Weekly Fallacy Update: Logical Fallacies in the 2026 Midterms
Neither party has a monopoly on bad arguments. In just the past two months of midterm campaigning, Democrats and Republicans alike have attacked opponents personally, smeared them by association, stoked fear with misleading predictions, and leaned on emotional stories that don’t hold up. The tactics are identical; only the targets change.
Ad hominem: attacking the person instead of the argument
- Democrats: In the Oct. 8 Georgia Senate debate, Ossoff called Collins a “bigot” and a “Trump puppet,” and said Collins had staffed his office “with half of the Third Reich.” He also said that if John Lewis were marching from Selma to Montgomery today, Collins “would be grabbing a billy club.”
- Republicans: In the same debate, Collins called Ossoff a “trust fund kid who has never had a job in his life” and a “radical.” At a San Antonio rally, Trump said Texas Democrat James Talarico is a vegan who gets sick after eating meat for show, and blamed Talarico’s flu on that routine. Talarico is not a vegan.
Guilt by association: discrediting someone through their connections
- Democrats: Massachusetts Gov. Maura Healey said “Trump” 36 times in her first debate; her opponent, Mike Minogue, said it zero times. She also claimed Minogue “wrote a million-dollar check to Donald Trump,” but he actually gave about $933,000 to Trump and other Republicans across several donations.
- Republicans: In Michigan, Mike Rogers repeatedly invoked al-Qaida and Hamas to suggest Abdul El-Sayed is backed by people who support those groups. He then made a dark insinuation about El-Sayed’s mother, referring to her early-2000s work for the Islamic American Relief Agency, a humanitarian nonprofit.
Appeal to fear: persuading through alarm rather than evidence
- Democrats: Kentucky Gov. Andy Beshear posted that the Senate had said it was okay to “close 35 rural hospitals in our state.” The figure came from a list of at-risk rural hospitals published by Democratic senators. Republican Rep. Andy Barr of Kentucky has since pointed out that all 35 are still open.
- Republicans: Speakers at Trump’s Dallas convention mentioned communism or communists at least 60 times. Trump himself warned, “It’s going to be a communist country if they win,” though no credible midterm candidate identifies as a communist.
Appeal to emotion / misleading anecdote: using a moving story in place of accurate facts
- Democrats: Talarico’s campaign posted that Paxton, as attorney general, “protected a research lab that tortured 400 puppies,” and Talarico called him “anti-puppy.” The record is narrower: more than a decade ago, Paxton ruled that animal-testing records at a public university could stay confidential.
- Republicans: In Senate Leadership Fund ads against Sherrod Brown, Soren Aldaco says Brown supports “irreversible surgery on kids like me.” Court records from her malpractice suit show she had the surgery in Austin in June 2021, at age 19. She also isn’t from Ohio.
The takeaway isn’t that one side is honest and the other isn’t. It’s that voters should scrutinize every claim, especially the ones from the side they already agree with.
Get Mary Maccabee’s stories in your inbox
Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.
Sources:
- WTOC (Gray TV): Ossoff, Collins clash in Georgia Senate debate
- Boston Globe: Georgia Senate debate
- KBTX: Talarico returns to campaign trail
- Axios Boston: Healey ties Minogue to Trump
- Boston Globe: Healey blamed Trump, Minogue blamed Healey
- New York Times (via GV Wire): 5 key moments from a hostile Michigan debate
- TheGrio: Rogers pulls the “your Mom” card
- Spectrum News: Barr, Beshear on Medicaid and hospitals
- New York Times (via UDN): Republicans try to brand Democrats as communists
- Christian Post: Talarico calls Paxton “anti-puppy”
- News From The States (News 5 Cleveland): Woman in Brown ad didn’t have procedure as minor
- Raw Story: Texas court fight and the GOP attack ad
