Pedagogy of the Stolen: Adoption and Freire
Culture of Silence
Paulo Freire (1921–1997) was a Brazilian educator and philosopher whose work focused on the relationship between oppression, education, and liberation. His most famous book, Pedagogy of the Oppressed, was written during his exile from Brazil and published in English in 1970.
Freire argued that oppressed people are not passive victims but active participants in their own domination when they internalize the oppressor’s values and accept the story imposed on them.
His concepts of the “culture of silence,” “banking education,” and “conscientização” have shaped critical pedagogy and social justice movements worldwide.
Closed adoption operates as a culture of silence. Freire described this as a state where dominant groups impose their reality on the oppressed, who learn to see their own experience as invalid and their own voice as illegitimate.
The adoptee learns early which questions land like grenades at the dinner table. Curiosity gets rebranded as disloyalty, sorrow as spoiled ingratitude. The child absorbs the lesson that peace depends on pretending, and that play-acting becomes a second skin.
Banking Model of Family
Freire criticized what he called “banking education,” where teachers deposit information into passive students, treating them as empty containers waiting to be filled . The student is an object, not a subject. The knowledge flows one direction.
Adoption operates as a banking model of kinship. The adopters deposit a new name, new history, new identity into the child. The child is expected to accept the deposit without question. The original self, true family, real name: all erased to make room for the deposit. The adoptee is treated as an empty vessel, a blank slate, an object to be filled with whatever story the system provides.
Conscientização
Freire called the awakening to oppression “conscientização,” a critical awareness that emerges through dialogue and reflection on lived experience. The oppressed begin to see the structures that shape their suffering. They name the oppression. They recognize that their suffering has a source beyond themselves.
Get MS’s stories in your inbox
Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.
Adoptees experience conscientização when they stop believing the story. They recognize the sealed file as a weapon. They see the falsified certificate for what it is. They understand that their pain comes from a system designed to erase them, not from their own failure to be grateful.
Oppressed Hosting Oppressor
Freire observed that the oppressed often internalize the oppressor’s values, wanting to look like them, dress like them, and walk their way. The oppressed carry the oppressor inside them, measuring themselves by the standards of those who subjugated them.
Adoptees carry the adoption system inside them. They measure themselves by the gratitude narrative, and even judge their own grief as pathological. They repeat the story of the ‘happy adoptee’ because the alternative feels like a betrayal of the people who raised them. The system lives rent-free inside the minds of the people it trafficked and traumatized.
Praxis and Liberation
Freire insisted that awareness alone is insufficient. Liberation requires praxis: reflection combined with action that transforms reality. Theory without action is empty. Action without reflection is blind.
Adoptees who awaken to the truth face a choice. They can sit with the awareness, carrying the pain in private. Or they can act. They can demand their records, speak out publicly, organize with other adoptees, and refuse the script to build a new story.
Freire wrote that liberation is a mutual process, that the oppressed and the oppressors must both be freed. An adoptee who heals and speaks becomes part of a larger movement. Their individual liberation connects to collective liberation. The personal becomes political.
The Limit-Act
Freire described “limit-situations” as barriers that appear insurmountable, and “limit-acts” as actions taken to overcome them. The sealed file is a limit-situation. The falsified certificate is a limit-situation. The silence that surrounds adoption is a limit-situation.
Every adoptee who demands their truth performs a limit-act. Every person who refuses the thankfulness script performs a limit-act. These accumulate, and the limit-situations weaken.
The pedagogy of the oppressed is not a metaphor for adoption. It is the framework that explains how the system maintains control and how the stolen can reclaim their voice.
The culture of silence can be broken. The banking model can be rejected. The oppressor inside can be evicted.
~~~~~
Sources:
Freire, Paulo. Pedagogy of the Oppressed. Translated by Myra Bergman Ramos, Continuum, 1982. (Original work published 1968)
