Sitemap

Same Storm; Different Boat

4 min readApr 20, 2020

--

There’s a beautiful piece of writing (and derivatives of it) circulating now, which uses a spin on the “we’re-all-in-the-same-boat” metaphor as a call for compassion. The brilliant twist is the assertion that: We’re NOT in the same boat…even if we are in the same storm.

Everyone’s circumstances are different. For some of us, isolation might be a lovely time to reconnect, clean the house and get things done. For others, it’s a major or minor inconvenience. And for some people, the current circumstances may actually threaten their physical and mental health as much or more than the virus itself. The trickle-down effects are, and will continue to take an enormous toll and shouldn’t be missed or minimized.

I know for sure that fear makes us all a little crazy. That’s human nature! Our nervous systems freak out. The amygdala gets activated and we rush to find some ground to stand on: statistics, experts with certainty, mathematical models we can verify and then send around to make sure everyone else is on the same page…because we’re all in the same boat, right!? But the truth is that we’re not all in the same boat. There’s just not enough room there.

Our circumstances are varied. Death may be our greatest, shared, instinctively-based existential fear, and exactly what you want to avoid. But it’s really only one part of the equation. Because the storm isn’t just a virus, or the possible overwhelm of the medical system, or closer proximity to death!

pc: Pat LaCroix; Kew Beach, Toronto, Canada 2020

The storm is also devastating emotional isolation, the long-term impact that lack of physical contact has on developing psyches, elders dying alone, families split apart, unsafe physical environments that are far from “shelters”, mental health breakdowns, economic instability, an increase in impoverishment, exposure to more violence…and probably 20 more situations I haven’t thought of.

This weekend, I stayed in bed because I couldn’t think of a reason to get up. I haven’t touched another living creature besides my kids (which is also rare) in close to six weeks, and I haven’t seen a friend in 3D for almost three.

So, if I, with my privilege and resources, am experiencing down-heartedness and depression, I can only imagine the pain and suffering others must be facing. I mean, I have a good mindset practice, technology, the ability to virtually connect with friends and loved ones, interests, things to engage with, work to do, plants to grow, enough food to eat, health, and so much more! What two days in bed gave me was a tiny, but visceral insight into how much greater suffering there is out there right now.

Get Lisa Betts-LaCroix’s stories in your inbox

Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.

And because the human experience is complex and multi-faceted and filled with paradox, the truth is that our protection, our solutions are keeping some of us safe and taking other people down.

So am I saying don’t isolate or suggesting that we should break the quarantine? God, no! Not at all. It’s the only thing we can do right now, as far as I can tell. COVID-19 is bad. Even if you don’t die from (which you probably won’t statistically speaking) it’s a bad one and has potential long term effects. So, of course, we need to flatten the curve and increase the medical community’s ability to respond to serious cases.

But none of this is simple. We can flatten the curve but we can’t end the storm. And if our best human efforts for control can only plug one hole at a time and there is no calming the storm in its entirety what can we do?

We need to find ways to expand our closed individual and family groupings because no matter how good our mindset work, or how much we focus on gratitude, passion work and planning for “back to normal” (spoiler alert which I’m sure you’ve probably already realized; that’s not happening) human beings cannot sustain physical isolation without an enormous and as yet unimaginable toll on our collective minds, bodies, and spirits.

And in the meantime, I too, am calling for more compassion. More love. More understanding. More patience.

Everyone’s circumstances are different. So before you judge too quickly or condemn someone for their actions because they are different from what you believe they should be doing (and because you have 8 studies to back up why you are right) please take a breath. Before you rush to shame, scold or unfriend someone because you feel righteous and angry and certain that their behavior endangers you, please pause.

What threatens them may be just as terrifying, dangerous and risky as that which threatens you even though it might look, feel and be vastly different.

As that uncredited author wrote: “Some want to go back to work because they are running out of money. Others want to kill those who break the quarantine. […] Don’t be a judge. We are on different ships looking to survive. Let everyone navigate their route with respect, empathy, and responsibility.”

Not everyone is in the same boat. And theirs could be even less equipped to weather the storm.

ps. Here’s a link to the original unknown piece. https://www.reclaimleadership.org/reclaimed/2020/4/19/different-boat-same-storm?fbclid=IwAR2gfjwCU6i1pxjeYCrofKuht4cTvqFZlmqQCwElrtZVnOfAiU9AnZYh41U

--

--

Lisa Betts-LaCroix
Lisa Betts-LaCroix

Written by Lisa Betts-LaCroix

Lisa Betts-LaCroix is a writer, speaker, actor and dancer, and host of the Super Power U podcast. @lisabl on Instagram