A Reply to Free Mind
A link to the article I will debunk here.
“No Nation is Perfect, But None Deserves Your Hatred”
Desert is kind of besides the point. Does sodium deserve a violent chemical reaction whenever exposed to water? Hatred is what happens when someone is exposed to a community they aren’t compatible with. Being barred from extricating oneself from the community in question makes matters worse.
“[H]ating your homeland because of its imperfections is like hating your family for its dysfunctions while ignoring its strengths.”
There are cases where I wouldn’t blame anyone for hating their literal family. If my father was Jeffrey Epstein, I wouldn’t even pretend to like him.
“National identity, whether fully embraced or reluctantly acknowledged, is part of who you are. Language, traditions, history, and shared values shape your worldview.”
If someone grew up in some kind of cult, such as the Church of Scientology or a neo-Nazi community, but then came to completely reject it, then of course the context of their nativity would continue to shape them, but the negation of their original community would be no less constitutive of who they are.
“Many who despise their homeland fantasize about other nations as utopias, only to discover that those places have their own deep flaws. No society is a paradise, and those who flee their country in hatred often find that their discontent follows them.”
Get Snowdrop’s stories in your inbox
Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.
It has the same energy as “no person is perfect, and those who flee a forced marriage in hatred often find that their discontent follows them”.
“If you believe your country is flawed, the answer is not hatred but effort. Every great reform — whether social, political, or economic — came from people who cared enough to demand better from their society. True reformers do not wallow in bitterness; they work to improve things.”
Not every political change that is imaginable is realistically feasible. Wisdom is realizing when something has become a lost cause and it is time to extricate oneself. If the Axis powers had somehow won WWII, France would quite conceivably have remained exposed to the capricious tyranny of the German Nazis for the rest of human history.
“Ingratitude is a Moral Failure”
It is questionable to demand gratitude for something that a person did not request or consent to.
“A nation is not just a government or a piece of land; it is a shared project, a collective inheritance.”
In some cases that inheritance is net debt.
“To hate it is to reject your own role in that story.”
And that is bad?
