When Respect Depends on What Someone Does for a Living
At a gathering, someone asks what you do.
You tell them your profession. Their expression brightens. They ask where you work, offer you a seat and introduce you to someone across the room.
A few minutes later, another person answers the same question.
The response is shorter.
“Oh. I see.”
The conversation moves on.
Nothing openly insulting has happened. Yet the difference is difficult to miss.
One answer opened a door. The other seemed to close it.
The Question After the Name
Asking about work is a natural way to get to know someone. It tells us something about how they spend their days, what they have learned and the responsibilities they carry.
But sometimes we use the answer to decide how much attention they deserve.
We become more patient with someone whose title impresses us. We overlook an interruption from a wealthy acquaintance that would irritate us coming from someone else. We remember the name of the person who owns the business while referring to the person cleaning it only by their task.
These small differences reveal a hierarchy we may never admit to believing in.
We might sincerely say that everyone deserves respect. The more difficult question is whether everyone receives it from us.
Knowing the Value of Work
In Pakistani families, conversations about employment often carry understandable concern.
Parents who have experienced financial insecurity may want their children to find stable professions. A dependable income can mean rent paid on time, treatment when someone is ill and fewer nights spent worrying about the next expense.
There is nothing shallow about wanting that security.
The problem begins when concern about someone’s circumstances becomes a judgment about their worth.
A person can need a better salary without needing to feel ashamed of the work they currently do. A family can encourage ambition without making affection sound conditional on a promotion.
Yet encouragement sometimes arrives as comparison.
“Look where your cousin has reached.”
“After all that education, this is what you’re doing?”
The speaker may intend to motivate. The person hearing it may learn to avoid conversations about work altogether.
The Labour We Rely On
Consider how much of an ordinary day depends on people whose jobs receive little admiration.
Get Encrypted Human’s stories in your inbox
Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.
Someone prepares the food we eat outside our homes. Someone delivers a parcel through unfamiliar streets. Someone cleans a washroom that hundreds of people will use.
We notice quickly when this work is delayed or done poorly. We can be much slower to notice the person doing it well.
At a restaurant, we may speak warmly to the manager and barely look at the person clearing the table. We may complain about a late delivery without allowing the rider enough time to explain where they got stuck.
Good service matters. People should be able to raise genuine problems. But a complaint can be clear without becoming an opportunity to humiliate someone.
The person receiving it still has a name, a working day and circumstances we cannot see.
Being Praised as Hardworking
Even our praise can carry an uncomfortable condition.
We describe someone as deserving respect because they work long hours, never complain and sacrifice everything for their family.
Their effort deserves recognition. But where does that leave someone who is ill, unemployed or unable to keep going at the same pace?
A person should not have to present an extraordinary story of struggle before we treat them decently.
Someone between jobs can still contribute to a conversation. Someone doing routine work can have insight that has nothing to do with their occupation. An older relative’s importance does not disappear when their earning years end.
If we recognise people only through their usefulness, there will always be moments when they fear they have become less worthy of our attention.
What We Teach Without Saying
Children notice whom adults listen to.
They see whether we greet the security guard. They hear how we speak about domestic workers when they are absent. They watch a relative’s confidence change when a more influential guest enters the room.
From these moments, they can learn that manners depend on who has power.
They can also learn something better.
They can see us thank someone without making a performance of it. They can hear us correct a mistake without insulting the person who made it. They can watch us show interest in someone who has nothing to offer us professionally or socially.
Those habits make our stated values more believable.
Asking a Better Second Question
The next time someone tells you what they do, notice your first response.
Perhaps the answer impresses you. Perhaps it does not. You do not need to turn that reaction into the shape of the whole conversation.
Ask what their day is like. Find out what they enjoy outside work. Give them the same room to speak that you would give someone whose title you admire.
There may be a story there. There may simply be an ordinary conversation.
Either is enough.
And when someone serving you finishes a task, look up before they walk away.
The work may have brought them into the room. How you speak to them is your decision.
— Encrypted Human
Decoding society. Exploring humanity.
