How to Become Indispensable in Business: Carly’s Playbook
The Skill She Was Worst At Became Her Career: Carly on How to Become Indispensable in Business | Overpressure, Podcast
Quick Answer: You don’t start out indispensable in business. You build it. Ask for more work than your role requires, find mentors who will train you in your weakest area, and do the work you love so consistently that no colleague, competitor, or AI tool can replace you. Southern California coach and consultant Carly Pepin makes this case on a recent episode of the Overpressure Podcast.
Most career advice treats being indispensable as a personality trait. On a recent episode of Overpressure, the military transition podcast hosted by Austin Holmes, Carly Pepin argues the opposite. Her career is the evidence. A skincare startup lost ground because the founders didn’t understand marketing. She then took an executive assistant job, kept asking for more work, and became the marketing manager. That relationship is still going 25 years later.
Watch the full episode on YouTube.
How do you make yourself indispensable at work?
You become indispensable by repeatedly asking what you could do that would move the needle so much that someone wouldn’t want to lose you. Carly got this advice from her father, and she still uses it with every client. The aim is to be so useful that a client won’t want to stop working with her, and would come back if they did.
She applied the rule early. As the first executive assistant to fashion designer Tadashi, she kept running out of work. She didn’t coast. She told the marketing manager who hired her that she had capacity. That manager was already doing far more than her title suggested, so she started giving Carly marketing projects and training her as she went. Within three months, Carly was working for her.
Many people wait for permission to grow. Carly’s version is simpler: finish your work and ask for the next problem.
Can the skill you’re worst at become your career?
Yes, if you treat the weakness as a gap in training and not a fixed trait. Carly’s biggest professional weakness turned into her career once she had the right marketing mentorship.
The weakness showed up first. After a career advisor at community college told her the path she wanted didn’t exist, her entrepreneur parents suggested a different education. The three of them launched a skincare business with a retail store in Santa Monica. Carly calls it her degree.
The company sold well, but she says that in the early 2000s they didn’t understand marketing. They committed fully to product design and packaging before doing enough research. When Burke Williams wanted the products in its spas, the deal required a complete packaging redesign. A few years later, the family wound the business down.
These are useful entrepreneur lessons because they are specific. Research comes before packaging, and a strong sales team can’t make up for weak marketing. Carly’s own conclusion is that she was never bad at marketing. She hadn’t been mentored in it yet. At Tadashi’s company she got that mentorship and eventually became the marketing manager.
How do you find your zone of genius?
Look at where you already spend the most time and money, and what you study and talk about most. Carly says that pattern points to your zone of genius, and your business belongs where it overlaps with what the market actually wants.
The exercise works because it relies on what you already do, not on guessing your passion. A receipt history and a reading list say more than a personality quiz. Her own record fits the pattern. She was selling products in fourth grade and got in trouble for it at school. She took two lessons from that: people value good things, and she wasn’t going to give hers away for free. She was doing her mother’s accounting in QuickBooks at 11, and in high school she went from employee to manager at a surf shop.
Get Raphaella Vidal’s stories in your inbox
Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.
Fashion taught her the market half of the equation. A dress isn’t meant for any celebrity who will wear it. It’s meant for the woman who is actually looking for that refined look. She also tracked which magazine placements produced real traction and learned that the expensive ones sometimes earned their cost.
What makes a business coaching strategy work?
A strong business coaching strategy pairs mindset work with real structure. Clearing mental blocks without a plan leaves a business stuck in place. After about 10 years of coaching, Carly noticed a gap in her own client results and began adding strategy, drawing on writers like Jim Collins and Peter Drucker, to her mindset work. She and her husband now run business-to-business engagements in that order: remove the mental blocks first, then put systems in place so the business runs smoothly.
Her practical instincts come from working with creative founders. Working for a designer doing about $20 million a year, she learned to let a visionary try ideas while keeping them grounded with a budget and a plan, knowing some ideas would fail. When photographer Giuliano wanted to become a fine artist and others doubted him, she was the practical voice. She booked enough paid shoots to fund his personal work. He is a fine artist today, and she still consults with him.
For creative founders, the takeaway is to find the person who will fund your ambition with a spreadsheet, not just cheer for it.
Should AI make your business decisions?
No. Carly’s view is that AI should ask you questions, not make your decisions. When you’re working in your area of expertise, she says, you have the best final answer.
She applies the same logic to staffing. The smartest companies, in her view, aren’t replacing 50 people with five people and AI. They’re training all 50 to work with AI and getting far more output. A company that just wants to swap its people for agents probably isn’t a place worth working.
This brings the argument back to being indispensable. AI in business decisions is a tool for someone who already knows their zone of genius. The more consistently you do work you’re good at and care about, the harder you are to replace with any technology.
Related Questions
What does it mean to be indispensable in business?
It means delivering so much value that a client or employer wouldn’t want to stop working with you, and would come back if they did. Carly builds this by asking what would move the needle most for each client.
How can a sales-strong founder fix weak marketing?
Research your customer before committing to product design or packaging, and get mentorship in the area where you’re weak. Carly’s skincare startup sold well but had to redesign its packaging to land a spa partner.
How do I identify my zone of genius?
Track where you spend the most time and money and what you study and talk about most. Then look for where that pattern overlaps with what the market wants to buy.
Will AI replace the need for business expertise?
Not in Carly’s view. AI is useful for asking you sharper questions, but the person with real expertise should still make the final decision.
Suggested anchor texts:
- “listen to the Overpressure Podcast” → https://overpressurepodcast.com/
- “Carly’s full interview on YouTube” → https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yDQu5ZBMVoY
- “Peter Drucker’s management principles” → an authoritative external resource, or your own internal post on business strategy
