The Missing Corpus
BY RAMEE DEEB
Over a hundred million years ago, resin would drip down trees and down to earth, where it would trap insects and bugs going on with their daily lives. Live or dead, it did not matter much, for they were frozen in time (and place). I have always found extraordinary how, after all these years, amber is still capable of ‘encapsulating’ those insects, floating eternally in their amber prison. Though, does a bug in amber really tell us much about the life it lived, the other insects that it has known throughout the course of its life, or even what life even looked like back then? Photography, just like amber, entails trapping within its boundaries the subjects it aims to expose and preserve for a long time to come. Many questions arise when dissecting a photograph, specifically concerning the temporal as well as the indexical portrayal of its subject and the purpose for which it was originally taken. In this, rather humble, attempt of grasping the visual stakes of a photograph in terms of portraying a subject and the contextual elements that go beyond its two-dimensional borders, we take a closer look at a photography project aimed towards exposing the missing family members of Syrian refugees in the Lebanese Bekaa valey.
Upon being asked whether he knew that he was capturing fleeting moments, world-known American photographer Ansel Adams challenges the notion of ‘fleeting’ saying that ‘in the ideological sense, a year could be a fleeting moment and at times it could be the 25th of a second’. There have been long debates about the temporal as much as the indexical nature of ‘the photograph’, specifically on what a photograph reflects and under what logic of representation it lives. I bring this topic up mainly to investigate within a practical framework that encompasses three dimensions: the ethics of a photograph, the visual construct of a photograph, and the epistemological boundaries that contribute to a photograph.
In Okwui Enwezor’s essay “Archive Fever” he examines the relationship between photography and the archival practice, calling the camera an archiving machine and ‘every film is a priori an archival object’. “The capacity for mechanical inscription and the order of direct reference that links the photograph with the indisputable fact of its subject’s existence are the bedrock of photography and film.” Though, photography, as we shall see later , does not always faithfully fulfill that duty of acting as ‘proof’ of that subject’s existence, mainly due to the way the photograph was taken out of context.
Italian photographer Dario Mitidieri, have recently gone to a Syrian refugee camp in the Bekaa Valley of Lebanon and invited families to pose for ‘formal’ photographs, only for these families — because of war — some of its members were missing.
The aim of his project, as he said to Joanna Moorhead in an interview to The Guardian, is to make war photography ‘real’ again by telling the stories of the individuals affected most by it: the refugees. By showing the family in the context of a formal portrait, we presume a utopian representation of that family: best clothes, shiniest smile, presumably a happy memory, though in this case it is completely the opposite. Dystopia qua utopia. It is the wreckage of a family portrait that we see, the elements are present, its members are absent.
During the past few years, there have been innumerable photographs portraying the lives of Syrian refugees across Europe, Lebanon, and Turkey; none was able to capture those who were not there, who did not even make it to seek refuge, those who were elsewhere, and those who are missing. In fact, Mitidieri’s project falls between that of exposure, and that of erasure.
To better comprehend what is at stake in this project, I shall closely examine the compositional as well as the visual elements of these photographs. By leaving an empty chair among the rest of the family members, the void the absence of one member leaves becomes visible, even though he/she is not present from the photograph: letting the viewer’s imagination visualize what is unseen as it asks “who should be there?” and “where are they now?”
In order to highlight the relationship that bonds these families with their missing members, Mitidiori purposefully posits his subjects in front of a black drop to give gravitas to the suspended and ongoing sadness that they are experiencing. These families know nothing about the fate of their loved ones, they cannot grieve, neither can they hope for their return. On the other hand, the black drop might serve an aesthetic purpose other than that of exposing the subjects in the already vulnerable position in front of the camera, and that is: removing them from the context where they belong to, it takes away the viewer’s right of genuine subjectivity that serves reality raw (the eye cannot wander to visit the background, thanks to the backdrop) — I find it quaint to adhere the fact that the only purpose for the black drop, in the first place, is give the notion of a ‘formal’ family portrait.
“So behind them you can see the mountains and that is Syria. Alongside them, you can see the tents and that is where they are living.”
If one would want to show the living conditions of these refugees, one could do so without a black drop: it is yet another taxidermic representation that resembles Daguerre’s attempts to define the ‘other’ physiologically and Galton’s pursuit of identifying the villains among society. I believe that the photographer should have put his subjects among the context that they belong to: endless stream of refugees surrounding them, accentuating the fact that they belong to a bigger societal circle.
In Susan Sontag’s seminal collection of essays ‘On Photography’ she says: “To photograph is to appropriate the thing photographed. It means putting oneself into a certain relation to the world that feels like knowledge — and, therefore, like power. A now notorious first fall into alienation, habituating people to abstract the world into printed words, is supposed to have engendered that surplus of Faustian energy and psychic damage needed to build modern, inorganic societies[…]photographed images do not seem to be statements about the world so much as pieces of it, miniatures of reality that anyone can make or acquire.”
Get Ramee Deeb’s stories in your inbox
Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.
In this process, the black drop dis-empowers the subjects it aims to empower, stripping them from any sense of agency towards what they want to convey and how the aim to achieve it. Also, having a black background gives any photography enthusiast the ability to manipulate the photograph by cropping it and thus rendering the whole project trivial. Even when the photograph succeeds in showing the broken state that these families are present in: discplaced and stranded in the middle of nowhere, it does not fulfill the epistemological boundaries of a ‘formal’ portrait photograph.
Within the intimately connected elements that create the photograph, it’s hard to really see the connection between the background and the foreground. It is as if their wounds were left open for a tourist to capture its photo: an enlarged microscopic image.
In WJT Mitchell’s ‘What Do Pictures Want?’ the surplus value of an image enables it to “continue to live on, haunting, tempting, and perhaps frightening or inspiring us”, where it belongs to a grander sphere that binds the photographer with the camera, the viewer, the subject, and the context. Images suddenly become strangely familiar to us, we attune to their needs, resonate with their vibrancies, thus we become of one realm. Though, looking at these pictures, I cannot but remain silent while attending to them, I cannot form that kind of relationship where I would enter into conversation with the image, which brings me to my next contemplation: On what side of the spectrum do these images belong to, do they act as evidence to these refugees’ living conditions or merely document them for archival purposes? Do they aim to cause a seismic shift in the public memory or remain latent within the folds of those families’ private histories?
The reason why I pose these questions is not necessarily to find answers to them, but instead to show that these images are in a suspended state of always already, constantly shifting between the binaries of contemporary amnesia and remembrance, document and monument, past and present. You cannot preserve a reality or a moment in time by the assumption that a photograph is a memory (memories belong to the past), because it is not: it is a violation to your visual and cognitive space, it forces you to see what is there and what is not.
Looking at portraits, one must be able to resonate with the peoples’ silent faces in the photograph, their gazes leaving a residue in one’s retina. I would hate to sound too critical when I say that this project is quite brutal in its attempt to bring up the missing, though after all photography is interconnected with death and the preserve of the dead (their life) against the flow of time : it is yet another homicide with quite a blatant evidence of its happening.
Unlike a fossil which only shows a creature’s trace, amber on the other hand traps it within.
Taking a closer look at these photographs, you realize that they have always been void, even while the “beetles” are entrapped. These photographs exposes one beetle, while disregarding the other millions that managed to escape that drop of resin. All you end up with is a totem of that creature’s existence, yet there’s nothing to look at beyond its humble missing corpus.
Ramee Deeb is a filmmaker, photographer, and an art enthusiast. MA in Media Studies from the American University of Beirut.
follow at: Ramee Deeb
References:
1. Sontag, Susan. On Photography. New York: Farrar, Straus and Giroux, 1997.
2. Enwezor, Okwui. Archive Fever: Uses of the Document in Contemporary Photography. Göttingen: Steidl, 2008.
3. Mitchell, W. J. T. What Do Pictures Want?: The Lives and Loves of Images. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 2005.
4. Barthes, Roland. Camera Lucida: Reflections on Photography. New York: Hill and Wang, 1981.
5. Moorhead, Joanna. “Portraits of Syrian Refugee Families — and an Empty Place for the Missing.” The Guardian. January 30, 2016. Accessed April 03, 2016. http://www.theguardian.com/lifeandstyle/2016/jan/30/portraits-of-syrian-refugee-families-and-an-empty-place-for-the-missing.
6. Bazin, Andre. “The Ontology of the Photographic Image.” Trans. Hugh Gray. Film Quarterly 13.4 (1960): 4–9.









