Sitemap
maddy cha

maddy cha

cmu school of design 2020

Process

30 min readJan 22, 2020

--

Problem Statement/Opportunity

6.5 million companion animals enter animal shelters nationwide every year. Of these pets, many have been abandoned by previous owners for a variety of reasons (e.g. financial concerns, behavior concerns, moving, etc.). Though obviously every situation is different & unexpected concerns always arise, a significant portion of these reasons can derive from pet owners not fully understanding the commitments their pets require.

We are interested in helping prepare potential pet owners with the knowledge to properly take care of their first pet, with the idea that this will lead to more permanent homes for shelter pets, and less pets being returned & in the shelter system overall. This may involve informing people about the monetary costs and time commitments of owning a pet, or providing more specific information about pets currently in the adoption system.

What is our direct contribution?

(note: this is tentative and is bound to change as we get further along in the process)

We are interested in designing a system (potentially an app/website) that helps to consolidate knowledge and resources that may benefit people interested in adopting pets, specifically cats and dogs. We are especially interested in making this information easily accessible and engaging through design, video, etc.

Who are we reaching?

We are planning on focusing on potential first-time pet owners, especially those who do not have as much knowledge about how to take care of a pet or understand the monetary/time commitments.

How are we reaching them?

Potentially, we could spread the word about this through a local campaign event where we connect fosters animals to local communities. We want to directly advertise to potential first-time pet owners. This campaign is going to require a branded design system composed of a couple of parts. (note: this is a tentative list and is bound to change as we get further along in the process)

  1. Campaign videos to be posted on social media. For spreading awareness about the event.
  2. Printed large-scale banners posted during the event. (text: “learn more about the dogs and cats you’re playing with on our app”)
  3. Documentation of the event as it’s going on to subsequently post on media channels.

Who are our potential partners that can help us accomplish this?

We’ve reached out to Humane Animal Rescue, Paws Over Pittsburgh, Colony Cafe, and Pupcycled — all organizations/local businesses that champion transparency in the adoption process. We’ll narrow down to one or two partners as we get further along in the process.

Next Steps (January 22nd through January 31)

  • We developed two surveys: the first for potential first-time pet owners to understand what expectations they have prior to adoption, the second for experienced pet owners to understand what they did and didn’t realize they were getting themselves into when adopting a pet.
  • We’ve sent initial emails to organizations/shelters to learn more about how they educate potential owners prior to adoption. We also aim to develop a partnership with one of the orgs that reaches back to us.

Brainstorming Problem Space

We started off by listing out topics we were interested in focusing on for the semester. From the ideas on our notecards, the ones that stuck out were preserving memories from online relationships, increasing the effectiveness of the pet adoption process, and delving into androgynous and sustainable fashion. To better understand each of these problem spaces, we started splitting up different aspects of each problem with considerations for stakeholders, impact, success metrics, constraints, etc. This also allowed us to better understand each of these areas while highlighting why we cared about each one. We talked over each of these areas as a group, and decided to move forward with improving the pet adoption process.

Press enter or click to view image in full size
figuring out problem space

Discussing Stakeholders

To better understand the problem space, we started to list out potential stakeholders that would be involved within the pet adoption process. Once we had a good grasp about what parties would be involved, we started to categorize them into primary and secondary groups, as well as map out relationships between stakeholders.

Press enter or click to view image in full size
brainstorming stakeholders
Press enter or click to view image in full size
initial stakeholder map

Survey

We decided to focus on first-time potential pet owners who are interested in adopting from a shelter as our main audience to account for the time constraint of the semester. To better understand our audience, we decided to create a survey to be distributed online. We split the survey into two sections — one for people without pet experience and one for people who have or have had pets in the past.

For the people without pet experience, we wanted to gain a better understanding of what information first-time potential pet owners were lacking, as well as what resources they would/have frequented for information on adopting a pet for the first time. For people with pet experience, we were more interested in why they chose what adoption service (e.g. shelter, foster, breeder, etc.) they did and what information they would have liked to have known about their pet before adopting, if any. For each group of people, we also asked about costs (how much they estimated owning a pet would cost vs. how much people estimated they spend on their pet) as well as what people would consider the main categories of costs for pets.

Press enter or click to view image in full size
survey for both owners & potential first time owners

Survey Analysis

We received 67 responses, with 12 responses from people who wanted to own pets and 55 from current (or past) pet owners.

Potential Pet Owners

Press enter or click to view image in full size
Press enter or click to view image in full size
Press enter or click to view image in full size

Among respondents who wanted to own pets & who had never had them before, the top 3 barriers to pet ownership were money, time, and current living situations. Many respondents were fairly confident in their knowledge of pet ownership (with five rating their current knowledge at 5 on a scale from 1–7, with 1 being “I only know I want a cat/dog” and 7 being “I understand the specific commitments a pet will require”). No respondent rated their knowledge over a 6. Most indicated that they were getting their information from friends who owned pets or the internet. When asked to select the methods they would want to obtain a pet from, shelters & fosters ranked the highest, though when asked to explain why respondents seemed to be less certain about the reasoning or information behind each potential choice.

Respondents’ answers to how much they thought they would spend a month ranged from around $100-$400, though a few admitted they had no idea. Interestingly even with the uncertainty, this was fairly similar to the estimates current pet owners gave for how much they spent per month. Most people also listed food & health as the biggest potential expense factors.

Current/Past Pet Owners

Press enter or click to view image in full size
Press enter or click to view image in full size

Among respondents who identified as having owned a pet, we discovered that the primary sources for obtaining pets included the shelter(1), breeder(2), foster care (3), and pet stores (4). The difference between these sources is minor. Owners are motivated to adopt from any of the sources for ethical drive. In the event that owners could not adopt from a shelter, many sourced “responsible breeders” as a justification.

Surprisingly, estimates for the monthly average aligned with potential pet owner respondents — owner respondents estimated $50 to $400, though interest extremities involve $20, $30, and $40 dollars per month. Their primary expenses involved food (1), medical expenses (2), cleanings/grooming (3), and toys (4). Owners responded that they would have liked to know about the quantity of vet costs/visits, how to discipline adoptees, and feeding costs related to the size of animals.

Preparing Interview Questions

Based on our project brief & some of the research we had already conducted, we created a general list of topics to ask the staff at Humane Animal Rescue. Our main area of interest was the adoption process & interactions with potential or new pet owners. We also wanted to ask about community outreach events the organization had participated in in the past, as we’ve considered the possibility of a local event or pop-up as a way to reach our audience.

Visiting the Humane Animal Rescue

We were able to talk with the chief program officer and the director of adoptions & animal care at Humane Animal Rescue, as well as view the facilities in North Side.

Key takeaways from our interview:

  • the organization does its best to make sure potential owners are fully prepared for adoption & care, connecting them with an adoption counselor during the process to show potential animal matches & information
  • new owners tended to be surprised by the period it took for animals to adjust from shelter life to their new homes, as it could take weeks to months for animals to transition to their new surroundings (and owners to put in the time to get to know the animals’ personalities & changes) — can lead to owners feeling guilty that they’re not the right home for the animal
  • something new owners also got back in contact for was understanding medical records, especially to confirm specific for pets with specific needs (even though potential owners all get informed about medical records, it can still be intimidating/ something they’re not sure if they got right)
  • overall, surprises (and potential returns) for pet owners boil down to mismatch of expectations, and making sure potential owners know what to actually expect (e.g. cost of food, potential lifestyle changes)
Press enter or click to view image in full size
workshop from Dan’s lecture

After listening to Dan’s lecture on research methods, we considered different ways we could conduct research & learn more about our problem space. Our main goals were to learn more about the processes current owners have gone through (and generally gather more personal stories and experiences), as well as potential owners’ understanding of their own knowledge.

Press enter or click to view image in full size
stakeholder journey map

We mapped out the general process that a potential pet owner might go through and the emotions, thoughts, and conversations they might be having throughout the process.

We learned that there’s ample opportunity to design an intervention in the pre-adoption phase and post-adoption phase, so we focused our lo-fi prototypes on those interventions.

Idea Generation

We decided to consolidate some of our ideas into three concrete solutions that we could begin creating low-fidelity prototypes for. We started off by considering the overall goals we had for the project and what we wanted our audience to get out of it. Once we agreed upon these goals, we started thinking about different mediums we could use to help inform our audience more transparently on the pet adoption process. We decided on prototyping a campaign to connect potential/first-time pet owners to experienced owners, a care package/starter kit personalized to newly adopted animals, and a card game that people could use to better prepare themselves for the responsibilities and commitments of taking care of a pet.

Press enter or click to view image in full size
brainstorming ideas

Meet-Up Events

Press enter or click to view image in full size
storyboard for local meet-up events

For our first concept, we thought about creating a three-way adoption-educational system through local meet-up events sponsored by local shelters.

During twice-a-month meet-up times, potential pet owners have the opportunity to meet experienced pet owners and their animal friends and openly ask questions about the adoption process. Shelter volunteers also stick around to answer any questions about the shelter animals or the logistics behind the adoption process. From this, potential owners get in-person knowledge about adoption, experience pet owners expand their networks, and shelter staff learn more about the expectations of potential pet owners and fill any gaps within their counseling process.

Press enter or click to view image in full size
lo-fi prototype of marketing materials

Marketing materials (see above) would be distributed by a shelter through print, social media, and postcard to advertise the event. Activities (see “Card Game” below) can facilitate conversations in a fun way.

Starter Pack

Press enter or click to view image in full size
storyboard for starter pack idea

For our second concept, we considered creating a care package, or “starter pack”, that new owners would receive when adopting a pet. These starter packs would be personalized to the type of pet they receive (e.g. small dog, large dog, indoor cat, etc.). These packs would include some sample toys that owners could use to bond with their pets, and give owners a better idea of what their pets like/dislike. Other items that could be included are different treats and collars/leashes.

Additionally, these kits would include a handbook of local resources — phone numbers of pet related organizations, low-cost veterinarians, hotlines, and potentially volunteer owners. This handbook could also include a short F.A.Q. section about their pets, so as to help ease nerves as owners are learning more about their new pets. Finally, the box could also include a log for owners to keep track of their pet’s behavior, medications, etc.

Press enter or click to view image in full size
low-fi prototype of handbook/log pages

Card Game

Press enter or click to view image in full size
storyboard of card game

Our third concept incorporates teaching through games. Using a tabletop card game designed to simulate owning a new pet, players would try to discover their pets’ personalities, raise affection, and generally care for them. The goal of this concept would not necessarily be to teach directly translatable skills, but rather to make the players aware of different concepts around new pet ownership (such as the idea that pets might need several weeks or months to fully show their personalities) that they could then investigate further on their own. Based on how we design the actual game, we could emphasize different concepts we would want potential pet owners to learn.

The game could potentially be distributed at animal shelter outreach events, or as something to print and play online.

Press enter or click to view image in full size
low-fi prototype of example cards

After receiving feedback from the silent critique, we decided to consolidate key points made from each of our reviewers.

  • consider more long-term processes (even if we’re just focusing on the first few months post-adoption, could be helpful to think through especially if we’re emphasizing owner responsibilities over a lifetime)
  • some more education around context e.g. why animals end up in shelters
  • each concept seems to focus on a different stage/part of the adoption
  • consider how concepts could feed into/support each other
  • consider how these might work in the context of animal shelters/humane societies actually implementing them
  • “would be interesting to see how people can gauge whether they should or shouldn’t own a pet”
  • “would like to see more explorations on type/image interactions, less illustration (but illustration style also sets you apart), more ‘brand’ development
  • “consider dog park as context” (but we also wanna focus on cats)
  • what phase are we focusing on?
  • what age/audience are we focusing on?
  • “starter pack is good since its important for pet owners to try certain things”

Overall, we need to consider who & what specifically we’re targeting with our concepts, as well as larger contexts around animal shelters and the adoption system.

From our feedback, we decided to continue exploring the game idea. People like the breadth of gameplay styles that could come from a game, while others also mentioned how games are great for educational experiences.

We think a physical game (cards, board games, etc.) also has a large reach, especially if we’re able to do it right by making it fun for any one playing. We think we can boil down a lot of the complexities of the pet adoption process through gameplay.

Moving forward, we’ll be lo-fi prototyping a variety of different games. We’ll also be collecting a board of visual inspiration as we move towards developing a visual language for the game.

As part of our iteration phase, we each individually pitched an idea for a physical game with the goal of educating players on the commitments and responsibilities. Each of us ended up designing games that were mainly card based. Two of the games focused on the transition stage from shelter to home, whereas the other one focused on matching pets with potential owners during the adoption phase.

Press enter or click to view image in full size
game pitch

From here, we decided to further flesh out each of these ideas while also considering other styles/types of games (such as board games).

Three Rivers Greyhound Call

We contacted Three Rivers Greyhound, a volunteer-run organization that focuses on providing homes for retired racing greyhounds, to learn more about how the adoption process might differ for more specialized animals that might be harder to adopt. There’s already a lot of supporting material on their site about caring for greyhounds, and potential owners have to fill out a fairly extensive application before getting in touch with the adoption committee. The volunteers we spoke with were all very knowledgeable about the specifics of taking care of greyhounds & a lot of misconceptions around them, and ensured that animals would find good homes through a combination of those requirements (for example, potential owners must have owned a dog before and must do a home visit) as well as supporting information (a checklist of items new owners would need to get). They also encourage post-adoption support through events where owners can meet each other, as well as promote overall awareness about greyhounds.

Humane Animal Rescue Training Session

As continuation on our research, we observed a beginner training class for dogs held at the Humane Animal Rescue. This was the third session of a multi-week class, with a mix of various skill levels and ages. The dogs and their owners were spread out around a large open room so that the dogs would not be as distracted by each other. The purpose of the class was to either relearn/practice skills or completely relearn them.

During the session that we observed, the dogs were tasked with the commands sit, lay down, sit nicely for pets, and focus & follow. From what we observed, it seemed like all of the owners had minimal experience with dog training, and the trainers conducted the session to account for various skill and knowledge levels. It was really interesting to see how each of the owners communicated with their dogs, and how the trainers communicated with each of the owners about positive/negative behavior. Full notes for this session can be found here.

Inspiration

To help us brainstorm, we created a Pinterest board of ideas for both visual and interactive elements of physical games. We focused on games that seemed easy enough to manufacture, and not overly complex. While we collected ideas that were more design-focused, we were more interested in looking at different ways of gameplay and board game techniques.

Press enter or click to view image in full size
Press enter or click to view image in full size
trails tales and the magic recipes board games

Candyland & Chutes and Ladders

We played some very basic board games to start thinking about different game elements and applications: Candyland and Chutes & Ladders, both of which are essentially just luck-based games where the goal is to get to the end of the board. The strengths of these are that they’re extremely easy for anyone to pick up and start playing right away with minimal understanding of the rules. The mechanics mean anyone can win, but also means that the games aren’t really very engaging beyond those basic mechanics.

Press enter or click to view image in full size
Press enter or click to view image in full size
candyland and chutes & ladders

Parcheesi

We decided to visit the Carnegie Library to check out the board games they had on hand. The first game we explored was Parcheesi, which was much more strategic and complex in nature than Candyland and Chutes & Ladders. Just like the other two games, the objective was to get your pieces to the end of the board. To us, this game was much more engaging, as it was not solely based on luck. The trade-off, however, was that it took longer to understand and explain the rules.

Press enter or click to view image in full size
Press enter or click to view image in full size
parcheesi

Would You Rather & Trivial Pursuit

From there, we explored the games Would You Rather and Trivial Pursuit. These games combined a set of cards and a board. With Would You Rather, the focus of the game seemed to be entertainment through discussion rather than actually getting to the end of the board. Trivial Pursuit was incredibly difficult to understand (the rules were a bit vague), and the questions on each of the cards seemed to be a bit more niche than “common knowledge”, which is what it was advertised as. However, in both games, the cards acted as prompts that supplemented movement on the board.

Press enter or click to view image in full size
Press enter or click to view image in full size
would you rather & trivial pursuit

After playing some board games, we were inspired by the simple game design techniques that they used to get players to quickly understand its goals and how to play it. We developed five low-fi concepts of games that covered different concepts like the importance of pet-owner matchups, the level of commitment owners need to take, and how pets communicate to owners non-verbally. This ranged from pure card games to Monopoly-like board games.

Press enter or click to view image in full size
Press enter or click to view image in full size
Press enter or click to view image in full size
low-fi prototypes of different game designs

Once each of the games was at a point where we could play through a couple of rounds, we worked together to explain and play each version. Through this, we were able to easily figure out things that we missed through the designs of each game, as well as what was and wasn’t working. Although all of our ideas were very different in terms of how they were played and the different strategies involved, there were a lot of high-level issues shared with each prototype. The biggest insight we found through this experience was that we needed to find a balance between simulating complex systems and making a game easy enough to pick up and play. Additionally, we need to further consider the amount of moving parts each game will have, especially in terms of calculating manufacturing costs.

Press enter or click to view image in full size
Press enter or click to view image in full size
testing rounds of gameplay

We mapped our project’s customer segments, key partners, value propositions, and revenue streams, among other business model categories, to understand our risks, unknowns, and possible blockades. Through this process, we identified key risks in the potential of our game as an actual educational tool, the prototyping capabilities we personally have, and the actual possibility of our game reducing the amount of unnecessary interactions made between first-time owners and shelter volunteers.

Press enter or click to view image in full size
business model canvas

Pitch:

We’re designing a card/board game that helps educate potential first-time pet owners (looking to adopt from a shelter) on what taking an animal home & caring for it is actually like.

We’ve worked with Humane Animal Rescue to learn more about the adoption process and common concerns that first-time adopters have. Our focus through the game is helping potential owners understand less concrete aspects of care, such as how an animal’s personality might develop and different behaviors they might encounter. By preparing potential owners, we hope to be able to reduce the amount of work shelter volunteers have to do both sharing information pre-adoption and when fielding calls from new owners post-adoption, and lead to better care and homes for animals overall.

The main customer would be shelters/ animal welfare organizations, which would be able to purchase the game or a digitally distributable version of it to keep costs low. Volunteers would distribute the game as part of outreach events to reach our main audience, and the game would act as a fun, low-barrier way for people to begin to consider the realities of pet ownership.

Due to the circumstances around switching to online learning, we were forced to rethink our entire project as we no longer had access to physical prototyping spaces or our community partner. Out of necessity, we shifted our focus to an interactive digital project instead, as that would be most viable to design and prototype remotely. After some discussion, especially around seeing how people were coming together to support their communities & different levels of care including how animal care was being handled, we decided we would design a service & app around communities & animal care. Our new goal would be to connect people with pet related needs to those willing or able to fulfill those needs.

To better immerse ourselves in the problem space, we continued researching different ways shelters were dealing with the COVID-19 situation.

Get maddy cha’s stories in your inbox

Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.

From our research, it appears that most shelters are not accepting animals unless considered an emergency situation, as their decrease in staff limits the amount of care they are able to provide. That being said, they are still finding ways to help animals in need through no-contact approaches. Thankfully, there are still numbers of people willing to offer up their time and resources to understaffed shelters.

Some shelters planned “adoption livestreams” where they would show off different animals that were available for adoption. Additionally, more and more people are volunteering to foster sheltered animals as well. Shelters have moved adoption and fostering screening to phone and video calls to comply with the no-contact guidance, while still allowing animals to find home during the pandemic.

“We show the pets, give them treats and belly rubs, talk about their personalities. It allows people to ‘be there’ without the crowds.” It seems to work: “We did 58 adoptions in the first six days. We are so excited!”

—Happy news: Pet adoptions are way up amid coronavirus crisis…

Other ways that people can and have been providing support to their local shelters include donating unopened pet food and supplies, ordering from online wishlists published by shelters, and giving monetary donations to support the staff and cover adoption fees.

On the other side, in light of nationwide losses of jobs & income, people with pets are also struggling to keep up with the needs their pets require on top of their personal struggles. The Humane Animal Rescue has said that there’s been an increase in the number of people using their pantry, and similar scenarios are playing out across the country. Social distancing, self-isolation & self-quarantining, as well as stay at home & shelter in place orders have also had an impact on pet care & who can access it, particularly for those without access to transportation & more vulnerable populations who are trying to avoid going outside.

Goals

For this app, our main goal was to facilitate the connection of people within a community around the topic of pet care. Those who had specific needs (e.g. help with cat food, someone to walk their dog) with those who were able & willing to fulfill those needs (e.g. someone with extra cans or who could drive to a pantry, someone with the mobility & time to take pets on walks). Exchanges would be pro bono with the intention of strengthening community networks, though there could be the option to pay-what-you-can / pay-it-forward for certain services.

Application Features

Step One — Browsing Experience

  • Customer-side — Pet owner users would be able to browse through emergency services like pet food pantries, dog walking services, pet fostering/animal-sitting, and pet adoption, amongst others that are in their local vicinity.
  • Service Provider-side — Service providers list their services on our app, including the following information: details of service, location of service, when service can be conducted, etc
Press enter or click to view image in full size
sample flow

Step Two — Scheduling Experience

  • Customer-side — After finding a service that would fit for their needs and reading through the service’s details, they’re able to schedule when they would need the service or contact for more information. They receive a message in the next step.
  • Service Provider-side — Service providers receive requests from users and align them with the times they have available before moving on to the next step.

Step Three — Communication Experience

  • Customer-side + Service Provider-side — Pet owners are pinged when they’re able to move forward in the process. At this point, they’re able to have a direct conversation with the service providers about their pet and their personal situation.

Step Four — During and Post-Service Experience + Tipping

  • Customer-side — Pet owners keep in touch with the service provider to ensure that the service is/was a success. While our service is pay-what-you-can, at this point pet owners can show gratuity through our tipping feature.
  • Service Provider-side — Service providers can make sure that pet owners are in a good place. They’re able to receive tips or great reviews from the pet owners.

User Flow

General

  • Onboarding process
  • User setting up profile (name, age, location, etc.)

Customer Side

  • User browses through available services in their area (can filter based on their needs)
  • User contacts someone for services
  • User leaves reviews on service and provider
  • User can leave tips for service provider (pay what you can)

Service Provider Side

  • User publishes available service (what they are offering, when, where, etc.)
  • User is contacted by someone requiring service
  • Service provider can leave reviews for user
  • Service Provider can take tip or donate to charity/pay-it-forward, etc.

Additionally, we began looking for more visual inspiration based around mobile applications. Luckily, we gathered a significant amount of branding inspiration previously that could still translate to a mobile setting.

Press enter or click to view image in full size
Press enter or click to view image in full size
Press enter or click to view image in full size
examples of visual inspiration

Storyboards

To help think through the features we had planned & quickly explain how community members might use the app, we storyboarded a potential use case for our app. A basic use case on the “customer” side might look like this: a community member with a need looks through options volunteers have posted and enters into conversation with a potential volunteer, who will then help fulfill their needs.

Press enter or click to view image in full size
storyboard

User Flow

We created a more concrete user flow to help us better plan what screens were most important to begin designing. We split it up into “customer” and “service provider” — we’re still considering terminology to use for the two sides, but it essentially boils down to “community member with a need” and “community member who can fulfill a need.” A single user can technically act as both, looking for services to fulfill their needs (or posting about what needs they have) or offering services they can provide to others. Users can contact each other to confirm details & requests. Though this app is primarily intended to facilitate community aid and as such will have no payment as default, we’re also discussing the option of adding a pay-what-you-can system for those who do have the means to either tip the service providers or pay-it-forward, possibly to other community members in need or local animal welfare funds.

Rover

We began looking into the application, Rover, which allows users to provide services for pet owners. As a first time user, there was prompt to create an account, but users are able to browse services without logging in. Rover focuses on multiple different care services for both dogs & cats. As such, it has a fairly robust search & filtering system (by pet type, service type, location, and range of dates). After filling in the appropriate details, users can then view potential service providers near them. Because of this, Rover also has good examples of how to promote trust between users, as potential sitters/ service providers have fairly detailed profiles with relevant information depending on which services they offer (e.g. house information for boarding), and highlights for repeating clients & reviews.

Press enter or click to view image in full size
Press enter or click to view image in full size
Press enter or click to view image in full size
Press enter or click to view image in full size
Press enter or click to view image in full size
Press enter or click to view image in full size

Wag

Wag is a competitor to Rover and offers similar services (though exclusively for dogs) in a much more image-oriented interface. Though it’s trying to feel friendlier as a service, the Rover interface ends up being much clearer to sort through. It also operates on a system more similar to Uber/Lyft — instead of choosing a service provider, you select the details for your service & pay before getting matched with someone. Ironically this makes Wag feel more corporate/ less person-focused than Rover, despite its visual language, as the focus is shifted almost entirely to the service provided. Users are that much more removed from the person taking care of their pet, which is the opposite of what we’d like to happen with our app.

Press enter or click to view image in full size
Press enter or click to view image in full size
Press enter or click to view image in full size
Press enter or click to view image in full size
Press enter or click to view image in full size
Press enter or click to view image in full size

Based on our user flow & other initial research, we began creating lo-fi prototypes of the app, starting with the customer-facing side.

Customer-facing side

Press enter or click to view image in full size
onboarding

Onboarding to the app would essentially follow the same pattern for both kinds of users, as again a single user could both search for needs and provide services. At sign-up, the user would provide relevant information including their general location/ neighborhood & their kinds of pet(s) which would help filter relevant information further along in the app. They would then be directed through a quick intro of what they could use the app for.

Press enter or click to view image in full size
search

Once in the app, users can search for specific needs or post about them if there’s not relevant services being offered. After an initial search, users can filter services offered by distance or availability. If they find a service that seems promising, they can view additional information about both the service and the community member offering that service before moving on to contact.

Press enter or click to view image in full size

Once a user finds a service that fits their need, location, and availability, they can contact the user who posted that service. Users can confirm that arrangements work for them before agreeing to request/ fulfill the service. There might need to be additional steps to clarify or streamline confirmation, but having contact with the community member fulfilling the request is a first step before needs can be meet.

Once we figured out the different screens and functionalities we wanted our application to include, we started deciding on visual variables.

Typography

As we wanted our application to focus on practicality, we tested with fonts that would be readable on a smaller scale. In the end, we decided to go with hk grotesk, as it seemed more friendly and approachable.

Press enter or click to view image in full size
font samples

Color Palette

After deciding on a font family, we experimented with a few different color palettes that we thought would be fitting for the mood of our application. We tested with a few different color palettes with variety in saturation, and decided to go with colors that were more muted, so as not to distract from visuals that may be included within each post on the application.

Press enter or click to view image in full size
color palette options

However, when testing with some of the proposed solutions, we realized that too many colors ended up being distracting from the information on the screens. Because of these, we decided to continue with using the dark green as a spot color, and would consider including other colors as needed.

Press enter or click to view image in full size
Press enter or click to view image in full size
Press enter or click to view image in full size
testing colors with screens

To keep ourselves on track to finishing the project, we wrote up a new updated timeline keeping in mind each of our various commitments outside of class.

Press enter or click to view image in full size
updated timeline

Based on feedback, we took a step back to fully think through our user flow & created a service blueprint to plan through the user experience of our app.

Press enter or click to view image in full size
service blueprint (top flow is provider posting a service, bottom flow is user posting a need)

One of the key considerations of our app was that users could theoretically both post needs and services they could provide & fill both sides of the experience. Another was who would be doing the posting: either providers could post services they could offer & users with needs could browse their posts, or users with needs could post requests and potential providers could see what needs they could fulfill.

Either way, overall user flow ended up being fairly similar after the posting process. Once users with needs & potential providers interact, they confirm their requests/ services and complete them, separately confirming the completion in-app. Both sides then have the opportunity to “review” the other (potentially something as indirect as marking the experience as positive or negative) as a way to start thinking about community trust, as well as post stories or pictures about their experiences.

There are then two optional steps: the first is a potential for “payment” where users with the means can tip the service providers or pay-it-forward to, for example, local animal welfare funds. We’re also considering what alternative means of “payment” could look like, though the emphasis of our app would always be that this is a mutual exchange of help. Secondly, if both users have had positive experiences & the user with the need would have a recurring request, there could be an option to help streamline repeating services (for example, daily dog walks or stopping by a pantry every few weeks).

Press enter or click to view image in full size
initial ux considerations

Based on the service blueprint, we generated a list of core UX needs and considerations for what that UX would look translated to UI. The overall UX could be separated into five general sections: onboarding, browsing, details, scheduling/chat, and fulfillment/review. With this as a guide, we returned to our initial app prototypes and began revising.

Press enter or click to view image in full size
Press enter or click to view image in full size
Press enter or click to view image in full size
Press enter or click to view image in full size
Press enter or click to view image in full size

User testing

Once we designed a full user flow, we tested on five different participants using think-alouds. We tasked users with contacting and scheduling a service listed on one of the service boards. Generally, participants were able to navigate our prototype & complete tasks. Users thought that the headers & bottom-navigation bars were really effectively in helping ground them within the application, and the consistency of the UI elements made it easy and seamless to go from page to page. Some of the more UI-focused comments we received through these tests:

  • preferred illustrated approach over photographs (more playful)
  • thought green was a bit too dark/didn’t match tone of the app
  • otherwise thought UI was clean and easy to navigate
  • is there a way to schedule recurring tasks?

From here, we analyzed all of the user testing results as a group to figure out what our direction should be from here. As most of our participants were able to navigate all of the information with ease, we decided to focus more on the comments relating to the visual design of the application.

Press enter or click to view image in full size
Press enter or click to view image in full size
Press enter or click to view image in full size
Press enter or click to view image in full size
Press enter or click to view image in full size
Press enter or click to view image in full size
Press enter or click to view image in full size
illustrations

Our final product consists of four main screens, plus onboarding:

  1. browsing needs/services
  2. requesting a service
  3. tipping and reviewing a service
  4. community highlights

Onboarding

Press enter or click to view image in full size
Press enter or click to view image in full size
Press enter or click to view image in full size

Browsing

Press enter or click to view image in full size
Press enter or click to view image in full size
Press enter or click to view image in full size

Requesting

Press enter or click to view image in full size
Press enter or click to view image in full size
Press enter or click to view image in full size

Contact & confirmation

Press enter or click to view image in full size
Press enter or click to view image in full size

Tipping

Press enter or click to view image in full size
Press enter or click to view image in full size
Press enter or click to view image in full size

Community

Press enter or click to view image in full size
Press enter or click to view image in full size
Press enter or click to view image in full size

--

--