Before You Pick a Hook, Decide What the Ad Needs to Prove
Put a glossy lunchbox under soft light, lift the lid, and let steam drift past the lens. I can already picture the opening. A bright lunch, shallow focus, a fork entering the frame.
It is an easy idea to like.
Now give that ad a brief: reach commuters who bring lunch to work but hate carrying another bag. The reason to consider this particular box is that it fits beside the things they already carry.
That changes the opening I want.
The food shot makes me want lunch. It leaves the choice of container largely unexplained. I could replace the box with a plate and preserve most of the appeal.
For this brief, I want to see an open work bag. The laptop and notebook are already inside. There is a narrow space left. A hand lowers the lunchbox into it, closes the zipper, and picks up the bag.
The little uncertainty is whether everything will fit. Closing the zipper resolves it. The product gets to do something useful before anyone has to describe it.
Get Astorie’s stories in your inbox
Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.
I prefer that opening because its attraction comes from the same thing the ad needs to establish. I am not asking an unrelated spectacle to earn attention and then handing the selling job to a later caption.
But it needs careful framing. Shoot too close and the bag becomes an unrecognizable patch of fabric. Shoot too wide and the viewer may miss the fit altogether. I want enough of the laptop visible to make the space understandable, with the box entering in one readable action.
I also want the everyday contents to stay in place. If the hand quietly removes the notebook to make room, the scene has solved the wrong problem. The whole point was to avoid rearranging the commute around lunch.
Astorie’s guide to building a promo around one message and one proof beat is useful when turning a choice like this into a short sequence. Here, the packing action earns its place first. The food, finish, and closing image can be chosen around it.
There is a cost. A work bag is less immediately appetizing than a beautifully prepared meal. This version gives up some sensory pleasure to make the purchase reason visible.
If the brief were about enjoying homemade food at the office, I might lead with the lid opening. Steam and texture would then be doing relevant work. I would want the meal to feel worth bringing.
Those two ads could use the same product, location, and cast. They would still need different openings.
That is why I find a page of hook ideas difficult to judge on its own. A surprising first frame can be clever without helping me decide which product to buy. Before choosing it, I want to know what doubt the rest of the ad is supposed to remove.
For this commuter, I am starting with the crowded bag. Once the box is inside and the zipper is closed, we can get to lunch.
