<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Alvin Carpio on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Alvin Carpio on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@AlvinCarpio?source=rss-5aa5805036ae------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Wed, 18 Nov 2026 08:04:45 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@AlvinCarpio/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[On the Politics of Food, Freedom, and Online Discourse]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@AlvinCarpio/on-the-politics-of-food-freedom-and-online-discourse-c146bcfc7e34?source=rss-5aa5805036ae------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/c146bcfc7e34</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Alvin Carpio]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 27 Aug 2019 14:25:56 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-08-27T19:36:32.018Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>I used the words “discrimination” and “fascism” in response to being banned from eating meat in a political programme for activists. I was wrong to do so. Here’s why:</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*U7zp1I3lPDFlKz8WtLze0g.png" /></figure><p>Yesterday I tried two things I haven’t done before:<br>1. Post when angry, and;<br>2. Refer to a statement by Piers Morgan who used the words “discrimination” and “fascism”.</p><p>It backfired. Hard. As soon as I posted on Facebook and Twitter, all hell broke loose. A barrage of critiques came my way, and whilst I defended my core point on freedom of expression, I questioned my position throughout.</p><p>So, 24 hours later, what are my conclusions? I’d like to discuss three key issues this episode raised: First, the politics of food. Second, freedom in today’s culture. And third, political discourse in the digital age.</p><h4>Food</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/525/1*UaYKAcEntSHF4kVIU3wlUg.jpeg" /></figure><p>A few years ago when I asked my grandad what the most important thing in life is, he answered simply: &quot;food&quot;. Whether he meant it in reference to needing it to live, or for something more poetic, I will never know. But, no doubt, I love food. I love the different flavours; the way a good meal makes you feel and how it can bring happiness; the way chefs and restaurants and pop-ups create beautiful and varied dishes worldwide; the way breakfasts lunches and dinners can bring people together. If I were able to choose a group of any people to have pint with, Anthony Bourdain would have been one of them.</p><p>Everyone, in my view, should be able to choose what they eat. So when I was told a type of food that I eat regularly was banned from a programme, I flipped. It’s worth bringing in the context here. The programme in question is the second of three gatherings of activists across Europe. The purpose of the programme is to develop strategies for transnational activism. The first session, though, led to a lot of people’s views being silenced for fear of being vilified for their opinions. This was particularly heightened given usual group dynamics of people wanting to belong. In effect, the dominating voices exclaimed the virtues of diversity and inclusion, but then dissented when other people voiced political beliefs different to their own. In a word, it was deeply frustrating: An organiser cried, a public event was disrupted, a person left the programme, and more are questioning whether or not to stay involved. For many different reasons, most if not all of us were deeply frustrated. When I have been asked whether I’d leave, I didn’t tease the idea as I didn’t want to be another Brit “Brexiting” from another European programme. People have different views, and the arena of politics can feel like a nonviolent battlefield where ideas and words are the weapons wielded, but that doesn’t mean you cower or run away. You engage.</p><p>The next second session of this programme is happening in a couple of weeks. The organiser sent a message to the group, and this time they stated that meat would be &quot;banned&quot;. Meat wouldn’t be served, and nobody was allowed to bring anything from outside. I put emphasis on the word banned because the immediate feeling in response to the ban was shock. It was as though feedback wouldn’t be considered, and it would be a continuation of the first session, where people’s participation and freedom to choose was suppressed. On this occasion, we have been told what food we can and cannot eat.</p><p>Now, this is where a lot of people in the comments and responses to my post yesterday felt a discord: It’s only one event; they’re not stopping you from eating meat before and after; and so forth. And I totally get it. It would be stupid if I believed that not getting to eat what you want at an event that you’re invited to, and are free to not attend, is a silly thing to complain about. Of course, in of itself, that would be silly. I have been to many amazing retreats, programmes, and events which serve only veggie and vegan options, and have been deeply thankful. I have huge gratitude for those who open their spaces, bring people together, and feed them. I respect different cultures food traditions. For me this was never a matter of the type of food (although, I could have made this much clearer). There are decent vegan burgers and there are yummy vegan sausages that are really tasty! I’m always up for a healthy salad too. I am forever grateful to anyone who provides food to guests, as my grandpa and family always taught me to be. This was never about the type of food, this is about being banned from eating certain foods, and restricting the ability to choose what one wants to consume.</p><h4>Freedom</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*0YMT-qNcCJsR4nrr1_tNMg.jpeg" /></figure><p>(Freedom is a big word to use in the case of catering at a programme, but please stick with me.) A few days ago I watched this <a href="https://www.facebook.com/TPointUK/videos/748891528897682/">clip of Piers Morgan</a> (yes, I’m quoting Piers Morgan who many of you detest, but again, please stick with me) who argued that liberals have become illiberal, and have been complicit in, what he described as, a “version of fascism”. In the video (<a href="https://www.facebook.com/TPointUK/videos/748891528897682/">watch</a>) he talked about snowflake culture and argued that “liberals have become unbearable”. For context, I’ve been doing a lot of research into how and why nationalist populists have grown and risen to power. These activities are to try and figure out how to address division and to help reverse the trends so that we’re more interested in building bridges not walls, and uniting around common agendas. Whilst some blame the rise of nationalist populism on the unequal gains and losses caused by globalisation, and others blame it on propaganda that have supposedly fooled what educated critics often refer to as the &quot;stupid masses&quot;, there is less discussion in some circles on the impact that the state of political discourse has had on people’s ability to express themselves. As a rule, intolerance cannot be beaten by further intolerance. Difference should be celebrated and at times challenged, but not suppressed. Political movements lose out sometimes because of the way they talk.</p><p>The particular point I want to make here is about freedom and liberalism. I believe that people should have the freedom to express themselves, no matter their view, and then to take in the responses to that expression, analyse and evaluate the position, then respond by either standing by their view, or holding their hands up and changing their outlook. I’ve tried stand by these democratic principles and do this over the last 24 hours.</p><p>The reason why this ban an issue for the programme I refer to is that it is a group of activists and organisers who are trying to develop ways to unite people around international causes across many countries across Europe. Many of us on the programme express the want to &quot;change the world&quot;. One issue that has come up is that we all have different views of the world we want to help build. Whilst this is one small programme with only 30 people, it is the way things like these are organised, these seemingly small things, that add up and collectively make up what society is. In the previous session, I was told afterwards that vegans were not catered to, nor halal food provided despite having a Muslim participant. This time around, the food I usually have, and the food the majority of people eat is not provided. Again, it is not about the food, it is the principle. If we are a group of people who want to change the world, I don’t think banning people from eating the food they usually eat is a good thing nor an example to set. That’s my view. The carrot and pen, rather than the stick and the sword. The ends do not justify the means.</p><p>However, two big disagreements to this view popped up: First, this is just a small event and you’re free to leave if you choose. And, second, you can eat meat-free food as it won’t kill you nor does it impact on your health. On the first disagreement, I do think these small things add up, especially when you have leaders of activist movements who espouse an inclusive world, but then exclude people by saying the vegan way is the best way, and no other way is allowed. If it wasn’t banned, and there was an educational aspect to it, or it was communicated without using the word banned, maybe my response would have been different. On the second disagreement, I don’t think things have to be a matter of life or death or health to be considered seriously. People can biologically eat food they’re morally against, as technically it won’t kill them. But I wouldn’t force you to eat the type of food you’re morally against. During a chat about this whole episode, someone told me that in Albania, there were stories of Muslim folk being forced to eat pork by dominant forces. In the worst cases, seemingly small ideas can provide a base, no matter how tiny, that helps justify worse things.</p><p>I don’t want to get into whether eating vegan food is the ultimate most concious and conscientious diet versus the diets most other people eat. This is not the place for that. (Although, this episode has pushed me to read and investigate more on that particular issue.) But what I do want to interrogate is the language used. Who knew catering could be so political? It is. For this final part, I’d like to share how people’s responses have got me reflecting about the state of political discourse, and the kind of things Piers Morgan provocatively argued in his video.</p><h4>Political discourse in the digital age</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/271/1*3EgEkVfnTJnt5NHCHbRWNw.jpeg" /></figure><p>The message I received on WhatsApp yesterday which sparked the Facebook and Twitter posts stated that it will not be allowed to eat meat. In response, I asked &quot;When you say meat is banned, does that mean nobody can get meat at the supermarket nor bring any meat based products?&quot; In response, they said that yes, that is the rule.</p><p>This got me a bit puzzled and made me question whether my gut (excuse the pun, although, I had just woken up on an empty stomach) response was fair. I drafted a tweet and a Facebook post which read: &quot;Just been informed that a programme I’m going to has banned all meat. As a meat-eater, I feel discriminated against. If vegans are catered to, why aren’t meat-eaters as well? Piers Morgan is right when he says many liberals have become illiberal, bordering on a form of fascism.&quot;</p><p>I tapped, &quot;Tweet&quot;, then &quot;Post&quot;, then the flood of criticism came.</p><p>I got a lot of criticism. On reflection, I think a lot of that criticism was well-placed and right. On reflection, there were many things I got wrong. I used language which, when I have seen misused elsewhere, have thought was ridiculous. On reflection, the use of the terms &quot;discrimination&quot; and &quot;bordering on Fascism&quot; should not have been used. In the moment, (without wanting to place blame elsewhere) I chose to use those words in direct reference to Piers Morgan’s statements in his video. As someone who has fought against discrimination my for over a decade, it was wrong to trivialise those words. I had thought it was okay to use given that there are many forms of discrimination, some very serious like racism and anti-immigrant, and others arguably less serious like heightism on dating apps. And whilst I tempered the reference to fascism by saying &quot;bordering on&quot;, it should not have been used given the real fascism expressed by the likes of the alt-right and the AfD in Germany, etc. At this point, it is a big lesson learned. There must not be an Olympics of Oppression.</p><p>When drafting the post, I thought I was coming from a good place. I was thinking of everything that’s happening out there: Brexit, Trump, Duterte, Bolsonaro, Orban, Bannon… I was thinking about the people out there who are deeply angered by the state of their world.</p><p>If there’s one thing that I stand by at this point, though, it is the belief that there is a hidden silent group of folk who do not feel they can express their views or opinions in public (whether that be online or offline) for fear of retribution, name-calling, and vitriol. In this instance, I couldn’t believe I was compared to a slave-owner! I couldn’t believe that the analogy was used for making a point about freedom of expression and consumption, misconstrued (due to my misuse of words) as an anti-vegan tirade. It was particularly discordant given that a lot of my work is based on a fight against the impacts of colonialism in places like the Philippines, modern day slavery of a significant number of Filipinos, and the injustices that impact the most marginalised and underrepresented in society. People were clearly offended. That comment got me flustered, but it did achieve one thing in forcing me to ask more questions about veganism and the food industry - e.g. can the production and consumption of cows and pigs really be compared to slavery of human beings? Is eating meat immoral? Many questions have been raised. Deep down, I don’t want to be judged based on what I choose to eat. I don’t want to be looked down upon as a stupid person because I have a certain diet. To be told what I can and cannot eat is, in my view, an affront to freedom. For me this is not a grandiose statement, for it is a very real thing that affects us all: How we choose to live our daily lives shouldn’t be forced and controlled by a minority.</p><p>Other words that were used in the comments were &quot;silly&quot; and &quot;stupid&quot;. These didn’t affect me as much, but it made me think, what of those people who are maybe less able to write or articulate their political and moral views in a culturally palatable way? First people mock the uneducated, then they mock the people who educated themselves, simply because they came to a different conclusion. Nationalist populism is somewhat oxymoronic, because the supporters of the movement’s leaders aren’t popular with swathes of people. Their supporters in general seem to be a group of people who feel silenced and have hidden themselves from public life. But they express their views publicly in one key way, and that is through the exercise of their vote.</p><p>One thing I found interesting was comparing responses on digital public fora versus private fora. The Twitter and Facebook posts got a lot of criticism, but on Messenger I got messages that signalled support for the core idea I tried (but in this case failed) to make about freedom. The responses on WhatsApp to the debate about what one would do if you were banned from eating a certain food were more direct and straightforward, and fundamentally expressed an opposite view to those expressed on Facebook and Twitter: “Offended. Sounds totalitarian.” “I would protest.” “Very illiberal, and I’m not sure it’s relevance for the objective of the programme.” “Be pissed. Major.” “A lot of activism is steeped in authoritarian-style policies. And they don’t see it.” (And many other expletives which I won’t include.) This set of responses, no matter how small, makes me think a few things: First, that, again, there is a hidden silent group of people who fear speaking in public fora, whether they be online or offline. And second, there is a gap of knowledge about how people (who aren’t expressing their views freely) <em>really</em> think and feel. For me this is dangerous as it means that this silencing (no matter who is to blame) leads to a lack of debate and challenging. Do we want that in our society? Is that the ideal we strive for in society? Maybe it <em>is</em> best to remain silent. Some educated people who base their opinions on research and incomplete data might be basing their own views and assumptions on information that doesn’t take into consideration what the hidden silenced groups think. Is this why Brexit and Trump was so shocking? I don’t know for sure. But I do know that these two things are threats to a healthy democracy. Illiberal tendencies masked as virtue and heightened understanding are threats and chains that may bring down democracy.</p><p>To conclude, I want to thank everyone who responded to the posts. As someone who posts a lot of political views and opinions publicly, this post has been one of the one most criticised post I’ve shared (the last one which sparked criticism were tweets relaying the racist comments Paul Gascoigne made to my friends, after which I was attacked online by Gazza fans and supporters). Nobody is perfect, people aren’t static creatures and we do change, and I don’t think anyone should expect to agree with everything one person says, for that would be a totalitarian state. But it is through open debate and discussion (no matter how, sadly, “open debate and discussion” has become a sometimes meaningless trope) that we figure out where we stand and what, in the end, we believe is right and wrong. Because of this, some of my own views have been changed, some have been reinforced. That’s the beauty of liberal democracy. This is why I will fight not only for your freedom to speak your beliefs, even if I disagree with you, but also your freedom to choose what you eat.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=c146bcfc7e34" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>