The hidden mess beneath Apple News’ minimal interface
Let’s take a trip back to 2010 — a time when mornings often began with a newspaper in one hand and a hot beverage in the other. While the ritual was comforting, managing those large, unwieldy pages could be quite the hassle. Fast forward to today, and newspapers have largely been replaced by sleek apps that deliver news with just a tap of your finger. It’s a shift that promises convenience and simplicity.
However, while we no longer worry about pages falling apart, we now face a different challenge: navigating through an overwhelming maze of articles. Sometimes, finding what you want to read feels less like browsing and more like searching for a needle in a haystack. This is where Apple News comes into focus a platform with great potential but one that can leave users feeling a little lost.
Introducing the app’s key pages
Apple News has 5 main pages —
- Today (Home Page): Inspired by the behavior of traditional newspapers, this page showcases fresh headlines daily, offering users a dynamic and updated news experience.
- News+: A subscription-based section providing access to premium content like magazines, journals, and newspapers from prominent publishers. Non-subscribers can still preview issues and volumes.
- Sports: This section delivers headlines on popular games while allowing users to follow their favorite teams for personalized updates on scores, highlights, and more.
- Audio: A dedicated space for audio stories, offering a variety of narrated news and headlines for users who prefer listening over reading.
- Following & Search: This page lists channels and topics you follow, along with saved stories, puzzles, special coverage topics, and personalized suggestions from Siri.
For this IA study, I will focus on analyzing the navigation system, information organization, and the effectiveness of the labeling system across each of these key pages.
Deconstructing the Information Architecture
1. Today (Home Page)
Apple News attempts to deliver a dynamic feed of news content but struggles with organization and usability. While the visual design is consistent, featuring card-based layouts separated by white space, the content hierarchy feels disjointed and unpredictable. Sections like Top Stories, Reader Favorites, and For You are interspersed with generic topics such as Health, Politics, and Food, creating cognitive overload for users.
The absence of a search bar further compounds this issue, making it difficult to locate specific content quickly. Additionally, the infinite scroll approach lacks filter pills or customization options, forcing users into a passive browsing experience.
Although the primary navigation bar at the bottom provides easy access to major pages, in-page navigation remains a challenge. By introducing filters, logical grouping of topics, and a prominently placed search bar, Apple News could significantly enhance discoverability and user experience.
2. News+ Discover
The News+ Discover section of Apple News offers a distinct browsing experience, with each magazine and newspaper having its own unique visual representation. Magazines feature vibrant, eye-catching designs reminiscent of physical magazine covers, while newspapers adopt a more professional and toned-down aesthetic, often using black-and-white color schemes with subtle accent colors. This differentiation in style helps users quickly identify content types at a glance.
Users can navigate this section using filter pills at the top, which are clearly labeled with appropriate icons for ease of use. However, the dropdown menu labeled “All Titles” offers a faster alternative to scrolling through the filters, reducing the frustration of slow progressive disclosure.
A notable usability issue is with the follow button: while it allows users to follow a title easily, unfollowing requires navigating into the publication and accessing additional options, which can initially cause confusion. Lastly, while the section primarily focuses on magazines, its nomenclature as “News+” may feel contradictory since newspapers seem less emphasized.
3. Sports
The Sports Section in Apple News introduces personalized content through the prominently placed Get Started button, which stands out due to its bright accent color and central placement in the visual hierarchy. However, the button’s name is not intuitive, and saving preferences requires clicking the Done button, which may confuse users unfamiliar with its purpose.
Get Trusha Neogi’s stories in your inbox
Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.
A significant usability issue arises when users wish to modify their preferences later — the option to manage teams is no longer visible in the same space. Instead, users must scroll down below Top Stories to the My Sports section to make changes. Additionally, both Manage and Add More buttons lead to the same page, making their placement redundant and potentially confusing.
While the section aesthetically presents scores and game coverage with a clean layout, the order in which teams and sports are listed lacks logical organization. Placing them alphabetically or categorically would improve navigation and visual hierarchy. Furthermore, the score page has no explicit label at the top indicating its purpose but uses a distinct UI design as a subtle signpost for users. Overall, while visually appealing, inconsistencies in labeling and redundant navigation elements detract from the overall user experience.
4. Audio
The UI of Apple News’ audio section is cluttered and unintuitive, creating a disjointed user experience. The floating Play button at the top auto-plays the first audio story without context, while simultaneously pushing the navigation bar upward to make space for the media controls, breaking a fundamental UX convention.
Users scrolling through audio stories encounter inconsistent interactions: some cards autoplay on tap, others open a details pop-up, and clicking certain CTAs triggers playback without visual feedback. Additionally, category pages like Apple News+ Narrated are duplicated across different flows, causing unnecessary repetition. Despite helpful subheadings that separate sections, the overall structure lacks clarity and predictability, leading to frequent confusion.
5. Following & Search
Firstly, labeling this section as ‘Following’ is misleading, since it contains more than just followed channels ; it also includes features like games, history, and saved stories. A more appropriate name would be something like ‘Interests’ or ‘Explore,’ which better captures the variety of content and user-curated elements in this section.
One thing that bothers me a lot is the Puzzles option under the Following tab that unexpectedly redirects first-time users to Apple’s Game Center setup screen, with no back button or visible exit path. This forces users to either proceed with Game Center, sign out, or force-close the app, creating a frustrating dead-end. In stark contrast, the Discover Channels CTA is well-designed, leading users to a clearly structured page.
The app lacks an overall robust and accessible search functionality. Key pages like Today, Sports, News+, and Audio do not have a visible search bar, limiting users’ ability to directly look up content. Search is only available in specific sections like Manage My Sports, Following, and Discover Channels, and even there, it’s restricted to teams, athletes, channels, topics, and stories, with no filters, sorting options, or recent search history. This limited and fragmented approach makes it difficult for users to quickly find relevant topics or articles, reducing overall discoverability and increasing the number of steps needed to access desired content.
Nevertheless, the search results is structured well, presenting results in a logical order, starting with the top result, followed by stories, channels, topics, and sports. However, with so many categories stacked vertically, scrolling can become tedious. Introducing horizontal tabs below the search bar to filter by result type would make navigation more efficient and help users quickly find what they’re looking for.
Quick UX Fixes
I’m focusing on improving the user experience for three key areas: the Today homepage, the search and filter functionality, and the Audio section.
Conclusion
Overall, my experience with the Apple News app was underwhelming. While its clean and minimal interface is visually appealing, the app’s usability and information architecture leave much to be desired. Navigation often feels inconsistent, with redundant sections, missing search functionality on key pages, and a lack of clear hierarchy across content types.
My redesign focuses on small but impactful changes: introducing a consistent search and filter framework across pages, streamlining layouts, and grouping content more meaningfully. These improvements aim to preserve the app’s simplicity while making the experience more intuitive, efficient, and user-friendly, unlocking the full potential of a platform that already excels in editorial quality and visual design.
