In Pursuit of the Perfect Flake
For years, Cornell & Diehl has made some excellent tobacco and some pretty questionable “flakes.”
The presentation is familiar: open the tin and instead of neat slices, there is something halfway between broken flake, ready-rubbed, and the aftermath of a small industrial accident. The tobacco may taste great, but calling it a flake sometimes requires a generous interpretation of the word.
Then photographs of the 2026 Carolina Red Flake began appearing online.
And now, C&D appears to have learned how to make a flake.
The slices are broad, rectangular, clearly layered, and — most importantly — intact. They actually look like something that can be pulled from the tin, folded, stuffed, rubbed out, or cube-cut by the smoker. That is what a flake is supposed to be.
C&D’s production process has apparently improved considerably. Its newer holding-press setup keeps blocks under sustained, regularly reapplied pressure, producing denser cakes that cut more cleanly. That alone seems to have solved a substantial part of the company’s traditional presentation problem.
But now that C&D has gotten this far, it should not stop.
Go Full European
If C&D can produce a coherent pressed block and slice it cleanly, the next step should be obvious:
Make proper European-style flakes.
Think Orlik, Capstan, Escudo, and the classic Mac Baren flakes — thin, uniform, flexible, cohesive sheets of tobacco.
C&D has traditionally taken pride in allowing pressure, moisture, and the natural properties of the tobacco to bind a flake together. That is admirable in principle.
It is also unnecessary.
European manufacturers have long used another tool: binding agents such as gum arabic.
This does not mean slathering tobacco in glue. Gum arabic can be used in very small quantities as part of a liquid casing or conditioning solution. The tobacco is treated, pressed, and allowed to set. The binder simply helps all those leaf surfaces remain attached when the block hits the cutter.
The result is an actual flake.
That seems like a good trade.
Purity Is Overrated When the Flake Falls Apart
There is a certain romance to saying that a flake contains nothing holding it together except tobacco itself.
But what practical benefit does the smoker actually receive from that philosophy?
C&D already uses normal tobacco-processing techniques throughout its catalog. Casings, toppings, humectants, steaming, pressing, aging, and moisture control are not somehow violations of tobacco purity. They are part of manufacturing pipe tobacco.
So why draw an ideological line at a tiny amount of neutral binder?
If 0.2 or 0.5 percent gum arabic means an intact Carolina Red Flake can be pulled from the tin instead of excavating tobacco rubble, use the gum arabic.
The tin label is not being smoked.
The tobacco is.
And if the binder is essentially flavorless at the amount required while dramatically improving the physical product, the downside is difficult to see.
And Then Come the Coins
This is where things get interesting.
Once C&D can reliably manufacture thin, cohesive sheets of pressed tobacco, it is no longer limited to rectangular flakes.
Get Supergrafx’s stories in your inbox
Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.
Those sheets can be rolled.
The manufacture of Peter Stokkebye Luxury Bullseye Flake demonstrates the basic concept beautifully. The outer tobacco is first formed into a pressed sheet. That sheet is then wrapped around a separate central core. The resulting cylindrical roll is set and sliced crosswise.
That is how the bullseye medallions are formed.
It is not magic.
And C&D already possesses the most important ingredient: fantastic tobacco.
Imagine a Carolina Red Virginia sheet rolled around a Perique-rich center.
Slice it into clean medallions.
Carolina Red Bullseye.
That would sell.
Or make a Bright Virginia and Burley coin. A Red Virginia coin with a dark Virginia center. A VaPer with Perique concentrated toward the middle so the smoker can decide whether to rub the entire coin together or manipulate the balance.
C&D has enough distinctive leaf to build an entire line around the format.
The Tobacco Has Never Been the Problem
That is really the frustrating part.
C&D does not need to become STG.
Its tobacco should not become Danish tobacco. Its blends should not become sweeter, milder, or more polished simply for the sake of being European.
Keep the American character.
Keep the bold Virginias.
Keep the Burley.
Keep the Perique.
Keep Jeremy Reeves doing strange things with interesting leaf.
Just improve the physical engineering of the finished product.
Because if the recent Carolina Red Flake photographs are representative, the hardest part may already be solved. C&D can now make a block dense enough and uniform enough to produce something that genuinely resembles a flake.
So go the rest of the way.
Use a little gum arabic when necessary. Tighten the moisture control. Cut the flakes thinner. Make the slices consistent. Package them carefully.
And once that is perfected?
Buy a rolling machine and start making coins.
Millions will be sold.
Possibly billions.
Okay, probably not billions.
But they would sell like hell.
