The Life We Didn't Choose
Ananya's earliest memories were full of noise.
Someone was always talking in their small house. Her father sang badly while shaving. Her mother hummed old songs while cooking. Children from the colony ran through the lanes until somebody's mother shouted them home.
When she was seven, her father bought her a second-hand bicycle.
It was too big. She could barely touch the ground and the brakes made a horrible scraping sound. She rode it every afternoon, knees permanently bruised.
Her father ran beside her, hand on the back of the seat.
"Don't let go!" she shouted.
"I'm not letting go!"
"You are! I can feel it!"
"Then keep riding and stop looking behind you!"
She turned forward just in time to crash into a pile of plastic crates.
He laughed so hard she threw dust at him.
That evening her mother cleaned the scratches while Ananya complained about the bicycle, her father, and the unfairness of being told not to look behind.
Her mother listened, then kissed the top of her head.
"You'll learn," she said.
Ananya believed her.
Their house had two rooms, a kitchen that was unbearably hot in summer, and a bathroom door that never closed. When it rained, water slipped through a crack and her father placed a bucket underneath.
But she never thought of herself as poor.
She had cheap birthday cakes, uniforms repaired by her mother, and a father who brought home a guava whenever he passed a fruit seller.
She ranked third in class. The first two had private tutors. She studied from borrowed guidebooks beside the kitchen window because it was the only place with light.
"Third again?" her father would ask.
"Good. Next time try for second."
"Why not first?"
"Because if you get first, I'll have to buy you something expensive."
She also filled old notebooks with stories about girls who discovered hidden kingdoms. She danced when the radio played, sang into a hairbrush, imagined applause from the other side of the door.
Her mother sometimes stood there listening. She never told Ananya.
Then Kunal was born.
Ananya was eleven when she held him. Red-faced, wrinkled, less impressive than expected.
"He looks angry," she whispered.
Her mother laughed from the bed. "He has every right to be. You've been standing outside every five minutes."
She loved his tiny fingers curling around hers. For a while she was delighted.
Then the house changed.
Her father came home later. Her mother slept less. Conversations about medicine, rent, delayed wages continued even when Ananya entered the room.
One afternoon she came home with her report card. Second place. She had beaten the boy ahead of her. She imagined her father's face all the way home.
Her mother was feeding Kunal, who had been crying for an hour. Ananya held out the card.
"Maa, look."
"Second? That's wonderful, beta."
Then Kunal started crying again. Her mother put the report card on the table and picked him up.
"Just a minute, beta."
Five minutes passed. Then ten.
She took the card back to her room and placed it inside a notebook.
By the time her father noticed it, the moment had passed. He congratulated her, kissed her forehead, promised to buy something nice.
She told him it was all right. She meant it, mostly. But she began keeping good news to herself.
By tenth grade she was good at pretending nothing bothered her.
Her father drank regularly. At first with men from the colony. Then alone. His temper worsened. Arguments over money became shouting, sometimes something breaking, then her mother's silence.
Ananya learned the difference between his ordinary footsteps and the unsteady ones that meant she should take Kunal into their room.
School was the only place where her problems became small enough to forget.
That was where she noticed Rohan.
Two rows away from the windows, uniform always neat, answers almost always correct. Polite but distant. People thought he was arrogant. He just didn't know how to be included.
She became curious after the mathematics exam. He scored full marks. She lost two points copying a number wrong.
"You could have checked it," the teacher told her.
"I did, sir."
"Then you should have checked it properly."
The class laughed. As lesson continued, she noticed Rohan looking at the same question.
When the bell rang she walked to his desk.
"Did you really get full marks?"
"Yes."
"Every question?"
"That's usually what full marks means."
She stared. Then noticed the faint smile.
"You could try being less irritating."
"I could."
"Will you?"
"No."
She laughed before she could stop herself. He looked surprised, then smiled.
That was how they began talking.
She borrowed his notes, returned them missing a page. He pointed it out. She accused him of counting pages to embarrass her. He helped her with a problem, refused the samosa she offered as thanks.
"You don't like samosas?"
"I do."
"Then take it."
"You bought it for yourself."
"I bought two. Because I thought you might be hungry."
He accepted it.
"Was that so difficult? Accepting something without acting like I asked you to sign a legal agreement?"
He laughed. First time she heard him laugh properly.
They began sharing lunch, walking to the bus stop together.
She discovered he wasn't unfriendly, just unused to being included. He didn't know most students' names. Had never attended a birthday party. When she asked what he did on weekends, he said he studied.
"What do you do for fun?"
He considered. "I don't know."
She thought he was joking. He wasn't.
She started bringing him pieces of her world. Stories she wrote but wouldn't let him read. Films she watched with her mother. Kunal's habit of putting everything in his mouth.
Rohan listened. Sometimes disagreed. Never told her it was stupid.
In return he told her about books, about his future with a certainty that made her envious. He had plans. She had wishes.
One afternoon she found him alone in an empty classroom, staring through the window.
"Are you waiting for someone?"
"No. I was thinking. What happens after school."
"College, obviously."
"And after college?"
"A job. Money. A house. Maybe a dog."
"You've planned your entire life around a dog?"
"At least I'll have someone waiting when I get home."
She said it lightly. Rohan didn't smile.
"Do you ever feel like everyone else knows what they're doing, and you're just trying to keep up?" he asked.
"Every day."
"Really?"
"Rohan, I once spent an entire evening worrying I couldn't afford a birthday present for my mother."
"What happened?"
"I made her a card. She kept it."
He nodded, looking back out the window. She wanted to ask what he was worrying about, but something stopped her.
"You don't have to figure out your whole life right now," she said.
He turned. "Neither do you."
That answer stayed with her long after she went home.
Board examinations came. Teachers spoke only of marks. Parents of admissions.
Ananya studied harder than ever. A scholarship might let her attend college without being a burden. Perhaps she could help her mother. Give Kunal opportunities.
Once she fell asleep over notes. When she woke the classroom was almost empty, her notebook placed beneath her cheek. Rohan was packing his bag.
"Why didn't you wake me?"
"You looked tired."
By then she recognized the feeling whenever he entered a room. She was falling in love with him. It frightened her more than expected.
In her stories love was simple. Two people met, understood each other, chose to remain together.
Real life seemed less accommodating.
Results were announced on a hot morning in May. She found her roll number near the top, far better than expected. She called her mother from a borrowed phone, both of them crying.
Her father was home when she arrived, smiling without alcohol for once. "Your mother and I are proud of you."
Later she discovered Rohan had ranked first across the state. She found him on the school steps, result sheet folded in hand.
"Congratulations!"
"Thank you."
"First across the state, Rohan. Do you understand how ridiculous that is?"
"I made mistakes."
"Are you ever happy with anything?"
"I don't know how to be," he said at last.
She took him to a small public garden the next day. They bought ice cream, sat on a bench while children played.
He watched the children. "I've never done this before. Spent an afternoon with someone just because they wanted to spend time with me."
She nudged his shoulder. "Well, get used to it. You're not very good company, but I can tolerate you."
Get LASTtorch’s stories in your inbox
Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.
On the way home he bought her a cheap keychain shaped like a little blue bird.
"It was on sale," he said.
"How romantic."
She closed her fingers around it. "Don't you dare take it back."
She kept it for years.
The celebration in the colony lasted into evening. Neighbours came, someone brought sweets. Then a car pulled into the lane.
The man who stepped out was one of the wealthiest employers in the area. Several people worked for him, including Ananya's father. He congratulated her and asked about her plans.
She said she hoped to attend college.
"Good," he said, and took out a small box. A fountain pen, polished metal clip, dark blue body. "For your studies."
"Thank you, sir."
He smiled at her parents. "My son will need a capable wife one day. I've been thinking about Ananya. She's intelligent, well-mannered, hardworking. When she turns eighteen, we can discuss marriage."
Nearby people exchanged delighted looks. Her mother seemed too surprised to answer. Her father looked as if someone had offered a way out of every problem.
"That would be a great honour," he said.
Ananya stood very still. She knew almost nothing about his son except he came from a wealthy family.
She looked at her father. He was smiling.
She wanted to ask whether he had considered what she wanted. Words never came.
That night she placed the pen on her desk and sat beside it.
Her father entered. "You're quiet."
"Do I have to marry him?"
"Not now. You're still young."
"But when I'm eighteen?"
"He's a good match. You'll have a comfortable life."
"What if I don't want to?"
"Don't start thinking foolishly. Do you know how many people would want this opportunity?"
She looked down. "Yes, Papa."
He softened. "I only want you to be safe. And if things go well, perhaps Kunal will study properly. We won't have to struggle forever."
Not a threat. Just another family problem placed gently in her hands.
After he left she took the blue bird keychain and held it.
For the first time she understood a person could be loved by their family and still be expected to give up the life they wanted.
Rohan noticed something changed. She stopped staying after school, stopped telling him about stories, seemed distracted.
He asked if she was all right. She said tired. The second time he didn't accept it.
"Did I do something wrong?"
"No."
"Then why are you avoiding me?"
"I'm not."
"You haven't looked at me properly all day."
He waited. She wanted to tell him everything. Wanted him to say they could find a way out.
But she also knew what happened when money disappeared from a household like theirs. Rohan could offer love. He couldn't promise love would protect everyone she cared about.
"I'm fine," she said.
A week later he waited after class.
"I need to tell you something," he said.
They went to the empty classroom, afternoon light across desks.
"I've been trying to understand when it happened. I don't know when you became the person I look for whenever something happens. When I do well, I want to tell you. When I do badly, I want to talk to you. I used to think being alone was easier because I didn't have to worry about losing anyone. Then I met you. You made ordinary things matter."
His hands were clasped so tightly his knuckles were pale.
"I love you, Ananya."
For a moment she forgot the house, money, temper, promise made without permission. There was only Rohan offering something she wanted more than she'd allowed.
She loved him. Wanted to tell him.
Instead heard herself say, "I'm sorry."
He went still.
"I don't feel that way about you. You're my friend. That's all."
He searched her face. "Are you sure?"
She forced a nod.
"I understand," he said, picked up his bag. At the door: "I hope things go well for you."
Then he left.
She remained until light faded.
Rohan never spoke to her again.
Not cruel. That made it worse. Losing someone didn't always involve argument or final goodbye. Sometimes a familiar person became a stranger while everyone else continued.
Two years passed. She turned eighteen, and promise became wedding arrangement. Her father's employer paid. Family wore new clothes. Neighbours said how fortunate she was.
She smiled for photographs. She had become very good at smiling when she wanted to cry.
On the night before, her mother sat beside her. "Are you happy?"
She wanted to tell everything. Wanted her mother to say she could refuse. But her mother looked so worried Ananya couldn't add another burden.
"I'm all right, Maa."
Next morning she married his son.
He barely spoke during ceremony. Later, alone, he removed his watch.
"I hope you understand this marriage is not what I wanted either. My father chose you. He thinks marrying someone from poor background will make you more grateful. You'll have comfortable life. In return, behave sensibly. Don't embarrass me, don't expect affection because we're married."
Ananya looked at bangles on her wrists. "I understand."
"Good. At least you're sensible. I was worried you'd expect this to be some love story."
She had imagined marriage might at least bring peace. She was beginning to understand comfort and peace were not same thing.
Six years later, Ananya stood beside a roadside stall with vegetables.
Her son asleep in cloth sling against her back. Afternoon warm, air smelling of dust, frying oil, rain that had fallen earlier.
She had learned to bargain, keep accounts, stretch money across week. Her husband gave her separate place after arguments became too frequent, though enough money to ensure she and child would not become public embarrassment.
Most days she didn't think about it. There were bills, meals, small boy who decided sleep was insult invented by adults.
She loved him fiercely. When he smiled, world became simpler.
She was arranging tomatoes when a car stopped opposite. A man stepped out, dark suit, phone in hand. Two other men followed, speaking about meeting.
She barely glanced. Then man turned toward road.
Basket slipped slightly in her hands.
"Rohan?"
He turned. Men beside him continued until noticing he wasn't listening.
He looked at her. Recognition arriving before he seemed prepared.
"Ananya?"
"Hello."
Neither moved. Then Rohan crossed road.
"How long has it been?"
"Six, I think."
"You remember?"
"I remember a lot of things."
She looked at car. "You're doing well."
"Some days. That's very modest answer for someone who arrives with two people carrying folders."
He laughed. Sound brought back classroom, shared samosa, boy who looked as if happiness was something he had to study.
"How are you?" he asked.
"I'm fine." He glanced at vegetables, then sleeping child. "Your son?"
"Arjun. Two."
"That's good name."
One of men called from car. Rohan raised hand.
"Are you happy?" he asked.
She could have smiled and said everything fine. Instead looked at son.
"I have good days," she said.
He nodded, accepting without asking to explain.
"I'm glad."
She wanted to ask about his life. Whether married. Whether happy. Whether he ever thought about classroom, garden, girl who said she saw him only as friend. Questions seemed selfish now. He had built life without her. She had without him.
"Rohan," she said. "I'm sorry."
His expression softened, though he didn't pretend to misunderstand.
"Take care of yourself, Ananya."
"You too."
He returned to car. Before getting inside, glanced back once. She raised hand.
Car pulled away. She watched it disappear.
Her son stirred against back, making small unhappy sound. She patted him until settled. Tomatoes still needed arranging. Customer waiting. Afternoon getting hotter.
She returned to work.
That evening after putting son to bed, she found blue bird keychain inside tin box beneath clothes. Had carried it through two houses, marriage, six years of life never imagined at fifteen.
She held it in palm. Could still remember boy who bought it because on sale. Way he looked when told her he loved her, way he left when she said she didn't.
She had loved him. Been afraid. Both true.
She placed keychain back and closed lid.
She didn't know whether different choice would have made her happier. Perhaps they would have struggled together. Perhaps failed. Perhaps found way to build something good.
There was no answer.
She turned off light and lay beside sleeping son. Outside someone laughing in lane. Pressure cooker whistling next door. Train passing through city.
Life continued.
Ananya closed eyes. She loved her son. Would protect him, teach him, give every opportunity she could. Would not tell him his life was mistake.
But sometimes when house quiet and nothing left to do, she wondered about girl she had been before she learned to put everyone else's future ahead of her own.
She wondered what that girl might have become.
Then morning would come, and she would rise to meet it.
There was still a life to live, even if it wasn't the one she had once wanted.
And perhaps that was cruelest part of all: world had not ended when she gave up her choice.
It had simply carried on without asking whether she was ready.
