Why I Keep Writing the Rejection Scene
If you read werewolf romance, you know the scene. The Alpha finds his fated mate, decides she isn’t good enough, and rejects her in front of everyone. She falls to her knees. The bond tears. Everybody watches.
I have read that scene maybe two hundred times, and I still read it. I wanted to understand why, so I started writing my own version and paying attention to which parts made my stomach drop.
It wasn’t the cruelty. Plenty of books are cruel and I forget them by the next morning. What stays with me is the half second after the words are said, when the heroine has to decide what to do with her face. Three hundred people are looking at her. She has nothing in her hands. The only thing she controls is whether she gives them the reaction they came for.
So in my book she doesn’t. She accepts the rejection out loud, she stays standing, and he’s the one who goes down. I won’t spoil why. But writing it changed how I think about the whole genre.
Get Maren Ashby’s stories in your inbox
Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.
A rejected mate story is a revenge story with the revenge postponed. The reader signs up for a long delay. We are promised that the people who laughed will eventually have to look at her again, and that she will be different when they do. The fun is in the waiting, and the waiting only works if she is doing something while we wait. Surviving counts, and so does learning, but being clever with very little counts most.
The version of this trope I find hard to read is the one where she is passive for twenty chapters and then gets rescued by a bigger, nicer Alpha. I like the second love interest. I just want him to show up late, after she has already handled it, and be impressed.
That is the rule I wrote on a sticky note above my desk: he arrives after she wins.
I’m drafting this book now in short chapters, about twelve hundred words each, because that is how most people read these stories, on a phone, on a bus, ten minutes at a time. It is a good discipline. Every chapter has to end with a reason to open the next one.
If you love this trope too, I would love to know which version of the rejection scene you remember best, and why.
