The 10 Best Supporting Characters in HBO’s Game of Thrones Who Died Before the Story Ruined Them
Unnecessary disclaimer, in case it isn’t obvious: the whole bloody article is one big spoiler. The bloody characters are dead!
And Now Their Watch has Ended
Writing about the best characters and performances in Game of Thrones is almost as complicated as the show itself — and for the exact same reasons. Across eight seasons, HBO juggled roughly fifty main characters, more than two hundred recurring ones (many of whom eventually became main), and over five hundred distinctly named faces. That’s nearly double what Lost (2004–2010) ever managed. Unsurprisingly, the result was some of the most iconic character work in television history.
But like any show that eventually loses its way (looking at you again, Lost), Game of Thrones sent several of its once-great characters crashing into the abyss. Some arcs were derailed, others reduced to nonsense, and a few ended in ways so meaningless they managed to rewrite a character’s legacy in the worst possible way.
We all remember those creative atrocities — no need to name names or rehash the trauma. Future generations will have their own entertainment disasters to suffer through; we can spare them the postmortem.
Still, Thrones deserves credit where it’s due: few shows have ever killed off characters better. At its peak, that was the very essence of its drama. But as the storytelling ran out of steam — gradually after Season 4, then in freefall by the end — anyone left alive (and Bran, who literally couldn’t stand) turned into a shell of who they once were.
Then there were the ones who didn’t die but probably should have. Characters like Brienne or Davos — once brilliant, now overstaying their own arcs — lingered long enough to fade into mediocrity. I wouldn’t say they should’ve been killed off, but it’s hard to deny they outlived their greatness. So, they’re out too.
And because this is Game of Thrones — where no one really wins — any character who survived the final episode (or whose death wasn’t confirmed; looking at you, Ilyn Payne) is automatically disqualified from this list.
Now, a quick note on definitions: in a world this sprawling, “main character” vs. “supporting character” is murky territory. We might not agree on who counts as which — and honestly, that changes season by season. So let’s not get hung up on it. For simplicity’s sake, we’ll treat “supporting characters” as shorthand for anyone clearly outside the central spotlight, even if their screen time or importance sometimes says otherwise.
Wait — why rank supporting characters and not main characters??
Of course, many of the main characters rank among the best in the show — Game of Thrones couldn’t have reached its heights otherwise. The ones fortunate enough to die back when George R.R. Martin’s influence still loomed large — Robert Baratheon, Ned Stark, Joffrey Baratheon, Tywin Lannister — remain near flawless.
But pointing out the main characters who made it to the end without collapsing isn’t much of a challenge. (And identifying the ones who crashed the hardest? Even easier. Jon, Dany, I’m looking at you.)
Once excellent supporting characters
Then there are the beloved supporting characters who outlived their usefulness — to the plot, to the tone, or even to their own roles as comic relief. Most notably: Bronn, everyone’s favorite roguish sellsword.
His final great moment comes when he refuses to fight as Tyrion’s champion against the Mountain. It’s the perfect bookend to their first meeting, when Bronn did fight for Tyrion at the Eyrie — also for gold, of course. (“It pays better than escorting a prisoner.”) In both trials, Tyrion was innocent, and the symmetry is beautiful.
But that scene marks the end of Bronn’s arc. From there, he’s shoved into a dreadful buddy-comedy subplot with Jaime in Dorne, and whatever made Bronn interesting is gone. The character we knew never returns — just the husk.
Theon, by contrast, has one of the strongest arcs in the entire series. From his conflicted status as a hostage/adopted son of the Starks, to his brotherhood with Robb, to his betrayal in a desperate bid for his father’s approval, and finally to his brutal fall and eventual redemption — his journey is tragic, layered, and deeply human.
His story was already complete when he rescued Sansa. That was his redemption, and it’s one of the best in modern pop culture. Honestly, it deserves its own article.
Unfortunately, Thrones couldn’t leave well enough alone. After Sansa’s forgiveness, Theon drifts into an exceedingly dull Iron Islands family drama — one of the weakest plotlines in the show. His final sacrifice, protecting Bran, is meant to bring his arc full circle, but it ends up meaningless. If Arya hadn’t suddenly turned into Nightcrawler and teleported in to kill the Night King, Bran would’ve died anyway. (And since Bran’s entire arc goes nowhere, that sacrifice feels even emptier.)
But the worst of all — worse than Jon Snow’s magical resurrection — is the fake resurrection of The Hound, my personal favorite character. Sandor Clegane dies perfectly: abandoned by Arya and denied even a mercy killing after their incredible shared journey. Perfect ending.
Aaaaand then, suddenly — he’s back! Chopping wood with some villagers. Because the writers knew fans loved him, and for literally no other plot-serving reason. From that point on, The Hound has nothing meaningful left to do. His final showdown with his zombified brother, hyped for years, lands with a thud — empty and anticlimactic.
Excellent, but for one flaw
“I hate a good many things, but I suffer them all the same.”
Stannis Baratheon is pure stubbornness made flesh — grim, joyless, and unbending. Stephen Dillane plays him to perfection: a man so solemn and sour he seems allergic to joy, yet absolutely convincing as the rightful heir to his brother’s throne.
His death at Brienne’s hand, following his crushing defeat at Winterfell, is as dignified as such a fate allows — and entirely earned.
But the show undermines him long before that. Game of Thrones makes it clear that Stannis loves his daughter. The decision to burn Shireen, no matter how desperate his situation, simply doesn’t fit the man we’ve come to know. Yes, it’s a very Thrones-like twist, but it’s not a Stannis-like one.
He might despise defeat and humiliation — especially repeated ones — but as he himself says, he would “suffer them all the same.” That line defines him. Ignoring it breaks the character.
The inconsistency ruins what was otherwise one of the most consistent portrayals in the series.
Characters with a complete arc and a timely death — in no particular order
Fortunately, Game of Thrones did bless us with a few characters who were great from beginning to end — those lucky enough to die before the writers could ruin them.
So, without further ado, let’s get into it.
Oberyn Martell
“Can I tell you a secret? You’re not a golden lion. You’re just a pink little man who’s far too slow on the draw.”
Before there was Pedro Pascal fatigue, there was Oberyn, the hilarious, swashbuckling gangster prince of Dorne, the one-man wild-card antagonist to the Lannisters, after their victory in the War of the Five Kings.
He’s full of swagger, deadly, and constantly provokes the most powerful people in the Seven Kingdoms (to be fair, Dorne is holding the king’s sister “hostage”).
But his vanity is his eventual downfall. After getting the better of one of the most terrifying warriors in the entire show, he turns his back for one second and loses his face.
Khal Drogo
“Crown for king!”
A perfectly cast Jason Momoa in his breakout role, who speaks mostly in huffs and grunts, Drogo is one of the most fearsome men in GOT, a horse-lord with tens of thousands at his command; King Robert even considers him a credible threat, despite the Dothraki’s lack of seamanship.
And Drogo nearly sets out to do just that, to take the throne for his yet-unborn son, when his plans get derailed by dying of sepsis, because medicine is for pussies. (At least it wasn’t dysentery!)
His Conan speech to rouse his troops to war is chilling, and the scene in which he takes off his weapons to fight his disgruntled captain, slicing his throat with his own sword is one of the most badass moments of the show (much like Oberyn’s dual with The Mountain); which will be given an homage of sorts in House of The Dragon, with prince Daemon slicing Vaemond’s face…off. Gruesome yet epic. Precisely what the GOT-verse is all about.
Syrio Forrel
“What do we say to the God of Death?”
If you want to call this character minor rather than supporting, I won’t fight you over it.
Syrio is Arya’s Braavosi Dancing (swordfighting) Master, her first in a long line of distinguished mentors. A small man with a huge personality. He is hilarious, demanding, and ferociously protective. All of his scenes are electric, his death is incredibly tragic, and his role is vital in setting up Arya’s entire arc — which was absolutely great until she quit her job as a Westerosi outlaw to sell oysters, clams, and cockles instead.
Viserys Targaryen
“You don’t want to wake the dragon, do you?”
Danny’s elder brother. Entirely one note, and utterly goofy — but elevated by a fully committed performance by Harry Lloyd — Viserys’s short life is incredibly tragic.
Get Nerd Card Revoked’s stories in your inbox
Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.
He survives the massacre of his family, only to become a political pawn in a game he has no comprehension of. He grows up fully deluded by stories of his legitimacy to the Iron Throne, and thinks of himself as the heir to the most powerful dynasty in living memory, despite his precarious existence that relies on the fickle charity of Essosi lords.
A sleazy, entitled brat, he sells his sister in a marriage pact for an alleged promise of an army located on the other wrong side of the Narrow Sea that doesn’t even use ships, and rapidly loses all the power and allies he thought he had at his disposal, right up until his gruesome death.
All he wanted was what he was led to believe he deserved, and he ends up utterly humiliated and abandoned before his (fully deserved) execution. He has brought everything upon himself by his actions, foreshadowing the path that Joffrey’s arc ends up taking, though the former is predominantly a weakling and the latter a psychopath (one of the best we’ve ever had).
His short arc is the inverse of that of Danny’s in the first season. You know — back when she was actually a good character.
Maester Aemon
“None of us are free. We are men of the Night’s Watch. But we won’t be taking your head today, Jon Snow. ”
The old blind Maester of the Wall, Aemon, serves as a mentor to Jon, ultimately casting the final vote, electing him Lord Commander. His screen time is limited, but it is incredibly impactful. Confronting Jon about his pride, entitlement, and place in the Night’s Watch; revealing his true identity as a would-have-been Targaryen king to Jon; having the only effective conversation that can be had after the news of Robb’s declaration of war; his protection of Jon from execution upon his return from beyond the wall.
He is one of the best exposition characters in the show, as the audience learns from his instruction to Jon what serving in the Night’s Watch really means, which is where his growth and meaningful arc come into play, leaving behind his childish notions of the Wall as a solution to his personal problems. One of the most meaningful arcs in the show.
Yoren
“I sharpened this blade before breakfast. I could shave a Spider’s arse if I wanted to.”
Recruiter for the Night’s Watch, magnificently portrayed by Francis Magee, Yoren is first introduced as a potential comedic relief character. But things change rapidly as he makes his way to King’s Landing to recruit from the dungeons. Yoren has been traveling with Tyrion until Cat apprehends him at an inn on the king’s road. He warns Ned, who tragically misjudges the danger to his family and strategizes poorly for what’s to come.
At Ned’s execution, Yoren hauls a fugitive Arya from the Sept of Baelor, hides her identity by cutting off her hair with a knife, and takes her out of the city under the guise of a Night’s Watch recruit.
He has a hard role to play as a mentor for her survival in hiding amongst the criminals he escorts to The Wall, while providing his form of crude solace for her father’s horrible fate.
But now the Lannisters are after the group of recruits. Arya assumes it’s for her, but they are actually after Gendry, the smith’s apprentice, and the bastard of the late King Robert. None of the recruits can fight. Protecting them for any length of time is entirely up to Yoren. And his death is tantamount to Boromir’s last stand in The Fellowship of the Ring, only with a lot more brash dark humor.
Ramsay Bolton (Snow? Snolton?)
“Bastard, come and see.”
Everyone’s favorite psychopath of Westeros first shows up looking like a misplaced hobbit from Peter Jackson’s The Lord of the Rings — only to reveal his true nature as a gleeful sadist with a flair for elaborate torture.
Ramsay Bolton is a hunter, fighter, and tactician with zero redeeming qualities — but plenty of sharp-line dialogue, a twisted sense of humor, and a sadistic streak to rival the Jigsaw Killer from the Saw movies, delivered all with a gleeful smile borrowed from the Joker himself. Iwan Rheon (of Misfits, 2009–2013) plays him to terrifying, memorable perfection.
Ramsay, another bastard of the North, mirrors Jon in many ways. Of a similar age and build, both are haunted by semi-ignoble lineage and lack of real standing amongst the lords of Westeros. Yet both ultimately rise high as powerful leaders despite their low status. But Ramsay’s bitterness about his station in life takes him down a very different path.
Their final showdown is nothing short of legendary. “Battle of the Bastards” (Season 6, Episode 9) remains one of the most stunning battle sequences ever put to screen — on TV or in film. It also marks, arguably, the last truly great episode before the show’s creative collapse into the cringe of Season 7 and the infamy of Season 8.
Ramsay took one look at Joffrey’s villain antics down in King’s Landing, said, “Hold my beer,” and delivered pure, elegant evil. His mind games fueled some of the show’s most tense and unforgettable moments — and his cruelty gave us Theon’s downfall and eventual redemption.
Never a dull moment with this one. Ramsay is the perfect villain — right up until the moment Sansa feeds him to his own hounds.
Ygritte
“You know nothing, Jon Snow.”
The lone survivor of a skirmish with a Night’s Watch ranging party beyond The Wall, Ygritte is our window into the world of the Wildlings. Another absolutely inspired casting choice with Rose Leslie.
Jon Snow is instructed to execute her, but his hesitation ends up getting him captured and begrudingly taken in by the Wildlings. Ygritte takes a liking to him (probably because he looks like Kit Harrington) and tries to convert him to their way of life. But she underestimates how much of a stick in the mud he is, so she ends up shooting him full of arrows. (Breakups are rough, man.)
Their brief reunion later puts an end to a beautifully tragic love story, which mirrors his brother Robb’s similarly doomed love affair.
She is a deadly archer, sharp, tough as nails, spicy, and sassy. Her endearing love story with Jon is the catalyst that transforms him into an actual three-dimensional human character and a true man worthy of leading the Night's Watch. “Betraying” Ygritte is where his boyhood ends.
Her death at the hands of an archer, and a boy at that, is irony at its most tragic, and it’s most beautiful.
Which brings us promptly to…
Olly
“For the Watch.”
Olly is certainly a minor character, but Game of Thrones manages to achieve a lot with very little screen time.
A boy from a village near the Wall, Olly, becomes the lone survivor of a brutal Wildling raid. He finds refuge at Castle Black and joins the Night’s Watch just before the Battle on the Wall.
When Ygritte and Jon finally reunite in the chaos of battle, Olly delivers the arrow that kills her — avenging his slaughtered family, but also shattering Jon. The moment is chilling: Olly’s silent nod of “You’re welcome” meets Jon’s stunned heartbreak. There is no doubt Jon cared for the boy, seeing in him the echoes of his own younger brothers, now estranged through circumstance. That makes Olly’s final act all the more devastating.
After Jon rescues the surviving Wildlings at Hardhome, Olly joins the mutineers who assassinate their Lord Commander. When it’s his turn to stab Jon, he hesitates — just for a second. Jon’s face is pure disbelief and sorrow. Then Olly strikes.
Upon Jon’s resurrection, Olly is among the Brothers he must execute by hanging. The boy’s last look — frozen rage and betrayal — haunts both Jon and the audience.
Olly may be a minor character, but his brief, tragic arc is one of the most quietly heartbreaking in the series.
Alliser Thorne
“Go find a chamber pot to empty.”
An incredibly unpleasant man, the Night’s Watch Master at Arms, later Acting Lord Commander, Thorne is a great foil to Jon. He is abusive, demeaning, and antagonizing.
As acting Lord Commander, he utterly ignores all of Jon’s incredibly valuable intel from his time with the Wildlings and even attempts to have him executed for actions beyond The Wall.
But that is not all he is. He also proves himself a leader and a warrior, especially getting the better of Tormund in combat. At the battle, he and Jon become allies for the first time, faced with annihilation. But it does not last long.
His utter bitterness at losing the vote for Lord Commander to Jon is the final straw. And after Jon returns to The Wall with the Wildlings after Hardhome, he orchestrates the assassination conspiracy. And when it fails, with magic, he accepts full accountability for his mutiny, with the rope around his neck, and dies without losing his dignity, assured of his choices.
Parting Words
In George R.R. Martin’s sprawling world of Westeros and Essos, both living well and dying well are luxuries afforded to very few. The best you can hope for — if you’re lucky — is to die on time, before the writers have a chance to assassinate your character. Sometimes even dying early is a blessing, because it’s the only guarantee that your arc remains intact.
Too many who began as great characters, or grew into greatness, lingered past their moment and left us with nothing but the bitter aftertaste of what once was.
HBO’s Game of Thrones had everything going for it; the depths of its fall remain one of television’s greatest tragedies. Destroying beloved characters became one of its defining sins — but when the writing collapses, no character can survive it. In Thrones, survival isn’t a reward. It’s a burden.
