<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Good Bad Science on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Good Bad Science on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@GoodBadSci?source=rss-852acdf3a0c1------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Wed, 18 Nov 2026 20:20:54 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@GoodBadSci/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Thank you, Mr. Nimoy]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/the-good-the-bad-and-the-science/thank-you-mr-nimoy-de9bb8feedcc?source=rss-852acdf3a0c1------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/de9bb8feedcc</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[peace]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[science]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[leonard-nimoy]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Good Bad Science]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 04 Mar 2015 20:24:23 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2015-03-04T23:44:20.506Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>I don’t usually get emotional at the news of some famous person or other passing. Even when someone famous dies tragically young, to me it is rarely more than a passing impression of tragedy and waste, just one more poor soul who couldn&#39;t make it out of life alive. I’m just not that emotional of a person, I guess; or I&#39;ve seen enough of the world that I&#39;ve become somewhat immune to tragedy, my capacity for empathy diminished by the unending tide of tragedy-porn that passes for news in our time.</p><p>When I heard that Leonard Nimoy had passed away, I sat at my desk and cried. His death was not entirely unexpected — it had been well-known that he had been suffering from COPD, brought on by years of smoking — something he was at no loss to communicate to younger folk, so that they may avoid a similar fate. Yet, the news that he would no longer be among us literally brought me to tears. I had never met the man, let along spoke with him, and yet when I heard that he had died, it felt like a real part of my life was gone forever, leaving a gap that could not be filled.</p><p>When I was a child, I loved science and history. I could spend hours reading books by myself, taking in everything that there was to learn and know about. I wouldn&#39;t say I was particularly lonely, because I was often doing what I loved, but I did find it difficult to make friends. Other children were fun to be around and interact with, but I somehow lacked the ability to really connect with them on a more personal level. As a result, I always had a lot of acquaintances, but few real friends.</p><p>I also struggled as I grew up to reconcile two distinct worlds that I inhabited. I loved science, technology, and mathematics, and yet I grew up in a very religious household. I attended church at least every Sunday (and often much more often) with my parents, where things <em>just were</em>. As I grew, I began to read theological texts like I read science or history books; cover-to-cover, making sure that I took everything in and understood how one event would relate to another. I learned how all ‘good’ moral behavior can derive from a relatively small number of essential truths. And yet, society deemed these two worlds incompatible — in science, truth can only be derived through logic, reason, and most of all, experiment — while humanity, morals, empathy, duty to society — were tenets of religion, given to mankind by their benevolent creator alone.</p><p>Leonard Nimoy changed everything for me. From the first time I saw Star Trek reruns before the evening news came on, I understood that Mr Spock was more than just an exotic alien crewmember of the USS Enterprise — he was the very embodiment of humanity, of the struggle between his logical (Vulcan) and emotional (Human) sides, played out as an underlying subplot to the fantastic adventures of the crew.</p><p>Spock was the science officer, but was no geeky, lab-and-library-bound loner like I was —indeed, he was the biggest hardass on the ship! For all of Kirk’s bluster and passion, Scottie’s never-say-die, get-it-done attitude, and all the other adventurers — it was Spock alone who could lay out any man with a simple one-handed grip on their neck. Spock was an inspriation — he taught me that science was something that related directly to the Universe. He taught me that pursuing knoweldge could be an adventure, one that could stretch to the ends of the Universe and back. He made me realize that science was something that could be fun to do for a living.</p><p>But much more than this, Spock was the key to reconciling the worlds that I inhabited, and showed me that they were really one and the same. Spock alone showed me how human emotions and desires — empathy, moral behavior, friendship, teamwork — can be derived entirely logically from our own place in the Universe, and our relationship to those we cohabit this world with. He made me understand that there is no real conflict between the religious quest for the meaning of life and the scientific one. That it does not matter from where truth is derived, only the nature of the truth itself. That on the most fundamental level, all truth is unified — it is only our path to it that differs. That conflict arises from our inability to understand things from another person’s point of view — and therefore that even the most intractable disagreements can be overcome by the mutual understanding of each other‘s situation. That at the most fundamental level, all truth is out there waiting to be discovered and understood, if only we have the humility to put its pursuit ahead of our own ego and preconditioned ideas.</p><blockquote>Of all the souls I have encountered in my travels, his was the most… human. — <em>Capt James T Kirk</em></blockquote><p>Spock may have been a creation of a show writer, a character built into the Star Trek narrative in the ancient tradition of the Wise Outsider; <em>Deus ex machina</em>. His character, his soul, however came from Leonard Nimoy.</p><p>Without Nimoy’s skill, his nuance, his dedication to his craft, Spock was merely the narrator — the character whose job it was to explain the plot so that the show could move on to the next commercial break without losing the audience’s interest. Nimoy made him so much greater, and in the process, made me see the Universe as a bigger, more wonderful and aweful place than I could have possibly imagined. He made me understand that goodness and dignity were as essential to the pursuit of a meaningful life as any individual achievement. He showed me that there is nothing in this Universe that cannot be discovered, that cannot be solved by a focused and dispassionate dedication to finding a solution. That peace is a both a more logical and moral solution than conflict.</p><p>Leonard Nimoy taught me that my life could be worth living, that my dreams were valid, and worth following. And for that, I can never thank him.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=de9bb8feedcc" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/the-good-the-bad-and-the-science/thank-you-mr-nimoy-de9bb8feedcc">Thank you, Mr. Nimoy</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/the-good-the-bad-and-the-science">The Good The Bad and The Science</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Math vs. Science]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/science-and-its-communication/math-vs-science-3ae726669528?source=rss-852acdf3a0c1------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/3ae726669528</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Good Bad Science]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 26 Jul 2014 15:53:17 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2014-07-26T15:53:17.855Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>A personal journey of discovery</h4><p><strong>Over the course </strong>of a human lifetime, a small number of critical decisions or events can change the direction of a person’s existence forever. This singular inflection point of fate is a favorite theme for science fiction writers and therapists alike. For me, one of these came at the age of 17 while sitting in math class on the first cool day of autumn.</p><p><strong>I had always loved</strong> mathematics. The Count was by far my favorite character on Sesame Street. My childhood scribblings more often than not involved a ruler, or a protractor, or any other number other classroom geometry tools. I kept meticulous game-by-game statistical records of the progress of the local soccer team. While I was far from being the smartest kid in class, I had never failed to get an ‘A’ on my school reports in math.</p><p>On this particular day, I took my usual seat by the window. My school was built in the bucolic neighborhood surrounding an English cathedral, and the windows of the mathematics department looked out across a grassy courtyard to the great old church beyond. In my mind, the cathedral and mathematics had always been somehow inextricably linked — in the years I had spent sitting in this room, I had calculated all the angles on the vast cathedral’s various intersecting parts, practiced trigonometry to calculate its height and length from my seat in the classroom. I had mnemonically named many angular parts of the building, or its monuments, after mathematical principles that I would need to remember on tests — when exam time came, I simply had to look out of the window at the timeless architecture beyond — my own personal crib sheet. My faith in the indisputable truth of mathematics was as unquestioningly solid as that of the people who had built the great stone edifice long ago.</p><p><strong>Calculus. </strong>Excellent. The riddle-solving part of math class. The perfect way to spend a chilly Friday morning. Solve a dozen or so questions to find the value of <em>x</em>, and spend the rest of the morning getting ahead on homework. Then bunk off for the whole weekend while everyone else is still studying.</p><p>The teacher started writing out an equation on the blackboard. Nuts — this was going to be one of those instructional lessons that I was going to have to pay attention to. The last time we had one of these, he had introduced us to the concept of <em>i </em>and imaginary numbers, which made no sense at all at the time. This would be even worse. This is what he wrote:</p><blockquote><em>a=b</em><br>Multiply by a: <em>a^2 = ab</em><br>Subtract b^2 from both sides: <em>a^2 -b^2 = ab -b^2</em><br>Which is: <em>(a+b)(a-b)= b(a-b)</em><br>Cancel out (a-b) on both sides: <em>a+b=b</em><br>Since a = b, then: <em>a+a=a</em><br>Therefore: <em>2a=a</em><br>Thus: <strong><em>2=1</em></strong></blockquote><p>It <em>looked </em>right. It certainly didn’t feel right, but I couldn’t work out how. Nothing seemed to violate the logic of calculus as far as I could understand. All of the factors added up correctly. But it couldn’t be right. It just couldn’t! If it were this easy to prove 1=2, then how could anything in math ever make sense again? The teacher told us to work it out and we’ll discuss on Monday. The bastard.</p><p><strong>My weekend </strong>was a bust. I could not work it out, nor could I banish the riddle from my mind. By the time I sat back in class on Monday morning, I was utterly dejected. I was sure there was a simple trick, but I just could not see it. The teacher wrote out a question on the blackboard:</p><blockquote>Calculate <em>(a-b)</em></blockquote><p><strong><em>Zero! </em></strong>Suddenly, it all made sense. In line 5, we cancelled out the identical (a-b) on both sides of the equation. More accurately — we had divided everything by (a-b). <em>But (a-b) is</em><strong><em> </em></strong><em>Zero</em>!<strong> </strong>We had been tricked into committing a mathematical fallacy by misleading jargon! Simply substituting the phrase “cancel out” for “divide” had been enough to fool the entire class into making a critical error in logic.</p><p>For the teacher, this might have been a fun trick, a good introduction to the nuances of calculus and sources of error in logic systems that could be caused by unexpected zero-value calculations. For me, I couldn&#39;t stop thinking about which other solid truths I knew might be undermined by erroneous assumptions and misleading jargon. While the other students were beginning to dream of which University they would ideally like to attend after graduation, I was becoming trapped in a paranoia that everything I had ever learned could be wrong, just because someone forgot to account for a zero in the math.</p><p><strong>I found </strong>a refuge in biology class. I had always enjoyed biology for many of the same reasons as math — the way that a series of relatively simple repeating patterns could interact to create the complex molecular and cellular makeup of all living things fascinated me. While physical scientists would pillory biology as inexact or mathematically weak, it represented a bridge to the natural world that dry calculations could not. The nuanced observations and logical arguments of Darwin’s <a href="http://www.literature.org/authors/darwin-charles/the-origin-of-species/">The Origin of Species</a> came to be more satisfying to my mind than a thousand mathematical proofs. It was a science where I could feel comfortable that what I was studying was <em>real</em>, because it was there, right in front of me. Science, after all, was supposed to be about <em>testing </em>ideas, not just justifying them with fancy logic systems.</p><p>Over the next few weeks, our class completed a genetics experiment with fruit flies. Every morning, we had to collect flies from the plastic incubator chamber, using Ethyl Ether to anesthetize them. Then we would carefully count whether they had black abdomens, or stripey ones — all before they woke up and started flying off around the room. Over the course of several weeks we learned three crucial principles: the biological basis of simple dominant/recessive Mendelian genetics; that handling living creatures is difficult, time-consuming, and easy to screw up; and that if you accidentally leave the stopper off a large demijohn of Ether, all the kids who have lessons in that classroom later in the day will get high.</p><p>At the end of the month, we tallied up the results:</p><blockquote>Black Butts: 2,247 — Stripey Butts: 752</blockquote><blockquote>Ratio of Black Butts : Stripey Butts = 2.99 : 1</blockquote><p><strong>Mendelian genetic inheritance</strong>, as we had been taught, predicted that there should be a 3 : 1 ratio of black-bottomed flies (the “dominant trait”) in our population to flies with a striped pattern on their abdomen (the “recessive trait”). In our actual experiment, in which we looked at almost 3,000 flies, we found a ratio of 2.99 : 1 . Not a very big difference, but how do we know whather it matters or not? After all, very small differences can add up make a very large effect over long periods of time.</p><p>Now, barely a month after my faith in the predictive power of mathematics had been rocked by my teacher’s trickery, our biology class needed to turn to math in order to understand our experimental results. A chi-square test is a common statistical tool for determining if data fits into a predicted ratio — plugging our numbers into chi-sqaure gives a “two-tailed <em>p </em>value” of 0.92 . Simply put, this means that there is a 92% chance that our numbers do indeed fit into the predicted 3 : 1 ratio, after accounting for random variance. In high-school biology class, this was considered a significant value, and therefore our observed ratio was “correct” as predicted by the theory of genetic inheritance discovered by <a href="http://www.biography.com/people/gregor-mendel-39282">Gregor Mendel</a>. That was good for an A.</p><p><strong>Years later</strong>, and I am still working in biological science. Whereas my 17 year-old self was engaged with deciphering the colors and patterns on the back end of fruit flies, I now help to develop biotech ideas from research labs into new medicines and other products. Just like anyone else evaluating a new technology, my first job is to make a determination if it is feasible. After all, no one wants to invest precious resources to develop a technology that isn&#39;t likely to work in the first place. There are many reasons a new biotechnology product might fail — for instance, biological systems can develop resistance, or other molecular pathways might compensate for the activity of a drug, rendering it useless. The most critical issue I have to determine though, is if the scientists’ original research actually shows what they say (or what they think) it does.</p><p>Every day, I read scientific papers outlining the research that I am examining. In every case, their papers detail their hypothesis, the experiments they performed to test it, and statistical analysis of their results, confidently capped with a statement that <strong><em>p </em>&lt;0.05</strong> . That is, there is a less than 5% chance that their results are merely coincidentally aligned with their predictions. A skeptic might point out that if that were literally the case, you just need to perform an experiment 20 times for it to show a positive result by chance alone. Then publish <em>that</em> one. In a world where only about 10% of “landmark” cancer research papers <a href="http://blog.scienceexchange.com/2012/04/the-need-for-reproducibility-in-academic-research/">could be independently reproduce</a>d by the pharmaceutical companies they were licensed to, there is good reason to be skeptical of published reports, even (especially) when their data seems overwhelmingly positive.</p><p><strong>In the end</strong>, it is always a judgment call. We make our decisions based on where we determine the consensus of scientific knowledge to be at the time. Over the long-term, science is ultimately self-correcting. Unlike every other philosophy or method that has been employed by man to describe the Universe around us, science uniquely allows itself to be rewritten when new evidence shows old models to be incorrect. The scientific literature is not, nor should be, viewed as an inerrant body of knowledge. After all, scientists are people too and make errors in their work, just like anyone else. Rather, it is a continually updated narrative of a massive voyage of discovery that is shared by every person on Earth who asks a scientific question. All journeys take wrong turns and reach dead-ends. Eventually, even the most entrenched <a href="http://www.toptenz.net/top-10-most-famous-scientific-theories-that-turned-out-to-be-wrong.php">assumptions can be shaken</a> by the weight of new evidence against them, freeing us again to explore a new and uncharted domain.</p><p>It is easy to be distracted by a headline about a scientific breakthrough, or a tweet about a fantastic new discovery. After all, many of our reward systems in society encourage the idea that a single genius discovery will cure <em>X</em> or fix <em>Y</em>. No one single result, or paper, or model system, should be taken by itself as gospel. Scientific knowledge is the result of the amalgamation of many studies, from many different perspectives, to advance the body of its whole. Even then, it is subject to revision, nuance, and even complete rewriting.</p><blockquote>Nullius in verba</blockquote><p>The journey is never easy, but should we expect it to be for such an immense cause as the knowledge of the Universe?</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=3ae726669528" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/science-and-its-communication/math-vs-science-3ae726669528">Math vs. Science</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/science-and-its-communication">Science for All</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Masters of the 3rd Dimension]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/world-of-tomorrow/masters-of-the-3rd-dimension-1030f95735ab?source=rss-852acdf3a0c1------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/1030f95735ab</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Good Bad Science]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 12 Jul 2014 14:31:08 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2014-07-12T16:29:07.487Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Humans are on the precipice of breaking the z barrier, and life on Earth will never be the same again.</h4><p><strong>May 1st, 1870</strong> was a day that changed the world forever, except that most people don’t know about it. It is one of those rarest of days that marks a turning point in history, when a new technology emerges such that nothing can ever be the same again. For a man named Elisha Otis, it represented vindication of his two decade-long struggle to convince people of his invention’s utility.</p><p>The Equitable Life office building at 120 Broadway in New York City was the newest, biggest building in the world. At a soaring 130 feet, it dwarfed its neighbors in lower Manhattan, beginning an architectural arms race for prestige that still continues today between the world’s wealthiest businesses. As a structure, the building was no more technologically advanced than many of its contemporaries, but its great height was made feasible by Otis’ incredible invention — the passenger elevator. At first, it was ridiculed by the press as a gimmick, or worse, a ‘dumbwaiter’ to move the lower classes of workers swiftly up to their desks on higher floors, bypassing elegant staircases where businessmen might wish to congregate and discuss their dealings. Within just a few months however, the upper floors were fully occupied not by crowded factory-style offices of secretarial employees, but by the most prominent lawyers and bankers in the City. The elevator had literally turned the building upside-down. The penthouse was born, and the sky was now the limit for the new class of skyscrapers that would come to dominate cities worldwide within a century.</p><p><strong>Barely thirty years </strong>after Elisha Otis’ invention allowed cities to begin building upwards as well as outwards, the Wright brothers were testing a more daring means for mankind to leave the ground over the sands of Kitty Hawk in North Carolina’s Outer Banks. Since time immemorial, people had dreamed of acquiring the abilities of birds, of flying away from the ground into the freedom of the air above. <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Icarus">Tales from ancient times</a> tell of man’s attempts to engineer flight, and some of the <a href="http://www.da-vinci-inventions.com/flying-machine.aspx">greatest minds in history</a> had tried to imagine how a functional flying machine might work in practice, but none had yet been built.</p><p>Mastering flight would seemingly allow one to overcome any obstacle, travel anywhere, with complete freedom of the Earth. For Orville and Wilbur Wright, this was an opportunity to apply their knowledge of cutting-edge engineering and physics to do what no one had previously accomplished, and create powered flight at last. Their early prototype aircraft were crude and only flew for a few hundred feet, but were sufficient to prove that it was possible to overcome the iron grip of gravity using modern technology and engineering, such as it was in 1903. Just as Otis’ elevator allowed people to leave the ground — to create buildings that allowed their occupants to move ever upward — the Wrights’ invention would lead to a new kind of freedom in the skies above our Earth.</p><p><strong>Over a century </strong>has passed since Orville and Wilbur Wright first demonstrated that human flight was possible. Aircraft have been refined and developed to the extent that millions of people fly thousands of miles every day. Humans have even flown to the Moon and back, and sent robotic probes on journeys throughout the solar system. You can now go to any hobbyist store and buy a model aircraft that has far greater range and maneuverability than anything the Wright brothers were able to create over their entire careers, for less than the price of a big-screen TV. Yet human civilization remains a largely two-dimensional affair.</p><p>Even though the utility of elevators has allowed architects to stretch their buildings high into the sky above the ground, they remain a stack of individual two-dimensional spaces. Virtually all of human civilization can be effectively mapped on the <a href="https://www.google.com/maps/">two-dimensional screen of a smartphone</a>, and the layering of a few two-dimensional floor maps is sufficient to fill in the details of multistory buildings such as malls. Modern planes fly passengers thousands of miles across the globe, but are essentially still barely more than highly-maneuverable projectiles, destined to travel directly from one point on the surface of the Earth to another. Although we are three-dimensional creatures, we are still largely trapped inside a two-dimensional maze that is our civilization. We have but <a href="http://www.nasa.gov/mission_pages/station/main/#.U8BOepRX-uY">one outpost</a>, a tiny colony of 6 people in orbit about 200 miles above the surface of the Earth, where humans truly exist in a three-dimensional environment, and things work very differently up there.</p><p><strong>May 1st, 2020</strong>. Exactly 150 years after the passenger elevator first allowed humans to realize the dream of ascending out of the dirt of the city to reach the clean and clear skies above. I’m on the phone with my Mother to wish her a happy birthday and check her cake arrived OK.</p><blockquote>“Hang on dear, I think I can hear an Amazon Drone outside the front door now. That’s probably it.”</blockquote><p>The video on my screen jerks around drunkenly. Mom never remembers to leave her phone alone when video chatting, so I get to watch a ten second flyover shot of her living room carpet. As she opens the door, a small black quadcopter rises from the porch and buzzes off into the sunshine like a giant, crazy insect, leaving a small brown box behind.</p><p>Back inside, Mom opens the box and thanks me for the lovely cake we just sent. <em>How did anyone deliver fresh food or flowers before we had the drones to carry them high over all the rough city streets? Everything used to get so mushed up. It’s amazing what all this technology does nowadays</em>, she wonders aloud, before we say our goodbyes and hang up. I turn on the TV and continue watching a live video stream from the drone swarm that is following a family of blue whales migrating off the California coast.</p><p><strong>A confluence </strong>of technologies is once again about the change the way we live forever. The camera drones that some feel threaten their privacy are only the beginning of a new wave of flying machines that will move human civilization further into the third dimension. The continuing downward spiral in the cost of sensors and computing power will allow more and more autonomous robots to navigate the skies around each other. As these aircraft begin to be used for logistics and delivery services, market pressures will inevitably push the development of more efficient and powerful machines to carry larger loads, just as happened when railways and motor cars were “crazy new things”. Once the technology to safely carry 500 pounds or more becomes widely affordable, it is inevitable that people will want to start riding them. The longed-for flying car might finally soon be here at last, in some form or other. Regardless, the sky is soon set to become a much busier place.</p><p>What will all this mean for human civilization? Our towns and cities have developed throughout history based on ownership of flat squares of earth. What happens to our carefully laid out urban landscapes when flying machines can simply zip over the top of obstacles or bypass the road system? What happens if a major drone flight path passes right over your house? Are cities going to create no-fly routes, or minimum altitudes for drone flights, to minimize disruption to people living on the surface? Will we create <a href="http://fusion-industries2.tripod.com/scene3hillvalley2015/">highways in the sky</a> to funnel traffic through routes that minimize noise and danger to the surface below? Is it even possible to create a fixed infrastructure for autonomous aerial vehicles? How will people maintain privacy when a fence or hedge is no longer sufficient to obscure their home from the public spaces beyond? How will governments secure important buildings and military bases when the skies above them are open and accessible to everyone? The technology is already here, and the products will soon follow. The question is whether human society is ready to move deliberately into the third dimension, or if we will once again undergo a cultural shock that upends the fabric of our way of life before we accept its reality.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=1030f95735ab" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/world-of-tomorrow/masters-of-the-3rd-dimension-1030f95735ab">Masters of the 3rd Dimension</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/world-of-tomorrow">World of Tomorrow</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Your Ass is Killing You]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/world-of-tomorrow/your-ass-is-killing-you-d8d4da3fd95f?source=rss-852acdf3a0c1------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/d8d4da3fd95f</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Good Bad Science]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 28 Jun 2014 14:29:26 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2014-06-28T14:29:26.999Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>The experience of moving to a standing desk, and what it tells us about our 21st Century lifestyles</h4><p><strong>It began</strong> the morning I woke up with an incredibly stiff neck. For more then two weeks, I could barely turn my head to the left, until the knot of muscle around my spine finally released its grip with a sudden, audible ‘pop’. I decided right then that I needed to change something in my life. In my mid-30s, 25lbs or so over my ideal weight, I realized I had come to an inflection point — carry on the way I was going, and end up progressively slower, stiffer, heavier, and less healthy forever more — or try to do something about it, stop the rot before it was too late. I already exercised reasonably often (although less than I should), and my diet was pretty ok, insofar as a modern Western diet goes. So I decided to stand up.</p><p><strong>More than 800,000 Americans </strong><a href="http://www.heart.org/HEARTORG/General/About-American-Heart_UCM_452487_Article.jsp#mainContent">die every year</a> due to heart disease or stroke. An estimated one in three adults has some form of cardiovascular disease, leading to a plethora of disabilities and expensive medical care. The primary causes of cardiovascular disease are usually listed as a calorie-intensive diet high in saturated fats and cholesterol, lack of exercise, smoking, and abnormal sugar levels in the blood due to diabetes (which is itself primarily caused by poor diet and lack of exercise). The <a href="http://www.cdc.gov/chronicdisease/resources/publications/aag/dhdsp.htm">total cost</a> of treating cardiovascular disease in the USA is estimated at around $450 Billion per year — almost 1/6th of the total spent on healthcare overall — and much of this comes from public funding, due to the high concentration of cardiovascular illness among the elderly (Medicare) and low income communities (Medicaid). Heart disease is not just a public health concern — it is a serious drain on public finances, and pulls scarce funding away other areas, leaving less money available for research and treatment of cancer, Alzheimer’s, and other debilitating diseases.</p><p>Doctors recommend eating healthily and getting a minimum of 30 minutes of exercise a day to prevent cardiovascular disease. Public health advocates campaign for better preventative services for at-risk populations, and an end to <a href="https://apps.ams.usda.gov/fooddeserts/foodDeserts.aspx">“Food Deserts”</a>; areas where it is impossible to buy fresh, healthy, and affordable food. Success in these areas would go a long way to preventing cardiovascular disease — but is it enough? Are there other factors at work that are significantly contributing to the high levels of heart disease and stroke in America?</p><p><strong>Two weeks</strong> in, and my lower back hurts all the time. I tried not to significantly change any other aspects of my life, so I could get a clear idea of what specific difference, if any, that using a standing desk would have on my health (yay science!). So far, I’m constantly hungry, I have a dull, aching tightness in the small of my back that won’t go away, my knees hurt, and my feet are killing me.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/720/1*-hKF5CDfZ9LrNilR3BFQIA.jpeg" /><figcaption>I made this</figcaption></figure><p>My first standing desk is a crude effort, constructed by simply putting an Ikea coffee table on top of my old desk and screwing a matching shelf onto the front at elbow height. $115 in parts and about 30 mins to put it all together.</p><p>My office has since seen a parade of looky-loos consisting of everyone from the janitor to the senior executives, who have been continually dropping by to stare quizzically at my new desk (more specifically, at me standing in front of it, trying to actually get stuff done while they gawk at me like a zoo animal). They stare at the desk, and back again at me, as if they were looking at some kind of alien spaceship that has just landed. “So you stand up <em>all day long</em>??”, they ask incredulously. It is clear that, to many of my colleagues, the idea of standing up to work belongs in another era, or another society, but certainly not in 21st Century America with our comfy chairs, multiscreens, and endless cupholders. The only exception is the janitor, who seems genuinely confused as to why someone would actually <em>choose</em> to be on their feet all day, when everyone else above his pay grade gets a nice comfy chair to sit in. Standing desks might already be <em>de rigeur </em>in parts of the tech world, but here in corporate America, I am clearly marking myself out as some kind of freak.</p><p>I really want to sit down, even for just 15 minutes. Preferably in some kind of lounge chair that I could pretty much lay down on, taking all of the strain off my back. For some reason, my shoulders feel unnaturally tight, as if I had been moving heavy boxes all the day before and hadn&#39;t yet shaken off the stiffness. I want to take off my shoes so badly. Maybe I can sneak lunch in the locker room, where I could at least sit on a bench for a few minutes and eat a sandwich without being noticed — especially if I can avoid the lunchtime rush when all the hourly employees take their 12-1 pm break religiously.</p><p><strong>Picture a stereotype </strong>of the American Sedentary Lifestyle, and more likely than not, you’ll imagine an <a href="http://www.thesimpsons.com/">overweight family</a>, sitting on a couch watching TV. It’s a common image from public health campaigns, the media, and advocates/salesmen for healthier lifestyles. We seem to have an ingrained concern about how much time people spend sitting on their family couch of an evening — but what of the 50-60 hours per week the average American worker spends sitting on a chair at their job?</p><p>The scientific literature is full of studies that generally agree about the pervasive and negative physiological effects of sitting for long periods of time: women who sit for more than 6 hours a day <a href="http://aje.oxfordjournals.org/content/172/4/419.abstract">have a 40% higher </a>chance of death from <em>any</em> cause than those who do not, regardless of their overall activity level. In large population studies, long periods of sitting have been associated with increased risks for several types of terminal diseases, <a href="http://www.plosone.org/article/info%3Adoi%2F10.1371%2Fjournal.pone.0073753">including cancer</a>s. Even getting regular exercise, as recommended by doctors, <a href="http://jnci.oxfordjournals.org/content/106/7/dju098.full">does not undo</a> the damage caused by sitting on your ass all day long.</p><p>The human body evolved to move. A lot. Our natural posture is standing upright — we have long limbs and efficient cardiovascular systems that allow us to travel long distances on foot, and at some speed relative to many other creatures. We have giant blood vessels to provide blood to the powerful muscles in our legs; the femoral artery is so large that, if severed, a patient will bleed out and die within a couple of minutes without immediate medical help. To return all this blood to the heart and lungs, there are equally great veins, buried deep under the leg muscles. As you stand, move around, walk, or run, your leg muscles squeeze these veins, pushing all the used, oxygen-depleted blood up toward your heart for a round-trip to the lungs for oxygen reloading. When you sit down for long periods of time, your leg muscles relax, and blood begins to pool in these deep veins. This is why your legs still feel heavy and swollen after sitting at a desk all day, and it can lead to deep vein thrombosis, or even to pulmonary embolism or stroke.</p><p>Sitting down all day even has an effect on our bodies at the cellular level. Studies of fat cells (which, unsurprisingly, store fat for the body) show that when they are subjected to prolonged increases in pressure — such as sitting on them — <a href="http://ajpcell.physiology.org/content/302/2/C429">they produce more triglycerides</a>, and at an increased rate. In essence, simply sitting on your ass makes it produce and accumulate more of the fats that are associated with heart disease and stroke.</p><p><strong>I am never </strong>sitting down again. Not at a work desk anyway. It has been just over two months since I started using the standing desk, and I literally feel years younger. I sleep better. I no longer have a constant pain in my upper back from crouching over the computer screen. I have lost 12 lbs — I have to admit, I cheated on the scientific study of how this would work — after the first month of using the desk, I started jogging more often and for longer, because <em>I wanted to</em>. It no longer felt like a chore to work out. I feel stronger, not just in my legs, but all through the core of my body. I feel like I have had a whole new gear added that allows me to put down more power when running uphill, or sprint after a soccer ball. I feel taller, and my posture is noticeably straighter than before. I look, and I feel more confident.</p><p>People still drop by my office, but increasingly more often out of genuine interest than sideshow curiosity. A small number of people seem to come by every week or so, just to see how it is going, or to ask how I built it, or how they should approach their supervisor to try one out. I’ve had long discussions about compromise desk ideas — an adjustable sit/stand design, or a lean-to chair with a high desk. Some of the executive leadership still drops in for a snide remark and a chuckle at the weird person, but others have shown a genuine interest in the idea, and allowed me to mildly proselytize to them about how much it has improved my everyday life.</p><p>I am more productive now. My attention span has increased, and I’m able to mentally organize projects much better than before. I am more focused. I find that the ability to physically step back for a second, take a breath, and then launch right back into work, allows me to plow through difficult and complex tasks much faster <em>and</em> more accurately than before.</p><p>Also, my butt looks great in these jeans.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=d8d4da3fd95f" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/world-of-tomorrow/your-ass-is-killing-you-d8d4da3fd95f">Your Ass is Killing You</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/world-of-tomorrow">World of Tomorrow</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Science Forward: Indie Science]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/the-good-the-bad-and-the-science/science-forward-indie-science-81ed67807b3a?source=rss-852acdf3a0c1------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/81ed67807b3a</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Good Bad Science]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 24 Jun 2014 23:27:32 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2014-06-24T23:42:10.312Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>GoodBadScience talks to Dr Ethan Perlstein, Founder &amp; CEO of Perlstein Labs.</h4><p><strong>Dr Ethan Perlstein </strong>founded <a href="http://perlsteinlab.com/">Perlstein Labs</a> to investigate rare diseases, and to find novel therapies for them. GoodBadScience caught up with Dr Perlstein to talk about Independent Science, launching a biotech startup, entrepreneurship in science, and the future of the biotech economy.</p><p>What follows is an edited summary of our discussion. You can watch the whole interview <a href="http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vBTjIXv-Sk8"><strong>here</strong></a>.</p><p><strong>GoodBadScience: </strong>Tell us a little bit your research. What scientific questions are you interested in?</p><p><strong>Ethan Perlstein: </strong>Perlstein Labs is interested in orphan disease drug discovery: orphan diseases are also referred to as rare diseases — these are defined as illnesses that afflict 200,000 or fewer patients in the United States, with a similar threshold in Europe. These diseases have traditionally been neglected by both Academia and Pharma for the same reason — basically there’s just not enough money in it, either in terms of government research dollars or market value to attract pharmaceuticals to the space.</p><p>We’re trying to approach this problem from a different angle in a way that we hope that is both lean and capital efficient, but also scientifically valid and likely to generate more effective drugs.</p><p><strong>GoodBadScience: </strong>Perlstein Labs has somewhat of a new and unique business structure. Can you tell us a little bit about how Perlstein Labs operates?</p><p><strong>Ethan Perlstein: </strong>Because we’re working on the rare disease space, I realized that there was an opportunity to do something a little bit different here. In the early stage of company formation, I spent a lot of time with my brother, who is also an entrepreneur in a different space — he gave me the idea of a thing called a B-corp, or Benefit Corp. This is a different form of incorporation than maybe most people are familiar with; there’s only about a thousand in the world, with most of them in United States and some in Canada as well. Basically, it allows a company to be for-profit, but with a constitutional balance that shares the profitability with a social and environmental mission. I think it’s appropriate for the space we’re operating in.</p><p>Other than our organization’s social mission, we’re operating on the ground just like many other biotech start-ups. Although, I think culturally speaking, we have more open-science indie flair to it! We’re one of the first biotech B-corps out there — I hope it starts a trend.</p><p><strong>GoodBadScience:</strong> You’re one of the first, if not the first, to try this model. How did you attract start-up funding to actually get such a novel idea off the ground?</p><p><strong>Ethan Perlstein:</strong> I realized really early on that VCs weren’t going to be interested; most of them are just not interested in the really early stage stuff. That left angel investors, which is a very large category. These are people who have registered with the SEC as having over a certain amount of annual income, and so are allowed to invest freely in premarket companies. I knew that somehow we would have to find someone within this large body of angel investors. I had mostly ruled out grants and other ‘non-diluted’ funding from SBIR/STTR, because the grant cycle is just so long and the pay lines — the probability of getting funded — is not terribly high.</p><p>As I made the journey out of Academia into this new world, I used Twitter as a global support group, but it also allowed me the ability to network with people in a very targeted way; you can follow conversations within very specific communities, and begin to chime in when appropriate. I knew a lot of the people in the orphan disease space that were also accredited investors, and figured that those might also be the likely candidates for seed investors because they’ve got money, and they also have a personal interest in a rare disease. I think all the investors that we have in our seed round fit that category: where they have some kind of direct, personal connection to a rare disease.</p><p>I think that the fundraising part has been the most surprising, but also most gratifying. Although I only started fundraising at the beginning of this year, we’re closing out the seed round in a couple of weeks — that is definitely way faster than the time it would take to get an SBIR or some other seed grant funding that many people rely on.</p><p>Fundraising is a very difficult process, but it also incredibly rewarding. My advice for people who are looking for seed funding is that angel investors are the place to go. You need to realize it’s an 8-million person community, so you have to be really targeted about who are the kinds of people who are going to be seriously interested in funding something that you’re doing. It’s not just the fact that they have money — they also have some kind of pretty substantial connection to the topic your company will be investing in.</p><p><strong>GoodBadScience: </strong>Your investors, even though they’re already advocates for curing the diseases you’re studying — eventually they’re going to want to see a return on their investment. Could you tell us a little bit about how you plan to commercialize any discoveries you make in this lab? Are you going to be developing them yourself or are you looking to create more of a licensing model like Academia tends to?</p><p><strong>Ethan Perlstein: </strong>We want to try to do a hybrid model — in a lot of ways we’re already trying to hybridize the best elements of Academia and Industry. For us, the value proposition is a small molecule drug candidate. We’re a hybrid model in the sense that we’re going to take these small molecules that we discover and file patents for them. Because we’re using small model organisms to do screens, and screens can be done really quickly, we think we’re going to have an excess of candidates that we can’t develop internally. We will either develop individual molecules internally [after raising more money to do that], or because we think that we’re actually going to generate an excess of candidates, we’ll out-license to pharmaceutical partners who could take those candidates into clinical development with us.</p><p><strong>GoodBadScience:</strong> You are well-known for blogging pretty extensively about the state of the current job market for science PhDs. Do you think that this indie start-up model is something that’s widely applicable — or is it something that will only really be relevant for a few people like yourself with a very unique set of skills?</p><p><strong>Ethan Perlstein: </strong>If you listen to my critics (or even my haters!), I’m just some freak out there who is an <em>n </em>of one. I don’t believe that. Do I think it’s completely generalized at this stage? No. I think there are certain personality types, or certain personal circumstances, or certain scientific research areas, and it’s a confluence of all those factors that is most likely succeed within an indie start-up model.</p><p>I think “indie” can be better defined culturally as opposed to as a business model <em>per se. </em>We’re getting investors and they’re giving us money in exchange for shares or equity — that’s pretty traditional. But I think the types of investors we have is very different to the kinds of investors you would see in other kinds of biotech start-ups. It is in practice and in culture where I think the indie part comes out. There are definitely already other indie scientists out there that I have come across, but not much in the biomedical space. You tend to see them more in ecology and other sorts of non-medical spaces, but they certainly exist.</p><p>I’m hopeful that other people will start experimenting and that they put their own individual stamp on what they call “indie”, and then eventually we will probably see some kind of consensus emerge around best practices. But in this early stage, I think it’s a good thing to see all ideas that people come up with.</p><p><strong>GoodBadScience: </strong>What would your advice be for a recent graduate, or someone who’s stuck in an endless postdoc, and wants to try going the indie science route? What kind of key skills should they be developing? What kind of support is out there for people trying to do something on their own for the first time?</p><p><strong>Ethan Perlstein:</strong> I think it could start really simple. There’s a lot of folks, a part of generation “postdocalypse” who have not worked outside of Academia, and may not even have an understanding of what options are out there.</p><p>What worked for me was that I had a part time consulting gig that helped me land on my feet and helped me deploy some of the skills that I had acquired. It made me feel good about myself after the rejection of Academia which really feels like kind of intellectual rejection of <em>you. </em>There’s really no other way to spin it — it was nice to be able to work on something that was different than I’ve done before, but where people valued my effort and paid me to do it! Then of course, I was also lucky to do this in the context of a young start-up [<a href="http://experiment.com/">Experiment.com</a>] where I got to see company formation in action — I saw a group go from two co-founders to their core team, to closing out their first round, to trying to maintain their week-over-week metrics. That was really invaluable to really just see with my own eyes how another startup company was doing this.</p><p>I guess what I would say is to start small, and I think consulting is catch-all phrase and there’s a lot of ways you can do that. Recently, I’ve heard people talk about micro-jobs. Perlstein Labs uses a virtual lab manager called <a href="http://www.happilabs.org/">HappiLabs</a>, and they’ve been talking recently about creating micro-jobs where trainees (post-docs, residents, etc.) work on very specific focused projects, to give them to get a taste for a timetable, deliverables, project management, stuff like that. I think there are definitely examples and you can find a lot of this on Twitter — folks who are putting out not exactly recipes, but their stories of how they found their consulting gig. People just need to do a little bit of digging, but I think they’ll immediately find there’s a broad community of folks who are trying to do this.</p><p><strong>GoodBadScience:</strong> Perlstein Labs is located in the QB3 incubator — what kind of support has that been able to provide you in lowering the barriers to create your own business? What could other cities learn from what is happening up in the Bay Area with the various bio incubators?</p><p><strong>Ethan Perlstein:</strong> There are QB3 incubators across the Bay Area including Berkeley and the East Bay; that has definitely opened up possibilities for us to be capital efficient. For us, that means incubators, the ability to rent per bench, rent per office, or per desk. This definitely keeps down our burn-rate because we don’t have to worry about getting our own 5,000 square foot or so facility or lab. We have basically one long bench — five of us work in a room, which is perfect for us to prove our concept. Being in QB3 and being able to incubate has been invaluable to what we’re doing, and allowed us to raise an initial $2 million investment round instead of having to raise $10 million or $15 million.</p><p>We also save quite a bit in terms of having access to communal equipment and other aspects of communal science here, meaning that we don’t have to buy things we otherwise would for a large, standalone lab. The other piece I would say is that not just the incubation facility itself, but the fact that we could avail ourselves of sourcing through QB3’s partners. We use <a href="http://scienceexchange.com/">Science Exchange</a>, which is an online marketplace for matching people who need experiments done, with facilities that can supply those experiments. We’ve used them to contract with core facilities to do some work for us, so we can keep things running along.</p><p>What can other cities do to emulate this? That’s a great question. I think what’s interesting about QB3 is that the facility where we’re at is the sixth in the succession of incubators that they started years ago. It’s clear that they learned from each generation. For other cities, the recipes are there for seeing how you could setup an incubator, what services they should provide, price points, and stuff like that.</p><p>Boston is already doing this, and San Diego as well. When it comes to those cities that are smaller bioclusters like Seattle, Chicago, LA — what can these cities learn? That’s really going to be key. All of them have great institutions of higher learning. All of them are producing professionally trained life scientists. Is there a critical mass? I don’t know. You can ask why there aren’t more biotech VC dollars flowing to these other towns as well. I think there’s a lot of things that these other cities face in terms of challenges. The big bioclusters are already doing what’s happening here [in San Francisco]. I think ultimately the model has to be able to be exported to other cities.</p><p><strong>GoodBadScience: </strong>One final question, where can we hope to see Perlstein Labs in 5 to 10 years’ time? What’s your ultimate goal?</p><p><strong>Ethan Perlstein:</strong> People talk about the 100-year company, and although it’s kind of grandiose for me to be saying this in such an early stage of company formation, that concept resonates with me. I don’t want to just create a company that I flip in a couple of years; that’s partly why I put my family name on it. I think that’s a signal, an intentional signal I want to send, that I want to build something of value that my team is going to make possible. It really is all about the team.</p><p>I think the long term goal for us is to eventually go down the IPO path as opposed to the merger-acquisition path. It would be foolish of me to predict too much into the future. But that is the long term vision, to build a company of value.</p><p>The fact is, we’re trying to build a platform that could address potentially thousands of diseases — that’s going to keep us occupied for some amount of time. Most other biotech start-ups focus around one asset or set of candidates; either those succeed, or they flail and the game is over. For us, there’s a huge space of orphan diseases — we’re trying to build a platform to address this. That already is putting us in the five- to ten-year time frame.</p><p>Thank you so much for having me and I hope this generates a discussion. Anyone who wants to follow up they can find me on Twitter: <a href="http://twitter.com/@eperlste">@eperlste</a>.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=81ed67807b3a" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/the-good-the-bad-and-the-science/science-forward-indie-science-81ed67807b3a">Science Forward: Indie Science</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/the-good-the-bad-and-the-science">The Good The Bad and The Science</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Illusion of Safety]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@GoodBadSci/the-illusion-of-control-448e282bcddf?source=rss-852acdf3a0c1------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/448e282bcddf</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Good Bad Science]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 21 Jun 2014 14:13:49 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2014-06-22T02:11:05.393Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>How a false belief in control undermines human progress</h4><p><strong>I can’t remember</strong> the first time I heard about the Precautionary Principle. Maybe it was back in school. Whenever it was, it seemed to make a lot of sense at the time, only less so the longer I thought about it.</p><p>After two centuries of industrial pollution, this principle — the idea that an action has to prove it is <em>not </em>harmful to the public or environment before it is permissible — became a powerful and persuasive policy instrument for governments, becoming legally enshrined in the UN’s <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/World_Charter_for_Nature">World Charter for Nature</a> in 1982. It has since been incorporated into numerous international treaties and agreements, including the <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Montreal_Protocol">Montreal Protocol</a>, <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rio_Declaration">Rio Declaration</a> and <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kyoto_Protocol">Kyoto Protocol</a>.</p><p>It made sense that after decades of industrial pollution, ecological damage, unsustainable hunting and harvesting, and trade in ineffective and dangerous “medicines”, to insist that companies take responsibility for the safety and environmental impact of their products. But is it reasonable, or even possible to anticipate and plan for every risk? What risks are foreseeable, and what is genuinely unknowable?</p><p><strong>The Science </strong>of toxicology is a highly reliable tool for determining the exact level of biological damage a particular chemical can cause. By using highly standardized methodologies and meticulous controls, a well-managed toxicology lab will determine the specific dose of a substance that will cause significant damage to an animal, plant, or biological system.</p><p>When a pharmaceutical company invents a new drug candidate, it is put through a wide battery of tests to determine whether it is safe enough for the FDA to approve its use in patients. A toxicology lab will determine the lethal dose for the chemical using cell-based and animal models to ensure that the drug does not risk damage to patients within the dose range that it will be used at therapeutically. A key principle in this process , in the words of the 16th Century German chemist Paracelsus, is “<em>Alle Dinge sind Gift und nichts ist ohne Gift; allein die Dosis macht, dass ein Ding kein Gift ist.” —</em> “All things are poison and nothing is without poison; only the dose makes a thing not a poison.”. That is, <strong><em>every</em></strong><em> </em>substance is toxic — at a certain dose. Many of the over-the-counter medicines we use regularly can be highly damaging, even lethal, if used at super-therapeutic doses, or for longer periods than is recommended. Even herbal and other organic remedies obey this principle — only there is no FDA to ensure safety precautions for “natural” substances and establish maximum safe doses.</p><p>Despite this broad and meticulous testing regime, drugs that turn out to have damaging effects in patients, even at the recommended “safe” dose, are sometimes still approved for use . Why should this be, if the drug has been through such a meticulous series of tests before it is approved? What is missing in this system, founded in the philosophy of the precautionary principle with all its oversight and regulation, that sometimes lets lethal drugs slip through the process and hurt some of the patients they were designed to cure?</p><blockquote>The art of predicting the future is being able to know what is unknowable.</blockquote><p><strong>Humans are</strong> notoriously bad at predicting the future, with a success rate that falls to virtually zero within just a few decades. This isn&#39;t because we are not naturally gifted in reading patterns and interpreting trends — it is this very ability that underpins our intellectual ability to invent agriculture and live in complex societies. It is the unforeseen variables that cause our predictions to falter — and these inaccuracies accumulate rapidly as time progresses.</p><p>A pre-industrial farmer would have benefited from their years of experience and careful observations of nature to predict when the rainy season will come, and when the crops will blossom — but they could not possibly have known about the once-in-a-century storm that was barreling towards them in the ages before radar and satellite meteorology. Even with all the tools and technologies of modern atmospheric science, our weather forecasts are still only most-probable models for what is likely to occur over the following few days — there are just too many variables with unknown effects to render a truly accurate forecast.</p><p>This is how dangerous products are able to enter the marketplace, even in such highly-regulated industries as pharmaceuticals. Toxicology labs are very effective at determining whether a substance is poisonous to a particular system or tissue — but they can only find problems that they look for. It is often the unforeseen, the unexpected problem in some random other tissue, or in a small subgroup of patients, or that only manifests itself only after several years, that no one even imagined would ever be an issue, which causes harm to patients. If all reasonable measures have been taken to ensure the drug is safe, is it really the manufacturer’s fault if it turns out to have a dangerous flaw that was not picked up in testing?</p><p>Strict adherence to the precautionary principle would then insist on doing <em>every </em>test imaginable, on <em>every </em>new substance, before it is allowed into the marketplace, just to be sure. Even then, we cannot be sure to have accounted for every possible effect a chemical might have — only the ones that we currently have effective tests for. With average drug development costs already estimated at $1 Billion over a period of 10 years — predominantly in the safety/efficacy clinical testing phase — it seems that taking a “safer” approach would not much help this situation.</p><p><strong>A common </strong>criticism of the precautionary principle is that it would have prevented development of both fire and the wheel. This is quite true, but a more central flaw is its total dependence on the hubris that people can anticipate and mitigate all the possible dangers associated with an action before allowing it to happen.</p><p>It is important that we take all reasonable steps to protect the fragile environment in which we live, and limit the amounts of hazardous drugs and chemicals that we expose our bodies to. However, as long as uncertainty exists in the Universe, we will never be able to anticipate every possible outcome for good or ill. Even with every safety test in the world, every precaution, every law to protect us from ourselves, tragedies will still happen, because they are unpredictable.</p><blockquote>As for me, all I know is that I know nothing — <em>Socrates</em></blockquote><p>One of the only certainties in life is that unexpected things will happen. We can and should take all reasonable measures to make sure that the drugs we take are safe, and our industries do not poison the environment. However, the biggest risk to our future is imagining that we can predict every problem and mitigate every risk. We should not pretend that we can anticipate and account for every eventuality — and to try to do so would drive up the costs of innovation so high that technological progress stalls. Civilizations constantly rise and fall, and stagnation is not a good prognosis for their future.</p><p>No activity of mankind can happen without affecting the world around us in some way — and this is just as true for traditional societies as it is industrial ones. “Leave no trace” is not a realistic option for civilization. We are part of nature, not separate from it. Our job therefore is to minimize our impacts on the delicate environment that we live in, not pretend that we can withdraw from it into a safety bubble of our own imagination.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=448e282bcddf" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[A Machine with a Soul]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/the-good-the-bad-and-the-science/the-machine-with-a-soul-484b0ed8b816?source=rss-852acdf3a0c1------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/484b0ed8b816</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Good Bad Science]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 14 Jun 2014 14:11:37 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2014-06-14T19:47:57.197Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Does passing the Turing test bestow a computer with consciousness? And what would we do if it does?</h4><p><strong>On </strong>an otherwise unremarkable Saturday in June 2014, a group of computer scientists, public figures, and celebrities gathered at London’s Royal Society. They were all there for one reason — to engage in a text-based chat game to determine if a computer could pass the “iconic” Turing test.</p><p>A few hours later, the results were in. Professor Warwick of Reading University announced that a chatbot had successfully tricked 33% of the judges into thinking it was a real boy, and had therefore become the first computer to have passed the Turing test:</p><blockquote>It is fitting that such an important landmark has been reached at the Royal Society in London, the home of British science and the scene of many great advances in human understanding over the centuries. This milestone will go down in history as one of the most exciting. — <em>Prof. Kevin Warwick</em></blockquote><p>Within hours, breathless tweets, likes and pins swept across the internet, announcing this amazing result to the world, or at least across the subculture that apparently really f***ing loves science, but doesn&#39;t seem to have much time or inclination toward actual critical analysis. A day or so later came the rebuttals and debunkings from the more inquisitive corners of the online universe. So what really happened, and what does a machine passing a Turing test mean for society?</p><p><strong>In 1950</strong>, mathematical pioneer and legendary code-breaker <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alan_Turing">Alan Turing</a> published a paper entitled “<a href="http://www.loebner.net/Prizef/TuringArticle.html">Computing Machinery and Intelligence</a>”. Turing proposed to address how it could be possible to answer the question “Can machines think?” — that is, how would we test whether a super-intelligent computer could independently create and express its own original ideas in a manner equivalent to humans.</p><p>In this paper, Turing proposed a test that he called “The Imitation Game” : in this game, two subjects — a man and a woman — take part in a text-based conversation with an interrogator. The goal for the interrogator is to determine which of the subjects is the man, and which is the woman. In Turing’s experiment, the Man’s goal is to deceive the interrogator, but the Woman’s is to help them. Turing reasoned that, for the Man to successfully imitate a woman requires abstract and creative thought, a knowledge of social norms and rules, and an ability to integrate complex imaginary geographical and social histories into his answers.</p><p>Turing then proposes to replace the male subject with a computer — would a machine be able to beat the interrogator as often as the human male was able to? If so, then it could be concluded that the machine had achieved a level of original “thinking” comparable to a human.</p><p><strong>At the Royal Society</strong>, “Eugene Goostman’’, a 13-year old boy from Ukraine had been busy. As a participant in the test, he was engaged in 30 different five-minute text conversations with the celebrities and scientists that made up the panel of event judges. At the end of the day, 11 out of the 30 judges who talked to Eugene thought he was a real young man from Eastern Europe. The majority 19 interviewers who realized that Eugene was, in fact, a very well-programmed computer were probably alerted to the fact by a series of evasive answers, awkward linguistic phrasing, and very limited social knowledge displayed by Eugene.</p><p>Nevertheless, the organizers declared that Eugene had passed the Turing test by deceiving more than 1 in 3 of the judges — a hypothetical threshold Turing had proposed in his thought experiment (but nowhere close to the 95% confidence level that most scientific studies are measured by). Turing’s experiment had also required the interrogator determining which of two subjects — one human, one a computer — was human; at the Royal Society, Eugene Goostman was interrogated in isolation, with the judges making a yes/no determination as to whether he was human or not. Even if Turing’s 1/3 success rate could be validated, it would not be applicable to this experiment because it recorded a fundamentally different output from the judges.</p><p>Ultimately, Eugene Goostman was able to beat the Turing test because Eugene Goostman was specifically designed to beat the Turing test. The persona of a teenage subject, a non-native English speaker, gave cover to its limitations in conducting a live conversation; enough judges were tricked into ignoring the machine’s shortcomings by the illusion that it was a linguistically-challenged young person with limited social skills and knowledge.</p><p>Turing proposed this experiment as a way to test whether a machine could think for itself. The purpose of the Turing test is to assess creative, integrated strategic thinking that is the hallmark of human consciousness. By gaming the way that the test was assessed, reducing it to textual trickery, the experiment at the Royal Society was a superb demonstration of programming finesse, but did not shed any new light on the feasibility of genuine artificial consciousness.</p><p><strong>What if </strong>a computer did<strong> </strong>pass a true Turing test, as originally envisioned by Alan Turing ? Would the ability of a computer to successfully imitate a human such that another human can not tell them apart be a true test of “thinking”, or just a really awesome, high-tech parlor trick?</p><p>Turing’s understanding of mathematics, coding, and the possibilities for artificial intelligence were far ahead of his time. However, his understanding of the human mind and cognition were firmly rooted in the age he lived in. After all, this was a man who struggled deeply with depression, in large part due to the prevailing “wisdom” of his time that his homosexuality was a deviant behavior — eventually accepting chemical castration as a “cure”, thanks to the primitive assumption that male sexuality was as simple as a testosterone-driven desire that could only be sated through sex (and therefore cured by cutting off the flow of hormones by destroying the testes).</p><p>In Turing’s time of the early 1950s, neuroscience had barely moved on from the phrenology and charlatan psychotherapists of the Victorian age. What little was understood of mental function was mostly derived from certain brain-injured patients, and our cellular understanding of neuronal processing was limited to a few electrical experiments using squid and sea slugs. Today, we understand human consciousness as part of a continuous stream of signalling that occurs in every part of the brain, all the time. While some activities such as visual processing or movement are coordinated from discrete regions of the cerebral cortex, the totality of a person’s mental existence comes from a global integration of signaling across the billions of nerve cells in the brain. While some still speculate that this or that particular section of cortex is the seat of the mind or self, it is usually thanks to a narrow definition that allows consciousness to be artificially simplified to a limited trait, such as self-awareness or integrated memory retrieval.</p><p>In many ways, the original Turing test reflects the simplistic understanding of human thought that existed in the 1950s — that imitating a human to the extent that it could successfully be mistaken for one represents confirmation that a computer “thinks” for itself. A well-controlled Turing test given to a computer [that was not specifically programmed to pass the Turing test] might turn out to be an excellent benchmark for the development of integrated, creative and original strategic calculation, but is unlikely to answer the complex questions of self-awareness, autonomy, or individuality that are central to our understanding of “consciousness”.</p><p>Conversely, a dog is unlikely to ever pass a Turing test — but most dog owners would agree that they have consciousness and agency of their own.</p><p><strong>In many ways</strong>, the experiment at the Royal Society epitomizes our civilization’s schizophrenic relationship with science and technology. This is far from the only example of a “scientific” event that was more focused on grabbing headlines and publicity for technology, rather than a rigorous examination of its veracity. In a society that seeks heroes and superstars for worship, we elevate figures like Turing, Einstein, and Tesla to almost superhuman status — and Turing’s very real suffering at the hands of primitively-minded authorities only serves to exacerbate his status as a martyr to the cause. Our understanding of science as a deliberate, exact examination of the Universe has been supplanted by an Instagram-ready hunger for stunning imagery and witty non-sequiteurs to be deployed against unbelievers.</p><p>Our obsession with data, but not with its rigorous scientific examination, has led us to a world where it is too easy to lose sight of our real goals. As companies and governments find more effective ways to track their progress against benchmark metrics, it is all too easy to forget the real goals of a project and simply work on maximizing the metric scores — leading to schools “teaching to the test”, or hospitals <a href="http://www.nationaljournal.com/defense/fbi-joins-investigation-into-va-wait-times-20140611">minimizing [reported] waiting times</a> at the expense of delivering effective care, among many other sad examples. Similarly, by creating a machine designed to “win” at the Turing test through misdirection and obfuscation, we lose sight of the diligent work of thousands of people who seek to understand how to make machines smarter, more responsive, and better able to respond to people’s needs.</p><p><strong>As artificial intelligence </strong>becomes more and more a part of our lives, it is quite conceivable that we will someday need an effective Turing test to tell humans apart from machines. If computers were to develop real consciousness, self-awareness, and agency, then we would have to answer serious questions about our relationship with them. Does real consciousness bestow rights, such as the right to live? If so, could you then “murder” a computer? What consists the essence of the conscious computer — the hardware or the software? Would synthetic beings be treated as a special class, akin to apes or whales — not equal with humans, but legally protected from unnecessary killing and experimental treatments? In this scenario, would a “robot rights” movement emerge to challenge their second-class treatment by humans?</p><p>The world is changing rapidly. Disparate societies are more interconnected than ever, and systems are ever more autonomous. As our machinery develops higher levels of consciousness, our relationship with it changes. In order to remain masters of our own destiny, humans must ask the hard questions about our relationships with technology — and ask them scientifically — in order to stay ahead of ourselves. To do otherwise is to surrender to assumption, superstition, and decline.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=484b0ed8b816" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/the-good-the-bad-and-the-science/the-machine-with-a-soul-484b0ed8b816">A Machine with a Soul</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/the-good-the-bad-and-the-science">The Good The Bad and The Science</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Can You Afford to Live Forever?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/world-of-tomorrow/can-you-afford-to-live-forever-eea0d665a146?source=rss-852acdf3a0c1------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/eea0d665a146</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Good Bad Science]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 07 Jun 2014 13:56:40 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2014-06-07T13:56:40.728Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Medical progress upends the social structure of society.</h4><p><strong>There is</strong> a TV commercial where the host gives a bunch of ‘regular folks’ a ribbon to represent the total value of their savings, and they then dutifully walk outward from the center of a marked circle to visualize how their financial cushion will last for just a few years after retirement. One woman quips “I’m going to have to rethink this thing”, when the ribbon representing her life savings runs out at just around 70. The implication of the ad is that most people have not saved enough for a 30+ year-long retirement, and therefore need to pay this company to help them better manage their finances. The assumption they convey is that most people will live to somewhere between 80 and 100, and so need to save enough to cover their living expenses for about 20—30 years of retirement.</p><p>Retirement planning is a poster child example of the limits of economic forecasting in any long-term plan; the average retirement timespan in industrialized countries is already approaching the total length of the average working life of an adult, and the mathematics of the system are starting to break down. Public and private pension funds have repeatedly collapsed or been bailed-out over the past few years across major economies around the world. Part of this is due to mismanagement and overly optimistic assumptions about risk and returns. However, the biggest flaw in these schemes is that they have already had to pay out benefits to far more people than they had planned for, and for much longer, as contributing workers who were originally expected to survive for 5-15 years past retirement are living well into their 80s, 90s, and beyond. The depletion of funds’ principal through unexpectedly high outlays diminishes their investment opportunities, creating a death spiral for the fund as more and more benefits are distributed to older and sicker retirees, and the remaining principal is more limited in its potential to generate positive returns.</p><p><strong>Scientist Aubrey de Grey</strong> of the <a href="http://sens.org/">SENS Foundation</a> has famously claimed that the first humans to live to 1,000 years old may <a href="http://www.ted.com/talks/aubrey_de_grey_says_we_can_avoid_aging">have already been born</a>. The increase in longevity over the past hundred years or so, when average life expectancy <a href="http://www.infoplease.com/ipa/A0005140.html">almost doubled</a> over a single century, can be attributed in large part to improved nutrition, to the discovery of antibiotics and rapid development of vaccines, as well as our increased ability to repair and replace damaged body parts following injury or disease. The major historical causes of death: hunger, disease, and injury, are now much more survivable than they have ever been, and many of us already live long into historical old age.</p><p>As medical technology continues to make progress against the new killer diseases of aging humans — cancer and heart disease — we can expect to see more and more people living well past the century mark in the very near future. Studies have shown that the group of people who currently live to extreme old age (over 100) <a href="http://www.sciencecodex.com/place_and_cause_of_death_in_centenarians_a_populationbased_observational_study_in_england-134936">more often die of pneumonia or extreme frailty</a>, rather than cancer and ischemic heart disease that are the biggest killers of elderly adults under 100 years old, promising an end to the scourge of these diseases once they can be overcome in middle age. The rapid development of prosthetic limbs and organs will help to replace the parts that cannot be repaired with medicine. These technologies, together with lifestyle <a href="http://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2014/05/140505104221.htm">robot assistance</a>, will allow aging people to live more independently, turning old age from a senescence to be managed, into a treatable long-term condition. Advancements in stem cell technology and our understanding of genetic information management inside cells promise a future where we are able to manage the cellular turnover and health of non-replaceable body parts, such as our brains. Once we overcome this hurdle, possibly within a century, we will truly stand on the threshold of biological immortality, where the only remaining threat to our lives is extreme trauma.</p><p><strong>How much </strong>will you need to save for your retirement? Is it even possible to save enough during a 40 year or so working life to support a lifetime of 50 — 100 years after a retirement? As human lifespan approaches the level of biological immortality, then the amount of savings required to support a person’s lifestyle consequently approaches infinity. Economics as understood by early 21st Century mortals is insufficient to account for the life and health of immortal human beings. If we are to live for ever, then we will need a better financial plan.</p><p>Current retirement models are already outdated. Just as the pensions of the latter 20th Century mistook the average retirement of its members as a period of 5-10 years, rather than the reality of 20-30 years, most current financial models used to calculate workers’ retirement savings assume that this timespan has plateaued at around 30 years. Given that current young professionals won’t even reach retirement age for another three decades, it seems highly implausible that medical progress and aging research will stall for this entire period, leaving current workers with no realistic hope for a greater lifespan than their parents. It would seem far more likely that current young workers, who have already benefited from decades of improved nutrition and healthcare, can expect to live far longer into extreme old age than their parents.</p><p>In an age of immortality, it seems likely we would have to reconsider the very idea of retirement. Advancements toward permanent biological maintenance are heavily intertwined with technologies to improve the function of aging bodies. As we reach a state of biological immortality, our next goal would surely be to make that eternity physically tolerable, if not comfortable and productive. If we could remain productive for all time, then would we need to retire at all? The very idea of retirement was developed in the late 19th Century to provide workers who reached old age with a small level of comfort in the few years they could expect to live once they were no longer able to be economically productive. If our productivity could be maintained in perpetuity, then the foundation of the concept of retirement itself is questionable.</p><p><strong>An era </strong>when humans will live for an extremely long time, even forever, is closer than many of us would imagine. Once we reach a state where we can overcome our mortality, we also find ourselves in a place where fundamental assumptions about economics no longer hold. Just as when we reach a stage where food can be easily produced beyond the needs of all humans, overcoming biological death represents the beginning of a post-scarcity civilization that upsets the very essence of supply-and-demand by providing essentially infinite supply. Workers who never grow frail and die would no longer need to be replaced — but this would limit opportunities for new generations until new occupations could be developed.</p><p>How would we be compensated for work in an economy where labor supply is unlimited? In a Universe where we were not bound by the pressure of our mortality, how would people motivate to get things done when there is <em>always </em>tomorrow? The only thing we know for sure is that every economic system so far devised is flawed, and none is capable of coping with a vastly different world where humans could live for ever. The future will come to us whether we wish it to or not, and so the time to consider these things is now, unless the shock of its realization causes terminal chaos. Perhaps a good place to start is in the minds of those who try to imagine how <a href="https://medium.com/medium-long/the-economics-of-star-trek-29bab88d50">post-scarcity civilizations might function</a>.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=eea0d665a146" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/world-of-tomorrow/can-you-afford-to-live-forever-eea0d665a146">Can You Afford to Live Forever?</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/world-of-tomorrow">World of Tomorrow</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Tell Me A Lie]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/the-good-the-bad-and-the-science/tell-me-a-lie-5e8d81603eaf?source=rss-852acdf3a0c1------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/5e8d81603eaf</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Good Bad Science]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 31 May 2014 14:22:11 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2014-05-31T14:22:11.905Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>The Sometimes Scientific Quest for Telling the Truth</h4><p><strong>The young gentleman</strong> on the <a href="http://www.mauryshow.com/">Maury Show</a> is looking uncomfortable. He shuffles uncomfortably in his seat as the genial Maury Povich reads aloud the results of his recent polygraph test to the audience in the studio, who dutifully greet each new result with a hearty chorus of boos.</p><blockquote>You told the Lie Detector that you did not sleep with Tiffany’s best friend, Candace.</blockquote><blockquote>The Lie Detector determined <strong>that</strong> was a lie.</blockquote><p>More booing. Tiffany, a heavy-set young woman sitting in the next seat along, jumps to her feet and screams a continual stream of expletives at the young man that lasts for at least a minute. The censorious *bleep* edit will be working overtime on this episode. An immense bodyguard effortlessly holds her back as she flails madly around him with her fists, trying to make contact with the young man’s face. Eventually, she gives up and storms off the stage, a mobile camera crew hot in pursuit as she flees backstage to the Green Room.</p><p><strong>The ability</strong> to differentiate the truth from lies has been the most basic challenge for law-keepers since the very beginning of society. If a criminal is able to deceive their way out of trouble, then not only does the original ill-deed go without justice, but all society is at risk as the offender lives out their destructive life with a sense of impunity.</p><p>For most of history, the focus of an interrogator was to force a suspect or witness into telling the truth. Naturally, this led to the use of many and various forms of torture which, apart from being inhumanely barbarous, have the unfortunate effect of making people confess to crimes that they are completely innocent of. As the rise of industrial civilization led to the creation of professional police forces in urban cities, more formalized and effective methods of questioning were developed that would allow the police to catch a suspect in a lie by challenging their account with logic and evidence. However, a skillful criminal who adequately covered their tracks could still often escape justice, especially in the days before modern forensic science.</p><p>The rapid development of neuroscience during the early 20th Century led to the idea that a machine might be created that would be able to distinguish whether a subject was telling the truth or not. In 1921, John Augustus Larson, who was oddly both a medical student and police officer in Berkeley, California, invented the modern polygraph test. Larson reasoned that the mental creation and maintenance of a lie was more stressful than simply telling the truth. Therefore, by monitoring several key physiological aspects including blood pressure, pulse, and skin conductivity, an examiner might be able to spot a subject in the act of a lie. A telltale increase in sweating and heart rate would indicate an increase in the subject’s stress level as they struggled to mentally process the tangled fiction of the lie that they were concocting.</p><p>Larson’s invention caught on, and in the 90 years since, polygraphs have assisted in the processing of many thousands of criminal cases, high-security clearance tests, and episodes of The Maury Show.</p><p><strong>There is</strong> <strong>one</strong> problem with the polygraph test — it doesn&#39;t actually work. Despite decades of use in the field, the machine’s effectiveness cannot be scientifically substantiated, and it is not widely considered allowable in courts as evidence. The National Academies of Sciences found in 2003 that the majority of polygraph research that had been done to date was “<a href="http://www.nap.edu/openbook.php?isbn=0309084369">unreliable, unscientific and biased</a>”. It is well known that there are <a href="http://www.wikihow.com/Cheat-a-Polygraph-Test-%28Lie-Detector%29">established techniques to cheat</a> the test — as the polygraph essentially measures physiological stress as a corollary for lying, a skilled liar can easily pass the test by maintaining calm and focus.</p><p><em>If polygraphs are so unreliable, then why are they still used? </em>Although they are not a reliable scientific method to establish for sure whether or not a subject is being truthful, polygraphs are still very useful as an investigative tool. Among the best-established interrogative methods for outing a liar is to unsettle the subject, to mislead them into thinking that the interrogator knows a truth that will ultimately uncover their lie anyway. The theater of the polygraph can have a powerful effect on the weak-minded — like a voodoo curse, it only works if the recipient thinks it does. A focused, relaxed subject may be able to beat the test, but its very use is often enough to induce the unsuspecting into confessing the truth.</p><p><strong>The development</strong> of functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) allows scientists to look into the biochemical environment inside the brain, and determine which areas become more or less active during a given task. Recalling an artificial memory or creating a fictional story will cause increased activity in slightly different areas of the brain than recalling a true memory, as they require distinct mental processes. Conducting an interview with a subject inside a fMRI scanner <a href="http://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/14789940903220676#.U4jI4xVX-uY">might then be a more reliable</a> means of establishing whether they are being truthful or not.</p><p>Of course, fMRI machines are huge, power-hungry, million-dollar pieces of equipment that require extensive shielding to prevent their massive electromagnets from frying any nearby electronics, so it’s unlikely that we would see them deployed to every urban police department any time soon. There is also the consideration over how and when it would be appropriate to use such an invasive tool in an investigative setting — looking directly into the brain activity of a person without their consent or very good reason indeed might be considered overly intrusive by many a court of law.</p><p>Is it possible that some inventor will create a micro-fMRI scanner that could be portable and energy efficient? There is no fundamental scientific problem that would prevent such a device, once considerations such as power consumption and magnet strength could be overcome at smaller scales. Perhaps it might also be possible to better interpret electrical signals around the brain (such as an EEG) to extrapolate a model of the brain’s internal functioning. Would these be reasonable investigative tools, or an intrusive violation of a suspect’s basic civil rights? Should the inner workings of the human mind, the final sanctuary of our individuality, be off-limits to investigators?</p><p><strong>Any test</strong> that requires human interpretation can be biased. No matter how high-tech the test’s technical underpinnings, as long as a human being is responsible for determining the outcome, then it will always have a flawed quality of individual judgement built-in. If a more advanced lie detector test in the future is ever to be considered reliable, it will need to operate and analyze its data autonomously. To be considered accurate and reliable, it would also need to be extensively validated by experts other than the police or prosecutors it will serve.</p><p>Ultimately, even with the best of tools and a free hand to use them, we will only ever be able to find out if a subject <strong><em>thinks</em></strong> they are telling a true and accurate account of what occurred. Human memory is <a href="http://blogs.scientificamerican.com/observations/2011/08/04/4-things-most-people-get-wrong-about-memory/">far from accurate</a>, and so by itself is still an unreliable witness to the truth, regardless of how expert we grow able to harvest it from the minds of others.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=5e8d81603eaf" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/the-good-the-bad-and-the-science/tell-me-a-lie-5e8d81603eaf">Tell Me A Lie</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/the-good-the-bad-and-the-science">The Good The Bad and The Science</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Lemony-Fresh Scent of Death]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/the-good-the-bad-and-the-science/the-lemony-fresh-scent-of-death-9c2eb20f4901?source=rss-852acdf3a0c1------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/9c2eb20f4901</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Good Bad Science]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 24 May 2014 13:08:41 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2014-05-27T23:55:40.523Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>What’s in a Smell Anyway?</h4><p>There were two rogue ants in the bathroom to begin with. Scuttling along the back of the sink, they seemed so innocuous that they were easily ignored. Within a day, dozens of their comrades would be running a trail from behind the cabinet, along the edge where the bathtub meets the floor, and into a small crack in the far corner of the tile work that surrounds it.</p><p>As the Santa Ana winds strengthened over the following days, bringing dry, searing heat to southern California, more and more ants began to find their way into the house. Driven inside by the roasting sun outside, or just in search of food made scarce by the continuing drought, they came in their thousands. The trusty barrier of cinnamon dust that runs under the steps by the kitchen door had been breached, and the colony had somehow established a masthead inside the house.</p><p>The initial battles were a one-sided war of attrition. As the ants appeared in a new room, running a trail from one crack to another, the scouts were squashed, the trails cleaned up with detergent. Barriers of natural ant repellents: baking soda, cinnamon, cloves, and cayenne pepper, were deployed around known points of entry. Eventually though, we would go to sleep. The ants would not.</p><p>By Day Three, we were on the run. Even as our rudimentary defenses had held in the bathroom, pushing the enemy back into its bastions below the walls, the ants had established multiple inroads into the kitchen. From a staging post behind the dishwasher, they were able to reach the cabinetry, and the boxes of sugar within. They had reached their goal; our defenses had fallen, and the rest of our food seemed within their grasp.</p><p>Sometimes, the only way out of a corner is to fight. Our failed defenses had been based on a desire to avoid collateral damage. To minimize unnecessary exposure of ourselves and our pets to harmful chemicals by using more natural methods — at worst, some detergent to clear up the ants’ own chemical trails. But now, the unnecessary had become necessary. We would strike back mercilessly with the most effective means at our disposal. Nothing short of total victory would be enough to save our home from the invasion, and we would not rest until the ants were driven out entirely, by any means necessary.</p><p>In the 1960s, American farmers were struggling to keep up with the food demands of a booming population following the end of World War II. Innovations in intensive farming, aided in part by new chemical fertilizers, promised to dramatically increase productivity. However, intensively farmed crops were more vulnerable to losses from pests and infection. Widespread spraying of DDT had been largely effective in wiping out malaria in Europe and North America, but questions were already beginning to be asked about its safety and effects on the environment. In fact, DDT’s <a href="http://www.fws.gov/contaminants/info/ddt.html">harmful effects</a> on wildlife and human health turned out to be so pervasive and-long lived that the US passed an outright ban in 1972 on its use in agriculture.</p><p>A solution to this problem presented itself in the chemistry of Pyrethroids, synthetic variants of the molecule Pyrethrum which is found in the petals of the Chrysanthemum plant. Powdered Chrysanthemums have been used as an insecticide for over 2000 years, and are still commercially produced in mountainous areas of Kenya and Tanzania. Pyrethrum and its variants are lethal to many insects; the chemical binds to voltage-gated sodium channels in the insect’s nervous system. This causes the channels to lock open, allowing unlimited amounts of sodium ions to flow into the nerve cell — in effect, the insect’s nervous system is instantly fried by global hyperactivity, just as if they had been put into an electric chair.</p><p>From the 1970s onward, pyrethroids became the predominant choice for agricultural insecticides, and are still the most common insecticide for domestic and food use today. They are naturally broken down by sunlight, so are less likely to accumulate in the environment than organochlorides such as DDT. Pyrethroids are also much less harmful to humans and other animals: our nervous system’s sodium channels are sufficiently different to insects’, such that pyrethroids do not bind to- and lock them open until we are exposed at many thousands of times the concentrations of pyrethroids used in commercial insecticides. We also have a class of enzymes called glucuronidases in our liver that rapidly break down toxins like pyrethroids.</p><p>Despite having a much safer profile than older pesticides like DDT, pyrethroids still present a <a href="http://www.epa.gov/oppsrrd1/reevaluation/pyrethroids-pyrethrins.html">number of hazards </a>that mean they need to be used with great care; indiscriminate spraying for agricultural use would cause the death of many helpful insects such as bees, and soil-dwelling invertebrates. Chronic human exposure to pyrethroids has been linked to a number of health issues, including endocrine disorders and cancer. In domestic situations, pet cats are especially vulnerable to pyrethroid poisoning, as they lack glucuronidases in their livers to break down these chemicals.</p><p>The hardware store was busy — it seemed that we were not the only ones experiencing a bout of weather-related insect infestation, along with the traffic from multiple emergency HVAC repairs that were necessary after three days of 100-degree temperatures in a row.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*6mWuehvz5IZ0_PuOeWQmSQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>A group of people were crowded around the section that contained pesticides, insecticides, herbicides, and all the other deadly chemicals one might want to maintain a biology-free environment. A store attendant was waiting by the shelves, ready to help another poor homeowner work out how best to repel an invasion of ants, spiders, roaches, or rats. Two different brands of aerosolized chemical warfare agents claimed to kill ants dead on contact. The attendant asked me if I had any questions.</p><blockquote>Which of these will work best, and how much cancer will they give me?</blockquote><p>He assured me both brands would be very effective for killing ants, before quickly turning away to find a different customer to help. I picked up the brand that came with 25% extra free, and had a fresh, floral scent.</p><p>The widespread introduction of scented additives to cleaning products is often traced to the invention of Pine-Sol in 1929 by Harry A. Cole. A chemist from Jackson, Mississippi, Dr. Cole used the plentiful pine oil available from local forests as an antibacterial ingredient for his new cleaning product. Dr. Cole’s invention would go on to enjoy decades of success as the biggest selling household cleaner in the world — a status that owes as much to its pleasing ‘fresh pine scent’, as it does to its effectiveness as a cleaner.</p><p>The runaway success of Pine-Sol was a game-changer for the household cleaning products industry. Previous products had been largely unadulterated, functional products, such as bleach, soap, or carbolic acid. The introduction of a product that not only left surfaces clean, but allowed the home to <em>smell </em>clean afterwards unleashed a wave of floral, woody, and citrus perfume additives for cleaning products onto the market. Cleaning product manufacturers quickly discovered that the smell of a product alone can be enough to generate brand loyalty, even if the product itself is inferior to a rival in terms of cleaning power — truly any marketer’s dream!</p><p>However, unlike active ingredients such as the pyrethroids, the ingredients that constitute the scent in household cleaning products are a mystery to the consumer, as are any health risks associated with them. Due to its historical reliance on distillates of plant-based ingredients, much of the accumulated knowledge in the perfume industry has traditionally been considered trade secrets, as methods for growing and processing plants are readily copied. This secrecy has persisted into the modern era, where fragrance manufacturers make few disclosures about the nature of chemicals in their products, yet neither the FDA or EPA has any authority to regulate perfumes and fragrances. Just as with pyrethroids, the chemical constituents of perfumes are almost entirely synthetic derivatives of naturally-occurring chemical families found in plants. However, without the history of safety testing and public disclosure that all insecticides, herbicides, or cleaning chemicals have undergone, the chemical constituents and specific <a href="http://www.psr.org/environment-and-health/environmental-health-policy-institute/responses/health-hazards-of-fragrance-in-cleaning-products.html">health hazards</a> of the various fragrances in cleaning products are unknowable.</p><p>The day of our fightback came with a fresh wind and cooler temperatures. With windows open and a cool sea breeze to clear out the house air, all remaining foodstuffs were removed from the kitchen. Open packages were discarded and the remainder stored in the garage. The cat and dog were confused by the reassignment of their feeding and water stations to the yard, and then by their own exile to the same. It was time for war to begin.</p><p>Poisoned bait traps were deployed to areas where the pets could not reach them — behind baseboards, under the crawlspaces, and behind the dishwasher. With the areas that we could not readily reach baited to attract ants who would take the baited poison back to their hive and kill the colony, it was time to take on the foot soldiers.</p><p>Sometimes, claims on cleaning products can seem inflated. In this case, <em>kills on contact</em> was almost an understatement. The battle was over almost as soon as it had begun. As each edge under a door, along a baseboard, under the edge of a cabinet, was briefly sprayed, every ant instantly stopped still as if frozen to the ground.</p><p>After the slaughter was over, every surface was cleaned over with soapy water to remove residual insecticide and insect remains. Small amounts of the pyrethroid chemicals would persist inside the cracks and joints that were the ants’ entrances for weeks to come, protected by the darkness inside, ready to kill any insect that dared try to re-enter our home. All the cabinets and floors were cleaned with detergent, removing the last of the ants’ chemical signals for directing each other to our food. It was over. They were gone.</p><p>Days later, there are no more signs of ants inside the house. Everything has been returned to its rightful place, and neither of our pets has shown any sign of being adversely affected by the insecticide. All that remains in a hint of the <em>Fresh Floral Scent</em> of the insecticide spray.</p><p>I know that by now, both of the two active pyrethroids in the spray will have dried down, dissipated, and been chemically broken down by heat and light. If I were still concerned, I can easily look up their chemistry online, and the history of studies that have been performed on them to analyse their safety and long-term effects on humans and animals. I can even visit the <a href="http://www.epa.gov/">EPA’s website</a> to learn more about these insecticides, or to report a problem with their use.</p><p>Yet the fresh floral scent remains. What chemicals did the manufacturer use to get the smell of fresh-cut roses and lilies almost exactly right (yet completely wrong)? How were they able to tweak the formulation such that the scent would be released slowly, still detectable after several days with windows wide open? Are any of the perfume ingredients known to be harmful to human or animal health? Did the fragrance come from processed flowers or herbs, or (more likely) a petrochemical production plant? We will likely never know.</p><blockquote><strong>In conflict, the biggest loser is often the battlefield.</strong></blockquote><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=9c2eb20f4901" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/the-good-the-bad-and-the-science/the-lemony-fresh-scent-of-death-9c2eb20f4901">The Lemony-Fresh Scent of Death</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/the-good-the-bad-and-the-science">The Good The Bad and The Science</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>