<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Brady Pesola on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Brady Pesola on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@BradyPesola?source=rss-04093e2a9d64------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Sat, 21 Nov 2026 06:33:10 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@BradyPesola/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Critical Thinking: The Most Misused Skill in Modern Discourse]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@BradyPesola/critical-thinking-the-most-misused-skill-in-modern-discourse-b6792830f982?source=rss-04093e2a9d64------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/b6792830f982</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Brady Pesola]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 03 Apr 2025 13:30:55 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-04-03T13:48:30.802Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*zhPacTHB0wJN-vQ_yeEXcA.png" /></figure><p>By Brady Pesola | Analysis</p><p>There isn’t a day that goes by where I don’t see someone on social media, usually in a snarky and overly confident tone, telling someone else to “do some critical thinking”, or accusing them of lacking the capacity for it altogether. You’ll see it in political debates, comment sections, podcast discussions, and even in casual conversations. And it doesn’t matter which side it’s coming from, left to right, or right to left. Everyone claims to be the one “thinking critically,” while insisting the other is brainwashed.</p><p>But somewhere along the way, <em>critical thinking</em> stopped being a process and became a buzzword. A rhetorical weapon. A smug dismissal. A stand-in for <em>“you don’t think like me, so you must not be thinking at all.”</em></p><p>It’s time to strip that away.</p><p>If we want to reclaim the value of critical thinking, actually <em>use it</em> rather than just accuse others of not using it, we have to understand what it really is, how it functions in the brain, why so many misuse it, and how we can utilize it properly. Lastly, understand that its not a weapon for snark, rather a personal tool for us to use to become better thinkers and more informed.</p><h3><strong>What Critical Thinking Actually Is</strong></h3><p>Before we can talk about how the term is misused, we have to define it — not as a label, but as a <em>discipline</em>.</p><p>Critical thinking is the deliberate, structured ability to reflect, analyze, and evaluate information with intellectual honesty. It isn’t contrarianism. It isn’t instinctive distrust of authority. And it isn’t about positioning yourself as the lone genius in the room. At its core, critical thinking is about <em>methodical process, </em>not personal superiority.</p><p>It means examining a claim <em>on its own merit, </em>whether that claim comes from a peer-reviewed journal, a news anchor, a TikTok personality, or your own internal assumptions. It means asking: <em>What is this based on? What does it actually prove? And what am I bringing into this evaluation that might be distorting my judgment?</em></p><p>At the functional level, it includes:</p><ul><li><strong>Analyzing evidence:</strong> Not just what the data says, but how it was gathered, framed, and presented.</li><li><strong>Evaluating arguments: </strong>Understanding the structure of a claim and whether the conclusion logically follows.</li><li><strong>Drawing inferences:</strong> Knowing the difference between a reasonable assumption and a convenient leap.</li><li><strong>Identifying bias:</strong> In the source, in the framing, and most importantly, in yourself.</li><li><strong>Revising beliefs when warranted:</strong> Not based on pressure, but because the weight of reason demands it.</li></ul><p>But here’s the problem: most people treat these like bullet points to memorize, not like <em>habits</em> to develop. And that’s the difference, critical thinking isn’t a checklist, it’s a cognitive discipline. One that requires consistent practice, internal resistance, and long-term mental conditioning. It doesn’t just live in your conclusions, it lives in your processes.</p><p>If you never put that process under pressure, it doesn’t grow. Just like physical strength, critical thinking only improves when it meets <em>resistance</em>. That resistance often shows up as dissonance, new information that threatens your beliefs, contradicts your identity, or forces you to admit that you might’ve been wrong.</p><p>That’s where most people tap out.</p><p>Because doing this well also demands emotional regulation. And without that, all the logic in the world won’t matter. If your ego or social identity feels threatened, your reasoning shuts down. Your limbic system (your emotional brain) takes over. And once that happens, it’s not critical thinking anymore. It’s self-defense disguised as logic.</p><p>This is why <em>how you feel while thinking</em> matters. If you’re defensive, impulsive, or rushing to “win,” you’re probably not reasoning, you’re rationalizing. The ability to pause, reflect, and adjust in real-time is what separates analysis from reactivity.</p><p>And this brings us to one of the most overlooked components of real critical thinking: metacognition.</p><p>Metacognition is the ability to think <em>about</em> your thinking. It’s what allows you to monitor your own reasoning in motion. Not just <em>what</em> you think, but <em>how</em> you got there. It lets you catch yourself making assumptions. It helps you spot patterns in your own logic. And it gives you the distance to say, “I might be wrong,” without collapsing into insecurity.</p><p>Most people don’t engage this level of reflection. They stop at “I’ve done my research” or “I’ve thought this through.” But critical thinking demands <em>self-observation</em>. Not just analysis of facts, but interrogation of the lens you’re using to interpret them.</p><p>And here’s what that all adds up to:</p><p>Critical thinking doesn’t exist to serve your ego. It’s not supposed to make you feel smarter than everyone else. It’s supposed to make you <em>less wrong over time</em>. And that means doing the uncomfortable work of surrendering certainty in service of reason, objectivity, actual logic. The goal isn’t to “win” the argument. The goal is to align yourself more closely with reality, especially when it costs you something.</p><h3><strong>How Both Political Sides Weaponize “Critical Thinking”</strong></h3><p>It’s not uncommon to see people online proudly claim their side is the only one using reason, facts, and logic, while accusing the opposition of being emotionally reactive, brainwashed, or outright stupid. “You clearly lack critical thinking” has become one of the most common (and lazy) insults in political discourse today.</p><p>And it doesn’t matter which side you’re on. The left claims the right denies science and facts. The right claims the left is gullible, overly emotional, or blindly loyal to institutions. Each side points the finger at the other and says, “You don’t think critically.” And each side would be right in saying so, but also wrong in thinking they it was just the other-side.</p><p>They’re right that failures of reasoning and logic exist on the other side. But they’re wrong to assume those failures are exclusive to their opponents. The reality is, every group is vulnerable to emotional reasoning, tribal loyalty, and motivated thinking. Not because they’re stupid, but because they’re human, but they’re also fed by algorithms, outrage cycles, and echo chambers that reward tribal certainty over intellectual effort. Both sides are being trained to think they’re the only rational ones in the room.</p><p>From a cognitive standpoint, this makes sense. The brain isn’t wired for impartial reasoning by default. It’s wired for <em>survival and belonging</em>. When identity is threatened, the brain doesn’t ask <em>“What’s true?” — </em>it asks <em>“How do I defend myself?” </em>So rather than recognize one might be wrong or not thinking critically themselves, most people tend to double down and point the finger at their political or intellectual opponents.</p><p>You see it online all the time. But you also see it in real life, even between professionals, where pride and status quietly hijack the conversation.</p><p>That’s why, when someone wants to engage with me, I ask a simple question: “Do you want a debate, or a discussion?” Because a debate is inherently adversarial. It’s about performance. A winner, a loser. Nothing is learned and no information is exchanged. It’s about ego, snark, and making the other person look stupid. But a discussion? That’s where real thinking happens. It’s not about who’s right, it’s about getting it right. It’s about exchanging information, not egos. If we’re serious about critical thinking, we need to stop treating conversations like competitions. A debate is about winning. A discussion is about understanding. And only one of those sharpens the mind. It’s about humility, curiosity, and connection, three things no debate ever really rewards.</p><h3><strong>Critical Thinking and “I Do My Own Research”</strong></h3><p>This brings me to something that’s felt off in recent years, especially since the COVID era: the idea that we’re supposed to think critically, but we’re <em>not</em> supposed to “do our own research.” That doesn’t add up.</p><p>We’re told to question misinformation, think for ourselves, and avoid blind trust. But then we’re told not to look too closely, not to deviate from the narrative, and definitely not to form opinions from independent research. That contradiction has created confusion, and it’s turned a vital skill into a cultural joke.</p><p>Few phrases have been more mocked than “I do my own research.” It’s often used as shorthand for conspiracy theories, pseudoscience, or internet rabbit holes. But doing your own research is not the problem. In fact, it’s a necessary part of critical thinking. The issue isn’t <em>that</em> people research, it’s <em>how</em> they do it, and more importantly, how they interpret what they find.</p><p>Access to information used to be a privilege reserved for scholars and institutions. Today, anyone can access peer-reviewed journals, raw data, public health policy, declassified documents, and long-form investigations, from their phone. That’s a powerful shift. But access doesn’t equal understanding. The ability to find information is not the same as the ability to evaluate it. And that’s where things go sideways.</p><p>Meaningful research takes structure and discipline. It means cross-checking sources, understanding context, recognizing bias, interpreting data within its proper scope, and being willing to say “I don’t know yet.” It’s slow. It’s uncomfortable. It demands effort. Most people don’t approach it that way. What they call “research” is often just a rapid search for anything that confirms what they already believe. That’s not research, that’s rationalization.</p><p>And this is where the Dunning-Kruger effect quietly kicks in.</p><p>It’s a well-documented cognitive bias where people with limited knowledge in a domain overestimate their competence. In other words, the less you know about a subject, the more likely you are to feel confident in your understanding of it, because you don’t know enough to recognize how wrong you actually are.</p><p>Simply put, you know enough surface information to think you’re right, but not enough depth of the information to know you are wrong.</p><p>A little information feels like expertise when you’re emotionally invested and unaware of your own limitations. Combine that with unlimited access to headlines, threads, blogs, videos, memes and niche experts, and you’ve got a recipe for dangerous overconfidence. You don’t just believe you’re informed, you believe you’re <em>more</em> informed than people who’ve spent decades studying the topic.</p><p>That’s how we end up with entire subcultures that think they’ve “seen through the lies,” when in reality, they’ve just walked into a new kind of echo chamber. One that <em>feels</em> like enlightenment, but is actually just another layer of curated belief. That doesn’t mean we should shame people for wanting to understand things more in depth. Quite the opposite. Mocking “do your own research” is lazy. It assumes that real thinking and research is only for the credentialed elite, and that anyone outside that system should sit down, shut up, and accept what they’re told. That’s not critical thinking. That’s intellectual gatekeeping.</p><p>Worse, it reinforces two false beliefs:</p><ol><li>That scientists, doctors, and credentialed professionals are <strong>always right</strong>, and beyond scrutiny.</li><li>That the only legitimate knowledge is produced <strong>inside institutions</strong>, not examined independently.</li></ol><p>You’ll often hear this mockery framed with sarcasm: <em>“Oh, so you’re a scientist now?”</em> or <em>“What, are you in a lab running experiments?”</em> — as if the only valid form of research requires a white coat, a PhD, and access to institutional labs. The underlying assumption is that unless you’re part of the academic elite, you’re incapable of understanding complex topics, let alone forming a rational conclusion about them.</p><p>But that’s not how reasoning works. You don’t need a doctorate to identify inconsistencies, analyze evidence, or spot flawed arguments. You don’t need to conduct original experiments to understand the implications of published data. Critical thinking isn’t the exclusive domain of experts, it’s a skill anyone can develop, and everyone should be held accountable to. Research, in this broader sense, means approaching information methodically, not passively consuming narratives or outsourcing judgment to authority. In reality, critical inquiry is available to anyone with the tools and patience to pursue it responsibly. With access to peer-reviewed databases, translated academic texts, and AI-powered breakdowns of technical language, even non-experts can learn to interpret complex material, identify weak claims, and form educated perspectives over time.</p><p>Now, that doesn’t mean everyone becomes an expert overnight. But it does mean we should stop ridiculing people for wanting to learn, and start giving them better frameworks for how to do it. Because in a world drowning in information, <strong>t</strong>he ability to interpret is far more valuable than the ability to access. But that’s where we run into a deeper problem. It’s not just misinformation. It’s not just access. It’s how our own minds fight against solid information, even when we have the right tools<strong>. </strong>The greatest threat to critical thinking isn’t ignorance, it’s emotional certainty.</p><p>Before we move on, I want you to ask yourself which political side you had in mind when you read the above, and then I want you to ask yourself how you felt, why you agreed or disagreed and then re-evaluate. Why did you agree or disagree? Are you right or wrong? Now we are critically thinking</p><h3><strong>Critical Thinking: Psychologically and Physiologically.</strong></h3><p>At the most basic level, critical thinking is a function of the brain’s executive system, centered primarily in the prefrontal cortex, which governs reasoning, analysis, planning, and inhibition. This region allows us to evaluate complex ideas, weigh trade-offs, hold competing possibilities in mind, and suppress immediate emotional or instinctive reactions in favor of deliberate thought. But the brain doesn’t operate as a unified machine. It’s a layered system evolved over time, where older, survival-driven mechanisms still run in parallel with our higher reasoning capacities. This is where the conflict arises.</p><p>When the brain perceives a social or emotional threat, it triggers the limbic system, particularly the amygdala, to prioritize safety. This neurological override is commonly referred to as an amygdala hijack. It shifts control away from the rational, reflective system (prefrontal cortex) toward reactive behavior patterns. The goal is speed and protection, not accuracy or objectivity.</p><p>In evolutionary terms, this made sense. Survival depended more on rapid threat detection than careful philosophical inquiry. But in modern settings, debates, social conflict, ideological disputes, this same override can sabotage logical or rational thinking. Once triggered, we don’t analyze. We react.</p><p><strong>The Role of Emotion in Cognitive Collapse</strong></p><p>The thing is, emotion isn’t inherently irrational, especially when guided by reason. But when it becomes the dominant filter, it distorts how information is received and processed. Studies in neuroscience and psychology have consistently shown that emotionally charged stimuli reduce working memory capacity, impair judgment, and increase cognitive rigidity. In other words: when you’re emotionally activated, you’re more likely to <em>cling</em> to what you already believe and <em>resist</em> what challenges it, regardless of the actual strength of the evidence. The reasoning center isn’t shut off entirely, t’s redirected toward defending existing beliefs.</p><p>This is why emotionally intelligent people aren’t necessarily more rational. Without discipline, even emotional awareness becomes another tool for manipulation or self-justification. Critical thinking requires the ability to notice when emotion is influencing your process, and to deliberately recalibrate. Now, lets talk about how Bias affects critical thinking</p><p>The brain also relies on heuristics, mental shortcuts that help us process information quickly. These are evolutionary and adaptive tools of survival, but when applied to complex or unfamiliar problems, they often lead to systematic errors in judgment. These errors are what we refer to as cognitive biases.</p><p>Here are a few that directly interfere with critical thinking:</p><ul><li><strong>Confirmation Bias</strong>: Interpreting evidence in a way that supports what we already believe</li><li><strong>Anchoring Bias</strong>: Overweighting the first piece of information we hear</li><li><strong>Negativity Bias</strong>: Giving more attention to threats or bad outcomes than neutral or positive data</li><li><strong>Status Quo Bias</strong>: Preferring familiar conclusions over potentially better but disruptive ones</li></ul><p>What’s dangerous about these biases is that they often operate <strong>beneath awareness</strong>. You’re not always choosing to be biased, it’s happening automatically, silently, and it still feels like you’re thinking critically and logically.</p><p>This is the most deceptive part of emotionally charged or biased reasoning: it mimics the external form of critical thought. Most people don’t form beliefs by carefully analyzing evidence and applying logic. They form beliefs <em>first, </em>emotionally, socially, or instinctively, and then justify them afterward. That process is called Motivated Reasoning. And it’s not some fringe phenomenon. It’s how the human brain naturally tries to protect itself. Motivated reasoning isn’t about finding out what’s true. It’s about defending what’s comfortable. When you hear a new idea, your brain doesn’t ask, <em>“Is this accurate?”</em> It asks, <em>“Does this threaten what I already believe?” </em>That threat doesn’t need to be physical. It can be social, psychological, or ideological. And once that threat is felt, your reasoning changes. The filters go up. The defenses kick in. And the same brain that’s capable of deep logic becomes a very sophisticated tool for self-preservation.</p><p>Take an example: a person committed to a specific nutritional ideology may spend hours reading studies and citing data to prove what they already <em>know.</em> But if their process involves ignoring contradictory evidence, discrediting sources preemptively, or twisting risk assessments to protect a belief, then they’re not engaged in critical thinking, they’re engaged in validation. This doesn’t make them dishonest. It makes them human. And this is where critical thinking most often fails, not from a lack of information, but from a lack of awareness and regulation over how information is interpreted under emotional, professional or ideological pressure. You might cite sources, debate a position, or explain your rationale in great detail, but underneath that surface activity, the function has shifted. You’re not reasoning toward understanding. You’re defending what’s already been decided.</p><p>Even highly intelligent individuals are prone to distorted reasoning. In fact, intelligence can amplify the problem. A higher cognitive capacity doesn’t eliminate bias, it enables more complex justifications for it. The smarter you are, the more capable you become at constructing plausible-sounding arguments, sourcing confirmatory evidence quickly, and reinforcing existing beliefs with technical precision. Bias doesn’t disappear, it becomes more sophisticated.</p><p>There’s also a tendency among experts or well-read individuals to anchor themselves to prior knowledge. Once an idea becomes tied to identity, professional credibility, or years of reinforcement, new or contradicting information, especially if it comes from non-academic sources , is often met with reflexive dismissal rather than objective evaluation. The error isn’t stupidity. It’s intellectual overconfidence. The assumption that “if it were valid, I would’ve already known” blinds even the most competent minds to new insight. What’s worse and more often the case for academics and “experts”, is fear of peer ridicule and losing respect in their respective communities.</p><p>That’s why emotion is such a dangerous factor in critical thinking. Without emotional regulation, all the intellectual horsepower in the world can still drive you straight into the wall. When we feel challenged, embarrassed, or attacked, our reasoning collapses. Our brains prioritize defense over discovery. And this is exactly where critical thinking fails most often, not from a lack of information, but from a lack of discipline in how we emotionally handle that information.</p><p>When emotion distorts our reasoning and bias filters what we’re willing to consider, it becomes easy to dismiss anything we don’t immediately understand. We often confuse complexity or unfamiliarity with deception. Sometimes, what looks suspicious is just something we don’t yet have the tools or context to fully grasp.</p><p>This is also where another key tool of critical thinking should come into play: skepticism. But here’s the problem, most people only aim it outward. They question others, institutions, and claims they already disagree with. What they rarely do is turn that same skepticism inward. They don’t even have the humility to question themselves. The more emotionally invested someone is in being right, the less likely they are to examine their own reasoning. They become convinced of their accuracy, not because the evidence supports it, but because the belief is too tied to their identity to be questioned.</p><p>This is where skepticism stops being a tool for inquiry, and starts becoming a mask for cynicism.</p><h3>Skepticism vs. Cynicism</h3><p>Skepticism is a core part of critical thinking. It means slowing down, asking questions, and expecting claims to be backed by something solid. It’s not about being contrarian or dismissive, it’s about staying honest in how you come to conclusions. Skepticism creates space for better understanding. Skepticism is often held up as a virtue in critical thinking, and it should be. It means not accepting claims blindly. It means slowing down, asking for evidence, and giving ideas the space to be tested. Effective skepticism is grounded in curiosity. It wants to understand. It keeps the door open long enough to actually learn something.</p><p>But too often, skepticism is confused with something else entirely: cynicism. And the difference isn’t just a matter of attitude, it’s about function. Skepticism is a process. Cynicism is a posture. Skepticism questions so it can move forward. Cynicism questions so it doesn’t have to.</p><p>This confusion usually starts when people run into something that doesn’t immediately make sense to them. Instead of asking <em>why</em> it doesn’t make sense them, they jump to the conclusion that someone must be hiding something or its a conspiracy. This assumes they have all the information to make a conclusion with out recognizing that there is more nuance and it doesn&#39;t make sense because they don’ t have the specific insights or certain expertise to know why something doesn&#39;t add up. So it becomes easier to assume deception than to admit that they may not have the full picture. And in a world full of selective information, conflicting narratives, and media bias, it’s not hard to understand why people default to doubt. But not all doubt is created equal.</p><p>Skepticism says, “Let me look into this.”<br>Cynicism says, “It’s all BS.”</p><p>That distinction matters, because one keeps you thinking, and the other shuts thinking down.</p><p>A skeptic wants to find out what’s actually going on. They ask:</p><ul><li><em>“What’s this claim based on?”</em></li><li><em>“Is there a better explanation?”</em></li><li><em>“What would change my mind?”</em></li></ul><p>They aren’t looking to dismiss the idea, they’re looking to understand whether it holds up. If it does, they either investigate more or accept it. If it doesn’t, they move on. Either way, the goal is facts through investigation.</p><p>Cynicism, on the other hand, doesn’t care about investigation. It doesn’t care if the idea holds up or not, because it already assumes the answer: <em>everything is fake, everyone is corrupt, I already know what I need to know, and nothing is worth trusting.</em> Cynicism feels like critical thinking because it’s framed as doubt, but it’s not about learning. It’s about shielding yourself from the discomfort of not knowing or being proven wrong from what you are already emotionally attached to. And that’s the catch. Cynicism is a defense mechanism. It often comes from people who’ve been lied to, manipulated, or burned to much. It makes sense to be cautious. It makes sense to question things. But unchecked cynicism doesn’t make you harder to fool, it makes you harder to reach. You stop examining claims. You stop refining your thinking. You stop listening. You assume bad intent before you even hear the argument and it keeps from ever finding the truth you were looking for to begin with.</p><p>That mindset spreads fast, especially online. Entire communities form around shared distrust of the media, of institutions, of science, of each other. Can you blame them? People bond over what they reject. Algorithms feed it, and echo chambers reinforce it. Over time, that cynicism hardens into identity. It’s no longer about ideas, it’s about belonging to a group that refuses to believe anything and the payoff is emotional. Cynicism gives you a sense of certainty without the burden of investigation. If you think everyone’s lying, you never have to reevaluate your beliefs, admit when you’re wrong, or confront the uncomfortable reality that you might just be wrong in your assumptions and of what you think you know. You don’t have to do the work. You just dismiss and move on, knowing what you know and judging others for thinking differently. But that’s not insight or critical thinking. That’s avoidance and arrogance.</p><p>Cynicism feels like strength, but it’s actually a retreat, its intellectual weakness. It’s not a sign of deeper thinking, it’s what fills the space where thinking should be.</p><p>Skepticism though, when done right, sharpens thought. It makes you harder to manipulate because you’re willing to ask better questions and sit with uncertainty until you find something solid. Cynicism, in contrast, just makes you numb to nuance. It keeps you from engaging with anything at all, because you’ve already decided it’s not worth your time. The problem is that cynicism often wears the same clothes as skepticism. They both sound look like critical thinking. They both reject easy answers. But only one of them is looking for a better one. That’s the difference. And if you’re serious about critical thinking, you need to know which one you’re practicing, and which one you’re hiding behind.</p><blockquote>(Note: This isn’t to be confused with ancient Cynicism — the philosophical tradition that valued simplicity and virtue. Modern cynicism has no moral foundation. It’s just doubt, detached from discipline.)</blockquote><p>Recognizing the difference between skepticism and cynicism is important, but recognition alone doesn’t change how you think. Understanding how emotion and bias interfere with your judgment is necessary, but awareness isn’t enough. You can know all the theory, all the psychology, and all the terminology, and still default to the same mental habits you always have.</p><p>That’s because critical thinking isn’t just something you understand. It’s something you have to train. It doesn’t come from reading quotes or memorizing fallacies. It comes from putting pressure on your own beliefs, interrupting your reflexes, and learning to examine your thinking the same way you’d examine someone else’s. It takes repetition. It takes discomfort. And it takes work most people would rather avoid.</p><p>But if you’re serious about thinking better, the next step is practice.</p><h3><strong>Tools to Build Critical Thinking</strong></h3><p>Understanding what critical thinking is and what it isn’t, is only half the equation. The other half is harder: practicing it. Daily. Under stress. When it’s inconvenient. When you’re wrong.</p><p>These aren’t abstract “habits of mind.” They’re behaviors. They’re things you do, not things you claim to have. And the only way to get better at them is to do them deliberately, even when it feels unnatural or slow.</p><ol><li><strong>Ask Better Questions</strong></li></ol><p>Most people don’t ask questions to understand. They ask to prove a point, trap someone, or justify what they already believe. That’s not thinking. That’s fencing with facts.</p><p>Critical thinking starts with asking questions that challenge your initial assumptions, especially your own.</p><p>Ask:</p><ul><li><em>What is this claim actually based on?</em></li><li><em>Am I reacting to the tone, or to the substance?</em></li><li><em>What kind of evidence would prove me wrong?</em></li><li><em>What am I missing because of what I want to be true?</em></li></ul><p>Good questions expose weak arguments, yours and theirs. Bad questions just build stronger walls around ignorance.</p><p><strong>2. Steelman, Not Strawman</strong></p><p>Strawmanning is when you misrepresent someone’s argument to make it easier to destroy. Most people do it without realizing. It’s a defense mechanism, and it kills real dialogue and your own critical thinking.</p><p>Steelmanning is the opposite: deliberately trying to represent the other person’s position in its strongest, most reasonable form, even if you hate it.</p><p>If you can’t explain the other side’s view without mockery, distortion, or sarcasm, then you don’t understand it, and you’re not arguing from reason. You’re arguing from identity and a place of weakness.</p><p>Steelmanning forces you to slow down, actually listen, and test your own ideas against the best version of the opposition, not the dumbest caricature you can invent.</p><p><strong>3. Use the Scientific Method — Even Outside Science</strong></p><p>The scientific method isn’t just for researchers in white coats. It’s a repeatable process for testing ideas, arguably the most reliable thinking tool human beings have ever developed. And it works far beyond science.</p><p>You start with a question that can actually be answered with facts and without bias, not a rhetorical jab, not a setup to prove your point, but a real, testable question.</p><p>You form a hypothesis, something specific that could turn out to be wrong.<br> You gather evidence. You evaluate what the evidence actually shows. And what really hard for many folks, you adjust your belief based on the outcome, not on what you were hoping to confirm.</p><p>That last part is where most people fail. They don’t test. They assume. They skip the process and jump straight to conclusions that feel right.</p><p>But feelings aren’t tests. And instinct isn’t evidence. When you ignore the method, you’re not thinking. You’re just reacting, and calling it reason.</p><p><strong>4. Train Yourself to Pause</strong></p><p>The moment something pisses you off, or makes you feel smug, or hits a nerve, you should pause. Think Viktor Frankle. He said:</p><blockquote><em>“Between stimulus and response there is a space. In that space is our power to choose our response. In our response lies our growth and our freedom.”</em></blockquote><p>That pause allows you to work past an emotional reaciton to information. Not because emotion is bad, but because emotion rushes you. It pushes you to respond before you’ve actually thought anything through. And once you start talking and acting from emotion, you start allowing yourself to form and commit to decisions under the influence of emotion.</p><p>The ability to pause, to delay your response by even a few seconds, can mean the difference between reacting and reasoning. It’s not weakness. It’s the highest form of self control. If you let your thinking succumb to emotion in real-time, under pressure, and in defense of your ego, it’s probably not thinking at all. It’s distorted judgment in defense of your pride.</p><p><strong>5. Look for Dissonance, Not Comfort</strong></p><p>Most people aren’t looking for truth, they’re looking for reinforcement. They want to see their beliefs echoed, their biases confirmed, and their side validated. They don’t want to think, they want to win.</p><p>That’s the trap.</p><p>When something challenges your view or makes you uncomfortable, your instinct is to reject it. But that discomfort is the exact signal you should be paying attention to. It means something isn’t lining up with the mental model you’ve built. That tension is called cognitive dissonance, and it’s not a problem to avoid. It’s a signal to examine.</p><p>A lot of people think cognitive dissonance is a bad thing, as if feeling it means you’re wrong or confused. But that’s not what it is. It’s your brain telling you there’s a gap between what you believe and what you’re encountering. That feeling isn’t failure. It’s the beginning of critical thinking.</p><p>Instead of flinching away from it, ask:</p><ul><li><em>Why is this bothering me?</em></li><li><em>What part of my belief does this challenge?</em></li><li><em>Am I dismissing it because it’s wrong, or because it makes me feel wrong?</em></li></ul><p>Dissonance isn’t pleasant, but it’s useful. It shows you where your assumptions are rigid, where your logic breaks down, and where your identity might be tangled up in your opinions.</p><p>Most people avoid it. If you want to get sharper, learn to sit with it, and dig in to it.</p><p><strong>6. Use Modern Tools, But Think for Yourself</strong></p><p>AI, search engines, peer-reviewed databases, and massive open datasets are all available to the average person now. That’s a good thing. But having access to information doesn’t mean you’ve learned anything.</p><p>Too many people substitute tool use for thought. They use search results, ChatGPT, or video essays as a shortcut to conclusions they didn’t actually earn. The thinking isn’t happening, they’re just aggregating.</p><p>Use tools to break down complexity, translate jargon, and map ideas. But do not confuse using a tool with knowing how to reason. You still have to connect dots, weigh evidence, and make decisions. The tool can’t do that for you.</p><p><strong>7. Separate Information from Identity</strong></p><p>This might be the hardest one.</p><p>If your opinions are wrapped up in who you think you are, your politics, your tribe, religion, race, gender, your job title, your public image, then any challenge to your opinion feels like a challenge to you. That means you’ll defend bad ideas, ignore better ones, and refuse to adapt, just to protect a sense of self.</p><p>You have to be able to say, <em>“I believe this — but I am not this.”</em> You have to be able to admit when you’re wrong without seeing it as personal failure. And you have to stop tying your self-worth to being right.</p><p>You’re not your opinions. You’re the process that creates and refines them. That’s where growth happens.</p><p><strong>8. Pay Attention to Language and Source Framing</strong></p><p>Most people don’t read critically. They react to tone. If something sounds like it agrees with them, they trust it. If it sounds off, emotional, or uncomfortable, they write it off, even if it’s true.</p><p>But tone is not evidence. And neither is how something makes you feel.</p><p>Every piece of content, news, articles, videos, tweets, is crafted with intent. Every word choice, headline, photo, and omission serves a purpose. If you want to think clearly, you have to recognize when you’re being guided — subtly or directly, toward a certain conclusion. This is known as Framing Bias, the media has perfected it and content creators are dabbling in it for algorithmic advantage.</p><p>So ask yourself:</p><ul><li><em>What’s actually being said?</em></li><li><em>What’s being left out?</em></li><li><em>What kind of emotional tone is being used?</em></li><li><em>Is this about information, or is it about influence?</em></li><li><em>Why is this being published now, and why like this?</em></li></ul><p>This is especially important when you’re reading something that claims to be “news,” but feels like a personal attack. Because sometimes, that’s exactly what it is.</p><p>There’s a big difference between journalism and a hit piece. Journalism presents facts, regardless of how you feel about them. A hit piece presents a conclusion, then works backward to justify it. It’s not there to inform. It’s there to frame someone, something, or some idea in the worst possible light.</p><p>Hit pieces almost always follow a pattern:</p><ul><li>Emotionally loaded adjectives that shape your perception before facts are even introduced</li><li>Selective quotes ripped from context</li><li>Anonymous sources with unverifiable claims</li><li>Character framing instead of actual reporting</li><li>A tone of condescension, mockery, or moral superiority</li><li>And most importantly, they’re published with timing designed to damage someone, not to enlighten anyone</li></ul><p>It’s not always about what’s false, it’s about what’s framed. And framing is how people get manipulated without realizing it. It also relies on the laziness of the reader to not fact check, or even investigate the author for bias, reputation, and credibility.</p><p>If something you’re reading feels more like a personal grudge than an attempt to inform, trust that instinct, but verify it with critical questions.</p><p>Ask yourself: Is this informing me, or is it trying to shape what I think before I’ve had a chance to evaluate it for myself?</p><h3>Thinking Critically in the Age of Public Performance</h3><p>Ok this is long enought so lets wrap it up. “Critical thinking” gets thrown around like a badge, something you claim to have just because you’re skeptical, or contrarian, or pissed off online. It’s become more of a branding exercise than an actual practice. You see it used to posture in debates, dismiss opposing views, or signal intelligence — but rarely do you see it done.</p><p>It’s not a buzzword. It’s not an insult.<br> It’s not a personality trait.<br> And it sure as hell isn’t a shortcut to being right.</p><p>Critical thinking is work. It’s inconvenient. It’s uncomfortable. It slows you down when you’d rather react. It forces you to question not just the claims you hear, but the assumptions you already carry. It requires emotional regulation, intellectual restraint, and a willingness to be wrong.</p><p>Most people don’t want that. That’s why most arguments go nowhere. That’s why people confuse volume for validity, tone for truth, and style for substance. That’s why it’s easier to shout than to stop and think.</p><p>But like I said before, critical thinking isn’t just a mindset. It’s a mix of biology and discipline. Your ability to reason depends on real, physical processes in your brain. The prefrontal cortex handles logic, planning, and analysis. But under stress, emotion, or ego pressure, the limbic system — especially the amygdala, can override it. You shift from deliberate thinking to automatic defense. From analyzing to reacting. This isn’t a metaphor. It’s measurable. And if you don’t know it’s happening, you won’t stop it.</p><p>That’s why critical thinking takes more than just facts. It requires metacognition,<strong> </strong>the ability to think about your own thinking. To zoom out, check your process, and question your reactions in real time. Without metacognition, you’re just reacting with better vocabulary.</p><p>Psychologist Daniel Kahneman explained this with System 1 and System 2 thinking. System 1 is fast, automatic, emotional. System 2 is slow, deliberate, effortful. Most of us live in System 1. It’s easier. It feels natural. But it’s also lazy and full of blind spots. Critical thinking is what happens when you force yourself to switch to System 2. When you pause, evaluate, verify, and revise instead of instinctively pushing forward. It doesn’t come naturally. It’s not easy. But it’s the only way to stop outsourcing your thinking to reflex, bias, or tribal instinct.</p><p>If you care about truth, actual, hard-to-face, inconvenient truth, then you have to hold yourself to a higher standard. Not because it’s noble. Because anything less will leave you easy to manipulate and even easier to mislead. The cost of lazy thinking isn’t just bad information. It’s division. Resentment. Intellectual decay. The world doesn’t need more people claiming they think critically. It needs more people who actually do it, when it’s hard, when it’s slow, and when no one’s watching.</p><p>And that leads to something I’ll break down in a future piece:<br> What people <em>really</em> mean when they say “educate yourself.”<strong> </strong>Because most of the time, it’s not a call to learn. It’s a demand to comply.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=b6792830f982" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Death of Honest Discourse: Why I’m Writing in an Age of Ideological Chaos]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@BradyPesola/the-death-of-honest-discourse-why-im-writing-in-an-age-of-ideological-chaos-0af52a68965f?source=rss-04093e2a9d64------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/0af52a68965f</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[culture]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[writing]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[self-improvement]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Brady Pesola]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 17 Mar 2025 17:23:38 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-03-17T17:23:38.020Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>By Brady Pesola | Opinion</p><p><strong>Has Truth Been Replaced by Tribalism?</strong></p><p>Truth used to be truth. Now it’s just another political talking point.</p><p>Whether or not a fact is accepted depends less on reality and more on what side of the ideological line the speaker stands on. We’ve reached a point where everything — news, entertainment, even casual conversation — is filtered through a political lens first, and reality second. That’s a problem.</p><p>But before we go any further, let’s talk about truth itself — or at least, what people claim it to be.</p><p>Truth should be something objective, something that exists independent of personal beliefs. But today, it seems to have a broad and flexible definition, one that shifts depending on political affiliations, emotions, and personal interests. Instead of seeking what is, people often seek what supports their existing worldview and call that “truth.”</p><p>What we end up with isn’t truth at all. It’s subjective opinion, dressed up as fact, repackaged, and sold to the masses as unquestionable reality.</p><p>That’s the landscape we’re dealing with. And that’s why I’m here.</p><p><strong>Why Write?</strong></p><p>I’ve never really seen myself as a blogger, or even as a writer. But here I am, over 100,000 words into a book on mental resilience, so I guess I can’t pretend I’m not writing anymore. Whether or not that makes me an author, amateur or otherwise, is up for debate.</p><p>But I do know one thing — writing in a public space means opening yourself up to criticism. And that’s fine. It comes with the territory. Might as well step fully into the arena and give a semi-rational voice to the societal chaos that is public discourse.</p><p><strong>Why ‘Semi-Rational’?</strong></p><p>No one is purely logical, and I won’t pretend I am either. Humans aren’t built for perfect objectivity — we react, interpret, and filter reality through our own experiences. Even the best thinkers are at the mercy of their own biases, emotions, and limitations.</p><p>Plato pointed this out when he described how all things are perfect until they reach the mind of man — reason, objectivity, and logic exist as flawless ideals, but the moment they pass through the human mind, they become fallible, skewed, and distorted.</p><p>I recognize that. I’ll do my best to write with reason and clarity, but at the end of the day, I’m still human. And so are you.</p><p>In a time where emotional outrage dictates public discourse, I believe acknowledging that imperfection is just as important as striving for rationality.</p><p><strong>The Focus Here</strong></p><p>This isn’t about pushing an agenda or adding more noise. It’s about breaking through it. Topics I’ll cover include:</p><p>• The Role of Stoicism &amp; Philosophy in Modern Society</p><p>• Tactical &amp; Military Insights from Experience</p><p>• Mental Resilience, Social Independence, and Self-Reliance</p><p>• Rational Takes on Polarizing Social Issues</p><p>A guiding principle behind my writing is rooted in the Stoic cosmopolitan perspective — the idea that we are all interconnected, even when we disagree.</p><p>Marcus Aurelius wrote, <em>“Men exist for the sake of one another. Teach them or bear with them.”</em></p><p>I find this aspect of Stoicism particularly relevant today. The modern world makes it easy to retreat into factions, to engage with others as enemies rather than as fellow human beings. But what’s the alternative? A society where people refuse to even talk across ideological lines?</p><p>If the goal is to move toward a place of better discourse, then there are only two options: <em>teach or bear with them</em>. Anything else is just more division.</p><p><strong>What’s Next?</strong></p><p>I don’t write to push narratives — I write to examine them. Some topics will challenge widely accepted beliefs. Some may even challenge my own.</p><p>If that’s something you value, follow along. Push back where you disagree. Comment, discuss, and challenge.</p><p>At the end of the day, reason isn’t about what we believe — it’s about how we test those beliefs against reality.</p><p>But let’s be clear — this space is for rational pushback and disagreement, not emotion-filled anger, frustration, or snarky rhetoric. That does nothing for meaningful discourse and only damages public debate. If an argument has merit, it should stand on reason alone, not personal attacks or ideological grandstanding.</p><p><strong>Follow for More</strong></p><p>• Follow for regular articles on reason, philosophy, and discourse.</p><p>• Drop a comment — let’s engage in real discussion.</p><p>• Share this if you believe truth is more than just politics.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=0af52a68965f" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>