And I believe she’s quoting herself now for future people to be able to pinpoint this transitional moment. So in a few years looking back and listening to this song these words will have been realized. This is a stretch, but IDK what else she could be quoting here.
Current line & next line. She’s now speaking directly to the audience at the end. And she wants it clear that when you look at things truthfully you will remember her work as an artist because she has put in a lot of effort to the point that anyone should be able to acknowledge her achievements.
Last line. This makes me think “our” faces refer to her and her family, hence the word “legacy”. We all know Beyonce is preparing her daughter, Blue, for success and to be the next Beyonce.
Sixteen carriages drivin’ away
While I watch them ride with my dreams away
Now this changes the meaning a little at the end. With all of the context now known/assumed. Her dreams aren’t being taken away. She’s now watching these 16 carriages ride ahead, and she sees her dreams ahead of her going, but she’s following right behind and watching everything unfold.
At the moment she has already hit huge success, and she is clearly not done chasing her dreams, but she’s letting us know she has had to make sacrifices to produce this music for our entertainment, but also to go down in history with her peeps.
Literary devices
I like how the carriages hold a double meaning, I liked “tender problems”, and I enjoyed her use of clear/vague numbers. Overall, not too many devices that actually stand out.
Tones of voice
This song felt very ambitious and positive with a “never-give-up” energy. She mentions god & holy nights a lot. She mentions a long road that she’s on and how she has remained persistent and consistent. And homegirl has been relevant for 3 decades. So kudos to her.
Continuity, logic, story & theme
She stayed on topic the whole time and pretty much started the story in the present, took us to the past, and then gave us some details, and then told us what she expects for the future. I’d give this part a 10/10.
Creative moments
Nothing really stood out as being overly creative. I liked the word “umpteen” as we don’t hear it too much in music. Now that I think about it this line “On the back of the bus and a bunk with the band” could also refer to being with Destiny’s child. And just like this sentence, the “B” stands out in her band. If you know what I mean.
Vocal performance/ Execution of words
It’s Beyonce. The vocals will always be flawless.
Flow(s)
For a country song, she switches up the flow nicely several times.
Pronunciation
Crystal clear and clean
Relation to the Artist’s image (marketing)
So now she’s in her country era. And this song really shows it. She’s making waves and trying to go down in history. And she’s an artist which means she has some grand master plan in store ready to be released. This song is pretty on-brand for Beyonce. But I didn’t expect her to mention her not feeling like a good mom because she’s chasing these 16 carriages.
Relation to Artist’s personal life & growth
IDK her personal life. No one does. Beyonce keeps her life private.
How it fits in with the theme of the album (is there even a theme)
IDK yet. But I’m excited for it to drop on March 29th.
Are there areas for improvement?
The lyrics could be better. But again, she’s an artist so I can’t judge this song without hearing the whole album because maybe it ties into some other songs that she has on the upcoming album.
Who is the target audience and who is the speaker?
IDK if this will be a country album. She said, “This ain't a country album, this is a Beyonce album”. Which is nice. But on some real shit, this will be a country album, no matter how you try to present it. Unless she does something really new and creates a sub-genre within country. Which I doubt because she would get so much pushback. But she’s also trying to go down in history so it may be that she’s creating something new within country. The target audience is her existing fans
