I Didn’t Know Which Version Was Real
On realizing you were never meeting the same person twice.
Different Versions of the Same Person
Lately, I have been thinking a lot about how difficult it is to truly know people. Not in the casual sense where you slowly learn someone’s habits or preferences, but in the deeper sense of understanding who someone actually is underneath all the versions they present to different people. I used to think dishonesty was easy to recognize. I thought lies would be obvious, contradictions loud, and deception intentional. But the more I observe people, the more I realize the unsettling kind of dishonesty is quiet. It does not announce itself. It looks like someone slowly becoming different versions of themselves depending on who is in front of them.
At first, this feels normal. Everyone adjusts socially. You speak differently with friends, family, colleagues, strangers. That is just part of being human. But there is a point where adjustment stops being awareness and starts becoming performance. And when that happens for long enough, honesty itself starts to feel unstable. Not just for the people around them, but for the person doing it too. Because if you keep shifting who you are depending on the room you are in, at some point you stop asking which version is actually you.
Recently, I found myself sitting with that realization longer than I expected to. The more conversations I had, the more confused I became. Different stories, different behaviors, different personalities. It reached a point where it felt like everyone around me had met a completely different person, and that alone was already unsettling.
Why Lie About That?
What surprised me most was not the major things. It was the small lies. The unnecessary ones. The kind that make you pause and wonder why honesty felt difficult in a moment where the truth would not have changed anything at all. There are lies that come from fear or protection, and those I understand. But small lies feel different. They feel like habit. Like dishonesty is no longer a decision but something automatic.
And that is what made everything feel heavier over time. Even simple conversations started carrying a strange sense of inconsistency. Nothing dramatic on its own, just enough contradictions that slowly built up in the background until they could no longer be ignored. Eventually, I also started noticing how performative certain things felt. The way someone could speak about values or principles in one setting, then behave completely differently in another. Not because people are perfect, but because there is a difference between being inconsistent as a human and constantly shaping yourself depending on the audience in front of you.
Authenticity Matters
Maybe that is why this affected me more than I wanted to admit. My friends have always described me as very honest, sometimes even painfully honest, and I think that is true. I try to stay the same person no matter who I am with. So when I encountered someone who felt completely different depending on context, it honestly confused me. Especially when I began hearing things from other people that did not match what I was being told directly.
That was when something in me shifted quietly. It became harder to trust my own understanding of things because the version I was receiving was no longer the only version that existed. And once that starts happening, even simple memories begin to feel uncertain. You replay conversations in your head, question tone, intention, meaning, and slowly everything that once felt stable starts to feel unclear.
I thought I was fine during that time. I was not crying or breaking down, and most of what I felt was anger, so I convinced myself I was okay. But I was not actually processing anything. I was just delaying it.
I tried to bring up the inconsistencies once, not in an attacking way, but because I genuinely wanted clarity more than conflict. But the moment honesty entered the conversation, the entire energy changed. Defensiveness came quickly, voices became sharper, and the space shifted in a way that made it clear the conversation was no longer about understanding.
I remember sitting there holding everything in, not because I had nothing to say, but because I could already feel that saying it would not lead anywhere safe. And there is something deeply isolating about realising that honesty can feel like a threat in a moment where it should bring clarity.
There was also something that stayed with me longer than expected. Someone once questioned why I was still kind in situations where I had every reason not to be. And I did not really have a dramatic answer for it.
Get Zining L.’s stories in your inbox
Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.
Because it was never a strategy for me. I was not trying to prove strength or stay composed for appearance’s sake. I simply do not operate like that. If something is talked through properly, if there is accountability and a genuine apology, I can move forward. I do not hold onto things just to punish people emotionally or to balance out what happened.
That is just who I am.
Even when I am hurt, even when I am confused, I cannot force myself into becoming someone harsh just because a situation feels unfair. I cannot be selectively kind, and I cannot become someone I am not just to match someone else’s behaviour. I refuse to lose myself.
Connecting the Dots
The betrayal was never one single moment. It was fragments. Small conversations, offhand comments, and other people’s versions of events slowly filling in gaps I did not even know existed. Until eventually, I realized I was getting more clarity from people around the situation than from the person themselves. And that is a strange kind of disorientation. Not confusion exactly, but something closer to instability, like trying to hold together a story that keeps changing depending on who is telling it.
Even until the end, honesty still felt optional in certain moments. Even when things were already obvious. Even when contradictions no longer made sense. And after a while, the small lies started to feel heavier than anything else, because when someone lies about things that do not need to be lied about, it stops feeling like strategy, and starts feeling like character.
The Ending
I kept trying to rationalize everything for a long time because I wanted to believe there was still sincerity somewhere in it. But eventually, I reached a point where I could not keep doing that. If I have to search everywhere for truth except from the person themselves, then trust is already gone. And once trust is gone, everything else becomes unstable.
Looking back, I do not think I was as unaffected as I told myself. I thought I was fine because I was not breaking down emotionally, only feeling anger and betrayal. But when everything ended, it all came back at once. And I realized something I had been avoiding for a long time.
I care.
A lot more than I allowed myself to admit, for I am human! For a while, I thought being understanding meant I had nothing to lose. That staying calm, rational, and forgiving would leave me untouched by whatever happened.
But I see it differently now. I still believe I had nothing to lose in the way I showed up. I did not beg for certainty, or demand perfection, or ask for anything extraordinary in return. I only ever showed up honestly.
And I am glad this all ended.
Because if I am honest with myself, I did not lose who I am in the process. I stayed sincere the entire time, even when things were unclear. Even when it would have been easier not to care. And strangely (perhaps not), I feel lighter, happier now. Not because everything made sense in the end, but because I stopped trying to force it to.
And in that sense, I walked away with the only thing I actually had control over. The way I chose to care, love, show up, and remain true to myself.
And I cared because I cared. That is all it ever was.
And maybe that is the part I am finally okay with admitting. Not that it did not affect me, but that it did. And I still chose to care anyway.
