<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Betsy Hodges on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Betsy Hodges on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@BetsyHodges?source=rss-eb3d732e689c------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Wed, 18 Nov 2026 14:29:35 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@BetsyHodges/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Will White Women Show Up For VP Harris?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@BetsyHodges/will-white-women-show-up-for-vp-harris-b646e3ce8b07?source=rss-eb3d732e689c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/b646e3ce8b07</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[white-women]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[race]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[whiteness]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[harris-walz-2024]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[voting]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Betsy Hodges]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 24 Oct 2024 19:08:16 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-10-24T19:08:16.914Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*cnM84FaFcAd5aS62NgnNxA.jpeg" /><figcaption>image: cottonbro studio</figcaption></figure><p>When I campaigned for Mayor of Minneapolis on a platform of racial equity in 2013, I could hear the white people in the room stop breathing whenever I used the phrase “white people.” For most of us, it is taboo to discuss race with one another, particularly our own.</p><p>But 11 years later, we do not have the time to stop breathing, to stop doing anything. The future of American democracy rests on whether enough white women will vote for a Black and South Asian woman for president. And to do that we must acknowledge how race impacts this election.</p><p>As white women Democrats, we are tempted to think that pushing each other to vote for Kamala Harris is not as urgent as persuading other groups. That’s false and dangerous.</p><p>White women in the United States have voted for the Republican candidate for president in all but two elections since 1952. Yes, that includes Trump in 2016 — and 2020.</p><p>How do we change that trend? We need to call voters, knock on doors, and talk to other white women about the election. Sounds simple enough, but nothing about this election is simple, especially its racial and gender implications.</p><p>Here is what I have seen as a white woman who both held office with a racial equity agenda and as a teacher of workshops on white racial identity: so many of us white women want to do the work, but we hesitate to door-knock, make calls, or rally our peers.</p><p>The reason is our racial conditioning.</p><p>It was like this in 2020. After George Floyd was murdered in Minneapolis, we were geared up for action on race and ready to get different outcomes for people of color, especially regarding public safety. We read books, we voted, we sent emails asking elected officials to change budgets and polices around policing, maybe we participated in the DEI trainings that were ubiquitous for 18 months.</p><p>This churn felt promising to us. But we didn’t build these efforts into our lives sustainably, our attention dwindled, and our burst of enthusiasm did not translate into widespread systemic change.</p><p>Even regarding policing, in 2024 many American cities spend <em>more</em> money on traditional policing, including Minneapolis itself. Calls from other white people to shut down DEI work and, in some states, to forbid it — have gained traction.</p><p>Status quo social systems are structured to make persistent thinking and action about racial equity difficult for white people. Under ideal circumstances, we could strategize ways to act against our social conditioning over the long haul.</p><p>But insight is not change and at this point we have 12 days (as of this writing). Even to give ourselves the space to change, Harris and Walz need to win the White House in November. If not, there will be a very different kind of racial reckoning, one that will drive our country backwards.</p><p>To ensure that our democracy not only continues, but progresses, I urge white women to acknowledge our racial conditioning and then take these three positive steps forward.</p><p>First, although we may feel like we are not equipped to overcome our racial conditioning, all we need to do is listen to what Vice President Harris and her campaign managers are telling us: Door knock, lit drop, make calls and talk to the people in our circles, big and small.</p><p>Second, no matter where we fall on the political scale, white people are conditioned to think that our ideas are inherently superior to those of people of color. That bias tempts us to criticize leaders of color, and women of color even more so.</p><p>Instead, hold off your criticism. We do not have the luxury to question or be critical, saying things like, “This door-knocking script is all wrong” or “Why did she say <em>that</em> ?”</p><p>Finally, for many white women, especially middle-class white women, talking about race — especially our own — violates social norms. I didn’t grow up talking about race at the dinner table. So I was floored that my husband and his family, who are African American, bring up race like it’s no big deal.</p><p>We are unlikely to be that comfortable talking about race by November 5. But we need to acknowledge the discomfort and band together.</p><p>We need to talk about why race matters more than ever this election. We need to talk about why Vice President Harris is the most qualified candidate and why her victory matters to democracy. Then we get to vote.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=b646e3ce8b07" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Trump at 87 Days and 7 Years]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@BetsyHodges/trump-at-87-days-and-7-years-4911d0c112ea?source=rss-eb3d732e689c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/4911d0c112ea</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[trumpism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[authoritarianism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[fascism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[donald-trump]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Betsy Hodges]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 17 Apr 2024 18:02:23 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-04-17T18:04:57.380Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/463/1*K12Tj1-AYTHsee-CUr2PXA.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/550/1*gXoLUBT7yiR_vY3g8qNJPQ.png" /><figcaption>Trump, April 2017, Photo: Alex Brandon; Hodges April 2017, Photo: Glen Stubbe</figcaption></figure><p>On April 19th, 2017, Donald Trump had been president for 87 days. His campaign had been prologue for his Presidency, which was prologue for January 6th, which was prologue for his current campaign. He was clear about his desire to be a dictator long before he said the words aloud.</p><p>I was mayor of Minneapolis, Minnesota at the time. Knowing that Trump was walking the path of fascists and authoritarians before him, I asked myself what I would have wanted the mayor of Düsseldorf, Germany to have done in 1933.</p><p>(I mean that literally, by the way, not as a rhetorical device seven years later. It was how I gave myself clarity of purpose.)</p><p>In response to that question, my team and I put together a slate of policy changes and budget investments we could make right away that could serve as antidotes to the Trump agenda, and later that year I also invested more in the budget.</p><p>I also gave a speech outlining what I was seeing and what Minneapolis as a city could do in response. It was the only official stand-alone speech I gave as mayor aside from my State of the City and budget addresses, so it was a pretty big deal for me.</p><p>It landed with a thud. I was running for re-election at the time, and the paper of record in Minneapolis gave my opponents plenty of space to accuse me of pandering. The New York Times came to interview me about it, which I was excited about, but then <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2017/07/10/us/democrat-mayor-candidates.html">published a piece</a> portraying the speech as a cynical, ineffective headlines grab during an election year (and also gave my opponents plenty of space to criticize me). A lot of my constituents thought I was blowing things out of proportion and went out of their way to tell me so.</p><p>At the time I figured, so be it. I believed that it was important for me to use my platform in any ways I could to combat Trump’s agenda to destroy American democracy. I gave the speech, made the financial investments and policy changes that I could, lost my bid for re-election, and have gone about my life ever since.</p><p>But with the anniversary of the speech so close, and Trump 2.0 back and worse than ever, I decided to take another look at it. It is seven years later, I am not running for anything, Trump’s agenda has curdled into a solid plan for dictatorship and authoritarianism (at best), and the policy template for government is still relevant. So I offer it again here as one small offering to the cause of saving the chance for American democracy.</p><p>The speech is posted below, in its entirety.</p><p>********</p><p>Thank you Luke and to Rabbi Latz, for that introduction, and for your warm hospitality in hosting us here this evening. I am deeply grateful to you both for your friendship and leadership, and you, Rabbi, for your unceasing prophetic witness. And thank you very much to Council Member Linea Palmisano for hosting us in her ward tonight.</p><p>We stand at a unique moment in the history of humanity. For the first time ever, a majority of humans live in cities. This fact provides our species with a unique opportunity to come together, understand each other, and connect with one another. It is in the close proximity of our cities where we as humans get to make one another feel welcome, connect on a human level, and come together to advance a common purpose.</p><p>We also stand at a unique moment in the history of the United States. Donald Trump has been president for 87 days. We do not know how many more days like the last 87 lie ahead of us.</p><p>In this unique moment, in the time of Trump, cities and the people who live in them are on the front lines. In the time of Trump, as the federal government abandons people, we who live in cities are the principal targets of attack.</p><p>I am mayor of a city at a time when Donald Trump is the president of the United States. I am also mayor of a city whose people have made the commitment to come together as One Minneapolis, to build a city that now more than ever, will prove a beacon for the rest of the country.</p><p>* * *</p><p>As a City government, our first order of business in the time of Trump is to stand firm with, defend, and support our people and our communities who are under attack.</p><p>This means we stand firm with trans students and the entire GLBTQ community. In February, Donald Trump sent them a clear message: he as our president, and they as our federal government, will no longer protect transgender students.</p><p>There are those who seek to reassure us by saying that rolling back protections for transgender students was merely a symbolic act, that some local school districts will continue to protect trans children and GLBTQ children.</p><p>That makes the point, however: the federal government is abandoning our most vulnerable young people. We at the local level can make another choice: we get to stand firm on our values.</p><p>Here in Minneapolis, we have stood firm and will stand firm with our <strong>trans youth, our transgender and gender diverse neighbors, and the GLBTQ community</strong>.</p><p>Already that has meant working with the City Council to create the brand-new Transgender Equity Council, the successor to the Transgender Issues Work Group. From their recommendations, we have invested in updating City properties so that restrooms are thoughtfully available to everyone. It has also meant pulling people together from across the community at the once-groundbreaking, now-annual Transgender Equity Summit, which is unlike any other in the country so far.</p><p>In the time of Trump, that work and more will and must continue. We must be more visible as allies, not less, when our neighbors are being abandoned and jeopardized by national leadership.</p><p>As mayor, I say again to the people of our GLBTQ community, especially our transgender and gender diverse neighbors: I see you, you matter to Minneapolis and the world, and we will continue to work to create a world that reflects your value as people and our values as a community.</p><p>We have also seen Minneapolis stand firm and come together with our <strong>immigrant neighbors</strong>. Our cosmopolitan city benefits from our immigrant residents in every aspect of our way of life: our culture, our values, our economy, and our future depend on us continuing to be a welcoming place for all.</p><p>City leaders and I, including Chief Harteau, have made it clear, and will continue to make it clear: our police officers do not and will not ask people their immigration status. We stand by our City’s separation ordinance: indeed, Council Member Alondra Cano is leading an effort to strengthen it, which I support. By guaranteeing that anyone who is a witness to or victim of a crime can feel safe interacting with police, the ordinance makes every community in our city safer. We have all been working too hard and too long in Minneapolis to build trust between the police and the rest of the community — and we still have a long way to go — to let President Trump get in the middle of that relationship.</p><p>We are also fighting in the courts: in March, Minneapolis joined 33 cities and counties in asking a federal court to find unconstitutional Trump’s executive order that threatens federal funds for cities like ours — cities that value the safety of all our residents.</p><p>Another area where we are on the front lines is in providing accurate information to our immigrant and refugee communities. City staff are developing consistent, accessible messaging that includes whom to call in case of an immigration-related emergency and what individuals’ rights are. MPD has released videos in Spanish, Somali, and English that explains the City’s separation ordinance. And Minneapolis 311 has made it easier to access Spanish-language resources, and is developing new tools to help people who are looking for immigration-related resources or assistance.</p><p>After the election of Trump, Council Vice President Elizabeth Glidden recognized that the City would soon be called on to meet urgent needs in the immigrant community, so I was pleased to support her amendment to the 2017 budget to add $35,000 for that purpose. She has convened a work group to identify current service or information gaps in the immigrant and refugee communities that this money might quickly and effectively fill, and I look forward to hearing of their proposal soon. Today, in partnership with Council Vice President Glidden and Ways and Means/Budget Committee Chair John Quincy, I am asking the Council to appropriate an additional $15,000 to this effort, to bring the total amount to $50,000.</p><p>Our community, too, has rallied to support our immigrant communities. Advocates like the Immigrant Law Center of Minnesota and volunteer lawyers have been working hard to meet the urgent legal needs of families with loved ones facing deportation. Congregations, many of them trained and organized by the faith-based coalition Isaiah, are publicly declaring that they are prepared to offer sanctuary to immigrant families throughout our city and state. Shir Tikvah is one of these congregations. Thank you.</p><p>I have said repeatedly that if Donald Trump is coming after our immigrant community, he’ll have to get through me first, through all the rest of Minneapolis first.</p><p>We also stand shoulder to shoulder with a segment of our community that is under particular attack: our <strong>Muslim community</strong>. Our Muslim brothers and sisters now live in every neighborhood and have become an increasingly large part of the very fabric of our city. They have transformed it for the better, and we are blessed for it.</p><p>Well before Donald Trump, we have known in Minneapolis that we all do better when we all do better: for a number of years, we as a city have invested in the health, safety, and prosperity of our Muslim community. This intentional work has included new investments in large-family affordable housing to better accommodate East African families; the recent opening of the Cedar Riverside Opportunity Center, of which Council Member Abdi Warsame has been the champion; and close collaboration between the Police Department and the community to build trust in our police officers — including by hiring and promoting 10 Somali officers, an accomplishment no other city can boast of and a foundation on which we must build.</p><p>The City of Minneapolis is also defending our Muslim community in the courts: we have filed an amicus brief with the lawsuit brought by the states of Minnesota and Washington against Trump’s shameful, discriminatory, illegal, and unconstitutional travel ban.</p><p>And let me say this loud and clear: if Trump somehow starts a registry of Muslims, I will be the first to sign up and I ask all of you to join me.</p><p>Also unlike Donald Trump — whose limits, if there are any, to his capacity for belittling entire communities have yet to be found — we as a city get to stand firmly with <strong>people with disabilities</strong>. Indeed, in the past three years, we’ve made more progress on ADA compliance and accessibility than in the previous two decades. In 2015, the City decided proactively to evaluate our own buildings and services to ensure that we are ADA-compliant and accessible to all residents. Our 2017–19 ADA Action Plan calls us to hire ADA Title II certified coordinators, fully caption meeting broadcasts and informational videos, and upgrade City web content to be accessible for everyone, among other goals that I am committed to reaching. We have also enhanced Minneapolis 311 to help log and respond to ADA issues that our residents may have. And our next-generation complete streets policy, which Council Members Lisa Bender, Cam Gordon, Kevin Reich and I worked on, prioritizes pedestrians and people with disabilities first.</p><p>While the video clip of Trump choosing to mock a reporter with a disability is seared forever in our brains, we in Minneapolis have made different choices, and put the resources behind them, to ensure that people living with disabilities can fully participate in our shared life. This is the kind of nation-leading work that is making Minneapolis a beacon of unity in a time of deliberate division.</p><p>We are just as firmly united as a city in defense of, and love for, our <strong>Jewish community.</strong></p><p>Let’s be perfectly clear: first candidate Trump, then President Trump, has shamelessly used the language and imagery of anti-Semitism. He has given open license to anti-Semitic individuals and groups across the country and across the world. There is a direct line between Trump’s words and images and the more than 100 disgraceful threats toward and attacks on Jewish targets, including bomb threats at Jewish community centers and the desecration of Jewish cemeteries, that have taken place just since January. They have even happened in our region.</p><p>Tonight, here, in this sanctuary, tonight, I say to our Jewish brothers and sisters, your city and your mayor stand with you. We love you. I love you.</p><p>I am not happy to report that the City Council and I anticipated that this awful trend would continue. But we did, which is why we added a position in the Department of Civil Rights to investigate complaints of discrimination and hate crimes, and why Civil Rights staff have increased outreach throughout the City. In addition, Minneapolis 311 has developed new codes to better track reports of hate crimes.</p><p>I say to our Jewish, Muslim, immigrant, and LGBTQ, and disability communities — as well as to our Native community, our refugee communities, and communities of color, and women — that if you experience any form of discrimination, including and especially crimes motivated by hate, we will investigate and we will act. Particularly at this moment in the life of our country, your city is by your side.</p><p>Because, yes, women too are under attack during this time of a President who throughout his life has degraded, objectified — and, it would seem, assaulted — women in his professional and personal life. Just weeks ago, Trump actually revoked a President Obama executive order that protected women from discrimination, harassment, and pay inequity in federal contracts.</p><p>We in Minneapolis have made, and get to continue making, different, better choices to improve the lives of <strong>women</strong>. As an employer, we in the City have set the ambitious goal of a 45 percent female workforce by 2020, from the 29 percent where we stand now. We are intentionally recruiting women in our most traditionally male-dominated departments: Police, Fire, and Public Works. Our employees also started an employee-resource group called the “29 Percent Club” that is focused on networking, retention, and promotion for women.</p><p>In the community, some of the work we are doing that I am most proud of is in combatting sexual assault. In this, Sexual Violence Awareness Month, the Hennepin County SMARTeam unveiled a new cross-disciplinary protocol that the City, and I personally, have supported to strengthen the ways that we respond to and support survivors of sexual assault.</p><p>In Minneapolis, we not only work to improve the lives of women in the workplace and in our community, we choose women for leadership roles. From our Council President and Vice President, School Board President, Park Board President, and Park Board Superintendent, to our Police Chief, City Attorney, Civil Rights Director, Public Works Director, Health Commissioner, Chief Human Resources Officer and, yes, to our Mayor, Minneapolis is led by progressive women executives and legislators who every day get to call out the sexist assumptions and outright misogyny that come with this time of Trump and Trump himself, and to lead us through it all to a better, more connected, more unified One Minneapolis.</p><p>* * *</p><p>These attacks on our people and our values in the time of Trump are appalling. We in Minneapolis not only get to fight back against them: we get to create, with our words and our deeds, real, lived alternatives to them that lift people up, break down barriers, and bind us more closely to one another.</p><p>Yet while these attacks are appalling — and, in the time of Trump, alarming as well — they are in many ways a logical extension of part — not all, but part — of the standard conservative agenda of the last three and a half decades. That agenda includes policies that call for tax reform, repealing a woman’s right to choose an abortion, the repeal of health care, and repealing court decisions affirming the right of same-sex couples to marry.</p><p>Indeed, Donald Trump, Mike Pence, and Steve Bannon have been pursuing strategies that we would consider planks in that part of the conservative agenda: for example, nominating a Supreme Court Justice who supports overturning Roe v. Wade, ending protections for trans kids, or focusing solely on law enforcement to the exclusion of community. The list is long.</p><p>In this sense, Trump, Pence, and Bannon are peddling a particular brand of conservatism, one well known to us as the right-wing agenda of the last three and a half decades. It is pernicious, yes, but not uniquely pernicious.</p><p>This particular brand of conservatism, however, is not the sole thrust of the Trump/Pence/Bannon White House. Rather, I posit that what we have now is an agenda distinct and removed from what Americans have previously considered our conservatism. What we have now is, indeed, uniquely pernicious.</p><p>What most distinguishes this president from the 44 who preceded him, including other conservative presidents, is his agenda of suppression. It is an agenda designed to centralize power in the White House by manipulating some of the levers of the federal government, and disrupting others, to create the confusion and chaos that would undermine our democracy and thereby justify limiting our freedom.</p><p>When you have decided to use the levers of our democracy to undermine our democracy and centralize your personal authority, you must also work hard to suppress dissent. That is a lesson the world knows well from the playbook used by Nazi, Communist, and fascist dictatorships in Europe in the early- to mid-20th century, and in Russia in late 20th and early 21st century.</p><p>As a result, President Trump is trying to quash dissent where he can.</p><p>One of the things he did immediately upon his inauguration was to scrub the White House website clean of any mention of climate change, any mention of GLBTQ people, any mention of Latino people or Native people. He has muzzled scientists who work for the Federal government, and soon any who are funded by the government.</p><p>He wants to suppress the voices of artists and scholars: his budget takes out all funding for the NEA, the NEH, and PBS. He has repeatedly asserted the utter, demonstrable falsehood that there is widespread voter fraud in our country. He gets his information from 24-hour cable TV news, eschewing the advice of the experts at his disposal, while also casting aspersions on reliable news sources and freezing them out of official briefings. He encourages punishment and retribution for people who peaceably demonstrate as an expression of their First Amendment rights. And he has silenced scientists, unconscionably prohibiting them from even speaking about an imminent danger to millions of people on our planet, and the greatest threat to humanity: climate change.</p><p>Trump is on to something. Again, I say that if you want to limit democracy and centralize your power by suppressing the voices of dissent, then do your best to silence artists, voters, the media, and those who actively protest in the streets.</p><p>Today, I also say: not in my country, and not in Minneapolis.</p><p>In Minneapolis, we lift up our neighbors. We actively encourage everyone who can vote to vote. We support the First Amendment, a thriving media, and healthy protest. And we value our artists as creators of beauty, uniters of humanity, and the voice of our conscience.</p><p>So today, I propose first steps that we as a city can take to lift up and support these important voices in our democracy.</p><p>* * *</p><p>First, in the time of Trump, we get to lift up and support <strong>voters</strong>. In no other way has Donald Trump made his contempt for democracy more clear than in his attacks on voters. His reckless, fact-free claims that millions of votes were cast illegally last year are designed not only to bolster the legitimacy of his presidency after losing the national popular vote by more than 3 million votes, they are designed to undermine our democracy by sowing fear and distrust in it. The less trust Americans have in our democracy, the more it falters; and the more it falters, the more vulnerable we become to authoritarian manipulation.</p><p>More specifically, Trump’s attacks on voters are explicitly attacks on immigrants and people of color. They are also attacks on people who live in cities. In addition to losing the popular vote nationwide by nearly 3 million votes, Trump lost resoundingly in most of the large cities in America. No wonder that cities and the people who live in them are on the front lines of his attacks.</p><p>In Minneapolis, we are having none of it. We are exceedingly proud — I dare say boastful — of the fact that we have one of the highest voter-turnout rates of any big city in America.</p><p>It is no accident. We have worked hard and intentionally in Minneapolis to ensure that everyone with a right to cast a vote does cast one. Among the steps we have taken in recent years to make that a reality are:</p><p>· Establishing four early-vote centers around the city. Minneapolis provided more early-vote centers, and more hours for in-person service, than any jurisdiction in Minnesota.</p><p>· Using community specialists to promote the early-vote centers to residents.</p><p>· The Tenant Notification of Voter Registration program that Council Member Jacob Frey has championed, which helped increase the number of pre-registered voters. Among the benefits of more pre-registered voters are fewer voters needing to register on Election Day, which means shorter lines that make voting more accessible to everyone.</p><p>Our work was aided by bills that the DFL-controlled Legislature passed and Governor Dayton signed in 2013 and 2014 to allow online voter registration and no-excuse absentee voting.</p><p>All of this work has led to terrific results:</p><p>· Voter turnout in Minneapolis in 2016 was 79 percent, the second-highest rate in recent history.</p><p>· The total number of votes cast in Minneapolis — more than 217,000 — was the highest ever.</p><p>· Absentee ballots cast increased 400 percent.</p><p>· The number of pre-registered voters is now the highest in 48 years.</p><p>Please join me in thanking City Clerk Casey Carl and Elections and Voter Services Director Grace Wachlarowicz for their vision, leadership, and hard work in making Minneapolis a shining example of voter enfranchisement for cities around the country.</p><p>Continuing and expanding on this good work to lift up and enfranchise every legal voter is essential to fighting Donald Trump’s suppression agenda. It is work that is being supported at the grassroots in Minneapolis this year, when so many groups and individuals are engaging and organizing people in this year’s municipal elections. In the time of Trump, Minneapolis gets to, and will continue to, lead the way in defending and expanding our democratic right to vote.</p><p>Second, in the time of Trump, we get to lift up and support the essential work of <strong>journalism</strong> and journalists who do it. Donald Trump’s contempt for voters seems to be matched by his contempt for journalists. His relationship with journalists goes far beyond the usual tension between the press and the White House. He has excluded entire major news organizations from covering his campaign and the White House. His administration has given privileged access to previously fringe right-wing websites. Trump himself has publicly mocked reporters, and has encouraged crowds to attack them physically.</p><p>This is another threat to our democracy. If the federal government under Trump is going to silence experts, erase facts, and intimidate journalists, Minneapolis can and must set a counter-example: we get to be more transparent.</p><p>To this end, I am convening key city leadership, including City Coordinator Spencer Cronk, City Attorney Susan Segal, City Clerk Casey Carl, and Communications Director Greta Bergstrom to review how Minneapolis can be more responsive to requests for information from journalists, media, and the public. Council Member Andrew Johnson and Council Vice President Elizabeth Glidden have agreed to join me in this work.</p><p>As this work gets underway, I do want to is acknowledge reporter Peter Callahan of MinnPost. For some of the data requests he has made of the City of Minneapolis he has had to endure wait times that have been excessive, frankly, even for large requests like the ones he has made. He has rightly called out these delays in his publication and on social media. I am sorry, Peter, and I am taking this step so that we can do better.</p><p>Third, in the time of Trump, we get to lift up and support <strong>demonstrators</strong> and all people exercising their First Amendment right to peaceful protest. Trump personally attacked the massive Women’s Marches held the day after the inauguration — one that included 90,000 people in Saint Paul, Minnesota’s largest protest march ever — denigrated people who have been flooding congressional town halls across the country to defend the Affordable Care Act, and belittled demonstrators at last Saturday’s Tax Marches, including one that I was proud to attend.</p><p>Trump’s tantrums about demonstrations and lack of respect for constitutional rights would be bad enough. However, in this time of Trump, bills have been introduced in state legislatures across the country to cripple or charge for protest, including one in our own Legislature. Make no mistake: these bills are part of a concerted effort to suppress peaceful protest, stifle dissent, and sow the fear that fertilizes authoritarianism.</p><p>Not in Minneapolis. What we get to do in Minneapolis instead is to welcome peaceful demonstrations as an important indicator of the health of our democracy, and to manage it well. Since the election, we have seen a number of large demonstrations in our city that police and organizers worked together to ensure were peaceful and powerful. I am grateful that Chief Janeé Harteau and her leadership team recognize the increased importance of peaceful demonstration in the time of Trump and are committed to facilitating it in close communication and cooperation with organizers, for the safety of everyone.</p><p>Fourth, we get to lift up and support our <strong>artists</strong>. No one can be surprised by Trump’s disregard for art and artists: after all, he has proposed cutting all funding for the National Endowment for the Arts, the National Endowment for the Humanities, and public broadcasting.</p><p>Now more than ever, we need our artists: poets, actors, dancers, writers, singers, directors, choreographers, filmmakers, photographers, painters, sculptors, every one of them. Artists remind us who we are at our best, they reveal who we are at our worst, and they invite us to come together and connect with each other through our differences on the common ground of our humanity.</p><p>We are blessed in Minneapolis to be the home of the most vibrant arts community anywhere — and I mean anywhere. Our artists sustain our minds and our souls, especially in this challenging time — and we get to lift them up and support them, especially at a time when Trump wants to silence them.</p><p>To that end, I’m extremely happy to be the first to announce that the Kresge Foundation has awarded Minneapolis $1,125,000 to continue our groundbreaking Creative CityMaking initiative that is transforming the way that the City of Minneapolis connects and engages with our residents and communities. I am grateful to all the City departments that have taken advantage of this amazing resource, and to Arts, Culture, and Creative Economy Director Gülgün Kayim for relentlessly advocating for this initiative.</p><p>I will also meet soon with the heads of major, mid-size, and small arts organizations and festivals in Minneapolis to hear their concerns about and hopes for artistic expression in the time of Trump, and to ask them what the City can do to help it flourish in the face of forces who would prefer artistic expression to wither.</p><p>And finally, this is National Poetry month. In the spirit of elevating arts and artists, I asked Camille Gage to help uplift local poets. Every day at the Facebook page “MPLS Write Now” — that’s M-P-L-S W-R-I-T-E Now — you can read a selection from a local poet. Today, it is Bao Phi. And this Thursday at 7:00 p.m. at MCTC, there will be a poetry reading in honor of the memory of Kirk Washington, a local poet and advocate whom we lost too soon last year. His voice lives on in our community and we will honor his life and work on Thursday. Please join us.</p><p>We have committed, together as a people and a city, to the goal of One Minneapolis. We cannot get there without artists. Artists relentlessly reflect truth, especially uncomfortable truth, back to us, and hold us accountable for acknowledging and acting on it to improve people’s lives. Our artists will hold us accountable for fully realizing One Minneapolis. Now more than ever in the time of Trump, we need them, and now more than ever, we get to support them.</p><p>* * *</p><p>So, Minneapolis, we — and cities like us, and the people who live in our city and cities like us — are at the forefront of attacks in the time of Trump. In response, we get to lift up and support all our communities that are under attack. We get to lead the country in resisting. In this perilous time, resistance to Trump’s policies is necessary. It may not, however, be sufficient.</p><p>What really must underlie our work at this time is not just resistance, it is compassion, love, and kindness.</p><p>Democracy done right is an organized way to care about all people and to care about all voices, and government is how we have decided to give form to our democracy. Government is one of the places where we come together as people and decide who we are as a people. It is an expression of our values. We love government in Minneapolis — we have so damn much of it — and now, especially now, we use it to express the value of connection, not disaffection.</p><p>This is why Trump’s agenda of suppression and undermining democracy is so pernicious: while we have and are the tools to fight his attacks on people, his suppression agenda and his attacks on our very democracy are actively designed to disassemble the tools we have for respecting, engaging, and connecting to one another.</p><p>So: when you undermine the arts, you undermine our mechanism for bypassing the meanness of the day-to-day and connecting us to something bigger than ourselves; you sever the bonds of empathy and compassion between people. When you seek to criminalize peaceful protest, you submerge uncomfortable truths. When you cut off the free flow of information and dismiss true facts as fake news, you destroy a common base of knowledge and understanding, and thereby sow distrust. And when you call into question the legitimacy of voting and let our enemies interfere with our elections, that’s a knife in the heart of our democracy.</p><p>Fundamentally, Trump’s attempts at suppression are attempts to disconnect us further from each other. His plans depend on it. His authority will be centralized only when we are disconnected from each other. When we are disconnected from each other, we forget our own humanity and the humanity of our neighbor. When we are disconnected from each other, we forget that the trans student is vulnerable and needs us to stand with her. When we are disconnected from each other, we forget that the undocumented worker has a family and a life and needs our respect. When we are disconnected from each other, we forget that a person isn’t disabled, but is a person who needs accommodations because we haven’t yet set the world up well for him to thrive. And when we are disconnected from each other, we forget that our brothers and sisters who voted for Trump feel vulnerable, too — that while we may disagree with them about policy, they too need and deserve our respect as a human beings.</p><p>This speech is about opposing Trump’s policies. We must not, however, use our opposition to his policies as a platform for opposing his supporters. If our attempts at human connection cannot extend to them, even in our thoughts, then we ourselves are reaping the disconnection that Trump is sowing. When we cannot accommodate Trump’s supporters in our landscape, we are fueling, not resisting, his agenda.</p><p>This is not an invitation to naivete — there are people who have harming others, physically and otherwise, as part of their agenda. We must all protect ourselves and our beloveds from imminent danger and from harm and from the policies that would allow harm. It is not necessary to forget people’s humanity while we do so, however.</p><p>So, Minneapolis, in the time of Trump, this is our call as a community and as people: we get to do what more of what we already do well, we get to come together even more. We get to be compassionate, loving, and kind to everyone: to immigrants, to Muslims, to single mothers, to trans kids, to Trump supporters. When we build our resistance with the power of love and compassion, on an agenda of connection and simple kindness, we will build a city and a country that naturally and organically rejects fear and mistrust, where attacks on the vulnerable and the suppression of democracy will simply wither on the vine.</p><p>In times of turmoil, oppression, and suppression, our call is to greatness. We cannot rise to the greatness that is required of us at this time, however, if we allow ourselves to remain alienated or disconnected from each other: rather, to rise to greatness, we must open ourselves to true connection. And the most basic way that humans connect with each other is by showing true, genuine kindness to each other.</p><p>Thus, our fundamental call in the time of Trump is to kindness, kindness to ourselves and to each other, even — or especially — to those whom we believe we have reason to fear or distrust. It is on the ground of kindness that we will build the One Minneapolis to which we have committed ourselves, the One Minneapolis that will lead America out of this darkness and into the light.</p><p>* * *</p><p>We are here in this beloved place of worship as Pesach, the Passover, is ending.</p><p>The last time I was at Shir Tikvah was for Shabbat service on the evening of Friday, January 20 — Inauguration Day. Coincidentally, or perhaps not, the Torah reading for that night was the first chapter of the book of Exodus. As Exodus begins, the Jews of Egypt had prospered and multiplied; then, a new pharaoh arose to whom the Jews meant nothing. The new pharaoh ordered the Jews enslaved, and terrifyingly, ordered that all newborn Hebrew boys be murdered.</p><p>In his <em>d’var Torah</em> that evening, Rabbi Latz celebrated the first great act of resistance of that terrible time. It was when the midwives Shifrah and Puah quietly defied Pharaoh’s order to kill the newborn boys. This brave act allowed the Jews to multiply even further.</p><p>Tonight, as we commemorate Moses finally freeing the Jews from the grip of Pharaoh after the terrible 10thplague that left the firstborn of every Egyptian dead, I cannot help but notice that the story of the plagues and the Passover is a story about objecting to the oppression of Pharaoh, not objecting to all the people of Egypt.</p><p>In this story that is about the enslavement and freeing of the Jews, I wonder about the Egyptians who saw what Pharaoh was doing and thought it was wrong. After all, when the plagues started rolling in one by one, no one paid a higher price for Pharaoh’s perfidy than the people of Egypt. I wonder if the Egyptian farmers who lost their livelihoods, because Pharaoh let their lands be overrun with locusts rather than keep his promise to the Israelites, thought continuing to enslave the Jews was worth it. I wonder if Egyptian wage workers, as they sat scratching and miserable during the plague of lice, thought that they might have more in common with the Israelites than they did with Pharaoh, and that common cause might be made with them. I wonder if the women of Egypt who lost their firstborn children questioned whether there could be a new system in which the greed and fear of pharaohs no longer led to the greatest grief of their lives.</p><p>I wonder if, as the darkness descended upon them, the Egyptians reached for one another’s hands in fear and in love and began to ask if there were a better way.</p><p>I believe some of them did. I believe they saw the plight of their Hebrew brothers and sisters and sought a better, more just, and more compassionate way.</p><p>The greatest tragedy is that as a result of Pharaoh’s persistent injustice and lies, the world has been robbed to this day of the miracles of the lives of those firstborn and those who would have been their descendants. The world is blessed that the homes of the Israelites were passed over, that the descendants of those children not sacrificed are still with us, perhaps even with us tonight. As we conclude the annual celebration of that miracle, we also mourn what the world lost that day, when Pharaoh forgot that children, that people are more important than pride or power.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=4911d0c112ea" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Socialized To Be White]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@BetsyHodges/socialized-to-be-white-c6d2304ed5e8?source=rss-eb3d732e689c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/c6d2304ed5e8</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[race]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[racism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[socialization]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[white-people]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[whiteness]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Betsy Hodges]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 04 Oct 2022 14:39:49 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-10-13T14:35:48.279Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*x6qr-1k7Wc5N3UixgCYnng.jpeg" /><figcaption>Photo by <a href="https://unsplash.com/@iamchang?utm_source=unsplash&amp;utm_medium=referral&amp;utm_content=creditCopyText">Chang Duong</a> on <a href="https://unsplash.com/s/photos/group?utm_source=unsplash&amp;utm_medium=referral&amp;utm_content=creditCopyText">Unsplash</a></figcaption></figure><p>We white people are socialized into our whiteness. I’m not an expert on identity formation, but I do know this: even though it happens very early for a lot of white kids, babies are not born thinking, “Oh, hey, I’m white. Under most circumstances, I am going to swim against the tide to have lots of global majority people close in my life. Plus, it is fine with me that GMI people pay the price for my comfort and convenience because I’m white and think my comfort and convenience outrank the basic humanity of GMI people.”</p><p>Seriously. Babies don’t think that. Babies have to learn how to be white along the way.</p><p>All of us were babies.</p><p>All white people learned how to be white along the way.</p><p>The phenomenon of socialization into cultural roles is not unique to whiteness and it isn’t unique to race. The identities we carry have to be learned along the way. What it means to be a man, a woman, what it means to be a Minnesotan, or a pipefitter, or a student, or a singer, or deaf — while the truth of the category may not change, what it signifies in the social sense is taught to us by the people who surround us and the culture we create together. All of us are shaped by the people and communities around us; the choices that are presented or not presented to us, explicitly or implicitly, and the visions we are given for how our lives can go, and the people we believe are “ours” and “not ours” are shaped for everyone, including white people, by the people and culture and communities around us.</p><p>If you’re a white person familiar with basic social-science concepts, probably none of this sounds like rocket science to you. “Yeah, Betsy, right. Culture is taught, norms are learned, no one is born anything in particular. We know that already.”</p><p>Right! We do! However, there are white people on the left who tend to forget this about each other. We can see racism operating, we understand more of our history as white people, we understand that injustices against GMI people have been and are happening at the hands of white people every day, and we have understandably negativefeelings about all of that. At the same time, we don’t extend that understanding to the origins of our own racial socialization. Many of us act like all white people — including ourselves — start out as bad, like from the beginning white people are unthinking, uncaring carriers of a tragic, oppressive past with no way out except unquestioning obedience to whatever our whiteness asks of us.</p><p>Whether we progressive white people forget this fundamental truth about other white people — that we have been socialized into our whiteness — or we know it but do not base our organizing strategies around it, we (re)create the conditions for the racism of the status quo to stay locked in place. The truth we supposedly understand — that white people are socialized into whiteness — does not shape how we interact with one another as white people. It should.</p><p>What do I mean that it doesn’t shape how we interact with one another? And why should we?</p><p>To paint a whole group of people as inherently bad (and/or evil, and/or immoral, and/or amoral) from birth is a tool of oppression: not the only tool, but a tool nonetheless. When said about white people (or men, or wealthy people, or straight people), it is, whether we realize it or not, the same tool of oppression used to deem any group inherently bad from the start, without regard to how culture, systemic limitation of choices, and individual experience shape who people become. White people using this tool of oppression on one another doesn’t have the same systemic and negative results as when white people use them on GMI people. <strong>However, if we use the tools of oppression on each other, we are locking their use into place.</strong> If we want to truly end oppression, we must acknowledge the tools of oppression we have been taught and then decide to countermand them, not use them.</p><p>If we don’t spend time talking about how white people are socialized into our whiteness, then we don’t have any compassion at all for each other as white people. We blame, attack, and criticize one another about our whiteness, which, <a href="https://medium.com/@BetsyHodges/whiteness-proposition-two-7f12bc87c882">as I argue here</a>, is antithetical to the changes we say we would like to see in the world. This means we are going down a path that doesn’t appeal to or include very many white people. This matters, because in order for outcomes to change for BIPOC, the web of policies that determine how we distribute resources and opportunities needs to change, including consideration of and accounting for the historic harm done to GMI people by past policy.</p><p>The key reason I posit that it is more useful for white people to acknowledge that we are socialized into our whiteness and follow the conclusions that flow from there is because <em>if we don’t approach each other with that baseline level of compassion, will not get where we say we want to go. </em>Not absolution, but human compassion.</p><p>Right now, <strong>most policy changes that would make a meaningful, positive difference in outcomes for GMI people currently die on the hill of white resistance</strong>. Until there is a critical mass of us willing to actively work for change, white people <em>en masse </em>will keep getting in the way of better life outcomes for GMI people (and, therefore, all of us).</p><p>Now, even in an environment of blame, attack, and criticism of one another, however, I posit that there are at least three categories of white folks who, at the present moment, seem to be willing to do this work:</p><p>1. White people who are motivated in the work, for whatever reason, no matter what. Perhaps they see the bigger picture and persevere. It would be instructive to do research on the factors that contribute to their consistent dedication to the work.</p><p>2. White people whose whiteness drives them to be “white saviors” and “one of the good ones,” who deride white people themselves as part of their quest to distance themselves from whiteness and to play hero to GMI people.</p><p>3. White people who actually do respond well to being blamed, attacked, and criticized. For whatever reason, they have been conditioned to at least comply when shamed. For some, blame speaks to the interior mental parts that feel bad already and feels perversely validated when called out.</p><p>These three groups of white people, plus any others, together don’t add up enough to do our part to change outcomes for GMI people, however. The results speak for themselves, because the results are the status quo.</p><p>It is true that in my thirty years of doing this work, my impression is that the proportion of white people dedicated to anti-racist work has grown. Every new public atrocity gains more. The growth of mixed-race families has enrolled more white people, as well. The pace of our enrollment, however, is getting us the results we are getting: the current level of our understanding and revelation has not translated into actual, widespread policy changes that would measurably change outcomes for the better for global majority and Indigenous people — hence for everyone, including white people.</p><p>If white people are to contribute to a true transformation of results for GMI people, then we need enough of us to enroll whole-heartedly into the project of enacting anti-racist policy change everywhere we can, particularly in government and commerce. We will never enroll that many white people until we can approach one another with compassion. And the first way to do that is acknowledge that our whiteness is a product of culture and socialization, slathered onto our human hearts before we could make a decision about whether or not it made sense.</p><p><em>This is part of a series of pieces that explore what I have learned about whiteness, race, and human beings in the last 30 years. </em><a href="https://medium.com/@BetsyHodges/whiteness-proposition-one-66acc6ac6f19"><em>It starts here</em></a><em>. I am writing for readers, primarily white readers, who believe that racism exists and that it is bad, and I assume a basic level of understanding of racial concepts. A word about language: Currently I am using three phrases throughout these essays to encompass people of color, all of which are debated: “people of color”; “Black, Indigenous, and people of color/BIPOC”; and global majority and Indigenous people/GMI people”. All of them are meant to encompass the wide range of people, the majority of people around the world, who do not claim European heritage or who claim more than European heritage.</em></p><p><em>Some of the ideas in here have been and will be explored more fully in other pieces — please follow and come along for the ride!</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=c6d2304ed5e8" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[A Crucial Trick Of Whiteness]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@BetsyHodges/a-crucial-trick-of-whiteness-ef25520c56ce?source=rss-eb3d732e689c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/ef25520c56ce</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[whiteness]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[racism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[race]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[white-people]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Betsy Hodges]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 03 Aug 2022 12:04:56 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-08-03T12:07:02.425Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>One of the great tricks whiteness has played on white Americans since the Civil Rights Movement is to convince us that racism is merely a feeling in white people’s hearts that is demonstrated by interpersonal actions. If we don’t feel open antipathy in our hearts toward Global Majority and Indigenous people that we can recognize ourselves, then we cannot be behaving in a racist way. According to this belief, if racism is the sum total of those negative feelings and behaviors, then most liberal and progressive white people are and should be exempted from allegations of racism.</p><p>Here’s the truth: animus in our hearts and consciously negative behavior are neither necessary <em>nor sufficient</em> to obtain disparate outcomes in our social systems.</p><p>What do I mean?</p><p>Until we change what the systems are set up to do, they will continue to operate to get the same results. If you build a train to go between Chicago and Minneapolis, that train will always, always, <em>always</em> go between Minneapolis and Chicago. You won’t be able to get anywhere that isn’t on that line. If you want to catch a train to Des Moines <em>you’re going to have to build new train tracks</em>. Until we change what the system is for — from getting-to-Chicago to getting-to-Des-Moines — we will never create systems that are built to get a different result. In this scenario, it doesn’t matter if every single train engineer loves Des Moines and really, truly wants everyone to be able to take a train to Des Moines. If the train tracks don’t go there, you can’t take a train there, no matter what Engineer Billie feels in her heart.</p><p>The same is true for any of our social systems. Take housing. Banks, with the cooperation of municipal ordinances, decided which neighborhoods qualified for home loans and which did not. The Federal government’s GI Bill helped soldiers returning from WWII, mostly white soldiers, get low-rate mortgages. This led to an explosion of home-ownership among working-and middle-class white people and a significant expansion of the white middle class. This combination also widened a service and amenity gap between white and Black neighborhoods, and increased the wealth gap between white people and people of color.</p><p>The home-ownership systems in the US were explicitly set up for white people, at the expense of people of color (who were paying Federal taxes but not benefitting from the program), and to this day the overlay of those redlining maps predicts wealth, income, educational attainment, crime rates, health problems, and more in American cities. The policies that undergird our housing have not been changed enough to both serve Global Majority and Indigenous people equally, but they also have not been changed to make sure the results of past imbalanced policy are redressed.</p><p>I wrote about this dynamic and policing <a href="https://betsyhodges.com/as-mayor-of-minneapolis-i-saw-how-white-liberals-block-change-2/">here</a>.</p><p>Not a single white person working in those systems has to feel racism in their hearts for those systems to keep getting the disparate results they’re getting for Global Majority and Indigenous people. The fact that we continue to act like that’s the most relevant part of racism is why I contend it’s the biggest trick whiteness has played in the last fifty years.</p><p><strong>Staying comfortable with racism by distancing ourselves from its realities is one of the hallmarks of whiteness on the left.</strong> <strong>This trick — of focusing on how we feel in order to ignore systemic inequalities that lead to better outcomes for us as white people — is part of the smoke and mirrors we use with ourselves to stay dissociated from racism.</strong> Focusing on how we feel rather than the observable, material impacts of systems on Global Majority and Indigenous people also doubles down on centering the white experience in issues of race and racism.</p><p>We white people do get to heal and process our feelings about our whiteness, including any pulls we have to keep the comfort of the status quo. As a matter of fact, I believe it is required. We get to do that with one another, however, rather than burdening people of the Global Majority with our processes. (Stay tuned for the book I am writing about just how to do that.) In the meantime, the invitation to white people is to focus more on the systems of inequality and policies that will change them than we do on our feelings about race.</p><p><em>This is part of a series of pieces that explore what I have learned about whiteness, race, and human beings in the last 30 years. I am writing for readers, primarily white readers, who believe that racism exists and that it is bad, and I assume a basic level of understanding of racial concepts. A word about language: Currently I am using three phrases throughout these essays to encompass people of color, all of which are debated: “people of color”; “Black, Indigenous, and people of color/BIPOC”; and Global Majority and Indigenous people/GMI people”. All of them are meant to encompass the wide range of people, the majority of people around the world, who do not claim European heritage or who claim more than European heritage.</em></p><p><em>Some of the ideas in here have been and will be explored more fully in other pieces — please subscribe and come along for the ride!</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=ef25520c56ce" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Whiteness, White People, and Love; or, What I Learned from Thor: Ragnarok]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@BetsyHodges/whiteness-white-people-and-love-or-what-i-learned-from-thor-ragnarok-b127d92e386c?source=rss-eb3d732e689c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/b127d92e386c</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[whiteness]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[race-relations]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[white-people]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[race]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[racism]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Betsy Hodges]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 23 Jun 2022 21:16:51 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-06-23T21:22:40.520Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>When I left Minneapolis City Hall in 2018, I was exhausted from a tumultuous term as mayor and broken-hearted that I had lost re-election after twelve years of dedicated service to the city. Enrolling white people in the work of racial equity had been my mission since 1992, a story I outline <a href="https://betsyhodges.com/cnn-why-the-1992-l-a-uprising-may-hold-the-key-to-a-better-future-in-2020/">here</a> and <a href="https://betsyhodges.com/the-moment-you-realize-youre-white/">here</a>, and I had chosen the path of local government to make the commitment real. Suddenly leaving office left me feeling adrift without that tool and obsolete without that positional power.</p><p>A funny thing happened on the way to obsolescence, though.</p><p>I saw <em>Thor: Ragnorok</em>.</p><p>Thor, the god of lightning, is depressed and sitting at home. His hammer Mjolnir, through which he channels his power, has been broken by his evil sister in battle. She is going to destroy the world and Thor feels powerless to stop her.</p><p>Thor’s dead father returns to him in a vision to give him a loving, fatherly ass-kicking.</p><p>“Are you Thor, the God of Hammers, hm? That hammer was meant to help you control your power, to focus it. It was never your source of strength.” Thor then remembers that he is the god of lightning, not hammers, and vanquishes his sister using lightning directly, without his hammer.</p><p>I am not the god of anything, but I took the point. My mission wasn’t to Be Mayor. My mission is to enroll white people in ending racism, and leaving office didn’t change that. It merely changed the tools I have at hand to make progress.</p><p>That insight in hand, I set off a couple of weeks after leaving office for <a href="https://iop.harvard.edu/">a fellowship at Harvard</a>. I began having conversations with people about whiteness, how it functions, and what to do about it. Because those are the topics that interest me most, at first the conversations happened organically as I was going about my days. The more conversations I had, however, the more notes I took. I began to notice patterns in the notes. In addition to those I met in the normal course of life, I began to seek out people to talk with who had varied perspectives on the topic. I intentionally talked with all kinds of people — white people, people of color and Indigenous people, older, younger, different genders, different professions (including academics, activists, students, and elected officials) — about what they thought it would take to move enough white people to matter for the project of eliminating racism.</p><p>The three propositions and my question, written about <a href="https://medium.com/@BetsyHodges/whiteness-proposition-one-66acc6ac6f19">here,</a> <a href="https://medium.com/@BetsyHodges/whiteness-proposition-two-7f12bc87c882">here</a>, <a href="https://medium.com/@BetsyHodges/whiteness-proposition-three-80c3c5cb1366">here</a>, and <a href="https://medium.com/@BetsyHodges/the-question-ee1ac61fcb62">here,</a> were born of those conversations.</p><p>My own early work on race and whiteness corresponded with my early recovery from alcoholism. I got sober in 1989, and took on this project with my people in 1992. That means I was grappling with my own integrity and health in recovery at the same time that I was grappling with, well, my own integrity and health regarding race. In recovery, I was also witnessing the possibility that arises from owning my own behavior without conflating that behavior with my essential self. I could see the humanness in my fellow recovering alcoholics even as I was hearing about ways they had treated other people very, very badly.</p><p>I was willing to acknowledge that racism was awful, and that white people were at the heart of it. I wasn’t willing to cede my own capacity for humanness, however, no matter what my social conditioning had done to my connection to it. I felt the shame of whiteness (more on that in future pieces), but I saw the shame as something to feel and release rather than something to retain as a motivator to change.</p><p>The upshot is, I believed then, and I believe now, in the inherent human goodness of the human heart. I believe that our basic humanness is worthy of love, care, and attention. I believe things that hurt or make us question our basic humanness need to be healed. When we are hurt we forget our own humanness, and we are prey to forgetting the humanness of others. I believe, as the saying goes, that hurt people hurt people. I believe that when we heal from how we have been hurt, we are less likely to hurt other people.</p><p>I brought all of this with me into the conversations I was having about whiteness. At first, I wanted to hear what other people thought about whiteness and what we could do to move white people along. I realized quickly that another conversation, one that surprised me, had to happen first.</p><p>The depth and breadth of the discouragement of white people about other white people and themselves was my first realization. I would ask, “What can we do to enroll white people in the work of racial equity?” When I asked I thought I would hear ideas, but mostly I got a couple of responses.</p><p>First, I would get deflection and disassociation from whiteness. For example, one notable white progressive leader told me, “My identity as a white person is not central to my overall identity.” The implication was that he didn’t then consider it his work to organize white people. (I gently pointed out that while he did not consider himself as a white person, that pretty much every person of color and Indigenous person who met him knew he was white right away.) It also shows up when we talk about race and the behaviors of white people: we, especially those of us who consider ourselves progressives or liberal, talk about “them” and “they” rather than “us” and “we”. When we do it (and I catch myself doing it a lot) we are implying that somehow whiteness doesn’t include us. That yes, hurtful displays of whiteness are bad, but it is only <em>other</em> white people who do that, not us.</p><p>Second, and most common, I would get a lot of criticism of whiteness and white people. The conversation would turn to describing the awful behavior of white people, usually conservative white people. When I turned the conversation to the consideration of the racist behavior of liberal and progressive white people, the conversation would stutter and stall. The person would give me more descriptions of how awful extreme right wing white people’s behavior can be. I would press, and then the moment would arrive — it would be a natural next question for me to ask, “OK, well, do you think white people are worthy of love?”</p><p>The quality of the silence after I asked the question has not left me. No one, not a single white person, gave an immediate “yes” if they gave a yes at all.</p><p>Stop and think about that. Whiteness has confused white people about our basic human worth.</p><p>This is surprising, because inside the systems of race, whiteness defines the pinnacle of who is human, as if there could be such a thing. Every dominant cultural message about race is predicated on the lie that GMI people are less than human. The implicit bias about GMI people we are socialized into as white people is founded on that idea. We carry the arrogance of whiteness. We bristle when the behavior or expressed beliefs of Global Majority and Indigenous people don’t conform to our idea of the greater worthiness of whiteness.</p><p>Somewhere inside us, underneath the whiteness we’ve been socialized into, our own humanity knows this is wrong. We couldn’t possibly be as defensive about whiteness as we are if we didn’t know, <em>somewhere</em> inside us, that it was indefensible. We believe that we own the table of humanity — how could we doubt our worthiness to sit at it?</p><p>It turns out that the only way we as white people can possibly dehumanize other people to the extent that we have is to systematically disconnect from our own humanity. Whiteness and race as a system were designed to make sure that every social system we have — government, education, the economy, health, housing, employment, you name it — was designed to get better outcomes for white people <em>at the expense of</em> people of color and Indigenous people. In the name of whiteness and race and protecting those systems, white people have individually and systematically killed, abused, enslaved, subjugated, and derided people of color and Indigenous people. We have also stood by, silent and unmoving, as other white people did those things. We benefitted from that. When we look at the history of American whiteness and white people we have left a swath of blood and tears behind us wherever we have found ourselves. It is inhuman behavior. It has left almost all of us confused about whether we white people truly belong at the table of humanity, or whether history has culled the basic humanity from white hearts.</p><p>If, <a href="https://medium.com/@BetsyHodges/whiteness-proposition-two-7f12bc87c882">as I propose</a>, the work white people do with one another has to be based on compassion, on love, on reaching for the human in one another, this fundamental question of worthiness must be addressed. For white people to assume our rightful place at the table of humanity — side by side with everyone, ahead of none — we first have to believe that our beautiful beating human hearts belong there. We are fully human.</p><p><strong>Whiteness as a system? As an enculturated identity? There is nothing to love about it. It is inhumane to everyone, including us white people, and it is designed to interfere with our ability to see the humanity of others while, as a necessary corollary, occluding our picture of our own full humanity.</strong></p><p>I believe that underneath our individual cultural conditioning as white people — the arrogance, the implicit bias, the patterns of dominance and control that we all carry to some degree <em>in the arena of race</em> — is our individual, full humanity. A humanity that wants everyone to be in our circle of human concern, a humanity that understands we are stronger when connected to other people than when we are disconnected, a humanity that needs no justification besides birth to sit at the table of humanness.</p><p>It is, however, a humanity we have come to question. The idea of excising people from our circle of human concern, what john powell and <a href="https://belonging.berkeley.edu/">the Othering and Belonging Institute</a>[i] call “Othering,” is not containable. It is like an invasive species — once you’ve got buckthorn in one yard, it will shortly be in every yard. Once Othering is on the table for any group, it is on the table for all groups. We know this deep down already. <strong>When we deny a place at the table of humanity to other people, we know that it calls into question our own right to be there.</strong></p><p>Our socialization as white people has taught us that some people are worthy humans and some are not — and while the conditioning says that people of color and Indigenous people are unworthy, the humanness underneath that white socialization knows that the concept itself inherently means our own humanity can be called into question at any point.</p><p>This is no way to live, for anyone. It is no way to build a sustainable, thriving community or world.</p><p>So what I have learned about whiteness and white people starts here: white people are fully human, in spite of the whiteness that we slather on each other and the harm it has done to the world. Our humanness is fully worthy of love. Our humanness is worthy to sit at the table of humanity. If we want to take our seat, though, we get to disinvest in the whiteness that obscures that humanness, the whiteness that itself is not loveable. Our humanity is not the whiteness we carry. Our humanity lies underneath it, and we white people get to do the excavation work that gets us to it.</p><p><em>This is part of a series of pieces that explore what I have learned about whiteness, race, and human beings in the last 30 years. I am writing for readers, primarily white readers, who believe that racism exists and that it is bad, and I assume a basic level of understanding of racial concepts. A word about language: Currently I am using three phrases throughout these essays to encompass people of color, all of which are debated: “people of color”; “Black, Indigenous, and people of color/BIPOC”; and Global Majority and Indigenous people/GMI people”. All of them are meant to encompass the wide range of people, the majority of people around the world, who do not claim European heritage or who claim more than European heritage.</em></p><p><em>Some of the ideas in here have been and will be explored more fully in other pieces — please subscribe and come along for the ride!</em></p><p><em>When I left office and began having intentional conversations about whiteness, I began to have a clear question about what framework white people might need to effectively work with one another on issues of race. To even ask the question of my conversation partner, however, required me first to lay out three propositions as well as the question.</em></p><p><em>They are:</em></p><p><a href="https://medium.com/@BetsyHodges/whiteness-proposition-one-66acc6ac6f19"><em>Proposition One</em></a><em>: It is the work of white people to lead other white people away from an investment in whiteness and out of racist behavior. (White people are not the only people who do or could do this work, but it is work that white people can and should do.)</em></p><p><a href="https://medium.com/@BetsyHodges/whiteness-proposition-two-7f12bc87c882"><em>Proposition Two</em></a><em>: Blame, attack, criticism, fear, anger, and shame are not a sound basis for sustainable social change. Long-term change is built on human connection, compassion, love, and seeking what’s truly human in one another coupled with accountability and expectation. (It is not an act of love to treat other people badly or to allow someone to treat other people badly.)</em></p><p><a href="https://medium.com/@BetsyHodges/whiteness-proposition-three-80c3c5cb1366"><em>Proposition Three</em></a><em>: There is no widespread secular framework through which white people can work with one another explicitly as white people based on love and compassion; the only current secular framework through which that conversation is approached is through white supremacy.</em></p><p><em>The Question: Can we create a framework through which white people can work with one another on the basis of love and compassion rather than shame in order to do our part to end racism, a framework that does not condone or appear to condone the racism on which whiteness is predicated?</em></p><p><em>Each of the propositions is contested, and the question may not have an answer.</em></p><p>[i] I am a Senior Fellow at the Othering and Belonging Institute</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=b127d92e386c" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Whiteness: The Question]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@BetsyHodges/the-question-ee1ac61fcb62?source=rss-eb3d732e689c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/ee1ac61fcb62</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[whiteness]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[race-relations]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[race]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[white-privilege]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[white-supremacy]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Betsy Hodges]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 11 May 2022 16:03:29 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-05-11T16:06:52.233Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>This is part of a series of pieces that explore what I have learned about whiteness, race, and human beings in the last 30 years. I am writing for readers, primarily white readers, who believe that racism exists and that it is bad, and I assume a basic level of understanding of racial concepts. A word about language: Currently I am using three phrases throughout these essays to encompass people of color, all of which are debated: “people of color”; “Black, Indigenous, and people of color/BIPOC”; and Global Majority and Indigenous people/GMI people”. All of them are meant to encompass the wide range of people, the majority of people around the world, who do not claim European heritage or who claim more than European heritage.</em></p><p><em>Some of the ideas in here have been and will be explored more fully in other pieces — please subscribe and come along for the ride!</em></p><p><em>When I left office and began having intentional conversations about whiteness, I began to have a clear question about what framework white people might need to effectively work with one another on issues of race. To even ask the question of my conversation partner, however, required me first to lay out three propositions as well as the question.</em></p><p><em>They are:</em></p><p><a href="https://medium.com/@BetsyHodges/whiteness-proposition-one-66acc6ac6f19"><em>Proposition One</em></a><em>: It is the work of white people to lead other white people away from an investment in whiteness and out of racist behavior. (White people are not the only people who do or could do this work, but it is work that white people can and should do.)</em></p><p><a href="https://medium.com/@BetsyHodges/whiteness-proposition-two-7f12bc87c882"><em>Proposition Two</em></a><em>: Blame, attack, criticism, fear, anger, and shame are not a sound basis for sustainable social change. Long-term change is built on human connection, compassion, love, and seeking what’s truly human in one another coupled with accountability and expectation. (It is not an act of love to treat other people badly or to allow someone to treat other people badly.)</em></p><p><a href="https://medium.com/@BetsyHodges/whiteness-proposition-three-80c3c5cb1366"><em>Proposition Three</em></a><em>: There is no widespread secular framework through which white people can work with one another explicitly as white people based on love and compassion; the only current secular framework through which that conversation is approached is through white supremacy.</em></p><p><em>The Question: Can we create a framework through which white people can work with one another on the basis of love and compassion rather than shame in order to do our part to end racism, a framework that does not condone or appear to condone the racism on which whiteness is predicated?</em></p><p><em>Each of the propositions is contested, and the question may not have an answer.</em></p><p>The Question: Can we create a framework through which white people can work with one another on the basis of love and compassion rather than shame in order to do our part to end racism, a framework that does not condone or appear to condone the racism on which whiteness is predicated?</p><p>I will be open up front and say that I am not sure there’s an answer to this question yet.</p><p>Why is there not an answer yet?</p><p>First, for a time, in a world whose systems have been so thoroughly created to get better outcomes for white people, almost any framework created will have the impulses of those systems embedded in them somehow. Anyplace we white people start with a framework will have the impulses of our whiteness in them — until we quiet and release the impulses of our whiteness. It’s a catch-22, and I think it has stopped some of us from even trying to make a beginning. Even so, I think it is important that we start. We white people get to head toward one another and toward a set of agreements with each other that we intend for racism to end, for us to be part of that, and for us to reclaim our humanity as we walk fully into everyone else’s humanity. It will necessarily be an iterative process, but a valuable one.</p><p>Second, I think that there is not an answer to the question about framework yet because in this cultural moment, the pull to feel shame ourselves and its corollary, the pull to shame other people, is quite strong.</p><p>We are rewarded for finding newer and more clever ways to denigrate other people in general, and, in specific, people who we believe are doing harm. (When I say “we” I still mean white people — this idea may or may not hold for people of other races, but it is not my intention nor place to say.) This is most stark on social media. We are living in a time where bad news spreads quickly and the experience of hope and efficacy spread slowly. Levying criticism at people online, albeit unleavened by solutions or genuine communication with one another, is a way to feel like we are doing something useful. It is easy, doesn’t take much time, and if enough people do it occasionally it can change the course of an issue. It usually only has the impact of a mob, however. In side that mob, though, you can get some satisfaction and some good feelings — the algorithms are designed to give us hits of our brain’s feel-good chemicals, and mass social media criticism provides plenty of opportunity to do that.</p><p>I can speak from the user end. Things I said or did were frequent sources of social media critique. For example, as a regular champion for Somali and Somali-American people in Minneapolis I would recieve occasional waves of death and rape threats from white people (and their bots). Eventually I stopped looking at my social media accounts very much and had staff monitor them for trends, to see if anything rose to the level of needing action. Mostly it never did. It just left me needing to do the emotional work of staying open and responsive in a situation that was designed to at least try to elicit shame, caution, fear, and wariness in me.</p><p>All of this makes it harder to engage one another with compassion, however.</p><p>We white people also shame one another under the guise of course correction. For too long in history too many bad actors have gotten away with too much, for example, so we shame who we see as current bad actors in order to correct past harm (as well as to try and prevent current harm). The impulse to correct and repair past harm is a good one. Using the tools of oppression to do so may not get us where we say want to go, however.</p><p>It is dicey to call out the method while supporting the reason. I feel nervous just typing about this. For too long in history too many of us have been expected to stay silent about injustice. For white people, we have been socialized not to <em>see</em> injustice let alone say anything about it. So when we can actually see injustice and we raise our voices to name it and object to it, we are tempted to conflate questioning the manner in which we object to injustice with support for the injustice itself.</p><p>Now, sometimes questioning the process <em>is</em> used to deflect from the issue at hand or to disingenuously self-represent as a supporter of an issue while putting up significant resistance to actual change. White people do this a lot, and we do it well. For example, some of us we say we support housing options for all, but object to every housing plan that comes to our neighborhood. Some of us say we want to elevate educational outcomes for kids of color, but object to every single plan put forward to achieve that result. We do this, and it is understandable that we get called out for it. I will write more about this in the future.</p><p>But the point remains: sometimes the way white people call each other on our BS is inside the problem we say we are trying to solve. Part of the reason is because we don’t have access to commonly held frameworks that allow for accountability about our whiteness while honoring the human being inside the whiteness.</p><p>As mayor of Minneapolis, I was publicly shamed for two years by white people on the right and the left who disagreed with my response to a police shooting. It felt awful. I saw myself tempted to respond from my pain and anger and frustration by judging the people judging me, by writing them off altogether like they were writing me off. I could also feel that the temptation <em>itself</em> felt awful. I didn’t want to ignore people’s legitimate anger about systems that were failing people of color even when that anger was aimed at me. I didn’t want to ignore people’s genuinely-felt fear about what changes to the status quo would mean for them and their children even when that fear was aimed at me.</p><p>I decided to do my best not to take the anger and fear that were directed at me and reflect it back. I did my best to remember their humanity so that I could keep holding tight to my own. In the end, it changed how I approached policy. I still got fired in a blaze of public glory when I ran for re-election, but I didn’t add to that heartbreak by losing myself in resentment and acting out of the place where I felt angry about being shamed.</p><p>For these reasons, I think this is a difficult moment to propose a framework for white people that includes as part of the solution easing up on shaming one another for the problem. It’s one of the reasons I am careful about terms and explaining what I <em>don’t</em> mean: I understand the risks. I think the risks are worth it.</p><p>In upcoming essays, I will focus on models that I do think have promise. The work of the Othering and Belonging Institute at University of California-Berkeley[i] is a vital reframing of the problem we face: among other things, it rejects the disconnection from other people’s base-level humanity that jeopardizes our relationship to our sense of our <em>own</em> humanity. Another example is self-help; flaws and all, it may provide a path through the forest.</p><p>For now, though, I invite you as the reader to sit with the question I have asked, reflect on the challenges to answering it, and share with me whatever ideas you have about a framework that could be useful.</p><p>[i] I am proud to be a Senior Fellow at the Othering and Belonging Institute.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=ee1ac61fcb62" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Whiteness: Proposition Three]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@BetsyHodges/whiteness-proposition-three-80c3c5cb1366?source=rss-eb3d732e689c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/80c3c5cb1366</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[race-relations]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[race]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[whiteness]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[white-privilege]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Betsy Hodges]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 04 Apr 2022 17:12:08 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-04-04T17:12:08.098Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>This is part of a series of pieces that explore what I have learned about whiteness, race, and human beings in the last 30 years. I am writing for readers, primarily white readers, who believe that racism exists and that it is bad, and I assume a basic level of understanding of racial concepts. A word about language: Currently I am using three phrases throughout these essays to encompass people of color, all of which are debated: “people of color”; “Black, Indigenous, and people of color/BIPOC”; and Global Majority and Indigenous people/GMI people”. All of them are meant to encompass the wide range of people, the majority of people around the world, who do not claim European heritage or who claim more than European heritage.</em></p><p><em>Some of the ideas in here have been and will be explored more fully in other pieces — please subscribe and come along for the ride!</em></p><p><em>When I left office and began having intentional conversations about whiteness, I began to have a clear question about what framework white people might need to effectively work with one another on issues of race. To even ask the question of my conversation partner, however, required me first to lay out three propositions as well as the question.</em></p><p><em>They are:</em></p><p><a href="https://medium.com/@BetsyHodges/whiteness-proposition-one-66acc6ac6f19"><em>Proposition One</em></a><em>: It is the work of white people to lead other white people away from an investment in whiteness and out of racist behavior. (White people are not the only people who do or could do this work, but it is work that white people can and should do.)</em></p><p><a href="https://medium.com/@BetsyHodges/whiteness-proposition-two-7f12bc87c882"><em>Proposition Two</em></a><em>: Blame, attack, criticism, fear, anger, and shame are not a sound basis for sustainable social change. Long-term change is built on human connection, compassion, love, and seeking what’s truly human in one another coupled with accountability and expectation. (It is not an act of love to treat other people badly or to allow someone to treat other people badly.)</em></p><p><em>Proposition Three: There is no widespread secular framework through which white people can work with one another explicitly as white people based on love and compassion; the only current secular framework through which that conversation is approached is through white supremacy.</em></p><p><em>The Question: Can we create a framework through which white people can work with one another on the basis of love and compassion rather than shame in order to do our part to end racism, a framework that does not condone or appear to condone the racism on which whiteness is predicated?</em></p><p><em>Each of the propositions is contested, and the question may not have an answer.</em></p><p><strong>Proposition Three: There is no secular framework through which white people can work with one another explicitly as white people based on love and compassion; the only current secular framework through which that conversation is approached is through active White Supremacy.</strong></p><p>No matter who you are, if you’ve gotten this far in these essays, there’s a decent chance that you are deeply uncomfortable by now. You might be convinced that I am proposing an apology for whiteness that facilitates the continuation of race and racism rather than advocating to dismantle them. You might be thinking that I am, wittingly or unwittingly, playing into the hands of white supremacy as a system and perhaps bolstering active, open White Supremacist groups (like the Proud Boys or the KKK) with my beliefs.</p><p>That there is no secular way to read what I have written as anti-racist is part of the problem.</p><p>To be sure, there are excellent and fascinating conversations happening in religious and spiritual spaces. Many religions, including strains of Judaism, Islam, Buddhism, and Christianity, have an understanding that there is something sacred about human life regardless of the behavior of that human.</p><p>I am most familiar with Protestantism, personally (though I am not a practicing Christian), and I know there are denominations that preach that any sin is forgivable and any person can be redeemed. This concept lends itself well to a framework for whiteness that looks with compassion toward the white person who is acting out of their whiteness socialization in ways that harm Global Majority and Indigenous people. I know that Unitarian Universalists have a nationwide US program focused on racial justice, as does the Episcopal church.</p><p>It is useful to have non-secular frameworks through which to do this work. It is also essential to the work of dismantling racism to have a secular framework for white people to do this work, one that isn’t dependent on a belief in God or a connection to a religion, that could be used more widely between and among white people and in the wider secular world. There is no alternative secular framework that meets the need, however.</p><p>If a known liberal or progressive white minister were to stand up and say, “I love my people, including my white congregants,” there is the possibility that someone hearing that would be able to leave room for, “Ah, yes, that minister has a theology that calls for her to love all her congregants regardless of their behavior, though they might not love the behavior.” However, if a known liberal or progressive white <em>mayor</em> were to stand up and say, “I love my people, including my white constituents,” there is almost nowhere for that statement to land in the cultural imagination except for an immediate suspicion of a proclivity for right-wing extremism. There is no common, widespread vocabulary or framework in the secular space that allows for a public person to express that sentiment and have people understand that the compassion is for the person but not for racist beliefs or behavior. Even if the statement were coupled with copious explanation, bubble-wrapped in disclaimers about racism, it would understandably still be met with rancor and suspicion and accusation.</p><p>This dynamic is inside the problem we are trying to solve. We cannot build long-term, sustainable social change that outpaces systems’ ability to tolerate and absorb white people’s revelations without fundamentally changing outcomes for Global Majority and Indigenous people if white people can’t work with each other based on compassion, understanding, humanness, and love.</p><p>That’s a lot in one sentence, so I will parse it out. First, sustainable social change needs to be built on human connection rather than disconnection — a case I make in Proposition Two. Second, there isn’t a widespread secular framework for white people to make those human connections with each other around whiteness and racism. Third, individual white people, and small groups of white people, can and do have significant revelations and “aha” moments. While that is important for those white people, and collectively it can make a difference in our lives and the lives of the Global Majority and Indigenous people around us, it is not sufficient to make widespread social change.</p><p>Why? Because racism is systemic and those systems are good at maintaining themselves. They are flexible enough to adapt to the revelations of some white people — even every white person who read and was inspired by Ibram Kendi’s work or Robin DiAngelo’s work — while still managing to get the same consistent racial disparities in the outcomes that they were constructed to get.</p><p>If white people are going to engage in this work enough to support and help bring about truly anti-racist policy change, we are going to need to enroll in enough numbers at a fast enough clip to outpace the ability of the status quo systems to withstand and thwart the impact of our understanding (and the actions we take as a result).</p><p>Which brings us back to Proposition Two: That number of people requires effective organizing, and effective organizing requires a framework of compassion, connection, and love.</p><p><strong>If white people are going to work with white people based on love and compassion, rather than shame, to the scale required to transform whiteness as our part of ending racism, we are going to need a new secular framework in which to work.</strong></p><p>All of this leads us to the question: Can we create a wholly secular framework through which white people can work with one another on the basis of love and compassion (rather than shame) in order to do our part to end racism — a framework that does not condone or appear to condone the racism on which whiteness is predicated? That will be our next topic.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=80c3c5cb1366" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Whiteness: Proposition Two]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@BetsyHodges/whiteness-proposition-two-7f12bc87c882?source=rss-eb3d732e689c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/7f12bc87c882</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[whiteness]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[white-supremacy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[racism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[race]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[white-privilege]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Betsy Hodges]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 09 Mar 2022 19:13:56 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-03-09T19:13:56.896Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>This is part of a series of pieces that explore what I have learned about whiteness, race, and human beings in the last 30 years. I am writing for readers, primarily white readers, who believe that racism exists and that it is bad, and I assume a basic level of understanding of racial concepts. A word about language: Currently I am using three phrases throughout these essays to encompass people of color, all of which are debated: “people of color”; “Black, Indigenous, and people of color/BIPOC”; and Global Majority and Indigenous people/GMI people”. All of them are meant to encompass the wide range of people, the majority of people around the world, who do not claim European heritage or who claim more than European heritage.</em></p><p><em>Some of the ideas in here have been and will be explored more fully in other pieces — please subscribe and come along for the ride!</em></p><p><em>When I left office and began having intentional conversations about whiteness, I began to have a clear question about what framework white people might need to effectively work with one another on issues of race. To even ask the question of my conversation partner, however, required me first to lay out three propositions as well as the question.</em></p><p><em>They are:</em></p><p><em>Proposition One: It is the work of white people to lead other white people away from an investment in whiteness and out of racist behavior. (White people are not the only people who do or could do this work, but it is work that white people can and should do.)</em></p><p><em>Proposition Two: Blame, attack, criticism, fear, anger, and shame are not a sound basis for sustainable social change. Long-term change is built on human connection, compassion, love, and seeking what’s truly human in one another coupled with accountability and expectation. (It is not an act of love to treat other people badly or to allow someone to treat other people badly.)</em></p><p><em>Proposition Three: There is no widespread secular framework through which white people can work with one another explicitly as white people based on love and compassion; the only current secular framework through which that conversation is approached is through white supremacy.</em></p><p><em>The Question: What secular framework, if any, can we create through which white people can work with one another on the basis of love and compassion, rather than shame, in order to end racism; a framework that does not condone or appear to condone the racism on which whiteness is predicated?</em></p><p><em>Each of the propositions is contested, and the question may not have an answer. I will explore all of them in the coming weeks. Proposition One is </em><a href="https://medium.com/@BetsyHodges/whiteness-proposition-one-66acc6ac6f19"><em>here</em></a><em>.</em></p><p><strong>Proposition Two: Blame, attack, criticism, fear, anger, and shame are not a sound basis for sustainable social change. Long-term change is built on human connection, compassion, love, and seeking what’s truly human in one another, coupled with accountability and expectation. (It is not an act of love to treat other people badly or to allow someone to treat other people badly.)</strong></p><p>Racial social systems[i] can withstand negative emotions like grief, anger, fear, and shame — even and especially emphatic ones. In fact, they adapt well to them. Racial social systems are well constructed to co-opt and manipulate negative emotions and put them in service of either markets (e.g., Fox News and its profits) or marginalization (e.g., the stereotype of The Angry Black Man).</p><p>What all systems have difficulty withstanding is human connection. This is especially true for social systems based on racial hierarchy. One of the many reasons organizing works is because it requires human beings to connect with each other about things that matter to them. The stories that warm our hearts, that remind us of how we thought the world was supposed to be, are almost always those of people doing right by someone else by breaking a system’s rules and/or risking personal consequence. This includes things like refusing to kick a kid out of line for not having lunch money, courageous, career-risking votes by elected officials, and people who put themselves between another person and a physical threat like a person with a gun.</p><p>Shame and fear also have difficulty withstanding real human connection. As a result, human connection is a key ingredient for dissolving and transforming whiteness as well as the systems that are intertwined with it, because whiteness is socialized into white people using shame and fear of losing connection with people who are important to us.</p><p>What I mean is, white people rarely have stark stories about injustices against us that characterize our awareness of our own race. What we often have, which Thandeka explores in her book Becoming White, is an awareness, often subconscious, that if we don’t implicitly accept the racial injustice around us, we are at risk of losing social cohesion with our families and communities, cohesion we rely on to survive as children. It becomes a powerful norm for us that we are almost never invited to re-evaluate as adults. As Thandeka says about the stories she heard from white people she interviewed about their early memories of racial identity, “They are stories about children and adults who learned how to think of themselves as white in order to stay out of trouble with their caretakers and in the good graces of their peers or the enforcers of community racial standards. Their motive was not to attack someone outside of their own racial community. They simply wanted to remain within their own racial community — or at least not be abandoned by it.”[ii] (I will be writing more fully about this in a future essay.)</p><p>For white people to sustainably enroll other white people into racial liberation work, then, it will be necessary to contradict that shame and fear. To do that, we will need an approach that understands that in order for our social systems to persist, almost all white people are steeped, from a very early age, in our part of racial systems and culture. We are as impacted by social messages about our whiteness and what it means and how it shapes our world as any other race. The methods and the content of those messages are different, but the socialization is just as powerful.</p><p>As an example, some of us white liberals and progressives understand on a theoretical level that violence within marginalized communities is at least in part a consequence of systems and the harms caused by those systems. We believe racism and lack of opportunities in our social structures — education, employment, and housing among them — shape options and self-perceptions in those communities in real ways. This belief (along with any bias or implicit bias we still carry) shapes how we assess what solutions will and won’t work to prevent violence or disrupt poverty. We think that the context, including social systems that are not set up well for certain communities, matters for understanding the genesis of violent behavior. Understanding the context also means shaping solutions that change the context, not just an individual.</p><p>However, we fail to understand the corollary: In order for racial systems to function, this process of shaping options and self-perception happens to <em>everyone</em> in the system.</p><p>It is a part of whiteness that we do not understand that this has happened to us white people just as surely as it has happened to Global Majority and Indigenous people. Our role is just very different in a racialized system and, as a result, the methods used to shape us into our role are different, as well.</p><p>Any successful strategy for white people to enroll each other into the work of getting out from under whiteness and turning our energy toward racial equity has got to, at the very least, understand this dynamic <em>and</em> have compassion for it.</p><p>If this is true, then we white people get to work with other white people to challenge our whiteness and transform the systems that are based on it on the basis of love and compassion, coupled with expectation and accountability. Compassionate accountability, accountable compassion. Either way, we must build the work based on it. This is work that white people must do with white people.</p><p>Often, we white people are tempted to start with accountability, to put accountability in the first position when talking with another white person. We are tempted to start with the ways that whiteness is terrible, and ways we’ve inherited that which are terrible, and the suspicion that we white people are terrible, too. Whether it’s Uncle Phil at Thanksgiving going off about [insert any racial epitaph here] or Jenny in our book group rolling her eyes when Caste is the next book on the list, many of us (if we notice it at all) first (understandably) get mad or scared or upset or all three. Then, if we figure out how to do anything at all in that moment, we are tempted to start with why the other person is wrong and how bad it is that they demonstrated racist behavior. Our urge is to move straight to correction and accountability.</p><p>Here’s the thing, though. That doesn’t work very well for actually changing culture and systems over time. If we can sense that another person can’t see us, can’t truly value us in our full humanity — good and bad — then the conversation is over before it starts. If I don’t feel connected to you in some way first, if my humanness is not in the first position, then I am not going to trust you enough to follow your lead. This is true under almost any condition, on any issue, with any people. If my full personhood is not assumed before anything else, not much else of meaning is going to happen.</p><p>Now, if you lead with shame or fear or blame or criticism, instead of my humanity, you <em>can</em> get my compliance. I will shut up, or vote the way you need me to (if I am an elected official), or change my language. In many instances, those can be good short-term gains. It might be all you are aiming for in that moment. But the dividends on those gains are resentment and retaliation. As I type this, white people across the country, white people who decried the murder of George Floyd, are also electing leaders who will increase law enforcement in their cities, despite the overwhelming evidence that more law enforcement of the kind they are voting for more of disproportionately harms people of color. They don’t understand what’s in it for them to change how things have always been done (I wrote about that <a href="https://betsyhodges.com/as-mayor-of-minneapolis-i-saw-how-white-liberals-block-change-2/">here</a>.) and they’re tired of feeling like they’re being called bad people.</p><p>OK, look. I know. When it comes to whiteness and white people, there isn’t some magic way to approach us that isn’t going to ping our defensiveness. Robin DiAngelo writes about this beautifully in White Fragility. Defensiveness about our race is an almost universal feature, not a bug, of 21st-century American whiteness. The goal for us in working with each other isn’t to avoid that defensiveness — at this stage, I don’t think that’s possible. The goal is to couple it with enough connection to allow us to withstand the discomfort of our own defensiveness long enough to hear something in addition to the defensive voice in our heads.</p><p>This is one of the reasons I think white people are in a unique position to work with each other. We can identify with one another. We can let go of the judgment for other white people because we have been there ourselves. Then we can connect as people. “Jenny, I have been there. I know the creeping dread that comes over me when I think about having to talk about race. For me it’s really old, maybe for you, too. But we give up too much of ourselves when we stay in that place, and we inadvertently hurt a lot of other people in the process, too. We are all worthy of more.”</p><p>One of the reasons can be controversial is because on its surface it looks like side-stepping responsibility, like an easy harbor for the white desire for comfort. Whiteness wants comfort more than almost anything else. An exhortation to compassion sounds like new language for the old habit of the white trend to comfort. That is why I am so clear that it must be paired with accountability and expectation.</p><p>Why accountability and expectation, if those engender such defensiveness? Two reasons. First, it’s how we will actually move things. Without it, we really are just telling each other as white people that racism isn’t our fault — so we shouldn’t do anything about it.</p><p>Second, it isn’t an act of compassion to leave each other sitting in our whiteness and our racist behavior. Hurting other people every day (unintentionally or not), benefiting from the harm of others, having an asterisk next to our every success — those eat at the spirit of a person and of a people. The mental and spiritual gymnastics we do to avoid facing this reality lessens us as human beings. It is an act of compassion and love to offer another way and another perspective to each other.</p><p>Finally, I say all of this in the context of white people who are working with other white people. As a white person, I am not speaking to or attempting to guide the organizing strategies and principles of Global Majority and Indigenous people, unless explicitly invited to contribute to that conversation. The thinking I share here is designed as a basis for building a framework for white people, my people, to do effective anti-racism work with one another.</p><p>In sum: If Proposition One and Proposition Two both hold, then it will be necessary for white people to work with one another on the basis of love and compassion to do our part to end racism. What framework do we have that allows us to do that work with integrity? Well, we don’t have one. And that will be the subject of the next essay.</p><p>[i] “Racial social systems” and “racial systems” refer to the concept that the policies, procedures, and cultures that tie together how people interact with each other as groups and individuals were and are structured to get better outcomes for white people. Systems include government, health, education, employment, housing, and transportation as well as broader systems like the economy, the family, and politics.</p><p>[ii] Learning To Be White by Thandeka, 1999, Bloomsbury Academic, p. 20</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=7f12bc87c882" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Whiteness: Proposition One]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@BetsyHodges/whiteness-proposition-one-66acc6ac6f19?source=rss-eb3d732e689c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/66acc6ac6f19</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[race]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[social-change]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[whiteness]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Betsy Hodges]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 24 Feb 2022 17:06:49 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-02-24T17:06:49.199Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>This is part of a series of pieces that explore what I have learned about whiteness, race, and human beings in the last 30 years. I am writing for readers, primarily white readers, who believe that racism exists and that it is bad, and I assume a basic level of understanding of racial concepts. A word about language: Currently I am using three phrases throughout these essays to encompass people of color, all of which are debated: “people of color”; “Black, Indigenous, and people of color/BIPOC”; and Global Majority and Indigenous people/GMI people”. All of them are meant to encompass the wide range of people, the majority of people around the world, who do not claim European heritage or who claim more than European heritage.</em></p><p><em>Some of the ideas in here have been and will be explored more fully in other pieces — please subscribe and come along for the ride!</em></p><p>When I left office and began having intentional conversations about whiteness, I began to have a clear question about what framework white people might need to effectively work with one another on issues of race in order to play our part in ending racism. To even ask the question of my conversation partner, however, required me first to lay out three propositions before asking the question.</p><p>They are:</p><p><strong>Proposition One</strong>: It is the work of white people to lead other white people away from an investment in whiteness and out of racist behavior. (White people are not the only people who do or could do this work, but it is work that white people can and should do.)</p><p><strong>Proposition Two</strong>: Blame, attack, criticism, fear, anger, and shame are not a sound basis for sustainable social change. Long-term change is built on human connection, compassion, love, and seeking what’s truly human in one another <em>coupled with </em>accountability and expectation. (It is not an act of love to treat other people badly or to allow someone to treat other people badly.)</p><p><strong>Proposition Three</strong>: There is no widespread secular framework through which white people can work with one another explicitly as white people based on love and compassion; the only current secular framework through which that conversation is approached is through white supremacy.</p><p><strong>The Question</strong>: Can we create a framework through which white people can work with one another on the basis of love and compassion rather than shame in order to do our part to end racism, a framework that does not condone or appear to condone the racism on which whiteness is predicated?</p><p>Each of these propositions is contested — and the question may not have an answer. I will explore all of them in the coming weeks.</p><p>We begin with Proposition One.</p><p><strong>Proposition One: It is the work of white people to lead other white people away from an investment in whiteness and out of racist behavior. </strong>(White people are not the only people who do or could do this work, but it is work that white people can and should do.)</p><p>It is part of racism — a curious part, when you stop to think about it — that white people expect Black, Indigenous, and people of color to lead us out of it.</p><p>I will say that again: It is part of racism that white people expect Black, Indigenous, and people of color to lead us out if it. For we white people who believe that racism exists and believe that it is bad, this expectation is a feature, not a bug, of whiteness.</p><p>There are two problems with white people’s expectation that Black, Indigenous, and people of color will lead us out of racism.</p><p>1) The first problem is that it puts the burden of the work of getting to something better than racism onto Black, Indigenous, and people of color.</p><p>· In and of itself, this white expectation of the intellectual labor and emotional labor of Black, Indigenous, and people of color is inside the racist systems we are trying to dismantle. It indicates that we believe that the problems of racism are not about us, do not meaningfully affect us, do not harm us, and are not our responsibility. (This misconception will be the topic of a future essay.)</p><p>· A corollary is that this expectation indicates the tendency of white people to see anti-racism work as a charitable contribution of our time and attention, given to those we see as less fortunate than we are. It undergirds our worst paternalistic instincts, especially in the stance we take to address issues of race.</p><p>· It also reveals our belief as white people — which we come by through our socialization and is reinforced by dominant cultural messages — that we fundamentally cannot think about race, so need others to do the intellectual labor for us that we are unable to do for ourselves. This is not true. There is nothing inherent in our biology that renders us incapable of learning about race and whiteness and how they function. It is our social conditioning that creates the white taboos about discussing race (especially our own). It is social conditioning that makes it feel like there are insurmountable roadblocks to understanding how it functions and that those roadblocks are a personal flaw.</p><p>2) The second problem with the white expectation that people of color will lead us out of our racism is that there are significant design flaws inherent in it.</p><p>· First, our socialization as white people inherently includes a limit on the number of us who will follow the lead of people of color at all. If we expect to be led by people who we won’t actually follow, we will not get where we need to go. This expectation serves the racial status quo rather than an agenda for change.</p><p>· Second, even when we white people believe we are willing to follow a leader of color, our race socialization also places limits on the capacity of even willing white people to respect and trust the leadership of a Black, Indigenous, or person of color. We will resist it in ways we don’t even recognize as being about race, and react defensively if this is pointed out. Until we work on our implicit biases, they will run the show.</p><p>· Third, as a result of our whiteness, even well-meaning white people have enormous gaps in awareness about our whiteness, how it functions, and its role in the systems of race. We get to shrink these gaps — which requires learning from Black, Indigenous, and people of color, who do not share them — but inside our awareness gaps is often an inability to listen to and truly understand what Black, Indigenous, and people of color tell us about their experiences of race, racism, and whiteness.</p><p>· A fourth design flaw is that it doubles down on the cultural norm that white people won’t talk about whiteness, especially to one another. Under some conditions we might be willing to talk about race in general. We might even be willing to talk about white people in the abstract. But the norm against talking about our own whiteness is strong enough to call it a taboo. When I speak to groups composed of a majority of white people, the first time I bring up our whiteness openly I can hear the white people in the room stop breathing. There is a particular quality to the silence that I only hear in that circumstance.</p><p>As a result of all this, I posit that talking and working with each other on whiteness <em>as people who experience whiteness as white people</em> is a necessary part of emerging out of our racism and becoming effective advocates for anti-racist policy change — necessary, but not sufficient.</p><p>A few final points about Proposition One:</p><p>· It is true that there are many things that Black, Indigenous, and people of color understand about whiteness that white people do not. Almost all of what white people have come to understand about race and our whiteness has come as a result of following this knowledge. This is understandable: a notable result of whiteness conditioning is to be left largely ignorant about the dynamics of race, particularly our own. Most of what white people have learned about race in the last fifty years has come from Black, Indigenous, and people of color. People of color have reflected to me that they see certain aspects of whiteness clearly because they have to navigate them every day.</p><p>· These understandings that people of color share are necessary for us white people to know and understand in order to emerge out of racism. I propose, however, that, like the work white people do with one another, those understandings, while necessary, are also not sufficient unto themselves to get the job done.</p><p>· This is because there is a key aspect of whiteness that <em>white</em> people understand that Black, Indigenous, and people of color do not: <em>what it is like to be white from inside of whiteness</em>. This means white people have a special ability to work with one another inside that particular space. I believe when we do work effectively with each other there, it can hasten the pace of changes that can dismantle racism.</p><p>· However, white people’s investment in whiteness means this work must be in consultation with Black, Indigenous, and people of color. Nothing can replace that. With that in mind, I propose that even so, <em>anti-racist work must also be done by white people with other white people</em>.</p><p>This is my first proposition for white people working with white people about whiteness and race.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=66acc6ac6f19" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Without Reservation, We Support Keith Ellison]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@BetsyHodges/without-reservation-we-support-keith-ellison-fec9511b0266?source=rss-eb3d732e689c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/fec9511b0266</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[keith-ellison]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[women]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mn-attorney-general]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mn2018]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Betsy Hodges]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 05 Oct 2018 20:15:52 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-10-05T20:15:52.861Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/375/1*EiLyV5dbpKh4beWlxKTTwA.jpeg" /></figure><p>Without Reservation, We Support Keith Ellison</p><p>We are women and gender nonconforming who are longtime progressives and DFLers who, like many Minnesotans, have been troubled by the accusations of abuse that Rep. Keith Ellison’s former partner of six years, Karen Monahan, has made against him. Like many women, some of us have our own histories of being survivors of assault. We have watched with awe as the #metoo moment has transformed the conversation about abuse in this country and has created an environment where women are breaking their silence, speaking their truth and telling their stories.</p><p>We have felt it important to listen to Ms. Monahan’s story as well, and we have. As we have listened, we have also had trouble reconciling the Keith Ellison we have known for many years — a fierce fighter for and a staunch ally of women, LGBTQ folks, people of color and indigenous people, family farmers, low-income people, and anyone treated unfairly by big money and corporate special interests — with the portrait that Ms. Monahan has painted of him and the allegations of abuse that she has leveled at him. For this reason, we have been anxious to hear the results of the independent investigation into Ms. Monahan’s claims.</p><p>The report of that independent investigation is now public: <a href="https://www.documentcloud.org/documents/4952674-Keith-Ellison-Investigation-Report.html">https://www.documentcloud.org/documents/4952674-Keith-Ellison-Investigation-Report.html</a>). The investigation finds that <strong>the allegations of physical abuse that Ms. Monahan has made against Keith Ellison are unsubstantiated</strong>. It paints a picture of a volatile relationship, and a long, messy breakup, but <strong>no abuse on Keith’s part</strong>.</p><p>Some of the findings of the report that we have found important and persuasive are that:</p><p>· <strong>There is no independent evidence that the incident of abuse Ms. Monahan has described took place.</strong>From the investigative report:</p><p>o “Ms. Monahan claims to have videotaped the alleged incident. Mr. Ellison flatly denies the alleged incident and has said the video could not exist because he did not engage in that behavior.”</p><p>o “According to [Ms. Monahan’s son] Austin Monahan, the video is almost two minutes long and ‘showed Keith Ellison dragging my mama off the bed by her feet.’But based on Ms. Monahan’s description of the alleged incident, it is unclear what was recorded for two full minutes…Ms. Monahan does not allege she was dragged off the bed.”</p><p>o “Mr. Monahan’s account of what he viewed on the video at least appears inconsistent with the actual conduct alleged.But neither Austin Monahan, nor Justin Monahan who was also said to have viewed the tape, would make themselves available for an interview to explain and potentially clarify these possible discrepancies.”</p><p>o “In her public interviews, Ms. Monahan has provided different reasons for not releasing the video. She has stated that it was misplaced, that it is too embarrassing and traumatic, that it is on a flash drive packed away in boxes in storage, and that she should not have to prove that she is telling the truth. I offered to view the video privately but Ms. Monahan ultimately refused to allow me to see it.”</p><p>o “Also supporting Mr. Ellison’s denial of the allegations is the fact that Ms. Monahan left at his home a notebook with her personal notes made on January 2, 2017.… The journal does not mention the alleged incident of physical abuse. … She also writes, ‘Keith is a good person and I know this from my core. I have no place to judge him because I have done the same thing.’”</p><p>· <strong>There is no pattern of abusive conduct by Keith Ellison.</strong>From the report:</p><p>o “In 2006, another woman, Amy Alexander, accused Mr. Ellison of grabbing her and threatening her. Mr. Ellison denied those allegations. At the time, the Star Tribune investigated the allegations, including interviewing witnesses identified by Alexander, but the paper was unable to corroborate her claims. A court granted Ellison a restraining order against Alexander in June 2005 based on allegations that she was harassing him, and denied a similar request by Alexander. Several facts uncovered during the Star Tribune’s investigation called into serious doubt the credibility and motives of Ms. Alexander.Given the lack of reliability around the twelve-year-old allegation by Ms. Alexander, issues relating to that relationship or her allegation were not considered and thus do not support any suggestion of a pattern of conduct.”</p><p>o “Mr. Ellison’s ex-wife, Kim Ellison, publicly stated, ‘I want members of our community to know that the behavior described does not match the character of the Keith I know.’I interviewed Ms. Ellison and she firmly stated that Mr. Ellison had never engaged in any abuse, physical or otherwise, ‘before, during, or after’ their twenty-five-year marriage.”</p><p>· <strong>The allegation is unsubstantiated.</strong>From the report:</p><p>o “Mr. Ellison was credible in his denial of the allegations and truly seemed not to recall the incident ever happening.He presented as sincere in his shock, hurt, and disbelief that Ms. Monahan would make these allegations against him.”</p><p>o “Mr. Ellison painted a convincing picture of Ms. Monahan as being suspicious, questioning, and aggressively accusing him of lying and cheating. … Mr. Ellison believes Ms. Monahan could not accept that he moved on to another serious relationship so quickly…He feels this jealousy and belief that he was not faithful to her is motivating the current allegations.”</p><p>o “A mutual friend who had talked to both parties understood the breakup to be ugly and messy. Another mutual friend who has known both parties for years said she had seen Mr. Ellison be ‘crabby and dismissive’but never exhibit uncontrolled anger or rage. Kim Ellison denied that he had ever engaged in any physical abuse during their 25-year marriage.”</p><p>o “I asked Ms. Monahan to allow me to view the videotape and assured her I would not share the tape with anyone or release it publicly.As I told Ms. Monahan, the withholding of a videotape that she has affirmatively represented to exist as proof her allegations necessarily creates doubt around her allegation. … Ms. Monahan ultimately refused to show me the video…”</p><p>o “An allegation standing alone is not necessarily sufficient to conclude that conduct occurred, particularly where the accusing party declines to produce supporting evidence that she herself asserts exists. The accusing party’s statement must be evaluated in light of the available evidence, including the accused party’s response, a credibility assessment of both parties and any witnesses, and corroborating evidence if it exists.”</p><p>o “That the accusing party claims to have but refuses to provide key, dispositive evidence that the accused has flatly denied, causes me to <strong>conclude that the allegation is unsubstantiated</strong>.”</p><p>In this investigation (as well as in other public accounts — for example, <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2018/08/30/us/keith-elllison-karen-monahan.html">https://www.nytimes.com/2018/08/30/us/keith-elllison-karen-monahan.html</a>and <a href="https://naomikritzer.com/2018/09/29/election-2018-attorney-general">https://naomikritzer.com/2018/09/29/election-2018-attorney-general</a>— it is clear that Keith is trying to navigate a difficult breakup, maintain a good relationship with his former partner, be an effective member of Congress, and move on with his life — as all of us have tried to do as relationships have ended in our lives. <strong>Adifficult breakup is not abuse.</strong></p><p>We know how painful it is when women who come forward with stories of abuse are not believed, and we are glad that we are having a national conversation about that. At the same time, this investigation also leaves us with serious concerns about<strong>Ms. Monahan’s repeated attacks on Keith’s current relationship.</strong>From the report:</p><p>· In the journal dated January 2, 2017, “Ms. Monahan mentions … MH specifically and says ‘I will not take her to a back alley and box the living shit out of her old ass.’”</p><p>· “On December 31, 2017, Ms. Monahan wrote a letter to MH, Mr. Ellison’s current girlfriend. In that letter, Ms. Monahan told MH that she had ‘impacted [Ms. Monahan’s] personal life journey,’ she questioned MH’s motives for interjecting herself into Ms. Monahan’s relationship with Mr. Ellison, and stated that MH had not considered Mr. Ellison’s well-being and how he and his family would be ‘hurt and negatively impacted’ by her actions. ‘But you didn’t take into account. You thought of your needs, what you wanted, your desires and it didn’t matter who you hurt.’”</p><p>· “In March 2018, Ms. Monahan sent Mr. Ellison copies of texts she claimed were from her friends making derogatory comments about MH’s age and appearance.”</p><p>We also have grave concerns about the <strong>timing of Ms. Monahan’s allegations</strong>, coming just three days before a contested primary. From the report:</p><p>· “The timing of the public release of Ms. Monahan’s allegations is also a factor that must be considered in assessing the credibility of the parties. Ms. Monahan’s son posted the allegations regarding Mr. Ellison three days prior to the primary election, inevitably creating suspicion as to the motive behind the disclosure.In his August 11 post, Austin Monahan tagged Debra Hillstrom, Mr. Ellison’s opponent in the Attorney General primary, which could suggest some political motive.”</p><p>· Ms. Monahan“admitted Mr. Ellison’s filing for Attorney General triggered her decision to move forward with publicizing her story.”</p><p>Our concerns on this point are frankly more serious than the understated tone of the report. The timing of Ms. Monahan’s allegations, her retaining a Republican attorney who is a former supervisor and active supporter of Keith’s opponent, and her apparent willingness to be used by and possibly collaborate with right-wing, sometimes Islamophobic media, strongly suggest that <strong>these allegations have become politically as well as personally motivated</strong>.</p><p>It’s important to note that this investigation was conducted by attorney Susan Ellingstad, a partner in the noted and respected Minneapolis law firm Lockridge Grindal Nauen. Ms. Ellingstad is a partner of the firm who heads its employment law department. She conducts independent workplace investigations in response to workplace complaints. Even Ms. Monahan’s Republican attorney has said in the media that Ms. Ellingstad is a “good lawyer” from a “very good law firm,” and that he likes her “very much.”</p><p>It’s also important to us that unlike when most powerful men are accused, Keith did not shout down his accuser or demand we ignore her — rather, <strong>Keith welcomed and fully and willingly cooperated with this independent investigation</strong>. While we have wanted to hear Keith’s story from him, we also understand and respect why he has largely kept silent about the details of this relationship: because he wanted the investigation to continue independently, and because he did not want to contribute in any way to shutting down the #metoo conversation, even in legitimate self-defense.</p><p>And even though this independent investigation has found the allegations of abuse unsubstantiated, Keith has nonetheless requested that the Ethics Committee of the U.S. House of Representatives conduct a second investigation.</p><p>Even as a handful of <strong>craven politicians seek to exploit Keith’s race and religious beliefs</strong>as reasons to question him, he has insisted we listen fairly and find out the facts — not cover them up.</p><p>These actions leave us with the unmistakable impression that <strong>Keith has nothing to hide</strong>.</p><p><strong>This is the Keith Ellison that we know.</strong></p><p>We find the report of this investigation, conducted independently by a respected attorney experienced in investigating claims like these, to be persuasive. As a result, <strong>we can say without hesitation or reservation that we believe Keith committed no abuse toward Ms. Monahan</strong>. As a result, and that <strong>we support Keith fully and wholeheartedly in his campaign for attorney general</strong>.</p><p>It is <strong>critically important</strong>that now, every progressive, every DFLer, and every person who believes that people matter more than corporations work as hard as possible over the next month to<strong>elect Keith Ellison our next Attorney General. </strong>Both <strong>because of who Keith Ellison is and what he will fight for</strong>, and <strong>because of who his opponent is and how he would put impose Trump’s agenda on people and communities we care about.</strong></p><p>For his entire career in public life, Keith has stood for the principle that has become his signature: <strong>everybody counts, everybody matters</strong>. Now Keith is asking us to make him the “People’s Lawyer.” As our attorney general, Keith will:</p><p>· <strong>Increase access to affordable health care</strong>, by defending the Affordable Care Act and coverage for pre-existing conditions, holding drug companies accountable for skyrocketing drug prices, and cracking down on opioid manufacturers;</p><p>· <strong>Fight for a fair economy for all</strong>, not just those at the top, by fighting for a $15 minimum wage and protecting workers’ rights, ensuring women receive equal pay for equal work and are protected on the job, and holding student-loan providers accountable for high rates and fees; and</p><p>· <strong>Protect civil rights and equal opportunity throughout Minnesota</strong>, by fighting Trump’s efforts to remove protections for Dreamers and our immigrant neighbors, defending all Minnesotans against discrimination and harm, and protecting our older and vulnerable adults from fraud and abuse.</p><p>And in the sharpest possible contrast, Keith’s opponent Doug Wardlow has openly pledged to promote Trump’s agenda in Minnesota. He would tear down to everything that Keith — and we — have fought for. He would repeal the Affordable Care Act and its coverage of preexisting conditions, he would let corporations get away with fraud, abuse, and polluting our environment, he would suppress the right to vote by pursuing Trump’s false claims of “voter fraud,” he would side with corporate special interests over workers, he would threaten the hard-won rights of LGTBQ people, and he has said that attacking a woman’s right to choose would be a priority in his office.</p><p>What’s even worse is that Wardlow is trying to hide his true, radical right-wing agenda by masquerading as a moderate who will simply enforce existing law. We cannot let him get away with that lie.</p><p>And so we are left with a clear outcome and call to action — <strong>the allegations against Keith are unsubstantiated</strong>, and it is time we <strong>do everything we can without hesitation or reservation to elect Keith Ellison our next Attorney General.</strong></p><p>Sincerely,</p><p><strong>Abena Abraham, </strong>Shoreview</p><p><strong>Shay Berkowitz, </strong>Fierce truth speaker, Minneapolis</p><p><strong>Ramsey County Commissioner Toni Carter, </strong>Saint Paul</p><p><strong>JoAnn Clark</strong></p><p><strong>Roann Cramer, </strong>Progressive activist, former DFL Senate District 61 chair, Minneapolis</p><p><strong>Rev. Laurie Eaton, </strong>Pastor, Our Saviour’s Lutheran Church ELCA, Minneapolis</p><p><strong>Emilia González Ávalos, </strong>Minneapolis</p><p><strong>Emily Marie Buehler, </strong>Justice and Peace Studies Faculty, University of St. Thomas, Mazeppa</p><p><strong>Roxanne Givens, </strong>Minneapolis</p><p><strong>Andrena Guines, </strong>Project management consultant, DFL State Central Committee member, CD4, New Brighton</p><p><strong>Betsy Hodges </strong>Former Mayor, Minneapolis</p><p><strong>Shirlynn LaChapelle</strong>, RN, BSN, PHN, SNP, President, Nursing is the Answer!</p><p><strong>Connie Lewis, </strong>Community activist, Saint Paul</p><p><strong>State Representative Rena Moran, </strong>Saint Paul</p><p><strong>M. Kathleen Murphy, </strong>Women’s rights advocate, Saint Paul</p><p><strong>Lori Bergland Olson, </strong>Farmer, Thief River Falls</p><p><strong>State Senator Patricia Torres Ray, </strong>Minneapolis</p><p><strong>Phyllis Wiener, </strong>Social justice activist, Minneapolis</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=fec9511b0266" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>