<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Ben Sawyer on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Ben Sawyer on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@BenSawyer?source=rss-127479852553------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Fri, 20 Nov 2026 02:49:03 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@BenSawyer/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Predictions 2017]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@BenSawyer/predictions-2017-3b67c6a32533?source=rss-127479852553------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/3b67c6a32533</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[forecasting]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[future]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[tech]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[predictions]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[2017]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ben Sawyer]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 09 Jan 2017 20:55:04 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-01-09T20:57:56.001Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Last year I did a series of predictions for 2016. A mash of ideas based on my exposure to various technology areas I work in, mostly games, but health, edtech, etc. I wanted to do it again this year, but also wanted the 2.0 version to be better. I had three goals:</p><p><a href="https://medium.com/@BenSawyer/reviewing-my-2016-tech-predictions-e1f92a6bef36#.9ovq0clxf">1. Evaluate last year’s predictions</a></p><p><a href="https://medium.com/@BenSawyer/tech-predictions-2017-roundup-8132d5daf5c#.r7mhfp7ed">2. Collect some level of other prediction stories that exist</a></p><p>3. Make better predictions (hah!)</p><p>The overall goal for me is to better think about what’s going on in the near term and hope it offers some guidance. At the very least it forces me to read a bit more.</p><p><em>Given all that here’s what I got…Please put your predictions in the responses…</em></p><h4>1. VR / AR continues to fail at scale, but the split to casual VR is the story for 2017.</h4><p>I’m a big skeptic of AR/VR overall. I just don’t see it working at scale in terms of these big efforts like Vive and Oculus that everyone who talks about VR focuses on. It’s an argument of degree, but significant.</p><p>VR is a business for sure but it’s so far ahead of itself in the hype cycle. I think what’s happening in the near term of 2017 is the rise of casual VR. Short, low-cost, mobile driven moments in VR driven by kits more like <a href="https://vr.google.com/daydream/">Google’s DayDream</a>. I think it’s why <a href="http://www.businessinsider.com/facebook-oculus-split-signals-increasing-division-in-vr-market-2016-12">Oculus split in two</a>. The PC division is like the race-car teams for Honda, and the mobile division is where they will make the Civic. Casual, mobile VR experiences I do think have a lot of value and it’s where the focus will shift.</p><p>How this drives adoption and, most importantly, developer revenues I’m not sure. High-end VR will continue to exist, and grow a bit, but it’s not enough to generate the economics everyone is depending on. Casual VR really rests with the growth of mobile headsets, especially DayDream. Apple not getting into this space is hurting it, or giving Google opportunity. The question, is whether widespread availability of a decent quality low-cost VR solution creates salable software opportunities. It may be that what happens is VR is monetized more like YouTube is, via producers working through aggregators and various studios learning to match input costs with probable, not outsized, returns.</p><p>A/R is even more b.s. than VR for now. I agree it’s going to be bigger as a baseline technology, and eventually VR/AR will all be the same platform, but aside from some fun, LBE experiences, which eventually fade, A/R is not a mainstream consumer tech for a while. 2020 at best.</p><h4>2. Prototyping and easy development tool chains for HTML5/mobile applications start to become major competitive force.</h4><p>I spent the end of 2016 playing a bit with <a href="http://origami.design/">Origami from Facebook</a>, <a href="https://framer.com/">FramerJS</a>g, <a href="http://www.relativewave.com/form/">Google Form</a>, and others. All of these prototyping environments are really similar. They’re all chasing the ghosts of HyperCard, and VisualBasic 3. There does seem, however, to be some sort of emerging value if the right company can put together a true rapid building environment for mobile-social-Web products that go beyond what these system do. Something that maybe combines King’s <strong><em>awesome</em></strong> <a href="http://www.defold.com/">Defold game engine</a>, with these more app-centric prototyping environments like Origami. If someone can do that, and create a top-most user layer that can be used by the masses, and then tie it to a cloud-based services platform they’re going to clean up.</p><p>I think as that becomes more apparent in 2017, we’re going to see this emerge not just as a product, but as a key area of competition between companies like Adobe, Microsoft, Amazon, and hopefully Apple.</p><p><em>Honestly this is as much a wish as a prediction.</em></p><h4>3. Apple cleans up lots of loose ends.</h4><p>If you look at Apple’s product line it’s getting messy and disparate. I think we see some effort around cleaning it up and evening up different platforms.</p><p>Apple is a gigantic mess. But don’t let the Apple haters fool you. Their idea of a mess is that Apple isn’t innovating. My version of Apple’s mess is that it’s now got six major platforms, Mac, iPhone, iPad, Watch, Safari/iCloud, and AppleTV and they’ve each gotten bits and pieces of Apple’s leading edge innovation. For example, the Taptic Engine was in the Apple Watch before migrating to the iPhone 7, and the Mac, but not yet the iPad. There’s just a lot of moving pieces at Apple and in my mind, Apple would do well to try and even it all up a bit, get everything moving together a bit tighter than it has the last three years. This article made a good point of the mess I’m talking about. I think we’ll see some good progress on this in 2017 from Apple. Not only progress but outward discussion by Apple executives of the work they’re doing to clean up some of the loose ends that has accumulated over the past few years.</p><p>The downside of this is that it may actually look like Apple’s not innovating, when in-fact I would argue it’s just tidying up the workshop, and getting ready for a big 2018.</p><p>I think one major thing that will happen this year is Apple will release technology that finally makes multi-user iPads possible. What effect this has on sales I don’t know, but the ability to have an iPad that is truly multiuser across a household, and done well, will be great.</p><h4>3. Nintendo Switch 3rd-party support will not thrive</h4><p>I like the Switch concept, I wish it were out a year or more ago. I like Nintendo’s efforts the past year, but as <a href="https://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2016/12/super-marios-sorrow/511187/">Ian Bogost wrote</a>, and as <a href="https://twitter.com/bensawyer/status/810951181178699776">I tweeted</a>, despite such progress it still feels like Nintendo is dealing with a lot of regression. I think Switch will get some third-party, but I don’t see the Switch by itself reversing the current status of third-party titles for their platforms.</p><p>I’m not sure how Nintendo fixes this problem, but more importantly does it have to? Nintendo should just go private, and be what they are, a great company at developing unique franchise games and products that do well under specific controlled circumstances. They could partner more, and embrace mobile a bit more than they are, but in general Nintendo is no longer a growth company.</p><p>As for the Switch, I think it’ll initially do well, and some 3rd parties will try to grab some first-mover sales, but overall I don’t see it doing really well unless some sort of virality creeps in involving in-person multiplayer games.</p><h4>4. Adobe makes a big move</h4><p>Adobe has done a good job of moving its userbase to lower-cost wider-audience service delivery of its leading applications. However, the death of Flash leaves it a big gap in terms of the app economy. It’s cash position has been growing is now tops over $4B. It’s Market cap is &gt;$50B and its stock is very high. Seems like a good time for them to pull the trigger on something bigger.</p><p>This is why I keep wondering if it goes after Unity at some point… It helps them fill some gaps as Flash drops in reach, and sets them up nicely in VR. Most of my reasoning is that Adobe is getting huge growth out of it’s digital marketing cloud products and services. If they applied this to the various activities Unity has done here and then used Unity’s products to reach game, media, and VR developers and bring them together with their pipelines to major brands and agencies using their marketing tools I think they can rationalize a good offer price for Unity.</p><p>Adobe could also help Unity with its HTML5 push, and maybe even morph together some of its own emerging HTML5 app prototyping technology with Unity’s HTML5 tools to truly try to dominate HTML5 based app development.</p><p>At the end of the day it’s hard to predict acquisitions and mergers, so in the most abstract sense, I think Adobe makes a bigger-than-normal move with its stock+cash position this year and I believe it will be on the development/developer side of the house.</p><h4>5. Apple’s ambition in consumer health &amp; healthcare becomes much more apparent…</h4><p>As if it shouldn’t be already, I still feel like Apple’s ambition for revenues in health &amp; healthcare are not appreciated as much as they should be. They’re going to be VERY big, and I feel like toward the end of 2017, be it from product releases (3rd generation Apple Watch?) SDK announcements, acquisitions, or a good Mark Gurman article on Bloomberg, we’re going to see more people realize how big Apple’s plans are for generating significant revenues tied closely to health &amp; healthcare are.</p><h4>6. Voice-Based Games will become a thing…</h4><p>While most of the game industry is focused on AR/VR platforms, the rise of Alexa as a mass-market consumer device, let alone the likely entrance of Apple, and others into this space means voice-only gaming could be a possible thing in 2017. There are already such games, but it’s possible we’ll see some sort of game in 2017 that could become a “hit” as a voice-only game for Alexa or otherwise</p><h4>7. Rise Micro-Service Businesses</h4><p>One trend I’m looking to make sense of in 2017 is the rise of micro-service businesses. <a href="http://www.martinfowler.com/articles/microservices.html">As defined here</a>, micro-services are “<em>An approach to developing a single application as a suite of small services, each running in its own process and communicating with lightweight mechanisms, often an HTTP resource API.</em>”</p><p>I think with the rise of AWS and Azure we’re already seeing the rise of various services. More specifically though, I think we’ll start to see more and more independent developers building very specific microservice offerings that they then charge for as you integrate them into your own large needs. For example, I worked with developer <a href="http://www.stfj.net/">Zach Gage</a>, and developer <a href="https://www.linkedin.com/in/knakai">LFG Studios</a> to build an AWS based service that handles a very useful and specific form of daily high score leaderboards. It took a year to build, iterating slowly, as a part time project and then debuting first in his game <a href="http://www.reallybadchess.com/">Really Bad Chess</a>. It’s a service focused only on that specific need, and nothing else. It’s delivered via HTTPS and it works very nicely.</p><p>As more and more of these services get developed we should begin to see them made available to developers by other developers. Standard pricing will evolve, and I can even see a point where Amazon and Microsoft start acquiring the best ones to integrate into their systems, or some sort of “micro-service app store”. Already Amazon offers access to specific open-source datasets they’ve assembled, why not microservices too.</p><p>The point is that these would be small businesses, built by independent developers, that then make them available and benefit financially from their use. The best ones will last, and provide annual income and overtime become integrated into leading Web services platforms to ensure greater reliability.</p><h4>8. Niche Hardware is a Big Business</h4><p>Really, this is already true, but 2017 will see this trend emerge even more so. <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SGJ5cZnoodY">The entire Shenzhen and maker scene</a> has distorted our sense of hardware as the new software. By that I mean we’ve at times over-subscribed the impact of hardware. Many ideas have failed (e.g. many KickStarter hardware items) but if you peel things back a bit, and start to look at some of the less <a href="http://www.thepixelstick.com/">noticeable hardware businesses</a> out there you begin to find some that are <a href="https://sen.se/store/c/peanuts/">very interesting</a>. I think in 2017 we’ll start to see <a href="https://vr.google.com/daydream/">smarter investments</a> in new hardware businesses, <a href="http://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2016/12/microsofts-surface-hub-sales-surprisingly-strong-its-a-huge-hardware-hit/">especially from bigger companies</a>, and the results will be the development of many more $1B product lines than we realized.</p><h4>9. YouTube Red Shuts down</h4><p>It probably won’t, but isn’t it already more or less a failure? I asked my kids if they wanted it, they watch so much YouTube it’s scary. Neither has asked for it, neither wanted it when I offered it (my N of 2 research method). Google tends to shut down things — sometimes <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Google_Reader">when they shouldn’t.</a> Is YouTube Red something they should otherwise keep open? What strategic value is it offering for YouTube. Do people actually leave YouTube if they can’t subscribe to it? At first I thought it had big potential, but given my kids input, I think it’s DOA.</p><h4>10. Food Tech gets even more interesting</h4><p>Honestly I don’t have a lot to say to buttress this claim, I’m just finding the total reinvention of food from farm-to-table really interesting. <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OPIfw5_WoLU">Things like this</a> device from Farmers Friend, LLC, and companies like this <a href="https://www.agrilyst.com/">Agrilyst</a> and <a href="https://www.amazon.com/b/ref=pntry_wayfind_1?node=8422704011">shopping for food online</a>, and how it relates to improving possible nutrition and social outcomes increasingly interests me.</p><p>So my prediction is it will become even more interesting and widely appreciated in 2017 — at least in my household.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=3b67c6a32533" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Reviewing my 2016 Tech Predictions]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@BenSawyer/reviewing-my-2016-tech-predictions-e1f92a6bef36?source=rss-127479852553------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/e1f92a6bef36</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[tech]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[forecasting]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[future]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[predictions]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[2016]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ben Sawyer]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 06 Jan 2017 16:49:59 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-01-06T16:53:28.789Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>In 2016 I decided to think about what comes next in consumer tech. You can see my specific <a href="https://medium.com/@BenSawyer/ten-2016-predictions-1763097a29dc#.okyuptytr">predictions from last year</a>.</p><p><em>Here is my biased readout of how “well” I did…</em></p><h4>1. Apple Reinvigorate App Store</h4><p>I offered a mix of ideas around future of Apple’s App Store platform</p><p><strong>GRADE: </strong>C+</p><p>It did things, but not what I predicted on advertising platform…I do believe Apple’s doing what I predicted about being a compile on demand system but there’s not more technical proof on that front. I believe more will come in 2017. WWDC will see Apple prove it can make significant progress yearly on App Store ROI for developers.</p><h4>2. VR will be ‘big’ but won’t stave off the ‘indiepocalypse’</h4><p>GRADE: B+</p><p>I think this has been mostly true, though from an indie standpoint it seems things are continuing to “thrive” as new entrants take their chances and there is no aggregate slow-down even if there is no upside for most either.</p><h4>3. Nintendo Hybrid Console</h4><p>GRADE: A+ — pretty much nailed that — it wasn’t hard.</p><h4>4. Draft Kings &amp; Fan Duel will Collapse in Value</h4><p>GRADE: B+</p><p>I think I got this right — except I predicted they’d be acquired but instead they merged — bottom line: value lost, and this is the response.</p><h4>5. Apple in search engine business…</h4><p>GRADE: D+</p><p>Not really, clearly Siri and in-browser returns via Safari are making this more true than ever, but it’s sub-surface.</p><p>Still think it could happen more above the fold in 2017</p><h4>6. Microsoft will morph Xbox into Cloud based system</h4><p>GRADE: F</p><p>Nope. Instead they went more expensive with Scorpio.</p><h4>7. Slack gets bought</h4><p>GRADE: F</p><p>Didn’t happen. I’ll double down on 2017 and now say Salesforce most likely.</p><h4>8. There will be a shakeout in the RFID toy business.</h4><p>GRADE: B-</p><p>This was so close to an A+ except instead of Lego is was Disney who bit it hard and inventory controls was a MAJOR cited reason. Still think Lego is going to get out too but rumors are sales have been ok. I wonder if they’re selling more as just sets than as Dimensions. I bought the B.A. Baracus one for that same reason. Tons of Amiibo sales for Nintendo aren’t even for the games. Same dynamic seems to be at play for Lego which is good at managing inventory so maybe it lasts a bit, and morphs over time into some sort of funny mobile AR product?</p><h4>9. Cable &amp; Mobile Data Caps Competition Changes</h4><p>GRADE: A+</p><p>This is definitely happening. Comcast increased my cap and I’m seeing more ads for free caps on streaming if I’m a customer of X on TV.</p><h4>10. As Web advertising comes under Adblock Pressure — In App Advertising grows significantly.</h4><p>GRADE: C</p><p>It seems like this is happening but haven’t found much in the way of headlines to showcase the actual split/growth. So will take a C.</p><h4>Summary Grade(s)</h4><p>So in total I gave myself: Two F’s, 1 D, 2 Cs, 3 Bs and 2 As which using GPACalulator.Net turns in a 2.36 GPA or essentially a C+. I’m just above average! If Slack had gotten bought, and I had chosen Disney vs. Lego to flame I’d have pulled close to a B. Oh well. Better luck next year!</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=e1f92a6bef36" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Tech Predictions 2017 Roundup]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@BenSawyer/tech-predictions-2017-roundup-8132d5daf5c?source=rss-127479852553------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/8132d5daf5c</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[2017]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[tech]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[future]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[predictions]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[forecast]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ben Sawyer]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 05 Jan 2017 20:19:49 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-01-05T20:19:49.240Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Last year I made predictions… I’m preparing my predictions for this year. Before I worked on my own I decided to spend time looking at any number of similar, tech-centric, prediction articles for 2017. Lots of discussion of VR/AR, robots, and voice systems.</p><p>Here, in no particular order are ones I found, though will say I liked Recode’s, MobiHealthNews’, Computer World’s, and John Battelle’s the most.</p><p>What are your predictions for 2017? Put your ideas in the response section below, and if there are other lists to add here let me know.</p><p>Happy 2017…</p><h4>John Battelle/NewShift</h4><p><a href="https://shift.newco.co/my-2016-predictions-howd-i-do-5f0b7be13541#.br1p4l542">https://shift.newco.co/my-2016-predictions-howd-i-do-5f0b7be13541#.br1p4l542</a></p><h4>Larry Magid</h4><p><a href="http://www.mercurynews.com/2016/12/29/trumps-impact-and-other-tech-predictions-for-2017/">http://www.mercurynews.com/2016/12/29/trumps-impact-and-other-tech-predictions-for-2017/</a></p><h4>Forbes.com</h4><p>is a bit of an open-publishing platform so there were several to read I found:</p><p><strong>Andy Swan : </strong><a href="http://www.forbes.com/sites/andyswan/2016/12/27/consumer-tech-stock-predictions-for-2017/#5251680140af">http://www.forbes.com/sites/andyswan/2016/12/27/consumer-tech-stock-predictions-for-2017/#5251680140af</a></p><p><strong>Bernard Marr :</strong> <a href="http://www.forbes.com/sites/bernardmarr/2016/12/16/the-7-unmissable-tech-predictions-that-will-define-2017/#5d084dcf75e4">http://www.forbes.com/sites/bernardmarr/2016/12/16/the-7-unmissable-tech-predictions-that-will-define-2017/#5d084dcf75e4</a></p><p><strong>Sarwant Singh:</strong> <a href="http://www.forbes.com/sites/sarwantsingh/2016/12/05/top-17-trends-for-2017/#6698e33860e7">http://www.forbes.com/sites/sarwantsingh/2016/12/05/top-17-trends-for-2017/#6698e33860e7</a></p><h4>Fortune.com</h4><p>Had a couple…</p><p><strong>Enterprise :</strong> <a href="http://fortune.com/2016/12/28/enterprise-tech-predictions-2017/">http://fortune.com/2016/12/28/enterprise-tech-predictions-2017/</a></p><p><strong>Tech :</strong> <a href="http://fortune.com/2016/12/27/tech-predictions-2017/">http://fortune.com/2016/12/27/tech-predictions-2017/</a></p><h4>Recode</h4><p><a href="http://www.recode.net/2017/1/3/14154874/2017-predictions-top-10-technology-mobile-ai-smart-home">http://www.recode.net/2017/1/3/14154874/2017-predictions-top-10-technology-mobile-ai-smart-home</a></p><h4>Fox Business</h4><p><a href="http://www.foxbusiness.com/markets/2016/12/27/10-tech-predictions-for-2017.html">http://www.foxbusiness.com/markets/2016/12/27/10-tech-predictions-for-2017.html</a></p><h4>Belfast Telegraph</h4><p><a href="http://www.belfasttelegraph.co.uk/technology/gadget-and-tech-predictions-for-2017-35330627.html">http://www.belfasttelegraph.co.uk/technology/gadget-and-tech-predictions-for-2017-35330627.html</a></p><h4>MobiHealthNews</h4><p><a href="http://www.mobihealthnews.com/content/eight-digital-health-predictions-2017">http://www.mobihealthnews.com/content/eight-digital-health-predictions-2017</a></p><h4>Newstalk.com</h4><p><a href="http://www.newstalk.com/Tech-Predictions-for-2017:-From-10th-anniversary-iPhone-to-talking-computers-">http://www.newstalk.com/Tech-Predictions-for-2017:-From-10th-anniversary-iPhone-to-talking-computers-</a></p><h4>Design Boom</h4><p>Had six different ones found collectively here:</p><p><a href="http://www.designboom.com/tag/tech-predictions-for-2017">http://www.designboom.com/tag/tech-predictions-for-2017</a></p><h4>John Dvorak</h4><p><a href="http://www.pcmag.com/commentary/350599/the-big-tech-trends-of-2017-will-probably-not-happen-in-201">http://www.pcmag.com/commentary/350599/the-big-tech-trends-of-2017-will-probably-not-happen-in-201</a></p><h4>BetaNews</h4><p><a href="http://betanews.com/2016/12/28/tech-predictions-2016-to-2017/">http://betanews.com/2016/12/28/tech-predictions-2016-to-2017/</a></p><h4>Some Digital Marketing Predictions</h4><p><a href="http://www.business2community.com/brandviews/mainstreethost/5-digital-marketing-predictions-2017-01744899#gOmB5MRfg8kS5SQU.97">http://www.business2community.com/brandviews/mainstreethost/5-digital-marketing-predictions-2017-01744899#gOmB5MRfg8kS5SQU.97</a></p><h4>Mashable</h4><p><a href="http://mashable.com/2016/12/21/content-marketing-2017/#O757zHsTAZq4">http://mashable.com/2016/12/21/content-marketing-2017/#O757zHsTAZq4</a></p><h4>Techcrunch</h4><p>Sported a couple of prediction galleries including one with Norwest Venture Partners</p><p><strong>Digital Media Predictions :</strong> <a href="https://techcrunch.com/gallery/top-10-digital-media-predictions-for-2017/">https://techcrunch.com/gallery/top-10-digital-media-predictions-for-2017/</a></p><p><strong>Norwest Venture Partners :</strong> <a href="https://techcrunch.com/gallery/top-predictions-on-tech-in-2017-from-norwest-venture-partners/">https://techcrunch.com/gallery/top-predictions-on-tech-in-2017-from-norwest-venture-partners/</a></p><h4>The Street.com</h4><p><a href="https://www.thestreet.com/story/13930252/1/10-more-fearless-tech-stock-predictions-for-2017.html">https://www.thestreet.com/story/13930252/1/10-more-fearless-tech-stock-predictions-for-2017.html</a></p><h4>PC Mag</h4><p><a href="http://www.pcmag.com/article/350252/12-enterprise-and-mobile-it-predictions-for-2017">http://www.pcmag.com/article/350252/12-enterprise-and-mobile-it-predictions-for-2017</a></p><h4>Time</h4><p><a href="http://time.com/4609004/tech-predictions-2017/">http://time.com/4609004/tech-predictions-2017/</a></p><h4>BizJournals</h4><p><a href="http://www.bizjournals.com/bizjournals/how-to/technology/2016/12/top-5-technology-trends-predictions-for-2017.html">http://www.bizjournals.com/bizjournals/how-to/technology/2016/12/top-5-technology-trends-predictions-for-2017.html</a></p><h4>ComputerWorld</h4><p><a href="http://www.computerworld.com/article/3151020/emerging-technology/tech-execs-boldest-predictions-for-2017-and-beyond.html">http://www.computerworld.com/article/3151020/emerging-technology/tech-execs-boldest-predictions-for-2017-and-beyond.html</a></p><h4>Network World</h4><p><a href="http://www.networkworld.com/article/3148850/cloud-computing/tech-predictions-for-2017-what-i-expect-to-happen-and-what-i-hope-will-happen.html">http://www.networkworld.com/article/3148850/cloud-computing/tech-predictions-for-2017-what-i-expect-to-happen-and-what-i-hope-will-happen.html</a></p><h4>PJ media</h4><p><a href="https://pjmedia.com/lifestyle/2016/12/22/11-tech-predictions-for-2017/">https://pjmedia.com/lifestyle/2016/12/22/11-tech-predictions-for-2017/</a></p><h4>Silicon Angle</h4><p><a href="http://siliconangle.com/blog/2016/12/23/predictions-2017-trump-tech-containers-take-microsoft-buys-red-hat/">http://siliconangle.com/blog/2016/12/23/predictions-2017-trump-tech-containers-take-microsoft-buys-red-hat/</a></p><h4>GamesIndustry.Biz</h4><p><a href="http://www.gamesindustry.biz/articles/2016-12-20-what-to-expect-in-the-games-biz-for-2017">http://www.gamesindustry.biz/articles/2016-12-20-what-to-expect-in-the-games-biz-for-2017</a></p><h4>Whole Food via Health.com</h4><p><a href="http://www.health.com/food/whole-foods-food-trends-2017">http://www.health.com/food/whole-foods-food-trends-2017</a></p><h4>Apple Predictions for 2017 at Computerworld</h4><p><a href="http://www.computerworld.com/article/3152698/apple-mac/what-to-expect-from-apple-in-2017.html">http://www.computerworld.com/article/3152698/apple-mac/what-to-expect-from-apple-in-2017.html</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=8132d5daf5c" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[A 2017 Review of MacBook Pro 2016]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@BenSawyer/a-2017-review-of-macbook-pro-2016-70d4add93911?source=rss-127479852553------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/70d4add93911</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[macbook-pro]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[touch-bar]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[tech]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[apple]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[touch-id]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ben Sawyer]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 04 Jan 2017 14:38:29 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-01-04T14:38:29.142Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>I finally got a new computer after 5 years with the same Mac. There has been a lot written about the new Macbook Pros so far, but hopefully this adds something to it all. I’ve had my MBP since late November.</p><p>Overall the new MacBook Pro is a great machine. I got a 15&quot; with the highest GPU possible because my goal is this machine will serve me well for as long as five years. People are spoiled by the advances Apple has made on the iPhone and iPad, but those are completely different architectures, markets, and supply chains. That the Mac could make similar fast changes is not likely, yet the Mac has evolved. Yes, the Mac went an unreal amount of time between significant updates, but the idea that Apple has been phoning it in on a product that brings in $20B in revenue is insanity. There have been many issues preventing such a significant update from shipping. I don’t want to revisit them here, but lets just say Apple has been quite nice about not badmouthing some of its suppliers for their inability to ship products they need. Even just recently, a review of the latest Kaby Lake chips by Intel lamented that the CPU changes vs. Skylake CPUs (which these Macs use) was almost neglible.</p><h3>Apple Car…</h3><p>I think today it’s best to view the MacBook the way cars work. Every 5 years or so popular cars will undergo a significant re-design and from that new version, in subsequent years, the model will be refined and freshened but not substantially changed. The tooling and R&amp;D for cars just doesn’t allow for that. In some ways computers have become the same and much of that has to do with Intel and recent changes in its ability to ship significantly improved CPU architectures.</p><p>Sure Apple could get better at shipping minor changes and enhancements, perhaps it could even include important changes it might have been sitting on for a while like Touch ID on the Mac, but I think Apple’s goal has always been to significantly reset the Macbook Pro line such that it could serve as a platform for refined changes for the next 5 years. That’s what these new machines represent.</p><h3>PRECISION BUILT</h3><p>This is a precision built machine, thin yes, but made possible through significant focus on key constraints and overcoming them. Apple has gotten so good at precision manufacturing (see this…) that it’s really important to understand how much of this is the culmination of many R&amp;D efforts within their manufacturing ecosystem. Apple doesn’t just design new machines, they design the entire set of processes that build the machines they design.</p><p>When it can, Apple’s goal is to ship that culmination in a product, and then eventually spread those ideas across their ecosystem. Often the future of Apple’s products are tied to the ones that just shipped before it. For example, the Apple Watch saw the debut of the Taptic Engine which now drives the home button and more on the iPhone 7 and the trackpads on new Macs. Apple is good at keeping secrets but often the answers are right in front of us.</p><p>The space gray color option is great, it’s much darker than I expected, which I like.</p><h3>KEYBOARD &amp; TRACKPAD</h3><p>The keyboard is amazing, thin keys, but with good feel, so much better than the previous Macbook flat keyboard. Going back to other MacBook Pros the keyboards feel squishy and not as responsive. It’s louder than previous keyboards, and you do feel like you’re pounding the keys, because you can! It is not a great notebook for typing when someone is sleeping nearby.</p><p>A lot has been made of the introduction of fullsized keys for the ← and → keys. I’ve not found this to be as big a problem as previous reviews of this change had been leading me to fear.</p><p>The LED backlighting benefits from the precision manufacturing of the keyboard, it’s more specific to each key and less leakage to beyond the key’s letter.</p><p>The trackpad is big, the palm detection is good. The Taptic engine for clicks is awesome and it feels really good. However, it’s still not clear what benefit the larger trackpad provides other than it’s <strong><em>the first thing</em></strong> people notice about the machine.</p><h3>POWER &amp; PORTS</h3><p>Being able to plug in power on both sides of the machine to any available port is a great feature you don’t realize until you start using it</p><p>MagSafe is missed, not sure it’ll ever be back, maybe with inductive charging some day.</p><p>The USB-C architecture is great. Yes, I had to buy some dongles, and plan to get a new OWC dock, but I was getting a dock regardless because I use my laptop with multiple monitors and drives at my desktop, and I like just plugging in one wire to start my day. Dongles are still a necessary evil, and I’m glad Apple cut the pricing on them.</p><p>The upside, <a href="https://medium.com/@ageitgey/the-new-macbook-pro-is-kind-of-great-for-hackers-64c1c577a4d2#.mk3o83bjd">as seen in this article</a>, USB-C is now, and increasingly in the future, will be a really good thing across the device spectrum. Wireless overall is the future over the next ten years, and now Apple is one port removal from achieving it for the Mac. The next camera I have an eye on is wireless. The next everything I have my eye on is wireless so this direction makes sense.</p><p>One nice feature of the new power supply is that both sides of the power supply’s cords are now removeable. I’ve frayed so many cords on past power supplies. Seriously, like across the machines my family owns, it’s got to be six or more. It’s now much cheaper to replace them because it’s likely to just be the cord itself that’s the issue. Big savings. I also can by longer USB-C cords to extend the length of my power cable — nice for traveling.</p><h3>SCREEN &amp; SPEAKERS</h3><p>The screen is much brighter and vibrant, almost too much so for working in dark rooms, or reading at night</p><p>The speakers are amazing, this is the first laptop my wife has remarked that the speakers are actually acceptable to her. Not tinny, or cheap sounding. However, they are MUCH louder than expected, full volume on this laptop is loud.</p><p>I do not miss the glowing lights from previous Macbooks with the exception of the battery charged indicating light on the previous power supplies. That was a useful feature especially when charging a laptop prior to, or during travel.</p><h3>THE TOUCH BAR and TOUCH ID</h3><p>The Touch Bar is, um, it’s interesting but there are a lot of pros and cons so far, most of them software fixable…</p><p>My biggest peeve with the Touch Bar is that I often will touch off an event on it, especially in the upper left corner when I don’t intend to. This is because it’s touch sensitive, not force-touch sensitive.</p><p>Not every app allows you to rearrange the bar such that you can avoid having the worst touch-sensitive options where you’re most likely to mistakingly fire-them-off.</p><p>Many of the features you want to use the bar for, that fit into useful workflows are not on the bar for any number of reasons, this will take some time, but I expect it to work itself out as more apps support the Touch Bar and offer useful customization options plus better initial design. Already Spotify added support for it, and it definitely improves usability a bit.</p><p>Another interesting insight into the Touch Bar is how volume works. Traditionally the Mac has two ways to change volume, one is a on-screen slider that works more like an analog dial, it has a more discreet level of fine tuning for volume. The otherway is the previous keyboard shortcut that offers a step-based increase to volume reinforced by an onscreen icon. The new Touch Bar slider is itself more like the analog dial but the on-screen cue remains that only changes when you hit the stepwise threshold. This creates a bit of a disconnect between the setting and the visual feedback provided to the user.</p><p>There is no physical feedback for touching the Touch Bar. Obviously some level of Taptic Engine feedback could work here in the future and would be an amazing addition to the system though I have no idea how expensive and possible that would be today, let alone tomorrow.</p><p>At the same time, the ESC key not being an actual key, and being slightly right of its original position on the keyboard is not as big a deal as I expected. I’m already used to it.</p><p>The bottom line is the Touch Bar is just such a work in progress that it is really just a large batch of potential for Apple and not a true “you’ve got to see this” differentiator. It has the chance to evolve to being a major differentiator for the Mac for the next decade, but it’s not clear if it will be. My own hunch is that in the next 2 years we will see some very novel developers, let alone demos, that radically change the value proposition for the Touch Bar to that can’t believe it moment, and that Apple, will ideally refine the hardware itself as part of that evolution. My sense is some level of physical feedback is a big goal, and perhaps making it slightly larger has potential.</p><p>The integrated Touch ID is awesome, you do save time and hassle from typing in your password all the time, and it enables Apple Pay which is great. It’s also a physical clickable button that’s used for triggering accessibility functions and power-reset. There are currently three ways to unlock a MacBook Pro, type in your login, Touch ID, and Unlock with Apple Watch. Whichever is most immediately present is what works.</p><h3>APPLICATIONS &amp; OPERATION</h3><p>As a gaming machine the 15&quot; machine is pretty good, don’t believe the naysayers who feel gaming means playing only the most high-end first-person-shooters, and VR. You can play plenty of great games at great resolution on this machine including Civ 6 and a variety of other games. I also invested in a laptop with an NVidea 1070 GPU because, yes, not all cutting edge games, at cutting edge frames-per-second will run on this machine, but if you’re buying a Mac as a primary game machine that seems a mistake, but its also a mistake to thing that you won’t be playing lots of great games for years to come with this machine. I still play a ton of Minecraft, and it looks gorgeous on this machine, I’ve got a PS4 to play BF1 on — I’m not really that concerned.</p><p>The 460GPU drives two external monitors I have quite nicely, they’re old portrait displays I have, which means they’re not terribly hi-res, but they serve well to keep an open Twitter feed, Email, Chat, active to the sides, while I work on the main screen. Someday I’ll upgrade my screens to something Retina and gorgeous, but for now it’s working.</p><p>The machine is really quite fast, and I believe, as others have reported, a key part of that is the state-of-the-art SSD it includes using custom technology Apple bought a while ago. The entire 16GB of RAM issue is an overhyped, sure more RAM would be nice for some specific applications, but the SSD getting faster-and-faster begins to negate that except in these rare cases. As has been detailed elsewhere, there are a lot of issues with state-of-the-art memory components, and I think Apple chose wisely given where these components are right now. People are making comments without understanding the deeper details. At the same time, Apple could have anticipated these PR issues and planned for them better.</p><h3>WHAT TO EXPECT</h3><p>I believe that in time the review of this machine will only grow more positive. But the more important aspect of all of this is what does it say about Apple’s and Mac’s future? That can be divided into two categories of expectations, first, the tactical of what’s next in the hardware roadmap, and then what it says about the larger future of Apple?</p><h3>FUTURE ROADMAP</h3><p>I would say with this redesign Apple is set to make some noticeable updates in the future. First would be speed bumps in processors and other components. Interestingly it’s not certain this would involve using the next-generation Kaby Lake processors from Intel (see above). Specific elements of those chips don’t necessarily give you a lot more change. Apple has designed around the deficiences between Skylake architecture and Kaby Lake such that it might be able to sufficiently wait for the next level of chip architecture (Intel’s 10nm Cannon/Ice/Tiger lake chips due in 2H of 2017–2019) and then produce a proper internal update to what will otherwise be the same machines. Apple might use Kaby Lake just for the PR value, but the actual hardware gains won’t be so big. My sense is we would see instead innovation in terms of battery design, and slight tweaks to SSD, and memory systems designed to improve overall system speeds. GPUs (see below) would be another big area of possible improvement distinct from CPU changes dependent on Intel’s success at 10nm production.</p><p>Clearly the Touch Bar will continue to proliferate across Apple’s product lines, especially if they can optimize costs, and the previously mentioned UI/UX issues. The ability for the Touch Bar to grow seems quite good, but it also needs to be optimized for price and other aspects if it’s going to eventually be a default element of all Macs including iMacs and Mac Pros. One thing I could imagine is adding more touch capacities to other parts of the Mac, such as the ability to force touch keys, or slide your thumb on the spacebar, or having a touch capable surface (even if not screen) on the side of the keyboard for different UI. Apple is good at not over-doing things, so I wouldn’t expect these features to suddenly appear, but the overall idea that the typing surface of the MacBook Pro is now open for additional innovation and evolution seems entirely the case.</p><blockquote>Speaking of the MacPro, if there is any computer product in the Mac line that is more embarrassing for Apple I’m not sure what it is. The MacPro suffers from the famous kickoff it got from Schiller at its debut with his “can’t innovate my ass” comment, and the fact that it was designed for expansion but Apple didn’t expand it as it seemed it would.</blockquote><blockquote>I believe Apple needs to have a Mac Pro, and as such have a desktop machine that rivals all others and performs important work for top tier design, video, and development groups. It’s like having a racing division at Honda. It really needs to exist. There have been problems again with key component suppliers (looking at you Intel) that are part of the problem.</blockquote><p>In terms of GPUs I think we’re going to see more work here by Apple. They are getting more aggressive on the GPU front if you look at what they’re doing with their internal chip design work for iOS devices, and look at the recent news about their work with NVIDEA. Apple isn’t oblivious about what GPUs mean to computing overall, but also to machine learning, computer vision, and more. The issue is that Apple understands that other drivers, thinness, thermal profile, and battery life are the constraints upon which primary decisions should be made. Thus it’s clear Apple realizes that the optimization of GPUs for its products under those constraints is something it has to work harder on to close gaps between itself and systems that ignore these constraints (at their own peril). This does not mean Macbooks will ever lead the GPU race, but I do think we will see better performance and more specialized adaptations to achieve it over the next few years.</p><p>In terms of ports USB-C will likely be the last level of ports before everything is totally wireless. Maybe, what will come after is magnetic couplings on otherwise sealed ports but still wired cabling, but my sense is with four ports, all the same, driving all peripherals we’re one move away from zero. The audio port may likely fade before USB-C, but for now it remains.</p><h3>WHAT DOES THIS MEAN FOR APPLE?</h3><p>I think it’s important to understand that Apple loves the Mac and it shows in this machine. These machines are not stopgaps for weary Mac Users, they are the progression of where laptop and desktop computing are headed. That Apple has an incredible amount of cleanup to do on the Mac line as a whole doesn’t mean they are without love for the Mac.</p><p>What these new Macs show however, is that Apple knows that it has to keep building key elements of separation from other hardware producers working to build desirable machines from commodified products. Most of them do it by squeezing in every new component they can and shipping feature lists (a recent ASUS machine displayed at CES had a $9,000 price tag and looked like you could drive it home), but that’s a fools errand that can work well for some, but not for a company the size of Apple, let alone one with their sensibilities of what’s important.</p><p>Instead Apple is working toward building a suite of technologies that it can control, that it wraps around the most mainstream of these commodified technologies, and evolves that to a point there really is a big difference between a Mac and any other PC. I definitely feel in terms of quality build the new Macbook Pros represent that. Beyond that key element, and problably , there is definitely innovation (Touch Bar, Touch ID) but it’s not 100% clear yet it’s a BIG difference. We’re going to need more time for that to be clear.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=70d4add93911" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The day I Helped Hillary Clinton Invade the NYC Subway…]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@BenSawyer/the-day-i-helped-hillary-clinton-invade-the-nyc-subway-ba56b6d84f99?source=rss-127479852553------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/ba56b6d84f99</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[subway]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[hillary-clinton]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ben Sawyer]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 07 Apr 2016 23:54:37 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-04-08T00:26:14.023Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Today, April 7, 2016 the press seems to be over-covering Sec. Clinton’s trip on the NYC Subway system. <a href="http://www.politico.com/blogs/2016-dem-primary-live-updates-and-results/2016/04/hillary-clinton-new-york-subway-card-221675">Seems she had trouble swiping her metro card</a>. Big whoop. Sometimes they don’t work well.</p><p>However, it does give me a moment to recount what was probably the first time Mrs. Clinton ever rode the NYC subway almost exactly 24 years ago.</p><p>In 1991 I read a Joe Klein article about then Governor Bill Clinton of Arkansas, and his early run for the Presidency. I decided on the basis of that article he had a chance to win. My family had worked in politics a long time, and so now was my chance to have that experience. Needless to say, good choice… it was an amazing ride working on that campaign across several states, the convention in NYC, and much more.</p><p>In March, the primary campaign rolled into New York State, which by then, was down to Gov. Clinton, and Fmr. (at the time) Governor Jerry Brown of California.</p><p>Susan Thomases, a close friend and advisor of Mrs. Clinton’s, decided that it would be an fun idea to have Mrs. Clinton take the Subway from the hotel where the campaign was ensconced at that point (I think it was the Hilton), downtown to a planned speech at the NYU School of Law. I’m sure that Susan thought it would be a press opportunity specific to Mrs. Clinton, but frankly I also think as a New Yorker, Susan just wanted to take her freind on a Subway ride and show her an authentic NYC experience. I remember Susan more-or-less having the most fun with it.</p><p>An advance team was assigned to help with it, except none of them were from NY. I was asked to pitch in given my familiarity with the subway. The plan was to get the 1 train down the west side, exit at Christopher Street and Sheridan Station, then walk east to NYU.</p><p>We did a dry run, and returned back later that day. We made sure to have enough tokens, not only for all the campaign people, but also the press, etc. There were no metro cards then — <a href="http://www.nydailynews.com/news/politics/bernie-sanders-not-savvy-subway-rider-article-1.2585761">just ask Senator Sanders</a>.</p><p>Everything seemed good enough, we met Mrs. Clinton, Susan Thomases and a small co-hort of press, and otherwise, at the hotel and proceeded to the station. Press were of course interested and covering the event. People looked on, but it was middle of the day, and so it wasn’t an overload. I acted essentially as a point person moving ahead of everyone, making sure to use just the right entrance, where to stand so we were on the same car as the conductor, and ready to exit properly, etc.</p><p>When we got to the station, the subway had not yet arrived. The gaggle of reporters turned their attention to me. I knew not to speak to the press in general, but someone asked me, who are you, and why are you here. I didn’t offer much, I just said, I’m Ben Sawyer and I’m just a local volunteer who was here because I knew the subway. END OF STORY.</p><p><em>Or so I thought.</em></p><p>We exited the station, made it to the school, and since Mrs. Clinton was then scheduled to move from NYU to other events by motorcade, I returned back to the campaign headquarters. Duty done, back to other work.</p><p>Later the next day The New York Times came out…</p><blockquote>This is PRE-INTERNET so no same day news. The earliest you could get the paper was mid-night at the Times HQ just off Times Square. One of my many duties those days was to get the FIRST copy off the press, read it on site, and then phone back to Arkansas from NYC HQ that night if there was anything that had to be known. Seriously. Rapid response in 1992, was me, up until mid-night in Times Square, phoning Little Rock. I’d be the only person in the office, save maybe Harold Ickes some nights. I actually kept a Sega Genesis with Bulls vs. Lakers (EA SPORTS) in Harold’s office so I could pass the time before going over to the Times building.</blockquote><p>April 1, the day after the subway ride, myself, and two other of the top “staff” (we were paid staff we were told “so we can yell at you!” unlike the other volunteers) were watching news recharging for the late afternoon push of work, when Kevin Thurm, the day-to-day manager for New York came flying out of his office. “SAWYER! WAY TO GO, YOU MADE THE PAPER.”</p><p>Oh no. My (campaign) life flashed before me. I knew exactly what happened, and I thought for sure, I’m going to get fired. I did not feel I had spoken to the press, I merely identified who I was, and what I was doing.</p><p>Then Kevin gives me a giant high-five. <strong>He thought it was <em>funny</em>. </strong>All I kept jabbering was “oh no, oh no…”</p><p>I then actually read the article, and I was pretty upset, and still <em>REALLY </em>worried.</p><p>Here’s the article in its entirety. Keep in mind this is the New York Times…(and now also reposted on <a href="http://pictorial.jezebel.com/this-isnt-hillary-clintons-first-campaign-subway-ride-1769674035">Jezebel</a>)…</p><p><em>“</em><strong><em>Hillary Clinton Invades Subway</em></strong></p><p><em>Hillary Rodham Clinton rode the subway from midtown to Greenwich Village yesterday.</em></p><p><em>First, of course, her advance team bought seven 10 packs of tokens to distribute to each other and to members of the press.</em></p><p><em>Then they gave instructions. “Each train has three doors,” said Ben Sawyer, a Clinton volunteer who said he was selected for this assignment because “they needed somebody who knows downtown from uptown.” Then Mrs. Clinton, her entourage and about 40 members of the press drifted like a giant amoeba from the Sheraton Manhattan Hotel at 51st Street to the No. 1 train for the trip downtown.</em></p><p><em>“Who is that woman?” said John Martinez, a messenger who was almost run down by the horde as it stomped into the station at 50th Street. “Did she win the lottery or something” —</em><a href="http://www.nytimes.com/1992/03/31/us/the-1992-campaign-campaign-trail-clinton-cites-schedule-to-avoid-dicey-dinner.html"><em> New York Times, March 31, 1992</em></a></p><p>So first of all, I <strong>NEVER</strong> said “<em>knows uptown from downtown”</em>. But that wouldn’t make for a funny quote for a filler piece in the campaign notebook section — would it? The Times reporter probably thought it was cool, but I spent the rest of the day waiting for a press person from Little Rock to call Kevin, and make sure I never set foot inside the office again for providing a quote that made it seem Mrs. Clinton didn’t know A from B.</p><p>Luckily for me the call never came, and I spent the rest of 1992, working my ass off, and having many similar adventures of a lifetime.</p><p>I have since had numerous interviews with reporters — and to this day, unlike some other peers, I honestly don’t think much about misquotes, slight or practically fabricated. I learned early on, that’s par-for-the-course depending on the situation, and as far as I was concerned the infamous “uptown from downtown” story was as near death as it gets.</p><p>Flash forward to today. Articles abound similar to the “uptown from downtown” moment trying to exagerate the fish out of water concept of someone like Secretary Clinton on the subway, except this time it’s having to multi-swipe a metro-card, something I’ve had to do multiple times in NYC since then, and in D.C. which is can be just as finicky — even worse.</p><p>But maybe the press is missing the point, because in my own analysis…</p><p><strong>In years past when the press has tried to make hay out of otherwise normal subway rides in NYC by Hillary Clinton, a Clinton has won the White House.</strong></p><p><em>May it happen just as easily again.</em></p><p>In 1992 a single subway token was $1.25. Today a single ride metro ticket today is $3.00. If you support Secretary Clinton, or you just sympathize that the press makes mountains out of mole-hills, consider <a href="https://www.hillaryclinton.com/donate/?amount=3">donating a single fare subway ride to her campaign.</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=ba56b6d84f99" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Health Games for Everyone!]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@BenSawyer/health-games-for-everyone-21f4d7200640?source=rss-127479852553------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/21f4d7200640</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[health]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[games]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[public-health]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ben Sawyer]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 13 Jan 2016 17:40:32 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-10-16T10:36:37.111Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>The first Games for Health Project activities started in 2003 with a small effort to gather like-minded people in an online discussion via an email listserv. Since that time Games for Health and held over a dozen events including ten annual conferences. Today the <a href="http://www.pchalliance.org/">Personal Connected Health Alliance</a> now holds Games for Health meetings at their events.</p><p>Since 2002, several hundred games have been created, mostly prototypes, and a number of efforts have seen extensive press coverage.</p><p>Today, the idea of using a game to advance health &amp; healthcare is not dismissed out-of-hand, and every month there seem to be new ideas that pop up. Much of this would be cause for celebration, but the question that hangs over all of this is where is the large-scale impact that one hopes to achieve with disruptive innovations like the use of videogames to advance health &amp; healthcare?</p><p>Nearly ten years has gone by since an official “Games for Health” effort got started. Millions have been expended in private and public money, yet the biggest impact has been to get past the point that games can work. This is a great achievement to be sure. To get to a point where conventional wisdom is flipped is not a trivial thing but perhaps this is where the heavy lifting really begins?</p><p>Over the past several years I’ve been exploring the future of health &amp; healthcare, and thinking about the contributions games have made, and can make to creating larger impact. The big question asked so far is why aren’t there bigger success stories in games for health ten+ years in? This of course requires deeper questions to construct an answer: <em>Is it because games aren’t capable? Is it because we’re not building the best games possible? Maybe consumers just don’t want them? Perhaps it’s because its all too expensive?</em></p><p>The goal of this internal assessment was to determine what further could be done to help see games contribute to a larger goal of improving health &amp; healthcare, and contributing to a culture of health.</p><p>In 2012, The Games for Health Project began to believe that point one was beginning to be fulfilled. 400+ people regularly attended the largest event. Events were spawning in other parts of the world. A journal was being created specifically for the field, and the research and publishing activity overall was a large multiple of where it was when The Games for Health Project started. Several interesting projects and collaborations had come about as a result of this work as well. As this maturation of the field set in thoughts turned to the question of why there were not bigger success stories.</p><h3><strong>What is Success?</strong></h3><p>Success, at times, is graded on a scale. It is defined not only by those who claim it, but others who critique both the success, and the claims. The point has always been to be careful to not overhype the reality of games for health, and to focus as much on the potential and specific successes we felt were evident. Witness the recent FTC fines leveled at Lumosity as perfect examples where overhyping can create large problems, not only for the field, but specifically for people seeking help and hope for their health. Rationalization is a strength over-time, and avoiding the cry-wolf syndrome is an important element of long-term advocacy for an issue or idea.</p><p>Success for games applied to fields beyond entertainment is always about more than sales, user reviews, and Metacritic scores. For efforts like games for health, or learning games, or any applied use of games and game technologies there is a very specific set of goals to declare major success:</p><h4><strong>Success through comparative advantages.</strong></h4><p>Projects that improve health &amp; healthcare outcomes must be able to articulate the reasons their chosen form of game gave them advantages over other possible intervention methods. Ideally this would be bore out by evidence-based findings past-or-present but we should accept that some cases may be made more on observation then empirical results. For example, in an electronic form games may gain some distribution and marginal cost advantages over other forms of training such as role-play.</p><blockquote>Everyone working with games for purposes such as health, learning, science, or otherwise, should be ideally seeking, success at scale.</blockquote><p>Success-at-scale is the ability for a particular intervention to show strong population level effects and ideally a return on investment for such achievement. We can look at two important forms of success-at-scale:</p><p><strong>1. Relative Success in a Defined Population</strong></p><p>It could be absolute, or relative. In relative form a population is defined that has its specific addressable population and then a game should achieve some meaningful level of that population in relative form. What represents a success point even in relative form can be debated. One would recognize that anything in excess of 10% of a population, unless incredibly small, is large enough to likely drive a highly observable impact on a population — assuming each individual effect is significant enough. Anything greater then that only improves the success-at-scale claim. In some more discreet populations or markets relative penetration may need to be higher.</p><p><strong>2. Absolute Success relative to Costs</strong></p><p>In the case of absolute success a project achieves a high number of users. These impacts are documented in some form, and ideally a sampling of those users provides evidence for significant per-user impact. When the number of impacts is divided by the cost of the project the goal is a low-cost per user. Ideally lower than other approaches. Such success points are measured in dollar-per-impact.</p><p><strong>Present Success?</strong></p><p>From research there is no doubt that games are generating positive impacts at individual levels. Almost every game has some sort of anecdotal story or small population research showing it can generate an effect and impact. In total there may very well be thousands of people whose health has been positively affected through videogame-based interventions. The largest batch of success overall has been among leading exergaming and some cognitive training products which has by our opinion largely been a success of sales &amp; revenues.</p><p>However, there is not nearly any project that has reached success-at-scale where the resulting population health-effects are easily observable. Where success has happened, the most notable is HopeLab’s ReMission game for pediatric cancer patients. Its relative success is helped not only be a well designed intervention, and carefully developed evidence-based findings, but from targeting a relatively small patient population. This isn’t to be dismissive of that effort, ReMission is a great project, a pillar in the games for health community, but years later, and relative to the scale of problems like obesity, heart disease, mental health, and more, its success has to be put in context.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*g65nP6LJeD7oVpMTbfBWqg.jpeg" /><figcaption>ReMission from Hopelab.org</figcaption></figure><p><strong>The Role of Sustainability</strong></p><p>If a project is to ideally reach success-at-scale it likely needs the time to do so. Often that time requires that a project survive in feasible form beyond the initial funding it obtains. Thus, a project must find sustainability methods in order to drive necessary follow-on activities, support, and efforts that can play a key role in achieving health impacts.</p><p>The problem with sustainability as a sole success-point is that sustainability can be driven only by the ability to generate revenues, or continued public support to remain operational. While there should be a strong correlation between remaining operational and health impact that is not necessarily the case on a per-instance basis. So merely remaining around by-itself is not the measure of success we can claim as an exemplar of the opportunity in games for health.</p><p>Sustainability must be ideally driven by achieving consistent health impact within the population reached thus far, and year-over-year growth toward an ever-larger user base with similar health results. That activity together ideally drives funding (public or private) that continues to scale the impact over-time.</p><p>Success-at-scale need not be overnight — however it can not be a decade-long effort that is still striving to reach 1% of its target population, or an absolute number of users that shows significant ROI.</p><p><strong>Defining Success-at-Scale</strong></p><p>Looking across the work-to-date and thinking about benchmarks I offer the following 10% rules (whereby success is qualifying for one-or-more of them) for defining success-at-scale:</p><blockquote>1. Achieving 10% or more of market share or use with measure per-user impact for a defined population.</blockquote><blockquote>2. Achieving 1,000,000 or more users with a measurable health-impact for 10% or more of those users.</blockquote><blockquote>3. Achieving a cost-per-impact that is 10% or better than the comparable intervention once you reach 10% or more of the comparable interventions overall use.</blockquote><blockquote>4. If scale is slow to achieve: a sustainable solution that results in 10% growth toward your goal each year on average would show progress toward one of the above outcomes as being potentially achievable in a 10-year or less time frame.</blockquote><p>Given what we know of the games for health field this rule of thumb is likely not obtained by anything but a few star projects.</p><p><strong>Failure?</strong></p><p>Despite these specific goals, and associated criticisms the games for health field is not a failure. Impatient as some of its supporters (and detractors) may be the hard fact remains the field is still young, and has much to learn and achieve. Instead, we’d argue that the fact that we can start to contemplate holding projects to the above benchmarks is itself a sign of success and maturation.</p><p>No longer is the fact that a game for health exists, and might help an individual player a means for celebration. No longer are the first few thousands users toasted. A specific study, however strong the results, is still critically important on many levels, but those results must be translated out of the lab and into the general population. The end result of a publish peer-reviewed study must now be a way point at best.</p><p>Failure is part of the process, but as progress arises from each successive try the bar must be raised and we are now at that juncture for the games for health field.</p><p>There must be a discernible split where a new round of projects, organizations, and efforts move beyond an ever-sustainable amount of research &amp; development to become true successes generating important population health results through comparative-advantages documented by evidence based-findings. It must be all of that and no-less and it must be done on a regular basis per-anum. One project per year in some ways would be a start, but 10 years from now would be a less-than-amazing performance. For all of the dot-com busts in the past 2.5 decades there have been an amazing amount of success-stories. A portfolio of any activity has to eventually do better then 1:10 where the stars can carry the remainder of the portfolio.</p><p>Games for health has reached a point where the expectations have risen. That is a success point. Its success-or-failure now requires much more.</p><p><strong>Finding Success</strong></p><p>One of the single most amazing elements of the games for health field is the breadth of work seen. Research and development projects, be they in labs, or sent-to-deployment have addressed a dizzying array of problems in health &amp; healthcare. This is the key reason games should be cast as strategic to health &amp; healthcare, rather than concentrated in one specific investment area.</p><p>However, not all areas of activity offer the same opportunities for impact. Some areas, that seem ripe for disruption and large-scale return are tougher than they first appear. And in fact, one of the factors perhaps holding back seeing more projects reach success at scale is that they’re pointed at the wrong targets with poorly defined addressable markets, or markets with too many barriers to entry and gatekeepers that may not respond as readily to a product’s better mousetrap proposition.</p><p>This is not necessarily the fault of game developers and researchers. In many cases, the structure of health &amp; healthcare funding and markets funnels resources toward very specific targeted disease states, populations, and customers. That the games for health field is equally trapped by such decades old pathways is not a surprise. That doesn’t mean however that the field should continue down these roads.</p><p>Looking across a decade of work and observations I’ve been considering what paths might offer break-out opportunities to see games reach large-scale success. Such successes would not only be great in and of themselves but would ideally provide further incentive for continued investment across-the-board strategically in the field, and provide patterns that can help others. These success points would be the breakout moments for the games for health field that are needed at this point going-forward.</p><h3><strong>Seeking Scale</strong></h3><p>Looking at the previously set benchmarks for scale, the first issue to consider was why so few projects have achieved those results? There are many reasons this has happened. A small list is worth reviewing:</p><p><strong>1. Too many projects were not moved past the research phase.</strong> In some cases this is purposeful as the success of a peer-reviewed study finds the researcher(s) moving on to the next project relevant to their publish-or-perish concerns. Much of the work in games for health is often grad-student led and they too, move on to other activities leaving no true owner to advance the work to a full deployment.</p><p><strong>2. The process of distributing a project to its target population has been difficult.</strong> Only recently have easier methods of software distribution been made possible. This of course, has been replaced by problems with discovery and integration.</p><p><strong>3. Games built so far have often lacked connectivity within health IT systems </strong>and infrastructure and thus lack opportunity to be more expertly integrated into existing health system value-chains. Without integration, it’s hard to foster partnerships at scale, and overcome issues with discovery that plague apps and games as a whole.</p><p><strong>4. Specific disease/condition-state populations are hard to reach unless key gatekeepers and promotors sign on. </strong>These gatekeepers are difficult to reach, and are risk averse. They are often unwilling to invest further to help with difficult last-mile issues found in many cases.</p><p><strong>5. Projects that reach deployment often are not prepared for the time required to get a sales and distribution process that is viable enough to justify the ongoing cost-of-operations.</strong> As such they fail to reach even minimal sustainability levels.</p><p><strong>6. Cost saving models are not the factors as readily sought by large-scale concerns in health &amp; healthcare. Instead</strong>, they’ve focused on games for new revenue streams, consumer engagement, sales &amp; marketing. The result is that projects seeking business models based on improved costs results have had a tough time matching up to the market.</p><p><strong>7. Disease-state based projects have little room to maneuver to new markets if they’re so specific and attuned.</strong> They are also often specific to a time-and-place where they achieve maximum success. Anything disrupting that intervention window results in less likely use and success.</p><p><strong>8. Effort requires that person paying is not person game is targeted at.</strong> This creates harder sales &amp; marketing environment often made more complicated by difficult contracting and payment processes. The result is revenues are too slow to materialize.</p><p><strong>9. Projects are often making large requirements on users in terms of platform access, clinician support, and more.</strong> Furthermore, and this is very true of disease-state based projects, too often projects focus on the negative space of health issues. As someone famously asked me, “who <strong><em>wants</em></strong> to play a game about being sick?”</p><p><strong>10. Too many poor projects.</strong> Production values are not strong, benefit to user is not clear, entertainment value (even relative to context) is not optimized. Overall the project is not likely made well enough to succeed.</p><p>The result overall is that projects succumb to the barriers they encounter which are numerous. The question is can some of these barriers be removed and clearer pathways determined that might ideally result in more successes at scale?</p><h3><strong>Health Games for Everyone!</strong></h3><p>In discussing the factors creating barriers for researchers &amp; developers I searched for ideas that could help it unlock opportunities for the games for health field. What we hit upon was a singular approach that attempts to cut through the problems as they exist. The goal was to create a vision that could create a new path to success-at-scale. I call this effort “<strong><em>Health Games for Everyone</em></strong>”.</p><p>The idea is that often too many games for health seek a specific population of users, and attempt to fix an easily pictured problem (e.g. people with Type II diabetes, or patients recovering from knee surgery) and they then set out to address that problem only to find themselves, even if effective, trapped by many problems that exist between them and adoption by the public-at-large.</p><p>At the same time, many of these projects are attempting to solve a problem of infirmary which while noble, immediately instigates the silo’d vertical market syndrome that has held games for health in check for 10+ years. Perhaps there were breakout opportunities with larger more everyday populations that could provide less landmines?</p><p><strong><em>Health Games for Everyone</em></strong>, instead of specifically targeting infirmities instead targets everyday health and healthcare issues that are nearly universal in application. It refocuses the games for health field on the largest opportunities and attempts to focus as much on direct-to-consumer models as possible. One goal of this is to align games and health where they may prove more easily compatible.</p><p><em>A Health Game for Everyone is defined as follows:</em></p><p><strong>* Not disease based.</strong> Such games help those who are generally healthy and those who are sick by improving their baseline health and developing health assets they can utilize to live the fullest healthiest life possible with or without additional health conditions present.</p><p><strong>* Has stronger capacity to focus on direct-to-consumer distribution </strong>and usage models. This creates a clearer path to market, and better chance to have the player be the direct revenue source for the product, which makes for cleaner business models. Not every product will work this way, but we need more that do.</p><p><strong>* Ideally could address multiple health issues</strong> per product (e.g. a game about cooking well addresses heart disease &amp; diabetes to name a few issues)</p><p><strong>* It is global in capacity</strong> — everyone on the planet could qualify in some way to gain benefit by playing it.</p><p>* Barring a pre-existing condition or unforeseen side-effect, <strong>you are most likely to be immediately healthy after a single strong exposure</strong> to the game. A decay rate may be immediate or not at all, but subsequent play could mitigate decay-over-time if needed.</p><p>* Such games would <strong>offer population and social health effects</strong>. People within proximity to a player might benefit without even playing the game themselves. For example, a person who learns to eat healthier helps others around them do the same. As such these games hit upon a critical public-health goal.</p><p>* Such games address n<strong>ew models of personal and public health </strong>that align with policy, market, and technology changes taking hold over the next decade or more. The Robert Wood Johnson Foundation, recently started to focus nearly all of its efforts on instantiating a “C<a href="http://www.rwjf.org/en/library/annual-reports/presidents-message-2014.html"><em>ulture of Health</em></a>” whereby health ideas permeate many aspects of our life, not just the obvious ones, and as such represents a pervasive, and wholistic approach to our everyday health. Games could easily integrate into that model, and others like them that focus on raising health all status, not just healing from sickness.</p><h3>A New Health Model</h3><p>Healthcare is going through tremendous changes. In the U.S. major policy changes are upending the model of healthcare delivery that has been in place for decades. Globally aging populations in many developed nations a bubble effect that has the potential to overwhelm healthcare systems is now approaching. Alongside this major technology changes such as genomic medicine, proteomics, nanotechnologies, and more will change the nature of what medicine is and how it’s practiced. A system currently under-supported by the individual behaviors and public health literacy levels is now a big moving target.</p><p>What’s needed aren’t just replies to the health system as it works today but products and services that support the health system that will be, and that ideally would be optimized for the needs of the 21st century.</p><p>The opportunity for a new health model revolves around four key principles that games can be a centerpiece of:</p><p><strong>1. A focus on developing a lifelong set of health assets, definable, measurable skills, and markers</strong> (psychological, physiological, and functional) that promote positive health outcomes. People who upgrade and improve these assets are less susceptible to negative health outcomes, recover from illness faster, and lead overall healthier lives the more they acquire and/or maintain them.</p><p><strong>2. The creation of a total life approach to health and health information systems </strong>that results in a life-long interface to your health and health assets that is seductive and engaging to people of all levels of health and age.</p><p><strong>3. A massive commitment to baseline health knowledge and literacy</strong> that focuses on preparing people to understand how healthcare of the future will work, and prepares them for the interventions they may need before they need them. This includes improved literacies around science, probability, risk taking, behavioral economics, and more.</p><p><strong>4. Contributing to a Culture of Health </strong>whereby games, as a growing national and global media form, contribute to enabling key aspects of the Culture of Health ideas put forward by the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation…</p><blockquote>“Seeing a Culture of Health from a bird’s-eye view means taking in the bigger picture of what defines health in America — how health will always be linked to health care, but also extends to work, family, and community life; how health equity is connected to opportunity; and how we, as a nation, must balance the costs, benefits, and effectiveness of treatment and prevention to provide our people with care of the highest possible value. It means focusing on the grander whole of what being healthy and staying healthy means. And it requires an understanding of a dynamic new world of Big Data, social networking, and creative innovation that is both cross-disciplinary and interprofessional. “</blockquote><blockquote>— Risa Lavizzo-Mourey, President &amp; CEO Robert Wood Johnson Foundation</blockquote><p>Together these can become the means by which we embue a population with the right personal tools and capabilities to be healthier and to make those around them also healthier.</p><h3><strong>Specific Games &amp; Specific Goals</strong></h3><p>Combining the two ideas of Health Games for Everyone and new models for personal and public health results in very interesting opportunities for the games for health field. Through conversations with games for health community members and health experts I identified 16 areas of immediate opportunity across four specific areas of health &amp; healthcare:</p><h4><em>Health Risk Reduction Skills &amp; Lifelong Health Literacy</em></h4><p><strong>Healthy Me<br></strong>This category of games would drive up longitudinal health literacy and improve both short-term and long-term health decision making preparing its user to make better overall decisions relative to their health today and tomorrow.</p><p><strong>Risky Me<br></strong>Avoiding risky behaviors of many kinds, and improving decision making in risky situations can help across a multitude of safety, and health related areas. This game focuses users on how to deal with any number of possible risk-reward environments they would do better if prepared for ahead of time.</p><p><strong>Anti-Drug, Alcohol, Smoking, and STD<br></strong>Games built specific to these especially important areas of health and exposure. Drugs, alcohol, Smoking, and STDs each can benefit from specific styled interventions that build upon generalizable health efficacies.</p><p><strong>Improving Probability Literacy<br></strong>Probability is increasingly a part of health discussions both on a policy, and personal level. However, probability is one of the most poorly understood areas of math and that translates into a number of issues like poor risk perception, indecision in health situations, and lower levels of participatory decision making. By improving probability skills across the population we instantly put people in a better position to make smarter decisions when faced with increasing levels of probabilistic decision making in life and especially health.</p><h4><em>Personal Health &amp; Healthcare Skills &amp; Traits</em></h4><p><strong>Nutrition<br></strong>Nutrition has been an area of intense interest in games, apps, and interventions far-and-wide. It lies at the base of lifelong health and still to this day the level of innovation has not met the promise. However, the payoff is far too great to give up. This is an area of opportunity that deserves 1001 attempts.</p><p><strong>Exergaming<br></strong>The exergaming market has evolved over the past decade to be one mostly concerned with fitness market sales then the multitude of health outcomes related to increased low-intensity activity performed on a consistent basis throughout life. By looking at how games can become part of a more pervasive, innovative, evidence based world of new activity-based ecosystem we hope to move beyond the poor-consumerist version of exergames that exists right now.</p><p><strong>Self Diagnostics<br></strong>There are a number of diagnostic activities that people can perform on themselves and those they care for. By raising awareness, skills, and habits related to various forms of cancer and other ailments that can improve proper early detection we can save lives and costs with games so simple they’d make Angry Birds look like a full fledge epic RPG.</p><p><strong>First Aid<br></strong>For all that’s been spent on professional development in healthcare we’ve seen not nearly the return that could come from doubling or tripling the population of people with key first-aid skills like hands-only CPR. While we applaud the effort to reduce the plague of medical errors the four out of five cardiac arrests happen at home. If more households had CPR skilled occupants thousands of lives could easily be saved. The opportunity for low-cost first aid training for CPR and other major health events (e.g. concussions) is itself significant and poorly responded to.</p><h4><em>Health Economics &amp; Behavioral Economics</em></h4><p><strong>Vaccines<br></strong>The public overall has begun to become confused about vaccines. As such compliance with vaccine programs has been dropping and traced to the source of various outbreaks of diseases once thought near erradicated. Helping people understand the greater good of vaccines and their role in keeping us healthy is a target.</p><p><strong>Hygiene / Infectious Health<br></strong>While we focus less on states of infirmity general viral health related to colds, and flu are nearly universal. At some point viral health is a factor in even the youngest lives. Utilizing games to help improve proactive and reactive health behaviors related to flu, cold, and other infectious diseases is a generalizable public health goal. Most important in this regard is having these games provided before outbreaks occur. Helping to produce not only savvy populations before its too late, but also being available during information spikes that accompany seasonal and other periodic spikes in demand.</p><p><strong>Health Finances &amp; Consumption<br></strong>Even in the most generous of health payment ecosystems there are still important issues related to personal finances and health. Helping people improve their financial literacy in general, and more specifically related to health planning can help with several important factors. First, is improved resilience and preparedness such that when a health event occurs, it doesn’t spillover into other areas of stress that can deter smart health decisions. Second, helping people understand what not to consume (e.g. costly services) and how to seek quality where available could have an important effect across healthcare systems.</p><p><strong>Crowdsourcing for Health<br></strong>The opportunity to use wisdom of crowds to help create new means for drug discovery, health data analysis benefits the larger the crowd is. Using games to drive motivation, information architecture, and improved participation in support of crowdsourcing efforts in health &amp; healthcare is already one of the best success stories in games for health — if the early work and opportunities continue to build out the potential benefits are significant.</p><h4><em>Cognitive &amp; Emotional Health</em></h4><p><strong>Positive Psychology<br></strong>Building within the new branch of Positive Psychology as defined by Martin Seligman and Mihaly Csiksgentmihalyi, games would seek to help people maximize goals, happiness, and other positive emotions and related accomplishments.</p><p><strong>Emotional Health &amp; Resilience<br></strong>General emotional health involves any spectrum of depression and anxiety along with factors like self esteem that can provide or detract from general ability to function. Learning to manage emotional health is a critical life skill. Having tools available to help people track their emotional health and optimize the factors that can affect it (e.g. exercise, sleep) could improve an individuals’ ability to maximize their emotional health in general and ability to recover to emotional health trauma.</p><p><strong>Cognitive Health &amp; Function<br></strong>The emergent field of neurotherapuetics suggest that brain plasticity combined with good health, aerobic exercise and stress management can provide the foundation for improved cognitive health and function. While this field has brought forward its share of critics and early products with questionable efficacy work continues toward stronger understanding and potentially effective products using biofeedback and other approaches being simple “mind tricks”. Despite an uncertain state, what our conversations with leading experts has made clearest of all is that the delivery method of choice for cognitive training for health and function is and will be games that uniquely deliver interventions in an engaging and structured form.</p><p><strong>Stress Management<br></strong>Stress of various levels is an element of everyone’s lives. Some people deal better with stress than others, and for some stress is a major disruptor and health issue. Games have been shown to help with stress management from teaching specific stress management techniques, to offering diversionary entertainment, games can play a positive role in lifelong management of stress.</p><h3><strong>Games &amp; Beyond Games</strong></h3><p>The goal of <strong><em>Health Games for Everyone</em></strong> is to help foster an overall environment within the greater games for health field that sees a large uptick in activity in these segments geared toward not only the creation of these games, but the means and methods that see them produce individual results and then see those results replicate at much larger population scales. The hope is that multiple games will launch and compete within each segment and that ideally derivatives within a segment, or other features may help them tailor beyond their generalizable population into more specific niches.</p><p>While <strong><em>Health Games for Everyone</em></strong> envisions products that are open to all irregardless of health state we see that providing basis for derivatives that do offered more tailored experiences. Thus each generalizable game acts as a design and production platform for more specific games lowering their costs and thus allowing more niche products to inheret a lower break-even point.</p><p>At the same time, this effort also looks beyond just games as the necessary ingredient.</p><p>At first glance the opportunity to develop toward these goals would seem to only involve the need for new and better games. However, it is important to think that in some cases what is needed aren’t necessarily just better games but in fact improved elements and circumstances that support games of the type listed. For example, in exergaming there are increasingly seeing interesting forays into the market from established and upstart developers. The problems we see however are that still many of these games don’t enable users to move freely between them, to share data with friends and health coaches, to quickly play the game faster than climbing on a treadmill, and to use less expensive hardware. Perhaps the best means to improve exercise with games then is to help improve those traits respective to all exergames vs. just building another competing product for the market?</p><p>In the case of cognitive exercise efforts there is the danger that could arise from products that make outsized claims, and others that provide little or no efficacy, saturating the market and generating a negative backlash as it’s shown that the effects are tiny, not generalizable, and perhaps no better than placebo. The need to help that segment of the health games for everyone outline might have more to do with helping consumers understand what has relevancy and what doesn’t.</p><p>The bottom-line goal is to see users surrounded to a pervasive and easily accessible level with games that upon consumption provide them with the means to lead a healthier life. This requires focusing very specifically on building across the spectrum of our outline, and focusing on what drives up scale both of use and the impact coefficient among any sizable population of users.</p><h3><strong>How &amp; How Much?</strong></h3><p>The goal with <strong><em>Health Games for Everyone</em></strong> is to see these games arise from across a broad spectrum of developers especially smaller independent developers who are building games not only for health, but games about health, such as the recently released <a href="http://www.thatdragoncancer.com/">That Dragon Cancer</a> which poignantly depicts the life of a family dealing with pediatric cancer. With additional tools, and efforts that drive down the cost, and complexities of making games like Twine, Defold Engine, GameSalad, and more we can even see more attempts at games that come directly from doctors, nurses, coaches, nutritionists, and public health experts. In order to have a true Culture of Health that involves games, we need games to come from many different cultures, not just through direct and expensive collaborations, but even more-so through federated systems of technology and community that enable 1000’s of games to be built and trialed.</p><p>By lowering the cost of pre-production research &amp; design, demos, prototypes, 1st playables and even full games are more easily obtained and the risk of any particular project goes down, enabling more development, faster deployment, and ideally better games to become available.</p><p>The belief is also that for many of these categories of games that we need not one or two games but <strong><em>hundreds</em></strong> of games that comply with the traits outlined here.</p><p>Users should be flooded with choice and competition that yields the greatest potential not only for hit products and services but which fit the various modes of life and systems by which people would find, acquire, and utilize these games to obtain their benefits.</p><h3><strong>A Platform for Maximum Individual, Public, and Global Health</strong></h3><p>Individually each game offers a wide-open market with vast potential for millions of users and ideally large-scale health impacts as well. Collectively, games across the categories outlined could form a robust method for raising collective positive health across a global population.</p><p>If positive health assets can be developed and acquired en-masse, and then measured for incidence, efficacy, and functional level we could begin to create an active interface that involves learning, practice, management, and behavior change all-in-one. This hypothesis also includes the fact that for many of these games the total playtime may not be more than a few hours and in many cases top out at 15–30 minutes of play.</p><p>Through games, the availability and immediacy of results could see key health skills and traits available at the point of download on any device in any region.</p><p>These games can be targeted to measure and maximize human performance with outcomes across key psychological, physiological, functional, and occupational markers. The breakout stars for games likely lie in these generalized health goals and it is where the games for health community specifically, but really the entire ecosystem of the videogame and health communities overall should head.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=21f4d7200640" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Ten 2016 Predictions]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@BenSawyer/ten-2016-predictions-1763097a29dc?source=rss-127479852553------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/1763097a29dc</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[2016]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[predictions]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[2016-predictions]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ben Sawyer]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 04 Jan 2016 15:44:39 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-01-07T11:46:49.063Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>10 Predictions</p><p><em>These are in no order of importance… &lt; 365 days to see how right or wrong I am…</em></p><ol><li><strong>Apple will reinvigorate ROI for its developers</strong></li></ol><p>Apple will use WWDC to start addressing issues concerning how iTunes works (or doesn’t) economically for developers. It will either be a smaller focus, that foreshadows more to come, or a big overhaul that’s been in the works for a while but not addressed due to wanting to get all their other platforms out so it could be addressed all at once.</p><p>A key element of this strategic invigoration of the App store will be the increasing shift toward the App store being a system where each product is compiled on-demand for the user’s device when ordered. Developers will increasingly be uploading entire repositories for their products, not finished single executables. Over-time this will take on more sophistication and will enable Apple to better improve more than just bandwidth issues around delivery of product.</p><p>A couple of late additions to this. First, Phil Schiller taking over the entirety of the App Store bodes well for this prediction. There is a need for better dialogue and pronounced action and hopefully this will help (WWDC will be key). Second, does Apple directly do more to help with advertising monetization (especially for AppleTV apps) that is increasingly a major area that helps developers monetize their work (see last prediction) and could still stand a lot of improvement if Apple cares to do more with iAd than it’s done thus far.</p><p><strong>2. VR will be ‘big’ but won’t stave off the ‘indiepocalypse’</strong></p><p>The VR craze will hit, and the press will be massive, but the experience will be short lived, and the opportunity for it to be a strong new market for indie developers will be pierced quickly.</p><p><strong>3. Nintendo’s Hybrid Console is Last Shot in Hardware</strong></p><p>Nintendo’s new console will be a major story not only because the company needs to right its ship, but because it likely becomes the first home console to be simultaneously portable.</p><p>Setting aside how this still competes in an age of mobile phones and tablets, this has potential to be disruptive in terms of the videogame market itself and it will be recognized as the last best-hope Nintendo has before it may have to make a life-changing decision to exit console hardware completely.</p><p><strong>4. Draft Kings and Fan Duel will collapse in value</strong></p><p>Due to increasing regulatory issues. Their last best hope may be winning major federal court cases. The stakes are enormous for these companies. The bigger issue, however, may not be that the cases change the definition of their product, but that the cases expose the one-sided nature of the business where 95% or more players lose $$ playing — turning away most players. It’s quite possible Draft Kings and Fan Duel will cease to exist in the next 24 months — or otherwise be acquired by large established gambling concerns at fractions of the value they once seemed headed toward.</p><p><strong>5. Apple will enter the search engine business.</strong></p><p>Apple already is making progress in doing so by integrating Siri and Safari directly with search results that bypass Google. Plain old search results currently sourced mostly from Google will essentially be a derivative move away for the tech-giant, made even more possible by an expanded partnership with DuckDuckGo, or an outright acquisition of the company. Google’s stock will take a hit which is exactly what Apple wants. The issue isn’t how much more $$ Apple makes by increasingly offering non-Google search capability, the question is how much does it hurt Google’s market-value.</p><p><strong>6. Microsoft will slowly morph the Xbox into being a cloud-based system that runs over increasingly cheaper hardware.</strong></p><p>Looking to make Xbox essentially a unified games business that is no longer about the hardware tied within a specific device that sits in a living room. Clamor will grow for Microsoft to exit the hardware business with XBox and the response will be to subsume it into the growing Surface Tablet business.</p><p><strong>7. Microsoft or Google will buy Slack for an astronomical sum above its current unicorn valuation.</strong></p><p>Slack has caught the tiger-by-the-tail and is creating an API for distributed teams within fluid organizations. It’s great stuff — especially if it becomes even bigger as a developer ecosystem.</p><p>The other option is for <strong><em>Salesforce</em></strong> to do it via a major merger. My money is on Microsoft but if I were Benioff I’d find a way to write the biggest check I could and then parlay that into dominating the next decade.</p><p><strong>8. There will be a shakeout in the RFID toy business.</strong></p><p>There are too many competitors. Nintendo’s Amiibo will continue to do well less as a game business, and more as proof that Nintendo has a major opportunity in the action figure business. Someone is going to eat a lot of inventory in this business — and my bet will be Lego.</p><p><strong>9. Cable and Mobile companies will increasingly use data-caps not preferred bandwidth to compete.</strong></p><p>Increasingly bandwidth will be free for certain, mostly streaming services, as a market differentiator that doesn’t violate net-neutrality since packets are not prioritized, but are discounted toward exceeding bandwidth caps. Given that only a handful of services actually make up the bulk of such caps, it will be interesting to see how it plays out and affects cord cutting, telco service providers, HBO vs. NetFlix vs. Hulu, etc.</p><p><strong>10. As the Web fades as an advertising medium, in-app advertising will rise, because there is no way to block ads within individual apps.</strong></p><p>eCPMs will rise, and increasingly advertising in games, let alone corporations producing ever-more entertainment directly, will continue to transform the games business. At the same time, mobile-social mindshare, and where people spend their down-time online will increasingly not be a game A vs. game B issue and instead be seen as Facebook vs. Games, Netflix vs. Games. I would not be shocked to eventually see Netflix attempt to create integrated games and series for kids.</p><p>This form of advertising is big for games, because despite no-one loving it, it feels more in-place for games than for utilitarian applications like photo-sharing. As such games will increasingly gain major favor for branded digital advertising. Right not eCPMs are dominated by whale-searching mobile games, but eventually this will give way to much bigger advertising markets like cars, and movies.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=1763097a29dc" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[App Store Outcome Calculator]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@BenSawyer/app-store-outcome-calculator-f77347e79bcc?source=rss-127479852553------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/f77347e79bcc</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[app-store]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[game-development]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[business-strategy]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ben Sawyer]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 14 Dec 2015 21:49:12 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2015-12-15T15:21:48.672Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>One of the critical issues with building games (or any software) is trying to understand the general economics such that it can inform your approach.</p><p>For games, success is often very poorly defined, especially for those new to the industry. This is because many developers either see blue-sky, or otherwise ignore the costs of their undertaking, hoping it will all settle out in the end.</p><p>Big revenues for most indie games are not likely. However, sustainability might be more likely, if there was a bit more realism going in to the entire process. The game comes first is an easy way to live when you’re making a game, but it’s not necessarily a great idea that it drown out other perspective.</p><p>To help with setting my own expectations, and to help with understanding how to aid others I work with making games, I decided to put together a simple app store outcome calculator.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*4RH6hNk5J4EpxISfHuaEag.png" /></figure><p>You can download this quite simple spreadsheet here:</p><p><a href="http://www.bit.ly/appstorecalc">AppStoreOutcomes.xlsx</a></p><p>What follows is an explanation of it all with some injected editorializing…</p><p>The file has two sheets in it. Sheet 1 is <strong><em>Inputs</em></strong>, place your pricing ideas, conversion expectations, and other data here. Sheet 2 is <strong><em>Outcomes</em></strong> where you can see a simple set of calculations for different levels of sales.</p><p>I placed the system on two different sheets because I thought it would be nice to focus my attention first on my inputs, as assumptions, <em>then </em>switch to the second sheet to see how they played out.</p><h3>Inputs</h3><p><strong><em>Sheet One: Inputs </em></strong><em>has the following variables you can set up:</em></p><ol><li><strong>Initial Game Price</strong></li></ol><p>If you have a game that is a initially paid product, put the price here. Free-to-play is becoming pretty much the default, but that hasn’t stopped some great, and successful projects from simply being paid downloads.</p><p><strong>Landing Page Conversion Rate </strong>is set to the right of Initial Game Price put your app store landing page conversion rate. This is the rate at which any user actually downloads your game after getting to its app store homepage.</p><p><strong>IAP Pricing </strong>features up to five slots for various styles of IAP (In-App Purchases) which you can set. Next to each one are two conversion metrics. First is a number represent the % of owners who purchase that specific IAP. Next to that is the average number of purchases each IAP conversion makes in their product engagement lifetime.</p><p>For example: If you have a $2.99 IAP and 4% of people purchase it but it’s a 1X IAP then the three numbers for IAP 1, are $2.99, 4%, and 1.0. If however, it’s a recurring IAP opportunity and you have 1000 IAP purchases for 500 users then the three numbers would be $2.99, 4%, 2.0 representing the 2X each user on average purchases that IAP.</p><p><strong>eCPM </strong>is one of three three key advertising metrics and lets you set the anticipated Effective CPM.</p><p>Effective CPM is the average revenue per 1000 ads served you expect to earn across an amalgamation of number of ad types, click-through-rate of your audience, provided demographics, and networks you employ, etc.</p><p>In general these rates can vary a lot from game-to-game, developer-to-developer. Looking at eCPM averages for mobile products on the Web that are U.S. market dominant an eCPM of $2–3 is not uncommon. <strong>But do your own homework and see what you feel sure of putting down as many variables can bring this number down, or raise it, quite a bit.</strong></p><p><strong>Average Ads Requested Per User </strong>is based on many factors such as how your game displays ads, frequency of play, and how many users stay engaged over the long term of the game’s popular existence. A request is an instance where the game can show an ad to the user, and requests an ad to show from an ad provider. Requests are sometimes unfulfilled so by itself it’s not a certain metric.</p><p><strong>Fill Rate</strong> is what percentage of your requests results in an add shown ad that then ultimately results in revenue. 100% fill rates are not uncommon for popular games using many networks and being careful about how often they’re showing a user an ad. However, many developers don’t hit 100% fill rates. Ask around and put in a value you’re as certain of as can be.</p><p><strong>Year Drops </strong>lets you add up to 4 additional years of projected income based on your projected year 1 income.</p><p>For each row place the amount of the drop you expect from the previous year. If you expect revenues to drop 80% then put 80% in the field.</p><p>Each successive year drops from the year before so in the above example your Year 1 revenue is $1000 and your Year 2 drop is 80% then you now have $200 in income. If Year 3 is 50% then that means you’re expecting to maintain 50% of the $200 in expected income from Year 2, or $100.</p><p>What’s important to remember about your Year Drop values is that by all account the drop after initial income is pretty steep. It’s best to be aggressive here especially with the Year 2 drop value. After that, you might be more willing to stabilize it a bit more so having values like 85%, 50%, 50%, 20% is probably not the worst forecast.</p><p><strong>App Store Cost </strong>lets you set the amount taken off-the-top by an app store commission. 30% off-the-top is norm. It’s almost written in stone, but you can change it if you have some reason to.</p><p><strong>Expected Day-to-Day Overhead </strong>helps you account for various costs of doing business or other fluxations. For example. when looking at some recent IAP revenue values I found that some revenues from a straight calculation of IAP purchases * 70% was off by 2% due to returns, currency fluctuations, etc. Also if you have costs like a small split to an artist, or backend Web services fees, paper-work fees, etc. you can put an overhead charge on all your revenues here.</p><p><strong>Taxes </strong>is a setting because, as an indie developer, you’ll pay taxes on various income. If you have a sense of your overall tax rate including payroll taxes, etc. you can place that here. This lets the system show you a group of numbers that reduces your income to some basic level of net-of-taxes level such that you remember that you’re not just sharing a cut of your revenues with the app stores alone.</p><h3><strong>Outcomes</strong></h3><p>Once you’ve put in all your inputs switch to the <strong><em>Outcomes</em></strong> sheet.</p><p>Here you’ll find almost 30 columns, and 17 rows of data.</p><p>Each row of data is anchored on the number of downloads you generate for your game in the first year of its life. I picked a year even though many games do the bulk of their business in under a year, closer to launch or soon thereafter.</p><p><strong>Downloads</strong> start at 5,000 and rise to 500,000 moving up in ever larger increments.</p><p><strong>Landing page hits</strong> is shown first, and is backed-out from the number of downloads using the Landing Page Conversion metric from the Inputs page.</p><p><strong>Minimum Averages Required</strong> shows you how many daily views and downloads you need to reach that top-line number in one year. As you can see you quickly need 100 or more downloads to get to 40,000+ users inside a year. Given most app store conversion rates are under 30% and often under 15% you’re going to need thousands, to millions of views to reach a large number of users. Keep in mind how fast things scale when considering how likely meeting your goals will be.</p><p>Obviously FTP (Free-to-Play) games perform initial conversions easier, but things quickly regress from there when working to get a free-download to monetize.</p><p><strong>Advertising Outcomes</strong>, include <strong>Expected Ads Served</strong>, and <strong>CPM Blocks</strong> (essentially Expected Ads Served/1000).</p><p><strong>Expected Revenues</strong>, tallies up the revenue from any purchase inputs. Keep in mind that all IAP is subject to your conversion rates, but if you have an outright price to your game that is multiplied by the number of downloads which means, as originally constituted on the sheet provided here you can’t do models for under 5000 initial sales without changing the number on the output rows.</p><p><strong>Advertising Revenue</strong>, looks at all your expected users, the number of ads they’ll request over their lifetime of play on average, and how many are actually filled, and then cuts that number into blocks of 1000 and then multiplies those blocks by your expected eCPM.</p><p><strong>Total Revenue</strong>, adds the two numbers together. This is your year 1 expected revenue.</p><p><strong>Average Revenue Per User, and Per Landing Page Visitor</strong> gives you a sense with all your downloads, many of whom might not convert to IAP customers, or view ads ad-infinitum, of how much money per user, and per visitor to your landing page, you make. These are useful metrics because they give you a sense of how successful you’ve been all the way through the value chain of discovery, conversion, and engagement you might expect to do. That these numbers end up quite small shouldn’t be alarming, but definitely humbling.</p><p><strong>Expected Long Tail Revenues</strong>, applies those year-to-year revenue drops from the <strong><em>Input</em></strong> sheet. I decided to give you the ability to potentially project up to 5 years in revenues even if the long-tail might be no more than another 5–15% of your overall revenue. It’s useful to look at these numbers if only to realize two things, first, the drops after initial debut are big by all accounts, and second, there is some measurable longevity to decent app store games, and every bit of revenue counts.</p><p><strong>Daily Average Revenue,</strong> takes the revenues yearly, and divides them by 365. It’s useful to see what your daily revenue might be as a means of focusing yourself in on the reality of releasing a game that might only generate $10-$15 a day, if that.</p><p><strong>After Costs &amp; Taxes</strong>, reduces your revenues by your overhead and tax rate. These numbers are fed into the hourly rate projections that follow.</p><p><strong>Development Time/Revenue </strong>has three blocks of time in hours you can place. I chose 400, 800, and 1600 hours as good intervals of 10, 20, and 40 weeks of development (assuming 40 hours per week full time, or some measure of part-time hours) and I didn’t go any higher. Given most accounts, and my own observations, the best way to have some level of sustainability in the fast-play/fast-discard world of mobile games is to limit the overall time you spend making a game such that when you run this metric against your expected revenues you get a number that’s meaningful. For my own work I’m targeting no more than 400 hours of development time. If an idea is not able to be executed at that level of development it feels hard for me to justify the risk. Harsh, but realistic.</p><p>The first few times I ran this chart and put in numbers I knew to be semi-accurate based on actual numbers from other projects I had access to… it took 175,000 downloads before I was earning more than $25/hour for a long development period.</p><p>Of all the forecasts this one is very humbling.</p><h3><strong>Charts and Summaries</strong></h3><p>The <strong><em>Outcomes</em></strong> sheet also features a few summary values, and a couple of charts. The idea is to show key reminders (e.g. conversion rate from app store page views), and new information such as average transaction value based on your IAP model. You can also input how many hours a week are devoted to your game’s development to translate hours spent developing into weeks. It’s just a bit of extra information to spur thought and discussion.</p><h3><strong>Lessons Learned?</strong></h3><p>The harsh reality of making games, let alone any consumer product, is just how risky a business it is. Even if your initial costs are low because you don’t need more than a computer and time, the opportunity costs are high and thus failure can still have significant costs associated with it.</p><p>Many people don’t pursue making games as a full-time business. For myself, I spend a lot of time consulting, and now fill my free time making products that I <em>want</em> to make, but with an eye on keeping my costs low, my ideas humble, and my forecasts minimal. That’s a big reason I built this spreadsheet, to see what the revenues of extremely modest sales expectations looked like if I could extrapolate them out 3–4 years.</p><blockquote>Your own sense of success could easily be driven by setting and surviving low-expectations.</blockquote><p><em>The specific lessons of the App Store Calculator that I got out of building it are as follows:</em></p><ol><li>If your total time/cost of development is high, it really is daunting to see what you have to achieve in terms of actual downloads, and conversions to make at least a $20 or better hourly rate. <strong>Backing out your number is something EVERY wanna-indie developer really needs to do.</strong></li><li>The indies I know well, either personally, or from afar, are almost 90% lone-wolves. At best they recruit art, or other media on a small cost or small rev-share basis. <strong>I can’t imagine building indie-games with a large-sized team of more then two people.</strong></li><li>It’s important to use this calculator to see how big the conversion rates have to get, and the pricing, and the fill rates, and the eCPM, in order to see sizable revenues from not large download rates. You quickly hit numbers like $15 eCPMs that are absolutely impossible to use with a straight face. <strong>A key output of this calculator is how miserly you need to be with your development time and costs.</strong> Once you play with it enough these lessons become very apparent.</li><li>The final lesson I learned was <strong>really understanding what the low-end of success and sustainability could look like</strong>. Building a model that generated $20,000 in revenue per title over more than one year, and then seeing what was a realistic input to make that even<em> remotely </em>sustainable was an important step in understanding what the risk might be in spending any time making and releasing a game on app stores.</li></ol><h3><strong>When do I lie awake at night?</strong></h3><p>I asked a friend once how he priced his products. He was a successful trade book publisher who eventually sold his company and retired. He told me that whether he was pricing a product up, or down, he kept going in the direction he was seeking, premium, or broad audience pricing, while the book was in development, until he literally couldn’t see himself sleeping at night without worrying he’d priced it wrong.</p><p>To me, that’s a good way to use this tool. Futz with the different values, and play with either ends of the success curve. Raise prices, up conversion rates, maximize revenues, but ask yourself if you think you can lie asleep at night without fear you’ve way over-estimated. Then go in the other direction, lower everything, increasing the likelihood you meet those targets, but stop when you can’t imagine that the resulting lower revenues is feasible for your income goals.</p><p>Once you’ve tested both extremes, you will have easily challenged some of your assumptions, and you can begin to settle toward a set of inputs and values you feel represent realistic expectations, let alone minimum goals. Even then don’t be afraid to realize it may not be working out.</p><p>I would then encourage you to share those with others for input, and find supporting information for your assumptions. The more you reinforce your values, the more you can approach them with confidence, and use them to inform any number of other plans for your game.</p><h3><strong>Setting Your Success Expectations</strong></h3><p>Building a successful game can mean many things to many different people. The goal of the <em>App Store Calculator</em> isn’t to say there is one level of financial success that is right, or works. For many people just building and releasing something fun for friends and the public to play is all they wish for. Anything earned then becomes icing on the cake — a not unhealthy approach in many ways so long as you’re paying your rent.</p><p>However, if you also want to build games such that the revenue returned is a key part of success and sustainability of your efforts, let alone build a true business, then a few minutes with this tool might help you better think through how you’re going to achieve that, and have expectations level set as you start that process.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=f77347e79bcc" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Indie Game App Store Gap]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@BenSawyer/minding-gaps-in-indie-game-development-1787972115d2?source=rss-127479852553------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/1787972115d2</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[business-development]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[game-development]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[apps]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ben Sawyer]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 18 Nov 2015 18:02:08 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2015-12-09T14:02:26.011Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>The advent of mobile platforms has been an amazing boom to independent developers. The app economy has been a virtual gold rush, in all the best, and worst ways. Since the advent of Steam, iOS, Android, Humble Bundle etc., each with their own developer ecosystems, there has been an explosion of channels for indie game developers. I’ve dabbled in some of these since their inception, but in the last year I’ve become more involved through helping a friend, a gifted designer, with their efforts to survive, and thrive as an independent game developer.</p><p>I’ve learned a few things helping him, and watching others. The sporadic, and growing habit among indies to publish their exploits has provided an interesting text-based, episodic form of reality series on life as a modern <em>solo-to-small company</em> game developer. Like stories of other pioneers, and explorers, many don’t end well. These post-mortem lessons are sometimes hard to read, let alone hard to take.</p><p>A big problem isn’t that they don’t always end well. The problems, as I’ve encountered it, both helping others, and working toward a few releases of my own, is that for all the activity going on in independent games, let alone media, and independent software development, there is a lack of actionable insight, and a dearth of deconstructed models and systems for the reader to learn from. Instead, we’re left to cobble together bits and pieces of information, hack through false axioms, and superlatives, and deal with amazing declaratives that are the false-idols of advice.</p><p>A recent article on Gamasutra offered the analysis of the top three reasons games failed: Quality, Positioning, Visibility.</p><blockquote>Let’s be clear, there are many games that aren’t fun, and many pieces of software that have defects they should not. Lots of games that lack visibility, but if you’re at a point where advice like Quality, Positioning, and Visibility are meaningful, you’re in a heap of trouble. And if you’re dispensing such advice, you’re not helping anyone who is otherwise capable, but is thirsty for something actionable.</blockquote><p>With all this in mind, and a lot learned, it seemed worthwhile to try and present something I wish was more representative of what game developers should be sharing with each other.</p><h3><strong>Models Needed</strong></h3><p>For me, one of the biggest issues going has been to try and understand things beyond the disparate parts. To actually construct models, and written descriptions of what constitutes useful strategies for indie game development. By trying to stitch together various ideas into something more whole, in written form, it forces truth above fiction. It requires digging in, because at the end of the day you need enough parts, enough truths, enough <em>evidence</em>, and<em> insights</em>, to be able to cobble together something complete, and decently detailed.</p><h4><strong>Set The Game Aside for Now</strong></h4><p>Recently my friend launched a game on the iOS App Store. As I said, he’s gifted, and so it’s doing well. By all accounts it’s a decent hit, and the hand-crafted nature of his efforts means it’s profitable. So a successful game launched it is, but it’s not without faults and interesting lessons, and deep within the fault lines of an otherwise successful game I think lies some important discussion for independent game developers operating in today’s app store dominated world.</p><p><em>For my friend I work on three core tasks:</em></p><p><strong>1. I play early versions of games he is developing. </strong>I offer my own thoughts both as a designer/producer, but also someone trying to focus one-or-two steps ahead in terms of how to sell, and earn produce revenue.</p><p><strong>2. I participate in launch, providing help with organization of PR, and other tasks around visibility,</strong> messaging, and merchandising. I suggest ideas, keep a punch list, and help on the ones that seem doable, and fit his vision for how he wants to sell his game. This also includes pitching in on possible biz dev ideas when they come across his email.</p><p><strong>3. I analyze resulting data</strong>, and look at data and evidence from other developers (game and otherwise) that offer insight as to what to do next immediately, and for future games.</p><p>All of these efforts, and his efforts to build the game, require constant questioning of the value of effort, time, and out-of-pocket costs. Small developers have unusually high opportunity costs that can trap them. They can only do so much due to time, attention to more important things, and pure capacity. At the end of the day, getting the game done, or updated, always wins out, which lowers energy and time spent on other tasks. Such limited capacity means every decision is seen as a risk more than an requirement; evaluating opportunities to understand what they represent can be a task left unattended.</p><p>One task I’ve been working on is trying to build a model around the opportunity for paid media in promoting his latest game. This analysis also serves as a test-case for eventually promoting all his work, past and future. There are two reasons I’ve been pursuing this:</p><p><strong>1. Making paid media a net-positive contributor to a sustainable business is in itself a major milestone.</strong> Think for a second how many businesses you see who can survive the expense of even modest advertising? By setting this as a goal, it forces many downstream decisions and discussions. Even if advertising is never undertaken, let alone proven sustainable, considering it seriously is helpful as a developer.</p><p>2. <strong>Investing in paid media forces you to build a model of your games sales and life-cycle</strong>, because advertising blindly, is a fool’s errand.</p><p>A great element of modern-day game development with app stores is great access to daily data. With services like Sensor Tower, Appfigures, and AppAnnie, you can start to look at your own data, as well as competitors data. The problem for independents with data works as follows:</p><p><strong>1. Better levels of data are hard to come by.</strong> Competitive intelligence data from some of the services previously mentioned sources is usually housed behind paid expensive levels of service. Some of the social network competitive intelligence tools don’t even list pricing — you can guess what that means. Paid sales people on the other end of the line aren’t selling $99.00 yearly subscriptions. Thankfully you can avoid most of these higher paid tiers. So far I’ve paid for some services like AppFigures, or Twitonomy, I’ve spent less than $200.00 for extra reporting and insight systems.</p><p><strong>2. It’s easy to get OCD over your daily, let alone hourly sales figures</strong>, and feel this urge to act in response. Sometimes this is good, motivation can come in many different forms, but often, it can lead to a distractive, even negative, read-and-react nature.</p><p><strong>3. It doesn’t necessarily tell you things that are actionable</strong>. Data can be confusing, and deeper analysis, often requires more of it, and stronger analysis skills than most independents have. For what it’s worth, the things I will explain, were arrived at with what I describe to my friend as nothing more than good high-school level math skills, and “course” forecasts.</p><p>At the same time, the more I work with data just exploring it without the drive to find “actionable” data, the more it actually results in insights that do drive actionable discussions.</p><p>For example, I did the graph in Figure 1.1 to show him how much the overall average daily decline in sales was improving — meaning more long tail! It didn’t necessarily tell him something he couldn’t sort of see just looking at the daily sales/ad data, but it was a reassuring story to see, and it offered additional perspective and conversation over how each update, and promotion was strengthening the title’s long-term horizontal flow toward steadier long-term sales.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/882/0*_ZB0yYCRw0Yq_c3u." /><figcaption><strong>Figure 1.1 </strong>Looking at the rate of decline in sales as it slows over time providing more likelihood of long-tail sales</figcaption></figure><p><strong>4. Building systems to combine various datasets, and create customized work and reporting environments is tough.</strong> It’s an area I want to improve, but for now we’re just doing some basic importing of different data-sets into Google Sheets. At some point using something more rigorous, and automating it more with scripts, is the goal. There are some higher-end tools focused on these via a SaaS model, but the expense and time to devote to them makes them temporarily prohibitive.</p><p>Independents have to make do with what they have vs. larger concerns. We’re not all MBAs working at P&amp;G or Unilever, two of the most data-driven consumer goods companies you can find, with unparalleled access to data and analysis capacities. So to make use of this, we must build models, often with gaps, but ideally with evidence, and basic logic, and then merge those with strong opinion over what the goals are, and what the ethics will be.</p><h3><strong>Ranks, Revenues, and CPMs</strong></h3><p>As of this writing I’ve got some 50+ days of sales data to look at, some other older title sales data, and a bunch of low-level competitive intelligence data.</p><p><em>Lets first understand what the data says, and what it tells you about app stores.</em></p><p><strong>1. Everything is about narrow funnels.</strong></p><p>It’s no secret the draw back to app stores is everything goes through a narrow funnel of getting someone to notice your game, pushing them on some device to an app store landing page, and then hoping they click download, open the app, play, and ideally play it enough.</p><p>For paid titles the initial download includes revenue, but for free-to-play titles, a download is the first part of a longer journey of monetization using advertising, in-app purchases, or both.</p><p>The app store landing page is the first critical juncture, creating three elements of a revenue-yielding value-chain:</p><p><strong>Element 1</strong> is <strong>pre-landing page</strong>, it is everything that generates attention and ideally planned behavior to play, and ideally make a purchase, ahead of the requirement to download.</p><p><strong>Element 2</strong> is the <strong>landing page itself</strong>, and other tasks such as SEO and app store SEO to fish additional players from the serendipitous audience finding your game among any specific platforms’ customer base.</p><p><strong>Element 3</strong> is <strong>everything you within game, and amongst your downloaded audience</strong> (which may be out-of-game) to continue to engage them and generate additional revenue per user, and word-of-mouth/social activity that generates person-to-person promotion for your game.</p><p><strong>NOTE: </strong>The A in ARPU means average, but I think <em>additional</em> is better in terms of what you should be doing. Rising ARPU is the results of <em>additional</em> revenues per user, after initial contact, be it a free or paid user. Additional also signifies that games which earn key revenues from advertising, that this additional revenue is a direct result of sustained engagement which delivers more ads over the course of thatengagement vs. specific purchase decisions by the audience. Advertising is passive ARPU, derived from engagement only, not just engagement + transactional behavior.</p><p>The funnel in its best form is more of an hourglass. Going in are Elements 1 &amp; 2, through the narrow channel, then coming out the other side is everything from Element 3 above.</p><p><strong>2. The data has huge gaps and different sensitivities.</strong></p><p>Unless you have time and set up additional, sometimes costlier systems, your data is going to have large gaps, and different sensitivities to understand. For example, Apple provides you data on what direct referral links have led to revenue, usually from specific articles where the publisher uses referral links to generate revenue from their coverage. Others are from third-party app directories. The reports are useful, but they only capture the small slice of users who directly click over, and many users don’t do that. Instead users often choose to open the app store on their device and search for the name of a title they just read about earlier. Lost in that moment is the direct link between PR or other referral efforts and your game.</p><p>Revenues for the day will include late settlements, refunds, etc. So it’s not precise either. Sometimes aggregation services like AppAnnie or AppFigures can have hiccups importing correct data from iTunes (which also gets fixed, and may not be their fault) so any given day isn’t really what it is.</p><p>In comparing days with similar results say on app page visits, you will find different results in terms of downloads. Some days ad revenue is higher because eCPM was higher, not because your users played more. For country-by-country advertising data the second largest segment of performance is Unknown country. While we can assume it likely breaks down similar in percentage to the known countries when a report has Unknown as its second biggest category that is a gap in your confirmed knowledge base.</p><p>There are ways to deal with these problems. One is looking at internal analytics from the app to see what it tells you about the app vs. what store and ad network data tells you. Another simple method is to chart a rolling 7 day average for key metrics as that will help smooth out mini-spikes and dips. It’s also good to potentially remove your biggest launch period out for some basic analysis since, almost nothing will be as big as your launch.</p><p>As data expands I also look for “comparables” to learn from. For example, compare days that had the same number of downloads, or the same number of in-app-purchase events. These are interesting because the can help to spark conversations and investigations into your game, marketing, etc. Most of all they give you insight into what’s going on. For example, during a period where we had unusually high conversion rates for IAP, we traced it to a specific review. That may not necessarily give us anything especially great to use, but I do believe the more we understand things the better.</p><p>Another tidbit of late. The game started gaining traction in China. However Chinese consumers are not big spenders, preferring to grind out on free-to-play modes. The sheer volume of page views generated by interest from China coupled with lower IAP conversion means that our IAP conversion metrics ended up radically skewed. Hence, we now have to remove China-based downloads from our download-to-IAP conversion formulas to otherwise have a more accurate depiction of our IAP conversion performance where culturally it’s more of a behavioral fit.</p><p><strong>Given all this data I did a few things:</strong></p><p>1. I took all pageviews on the app store, download statistics, each ad networks’ revenues and impressions, and rankings from AppAnnie and began logging them daily. I created several simple statistics from this:</p><p><strong>A. Conversion rates : page views to downloads, downloads to IAP, etc.</strong></p><p>Not only did I do singular points of these statistics, I also created “available to convert” statistics both in total and on a 7 day rolling average.</p><p><strong>Available to convert is basically:</strong><br><em>All downloads-IAP Purchasers. Since the game only has a single IAP, once you buy it two things happen. First, you no longer see ads, so those customers should be removed from the impressions/user category. Second, you can’t be converted twice. Thus, what we want to know is not only on a daily basis how many people converted, but what was the total population of un-converted users left to convert them from.</em></p><p>Some of these stats could be improved through better in-app analytics. For example, the statistic of current day conversion being <em>current day downloads/current IAP income</em> is not great. With the model we’re using it’s likely 50% or more of the IAP purchase from any one day is earned from a user obtained prior to that day. However, I’m not using in-app analytics because of several issues. First, depending on the user, while I know when they purchase, the app store might not settle their payment for several days, second they might take a refund, third, it might be affected by exchange rates. By only using app store provided sales data, and then using some cumulative and rolling averages, I can still get a strong gist of what I want and I’m not mixing two different analytic feeds at the same time.</p><p><strong>Remember:</strong> independents, less capacities, etc. Yes, someday, over time I want to merge the two systems of in-app, and app store end result analytics, but for now, keeping it simple isn’t the worst outcome.</p><p><strong>B. Impressions per user and eCPM: </strong>The current game uses four (and possibly soon five) different ad networks, and two different ad products. The nature of ad networks is an entirely other article, but for now understand we’re analyzing the following as it relates to in-game advertising:</p><p><strong>I. Gross impressions per-day</strong> per network.</p><p><strong>II. Per-user impressions on average: </strong>total impressions/ad-exposed users</p><p><strong>III. The Effective CPM: </strong>total ad revenue / (total impressions / 1000)</p><p><strong>IV. The Average eCPM per day, per all ad-exposed users</strong>: Total Ad Revenue / Ad Exposed Users</p><p><strong>V. Requests/Fill-Rate per-day /per country: </strong>An indication of where we’re missing out on possible revenue due to poor in-country coverage.</p><p>Ideally we should also be measuring subsets of our ad exposed users, specifically Ad Revenue/DAUs for that day, but again, that’s a different set of data than the gross data I’m working with. By dividing by our entire user base, even those who drop out, we’re doing two things. First, we’re looking at lifetime expectations for any user. Second, we’re penalizing ourselves a bit for users who drop out from playing, and not forgetting that bringing them back to the game, can have a great impact on our overall audience availability, and ideally ads served, and revenue generated.</p><p>For all these numbers we compute each individual ad network for comparisons, and the total for all ad networks.</p><p><strong>C. Total revenues &amp; revenues per X: </strong>Once all revenues sources are available, I look at not only revenues per day, but most importantly revenues per download, and revenues per page view. Ultimately, if all revenues must start with someone actively hitting the app’s download page, the ability to convert from that first-visible metric is key. If page-views rise but revenue doesn’t rise in relation to that, each page view will be worth less and less. If it’s the opposite then it might indicate the viability of blindly getting more people to that page whatever means possible.</p><p><strong>D. Cumulatives &amp; Rolling Averages : </strong>Given the day-to-day ups and downs of app stores and ad networks, not to mention general 7 day retention, I’ve found a simple rule-of-thumb is using 7-day rolling averages for most daily stats results in a better set of numbers to work with. It’s a simple smoothing process, and helps to create more honest comparisons of day-to-day points when looking at comparable periods. I also look at the overall average since inception, or some other long period of time, so I can compare what any given day is doing vs. what has been the overall average— <em>is it above or below?</em> Finally, I look at every new day, and mark (using conditional formatting features) if this day is bringing the average down or up overall.</p><p>The goal is to have simple data points that help with identifying positive or negative anomalies daily, or in short periods, because those are times where you can learn more. Ideally you can trace these moments to something that happened which might lead to further actions you can take or learn from.</p><p><strong>E. Curve fit forecasts : </strong>A key issue for any developer and their total revenues for a title is the notion of sustainability and the long tail. Much has been written about the long tail, which I won’t recreate. Instead, let’s use sustainability, best described in the following contextual terms:</p><p><em>The long term capacity for your game to return meaningful daily revenue for as long as possible with less and less tangible investment to maintain an acceptable level of sustainabile daily revenue.</em></p><p>In fact, what I’d argue is the goal for any independent game developer (and really any independent app developer) is that this really is the ultimate floor. If you can earn $20/day from a title for four or more years with minimal effort after its biggest sales are behind it, that’s the result of a successfully achieved sustainable position — especially if you’ve been very careful with your total input — which unfortunately for many indies may not be the case.</p><p>What this says about what your inputs should be is also, an entirely different article, but the short version is here:</p><blockquote><em>My opinion is most indies fail to achieve sustainability because they don’t plan for what it looks like at the outset and don’t know how to achieve it in the end. This most often manifests itself in the form of too much expense in terms of developmental hours, loss of other income, and team size/tactics.</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>In general I can’t imagine broad swaths of the indie/hobbyist community resting its survival on sustainable titles that require long tails in excess of $20-$50 a day in daily income. There is for now, no data, I’ve seen showing that there are enough slots for games earning in excess of $200-$500 a day to support the population of indie/hobbyist developers as it exists today.</em></blockquote><p>In terms of my friend’s game, what I have done is taken the first 60 days of revenue and charted it out looking at daily revenues and number of users, and the day-to-day raise or decline. With that chart, and some other futzing, I’m able to calculate an equivalent daily-average-decline rate long term for the title. This provides a course ability to project future revenue and over time it’s updated. While it would be nice to have a title that hits a self-sustaining life-cycle in the top ten of its category, the reality is people move on to other titles, and App Store featuring isn’t a permanent position for those on the outside of top 20 category charts. So plotting out your own game’s downfall is humbling but important.</p><p>Hopefully, the success of the title so far, sees the bottom end of the curve flatten out much more as time goes on, and settles into that $20+ level of sustainability for a long time.</p><p>Another important reason to do this, isn’t just ideally peace of mind, but the great confidence you have in your unaltered projected revenues, the more you can decide if you want to risk some of that future revenue on boosts to your marketing that results in better near term revenues and ultimately overall as well. <em>It’s a risk, but clearly by definition, a calculated one.</em></p><p><strong>2. I Created some Models for Sustainable Advertising</strong></p><p>As said earlier a key goal is to look for evidence, and build a model that justifies the use of paid-media to achieve sales, revenue, and ultimately profit growth for the title.</p><p>To do this I look at a combination of the sales data, and data gathered from other sources. I have constructed two approaches to look at:</p><p><strong>Approach #1 : Looking at Per 1000 Revenues</strong></p><p>Approach number one is the total amount of income per download (aka user), and then total income per page view on the app store. Both are different derivatives of ARPU (<em>Average Revenue Per User</em>) or even ARPDAU (<em>Average Revenue Per Daily Average User</em>). I then calculate that to a CPM metric so it’s easy to understand the relationship of a CPM ad rate, and a RPM revenue per 1000 users rate. It’s a nice 1:1 comparison.</p><p><em>There are a some issues with this approach worth discussing before getting to additional conclusions:</em></p><p><strong>1. I’m looking at advertising costs on a pure CPM basis. </strong>CPI (Costs-Per-Install) rates are high because of three things: first, direct CPI purchasing offers a certain level of security that larger companies which have games or businesses that generate a higher ARPU can afford to pay for. Second, there is an over-abundance of demand overall, fueled in part because of cheap money flowing through VC and private equity paying for higher user acquisition costs. You’re not just competing for CPI with Clash of Clans, but Uber, and others. Third, to justify CPI, you need to do additional engineering to track it all properly.</p><p>This means for developers who want to advertise, competing on direct CPI buys is really hard, unless you can see an ARPU that justifies it, and that’s only likely if you’re engaging in chasing down revenue through some of the less ethical elements of FTP (free-to-play). Instead, smaller developers, those with titles that aren’t engineered for large average customer revenues will have to consider the risk of extracting installs through CPC and CPM purchases.</p><p>Since the assurance of install success with these campaigns drops, and inventory is more plentiful relative to demand, there is opportunity to purchase advertising at much smaller CPMs. As such, you’re counting on the results of your funnel to generate the assurance of converting users at a profit that a CPI ad buy would give. If your funnel’s monetization is not good enough, then it will fail.</p><p>Given the cost of CPI relative to my friends revenue model there really isn’t any other choice.</p><p>2. <strong>Extracting the costs of advertising </strong>so we can consider various forms, because advertising cost data is hard to come by. This is not only because of the seismic movements in the adtech world that constantly take place, but also because of the normalized nature of what essentially is a global daily, hourly even, auction system around advertising.</p><p>Furthermore, much of this auction pricing is opaque, hidden behind ad marketplace systems you have to sign up for, and then individually understand. All of them have a bevy (understatement!) of choices for targeting, customizing, pricing, and sometimes investigating result forecasts.</p><p>To this day, I still don’t feel I fully understand how to optimize an ad buy on Google. Facebook’s system is less complex, but still has a ton of options. Apple’s iAd is much easier to use, but its forecasting for anything other than banners isn’t clear up front. I’ve yet to unpack other systems that exist.</p><p>From an indie perspective purchasing advertising to support your title is a daunting task, and that’s even before you decide to even begin to consider the risk of laying out actual dollars.</p><p><strong>NOTE:</strong> Most of the previously mentioned indie stories I’ve seen, have tests of advertising early in their marketing campaign, and it usually is less than $500.00 spent. The results aren’t promising, but it’s important to state, when I’ve seen this discussed, the buy is pretty blind, has been mostly adwords based, and likely too small a sample size.</p><p>Looking at the data of the most recently launched title it is earnings $XX per 1000 page view on iOS App Store. Per 1000 users the game is earning ~$X00. The multiple of these two numbers is essentially 100/conversion rate of views to downloads.</p><p><em>What this means is that for advertising to work and be of value to the title the following formula has to be true:</em></p><p>Cost of 1 CPM Unit of Advertising &lt; Resulting Revenue from Users</p><p>This is where the performance of the game, and the performance of advertising conversion rates all begin to align, and the funnel nature of digital businesses becomes all-encompassing.</p><p>According to Adivity the average CTR (click-through-rate) in the U.S. for moPub is 2% for iOS and .8% for Android. For other ad networks it changes. This is a composite of all ad types so again, it’s a bit opaque. Mobile Interstitials are reported to have a 5.5% CTR. Video ads would ideally be higher as well, but likely cost prohibitive. Let’s assume then that mobile CTRs run the gamut from .5% CTR to 7% CTR depending on many factors including audience, creative, targeting, competition, time-of-year, and what color the sunset was last night. Assume for a moment that you could assemble a mix of advertising that performed at a 2% CTR.</p><p>To get 1000 impressions to the App Store would require 50,000 impressions. That means I need to purchase 50 CPMs and for that, if all else held true we’d make $XX back. The average eCPM on MoPub in the U.S. is $2.09 according to recently published data, so $50 CPMs is $104.50. Now I don’t have to even tell you how much my friend is earning for you to figure out that $104.50 minus any two-digit revenue number is a loss.</p><p>Looking at it from the revenue per downloads perspective, to achieve 1000 downloads requires hitting a much larger multiple of page views to the App Store. If we even hit a 20% download conversion rate from the App Store page we’d need 5000 app store page views to generate that would take 250,000 CPMs assuming a 2% CTR. 250,000 CPMS is going to cost $522.50. Currently my friend is making some level below that per 1000 downloads.</p><p><strong>Approach #2 Looking at Rank to Revenue Relationships</strong></p><p>With App stores you get rank data. Given enough time, and with the fact that an update, plus some App-Store promotions helped to push the title back in-and-out of higher ranks, I was able to use some basic regression analysis to rough out numbers showing the relationship between rank in the key games subcategory for the game, and resulting revenue. There is expected variance, but using some averaging, and an exponential curve fit, the confidence level for the final set of data was pretty strong.</p><p>The data shows the value of moving up from a rank of 200 to 100, or 160 to 80, or 80 to 40. By looking at this data it indicates that if several thousands of dollars successful improved the rank of his game from 160 to 80 the resulting rise in revenue would likely be recouped. This assumes the comparison is a weekly one. The difference in being ranked around 160 for a week, and being ranked 80 for a week, in the game’s specific App Store game sub-category was just under $5K. If the move resulted in going from a sustained ranking of 160 for a week, to a sustained ranking in the 50s in the U.S. App Store, the gain in revenue would be closer to $10K-$12K.</p><p><strong>NOTE: </strong>These figures are just for the U.S. iOS App Store which is the #1 market in the world in terms of total gross revenues. They are also for sub-categories within the games category and shouldn’t be confused with the recently published data on costs to reach top tier status overall — as those numbers are much higher. Aside from the U.S. App Store we could also look at some individual countries and see if some pockets outside the U.S. are worth calculating similar values for, but it’s likely no more than five have a sizeable enough aggregate audience to make this work useful.</p><p>Keep in mind that the goal for this analysis was to determine how much a sustained period of ranking was worth. This doesn’t mean the ranking itself achieves the results for you. Yes within the top 25, or 50, I am pretty certain it is true the higher you get, the more that rank brings with it increasing organic visibility on app stores. Overall, my sense is rankings outside the top 50 or so are likely to be indicative of what you’ve done with your game, and its related visibility/word-of-mouth and advertising, and not the result of self-fulfilling app store presence. There may be some, as some consumers plunge through the top category charts in search of titles that catch their eye, but so far I have no sense of how much each rank within an app stores larger top 200, 500, 1000 contributes-by-itself to future sales.</p><p>When discussing moving an app from 160 to 80 in rank, my goal is to use that to forecast what that likely brings in future downloads, installs, and revenues so we can see if the cost of getting there equals the return.</p><p>I also have no idea of the cost of getting from 200 to 100, 160 to 80, or higher. I can assume it has some level of exponential curve correlated to the activity exhibited by titles at those ranks but I have no certain sense what that number is. And as I said earlier, the only public forecasts are for much higher tiered categories and even then, those numbers are under dispute. Furthermore, issues like creative, ad size, demographics targeted, etc. will all affect the resulting outcome of any ad campaign.</p><p>So Approach #1 shows a likely financial shortfall in its model, and the rank raising model shows the possible return but not the definitive cost. Both have enough uncertainty, and unanswered questions. So it would seem that we’re coming up short, we should end the analysis, and the conclusion is don’t do any advertising. But the reality is this:</p><p>The gap between your game’s revenues, and revenues that enable some level of sustainable advertising can fall into three categories:</p><ol><li><strong>Already positive</strong> (i.e. revenues from 1000 users outstrip cost of acquiring 1000 users)</li><li><strong>Close</strong> (i.e. revenues from 1000 users is close but not profitable using data available)</li><li><strong>Far</strong> (i.e. anything &lt;50% of the cost per 1000 users acquired.)</li></ol><p>With so many games being released everyday, and so many other non-game applications, media, and social media efforts vying for attention of users, there is only so much attention any given release can hold, for so long. While some developers are inventive enough to find new ways over time to keep their game visible, almost every such effort other than advertising requires approval of people other than the user, be it a journalist, or some other gatekeeper. Advertising, on the other hand, has less restrictions, and if successful, can extend the sustainability of a title, raising its audience, and profitability for some time beyond the capacity of free-media, and updates.</p><blockquote>Achieving a game whose profitability outstrips your probable cost and risk of advertising makes it a more favored candidate for longer term success at higher levels of revenue and ideally profit.</blockquote><h3><strong>Making the Leap</strong></h3><p>Advertising by itself it is a risk. Despite years of clickstream data, and the rise of deeper analytics over response rates, there are still no guarantees. Many elements could conspire for/against any particular developer. In the cases where creative is great, and targeting is spot on, and those reached by the advertising are receptive, you may be able to be successful with a gap that isn’t quite closed or slightly closed mathematically. In negative cases, even if your title mathematically seems well positioned for advertising it may still not return on its investment.</p><p>Making the leap for advertising, especially for smaller developers, is always going to be risky, and difficult, but ultimately, as stated previously, this goal provides a level of rigor to shoot for even if you never pull the trigger.</p><p>Everyone wants their games to do better, to reach the most audience, to generate impact among their players, and ultimately to profit well from privind that value. My search for an overall sustainable model including advertising just tries to put some numbers to it.</p><p>In the case of my friends game there are no some very concrete goals and hypothesis to consider as follows:</p><ol><li><strong>Can $5000 worth of sustained advertising improve his average rank from 160 or worse to 80 </strong>or better within his given game subcategory? That’s a nice hypothesis to have, it’s got great bounds, and we can measure it. Aside from a guarantee it’s the next best thing.</li><li><strong>Can we improve all aspects of his funnel, the landing page, the game itself, long-term PR, ad network optimization, localization</strong>, etc. to improve the gap between the cost of blanket CPM advertising to generate 1000 installs (assuming what we believe to be industry standard CTRs) and the revenue earned from those 1000 installs?</li></ol><p>The first hypothesis is good — it may be proven wrong, but it’s a solid hypothesis created from observable data with reasonable confidence.</p><p>The second goal, is a question of work and faith. So far my friend and I have done some optimizations to the game’s App store landing page, improved social sharing on the game, and continued to look for PR opportunities. There are other in-game actions planned to try and improve IAP conversion, and currently we’re learning how to optimize ad revenues both overall and on a country-by-country basis.</p><p>What’s most important about everything I’ve explained up to now is we actually have some semblance in numbers and models to guide what to do, why to do it, and ultimately what it might be worth. Do I wish it was way better, given how many gaps I’ve explained? Yes. However, given everything we’ve cobbled together to get to this point, the learning and perspective has been tremendous and will help his current title and follow on works. This work breeds higher levels of certainty, despite gaps, and deeper levels of perspective, that ultimately should make things less paralyzing.</p><p>I don’t foresee overcoming the gap between forecasted revenues and forecasted costs of advertising entirely, the game just does not monetize any individual user at super high numbers like a Candy Crush Saga does — and that’s by choice. What’s left to ascertain is, how much flywheel effect can come from advertising?</p><p>Assume several thousands of dollars was spent on a CPM-style campaign to acquire users. The campaign would use either low-effect banners, or slightly better static/animated interstitials, video ads are too expensive.</p><p>The question will be “does the advertising move the needle enough to produce four pools of revenue that we can measure, and once we do, it outstrips the spend?”</p><p><em>What we’d be looking for are the following:</em></p><ol><li><strong>Immediate response in our downloads, IAP conversion, and ad revenue</strong> over time that clearly is more than what it was and we then have reasonable confidence to attribute that to the advertising. Yes come CPI systems like Facebook can help track that more specifically but again — expense of implementing these is not viable.</li><li><strong>Does the climb in rank bring in other visibility</strong>, and thus installs, that helps make up some of the gap? These customers are captured not directly from ads, but from the climb in rank that catches their eye otherwise. Harder to capture, but if the rank climbs well, we will likely see some effect.</li><li><strong>Do these new users</strong>, captured outside the usual haunts of game review sites, top category lists, etc.<strong> generate new word-of-mouth pathways</strong> that provide prolonged effect? If we capture 1000 new users for $4000 but they’re only worth $2.00 each that’s not great, but if those new users eventually lead to another couple thousand users due to new word of mouth pathways, we move easily into a good ROI for that money. The issue is seeing prolonged word-of-mouth effect will take some time.</li><li><strong>Do these new users monetize differently, and outperform the current population?</strong> Maybe we’re underestimating or overestimating? Even with concrete performance data the vast majority of our users were acquired through PR, App Store features, and especially mindful App Store visitors? While it might be easy to say those further from the gaming core are less likely to monetize similarly, the nature of this game is it appeals to people who aren’t core gamers once they start playing it. So it may go against conventional wisdom.</li></ol><p>In all these cases, and others I have discussed, there are decent hypothesis that represent reason to believe that a close gap between revenues and cost-of-advertising might be overcome.</p><p>Already some improvements, born from looking at the same data, and seeking to quantify the risk-return of advertising have resulted in excellent improvements. This includes the game, its marketing, and general understanding of the systems that control who plays his game, for how long, and at what financial benefit.</p><p>By optimizing everything we can, within reason, the stage is set to advertise.</p><p>Depending on your corporate structure consider that the risk of advertising, at least in trial form, is a shared risk. Assuming you’re reinvesting some level of incoming revenue post-launch, those funds spent are not net-of-taxes. So if your tax rate for pass-through income is, for sake of argument, 40% (don’t forget self-employment tax in the U.S.), then risking $5K on advertising is really “only” risking $3K in personal income, net-of-taxes.</p><blockquote>For many indies, income net-of-taxes is the true sense of what’s at risk, provided your overall business obligations are low — which by default, as an indie, they should be.</blockquote><p>I can’t say yet what the results will be. The decision to spend is not with me, but ideally I’ve made that a less stressful decision because there is a greater sense of the risk and possible return. if/when he does, I promise to bring back the results, and explore further what worked and didn’t.</p><p><strong>NOTE:</strong> For “I told you so” sakes, I predict that the advertising, provided the creative is decent enough, will break even in the short-term or just fall short, but that it will measurably improve the game’s overall revenues over a longer period of time, as those new breakeven users add long term to the games word-of-mouth related revenues. Initial returns on advertising will be mixed, to break-even, and we’ll potentially recycle those revenues for a slightly longer period of time, and then see a bit of a pro-longed lifecycle over the succeeding weeks and months as those new users, bring in new users through word-of-mouth. Depending on how much of a boost that last bit is, will determine if the effort to advertise overall was worth it.</p><p>The positive x-factor will be if rank growth turns into a super-positive upside flywheel, and the negative x-factor will be if general apathy toward display ads (banners, or interstitials) in mobile apps is just too hard to escape.</p><h3>App Store Gaps or Something More?</h3><p>While so much of this essay has been about advertising, the true title of the essay, is about the gap that exists on app stores for indies.</p><p>The specific gap I’ve outlined is around the bigger question of can advertising help my friends title earn more money, for longer periods of time, and ultimately help it have a more sustainable existence on app stores?</p><blockquote>But the larger question that underlies this all is the overall gap that exists between most indies today, and their own confidence, and sustainability.</blockquote><p>True long-term return is best achieved through sustainable approaches. Punching a lottery ticket can still happen, but if all you’re around for is the purchase of a single ticket, you need to be infinitely more lucky than the developer with 5–6 sustainable titles who gets to try again, and again.</p><p>When app stores were fresh, visibility was easier. As more products entered the fray, and stores didn’t necessarily respond with a bevy of systems to improve the chances to breakout beyond the narrow windows of visibility afforded by those same stores, indies have arrived at a point where it’s much harder to flourish on game alone. Sure it’s possible, and that’s one of the charms of the games business, and the attraction we heap upon brilliant indies, but this is but a small swath of the total industry. And it’s not the subset of the industry I’d want my kids hanging their hat on should they tell me they’re going to do what Notch or Jonathan Blow did.</p><p>Today, modern game development, even for indies, requires having not only a good game, and a clear audience target, but you need systems that measure many data points, and means to quickly adjust and tweak related revenue systems. You need models by which to make continuous opportunity cost decisions, you need in-app systems to cross promote titles, systems to mediate multiple advertising networks to optimize revenues amongst real-time advertising markets, and much more. These are not the sexy things that we associate with indie success but they are the reality now.</p><p>While I applaud most indies for <strong><em>not</em></strong> jumping down the ethical trap many FTP+microtransaction titles fall into, it’simportant to know implementing those systems effectively means a CPI model (which is expensive but has more certainty) requires expensive systems and work to do — let alone ethical landmines to navigate. It’s as much hard to do, as hard to stomach.</p><p>For many indies, development has becomes publish your game, send out some PR, and hope for the best. There have been many talking about the so-called Indie Apocalypse. The only Indie Apocalypse I see concerns approaches, not indies themselves.</p><p>There is a real Indie App Store Gap. It lies between big companies, and smaller ones, who are operating with some, or more of the systems and models that let them chase more certainty, and sustainability, let alone high-level success, and those indies who aren’t doing it, or even trying.</p><p>My advice here isn’t only about advertising or other higher-order marketing efforts. My advice is to identify, understand, and be realistic about the many gaps in knowledge, data, and capacities that exist for smaller game developers. Carefully build models, and test them, with the goal of increasingly gaining control over systems that govern sustainable success for you (not just your games) over the long term.</p><p>As you do, please share some of this, so we those that are more deeply and rationally committed beyond the dream of a hit game, can benefit as well. Together maybe we can close some of the gap, so everyone has a slightly better chance at sustainable success.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=1787972115d2" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>