<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Viktor van Niekerk on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Viktor van Niekerk on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@10string?source=rss-8026079d565e------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Tue, 17 Nov 2026 16:49:46 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@10string/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Limits of Self-Explanation]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@10string/delcamp-classical-guitar-discourse-analysis-b11f43897272?source=rss-8026079d565e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/b11f43897272</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[psychology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[sociology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[music]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[internet-culture]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Viktor van Niekerk]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 21 Jul 2026 08:08:21 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-07-22T15:49:56.104Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>A Discourse Analysis of Self-Understanding in an Online Classical Guitar Community</h3><h3>Abstract</h3><p>This paper examines a corpus of discussions from the Delcamp Classical Guitar Forum during 2026. Rather than investigating the historical causes of classical guitar’s present cultural position directly, it analyses how members of one of the longest-established English-language forums dedicated to classical guitar describe and respond to that position.</p><p>The corpus reveals several recurring discursive patterns. Contributors repeatedly acknowledge that classical guitar occupies a culturally marginal position, describing the repertoire as misunderstood, the audience as small, and public appreciation as declining. These perceptions are rarely disputed. Instead, discussion centres on explaining this condition.</p><p>The dominant explanatory tendency attributes marginality to external factors: contemporary culture, mass entertainment, changing educational priorities, consumer preferences, and what contributors characterise as the public’s limited capacity for sustained aesthetic attention. Conversely, relatively little discussion is devoted to considering whether aspects of the classical guitar community itself — including its institutions, ideological commitments, aesthetic assumptions, pedagogical traditions, definitions of technique, repertoire currency, historical narratives, or performance culture — might contribute to its present condition.</p><p>The paper argues that this asymmetry constitutes a significant feature of the discourse itself. Importantly, the paper takes no position on whether external explanations are true or false, or whether internal explanations are correct or mistaken; the corpus is not the kind of evidence that could settle either question. Rather, it suggests that one category of explanation is discussed extensively whereas another receives comparatively little attention.</p><p>To interpret this asymmetry, the paper draws upon established work in social psychology — including Social Identity Theory, Cognitive Dissonance Theory, motivated reasoning, identity-protective cognition, system justification, group-serving attribution, and groupthink — as well as sociological perspectives concerning cultural fields, doxa, and institutional reproduction. It also employs an interpretive register — encompassing the scapegoat mechanism, a phenomenological account of alterity, and the musicological distinction between gnostic and drastic forms of musical understanding<em> </em>— to address how a community’s discourse relates to whatever it names as exterior to itself. These theories are employed not as proof of participants’ motivations but as independently developed explanatory frameworks whose convergent expectations are compared with the observed discourse.</p><p>Finally, the paper considers whether the observed asymmetry is consistent with a broader epistemic phenomenon identified across several independent traditions of research: that communities often possess interpretive frameworks which make certain explanations more cognitively available than others, while rendering those very frameworks comparatively difficult to recognise as frameworks at all. The present analysis does not seek to generalise beyond its corpus. Rather, it offers a sustained, closely textured case study of how this broader phenomenon may operate within one specialist community.</p><h3>1. Introduction</h3><p>The classical guitar occupies a curious position within contemporary musical culture. It enjoys institutional presence. Conservatories teach it. Universities award degrees in it. International competitions attract accomplished performers. Scholarly research continues, and festivals are organised throughout Europe, Asia, and the Americas. Yet many participants within the community simultaneously describe the instrument as culturally marginal.</p><p>This apparent paradox appears repeatedly in informal discussions among performers, teachers, amateur enthusiasts, and instrument makers. Participants frequently lament small audiences, declining public interest, limited media visibility, and the perception that classical guitar occupies little space within broader musical culture.</p><p>The present paper does not attempt to determine whether these perceptions are objectively correct. Instead, it asks a different question. <em>How does one community explain its self-described marginality? </em>This distinction is fundamental.</p><p>One may investigate the actual causes of classical guitar’s cultural position through historical research, the history of ideas, sociology of culture, economics, educational policy, audience studies, musicology, philosophy of music, performance studies, acoustics, or biomechanics. One may instead investigate how members of a community themselves describe that position. The latter is the concern of discourse analysis.</p><p>Accordingly, this paper treats forum discussions not as transparent windows into the phenomena they describe, but as cultural artefacts revealing patterns of collective interpretation. The principal question therefore becomes:</p><p><em>When members of the classical guitar community discuss their self-described marginality, what kinds of explanations do they produce, and which kinds of explanations remain comparatively absent?</em></p><p>The answer to this question need not determine whether those explanations are historically correct. It instead illuminates the explanatory habits of the community itself.</p><p>Although the present study concerns one specialist musical community, it is informed by a broader epistemological question already raised across several independent traditions of scholarship. The Delcamp corpus therefore functions as a case study through which that wider phenomenon may be examined within one specialist community.</p><h3>2. Scope</h3><p>This study analyses a corpus drawn from discussions on the Delcamp Classical Guitar Forum during 2026. The corpus comprises six discussion threads (259 posts in total) selected because they address complementary aspects of the community’s understanding of its perceived place within contemporary musical culture: <em>Praise Well-Earned</em> (4 posts; community affirmation), <em>Close to depression</em> (39 posts; the emotional experience of marginality), <em>An experiment, a small rant</em> (36 posts; encounters with non-specialist audiences), <em>Winning the GFA While Working In A Cafe</em> (17 posts; professional precarity despite institutional success), <em>So why is traffic at Delcamp in decline?</em> (137 posts; institutional decline and self-understanding), and <em>The Future of Classical Guitar Concerts</em> (26 posts; audience formation and public engagement). Although initiated independently and concerned with different immediate questions, these discussions converge repeatedly on participants’ attempts to explain the community’s place within contemporary musical culture.</p><p>The corpus was not selected randomly. Rather, it was selected because these discussions explicitly address participants’ understanding of classical guitar’s place within contemporary culture, or illustrate that place directly through reported circumstance (for instance, concert attendance figures or the economic situation of competition-winning performers).</p><p>The findings should not be generalised automatically to all classical guitar communities. Nor should they be interpreted as representing all members of the Delcamp forum. Instead, they describe recurring patterns within this particular body of discourse.</p><h3>3. Methodological Position</h3><p>The paper adopts a qualitative discourse-analytic approach informed by social psychology, sociology, organisational theory, philosophy of science, phenomenological ethics, and the philosophy of music.</p><p>It does not attempt to infer hidden mental states directly from written posts. This distinction deserves emphasis. Written discourse permits observation of <em>language</em>. It does not permit direct observation of thoughts, intentions, or emotions.</p><p>What it does permit is observation of how those private states are represented in language — and representation, by its nature, is both selective and transformative: the words in which a mental state is rendered inevitably reduce and alter whatever they purport to convey. The representations are what this paper analyses; the states they purport to represent remain, strictly speaking, unobservable.</p><p>Consequently, throughout this paper four distinct levels of analysis are maintained.</p><p><strong>Level One: Observation.</strong> Observation consists solely of describing what participants explicitly <em>say</em>. For example: contributors describe classical guitar as culturally marginal; contributors attribute marginality to contemporary culture; contributors praise the forum as an important refuge. These are empirical observations concerning discourse rather than the external conditions to which the discourse refers. Whether participants’ claims are true, false, or partly true lies outside the scope of Level One. No psychological inference is required.</p><p><strong>Level Two: Discursive Pattern.</strong> Patterns emerge when observations recur across multiple contributors. For example: external explanations substantially outnumber internal explanations; expressions of solidarity frequently accompany discussions of marginality; contributors repeatedly affirm what they describe as the intrinsic value of classical guitar despite its limited broader recognition. These remain descriptive claims about discourse.</p><p><strong>Level Three: Psychological Interpretation.</strong> Only after establishing discursive patterns does the paper introduce psychological interpretation. Here, established theories may illuminate why certain forms of discourse commonly emerge within human groups. Importantly, such theories do not prove individual motivation. Instead, the appropriate formulation is: <em>the observed discourse is consistent with mechanisms described by…</em> rather than <em>participants are motivated by…</em> The distinction is epistemologically essential.</p><p><strong>Level Four: Broader Hypothesis.</strong> Finally, broader hypotheses may be proposed. These extend beyond the corpus itself. For example: specialist communities may preferentially rely upon external explanations for collective difficulties; institutional identities may influence which explanatory frameworks become culturally available; communities may systematically underexplore explanations that implicate their own assumptions. These hypotheses remain provisional. They invite further investigation rather than concluding it. The structure of the paper follows these four levels explicitly. Observations are distinguished from recurring patterns, recurring patterns from theoretical interpretation, and theoretical interpretation from broader hypothesis, allowing readers to evaluate each inferential step independently. In the present paper, Level Four reasoning is developed explicitly in §§9–10, where the discussion moves from interpretation of the corpus to broader epistemological hypotheses.</p><h3>4. What This Paper Does Not Claim</h3><p>Several misunderstandings should be anticipated and addressed immediately.</p><p>First, this paper takes no position on classical guitar’s actual cultural standing — whether it is or is not culturally relevant, marginal, or irrelevant. It examines only how participants themselves describe that position.</p><p>Second, it does not adjudicate whether external explanations are accurate or internal ones are mistaken, or the reverse. Modern media environments, educational changes, commercial entertainment, and shifting cultural priorities may well influence artistic life, just as inherited institutions, pedagogies, and aesthetic assumptions may also do. The present analysis is not positioned to weigh these possibilities against one another. It is positioned to describe how frequently each is discussed.</p><p>Third, it takes no position on the extent to which characteristics of the classical guitar community may or may not contribute causally to its present circumstances. That causal question falls outside the scope of discourse analysis and is not addressed here.</p><p>Finally, this paper does not attempt to diagnose individual contributors psychologically. Psychological theories are employed to interpret recurring patterns of discourse, not to identify private mental states.</p><h3>5. Central Hypothesis</h3><p>The central hypothesis of this paper is precisely scoped to what discourse analysis can establish. This paper does not determine whether the community correctly or incorrectly understands the causes of its own situation. Instead, the hypothesis is this:</p><p><em>Within the present corpus, explanations that locate the causes of classical guitar’s self-described marginality in external cultural forces occur far more frequently than explanations that consider whether characteristics of the classical guitar community itself may contribute to that condition.</em></p><p>That claim concerns discourse rather than historical causation.</p><p>Having established this descriptive asymmetry, the paper then asks whether established work in social psychology and sociology offers plausible frameworks for understanding why such asymmetries commonly emerge within human communities.</p><h3>6. Literature Review</h3><p>The interpretive apparatus of this paper draws on five distinct bodies of scholarship, reviewed in the subsections below. Social psychology (§§6.1–6.5) addresses how individuals and groups reason and communicate under conditions of identity-relevant threat. Sociology of culture and organisational theory (§§6.6–6.7) address how fields and institutions reproduce their own governing assumptions independently of individual cognition — including through doxa, habitus, and the distribution of symbolic capital — and how those assumptions resist revision. Philosophy of science (invoked in §9 and §10 rather than reviewed here, since it supplies structural argument rather than an applied lens) addresses how explanatory frameworks become resistant to self-examination across intellectual communities generally. Phenomenological ethics and the anthropology of religion (§6.8, Levinas and Girard) address the structure of a self-identical system’s relation to whatever lies outside it. The philosophy of music and musicology (§6.8, Jankélévitch and Abbate) address the distinction between gnostic and drastic<em> </em>forms of musical understanding. Most sections reviewed here in §6 are applied directly to the corpus in §8. Where a body of scholarship is reviewed for background or comparative purposes without direct application, this is noted at the relevant point.</p><h3>6.1 Identity Protection and Social Identity Theory</h3><p>Tajfel and Turner’s Social Identity Theory established that individuals derive part of their self-concept from group membership, and that this generates a motivation to maintain positive distinctiveness for the in-group relative to out-groups (Tajfel &amp; Turner, 1979). The empirical foundation for this claim is Tajfel’s minimal-group paradigm: experiments in which participants were assigned to groups on a trivial or explicitly arbitrary basis — for instance, by a coin toss — nonetheless went on to allocate resources in ways that favoured their own group, even at the cost of maximising absolute gain for all parties. The significance of this finding for the present paper is that in-group favouritism does not require a real conflict of interest, a history of grievance, or even a meaningful basis for group membership. Group identity alone appears sufficient to bias evaluation. Applied to communities organised not around an arbitrary label but around genuinely shared aesthetic commitments, ideological commitments, definitions of technique, and historical narratives, the theory predicts a considerably stronger effect than the minimal-group studies themselves demonstrate.</p><h3>6.2 Motivated Reasoning</h3><p>Kunda’s influential review distinguished <em>accuracy goals</em>, in which reasoning is directed at reaching a correct conclusion, from <em>directional goals</em>, in which reasoning is directed at reaching a desired conclusion (Kunda, 1990). Kunda’s central claim is that motivated reasoners are not simply dishonest; they are constrained by the need to construct a justification that would appear plausible to a neutral observer, and so seek out and weight evidence selectively rather than fabricating conclusions outright. This produces reasoning that feels, to the reasoner, indistinguishable from accuracy-seeking.</p><p>Kahan’s subsequent work on cultural cognition extended this account with a striking empirical refinement. In a series of studies on the interpretation of statistical data, Kahan and colleagues found that subjects with <em>greater</em> numerical reasoning ability showed <em>greater</em>, not lesser, polarisation when the same data set was framed as relevant to a politically or culturally charged question, compared to when an identical data set was framed neutrally (Kahan, Peters, Dawson, &amp; Slovic, 2017). Sophistication did not correct the bias; it supplied better tools for rationalising the conclusion the reasoner was already disposed to prefer. This finding is directly relevant to any community, including the one examined here, whose contributors include individuals demonstrably capable of nuanced, technically literate discussion: such capability does not, on the evidence of this literature, predict freedom from motivated reasoning, and may in some circumstances be redeployed in its service.</p><h3>6.3 Cognitive Dissonance</h3><p>Festinger’s original formulation holds that the simultaneous possession of two psychologically inconsistent cognitions produces discomfort, and that this discomfort motivates a reduction in inconsistency — not necessarily by changing the belief that generated the inconsistency, but often by reinterpreting evidence, narrowing attention, or shifting explanatory emphasis (Festinger, 1957). The classic empirical illustration remains Festinger et al.’s field study of a millenarian group whose prophecy of apocalypse failed to materialise (Festinger, Riecken, &amp; Schachter, 1956). Rather than abandoning the belief system, core members of the group intensified their commitment and proselytising activity following disconfirmation — a result that has become a foundational demonstration that dissonance reduction often proceeds by reinterpretation and recommitment rather than by revision.</p><h3>6.4 System Justification and Group-Serving Attribution</h3><p>Jost and Banaji’s system justification theory proposes that individuals are motivated not only to defend their own group’s standing but to defend the legitimacy of the broader social or institutional system within which that standing is determined, independently of whether the system serves their own interests (Jost &amp; Banaji, 1994). The theory’s most counter-intuitive yet strongly-supported empirical finding is that members of disadvantaged groups frequently endorse the legitimacy of the very systems responsible for their disadvantage, sometimes more strongly than members of advantaged groups do (Jost, Pelham, Sheldon, &amp; Sullivan, 2003). This finding is of particular relevance to a community that explicitly and repeatedly describes itself as marginal: system-justification research predicts that marginal status is not a reliable predictor of institutional critique, and may, under some conditions, correlate with the opposite.</p><p>A related but distinct literature addresses not the defence of institutions as such but the simpler, more general tendency to attribute success internally and failure externally. Miller and Ross’s review of the self-serving bias in individual attribution found that people characteristically credit their own dispositional qualities for successful outcomes while attributing failures to situational or external factors, a pattern that holds even when the relevant outcomes are substantially governed by chance (Miller &amp; Ross, 1975). Taylor and Doria’s extension of this finding to group contexts demonstrated that the same asymmetry operates at the level of group membership: positive outcomes for a group to which a person belongs are credited to the group’s own qualities, while negative outcomes are attributed to circumstances external to the group (Taylor &amp; Doria, 1981). This group-serving variant is structurally distinct from system justification: where system justification predicts that an institution will be defended even against a member’s own interests, group-serving attribution predicts something narrower and more mechanical — that whatever credit is available for a positive outcome will be claimed internally, and whatever blame is available for a negative outcome will be assigned externally, independently of whether either attribution serves the institution’s broader legitimacy.</p><h3>6.5 Groupthink and Collective Self-Censorship</h3><p>Janis’s case-study analyses of foreign-policy fiascos identified a recurring cluster of symptoms in cohesive decision-making groups under stress, including an illusion of invulnerability, collective rationalisation of disconfirming information, and self-censorship of individual doubts in the interest of preserving apparent consensus (Janis, 1972). Janis’s framework was developed for small, high-stakes decision-making bodies rather than for large, loosely bounded online communities, and this difference in scale and structure should be borne in mind when the framework is applied below; the relevant transferable insight is not the specific institutional setting but the demonstrated tendency for group cohesion itself to suppress the expression of dissenting analysis, independently of whether any individual member privately holds such an analysis.</p><h3>6.6 Field Theory and Doxa</h3><p>The sociological counterpart to this literature begins with Bourdieu’s concept of the field: a structured social space organised around its own specific stakes, hierarchies, and criteria of legitimacy, which are not transparent to outsiders and need not be consciously held by insiders (Bourdieu, 1977). Central to this account is the concept of <em>doxa</em> — the universe of tacit, unargued presuppositions that structure a field and that are experienced by its participants not as one possible set of assumptions among others, but as simply how things are. Bourdieu’s account predicts that doxa becomes <em>less</em> visible, not more, the more fully a participant has been socialised into a field, since what a field defines as full competence consists in the internalisation of its doxa to the point of unreflective fluency (Bourdieu, 1984). This is a structurally different mechanism from the psychological theories reviewed above: it does not depend on motivation, perceived threat, or identity defence, but on the constitutive relationship between field-defined mastery and the invisibility of that field’s own assumptions.</p><p>Closely related is Bourdieu’s concept of <em>habitus</em>: the system of durable, embodied dispositions that field participation deposits in practitioners through repeated exposure, training, and practice (Bourdieu, 1977). Where doxa operates at the level of tacit assumption — what goes without saying — habitus operates at the level of pre-reflective, bodily response. Practitioners who have fully internalised a field’s habitus do not reason their way to rejecting unfamiliar positions; they encounter them as immediately, viscerally “wrong” before any deliberation begins. This is why challenges to a field’s foundational assumptions so frequently meet not with counter-argument but with what feels like simple recognition of “error” — a response that is experienced as perception rather than evaluation, and that is accordingly more difficult to dislodge than a consciously held belief.</p><p>The field’s internal economy also distributes <em>symbolic capital</em>: the prestige, recognition, and internal standing that a field confers on those whose credentials, associations, and positions it treats as authoritative within its own hierarchy (Bourdieu, 1984). Symbolic capital in this sense need not be convertible outside the field’s boundaries — a practitioner may accumulate considerable standing within the classical guitar community while remaining unknown to broader musical culture, and the forms of recognition that circulate within the field may carry little weight in the wider cultural economy.</p><p>Whereas Bourdieu’s account explains how a field reproduces itself through the embodied dispositions of its participants, institutional theory shifts the analytical focus to the organisations that constitute and sustain the field. The question becomes not only how practitioners come to perceive the world through shared assumptions, but how those assumptions acquire stability through convergent institutional structures.</p><p>DiMaggio and Powell’s account of institutional isomorphism operates at the level of organisations within a shared field — e.g., conservatories, guitar societies, competitions, publishing houses, and dedicated online forums — proposing that such organisations tend to converge on similar structures and practices over time through normative, mimetic, and coercive pressures, independently of whether those structures remain functionally optimal (DiMaggio &amp; Powell, 1983). Among the mechanisms they identify, the most relevant here is normative isomorphism: practitioners trained within similarly converging institutions carry those norms outward as professional assumptions, producing community-wide homogenisation of pedagogical and aesthetic standards without any single actor consciously designing that outcome. The result is that inherited institutional structures persist not because they have been demonstrated to serve the community’s current circumstances, but because they have become the field’s normal way of operating — and because both the professionals the field produces and the amateurs it socialises are, by their formation, unlikely to experience them as contingent.</p><h3>6.7 Organisational Defensive Routines</h3><p>Argyris and Schön’s distinction between single-loop and double-loop learning provides the literature’s most direct conceptual bridge between the psychological and sociological lineages reviewed above (Argyris &amp; Schön, 1978). Single-loop learning corrects performance within an existing set of governing assumptions; double-loop learning subjects the governing assumptions themselves to scrutiny. Argyris’s empirical work with professionals and executives — often individuals explicitly and sincerely committed to organisational learning — found a consistent pattern of <em>skilled incompetence</em>: considerable sophistication in solving problems within inherited frameworks, paired with a much less developed capacity, often unrecognised by the practitioners themselves, to examine the frameworks doing the framing (Argyris, 1990). This finding supplies the closest existing empirical analogue to the meta-reflective asymmetry this paper documents in the Delcamp corpus, and it is for that reason treated as the strongest single fit among the empirical mechanisms reviewed in this section.</p><h3>6.8 The Scapegoat Mechanism and the Order of the Same</h3><p>The literatures reviewed above explain why explanatory attention is directed outward; they say comparatively little about what determines the specific content of that “outward,” or about the structural relationship between a community and whatever it names as exterior to itself. Three further bodies of thought, of a different register from the empirical psychology and sociology reviewed in §§6.1–6.7 — interpretive and phenomenological rather than experimental — address this gap.</p><p>Girard’s account of the scapegoat mechanism, developed across his work on mimetic rivalry and the sacred, proposes that communities under internal strain characteristically discharge that strain by directing blame towards a victim marked by sufficient difference from the community’s norm — whether through marginal status, exceptional standing, perceived transgression, or position outside the community’s reciprocal bonds — such that the community’s internal tensions can be displaced onto them without the mechanism of blame being turned back on the community itself (Girard, 1977, 1986). A structural signature of this mechanism, on Girard’s account, is the scapegoat’s fungibility: the specific identity of the blamed party matters far less than the function of having one, which is why a community under strain will often cycle through several candidate culprits in succession, or hold more than one simultaneously, without apparent need to adjudicate between them.</p><p>Levinas’s phenomenology of alterity addresses a related but distinct question: not why blame is displaced, but how a self-identical system relates to whatever lies genuinely outside it. Levinas terms the economy of the ego and its world the Same (<em>le Même</em>): the totalising, representational relation through which consciousness comprehends its surroundings by reducing them to categories it already possesses. The Other (<em>l’Autre</em>; and in its personal, ethical dimension, <em>Autrui</em>) is, for Levinas, what resists this reduction — an exteriority encountered, if at all, prior to and independently of comprehension (Levinas, 1969). A system operating wholly within the order of the Same does not, on this account, fail to encounter alterity. Rather, it assimilates alterity by reducing it to a known type already available within its own representational economy before its actual difference can be encountered.</p><p>A third resource, drawn from the philosophy and musicology of musical experience specifically, names a more precise version of the same move. Jankélévitch distinguished musical engagement that is gnostic — grounded in conceptual or theoretical knowledge of how music is made and structured — from engagement that is drastic: immediate, enacted, and irreducible to any such knowledge (Jankélévitch, 1961/2003). Abbate’s subsequent treatment of the distinction argues that musicology and, by extension, institutional cultures surrounding Western art music have characteristically privileged the gnostic over the drastic, treating conceptual mastery as the legitimate form of musical understanding and according the drastic, when it is noticed at all, a secondary or merely sensory status (Abbate, 2004). Where Levinas’s account explains why an outside perspective is assimilated rather than encountered, the gnostic/drastic distinction supplies the specific currency in which that assimilation is denominated here: appreciation is treated as something that presupposes conceptual or theoretical knowledge, such that an audience’s lack of such knowledge becomes, without further argument, evidence of its incapacity to appreciate. The asymmetry is not unidirectional: the same privileging of the gnostic that excludes drastic appreciation has also served, within the field’s own economy, to confer authority on those whose theoretical or analytical standing is not matched by demonstrable drastic ability — the capacity to perform in a way that communicates to listeners who have not been initiated into the field’s gnostic standards.</p><p>None of these three frameworks is offered here as an empirically grounded mechanism in the sense that the literature reviewed in §§6.1–6.7 is; all three are interpretive frameworks, closer in epistemic status to the philosophy-of-science material introduced in §9 than to the experimental, survey, and observational evidence reviewed earlier in this section. Their value lies in supplying a vocabulary for features of the corpus that attribution theory alone does not capture: not merely that blame and exclusion move outward, but what kind of relationship a community’s discourse establishes with whatever it names as outside itself, and on what terms that relationship is justified.</p><h3><strong>6.9 Summary of the Interpretive Framework</strong></h3><p>Taken as a whole, the literature reviewed in this section is not presented as a collection of competing explanations from which a single correct account must be chosen. Rather, these largely independent theoretical traditions converge on a common expectation: that communities often exhibit systematic asymmetries in how they explain themselves. The analysis that follows therefore asks not which framework best explains the Delcamp corpus, but whether the explanatory pattern observed in the corpus is consistent with expectations arising independently from these otherwise distinct theoretical traditions.</p><h3>7. The Empirical Corpus</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*SWcyrWYl89oJFB8S77yFJw.png" /><figcaption><strong>Figure 1.</strong> The Delcamp Classical Guitar Forum discussion <em>“Close to depression”</em>, one of the corpus threads analysed in this paper.</figcaption></figure><h3>7.1 Theme One: Cultural and Economic Marginality</h3><p>The clearest statement of marginality in the corpus appears at the beginning of <em>Close to depression</em> (Figure 1). Didac Hoyo i Martínez writes:</p><blockquote><em>I understand that the love for classical guitar is marginal. Very, very marginal.</em></blockquote><p>This is not advanced as a controversial claim requiring defence; it is offered as the shared ground from which the rest of the post proceeds. The same register recurs across contributors and across threads. The recurrence matters methodologically because the argument of this paper rests not on isolated quotations but on patterns distributed across independently initiated discussions. Conall McKay, replying in the same thread, confirms the pattern from his own household:</p><blockquote><em>My wife and children don’t like my music. Most of my non musician friends prefer pop &amp; rock.</em></blockquote><p>User riffmeister narrows the claim to the repertoire itself rather than to personal relationships:</p><blockquote><em>But classical guitar music….most people don’t know it and have little appreciation for it.</em></blockquote><p>And Gitarro nests the claim, presenting classical guitar as a marginal instance of an already marginal activity:</p><blockquote><em>Learning to play ANY musical instrument even to play popular mainstream music songs is quite rare, let alone classical music or jazz music.</em></blockquote><p>David Norton, in <em>The Future of Classical Guitar Concerts</em> (hereafter the concert-promotion thread), supplies the corpus’s most economical formulation of the same idea, compressed into an institutional epithet:</p><blockquote><em>Classical guitarists live in a “CG ghetto”. We know this.</em></blockquote><p>The phrase is notable for its casualness. It is offered in passing, not as a finding but as something already known and shared — the status identified above as characteristic of the corpus’s treatment of marginality generally.</p><p>Marginality in this corpus is not confined to questions of taste or audience size; it extends to economic precarity among accomplished performers. The thread title <em>Winning the GFA While Working In A Cafe</em> states this directly in its premise: that playing in the manner that wins international competitions does not exempt a guitarist from ordinary economic insecurity is treated by participants as noteworthy rather than as a contradiction requiring explanation. User cafetero’s congratulatory post in that thread — praising a recital’s programming choices — proceeds without pausing on the juxtaposition the title announces, which is itself consistent with the corpus’s general pattern of acknowledging marginality without dwelling on its implications.</p><p>A structurally similar moment recurs in the concert-promotion thread. User magmasystems observes:</p><blockquote><em>It’s curious that almost all of the guitar concerts that I see are put on by Guitar Societies. […] So you have one guitarist playing for a room full of other guitarists. In NYC, we can get about 100 people in the audience for a concert that is put on by the big NYC Guitar Society. But that audience can multiply by two or three if one of the ‘YouTube Stars’ comes and plays.</em></blockquote><p>The observation describes an audience that is, in effect, the profession looking at itself — a self-referential structure that is itself a form of marginalisation from the broader public, distinct from low absolute attendance. The figure magmasystems supplies — roughly one hundred attendees as a typical outcome, which he suggests could multiply if “YouTube Stars” were to play in New York City, one of the world’s largest cultural markets — establishes the corpus’s own benchmark for what currently counts as a successful classical guitar concert.</p><p>Against this benchmark, two further figures in the corpus read not as a complication of the marginality thesis but as confirmation of it at a different scale. User lagartija, a forum moderator describing a university concert series in Western Massachusetts regarded within the thread as a success story, reports:</p><blockquote><em>Our last concert with Kevin Loh sold 136 out of 150 seats.</em></blockquote><p>A capacity of 150 is itself the relevant datum; that fourteen seats remained unsold even with a presumably receptive, campus-adjacent audience underlines rather than qualifies the point. David Norton, organising for the Utah Classical Guitar Society in a 172-seat venue, supplies a directly comparable ceiling, with the added detail that even a sold-out show by Guitar Foundation of America winner Leonela Alejandro — the guitarist discussed in <em>Winning the GFA While Working In A Cafe</em> — does not move the absolute scale beyond this range:</p><blockquote><em>Utah CG Society hosts concerts in a venue with 172 seats. Our first two shows this season had just over 1/3 of the seats taken for each event. Leonela Alejandro was here two weeks ago and her show was sold out.</em></blockquote><p>The pattern across three independent organisers, in three different cities, is therefore one of convergence rather than divergence: the upper bound of what classical guitar concert promotion currently achieves, as reported within the corpus, sits in the range of one to two hundred attendees, and this ceiling holds in New York City as much as in Salt Lake City. David Norton’s own epithet, “CG ghetto,” quoted above, should accordingly be read not as hyperbole but as a literal description of the dimensions the corpus’s own organisers report.</p><p>The corpus also registers a temporal dimension to this marginality, distinct from its absolute scale. Julian Ward, in <em>Close to depression</em>, describes the diminished reception of a recorded performance posted to social media compared to a decade earlier:</p><blockquote><em>The few hours that it was up[…] saw it receive just a lowly couple of polite comments and a spattering of likes…. […] Just ten years ago, that sane [</em>sic<em>] level of “entertainment” would have gathered a huge interest and congratulations from many folk.</em></blockquote><p>User cafetero, in <em>So why is traffic at Delcamp in decline?</em> (hereafter the Delcamp-decline thread), extends the claim from audience reception and recorded performance to professional livelihood:</p><blockquote><em>I have the impression that quite a few teachers have disappeared, maybe owing to disenchantment or even loss of business in the wake of recent developments[…]</em></blockquote><p>The corpus is not, however, internally consistent on this point, and accuracy requires noting this directly. The seat-count figures discussed above are reported by organisers as qualified successes within their own frame of reference, even as they confirm the scale-level marginality this section identifies. This tension — between an absolute scale that is small by any reasonable comparison, and a local frame in which that same scale counts as achievement — is itself diagnostic, and is returned to in §8.</p><h3>7.2 Theme Two: External Attribution</h3><p>If Theme One establishes that marginality is acknowledged, Theme Two establishes where the corpus attributes its causes. The pattern recurs across discussions of classical guitar’s cultural position and the thread concerned more narrowly with forum participation, suggesting that this explanatory habit is not specific to one topic but characterises the community’s accounts of diminished standing across different contexts.</p><p>Didac Hoyo i Martínez supplies the corpus’s clearest single-sentence statement of the orientation in <em>Close to depression</em>:</p><blockquote><em>I console myself by telling myself that the problem lies with culture.</em></blockquote><p>User soltirefa narrows the same attribution to the audience specifically, rather than to culture abstractly:</p><blockquote><em>People are clueless as to what it takes to play the guitar.</em></blockquote><p>Julian Ward offers the most extended statement of this kind in the corpus, attributing declining engagement to a generalised condition of audience satiation:</p><blockquote><em>We live in a world where people are not really impressed by anything anymore. They’ve seen it all, and are constantly surrounded and entertained by the most flashy, explosive and incredible sights and sounds at the touch of a smart phone… […] The bottom line is, people just don’t really care about other people much.</em></blockquote><p>CoastStrings supplies a more compressed version of the same attribution:</p><blockquote><em>we live in a world dominated by mass-market entertainment.</em></blockquote><p>The Delcamp-decline thread, concerned with a narrower question — forum participation rather than classical guitar’s cultural standing generally — reproduces the identical explanatory structure with a different vocabulary. User magmasystems attributes declining engagement to ambient social conditions:</p><blockquote><em>I am wondering if the decline in participation has anything to do with the current state of the world? When people feel uneasy about their environment, they might just slide into a hole and not want to have that much human interaction.</em></blockquote><p>Fawkes attributes the cause to the medium itself rather than to the community using it:</p><blockquote><em>the culture today is strangely not great soil for forums to grow in. […] they have been shrinking with the rise of social media and its “information exchange” offshoots.</em></blockquote><p>StringBean offers the corpus’s most vivid formulation, attributing decline to an alleged shift in patterns of attention itself:</p><blockquote><em>Forums are out! Too much reading! People can use AI summary with much less effort. […] Brevity is no longer the soul of wit, it’s the complete attention span.</em></blockquote><p>Jack Douglas attributes the cause to macroeconomic and political conditions rather than cultural or technological ones, broadening the explanatory repertoire without altering its outward direction:</p><blockquote><em>the current economic and political climate has created a population that has lost purchasing power. […] So Delcamp has suffered from today’s realities.</em></blockquote><p>Yisrael van Handel attributes the same decline to the substitutive capacity of artificial intelligence:</p><blockquote><em>AI makes the forum less urgent. AI can answer many questions.</em></blockquote><p>Julian Ward, in the same thread, frames the forum’s situation as a survival story against an external predator:</p><blockquote><em>it is one of the very few that survived the great face book [</em>sic<em>] destruction of the forums globally. People just want to click on face book.</em></blockquote><p>User cafetero, defending the legitimacy of his original question against a charge of mere complaint, restates the same external orientation explicitly as the thread’s underlying premise:</p><blockquote><em>my preoccupation with the increasing influence of influencers[…] of social media in general — not only their mere existence and the competition that they bring, but the model of behaviour that they are propagating, which makes itself increasingly felt here at DC.</em></blockquote><p>Finally, the explanatory repertoire extends even to the forum’s own traffic statistics. When a member points to apparently high view counts as evidence against decline, the forum’s owner, Jean-François Delcamp, attributes the figures to non-human activity:</p><blockquote><em>Of the 47,925 visitors recorded in 30 minutes, there are probably 47,000 “fake” visitors who are actually search engine bots or bots working for AI development.</em></blockquote><p>User cafetero extends this attribution further, again locating the explanatory agent entirely outside the community:</p><blockquote><em>these numbers reflect data scraping by bots to fill the hard disks of these enormous AI data farms that are being built fro [</em>sic<em>] trillions of dollars.</em></blockquote><p>These passages — a selection from a substantially larger pattern of external attribution running throughout the corpus — converge on a single structural habit: causal agency is located in “culture,” other “people,” “the world,” “social media,” “AI,” and “bots,” rather than in the community’s own institutions, ideological commitments, aesthetic assumptions, pedagogical traditions, definitions of technique, repertoire currency, historical narratives, or performance culture.</p><h3>7.3 Theme Three: Community Affirmation</h3><p>The corpus’s third recurring pattern accompanies the first two. Having acknowledged marginality and attributed it outward, contributors repeatedly redirect attention towards what they characterise as the value of the community itself, redirecting attention from external neglect towards expressions of internal solidarity.</p><p>User riffmeister supplies the clearest statement of this discursive move in <em>Close to depression</em>:</p><blockquote><em>that’s why we have this enduring forum….like minded folk with whom we can communicate our passions.</em></blockquote><p>StringBean, in the same thread, generalises the sentiment into something closer to a collective imperative:</p><blockquote><em>We classical guitarists have to seek each other out, online but also in person!</em></blockquote><p>The Delcamp-decline thread, despite opening with an explicit question about the forum’s possible failure, produces an unusually dense concentration of affirmations. Underground_Musician writes:</p><blockquote><em>This site is a library; a curated collection of information on a few specific topics. I’m glad that Delcamp exists; glad enough to re-subscribe[…]</em></blockquote><p>User rojarosguitar extends gratitude to the forum’s maintainers directly:</p><blockquote><em>I do enjoy this forum as one of the best maintained and nurtured forums within the realm of some of my interests[…] Please keep going! My gratitude to all who do the work.</em></blockquote><p>User riffmeister, in the same thread, frames the forum as singular among its alternatives:</p><blockquote><em>There aren’t any other great CG forums like this one that I am aware of. Thank you J-F Delcamp!</em></blockquote><p>Winterdune supplies a superlative formulation:</p><blockquote><em>I love this place. It’s helped me in so many ways[…] For me, it’s a thousand times better than any other CG site on the internet.</em></blockquote><p>Canuck, responding to the Delcamp-decline thread’s own rising view count as evidence against the premise of decline, closes with a literary flourish that converts the moment into reassurance:</p><blockquote><em>the Delcamp forum has been a comforting bit of stability and calm in all this churn. As Mark Twain once wrote, “Reports of my death have been greatly exaggerated.”</em></blockquote><p>Doctor7 frames the forum’s possible disappearance explicitly as what he anticipates would be a loss to the community:</p><blockquote><em>It would be extremely sad if this forum comes to an end[…] the discussions [elsewhere] are not nearly as good as in here, in my opinion.</em></blockquote><p>User tanaka, recounting a week’s inaccessibility during an alleged cyberattack, describes the experience in terms of personal absence rather than mere inconvenience:</p><blockquote><em>I felt something part of me is lost and it’s almost like waking up in the morning without my newspaper at my door[…] Thank you to all past and present declampers.</em></blockquote><p>A separate, shorter thread — titled, without irony, <em>Praise Well-Earned</em> — consists almost entirely of this move in isolation, detached from any preceding discussion of decline. Godlovitch opens by reporting that a respondent from another forum (identified in the corpus only by the abbreviation AGS) had described Delcamp as a “treasure”, to which Canuck replies:</p><blockquote><em>Agreed, there is nowhere else. […] So this is it. Thanks, Jean-François.</em></blockquote><p>The recurrence of this affirmation across threads with different proximate occasions — a perceived decline, an alleged cyberattack, an unprompted post of gratitude — indicates that community affirmation functions within the corpus not merely as a response to crisis but as a recurring discursive resource to which participants return independently of any particular triggering event.</p><h3>7.4 Theme Four: The Comparative Absence of Internal Critique</h3><p>Establishing an absence requires more care than establishing a presence. The claim advanced here is therefore deliberately formulated in qualified terms. It is not that the corpus contains zero instances of dissatisfaction directed at the community itself. It is that such instances are markedly rarer than the external and affirmative moves catalogued above, and that on the occasions where an internal question or challenge is gestured towards — by the original poster or by a respondent — the discussion characteristically moves away from it rather than through it. Several moments in the corpus illustrate this pattern with particular clarity.</p><p><strong>The deflected institutional question.</strong> User cafetero’s opening post in the Delcamp-decline thread raises something closer to an internal-institutional question than any other passage in the corpus:</p><blockquote><em>There have been some (veiled or open) accusations recently that Delcamp is simple [</em>sic<em>] “too conservative” and “dominated by old men”. Do you think this is true?</em></blockquote><p>This is, on its face, an invitation to examine an inherited institutional characteristic rather than an external condition — though cafetero notably attributes the invitation to unnamed external parties (“accusations”) rather than advancing it as his own position. The question arrives in the corpus already at one remove from its source, and the response documents not only the deflection of an institutional question but the simultaneous absorption and anonymisation of the external challenge that generated it. The response it receives, from Underground_Musician, accepts the factual premise but converts it immediately into a defence rather than an inquiry:</p><blockquote><em>Yes, but the conservatism (regarding music, not politics) is part of the appeal. Guitar music, and art music in general, is a niche. I appreciate a discussion venue that doesn’t weaken its purpose by trying to be relevant to everybody and everything. Broad appeal usually equates to shallowness. “Old men” does not necessarily equal “bad”</em></blockquote><p>Underground_Musician’s parenthetical qualifier, “regarding music, not politics,” asserts a clean separation between musical and political conservatism as if that separation were self-evident, without argument for the implied claim that the two can be so cleanly divided. The question cafetero posed — <em>is this true, and if so, does it matter</em> — is answered only on its first half. Whether age-skew or conservatism has contributed causally to the decline cafetero is asking about is not addressed; instead, the characteristic is reframed — as if it were not merely a fact about classical guitar but a virtue constitutive of what classical guitar is and ought to remain — rather than interrogated as a possible cause specific to the forum’s decline. A second response, from DevonBadger, takes a different deflective route, disputing the evidentiary basis for the premise itself rather than engaging with its institutional implications:</p><blockquote><em>to use the word decline seems to be passing judgement on the quality of posts rather than merely commenting on the volume. Whilst that may be your impression, you’re going to have a hard time to provide concrete evidence[…]</em></blockquote><p>Between these two responses, the institutional question cafetero gestured towards is neither confirmed, refuted, nor pursued. It is absorbed.</p><p><strong>The single-loop pivot.</strong> In the concert-promotion thread, magmasystems’s observation that guitar audiences consist substantially of other guitarists — quoted above under Theme One — contains the seed of a genuinely institutional question: why does classical guitar so often perform primarily to itself, and to what extent might that pattern reflect the field’s own institutions, performance culture, aesthetic assumptions, pedagogical traditions, or repertoire choices, rather than merely deficiencies in external audiences or publicity? The thread does not pursue this question. The subsequent exchange moves immediately to acoustic rationalisations, venue capacity, and comparisons between churches and auditoriums — a set of practical, adaptive responses that leave the underlying constitution of the audience unexamined. This is a clear instance of the single-loop reasoning discussed in §6.7: contributors solve the problem of how best to present classical guitar within its existing institutional and aesthetic framework, rather than asking whether features of that framework itself contribute to the audience composition they seek to explain.</p><p><strong>A near-miss towards internal challenge, and its rebuttal.</strong> The corpus contains one passage that approaches genuine self-examination of an inherited assumption rather than of an external circumstance or an individual’s behaviour. Responding to Didac Hoyo’s framing of classical guitar appreciation as evidence of cultural sophistication, Canuck writes:</p><blockquote><em>Some classical music is digestible and fast-paced, and some music in other genres (including jazz and pop) is quite sophisticated. It’s a mistake to think we’re more cultured because we play or listen to classical music; it’s simply what we happen to love. […] It’s great that classical music is what moves your soul — same for mine — but don’t build walls around yourself.</em></blockquote><p>This is the closest the corpus comes to challenging an inherited evaluative hierarchy — the assumption, present throughout <em>Close to depression</em>, that classical guitar’s marginal status reflects badly on its audience rather than on any feature of the genre or its presentation. The challenge, however, concerns a taste hierarchy rather than an ideological commitment, aesthetic assumption, or definition of technique; it does not extend to the questions enumerated in §9 (has our definition of “technique” itself narrowed what counts as “musical,” have our institutions adapted, and so forth). It also accepts, without examination, an implicit opposition between “fast” and “sophisticated”. Even at this narrower scope, the challenge receives an immediate corrective reply. Responding to Canuck’s closing suggestion that “it wouldn’t be the end of the world” if a classical guitarist “learned to play […] a Taylor Swift song,” latimi replies:</p><blockquote><em>I would never do that to my guitar. This would be devaluing something that is sacred.</em></blockquote><p>The exchange is brief, but its structure is instructive: a rare move towards questioning an inherited boundary is met not with engagement but with a restatement of the boundary in explicitly sacralising terms. Whether this single exchange indicates a more general tendency towards boundary-reassertion cannot be established from one instance; it is reported here as an observation, not generalised into a pattern.</p><p><strong>A missed opportunity for self-critique.</strong> A further passage contains material that could have supported internal critique, though the speaker’s own words do not reach towards it. Discussing a separate office-performance episode (in the <em>An experiment, a small rant </em>thread), m k ljus observes of non-musician listeners:</p><blockquote><em>they have not categorized music into things they like and don’t like. It’s always refreshing to hear impressions from people who don’t play guitar or any other instrument[…]</em></blockquote><p>Read alongside its context, the comment comes close to suggesting that classical guitarists’ own categorising, comparative disposition towards performance may itself narrow what they are able to enjoy or communicate — a disposition that could, in principle, extend to questions concerning how classical guitarists are trained, what they learn to value aesthetically, how technique comes to be defined, and the performance culture those assumptions collectively sustain. The comment does not draw that connection explicitly, and it is framed as a remark about the perceptiveness of non-musicians (a drastic mode of appreciation, in the sense established in §6.8) rather than as a critique of guitarists’ own playing/listening habits. It is reported here as a missed opportunity: a passage whose content could support the second-order territory mapped in §9, but whose own framing does not reach towards it.</p><p>Taken together, these instances — which represent the closest the corpus comes to internal critique — do not establish that the classical guitar community is entirely incapable of internal reflection or internal critique. They establish something more specific. In each case, a second-order question is gestured towards or implicit in the discussion, and then deflected — through reframing, through disputing the premise, through practical pivot, or through immediate reassertion of the boundary in question — rather than pursued. What remains comparatively absent throughout is sustained scrutiny of the field’s own inherited assumptions. This is the asymmetry the paper’s central hypothesis describes: not an absolute inability to look inward, but a consistent tendency for that inward look to stop one level short of the field’s own governing assumptions. Measured against the thirteen external attributions catalogued in §7.2, this section’s search for an internal counterpart yields, at most, four candidates — and even these stop short, redirected before they are pursued.</p><p>Before turning to the interpretive frameworks reviewed in §6, one further observation should be made. The corpus is not characterised by uniformity of opinion, hostility, or an absence of reflection. It contains humour, disagreement, practical advice, and genuine attempts to understand the issues under discussion. The argument advanced below is therefore not that participants are unusually irrational or incapable of critical thought. Rather, it concerns the overall pattern of explanation that nonetheless emerges across discussions involving different contributors.</p><h3>8. Discussion: Applying the Literature to the Corpus</h3><p>This section takes the literature reviewed in §6 on its own terms and maps phenomenona explicitly onto the corpus findings of §7.</p><p>Identity protection (§6.1) predicts that criticism directed at a community’s inherited assumptions will be experienced as a threat to the self insofar as those assumptions are bound up with group identity. The relevant group in the present corpus is not “classical guitarists” as a bare label but the community constituted by shared aesthetic commitments, ideological commitments, definitions of technique, and historical narrative — the same community whose conservatism cafetero gestured towards questioning in §7.4, and which Underground_Musician defended not by disputing the premise but by reframing it as a virtue. This is consistent with, though not proof of, an identity-protective response. A related Social Identity Theory prediction — that in-groups maintain positive distinctiveness through unfavourable comparison with out-groups — is visible elsewhere in the same Delcamp-decline thread. Canuck’s survey of alternative platforms concludes that Reddit “seemed to consist of mainly young gamer-type males with fragile egos flaming each-other (so, standard Reddit),” before adding that Delcamp’s membership “skew[s] more ‘older retired-type males getting politely defensive’.” The in-group is maintained through the contrast even when the self-description is self-deprecating: “getting politely defensive” is acknowledged as a failing, but the acknowledgement is framed as a comparative virtue. The in-group’s positive distinctiveness survives its own candour.</p><p>Motivated reasoning (§6.2) offers a parallel account of the corpus’s explanatory asymmetry. External explanations — culture, audiences, technology, bots — preserve the community’s existing self-understanding; internal explanations require entertaining the possibility that inherited assumptions themselves are inadequate. Kahan’s finding that sophistication does not reduce motivated reasoning, and may sharpen it, is particularly relevant given that the corpus’s external-attribution statements (§7.2) are frequently articulated with considerable nuance and self-awareness — magmasystems’s and Julian Ward’s posts being clear examples of contributors reasoning carefully in support of a conclusion that happens also to be the one that leaves the community’s own practices unexamined.</p><p>Cognitive dissonance (§6.3) is directly legible in the corpus’s repeated, near-simultaneous affirmation of two propositions: that classical guitar is represented within the corpus as both possessing profound value and occupying a marginal cultural position. Didac Hoyo’s opening post in <em>Close to depression</em> holds both without resolving the tension between them; the dissonance-reduction literature predicts precisely the sort of move that follows across the thread — not a revision of either premise, but a redirection of attention towards consolation, solidarity, and external blame, each of which reduces the discomfort of the pairing without requiring either proposition to change. A stronger instance of the same mechanism, because it eliminates the tension rather than managing it, appears in the Delcamp-decline thread. Underground_Musician’s defence of the forum’s conservatism holds that “Guitar music, and art music in general, is a niche. I appreciate a discussion venue that doesn’t weaken its purpose by trying to be relevant to everybody and everything. Broad appeal usually equates to shallowness.” Across the same corpus, niche status is repeatedly described as a source of loneliness, cultural isolation, and near-depression. The same condition that prompts distress in one thread is converted into a mark of distinction in another, without any sign that the contradiction registers. This is not the same dissonance-reduction move as Didac Hoyo’s: where Hoyo acknowledges the tension and redirects away from it, Underground_Musician reconceptualises the problem as its own solution — a more thoroughgoing reduction because it leaves nothing to redirect away from.</p><p>System justification (§6.4) supplies a sharp account of why a self-described marginal community would defend, rather than interrogate, the institutional arrangements responsible for that marginality — the pattern observed in cafetero’s deflected question about conservatism and old-male dominance (§7.4). Jost’s finding that disadvantage often correlates with stronger system defence, rather than weaker, fits this exchange better than a generic self-serving-bias account would, since self-serving bias predicts only that failure will be externally attributed, not that an institutional characteristic, once named, will be actively defended as a virtue.</p><p>Group-serving attribution (§6.4) is legible not in any single passage but in the corpus’s overall shape, once Themes One/Two and Three are read against each other rather than separately. Across the explanations examined here, the community’s negative condition — its cultural marginality, its declining participation — locates the cause outside the community: e.g., in audiences, technology, economics, AI, or bots (§7.2). No comparable external attribution appears for the community’s positive self-assessment. When contributors affirm the forum’s value, credit is placed squarely inside the community: rojarosguitar thanks “all who do the work,” tanaka thanks “all past and present declampers,” and riffmeister and Canuck attribute the forum’s continued worth to “like minded folk” and to Jean-François Delcamp personally (§7.3). Taylor and Doria’s finding predicts this asymmetry: bad outcomes pushed outward, good outcomes pulled inward, with no logical requirement that the same causal story govern both. The pattern derives its force from its recurrence across three separate threads addressing different questions — classical guitar’s broader cultural position, the forum’s own declining participation, and an unprompted thread of praise for the forum — rather than from any isolated exchange or quotation.</p><p>Groupthink (§6.5) is visible in the affirmation thread examined in §7.3, where Canuck’s closing invocation of Mark Twain performs the self-censoring, consensus-preserving function Janis’s framework describes, even though the Delcamp forum is a far larger and more loosely bounded body than the small decision-making groups Janis originally studied; the mechanism Janis identifies — cohesion suppressing dissent independently of private belief — transfers more readily than the specific institutional setting does. Three further instances, each illustrating a distinct mechanism within Janis’s account, appear elsewhere in the corpus. In the Delcamp-decline thread, lp4guitar raises what is in substance the corpus’s only genuine behavioural self-critique — that the Delcamp community’s own treatment of performers drove people away — noting that “the criticism of music that Isn’t strictly classical has helped much [<em>sic</em>], neither did the abuse Sean Shibe and many others got from past videos and performances.” The observation receives no uptake. The thread continues as if it had not been made. This is not deflection in the sense documented in §7.4 — the observation is not reframed or disputed; it receives no substantive engagement, which is the more thoroughgoing suppression. In the same thread, joachim33 states explicitly: “I am very disappointed by some of the contributions here […] While I was originally interested in contributing to the core of this thread, I am not any longer.” This is voluntary self-removal under social pressure — not the suppression of a private doubt but its explicit announcement followed by withdrawal — which is what Janis means by self-censorship operating independently of the censored party’s actual views. Finally, the <em>Praise Well-Earned</em> thread exemplifies Janis’s collective rationalisation of disconfirming information: the failure of an alternative forum — “their membership number seemed to be stuck at 68 members, and they couldn’t find a way to grow the community” — is interpreted as reinforcing Delcamp’s perceived exceptional status, rather than as an occasion to ask whether the same underlying dynamics might also bear on Delcamp itself. Evidence that could generate a question is instead absorbed into the consensus it might otherwise have disturbed.</p><p>Field theory and doxa (§6.6) account for a feature of the corpus that the psychological literature alone does not: the sheer rarity with which contributors treat any of the community’s foundational assumptions as a <em>question</em> at all, rather than as background. Bourdieu’s prediction that doxa becomes less visible with greater fluency in a field is consistent with the corpus’s most fully acculturated, most experienced contributors being among those least likely to raise the internal questions catalogued in §7.4 and §9. The same mechanism accounts for the tension noted in §7.1, where concert organisers reporting attendance in the low hundreds nonetheless frame those figures, within their own posts, as qualified successes: the standard against which “success” is measured is generated entirely within the field’s own contracted expectations, which is what an unexamined, doxic standard of evaluation would be expected to produce.</p><p>Habitus (§6.6) supplies an account of why the deflected institutional questions in §7.4 so consistently take the form of immediate reframing rather than considered rebuttal: Underground_Musician’s defence of conservatism, or latimi’s characterisation of the classical guitar as “sacred,” arrives not as the conclusion of an argument but with the pre-reflective force of something that has been felt as correct before it was stated — which is what habitus, rather than reasoned belief, would predict.</p><p>Symbolic capital (§6.6) is legible in two complementary observations from the concert-promotion discussion, read alongside the separate thread <em>Winning the GFA While Working In A Cafe</em>. David Norton reports that the Utah Classical Guitar Society ordinarily fills only about one-third of its 172-seat venue, yet Leonela Alejandro’s appearance sold out the hall. Elsewhere, magmasystems suggests that a typical New York guitar-society audience of around one hundred could multiply if one of the “YouTube Stars” performs. These examples point to two different currencies of symbolic capital operating within the same field. Alejandro’s ability to attract a relatively larger audience within the classical-guitar community derives from institutional prestige conferred through the Guitar Foundation of America competition; the “YouTube Star” derives comparable appeal among largely the same specialist audience through digital visibility and online recognition. Both forms of symbolic capital are associated with audiences roughly two or three times larger than those reported for ordinary society concerts, yet neither alters the broader pattern documented in §7.1: even their most successful concerts remain measured in the low hundreds. The corpus therefore illustrates Bourdieu’s claim that symbolic capital is field-specific rather than unitary. Different forms of legitimacy circulate through different institutional economies, but all remain constrained by the comparatively limited public visibility of the field itself.</p><p>DiMaggio and Powell’s institutional isomorphism (§6.6) is similarly legible in the single-loop pivot identified in the concert-promotion thread: organisers converge on the same venue-and-acoustic-rationalisation responses to a self-referential audience problem without the underlying institutional structure — guitar-society-organised concerts attended principally by guitarists — itself becoming a candidate for revision.</p><p>Organisational defensive routines (§6.7) provide the most direct fit of all among the empirical mechanisms reviewed in §§6.1–6.7, and the clearest bridge between the psychological and sociological literatures. Argyris’s distinction between single-loop and double-loop learning maps closely onto the difference between the corpus’s many practical, adaptive suggestions — use AI summaries less, switch platforms, improve acoustics, attract younger members — and its near-total absence of questions about whether the community’s own institutions, inherited assumptions, pedagogical practices, definitions of technique, repertoire currency, historical narratives, and performance culture should themselves be reconsidered. What is comparatively absent is any suggestion that targets the frame within which those suggestions are generated.</p><p>Three further frameworks, reviewed separately in §6.8 because they belong to a different register — interpretive and phenomenological rather than experimental, survey-based, or observational — return to a question system justification (§6.4) leaves open. If the institution itself is defended rather than blamed, where does the blame actually go, and how does the community relate to whatever it names there?</p><p>The scapegoat mechanism supplies a vocabulary for a feature of the corpus’s external attributions that the literature reviewed above describes the direction of but not the texture of. Section 7.2 catalogued thirteen distinct external explanations advanced by contributors across the threads under discussion in that subsection: culture in general, audience cluelessness, entertainment saturation, mass-market culture, generalised unease, the unsuitability of social media as a medium, a shift in patterns of attention, AI summarisation, economic and political conditions, the substitutive capacity of artificial intelligence, the “great face book destruction,” the behavioural norms propagated by social-media influencers, and, repeatedly, bots. These explanations are drawn from quite different explanatory frameworks — cultural, technological, economic, demographic, cognitive, and statistical — and some sit in evident tension with one another. Economic hardship and AI-enabled distraction, for example, are not obviously the same diagnosis of declining participation, nor is the claim that participation has fallen easily reconciled with explanations centred on inflated bot traffic. Yet the corpus exhibits no apparent pressure to compare, prioritise, or adjudicate between these competing explanations. The attribution to bots furnishes the purest instance: a non-human, unidentifiable, and largely unfalsifiable explanatory agent, invoked by both the forum’s owner and one of its most active contributors to account for the bulk of the forum’s own traffic statistics. This fungibility — the ease with which one candidate cause is exchanged for, or simply added to, another, without strain — is precisely the sort of pattern Girard’s account of a scapegoat mechanism would predict, and is harder to derive from attribution theory alone, which is agnostic about whether a community settles on one external cause or cycles through many.</p><p>Levinas’s account of the Same is similarly legible in the specific terms the corpus uses to characterise whatever lies outside the community, and the relevant material here extends well beyond the passages already presented in §7. In <em>Close to depression</em>, Julian Ward warns that “a bit of Fernando Sor — no matter how well played, just probably isn’t going to cut it with average Joe”; dvh1978 advises a despondent contributor to tell sceptical friends that “the music you play is on another level compared to the mainstream pop &amp; rock or fast-paced whatever they are listening to”; CoastStrings characterises requests for a pop song as listeners “just looking for that same kind of easy, shared familiarity”; Gitarro observes that “most people consume and do not participate in creating anything because to do so requires high levels of disciplined and persevering effort and time[…]”; and Conall McKay, more guardedly, advises a fellow contributor to “let others enjoy theirs, even if you believe theirs is inferior to yours” — naming the hierarchy outright even while counselling tolerance of it. None of these statements engages “average Joe,” “the mainstream,” or other “people” as a perspective the community might be required to understand on its own terms or from which it might have something to learn. They appear instead only through evaluative distinctions already available within the discourse — distinctions between what contributors construe as sophistication and vulgarity, disciplined effort and passive consumption, and depth and easy familiarity — which assimilate exteriority to categories the community already possesses, regardless of what the public actually turns out to want, value, or disclose.</p><p>The sharpest instance of the pattern involves no member of “the public” at all. Also in <em>Close to depression</em>, Mark Clifton-Gaultier recounts performing a Bach fugue to an audience he describes as “co-residents [who] were all supposedly broadly educated, culturally well nourished post-grads”, only to be asked, at the end, whether he knew “anything with a tune.” He obliged with a popular piece, which the room applauded; he records the outcome as a tune that “nailed my reputation as a great player … and theirs as witless imbeciles.” A second contributor to the same thread, MartinCogg, recalls a listener mistaking a Sor study for another, more familiar piece, and glosses the moment with the aside: “Lordy, thinks me… she’s mistooken [<em>sic</em>] it for the ‘Spanish Romance’”. In both cases the Other being constituted is not an uneducated or necessarily unmusical mass; it is composed of people the contributors themselves describe as cultured. What disqualifies them from the category of genuine interlocutor is not a lack of sophistication but a failure to share this particular community’s aesthetic assumptions, repertoire values, and evaluative hierarchy. On Levinas’s account, this is a purer instance of the Same at work than condescension towards an obviously unsophisticated audience would be: the boundary being drawn is not between the cultured and the uncultured, but between those who already think like the in-group and everyone else.</p><p>This is not, on Levinas’s account, a failure to notice the public, nor a total failure of generosity by any individual contributor; several of those quoted above are otherwise sympathetic, encouraging correspondents elsewhere in the same threads. It is what relating to an Other entirely within the economy of the Same characteristically produces, regardless of the warmth or hostility of the tone in which any individual instance is expressed. Nor is the pattern exceptionless. Canuck’s challenge to the assumption that classical-music taste signals cultural superiority (§7.4) explicitly resists this move, and m k ljus’s observation that non-musicians have not categorised music into things they like and don’t like (§7.4) treats an outside perspective as something to learn from rather than something to place. That the corpus contains both moves — assimilation into the Same as the dominant pattern, and occasional genuine encounter with alterity as a rare counter-current — is itself consistent with the asymmetry this paper documents throughout: the second move is available to this discourse, but it is not the one the discourse reaches for first.</p><p>A further instance of the same mechanism operates through a more specific logical move: the conflation of conceptual knowledge with appreciation. User riffmeister’s claim that “classical guitar music… most people don’t know it and have little appreciation for it” (§7.1), and soltirefa’s claim that “people are clueless as to what it takes to play the guitar” (§7.2), rest on the same underlying inference — that limited familiarity with the community’s own definitions of technique, aesthetic assumptions, and broader interpretive framework is sufficient grounds for concluding that the music cannot be genuinely appreciated. The gnostic/drastic distinction reviewed in §6.8 names what this inference erases: it treats gnostic access as a precondition for appreciation, foreclosing in advance the possibility that drastic appreciation — immediate and enacted, rather than mediated by the community’s own gnostic/interpretive framework — might be precisely the form of appreciation an audience is in fact extending to the music, on terms the inference has no means of recognising as appreciation at all.</p><p>The Same’s relation to the Other is, moreover, asymmetric in its standards of generalisation, and the asymmetry is visible within a single post. Underground_Musician writes, defending Delcamp’s conservatism in the exchange examined in §7.4: “Guitar music, and art music in general, is a niche. […] Broad appeal usually equates to shallowness” — and, two sentences later, in the same post: “”Old men” does not necessarily equal “bad””. The first statement is a sweeping generalisation about an external category, anything with broad appeal, asserted without qualification. The second is an explicit refusal to let an equally sweeping generalisation stand once the category in question is one that substantially overlaps with the community’s own demographic. The discourse exhibits a standard of individuation that it does not extend to whatever lies outside it; nothing in the post suggests this asymmetry is registered as a tension requiring resolution, which is more consistent with an unexamined economy of the Same than with a consciously maintained double standard.</p><h3>9. Beyond Attribution: First-Order and Second-Order Inquiry</h3><p>§8 traced the corpus’s attributional asymmetry mechanism by mechanism — identity protection, motivated reasoning, dissonance, system justification, group-serving attribution, groupthink, doxa, institutional isomorphism, organisational defensive routines, scapegoating, and the Order of the Same, among others — each supplying a partial account of the corpus’s recurrent preference for adaptive responses over revision of the community’s own governing assumptions. What remains is to ask what these mechanisms jointly imply about the structure of inquiry itself, independently of which one is doing the work in any given instance.</p><p>The corpus’s contributors are not short of reflection. They reason fluently about education, taste, commercial culture, technology, and the economics of attention; many of the passages quoted in §7 are nuanced, self-aware, and sympathetic. The asymmetry under discussion therefore does not concern the presence or absence of intelligence, reflection, or ethical concern. It concerns what the discourse renders readily thinkable — and, in Levinas’s sense, what it renders genuinely encounterable as Other. More precisely, it concerns what level of question gets asked.</p><p>The clearest way to state this is as a distinction between first-order and second-order inquiry. A first-order question asks why a perceived problem exists: why have audiences changed, why has culture shifted towards mass entertainment, why do people now seek different forms of attention. A second-order question asks something else: why does this particular explanation present itself as obvious, while another barely occurs to anyone; what has to be true of a community’s own assumptions for one account to feel like common sense and another to feel, if it is raised at all, like an accusation requiring rebuttal.</p><p>The corpus readily supplies the first-order problems to which its contributors repeatedly propose answers, even where those problems are not always explicitly formulated as questions: why is this forum declining, why does classical guitar occupy so marginal a position? What it supplies in abundance are not the questions themselves but proposed answers to them — §7.2 catalogues thirteen distinct attributions offered in response to a comparatively small number of such questions, which is itself consistent with the fungibility already noted in §8: many candidate answers circulating around one or two questions, with no apparent pressure to settle on a single account. Near-second-order questions appear only at the margins of the corpus, and the two clearest instances were already examined in §7.4 for a narrower purpose and bear revisiting here for what they show about the structure of inquiry rather than its content. User cafetero’s question about whether Delcamp’s conservatism and age-skew might be implicated in its decline gestures towards a second-order question in the sense intended here, even as cafetero attributes it to unnamed others rather than posing it outright — it asks whether an inherited characteristic of the community, rather than of the world outside it, might be doing causal work. Underground_Musician’s reply does not refuse the question; it answers a different, first-order-compatible question instead, converting a question about whether conservatism matters into an assertion that conservatism is a virtue. Canuck’s challenge to the assumption that classical-music taste signals cultural superiority performs a similar near-second-order move with respect to a different inherited assumption, and meets a similarly immediate redirection — not a rebuttal of the challenge, but a reassertion, in latimi’s reply, of the boundary the challenge had questioned. Neither exchange demonstrates that these questions cannot be answered from within the community. Both demonstrate that, on the rare occasions such questions are even gestured towards, the discourse’s available moves are to redirect, reframe, or reassert — not to pursue.</p><p>Three independent bodies of scholarship, developed in different disciplines for different purposes, converge on the expectation that explanatory frameworks characteristically resist scrutiny of their own governing assumptions. Kuhn observed that periods of normal science consist of puzzle-solving conducted within an accepted paradigm rather than continual reconsideration of the paradigm itself (Kuhn, 1970). Popper warned that explanatory systems can become increasingly resistant to revision through auxiliary explanations that protect their central assumptions (Popper, 1963). Lakatos described research programmes whose “protective belts” absorb anomalies in order to preserve their theoretical cores (Lakatos, 1978). None was writing about online communities, still less about classical guitar; their shared claim is a general one about the architecture of any sufficiently developed explanatory framework, scientific or otherwise. Bourdieu’s account of doxa, reviewed in §6.6 and applied directly in §8, supplies the sociological counterpart: a framework’s invisibility to those most fully socialised into it is not a lapse of attention but a constitutive feature of field-specific fluency. Argyris’s single-loop/double-loop distinction, reviewed in §6.7 and likewise applied in §8, supplies the organisational-learning counterpart, and need not be re-argued here.</p><p>What these convergent literatures jointly imply is that the present argument exceeds psychology. Psychological theories explain why a community might preferentially preserve a valued identity under conditions of perceived threat. The phenomenon traced here concerns something broader: the epistemological structure through which communal inquiry is organised, particularly the asymmetric ease with which a framework generates first-order questions compared with the difficulty with which it generates questions about itself. Every intellectual tradition has blind spots of this kind; their existence is not in question. What the present corpus illustrates is not that the classical guitar community possesses blind spots, but how a sophisticated, reflective discourse can hold one in place without any single participant intending to.</p><p>The common feature uniting these otherwise disparate traditions is that the assumptions through which a community renders its experience intelligible ordinarily function as conditions of intelligibility rather than objects of inquiry. Precisely because they organise what can be readily perceived, they are comparatively unlikely to become salient as assumptions in their own right.</p><h3>10. Philosophical Epilogue</h3><p>The asymmetry documented throughout this paper raises a question that exceeds what the corpus itself can answer, but which the corpus’s own structure makes difficult to avoid: is the systematic examination of a field’s own doxa possible from within the field at all, or does it require, as a structural matter rather than an accident of any individual’s insight, a vantage point outside or at the margins of that field?</p><p>Three independent traditions converge on the latter possibility, though none establishes it as a settled empirical law. Kuhn’s account of scientific revolution locates the trigger for paradigm change not in the accumulated reflection of a paradigm’s most successful practitioners, but in the gradual, often resisted accumulation of anomalies — observations the reigning paradigm cannot comfortably absorb. Kuhn also observed, as a historical generalisation rather than an empirically established law, that paradigm change commonly gains its earliest adherents among younger scientists or those less deeply committed to the existing paradigm, whose professional and intellectual investments in its continuation are correspondingly weaker (Kuhn, 1970). Bourdieu’s account of field dynamics supplies a more structural version of the same claim. Every field, on this account, contains agents occupying dominant, orthodox positions, for whom the field’s existing distribution of legitimacy is a known and favourable arrangement, and agents occupying dominated, heterodox positions, for whom that arrangement is a constraint rather than an achievement. Doxa — the field’s unargued ‘common sense’ — is converted into explicit, contestable orthodoxy typically only when heterodox agents name it as one assumption among others rather than as simply ‘how things are’; this is, on Bourdieu’s account, definitionally not a move the field’s most fully orthodox members have comparable reason to make (Bourdieu, 1977, 1984).</p><p>A third tradition, of a different kind again, arrives at a structurally similar place by an entirely separate route. Extended to the present case, Levinas’s account of the Same and the Other, reviewed in §6.8, holds that a system organised around its own categories of comprehension does not relate to genuine exteriority by examining it, but by assimilating it through reduction to a known type before any actual encounter with its difference can occur. Applied to the present question, this suggests that a field’s relation to its own doxa and its relation to whatever lies outside it may be two expressions of a single underlying structure. In the first case, anomalies, critics, and publics are rendered intelligible through categories the field already possesses before they can appear on their own terms. In the second, the field’s own governing assumptions ordinarily fail to appear as assumptions at all. Precisely because they constitute the horizon within which experience is organised, they remain difficult to encounter as historical, contingent, or revisable objects of inquiry. In this sense, the field’s doxa occupies a position structurally analogous to exteriority: not because it lies beyond the field, but because, as the very framework through which the field organises experience, it ordinarily remains outside the field’s reflective awareness.</p><p>History and philosophy of science, sociology of culture, and phenomenological ethics each developed distinct theoretical accounts for different purposes. None was formulated with the Delcamp forum, or any online community, in view. Yet all three imply a structurally similar asymmetry between the taken-for-granted framework through which experience is organised and the relative difficulty of bringing that framework itself into view. That all three nonetheless converge on a structurally similar prediction is not proof that the prediction is correct. It is a reason to take it seriously.</p><p>Taken together, these convergences suggest a broader epistemological possibility: that the interpretive framework through which a community understands the world may itself be the aspect of that world least available to the community’s own scrutiny.</p><p>If this convergence holds, even provisionally, it reframes the asymmetry documented in this paper. The near-absence of second-order questioning in the Delcamp corpus would not necessarily indicate any deficiency, individual or collective, among its most active contributors. It might instead indicate that double-loop revision of a field’s own governing assumptions is structurally unlikely to originate from the population a long-running, identity-rich forum predominantly retains: precisely its most established, most fully acculturated, most thoroughly socialised members. The corpus itself contains an incidental observation consistent with this possibility. Yisrael van Handel, in the Delcamp-decline thread, observes without any apparent diagnostic intent: “Many, many of the forum members joined in years of high web activity and are now well past 70 and getting older.” A community composed substantially of its field’s most senior and longest-tenured participants would, on this account, constitute something close to a structural worst case for generating double-loop revision from within.</p><p>This hypothesis should be treated explicitly as a Level Four hypothesis in the terms set out in §3: it extends well beyond what the corpus can confirm, and rests on a single, unsystematically gathered demographic remark rather than on any survey of the forum’s actual age distribution. But if this broader structural hypothesis is correct, it has implications not only for the corpus but also for the standpoint from which the present analysis has been conducted. It bears directly on the positionality disclosed in §12. If heterodox or externally positioned agents are structurally more likely to raise the second-order questions a field’s orthodox population rarely raises of itself, then the present writer’s dual position as both published critic and present analyst is not merely a conflict to be managed but is itself an instance of the very structural pattern this epilogue describes. This should not be mistaken for a claim that heterodox positioning makes a critique correct: the account given above predicts only who is structurally well placed to ask a question, not whether the answer they propose to it is right. The corpus analysed in this paper cannot adjudicate that further question. It can only report that, within this discourse, second-order questions about the community’s own governing assumptions were very rarely asked at all. The broader Level Four hypotheses outlined in §3 — concerning explanatory asymmetry, institutional identity, and the availability of explanatory frameworks — lie beyond the scope of the present paper and may be examined in a separate study.</p><h3>11. Conclusion</h3><p>The question this paper set out to answer was specific: when members of the classical guitar community discuss their self-described marginality, what kinds of explanations do they produce, and which kinds remain comparatively absent?</p><p>The corpus answers with some consistency. Explanations for marginality are directed overwhelmingly outward — towards culture, audiences, technology, economics, and, in the case of the forum’s own declining participation, bots. Explanations directed inward — towards the community’s own institutions, ideological commitments, aesthetic assumptions, pedagogical traditions, definitions of technique, repertoire currency, historical narratives, or performance culture — occur only at the margins of the discourse, are often only indicated rather than developed, and, on the rare occasions they surface, the discussion moves past them rather than through them. This is a claim about discourse, not about historical causation. It does not establish that the external explanations are wrong, nor that the internal ones are right.</p><p>The literature reviewed in §6, and applied directly in §8, does more than describe this pattern after the fact. The contribution of the present analysis is to show that the asymmetry documented here is anticipated by a wide range of otherwise independent theoretical traditions developed across several disciplines. Identity protection, motivated reasoning, cognitive dissonance, system justification, group-serving attribution, groupthink, the scapegoat mechanism, the Order of the Same, the distinction between gnostic and drastic understanding, field-level doxa, institutional isomorphism, and organisational defensive routines comprise twelve largely independent theoretical traditions, developed for different purposes across psychology, sociology, anthropology, phenomenological ethics, philosophy of science, organisational studies, and the philosophy of musical experience. That nearly all of them predict some version of the asymmetry observed here is not proof that any one of them correctly describes what is happening inside any individual contributor’s reasoning. It does, however, suggest that the asymmetry documented here is not merely a peculiarity of one forum, but is consistent with a considerably more general phenomenon concerning how communities relate to their own governing assumptions.</p><p>The practical stakes of the distinction are real, even though the corpus cannot settle them. If the causes of classical guitar’s marginalisation are substantially external, better advocacy, education, and outreach should eventually move the figures discussed in §7.1. If some causes are internal, external advocacy alone will not be sufficient, however well it is executed — and if the argument of §9 and §10 is right, the questions whose answers would matter most for settling that distinction are the ones a community of this kind is least structurally disposed to ask of itself. This paper has not asked those questions on the community’s behalf, nor answered them. It has established only that, within this discourse, they are very rarely asked at all — which is the precondition for everything that would need to follow.</p><p>More broadly, the present case is consistent with a limitation that several independent traditions suggest may extend beyond the classical guitar community. Communities need not lack intelligence, sincerity, or goodwill in order to develop systematic blind spots about themselves. Indeed, highly reflective communities may become especially adept at generating explanations within their inherited interpretive frameworks while remaining comparatively less equipped to question those frameworks themselves. If so, the principal issue disclosed by the Delcamp corpus is epistemological before it is psychological: not whether its members reason or mean well, but which questions the structure of communal reasoning renders readily thinkable — and which it renders comparatively difficult even to formulate.</p><h3>12. Methodological Reflections and Limitations</h3><h3>The Nature of the Evidence</h3><p>This paper does not claim to establish the causes of the classical guitar’s contemporary cultural position. Its evidence consists of publicly available discussions drawn from one of the longest-established online forums devoted to classical guitar. The object of analysis is therefore not the classical guitar itself but the discourse through which members of one online classical guitar community describe, explain, and interpret their own situation.</p><p>This distinction is essential. The paper makes claims about explanatory patterns within discourse, not about the objective truth of every explanation offered by participants. Consequently, the analysis should be understood as qualitative and interpretive rather than statistical or experimental.</p><h3><strong>The Corpus and Source Documentation</strong></h3><p>The corpus comprises publicly accessible discussion threads drawn from the Delcamp Classical Guitar Forum. Owing to the length of the discussions and the copyright status of forum posts, the corpus is not reproduced as an appendix. Instead, thread titles are identified on first mention and quotations are reproduced as they appear in the original discussions, including typographical and grammatical irregularities where these occur. Truncations are indicated by ellipses in square brackets. The analysis is therefore intended to be transparent without reproducing the source material in full.</p><p>The corpus is also temporally bounded. It analyses six discussions conducted during 2026 and therefore makes no claim that the explanatory patterns identified here characterise the forum’s discourse outside that period. The conclusions advanced in this paper are therefore confined to the corpus defined in §2.</p><h3>Public Discourse as Evidence</h3><p>One possible objection is that internet forum discussions do not necessarily represent the beliefs of the wider classical guitar community. This objection is reasonable but does not invalidate the present study. Public discourse is itself a relevant object of investigation. Communities express and negotiate identities through public conversation. Such conversations reveal recurring assumptions, preferred explanations, acceptable narratives, and the boundaries of legitimate disagreement. Whether every individual member privately shares every opinion expressed is less important than the explanatory patterns that repeatedly emerge within the discourse itself.</p><h3>Recurrence Rather Than Isolated Quotations</h3><p>No single quotation demonstrates the conclusions advanced here. The argument instead rests upon repetition. Across multiple discussions involving different participants, similar explanatory structures recur. The language changes. The examples differ. The underlying explanatory orientation remains consistent. The significance therefore lies not in individual statements but in their cumulative regularity.</p><h3>Interpretation and Psychological Inference</h3><p>The paper does not claim direct access to participants’ intentions, emotions, or internal mental states. It does not diagnose anxiety, denial, defensiveness, or cognitive dissonance in particular individuals. Instead, the analysis employs concepts developed within social psychology and sociology to illuminate recurring features of collective discourse. These concepts function as explanatory models rather than diagnoses. The claim is not that contributors consciously engaged in these processes; rather, the observed discourse exhibits features consistent with mechanisms extensively documented within the literature reviewed in §6.</p><h3>On Positionality and Chronology</h3><p>A final methodological matter concerns the relationship between the author of this paper and the discourse under analysis, and requires disclosure rather than the pretence of an external vantage point the present author does not occupy.</p><p>Several of the discussions examined in this corpus occurred within weeks or months of the publication of public criticisms directed at prevailing institutional and historiographical assumptions within the classical guitar community — criticisms authored by the present writer. None of the six threads analysed here concerns the present writer or his published work; the proximity noted is chronological, not topical. This temporal proximity is registered here as relevant context, not as a causal claim. The paper does not infer, and the available evidence could not support, that the present writer’s own publications materially influenced the discursive patterns documented above; the asymmetry this paper identifies is established independently, through the corpus’s own recurring structure, and would stand or fall on that evidence regardless of its timing relative to any other publication.</p><p>The disclosure is nonetheless necessary. The present writer occupies a dual position with respect to this material: as the analyst of a community’s discourse, and as the author of criticism that forms part of that community’s recent discursive environment. Such dual positions are well recognised in the sociology of knowledge and in discourse-analytic and ethnographic research conducted by scholars embedded within, or otherwise implicated in, the communities they study; Bourdieu’s own insistence on a reflexive sociology — one that subjects the sociologist’s own position to the same analytic scrutiny applied to the object of study — is the relevant methodological precedent (Bourdieu &amp; Wacquant, 1992). The appropriate methodological response is therefore disclosure, and the caution exercised throughout this paper — the strict separation of observation, interpretation, and hypothesis maintained in §3 — rather than a claim to neutrality the present writer’s actual position does not support.</p><h3>Alternative Explanations and Scope of the Conclusions</h3><p>The present interpretation is not the only possible reading of the corpus. It is possible that external cultural forces are substantially responsible for the classical guitar’s marginality. It is possible that internal causes have already been examined elsewhere outside the present corpus. It is possible that forum discussions naturally encourage practical rather than self-critical conversation. None of these possibilities is excluded by the present analysis. The paper therefore does not argue that internal explanations are necessarily superior; it argues only that they appear comparatively underrepresented within the discourse examined.</p><p>This study does not demonstrate that the classical guitar community is uniquely resistant to self-examination. Comparable tendencies have been documented across scientific disciplines, political movements, religious traditions, professions, artistic communities, and organisations generally, as the literature reviewed in §6 illustrates. Nor does the paper imply that the classical guitar community lacks thoughtful individuals or serious intellectual engagement. The present analysis concerns the structure of collective explanation rather than the intelligence or sincerity of individual participants.</p><h3>Reflexivity</h3><p>Finally, the present paper is itself subject to the distinction between first-order and second-order inquiry developed above. However self-conscious its method, it cannot assume that it has fully escaped the interpretive conditions under which it was written. If the argument advanced throughout this paper is sound, then its own governing assumptions will almost certainly be easier to identify retrospectively than contemporaneously. The argument offered here should therefore be understood as a hypothesis inviting further examination rather than as a definitive explanation. Its principal contribution lies not in closing debate but in widening it.</p><h3>Bibliography</h3><p>Abbate, C. (2004). Music — Drastic or Gnostic? <em>Critical Inquiry</em>, 30(3), 505–536.</p><p>Argyris, C. (1990). <em>Overcoming Organizational Defenses: Facilitating Organizational Learning.</em> Boston, MA: Allyn and Bacon.</p><p>Argyris, C., &amp; Schön, D. A. (1978). <em>Organizational Learning: A Theory of Action Perspective</em>. Reading, MA: Addison-Wesley.</p><p>Bourdieu, P. (1977). <em>Outline of a Theory of Practice</em> (R. Nice, Trans.). Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.</p><p>Bourdieu, P. (1984). <em>Distinction: A Social Critique of the Judgement of Taste</em> (R. Nice, Trans.). Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.</p><p>Bourdieu, P., &amp; Wacquant, L. (1992). <em>An Invitation to Reflexive Sociology</em>. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.</p><p>DiMaggio, P. J., &amp; Powell, W. W. (1983). The iron cage revisited: Institutional isomorphism and collective rationality in organizational fields. <em>American Sociological Review</em>, 48(2), 147–160.</p><p>Festinger, L. (1957). <em>A Theory of Cognitive Dissonance</em>. Stanford: Stanford University Press.</p><p>Festinger, L., Riecken, H. W., &amp; Schachter, S. (1956). <em>When Prophecy Fails</em>. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.</p><p>Girard, R. (1977). <em>Violence and the Sacred</em> (P. Gregory, Trans.). Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press. (Original work published 1972)</p><p>Girard, R. (1986). <em>The Scapegoat</em> (Y. Freccero, Trans.). Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press. (Original work published 1982)</p><p>Janis, I. L. (1972). <em>Victims of Groupthink: A Psychological Study of Foreign-Policy Decisions and Fiascoes</em>. Boston: Houghton Mifflin.</p><p>Jankélévitch, V. (2003). <em>Music and the Ineffable</em> (C. Abbate, Trans.). Princeton: Princeton University Press. (Original work published 1961)</p><p>Jost, J. T., &amp; Banaji, M. R. (1994). The role of stereotyping in system-justification and the production of false consciousness. <em>British Journal of Social Psychology</em>, 33(1), 1–27.</p><p>Jost, J. T., Pelham, B. W., Sheldon, O., &amp; Sullivan, B. N. (2003). Social inequality and the reduction of ideological dissonance on behalf of the system: Evidence of enhanced system justification among the disadvantaged. <em>European Journal of Social Psychology</em>, 33(1), 13–36.</p><p>Kahan, D. M., Peters, E., Dawson, E., &amp; Slovic, P. (2017). Motivated numeracy and enlightened self-government. <em>Behavioural Public Policy</em>, 1(1), 54–86.</p><p>Kuhn, T. S. (1970). <em>The Structure of Scientific Revolutions</em> (2nd ed.). Chicago: University of Chicago Press.</p><p>Kunda, Z. (1990). The case for motivated reasoning. <em>Psychological Bulletin</em>, 108(3), 480–498.</p><p>Lakatos, I. (1978). <em>The Methodology of Scientific Research Programmes</em>. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.</p><p>Levinas, E. (1969). <em>Totality and Infinity: An Essay on Exteriority</em> (A. Lingis, Trans.). Pittsburgh: Duquesne University Press. (Original work published 1961)</p><p>Miller, D. T., &amp; Ross, M. (1975). Self-serving biases in the attribution of causality: Fact or fiction? <em>Psychological Bulletin</em>, 82(2), 213–225.</p><p>Popper, K. (1963). <em>Conjectures and Refutations: The Growth of Scientific Knowledge</em>. London: Routledge.</p><p>Tajfel, H., &amp; Turner, J. C. (1979). An integrative theory of intergroup conflict. In W. G. Austin &amp; S. Worchel (Eds.), <em>The Social Psychology of Intergroup Relations</em>. Monterey, CA: Brooks/Cole.</p><p>Taylor, D. M., &amp; Doria, J. R. (1981). Self-serving and group-serving bias in attribution. <em>Journal of Social Psychology</em>, 113(2), 201–211.</p><h3>Corpus Sources</h3><p>The six Delcamp Classical Guitar Forum discussions constituting the primary corpus are listed separately because they serve as the study’s primary evidence rather than as secondary scholarly sources.</p><p>Delcamp Classical Guitar Forum. (2026). <em>Close to depression</em>. Retrieved 1 July 2026. <a href="https://www.classicalguitardelcamp.com/viewtopic.php?t=164908">https://www.classicalguitardelcamp.com/viewtopic.php?t=164908</a></p><p>Delcamp Classical Guitar Forum. (2026). <em>An experiment, a small rant.</em> Retrieved 1 July 2026. <a href="https://www.classicalguitardelcamp.com/viewtopic.php?t=164350">https://www.classicalguitardelcamp.com/viewtopic.php?t=164350</a></p><p>Delcamp Classical Guitar Forum. (2026). <em>The Future of Classical Guitar Concerts</em>. Retrieved 1 July 2026. <a href="https://www.classicalguitardelcamp.com/viewtopic.php?t=164515">https://www.classicalguitardelcamp.com/viewtopic.php?t=164515</a></p><p>Delcamp Classical Guitar Forum. (2026). <em>Praise Well-Earned</em>. Retrieved 1 July 2026. <a href="https://www.classicalguitardelcamp.com/viewtopic.php?t=164933">https://www.classicalguitardelcamp.com/viewtopic.php?t=164933</a></p><p>Delcamp Classical Guitar Forum. (2026). <em>So why is traffic at Delcamp in decline?</em> Retrieved 1 July 2026. <a href="https://www.classicalguitardelcamp.com/viewtopic.php?t=164049">https://www.classicalguitardelcamp.com/viewtopic.php?t=164049</a></p><p>Delcamp Classical Guitar Forum. (2026). <em>Winning the GFA While Working In A Cafe</em>. Retrieved 1 July 2026. <a href="https://www.classicalguitardelcamp.com/viewtopic.php?t=164240">https://www.classicalguitardelcamp.com/viewtopic.php?t=164240</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=b11f43897272" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Peel Truth: “Thank Heavens No One Entrusted Mr. Peel with a Critic’s Job”]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@10string/douglas-peel-1a42846d235e?source=rss-8026079d565e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/1a42846d235e</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[music-criticism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[classical-guitar]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[narciso-yepes]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[music-history]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[andres-segovia]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Viktor van Niekerk]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 08 Jul 2026 08:12:33 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-07-08T08:12:33.231Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>How a Portsmouth guitar teacher called Narciso Yepes “the greatest guitarist of all time,” was told by Britain’s most malignant guitar critic that he was unfit to hold “a critic’s job,” and then disappeared.</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*UJT5Q0r-ayhZ4FZErw_jXg.png" /><figcaption>Douglas Peel — Portsmouth guitar teacher and B.M.G. feature writer. Detail from a photograph, May 1982 (Vicente Gómez Collection, California State University Northridge, IGRA.VGC, Box 7, Folder 66).</figcaption></figure><p>This article belongs to a series documenting how the Anglophone classical guitar press represented Narciso Yepes across half a century. The previous instalments examined men whose institutional careers flourished amid a documented and sustained misrepresentation of Narciso Yepes: John W. Duarte, who conducted four decades of attack from a position of critical authority the documentary record suggests he was not qualified to occupy; Graham Wade, who assessed Yepes objectively in 1974 and then spent the next forty years writing him out of the record he himself had once helped to set straight. Douglas Peel’s case does not fit that pattern, and it should not be forced into it. Duarte and Wade distorted Yepes’s reception and were institutionally rewarded. Peel documented what he actually heard, and vanished.</p><p>We know almost nothing about Douglas Peel beyond what he wrote. No obituary has surfaced. No second career. No portrait beyond a photograph from the Vicente Gómez Collection at California State University and the one he occasionally drew of himself in his own letters: a guitar teacher in Portsmouth, “just about six feet” tall and “fourteen stone ten pounds,” with hands he himself admitted could “hardly be described as ‘artistic.’” He took his first guitar lessons in the early 1930s. He had, by his own account, “knocked around the world a bit” — twenty-four countries — and belonged for many years to the Hispanic Society in London. He wrote to and for <em>B.M.G.</em> magazine, on and off, from at least 1956 until January 1976, on subjects ranging from Paganini to the manufacture of guitar string wire to the gypsy roads of Andalusia. He described himself, with evident sincerity rather than false modesty, as “a feature-writer, and not a musical critic — a big difference.”</p><p>That distinction mattered to him, and it was eventually thrown back at him as an insult. In December 1970, John W. Duarte — by then the dominant critical voice in British guitar journalism, intimate, by his own repeated account, with Andrés Segovia and “most of the world’s top players” — used the pages of <em>B.M.G.</em> to tell its readers, by name, that Douglas Peel displayed “such a degree of ignorance and/or bias” that there was no point engaging him, and that “Thank heavens no one has yet entrusted Mr. Peel with a critic’s job” (<em>B.M.G.</em>, December 1970, p. 104). Among the documented attacks on Yepes and his defenders this series has assembled, it is one of the most personal and most directly humiliating: not a coded slight buried in vocabulary, of the kind this series has spent other articles decoding in print, but a critic with institutional standing publicly telling a provincial guitar teacher that his observations did not merit a hearing.</p><p>What had Peel actually said to provoke it? He had called Narciso Yepes “the greatest guitarist of all time” and “the most outstanding guitar virtuoso of them all,” with the most projecting, most “sublime” tone production. He had said it more than once, years apart, in language that did not hedge.</p><p><strong>The Habit, Already in Place</strong></p><p>Peel’s instinct did not begin with Yepes. As early as February 1956, in a <em>B.M.G.</em> letter arguing against the overvaluation of sight-reading, Peel articulated a critical principle he never abandoned: the ear, not credentials or orthodox measures of accomplishment, is the final court of appeal. “The Spaniards have a saying relating to the guitar,” he wrote: “<em>seis cuerdas y un corazon </em>— six strings and a heart. To them the guitar is not a piece of machinery. It is a living thing. It is a medium between the player and the ears of the listeners. No matter how good the architect if the workman does not carry out the work properly!” He went on: “Throughout the world today there are hundreds or thousands of certificates hanging on walls — but where are the Giglis, the Segovias, the Paganinis? Need I say more?” (<em>B.M.G.</em>, February 1956, p. 137). Notice who appears in that sentence, and how. Fourteen years before Duarte turned on him, Andrés Segovia is Peel’s own benchmark of guitaristic greatness, named in the same breath as Niccolò Paganini and the tenor Beniamino Gigli, with no irony and no qualification. Whatever happened later, it did not begin as hostility to Segovia.</p><p>What it did begin as — and this is worth establishing on its own terms, because it is a separate thing from the Yepes question and predates it by years — was an objection to Segovia being deployed as an automatic yardstick against which every other artist had to be measured and found wanting (<em>à la</em> Duarte). In September 1968, defending the flamenco guitarist Manitas de Plata against a reader’s dismissal of him as a “gimmick,” Peel wrote: “George Barnes, like so many others, brings in the magic of Segovia. But why? We were discussing another artist… Of course, we all admire Segovia. I have never missed a performance of his that was within reasonable travelling time. But if Manitas de Plata has never had the opportunities of a traditional training and colourful and extensive repertoires, why make such pointless comparison?” (<em>B.M.G.</em>, September 1968, p. 399). Admiration for Segovia and irritation at Segovia-as-trump-card are, in Peel’s own prose, two entirely separate things, held without contradiction, two years before Yepes became the tacit issue between him and Duarte.</p><p>The same instinct, sharpened into something closer to contempt, appears in May 1969: “The snob, the pretentious pedant, in any field of activity is to be pitied, being so totally uninspired and intellectually impoverished. They are the ‘spivs’ and ‘layabouts’ of the cultural world.” Peel adds, in the same letter: “Any so-called limitations the guitar was supposed to have, have been overcome by Narciso Yepes with his new ‘Laudarra’ [<em>a name some attached to the ten-string guitar; it never caught on, and Yepes didn’t use it himself</em>]. As far as I know, the snobs haven’t got around to that yet” (<em>B.M.G.</em>, May 1969, pp. 280–281).</p><p><strong>What He Heard</strong></p><p>Across the 1960s and ’70s, Peel returned to a single, specific, falsifiable claim about Yepes’s sound, in terms no one could honestly call vague.</p><p>“I well remember Yepes at the Wigmore Hall,” he wrote in May 1975, recalling the guitarist’s London recital of 1961, when Yepes still played a six-string instrument,</p><blockquote>“and even then he was the most powerful guitarist I had (and still have) heard. I was right at the back and side of the hall, and might as well have been much closer, everything came across beautifully” (<em>B.M.G.</em>, May 1975, p. 28).</blockquote><p>Three years earlier, in his account of the Portsmouth Festival of 1972, he had written of the same player, by then performing on the ten-string instrument he had developed himself:</p><blockquote>“From the first notes struck by the artist, one is instantly made aware of the improvement and advantages gained with increased volume of sound, and enhanced resonances. For the writer, personally, the sounds previously produced by Yepes from his six-stringed guitar were sublime, yet somehow he has attained new heights of perfection” (<em>B.M.G.</em>, July 1972, p. 341).</blockquote><p>Read these passages in the order Peel himself experienced the events. After hearing Yepes at the Wigmore Hall in November 1961, Peel formed the opinion that here was “the most outstanding guitar virtuoso of them all” — a judgement he repeated in retrospect in 1972 while recalling the same concert (<em>B.M.G.</em>, July 1972, p. 340). The six-string sound is established, independently, years before the ten-string existed, as “sublime” and as “the most powerful” he had ever heard. The subsequent ten-string gain is described, explicitly, as an addition to that baseline, not an explanation of it. No honest reading of this testimony is available in which the instrument did the work; Peel’s testimony will not permit it. What he is describing, twice, in different years, from different seats in different halls, is a player’s mastery of touch — the only place that sound can come from, on any guitar, six strings or ten. A guitar can only reflect what a hand already knows how to do; it cannot manufacture what isn’t there. Peel, a guitar teacher rather than a concert virtuoso, and one with no professional investment in defending either Yepes or an established orthodoxy, simply reported what his ears told him in 1961 and again in 1972 — and what his ears told him was the same thing both times: this was the most powerful sound he had heard from the guitar, full stop, regardless of how many strings were strung across it.</p><p>He went further still. Calling Yepes, in November 1970, “the greatest guitarist of all time,” Peel then reached immediately for a description of inspired expressive depth, not technical display, quoting the French critic Ghislaine Juramie’s verdict on Yepes: “it is as though each string were a heart on which he played” (<em>B.M.G.</em>, November 1970, p. 63). Peel deploys that line in a letter explicitly directed at Duarte, in defence of the innate “gift” of “true talent” over acquired skills. Read alongside Duarte’s earlier criticisms of Yepes, it also becomes an implicit critique of the established caricature of Yepes as a cold technician — the “academic rather than sentient” meme this series has already traced to Duarte’s own pen.</p><p>In these accounts, Peel is describing neither spectral brightness nor sheer volume nor mere technical facility. He is describing precisely those qualities that Duarte’s circle had been denying Yepes possessed — in tone and expression — since 1955.</p><p>The same pattern appears again five years later. Recalling the 1961 Wigmore Hall recital, Peel writes that “it was the same” when he heard Yepes perform Rodrigo’s <em>Concierto de Aranjuez</em> with the London Symphony Orchestra in January 1975: “everything came across beautifully” (<em>B.M.G.</em>, May 1975, p. 28). Having heard Yepes project effortlessly within a symphony orchestra — without amplification — he adds a line easy to read past and worth pausing on: “anyone having the rare benefit of tuition from this great artist is lucky indeed.” The remark carries at least one obvious implication. Where else could a classical guitarist learn to project? Not merely a great performer, in Peel’s account, but a teacher whose instruction is itself a stroke of fortune — the considered judgement of a working guitar teacher, offered without any apparent concern that it contradicted almost everything else being printed about Yepes in British guitar journalism at the time.</p><p><strong>The Lie He Was Testifying Against</strong></p><p>This testimony matters for reasons beyond Peel’s biography, because it falls directly across one of classical guitar’s most durable and least examined articles of faith: that a bright tone is what allows a guitar to project — and that Segovia, who allegedly brought the guitar to the concert hall for the first time and whose sound several independent witnesses and spectrographic analysis alike describe as comparatively bright, lightweight, dynamically miniaturised, and often <em>staccato</em>-articulated, therefore represented the technically superior school, against which Yepes’s darker, more intense, more dynamically expressive, more sustained sound was by definition inferior.</p><p>It is not true, and it was never true. Guitar projection in a concert hall (with or without orchestra) is the product of four inter-related factors: spectral character (energy concentrated in the fundamental and first few partials — what acousticians describe as a “dark” sound); sustain (longer note envelopes that the room can build upon and amplify, since the ear integrates acoustic energy over time and rewards continuity over brief spikes); an undamped soundboard; and aim (whether the guitar’s geometry directs its sound towards the audience rather than upwards and to the right). Brightness — the quality the orthodox approach maximises — lives predominantly above 3 kHz. Such high-frequency content travels in a narrow forward cone relative to the soundboard, dissipates rapidly with distance and air absorption, and is easily masked by the orchestra’s sheen in precisely the spectral region it occupies. It impresses at close range and on microphones. It does not fill a hall.</p><p>The orthodox recipe — high neck angle (soundboard aimed up and to the right), forearm resting against the soundboard near the lower bout, perpendicular nail attack, <em>staccato</em> (“planted”) articulation — damages all four factors simultaneously. A perpendicular nail attack is velocity-biased excitation: short contact, a large high-frequency transient, and a fast decay. The forearm on the lower bout damps the soundboard. The high neck angle plus bright timbre combination directs the guitar’s sound upwards and to the right, away from most of the audience. And <em>staccato</em> articulation is perceived as softer than more <em>legato</em> sound of objectively equal loudness. Yepes’s approach inverts all four: an oblique flesh-and-nail release displaces rather than snaps the string, pumping energy into the fundamental and low partials and lengthening the decay; the soundboard goes undamped; a lower neck angle directs the soundboard towards the audience; and a sustained, <em>legato</em> line works with, not against, a well-established psychoacoustic phenomenon. The result is a larger sound at the back of a large hall — on any guitar.</p><p>That Segovia did not in fact solve this problem — that the claim to have brought the guitar into the concert hall is more complicated than the legend suggests — is not hard to establish from the contemporary critical record, though it has rarely been assembled in one place. Robert C. Marsh, reviewing Segovia’s fiftieth Chicago recital at Orchestra Hall in 1982, was categorical:</p><blockquote>“the instrument had a small tone. Segovia has always worked with the lowest number of decibels of any recitalist in Orchestra Hall, but this time some passages were so quiet that they did not project well enough to be fully appreciated… Sunday it was not just a matter of concentrating — you always do that when Segovia is playing — it was straining to hear” (<em>Chicago Sun-Times</em>, 15 March 1982).</blockquote><p>At the same venue five years later, Marsh again: the concert “was incredibly quiet — like concentrating on a wisp of smoke” (23 March 1987). Peter Stadlen, in <em>The Daily Telegraph</em>, reported that at a Royal Festival Hall recital in 1973 Segovia “tunes inaudibly and all but invisibly. When he does seem to be tuning, the piece has in fact started and it is up to us to adjust to a small tone.” <em>The Pittsburgh Press</em> reported an even more concrete consequence. Reviewing Segovia’s recital in 1983, Carl Apone wrote:</p><blockquote>“Ushers said some members of the audience left early in the program because they could not hear… The last time I heard (?) him was at the Syria Mosque in concert with the Pittsburgh Symphony, and without amplification, the guitar sound did not come through there either. What good is a soloist if he cannot be heard properly?” (24 March 1983).</blockquote><p>J. Kenneth Townsend, in <em>The Washington Post</em> in 1985, found that “Segovia played all the works softly, sometimes imperceptibly, in the cavernous Concert Hall. At times Segovia’s celebrated technical skills were severely tested, and the recital’s pace was soporific.” Tim Smith, also in <em>The</em> <em>Washington Post</em>, observed in 1981 that the concert hall’s size “severely limiting the aural appreciation of the music” was the operative condition of a Segovia recital. Segovia himself, interviewed for the same newspaper in 1980, described the guitar’s sound in terms he had “used many times”: “not voluminous, but luminous” (not broad, but bright) — an explicit acknowledgement that neither dynamics nor projection was the defining characteristic of either his expressive or tonal ideal. And Louise Sweeney, also in 1980, reported in <em>The Christian Science Monitor</em>: “A hush is what Segovia loves… a capacity audience sat as quietly as if listening to a whisper…”</p><p>One further piece of evidence from this record stops well short of the Yepes era and lands closer to its origin. Harold Meadmore, reviewing Segovia in <em>Gramophone</em> in December 1928, described a tone in which “at one time it is the sharp, <em>staccato</em> tones of the <em>clavecin</em> that one hears, at another the quality of the harp intrudes” (p. 337). The <em>clavecin </em>— the harpsichord. This is the identical accusation that John Duarte and his circle would spend decades directing at Narciso Yepes: a “clipped,” “thin,” harpsichord-like tone, presented as if it were Yepes’s particular inadequacy. A British critic had heard exactly that quality in parts of Segovia’s own playing (upon which a more harp-like tone occasionally “intrudes”) twenty-seven years before Yepes’s London debut and put it in print as plain description, apparently intended as part of a positive characterisation of Segovia’s timbral range. The myth was not merely wrong. It was precisely inverted. The “harpsichord tone” charge that Duarte would later level at Yepes better described aspects of Segovia’s documented sound — and had been so described by a contemporary witness before the campaign against Yepes had even begun.</p><p>By way of contrast, when Thor Eckert Jr., <em>The Christian Science Monitor</em>’s music critic, heard Yepes at Carnegie Hall in 1982, he reported without qualification:</p><blockquote>“Guitar concerts in Carnegie Hall can be a frustrating affair. Narciso Yepes brought his 10-string invention there last Thursday, and suddenly it was not a problem hearing that instrument in that space. His guitar fills the hall with sound<em>…</em> One left his recital stimulated and elated, with nary a thought as to the potential limitations of the instrument, dynamically or musically.”</blockquote><p>Michael Saffle (an organist and musicologist), reviewing a Stanford University recital in 1973, noted that Yepes’s sound “carried beautifully” despite Dinkelspiel Auditorium’s “notoriously weak acoustics.” Guitarists in the audience left “playfully threatening to throw their own instruments away” (<em>The Stanford Daily</em>, 6 November 1973, p. 6). Neither professional critic had any stake in any guitar-world quarrel, and neither was answering Duarte’s contradictory accusations. They were independently confirming, a decade and a continent apart, the identical observation a Portsmouth guitar teacher had already been noting from the back of English concert halls since 1961: this guitar, <em>this player</em>, projects.</p><p>Closer to home, the true acoustic character of Yepes’s approach was documented at first hand at the very Wigmore Hall recital Peel attended. Ivor Mairants recorded what happened when Yepes demonstrated his technique directly: the chord sound was “much thicker and stronger; less ‘edge’ and more body,” and when playing a chord at full volume, Yepes explained, it could be done “without any snap” — after which Mairants reported that “the chord certainly sounded more firm, had more breadth and strength, than when played the other [orthodox] way” (<em>B.M.G.</em>, April 1961, p. 206). The vocabulary is plain English, not acoustic physics — but the correspondence is exact: less spectral “edge” is less high-frequency content; “more body” is more low-mid energy (i.e., a darker tone); “without any snap” describes displacement-biased rather than velocity-biased (“plucked”) excitation; and firmer, broader, stronger is precisely what that approach produces. Mairants was not a Yepes partisan; his expertise was jazz, and he was reporting what he heard when two approaches were demonstrated side by side. Thirteen years later, and from a pen that would shortly be turned against Yepes, Graham Wade confirmed the same finding in a far larger space: writing about two sold-out April recitals at the Queen Elizabeth Hall — a venue then seating between 900 and 1,100 — Wade reported that “the art of Yepes filled the large hall with deep, unexpected resonances” (<em>B.M.G.</em>, May 1974, p. 10). That sentence was written by the same critic who, six years later, would repackage Yepes’s concert success as mere “box-office attraction.” Before ideology overtook observation, even some of Yepes’s eventual detractors confirmed the same finding.</p><p>Peel’s testimony — that Narciso Yepes “was the most powerful guitarist I had (and still have) heard” — is the missing witness in this argument, and it carries a weight that theory alone does not. He had no spectrograph, no acoustics training, and no friendship with the subject of his review either to defend or to invoke as claim to ‘authority’; he simply sat at the back of two different halls, listening to Yepes on a six-string and then on a ten-string instrument, and reported the same finding both times, in his own unguarded words: everything coming across beautifully even from one of the worst seats in the house. Duarte’s case against Yepes required readers never to check his “thin,” “clipped” verdicts against an actual witness sitting in an actual hall. Peel, without ever framing it as a rebuttal, was that witness, on the record, years before anyone thought to ask him to be.</p><p><strong>The Collision</strong></p><p>The exchange that produced Duarte’s verdict on Peel’s critical judgement began over a different player entirely. In November 1970, responding to Duarte’s recurring insistence that Segovia’s standing required no outside corroboration, Peel objected specifically to something Duarte had written about Regino Sainz de la Maza — the guitarist to whom Joaquín Rodrigo had dedicated the <em>Concierto de Aranjuez</em>. Duarte, Peel wrote, “has written some pretty scathing stuff about great artists in the past. For instance, he likened the right-hand technique of Regino Sainz de la Maza to ‘the slapping on of paint.’ Such criticism about an artist to whom Spain’s greatest contemporary composer… dedicated his finest work will do little to encourage any serious attention to John Duarte either as a musician, writer or composer” (<em>B.M.G.</em>, November 1970, p. 63). In the same letter, Peel dismantled “the often repeated myth of the supposed Segovia guitar tradition, forged by himself. He has done no such thing” — pointing out (whether rightly or wrongly) that Segovia inherited, rather than founded, a tradition that long predated him.</p><p>Duarte’s reply, the following month, did not engage a single one of these points. It engaged Peel, personally, with <em>ad hominems</em>. “Mr. Peel displays such a degree of ignorance and/or bias in relation to so many of the matters he raises that I lack the time and you the space to deal with them,” he wrote, before delivering the telling line: “Thank heavens no one has yet entrusted Mr. Peel with a critic’s job.” Duarte dismissed Peel’s appreciative register specifically as “the romantic type of review,” adding that this “stamps him as unregarding of the importance to the guitar of strict criticism” (<em>B.M.G.</em>, December 1970, p. 104).</p><p>That charge is worth pausing on, because Duarte did not hold it as a fixed principle — he held it only when it was useful. This series has already documented his December 1978 <em>Gramophone</em> review of Bream and Yepes’s recordings of Villa-Lobos repertoire, in which Duarte credits Julian Bream with carrying the listener “into its heart, and there we find the heart of Villa-Lobos, who loved both the guitar and music deeply” (<em>Gramophone</em>, December 1978, p. 1136) — precisely the vocabulary of feeling (“heart,” “love,” “charm,” and “affection”) that he mocks as “romantic” and beneath “strict criticism” when Peel reaches for it on Yepes’s behalf. Duarte was not, and never claimed to be, on the Romantic side of any genuine aesthetic divide; his own commitments, like Segovia’s, sat squarely within the neoclassical Modernist orthodoxy this series has traced elsewhere — impersonal execution, reproduction of institutionally-approved models, suspicion of audience emotion as a measure of anything. Neither “romantic” nor “objective” was ever a description of his own position. They were labels he reached for or withheld depending entirely on whose feeling he wanted to dignify and whose he wanted to dismiss.</p><p><strong>Closing Ranks</strong></p><p>The same December 1970 issue that carried Duarte’s verdict on Peel also carried a letter from John Edwards defending Duarte in terms that now read as a gloss on exactly the kind of ‘authority’ Duarte had just exercised. Edwards insisted, with pragmatic paradox, that Duarte’s “numerous arrangements, theoretical works and original compositions admirably speak for themselves and prove him to be probably the foremost authority on the classic guitar in this country,” an authority reinforced by “his intimate friendship with most of the world’s top players; and his knowledge of their views and techniques” (<em>B.M.G.</em>, December 1970, pp. 106–107). It is the same appeal to authority-through-proximity this series has already traced in Duarte’s own 1961 reply to the critic Oliver Walker — <em>ask Andrés Segovia for my credentials</em> — recurring nine years later, this time in another voice, in the very issue that humiliated Peel.</p><p>Edwards, moreover, was not simply a member of the magazine’s readership. By 1970 he had himself emerged from the Spanish Guitar Centre network, teaching at its Bristol branch after studying there, and the same issue that published his defence of Duarte also carried a highly favourable review of his Oxford recital (p. 104). No impropriety follows from those facts alone; Edwards may simply have been an able young guitarist whose views were sincerely held. But they do illustrate the small, interconnected world of British classical-guitar journalism, in which teachers, performers, reviewers and correspondents frequently occupied overlapping roles. Appeals to authority did not circulate in the abstract; they circulated within a remarkably tight professional network.</p><p>Graham Wade, too, appears in that same issue’s correspondence pages, on an unrelated point about a misattributed work, praising Duarte — an apparent coincidence of layout. But it places him, four years before his own celebratory 1974 review of Yepes and a decade before his reversal on Yepes within <em>Traditions of the Classical Guitar</em>, inside the same circulation, the same small circle, in the same month Duarte was telling its readers that a provincial guitar teacher had no standing to admire Narciso Yepes out loud. Vladimir Bobri’s 1961 letter to <em>B.M.G.</em>, congratulating Duarte on his “lucid and constructive criticism” of Yepes and praising its effect in “dispelling… unwarranted admirations,” shows the same mechanism operating nine years earlier, against a different correspondent. Whatever else separates these episodes, the pattern does not change: an outsider speaks up for Yepes, and the institutional response arrives, by name, with the full weight of the circle’s accumulated credibility-by-association and -numbers behind it.</p><p><strong>What Peel Got Wrong, and When</strong></p><p>It would be dishonest to present Peel as Duarte’s mirror image — a Yepes partisan who saw through Segovia as clearly as he saw through Duarte’s claims about Yepes’s tone and expression. He did not. Peel’s laudations of Segovia are not isolated slips, and they should not be minimised to preserve a tidier story.</p><p>In May 1974, the same month Graham Wade published his own celebratory, soon-to-be-betrayed review of Yepes’s Queen Elizabeth Hall recitals, Peel published a warm, admiring tribute to Segovia, describing him as “a living link” between Tárrega “and ourselves” (<em>B.M.G.</em>, May 1974, p. 24). When he returned to the subject two years later, he publicly withdrew the literal basis for that description after learning from Segovia himself that the two men had never met. Yet he explicitly reaffirmed what he regarded as its underlying truth: “Nothing can alter the undeniable fact that the traditions handed down by those famous names [i.e., the Tárrega lineage] have been carefully preserved, and enhanced by Segovia” (<em>B.M.G.</em>, January 1976, p. 126).</p><p>In January 1976 — the last dated <em>B.M.G.</em> pieces available to this account, and quite possibly the last things Peel ever published — he returned to Segovia in two separate contributions to the same issue: a concert review describing him as “one of this century’s greatest musicians” (p. 109), and a letter containing the line that appears most to contradict his verdict on Yepes: “Segovia is still the greatest guitarist in the world” (p. 125). These statements follow his November 1970 verdict that Narciso Yepes is “the greatest guitarist of all time” and sit chronologically on either side of one of his strongest and most specific Yepes superlatives — “the most complete all-round guitarist of our time,” written in May 1975 (p. 28). They cannot be arranged into a conversion narrative in either direction.</p><p>The “Segovia is still the greatest guitarist in the world” sentence deserves closer reading than its surface suggests. It arrives immediately after Peel asks what remains to be said that critics and reporters worldwide have not already said — a framing that positions what follows as summarised consensus rather than his own contribution. He specifies at once what he himself is actually adding: “He gave us a lesson in tone [colour] production that might well stand for all time… the listener can always discover something new in his playing; some fresh <em>nuance</em> of sound. It is as though Segovia has a bottomless ‘bag of tricks.’” The praise is for tonal variety specifically — not for the all-round completeness he had assigned to Yepes ten months earlier. These are not the same judgement. Peel appears to have regarded the two men as great for different reasons: Segovia for multitudinous tonal colour; Yepes for all-round completeness. The apparent contradiction largely dissolves once the distinction is made.</p><p>What remains entirely to Peel’s credit is the treatment of the factual claim in that same letter. He had gone backstage after the reviewed Chichester recital on 23 October 1975 and asked Segovia directly: “Did you ever meet Tárrega, as this has often been the subject of dispute?” Segovia replied: “No — because, before I was fourteen, Tárrega had died.” “I was wrong in that actual statement,” Peel wrote, “although not in its intended spirit.” Peel went to the source, got the answer, found out he was wrong, and published the retraction in print. This is, in the documentary record this series has assembled, a genuinely uncommon act. John W. Duarte, whose two reviews of the same Villa-Lobos recording (<em>Gramophone</em>, December 1978, p. 1136; <em>Gramophone</em>, April 1989, p. 1597) contradicted each other on multiple substantive points, to mention just one of his critical blunders, never acknowledged a critical error in print. Graham Wade — whose September 1991 <em>Classical Guitar</em> article, “Segovia and the Spanish Character,” deployed a strategic ellipsis to suppress evidence that made his myth-seeding argument impossible — has offered no retraction. Peel — a self-described “feature-writer, not a musical critic” — corrected himself publicly after going directly to the source.</p><p>As already noted, the “living link” claim itself does not survive contact with the evidence — and Peel, to his credit, was willing to say so. What he could not have known in 1974 was how comprehensively Segovian mythology had been constructed. Graham Wade’s 1980 account of Segovia’s early career states plainly that Segovia “found it necessary to stress that he never met Tárrega,” and goes on to document not continuity but rupture: Tárrega’s actual pupils, in Wade’s own telling, rejected Segovia’s technique outright — “worst of all… he plucks the strings with his nails,” one evidently remarked at his Ateneo debut — and withheld their approval at Valencia, a stronghold of Tárrega’s school, for the same reason. Daniel Fortea, a genuine pupil of Tárrega, allegedly refused Segovia access to his late teacher’s manuscripts. Wade’s own language for these men — men who had actually studied under the figure whose lineage Segovia is supposed to have inherited — is “small-minded enthusiasts” guilty of “conservative timidity” and “the bigotry of the Tárrega clan,” who kept Tárrega’s “religious zeal” in “monastic isolation” until Segovia broke them open (<em>Traditions of the Classical Guitar</em>, 1980, pp. 150–151). A succession narrative that requires its own chronicler to call the inheritor’s alleged forebears bigots for declining to recognise him is not documenting a living link. It is documenting a hostile takeover, with the hagiography supplied afterwards. Even Miguel Llobet — the single Tárrega pupil Segovia’s circle has always pointed to as legitimating contact (however brief and informal) — receives, in the same book, Segovia’s own private verdict: “rasping, metallic tones, lacking in roundness, volume and resilience” (1980, p. 151). That is the same vocabulary — thin, metallic, lacking body — that would be turned on Narciso Yepes a generation later. It did not originate with Duarte (writing under the pseudonym “Discus”) in 1955. It was already the new lineage’s standing complaint against anyone, including its own claimed inheritance, who did not sound like Segovia.</p><p>Peel absorbed <em>part</em> of that self-mythology (the narrative Segovia had been supplying interviewers for decades), checked one of his own contributions to it when challenged, and corrected himself in print. The broader record does not present a conversion narrative or a case of institutional capture. It presents something more interesting: a guitar journalist who separated historical claims from artistic judgements, corrected the former when the evidence required it, and held firm on the latter. His admiration for Segovia’s tonal variety and his verdict on Yepes as “the most complete all-round guitarist of our time” are not the same kind of statement. In Peel’s own prose, they never appear to have struck him as contradictions requiring a choice.</p><p><strong>After the Silence: The Gómez Correspondence (1988–’89)</strong></p><p>In February 1988, twelve years after <em>B.M.G.</em>’s last issue, Douglas Peel was still living on King’s Road, Southsea, Portsmouth — the same address from which he had written his <em>B.M.G.</em> letters — and had begun corresponding with Vicente Gómez, the Madrid-born flamenco guitarist whose career had been built largely in Hollywood. The Vicente Gómez Collection at California State University, Northridge (IGRA.VGC, Box 7, Folder 66), preserves five letters from Peel to Gómez, and two replies, dated February 1988 to April 1989. They are the only presently-known documents that extend Peel’s biographical record past <em>B.M.G.</em>’s collapse, and they resolve several things at once.</p><p>His views on Yepes had not shifted. In November 1988, discussing his “several” recordings of Rodrigo’s <em>Concierto de Aranjuez</em>, Peel names three explicitly: Sainz de la Maza, “for whom, you will know, it was written”; Angel Romero; and “my favourite one, Narciso Yepes.” The names absent from that list — Julian Bream, John Williams — are the names Duarte had spent decades promoting as the legitimate measure of guitaristic greatness. Williams appears in the Gómez correspondence once, in passing: “our own fine classical player, John Williams goes there to take part and give master classes on the classical side of guitar” — mentioned in the context of Paco Peña’s summer school in Córdoba. “Fine.” No elaboration, no superlative, no warmth comparable to what Peel reserves for Gómez, for Yepes, for Peña, for Sainz de la Maza, for the Romeros, for Segovia. Twelve years after <em>B.M.G</em>.’s liquidation silenced him, Peel’s personal hierarchy had not moved.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*R-LjCgxkpgssbTvBLqbktA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Douglas Peel to Vicente Gómez, 10 November 1988: “…my favourite one, Narciso Yepes.” Vicente Gómez Collection, California State University Northridge (IGRA.VGC, Box 7, Folder 66).</figcaption></figure><p>His ear for tone had not changed either, and these letters give it sharper expression than anything in the <em>B.M.G.</em> years. Writing to Gómez in May 1988, after hearing his <em>Rio Flamenco Suite</em>, Peel observes: “So many of the young players one hears on radio today have a kind of harpsichord tone — not at all like the real warmth of the true Spanish sound which we of my generation were able to hear you yourself play through the films you appeared in.” He is writing ostensibly about flamenco, and about Gómez. But the acoustic principle is identical to everything this series has documented about Yepes: a dark/warm, sustained, resonant sound — energy concentrated in the low-mid spectral range that carries across a hall — as against the bright, lightweight timbre, with <em>staccato</em> articulation, that had become orthodox in both classical and flamenco worlds. Peel did not have a spectrograph. He wasn’t informed by psychoacoustics. He had his ears, and what they told him in 1988 was the same thing they had told him at the back of Wigmore Hall in 1961, and from the back and side of the Portsmouth hall in 1972: that purity of tone, not brightness, is what reaches the ears and the hearts of an audience. That preference is striking for another reason. Segovia himself recalled in 1976 that, in his youth, the guitar had “repelled” him because it retained what he called its “melancholic timbre” (<em>A Fondo</em>, TVE). Peel’s ideal, by contrast, remained precisely the “Spanish” sound associated with an earlier generation of players.</p><p>The same May 1988 letter contains a sentence that belongs alongside the <em>B.M.G.</em> testimony on tone production: “Always your tone, especially has been a source of real inspiration to me, Maestro, something to strive to imitate.” A guitar teacher in his later years, still playing, still measuring himself against a standard of warmth and depth. The guitar orthodoxy’s “harpsichord tone” — spectrally bright, lightweight, immediately present but quickly dissipating — had registered as a falling-off, not a new standard of perfection.</p><p>The correspondence also reveals, for the first time, what happened to Peel’s teaching after <em>B.M.G.</em> He had apparently stopped around 1977 — one year after the magazine folded — and had not resumed. In March 1989, explaining why he was planning to start again, he wrote: “I recently had a visit from an old pupil of twelve years ago. He was 15 years old then — now he is 26. He convinced me to start up again.” The pupil’s name, given a few lines later, is one John Walsh. Peel planned to teach small groups of six. He was already giving “little lecture-recitals to enthusiasts here” in Portsmouth. He described teaching as “a very satisfying pastime.” Why he had stopped in 1977, the letters do not say. The timing — exactly coincident with the collapse of the only national platform that had ever published him — does not resolve the question.</p><p>The correspondence ends in April 1989. Peel’s last documented words on the guitar, written to a Hollywood flamenco <em>maestro</em> from his Southsea sitting room, concern Fernando Sor, played by Gómez “so beautifully,” and the hope of passing Gómez’s artistry to “a young ‘generation’ of new guitar enthusiasts.” His last sentence about his own playing: “They [Gómez’s tapes] will also be an inspiration to strive for perfection in my own playing. I am always glad that I have two beautiful real Spanish hand-made guitars.” One was a José Ramírez purchased in Madrid in 1964. The other, a flamenco instrument, was bought from the Granada luthier Eduardo Ferrer at his shop at Cuesta Gomerez 26 in May 1982, chosen in person, in Andalusia. Among the papers in the Gómez collection is a photograph of the two men — Peel and Ferrer — standing together in what appears to be the latter’s workshop. Peel has signed it: “To Vicente Gómez, Best Wishes Douglas Peel 1988.” It is the only image of him that has surfaced. He ends one of his letters (26 May 1988), as he began his <em>B.M.G.</em> career in 1956, with the same seven words: “LA GUITARRA — SEIS CUERDAS y UN CORAZON.”</p><p>Peel’s closing words resonate for another reason. In 1989, Narciso Yepes would write in <em>Ser instrumento</em>: “<em>…me serviré de la guitarra como instrumento vivo…</em>” (p. 11); that is to say, “…I shall make use of the guitar as a living instrument…” Peel had already contrasted the guitar as “a piece of machinery” with the guitar as “a living thing.” Independently of one another, both men rejected the conception of the guitar as mere mechanism, preferring to speak of it as something living. The convergence is striking. It also sits comfortably alongside Peel’s consistently sympathetic response to Yepes’s musicianship, even when much of the Anglophone guitar press remained antagonistic.</p><p><strong>The Vanishing of Douglas Peel</strong></p><p><em>B.M.G.</em> magazine’s publisher went into liquidation in 1976, ending a run that had begun in 1903. Whatever silenced Douglas Peel after January of that year, he was not alone in losing his only platform; the entire readership of provincial enthusiasts he had written for, and to, for two decades lost theirs as well. That much can be stated as established fact, and it is the simplest, least sinister explanation available.</p><p>The Gómez correspondence confirms that the vanishing was from published writing specifically — not from the guitar world altogether, not from listening. He kept playing. He kept his ears. He kept forming observations. What he lost was the only national outlet that had ever printed them, and he did not find another. <em>B.M.G.</em>’s unofficial successor publications — <em>Guitar</em> magazine/<em>Guitar International</em>, <em>Classical Guitar</em> — were not platforms from which Peel wrote. They were, by contrast, among the platforms on which Duarte continued to write until his death in 2004, and on which Wade wrote until <em>Classical Guitar</em>’s demise in 2019.</p><p>The Peel–Gómez letters do not explain the asymmetry that follows. John W. Duarte’s reviewing career did not end with <em>B.M.G.</em>; it had already expanded to <em>Gramophone</em> in the 1950s and would continue there, and in the pages of <em>Soundboard</em>, <em>Guitar Review, Classical Guitar</em> and other magazines, for another quarter-century. Graham Wade’s career, by contrast, was only beginning: <em>Traditions of the Classical Guitar</em> appeared in 1980, with Andrés Segovia’s personal commendation on its back cover, and <em>Classical Guitar</em> magazine would carry his byline for decades after that. Both men, having helped entrench a demonstrably false account of Narciso Yepes — one through sustained, documented bad faith, the other through a documented and traceable capture — continued to write the instrument’s history for British and international readers for the rest of the century. Douglas Peel never published another word after January 1976.</p><p>This need not be stated as a verdict, because it cannot honestly be proved as one. It can simply be left as the question it actually is: <em>How is it that the men whose published accounts repeatedly misrepresented Narciso Yepes went on writing, while the man whose independent testimony consistently pointed in the opposite direction — publicly, from the back of different concert halls, and privately still in 1988, when no one was checking — did not?</em> If John Walsh of Portsmouth, who was fifteen years old in 1977 and persuaded Douglas Peel to start teaching again in 1989, is still reachable, he may be the last person who knew Peel as a teacher. <a href="http://10string.enquiries@dontsp.am/">This account</a> would like to hear from him, or from anyone who has light to shed on the curious case of Douglas Peel.</p><p>Peel reached for the same kind of touchstone more than once across twenty years of <em>B.M.G.</em> correspondence. Writing in 1956 about the gap between institutional measures of accomplishment and musical genius, he had already asked: “where are the Giglis, the Segovias, the Paganinis?” In 1974, titling an otherwise unrelated piece on the history of recorded sound, he reached (as he did on multiple occasions) for Keats’s “Ode to a Nightingale” and the nightingale’s song, “heard in ancient days by emperor and clown.” Keats’s line works by yoking the two ends of the social order — the highest rank and the lowest — to make a single point: great art does not check anyone’s institutional standing before it moves them. Emperor and clown hear the same song. That is very close to what happened to Narciso Yepes: the norm of sold-out halls and five-encore ovations came from general audiences who owed the guitar world nothing, and the non-guitarist composers who wrote for him were professionals with nothing to gain from flattering an outsider. ‘Top’ and ‘bottom’ agreed without consulting each other. It was the layer in between — partisan guitar critics with rank to protect — that never came round, the same musical “lower middle class” Richard Taruskin once diagnosed in an entirely different performer’s case, in <em>The Danger of Music</em> (2008). Peel never read Taruskin. He just watched the identical thing happen in London and Portsmouth and called it by its right name years earlier: snobs, pedants, “the ‘spivs’ and ‘layabouts’ of the cultural world.” Peel never asked his readers to choose between Segovia and Yepes. The demand for exclusive allegiance belonged to others. He never once wrote as though greatness needed rationing between one man and another. It is the stranger irony of this whole series that the one English writer who refused to ration it is also the one whose own name turned out finite enough to vanish, while the rationers’ names did not.</p><p><em>This article is part of a series examining the institutional treatment of Narciso Yepes in the English-language classical guitar press. Companion articles — “</em><a href="https://medium.com/@10string/duarte-attacked-yepes-institutional-gatekeeping-fe4e052794de"><em>The Machinery of Suppression: How John W. Duarte Tried to Destroy Narciso Yepes</em></a><em>,” “</em><a href="https://medium.com/@10string/graham-wade-narciso-yepes-classical-guitar-beeb617907d6"><em>‘True Love and Understanding’: What Happened to Graham Wade?,</em></a><em>” and “</em><a href="https://medium.com/@10string/the-modernist-lie-41b716eb0eae"><em>Why Do They All Hate Yepes?</em></a><em>” (Parts I–IV) — are available on the author’s Medium “</em><a href="https://medium.com/@10string"><em>Home</em></a><em>” page.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=1a42846d235e" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[“True Love and Understanding”: What Happened to Graham Wade, Author of Traditions of the Classical…]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@10string/graham-wade-narciso-yepes-classical-guitar-beeb617907d6?source=rss-8026079d565e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/beeb617907d6</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[classical-guitar]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[classical-music]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[music-criticism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[music-history]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[guitar]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Viktor van Niekerk]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 16 Jun 2026 07:24:41 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-06-16T07:24:41.285Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>“True Love and Understanding”: What Happened to Graham Wade, <em>Author of</em> Traditions of the Classical Guitar (1980)?</h3><p><em>Documenting how a writer who called Narciso Yepes’s ten-string guitar “vindicated as an ideal medium for Bach” (1974) became its most insidious institutional detractor.</em></p><p>This article has a companion piece. “<a href="https://medium.com/@10string/duarte-attacked-yepes-institutional-gatekeeping-fe4e052794de">The Machinery of Suppression</a>” documented how <strong>John W. Duarte</strong>, writing in <em>B.M.G.</em> magazine from 1955 onwards and in <em>Gramophone</em> thereafter, systematically planted myths about Narciso Yepes that have persisted to this day. Duarte’s typical method was non-falsifiable: emotional characterisation, rhetorical bullying, and unfalsifiable generalisations deployed as blanket character assessments — portraying Yepes as either a <em>heartless scholar</em> (“academic rather than sentient,” “wooden and stilted”) or an <em>incorrigible eccentric</em> (“wayward”) — designed to resist accountability by functioning as permanent labels rather than verifiable observations grounded in the specificity of a performance of a particular piece of music. His two contradictory <em>Gramophone</em> reviews (1978 and 1989) of the same 1971 Villa-Lobos recordings became falsifiable only because they contradicted each other: the same fixed performances cannot simultaneously be “accurate” and “distorted.” That case required Duarte to review the same recording twice (first on vinyl, then on CD). His usual method was designed to avoid such exposure.</p><p><strong>Graham Wade</strong> presents a different, and in some ways more instructive, problem. He was not always against Yepes. In May 1974, writing in the same <em>B.M.G.</em> magazine, he produced one of the most perceptive reviews of a Yepes concert published in the English-language guitar press. Six years later, he published <em>Traditions of the Classical Guitar</em> (1980), with the personal endorsement of Andrés Segovia emblazoned on its blurb: “Graham Wade has shown his love to the guitar from the first page of this book to the last one, true love and understanding.”</p><p>Something had changed between 1974 and 1980. This article documents what.</p><h3>Before Segovia Got to Him</h3><p>Yepes played two sold-out recitals at the Queen Elizabeth Hall on the 22nd and 29th of April, 1974. The hall was filled to capacity on both occasions; on the second night the audience gave a standing ovation and called him back five times, applauding enthusiastically when the encores were announced, after the encores, and sometimes during them. Wade attended both nights. His account, published in <em>B.M.G.</em> that May, deserves to be read in full.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Doh8Gu-6pelnVzvUtJ0tJA.jpeg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*q9kcEEuscbNxfGsJn7pFSw.jpeg" /><figcaption>The review that vanishes without trace from Wade’s later career.</figcaption></figure><p><em>(The full May 1974 issue of B.M.G. is freely available as a PDF download [</em><a href="https://www.classic-banjo.com/index.php?article_id=11&amp;downloadpdf=197405"><em>here</em></a><em>]. Wade’s review of the two Yepes recitals appears on pp. 10–11.)</em></p><p>On the instrument that would later become the central target of establishment derision, the 1974 Wade was unambiguous: “the ten-string guitar was vindicated as an ideal medium for Bach — evoking the sweet tensions of the Baroque lute without sacrificing its guitar qualities.” He was aware of the instrument’s detractors — aware enough to address them directly: “Despite the fears of some critics that the guitar may proliferate strings like the lute (and thus begin the end), I can only say that <strong>the art of Yepes filled the large hall with deep, unexpected resonances</strong>, and modern music or Baroque can in the maestro’s hands be given <strong>a new dimension and a new understanding.</strong>” The ten-string was <em>vindicated</em>. Those who feared it were wrong.</p><p>On Yepes’s artistic independence — which would later be coded, systematically, as “exhibitionism” throughout <em>Traditions</em> [for a full analysis of how that coding operated, see “<a href="https://medium.com/@10string/machinery-of-orthodoxy-05080cf6c53d">Why Do They All Hate Yepes? Part II: The Machinery</a>”] — the 1974 Wade was equally explicit: “Yepes makes up his own mind and carries it through… He is not deflected from his quest by fashion, popular opinion, or even what is common practice among certain guitarists.” This quality, which the later Wade would need his readers to experience as a flaw, is in 1974 described as “admirably refreshing.”</p><p>On audience response — which would later be reframed, through what Wade himself called “[t]he Utopian idealism of the purists” (1980: 70), as mere susceptibility to crowd-pleasing — the 1974 Wade documented it with evident approval. “The sort of reception given only to the great players,” he wrote. On ranking: Yepes stood “at the top of the international ratings along with Segovia, Bream, Williams and Diaz.” Not below them. Alongside them.</p><p>The prose itself repays attention, for what it reveals about the quality of observation behind it. Wade notes that on the first night, playing Bach’s Lute Suite in E major (BWV 1006a) whilst latecomers flooded in through the doors, Yepes “nearly came unstuck technically in the Gavotte.” This is specific: a named movement, a concrete observation, an honest acknowledgment of a technical near-failure (and reason why) in the midst of an enthusiastic review. (It is categorically different in character from Duarte’s characteristic mode: blanket epithets such as “academic rather than sentient” — or the “waywardness” he first misapplied to Mudarra’s compositional features in 1961 and thereafter recycled as a <em>permanent</em> label for Yepes, still invoking it in 1978 as a “well known” trait even whilst conceding, of the same review’s recording, that “even his waywardness of tempo is absent.”) Of Turina’s Sonata op. 61, Wade observed that Yepes “demonstrated how this somewhat neglected Sonata need not be just an echo of <em>Fandanguillo</em>” — a precise critical insight about interpretive achievement, not a vague encomium. These passages do not read like performed appreciation. They read like a man describing what he actually heard.</p><p>The vocabulary of the review confirms the impression: “an overwhelming response from his public;” “musicianly, scholarly, brilliant and intensely memorable;” “not impeccably accurate;” “lived with an abundance of interpretative felicity;” “a subtle barricade of coughing and fidgeting;” “the kind of hushed quiet appropriate to the demands of Bach;” “a vital and spontaneous reality far removed from the usual dreary repetition of these suites;” “the Spanish virtuoso exploring the textures of the modern instrument;” “the maestro brought out a bright sheeny glitter in the music and identified wholly with its vigour;” “a few notes went astray at one point but the momentum of the attack was never lost and it was all somewhat breathtaking;” “Yepes coaxed every possible variety of sound from the Ramirez guitar;” “Yepes filled the large hall with deep, unexpected resonances;” “here [in the Studies of Villa-Lobos] Yepes was the supreme master, never putting a foot wrong, exploring the music imaginatively, musically and brilliantly;” “a rapturous, almost hysterical audience;” “the penetrating musicality of his mind invariably throws new light on what is there.” This is the language of genuine critical engagement.</p><p>One further piece of evidence from this period is telling in its particularity. In a July 1974 <em>B.M.G.</em> review of a Purcell Room debut by one Rose Andresier, Wade notes that a <em>Passepied</em> by Bacarisse — the technically demanding piece Yepes habitually played as an encore, one that few other guitarists attempted, given its specific technical requirements — “with which Yepes had set the Queen Elizabeth Hall alight a month ago was unfortunately lost beyond recall.” The spontaneous invocation of Yepes as benchmark for that particular piece, in a review of an entirely different artist, reflects how recently and vividly the April concerts had registered. It is not a generalised statement about Yepes’s standing; it is a specific comparison for a specific, technically demanding work that belonged, in the guitar world of 1974, to Yepes’s particular province.</p><h3>A Qualification Worth Noting</h3><p>A separate <em>B.M.G.</em> article — published that October 1974, distinct from the May review under discussion — introduces a note that matters for what follows. Writing about the top international guitarists, Wade asserts that Bream, Williams, Díaz, and Yepes “all owe much to Segovia in their own development along the path towards virtuosity and world fame and are the first to acknowledge the immensity of their debt to his work.”</p><p>This is demonstrably false in Yepes’s case. His only documented pedagogical interaction with Segovia was a 1960 Santiago de Compostela masterclass that promptly ended in expulsion — witnessed and documented by the composer Leonardo Balada — when Segovia objected to Yepes’s own transcription of Bach’s Chaconne, which had been prepared under the guidance of Nadia Boulanger and Georges Enescu. Yepes’s pedagogical lineage ran through pupils of Francisco Tárrega (Estanislao Marco and Joaquín García de la Rosa) and through the composer Vicente Asencio, as well as some of the most prestigious non-guitarist musicians of the century: Nadia Boulanger, Walter Gieseking, and Georges Enescu. He cannot meaningfully have been “the first to acknowledge” a debt to a man who almost instantly expelled him from a masterclass, telling him to go to his assistant, José Tomás, to learn the Chaconne the ‘proper’ (Segovian) way.</p><p>This error in October 1974 is not evidence that Wade had at that point been captured against Yepes. His May appreciation was genuine. But the structural assumption that Segovia was the origin point of all serious twentieth-century guitarists was already in place. He was a Segovian by framework before he became a Segovian by faction. That framework did not prevent him from evaluating Yepes honestly in May 1974. It did, however, create a mechanism that could later be activated against Yepes without requiring Wade to recognise his own bad faith. He was already living inside a story in which Segovia’s primacy was axiomatic. He had not yet been asked to enforce it.</p><h3>The Hinge: “True Love and Understanding”</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/516/1*DrKUFndX3u6MYsUdNi_bLA.png" /><figcaption>Hagiographer and subject. The blurb endorsement of <em>Traditions of the Classical Guitar</em> (1980) — ‘true love and understanding’ — did not arrive without structural implications.</figcaption></figure><p>Segovia’s endorsement of <em>Traditions of the Classical Guitar</em> deserves more analytical attention than it typically receives. “Graham Wade has shown his love to the guitar from the first page of this book to the last one, true love and understanding.” (Andrés Segovia) This is not a scholarly commendation. Segovia does not praise Wade’s primary sources, his archival rigour, his historical method, or his analytical precision. He praises his “love.”</p><p>In Segovia’s usage, that word carried a specific ideological weight. “Love” for the guitar was not predominantly an emotion but an <em>allegiance</em> — to the guitar as <em>Segovia</em> had defined it, to the tradition as <em>he</em> had shaped it, to the hierarchy in which <em>his</em> authority was foundational. “True love and understanding” implies, structurally, the existence of false love and misunderstanding. The falsely-loving, the misunderstanding — these categories (which Richard Taruskin called “invidious antonyms”) are unstated but structurally present. By 1980, the guitar world knew who occupied them.</p><p>The word “love” did not circulate in isolation. It was part of the shared currency of a circle — examined in more detail below — whose members sorted musicians and critics by allegiance rather than insight. Segovia’s endorsement of Wade as a man of “true love and understanding” operated simultaneously as reward and as signal: this man is inside; those who fall outside the book’s evaluative frame are, in the formulation Wade would deploy on page 189 of <em>Traditions</em>, “cast, artistically, into outer darkness.”</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/669/1*urrDSm3n98FsWSNH_L7QMw.jpeg" /><figcaption><em>Traditions of the Classical Guitar</em> by Graham Wade (John Calder, 1980). The book in which the authentic 1974 Graham Wade — who called the ten-string guitar ‘vindicated as an ideal medium for Bach’ — does not appear.</figcaption></figure><h3>The After: Four Documented Pivots</h3><p>The shift in diction between the 1974 review and <em>Traditions</em> (1980) is itself evidence of what changed. In <em>B.M.G.</em>, Wade wrote the clear, observationally grounded prose of a critic describing what he heard: he named movements where technical difficulties occurred, identified what specific interpretive choices revealed about individual pieces, and measured audience responses with journalistic precision. In <em>Traditions</em>, something fundamentally different has replaced this clarity. The prose in which Segovia is described is purple, pseudo-poetic, and ornamental — substituting accumulated metaphor for analytical observation. Of Segovia’s habit of opening recitals with Renaissance pieces played very softly — to accustom listeners to the limited projection of his bright, lightweight tone and miniaturised dynamic range — Wade wrote:</p><blockquote>The effect was indeed magical, like the primeval stirrings of the first bird-song, wafted to the ear as enchanted fragments from some distant island. … Segovia used these antique relics of golden civilisations most tellingly for his own purposes — that of enticing his audience into the web of sound, delicate but intense, which for him characterised the guitar. <em>(1980: 12)</em></blockquote><p>“Primeval stirrings of the first bird-song, wafted to the ear as enchanted fragments from some distant island” is not criticism. It is incantation: purple prose engineered to produce an emotional state rather than to account for what was actually heard.</p><p>This register was not original to Wade. Segovia himself cultivated a manner of speaking that managed to sound so-called “poetic” without saying anything either deep or substantive. In Christopher Nupen’s hagiographic <em>Andrés Segovia: The Song of the Guitar </em>(1977), before playing the piece Albéniz titled simply “Preludio” — invariably rechristened not “Asturias” but “Leyenda” within the Segovian tradition, an act of renaming that is itself characteristic — Segovia narrates his own artistic biography with the declaration: “the rest was the mysterious stars of my firmament.” This diction is the template for “enchanted fragments from some distant island.” Both locate their subject in a vague cosmic grandeur immune to analytical scrutiny; both substitute ornamental imagery for any specific account of what was actually thought, played, or heard. Wade’s purple prose in <em>Traditions</em> was not an authentic idiosyncrasy. It was the Segovian rhetorical register adopted alongside the Segovian ideological one — the same shared vocabulary that, as documented below, extended to the word “love” itself.</p><p>Notably, <em>Traditions</em>’ explicit ideological framework — blessed by Segovia as “true … understanding” — still positioned the elderly Spaniard as an “Apollonian” neoclassicist (i.e., an Early Modernist) of impersonal restraint — yet this pseudo-poetic register was simultaneously <em>romanticising</em> him through accumulated imagery, laying emotional groundwork for the explicit “Spanish Romantic” label that Wade’s 1991 laundering operation would posthumously affix through underhanded argument. It is significant that Yepes, in the same book, receives neither the analytical precision of Wade’s 1974 review nor the romanticising aura lavished on the preceding pages: only the distancing and coding of the four pivots documented below.</p><p><em>Traditions of the Classical Guitar</em> devotes approximately eighty-three pages to Segovia and fewer than four to Yepes — whose own entry first appears at page 200, fewer than twenty pages from the book’s close. The disproportion is itself evidence, but it is the specific texture of those pages that documents the transformation most precisely. Four pivots are verifiable from the text itself, each turning on a formulation from the 1974 review.</p><p><strong>1) The ten-string instrument.</strong> The 1974 Wade called it “vindicated as an ideal medium for Bach.” The 1980 Wade describes it as “this hybrid guitar” — a term carrying connotations of impurity, of being caught between two identities, of belonging nowhere fully. “The adoption of this instrument has offended the purists” — the so-called purists, whose claim to “purity” rested on treating conformity to the Segovian ideal as a standard of musical authenticity. In 1974, Wade had explicitly counter-argued against these critics: “Despite the fears of some critics… I can only say that the art of Yepes filled the large hall with deep, unexpected resonances.” By 1980, their offence is stated as a fact about the instrument, their position left standing without challenge.</p><p>What replaces the counter-argument is more insidious. Within a single brief paragraph, earlier in the book, Wade quotes Michael Praetorius (1571–1621) complaining about “cheats and swindlers” who perform on the (then new) five-course guitar, pivots to noting the allegedly “shallow” available repertoire for the ten-string guitar — a claim presented without evidence, and a false one: the ten-string’s repertoire exceeds the six-string’s, encompassing the entire six-string literature plus works specifically composed (and transcribed) for the additional strings — and then delivers what he presents as Segovia’s verdict: “All this ten string monstrosity accomplishes is to turn the guitar from a voluptuous <em>femme</em> into a matronly hag.” (1980: 60) Wade offers no refutation.</p><p>The contrast with his habitual treatment of Segovia, Bream, and Williams in <em>Traditions</em> is telling. Throughout the book, Wade moves quickly to defend these three “Olympians” (his word) against any criticism levelled at them. By way of example, Segovia’s “cavalier disregard of the academic niceties of the score” is reframed as evidence of creative genius (p. 13); Williams is defended against critics who reduced his achievement to technical facility, his “superbly honed technique” understood as merely “a means to an end” for the “shaping spirit of musical intelligence” (p. 208). Yepes tellingly receives no equivalent defence. The man who wrote in 1974 that the ten-string was “vindicated” now reproduces a characterisation of it as a “monstrosity” and “hag” — without refutation, without explanatory context, within a paragraph that has already invoked “cheats and swindlers” — and moves on.</p><p><strong>2) Artistic independence.</strong> In 1974, Yepes’s refusal to be deflected by “fashion, popular opinion, or even what is common practice among certain guitarists” was “admirably refreshing.” In 1980, it becomes only “a sharp sense of individuality.” The phrase sounds neutral. It is not. Across the preceding two hundred pages — p. 200 being the point at which the Yepes entry begins — “individuality” has been systematically coded as “exhibitionism”: one of the terms Wade deploys against things Yepes championed and Segovia avoided, from the repertoire of Sanz as transcribed by Yepes, to Turina’s Sonata op. 61, to the extended 19th-century works Yepes performed and Segovia eschewed, to virtuosity and power of sound as such. Segovia’s “Apollonian restraint” is explicitly praised; Williams, “the least exhibitionist of all musicians,” is celebrated as “a true disciple of Segovia” (p. 208) for his submission to depersonalisation — for his “continual extinction of personality” (p. 211, quoting T.S. Eliot). Those who deviate from the mould of “impersonality” (ib.) are “cast, artistically, into outer darkness” (p. 189). By the time the reader reaches Yepes’s less-than-four pages, “individuality” has already been saturated with negative connotations. Wade does not need to write “exhibitionist” about Yepes directly. The preceding two hundred pages have done the work. The subsequent entry on John Williams, replete with textbook Modernist ideology from the pages of Eliot (which tellingly also opens <em>Traditions</em>), deals the decisive stroke.</p><p><strong>3) Audience response.</strong> The same sold-out halls, standing ovations, and five encores that Wade in 1974 described as “the sort of reception given only to the great players” become in 1980 evidence of “charismatic appeal” and box-office draw: “one of the greatest box-office attractions among modern players.” “Box-office attraction” is the vocabulary of entertainment, not art. “Charismatic appeal” explains audience enthusiasm as a function of <em>personality</em> (renounced by “true disciple[s] of Segovia”) rather than musical substance. The implicit contrast, developed across the preceding pages of hagiography, is with genuine musical greatness (“genuine” as defined by Segovia) as opposed to popular magnetism.</p><p><strong>4) Ranking and lineage.</strong> In 1974, Yepes stood “at the top of the international ratings <em>along with</em> Segovia, Bream, Williams and Diaz.” In 1980, he is “the most significant <em>Spanish</em> player <em>after</em> Segovia.” The mechanism is surgical. By shifting the category from international guitarists to Spanish players, Wade removes Yepes from the peer group of Bream and Williams without appearing to attack him. By inserting “after Segovia” within that already-restricted category, he demotes him twice over: first from international peer to national subcategory, then from co-equal to subordinate within that subcategory. It reads as praise and functions as relegation.</p><p>The treatment of Yepes’s education executes the same logic through omission. <em>Traditions</em> names Rafael Balaguer, Vicente Asencio, Ataúlfo Argenta, Georges Enescu, and Walter Gieseking as formative influences. Three credentials are absent. Estanislao Marco and Joaquín García de la Rosa — documented pupils of Francisco Tárrega, through whom Yepes inherited the very lineage Segovians had mythologised as their own — are nowhere mentioned. And Nadia Boulanger is tellingly absent: arguably the most prestigious music pedagogue of the twentieth century, whose students included Aaron Copland, Leonard Bernstein, Philip Glass, Daniel Barenboim, Elliott Carter, Jean Françaix, John Eliot Gardiner, Igor Markevitch, Manuel Ponce, and Virgil Thomson, amongst many others. Her inclusion would have placed Yepes within a pedagogical network of unimpeachable prestige — one that existed entirely outside the guitar world’s internal hierarchies, and beyond Segovia’s claim to legitimise or delegitimise careers. Yepes himself regularly cited his private studies with Boulanger in interviews and in the biographical notes for his concert programmes. The name was available in 1980.</p><p>That the omission was deliberate is not a hypothesis. In Wade’s 2017 liner notes for Deutsche Grammophon’s reissue of Yepes’s so-called <em>Complete Solo Recordings</em>, written four decades later, Boulanger’s name appears: “Yepes studied with Parisian musicians such as the violinist George Enescu, the pianist Walter Gieseking, and the composer Nadia Boulanger.” By 2017, the suppression had become unnecessary. The historical damage had already been done. Yepes had been dead for twenty years. The prejudice had been institutionalised, the received view set, and the four-decade-old omission had already served its ideological purpose. Boulanger’s name could safely reappear without threatening the narrative and cultural economy <em>Traditions</em> had established.</p><h3>How Wade’s Method Differs from Duarte’s</h3><p>The distinction between these two men’s methods matters for understanding why the Wade case requires this kind of analysis, rather than the more straightforward forensics of “The Machinery of Suppression.”</p><p>As noted at the outset, Duarte’s typical method was non-falsifiable: rhetorical, emotionally manipulative, deploying blanket character assessments — the <em>heartless scholar</em> or <em>incorrigible eccentric</em> memes — as permanent labels rather than verifiable observations. His condemnations of the same 1971 Villa-Lobos recordings in 1978 and 1989 became falsifiable only because they contradicted each other.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*bPuGBkojkObyibAQqj3wNw.jpeg" /><figcaption>The same 1971 Villa-Lobos recordings: condemned in 1978 for lacking rubato (‘an accurate account of the surface’) and in 1989 for excessive rubato (‘note-values that are too distorted to pass as rubato’). Mutually exclusive verdicts on a fixed recording. The goalposts moved; the guilty verdict did not.</figcaption></figure><p>The Wade of 1980 never makes demonstrable claims about Yepes’s playing: he does not write “Yepes is an exhibitionist” or “his tempos are wayward.” What he does is apply the word “exhibitionism” systematically to several things Yepes championed and reserves its antonyms for Segovia and Williams, allowing the accumulated vocabulary to do its work subliminally. [For a full analysis of this mechanism and the specific textual deployments of “exhibitionism” throughout <em>Traditions</em>, see “<a href="https://medium.com/@10string/machinery-of-orthodoxy-05080cf6c53d">Why Do They All Hate Yepes? Part II: The Machinery</a>.”] The condemnation is structural: it lives in the architecture of the book, not in any extractable proposition. This is what makes it resistant to the direct refutation that the 1978/1989 Villa-Lobos contradiction provides. It is also what makes it more insidious.</p><p>But <em>Traditions</em> makes the affiliation explicit in another way. Wade describes Duarte as “one of the most informed guitar critics on the English scene” (p. 14) and quotes his 1961 attack on Yepes’s Wigmore Hall debut as a critical authority — the same review that eyewitness Oliver Walker, chief music critic of Johannesburg’s <em>The Star</em>, refuted as an “odorous diatribe” animated by “envy, frustration, pettiness and plain jealousy.” Wade’s endorsement of Duarte’s authority is not a critical judgement. It is a declaration of affiliation. And the double standard is once again operational: Duarte had condemned dissonances and “a certain waywardness in the soloist’s rhythmic pulse” in Mudarra’s <em>Fantasía X</em> — yet Duarte himself admitted unfamiliarity with the work, which was “interesting and, to us, new.” The syncopated rhythms and false relations he found “disturbing” are intrinsic compositional features of Mudarra’s piece, not interpretive failings. Wade, who had read widely enough in guitar history to write a book about it, in all probability knew this. Nevertheless, he quotes Duarte’s verdict without correction — exactly as he reproduces Segovia’s “matronly” “monstrosity” verdict on the ten-string without counter-argument and without explaining the rationales behind either position. The pattern is consistent: where Segovia, Bream, and Williams are defended at every turn, Yepes is left to absorb every criticism uncontested.</p><h3>The “Love” Connection</h3><p>Segovia’s endorsement of Wade belongs to a larger rhetorical ecosystem. “Love” was part of the shared linguistic currency of the Segovian circle — a sorting mechanism that classified musicians and critics by their allegiance, not their insight.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/598/1*Tozdgor9cIzy1l13j7pfug.jpeg" /><figcaption>John W. Duarte and Julian Bream. ‘The heart of Villa-Lobos, who loved both the guitar and music deeply’ — <em>Gramophone</em>, December 1978. In the Segovian circle’s vocabulary, ‘love’ for the guitar was an ideological test, not a description of emotion.</figcaption></figure><p>Duarte’s December 1978 <em>Gramophone</em> review of Yepes’s Villa-Lobos recordings is one of the most explicit deployments of this vocabulary in print. Setting Bream against Yepes, Duarte credited Bream with carrying the listener “into its heart, and there we find the heart of Villa-Lobos, who loved both the guitar and music deeply.” Yepes, by contrast, supposedly offered only “an accurate account of the surface.” (Or was it “distorted” and “reduced to rubble”?) The review concluded: “unless you hate the guitar or Villa-Lobos, you must waste no time in buying this marvellous record” — meaning Duarte’s associate and fellow countryman Bream’s, not Yepes’s. The logic is a loyalty test: Bream <em>loves the guitar</em>; Yepes is <em>academic</em>; to buy Yepes’s record would be to declare oneself indifferent to the instrument’s ‘soul.’ This is not a critical argument. It is coercion through review copy.</p><p>The mechanism is identical to Segovia’s endorsement of Wade. “True love and understanding” positions Wade inside the circle of genuine devotion (again, “genuine” as defined by Segovia). The inside is defined by its outside (its Others) — those who ‘misunderstand’ the guitar, who love it ‘falsely,’ who produce records that the ‘truly loving’ need not buy (lest the insiders be judged and found wanting). By 1980, both the reward for submission/depersonalisation and the implicit penalty for freedom of thought/expression had been structurally established.</p><h3>The Pattern Continues: 1991–2019</h3><p>The 1980 pivot was not a one-time adjustment. It was the beginning of a sustained project, maintained across four decades.</p><p>In September 1991 — two years after <em>The Segovia–Ponce Letters</em> had published Segovia’s documented support for Franco’s regime, his defence of authoritarian regimes (including Hitler’s), his anti-Semitism, and his related Modernist aesthetic commitments — Wade published “Segovia and the Spanish Character” in <em>Classical Guitar</em> magazine. The article addressed none of this documentary record. Instead, it pursued systematic historical revision, arguing that Segovia was a “Romantic individualist” who “remained aloof from political dogma of all kinds.” The central method was a strategically placed ellipsis in a quotation from Fernando Díaz-Plaja’s popularising text — one that excised the actual examples Díaz-Plaja gave of Spanish ‘Romantic’ rebels (Don Juan, the pirate, the prostitute, the “generous bandit” who robbed the rich) — none of whom remotely resembled Segovia, the Marquis of Salobreña, who had explicitly committed himself to “the continuing traditions of Country, Religion and Authority” and warned that “no young artist should dare to introduce capricious changes in his instrument without the blessing of his elders in knowledge and guidance.” Wade’s argument required the excision because the available evidence made it impossible without it. [For a full analysis of this laundering operation, see “<a href="https://medium.com/@10string/the-yepes-erasure-569835f4d588">Why Do They All Hate Yepes? Part III: The Cover-Up</a>.”]</p><p>Wade had read English Literature at Jesus College, Cambridge — not Music. The detection of manipulative selective quotation, of the kind an ellipsis can perform, is a foundational competence of that discipline. He deployed the technique in print four decades after he had acquired the skills to identify it in others.</p><p>In 2006, Wade contributed to <em>Soundboard</em> magazine’s 24-page tribute to Duarte, whose contributors repeatedly insisted on Duarte’s “honesty” in terms that recalled Oliver Walker’s Shakespearean observation, decades earlier, about the lady protesting too much.</p><p>In 2012, when John Williams publicly criticised Segovia’s pedagogical authoritarianism — documented by Williams, Balada, and others as demanding that students copy his every inflection — Wade responded publicly by claiming that “Segovia’s pupils all played very differently.” This directly contradicted his own 1980 celebration in <em>Traditions</em> of Williams’s “ulterior impersonality” and “continual extinction of personality” (p. 211) as evidence that he was “a true disciple of Segovia” (p. 208). A man who publicly contradicts his own published text to defend Segovia in 2012 is not confused. He is loyal — and invested.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FwiAbqfaYGwk%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DwiAbqfaYGwk&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FwiAbqfaYGwk%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="640" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/73d63a28ac5908698e6cbd895cb8827b/href">https://medium.com/media/73d63a28ac5908698e6cbd895cb8827b/href</a></iframe><p>In 2015, Wade published an article in <em>Classical Guitar</em> dismissing as “myth” the connection between the stillbirth of Rodrigo’s child and the emotional character of the Adagio of the <em>Concierto de Aranjuez</em> — in the process overruling the testimony of both Pepe Romero and Narciso Yepes, who knew Rodrigo personally and interpreted — not “executed,” <em>interpreted </em>— the work with his explicit approval and gratitude. Rodrigo had called Yepes “my guitarist par excellence.” Wade used a 1943 letter to dismiss the testimony — and, by extension, the interpretations — of the composer’s two closest guitar performers. The intervention was designed to protect the Modernist fiction of music as impersonal text (thus, also, the ‘superiority’ of Williams and Bream’s straightforwardly rhythmicised executions) — still, <em>after</em> the 1991 “Romantic” rebranding of the Segovian lineage.</p><p>In 2017, Wade wrote the liner notes for Deutsche Grammophon’s first-ever worldwide CD and streaming reissue of Yepes’s so-called <em>Complete Solo Recordings </em>— recordings that for decades had been inaccessible outside Japan. The prose is more generous in tone than <em>Traditions</em>, driven perhaps by the commercial need to sell the recordings or, as already argued, by the fact that the insidious narratives of <em>Traditions</em> and Wade’s subsequent <em>Classical Guitar</em> magazine articles had already been established as received view. Boulanger’s name appears, as noted. Yet the architecture of diminishment (and historiographical negligence) persists, nearly four decades after <em>Traditions</em>. For example: The ten-string guitar “aroused some controversy from purists” — Wade still invoking “purism,” still without counter-argument. Yepes’s extensive concert tours of Africa (Egypt, Algeria, South Africa, and Namibia) are absent from his international touring biography. (Segovia performed in South Africa only once, in 1956; Bream and Williams never performed on the African continent.) The date of Yepes’s adoption of the ten-string in concert is given erroneously as 1963; it was March 1964. Asencio’s pedagogical demands are reduced to a concern about scale velocity, where Yepes’s own accounts document that Asencio demanded the full <em>legato</em> musicality of a trained orchestral musician — and extended far beyond scale technique. Yepes’s priority in recording Bach’s complete lute works (twice, on both lute and guitar) — the first complete recordings of them by any performer, on any instrument, achieved at a time when so-called “historically informed” lutenists were still declaring the works “impossible” to play on lute — goes unacknowledged, as does the scholarship that made it possible. Wade had, in <em>Traditions</em>, misogynistically dismissed the Mary Burwell Lute Book as “the girlish ardour of Miss Mary Burwell” (p. 86) — one of the very primary sources from which Yepes drew his understanding that baroque lutes, in certain keys, required raising the 1st and 4th courses a semitone, resolving what period specialists had declared insoluble. In the 2017 liner notes, meanwhile, Turina — whose Sonata op. 61, championed by Yepes, had in <em>Traditions</em> been associated with “exhibitionism” and appearing “rarely, if at all, in Segovia’s programmes” — is now quietly described as “outstanding.” No acknowledgement of the reversal is offered.</p><p>In 2018, Wade published a reflection on his career as a competition juror in <em>Classical Guitar</em>. His critical perspective, he wrote, had been “molded (I hope) over 50 years by the artistic examples of Julian Bream and John Williams.” The man who had written in 1974 of Yepes’s “utter musicianship” and “deep fund of experience of music, art and life” does not appear in his retrospective account of a fifty-year critical formation.</p><p>In 2019, near the end of his writing career, Wade published an article in the same magazine stating: “There is no ‘school’ of Segovia.” This was the myth his own book had spent over 219 pages constructing. No acknowledgement of the contradiction was offered. The sentence stood alone, as if the preceding forty years had not happened.</p><h3>What the Evidence Shows, and What It Suggests</h3><p>The documented record does not admit serious dispute. A critic who wrote in 1974 that Narciso Yepes’s ten-string guitar was “vindicated as an ideal medium for Bach,” who placed Yepes “at the top of the international ratings along with Segovia, Bream, Williams and Diaz,” who called his artistic independence “admirably refreshing” and his musicianship “utter” — that same critic produced, six years later, a book that demoted Yepes to “the most significant Spanish player after Segovia,” described his ten-string as a “hybrid guitar,” repackaged the art of his “utter musicianship” as the entertainment of “box-office attraction,” systematically deployed “exhibitionism” (among other invidious tropes) against almost everything he represented across more than two hundred pages, omitted his studies with Boulanger and with pupils of Francisco Tárrega, positioned his known antagonist Duarte (an industrial chemist by training) as “one of the most informed guitar critics on the English scene,” and reproduced Segovia’s misogynistic dismissal of the ten-string (a “monstrosity” and “matronly hag”) without refutation. That book received Segovia’s personal commendation as an act of “true love and understanding.”</p><p>The hypothesis that Segovia’s endorsement was conditional — that it required, or at minimum rewarded, the treatment of Yepes the book delivers — cannot be proved from the documentary record currently available. What can be factually established is this: Segovia’s vindictiveness towards rivals operated through private channels — behind closed doors, through correspondence and personal influence — in exactly the manner the suppression of Yepes would require. The correspondence with Manuel Ponce documents this across years. As early as 1933, Segovia was enquiring sarcastically after “what new system of cunning your ‘superior’ Sr. Chavez has employed to harrass [<em>sic</em>] you and exalt himself” (<em>The Segovia–Ponce Letters</em>, p. 142). In a subsequent letter, having read Mexico’s preeminent composer Carlos Chávez’s <em>New York Times </em>statement on breaking free from Eurocentric models in music (October 1936) — in which Ponce’s name was passed over in silence — Segovia wrote: “<strong>For my part I will do what I can, personally, to sterilize his opinions in the serious musical world of New York</strong>” (p. 170). And then the 1937 commitment that crystallises the method: “<strong>Leave it to me: I will take charge that he passes into History, with the nickname Carlos Chavez the Traitor…</strong>” (p. 175). “I will do what I can, personally.” “Leave it to me.” These are the phrases of a man who understood power as a private instrument, operated through back-channel influence rather than open confrontation — precisely the register of his admission, in the same correspondence, that “here [in America] I avoid imprudent declarations. I help Franco with what I can, ostensibly in Europe but <em>behind the scenes</em> in this country” (p. 168).</p><p>The irony is not incidental: Segovia was “indignant” at his friend’s rival for passing Ponce’s name “in silence” in print — the precise mechanism his circle would later deploy against Yepes: omission, that is, when he was not being tokenised and mischaracterised, or directly denigrated.</p><p>The mechanism of rewarding institutional loyalty is established by the endorsement itself — “true love and understanding” — and by the career that followed: published by John Calder (London), with <em>Traditions</em> throughout positioning Schott’s Guitar Archives — Segovia’s own publication network — as the standard of legitimacy; commissioned to write for <em>Classical Guitar</em> magazine and record liner notes; invited onto competition juries alongside Segovia-circle members; and mindlessly lauded to this day as “one of the foremost writers on the classical guitar” (Siccas Guitars), on the benighted digital platforms that succeeded the now (predictably) defunct legacy institutions like <em>Classical Guitar</em> magazine. The timeline of the transformation coincides precisely with the period in which Wade was writing a book that, whatever its other qualities, could not have received Segovia’s “true love” commendation had it presented Yepes’s innovations as legitimate alternatives to the Segovian model as the more authentic, 1974 version of Graham Wade had done.</p><p>Whether the arrangement was explicit or tacit, negotiated or simply understood, the documentary record does not presently resolve. What it establishes indisputably is that Segovia was not above vindictive machinations, that the transformation happened, that it was consistent, that it was sustained across four decades, and that it served identifiable interests.</p><p>In later years Wade pivoted to writing historical fiction — <em>The Fibonacci Confessions </em>(2010), <em>The Emperor’s Barber </em>(2017). The transition was less of a departure than it appeared. He had been practising the form for thirty years under the rubric of “classical guitar history.”</p><h3>Conclusion</h3><p>Graham Wade in 1974 was a critic doing his job — and doing it quite well. Graham Wade after 1980 was something else: a ‘historiographer’ constructing and maintaining an ideological narrative, with demonstrable editorial choices and sustained rhetorical methods, operating through the diction that Segovia’s circle had made its own. <em>That the 1974 Wade existed at all is the most damaging single fact in this account.</em> It proves that the 1980 position was not an honest assessment arrived at through experience. It was a departure from one.</p><p>What was suppressed — Yepes’s numerous innovations, his lineage, his scholarship, the acoustic and musical reasons behind the instrument he invented, the first complete recordings of Bach’s lute works, the full roster of composers who wrote for him, the ‘dark’ continent he toured that his rivals did not — has not disappeared. The recordings exist. The ten-string exists. The Yepes lineage exists — in South Africa. The documented history exists, for those willing to read it outside the guidance of those who preferred it buried.</p><p><em>İt ürür, kervan yürür </em>— “the dogs bark, but the caravan moves on.” Oliver Walker evoked this Middle-Eastern proverb in 1961, in <em>B.M.G.</em>, responding to Duarte’s “odorous diatribe.” It applies here with equal precision. The classical guitar community will eventually have to account for what was done — to Narciso Yepes, to those who recognised his value and stood up for it, and to the guitar itself — over seven decades of institutional suppression: Graham Wade’s four decades of “true love and understanding” were merely the most insidious chapter of a project that John W. Duarte had begun (more ineptly) in 1955. Wade’s case is simply one of the more instructive records of how it was done — and of what a critic looks like before, and after, an institution gets to him.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/413/0*MMQVd8LHIyZk_EVM.jpg" /></figure><p><em>This article is part of a series examining the institutional suppression of Narciso Yepes in the English-language classical guitar world. Companion articles: “The Machinery of Suppression: How John W. Duarte Tried to Destroy Narciso Yepes” and “Why Do They All Hate Yepes?” (Parts I–IV), amongst others, are available on the author’s Medium “</em><a href="https://medium.com/@10string"><em>Home</em></a><em>” page.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=beeb617907d6" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Classical Guitar’s Founding Myth: Segovia Was a Modernist, Not a Romantic]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@10string/segovia-modernist-81645dab107b?source=rss-8026079d565e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/81645dab107b</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[classical-music]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[music-history]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[music]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[guitar]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[classical-guitar]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Viktor van Niekerk]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 12 Jun 2026 07:45:47 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-06-12T07:45:47.505Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>This is a summary of a four-part series examining classical guitar’s Modernist origins and the institutional suppression of Narciso Yepes.</em> <em>— </em><a href="https://medium.com/@10string/the-modernist-lie-41b716eb0eae"><em>Part I: The Lie</em></a> <em>— </em><a href="https://medium.com/@10string/machinery-of-orthodoxy-05080cf6c53d"><em>Part II: The Machinery</em></a> <em>— </em><a href="https://medium.com/@10string/the-yepes-erasure-569835f4d588"><em>Part III: The Cover-Up</em></a> <em>— </em><a href="https://medium.com/@10string/developing-individuals-649a2825423d"><em>Part IV: The Living Witness</em></a><em> (and full reference list)</em> <a href="https://medium.com/@10string/segovia-modernism-6bb448803110"><em>Read the complete essay here.</em></a></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/600/0*c6AR7WW3DgK_LQQ4.jpg" /><figcaption>Andrés Segovia’s musical ideology was never Romantic or marketed as such during his heyday. The image of Segovia as ”Spanish Romantic” was posthumously fabricated in the Anglophone media to launder his image.</figcaption></figure><h3>The Inversion</h3><p>For decades, classical guitar culture has maintained a fiction: that Andrés Segovia embodied “Spanish Romantic” tradition while Narciso Yepes represented cold, alienating Modernism. The opposite is true. Segovia was a Modernist — not a high Modernist like Boulez, but as much a pioneer of the neoclassical Modernist performance ideology as Stravinsky and Ravel, both born more than a decade before him. Yepes’s performance practice, pedagogy, and musical ethics are precisely what Modernism was designed to suppress.</p><p>This is a summary of the evidence expounded in my essay, “Why Do They All Hate Yepes?”</p><h3>What Modernist Ideology Demanded of Performers</h3><p>The relevant strand is Stravinskian neoclassical Modernism — the aesthetics Igor Stravinsky articulated in his <em>Poétique musicale</em> (1942/1947) and his 1924 essay on his Octet, which together constitute the theoretical foundation of twentieth-century performance orthodoxy across multiple traditions, including “historically-informed performance” and “classical guitar.”</p><p>Stravinsky’s doctrine reduced the performer to an “executant”: someone realising the composer’s supposedly explicit (or at least discoverable) will without introducing personal interpretation. He framed this explicitly as ethical, not aesthetic — the distinction between execution and interpretation was, in his words, “a difference… of an ethical rather than of an aesthetic order” (1947: 123). Performance was not creative dialogue with a work but reproduction of an arbitrarily fixed model.</p><p>This doctrine had a specific aesthetic profile. Richard Taruskin, documenting its effects across twentieth-century performance, identifies Modernist practice as “lightweight, hence leery of the profound or the sublime” — text-centred, impersonal, unfriendly to spontaneity (1995: 167). In essence, it was antagonistic to <em>difference </em>— to alterity. Vladimir Jankélévitch identified the inevitable sonic result: “the <em>style plat</em>” — the flat style — produced by prohibitions against sonic depth, dynamic range and nuance, sustained lines, and tempo rubato: “the uniform speed of the machine” (<em>Music and the Ineffable</em> 1961: 45).</p><p>This is the ideology against which Segovia’s “classical guitar” movement must be reassessed — and against which Yepes’s institutional marginalisation finally makes sense.</p><h3>The Smoking Gun: 1947</h3><p>The classical guitar establishment’s alignment with Stravinskian doctrine was initially explicit. <em>Guitar Review</em> (1947) — whose editorial philosophy was, as Graham Wade documented, “initially based on the maestro’s principles” (1993: 31) — published this about Segovia: he “does not ‘interpret’ music to us — what we hear is the music itself” (<em>Guitar Review</em> 1[4]: 76).</p><p>The scare-quoted “interpret” and the claim to deliver “the music itself” are Stravinskian formulas, published the same year as the first English translation of Stravinsky’s <em>Poetics of Music</em> — containing the identical doctrine. But the critical mechanism is more specific than stylistic alignment. By declaring “Segovia <em>is</em> Bach — he <em>is</em> Albéniz … reincarnated”, <em>Guitar Review</em> (1947: 76) elevated Segovia to the level of the Composer himself: he does not merely execute the composer’s will faithfully (allegedly); he incarnates it. This elevation served a precise ideological function. Once Segovia’s performances were declared equivalent to the composer’s authority, other guitarists — students and competitors alike — were subjected to the Stravinskian executant doctrine in its most coercive form: not “replicate the score faithfully” but “replicate Segovia’s performance exactly.” Whether Segovia himself always performed in the <em>style plat </em>is secondary — though he did so in many instances, particularly earlier in his career, before the interpretive workarounds imposed by extreme old age. The ideology was never primarily about how Segovia performed. It was about what others were forbidden to do: to reject his moulds as mere <em>interpretations</em>, like every other performance of music.</p><h3>Segovia’s Own Words</h3><p><em>The Segovia–Ponce Letters</em> (1989) removed all ambiguity. The correspondence documents Segovia’s aesthetico-ideological commitments across decades.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/800/0*waiJNIg0IpbI1sZb.jpg" /><figcaption>The smoking gun. Published two years before Segovia’s ideology was rebranded as “Spanish Romanticism,” this correspondence documents Segovia’s Modernist commitments across decades — Schoenberg, Ortega y Gasset, Franco, and ”Be modern.”</figcaption></figure><p>In 1923 he wrote with enthusiasm about Modernist composers including Schoenberg and Wellesz. In January 1928: “Be modern.” In December 1929 he dismissed Turina and Manén as “old-fashioned music.” In September 1930 he called Paganini’s works “of inferior musical quality” — the anti-Romantic contempt of Modernist cultural politics. In September 1932 he praised Falla’s <em>El Retablo</em> for exceeding “the <em>insignificant humanity</em>” of other works on the night’s programme— a direct reference to Ortega y Gasset’s “dehumanisation of art” (1925), the theoretical foundation of Spanish Modernist aesthetics (<em>The Segovia–Ponce Letters</em> 1989: 3, 25, 49, 83, 121).</p><p>Segovia admired and knew Ortega y Gasset personally — he admitted as much in a 1976 television interview (<em>A Fondo</em>, TVE) — and the practical consequences are audible in documented testimony. His disciple Oscar Ghiglia confirmed that Segovia “wouldn’t allow the sorrow of… music to come through… Every piece played by Segovia ended up… with a happy ending” (<em>Guitar Review</em> 115: 12). In the same 1976 TVE interview, Segovia recalled that guitars in his youth “repelled” him because the instrument “retained its melancholic timbre.” Elsewhere, he declared the guitar “synonymous with mirth.” (Gavoty 1955: 17) This is Ortega applied: “the modern inspiration — and this is a strange fact indeed — is invariably waggish” (Ortega y Gasset 1925/1968: 47).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/764/1*YaEKh9z4dC_IQjQBTWx_wQ.png" /><figcaption>“Segovia” (1955) by Bernard Gavoty. Segovia in his own words, during his heyday: “I am suspicious of Bacchic ecstasies.” The Apollonian/Stravinskian declaration — published 36 years before the “Spanish Romantic” label was invented — was Segovia’s own self-presentation. No posthumous rebranding required; no ‘Romantic’ mythology in sight.</figcaption></figure><p>Segovia’s Apollonian declaration to Bernard Gavoty clinches the ideological identification: “I am suspicious of Bacchic [i.e., Dionysian] ecstasies” (Gavoty 1955: 17). Taruskin documents that Stravinsky’s self-declared Apollonianism was “explicitly political”: the Classic (Apollo) and the Romantic (Dionysus) “are opposed in Stravinsky’s exposition under the politically charged rubrics of submission and insubordination” (2008: 395). Segovia’s Apollonianism was not mere aesthetic preference; it was ideological allegiance.</p><p>The alignment was not just a case of two men independently arriving at similar ideas — there were actual documented personal and professional ties between Segovia’s world and Stravinsky’s. <em>Correspondence between Segovia and Stravinsky is documented through Robert Craft’s withheld letters</em> (Joseph 2001: 240). All of Segovia’s core composers had direct Stravinskian connections or influences: Tansman was Stravinsky’s close friend and biographer (Taruskin 2008: 443); even Moreno Torroba acknowledged the Russian’s influence in correspondence. The stylistic similarities between Stravinsky’s neoclassical period and Segovia-commissioned guitar works of Ponce and Castelnuovo-Tedesco are almost self-evident:</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2F4iEgMcw4io0%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3D4iEgMcw4io0&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2F4iEgMcw4io0%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="640" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/c7e13ef162c5397a5ececf429b0de0b3/href">https://medium.com/media/c7e13ef162c5397a5ececf429b0de0b3/href</a></iframe><h3>Pedagogical Authoritarianism as Doctrine</h3><p>Segovia enacted Stravinsky’s recording doctrine as pedagogy. John Williams testified that Segovia “made his students copy his every inflection,” acting “as if there was but one valid transcription, one interpretation and one fingering of anything in the repertoire — and they were his own” (Starling 2012: 101). Leonardo Balada confirmed this as an eyewitness at Segovia’s Santiago de Compostela masterclasses, stating that Segovia “forced all the players of the guitar” to make “the same phrasing as he was doing” (Duffie 1998).</p><p>Stravinsky had sought to create a recording archive to prevent what he called “irresponsible interpretations” and eliminate performers’ “notorious liberty” (<em>Autobiography</em> 1936: 101). Segovia substituted himself as the authority: his recordings were the fixed model, not through demonstrable truth, but through institutional enforcement that condemned deviation as moral failure.</p><p>A 1960 Compostela incident is paradigmatic. Balada reports: “I attended one of Segovia’s classes, in which John Williams and Narciso Yepes were present. When it was his turn, Narciso played his own version of Bach’s Chaconne [on which he had worked with Nadia Boulanger and George Enescu]. Segovia didn’t like this and was very hard on him.” (Bruzual 2008) Yepes was expelled for interpretive autonomy — the cardinal sin in Modernist pedagogy. The infamous Chapdelaine incident, caught on film near the end of Segovia’s life, confirms this was lifelong pattern, not temperament:</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FwiAbqfaYGwk%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DwiAbqfaYGwk&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FwiAbqfaYGwk%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="640" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/73d63a28ac5908698e6cbd895cb8827b/href">https://medium.com/media/73d63a28ac5908698e6cbd895cb8827b/href</a></iframe><h3>“Spanish Romanticism” Is a Historical Fiction</h3><p>The counter-label has no scholarly foundation. F. Courtney Tarr documented how non-Spanish commentators habitually misconstrued “a romantic caricature of Spain” based on “little interest in Spain for herself” (1940: 35). Romanticism proper was a predominantly Germanic, <em>Counter-Enlightenment</em> movement lasting roughly 1770–1850. Spain, under the Inquisition (1478–1834), underwent no significant Enlightenment influence and therefore produced no Counter-Enlightenment reaction — i.e., no true Romanticism. The Spanish politician and writer Antonio Alcalá Galiano (1789–1865), a contemporary witness, observed that there was “no Spanish Romanticism, but rather a masquerade in Romantic costumes” (quoted in King 1962: 8). Edmund King established that even this superficial Spanish adoption of ‘Romantic’ garb lasted only from 1834 to 1844 (King 1962: 8), ending 49 years before Segovia was born. King’s diagnosis: the supposed Spanish Romantics of 1834–44 “did not really, in a profound way, go through the spiritual experience behind the Romantic attitudes — they are answering questions that they have not asked” (8).</p><p>Segovia was born in 1893: wrong country, wrong epoch. Applying “Spanish Romantic” to him compounds falsification upon falsification: using a scholarly category that a contemporary witness and professional historians identify as superficial to non-existent to describe a figure born half a century after even the “masquerade” version ended.</p><p>The term “classical guitar” is itself symptomatic. It only entered common usage around the 1920s — the same decade Stravinsky’s neoclassicism emerged. Before this, it was simply “the guitar” or national variants thereof (the “Spanish guitar,” the “Russian guitar,” etc.). Around the same time, Segovia strategically differentiated himself from traditional guitarists precisely by adopting neoclassical works from Ponce, Tansman, and Castelnuovo-Tedesco, and Stravinskian attitudes towards musical authority. The terminological shift from “guitar” to “<em>classical</em> guitar” was not continuation of tradition but invention of a <em>Modernist</em> category claiming ‘classical’ legitimacy whilst breaking with actual historical practice — structurally identical to Stravinsky’s neoclassicism and the later “historically-informed performance” movement, both of which returned to a past that never was.</p><h3>Yepes: The Anti-Modernist</h3><p>Narciso Yepes’s own words and documented practice constitute a sustained rejection of everything Modernist performance ideology demanded.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FU6tZnajCVlk%3Fstart%3D1972%26feature%3Doembed%26start%3D1972&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DU6tZnajCVlk&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FU6tZnajCVlk%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/6877e1b3644bd8fbad1908213ffdb0e3/href">https://medium.com/media/6877e1b3644bd8fbad1908213ffdb0e3/href</a></iframe><p>On notation and fidelity, in <em>Grandes Intérpretes</em> (TVE, 1971): “Notation is no more or less than an indicator. Signs but not music.” And: textual fidelity in early repertoire is a mark of interpretive failure, not virtue — “The more faithful a player is to a sixteenth-century text, the worse interpreter he is.” At his 1961 Wigmore Hall debut, when Segovia’s interpretations were raised, Yepes stated plainly that “it was not necessary for him to listen to a Segovia record and try to copy it” (<em>B.M.G.</em> 58 no. 672 [April 1961]: 207).</p><p>On pedagogy, <em>TV-Kammerkonzert</em> (Südwestfunks, 1973): “if I can’t answer your <em>Why?</em>, then what I’ve told you is no good.” And, in teaching: “I consider the most important thing to <em>discover</em> the student’s [musical] personality, to <em>develop</em> it, and not for the student to play like me, but that he plays like <em>himself</em>.” This is the precise inverse of Segovia’s doctrine.</p><p>On audiences: Fritz Buss — who studied with Yepes from January 1961 — documents that Yepes explicitly told him his inner feeling on stage was one of “welcoming them into his being”; that performers must “respect” the audience because “they come and spend their time and money to listen to you — you have a responsibility towards them”; that each listener should “leave the concert taking a part of him with them.” In a 1982 <em>Los Angeles Times</em> interview, Yepes stated he played “for the <em>individual</em> there to hear him — concentrating on that one person, on always giving him my undivided attention, my best” (Saltzman 1982: 12). Stravinsky dismissed audiences seeking emotional connection as wanting “a drug” (<em>Autobiography</em> 1936: 163). Segovia’s hagiographers habitually patronised general audiences for appreciating Yepes and not appreciating classical guitar ‘elites’ more or equally. Yepes treated that same performer–listener connection as an ethical obligation.</p><p>On the composer–performer relationship, Rodrigo’s 1997 tribute is unambiguous: the <em>Concierto de Aranjuez</em> “took on a new nature” through Yepes’s interpretation, for which the composer credits the success of the concerto; their work was “an intense collaboration,” travelling “our musical trajectories side-by-side”; Yepes was “my guitarist par excellence. <em>My</em> guitarist” (Rodrigo 1997: 48). Three elements demolish Modernist doctrine simultaneously: the composer credits the performer with positively transforming the work; he frames the music as jointly owned; he identifies a personal artistic bond irreducible to interchangeable execution. Stravinsky had held that interpretation “risks the complete loss of meaning.” Rodrigo’s tribute says the opposite.</p><p>The composers Yepes championed confirm the alignment. By way of example, Maurice Ohana was systematically excluded from Boulez’s <em>Domaine musical</em> for opposing serialism, and marginalised by BBC programming throughout the 1960s and 1970s (Rae 2000: 22, 27). Ohana had co-founded the <em>Groupe Zodiaque</em> in 1947 explicitly to defend “freedom of musical expression from what they considered to be the tyranny of serialism” (Rae 2000: 24). The institutional enforcement was explicit: “In the 1960s, not to be serialist was like having some shameful disease” (Marius Constant, quoted in Rae 2000: 27). Yepes championed composers marginalised by the same Modernist establishment that marginalised him — composers who valued creative risk and expressive freedom over systematic control.</p><p>Spectrogram analysis confirms the acoustic dimension: Yepes’s tone shows energy concentrated in fundamental frequencies (c. 100–500 Hz) with continuous horizontal banding indicating sustain and legato phrasing. Segovia’s shows weaker fundamental energy (i.e., a brighter, lightweight sound) with fragmented phrase structure — vertical gaps marking staccato articulation. Taruskin’s characterisation of Modernist performance as “lightweight, hence leery of the profound or the sublime” (1995: 167) has a spectrographically measurable analogue:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/875/0*vJPTy0EJaYKhKK8A.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/875/0*T8Nfare9Tv3VNdeK.png" /><figcaption>Spectrograms: Yepes vs Segovia playing Bach’s Chaconne (same phrase). Top (Yepes 1959, dark tone): Energy concentrated in fundamental frequencies (c. 100–500 Hz, bright orange/yellow lower bands) with minimal/darker high-frequency content above 4 kHz. Note the continuous horizontal banding showing sustain and legato phrasing. Bottom (Segovia 1954, bright tone): Less energy in the fundamental frequency range (darker colouring in low-mid frequencies) with fragmented phrase structure (vertical gaps = staccato sound).</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/875/0*7JlmlJ8tMA_zbJGK.png" /><figcaption>Yepes (1961 Scarlatti K.11): Pronounced lower-frequency content (light orange/yellow banding) — a dark, projecting tone. Energy focused on fundamentals and low-mid partials, not high frequencies.</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/875/0*uVTzPmX8fgLZNlrR.png" /><figcaption>Segovia (1957 Scarlatti K.11): Less pronounced lower-frequency content, more mid-high spectral energy — a brighter, thinner tone than Yepes.</figcaption></figure><p>This spectral distinction, moreover, explains why Narciso Yepes was lauded by neutral, professional critics for his singular ability (as a guitarist) to “fill[] the hall with sound” (Eckert 1982) and project “beautifully” even in venues with “notoriously weak acoustics” (Saffle 1973: 6) — a fundamental level of mastery unattained by Segovia or his descendants within the classical-guitar establishment. (See my article “<a href="https://medium.com/@10string/guitar-projection-6b6d697eabc2">Bright ≠ Projection ≠ Loud: What Actually Makes a Classical Guitar Project</a>.”)</p><h3>A Note on Yepes and Romanticism</h3><p>This must be stated explicitly: Yepes was not a Romantic either. That would be as absurd as calling Segovia one. Romanticism as a philosophical and artistic movement ended decades before either man was born — in the wrong culture.</p><p>The argument is comparative and ideological: Yepes’s performance practice, pedagogy, and musical ethics <em>align</em> with what Romanticism valued and Modernism/Segovia explicitly suppressed. When Isaiah Berlin identifies the Romantic concept of <em>depth</em> as “inexhaustibility” — meaning that any description of a profound work opens further vistas, always demanding “three dots at the end” (<em>The Roots of Romanticism</em> 1999: 117) — Yepes’s declaration that “Music does not begin or end. Music <em>is</em>” (<em>Ser instrumento</em> 1989: 18) resonates directly. When the Romantics held that pure copying — as demanded by both Segovia and Stravinsky — was death to artistic meaning (Berlin 1999: 98), they articulated the principle Yepes enacted when he refused to reproduce Segovia’s recordings and demanded that each student develop their own musical identity.</p><p>Segovia’s Modernism exemplifies what the Romantics opposed: the belief that musical truth can be fixed, reproduced, and owned; that performance is execution of explicit instructions or reproduction of already extant phenomena rather than creative engagement with inexhaustible meaning. When <em>Guitar Review</em> declared (following Segovian principles) that “Segovia <em>is</em> Bach” — presenting “the music itself” (allegedly) without interpretation — they claimed to have seized what true Romantics insisted cannot be seized. When Segovia demanded students copy “his every inflection,” he imposed the “form” that Romantic principles identified as death to artistic meaning.</p><p>One approach assumes music is inexhaustible. The other claims to have exhausted it.</p><h3>The Laundering Operation: Wade, 1991</h3><p>The “Spanish Romantic” myth did not emerge organically from Segovia’s practice. It was manufactured, with identifiable authorship and timing. The primary document is Graham Wade’s article “Segovia and the Spanish Character” (<em>Classical Guitar</em> 10, no. 1, September 1991).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/516/1*DrKUFndX3u6MYsUdNi_bLA.png" /><figcaption>Graham Wade with Andrés Segovia: hagiographer and subject. Two years after The Segovia–Ponce Letters documented Segovia’s Modernist commitments, Wade published the article that manufactured the “Spanish Romantic” myth in their place.</figcaption></figure><p>The timing is critical. <em>The Segovia–Ponce Letters</em> had been published in 1989. Wade had access to the documentary record of Segovia’s Modernist commitments — the letters praising Schoenberg, dismissing composers as “old-fashioned,” commanding that works written for him must “be modern,” invoking Ortega y Gasset’s “dehumanisation of art,” and documenting political alignment with Franco’s regime. Yet Wade’s 1991 article addresses none of this. Instead, it pursues systematic historical revision.</p><p>Wade’s method: cite generalisations about so-called “Spanish character” from Fernando Díaz-Plaja’s <em>The Spaniard and the Seven Deadly Sins</em> (1971) — a popularising work the Spanish Royal Academy of History characterises as producing “anecdotes and general cultural observation” rather than rigorous analysis — then claim Segovia embodied these traits, therefore Segovia was “Romantic.” The central claim: “Segovia’s guitar is the epitome of the soloist as romantic image” (Wade 1991: 38).</p><p>Wade quotes Díaz-Plaja on the Spanish ‘Romantic’ character invoking “the admiration for the rebel… the praise of whoever lets himself be moved by passion rather than reason” (Díaz-Plaja 1971: 48f; Wade 1991: 38). The ellipsis marks where Wade excised Díaz-Plaja’s actual examples of Spanish ‘Romantic’ rebels: Don Juan, the pirate, the “generous bandit” who robs the rich, figures celebrating defiance of authority and Government. None of these describes Segovia, who had explicitly committed himself to “the continuing traditions of Country, Religion and Authority” (<em>The Segovia–Ponce Letters</em> 1989: 167) and whose pedagogical method was built on unconditional submission. In his own 1974 polemic against Yepes’s 10-string guitar, Segovia condemned rebelliousness directly, warning that “no young artist should dare to introduce capricious changes in his instrument without the blessing of his elders in knowledge and guidance” (<em>Guitar Review</em> 39 [1974]: n.p.). The excision was not editorial economy. It was suppression of evidence that made Wade’s sophomoric argument impossible.</p><p>The falsifications compound. Wade asserted that “Segovia expressed few overtly political or religious beliefs” and “remained aloof from political dogma of all kinds” (1991: 36). The <em>Segovia–Ponce Letters</em>, published two years earlier, already document the opposite: explicit support for Franco’s regime, performances in Nazi Germany, anti-Semitism, and extensive political commentary (<em>The Segovia–Ponce Letters</em> 1989: 168, 174, 243). Segovia himself had written: “here [in America] I avoid imprudent declarations. I help Franco with what I can, ostensibly in Europe but behind the scenes in this country” (168). Wade also claimed Segovia “did not go in for either great philosophical statements or for intellectual arguments” (1991: 36) — directly contradicting his own characterisation in <em>Traditions of the Classical Guitar</em> (1980), where Segovia and Williams were positioned as supposedly profound intellects. The reversal was strategic: if Segovia wasn’t an intellectual, readers would not expect rigorous analysis of his documented aesthetico-ideological commitments.</p><p>Most revealing is Wade’s characterisation of Segovia as embodying Spanish resistance to “collectivism” and “all that might curb individuality” (1991: 38), written without any mention of Segovia’s systematic suppression of individuality in students and competitors — his demand that they copy his every inflection, his expulsion of Yepes and others for interpretive autonomy, his decades-long pattern of pedagogical authoritarianism documented by Williams, Balada, and others. The figure celebrated as champion of “individualism” was, in documented practice, its most efficient suppressor.</p><p>D. L. Shaw, writing about the problematic topic of “Spanish Romanticism” and nineteenth-century Spanish literary revisionism, identified the exact mechanism Wade deployed: critics “attempt to drag [orthodox voices] willy-nilly into the fold by ignoring or suppressing part of the evidence” (1963: 191). Wade enacted this textbook suppression in 1991, two years after the <em>Segovia–Ponce Letters</em> had made that suppression necessary. This was not honest reevaluation. It was damage control masquerading as scholarship. Its insidious effect on the benighted culture of the classical guitar persists to this day.</p><h3>Conclusion</h3><p>“Classical guitar” culture was not built on Spanish tradition or Romantic expression. It was built on 1920s Modernist ideology — textual literalism, impersonal execution, copying of purportedly “proper” moulds, aesthetic “lightness,” contempt for audience emotion — that has systematically obscured its origins through historical revisionism.</p><p>The evidence for Segovia’s Modernism is primary, documentary, and abundant: his own letters, his composers’ Stravinskian networks, his Apollonian declarations, his Ortegan aesthetics, his pedagogical authoritarianism, and the acoustic properties of his tone. The “Spanish Romantic” label has no basis in Romantic historiography. It was manufactured with identifiable method by identifiable agents — most explicitly in Graham Wade’s 1991 laundering operation in <em>Classical Guitar</em> magazine, executed with full knowledge of the documentary record he chose to suppress.</p><p>Narciso Yepes was the casualty: marginalised not for musical inadequacy but for embodying precisely what Modernism cannot tolerate — interpretive autonomy, tonal depth, audience connection, collaborative creation, and the refusal to treat musical meaning as exhausted. Two non-guitarist critics said it plainly. Thor Eckert Jr., in <em>The Christian Science Monitor</em> (17 November 1982), reported that Yepes filled Carnegie Hall with sound: “One left his recital stimulated and elated, with nary a thought as to the potential limitations of the instrument, dynamically or musically.” Michael Saffle, in <em>The Stanford Daily</em> (6 November 1973), noted that guitarists, upon hearing Yepes, left “playfully threatening to throw their own instruments away.”</p><p>But Yepes was not the only casualty. The instrument itself was diminished: its acoustic and expressive potential — the dark, projecting, resonant sound Yepes demonstrated could fill Carnegie Hall with enthusiastic listeners, without amplification — was suppressed in favour of the Modernist <em>style plat</em>, and a pedagogical culture was built around the resulting tonal limitations, teaching successive generations to mistake those limitations for ideals. The classical guitar culture that emerged from this process has been ideologically confused and benighted ever since: trained to pursue brightness as ‘projection,’ submission as authenticity, and imitation as artistry — and to regard the documented counter-evidence as heresy rather than history.</p><p>The truth is documented. The lie is institutional. And the evidence has always been there.</p><p><em>This is a summary of a four-part series examining classical guitar’s Modernist origins and the institutional suppression of Narciso Yepes.</em> <em>— </em><a href="https://medium.com/@10string/the-modernist-lie-41b716eb0eae"><em>Part I: The Lie</em></a> <em>— </em><a href="https://medium.com/@10string/machinery-of-orthodoxy-05080cf6c53d"><em>Part II: The Machinery</em></a> <em>— </em><a href="https://medium.com/@10string/the-yepes-erasure-569835f4d588"><em>Part III: The Cover-Up</em></a> <em>— </em><a href="https://medium.com/@10string/developing-individuals-649a2825423d"><em>Part IV: The Living Witness</em></a><em> (and full reference list)</em> <a href="https://medium.com/@10string/segovia-modernism-6bb448803110"><em>Read the complete essay here.</em></a></p><h4>Primary Sources</h4><ul><li><em>Guitar Review</em> 1, no. 4 (1947): 76</li><li>Andrés Segovia, <em>The Segovia–Ponce Letters</em> (1989): 3, 25, 49, 83, 121, 167, 168, 174, 243</li><li>Andrés Segovia, “More Strings?,” <em>Guitar Review</em> 39 (1974)</li><li>Andrés Segovia, <em>A Fondo</em> (TVE, 1976)</li><li>Bernard Gavoty, <em>Andrés Segovia</em> (1955): 17</li><li>Igor Stravinsky, <em>Poetics of Music</em> (1947): 123</li><li>Igor Stravinsky, <em>An Autobiography</em> (1936): 101, 163</li><li>Narciso Yepes, <em>Grandes Intérpretes</em> (TVE, 1971)</li><li>Narciso Yepes, <em>TV-Kammerkonzert</em> (Südwestfunks, 1973)</li><li>Narciso Yepes, <em>Ser instrumento</em> (1989): 18</li><li>Joaquín Rodrigo, “Mi guitarrista,” <em>El Mundo</em> (4 May 1997): 48</li><li>Salvatore Cosentino, “Fundamentally Sound: A Talk with Oscar Ghiglia,” <em>Guitar Review</em> 115 (1999): 12</li><li>Joe Saltzman, “Narciso Yepes: Life, Music Hung by a 10-String Guitar,” <em>The Los Angeles Times</em> (22 October 1982): 12</li><li>William Starling, <em>Strings Attached: The Life &amp; Music of John Williams</em> (2012): 101</li><li>Alejandro Bruzual, “Entrevista a Leonardo Balada” (2008)</li><li>Bruce Duffie, “Composer Leonardo Balada: A Conversation” (1998)</li><li>Ivor Mairants, “Narciso Yepes,” <em>B.M.G.</em> 58, no. 672 (April 1961): 207</li><li>Graham Wade, “Segovia and the Spanish Character,” <em>Classical Guitar</em> 10, no. 1 (September 1991): 36, 38</li></ul><h4>Secondary Sources</h4><ul><li>Isaiah Berlin, <em>The Roots of Romanticism</em> (1999): 98, 117</li><li>Fernando Díaz-Plaja, <em>The Spaniard and the Seven Deadly Sins</em> (1971): 48f</li><li>Thor Eckert Jr., “Opera at Carnegie Hall?,” <em>The Christian Science Monitor</em> (17 November 1982)</li><li>Vladimir Jankélévitch, <em>Music and the Ineffable</em> (1961/1983): 45</li><li>Charles M. Joseph, <em>Stravinsky Inside Out</em> (2001): 240</li><li>Edmund L. King, “What Is Spanish Romanticism?,” <em>Studies in Romanticism</em> 2, no. 1 (1962): 8</li><li>José Ortega y Gasset, <em>The Dehumanization of Art</em> (1925/1968): 47</li><li>Caroline Rae, “Henri Dutilleux and Maurice Ohana: Victims of an Exclusion Zone?,” <em>Tempo</em> 212 (2000): 22–28</li><li>Michael Saffle, “Yepes Delights Guitar Aficionados,” <em>The Stanford Daily</em> (6 November 1973): 6</li><li>D. L. Shaw, “Towards the Understanding of Spanish Romanticism,” <em>The Modern Language Review</em> 58, no. 2 (1963): 191</li><li>F. Courtney Tarr, “Romanticism in Spain,” <em>PMLA</em> 55, no. 1 (1940): 35</li><li>Richard Taruskin, <em>Text &amp; Act: Essays on Music and Performance</em> (1995): 167</li><li>Richard Taruskin, <em>The Danger of Music: And Other Anti-Utopian Essays</em> (2008): 395, 443</li><li>Graham Wade, <em>Traditions of the Classical Guitar</em> (1980)</li><li>Graham Wade, “Segovia — A Centenary Celebration: Part III,” <em>Classical Guitar</em> 11, no. 8 (April 1993): 31</li></ul><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=81645dab107b" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[In Memory of Dr. Gerald Florian Messner (22 February 1937–2 June 2026)]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@10string/gerald-florian-messner-1937-2026-8b767654013b?source=rss-8026079d565e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/8b767654013b</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[death-and-dying]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ethnomusicology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[music]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[memoirs-and-histories]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[culture]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Viktor van Niekerk]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 03 Jun 2026 12:00:23 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-06-04T12:50:44.164Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>A personal tribute to a musician, scholar, and friend</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/851/0*yZsHJJbo2e8GLdYw.jpg" /><figcaption>Florian Messner (1937–2026)</figcaption></figure><p>When my then-girlfriend told me she wanted to introduce me to a couple called “Florian and Lala,” I almost declined. The names conjured images of hippies — airy-fairy, crystals-in-the-water-jug types I have no patience for.</p><p>Florian did keep crystals in his water jug.</p><p>He also stocked his guest bathroom with gag toilet paper bearing George W. Bush’s face on every sheet. He produced a taro-root fish curry unlike anything with an identifiable nationality. He served nothing but imperial-grade matcha and gyokuro (Japan’s most luxurious loose-leaf green tea) — genuine connoisseurship, held in permanent tension with an unfiltered, scatological sense of humour that treated pretension as an open invitation. He invariably told stories of the “wise fool” Mullah Nasruddin, then laughed his <em>Schadenfreude</em> snicker — an impish, fricative “ch-ch-ch” — before he had quite finished the punchline.</p><p>The man who admitted me to his Sydney home in the late-2000s was tall and broad-shouldered; handsome in his youth, which photographs from his acting years confirm; still, in his late sixties, a charmer and a hugger. His messages invariably closed with “A big hug and lots of love” — and he meant it. His name was Dr. Gerald Florian Messner, and he died on 2 June 2026, aged 89.</p><p>He was one of the most genuinely learned, wise, and deeply kind people I have ever known.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/572/0*kkgdsK2FZ56d4xn2.jpg" /><figcaption>Florian in “Man of La Mancha” in Hamburg.</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*9xf8iqh08hPJjcF7.jpg" /><figcaption>Florian in “Der Fall Harrer” (1986), a feature film directed by Antonis Lepeniotis.</figcaption></figure><p><strong>The man</strong></p><p>Born on 22 February 1937 in Bad Eisenkappel, in the bilingual Carinthian region of Austria, Messner accumulated credentials over the course of his life that resist summary without sounding like a parody of polymathic overachievement. He trained as an actor and director at the Max Reinhardt Seminar in Vienna. He took a doctorate in comparative musicology at the University of Vienna in 1975, his dissertation addressing the vocal polyphony of the Bulgarian village of Bistritsa. As an actor performing under the name Gerald Florian, he debuted in 1961 in a production of Dostoyevsky’s <em>The Idiot</em> at the Volkstheater Wien, and went on to appear on the stages of the Burgtheater Wien, the Volksoper, the Theater am Kurfürstendamm in Berlin, and in ORF television productions and Austrian feature films. He subsequently held academic posts in Vienna, at Deakin University in Australia, and as a guest professor at UCLA’s Department for World Arts and Cultures. He broadcast, composed, painted, and exhibited internationally — in Austria, Australia, China, the UAE, Kazakhstan — well into his late eighties.</p><p>In May 2026, he received a letter informing him that the Senate of the University of Vienna, on the recommendation of the Musicology Institute, had resolved to award him the Golden Doctorate — a ceremonial renewal of his original degree on its 50th anniversary, in recognition of exceptional scholarly achievement and continued connection to the university. The ceremony was scheduled for 29 June 2026. Travel was already a concern. He died on 2 June, nearly a month before he could have attended.</p><p>His wife, Lala, wrote to me to share the news of the honour a few days before his death. “Before,” she said, “they used to ridicule him because of his theatre background, but now they are guilding him.”</p><p>Florian, she reported, was laughing about it.</p><p>I can hear that laugh exactly.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*zcQH-M53rR-Epl0G.jpg" /><figcaption>Florian in Sri Lanka.</figcaption></figure><p><strong>The scholar</strong></p><p>Messner’s most enduring scientific contribution is the concept of <em>interferential diaphony</em> — in German, <em>Schwebungsdiaphonie</em> — which he coined to describe a specific multi-part vocal style he documented in the Bulgarian village of Bistritsa. The tradition involves singers performing polyphonically in extremely close intervals, producing microtonal friction and acoustic beating phenomena. Outsiders describe the sound as “maximally rough”; the singers themselves experience it as smooth, beautiful, and pleasant. Observers at greater remove tended to describe the result as sounding either like ringing bells or like the howling of wolves.</p><p>His 2013 study, published through Peter Lang, runs to 419 pages and engages the psychoacoustics, audiophysiology, and sonography of the tradition. His fieldwork on behalf of the Bistriza Babi — the choir of elderly Bulgarian women from Bistritsa — contributed directly to their inscription on the UNESCO Intangible Cultural Heritage list in 2005.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*d4a1yic7L1uwHvpuMgNwRA.jpeg" /></figure><p>His ethnomusicological reach extended to Papua New Guinea, the island of Flores in Indonesia, Manus Island, and Mexico. In Papua New Guinea, he documented the shark-calling rituals of New Ireland — ceremonies in which specific songs and movements were believed to summon sharks from the sea. He composed a piece for me, for ten-string guitar, based on that fieldwork: <em>The Echo of the Shark Caller</em>. He also wrote <em>Mnemosyne </em>for me, named for the Greek goddess of memory and mother of the Muses. Both pieces are characteristic of how Florian’s mind worked: scholarship and art were not separate territories but expressions of the same curiosity.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FFTbyViHY3Ls%3Fstart%3D46%26feature%3Doembed%26start%3D46&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DFTbyViHY3Ls&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FFTbyViHY3Ls%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="640" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/5dd59ad0f0d151af3eae5c5f626c0cc4/href">https://medium.com/media/5dd59ad0f0d151af3eae5c5f626c0cc4/href</a></iframe><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*-IrFwPh3pA_W4Oa4.jpg" /><figcaption>Florian with initiation “lounat” (a friction woodblock or idiophone) in Papua New Guinea.</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*HUlKaQEIELEYXq7o.jpg" /><figcaption>Florian doing field research in the highlands of Papua New Guinea.</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*QL1Ts5uI6z7iVv9h.jpg" /><figcaption>Florian doing field research on Tabar Island, Papua New Guinea.</figcaption></figure><p>He once told me, with that “ch-ch-ch” barely suppressed, that when he submitted a composition under a pseudonym he had won a prize that would have been denied to him under his own name, due to institutional prejudice against him. He found this more amusing than embittering.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fw.soundcloud.com%2Fplayer%2F%3Furl%3Dhttps%253A%252F%252Fapi.soundcloud.com%252Ftracks%252F7389238%26show_artwork%3Dtrue&amp;display_name=SoundCloud&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fsoundcloud.com%2Fgeflom%2Ftoccata%3Fin%3Dgeflom%2Fsets%2Fgilgamesh-a-chamber-opera%26si%3D5f01214651c94782a7e1bcc53b337570%26utm_source%3Dclipboard%26utm_medium%3Dtext%26utm_campaign%3Dsocial_sharing&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fsoundcloud.com%2Fimages%2Ffb_placeholder.png&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=soundcloud" width="800" height="166" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/d959a9352b8ad8b0353e510deba22177/href">https://medium.com/media/d959a9352b8ad8b0353e510deba22177/href</a></iframe><p><strong>The friend</strong></p><p>When I knew Florian in Sydney, between 2006 and 2010, he was working on the English translation of his landmark Bulgarian study. An older friend of ours named Marlene was helping him with the translation of his doctoral thesis from German. When Marlene died in 2010, he forwarded the following to her friends, including me:</p><p><em>“Marlene has gone on her final trip on this planet — last night at 1.30 she took her last breath. Her last few weeks were very peaceful. She felt she had done everything she needed to do and she was happy to go. Once, a while ago, when I asked her whether she was afraid of death she told me: ‘I have had a very full and rich life. And, you know: I am so curious! / </em>Und weißt Du, ich bin ja so neugierig!<em>’ So I hope and trust she has enjoyed the trip and has gone to a good place.”</em></p><p>I returned to that message when Florian died. Those weren’t his words — but I found myself thinking of the resonance between Marlene’s attitude and his own: the unsentimental warmth towards the dead, the genuine curiosity about what follows, the “I hope and trust” offered without irony or the embarrassed qualification that secular academics tend to append to such language.</p><p>Our Friday afternoons followed a ritual. I would arrive with my guitar after he had finished recording his German arts programme for SBS Radio. We would prepare lunch together — I scrubbed the vegetables with Veggie Wash, multiple passes, in the precise way he expected. He would cook. Whatever he produced belonged to no particular culinary tradition; it was its own thing. I remember his purple taro mash, and a fish curry with taro root that had no right to be as good as it was. Always the gyokuro, always the matcha, always something outrageously irreverent — unfiltered in the way that only the genuinely learned and the genuinely kind can get away with — followed by that impish snicker.</p><p>We talked through lunch and well into the afternoon/evening about anything: <em>The Mahabharata</em> and Hildegard von Bingen; isorhythmic motets of the fourteenth century and J.M. Coetzee; Apuleius’ <em>The Golden Ass</em> (one of his favourite books, and the proposed subject of a collaborative opera that never materialised as our lives diverged after 2010); Sufi poetry; Rumi; the wise-fool tales of Mullah Nasruddin; medieval proportionality in music; quantum mechanics; cinema... His knowledge of music history (especially “early music”) put to shame every oxygen-thieving occupant of institutional musicology I have since encountered. He had, in passing, studied voice with the last student of Luisa Tetrazzini. He practised Tai Chi Chen-style under Grandmaster Chen Xiaowang for over a decade. He had survived a heart attack as a young man, and a gas explosion that destroyed his Austrian home and most of his compositions.</p><p>Florian had strong musical opinions and was not shy with them; his criticism could be scathing. With me, it never was. His role in my musical formation was not to correct or instruct but to confirm: that my interpretive intuitions were legitimate, that I did not need to second-guess them.</p><p>He wrote, in an academic reference letter:</p><p><em>“Viktor van Niekerk is an exceedingly gifted, sensitive and intelligent musician, artist and extremely talented and promising scholar who has been conducting valuable research in all the disciplines of his specialisations.”</em></p><p>I am not certain I have lived up to it. But I carry it.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/proxy/1*JEo1VVuzQN5MnbqHaPwzmA.jpeg" /></figure><p><strong>What he gave</strong></p><p>Florian was there during the most difficult period of my life. In 2009, when I was in a very dark place, he was simply there — with his time, his knowledge, his warmth, his conversation, his cooking, his presence. It is not an exaggeration to say he saved my life.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*6j0gNvLCOqgJ8E9POEUB5w.jpeg" /></figure><p>I left Sydney in 2010. On my last day, I left him my art supplies. I like to think they played some small part in the extraordinary late flourishing of his visual practice: the paintings, dense with mythological content and the vivid, saturated palette of someone who heard colour and painted sound, that would go on to be exhibited in Austria, Shanghai, Abu Dhabi, and Astana (Kazakhstan) where he spent his last years. Reviewers in Abu Dhabi described his 2013 solo exhibition as the “main event” of the day. He was seventy-six.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/795/0*imHeZ30f5tcFDFj_.jpg" /><figcaption>“Caves, Lakes, and Streams of Mnemosyne” (Florian Messner, 2013, acrylic on canvas)</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/813/0*XhRxmoVEC7rksEB5.jpg" /><figcaption>“Insideout” (Florian Messner, oil on canvas)</figcaption></figure><p>In one of his last filmed appearances, he told <em>The Astana Times</em>: “My advice is follow your intuition and be consistent and don’t give up. And if you can’t do that, then don’t touch the arts at all.”</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.instagram.com%2Freel%2FC7059WHs_DW%2F&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=instagram&amp;display_name=Instagram&amp;src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.instagram.com%2Freel%2FC7059WHs_DW%2Fembed%2F%3Fcr%3D1%26v%3D14" width="400" height="711" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/52331fba9029253cafe1ee705723ecc5/href">https://medium.com/media/52331fba9029253cafe1ee705723ecc5/href</a></iframe><p>On 2 June 2026, Lala wrote to me from Florian’s instant messaging account:</p><p><em>“Hello Victor, this is Lala. I have very sad news: Florian passed away today. Please pray for him 🙏”</em></p><p>And, shortly after:</p><p><em>“Yes, it is devastating for me and all of us, but he was ready to go, he told me on Sunday that death was calling him. He was not very well. We will discuss this later. 🙏 Love and hugs, L”</em></p><p>He was ready. Like Marlene before him — <em>“Und weißt Du, ich bin ja so neugierig!”</em> — I am certain he was curious, too.</p><p>Florian often quoted a stanza from Sir Richard Francis Burton’s Sufi-inspired philosophical poem <em>The Kasidah</em> (1880):</p><blockquote>Cease, Man, to mourn, to weep, to wail;<br>Enjoy thy shining hour of sun;<br>We dance along Death’s icy brink,<br>But is the dance less full of fun?</blockquote><p>A big hug and lots of love, dearest Florian. I hope and trust you have enjoyed the dance.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fw.soundcloud.com%2Fplayer%2F%3Furl%3Dhttps%253A%252F%252Fapi.soundcloud.com%252Ftracks%252F7386380%26show_artwork%3Dtrue&amp;display_name=SoundCloud&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fsoundcloud.com%2Fgeflom%2Fthedance%3Fin%3Dgeflom%2Fsets%2Fgilgamesh-a-chamber-opera%26si%3D6a6c9ae6b4a44a4dba38e5611882b4fc%26utm_source%3Dclipboard%26utm_medium%3Dtext%26utm_campaign%3Dsocial_sharing&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fsoundcloud.com%2Fimages%2Ffb_placeholder.png&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=soundcloud" width="800" height="166" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/44830418ba7132428fe70f53729ca6e4/href">https://medium.com/media/44830418ba7132428fe70f53729ca6e4/href</a></iframe><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/540/0*AnSI1kQGTSiqTTCm.jpg" /><figcaption>Cancun (Mexico). Florian at sunrise.</figcaption></figure><p><em>Dr. Gerald Florian Messner is survived by his wife, Lala. The University of Vienna had intended to award him the Golden Doctorate on 29 June 2026, in recognition of fifty years of exceptional contribution to ethnomusicology.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=8b767654013b" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[While the Guitar Looked the Other Way]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@10string/guitar-modernism-paradigm-shift-d69d7dc91535?source=rss-8026079d565e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/d69d7dc91535</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[music-theory]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[contemporary-classical]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[music-history]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[guitar]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[classical-music]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Viktor van Niekerk]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 01 Apr 2026 10:52:51 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-04-01T12:41:37.238Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Amongst the most significant living composer-performers working today — figures whose combined audiences dwarf anything the classical guitar world has produced in decades — a Modernist settlement that dominated Western art music for most of the twentieth century has been quietly, thoroughly dismantled. Not through polemics. Through practice.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*-ny03fPCHSvf4TsrFOgbnw.png" /><figcaption><strong>Image 1 (Felt):</strong> <em>Opening of “Remain” (Viktor van Niekerk, 2026), rendered on Hamburg Steinway D with felt preparation (Pianoteq 8). Energy concentrates in the fundamental and lower partials; upper partial content falls away steeply. This is the spectral signature of the tonal world today’s leading composer-performers have deliberately chosen: dark/warm, sustained, fundamentally concentrated. It is also analogous to the acoustic signature of the “Yepes” sound.</em></figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*OJAaJUVsJ33T7NSrCt6AWg.png" /><figcaption><strong>Image 2 (Steinway):</strong> <em>The same passage, same instrument, without felt preparation. Upper partial energy extends prominently across the frequency range; attack transients are sharper and more spectrally dispersed. </em>This is analogous to the spectral signature of the tonal ideal the classical guitar establishment has spent decades treating as its standard — and that today’s most significant living composer-performers have spent the same decades moving away from.</figcaption></figure><h3>I.</h3><p>The Modernist performance ideology, in its earliest and most naive form, rested on a deceptively simple claim: the score was the work. A fixed object, authoritative and complete, to which the performer owed fidelity. The Romantic concept of <em>Werktreue</em> — fidelity to the work — quietly collapsed into fidelity to the text. Deviation was not interpretation; it was transgression. The performer’s subjectivity was an obstacle to be disciplined. “Correct” execution — accurate, precise, emotionally restrained — was the goal.</p><p>This was the position of the young Stravinsky, laid out in the <em>Poetics of Music</em> and enacted in his early performance editions. It was also, broadly, the position of his contemporaries — Ravel, Toscanini, and others who shared the Modernist suspicion of Romantic expressive “excess.”</p><p>But Stravinsky himself did not hold it for long. Over the course of his career he came to recognise an irreducible gap between his intentions and their textual representation — between what he heard in his mind (or wanted to hear) and what notation could capture. His response was characteristic, and characteristically rigid: he shifted the locus of authority from the score to the recording. His own recordings, he implied, were his intentions made audible — and therefore the standard against which performances should be measured. The recording replaced the score as the fixed object. The ideology of reproduction remained intact; only the thing to be reproduced had changed.</p><p>It was this later, recording-centred version of the ideology that Segovia absorbed and transmitted to the classical guitar world. Players were expected not merely to be faithful to the score but to reproduce — the word is exact — Segovia’s recorded performances. Where Segovia had not recorded a work, the recordings of his anointed heirs served as substitute. Deviation remained a transgression. The hierarchy remained vertical. The performer’s task remained reproduction rather than (re)interpretation.</p><p>What makes this history particularly revealing is what happened next — or rather, what happened to Stravinsky but not to the classical guitar establishment of the twentieth century. Towards the end of his life, Stravinsky arrived at a position he could not have held in his youth: that nothing is stable. That his own tempo feelings had changed over time, sometimes dramatically. That the recording that had seemed definitive at one moment could not be definitive for all moments, because the music itself — even music as rigid as his — was not the fixed object he once touted it to be but something alive and mutable. The ideology of reproduction, which had defined his public position for decades, quietly dissolved under the weight of his own experience.</p><p>The classical guitar establishment didn’t follow him. It froze at the stage Stravinsky had already passed through and discarded — the stage at which recordings are authoritative, at which the master’s performance is the standard, at which fidelity to a fixed model is the measure of seriousness. Even the shadow originator of the “classical guitar” movement’s beliefs had evolved beyond those positions. The guitar world looked the other way.</p><p>And the broader musical culture moved on entirely.</p><h3>II.</h3><p>Consider the following, from the published score of one of the most widely heard composer-pianists working today — a figure whose music reaches audiences of millions through streaming and live performance, and whose sheet music is now in wide circulation:</p><blockquote>“My music shouldn’t be played too accurately — most of the pieces were improvised and transcribed directly from the record. I would maybe change some notes if I could travel back in time. So if you happen to modify the pieces you can be sure that I like the idea. Make the music yours and play it loudly and quietly to yourself and others. This book is meant to make you create your own melodies, tempi, and sounds.” <em>(2022)</em></blockquote><p>The score is not the work. It is a <em>transcription</em> — the composer’s own word — of an improvised performance that was itself unrepeatable: “Most of my recordings are improvised takes. If I played them today, they would be different.” The notated object is explicitly provisional, explicitly imperfect, explicitly open. Modification is not merely tolerated — it is welcomed as evidence that the invitation has been understood. And the ethical direction is precisely reversed from the Modernist position: “I really mean it, I even insist on it.”</p><p>Where Stravinsky’s performer or Segovia’s pupil transgresses by deviating from the fixed object, this composer’s performer transgresses by failing to deviate. The ethical poles have been swapped entirely.</p><p>In a companion volume (2018), the same composer goes further. Of a specific piece he writes: “The piece has yet to be finished by the composer — me or you. When you are feeling comfortable with playing what you are reading, feel free to try different notes in the bass or even invent new chords.” The work is not merely open to interpretation; it is structurally incomplete without the performer’s creative contribution. The composer explicitly shares the title of creator. And in the same volume’s general introduction, the position is stated with disarming directness:</p><blockquote>“I would suggest to play as much as possible by ear. If you get stuck, you can still look it up, but don’t be bothered with being overly exact. Do you feel like changing a note or skipping another one? Does a pause seem too long or too short for your ears? Change it then! Be brave! Playing my pieces live, I always change them slightly. I feel they should be in progress rather than set in stone.”</blockquote><p>The injunction to be brave is not rhetorical. Bravery is required precisely because the accumulated weight of the Modernist tradition — the edition, the authoritative recording, the master’s interpretation — presses in the opposite direction. He knows what he is asking. And then, characteristically, he frames the entire score as “a colouring book: Here are the shapes and outlines. It’s up to you to pick your favourite colours.” The score as outline, not as object. The performer as colourist, not as conduit. Music as something that happens between the page and the player, not something stored in the page and transmitted through the player.</p><p>Another leading composer-pianist of the present moment — a figure whose debut album spread rapidly across the world through digital platforms before he had any conventional classical career — opens his published score with a single word that repays attention: he calls it “the transcription of the music that appeared on” his album (2018). Not the score or the work. The <em>transcription</em> of the music. The <em>music</em> exists elsewhere… The notation is an after-the-fact representation of <em>something</em> that came first and cannot be fully captured. Like the first composer, he is explicit about the consequence: “It doesn’t matter if you play it ‘perfectly’ as, well, there isn’t such a thing if you ask me.”</p><p>There is no correct reading. This is not a consolation offered to the technically inadequate. It is a statement about what music <em>is</em>.</p><p>A third composer-pianist distils the same position to its essentials: “I compose not by writing, but by instinct, and without rules.” (2022) And: “There are as many ways to play the piano as there are pianists. Trust your inner self.” The hierarchy of text over performer, rule over instinct, structure over expression — the entire armature of Modernist performance ideology — is simply absent. Not argued against. <em>Absent</em>. It does not appear as a position to be refuted because it does not appear as a position at all.</p><p>A fourth figure, a multi-instrumentalist, addresses the same question from a different angle. He has omitted dynamics from his piano scores entirely — not through carelessness but on principle: “I have found, in playing these songs over the years, that my own dynamics naturally change over time, sometimes in a subtle way and sometimes more drastically… I encourage anyone who plays these songs to make them their own, swelling dynamically in whatever way feels right.” (2017) And on the score itself: “As someone who has tended to write music purely by listening and feeling, there is something almost unnatural about trying to transcribe that music onto paper. In many cases it feels as if the notation is simply not enough.”</p><p>Note carefully what he is and is not saying. He does not find transcription — in the conventional sense of adapting music for a different instrument — unnatural. He finds representing music through notation unnatural. The written score is the inadequate object; the music it attempts to represent is something else, something that resists capture.</p><p>Across these four representative figures — independent of one another, working in different countries and contexts, with no shared manifesto — the same cluster of positions recurs with striking consistency. The score is a provisional trace, not an authoritative object. The performer is a co-creator, not a servant of the text or even the recording. There is no single correct reading, because there is no fixed target. Instinct and feeling are not obstacles to musical understanding but its primary instruments. And the ethical relationship between composer and performer runs not from authority downwards but as an invitation outwards — towards the performer’s autonomy, not away from it.</p><p>This is not a school. It is a paradigm.</p><h3>III.</h3><p>The ideological shift documented above has a direct acoustic counterpart — and this is where the classical guitar world’s situation becomes precise.</p><p>The music these composer-pianists make is not merely philosophically incompatible with the Modernist aesthetic that tacitly undergirds Segovia’s “classical guitar” movement. It is spectrally incompatible with it. The tonal world these composers inhabit is warm, dark, resonant, and sustained — the opposite, in every acoustic particular, of the bright, transient-rich, dynamically compressed, fleet, and <em>détaché</em> sound the classical guitar establishment has spent decades treating as its ideal.</p><p>Three specific instrumental practices, each explicitly adopted by leading figures at the cutting edge of contemporary classical music, make that tonal world concrete — and each of them, by an acoustic logic that is not metaphorical, points directly to the 10-string guitar of Narciso Yepes as a medium aligned with the present musical moment.</p><p>The first is the <em>una corda</em> piano — a technique in which the soft pedal shifts the hammer so that it strikes a single string rather than the full unison group. One of the most widely performed composer-pianists working today has spoken of his love for this sound: its characteristic warmth derives precisely from the fact that the unstruck strings, tuned to the same pitch, continue to resonate sympathetically. Two acoustically coupled sound sources: one struck, one resonating freely in response. The 10-string guitar, in Yepes’s standard tuning, operates on the same principle. You attack one treble string; a sympathetic bass string immediately begins to resonate — untouched, unstruck — at the same frequency, that is, one of its natural partials. The structural identity is exact, not approximate.</p><p>The second practice is the felt piano — a preparation in which a strip of felt is placed between hammer and string, producing a darker, transient-reduced sound. This is not an isolated preference. It is a practice shared across the most prominent figures defining contemporary classical music today, and its acoustic signature — warmth, reduced attack, spectral emphasis on the fundamental rather than the upper partials — is analogous to the tonal ideal the Yepes school pursued on the guitar and the classical guitar establishment has spent decades resisting. The preference for felt piano sound in this musical world is not incidental to its aesthetic. It is constitutive of it.</p><p>The third practice is the near-ubiquitous use of the sustain pedal — which, for one of the most performed composer-pianists of the present moment, is not a resource to be deployed selectively but a permanent feature of the sonic environment. The pedal is essentially down throughout; only periodically lifted and reset. This means the music lives continuously inside a sympathetic field, with resonances accumulating, decaying, and interacting across the full sonic spectrum. The 10-string guitar provides this environment structurally, through its sympathetic resonator strings, without any additional mechanism. The 6-string guitar cannot provide it: its sympathetic resonance is partial and uneven across the twelve pitch classes, structurally limited to E’s, B’s, A’s, and D’s. The instrument is acoustically misaligned with the expressive logic of today’s music at its most fundamental level.</p><p>These are not metaphors or loose analogies. They are descriptions of the same acoustic preference — a preference for sustained resonance, warm spectral balance, and structural support for melodic and harmonic movement — arriving independently from three different directions. The music today’s leading composers make requires a specific resonant environment. The 10-string guitar provides that environment. The 6-string, and the tonal ideal the classical guitar establishment has built around it, do not.</p><p>A handful of classical guitarists have attempted to engage with this repertoire — transcribing isolated pieces, cautiously acknowledging composers at the forefront of the present moment. The results have been instructive. The instrument fights the music. The bright, transient-forward, and non-sustaining sound, the uneven sympathetic resonance, the pedagogically enforced technique — none of it meets today’s music on its own terms. The 6-string guitar can, at most, render the notes — in many cases, not even that. But it cannot enter the sonic world of the twenty-first century.</p><p>The classical guitar establishment is not defending a tradition. It is defending a historical moment — a specific, dateable, Modernist moment — whose aesthetic premises have been quietly abandoned by the most significant living composer-performers working today. The tonal ideal it resists, the instrument it dismisses, the performance philosophy it has suppressed: all of these align, with a precision that is not coincidental, with the music that is now reaching the largest and youngest audiences in the post-classical world.</p><p>The instrument suited to this moment already exists. It has existed since 1964. The guitar world simply hasn’t noticed.</p><p><em>Viktor van Niekerk is a classical guitarist specialising in the 10-string guitar system of Narciso Yepes.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=d69d7dc91535" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Three Thoughts on Classical Guitar Tone and Resonance]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@10string/classical-guitar-tone-resonance-modernism-e899dbe17f5d?source=rss-8026079d565e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/e899dbe17f5d</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[music-theory]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[classical-music]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[guitar]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[culture]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Viktor van Niekerk]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 25 Mar 2026 13:47:12 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-03-31T12:30:30.367Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Bz-s7uf2USZwM_uNSxhi4Q.jpeg" /><figcaption>The final note of the Sarabande from J.S. Bach’s Cello Suite №2 in D minor, BWV 1008 — rendered on harpsichord (left) and cello (right) — captured as spectrograms at the moment of attack. The harpsichord’s energy is scattered thinly across a wide spectral range. The cello’s is concentrated on the fundamental and the first few partials. That concentration is what carries in a hall. Spectral glare is not acoustic strength. The analogy to classical guitar tone is direct: the bright, spectrally dispersed sound the establishment treats as the norm corresponds to the harpsichord; the darker, fundamentally concentrated tone it resists approaches the cello.</figcaption></figure><p><strong>I.</strong></p><p>The classical guitar world has a tone problem — not in the sense that its players produce bad tone, but in the sense that it has lost the ability to evaluate tone honestly.</p><p>Start with the most basic confusion. A large part of the guitar establishment quietly equates brightness with quality. Acoustically, this is backwards. Projection in a hall is not determined by high-frequency content. It is determined by energy in the fundamental (the written note), energy in the first few partials, and temporal stability — sustain. When the fundamental collapses and the spectrum is dominated by upper partials, the sound becomes thin and localised. It may seem clear at close range, but it does not carry. This is why the instruments historically most admired for projection and tonal beauty — the cello, the viola, the human voice — are spectrally darker, not brighter. Purer, not more complex. Sustaining, not staccato. This is why a live harpsichord all but disappears in the midst of even the smallest ensembles. It is also why guitar harmonics — apparently very soft but spectrally pure — actually carry remarkably well in concert halls. Their near-total spectral concentration reduces inharmonic interference and produces a cleaner, more coherent signal at distance — carrying farther despite lower absolute energy.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*zHo2gmaL77KwSTL-jyfoqw.png" /><figcaption>Guitar harmonics from Narciso Yepes’s performance of Sor, Op. 60 №25. The preceding normal notes show a characteristic spread of partials. The harmonics show near-total spectral concentration (with sustain) — which is precisely why they carry in a hall despite their apparent softness.</figcaption></figure><p>The guitar establishment has systematically confused spectral glare with acoustic strength.</p><p>How did this confusion become so entrenched? Partly through a recording illusion that almost nobody discusses. Modern tone judgement is shaped overwhelmingly by digital recordings consumed on laptop speakers, phones, and cheap headphones. These systems favour narrow dynamic range, compressed signals, and strong high-frequency content. They make mediocre tone sound better than it does in reality. A purer, darker tone that projects effortlessly in a concert hall can therefore appear dull or recessed on consumer playback equipment, because the spectral balance that makes it powerful in space is precisely what gets flattened — and worse, distorted — by the digital chain and the majority of today’s playback devices. Players have been quietly optimising their tone for budget-to-mid-tier recording and playback equipment for decades, not for acoustic reality — not for human ears in real-world spaces. The result is an entire pedagogical culture calibrated to the wrong instruments: the laptop, the cellphone — not the hall, and not direct contact with human listeners.</p><p>Underneath this lies a much older sociological mechanism. When most members of a field share a limitation, the group tends to redefine the limitation as a virtue. Mediocre orchestras redefine rhythmic rigidity as precision — or “historically informed performance.” The protected denizens of the groves of Academe redefine pretentious jargon as intellectual rigour. Bureaucracies redefine paralysis as prudence. In the guitar world, the thin bright tone that most players produce most easily has quietly become the standard — not because it was ever demonstrated to be acoustically superior, but because it is common. Any middling player can produce it. Anything outside it becomes automatically suspect. The standard is not an achievement. It is a consensus built around the mean.</p><p>The psychological mechanism reinforcing this is equally predictable. When a player encounters a tone they cannot easily produce, two explanations are available: either that tone represents a higher degree of control, or it is defective. The second explanation is psychologically far easier to adopt. It requires no re-examination of one’s own beliefs and limitations. It protects the existing hierarchy. So the tone that requires the most control — the most virtuosity, in another, always-overlooked sense of the word — gets labelled as “bad,” “unpleasant,” etc. by the very players least equipped to produce it. This is not analysis. It is ego-protection dressed as criticism and “taste.”</p><p>What makes this psychological defence so durable is the sunk cost it protects. Producing a darker, purer, projecting tone is not simply a matter of adjusting a habit. It requires relearning from first principles — guitar positioning, nail conditioning, and the fundamental mechanics of right-hand touch. It is incompatible with the standardised orthodox technique that has dominated pedagogy for roughly three to four decades. In other words, acquiring it means discarding years — sometimes decades — of accumulated practice and rebuilding from the ground up. That is a demand most established players will not face. It is far easier, psychologically and practically, to declare the destination unreachable and undesirable than to acknowledge that the road one has spent a lifetime on leads somewhere else. The establishment’s attacks on darker, more projecting tone are not aesthetic judgements. They are sunk-cost rationalisations.</p><p>The establishment presents this “preference” as “tradition.” It is not. Pre-twentieth-century instrumental aesthetics consistently aimed towards vocal models: sustained tone, strong fundamental energy, projection, warmth. The thin, bright, dynamically compressed guitar tone treated today as the “historical sound” or “classical ideal” is a twentieth-century construction, coinciding precisely with the Modernist aesthetic Richard Taruskin documents in <em>Text &amp; Act: Essays on Music and Performance </em>(1995) — the same aesthetic that produced the neo-classical Stravinsky’s deliberate emotional austerity, Schoenberg’s rejection of Romantic warmth, and a broader cultural flight from the sustained, projecting, voice-like tone that Western music had pursued for centuries. The classical guitar establishment did not discover a timeless acoustic truth. It absorbed a hundred-year-old fashion and forgot it was a fashion.</p><p>Which leaves one question the establishment cannot answer without exposing itself:</p><blockquote>Is the modern classical guitar tone ideal an acoustic achievement — or a rationalisation of technical limits that happened to align with a Modernist aesthetic whose moment has passed?</blockquote><p><strong>II.</strong></p><p>Every discussion about guitars with more than six strings starts from a false baseline: that the six-string guitar is the historical norm, and everything else requires justification.</p><p>History says the opposite. Guitars with more than six strings were standard before the Segovia era — to say nothing of lutes. The standardisation of the six-string guitar is a contraction. It is the historical deviation. And that contraction was not acoustically motivated. It was aesthetically motivated — within a historical context that has passed. As Taruskin documents in <em>Text &amp; Act</em>, twentieth-century classical music systematically moved towards thin, lightweight, dynamically miniaturised sound. In that post-Stravinskian context, the six-string guitar’s limitations were not a problem to solve. They were the point.</p><p>This is why the instrument’s resonance architecture was never fixed — and why that word, “fixed,” still makes the establishment uncomfortable.</p><p>On a six-string guitar, sympathetic vibration is structurally uneven. Some notes receive reinforcement. Others receive none. But these resonances and gaps do not map onto musical meaning — they actively invert it.</p><p>Consider one of the most fundamental gestures in tonal music: the leading note resolving to the tonic. In A minor, the melody reaches G# — the leading note — sustains it, intensifies it, drives towards its resolution. That G# is one of the most expressive moments in the entire piece — possibly the most. Every note before it has been driving towards it. Anything after it resolves away from it. The entire expressive weight of the work converges on that one sound.</p><p>On a six-string guitar, that G# receives no open-string<strong> </strong>sympathetic reinforcement. Meanwhile, any already-sounding E, B, A, or D continues to assert itself — the notes that frame the resolution, not the tension. (The oft-invoked phenomenon of “mud.”) The instrument is structurally built to amplify the predictable and discard the expressive at precisely the moment expression is most required.</p><p>And it is worse than silence. When G# lacks its own resonance, the previous harmony does not simply stop. It bleeds forwards. The resonance that should have receded — subducted, overshadowed by a new and stronger G# resonance — fills the space where the leading note should be ringing with maximum clarity, sustain, and tension. The most expressive note in the piece is obscured by harmonic residue from what came before it. Then the tonic A arrives, not as resolution, but with insistence — the most predictable, least meaningful moment, emphasised by the instrument as if it were the point.</p><p>The instrument systematically undermines the expressive logic of the music at its most fundamental level.</p><p>Information theory makes the cost of this precise — not merely audible. In any tonal system, not all notes carry the same musical information. The tonic is the most predictable event in the system: the point of maximum stability and therefore minimum information. It is the musical equivalent of “<em>Hello. How are you? I’m fine, too, thank you.</em>” The leading note is its opposite: unstable, directional, charged with expectation. The same applies to other dissonances. The expressive energy of tonal music accumulates before the tonic, not on it.</p><p>This structural bias has direct, audible consequences in performance. Segovia’s recorded interpretations often place interpretive weight (Segovian warbles) on moments of open-string resonance — notes that happen to ring, and lend themselves to emphasis, not notes that carry the greatest harmonic tension. Williams’s well-known recording of <em>Asturias</em> closes with dynamic emphasis on the final tonic — the most predictable, least informationally dense event in the piece. No serious classical musician — pianist, violinist, singer — would structure an interpretation around the tonic in this way. The instrument’s resonance architecture has shaped the classical guitar’s idiosyncratic performance culture, and that performance culture has in turn defined what “expression” means on the classical guitar. The standard has been built around the instrument’s structural weaknesses, not around music.</p><p>The instrument amplifies the least informative event in the phrase and weakens the most informative one.</p><p>That is not a subjective claim about expression. That is not a matter of taste. The instrument is structurally biased against musical meaning itself — and that bias is measurable.</p><p>Narciso Yepes designed his 10-string guitar — his standard tuning — to eliminate this mechanism. Every pitch class has its sympathetic string. New resonances continuously subduct the old ones. The instrument follows melodic and harmonic movement rather than working against it. And it simultaneously extended the playable bass range — both problems solved, not one.</p><p>But here is the false distinction the “multi-string” or “extended-range” guitar world has quietly constructed, as a niche within the orthodoxy: they imply that Yepes addressed only resonance whilst they also address range — as if Yepes never played low bass notes, and as if their instruments share the same resonance architecture as his. This is either dishonest or displays a complete failure of understanding. Yepes’s instrument solved both problems simultaneously. Theirs solve one and exacerbate the other. The chromatic resonance gap remains on every guitar that has not addressed it specifically, regardless of string count. The leading note still has no voice. The bleed is still there, in those gaps. The “mud” the establishment routinely complains about is the acoustic evidence of their own instruments’ structural failures — attributed, conveniently, to the concept of sympathetic resonance itself.</p><p>A further manoeuvre follows from this. The same clique frames Yepes’s 10-string system as best suited to 12-tone or atonal music — implying that their own instruments, resonance gaps intact, are somehow more appropriate for tonal music. The inversion is precise, and it is not accidental. The chromatic resonance problem is a <em>tonal</em> music problem. Atonal music has no tonic, no leading note, no tension-resolution syntax — the resonance gap does no particular expressive damage where there is no expressive hierarchy to invert. Yepes’s solution matters most exactly where tonal syntax is most active. The clique has taken the argument that most damages them and reversed it: attributing the instrument designed to serve tonal music to the repertoire where its advantages are least relevant, whilst claiming their own acoustically unreformed instruments are better suited to the music they structurally compromise.</p><p>Such manoeuvres are intended to declare the problem understood, and close the conversation. But the conversation has never been had at the level of granularity it demands.</p><p>The question that remains is simple:</p><blockquote>If an instrument can be designed so that its resonance architecture supports melodic and harmonic movement across all twelve pitch classes — so that the leading note and other expressive moments may ring as clearly as the tonic — what is the <em>musical</em> argument against doing that?</blockquote><p>The classical guitar establishment has no answer to that question that does not expose itself as fundamentally Modernist — which is to say, not of today, but of the previous century.</p><p><strong>III.</strong></p><p>The same instrument that has been optimised for spectral glare rather than projection is also the instrument whose resonance architecture amplifies the least expressive moments in a phrase. These are not two separate problems. They are two symptoms of the same historical condition.</p><p>If the six-string guitar systematically reinforces predictable notes whilst failing to reinforce those carrying the greatest expressive tension, then the instrument is not a neutral vehicle for tonal music. It is biasing it — quietly pushing tonal music away from tension-driven harmonic movement and towards static sonority.</p><p>That bias is visible throughout the instrument’s repertoire: open-string tonal centres, sonority-based writing, modal colour, relatively static harmony. These characteristics are routinely described as “natural guitar writing.” They are not. They are compensations — adaptations of the repertoire to the structural weaknesses of the instrument.</p><p>A significant portion of what the classical guitar world calls its idiomatic language is simply the repertoire accommodating an acoustically compromised instrument.</p><p>Once that is acknowledged, the question changes entirely.</p><p>An instrument designed so that sympathetic resonance supports all twelve pitch classes no longer fights the basic syntax of tonal music. It supports it. For the first time.</p><p>Which means the question is no longer “why add strings?”</p><p>The real question — the one the establishment will not face — is this:</p><blockquote>Why has the classical guitar world spent decades defending an instrument whose resonance architecture systematically undermines the expressive logic of the music it claims to serve?</blockquote><p>There is only one honest answer. And it is the same answer that explains the entire history of resistance to Yepes’s innovation: the six-string guitar’s limitations were never a problem to be solved. Under a Modernist aesthetic, they were a virtue. The thin, the contained, the statically sonorous — these were not failures. They were the goal.</p><p>That goal belonged to a historical moment that has passed. The instrument’s defenders have not noticed.</p><p><em>Viktor van Niekerk is a classical guitarist specialising in the 10-string guitar system of Narciso Yepes.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=e899dbe17f5d" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Interview with Fritz Buss]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@10string/fritz-buss-narciso-yepes-10-string-guitar-interview-0e72ed0b2854?source=rss-8026079d565e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/0e72ed0b2854</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[music-history]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[music]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[classical-music]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[guitar]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[documentary]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Viktor van Niekerk]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 25 Dec 2025 20:05:06 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-12-26T07:29:28.279Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>An Insider’s Portrait of Narciso Yepes</h4><p><em>Conducted by Viktor van Niekerk, Johannesburg, 2004</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*tOPAkc3t8su9BFfoN5IMVw.png" /><figcaption>Fritz Buss, 1960s</figcaption></figure><p>Fritz Buss was born in Cologne on 26 December 1930. At 23, he settled in South Africa where he founded the Classical Guitar Society of South Africa in 1958. In 1960, Narciso Yepes invited him to study in Madrid. After a year’s intensive work with Yepes, Buss returned to his career as concertist and educator. He undertook further periods of study with Yepes in ’64, ’66, ’68, ’73 and ’75, earning such respect that he was invited to substitute as instructor for some of Yepes’s master classes in Paris, July 1975.</p><p>As concertist and educator, he was responsible for the acceptance of the guitar as a subject in schools and as a major instrument for the B.Mus. degree in South Africa. There he also introduced the 10-string guitar, adopted by several of his students during and after his three decades as the guitar instructor at Wits University. As the leading teacher of both 6- and 10-string guitar in South Africa, his pupils included, amongst many others, Simon Wynberg, Viktor van Niekerk, Tessa Ziegler, and the late guitarist-composers Timothy Walker, David Hewitt, and Dietrich Wagner. He gave sought-after annual master classes in Belgium, at the request of Godelieve Monden, and was invited to be a judge, alongside figures like Joaquín Rodrigo, at the 1981 Francisco Tárrega Competition (Benicàssim).</p><p>He has also composed a substantial amount of music for the guitar. He studied composition privately with Richard Cherry (1958–1960) and Michael Wolfson (1967–1972), but only found the time to write after ending his career as concertist, in October 1982, to focus exclusively on teaching and composition. His works include <em>30 Studies</em>, based largely on Yepes’s right-hand techniques.</p><p>He has lived in Brisbane, Australia, since retiring from teaching in 2019.</p><h3>What Others Have Said About Fritz Buss</h3><p>“Teaching is for me a great pleasure when I find a pupil of intelligence, who assimilates my conclusions with his own knowledge, developing his own personality. This is the case with Mr. FRITZ BUSS. … I can state that it is astonishing to what an extent he has imbibed the basic and profound knowledge demanded of a conscious artist.”<br><strong> — Narciso Yepes, reference letter, 20 August 1961</strong></p><p>“I feel very proud of him as my pupil and as my friend. … Fritz has become not only an excellent guitarist with a wonderful technique but also a deep musician aware of his responsibility and always in search of more knowledge and perfection. … I think that he is one of the best teachers I know in the world.”<br><strong> — Narciso Yepes, September 1976, in Fred Kazandjian’s <em>Fritz Buss and the Classical Guitar in South Africa </em>(1983)</strong></p><p>When asked <em>¿Quiénes son los mejores profesores de guitarra en todo el mundo?</em> (Who are the best guitar teachers in the entire world?), Yepes replied: “<em>En la Escuela de Lovaina (Bélgica), enseña Godelieve Monden. En África del Sur hay un profesor llamado Fritz Buss.</em>” (“At the School of Leuven in Belgium, Godelieve Monden teaches. In South Africa there is a teacher called Fritz Buss.”)<br><strong> —José Luis Rubio, <em>ABC Cultural</em> 7(43), December 1991</strong></p><p>“Fritz Buss is a man of infinite patience who will take endless pains to ensure that a pupil has clearly understood a particular point. I was always amazed by his ability to communicate his enthusiasm and love for the guitar, which is both reassuring and inspiring. Mr. Buss can also inspire and fascinate by his own playing on the guitar, thus demonstrating that the instrument can produce music on equal terms with any other instrument.<br> “It is one of his qualities as a born teacher that Fritz Buss encourages his students to become individuals and to express themselves on the guitar in their own way. He is quick to spot a particular gift and to encourage a pupil to develop this ability to the full.”<br><strong> — Dietrich Wagner, 1982, in Kazandjian (1983)</strong></p><p>“I have no hesitation whatsoever in saying that he stands out amongst the finest musicians and teachers I have known in my career in a number of countries, including Britain and the United States of America.”<br><strong> — Joe Sack (cellist-composer and critic), 26 August 1976, in Kazandjian (1983)</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*5rYIQsR26vKL0BrRIeaSag.png" /></figure><p>“…a society which seems, generally, to encourage mediocrity and shows confusion, and even hostility, when confronted with greatness. These and related subjects used to leave Fritz Buss furious, resulting in some very tough lessons for me to learn. I now realise that it was largely due to the frustration of trying to project himself into my future so as to help me through all those pains and setbacks any ambitious musician is bound to go through.<br> “My lessons with Fritz were so inspirational and his enthusiasm so contagious that my transition from popular to classical music seemed the most natural thing for me to do, as he guided, and sometimes pushed me into a world I hadn’t known existed.”<br><strong> — David Hewitt, 1983, in Kazandjian (1983)</strong></p><p>“South Africa’s leading guitar soloist … keeps busy with a large teaching connection and is in constant demand for concerts and recitals. An attractive personality and an entertaining conversationalist...”<br><strong> — <em>B.M.G. </em>LXIII(735),<em> </em>July 1966</strong></p><p>“Buss … gave a most interesting and varied recital. … The phrasing was perfect and the finesse truly professional. … Buss’s musical interpretation … was outstanding. The chromaticisms … and carrying melodic line were all played with feeling and expertise which were truly remarkable in their execution. … Buss put across the romantic feeling with delicacy. The two pieces by Savio … showed that Buss was master of all aspects of guitar pyrotechnics.”<br><strong> — Margaret Nabarro (reviewing Buss’s final public recital), <em>The Star</em>, 26 October 1982</strong></p><p>“He has raised the standard of performance in this instrument to a very high level indeed, and in fact has contributed to a large extent in achieving the same for the guitar on a national level in South Africa.<br> “Mr. F. Buss is conscientious, gives his students of his best, is well liked and respected by them. During the years he has been associated with us, he has achieved international recognition as a teacher and our University is fortunate in having a person of his calibre on its staff.”<br><strong> — Prof. D.J. Reid (Director of the Wits Conservatoire of Music), 24 August 1976, in Kazandjian (1983)</strong></p><p>“Through exhaustive and dedicated work, Mr Buss has brought about a position that today, there are many competent players in this country, our concert-going public enthusiastically support guitar recitals, and many international guitarists have expressed their surprise and pleasure at the advanced musical standard that we maintain.”<br><strong> — Lee Goodman (Chair of the Classical Guitar Society of South Africa), 1976, in Kazandjian (1983)</strong></p><p>“… Fritz Buss, warmly acknowledged as the father of the [classical guitar] genre in this country …”<br><strong> — <em>South African Jewish Report</em>, 15 May 2009</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*X7rPxVwA5fBYbwAxTcVtzA.png" /><figcaption>Letter from Narciso Yepes to Fritz Buss (excerpt), dictated to and signed by Marysia Yepes, 3 March 1975</figcaption></figure><h3>The Interview</h3><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FoYl9is2IaX8%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DoYl9is2IaX8&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FoYl9is2IaX8%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/b01f15ed5dec7ae6d896d7d954c7b805/href">https://medium.com/media/b01f15ed5dec7ae6d896d7d954c7b805/href</a></iframe><h3>Studies with Yepes</h3><p><strong>Viktor van Niekerk</strong>: <em>Fritz, you had the opportunity to meet Andrés Segovia in 1956 when he visited South Africa to perform at the Johannesburg Music Festival. I understand that he was pleased with your playing. What happened during this meeting?</em></p><p><strong>Fritz Buss</strong>: Well, it was very interesting and, for me, very nerve-wracking. Not much happened really, I just played for him — several things — and he said, “Well, you haven’t had a teacher, but that sometimes might be better than having one.” [<em>Laughs</em>.] Subsequently he offered me the opportunity to come to study with him at one of his master classes in Santiago de Compostela [or Sienna, Italy].</p><p><strong>VvN</strong>: <em>You were initially more interested in Segovia than Narciso Yepes.</em></p><p><strong>FB</strong>: Oh yes! We all were. At that time he was <em>the</em> man, and he was the only one that was making many recordings. So we were all interested, in more or less degrees, in Segovia. Yes, definitely. Of course, I also had heard a recording of Yepes. But somehow I just didn’t take notice of it because, I think, we were all so influenced and taken by Segovia that when it came to many other recordings we didn’t really listen.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*QFKYjxP4Gb98rkAwxqySHg.png" /><figcaption>First meeting between Fritz Buss and Narciso Yepes, Jan Smuts International Airport, Johannesburg, June 1960</figcaption></figure><p><strong>VvN</strong>: <em>In June 1960 (four years after you met Segovia) Yepes visited South Africa for what became the first of his numerous concert tours of the country. What was your impression of Yepes after attending this recital, and why had it changed?</em></p><p><strong>FB</strong>: Well, I think, for me the main event was when Yepes played Bach’s Chaconne — his own transcription — and also, I noticed immediately that he had a different sitting stance. He played in a different way from the positions that we were all using at that time. That was the first thing that struck me before he even started to play. However, my biggest impression was definitely that Chaconne. I’d never, ever heard such clarity, such separation of contrapuntal lines, and not a single mistake whatsoever — not that that is very important — but I was utterly and completely stunned at that performance.</p><p><strong>VvN</strong>: <em>Both Yepes and Segovia invited you to study with them. Why did you take up the offer from Yepes?</em></p><p><strong>FB</strong>: Well, after Segovia invited me to go to Santiago de Compostela I was encouraged and really started working. Through Segovia I got the method by Emilio Pujol and I really worked through that as much as I could. So I had another four years of working very hard on the instrument. Then, after hearing that performance of Yepes in the Great Hall of Wits University, I made sure that I would meet Yepes. I met him and I played for him. During that meeting an idea occurred to me and I said, “Would you like to go to the Kruger National Park?” and his eyes lit up and became very big. He said, “Yes! Yes!” He looked at his schedule and we had about four days. I took one of my students, Timothy Walker, with and the three of us went to the game reserve. Before we left, Yepes said, “But take your guitar, I want to hear you again.” So I took my guitar along to the Kruger Park where we had a beautiful time and every night I played for him and he played for us. I asked him to go through the Chaconne. He said, “I’m very happy because I have just written out the Chaconne from memory and sent it to Marysia, my wife, and she told me I didn’t make a mistake.” After that meeting I met him once or twice more and he said to me, “I will write to you in September and if I am in Madrid next year then you can come and study with me.”</p><p><strong>VvN</strong>: <em>Your first official lesson with Yepes was on 5 January 1961, and you spent most of that year studying with him in Spain. What was his approach to teaching the guitar?</em></p><p><strong>FB</strong>: Well, first of all, he always had an underlying kindness towards his students — or towards me anyway, I can only talk of my own experience — towards the nervous and shivering student in front of this Maestro. But the first thing he said to me was, “You have to realise, we are not just learning the guitar now — we are learning about music, because that is the most important thing. We only make use of the guitar to express the music.”</p><p><strong>VvN</strong>: <em>How did studying with him influence your own teaching?</em></p><p><strong>FB</strong>: One thing is not to break a pupil down. People have come to me even if they have little talent but with the desire to play. Who am I to say, “You are no-good”? That’s a bad thing to do. You have to find a way, and I must say, in most cases they all learn something and they’re happy and the guitar becomes a way of life for them. And always to say that music is something that you take with you through your life. Often they ask me, “How long will it take me to learn the guitar?” My answer is always: forever.</p><p><strong>VvN</strong>: <em>This was Yepes’s philosophy as well, wasn’t it? To focus only on the positive and always to strive for greater perfection.</em></p><p><strong>FB</strong>: That’s right. He always concentrated on my strong points. He never ran me down. He never made me feel inferior. I had three lessons with him in a week and some mornings I would say to him, “Mr Yepes, today I don’t feel like playing.” He used to say, “Okay, come, let’s have some coffee. We will talk.” And there I learnt perhaps as much, if not sometimes more, than I did in the lessons.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*hg0VKtFPI0Hod3xozBhSyA.png" /><figcaption>Fritz Buss and Narciso Yepes, Torrevieja, summer 1964 — the friendship beyond the lessons</figcaption></figure><p><strong>VvN</strong>: <em>What was the most important thing you learnt from him?</em></p><p><strong>FB</strong>: The most important is to put the music first. Music, guitar, yourself, in that order. But, Yepes had a way of learning music that is impossible for me and perhaps for many guitarists to do, which was that he never touched the guitar until he had thoroughly studied and memorised the score. He had the fortunate ability that whatever he read he could hear perfectly and was therefore able to tell, before he picked up the guitar, what the composer was after. That was in particular with regard to the modern works. With the traditional works most of us already hear them in our minds. But with anything new, like the Concerto [<em>Trois Graphiques</em>] by Maurice Ohana, he would look over the music for hours, sort of mumbling, like singing, in a way. [<em>Laughs</em>.] He had very bad eyesight, so he had a magnifying glass and he hovered about two or three inches over the score with his left eye, reading and memorising the music.</p><p><strong>VvN</strong>: <em>You think he had an eidetic memory? Is it also true that, in order to get around, he would memorise maps of new cities he travelled to for his concert tours?</em></p><p><strong>FB</strong>: That’s right. And there is one thing I’d like to mention here that put a lot of people off. They didn’t understand. If you first met Narciso, he would look at you and then his eyes would flick very rapidly to left, right, left, right, left, right and then stop. At that moment — because there were several holes in his vision — he then had seen your face and now remembered your face. And that action often put people off because they did not understand his situation.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2F8pPbqFkofdg%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3D8pPbqFkofdg&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2F8pPbqFkofdg%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/267c8797113c3684e31bdb35fa6f4f93/href">https://medium.com/media/267c8797113c3684e31bdb35fa6f4f93/href</a></iframe><h3>The 10-String Guitar</h3><p><strong>VvN</strong>: <em>Of course, when you first met Yepes, and subsequently during your first period of study in Spain, he was still using a six-string guitar. However, I believe you had first-hand experience of his dissatisfaction and his search for a new instrument.</em></p><p><strong>FB</strong>: Oh yes, this is very important. This really was something. This happened to be some time in March [or early] 1961. Timothy and I went to Yepes’s concert, which was an all-Bach concert, of his lute music, played on the six-string guitar. While he was playing I felt this uneasiness in him. So when the concert was finished and we went to get some coffee, I said to him, “Narciso, I had the feeling you were not happy.” He said, “How can I be happy? I only played half of Bach.” So I asked him, “What do you mean?” He said, “Yes. All the music I had to rearrange, leave the basses out or play them at a higher octave. I know that tonight there were very important musicians and people in the audience and I felt that I had cheated them by playing only half of Bach.”</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2Fab2fSbCwEWk%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3Dab2fSbCwEWk&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2Fab2fSbCwEWk%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/592be26f33046ec8683292c820367cc4/href">https://medium.com/media/592be26f33046ec8683292c820367cc4/href</a></iframe><p><strong>VvN</strong>: <em>In your practical experience, how much of an improvement did the 10-string guitar offer? And what other benefits are there in using the 10-string?</em></p><p><strong>FB</strong>: Well, apart from the obvious, that you can use it for baroque music and also in modern music where you have the opportunity of using the extra strings, I still play much of the traditional guitar repertoire. The 10-string balanced out the overtone [i.e., sympathetic resonance] situation by a very large degree. It makes the instrument far more balanced. If there are overtones [i.e., resonances] you don’t want, stop them. It’s as simple as that, but on a six-string you don’t have that choice. As Yepes used to say, “I cannot stop something that I don’t have.” If there was a disruptive overtone he was perfectly capable of stopping it. It is impossible for me, now, to play a six-string guitar for any length of time because I wouldn’t hear what I want to hear. I couldn’t interpret the way I would like to, especially in slow movements. On the six-string guitar one always has this <em>Tonangst </em>[“tone anxiety”], a fear of running out of sound. On a 10-string you can perform and interpret, especially slow movements, far better than on a six-string guitar.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/proxy/1*_qh6UYSsdlrk7uIRPx6ijg.png" /><figcaption>Fritz Buss, 1970s</figcaption></figure><h3>Technique and Performance</h3><p><strong>VvN</strong>: <em>Aside from his instrument, what made Yepes different from his contemporaries?</em></p><p><strong>FB</strong>: Well, one could never say to Narciso that something is impossible. He took the example from his teacher, [Vicente] Asencio, who said to him, “Can you do this on the guitar?” And he played for him some <em>prestissimo</em> scales on the piano, in a beautiful <em>legato</em> way. And Yepes said, “No, no, we can’t do that.” And Asencio said to him, “You have so much talent. Why do you play this instrument and not the violin or piano?” This is when Yepes started to develop new techniques that enabled him to do what could be done on the piano. If you listen to his playing, especially in fast passages, it’s almost like a pianist. Now, I know we can’t sound exactly like pianists — we don’t have to sound like pianists — but at least we can learn from them as far as the music is concerned. Definitely. Anyone who has his later recording of the <em>Concierto de Aranjuez</em>, just to mention one thing, could listen to the last few bars of the second movement, to that trill, which sounds like a pianist would play it. Listen to most other guitarists and you hear them battling, trying to slur these notes. Yepes, however, had invented a technique to play such trills with three fingers of the right hand. That is just one little example, and there are many of them. I have based some of my own <em>30 Studies</em> on that technique, the three-finger playing of fast figures, trills, scales, and so on. Perhaps today this is no longer anything surprising, but at that time certain guitarists picked up on the fact that Yepes used three fingers to play scales and denounced this. It is a ridiculous mentality. It’s just as well as telling a pianist never to use his thumbs.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*wjwyyJNQjXDnNFfU3YxWVg.png" /><figcaption>Yepes’s right hand, photographed by Fritz Buss during their time together in Torrevieja, summer 1964</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*n9-eHb_zU2nXzv6NZnqrJg.png" /><figcaption>Yepes’s right hand, photographed by Fritz Buss during their time together in Torrevieja, summer 1964</figcaption></figure><p><strong>VvN</strong>: <em>Which of his recordings would you recommend to listeners?</em></p><p><strong>FB</strong>: One I would say is his all-Tárrega recording [1983]. Then he did a whole disc of Scarlatti [1985], which I think is just unreal. To me that record is superior to anything I’ve ever heard. The other one is a disc of Rodrigo’s solo guitar works [1987]. I don’t know how he plays like that, because I hadn’t seen him after that recording. It’s not that we lost touch, but I never had the opportunity to ask him about that. Those three records in particular and I would also mention his first recording of the Bach Chaconne [London Records, CM 9270], which was still on a six-string. It was just an unbelievable recording. It’s very old. You’ll not find it anymore, but I still have it, and it’s full of scratches. [<em>Laughs</em>.]</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2Fvideoseries%3Flist%3DPL8NEE_w73Kr18k0isC5_NYuziRY-KJPmu&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fplaylist%3Flist%3DPL8NEE_w73Kr18k0isC5_NYuziRY-KJPmu&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FmlNaY6g2Wag%2Fhqdefault.jpg%3Fsqp%3D-oaymwEXCOADEI4CSFryq4qpAwkIARUAAIhCGAE%3D%26rs%3DAOn4CLAQBvxbRx4i8_yK8zTPiuIbxachTw%26days_since_epoch%3D20447&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="853" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/03a230c4f99751a291bdec08221e6bb5/href">https://medium.com/media/03a230c4f99751a291bdec08221e6bb5/href</a></iframe><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2Fvideoseries%3Flist%3DPL8NEE_w73Kr0ujqRlue8s3pqcg2rEhS79&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fplaylist%3Flist%3DPL8NEE_w73Kr0ujqRlue8s3pqcg2rEhS79&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FvHQbhvevnm0%2Fhqdefault.jpg%3Fsqp%3D-oaymwEXCOADEI4CSFryq4qpAwkIARUAAIhCGAE%3D%26rs%3DAOn4CLBOOnFfgc7n3jdY-42aXZS08CCzuw%26days_since_epoch%3D20447&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="853" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/a4cce94f9540be89300315f2f59f9fbd/href">https://medium.com/media/a4cce94f9540be89300315f2f59f9fbd/href</a></iframe><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2Fvideoseries%3Flist%3DPL8NEE_w73Kr0sSiXzoMG4eGVn8lJRNaBB&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fplaylist%3Flist%3DPL8NEE_w73Kr0sSiXzoMG4eGVn8lJRNaBB&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FysjS5FfIttU%2Fhqdefault.jpg%3Fsqp%3D-oaymwEXCOADEI4CSFryq4qpAwkIARUAAIhCGAE%3D%26rs%3DAOn4CLDKL7Kn94Ia7bWn4xGnVl2nPFleGw%26days_since_epoch%3D20447&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="853" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/983cd0f08fc8f80324b1fa7229f497e5/href">https://medium.com/media/983cd0f08fc8f80324b1fa7229f497e5/href</a></iframe><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2Fuj8BRY-EQSQ%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3Duj8BRY-EQSQ&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2Fuj8BRY-EQSQ%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="640" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/a84b532e7ce59b3f962140f88b587440/href">https://medium.com/media/a84b532e7ce59b3f962140f88b587440/href</a></iframe><p><strong>VvN</strong>: <em>You always have entertaining stories to tell, stories which one would have to experience first-hand, in an oral setting, to appreciate fully. Nonetheless, would you share a memory of Yepes’s sense of humour?</em></p><p><strong>FB</strong>: [<em>Laughs</em>.] I remember in Paris [July 1975], we were running down some big stairs after a concert at the university and a young man was running up to Yepes in the opposite direction saying, “Mr Yepes, I believe you play a 10-string guitar!” So, without stopping, Yepes said, “Yes! Yes! A string for each finger!” He had a tremendous, almost sardonic sense of humour.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*GoaImMBFuW2kNu721L0VhA.png" /><figcaption>Godelieve Monden, Fritz Buss, and Narciso Yepes (Paris, July 1975)</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*EuhhrRwB9oQgcVsNxWBmFA.png" /><figcaption>Fritz Buss and Narciso Yepes (1970s) — to Yepes’s right are Tessa Ziegler, David Hewitt, and Lee Goodman</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*sNNtqpPopxSkMm0jziQQJQ.png" /><figcaption>Fritz adjudicating the Francisco Tárrega International Guitar Competition, Benicàssim, Spain, August 1981</figcaption></figure><p><strong>VvN</strong>: <em>You also have first-hand experience of some remarkable events that underscore his exceptional abilities.</em></p><p><strong>FB</strong>: Oh my goodness! He had to play a concert in Germany [1966]. We went to check the hall and he looked at the printed programme and his face fell. He said, “But this is the wrong programme.” So he looked at me and he said, “Have you studied the Chaconne lately?” I said, “Yes, I’ve been busy with it.” He said, “Come on, let’s get to the room and go through the Chaconne. I will have to play the programme as printed, but at least let’s go through the Chaconne so I remember.” [<em>Laughs</em>.] For about two hours we worked on the Chaconne and then, that night, he just sat there and played a different concert than what he had imagined he should play.</p><p><strong>VvN</strong>: <em>How did it go?</em></p><p><strong>FB</strong>: Oh, absolutely 100%. There was nothing wrong with it. In any event, whenever Yepes came to South Africa he usually sent in about four or five different programmes, plus two or three concertos for us to choose from. He would just play any of them. He had, without a doubt, the biggest repertoire of any guitarist. There are no two ways about that. He had an enormous repertoire.</p><p>Also, I remember an incident in Paris when a young man at a master class was having trouble with the fingering of <em>The King of Denmark’s Galliard</em> by John Dowland. Looking at the music, Yepes took his left hand and put it on his right forearm, worked out the fingering, wrote it in pencil, took the guitar, and just played it. [<em>Laughs</em>.]</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FcuSPQoeQv6o%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DcuSPQoeQv6o&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FcuSPQoeQv6o%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="640" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/319e731ab2e763ffc6ac3aca414a8f6c/href">https://medium.com/media/319e731ab2e763ffc6ac3aca414a8f6c/href</a></iframe><p>There was also an incident when he had to play a concert in Windhoek [Namibia]. It was a particularly difficult concert. He played, among other things, the Asencio suite [<em>Collectici íntim</em>]. And just as he was playing his second piece there was a power failure. Not a light in sight. You just saw this shadow sitting on the stage, just continuing, just carrying on, playing as if nothing had happened. So at the interval I rushed backstage; I said, “Narciso, what are we going to do?” He said, “Nothing. I have the habit.” [<em>Laughs</em>.] I said, “Would you like candles?” He said, “No, no, they flicker. No, no, I’m fine. There’s nothing to be done. I have the habit.” So he played the whole concert in the dark.</p><p>On the plane to this concert in Windhoek, I asked him to help me a little with the fingering for the Second Lute Suite by Silvius Weiss, which he had transcribed for 10-string guitar. I had the music with me, which he had given me. So he took the whole suite, pulled out his fountain pen, and proceeded for the next half an hour [<em>laughs</em>] to write all the fingering for all the movements from memory. I’m sure some other musicians could do that too, but for me it was a revelation.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/875/0*eid2OKxiqwy0e7o5.jpeg" /><figcaption>Excerpt from Yepes’s autograph manuscript of Weiss’s Sonata 2: Sarabande (bars 9–15)</figcaption></figure><p><strong>VvN</strong>: <em>What advice do you have for today’s young players?</em></p><p><strong>FB</strong>: I would like to say, you don’t have to imitate Yepes, but listen. Listen carefully and you will hear things you do not hear with many other guitarists. You will hear not just guitar playing, but first and foremost the ideas behind the composers’ music. Listen to his performance of the <em>Concierto de Aranjuez</em>, especially the slow movement and the cadenza. Listen carefully and you will hear what the guitar is really capable of doing. Narciso always told me to listen. Listen to orchestras. Listen to modern music. Listen to the great musicians. That’s where you learn.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*7d9tXVLiY2dm7KX79S3xqQ.png" /><figcaption>Fritz’s master classes in Belgium (1980s)</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*a5mnumK1eWmLq_oxPIBtFA.png" /><figcaption>Fritz’s master classes in Belgium (1980s)</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*wnJneWPlAyA_XuL4SiZoaQ.png" /><figcaption>Viktor van Niekerk and Fritz Buss — collaborating on forthcoming publications (2013)</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*whXDRjdVzHSOTaN1oGAWfQ.png" /><figcaption>Fritz Buss (2014)</figcaption></figure><p><em>This interview originally appeared on tenstringguitar.info in the early 2010s. (The author has not been associated with that website for several years and it can no longer be trusted as a reliable source.) This material — and more — is explored in depth in Viktor van Niekerk’s forthcoming documentary </em>A Meeting of Minds<em>, which chronicles Fritz Buss’s artistic career and his studies and friendship with Narciso Yepes. The documentary offers an unprecedented portrait of Yepes’s art from the perspective of a fellow guitarist who was simultaneously student, teaching assistant, and friend — an insider’s view that reveals dimensions of Yepes’s musicianship inaccessible to critics, orthodox guitarists, or even family members observing from outside the artistic process.</em></p><p><em>Copyright © 2004, 2025 by Viktor van Niekerk. All rights reserved.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=0e72ed0b2854" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Who Invented Narciso Yepes’s Ten-String Guitar? Dismantling Six Decades of Misattribution]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@10string/who-invented-yepes-10-string-guitar-8e62c83d0b41?source=rss-8026079d565e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/8e62c83d0b41</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[music-history]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[innovation]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[classical-guitar]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[musical-instruments]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[patent-law]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Viktor van Niekerk]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 14 Dec 2025 21:09:19 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-12-14T22:12:26.236Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*U3UTOd-rN8GHfaKe0_5WRw.png" /><figcaption><em>Narciso Yepes with his 10-string guitar.</em></figcaption></figure><h3>Introduction: The Legal Framework</h3><p>In patent law, the distinction between an <em>inventor</em> and a <em>non-inventor contributor</em> is fundamental and fact-specific. An <strong>inventor</strong> conceives the core inventive <em>idea</em> or solution that makes the invention <em>novel and non-obvious</em>. A <strong>non-inventor contributor</strong> assists with routine fabrication tasks or follows instructions during the development process.</p><p>The key criterion is contribution to the <strong>inventive concept</strong> as defined by the patent claims. Conception — <em>the mental formulation of the solution</em> — is what matters, not “<em>reduction to practice</em>” (building or testing the invention). Supervisors who direct projects are not automatically inventors unless they contributed to the actual inventive <em>concept</em>. A musician who conceives a solution to a musical problem on a particular instrument is the inventor; an instrument maker who then builds a prototype realising that solution is a non-inventor contributor who merely reduces the invention to practice.</p><p>This distinction is universal in patent law. It determines who rightly receives credit in history, whose name appears in encyclopaedias, and whose contribution is understood by future generations. Over the course of six decades, the invention of the particular ten-string guitar played by Narciso Yepes has been systematically misattributed — first to luthier José Ramírez III, later to composer Maurice Ohana, and even to eighteenth- or nineteenth-century harp-guitarists. All three claims collapse under scrutiny.</p><p><strong>The inventor was Narciso Yepes.</strong> The evidence is overwhelming, documented in Ramírez’s own writings, contemporaneous journalism, and Yepes’s detailed technical explanations. What follows dismantles six decades of false attribution.</p><h3>I. The 1965 Smoking Gun and Genesis of the Invention</h3><p>In January 1965 —ten months after the instrument’s delivery —<em>Guitarra Magazine</em> publishes an interview with Yepes (Sherry 1965a) that demolishes every element of Ramírez’s later narrative. Asked about the instrument’s origin, Yepes states:</p><blockquote><em>“The idea for this 10 string guitar </em><strong><em>came to me 16 years ago</em></strong><em> when I became completely dissatisfied with the uneven resonance of the 6 string guitar, no matter who played it. I </em><strong><em>completed the plans</em></strong><em> for this instrument recently and </em><strong><em>presented them to Jose Ramirez</em></strong><em>. At seeing the plans, Sr. Ramirez thought I was insane. But, after awhile he agreed to start making the instrument. </em><strong><em>During the process of making the guitar he called me many times to say he was giving up the project saying it was impossible.</em></strong><em> After many months of work Sr. Ramirez called me to say the guitar was completed. When I arrived at Sr. Ramirez’ workshop, he handed me the guitar and said, ‘let’s see you play it’, which I did not do. Instead, </em><strong><em>I took the guitar home and practiced. 15 days later I gave my first concert</em></strong><em> with the 10 string guitar, it was an overwhelming success.” (p. 14)</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>SHERRY: “We understand you have a patent on this new guitar.”<br>YEPES: “That is correct.” (p. 16)</em></blockquote><p>This account, published contemporaneously in January 1965, establishes:</p><p><strong>Fourteen-year conception period (1949–1963):</strong> Yepes identified the “uneven resonance” problem in 1949 — <strong>fourteen years before approaching Ramírez </strong>(sixteen years before the 1965 interview). This wasn’t collaboration; it was systematic development of a solution to a long-identified problem.</p><p><strong>Completed plans presented to Ramírez:</strong> Yepes arrived with finished specifications, not vague ideas. “Completed plans” = complete conception. Ramírez’s role was execution, not co-development.</p><p><strong>Ramírez thought the design was “insane” and “impossible”:</strong> This confirms Ramírez didn’t understand the acoustic and musical reasoning. A co-inventor wouldn’t think his own design was insane. Ramírez was a sceptical fabricator being asked to build something beyond his comprehension.</p><p><strong>Ramírez repeatedly tried to abandon the project</strong>: “During the process… he called me many times… saying it was impossible.” This is not collaboration — it’s reluctant fabrication by someone who doesn’t grasp why the design works.</p><p>Yepes later revealed the full context of Ramírez’s initial refusal. From Reeder’s 1982 radio interview, published in <em>Guitarra Magazine</em> (1984: p. 10):</p><blockquote><em>“In the </em><strong><em>summer of 1963</em></strong><em> I spoke with Ramirez, the guitar maker in Madrid, and I told him </em><strong><em>I had an idea for a long time</em></strong><em> and I tell you this because </em><strong><em>I would like for you to build a 10 string guitar</em></strong><em>. He said, ‘What! A 10 string guitar!’ Then I showed him many pictures from several museums about instruments which had more than 6 strings, for example 18 strings or 10. Then I showed him a Torres guitar which had 11 strings [</em>i.e., the guitar played by Antonio Jiménez-Manjón<em>]. He was very surprised because he did not know that guitar existed. Then I mentioned again that I wanted him to build for me a 10 string guitar. He said, </em><strong><em>‘No, that is impossible!’</em></strong><em> I said, ‘O.K. if it’s impossible don’t worry about it, </em><strong><em>I will go tomorrow to Barcelona and have Fleta make the 10 string guitar</em></strong><em>.’ Fleta and Ramirez were at that time the only great guitar makers. Then he said, ‘O.K. I shall think about it.’ </em><strong><em>After much thought, he said he would try to make the guitar</em></strong><em>.”</em></blockquote><p>These exchanges prove:</p><ul><li>Yepes initiated the commission with “completed plans” developed over fourteen years</li><li>Ramírez didn’t know guitars with more than six strings — hyperhexachordal guitars — existed</li><li>Ramírez dismissed the concept as “impossible”</li><li>Only the threat to commission Ignacio Fleta — Ramírez’s primary competitor — forced agreement</li><li>Ramírez’s capitulation was competitive, not collaborative: “O.K. I shall think about it”</li></ul><p>If Ramírez had “invented” or “co-developed” the ten-string, why would he initially refuse to build it? Why would Yepes need to threaten to take the commission to a competitor? The sequence makes sense only if Yepes was the inventor commissioning fabrication of his design.</p><p><strong>Mastery in 15 days</strong>: Yepes received the instrument on 1 March 1964 and practised for fifteen days. On 15 March, he organised a private house concert, inviting non-guitarist musicians — violinists, critics, etc. — to hear the same programme performed twice: once on six-string, once on ten-string. From the same Reeder interview:</p><blockquote><em>“Then I asked them to decide with their ear of musicians and not with an ear and their habit of guitarist — because they were not guitarists — to tell me which guitar they preferred that I take to Berlin. They were very excited with this idea.<br> “I played the program, some of the pieces twice, once with 6 string and then with the 10 string guitar. After the experiance [</em>sic<em>] everybody said you must go with the 10 string guitar because it sounds much better. You must imagine at that moment I did not play the 10 string like I do now because I had the instrument for only two weeks.” (</em>ib<em>.)</em></blockquote><p>Five days later (20 March 1964), Yepes debuted the ten-string publicly in Berlin. This systematic preparation — fifteen days of intense practice, a controlled A/B comparison before non-guitarists (to avoid guitaristic prejudice), unanimous approval, then public debut — demonstrates the conception-to-mastery continuity of an inventor who understood exactly what he had created.</p><p>This directly contradicts Ramírez’s later claim (<em>Things About the Guitar </em>[1994], p. 140) that the guitarist initially “resembled a first-year student” yet performed on the instrument “five days” later. Ramírez’s account makes the instrument seem alien to Yepes, breaking the conception-to-mastery continuity that proves authorship. Yepes’s contemporaneous account reveals systematic preparation by someone who had spent fourteen years developing this solution.</p><p>These accounts establish the actual timeline of invention and confirm Yepes’s contemporaneous claim to sole authorship. When asked: “We understand you have a patent on this new guitar,” Yepes responded: “That is correct.” (Sherry 1965a: 16) Whether or not a formal patent was granted, Yepes’s 1965 claim — undisputed by Ramírez or anyone else at the time — establishes that all parties understood: Yepes was the inventor.</p><h4>Yepes’s Long Development Arc</h4><p>Yepes’s 1965 statement that the idea “came to me 16 years ago” reflects a conception period beginning in 1949 — long before Ramírez, Ohana, or anyone else entered the picture. This wasn’t whim or sudden inspiration; it was systematic problem-identification that would take fourteen years to develop into “completed plans.”</p><p><strong>The Context of 1949 — An Established Artist Identifies a Problem:</strong></p><p>By 1949, Yepes was no student or amateur player making casual observations. He had already performed and premiered several new works (e.g., those by Manuel Palau) and was actively touring Europe as a highly-regarded concert guitarist, building on his successful Madrid debut with Rodrigo’s <em>Concierto de Aranjuez</em> (1947). In January 1949, Joaquín Rodrigo stated that Yepes was a guitarist “before whom the most certain triumph lies” (quoted in Pérez Castillo [2014]: p. 63).</p><p>In May 1949, <em>B.M.G.</em> reported on an international broadcast live from Geneva (see Appleby 1949: p. 166):</p><blockquote><em>“Not since Segovia’s visit to England have I heard such an outstanding and masterly performance as the Rodrigo ‘Concerto’ played by Narciso Yepes. He is in the very first rank. He interpreted this ultra Spanish music with a fiery musicality I have seldom heard equalled.<br> “His technique is so effortless that one does not notice it; his tone mellow and crystal clear. He made us live the very spirit of this remarkable modern work.<br> “The Adagio movement was particularly beautiful, full of restrained and dignified feeling, and the last movement was playfully sparkling. Altogether a remarkable performance by a remarkable young man.”</em></blockquote><p>This wasn’t a student pondering vague dissatisfactions — he was a conscious artist, compared favourably to Segovia by critics of that (pre-1955) period, identifying a systematic acoustic limitation in his instrument. The resonance imbalance Yepes observed in 1949 was noticed precisely <em>because</em> his technique and musicianship had developed to a level where such structural limitations became audible and artistically constraining. When a critic notes your “tone mellow and crystal clear” and “technique so effortless that one does not notice it,” you’re operating at a level where the instrument’s acoustic foibles — not your technical skills — become the limiting factor.</p><p><strong>1961 — Fritz Buss Witnesses Continuing Dissatisfaction:</strong></p><p>Fritz Buss, who was studying with Yepes during the critical period of 1961, witnessed his mentor’s continuing dissatisfaction with the six-string — twelve years into the development process. After attending Yepes’s all-Bach recital in Madrid (around January/February 1961), Buss joined him for coffee. “I wasn’t trying to be forward,” Buss recalled, “but I had the feeling that he wasn’t happy.” Yepes confirmed he wasn’t satisfied — he felt he couldn’t do justice to Bach’s music, having to compromise bass lines by transposing individual notes up an octave or omit other elements entirely due to the six-string’s limitations.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2Fab2fSbCwEWk%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3Dab2fSbCwEWk&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2Fab2fSbCwEWk%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/592be26f33046ec8683292c820367cc4/href">https://medium.com/media/592be26f33046ec8683292c820367cc4/href</a></iframe><p>Buss observed that “maybe something was already going on in his [Yepes’s] mind — maybe just instinctive for some time, but he was not happy and he admitted it: that he felt he didn’t do justice to the music that Bach really wrote.” These forced transpositions in baroque lute music include not only the obvious moments where the bass range exceeds that of the six-string; they also frequently include contexts where it’s impossible to fret basses in the first positions of the 6th string, owing to the fact that the left hand is playing higher up the fretboard. Yepes wasn’t just pondering the guitar’s unbalanced resonance — he was also wrestling with the problem of playing Bach and baroque lutenist’s music on the guitar, without having to make undesirable leaps in bass lines (stylistically anathema).</p><p><strong>Early Foundations — Estanislao Marco and Guitars with More than Six Strings:</strong></p><p>Yepes’s early exposure to hyperhexachordal guitars arguably came from his teacher Estanislao Marco (pupil of Francisco Tárrega), who played a nine-stringed guitar. The concept of hyperhexachordal guitars was thus familiar to Yepes from his formative years — part of his musical DNA, not a borrowed idea from Ramírez or anyone else.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/proxy/1*ueSpZZ3rltUcqxlBpHAxhg.png" /><figcaption>Estanislao Marco (pupil of Francisco Tárrega), who played a nine-stringed guitar — one of Yepes’s earliest teachers.</figcaption></figure><p>As Yepes later recounted in an interview with Gabriel Estarellas, filmed at the Auditórium de Palma (Balearic Islands):</p><blockquote><em>“There was </em><strong><em>something that always bothered me</em></strong><em>, namely, why play a [6-string] guitar if we spend our lives trying to play music written for the lute, music written for the theorbo, and </em><strong><em>music written for so many instruments that had more than 6 strings</em></strong><em>? To think that in the nineteenth century the guitar was an instrument with either 6, or 7, or 8, or 10, or 11 strings. In other words, on a tour of any museum of musical instruments in Europe one can find guitars with up to twenty-two strings [</em>e.g., the 21-stringed <em>harpolyre</em> for which Sor composed several works<em>]. And I needed some strings that would give the resonance that we’ve already commented on many times, that is, resonance for each of the 12 notes of the scale.”</em></blockquote><p>A near-complete development arc can now be established.</p><p><strong>The Preliminary Timeline:</strong></p><ul><li><strong>1949</strong>: Yepes identifies the problem of the guitar’s unbalanced resonance</li><li><strong>1961</strong>: Buss witnesses continued dissatisfaction, now focused also on baroque lute music compromises</li><li><strong>Summer 1963</strong>: Yepes completes plans, commissions Ramírez; Ramírez refuses, calling design “impossible” and “insane”; Yepes threatens to commission Fleta; Ramírez reluctantly agrees</li><li><strong>1963–64</strong>: Ramírez repeatedly tries to abandon project; Paulino Bernabé Snr builds as Ramírez foreman (discussed in §XI, below)</li><li><strong>1 March 1964</strong>: Delivery, following which Yepes practises 15 days</li><li><strong>15 March 1964</strong>: Private house concert for non-guitarist musicians — Yepes performs same programme twice (six-string, then ten-string); gathered musicians unanimously prefer the latter</li><li><strong>20 March 1964</strong>: Public debut of Yepes’s ten-string in Berlin; critical approval</li><li><strong>January 1965</strong>: <em>Guitarra Magazine</em> interview confirms fourteen-year conception period (1949–63) and patent claims</li></ul><p>This sixteen-year arc makes nonsense of any subsequent “collaboration” narrative. Ramírez wasn’t collaborating on a multi-year study; he was executing a commission he initially refused, thought was “impossible,” and repeatedly tried to abandon. The “several years” of work Amalia Ramírez would later claim (discussed in §IV, below) was Yepes developing his solution — <em>before</em> approaching her father in the summer of 1963 to construct it. What Amalia recasts as multi-year collaboration was actually: brief commissioning discussion (summer 1963) → refusal → threat → reluctant acceptance → fabrication over c. 8 months or less (delegated to Paulino Bernabé) — conflated with a completely different instrument: Ramírez’s “d’amore” guitar experiment.</p><p>Everything that follows — Ramírez’s 1994 book, Amalia’s 2020s blog posts, academic claims about Ohana — must be measured against this contemporaneous testimony.</p><h3>II. The Ramírez Deception: Typographical Conflation in Things About the Guitar</h3><p>José Ramírez III’s book <em>Things About the Guitar</em> (1994) contains a two-page chapter titled “The Ten-String Guitar” (pp. 137, 140). Within this single chapter, Ramírez misleadingly describes <strong>two completely different instruments</strong> under the same rubric — a rhetorical and typographical sleight of hand that has confused readers for decades.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/proxy/1*Mlb6V50g_qZIib4o1IVvnA.jpeg" /><figcaption><em>How Ramírez misleadingly presented two acoustically antithetical instruments (his “d’amore” guitar experiment and Yepes’s ten-string invention) under the same heading.</em></figcaption></figure><h4><strong>The Two Instruments</strong></h4><p><strong>Instrument #1 — Ramírez’s “d’Amore” Guitar (Failed Prototype):</strong></p><ul><li>6 inner sympathetic strings running through a hollow neck</li><li>Tuned <em>identically</em> to the 6 outer strings: E4-B3-G3-D3-A2-E2</li><li>Allegedly inspired by the viola d’amore</li><li>Duplicating the guitar’s already-resonant pitch classes without addressing weaker notes other than G3, G4, G5, and F♯5 (via the inner — always open — G3 and B3 strings)</li><li>Result: uncontrollable resonance that “kept on resounding and muddling the continuation of the musical piece being interpreted” (p. 137)</li><li>Musically nonsensical due to this conspicuous, uncontrollable bleeding of resonances into harmonies where they don’t belong</li><li>Ultimately rejected by Andrés Segovia and Narciso Yepes as non-viable in praxis</li></ul><p><strong>Instrument #2 — Yepes’s Chromatic Resonance Lattice</strong> (i.e., the interconnected network of sympathetic resonances created by his specific tuning and arrangement of the bass strings):</p><ul><li>4 external — playable, frettable, and mutable — strings</li><li>Tuned C2-B♭2-G♯2-F♯2 (or enharmonic equivalents), 7=C being the lowest/thickest string</li><li>Specifically designed to supply sympathetic resonance for the 8 weak pitch classes on the 6-string guitar (C, C♯, D♯, F, F♯, G, G♯, B♭ or their enharmonic equivalents)</li><li>Controllable via right-hand — or left-hand — damping</li><li>Played by Yepes for over 30 years in annual concert tours of c. 120–150 engagements per year; adopted by several other guitarists across all inhabited continents</li></ul><p><strong>Ramírez’s “d’amore” concept wasn’t original </strong>— identical guitars with sympathetic strings in hollow necks date to the 1850s (e.g., Tomasz Zach, Prague), documented in period literature and patented repeatedly throughout the nineteenth century (Miner 2013). All failed commercially. Ramírez was recycling a century-old idea that the market had already rejected — one that still couldn’t solve the guitar’s resonance imbalance because it duplicated existing resonances rather than supplying strings sympathetic with the eight pitch classes that lack such support.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/proxy/1*-UoejRMZc9eDcpwEgN30xw.png" /><figcaption><em>An example of an 1850s “d’amore” guitar (Miner 2013).</em></figcaption></figure><h4><strong>Why This Typographical Conflation Is Dishonest</strong></h4><p>The two instruments Ramírez discusses under the same heading<strong> </strong>are not variations of the same concept. They are <strong>acoustically antithetical</strong>. Indeed, both instruments employ sympathetic strings, but this superficial similarity has enabled six decades of confusion. Sympathetic strings, in and of themselves, are not a concept; they are a mechanism. What matters is <em>what those strings are tuned to accomplish</em>. A scalpel and a cleaver are both blades, but one performs life-saving surgery while the other butchers meat; the blade is neutral, the application is everything. Ramírez and Yepes both used sympathetic strings to address resonance — but towards opposite acoustic goals.</p><h3>VII. The Viola d’Amore Red Herring: Why Ramírez’s Concept Was the Opposite</h3><p>One of the most persistent myths is that Yepes’s ten-string is based on the viola d’amore principle. Ramírez encouraged this confusion by placing his failed “d’amore” experiment under the same chapter heading as Yepes’s invention. But Yepes himself explicitly refuted this connection.</p><h4>Yepes Explains Why His Concept Is “Exactly the Contrary”</h4><p>From Snitzler’s 1978 interview (p. 46):</p><blockquote><em>“Normally, the tuning of the four supplementary bass strings is C, B♭, A♭, G♭. In that way I have overtones for all twelve notes of the scale. Many people have said to me that this is the same principle as that used for the </em><strong><em>viola d’amore</em></strong><em>, which was an early eighteenth century instrument with seven strings that were mounted underneath the normal ones and vibrated in sympathy. But there was a problem with that instrument: </em><strong><em>The tuning — of both the bowed strings above and the sympathetic strings below — was</em></strong><em> </em><strong><em>D, A, F, D, A, F, D</em></strong><em>, and the F was either sharp or natural, depending on whether the key of the piece was D major or D minor. Thus when you played a D you had not only the sound of that one string, but also the sound of all the other Ds on the instrument, so you had a very big D! But, when you played G, for example, you had absolutely nothing in the way of resonance. </em><strong><em>My idea of the 10-string guitar is exactly the contrary</em></strong><em> — to provide sympathetic vibration for the notes that do not have this kind of reinforcement on a normal 6-string guitar.”</em></blockquote><p><strong>This is unambiguous.</strong> Yepes states his concept is <strong>“exactly the contrary”</strong> of the viola d’amore principle:</p><p><strong>Ramírez’s “d’Amore” Guitar</strong></p><ul><li>Duplicates existing strings (E4-B4-G3-D3-A2-E2)</li><li>Reinforces already-resonant pitch classes</li><li>Worsens acoustic imbalance</li><li>Uncontrollable sympathetic vibration</li><li>Never concertised</li><li>Ultimately rejected by Segovia and Yepes</li></ul><p><strong>Yepes’s Ten-String Guitar</strong></p><ul><li>Adds acoustically and harmonically non-redundant strings (C2-B♭2-G♯2-F♯2)</li><li>Supplies only missing resonances (reinforces all the weak pitch classes across the treble strings)</li><li>Creates chromatic balance as a baseline (the performer’s <em>will</em> — not the guitar’s <em>whim</em> — can now shape the interpretation)</li><li>Controllable via right and left hand</li><li>60+ years of concert use (c. 30 years by Yepes)</li><li>Solution to the “uneven resonance” problem Yepes had identified in 1949</li><li>Solution to Segovia’s documented complaints about guitars having some “snuffed” treble notes (despite his hypocritical rejection of the solution, discussed in §§V and X)</li></ul><p><strong>Ramírez’s “d’amore” instrument would have made the guitar’s resonance problem worse, not better.</strong> By duplicating E-B-G-D-A-E, it added more reinforcement to pitch classes that were already supported whilst doing nothing for C, C♯, D♯, F, F♯ [other than the highest F♯5], G♯, and B♭ (or enharmonic equivalents) — which no doubt included the notes Segovia persistently complained about as being “weak,” “snuffed,” or “muffled” on the six-string guitar.</p><p>Moreover, two sets of E-B-G-D-A-E strings cannot maintain perfect unison. Temperature, humidity, and string ageing affect them differently. Inner strings in a hollow neck exist in a different acoustic environment than outer strings over the soundboard. The result of multiple strings resonating in less-than-perfect unison would be <strong>beating, phase cancellation, and microtonal mud</strong> — exactly what Segovia described as “muddling the continuation of the musical piece,” above and beyond the fact that the sympathetic strings’ resonance would have bled into harmonies where they didn’t belong. Simply: the instrument would have sounded constantly out of tune with itself — above and beyond the guitar’s already tempered intonation due to its frets. (This acoustic beating is precisely the phenomenon that can unfortunately be observed too often amongst players who insist on stringing and tuning Yepes’s ten-string incorrectly with D2-C2-B1-A1 basses that <strong>Yepes never intended for his instrument</strong>.)</p><p>This is why Segovia rejected the “d’amore” guitar despite liking its “beautiful sound” <em>in the abstract</em>. It was unusable in actual musical contexts.</p><p>Ramírez’s conflation proves he didn’t understand Yepes’s instrument. You can’t be the inventor of something you don’t understand.</p><h4><strong>The Strategic Function of This Conflation</strong></h4><p>By placing both instruments under the heading “The Ten-String Guitar,” Ramírez creates several false impressions:</p><ol><li>That his “d’amore” experiment and Yepes’s solution are “stages” of a single Ramírez project</li><li>That his starry-eyed recycling of a flawed idea “inspired” or “led to” Yepes’s novel and non-obvious invention</li><li>That the progression from 12-string to 10-string represents a development of <em>his</em> concept</li></ol><p>The reality, documented on page 140 of his own book, is that <strong>Yepes rejected Ramírez’s concept entirely</strong> and replaced it with something fundamentally different. This followed a brief period during which Yepes entertained Ramírez’s experimentation by suggesting he might add a “pedal” mechanism to mute the inner strings of his “d’amore” guitar. The two instruments remain acoustically antithetical.</p><h3>III. The Phone Call: Ramírez’s Own Documentation of Yepes’s Conception</h3><p>On page 140 of <em>Things About the Guitar</em>, Ramírez records the moment that inadvertently proves Yepes’s authorship beyond any doubt. After his “d’amore” guitar failed, Ramírez received a phone call from Yepes:</p><blockquote><em>“Yepes telephoned me from somewhere that he had gone to give a concert, and told me: ‘</em><strong><em>Forget the inner strings</em></strong>.<em> If you add four strings to the six normal strings, all on the outside, and </em><strong><em>these four strings are tuned in a certain way for which I have made a study</em></strong><em>, we will have the same resonant and harmonic supports as with the inner strings, but with the advantage that by using a special technique, they can be easily muffled with the right hand whenever necessary.’”</em></blockquote><p>This single paragraph contains <strong>complete conception of the invention</strong>:</p><ol><li><strong>Layout specification</strong>: “all on the outside” (external [frettable] strings)</li><li><strong>Prior study</strong>: “for which I have made a study” (pre-existing research and solution)</li><li><strong>Acoustic reasoning</strong>: sympathetic reinforcement via a <em>particular tuning</em></li><li><strong>Technical solution</strong>: “easily muffled with the right hand” (controllable damping)</li><li><strong>Complete rejection of Ramírez’s concept</strong>: “Forget the inner strings”</li></ol><h4>The Misleading Phrase: “The Same Resonant and Harmonic Supports”</h4><p>Notice Ramírez’s claim that Yepes said they would have “<strong>the same</strong> resonant and harmonic supports as with the inner strings.” This phrase proves Ramírez never grasped the acoustic distinction. This isn’t rhetorical distortion — it’s documented incomprehension.</p><p>Yepes would have said “all 12 notes will have the same resonance,” but <strong>he would never have said his solution has “the same” resonance as the inner strings of the “d’amore” guitar</strong> because the two concepts are entirely different:</p><ul><li><strong>Ramírez’s “d’amore” experiment</strong>: duplicates E-B-G-D-A-E, creating more of what already exists</li><li><strong>Yepes’s ten-string</strong>: adds C-B♭-G♯-F♯, adding what’s missing</li></ul><p>These produce fundamentally <strong>different</strong> resonance maps. Ramírez is either:</p><ol><li><strong>Misunderstanding the acoustic distinction</strong> (proving he couldn’t have invented the solution), or</li><li><strong>Deliberately conflating</strong> the two concepts to make it appear as if “the very inaccessible magic of the guitar with inner strings” (p. 140) inspired Yepes’s “short-falling” (but playable) design</li></ol><p>Either interpretation exposes the dubiousness of Ramírez’s narrative. If he understood Yepes’s solution, he knew it wasn’t “the same” resonance. If he didn’t understand it, there are no grounds to attribute “authorship” to him.</p><p>Yepes’s own 1965 account makes clear he presented “completed plans” to Ramírez — not vague ideas requiring collaborative development. Ramírez thought the plans were “insane” — “impossible!” — and repeatedly tried to abandon the project, behaviour incompatible with co-invention.</p><h4>Ramírez’s Inversion</h4><p>Ramírez’s next sentence performs the credit flip that has distorted history for decades:</p><blockquote><em>“In fact, this was a ten-string guitar. </em><strong><em>I easily designed this special guitar and built it with no trouble.</em></strong><em> The only thing that concerned me was the increased tension on the bridge due to the larger number of strings, so I reinforced the resistance somewhat in this area.” (p. 140)</em></blockquote><p><strong>Translation:</strong> Yepes provides <em>complete conception</em> → the Ramírez workshop executes <em>routine construction</em> (“easily… with no trouble”) → Ramírez claims authorship.</p><p>The phrase “easily… with no trouble” is inadvertently revealing. The construction was straightforward <strong>because the hard part — the <em>conception </em>of the novel and non-obvious solution — had already been provided by Yepes.</strong> Ramírez’s only concern was bridge tension, a matter of routine luthiery: making the bridge strong enough to withstand additional string tension.</p><p>This is <em>reduction to practice</em>, not invention. This is fabrication following instructions, <em>not conception</em> of a novel solution.</p><h4>What Ramírez Never States</h4><p>Crucially, neither in this chapter nor anywhere else in his book does Ramírez:</p><ul><li>State the actual tuning (C2-B♭2-G♯2-F♯2)</li><li>Explain which pitch classes these strings reinforce</li><li>Demonstrate understanding of why these specific pitches solve the resonance problem</li></ul><blockquote><em>If you hide the tuning, you hide the invention.</em></blockquote><p><strong>The omission of the tuning implies calculation.</strong> Without the tuning, the ten-string appears to be “just a guitar with four more strings,” which could be strung and tuned any which way (as it consequently has been by players who’ve often uncomprehendingly or dishonestly claimed that Yepes’s rationales —i.e., “the same resonance [across all pitch classes]” and appropriateness for baroque lute music — still apply), reducing the “invention” to physical construction, which centres the luthier. But <strong><em>the tuning</em> is <em>the invention.</em></strong> The tuning is the solution to the acoustic problem — and other musical ones (to be expounded in subsequent articles in this series). That tuning came from Yepes, not Ramírez.</p><p>This omission pattern persists even in contemporary scholarship. For example, academic studies citing the composer Maurice Ohana as co-inventor (discussed in §VII,<strong> </strong>below) similarly fail to expound the multiple functions of the tuning concept — because acknowledging the technical specificities would expose that only one person involved with the origin of the novel ten-string guitar displayed this knowledge holistically in documentation: Narciso Yepes.</p><h3>IV. Amalia Ramírez’s Blog Posts: Polishing the Distortion</h3><p>In April 2020 and November 2022, Amalia Ramírez published two pieces on the Guitarras Ramírez website’s blog that repeat and refine her father’s questionable narrative.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/proxy/1*S-PNF9mhTv6eV8Lyep3yag.png" /><figcaption><em>Screenshot of Amalia Ramírez’s 21 April 2020 blog post.</em></figcaption></figure><h4><strong>21 April 2020: “10 string guitar and its author”</strong></h4><p>The post opens by disputing Paulino Bernabé’s authorship (correctly — Bernabé, then foreman at the Ramírez workshop, built [and later refined] Yepes’s instruments but didn’t invent the concept). But Amalia then makes her own false claim:</p><blockquote><em>“he [Bernabé] built his own version of this </em><strong><em>instrument created by my father, José Ramírez III, with the collaboration of Narciso Yepes</em></strong><em>, who was enthusiastic about </em><strong><em>my father’s idea</em></strong><em> and was very committed to contributing his valuable ideas as a guitarist.”</em></blockquote><p>This framing — “created by my father… with the collaboration of Yepes” — inverts the documented reality. It positions Ramírez III as originator and Yepes as helpful assistant.</p><p>Amalia then retells the story:</p><blockquote><em>“In 1963 my father started to think about creating a 10-string guitar, inspired by the viola d’amore… My father discussed this project with Andrés Segovia… [who] loved the sound, but had a problem because the inner strings did not stop sounding… So, my father’s next step was to discuss his idea with Narciso Yepes… Yepes was very enthusiastic about the idea to the point that they worked together for several years until they achieved something that finally satisfied both of them, and it was </em><strong><em>thanks to a call from Yepes to my father telling him to simply add four strings on the fingerboard</em></strong><em> since that would allow him to silence them when necessary with the right hand.”</em></blockquote><p>Notice the rhetorical manoeuvre:</p><ol><li>José “started to think about” the “10-string” (originator)</li><li>Segovia gave mixed feedback (legitimising authority)</li><li>José then “discussed his idea” with Yepes (José’s idea, Yepes consulted)</li><li>They “worked together for several years” (equal partnership)</li><li>The solution came via “a call from Yepes” (downplayed as one contribution amongst many)</li></ol><h4><strong>The Chronological Impossibility</strong></h4><p>Amalia’s timeline contains a mathematical absurdity. She claims:</p><ol><li><strong>“In 1963</strong> my father started to think about creating a 10-string guitar”</li><li>“Yepes was very enthusiastic about the idea to the point that <strong>they worked together for several years</strong>”</li></ol><p>Yet we know for a fact that the instrument was delivered on <strong>1 March 1964</strong>.</p><p><strong>“Several years” of collaboration compressed into less than 1 year (summer 1963 to 1 March 1964).</strong> This is not vague language — it’s chronological impossibility deployed to manufacture a partnership narrative. In reality:</p><ul><li><strong>1949</strong>: Yepes identifies the problem of the guitar’s unbalanced resonance</li><li><strong>1961</strong>: Yepes expresses dissatisfaction with the six-string as medium for the performance of baroque lute music (witnessed by Buss)</li><li><strong>Summer 1963</strong>: Yepes commissions the 10-string, Ramírez initially refuses, Yepes threatens to go to Fleta</li><li><strong>1963–64</strong>: The initial prototype is built at the Ramírez workshop (construction, not conception)</li><li><strong>1 March 1964</strong>: Delivery</li></ul><p>The “several years” of work was Yepes developing his study — <em>before</em> approaching Ramírez. What Amalia recasts as multi-year collaboration was actually: brief commissioning discussion → refusal → threat → reluctant fabrication over several months (tacitly delegated to Paulino Bernabé)— conflated with a separate and failed experiment (the “d’amore” guitar), concerning which Ramírez had consulted both Segovia and Yepes.</p><p>The phone call — which contains complete conception — is buried as a minor detail in a (chrono)logically impossible, multi-year “collaboration” between the summer of 1963 and 1 March 1964. The <strong>12</strong>-stringed “d’amore” guitar — with its six duplicated, internal strings and antithetical acoustic properties to Yepes’s guitar — is mischaracterised as a “[thought] about creating a <strong>10</strong>-string guitar.”</p><h4><strong>The Buried Admission</strong></h4><p>Then comes the most revealing sentence in the entire post:</p><blockquote><em>“The design, as my father explains in his book ‘Things about the guitar’, was easy, the complicated thing came with its construction, since it needed a bridge strong enough to withstand the tension of 10 strings. And he did it. </em><strong><em>And Narciso Yepes popularized this instrument all over the world, devised a tuning system for the additional 4 strings</em></strong><em>, and got string makers to make the necessary strings for this guitar.”</em></blockquote><p><strong>Amalia admits Yepes “devised a tuning system for the additional 4 strings.”</strong></p><p>In terms of patent law, <strong>devising this novel and non-obvious tuning system IS the invention.</strong> The tuning system <em>is</em> the solution to the sympathetic resonance problem (Yepes’s “uneven resonance” problem [1949], Segovia’s documented “muffled” notes complaints) that always eluded José. It is also a solution to the problem of playing 11-course (and most 13-course) baroque lute works on the guitar. Everything else — making the bridge stronger, adding tuning machines, carving a wider neck — is routine luthiery applied to realise these solutions.</p><p>Yet this admission is presented as an afterthought, coming <em>after</em> the construction narrative and framed as mere “popularisation” details.</p><h4><strong>Amalia’s Fabricated Complications</strong></h4><p>Notice Amalia’s distortion of her father’s own words. She writes: “The design… was easy, <strong>the complicated thing came with its construction</strong>, since it needed a bridge strong enough to withstand the tension of 10 strings.”</p><p>But her father wrote: “I easily designed this special guitar and <strong>built it with no trouble</strong>. The only thing that <strong>concerned</strong> me was the increased tension on the bridge.” (p. 140)</p><p><strong>Daughter:</strong> Construction was “complicated” (2020)<br> <strong>Father:</strong> Built “with no trouble,” mentioning only “concern” about bridge stability (1994)</p><p>Amalia invents “complications” her father never mentioned — to inflate his contribution. But the inversion reveals the strategy: <strong>minimise the actual innovation</strong> (Yepes’s conception), <strong>exaggerate the fabricator’s role</strong> (Ramírez’s construction). When even “no-trouble” construction must be recast as “complicated,” the desperation to claim credit becomes transparent.</p><h4><strong>What Amalia Never Explains</strong></h4><p>Like her father, Amalia never states the tuning (C2-B♭2-G♯2-F♯2), never explains its acoustic function, never demonstrates understanding of why <em>these specific pitches</em> matter (either acoustically or musically). In fact, neither this nor her subsequent blog post even mentions the central question of <strong>chromatic resonance</strong> — the very problem the instrument was designed to solve. All she says is that “it is a very enriching instrument since the 4 extra strings add richness and depth to the sound that the 6-string guitar does not provide.” This is ambiguous — “richness and depth” could be interpreted as mere loudness and/or extension of the bass range, or as precisely the sort of resonant “muddling” that Segovia noted made José’ “d’amore” guitar useless in praxis.</p><p>This pattern of omission is not accidental.</p><blockquote><em>If you hide the tuning, you hide the invention.</em></blockquote><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/proxy/1*YVqp0nSD2RTBYpBRrJ4FcQ.png" /><figcaption><em>Screenshot of Amalia Ramírez’s 16 November 2022 blog post.</em></figcaption></figure><h4><strong>16 November 2022: “José Ramírez III talking about Narciso Yepes…”</strong></h4><p>The second of Amalia’s blog posts frames the story through a 1988 radio interview with her father:</p><blockquote><em>“The 10-string guitar was a guitar </em><strong><em>developed by José Ramírez III with the collaboration of Narciso Yepes</em></strong><em>, who did not hesitate to try out all the tests that José carried out until he achieved the definitive model.”</em></blockquote><p>Again: “developed by José… with the collaboration of Narciso.”<br>Again: Yepes cast as tester, Ramírez as developer.</p><p>The transcribed audio reveals José’s view of the relationship in general (not the specific question of the ten-string’s conception):</p><blockquote><em>“Narciso Yepes has been a very important person for me, because of his great interest in everything related to sound and study, because he is a tremendous scholar, who has helped me a lot to compare and check all the studies I have done and continue to do related to sound. </em><strong><em>He never really went into the pure technique of building an instrument</em></strong><em>, but he did provide me with a series of observations on the development of the sound wave, on its behaviour in spaces such as a theatre, open spaces and things of this type that have been enormously useful to me.”</em></blockquote><p><strong>This is a red herring.</strong> <em>Conception</em> of a musical system is not “the pure technique of building an instrument.” Planing braces, gluing bridges, and calculating string tension are building technique. Determining which four pitches will create chromatic resonance balance (addressing those particular pitch classes that sound relatively dry and clipped on the guitar) is acoustic conception — <em>the invention itself</em>.</p><p>By quoting this section of José’s 1988 radio interview, Amalia attempts to equate invention with construction, allowing the Ramírez brand to claim “authorship” whilst relegating Yepes to consultant who provided “observations.”</p><p>Notice, at least, that José corroborated that Yepes was (unlike Segovia) a musician capable of providing “enormously useful” “observations on the development of the sound wave, on its behaviour in spaces such as a theatre, open spaces and things of this type.” This is precisely why Yepes understood and demonstrated the possibility of the guitar’s unamplified projection in concert halls (with or without orchestra), not through loudness or brightness (neither of which is tantamount to projection) but by his positioning of the instrument relative, firstly, to his right hand and, secondly, to the audience — a fundamental aspect of technique still not understood by the vast majority of classical guitarists due to institutional gatekeeping (i.e., pseudo-ergonomic claims about “proper posture,” refuted in previous articles in this series).</p><h3>V. The Acoustic Problem: What Segovia Complained About for Decades</h3><p>To understand why Yepes’s invention was necessary — and why neither Ramírez nor Segovia could solve the problem themselves — we must examine what Ramírez documents about Segovia’s own persistent complaints about the guitar’s fickle response across its treble notes.</p><h4><strong>Segovia’s Letters and Complaints: “Weak,” “Muffled,” “Snuffed,” “Lazy” Notes</strong></h4><p>On pages 199–201 of his book, Ramírez describes Segovia’s decades-long frustration with certain treble notes:</p><blockquote><em>“My Hauser guitar has fallen ill. It has a strange vibration and furthermore, there are </em><strong><em>two notes on the first string that do not have the same intensity as the others</em></strong><em>. I would like you to repair it for me.” (p. 199)</em></blockquote><p>Ramírez’s response reveals his helplessness:</p><blockquote><em>“However, </em><strong><em>it was not within my grasp to repair the weaker notes, and I do not think there is anyone in the world capable of correcting them</em></strong><em>. These are the famous ‘wolf’ notes that all wooden and stringed instruments have.” (</em>ib<em>.) [Note: Ramírez misapplies the term “wolf” in context.]</em></blockquote><p>On page 200, Ramírez describes a conversation with Segovia about the problem:</p><blockquote><em>“I explained all this to the Maestro, who listened patiently, but with an expression on his face which denoted that my long-winded speech went in one ear and out the other. He refused to enter into technical matters and only wanted to see results.”</em></blockquote><p>And on page 208, Ramírez documents that Segovia’s “frequent” complaints about “snuffed” or “weak” notes continued for decades:</p><blockquote><em>“Time passed by uneventfully for a number of years, sprinkled only by the Maestro’s frequent letters in which </em><strong><em>the famous wolf notes</em></strong><em> </em><strong><em>were always mentioned</em></strong><em>. In one of his letters he told me that </em><strong><em>he had had to substitute or cancel a specific musical piece from one of his programs because the note that he had to emphasize coincided with one of the mortifying wolf notes</em></strong><em> which I was wracking my brains to eliminate, conscious of the fact that no lutenist [</em>sic<em>] had ever succeeded in doing so.”</em></blockquote><p>Even as late as 1974–75, Segovia was still complaining and cancelling repertoire over weak notes.</p><h4><strong>The Terminological Error: Not “Wolf Notes”</strong></h4><p>Ramírez repeatedly calls these problems “wolf notes” <em>after</em> establishing, in context, that he and Segovia meant notes that were <em>weaker</em> than others (see, e.g., p. 199). He documents that Segovia “himself taught me what the word ‘wolf’ meant in English and German” (p. 142). This is a <strong>category error </strong>— originating with Segovia — that has confused generations of guitarists.</p><p><strong>True wolf notes</strong> (in the scientific sense) are frequencies where a played pitch beats against the instrument body’s natural resonant frequency, producing a “howling” sound. They are common in bowed instruments like cellos.</p><p><strong>What Segovia described were under-resonant notes</strong>, described in context as<strong> </strong>“weak,” “muffled,” “snuffed,” “lazy,” lacking sustain, lacking projection, “falling short” when emphasis was needed. These are not wolves; they are the opposite — pitches that <em>lack</em> sympathetic reinforcement.</p><p>This terminological confusion served a function, whether inadvertently or by design: by using a dramatic, technical-sounding term (“wolf notes”), Ramírez and Segovia externalised the problem as a mysterious and irrevocable acoustic curse rather than acknowledging it as a solvable <strong>structural imbalance</strong> in the six-string guitar’s tuning. Critically, it obfuscated generations of guitarists’ understanding that Yepes’s invention actually solved a problem that neither Segovia nor Ramírez had been equipped to understand — let alone solve.</p><h4><strong>Why the Complaints Were Structurally Inevitable</strong></h4><p>The “snuffed” notes Segovia complained about are a direct consequence of the six-string guitar’s tuning. When you play certain pitches on the treble strings of a (6-string) guitar, they trigger sympathetic vibrations in open bass strings <strong>tuned to those pitch classes</strong> or their perfect fourths — i.e., bass strings whose 2nd, 4th, and 8th harmonic partials (<strong>octaves</strong>) plus 3rd and 6th harmonic partials (<strong>compound fifths</strong> above the bass’s fundamental) are in tune with the played notes and, thus, resonate <strong>in unison</strong> with said played notes:</p><ul><li>Play treble <strong>E4</strong>: both the 6th string (E2) <em>and</em> 5th string (A2, which has E4 as its 3rd harmonic partial) vibrate sympathetically at the pitch of E4</li><li>Play treble <strong>A4</strong>: both the 5th string (A2) <em>and</em> 4th string (D3, which has A4 as its 3rd harmonic partial) vibrate sympathetically at the pitch of A4</li><li>Play treble <strong>B3 and/or B4</strong>: the 6th string (E2, which has B3 and B4 as its 3rd and 6th harmonic partials) vibrates sympathetically at the pitch(es) of B3 and/or B4</li><li>Play treble <strong>D4 and/or D5</strong>: the 4th string (D3), likewise, vibrates sympathetically — <em>in unison with the played note(s)</em></li></ul><p>But when you play <strong>C</strong>, <strong>C♯</strong>, <strong>D♯</strong>, <strong>F</strong>, <strong>F♯</strong>, <strong>G</strong>, <strong>G♯</strong>, or <strong>B♭</strong> (or their enharmonic equivalents) on the treble strings, there are <strong>no open bass strings tuned to provide sympathetic reinforcement</strong>. These pitch classes sound dry, clipped, lacking the sustain and bloom that the pitch classes of D, E, A, and B enjoy.</p><p>This is why Segovia found certain treble notes “gave me a lot of trouble when trying to draw the expressiveness that I wanted” and “always <strong>fell short and weak when I needed strong and prolonged accentuation</strong> the most.” (p. 201) It’s not a defect of Hauser’s or Ramírez’s construction. It’s inherent to the (6-string) guitar’s tuning. Critically, it is also inherent to most hyperhexachordal guitar tunings — including incorrectly strung and tuned 10-string guitars with D2-C2-B1-A1 basses, which undesirably duplicate resonances across multiple strings (D [2 strings], E [3 strings], A [3 strings], and B [2 strings]) and lack equivalent sympathetic support for the pitch classes of <strong>C♯</strong>, <strong>D♯</strong>, <strong>F</strong>, <strong>G♯</strong>, and <strong>B♭</strong>.</p><p><strong>It is evident that neither Ramírez nor Segovia understood these acoustic realities.</strong> Ramírez thought the guitar’s “snuffed” note problem was a “wolf” note problem requiring cabinet-making ‘solutions,’ resulting in his largely unadopted “De Cámara” model (another failed prototype). Segovia thought it was a construction defect that a ‘better’ luthier could fix. More precisely, he didn’t <em>think</em> about the problem at all — he only complained and demanded solutions.</p><p><strong>Yepes, by contrast, understood it was a system-level acoustic problem, related to the tuning of the guitar, requiring a system-level solution. And he solved it </strong>by adding <em>specific sympathetic strings </em>(<strong>C2</strong>, <strong>B♭2</strong>, <strong>G♯2</strong>, <strong>F♯2</strong>), functioning as <em>tuned</em> <em>resonators</em>.</p><h3>VI. Yepes’s Solution: The Chromatic Resonance Lattice</h3><p>Narciso Yepes articulated the problem and solution with technical precision across numerous interviews from the 1960s through ’90s. His explanations are consistent, detailed enough (to err on the side of brevity), and indicate extensive understanding of the acoustic physics involved.</p><h4><strong>The Problem Stated Clearly</strong></h4><p>From Larry Snitzler’s 1978 interview (p. 26):</p><blockquote><em>“I ordered it [</em>the construction of the ten-string<em>] for several reasons: The first reason is that the 6-string guitar is not a ‘balanced’ instrument. On a normal guitar, when you play the notes E, A, B, or D, you always have overtones [</em>on bass strings sympathetic with those played treble notes<em>], and therefore, a resonance from harmonics caused by sympathetic vibration with these four notes [</em>i.e., the 4 pitch classes E, A, B, and D<em>]. For example, if you play the first string E open, then stop it, you will hear the [</em>unison<em>] resonance of this note in the fifth and sixth strings. When you play A on the same [</em>first<em>] string, it is the same [</em>i.e., resonance from the fourth and fifth strings — in unison with the played A4<em>]. This is a well-known acoustical phenomenon; it’s nothing new. Sympathetic vibration can be the reason why a musical note can cause a certain object in the room to rattle. Well, this vibration is produced basically by only four notes [</em>the pitch classes E, A, B, and D<em>] on the traditional 6-string guitar. But the other eight notes of the chromatic scale are without strong overtones [</em>i.e., there are no harmonic partials of open bass strings that are in tune with the pitch classes of C, C♯, D♯, F, F♯, G, G♯, or B♭ played on a treble string<em>], so there is hardly any resonance at all. The question in my mind was, ‘Why have only four notes which are very rich and beautiful and eight notes that sound very dry?’”</em></blockquote><p>From Allan Kozinn’s 1980 article (p. 39):</p><blockquote><em>“My idea in creating this guitar was to correct the guitar’s lack of balance. The 6-string guitar has four harmonics: [</em>i.e., harmonic partials of open basses that are in tune with the pitch classes<em>] E, A, B, and D. If you play one of those notes on the first string, and then stop the string from sounding, you will notice that the note continues to sound, softly, because its vibrations have caused harmonics on the other strings. But if you play [D♯,] F, F♯, G, G♯, B♭, C, or C♯, you will have no residual resonance at all.”</em></blockquote><h4><strong>The Solution: Specific Tuning, Specific Functions</strong></h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/proxy/1*fxZ9QfgFWbZaphlJ_XVQ8Q.png" /><figcaption><em>Standard tuning of Yepes’s ten-string guitar — the true invention.</em></figcaption></figure><p>From John Schneider’s 1983 interview (p. 66):</p><blockquote><em>“</em><strong><em>The normal tuning</em></strong><em> that I use for the resonance, for the overtones, is: </em><strong><em>C, B♭, A♭, G♭</em></strong><em>.” [In enharmonic spelling: C, B♭, G♯, F♯.]</em></blockquote><p>From a 1973 statement (“The Ten-String Guitar,” p. 2):</p><blockquote><em>“In the first place, the four supplementary strings give it a balanced sound which the six-string guitar is far from having. In fact, at the moment of playing a note on one string, another begins to vibrate [</em>in unison with the played one<em>] by sympathetic resonance. On the six-string guitar this phenomenon is produced only on four notes, whilst </em><strong><em>on mine the twelve notes of the scale each have their sympathetic resonance</em></strong><em>. Thus the lopsided sonority of the six-string guitar is transformed into </em><strong><em>a wider and equal sonority on a ten-string guitar</em></strong><em>.”</em></blockquote><p>From Allan Kozinn’s 1981 article (p. 21):</p><blockquote><em>“</em><strong><em>My reasons were purely musical</em></strong><em>, and the first of them was that the guitar was not properly balanced. There was no equilibrium, because of the 12 notes of the scale, only four — E, A, B, D — had any resonance. If you play one of those notes and then stop the string with your finger, you will hear the sound lingering. But if you play one of the other eight notes of the scale, the sound dies immediately. </em><strong><em>On the 10-string guitar, I have resonance on all 12 notes </em></strong><em>[</em>i.e., all 12 equal-tempered pitch classes<em>].”</em></blockquote><p>From Fred Kazandjian’s 1987 interview (in Kazandjian 1992: 233):</p><blockquote><em>“A few years before 1964, I was unhappy with the six-string guitar because it is not a balanced instrument. As you know, there are only four [</em>classes of<em>] tones on the six-string guitar, E, B, A and D, which have more resonance because of the basses, and eight [</em>classes of<em>] tones which are sounding very dry. To make it more balanced, I decided that four extra bass strings [</em>tuned a particular way<em>] would be all that was needed to make the difference so that </em><strong><em>all twelve [</em>classes of<em>] tones will have similar resonance</em></strong><em>.”</em></blockquote><p>From his 1989 speech <em>Ser instrumento</em> (p. 17):</p><blockquote><strong>“</strong>Yo no he añadido cuatro cuerdas a la guitarra por capricho, sino por necesidad. … Las cuerdas que yo he añadido confieren una amplitud de tesitura y además incorporan toda la resonancia natural que le faltaba al instrumento en ocho de las doce notas de la escala temperada. Una resonancia que no sólo sirve para tenerla sino para dejar de tenerla cuando no se necesita.”</blockquote><p>Translation:</p><blockquote><strong><em>“I didn’t add four strings to the guitar on a whim, but out of necessity</em></strong><em>. … The strings I added </em><strong><em>provide a wider range</em></strong><em> [</em>i.e., for playing lute and hyperhexachordal guitar music, and more faithful transcriptions in general<em>] and also incorporate </em><strong><em>all the natural resonance that the instrument lacked in eight of the twelve notes of the tempered scale.</em></strong><em> A resonance that can be used not only to have it but also to suppress it when it’s not needed.”</em></blockquote><h4><strong>How the System Works</strong></h4><p>Each of the four added strings supplies sympathetic reinforcement through the <strong>octaves</strong> and compound perfect <strong>fifths</strong> of their overtone series. Critically, the 4th overtone (forming the <em>true </em>major third), is <em>not in tune with the tempered scale and doesn’t resonate</em> — or does so only very weakly — when its <em>nominally</em> identical,<em> tempered</em> pitch is played on the fretboard. In other words, only those ‘overtones’ or harmonic partials corresponding to the octaves, fifths, and their octaves (in relation to the fundamental pitches of the open bass strings) are relevant to the sympathetic string resonance of the guitar. Thus, in addition to the six-string guitar’s extant resonances — already listed in §V —</p><p><strong>String 10=F♯</strong> reinforces:</p><ul><li>F♯ (fundamental and octaves: F♯2, F♯3, F♯4, F♯5)</li><li>C♯ (perfect fifth above fundamental’s octave and its octave: C♯4, C♯5)</li></ul><p><strong>String 9=G♯</strong> reinforces:</p><ul><li>G♯ (fundamental and octaves: G♯2, G♯3, G♯4, G♯5)</li><li>D♯ (perfect fifths: D♯4, D♯5)</li></ul><p><strong>String 8=B♭</strong> reinforces:</p><ul><li>B♭ (fundamental and octaves: B♭2, B♭3, B♭4, B♭5)</li><li>F (perfect fifths: F4, F5)</li></ul><p><strong>String 7=C</strong> reinforces:</p><ul><li>C (fundamental and octaves: C2, C3, C4, C5)</li><li>G (perfect fifths: G3, G4, G5)</li></ul><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*chCcW3V_-OBoIGsao-6USA.png" /><figcaption>Resonance map of the seven bass strings, indicating the resonances each is capable of passively producing in response to a note actively played on a different string — e.g., the 10th string ( G♭ or F♯) resonates in unison with the pitch classes of G♭ (octaves) and D♭ (compound perfect fifths) or their enharmonic equivalents (F♯ and C♯).</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/proxy/1*IsTG74wSY0qGI1RxnSk_-Q.jpeg" /><figcaption><em>The above chromatic scale represents treble notes actively played; the notes directly below them indicate the strings that passively resonate in unison with the played notes — e.g., when G3 (second from the left) is played, the seventh or C string resonates at the same frequency (G3).</em></figcaption></figure><p><strong>Result:</strong> Every treble-string semitone from F♯3/G3 (open 3rd string) to B5 (1st string, fret XIX) — the full treble string compass — receives sympathetic reinforcement through octaves, fifths, and octaves-of-fifths (i.e., harmonic partials of bass strings sympathetic with actively played treble notes).</p><p>The eight previously weak pitch classes (C, C♯, D♯, F, F♯, G, G♯, B♭) now have the same resonant support that Ds, Es, As, and Bs always enjoyed.</p><h4><strong>The Control Mechanism</strong></h4><p>From Snitzler 1978 (p. 26):</p><blockquote><em>“Also, if I have the resonance, I can always stop it, and when I stop it, you can hear the difference. But you hear me stop it only because I</em> have <em>it in the first place; if I don’t have the resonance, I can’t stop it.”</em></blockquote><p>From Yepes’s 1973 liner notes:</p><blockquote><em>“Secondly, I do not content myself with letting the extra strings vibrate passively in sympathy; I use them, I play them according to the demands of the music to be interpreted. </em><strong><em>I can control the volume of the resonances, or I can suppress them.</em></strong><em> I can damp one if it is inconvenient in a given passage, but if I can do this it is precisely because I have these resonances available. This allows me to modify at will not only the volume but also the tone-colours.”</em></blockquote><p>This controllability is one aspect of what makes the system musically useful. Unlike Ramírez’s “d’amore” guitar (which Segovia rejected because “the inner strings did not stop sounding”), Yepes’s strings can be engaged or silenced as the music requires. In the standard tuning, they don’t duplicate resonances across the string plane (as the incorrect D-C-B-A system does), making controlled and elegant cancelling of <em>individual</em> resonances possible. Also, contrary to anti-ten-string propaganda, these resonances need not be cancelled very often. Their loudness is always relatively soft in relation to played sounds and, critically, <strong>they are constantly changing in relation to the harmonic content of the music (not foreign to it)</strong>, with new resonances emerging and overshadowing the decaying ones. Over-ringing (harmonic “muddling”) is mostly a problem of six-string guitars and incorrectly strung and tuned 10-strings precisely because they have <strong>resonance gaps</strong> that starkly reveal when one harmony bleeds into another where it doesn’t belong — and isn’t subducted by new resonance(s). <strong>A good ten-string guitarist doesn’t have to think like a good six-string guitarist </strong>— the instruments have different acoustic properties, permitting or demanding different musico-technical approaches.</p><h4><strong>Secondary Rationale: Baroque Lute Repertoire</strong></h4><p>The chromatic resonance system was Yepes’s primary innovation, but the instrument’s design also addressed <strong>a second problem that only a guitarist well-versed in baroque repertoire would have identified</strong>: the six-string guitar’s inadequacy for lute music transcription.</p><p>As Fritz Buss witnessed in 1961, Yepes was dissatisfied with his all-Bach recital precisely because the six-string forced him to transpose individual bass notes up an octave and omit other elements entirely — compromises that violated the integrity of Bach’s lines. This wasn’t mere pedantry or authentistic literalism; it reflected Yepes’s understanding that <strong>lines and relations matter</strong>, especially in early music. If a composer like Bach or Weiss calls for a G2 or F♯2 bass (forming a step-wise line in relation to preceding and subsequent basses), it is not acceptable to transpose it up an octave to G3 or F♯3 (destroying the line and introducing leaps that are stylistically anathema) because the left hand happens to be in a high position and cannot reach fret III or II. For this reason, baroque lute music requires open bass strings the six-string guitar simply doesn’t possess —<em> not only lower </em>than the six-string’s<em> </em>but just as importantly those Yepes incorporated as his 9th and 10th strings.</p><p><strong>The ten-string’s re-entrant layout</strong> — with string 7 as the lowest (easily frettable) and strings 8–10 higher in pitch — <strong>wasn’t arbitrary</strong>. It was specifically designed to enable scordatura-based lute transcriptions. Yepes understood what many miss: for baroque lutenists (and pre-Modern musicians in general), absolute pitch was irrelevant. What mattered were the transposable intervallic <strong>relations</strong> of a musical work. The lute’s <em>accord nouveau </em>(“new tuning”) was neither rigidly nor actually a “D minor” tuning— it was just a minor-chord framework with diatonic basses, as a starting point, subject to countless piece-specific <em>scordature</em>. Yepes recognised that treating baroque tablature as if written for a lute in E (rather than the <em>purely nominal</em> “D”) created closer analogies to the guitar’s standard tuning, with minor, piece-specific adjustments via <em>scordature</em> of the four bass strings enabling renditions of any 11- and most 13-course lute pieces that retain their correct intervallic relations, and much of the lute idiom. (More on this topic in a follow-up article in this series.)</p><p>This solution required intimate knowledge of baroque lute tuning practices, transcription challenges specific to the guitar, and the technical demands of fingering baroque lute music on the guitar. The evidence is in the documentation: Yepes explained both the acoustic rationale <em>and</em> the lute music applications across decades of interviews, demonstrating deep understanding of baroque lute tuning conventions, scordatura practices, and guitar transcription challenges. Neither Ramírez (a luthier) nor Ohana (a twentieth-century composer who didn’t play guitar or transcribe baroque lute music) ever discussed these requirements or demonstrated such knowledge. The re-entrant layout, like the chromatic tuning itself, could only have been conceived by someone who combined acoustic understanding with specialist knowledge of baroque lute repertoire and guitar technique. The silence is definitive: Yepes’s alleged “co-inventors” couldn’t explain what they didn’t conceive.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*NKwa9FxsZe3QJ5-_9H_imw.jpeg" /><figcaption>All the open basses corresponding to the baroque lute’s 6th through 11th courses are available on Yepes’s 10-string guitar, as a starting point before applying piece-specific adjustments. For 13-course lute music, the 7th string is lowered (often to B) and fretted. Normally, any fingering adjustments that must be made due to the guitar’s lack of “chanterelle” (the lute’s 1st course) or the whole tone difference between the lute’s 5th course and the guitar’s 4th string are surmountable due to the fact that the basses can be played open.</figcaption></figure><h3>VII. The Ohana Misattribution: Early Adopter-Composer, Not Co-Inventor</h3><p>A second false narrative (now found in several academic studies) attributes the ten-string’s invention to Maurice Ohana, citing the “1963” date of <em>Si le jour paraît…</em>’s creation <em>before</em> delivery of Yepes’s first ten-string (1 March 1964). This claim collapses under chronological scrutiny.</p><h4>The Full Development Arc, including Ohana’s Involvement, Disproving Co-Invention</h4><ul><li><strong>1949</strong>: Yepes identifies “uneven resonance” problem</li><li><strong>1961</strong>: Buss witnesses continued dissatisfaction with six-string guitar (all-Bach recital in Madrid)</li><li><strong>1962–63</strong>: Ohana begins sketching “<strong>Synchronies</strong>” or “<strong>Synchronie-âge</strong>.” (The title varies across different accounts.) <em>This</em> work-in-progress (which will become <em>Si le jour paraît…</em>)<em> </em>exists before the ten-string instrument physically exists. The composer feels or had already “felt uncomfortable in the cage limited by the six strings of the traditional guitar.”<strong>†</strong></li><li><strong>1963</strong>: Yepes completes plans, presents to Ramírez; Ramírez considers design “insane” and “impossible,” eventually agrees when Yepes threatens to take it to Fleta</li><li><strong>1963–64</strong>: Ramírez repeatedly tries to abandon project; Bernabé builds as Ramírez foreman</li><li><strong>1 March 1964</strong>: Delivery</li><li><strong>15 March 1964</strong>: House concert for a group of non-guitarist musicians; unanimous approval</li><li><strong>20 March 1964</strong>: Debut of Yepes’s ten-string guitar in Berlin; critical approval</li><li><strong>1964–[65?]</strong>: Ohana completes <em>Si le jour paraît…</em> for ten-string guitar. The exact completion date cannot be determined from currently available evidence, though the work’s extended structure, delayed publication, and delayed premiere suggest significant revision time beyond the March 1964 delivery date and Berlin premiere of the new instrument.</li><li><strong>January 1965</strong>: <em>Guitarra Magazine</em> interview confirms 14-year conception period (1949–63) and patent claims</li><li><strong>1971–74</strong>: The seven movements of <em>Si le jour paraît…</em> are published individually by Gérard Billaudot, each bearing the misleading composition date of “1963” — no explicit indication of the tuning, but it is implicit in the writing and fingering.</li><li><strong>1973</strong>: Partial premiere of <em>Si le jour paraît…</em> for ORTF</li><li><strong>27 June 1974</strong>: Complete premiere at Festival de la Rochelle by Alberto Ponce, not Yepes</li></ul><p><strong>†</strong> Concerning the possible origins of Ohana’s suite, two scenarios are plausible:</p><p><strong>(A)</strong> The initial sketches of <em>Synchronies</em> are frustrated by “the cage” of “the six strings of the traditional guitar,” expressing Ohana’s documented dissatisfaction with the limitations of the instrument for which he began to sketch what would eventually become <em>Si le jour paraît…</em>;</p><p><strong>(B)</strong> Yepes discussed his conception of the ten-string with Ohana during the instrument’s development (c. 1961–63), and Ohana — as a kindred spirit who shared Yepes’s dissatisfaction with the six-string — immediately recognised the potential and began composing <strong>in anticipation</strong> of the instrument’s realisation.</p><p>Whether Ohana began <em>Synchronies</em> for 6-string guitar (frustrated by its limitations) or in anticipation of Yepes’s design (discussed during the first years of the 1960s), Yepes had already conceived the invention before Ohana began composing for it. Neither scenario constitutes co-invention of the tuning system itself.</p><p>Ohana–Yepes correspondence from the early 1960s and <em>Synchronie</em> sketches (if extant) might offer additional pointers — but such research must proceed critically, not from the received view that “Ohana co-invented the instrument.”</p><h4><strong>What the Composer Actually Said</strong></h4><p>From Ohana’s interview with Pascal Bolbach (1982, quoted in Pérez Castillo [2014], p. 80):</p><blockquote>«Très tôt, je me suis senti mal à l’aise dans la cage limitée par les six cordes de la guitare traditionnelle. Et <strong>c’est en parlant avec Yepes que l’idée nous est venue</strong> d’élargir l’instrument en le dotant de cordes qui complèteraient la gamme chromatique… Ainsi est née cette guitare à dix cordes dont Ramírez à Madrid construisit les premiers examplaires <em>[sic]</em>.»</blockquote><p>Translation: “Very early, I felt uncomfortable in the cage limited by the six strings of the traditional guitar. And <strong>it was in talking with Yepes that the idea came to us of enlarging the instrument</strong> by giving it strings that would complete the chromatic range… Thus was born this ten-string guitar, of which Ramírez in Madrid built the first examples.”</p><p><strong>Notice:</strong></p><ol><li><strong>Passive voice</strong>: “the idea came to us” (no agent specified)</li><li><strong>Collaborative framing</strong>: “in talking with Yepes”</li><li><strong>Two separate goals stated</strong>: (A) to be free of “the cage limited by the six strings of the traditional guitar,” and (B) to “complete the chromatic range” — the idea of “enlarging the instrument” undergirding (conflating) the two goals</li><li><strong>No technical detail</strong>: Ohana doesn’t state the tuning or explain the acoustics behind it</li></ol><p>What Ohana does, in the above quote from 1982, is describe <strong>two distinct aesthetic goals </strong>(<em>his</em> desire for freedom from “the cage limited by the six strings of the traditional guitar” and <em>Yepes’s</em> 1949 desire to “complete the chromatic range” of the instrument’s resonance, documented at least as early January 1965) — synergistic goals that became conflated. Ohana does not expound the <strong>technical solution</strong> (<em>which</em> four strings, <em>why</em> those pitches, <em>how</em> they function), though the tuning <em>is</em> implicit within the ultimately published scores of <em>Si le jour paraît…</em></p><p><strong>Ohana’s 1970 Statement — Naming the Tuning Without Explaining It:</strong></p><p>In a 1970 <em>France Culture</em> interview, Ohana does state the tuning whilst describing the new instrument:</p><blockquote>«Elle est accordée comme la guitare ordinaire, mais en plus de ces 6 cordes habituelles : mi, la, ré, sol, si, mi, il y en a quatre autres : si bémol, la bémol, sol bémol et do grave, ce qui donne un éventail d’harmoniques à peu près complet, et qui enrichit énormément les possibilités de masses sonores, de chromatisme et même de micro-chromatisme.» <em>(quoted in Sacchi 2019: 112)</em></blockquote><p>Translation: “It is tuned like the ordinary guitar, but in addition to these 6 usual strings: E, A, D, G, B, E, there are four others: B♭, A♭, G♭ and low C, which provides a nearly complete range of harmonics, and which enormously enriches the possibilities of sonorous masses, of chromaticism and even micro-chromaticism.”</p><p>This 1970 statement reveals three critical points:</p><p>First, Ohana names the tuning (“B♭-A♭-G♭-C”) — <strong>in the wrong order</strong> — six years <em>after</em> Yepes received the instrument (March 1964) and five years after Yepes’s 1965 <em>Guitarra Magazine</em> interview documenting his fourteen-year conception period (1949–63). Ohana’s 1970 description is retrospective, not proof of co-invention. If anything, his error is telling.</p><p>Second, Ohana’s explanation is <strong>acoustically imprecise</strong>: he claims the tuning “provides a nearly complete [<em>à peu près complet</em>] range of harmonics.” In reality, Yepes’s system provides <strong>absolutely complete</strong> chromatic sympathetic resonance coverage — critically, including gapless unison resonances across the entire treble-string compass (F♯3/G3 to B5). Ohana’s hedge (“nearly complete”) suggests incomplete understanding of the system’s actual acoustic function. Yepes never described his invention as “nearly” complete — because it isn’t. The resonances across the full range of the instrument are not <em>identically uniform</em> — as Fritz Buss says, “nothing is really perfect anyway; there is no such thing” — but they <em>are</em> complete.</p><p>Third, Ohana’s focus on “sonorous masses, chromaticism and micro-chromaticism” emphasises <strong>compositional possibilities</strong> (aesthetic goals) rather than <strong>acoustic physics</strong> (the technical solution to interpretive problems). He describes what the instrument enables him<em> to write</em>, not <em>why </em>these specific pitches solve the<em> resonance problem </em>(let alone the lute problem). This is the perspective of a composer recognising new creative possibilities, not an inventor-performer explaining the acoustic, interpretive, and technical reasoning behind the pitch selection.</p><p>Compare Ohana’s vague “nearly complete range of harmonics” statement with Yepes’s technical precision across multiple interviews in §VI, above.</p><p>Yepes consistently explained <strong><em>which</em> pitch classes lack resonance</strong>, <strong><em>why</em> those eight are weak</strong>, and <strong><em>how</em> the four added strings supply sympathetic reinforcement to <em>all</em> eight of those weaker pitch classes through harmonic partials, resulting in an instrument with <em>fully chromatic resonance</em></strong>. Ohana’s statement names the tuning but provides no such explanation.</p><p><strong>The Critical Distinction:</strong></p><p>Both men genuinely “enlarged the instrument” through “strings that would complete the chromatic range,” but it was the <em>performer</em> who conceived of the technical solution (identifying the eight weak pitch classes, understanding the harmonic partial relationships, determining which pitches would supply non-redundant sympathetic reinforcement, synthesising them with solutions to the problems of baroque lute transcription). The composer, for his part, enlarged the instrument <em>by writing for said solution</em>. Naming a tuning (imprecisely) six years after the instrument’s delivery ≠ conceiving the acoustic system. Acknowledgment ≠ invention.</p><h4><strong>Ana Yepes’s Testimony</strong></h4><p>From Stéphane Sacchi’s 2016 interview with Ana Yepes (Narciso’s daughter):</p><blockquote><strong>Sacchi:</strong> «Mais <em>[Yepes]</em> il répond aussi à la volonté d’Ohana d’élargir les résonances de l’instrument.»</blockquote><blockquote><strong>Ana Yepes:</strong> «Oui, mais <strong>mon père rend son idée réalisable</strong> avec cette proposition d’ajouter à la guitare quatre cordes.» <em>(Sacchi 2019: p. 420)</em></blockquote><p>Translation:</p><blockquote><strong><em>Sacchi:</em></strong><em> “But he [Yepes] also responds to Ohana’s desire to expand the instrument’s resonances.” [</em>Note the red herring.<em>]</em></blockquote><blockquote><strong><em>Ana Yepes:</em></strong><em> “Yes, but </em><strong><em>my father makes his idea feasible</em></strong><em> with this proposal to add four strings to the guitar.” [</em>Note the diplomatic correction.<em>]</em></blockquote><p><strong>This is the critical distinction:</strong></p><ul><li>Ohana expressed a <em>desire</em> (aesthetic goal): freedom from “the cage limited by the six strings”</li><li>Yepes provided the <em>solution</em> (technical specification): chromatic resonance balance via C2-B♭2-G♯2-F♯2 tuning</li></ul><p>These are not the same goal. Escaping the “cage” of six strings could mean extended range, alternate tunings, or countless other approaches. Completing the chromatic resonance architecture required understanding sympathetic vibration, harmonic partials, and pitch class distribution — knowledge Ohana may certainly have possessed but only Yepes <em>explicitly</em> demonstrated in the documentary evidence.</p><p><strong>Desire ≠ Invention. Solution = Invention.</strong></p><h4><strong>Sacchi’s Inadvertent Admission</strong></h4><p>Stéphane Sacchi’s 2019 thesis inadvertently confirms the distinction between desiring expansion and inventing a solution. Discussing Ohana’s Concerto (<em>Trois Graphiques</em>), Sacchi writes:</p><blockquote><em>“A few years after its creation, the work was rewritten for Yepes’s ten-string guitar. … Moreover, </em><strong><em>adapting the work for the ten-string guitar is not the same thing as having previously thought of it and conceived it in the sonority of this new instrument</em></strong><em>. Undoubtedly Ohana would not have composed this concerto in quite the same way for this enlarged guitar.” (p. 223)</em></blockquote><p>This admission is fatal to co-invention claims. Sacchi acknowledges that Ohana was <strong>retrofitting</strong> existing 6-string works (the Concerto and <em>Tiento</em>) to an instrument whose “sonority” was <strong>not in his conception</strong> when composing. He then describes the final passages of <em>Trois Graphiques</em> as embodying Ohana’s “prophetic dream” of “seeing the instrument’s sound space open up” — a “harbinger sign” of <em>Si le jour paraît… </em>(pp. 223<em>f</em>).</p><p><strong>A “prophetic dream” is not an invention.</strong> It is a wish. Yepes made that wish feasible by conceiving the specific tuning system that created the “opened sound space.” The chronology is unambiguous:</p><ol><li>Ohana composes 6-string works expressing frustration with the instrument’s limitations</li><li>Yepes invents the 10-string solution</li><li>Ohana adapts his existing works and writes new ones for the realised instrument</li></ol><p><strong>Desire → Invention → Adoption.</strong> Not co-invention.</p><p>Sacchi’s thesis makes stronger co-invention claims elsewhere, asserting that Yepes and Ohana <em>«ensemble… conçoivent l’invention de la guitare à dix cordes»</em> (“together conceive the invention of the ten-string guitar”) and framing the added strings as their “joint enterprise” (2019: 81, 118). Yet Sacchi provides no convincing documentary evidence of joint technical conception. He cites Yepes’s 1970 liner notes about not betraying tradition and Pascal Proust’s resonance analysis (with acoustic errors, e.g., giving the resonances of the 10th string as <em>«Solb2 </em><strong><em>Sol5</em></strong><em> Réb4 Solb4 Réb5 Solb5»</em>) — neither documents joint invention. More revealingly, Sacchi himself writes that <em>«Yepes conçoit en collaborant avec Ohana l’instrument»</em> (“Yepes designs, collaborating with Ohana, the instrument”) (p. 227) — admitting Yepes designed it whilst framing artistic collaboration (discussing repertoire possibilities) as technical co-invention. Sacchi’s “co-invention” narrative rests on interpreting aligned aesthetic goals as joint technical conception — the same conflation this article systematically refutes. Desiring (chromatic) expansion ≠ inventing the tuning system that achieves full chromatic coverage — and other musical possibilities (e.g., lute transcription) that have nothing to do with the musical world of Ohana.</p><h4><strong>Schmidt’s “Impossible” Claim: Prejudice Disguised as Evidence</strong></h4><p>The prejudice underlying Sacchi’s co-invention narrative becomes explicit in guitarist Stephan Schmidt’s 2015 interview. When Sacchi suggests the tuning came from Ohana, Schmidt responds:</p><blockquote>«Il a ajouté le do en septième corde, et après il a repris des cordes si bémol, la bémol, sol bémol… ça c’est Maurice. C’est impossible que ce soit Yepes parce que ça n’a rien à faire avec le monde de Narciso Yepes.» <em>(Sacchi 2019: 446)</em></blockquote><p>Translation: “He [Ohana] added C on the seventh string, then took up B♭, A♭, G♭ strings… that’s Maurice. It’s impossible that it was Yepes because it has nothing to do with the world of Narciso Yepes.”</p><p>Schmidt’s ‘reasoning’: Yepes didn’t perform or record the complete <em>Si le jour paraît…</em> suite, therefore he couldn’t have invented the tuning. This is a <strong>non sequitur</strong> — performing a composer’s work is unrelated to conceiving the instrument it’s written for. By this logic, Benjamin Franklin didn’t invent the <em>glass armonica</em> because he didn’t perform the first compositions for the instrument — Marianne Davies<strong> </strong>(c. 1743–1818) did.</p><p>More revealing is Schmidt’s assertion that the tuning system is “impossible” for Yepes “because it has nothing to do with the world of Narciso Yepes.” What is “Yepes’s world” supposed to be that makes chromatic resonance balance impossible? Schmidt doesn’t say — because the claim rests entirely on <strong>prejudice </strong>— not evidence.</p><p>But Schmidt’s claim reveals more than prejudice — it reveals the mechanism by which orthodoxy sanitises innovation. Players like Schmidt have adopted the ten-string guitar whilst stripping it of its specificity: orthodox 45° positioning of the instrument → orthodox sound production → diminished resonance and projection, flirtations with more thick strings and fewer (if any) re-entrant ones, and a functional reduction to a “six-string” sonority with some scattered tone clusters and/or low basses. In this way, the instrument becomes acceptable to classical-guitar orthodoxy precisely by erasing what made it distinctive — treated as a novelty for avant-garde repertoire rather than a systematic solution to the acoustic imbalance Yepes identified in 1949. Schmidt’s assertion that this solution “has nothing to do with the world of Narciso Yepes” shows the incomprehension masquerading as authority that underlies this sanitisation: he, like many, cannot fathom that the instrument’s primary purpose was not compositional but <em>interpretive</em> — enabling performers to shape musical expression according to artistic will, not guitaristic whims — irrespective of repertoire. Chromatic resonance balance has everything to do with Yepes’s world as a guitarist who was studying interpretation with Walter Gieseking, George Enesco, and Nadia Boulanger (c. 1950, around the time that he identified the guitar’s resonance problems). Schmidt evidently knows nothing of this world — which is why he must attribute the invention elsewhere whilst adopting its superficial form.</p><p>His <strong>assumption</strong> of Yepes’s inability is gatekeeping logic made explicit: if an innovation doesn’t fit the approved narrative of who Yepes supposedly was, it must have come from someone else — regardless of documentation. Schmidt’s “impossible” mirrors Ramírez’s initial “impossible” — both rooted in incomprehension of the Other, not in evidence.</p><p>As for Yepes not recording <em>Si le jour paraît…</em> or including the integral suite in his recitals: Firstly, this conflates commercial recording decisions (major label interests, repertoire marketability, Deutsche Grammophon’s classical guitar strategy) with technical capability. Yepes premiered or performed many twentieth-century works he never recorded (e.g., <em>Elegía para Gisela</em> by José Peris, <em>Bach Connexion</em> by Émile Naoumoff, or Ginastera’s Guitar Sonata). Non-recording of <em>Si le jour paraît… </em>≠ non-invention of the ten-string.</p><p>Secondly, Yepes — always considerate of his audience — never dedicated half a programme to a single avant-garde work like <em>Si le jour paraît…</em> or even the complete set of Villa-Lobos <em>Études</em>. He avoided eggheaded programming, to put it plainly. He included selections from such works in his varied programmes — or selections of integral but shorter twentieth-century works. The only exception to this principle was the inclusion of M.A. Cherubito’s exceedingly difficult, 30-minute <em>Suite Popular Argentina </em>(1989), which Yepes described, in the liner notes of his final solo album, as “one of the most applauded works in my vast repertoire.”</p><p>Schmidt’s claim is <strong>assertion masquerading as argument</strong> — exactly what academic texts attributing invention of Yepes’s guitar to Ohana have done at greater length.</p><h4><strong>The Vidal 1966 Interview: Contemporary Attribution</strong></h4><p>In June 1966, French journalist Pierre Vidal interviewed both Yepes and Ohana together for <em>Musica disques</em>. His published account of the conversation amongst the three men states:</p><blockquote>«<strong>Yepes eut l’idée d’une guitare à dix cordes, qu’il fit construire par le facteur Ramirez à Madrid.</strong> Maurice Ohana a écrit les ‘Synchronies’, sept pièces pour guitare à dix cordes.»<em> (p. 10)</em></blockquote><p>Translation: “<strong>Yepes had the idea of a ten-string guitar, which he had built by the maker Ramirez in Madrid.</strong> Maurice Ohana wrote the ‘Synchronies,’ seven pieces for ten-string guitar.”</p><p><strong>This is contemporaneous documentation — published only two years after the instrument’s realisation, with both men present — stating:</strong></p><ol><li>Yepes “had the idea” (conceived)</li><li>Yepes “had it built by” Ramírez (commissioned fabrication)</li><li>Ohana “wrote … for” the instrument (composed for existing instrument)</li></ol><p>Neither Yepes nor Ohana objected to this characterisation. Because it was accurate.</p><h4><strong>What Ohana’s Role Actually Was</strong></h4><p>Maurice Ohana was:</p><ul><li>A kindred spirit who, like Yepes, felt excessively restricted by the six-string guitar (for his part, <em>compositionally — </em>for the latter’s, <em>interpretively)</em></li><li>An <strong>early advocate</strong> who recognised the new instrument’s potential</li><li>A <strong>commissioned composer</strong> who wrote major works for it</li><li>A <strong>collaborator</strong> in the artistic sense — discussing repertoire possibilities, encouraging Yepes’s exploration</li><li>The <strong>first major composer</strong> to write extensively for the instrument</li></ul><p>What Ohana was <strong>not</strong>:</p><ul><li>The inventor of the tuning system</li><li>The solver of the sympathetic resonance problem</li><li>The designer of the re-entrant layout (the 7th/lowest string intended to be fretted — Yepes’s practical solution for playing 13-course baroque lute music, via <em>scordature</em>, without having to add acoustically redundant strings)</li><li>The specifier of which four pitches to add, in which order</li></ul><p><strong>Being first to write for an instrument ≠ inventing the instrument.</strong></p><p>Hector Berlioz’s inclusion of a saxophone part in <em>Chant Sacré</em> (premiered in 1844) doesn’t make him the (co-)inventor of Adolphe Sax’s saxophone. Writing <em>Si le jour paraît…</em> didn’t make Ohana the (co-)inventor of Yepes’s ten-string guitar.</p><h3>VIII. Contemporary Documentation: Neutral Sources Confirm Yepes’s Authorship</h3><p>Whilst Ramírez’s company promoted its own narrative and Ohana’s advocates claimed co-invention, neutral contemporaneous sources consistently attributed the invention to Yepes.</p><h4><strong>Anglophone Journalistic Attribution (1980s)</strong></h4><p><em>Frets Magazine</em> (Allan Kozinn, February 1980, p. 39):</p><blockquote><strong><em>“Early in the 1960s, Yepes began pondering the limitations of his instrument</em></strong><em>, theorising ways it could be improved. </em><strong><em>His solution</em></strong><em> was to increase the number of the instrument’s strings, adding four more (normally tuned C, B♭, A♭, G♭) below the sixth string (E).” [</em>Correction: string 8–10 are not below the range of the sixth string<em>.]</em></blockquote><p>“Guitarist Narciso Yepes, the virtuoso <strong>who invented his own instrument</strong>,” <em>The Christian Science Monitor</em> (Thor Eckert Jnr, 23 November 1981):</p><blockquote><em>“When Narciso Yepes travels, he needs two tickets, one for himself, the other for ‘Mrs. Guitar.’ Mrs. Guitar — as the airlines dubbed it — is none other than </em><strong><em>the 10-string instrument that he invented</em></strong><em> in 1964 and which has remained his trademark. Yepes is something of a renaissance man — inventor, virtuoso, scholar, composer.”</em></blockquote><p><em>Toronto Star</em> (Ronald Hambleton, 8 October 1986, p. D4):</p><blockquote><em>“This remarkable innovator and </em><strong><em>creator of the 10-string guitar</em></strong><em> merged with Camerata Bern in a classic exhibition of true ensemble playing.”</em></blockquote><p>These and many other journalistic publications, written during Yepes’s active career, consistently described him as the instrument’s inventor and creator, not as a “collaborator” with Ramírez or Ohana — claims that started after Yepes’s career was cut short by lymphoma and escalated after his death.</p><h3>IX. The “Any Ten Strings Will Do” Fallacy: What Yepes Actually Invented</h3><p>A third false attribution has emerged among players of ten-stringed instruments strung and tuned differently from Yepes’s specifications — typically with D2-C2-B1-A1 basses or other configurations of their own devising. Having replaced Yepes’s strings and tuning with their own, they then claim Yepes “invented nothing” because “the ten-string guitar” already existed in the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries (Carulli’s <em>décacorde</em>, Mertz’s harp-guitar, etc.) — erasing meaningful distinctions.</p><p>This conflation — treating “a guitar with ten strings” as if all such instruments are functionally identical — fundamentally misunderstands what Yepes invented.</p><h4>What Yepes Actually Said</h4><p>In his 1989 speech <em>Ser instrumento</em>, Yepes acknowledged the historical precedent:</p><blockquote>“Antes de seguir adelante me apresuro a decir que yo no he inventado nada. Desde el principio de la Historia de la Música, han ido cambiando, constantemente, quizás con más empuje que ninguno, los instrumentos de cuerdas pulsadas, en su estructura, en la forma, en el número de cuerdas e incluso en su cometido dentro del servicio a la Música.” <em>(pp. 15–16)</em></blockquote><p>Translation: “Before going further I hasten to say that I have invented nothing [<em>by ‘adding strings’ as such</em>]. Since the beginning of the History of Music, plucked string instruments have been constantly changing, perhaps with more momentum than any others, in their structure, form, number of strings and even in their role in the service of Music.”</p><p>He then provides extensive examples of historical instruments with varying numbers of strings, concluding:</p><blockquote>“Por esta razón yo no he añadido cuatro cuerdas a la guitarra por capricho, sino por necesidad. ¿Por qué tenemos que tocar obras antiguas con instrumentos modernos haciendo transcripciones inútiles que mutilan la música? Yo he salido al encuentro de esta limitación, restituyendo al mundo del Arte la guitarra de diez cuerdas que ya había existido en los siglos XVIII y XIX.” <em>(p. 17)</em></blockquote><p>Translation: “For this reason <strong>I have not added four strings to the guitar on a whim, but out of necessity</strong>. Why must we play old works with modern instruments making useless transcriptions that mutilate the music? <strong>I have met this limitation</strong> by restoring to the world of Art the ten-string guitar that had already existed in the 18th and 19th centuries.”</p><p><strong>This is characteristic Yepes humility</strong> — minimising the novelty of “adding strings” as such. But he immediately clarifies what <em>was</em> novel:</p><blockquote>“Las cuerdas que yo he añadido confieren una amplitud de tesitura y además incorporan toda la resonancia natural que le faltaba al instrumento en ocho de las doce notas de la escala temperada. Una resonancia que no sólo sirve para tenerla sino para dejar de tenerla cuando no se necesita.” <em>(ib.)</em></blockquote><p>Translation: “The strings I have added provide a wider range <strong>and also incorporate all the natural resonance that the instrument lacked in eight of the twelve notes of the tempered scale</strong>. A resonance that is useful not only to have but also to suppress when it is not needed.”</p><p>From John Schneider’s 1983 interview, discussing nineteenth-century <em>harp-</em>guitars:</p><blockquote><em>SCHNEIDER: “</em>So many of the truly romantic composers were using the ten-string. Did they tune the guitar similarly to the way you do?<em>”</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>YEPES: “Not exactly the same, because </em><strong><em>the tuning that I use is also for the resonance</em></strong><em>.” (p. 67)</em></blockquote><h4>The Critical Distinction</h4><p><strong>What is NOT the invention</strong>: Adding four strings to make ten total (done repeatedly throughout guitar history).</p><p><strong>What IS the invention</strong>:</p><ul><li><strong>The specific tuning</strong>: C2-B♭2-G♯2-F♯2 (or enharmonic equivalents)</li><li><strong>The acoustic function</strong>: Chromatic resonance balance via sympathetic reinforcement of the eight weak pitch classes (C, C♯, D♯, F, F♯, G, G♯, B♭)</li><li><strong>The re-entrant layout</strong>: String 7 lowest/frettable, strings 8–10 higher, enabling both resonance control and baroque lute repertoire</li><li><strong>The controllable system</strong>: Resonances can be engaged or selectively dampened as musical context requires</li></ul><p>Ferdinando Carulli’s <em>décacorde</em> (c. 1826) had five unfrettable harp-guitar basses below the A2 (standard tuning: E4-B3-G3-D3-A2 + <strong>G2-F2-E2-D2-C2</strong>), added for range extension and technical simplification for amateur players. While Carulli applied key-specific <em>scordature</em> that occasionally included pitches like G♯2 or F♯2 (<em>his</em> strings 6–7), <strong>he never mentioned resonance balance or lute music as design rationales</strong>. Even with G♯2 and F♯2 present, some weak pitch classes remained unsupported. More critically, his lowest four strings were unfrettable — a harp-guitar, not a frettable instrument like Yepes’s. Even with certain <em>scordature </em>approaching Yepes’s standard tuning, any resonance similarities would have been inadvertent and never fully chromatic. What’s worse: It’s impossible to play standard guitar repertoire (Sor, Giuliani, Villa-Lobos, etc.) on the <em>décacorde </em>without imposing upon it the same sort of distortion that Yepes wanted to avoid in transcriptions of baroque lute music.</p><p>Yepes’s re-entrant layout (string 7 lowest but frettable, strings 8–10 higher) is fundamentally different: all strings can be played and controlled by both hands. It enables both the chromatic resonance system and baroque lute repertoire performance — neither of which Carulli’s harp-guitar design addressed. And, unlike the <em>décacorde</em>, it remains (or includes within it) a six-string guitar — it is intended for standard guitar repertoire, not only transcriptions and/or its original compositions like Ohana’s.</p><p>Romantic harp-guitars (Stauffer, Scherzer, etc.) added bass strings for <strong>increased range</strong> — but tuned such that they largely duplicated existing pitch classes, inadvertently reinforcing already-resonant notes while doing little for the weak eight. They worsened the imbalance Yepes solved.</p><h4>Why the D-C-B-A Tuning Is Not Yepes’s Invention</h4><p>Guitarists who string their ten-strings with D2-C2-B1-A1 basses <em>appear</em> to be playing “Yepes’s instrument” while actually recreating the exact acoustic problems his invention solved. These players often justify this tuning by claiming it’s “necessary for baroque lute music” or by labelling it “the baroque tuning” — ignoring that Yepes explicitly rejected such thinking.</p><p>From Schneider’s 1983 interview (p. 66), when asked about using a baroque lute tuning on the guitar:</p><blockquote><em>“No, </em><strong><em>I do not play with a d-minor tuning</em></strong><em>, but I also have a guitar in d-minor tuning with fourteen strings; but for me it is very difficult to travel with the guitar and the lute, and the </em>other<em> guitar and the </em>other<em> lute, and the third guitar and the fourth lute…. With the ten-string guitar I have many possibilities, and </em><strong><em>I do not need the baroque tuning exactly</em></strong><em>.”</em></blockquote><p>Yepes understood that his C2-B♭2-G♯2-F♯2 tuning, with piece-specific <em>scordature</em>, provided sufficient flexibility for baroque lute repertoire without abandoning the chromatic resonance system entirely. The D2-C2-B1-A1 tuning wasn’t an improvement — it was a regression to the acoustic imbalance he had spent fourteen years solving.</p><p><strong>D2-C2-B1-A1 tuning produces</strong>:</p><ul><li><strong>D</strong>: 2 strings (4th + new 7th) = redundant reinforcement — worsened if a piece calls for 6=D (triple redundancy)</li><li><strong>E</strong>: 3 strings (6th + 5th + new 10th) = triple redundancy</li><li><strong>A</strong>: 3 strings (5th + 4th + new 10th) = triple redundancy</li><li><strong>B</strong>: 2 strings (6th + new 9th) = redundant reinforcement</li><li><strong>F♯</strong>: new 9th’s 3rd/6th partial = only one source</li><li><strong>G♯</strong>: missing entirely</li><li><strong>B♭</strong>: missing entirely</li><li><strong>C♯</strong>: missing entirely</li><li><strong>D♯</strong>: missing entirely</li><li><strong>F</strong>: missing entirely</li></ul><p>This creates the same “lopsided sonority” Yepes identified in 1949. It duplicates unwanted resonances (resulting in microtonal beating between imperfect unisons) whilst leaving five pitch classes (C♯, D♯, F, G♯, B♭ and enharmonic equivalents) completely unsupported. It is not Yepes’s invention — it is a misunderstanding of his invention.</p><p>Players who adopt this tuning sometimes explicitly state “Yepes invented nothing” (taking his 1989 “<em>inventado nada</em>” statement from <em>Ser instrumento</em> out of context) — a claim that only makes sense if you pseudo-scientifically conflate mechanism (ten strings total, irrespective of tuning) with function (chromatic resonance coverage), displaying total ignorance of the acoustic principles undergirding the instrument.</p><p>Such players also frequently claim that D2-C2-B1-A1 basses are “better for baroque lute music” (ignoring that Yepes — possessing deeper understanding — already designed his tuning for lute repertoire) or assert that “Yepes himself used D-C-B-A basses.” This last claim is patently false. Witnesses who studied directly with Yepes — including Fritz Buss, Godelieve Monden, Ismael Barambio — and family members (e.g., Ana Yepes) have stated explicitly that Narciso didn’t use D2-C2-B1-A1 basses for baroque lute music. He used <em>scordature</em>: piece-specific retuning of his C2-B♭2-G♯2-F♯2 strings, <em>not</em> string replacement or multiple, differently strung ten-strings. (For example: his re-tuning for Bach’s <em>Pièces pour la Luth</em>, BWV 995, was: 7=A1, 10=F♮2.) The documentary evidence (autograph manuscripts, concert programmes, and Yepes’s own documented words) supports this testimony.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*p-i9iEw0W5sg-QjfGTQvgw.png" /><figcaption>Yepes’s autograph manuscript of Weiss’s Allemande (Suite №2) shows the 7th string lowered from C2 to B1 via scordatura — a piece-specific retuning, not permanent string replacement — with D♯2 and C♯2 basses fretted on the 7th (the lowest string). This demonstrates his approach to baroque lute music: adjusting the C-B♭-G♯-F♯ tuning as needed, never abandoning it for D-C-B-A basses.</figcaption></figure><h4>What Yepes Invented</h4><p>Yepes did not invent “a guitar with ten strings.” He invented a <strong>tuning system designed to create complete chromatic sympathetic resonance </strong>without redundancy — something no previous guitar (six-string or hyperhexachordal) had achieved. As he stated repeatedly across decades:</p><ul><li>Previous ten-stringed guitars <strong>extended range</strong></li><li>His ten-string <strong>also completed sympathetic resonance coverage</strong></li><li>It also supplied all the open basses demanded by 11-course baroque lute music, as well as a practical solution for handling 13-course lute music</li></ul><p>The invention is not the number of strings. It is, first and foremost, the acoustic solution those specific strings, tuned C2-B♭2-G♯2-F♯2, provide; second, the musical solutions that <em>scordature</em> of those specific strings enable.</p><p>When players replace Yepes’s string configuration and tuning with others and then claim that they still have “the same resonance” or that “Yepes invented nothing because ten-string guitars already existed,” they are conflating the tool (ten strings total) with the application (chromatic resonance balance). By that logic, no one invented the thermometer because glass tubes already existed, and no one invented the telescope because lenses already existed.</p><p>Yepes invented the chromatic resonance lattice. The number of strings required to realise it <em>happened to be ten</em>. That is not the same as “inventing a ten-string guitar” — and Yepes, with characteristic humility and clarity of throught, made this meaningful distinction himself.</p><h3><strong>X. Segovia’s Shadow: Ideological Rejection and Institutional Erasure</strong></h3><p>Segovia’s decades of complaints about “weak” notes (documented in §V) make his rejection of Yepes’s solution all the more revealing. Despite decades of frustration — canceling repertoire over notes that “always fell short and weak” — Segovia condemned the instrument that solved the problem.</p><p>From his 1974 <em>Guitar Review</em> polemic, “More Strings?,” written against Yepes’s instrument:</p><blockquote><em>“I absolutely do not believe that the guitar requires additional strings, neither at the right nor at the left of its fingerboard . . . the six it traditionally possesses are quite sufficient.<br> The inventors [!] of this futile addition in sonority are far from having exhausted the natural resources of the instrument.” (p. 3)</em></blockquote><p>The irony is staggering: the same man who complained for decades about weak notes called the solution “futile.”</p><h4><strong>Segovia’s Errors Reveal Incomprehension</strong></h4><p>Segovia’s criticism reveals he never understood the instrument:</p><ul><li>Claimed Yepes “added four thick tongues” — factually wrong (only the 7th is a thicker string)</li><li>Asserted Sor “did not feel a need for additional strings” — historically false (Sor composed several works for the 21-stringed <em>harpolyre</em>)</li><li>Condemned the instrument “before he had seen or even heard” it (Kazandjian 1992: p. 234)</li></ul><p>This wasn’t musical judgment — it was <strong>ideological</strong> rejection.</p><p>The institutional dismissal extended beyond Segovia. John Williams, then studying with him, likewise condemned the instrument before hearing it in person (Sherry 1965b: pp. 6–7) — admitting his ‘judgment’ was based on friends’ reports — predicting instead that electronics would solve the resonance problem:</p><blockquote><em>SHERRY: “Have you seen Narciso Yepes play the new 10 string guitar?”</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>WILLIAMS: “No, but some of my friends have in New York. I don’t believe I would ever play one. No doubt this is an improvement over the present guitar. But, I feel in the near future, with all these new solid state electronic gadgets being produced, the guitar will have an unseen transistor system under the sound board to even out the resonance of all notes.”</em></blockquote><h4><strong>“A Sort of Devil of the Guitar”</strong></h4><p>As Ana Yepes observed in her 2016 interview with Stéphane Sacchi (2019: p. 420), the classical guitar establishment treated her father as “a sort of devil”:</p><blockquote>«Quant à Segovia, [Narciso] il l’admirait et le respectait, mais avait dû s’en éloigner, car celui-ci a critiqué sa technique novatrice en disant que ce n’était pas guitaristique. Du coup, il n’y a pas eu d’entente entre eux. Ils étaient dans des mondes opposés.</blockquote><blockquote>«Et [Segovia] il ne s’est pas privé de le faire savoir parmi le cercle de ses élèves, car l’on retrouve encore aujourd’hui des guitaristes pour qui Narciso Yepes est une sorte de diable de la guitare.»</blockquote><p>Translation:</p><blockquote><em>“As for Segovia, he [Narciso] admired and respected him, but had to distance himself from him because Segovia criticised his innovative technique, saying it wasn’t guitar-like. Consequently, </em><strong><em>there was no understanding between them. They were in opposite worlds.</em></strong></blockquote><blockquote><em>“And he </em><strong><em>[Segovia] didn’t hesitate to make it known amongst his circle of students</em></strong><em>, because </em><strong><em>we still find today guitarists for whom Narciso Yepes is a sort of devil of the guitar</em></strong><em>.”</em></blockquote><p>This wasn’t just aesthetic disagreement — it was <strong>systematic exclusion</strong>. Yepes’s technical innovations, his new instrument, his respect for but ultimate rejection of Segovia’s interpretations and tone ideals, his insistence on acoustic projection through positioning rather than misplaced faith in brightness or electronics — all made him a threat to the established orthodoxy.</p><h4><strong>Why Misattribution Served Institutional Interests</strong></h4><p>Segovia’s rejection of the ten-string protected the narrative that positioned him as arbiter of classical guitar orthodoxy. Admitting that:</p><ul><li>He had complained about a problem for decades</li><li>A performer outside his circle had solved it</li><li>The solution required understanding he lacked</li></ul><p>…would have undermined his authority. Better to dismiss the innovation, minimise Yepes’s achievement, and allow a luthier to claim credit for what was fundamentally a musician’s invention.</p><p>This is why Ramírez’s narrative — positioning the luthier as creator — was allowed to stand within the world of the classical guitar that, to this day, remains populated largely by descendants of Segovia’s glorified ignorance. It preserved the existing power structure whilst erasing the performer-innovator who challenged it. The ten-string misattribution is one piece of a larger pattern (see, e.g., my articles on “The Machinery of Suppression” — <a href="https://medium.com/@10string/duarte-attacked-yepes-institutional-gatekeeping-fe4e052794de">Part I</a> [2025a] and <a href="https://medium.com/@10string/duarte-yepes-suppression-realtime-d0da790b3ff3">Part II</a> [2025b]): systematic erasure of a performer who challenged every assumption the Segovia circle held sacred.</p><p>Segovia’s circle couldn’t solve the resonance problem he complained about for decades (Williams’s faith in gadgets never materialised) — but they could ensure the man who did solve it received no credit. That’s not historiography. <strong>That’s gatekeeping.</strong></p><h3>XI. Bernabé’s Role: The Actual Builder</h3><p>One final piece of the puzzle: Who actually built Yepes’s initial prototype at the Ramírez workshop?</p><p>From Ana Yepes’s 2016 interview with Sacchi (2019: p. 420):</p><blockquote>«Mon père a bien conçu cette guitare à dix cordes avec le luthier Paulino Bernabé… Je rappelle que dès 1969, Bernabé quitte la lutherie Ramirez III pour s’installer comme luthier indépendant. La guitare à dix cordes, contrairement à ce qui est souvent dit, est donc fabriquée par Bernabé.»</blockquote><p>Translation: “My father indeed conceived this ten-string guitar with the luthier <strong>Paulino Bernabé</strong>… I recall that from 1969, Bernabé left Ramírez III’s workshop to set up as an independent luthier. The ten-string guitar, contrary to what is often said, was thus <strong>made by Bernabé</strong>.”</p><p><strong>Paulino Bernabé Snr</strong> (1932–2007) was the foreman at José Ramírez III’s workshop during the critical period of 1963–64 (breaking with Ramírez in 1969). According to Ana Yepes’s testimony, <strong>Bernabé </strong>built the first <strong>Ramírez-branded</strong> ten-string for her father. After leaving the Ramírez workshop, Bernabé continued building and refining ten-strings under his own name, which Yepes actually played “for a long time in his concerts” (to recall Amalia Ramírez’s words) — not ten-strings built by José Ramírez III himself.</p><p><strong>The documented builder chain:</strong></p><ul><li><strong>1963–64</strong>: Bernabé builds initial Ramírez-<em>brand</em> ten-string guitar, according to Yepes’s complete conception, as Ramírez workshop foreman</li><li><strong>1969-onwards</strong>: Bernabé builds and continues to refine Yepes’s ten-string guitars under his own label — culminating in the extraordinary instrument(s) heard on Yepes’s final albums</li><li><strong>José Ramírez III</strong>: Supervised, branded, took credit</li></ul><p>This pattern is common in workshop production: the master luthier’s name appears on instruments built by employees or foremen. But it doesn’t make the master luthier the <em>inventor</em> of a novel design commissioned by a client.</p><p><strong>Proper attribution:</strong></p><ul><li><strong>Inventor</strong>: Narciso Yepes</li><li><strong>Prototype builder</strong>: Paulino Bernabé Snr (in Ramírez workshop)</li><li><strong>Yepes’s builder (post-1969)</strong>: Paulino Bernabé Snr (independent)</li><li><strong>Prototype brand/supervisor</strong>: Guitarras Ramírez/José Ramírez III</li><li><strong>Non-inventor contributor(s):</strong> José Ramírez III and/or Paulino Bernabé Snr</li></ul><p>As an instructive analogy: No one credits the <strong>engineers</strong>, <strong>digital modeling experts</strong>, <strong>fabricators</strong>, and <strong>horticulturalists </strong>who constructed the artist<strong> </strong>Jeff Koons’s <em>Puppy</em> (1992) as “co-creators” of the sculpture — i.e., as artists. Koons (the artist) <em>conceived</em> it; they (fabricators, assistants) <em>executed</em> his specifications. Yet when Paulino Bernabé built Yepes’s ten-string to Yepes’s specifications in Ramírez’s workshop, the brand on the label became “creator” and the inventor became “collaborator.” This isn’t how attribution works in any other field of creation/innovation — except when institutional interests require erasing an inconvenient innovator, denigrated as “a sort of devil of the guitar.”</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*fg7rc2I_Z_d75Y84bb-xPQ.png" /><figcaption>“Puppy” (1992) by Jeff Koons.</figcaption></figure><h3>XII. Conclusion: Why Accurate Attribution Matters</h3><p>Over the course of six decades, the invention of Narciso Yepes’s ten-string guitar has been systematically misattributed. José Ramírez III claimed credit by conflating his failed “d’amore” experiment with Yepes’s solution, minimising the documented phone call where Yepes provided complete conception, and never explaining the tuning that <em>is</em> the invention itself. His daughter Amalia has polished this narrative in recent blog posts, admitting Yepes “devised a tuning system” (never named or explained) whilst framing this as a minor detail in her father’s creation. Likewise, Maurice Ohana has been incorrectly credited by scholars who confuse a kindred spirit’s early adoption with co-invention.</p><p>The evidence for Yepes’s sole authorship is overwhelming:</p><p><strong>Patent Law</strong>: Conception (Yepes’s phone call to Ramírez detailing a novel and non-obvious solution to a musical problem) legally defines inventorship, not reduction to practice (Bernabé’s construction under Ramírez brand).</p><p><strong>Primary Source</strong>: Ramírez’s own book documents the phone call where Yepes rejected the “d’amore” guitar, specified external strings, cited his prior study, explained the acoustic reasoning, and provided the technical solution: four strings tuned a particular way, for which he had made a study.</p><p><strong>Technical Understanding</strong>: Yepes <em>explained</em> the tuning (C2-B♭2-G♯2-F♯2) and its function (chromatic resonance coverage and — with piece-specific <em>scordature</em> — lute transcription) with precision across dozens of interviews. Ramírez never demonstrated this understanding. Ohana mentioned the goal of “completing the chromatic range” but didn’t expound the acoustic reasons why these specific pitches (C2-B♭2-G♯2-F♯2) achieve that goal through harmonic partials, including <strong>not only their octaves but also their compound perfect fifths</strong>. Unlike Ramírez and Amalia, Ohana at least acknowledged the tuning (at times imprecisely) — but acknowledgment ≠ invention.</p><p><strong>Contemporaneous Attribution</strong>: Vidal 1966 (“Yepes had the idea… had it built”), <em>Chicago Tribune</em> 1987, <em>Christian Science Monitor</em> 1981, <em>Toronto Star</em> 1986, and many others — all attribute invention to Yepes.</p><p><strong>Timeline Evidence</strong>: Ohana sketched “Synchronies,” either for six-string guitar (feeling “caged” by its limitations) or in anticipation of the realisation of Yepes’s new instrument (discussed with the composer), before the ten-string physically existed, then finalised <em>Si le jour paraît…</em> some time after Yepes received the instrument on 1 March 1964.</p><p><strong>The Fleta Threat</strong>: Yepes had to threaten to commission another luthier before Ramírez agreed — proof that Yepes was client, not collaborator.</p><p><strong>Viola/Guitar d’Amore and Harp-guitar Refutation</strong>: Yepes explicitly stated his concept was “exactly the contrary” of duplicating already-resonant notes; his system supplies missing ones.</p><p><strong>Segovia’s Hypocrisy</strong>: Complained about “snuffed” notes for decades, rejected the solution, never credited Yepes, made factual errors about the instrument he immediately condemned before seeing or hearing it.</p><h4><strong>The Invention Defined</strong></h4><p>The ten-string guitar of Narciso Yepes is not “a guitar with four extra strings.” It is, first and foremost, a <strong>tuning system</strong> — a chromatic resonance lattice that completes the acoustic architecture the six-string guitar lacks. It also provides practical solutions for the transcription of baroque lute music — without sacrificing the standard configuration and tuning of the first six strings: it still contains a six-string guitar.</p><p><strong>The primary aspect of the invention consists of:</strong></p><ol><li>Four strings tuned C2-B♭2-G♯2-F♯2 (or C-B♭-A♭-G♭/C-A♯-G♯-F♯ in enharmonic spellings)</li><li>Positioned as strings 7–10, with string 7 lowest (easily frettable), strings 8–10 re-entrant (also potentially frettable)</li><li>Functioning through harmonic partials (octaves, compound fifths, and their octaves) to provide sympathetic reinforcement for every treble-string semitone from F♯3/G3 to B5 (the full treble string range)</li><li>Controllable via right-hand (or left-hand) damping for selective engagement or suppression</li></ol><p>This transforms the “lopsided sonority” of the six-string into chromatic balance as a baseline (the performer can now shape musical interpretation to <em>his</em> will, not the guitar’s <em>whims</em>), enables technical and interpretive possibilities (e.g., polyphonic clarity, emphasis/sustain where it is musically meaningful/demanded) otherwise compromised on the guitar, and eliminates the “weak,” “muffled,” “snuffed” notes Segovia “frequently” complained about.</p><h4><strong>Why This Matters</strong></h4><p>Accurate attribution shapes how we understand the guitar’s history, whose innovations we study and honour, and what possibilities we see for the instrument’s future.</p><p>If we accept the Ramírez narrative — that luthiers “create” instruments whilst performers “collaborate” — we reinforce a hierarchy where actual <em>musicians</em> are subordinate to builders, where <em>conception</em> is less valued than fabrication, and where performer-innovators like Yepes are erased from history. This isn’t merely incorrect attribution in the legal sense; it’s part of the institutional machinery that has suppressed Yepes’s legacy for six decades. As his daughter testified, the classical guitar establishment treated him as “a sort of devil” — not for lacking merit, but for possessing too much of it outside their approved channels.</p><p>If we accept the “Ohana” narrative — that composers “invent” instruments through their aesthetic desires — we erase the technical problem-solving that makes those aesthetic goals achievable.</p><p>The truth is that <strong>Narciso Yepes identified acoustic and musical problems, developed a system-level solution, and commissioned an instrument to realise that solution</strong>. He is the legally-defined inventor. José Ramírez III and/or Paulino Bernabé built it. Maurice Ohana was the first to write for it.</p><p>Each played a role. But only one conceived the invention.</p><p>This misattribution isn’t anomalous — it’s systematic machinery. When Ana Yepes described her father as treated like “a sort of devil of the guitar,” she was describing the institutional forces that made this theft possible. The same orthodoxy that dismissed Yepes’s technical innovations, rejected his acoustical understanding, and marginalised his interpretive approach also allowed a luthiery brand to claim credit for a musician’s invention, and academics to attribute it to a composer who recognised its significance (and eagerly embraced it) before anyone else did.</p><p>The ten-string attribution is one erasure among many. Correcting it means confronting not just bad history, but the power structures that created and maintain it. Segovia’s circle couldn’t solve the resonance problem Segovia complained about for decades (Williams’s prophetic faith in gadgets never came true) — but they could ensure the man who did solve it received no credit. That’s not historiography. <strong>That’s gatekeeping.</strong></p><h3>PRIMARY SOURCES: YEPES IN HIS OWN WORDS</h3><p>The evidence presented throughout this article draws extensively on Yepes’s own print-text explanations of his invention across multiple interviews spanning nearly three decades. Below are some additional documentary sources — an audio recording and a compilation of seven video clips — in which Yepes articulates (in his own words ) the acoustic reasoning, musical necessity, and systematic development that define his ten-string guitar as a novel solution to long-standing problems.</p><h4>Video 1: BBC Radio 3 Interview (13 July 1974)</h4><p><strong>Narciso Yepes Explains His Ten-String Guitar: Five Reasons</strong><br> <em>BBC Radio 3, “The Classical Guitar,” live from Broadcasting House, London</em><br> <em>Interviewed by Peter Sensier, 13 July 1974, 16:20</em></p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FqjADWHuLsRU%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DqjADWHuLsRU&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FqjADWHuLsRU%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/90e1d505420b6be2d261da8ca02e0d04/href">https://medium.com/media/90e1d505420b6be2d261da8ca02e0d04/href</a></iframe><p><strong>Timestamps:</strong></p><ul><li>00:00 • Introduction (Peter Sensier)</li><li>00:24 • <strong>First Reason (A): Resonance (‘Overtones’)</strong> — Yepes explains the chromatic resonance lattice</li><li>03:35 • <strong>First Reason (B): Legato</strong> — Interpretive advantages</li><li>04:48 • <strong>Second Reason: Baroque Lute Music</strong> — Scordatura applications</li><li>05:45 • <strong>Third Reason: New Music</strong> — Contemporary repertoire possibilities</li><li>06:03 • <strong>Fourth Reason: Justified Transcriptions</strong> — Maintaining compositional integrity</li><li>06:50 • <strong>Fifth Reason: It’s Still a 6-String Guitar</strong> — Refuting the “different instrument” fallacy (that it’s only meant for lute and/or contemporary music)</li></ul><h4>Video 2: Compilation of Interviews</h4><p><strong>Narciso Yepes Discusses the Ten-String Guitar Across Multiple Interviews</strong><br> <em>Compiled German, Spanish, and Japanese television interviews, various dates</em><br> (<em>English subtitles)</em></p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2F4pnC4JwJTtw%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3D4pnC4JwJTtw&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2F4pnC4JwJTtw%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/0c0347f775bda0c97383a022e6f70c89/href">https://medium.com/media/0c0347f775bda0c97383a022e6f70c89/href</a></iframe><p><strong>Timestamps:</strong></p><ul><li>00:00 • Introduction</li><li>00:07 • <strong>Interview A: A Musical Necessity</strong> — Not adding four strings to the guitar on a whim, but out of necessity</li><li>01:35 • <strong>Interview B: Critics vs Guitarists vs Listeners</strong> — Institutional resistance vs audience/critical acceptance</li><li>02:23 • <strong>Interview C: Resonance and Lute Music</strong> — Dual rationale for the invention</li><li>04:54 • <strong>Interview D: Unanimous Approval of Non-guitarist Musicians</strong> — Corroborates the 15 March 1964 house concert (§I)</li><li>06:58 • <strong>Interview E: Historically, the Guitar Had More than 6 Strings</strong> — Historical precedent and scordature for Bach’s lute music</li><li>12:24 • <strong>Interview F: The Innovation is in the Tuning, Not the Number of Strings</strong> — Explicitly refutes the “any ten strings will do” fallacy (§IX)</li><li>12:43 • <strong>Interview G: Resonance</strong> — Further explanation/demonstration of sympathetic vibration</li></ul><h3><strong>Works Cited</strong></h3><p>Appleby, Wilfrid M. 1949. “The Spanish Guitar: Outstanding Performance.” <em>B.M.G.</em>, XLVI(529): 166.</p><p>Eckert Jr, Thor. 1981. “Guitarist Narciso Yepes, the virtuoso who invented his own instrument.” <em>The Christian Science Monitor. </em>23 November. Online: <a href="https://www.csmonitor.com/1981/1123/112301.html">https://www.csmonitor.com/1981/1123/112301.html</a>.</p><p>Estarellas, Gabriel. [1989/1990?]. “Entrevista a Narciso Yepes.” Filmed interview at Auditórium de Palma, Balearic Islands. <a href="https://youtu.be/XH3RF9ud6Jg?si=1wBx_JSJCoPEZjEo&amp;t=1592">Online</a>.</p><p>Kazandjian, Fred. 1992. <em>The Concept and Development of the Yepes Ten-String Guitar: a Preliminary Investigation</em>. M.Mus. thesis, University of Cape Town.</p><p>Kozinn, Allan. 1980. “Narciso Yepes: Classical Master of the 10-string Guitar.” <em>Frets Magazine</em>, February: 39–41.</p><p>Kozinn, Allan. 1981. “Narciso Yepes and His 10-String Guitar”. <em>The New York Times</em>, Section 2, 22 November: D21–22.</p><p>Miner, Gregg. 2013. “Guitar d’Amore.” <em>Harpguitars.net</em> [website], 8 December. <a href="https://www.harpguitars.net/2013/12/08/guitar-damore/#:~:text=Dec%208,%202013,Ian%27s%20photos%20for%20this%20series:">Online</a>.</p><p>Pérez Castillo, Belén. 2014. “Narciso Yepes y los compositores de su tiempo,” in Tobalina, E. (ed.). <em>Narciso Yepes. </em>Nombres propios de la guitarra. Córdoba: Ayuntamiento de Córdoba, 43–103.</p><p>Ramírez, Amalia. 2022. “José Ramírez III talking about Narciso Yepes in the Figura y paisaje programme.” <em>Guitarrasramirez.com</em> [Website], <br>16 November. Online: <a href="https://guitarrasramirez.com/en/jose-ramirez-iii-narciso-yepes-figura-y-paisaje-programme/">https://guitarrasramirez.com/en/jose-ramirez-iii-narciso-yepes-figura-y-paisaje-programme/</a>.</p><p>Ramírez, Amalia. 2020. “Historical hints (C.13): 10 string guitar and its author.” <em>Guitarrasramirez.com</em> [Website], <br>21 April. Online: <a href="https://guitarrasramirez.com/en/historical-hints-c-13-10-string-guitar-and-its-author/">https://guitarrasramirez.com/en/jose-ramirez-iii-narciso-yepes-figura-y-paisaje-programme/</a>.</p><p>Ramírez, José III. 1994. <em>Things About the Guitar</em>. Madrid: Ediciones Casa Ramírez.</p><p>Reeder, Steve. 1984. “Face to Face with Narciso Yepes: Part II.” <em>Guitarra Magazine</em> 10(58): 8–10. Available at: <a href="https://www.digitalguitararchive.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/06/GuitarraMagazine-58.pdf">https://www.digitalguitararchive.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/06/GuitarraMagazine-58.pdf</a>.</p><p>Sacchi, Stéphane. 2019. <em>Des racines à la matière: l’univers sonore des oeuvres pour guitare de Maurice Ohana</em>. Doctoral thesis, Université de Rennes 2.</p><p>Schneider, John. 1983. “Conversation with Narciso Yepes.” <em>Soundboard</em>, Spring: 66–68.</p><p>Segovia, Andrés. 1974. “More Strings?” <em>Guitar Review </em>39, Summer: 2–4.</p><p>Sherry, James. 1965a. “A Surprise Visit from Narciso Yepes.” <em>Guitarra Magazine</em>, January–February: 12–16. Available at: <a href="https://www.digitalguitararchive.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/08/GuitarraMagazine-12.pdf">https://www.digitalguitararchive.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/08/GuitarraMagazine-12.pdf</a>.</p><p>Sherry, James. 1965b. “With John Williams.” <em>Guitarra Magazine</em>, January–February: 6–7.</p><p>Snitzler, Larry. 1978. “Narciso Yepes — The 10-string Guitar: Overcoming the Limitations of Six Strings.” <em>Guitar Player</em> 12(3): 26, 42, 46, 48, 52.</p><p>Van Niekerk, Viktor. 2025a. “The Machinery of Suppression: How John W. Duarte Tried to Destroy Narciso Yepes.” <em>Medium</em>. Online: <a href="https://medium.com/@10string/duarte-attacked-yepes-institutional-gatekeeping-fe4e052794de">https://medium.com/@10string/duarte-attacked-yepes-institutional-gatekeeping-fe4e052794de</a>.</p><p>Van Niekerk, Viktor. 2025b. “The Machinery of Suppression (Part II): A Real-Time Demonstration.” <em>Medium</em>. Online: <a href="https://medium.com/@10string/duarte-yepes-suppression-realtime-d0da790b3ff3">https://medium.com/@10string/duarte-yepes-suppression-realtime-d0da790b3ff3</a>.</p><p>Van Niekerk, Viktor. 2023. “Fritz Buss on the 10-string Guitar of Narciso Yepes,” from <em>A Meeting of Minds</em> [Video, online preview], Viktor van Niekerk 10-string guitar Channel, 5 June. Online: <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ab2fSbCwEWk">https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ab2fSbCwEWk</a>.</p><p>Vidal, Pierre. 1966. “Rencontre avec Maurice Ohana et Narciso Yepes au Club des Trois Centres.” <em>Musica disques</em> 147, June: 8–10.</p><p>Yepes, Narciso. 1989. <em>Ser instrumento</em>. Speech of Ingression into the Real Academia de Bellas Artes de San Fernando, 30 April.</p><p>Yepes, Narciso. 1973. “The Ten-string Guitar “ [Liner notes]. Trans. L. Salter. In: <em>La Guitare de Narciso Yepes </em>[Vinyl Record]. Deutsche Grammophon: 2.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=8e62c83d0b41" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Machinery of Suppression (Part II): A Real-Time Demonstration]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@10string/duarte-yepes-suppression-realtime-d0da790b3ff3?source=rss-8026079d565e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/d0da790b3ff3</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[classical-guitar]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[music-history]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[media-criticism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[institutional-critique]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[classical-music]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Viktor van Niekerk]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 04 Dec 2025 14:31:30 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-12-07T09:12:00.095Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>How forum responses and defensive emails prove the mechanisms documented in the original investigation</h4><p>Within days of publishing “<a href="https://medium.com/@10string/duarte-attacked-yepes-institutional-gatekeeping-fe4e052794de">The Machinery of Suppression: How John W. Duarte Tried to Destroy Narciso Yepes</a>,” the mechanisms documented in that investigation began operating in real time. Forum responses followed predictable patterns: dismissal without engagement, appeals to authority, character assassination. Then came an email from Chris Duarte, the critic’s son, attempting to defend his father’s legacy.</p><p>These responses don’t refute the investigation. They <strong>demonstrate</strong> it.</p><h3>What the Investigation Documented (Summary)</h3><p>The original article provided comprehensive evidence of systematic institutional gatekeeping spanning decades (1955–1989):</p><p><strong>Fabricated narrative:</strong> In July 1955, John W. Duarte (writing as “Discus”) claimed Narciso Yepes was “one of the two best known and most advanced pupils of Segovia.” This was false. Yepes never studied with Segovia. His only documented pedagogical interaction came in 1960 at Compostela, where Segovia “was very hard on him” for playing his own Bach transcription, effectively excommunicating him. Yet five years earlier, Duarte had already positioned Yepes as Segovia’s subordinate ‘student’ — <strong>fabricating a hierarchical relationship to naturalise future attacks</strong>.</p><p><strong>Acoustically untenable claims:</strong> Duarte accused Yepes of “thin tone” and “clipped bass notes” (1955–1961). Spectrographic analysis proves the opposite: Yepes’s recordings show greater sustain and low-mid spectral energy (dark, projecting tone) compared to Segovia’s brighter timbral characteristics and often staccato articulation. Duarte’s accusations described Segovia’s playing better than Yepes’s — <strong>an inversion of acoustic reality</strong>.</p><p><strong>Self-contradictory reviews:</strong> Reviewing Yepes’s 1971 Villa-Lobos album in <em>Gramophone</em> (December 1978), Duarte condemned it for being “accurate” with “none of the rubato that Bream deploys,” lamenting “even his waywardness of tempo is absent.” When the <strong>identical recordings</strong> were reissued on CD (1988), Duarte condemned them for “a kind of sentimentality… and note values that are too distorted,” “marked by slow tempos” (<em>Gramophone</em>, April 1989). <strong>Logical impossibility:</strong> The exact same performances cannot simultaneously be accurate (lack rubato) AND have distorted note values — unless the critic’s agenda supersedes observable reality. <strong>Proof of bad faith.</strong></p><p><strong>Eyewitness refutation:</strong> Oliver Walker, chief music critic of Johannesburg’s <em>The Star</em>, was present at Yepes’s 1961 Wigmore Hall debut. He described “a crowded and vociferously enthusiastic hall” and rejected Duarte’s criticisms as absurd: “either Mr. Duarte has mislaid his ear-trumpet or his arteries had got the better of him.” Walker characterised Duarte’s review as “bilious dissection… animated largely by envy, frustration, pettiness and plain jealousy.”</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*d3WoxZ1PJn3D5MaBEPdGbw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Oliver Walker’s July 1961 refutation of Duarte’s April 1961 attack on Yepes.</figcaption></figure><p><strong>Documented incompetence:</strong> Guitarist Philip Hii, who studied with Duarte in 1980, documented that Duarte “could hardly hold the guitar properly and what came out of his fingers were a few scratchy sounds.” Lessons consisted of gossip rather than instruction. When Hii sought another teacher, Duarte sent “three typed pages of pure vitriol and biting sarcasm,” threatening to contact immigration authorities to forcibly expel Hii from the UK.</p><p><strong>Network coordination:</strong> Vladimir Bobri, editor of <em>Guitar Review</em> and Segovia loyalist, publicly endorsed Duarte’s attack on Yepes: “Will you please convey my sincere congratulations to Jack Duarte on his lucid and constructive criticism… His is the sort of reporting that should do a great deal towards the dispelling of unwarranted admirations.” <strong>This proves network coordination, not isolated opinion.</strong></p><p>This wasn’t one critic’s idiosyncratic opinion. It was institutional enforcement.</p><h3>Forum Responses: A Taxonomy of Evasion</h3><h3>Pattern 1: Strategic Minimisation</h3><p><strong><em>Canuck</em> (Delcamp forum):</strong> “I feel that one or two examples would have been enough to show that Duarte didn’t give Yepes good reviews. It happens.”</p><p><strong>The rhetorical move: Strategic minimisation.</strong> Reduce decades of documented institutional suppression to “a critic gave bad reviews.” The comprehensiveness that makes the case ironclad becomes “excessive evidence.” What the investigation actually demonstrates (e.g., bad faith) is misrepresented as something else entirely (“bad reviews”).</p><p><strong>What Canuck actually wants:</strong> Just enough to note “Duarte didn’t like Yepes” — but <strong>not enough to prove systematic gatekeeping</strong>. One or two examples allow dismissal as isolated pettiness. Decades of coordinated attacks, network endorsement, fabricated timeline, and self-contradictory reviews prove <strong>institutional enforcement</strong>.</p><p>Canuck’s earlier, dishonest dismissal: “It’s a nitpicky article about a string of negative reviews of Yepes by a single anonymous critic.”</p><p><strong>Three errors in one sentence, each revealing:</strong></p><ol><li><strong>“Anonymous critic”</strong> — False. Duarte wrote under his own name AND the pseudonym “Discus” (confirmed to be Duarte by Paul Fowles in <em>Classical Guitar</em>, Autumn 2019). Claiming he was “anonymous” dishonestly erases the documented pattern.</li><li><strong>“Nitpicky”</strong> — Rhetorical dismissal. Forensic documentation of fabricated narrative, logical impossibilities, and network coordination becomes “nitpicky” when you can’t refute the evidence. An admission of defeat.</li><li><strong>“A string of negative reviews”</strong> — Minimisation. Not “negative reviews” — <strong>coordinated suppression</strong> endorsed by Segovia’s network (Bobri), contradicted by eyewitnesses (Walker), contradicting itself (1978 vs 1989), and perpetuating fabrications (1955 empirically untenable acoustic claims uncorrected in 1997 obituary and beyond).</li></ol><p><strong>Later escalation:</strong> “Critics are subjective and often petty and negative. There’s no need for pseudo-courtroom drama like ‘charges’ or ‘evidence’ or ‘judgment’. Are bad reviews often unfair? Yes. Is it surprising? No.”</p><p><strong>Canuck then adds “Dorothy Parker” deflection:</strong> Posts image with quip “Lucky thing Dorothy Parker didn’t review classical guitar performances.”</p><p><strong>The rhetorical move:</strong> Deflect with humour, imply the investigation is precious/oversensitive.</p><p><strong>The Dorothy Parker comparison is telling:</strong></p><p>Parker was a witty theatre critic known for devastating one-liners. She didn’t (to my knowledge):</p><ul><li>Fabricate biographical falsehoods about actors (Duarte: “pupil of Segovia”)</li><li>Publish contradictory reviews of the same performance (Duarte: 1978 vs 1989)</li><li>Threaten students with deportation (Duarte: Philip Hii)</li><li>Coordinate with powerful networks to suppress careers (Duarte: Bobri endorsement)</li></ul><p><strong>Comparing Duarte to Parker is a category error</strong> — confusing sharp criticism with institutional corruption. Parker’s wit was (to my knowledge) honest aesthetic judgement. Duarte’s attacks were domonstrable fabrications serving network enforcement.</p><p><strong>The rhetorical strategy: Normalisation.</strong> Frame documented fraud as inevitable critical pettiness. Dismiss forensic/historical evidence as “pseudo-courtroom drama.” Appeal to cynicism: “Everyone knows critics are mean — what’s new?”</p><p><strong>What this accomplishes:</strong> Inoculates readers against recognising <strong>systematic institutional corruption</strong> by treating it as ordinary critical disagreement. “Critics are petty” becomes a shield against examining whether specific criticisms were <strong>fabricated lies</strong> (pupil of Segovia), <strong>logical impossibilities</strong> (1978 vs 1989), or <strong>acoustically false</strong> (spectrographic evidence).</p><p><strong>The mechanism revealed:</strong> When comprehensive evidence can’t be refuted, reframe it as excessive, dismiss documentation as theatrical, and normalise fraud as “critics being critics.”</p><p><strong>What Canuck systematically ignores:</strong></p><ul><li>Fabricated “pupil of Segovia” timeline (factual untruth)</li><li>Spectrographic evidence (acoustic measurement)</li><li>1978 vs 1989 contradiction (logical impossibility)</li><li>Walker’s eyewitness refutation (direct contradiction of claimed facts by a professional critic)</li><li>Network coordination via Bobri endorsement (proves institutional enforcement, not isolated pettiness)</li></ul><h3>Pattern 2: Success-as-Refutation Deflection</h3><p><strong><em>m k ljus</em> (Delcamp forum):</strong> “my impression has always been that Yepes was one of the greatest and most successful guitarists of his generation with immense influence for subsequent generations, and the last time I checked, several pieces written for him are standard repertoire.”</p><p><strong>The rhetorical move: False dilemma.</strong> Frame the question as binary: either suppression <strong>completely prevented</strong> success, or suppression didn’t occur/didn’t matter. This ignores how institutional gatekeeping actually operates — not through total prevention, but through <strong>limitation, distortion, and marginalisation</strong>.</p><p><strong>The flawed logic unpacked:</strong></p><p><strong>1. Success despite suppression ≠ no suppression occurred.</strong></p><p>Yepes filled Carnegie Hall DESPITE the myths Duarte planted, not because they didn’t exist or didn’t mislead generations of guitarists. Thor Eckert Jr. (<em>The Christian Science Monitor</em>, 1982) reported: “His guitar fills the hall with sound. The musician who plucks it is one of the finest in the world today.”</p><p>Yet Allan Kozinn’s 1997 <em>New York Times</em> obituary still repeated Duarte’s fabrication: “Compared with the more flowing style of his older contemporary, Andrés Segovia… Mr. Yepes’ style could sound oddly clipped” — <strong>36 years after Oliver Walker’s eyewitness refutation</strong> and <strong>despite spectrographic proof of the opposite</strong>.</p><p><strong>This is how suppression operates long-term:</strong> Not by preventing all recognition, but by <strong>contaminating the historical record</strong>. The myths persist alongside the success, limiting full recognition and perpetuating hierarchies that frame Yepes as talented-but-flawed rather than offering equally valid alternative approaches.</p><p><strong>2. “Several pieces are standard repertoire”</strong> — <strong>Appeal to vague generality.</strong> Which ones? Compare: How many Segovia or Julian Bream dedications versus Yepes dedications are regularly programmed? The vast majority of music written for Yepes remains marginalised, even if we eliminate those that are unplayable without a 10-string. Empirical, peer-reviewed musicological research proved marginalisation concerning the BBC’s treatment of Maurice Ohana, to give one example — ironically, one of the Yepes composers whose pieces are now widely recorded, if not quite “standard repertoire.”</p><p>Moreover, even in the few works written for Yepes that have been adopted, adoption only occurs after the works have been <strong>“sanitised” and returned to orthodox technique</strong>. Consider Vicente Asencio’s <em>Col·lectici íntim</em> (1970): almost nobody who has adopted these pieces bothers to acquire the techniques around which they were written. Instead, they adapt the music to orthodox technique — precisely the conformity enforcement the investigation documents.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*c9SptlwzVXLz4ySX_7MM8g.jpeg" /><figcaption>Yepes and Asencio collaborating on the writing of “<em>Col·lectici íntim” (Cabo Roig, August 1970).</em></figcaption></figure><p>Example: the double-stop chromatic scale in bar 33 of <em>La gaubança</em>, which most performers either play as portamento or rasgueado instead of engaging properly with Yepes’s technical solution. These pieces were written in collaborative approach — Yepes and Asencio working together at the former’s home in Cabo Roig in 1970. The techniques were ones that Yepes developed whilst studying with Asencio: they’re integral to the work, not optional difficulties to be circumvented.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/proxy/1*nJ3aR-fxbRoc8P4P61hgfA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Yepes and Asencio collaborating on the writing of “<em>Col·lectici íntim” (Cabo Roig, August 1970).</em></figcaption></figure><p><strong>This reveals suppression through sanitised adoption:</strong> Permit the work into repertoire, but strip away the technical innovations that made it distinctive. The same goes for the 10-string guitar, positioned at a 45-degree angle (or strung/tuned incorrectly), stripped of its intended sonority. The result: superficial acceptance that erases the alternative approach the work/instrument represented. The piece/instrument enters standard repertoire/praxis only after being made to conform — exactly the template enforcement Duarte’s reviews demanded.</p><p><strong>3. The myths persist regardless of objective achievement.</strong></p><p>When institutional gatekeepers control the narrative for decades, fabrications become “common knowledge.” This is precisely how suppression operates long-term: not by preventing success, but by <strong>limiting, distorting, and marginalising</strong> what should have been central to the instrument’s development.</p><p><strong><em>m k ljus</em>’s concession reveals the evasion:</strong> “I understand that his recordings or concerts also divided opinions back then and continue to do so today, which I accept to be a genuine reaction, but I still consider Duarte’s quoted reviews a bit unfair.”</p><p><strong>“A bit unfair”</strong> — <strong>Radical understatement.</strong> Fabricating biographical untruth (“pupil of Segovia”)? Self-contradictory reviews (1978 vs 1989)? Acoustically untenable claims (spectrographically disproven)? Eyewitness-refuted accusations? These aren’t “a bit unfair” — they’re <strong>documented fraud masquerading as criticism</strong>.</p><p><strong>The rhetorical function:</strong> Minimise systematic institutional corruption as minor critical disagreement. “Divided opinions” conflates <strong>legitimate aesthetic disagreement</strong> with <strong>fabricated accusations</strong>. Some opinions were genuine. Others were lies. The investigation documents which were which.</p><p><strong>What <em>m k ljus</em> systematically ignores:</strong></p><ul><li>The fabricated biographical narrative (factual untruth)</li><li>The self-contradictory reviews (logical impossibilities)</li><li>The spectrographically disproven acoustic claims (measurable falsehoods)</li><li>The coordinated network attacks (not “divided opinions” — institutional enforcement)</li></ul><h3>Pattern 3: Damage Control Through Partial Concession</h3><p><strong>Stephen Kenyon (Delcamp forum):</strong> “the limits of Duarte’s practical musicianship… had fallen off greatly from whatever command he may have achieved in his prime… the only direct teaching situation I saw personally Duarte in (at a summer school) was acutely embarrassing, because, as per the article, he did little other than waffle anecdotes.”</p><p><strong>The rhetorical strategy: Damage control through tactical concession.</strong> Acknowledge obvious problems (incompetence, flawed personality) to establish credibility, then perform damage limitation that protects the institution whilst appearing reasonable.</p><p><strong>The concessions Kenyon makes:</strong></p><ul><li>Duarte’s playing ability “had fallen off greatly”</li><li>Teaching witnessed was “acutely embarrassing”</li><li>“He did little other than waffle anecdotes”</li><li>“A very flawed personality in some ways”</li></ul><p><strong>Each concession is immediately followed by deflection:</strong></p><p><strong>Deflection 1: Reviews Don’t Matter Anyway</strong></p><p><strong>Kenyon:</strong> “reviews are entirely irrelevant… for the great majority of an artist’s audience”</p><p><strong>The contradiction:</strong> If reviews are “irrelevant,” why did <em>Soundboard</em> dedicate 23 pages (plus cover) to a reviewer’s 2006 posthumous tribute, with multiple contributors insisting on his “honesty” as critic? Why the sustained, decades-long campaign against Yepes if it didn’t matter?</p><p><strong>The reality ignored by this deflection:</strong> Reviews matter immensely for <strong>institutional positioning</strong> — broadcast opportunities, pedagogical influence, historiographical narrative. Duarte’s fabrications (in)directly shaped how generations of guitarists learnt to think about Yepes. The acoustically untenable myths he planted in 1955 were still being repeated in the 1997 <em>New York Times</em> obituary and beyond, into the Wikipedia (and Delcamp) age of (dis)information. That’s not “irrelevant” — that’s successful long-term suppression.</p><p><strong>Deflection 2: Geographic Limitation</strong></p><p><strong>Kenyon:</strong> “The degree to which Duarte could act as gate-keeper was inherently limited” [as if he were the only gatekeeper, and as if the investigation didn’t explicitly state its scope]</p><p><strong>The double mechanism:</strong> Minimise London’s gatekeeping role.</p><p><strong>What this ignores:</strong></p><ul><li><strong><em>B.M.G.</em>’s international distribution</strong> across the (Anglophone) guitar world</li><li><strong>Vladimir Bobri’s immediate endorsement</strong> amplifying attacks in the US (<em>Guitar Review</em>)</li><li><strong>The myths becoming “common knowledge”</strong> (1997 obituary, forum discussions decades later)</li><li><strong>Institutional enforcement through pedagogy</strong> (students internalising these narratives)</li><li><strong>London WAS a gatekeeping node</strong> — Oliver Walker had to publish a rebuttal precisely <strong>because</strong> the attack was being circulated as far afield as South Africa</li></ul><p><strong>Deflection 3: Category Error on Playing vs Teaching</strong></p><p><strong>Kenyon:</strong> “for very many who teach at high levels of interpretive consideration, whether or not the tutor can match the playing level of the student is not an issue, as it is far more about how the feedback is managed verbally, ideas communicated etc.”</p><p><strong>The category error:</strong> The investigation doesn’t claim “Duarte couldn’t play at student level.” It documents that he <strong>couldn’t play the guitar at all</strong> whilst claiming authority to judge Yepes’s (and others’) technique and musicianship. We also see exemplified here the typically Modernist lie that one may possess “high levels of interpretive consideration” or understanding without ever having studied the art of interpretation as a competent player.</p><p><strong>The distinction that matters:</strong></p><ul><li><strong>A teacher whose playing has declined</strong> (e.g., due to extreme old age) but who understands technique and the art of interpretation and can communicate principles verbally = still legitimate pedagogue</li><li><strong>Someone who “could hardly hold the guitar properly”</strong> (Hii) producing “a few scratchy sounds” whilst condemning Yepes’s tone production, technical execution, and understanding of interpretation = fraudulent authority</li></ul><p>Kenyon himself witnessed teaching from Duarte that was “acutely embarrassing… he did little other than waffle anecdotes” — yet frames this as acceptable because “quite a number [of Duarte compositions] have entered the general repertoire” (<strong>appeal to <em>alleged</em> popularity</strong> regarding compositions, not teaching or criticism).</p><p><strong>The evasion:</strong> Acknowledge incompetence, then deflect to irrelevant credentials (compositional output, teaching invitations) to avoid the actual question: <strong>On what basis did someone who couldn’t demonstrate a modicum of practical musicianship claim authority to condemn Yepes’s technical and interpretive choices?</strong></p><p><strong>Deflection 4: Posthumous Rehabilitation</strong></p><p><strong>Kenyon:</strong> “Duarte seems to me to have been a very flawed personality in some ways… but he did grow and change and improve over the years”</p><p><strong>The rhetorical move: Narrative of redemption.</strong> Frame character flaws and early incompetence as growing pains — he got better, learnt from mistakes, matured. <em>Yet he never honestly retracted criticisms made in error.</em></p><p><strong>What this ignores:</strong> The investigation documents fabrications spanning <strong>1955–1989</strong> (including the 1978 vs 1989 Villa-Lobos contradictions). That’s 34 years of documented bad faith. At what point did this “improvement” occur?</p><ul><li>1955: “Pupil of Segovia” fabrication; acoustically untenable “thin tone” claim</li><li>1961: Eyewitness-refuted accusations</li><li>1978: “Accurate,” lacks rubato</li><li>1989: “Distorted note values” (same Villa-Lobos recording)</li></ul><p>When exactly did Duarte “improve” sufficiently to retract the 1955 lie (age 36), the 1961 accusations (age 42), the spectrographically disproven claims, or at least one of the mutually-exclusive 1978 vs 1989 accusations (age 58/69)? <strong>He didn’t.</strong> Because the problem wasn’t immaturity — it was <strong>systematic institutional enforcement through coordinated bad faith</strong>.</p><p><strong>Deflection 5: The Posthumous Shield</strong></p><p><strong>Kenyon:</strong> “one cannot speculate on how he would reflect on his early behaviours in the guitar world, whether he would still try to justify them, or repudiate them; and is long beyond asking as he is not here to defend himself”</p><p><strong>The rhetorical move: Appeal to charity.</strong> Now that he’s dead, ‘fairness’ demands we imagine he might have repented — and criticism becomes ‘unseemly’ because he can’t respond.</p><p><strong>The problem with this deflection:</strong> This is about history. The historical evidence doesn’t require his defence or repentance. Documented fabrications speak for themselves:</p><ul><li>1955: “Pupil of Segovia” (verifiable falsehood — Yepes never studied with Segovia before 1960 excommunication)</li><li>1961: Tuning accusations etc. (eyewitness-refuted by Walker, who was present)</li><li>1978: “Accurate,” lacks rubato / 1989: “Distorted note values” (logical impossibility — same recording — proves bad faith)</li><li>Throughout: “Thin/clipped tone” (spectrographically disproven — Yepes shows greater low-mid energy and sustain than Segovia and other guitarists, which is why his sound projected acoustically)</li></ul><p>These aren’t matters of interpretation where we need to hear “Duarte’s side.” They’re <strong>documented falsehoods</strong> and <strong>logical impossibilities</strong>. Whether Duarte would have defended or repudiated them is irrelevant — the evidence proves they were false. And we’ve heard more than enough of the one-sided narrative for 70 years already.</p><p><strong>The rhetorical function of Kenyon’s entire response:</strong> Appear reasonable and fair-minded. Concede obvious problems (incompetence, flawed personality). Then perform systematic damage control: reviews didn’t matter anyway, his influence was limited, teaching ability is separate from playing, he improved later, and we can’t judge him now, he’s dead.</p><p><strong>What Kenyon systematically ignores across all five deflections:</strong></p><ul><li>The spectrographic evidence disproving acoustic claims</li><li>The 1978 vs 1989 contradiction (logical impossibility = bad faith)</li><li>The fabricated “pupil of Segovia” timeline (verifiable falsehood)</li><li>Walker’s eyewitness refutation (direct contradiction)</li><li>Bobri’s coordinated endorsement (proves network enforcement)</li><li>The decades-long pattern proving systematic institutional suppression, not isolated pettiness</li></ul><p><strong>This is sophisticated institutional protection:</strong> Acknowledge enough to seem fair-minded, deflect from everything that proves systematic corruption.</p><h3>Pattern 4: Character Assassination</h3><p><strong>Peter Lovett (Delcamp forum):</strong> “The author of the article has some very opinionated views regarding every other classical guitarist other than Yepes and that extends to 10 string guitars as well. I have unfortunately crossed swords with him after reading what I thought was a remark by him that did not stand scrutiny… Others on this forum have also had the misfortune to incur the author’s wrath.”</p><p><strong>The rhetorical strategy: Ad hominem deflection.</strong> When evidence can’t be refuted, attack the messenger. (Automatic admission of defeat.) Lovett activates pre-established libel (David Norton’s dishonest November 2022 Delcamp thread, which framed the author as obsessive troublemaker, without a hint of context re Norton’s harassment via unsolicited DMs) to inoculate readers against taking the investigation seriously.</p><p><strong>The framing mechanisms:</strong></p><p><strong>1. False generalisation:</strong> “opinionated views regarding every other classical guitarist other than Yepes”</p><p><strong>The lie:</strong> Neither the particular investigation nor its author generally critiques “every other guitarist” —they critique <strong>institutional orthodoxy</strong> that suppresses alternatives through documented fraud. Numerous guitarists outside the Segovia network are praised or discussed neutrally. The critique targets <strong>the system</strong>, not individuals except where they perpetuated documented falsehoods.</p><p><strong>The hypocrisy:</strong> What is actually being objected to by the likes of Peter Lovett is the intolerable presence of neutral-to-positive assessment of Yepes together with absence of the usual unctuous praise of Segovia, Bream, and Williams, expected in relation to an internalised hierarchy that the original investigation exposed as having been fraudulently constructed, beginning publicly with Duarte’s lies of 1955.</p><p><strong>2. Vague insinuation:</strong> “extends to 10 string guitars as well”</p><p><strong>What this hides:</strong> The author corrected pseudoscientific claims about 10-string tuning and acoustics. When, e.g., forum members insisted (against physics) that an E string resonates with a fretted — <em>tempered </em>— G# “because overtones,” or that D-C-B-A basses produce “the same resonance” as Yepes’s C-B♭-G#-F# tuning (scientifically impossible), correction with facts became “opinionated views.” This is dishonesty wrapped in dishonesty.</p><p><strong>The mechanism:</strong> Reframe factual correction of pseudoscience as intolerant dogmatism. Those corrected can’t admit they were wrong about basic acoustics, so they frame the corrector as “opinionated.”</p><p><strong>3. Unnamed grievance:</strong> “I have unfortunately crossed swords with him after reading what I thought was a remark by him that did not stand scrutiny”</p><p><strong>The evasion:</strong> Reference prior “conflict” without specifics. No quote. No context. Just insinuation of previous “discrediting.”</p><p><strong>What this accomplishes:</strong> Plants doubt without providing checkable claims. Readers assume “where there’s smoke, there’s fire” without examining whether the “smoke” is fabricated. Here, too the machinery of suppression stands exposed for what it is.</p><p><strong>4. Appeal to group consensus:</strong> “Others on this forum have also had the misfortune to incur the author’s wrath”</p><p><strong>The bandwagon fallacy:</strong> Safety in numbers. Multiple people = validation. This ignores whether those “others” were corrected for demonstrable errors (like the D-C-B-A tuning fabrication) and responded with defensiveness rather than honesty.</p><p><strong>5. Victimhood framing:</strong> “misfortune to incur… wrath”</p><p><strong>The inversion:</strong> Those corrected for spreading mis- or disinformation are “victims” who suffered “wrath.” The corrector becomes aggressor. This protects group members from accountability — any challenge to their claims becomes “incurring wrath” rather than legitimate correction.</p><p><strong>What Lovett systematically ignores:</strong></p><ul><li>Any evidence presented in the investigation</li><li>Any specific factual claim</li><li>Any documented pattern</li><li>The spectrographic analysis</li><li>The logical impossibilities</li><li>The eyewitness testimonies</li><li>The fabricated timeline</li></ul><p><strong>This is pure ad hominem:</strong> Ignore the evidence, attempt to discredit the messenger. The subtext: “Don’t bother reading — this person has an axe to grind, attacks everyone, and has been ‘discredited’ before.”</p><p><strong>The mechanism revealed:</strong> When institutional orthodoxy faces challenge backed by comprehensive evidence, respond with character assassination rather than substantive refutation. Frame the challenger as obsessive, aggressive, intolerant — anything to avoid engaging the documented fraud.</p><h3>Pattern 5: Memetic Transmission and the Vocabulary of Unfalsifiable Condemnation</h3><p><strong>Joachim (German classical guitar forum):</strong> Yepes’s de Falla accompaniment with Teresa Berganza is “<em>hölzern</em>” (wooden). “How one can accompany such a musical and technically accomplished singer in such a wooden manner will remain an eternal mystery to me.”</p><p><strong>The mechanism revealed: Memetic transmission of Duarte’s invented critical vocabulary.</strong></p><p>Joachim likely has no idea he’s channelling Duarte’s conceptual framework. Example: In his 1989 <em>Gramophone</em> ‘review’ — immediately following self-contradictory accusations about rubato — Duarte wrote: “there is too much that is wooden and stilted, e.g., Etudes nos. 5 and 9, and nowhere is there genuine tension.”</p><p><strong>“Wooden” decoded:</strong> Not specific musical analysis. Not technical critique. <strong>Unfalsifiable aesthetic condemnation</strong> that sounds like expertise whilst actually enforcing template conformity.</p><p><strong>What “wooden” actually means in the context of the Villa-Lobos <em>Etudes</em>:</strong> “Doesn’t conform to the waggish, Modernist template I’ve internalised as ‘correct musical expression.’” / “Doesn’t imitate Bream’s waggish execution of №5.”</p><p><strong>The Villa-Lobos Etude №5 case study:</strong></p><p>Yepes’s interpretation reveals the work’s polyphonic architecture: three distinct voices (relentless middle ostinato, treble line above, bass below). The slower tempo (among other things) makes audible what faster, more waggishly “rhythmic” approaches compress into surface glitter.</p><p>Julian Bream’s canonical recording takes a faster, more overtly rhythmic approach — brilliant in its own way, serving <em>different</em> expressive ends.</p><p><strong>A responsible critic</strong> would explain what each interpretation reveals about the music’s potential:</p><ul><li>Bream’s approach: rhythmic vitality, surface energy, virtuosic brilliance</li><li>Yepes’s approach: contrapuntal clarity, spatial depth, architectural revelation, sense of line — tension is built on these structural (not surface) aspects</li></ul><p><strong>Duarte instead condemns</strong> Yepes for lacking “genuine tension” — <strong>as if there exists one objectively correct way to realise Villa-Lobos’s notation, and Duarte or Bream has privileged access to it</strong>.</p><p><strong>The Kantian category error:</strong></p><p>This is mistaking <strong>internalised aesthetic preference</strong> for knowledge of the <em>Ding an Sich</em> (the work-in-itself, composer’s intentions-in-themselves).</p><p>When Duarte accuses Yepes of being “wooden,” he’s not identifying <strong>absence of expression</strong> — he’s condemning <strong>the wrong kind of expression</strong>: non-conformity to the familiar template.</p><p><strong>The rhetorical function:</strong></p><ul><li><strong>Subjective opinion:</strong> “I prefer Bream’s approach” (honest, checkable)</li><li><strong>‘Objective’ condemnation:</strong> “Yepes is wooden” (disguises preference as deficiency)</li></ul><p>Claiming Yepes is “wooden” frames <strong>template deviation as objective inadequacy</strong> — making the critique unfalsifiable and the hierarchy seemingly natural.</p><p><strong>The de Falla case:</strong></p><p>Joachim expects Yepes to play de Falla with romanticised rubato (projecting German Romantic aesthetics onto Spanish repertoire), then condemns him for being “wooden” when he doesn’t.</p><p><strong>The irony:</strong> Spanish music is <strong>not</strong> Romantic music. Yepes, himself a Spaniard, trained by pupils of Tárrega and by conservatory pedagogues (Nadia Boulanger, George Enescu, Vicente Asencio, Gaspar Cassadó, Manuel Palau), approached Spanish repertoire with interpretive principles grounded in the music’s actual historical and cultural context — not the romanticised exoticism that Northern European and Anglo-American audiences misguidedly expect.</p><p><strong>What Joachim internalised without knowing its origin:</strong></p><ul><li>“Wooden” as condemnation (echoing Duarte)</li><li>Expectation of rubato as “natural” for Spanish music</li><li>Template conformity as musicality</li><li>Deviation from template as deficiency</li></ul><p><strong>This vocabulary — “wooden,” “wayward,” “thin,” “clipped,” “lacking spark” — persists because it sounds like technical judgement whilst actually enforcing aesthetic conformity.</strong></p><p>Decades after Duarte’s reviews, Joachim uses “<em>hölzern</em>” without recognising he’s inherited Duarte’s conceptual framework. The historical pseudo-reviews are forgotten. But the <strong>vocabulary of condemnation</strong> persists as “common knowledge.”</p><p><strong>How institutional suppression operates long-term:</strong></p><ol><li><strong>Authority figure plants vocabulary</strong> (Duarte: “wooden,” “thin,” “wayward”)</li><li><strong>Vocabulary enters pedagogical discourse</strong> (teachers repeat terms)</li><li><strong>Students internalise terms as legitimate critique</strong> (seems like expertise)</li><li><strong>Terms deploy unconsciously decades later</strong> (Joachim: “<em>hölzern</em>”)</li><li><strong>Original fabrications become “common knowledge”</strong> (no one remembers where they learnt this)</li><li><strong>Hierarchy perpetuates without conscious enforcement</strong> (feels natural, not constructed)</li></ol><p><strong>This is memetic transmission:</strong> Critics and teachers internalise these terms, deploy them unconsciously, and perpetuate the hierarchy without recognising its origins in documented bad faith.</p><h3>The Son’s Defence: A Case Study in Institutional Protection</h3><p>Within days of publication, I received an unsolicited email from Chris Duarte. His defence of his father’s legacy demonstrates every mechanism the investigation documented:</p><h3>1: The John Williams Teaching Claim — Red Herring</h3><p><strong>Chris Duarte:</strong> “My father was asked by Melaan (Ah Ket) Williams to ‘take over John’. I have the original letter from her. It was no ‘public claim’ as you suggest. JW came to our house near Arnos Grove once a week/fortnight, pretty much from the time my parents moved to London, in 1953, until JW went to the RCM.”</p><p><strong>The rhetorical move: Misdirection through literalism.</strong></p><p><strong>What the investigation (“</strong><a href="https://medium.com/@10string/segovia-modernism-6bb448803110"><strong>Why Do They All Hate Yepes?</strong></a><strong>”) actually claims:</strong> Quoting Williams’s official biographer William Starling, Duarte’s “sleeve notes… would have readers believe that he did everything but give birth to the guitarist.” The question isn’t whether teaching occurred or Duarte publicly proclaimed it, but (1) whether <strong>Duarte publicly exaggerated his role</strong> in Williams’s development, and (2) occupied the requisite distance from his subjects that professional music criticism demands.</p><p><strong>What Chris’s defence confirms:</strong> Teaching occurred. <em>B.M.G.</em> publicly claimed (April 1953) that Duarte had “taken over” Williams’s “musical education” — language repeated in Albert F. Kunze’s <em>Soundboard</em> tribute (2006).</p><p><strong>What Chris’s defence doesn’t refute:</strong> Whether that public framing exaggerated Duarte’s centrality to Williams’s development — precisely what Starling documented — and whether one could believe anything Duarte wrote because his ‘criticism’ involved the careers of his student(s), friend(s), and their rival(s).</p><p><strong>The actual point the investigation makes:</strong> Duarte’s ego was vested in: (1) the status of “his student” (Williams), (2) the status of “his friend” (Segovia), and (3) “his expertise” by association — all of which Yepes’s rise threatened to relativise.</p><p>Whether Duarte formally “took over” Williams’s instruction or merely claimed disproportionate credit, and whether you want to nitpick about whether he or <em>B.M.G.</em> publicly proclaimed to have taken over Williams’s musical ‘education,’ <strong>the ego investment remains</strong> — and provides motive for bias and the sustained attacks on Yepes.</p><p><strong>The mechanism:</strong> Chris refutes a narrow literal claim that the investigation doesn’t make, whilst ignoring the actual argument (ego investment in hierarchies Yepes threatened and lack of professional, critical distance).</p><h3>2: “Segovia Told Him” as Primary Source — Red Herring</h3><p><strong>Chris Duarte:</strong> “The Stravinsky/Segovia quote was told to him by Segovia. If you had read my father’s book, <em>Andrés Segovia, as I knew him</em> (Mel Bay) you would have been able to see this fact, but you didn’t quote the book in your ‘Bibliography’. Maybe it distorted your argument?”</p><p><strong>The rhetorical moves: Appeal to authority + implied incompetence.</strong></p><p><strong>The appeal to authority:</strong> “Segovia told him” = unquestionable source.</p><p><strong>The problem:</strong> The investigation states explicitly: “No primary source documents this exchange.” “Segovia told Duarte” is not a primary document. It is <strong>hearsay from the very source whose mythology the investigation critiques</strong>. Duarte’s book repeating what Segovia allegedly said is not a primary source — it’s a <strong>tertiary claim</strong> (Stravinsky → Segovia → Duarte → reader) with no documentary verification at any stage.</p><p><strong>Academic primary source = contemporaneous documentation:</strong> Letter from Stravinsky. Diary entry. Third-party witness account. Published interview. <strong>Not:</strong> “My friend told me...”</p><p><strong>The implied incompetence:</strong> “If you had read my father’s book… you didn’t quote the book… Maybe it distorted your argument?”</p><p><strong>The insinuation:</strong> Investigation is incomplete/biased because it didn’t cite Duarte’s book.</p><p><strong>The reality:</strong> Citing Duarte’s unverifiable claim doesn’t make it true. The investigation acknowledges this possibility: “Hypothetically, if a primary source were to exist: that would simply mean that the laundering operation started with Segovia himself. Duarte’s pattern of unreliability would still be established.”</p><p><strong>Why Duarte’s reliability matters:</strong> The investigation documents:</p><ul><li>Fabricated “pupil of Segovia” timeline (1955, five years before Compostela)</li><li>Self-contradictory reviews (1978 vs 1989 — same recording, opposite accusations)</li><li>Acoustically untenable claims (spectrographically disproven)</li><li>Eyewitness-refuted accusations (Walker)</li></ul><p>When a critic demonstrates this level of unreliability, his uncorroborated claims — even when attributed to Authority figures — cannot be accepted without verification.</p><p><strong>The mechanism:</strong> Chris shifts the unverifiable claim one degree removed (“Segovia told him”). This doesn’t establish truth — it substitutes one uncorroborated source for another.</p><h3>3: Teaching Invitations as Refutation — Category Error</h3><p><strong>Chris Duarte:</strong> “My father <strong>never</strong> considered himself to be a concert guitarist. You repeat Philip Hii’s insinuation several times, and then go on to say, without any corroboration, ‘who, by multiple accounts, could barely play the instrument’, but fail to mention the scores of guitarists all over the world who benefitted from my father’s teaching. If he was <strong>so</strong> bad, why was he invited to teach at the Juilliard, Manhattan School of Music, USC and plenty of other universities and music schools all over the USA. All over Europe, Japan, Russia, Australia, New Zealand and South America? Not bad for a person with ‘a few scratchy sounds’.”</p><p><strong>The rhetorical moves: Category error + appeal to institutional authority + false claim of no corroboration.</strong></p><p><strong>Category error:</strong> The investigation doesn’t fault Duarte for “failing as a concert guitarist.” It documents that he <strong>couldn’t play the instrument competently</strong> whilst claiming authority to judge others’ musicianship — and teach performance.</p><p>The distinction matters.</p><p><strong>The false claim: “without any corroboration”</strong></p><p>Philip Hii (2011): Duarte “could hardly hold the guitar properly and what came out of his fingers were a few scratchy sounds.” Lessons consisted of gossip. When Hii sought another teacher, Duarte sent threats.</p><p>Stephen Kenyon (Delcamp forum, December 2025): “the only direct teaching situation I saw personally Duarte in (at a summer school) was acutely embarrassing, because, as per the article, he did little other than waffle anecdotes.”</p><p><strong>That’s corroboration:</strong> Independent witness confirming Hii’s account 13 years later. Comments on Hii’s blog corroborated his account.</p><p>Moreover, <em>Guitar Magazine</em> ran a satirical comic strip “Wyndham Waffle” (bespectacled, pipe-smoking, bearded ‘expert’ with padlocked guitar case marked “Open in Emergency Only!”) — transparent satire of Duarte’s verbose evasions and avoidance of actual playing.</p><p><strong>The appeal to institutional authority:</strong> “Why was he invited to teach at Juilliard, Manhattan, USC…”</p><p><strong>The mechanism:</strong> Substitute institutional endorsement for demonstrated competence.</p><p><strong>Institutions could also have invited Duarte based on any of the following:</strong></p><ul><li>Network connections (documented “friendship of thirteen years or more” with Segovia)</li><li>Publications and critical prominence</li><li>Self-serving ends (one hand washes the other)</li><li>Not knowing any better (as Hii didn’t know any better before he discovered the truth behind the critic’s pretentions)</li></ul><p><strong>NOT demonstrated playing/teaching ability.</strong></p><p>Some teachers/students may have capitalised on Duarte’s industry connections and bias towards “friends” and “students.” This doesn’t refute that he <strong>lacked both technical and interpretive competence to evaluate performance execution</strong>.</p><p>The question isn’t “Did institutions invite him?” but “<strong>On what basis?</strong>” The answer: reputation constructed through proximity to Segovia, not demonstrated ability.</p><p><strong>Chris’s appeal proves the investigation’s thesis:</strong> Institutional authority can be built on network connections and propaganda rather than demonstrable competence.</p><p>But… This is all a red herring on Chris’s part. The investigations to which his missive responds are nowise dependent on whether or not Duarte was a competent guitarist/teacher. The historical record speaks for itself. Chris’s objections are all attempts to misdirect us away from the evidence and down a rabbit hole of peripheral matters. This, too, is the machinery of suppression at work in real time.</p><h3>4: The Coverage Comparison — Inadvertent Confirmation</h3><p><strong>Chris Duarte:</strong> “You complained about the lack of coverage of Yepes’ death, as opposed to the 23 pages that Soundboard… offered. Maybe that was a reflection on their respective contributions to the development of the classic guitar, post WWII?”</p><p><strong>The rhetorical move: False equivalence that inadvertently concedes the point.</strong></p><p><strong>What Chris frames as “contributions”:</strong></p><ul><li>Duarte: 23 pages in <em>Soundboard</em> (plus cover) posthumous tribute</li><li>Yepes: One page in <em>Classical Guitar</em> and <em>Guitar Review</em> (NYT reprint) riddled with misinformation</li></ul><p><strong>What Chris claims this reflects:</strong> Respective merit/contributions to the guitar.</p><p><strong>What this actually reveals:</strong> <strong>Institutional positioning within the Segovia network</strong>, not objective assessment of contribution.</p><p><strong>If we measure “contribution” by:</strong></p><ul><li><strong>Expanding the instrument’s possibilities:</strong> Yepes vastly exceeds Duarte</li><li><strong>Performance excellence:</strong> Yepes vastly exceeds Duarte</li><li><strong>Repertoire expansion:</strong> Yepes vastly exceeds Duarte</li><li><strong>Pedagogical legacy:</strong> Yepes’s students perpetuated innovative principles; Duarte’s teaching was “acutely embarrassing” (Kenyon)</li><li><strong>Positive influence on the culture of the guitar:</strong> The positive potential of Yepes’s ethics of alterity as a guiding principle for guitarists is substantially worthier than the toxic model of Duarte’s self-serving machinations</li><li><strong>Global guitar ambassador beyond classical-guitar circles: </strong>Yepes’s 120+ annual performances across all inhabited continents (loved by general audiences, respected by non-guitarist musicians/composers) vastly exceeds Duarte’s parochial relevance within the classical-guitar world</li></ul><p><strong>If we measure “contribution” by:</strong></p><ul><li><strong>Enforcement of Segovian orthodoxy:</strong> Duarte’s ‘reviews’ policed deviation</li><li><strong>Institutional positioning through network:</strong> Duarte’s one-hand-washes-the-other “friendship” with Segovia</li><li><strong>Gatekeeping to protect hierarchy:</strong> Duarte’s fabrications suppressed alternatives</li></ul><p>Then the coverage disparity makes sense — <strong>as reflection of institutional gatekeeping, not merit</strong>.</p><p><strong>Chris’s question inadvertently confirms the investigation’s thesis:</strong> The disparity in coverage demonstrates exactly what the article documents — institutional protection of network insiders regardless of demonstrated fraud.</p><h3>5: “Jack Was For Friends” — Gatekeeping Revelation</h3><p><strong>Chris Duarte:</strong> “You didn’t know him, so you have no right to write Sour grapes, Jack? Jack was for friends who knew him well. You’re no friend.”</p><p><strong>The rhetorical move: Gatekeeping through insider/outsider boundaries.</strong></p><p><strong>The mechanism revealed:</strong> Only “friends” (network insiders) can use first names. Outsiders must remain deferential. Only approved members can evaluate legacy.</p><p><strong>This is gatekeeping</strong> — the boundary enforcement that protects institutional orthodoxy from scrutiny.</p><p><strong>What the investigation evaluates:</strong> Documented evidence.</p><ul><li>Fabricated timeline (1955 “pupil of Segovia”)</li><li>Self-contradictory reviews (1978 vs 1989)</li><li>Spectrographic analysis (disproving acoustic claims)</li><li>Eyewitness testimony (Walker’s refutation)</li><li>Multiple corroborations (Hii etc. + Kenyon on incompetence)</li></ul><p><strong>These don’t require friendship. They require honesty.</strong></p><p><strong>Chris’s complaint about “Sour grapes, Jack?” reveals the mechanism:</strong></p><p>The phrase appeared in the context of audience appreciation. Duarte dismissed Yepes’s multiple encores at Wigmore Hall (following a sold-out concert, followed by an overflow crowd at the Instituto Cervantes five days later) as “encor-itis” — a “disease to which guitar audiences are peculiarly prone” — triggered by a “rabble rouser.”</p><p>The aside wasn’t gratuitous insult but <strong>contextual observation:</strong> Duarte’s contempt for audience appreciation revealed his motivations more clearly than his pseudo-technical criticisms. When a full house demands four encores and another overflow crowd appears five days later, dismissing this as sickness exposes the critic’s agenda.</p><p><strong>When a defensive son objects to first-name usage whilst his father’s attacks included:</strong></p><ul><li>Fabricated biographies</li><li>Logical impossibilities</li><li>Threats against students (Hii’s deportation threat)</li><li>Eyewitness-refuted accusations</li></ul><p><strong>The priorities reveal themselves:</strong> Protect the boundary. Police the tone. Ignore the evidence.</p><h3>What None of The Above Addresses</h3><p><strong>Comprehensive list of evidence systematically ignored across all forum responses and Chris Duarte’s impotent email:</strong></p><ol><li><strong>Spectrographic evidence</strong> disproving “thin/clipped tone” claims — Yepes shows greater sustain and low-mid spectral energy than Segovia</li><li><strong>1978 vs 1989 contradiction</strong> — identical recording condemned for opposite faults (merely accurate, lacks rubato / has distorted note values) — <strong>logical impossibility</strong></li><li><strong>Fabricated “pupil of Segovia” timeline</strong> — claimed 1955, documented reality: 1960 excommunication — <strong>verifiable falsehood</strong></li><li><strong>Oliver Walker’s eyewitness refutation</strong> — present in hall, contradicts tuning/reception claims, describes “crowded and vociferously enthusiastic” London audience — <strong>direct contradiction of claimed facts</strong></li><li><strong>Vladimir Bobri’s coordinated endorsement</strong> — proves network coordination, not isolated opinion — <strong>institutional enforcement</strong></li><li><strong>Philip Hii’s documentation + Stephen Kenyon’s corroboration</strong> — independent witnesses— <strong>multiple corroborations</strong></li><li><strong>Decades-long sustained campaign</strong> — not isolated “bad review” but systematic pattern from 1955 through 1989 — <strong>proves institutional gatekeeping, not critical disagreement</strong></li></ol><p><strong>The evasion pattern across all responses:</strong></p><p>When <em>Canuck</em> demands “one or two examples would have been enough,” he’s not asking for efficiency. He’s asking for <strong>just enough to note “Duarte didn’t like Yepes”</strong> without proving systematic institutional gatekeeping.</p><p>When <em>m k ljus</em> points to Yepes’s success as refutation, he ignores that <strong>success despite suppression doesn’t erase suppression</strong> — and that myths persist (e.g., 1997 obituary) regardless of objective achievement.</p><p>When Stephen Kenyon concedes Duarte’s flaws but frames him as someone who “improved,” he’s performing damage control: acknowledge problems to avoid addressing <strong>systematic corruption</strong>.</p><p>When Peter Lovett attacks the messenger without engaging evidence, he’s demonstrating the mechanism in action: <strong>when you can’t refute, resort to ad hominem</strong>. (When you resort to logical fallacies because you can’t refute the evidence, you already concede defeat.)</p><p>When Chris Duarte appeals to institutional endorsement and insider boundaries, he’s revealing <strong>how institutional authority operates</strong> — through network position, not demonstrated merit or honest engagement with evidence.</p><h3>Why This Matters Beyond One Critic</h3><p>This isn’t about rehabilitating Narciso Yepes’s reputation (though that’s necessary for the sake of the guitar). It’s about documenting how institutional orthodoxy suppresses alternatives through coordinated bad faith — and how that mechanism continues operating decades later.</p><p>The forums and emails demonstrate:</p><p><strong>Strategic minimisation</strong> reduces systematic suppression to “petty critic” — normalising fraud as ordinary disagreement.</p><p><strong>Success-as-refutation deflection</strong> ignores that myths persist despite partial success — and that suppression operates by limiting, distorting, and marginalising rather than completely preventing recognition.</p><p><strong>Damage control through partial concession</strong> acknowledges flaws to avoid engaging systematic patterns — protecting the institution whilst appearing reasonable.</p><p><strong>Character assassination</strong> attacks messenger when evidence can’t be refuted — the ad hominem fallacy as institutional defence mechanism.</p><p><strong>Institutional appeals</strong> substitute network position for demonstrable merit — “invited to teach at Juilliard” becomes proof of competence rather than proof of reputation management or quid pro quo.</p><p><strong>Memetic transmission</strong> perpetuates fabricated narratives as “common knowledge” — critics deploy “wooden,” “thin,” “wayward” without recognising these terms originated in documented bad faith.</p><p><strong>Gatekeeping boundaries</strong> protect insiders from scrutiny — “you didn’t know him” becomes justification for ignoring evidence.</p><p>These mechanisms apply beyond classical guitar: <strong>any field where institutional orthodoxy enforces conformity through reputational control rather than evidence</strong>.</p><p>When critics use vague aesthetic pejoratives (“wooden,” “thin,” “lacking spark”) without specific musical analysis, they’re revealing <strong>template enforcement</strong>, not criticism.</p><p>When defenders appeal to institutional position rather than engage documented fabrications, they’re revealing <strong>how institutional authority operates</strong> — through network rather than merit.</p><p>When character assassination replaces evidence engagement, <strong>the gatekeeping machinery is visible</strong>.</p><h3>Conclusion: The Investigation Stands</h3><p>The investigation documented decades of systematic suppression with:</p><ul><li>Fabricated biographical narrative</li><li>Acoustically false claims</li><li>Self-contradictory reviews</li><li>Coordinated network attacks</li><li>Eyewitness refutations systematically ignored</li><li>Multiple corroborations of incompetence</li></ul><p>The responses — forum dismissals, character assassination, and Chris Duarte’s defensive email — don’t refute this evidence.</p><p><strong>They demonstrate the mechanisms documented in the investigation.</strong></p><p>Strategic minimisation. Success-as-refutation deflection. Damage control through partial concession. Character assassination. Institutional appeals. Memetic transmission. Gatekeeping boundaries.</p><p>Every evasion pattern predicted by the investigation has manifested in real time. Not one substantive engagement with documented evidence. Not one explanation for:</p><ul><li>How the same recording can simultaneously be accurate and have distorted note values</li><li>Why “pupil of Segovia” appeared in 1955, five years before Compostela 1960</li><li>Why spectrographic analysis contradicts acoustic accusations</li><li>Why Oliver Walker’s eyewitness testimony should be dismissed and not Duarte’s</li><li>Why Philip Hii and Stephen Kenyon’s corroborating accounts don’t matter</li><li>Why network coordination (Bobri’s endorsement) doesn’t prove institutional enforcement</li></ul><p>The investigation stands on its evidence.</p><p>This response documents the suppression machinery operating exactly as predicted — proving that institutional gatekeeping doesn’t end when the gatekeeper dies. It persists through inherited vocabulary, defensive sons, forum gatekeepers, and the internalised hierarchies that make fabricated narratives feel like truth.</p><p><strong>The difference: now the mechanism is visible.</strong></p><p><strong>Read the original investigation:</strong> <a href="https://medium.com/@10string/duarte-attacked-yepes-institutional-gatekeeping-fe4e052794de">The Machinery of Suppression: How John W. Duarte Tried to Destroy Narciso Yepes</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=d0da790b3ff3" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>