What Closed Adoption Borrowed from Operation Paperclip
Obvious Problem
Comparing adoptees to Nazi scientists makes no sense. The scientists were perpetrators of horrific crimes. The adoptees were innocent infants. One group committed atrocities. The other group was ripped away from their moms before they could speak.
The comparison worth making sits elsewhere. Operation Paperclip did not just relocate people. It rewrote the records that defined them. Names, histories, and crimes all vanished from the official file. That is the method closed adoption borrowed.
What Paperclip Actually Did
After World War II, the United States brought over 1,500 German and Austrian scientists to work on American weapons and space programs. Many were Nazi Party members. Some had SS records. Some were involved in the exploitation of concentration camp prisoners.
The program’s name came from the paperclips officials placed on dossiers to signal that certain scientists should receive only cursory review. The paperclip meant one thing: do not look too closely at this person’s past.
The Joint Intelligence Objectives Agency whitewashed the records. It deceived other government agencies about what the security investigations had found. Scientists received new identities, new homes, and new lives. The old selves disappeared from the official record.
Method That Matters
Operation Paperclip did not change who the scientists were. It changed what the paperwork said about them. The men remained the same people. Their crimes remained the same crimes. The record simply stopped acknowledging any of it.
Closed adoption runs the same operation on a different subject. An adoptee’s true identity does not change. Their DNA cannot be edited. Their real parents don’t stop being their parents. Just the paperwork changes. The birth certificate is falsified and a new name appears. Authentic lineage disappears from official records.
Both programs produce the same result. A person walks around inside a life their documents no longer match.
Paperclip on the Dossier
The paperclip was a signal to stop investigating. The dossier existed, and evidence existed. The reviewer chose to look away.
Closed adoption works the same way. Original files exist, with the truth inside. Facts of the person’s birth and family names are documented and preserved. The state decides to seal it off and declare the matter closed. Adoptees who search for their family are asking the authorities to remove the paperclip.
Get MS’s stories in your inbox
Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.
The analogy extends further. The paperclip was not hidden. It sat on top of the file for anyone to see. The secrecy was institutional, rather than accidental. The same holds for adoption records. Everyone knows an honest, original certificate exists. The system asserts that certain people should never see it.
What Each Program Protected
Operation Paperclip protected the American military’s access to German expertise. The scientists’ crimes were the price of admission. The government decided the knowledge mattered more than accountability.
Closed adoption protects the adoption industry and adopters who paid for the arrangement. The infant’s trauma is the price of admission. The system decides that the transaction matters more than the child’s well-being.
Both programs trade a person’s truth for an institution’s convenience. Both programs seal the trade inside a file.
Remaining Differences
The scientists of Operation Paperclip carried their crimes with them. They knew what they had done. The paperwork just stopped mentioning it.
An adoptee carries no crime. They carry a stolen identity, a fabricated record, and a lifetime of questions that others refuse to answer. The scientists were protected from justice. The adoptee is protected from nothing. They lose everything after committing no crime. Then they are gaslit and told it is a perfectly normal fresh start.
The method is the same. The victims are not.
Paperclip Legacy
Operation Paperclip ended decades ago. The scientists are dead. The files have been partially declassified. The public knows what happened.
Closed adoption continues. Paperclips still sit on the dossiers. Files stay sealed. Adoptees keep looking for scraps of their own history.
The government learned the method in the 1940s. It applied it to vulnerable infants and never stopped.
The scientists got their fresh starts, handed to them by officials who owed them punishment. Adoptees got told they received a ‘fresh start’ too, when all they ever wanted was to stay with their family. Crime built on crime, and the paperwork made it all legal.
~~~~~
Sources:
Operation Paperclip. National Archives.
Crim, Brian E. Our Germans: Project Paperclip and the National Security State. Johns Hopkins University Press, 2018.
