Civil Disobedience
Henry David Thoreau Against Tyrants
(Iran War Version)
In this present year, the United States has cast itself upon Iran with a solemn cruelty that no longer surprises me. Nations, like men, grow old in vice; and ours, having long practiced domination abroad and complacency at home, now wages war as though it were merely fulfilling its nature. In May, the declaration was made; by July, I refused to pay the federal tax demanded of me, for I would not lend even a fraction of my substance to a deed so barren of justice. For this refusal, I was confined in the county jail — a place whose walls seemed more honest than the halls of government.
A Government That Has Forgotten Its Soul
I have accepted the motto, “That government is best which governs least,” yet I observe that ours governs most where it has least right to govern. It intrudes upon distant lands with the cold assurance of a machine that no longer remembers it was built by human hands.
This American government — or what remains of it — is a tradition worn thin, a husk endeavouring to transmit itself to posterity though its spirit has long departed. It possesses not the vitality of a single just man. It does not preserve liberty; it does not dispense justice; it does not uplift the poor or restrain the powerful. It is a mechanism that continues to turn only because the governed have forgotten how to step aside.
The Citizen’s Duty in an Age of Moral Exhaustion
I do not ask for no government, but for one that has not surrendered its conscience. Let each citizen declare what government he can respect — and let him withdraw from any other.
The majority rules not because it is right, nor because it is fair, but because it is inert. It is the tyranny of the unthinking. A government in which the majority decides all questions cannot be just, for justice is not a matter of arithmetic.
Must the citizen resign his conscience to the legislature? Why then has he a conscience at all? We must be men first, subjects afterward. The only obligation I acknowledge is to do at any moment what I believe to be right — though the world may not reward it.
The War Against Iran Reveals the Depth of Our Decline
How shall a man comport himself toward the American government today? He cannot do so without disgrace. I cannot recognize as my government one that wages an unjust war and calls its own aggression necessity.
These rulers speak of freedom while binding others; they speak of peace while sowing destruction; they speak of duty while pursuing ambition. Their words fall upon the ear like ashes.
Yet I do not hate them. I merely see them clearly — as men who have forgotten what it means to be human.
The True Enemy Is Apathy, Not Power
The real opponents of justice are not distant tyrants, but our own neighbors — merchants, farmers, and citizens who prefer comfort to conscience. They read the market reports and the war dispatches with equal indifference, and sleep soundly after both.
Get N R Thompson’s stories in your inbox
Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.
They obey because obedience is easy. They comply because compliance is habitual. They serve injustice because injustice asks only for silence.
Thus, tyranny thrives not on cruelty, but on apathy.
Unjust Laws Demand Not Hope, but Refusal
Unjust laws exist. Shall we obey them? Shall we wait for the majority to amend them? Or shall we break them at once?
Most believe they must wait until the majority agrees. They fear that resistance will bring greater harm than obedience. But it is the government that makes resistance perilous. Why does it not anticipate reform? Why does it not cherish its wise minority? Why does it punish those who point out its faults?
Because it fears conscience more than rebellion.
Thus, the citizen must refuse to obey unjust laws — not in anger, but in sorrow.
The Constitution Is a Mirror of Our Failings
The remedies provided by the State are slow and ineffectual. A man’s life will be spent before they bear fruit. And in this matter, the Constitution itself is the evil — not in its words, but in the way it reflects the moral laziness of those who wield it.
Those who oppose the war should withdraw their support — both in person and property — from the government, without waiting to become a majority. Any man more right than his neighbors is already a majority of one.
The Prison Is the Last Refuge of the Free
“Under a government which imprisons any unjustly, the true place for a just man is also a prison.”
Today, the only place the State has provided for its freer spirits is behind bars. There the Iranian civilian, the whistleblower, and the conscientious objector should find us — on ground more honourable than that occupied by those who command the war.
If a thousand men refused to pay their war taxes this year, that would constitute a peaceful revolution. To pay them is the violent act, for it enables the State to shed innocent blood.
Toward a State That Has Not Lost Its Soul
Government authority is impure unless it rests upon the consent of the governed. Democracy is not the final improvement in government. We must take another step toward recognizing the individual as the true source of political power.
I imagine a State led by men who have not forgotten their humanity, who can afford to be just to all, who treat the individual as a neighbour, who allow some to live apart from it without suspicion, fulfilling their duties to mankind without being bound by its machinery.
Such a State would prepare the way for one more perfect still — a State yet unseen in this world.
this 24th day of August Year Of our Lord Two Hundred And Twenty-Six
