<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by 0xCrixus on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by 0xCrixus on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@0xCrixus?source=rss-c696c5cbd911------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Tue, 17 Nov 2026 18:51:56 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@0xCrixus/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Tokenomics Guide #3: The Launch]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/deus-ex-dao/tokenomics-guide-3-the-launch-4c9b23cf9b5e?source=rss-c696c5cbd911------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/4c9b23cf9b5e</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[0xCrixus]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 30 Jan 2023 09:55:01 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-06-12T19:59:11.912Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>When to launch, Where to launch, How much liquidity do you need</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*lebTuc78NhuGyDQ7hvt7Aw.png" /></figure><p>The previous two articles of the Deus Ex DAO tokenomics series covered <a href="https://deusexdao.substack.com/p/tokenomics-guide-1-do-i-need-a-token">“Do I need a token”</a> and “<a href="https://deusexdao.substack.com/p/tokenomics-guide-2-real-yield-how?utm_source=post-email-title&amp;publication_id=807066&amp;post_id=95001414&amp;isFreemail=true&amp;utm_medium=email">Real Yield — How to distribute profits to token holders</a>”. These two articles have given some guidance around if a token is necessary for your project, an overview of what mechanisms capture value generated by the product and distribute this value to the token.</p><p>The below article will build upon the knowledge gained from the previous two articles and help give an overview on all things token launch. Looking at when to launch, where to launch, different launch mechanisms, liquidity and emissions. Attached is the <a href="https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1c5S_O1SprTop-1dPY-QKEYt3IiAsus6tVmYuVKPQApo/edit?usp=sharing">Deus Ex DAO tokenomics template</a>, a free tool to play around with that will give you some guidance on token distribution, valuation, allocations and vesting.</p><h3>When to launch</h3><p>As covered in <a href="https://deusexdao.substack.com/p/tokenomics-guide-1-do-i-need-a-token?utm_source=twitter&amp;sd=pf">Tokenomics Guide #1 Do I need a token?</a> launching the product before the token is becoming increasingly common and allows for the product to hopefully find PMF and a constant user base prior to token rewards beginning.</p><p>However, launching the token after the product may not be always possible, especially if the token is required for utility within the product (such as a blockchain which requires the token for securing the network) or if the team has self-funded and requires fundraising via token sales to further development.</p><p>If these considerations are not applicable and the token utility can enhance the product in a further version (think a v2 deployment coupled with token launch) then waiting for PMF is the ideal scenario.</p><p>Once all conditions have been met it’s time to think about the following considerations in regards to launching the token.</p><h3>Where to launch</h3><p>When thinking about where to launch, there are multiple options that projects will incorporate to balance the value add from investors, attract different types of investors and decentralization of holders.</p><p>Some of the major options are listed below in which a project may use 1 or a combination of when launching their token:</p><ol><li>Initial coin offering (ICO);</li></ol><p>The crypto equivalent of an initial public offering (IPO) used in traditional markets, ICOs were previously the biggest crypto start-up fundraising tool, ahead of venture capital and before launching on a decentralized exchange was common.</p><p>An initial coin offering works by selling tokens in exchange for another cryptocurrency such as ETH with the price and supply of tokens for sale being either static or dynamic, depending on the sales conditions. Generally an ICO is conducted at the very early stages of a project’s life cycle, before a product or potentially even a whitepaper has been released.</p><p>ICOs have come under regulatory scrutiny during the 2017/18 boom-bust cycle as they are seen to be unregulated and high risk investment vehicles and there are concerns around the status of the tokens raising via ICO being considered securities under U.S. securities law.</p><p>2. Pre-sales:</p><p>Pre-sales can come in various forms such as seed round investments, private rounds and public sales. These token sales are a way to distribute your token into the hands of early supporters who will be stakeholders at launch and beyond.</p><p>Tokens are sold at a discount to these investors as a way to incentivise them to assist with funding throughout the early stages of a project’s life cycle. Generally for seed and private round investors there is some token vesting component (potentially with or without a cliff), however for public sale participants these tokens are (generally) liquid upon launch.</p><p>3. Initial exchange offering (IEO);<br>IEOs are similar to an IDO, except launched on a centralized exchange rather than a decentralized exchange. The exchange that the token is launching on will charge a fee for their marketing services and also their infrastructure to facilitate the launch. A market maker will also have to be employed to provide the liquidity and allow for the post launch price discovery to be facilitated.</p><p>IEOs are very popular for more ‘normie’ crypto projects whose target audience may not be familiar with transacting on chain via a decentralized exchange. IEOs generally offer a sense of legitimacy or confidence to the launch as the exchange launching the token (should) complete some due diligence checks and also has reputation damage at risk.</p><p>Some other benefits of an IEO include:</p><ul><li><strong>Security for both the token issuers and investors:</strong> Token issuers gain as well since centralized exchanges platforms manage all things related to regulations, such as mandatory KYC/AML checks for every participant.</li><li><strong>Frictionless process:</strong> IEO platforms ensure almost anyone, regardless of their experience in the crypto space, can easily contribute.</li><li><strong>Guaranteed exchange listing:</strong> IEO tokens are listed on the IEO exchange soon after the IEO.</li><li><strong>Benefits for the projects:</strong> Such as enhanced marketing effort by the exchange, exposure, and interest in the project.</li><li><strong>Benefits for the exchanges:</strong> Including new users signing up with them only for the sake of purchasing and trading IEO tokens.</li></ul><p>IEOs also have some drawbacks due to the current unclear regulatory landscape and forcing investors to complete KYC checks, potential market manipulation, unclear supply dynamics and bots that may front-run the launch.</p><p>4. Initial DEX offering (IDO);<br>An IDO is a popular method of launching a token amongst web3 native and DeFi protocols. This is due to the target audience usually owning a self custody wallet and operating on chain using decentralized exchanges.</p><p>Initial DEX offerings have many benefits for projects looking to use their token launch as a fundraising mechanism and a way to distribute their token to the community. IDO’s also have a low cost of listing due to the fact that the project can seed the liquidity pool themselves which also allows them to have immediate liquidity for the token to be traded.</p><p>5. Liquidity bootstrapping pool (LBP);<br>Liquidity bootstrapping pools are the novel launch design product by <a href="https://docs.balancer.fi/products/balancer-pools/liquidity-bootstrapping-pools-lbps">Balancer</a>. These ‘smart pools’ are owned by a smart contract and allow any sort of arbitrary logic to be built.</p><p>In the token launch scenario, you can think of the starting price of your LBP as the ceiling you would want to set for the token sale. This may seem counterintuitive, but since LBPs work differently than other token sales, your starting price should be set much higher than what you believe is the fair price for your token.</p><p>By setting an intentionally high price, this strongly disincentivises whales and bots from snatching up much of the pool liquidity from the beginning of the launch. When LBPs are used for early-stage tokens, this mechanism can help to increase how widespread the token distribution is.</p><p>In the example below a team sets its project token to start at 80% weight and DAI to start at 20% (ETH or any other token can be substituted for DAI in practice).</p><p>Over a period of time the weights of the two tokens in the pool are adjusted and ultimately flip. This results in the slippage experienced on an order into the pool at the beginning of the token sale being significantly less as time progresses.</p><p>LBPs allow teams to build deeper liquidity for their tokens with lower upfront capital costs.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*orChiuchB4KJy3ot" /></figure><p><em>Source: Balancer docs</em></p><p>6. Liquidity mining campaign / Initial farm offering (IFO);</p><p>In some cases a token may be distributed to the community via a liquidity mining campaign or boosted rewards for using the product. These launch mechanisms are usually more common with products that can function without the need for a token. This token may be utilized as rewards prior to TGE and distributed to users of the product upon TGE which can be used to pair liquidity.</p><p>The token is then distributed to the greater community via token emissions on liquidity pools or via emissions to users of the protocol, for example lenders and borrowers on a money market.</p><p>When deciding where to launch, it is important to firstly determine who your target market of launch participants are. It is also important to factor in the expenses for each launch type, such as market making expenses with a professional firm like GSR or the cost of providing the liquidity yourself. It is also important to factor in the utility of your token within your product and where you would like the majority of your tokens being located. If your token has utility within the product and is used for staking or governance then launching on a decentralized exchange may be best as the tokens will be needed on chain to be utilised within the product.</p><h3>Picking a trading pair</h3><p>If you plan to have your token tradable on a decentralized exchange it will require a token to be paired with. This token should ideally be a common, highly liquid token such as ETH or USDC. In the current times of aggregators it no longer matters if the buyer has the token in their wallet but this token pairing is aimed more at what your liquidity providers would like to have exposure to. If you pick a more obscure pair, this may lower the appeal for a liquidity provider to provide liquidity to your token as they may not want exposure to the paired asset, thus the liquidity may be lower.</p><p>The most common pairs and ones we would advise are ETH or the L1 governance token, such as AVAX or SOL and a USD pegged stablecoin such as USDC, DAI or FRAX (or any of the other liquid stablecoins). As the token price is set between the ratio of the two tokens in the pool, utilizing ETH or a USD stablecoin will have different price effects as the overall market moves.</p><p>If you want exposure to the broader crypto market then pairing against ETH is your best bet, if you want to be more conservative and your token to trade more independently then pairing against a USD stablecoin is the way to go.</p><p>An example of this:</p><p>If your token (XYZ) is paired against ETH and the pool contains 500 ETH and 5,000 XYZ this means your token is worth 0.1 ETH. If the price of ETH (in USD) goes up 10% and there are no trades in your ETH:XYZ pool, XYZ will also go up 10% in USD terms since it is still worth 0.1 ETH. This is also true on the downside, so if ETH loses 10% (and there are no trades in the pool) XYZ will also go down 10%.</p><p>If your token is paired against DAI at a ratio of 1 DAI to 100 XYZ your token is worth $0.01. If there are no trades in the pool but the price of ETH goes up 10%, the price of XYZ token will remain unchanged in dollar terms.</p><h3>Trading liquidity target</h3><p>After deciding what to pair your token with, the next step is figuring out how much liquidity is required. There is no exact science with calculating a liquidity target but having a goal of 15%-20% of your circulating market cap in liquidity is a good target. This will allow for larger sized investors to enter and exit your token without incurring too much slippage and also allow for smooth price discovery.</p><p>A good resource is this liquidity cap target <a href="https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1fchtxg6hq2gBC4WcMoQ8OFgMv84BZLDIT5pOm9Z18w4/edit#gid=656976389">doc</a>, created by <a href="https://twitter.com/kek256">@wvaeu</a> and <a href="https://twitter.com/mechanismcap">@mechanismcap</a>. It shows how much liquidity is required for incremental trade sizes to maintain a &lt;2% slippage target for a 80/20 Balancer pool and a regular 50/50 univ2 style pool.</p><p>Now you know how much liquidity to target, there are a few options on how to obtain that liquidity.</p><h3>Rent</h3><p>Renting of liquidity, or better known as liquidity mining is the practice of incentivising liquidity providers to provide liquidity for your tokens in exchange for governance token rewards. Pioneered by Synthetix in early 2020, and subsequently made famous by Compound, high emissions and insane APRs were the narrative of DeFi summer.</p><p>In what looks similar to an equity give away, liquidity mining programs have shown to be quite effective in bootstrapping liquidity for early stage projects. Tokens are emitted by the protocol to attract liquidity providers in the hope of them depositing liquidity which will allow the protocol to function or the governance token to be tradeable on the open market.</p><p>Liquidity mining does have some positives:</p><ul><li>Acts as a means of distributing the governance token to those who are providing work to the protocol (providing liquidity). Protocols often have a treasury full of tokens which need to be distributed to the community. By distributing these tokens to actors helping with liquidity this allows governance power to be in the hands of users rather than just investors.</li><li>Low up front cost to attract liquidity as liquidity can be purchased on a block by block basis. Pairing liquidity is expensive as the protocol has to provide the other side with funds from investors and token sales, if there are not enough funds raised renting liquidity is the most cost effective option in the short term.</li><li>Liquidity can be attracted very quickly, due to the fact that a high APR acts as a marketing tactic. Farmers are always on the lookout for the next high APR farm and will move their capital to the highest yielding option at that time.</li></ul><p>Although there are some benefits there, that’s where they stop. Some negatives of liquidity mining are:</p><ul><li>Significant sell pressure: Inflationary token emission incentives short-term behavior that increases sell pressure on the farm tokens. Mercenary liquidity providers often sell their rewards to recoup their investments.</li><li>Goal misalignment between protocols and LPs: LPs are incentivised by higher reward rates, rather than a strong belief in the success of the protocol. Hence, when the rewards are scaled back or exhausted, the LPs will remove their capital and move on to the next opportunity.</li><li>Impermanent Loss (IL): The success of a protocol causes price appreciation in its native token, causing a significant impermanent loss scenario for liquidity providers. This misalignment disincentivises long-term LPs even if they are long-term believers in the protocol.</li><li>No buyer of last resort: During a market crash or in times of uncertainty, LPs tend to remove their liquidity from the pool as they run for safety. It is at these moments when liquidity is needed the most and if there is insufficient liquidity depth, it will lead to a downward death spiral of the protocol’s token price.</li></ul><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/791/0*WhNPOK-lW8-fJEeJ" /></figure><h3>Bribe</h3><p>Bribing for liquidity is the common term used to describe incentivising governance token holders of another protocol to direct their voting power in the direction that the briber choses. These governance token holders are incentivised with tokens that are in addition to their regular governance token rewards.</p><p>Incentivised voting (bribing) was made popular by protocols (such as Frax) bribing veCRV holders to direct CRV gauge emissions to their pools on Curve. By doing this, Frax was able to gain high amounts of CRV emissions on their FRAX pools which then can be used as income from protocol owned liquidity (POL) and attracts other liquidity providers to these pools, which in turn creates deep liquidity which is a must have of any pegged assets.</p><p>Bribing for liquidity quickly grew in popularity, with protocols bribing CVX holders for their governance power over the Curve protocol and then expanding to other meta-governance protocols. Currently almost any protocol with a vote-escrow token design has a meta-governance protocol built on top and a bribe market facilitating incentivised voting to the base vote-escrow token holders.</p><p>Although bribing for liquidity does require a specific base asset design, such as Curve gauges to direct emissions, if you were planning on launching on Curve or Balancer there are marketplaces which facilitate incentivised voting to the governance token holders of these platforms.</p><p>Positives of bribing for liquidity:</p><ul><li>Due to emissions being paid in other protocols governance tokens, yield can be earned on POL and sold without impacting the bribing protocols token price. This is especially true for protocols who own a large amount of their own liquidity as the emissions directed to these pools can act as another form of revenue, or could be locked for additional governance power over the DEX the liquidity is pooled upon.</li><li>Can be used to facilitate governance decisions as well as liquidity. Bribe marketplaces are also possible for general governance decisions. For example, you could bribe a DEXs governance token holders to be issued a gauge position on that DEX.</li></ul><p>Some negatives:</p><ul><li>Only profitable in certain conditions. If there is large competition against other protocols who are also bribing this can drive up the necessary amount of tokens to be distributed in order to gain any sort of voting power, thus making bribing less profitable.</li><li>Profitability may also reduce as the price of the governance token emitted from the gauge emissions drops in price.</li><li>Bribing for liquidity is only a temporary solution. Much like renting liquidity, bribing is only applicable for the voting round that is current. Once the bribing stops (or reduces), those votes will move to the next highest bidder and the emissions will reduce. In turn LPs will usually chase the highest emissions so they will remove their liquidity from your pools.</li></ul><h3>Buy</h3><p>Buying liquidity is a concept pioneered by Olympus DAO and their bonding program, now <a href="https://bondprotocol.finance/">Bond Protocol</a>. Bonding works by protocols offering up their governance tokens at a discount compared to the market rate in exchange for assets they would like to accrue. In the majority of cases these assets are their own LP tokens.</p><p>By bonding their own LP tokens it allows the protocol to own their own liquidity. They are still emitting tokens to the market as is done with renting and bribing, although now they receive something in return that isn&#39;t temporary. Owning their own liquidity allows a protocol to earn trading fees from that liquidity that would usually be going to other LPs, minimize liquidity mining expenses (or end them all together) and build sustainable and reliable liquidity for their token.</p><p>As mentioned earlier, if a project can aim for 15%-20% of their circulating market cap in liquidity, ideally 60%-80% of this liquidity would be owned by the protocol itself. This allows for sufficient liquidity to remain during all market conditions and will act as another source of revenue for the protocol.</p><p>Some downsides of buying liquidity are:</p><ul><li>Buying liquidity is expensive due to the bond discount which is used to incentivise actors to visit a third party to bond their LP tokens rather than just buying the tokens off the open market. Without this discount the process doesn’t work. Although this is expensive, it is cheaper than giving the tokens out for free as is the case with renting and bribing for liquidity.</li><li>Bonding usually involves outsourcing the process to a third party, such as Bond Protocol. This third party and additional contract interaction adds further smart contract risk for the bonders and protocol.</li><li>Bonding tokens adds friction to an already poor UX. DeFi is still very difficult for the average user, so adding additional steps and complexities only reduces the market of users competent to perform them.</li></ul><p>In addition to bonding for liquidity, fundraising can also be utilized to buy and own your own liquidity. Whether this is from a private or public sale, selling tokens (or future tokens) to investors during seed, pre-sale and public sale rounds is a great way to raise funds to pair with your liquidity.</p><h3>Launch price</h3><p>Trying to determine the best launch price is one of the hardest decisions to make when launching a token.</p><p>If you set the launch price too low, you may miss out on a large amount of money you could have earned with a higher launch price. If you set the price too high, there is a risk of those with liquid tokens at launch selling their tokens and impacting the token price, public perception of the protocol and risk reputation damage.</p><p>Ideally, aiming for the lower side is a safer bet over the long term. This will allow early investors to (hopefully) see some nice price appreciation and attract new investors, liquidity providers and users to your protocol. Although the token is not a representation of the quality of the product, good price action can act as a marketing tool and gather attention of the wider market.</p><p>Below covers some options to look at when trying to determine what launch price is suitable:</p><ol><li>Research your competition if you have any and what their token launched at and their current market cap. This will give you a good insight into what the market thought of their launch price and what is the current perceived fair value for their token. Always remember first mover advantage is something to consider, so even if you believe your product is better it may pay to be conservative with your comparison to competition.</li><li>If you are self funding your liquidity pair, this can be used to determine the launch price. For example, if you have $500,000 to put towards your initial liquidity and you want to release 10% (10M) of your tokens your FDV will be $5,000,000 with a launch price of $0.05.</li><li>Utilize a bonding curve or auctions and let the market decide the price. Bonding curves and auctions are perfect for raising capital to seed initial liquidity with and distributing the token to the community whilst also letting the market decide what a fair launch price is. This is done in many different ways such as English or Dutch auctions or along a pre-programmed price curve. Although they all have their nuances, on the completion of the sale the perceived fair price is reached and this will determine the public launch price.</li></ol><h3>Deterring mercenary capital</h3><p><a href="https://www.nansen.ai/research/all-hail-masterchef-analysing-yield-farming-activity">Research</a> from Nansen analyzed activity on MasterChef.sol contracts to try to aggregate the data and see how yield farmers were behaving.</p><p>Some of the results from this research were shocking, although not that surprising:</p><ul><li>A large majority of farmers appear to exit within the first 5 days of entering a farm, and half of all farmers never stay beyond 15 days. 13% of addresses still have their funds in these contracts.</li><li>42% of yield farmers that enter a farm on the day it launches exit that farm within 24 hours. Around 16% leave within 48 hours and by the third day, 70% of the users who deposited on the first day of that farm had withdrawn from the contract. This is believed to be caused by the reduction in emissions that occur each block post launch.</li></ul><p>As shown by this research, deterring this mercenary capital is of the utmost importance and can be done by utilizing mechanisms such as locking or vesting rewards.</p><p>Requiring LPs to lock their LP tokens for an extended period of time or to earn boosted rewards is a great way to filter out the mercenary capital and leave behind LPs who are prepared to stick around for the long term. These locks may vary in length from a week to multiple months, with rewards being boosted for those who lock the longest.</p><p>Vesting of rewards was pioneered by GMX and has proven to be extremely successful. In the case of GMX their token emissions are distributed as <a href="https://gmxio.gitbook.io/gmx/rewards">esGMX</a>, a token with equal reward and governance weight as the regular staked GMX token without being liquid. These esGMX tokens can be vested over the course of 1 year if certain conditions are met, such as keeping your tokens or liquidity staked. By vesting rewards over a long period of time this still rewards past and present stakers with protocol fees and governance rights but requires them to stick around to vest their tokens and sell them.</p><h3>Conclusion</h3><p>As covered in this article, there are many moving parts when valuing, launching, distributing and maintaining a token. The information covered in this article is not exhaustive and the token launch space is ripe with innovation and experimentation.</p><p>Please experiment with the attached <a href="https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/165pFcKdJSCyshM7MPn1mRgehAGHtEOi-ivqw4LbSLyM/edit?usp=sharing">Deus Ex DAO tokenomics template</a>. This tool will allow you to input potential token allocations, vesting and supply schedules to give an overview of what certain token distributions may look like.</p><p>Navigating this space alone can be daunting, if you are looking for token advisory please reach out to us here at <a href="https://www.deusexdao.com/contact">Deus Ex DAO</a> and our advisors would be happy to help you with any token or product related questions.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=4c9b23cf9b5e" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/deus-ex-dao/tokenomics-guide-3-the-launch-4c9b23cf9b5e">Tokenomics Guide #3: The Launch</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/deus-ex-dao">Deus Ex DAO</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Tokenomics Guide #1: Do I need a token?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/deus-ex-dao/tokenomics-guide-1-do-i-need-a-token-afcb47c46bfa?source=rss-c696c5cbd911------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/afcb47c46bfa</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[cryptocurrency]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[defi]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[token]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ethereum]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[tokenomics]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[0xCrixus]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 13 Dec 2022 12:48:39 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-12-13T12:53:33.569Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*rUL6jwrsfo54p7KU" /></figure><h3>What are tokens?</h3><p>Crypto gave the world the ability to tokenise assets, complete cross border payments and raise money in ways that were unimaginable before. This has led to many narratives emerging and created quite a distorted view around tokens. Just ask your non-web3 family members what they think crypto is. The answer would generally be a currency used for payments.</p><p>Since the ICO era of 2017, tokens have seen multiple narratives surrounding them ranging from payments token, a fundraising mechanism, governance tokens used to incentivise user actions and revenue generating utility tokens.</p><p>This multitude of use cases have left the majority of people confused around the purpose of a token and if their project they are building needs one.</p><p>Similarly to the bear market in 2018, the bear market in 2022 is looking like another cycle of tokens being the enemy. This article will look at if your product needs a token, some benefits and drawbacks of tokens and one of the most common questions we get asked, “can i launch my token later?”.</p><h3>Does your product need a token?</h3><p>As tokens fall out of favor (again) investors and builders alike are asking the same question, does this product really need a token? In some cases, tokens may be essential to the functional operation of the product being built. In other cases a token may complement the product and enhance the user experience for those using the product, but not be essential to its operation. Finally the token may add no additional value to the product and will likely not be required.</p><p>In all cases, the token is not the product and cannot replace it. The quality of the product is the most important factor, along with a clear revenue generation model, plan on scaling and target market. When all of these areas align, the question of “does my product need a token” will become much clearer.</p><p>The key things to think about when building a product and deciding if a token is required are; will the token assist in helping the business reach its goals, will the token add extra friction for the user and can the same goals be achieved via another method. These other methods could be fiat or stablecoin payments for the product or an NFT with governance rights instead of a governance only token.</p><p>Below will focus on some sectors of web3 and give an overview of if a token could be useful or not:</p><ol><li>SaaS model (Web3 Tooling) — In the case of a B2B SaaS model, a token may not be necessary to the usage of the product. In most cases a token adds extra friction and complexity for the company building the product. If this is the case it is advised to raise via a SAFE and pursue capturing value via equity. An example of this model is <a href="https://www.infura.io/https://www.infura.io/">Infura</a>, the world’s largest blockchain API which connects applications to the blockchain. Infura utilised a subscription revenue model and does not have a token. Usually payment for these services are taken in fiat or potentially alternative cryptocurrencies such as stablecoins or Ether. Occasionally exceptions are made for companies that plan to decentralise even though the token does not have any utility within their product. The governance only token model does have its limitations but if decentralisation is a core concept a token can be utilised to achieve this.</li><li>DApps — With most decentralized applications (dApps), a token can be incorporated to gain the many benefits that a token can provide (listed below). Usually these tokens aren’t critical for the operation of the application, however they should aim to increase the user experience and share the success of the application with the token holders over its lifecycle. An example of this is <a href="https://gmx.io/#/https://gmx.io/#/">GMX</a>, although the token isn’t required to use the product, as a GMX staker you are rewarded with a share of the platform fees (paid in ETH) along with governance rights. The GMX governance token is also utilised to bootstrap liquidity to provide a superior on-chain trading experience, decentralisation of governance and marketing around the product.</li><li>Infrastructure projects (Layer 1s) — Infrastructure projects in the web3 space are the most likely to require a token for the product to function. In the case of layer 1 blockchains, the token is used to secure the network and pay validators who are running the consensus algorithms of the blockchains. The token is usually utilised as a unit of account and is required as a means of payment for each transaction that is validated to the blockchain. In the case of a PoW blockchain such as Bitcoin, the token is essential to pay the miners for their work. The two biggest examples of requiring a token to function are <a href="https://bitcoin.org/en/https://bitcoin.org/en/">Bitcoin </a>and <a href="https://ethereum.org/en/https://ethereum.org/en/">Ethereum</a>. This is also true for digital resource networks such as <a href="https://filecoin.io/https://filecoin.io/">Filecoin</a>.</li></ol><h3>Benefits of a token</h3><ul><li>Allows bootstrapping a product. This enables the product to overcome the <a href="https://medium.com/twosapp/the-cold-start-problem-how-to-start-and-scale-network-effects-by-andrew-chen-813f0668c70f">“cold start” problem</a> which is aided by token incentives attracting liquidity providers or users to a new protocol. The aim here is to have a nice product and use the token to draw the potential users in, hoping once they have used the product they will stay.</li><li>Marketing and awareness of the business — especially applicable if combined with an <a href="https://medium.com/deus-ex-dao/a-framework-for-airdrops-d585a2fae8f7">airdrop</a> or marketing campaign. Along with bootstrapping, a token public sale, launch, airdrop and IFO (initial farm offering) can work as excellent marketing tools to gain the eyes of potential users.</li><li>Potentially easier fundraising for the project and easier distribution to investors. Easier fundraising is especially common when the crypto markets are in a bull market. As shown in this <a href="https://twitter.com/DefiIgnas/status/1599671335260540928">tweet</a> by Defiignas, the web3 fundraising landscape is tightly correlated with the BTC price. Showing that when Bitcoin is increasing in value, funding is easier to come by.</li></ul><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*g0WTRs6Oxsw48HE3" /></figure><ul><li>Generally faster liquidity for the team and investors. In traditional markets, the average time from seed investment to IPO is around 10 years. In the crypto currency markets the average time from seed investment to liquidity can be as short as 12–24 months. This is a huge incentive for investors and team members to launch a token to reach liquidity faster.</li><li>Incentivisation of the community via:</li><li>User rewards</li><li>Rewards for actors providing a service, i.e. liquidity providers</li><li>Grants</li><li>Community building rewards</li><li>DAO contribution rewards</li><li>The community is incentivised to help create additional products, tooling or awareness through marketing for the project, which decentralizes the workforce.</li><li>Allows for a company to be decentralized. This can be done for ideological reasons or legal reasons. Either are achievable via the user of a token and governance process.</li><li>Aligns users, stakeholders and the team’s interests. This can be done via revenue share captured by the token. This aligns all users and stakeholders of the protocol to act in the best interests of the company.</li><li>Ideally increases user experience for product users.</li><li>Allows value to be captured and realised by all stakeholders.</li><li>Allows curation of data. This mechanism is especially common in products that need to crowdsource the correct answers from the community. For example, curating medical data in a DeSci protocol.</li><li>Allows stakers to take on an important function in securing the protocol. For example, the <a href="https://docs.aave.com/aavenomics/safety-module">Aave Safety Module</a> utilised the AAVE token as a liquidity backstop in the case of bad debt on the protocol.</li></ul><h3>Drawbacks of a token</h3><ul><li>Unclear regulatory landscape regarding tokens, especially in the US. This may lead to US users being geo-blocked or teams remaining anonymous.</li><li>Risks of value accrual to either the token or equity. This must be made clear to investors when fundraising as issues can arise between stakeholders if the value accrual mechanisms aren’t clear.</li><li>Complexity around token allocations, once allocated into buckets, distribution amounts are generally hard to alter. Alterations may be achieved via governance (if decentralized) at a later stage but it is best to get allocations correct from the beginning.</li><li>Extra complexity in relation to token utility and providing a balance between token supply and demand. If a token is not necessary for the product to operate, utility must be given to it to ensure there is sufficient demand for the token. Without sufficient utility and no demand the token price will likely suffer.</li><li>Potential friction and complexity for users. This is usually common with the token being used as a ‘payment token’. Requiring all transaction fees or marketplace costs to be paid in the governance token adds extra friction to the user experience as the user may have to go and purchase this governance token prior to completing their desired transaction. This adds extra cost and time to the process for little added benefit.</li><li>Complexity around governance. Some companies may not want to be decentralized and others may face governance attacks. Steps must be put in place to mitigate these risks.</li><li>Added costs to the company to gain liquidity, exchange listings, market makers and user rewards</li><li>Association with token market price and quality of product. This can cause a solid product to be tarnished by an underperforming token price due to association.</li><li>Generally retail community members are more sensitive to token price movements, this can cause demands or explanations from the team.</li></ul><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*NuMb-y1-xgtJDRhU" /></figure><h3>Can you launch first, then release a token?</h3><p>It is becoming increasingly common that companies launch their product prior to launching a token. This allows them to try to find product market fit whilst also remaining flexible if a pivot to a new focus is required. By launching first, the added complexity and cost associated with ensuring the token is liquid enough, has enough utility and the community members are satisfied with the tokens performance are removed and allows the team to focus on building out their product.</p><p>Another advantage of launching the product first is it allows the user base to grow (which can be used for a retroactive airdrop) and allows for the company to address any pain points and incentivise beneficial actions and disincentivise harmful actions by users.</p><p>Ideally the product will have a solid user base and PMF prior to launching the token, which when live accelerates the adoption of the product, acts as a marketing tool and allows the team, investors and community to all benefit from its success.</p><p>This also allows potential token holders to evaluate the business model instead of betting on a theoretical future construct, opening up the business to value-adding fundamental value investors rather than value-extractive speculators.</p><h3>Conclusion</h3><p>As outlined above there are many aspects to think about when deciding if a token is right for your project. The first step is to have a clear understanding of your product, how it will generate revenues and what actions (if any) you want to incentivise/disincentivise with a token. It is also imperative to understand who your users will be, what their web3 experience is and if they have the desire to interact with a token.</p><p>One cover all approach is to raise on a SAFE/SAFT and gather advice on how a token could look and complement your product. This will give you the time to launch the product, find PMF and then launch the token at a later stage.</p><p>One final thing to remember is, a token is not the product. The two things should compliment one another and align all stakeholders. A strong token design won’t save a weak product and a strong product won’t save a weak token design.</p><p>If you are looking for token advisory please reach out to us here at <a href="https://www.deusexdao.com/contact">Deus Ex DAO</a> and our advisors would be happy to advise you with any token related questions and modelling.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=afcb47c46bfa" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/deus-ex-dao/tokenomics-guide-1-do-i-need-a-token-afcb47c46bfa">Tokenomics Guide #1: Do I need a token?</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/deus-ex-dao">Deus Ex DAO</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>