Service Fee With Prime? Why Seamless Orders Suddenly Cost More — Even If You Already Pay for Amazon Prime
If you’ve ordered from Seamless or Grubhub lately using your Amazon Prime-linked Grubhub+ membership, you may have noticed something quietly creeping into your checkout screen: a “Service Fee (with Prime)” of a few dollars.
Wait a second. Wasn’t that supposed to be free?
🍔 The Promise: Free Delivery with Grubhub+ via Prime
When Amazon first partnered with Grubhub in 2022, it made a compelling offer to Prime subscribers: get Grubhub+ for free, which included:
- $0 delivery fees on eligible orders
- Reduced or waived service fees
- Access to Seamless (Grubhub’s sibling brand) with the same perks
It worked. Millions of users linked their Prime accounts to get essentially fee-free delivery from their favorite restaurants.
💸 The Quiet Shift: Service Fees Return
But in late 2023 and into 2024, users began to report something strange: while the delivery fee still showed as crossed out (“$0 with Prime”), a new line item appeared:
“Service Fee (with Prime): $2.75”
No announcement. No press release. Just a slow, quiet rollout across major metro areas.
Get OpenClassActions.com’s stories in your inbox
Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.
Even Reddit and Twitter threads show confusion:
“There’s now a service fee with Prime — I swear this wasn’t here before.”
And they’re right. The service fee is new, at least for Prime members who had previously seen $0 across the board.
🤔 What’s Actually Going On?
This change is part of a broader shift in how Grubhub and Seamless manage costs:
- Prime users still get free delivery, but that’s only one part of your checkout.
- Now, even with Prime, most users see a service fee between 5–15% of their order — capped in some cases, but unavoidable in many.
Why? Because the cost of subsidizing delivery — especially without minimum order sizes — is steep. By adding a service fee, Grubhub offsets some of that.
📉 The Small Print Changed
Grubhub’s updated terms now specify:
“Amazon Prime members receive free Grubhub+… which includes $0 delivery fees on eligible orders, but does not guarantee service fee waivers.”
🧾 So What’s on My Receipt Now?
Here’s how a typical Seamless or Grubhub order looks today with Prime:
Fee TypeWith PrimeDelivery Fee$0 ✅Service Fee$2.75–$4.00 ❌Small Order Fee (if <$15)Still appliesBag/Regulatory FeesVaries by cityTipOptional (but expected)
The result? What used to be a $25 order with zero fees might now total $29+, even with Prime.
🧠 Is It Still Worth It?
For many, the Prime + Grubhub+ combo is still worth it — especially if you order often, or from high-fee restaurants.
But for others, the unexpected reappearance of fees is prompting a second look at alternatives like DoorDash, Uber Eats, or even old-school pickup.
And for budget-conscious users, the takeaway is simple:
Always check the fine print — even if it’s labeled “with Prime.”
If you feel like your Seamless orders suddenly got more expensive — you’re not imagining it. The “Service Fee with Prime” is real, and it’s part of a quiet but significant policy shift.
Free delivery isn’t free anymore. At least, not fully.
