<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by HBM on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by HBM on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@HBM_afc?source=rss-9def112d885c------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Mon, 16 Nov 2026 02:00:17 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@HBM_afc/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Kai Havertz conundrum.]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@HBM_afc/the-kai-havertz-conundrum-d1f38583a2f0?source=rss-9def112d885c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/d1f38583a2f0</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[HBM]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 17 Dec 2023 21:12:28 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-12-17T21:12:53.615Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/800/1*C_o2eQDk698uPZlMBR5KZg.jpeg" /></figure><p>Kai Havertz has had a turbulent start to his Arsenal career, misjudged by many on what he was going to be with the resultant expectations of that misjudgement not being lived up, as a result the German has come under some serious criticism. I’d like to answer the question of whether that’s fair.</p><p>Is he actually useless? Or is he simply misused. There’s a lot to unpack with Kai Havertz and I’d be doing a disservice to him if I didn’t take in the full context. Was he a waste of money? A rare misstep by Arsenal’s recruitment team, or are the <strong>growing pains </strong>understandable and likely to only be a brief hiccup, entirely outstripped in importance by an excellent rest of his Arsenal career.</p><p>You can’t begin to tell the story of Kai Havertz without first examining Thomas Müller, the man who he’s been compared to consistently throughout his short career. Müller is an odd player, not the most athletic player on the planet nor the most technical, he fails nearly all measurable criteria to be an elite player in a specific position. If you put him up front he won’t stretch the defence, bully the centre halves or put the ball in the back of the net at every opportunity. He doesn’t have the legs or 1v1 calibre for the flanks, he’s not going to split the defence with a pass from midfield nor is he going to evade pressure in build up receiving deep. Yet he’s played 453 (and counting) league games for the biggest club in Germany and has played over 125 times for one of football’s great superpowers. So what’s his secret?</p><p>He’s the ultimate facilitator on the ball, his first thought is to find the better option, the more valuable space. However, that isn’t what’s most impressive about him, it’s not why the name Thomas Müller is so famous, to find that out we have to look away from the sun which the game orbits around- instead we must look at the cold vacuum of <strong>space</strong>.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/768/1*j8hgozOvLUEZfRGOSq9iDw.jpeg" /></figure><p>The English translation of the German word <strong>Raumdeuter </strong>is<strong> </strong>“space interpreter”, that word is entirely synonymous with Müller- if you look it up on google it doesn’t come to any sort of definition or explanation, it simply directs you to his Wikipedia page.</p><p>It’s a concept rather than a role, in essence it attempts to describe Thomas Müller’s ability to pick up valuable positions. It effectively describes a lot of what makes Thomas so good, he understands space and how to occupy it- something that exists similarly in Kai Havertz’s game.</p><p>The same understanding of space is useful out of possession as well, Thomas Müller is unsurprisingly a incredible presser, he shadows well and is a key leader in any successful Bayern side’s off the ball work. Kai Havertz is similar in this regard, he’s a top class presser but their similarities go beyond what they actually do on the football pitch.</p><p>Both Kai Havertz and Thomas Müller are minimalists, they’re efficient, clunky and unselfish. It can be to their detriment at times, when they aren’t producing output they tend to be criticised heavily, people like players that look good on the football pitch and that just isn’t either of them.</p><p>There’s a common misconception that their similarities mean that their usages have to be similar, that despite their obvious differences Kai Havertz is suited to being used in the same way Thomas Müller is. I disagree but I do empathise with this instinct and that empathy comes from what Kai Havertz did and what he was was during his days at Bayer Leverkusen.</p><h3><strong>The Bayer days and the impossibility of recapturing them.</strong></h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*ju78qjdV9TMofwFGCCsEsQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>When things aren’t going well for Kai Havertz many point towards his Leverkusen work as a reference to what once was and as a vehicle to lament the player that is. One thing that people get right when talking about those times is this: he was a very different player at Bayer, just watching him he was simply more fluid, more comfortable and a far bigger threat out wide (he even played a fair portion of his games on the right) than the player we see today. He was primarily a shadow striker at Bayer though, and a good one at that- quick, incisive and had the all important understanding of space, it was like if you gave Thomas Müller the physical gifts that he famously lacks.</p><p>However, I’d still argue that he wasn’t the reincarnation of Thomas Müller even back then, Müller’s lack of physical gifts is what saw him unable to thrive within a typical position, the existence of Kai’s meant that this was never likely to occur. Even during that time where the comparisons between the two were at their most fierce, Kai put in his best performances up front; suited to the more transitional nature of German football he thrived making runs in behind. In his 8 games there in the 19/20 season he scored as many goals and that’s what Chelsea believed they were signing, a player equally adept up front or in attacking midfield who guarenteed output while acting as a perfect facilitator for their other attackers. That is decidedly not what they got.</p><h4>The Growth Spurt: the worst/best thing that has happened to Kai Havertz.</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*E16zZX91oAv4czdo" /></figure><p>There’s been two big growth spurts in Kai Havertz’s footballing career thus far , one at age 14 when he went from the shortest kid on the team to the tallest and scuppered his dreams of replicating his childhood idol Lionel Messi (in playstyle that is…). More pertinent to this piece though was one roughly around 2020 when he went from the fluid, comfortable player that we saw at Bayer to the slightly unsettled, tentative mover that we’ve seen for the past few years. Most sites had Kai Havertz listed at roughly 6&quot;2 during his time at Bayer, fast forward to his transfer to Arsenal and he’s the tallest player at the football club at around 6&quot;4.</p><p>This growth spurt didn’t come at a good time either, his move to Chelsea was one that wasn’t particularly comfortable for him initially. He was frequently injured in his first season at Chelsea with him also contracting COVID-19 during the period. Whilst he did score the Champions League final winning goal (as well as producing one of the best out of possession performances by a forward that I’ve seen in the home leg of the Semi-Final against Real Madrid), it wasn’t a particularly productive season for him. There were slight signs of improvement under Thomas Tuchel the following year (10 goal contributions in 17 league games up front in 21/22), the German never really got going at Stamford Bridge. Thus, there was little to no uproar about his move from West to North (at least on Chelsea’s side that is) and it seemed to be a case of all parties being happy with their business.</p><p><em>So why was the growth spurt good?</em></p><p>His change in height left him uncoordinated, slower, a (statistically) weaker finisher, a less confident passer/carrier and generally led to a severe loss of confidence (only compounded by his surrounding environment being so poor in the years immediately succeeding) but, what it did do is create the potential for one of the best out and out centre forwards in Europe.</p><p>In the 22/23 Premier League season Kai Havertz was in the 96th percentile for percentage of aerial duels won, he’s been consistently above the 70th percentile in that statistic for his entire career. Stats don’t tell half the story though, Kai Havertz is one of the best aerial threats in Europe, he’s tall, slippery and a fantastic target to aim at. He also has the potential to be one of the best “box dominators” in Europe, very few in the world receive as many passes into the area as Kai Havertz does up top and that translates to a genuine gravity in the position- he draws defenders towards him like few else and it makes him a top tier facilitator without really having to try. He just wouldn’t have the ceiling he does today without that added height and while it’s certainly delayed the development of Kai Havertz into a true world beater, it’s likely worth it if he’s under the right guidance.</p><h3>Kai Havertz in midfield.</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/476/1*fo798Xb1CHC8qyeAEwDSCQ.png" /><figcaption>Kai’s statistical make-up about 3 weeks before this was published- work rate!</figcaption></figure><p>Stats are a very rudimentary form of judging a player. Especially stats such as these, they aren’t possession adjusted (why the duel winning numbers are so low) and they can back up multiple contradictory narratives at the same time. Some will tell you that these aren’t the statistics of a midfielder, that this “proves” that he’s either a poor footballer or should be moved further forward. Others will tell you that this presents Arteta’s Kai Havertz Raumdeuter vision, an aerial winner, a ghost who picks up positions and receives the ball where it’s dangerous. Here’s what I will say about Kai Havertz in midfield, he’s not anything in build up (frankly he’s a net negative in the pivot for the initial 4–2 shape that Arsenal use in the first phase), he’s a generally good ground duellist (wins a lot of them but his lack of control over his limbs is abundantly clear at times) and he’s not a player that is likely to dominate his zone that far deep.</p><p><em>So what does this mean for Kai Havertz in midfield?</em></p><p>As always it’s all about balance, if you are going to use him in midfield it cannot be with any deep phase responsibilities, he’s poor at getting away from his marker when receiving, he’s not technically consistent enough to get away with simply being a wall pass in the pivot and it’s simply just a waste of his height. You’ve also got to pair him with the correct winger, he’s not going to tilt the block towards his side through his gravity and volume of touches in the half space (as the ball dominant Martin Ødegaard does), nor is he going to overlap on the left hand side and whip are cross in.</p><p>The winger next to him ideally needs to be a good crosser of the ball, a wide creator in order to facilitate his runs in behind and a strong receiver when the ball goes to feet (both on the touchline and between the lines). Kai’s also more comfortable on the right, the open angles help him when receiving due to the lack of fluidity he has with his size. He can more easily turn and carry inside on his favoured left foot. What’s clear as a resultant function of these factors is that Kai Havertz doesn’t, didn’t and will never fit the LCM role at Arsenal. It’s simply not him- Gabriel Martinelli thrives next to a passer who can unleash him in behind, he wants to move inside and beyond as his first response to a variable change as well. Those two instincts, those two attributes can be just as equally stated to Kai Havertz- their movements are too similar to work, one must compromise, one must be suppressed and that is a frankly unacceptable thing, an unworkable thing to impose on talents such as these.</p><p><em>What about with a different winger on the left?</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*BiinDwnDKokbTqq5.jpg" /></figure><p>Even if the environment was perfect on the left, it still wouldn’t make much sense. Let’s say it was Reiss Nelson on the left wing and Leandro Trossard in the Centre Forward position, two ball dominant players who can feed him as he runs in behind as well as facilitating him in the area. An environment that couldn’t possibly be more suited to him. Even then, Kai Havertz’s primary job would still be to run the left channel- something that he isn’t particularly good at, he’s not overly dynamic on the underlap and he isn’t a particularly penetrative carrier from that side either. Not to mention the general awkwardness that he has playing on he left, he struggles to access and facilitate even a ball to feet winger like Nelson nor is he comfortable shooting and passing across his body with his angles closed off. The function of these flaws is that he’d simply not be asked to do the jobs that the dynamics demand of him, he’d play to his own ghostly whims- he’d score, he’d assist but he’d do little else. While some may argue that producing output is enough, that it’s the hardest thing to do in football and his value is therefore sufficient, I’d tend to disagree. Even in his best environment Kai Havertz the number 8 inevitably suppresses those around him, are we confident that his (lessened due to the deeper areas he’s responsible for) output would make up for this? I’m not.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/959/0*4PxiSuEctJjszbWu" /></figure><p>The left hand side of midfield is not an acceptable solution, the environment at it’s best is still unacceptable. He’ll win his duels, he’ll score goals and he’ll run in behind but it still isn’t good enough. Even if there are no deep phase responsibilities, it’s still not good enough- it’s still a desecration of what it means to be a number 8, a personal insult to the Pedri’s, De Jong’s and Gundogan’s of the world.</p><p>This is the situation that we’re looking at at the time of writing with Kai, he’s had the LCM role tailored to him- he’s high and asked to do his own thing, but it isn’t working, his output is up but Martinelli’s has suffered and that isn’t something that can occur in this Arsenal side. There is no concept of a sacrificial lamb in football, one players strengths cannot directly contribute to another player’s weaknesses in a functional team. The Kai Havertz LCM experiment has been optimised to it’s fullest with the players that are currently in the side but it simply must stop- it’s not optimal and it’s killing Arsenal’s best finisher.</p><h4>Kai Havertz on the right- a solution.</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*NP_7MI3uDBzwBnhf" /></figure><p><em>The positives.</em></p><p>Kai Havertz has a right hand side bias, he’s more comfortable there and crucially tends to drift there without specific instruction when starting in central areas. It gives him easier access to the left hand side of the pitch when receiving and it allows for him to drive inwards when carrying before playing outwards (something we’ve seen often in the time he’s played next to Saka).</p><p>This is crucial for improving the quality of 1v1’s that the winger takes, he’s dragging defenders away (or at least widening the channel when he’s attacking the back line) and therefore giving more space to the winger on the touchline to attack after he plays it out. This is an issue on the left with Martinelli, he either tends to directly forward (none of the aforementioned benefits being reaped as a product) or he doesn’t drive at all and plays it out early when the full back is still tight to Martinelli (therefore needing the Brazilian to create separation by himself in order to take the 1v1). Kai is not asked to do much straight line running on the right, which suits him- he’s just not built for it.</p><p>He’s also *likely* to produce more output from the right and over the course of a season should have a similar level of output to any of the other interiors that Arsenal could use in the position whether that be Vieira, Smith Rowe or Ødegaard. Playing on the right allows him to drift into the area and spend most of his time high, as long as he’s confident in himself a certain level of output is inevitable. Cutbacks, knock downs or simply sweeping up after the first phase of an attack (which he’s very good at- he inarguably sniffs out space very well), Kai Havertz <strong>will</strong> produce from the right.</p><p>The out of possession environment surrounding him is also more optimal on the right, he’s able to be part of the front 2 out of possession which he excels at- no longer having to block space in the pivot, he’s able to use his duel winning capabilities in high pressing situations.</p><p>It’s here that his intelligence in shadow marking and keeping the press compact is properly allowed to shine, there’s rarely space to exploit behind Kai Havertz in the press and that is largely due to his individual pragmatism and feel for when he needs to drop. Adding Kai Havertz to the right is also fantastic news for Arsenal’s out of possession play outside of an individual context, a front 2 of Havertz and Jesus is without doubt the best in world football, a perfect combination of aggression, intelligence and physical capacity in the duel. Kai Havertz at RCM enables Arsenal to uphold their reputation as the best out of possession team in world football.</p><p>Having him in the first line of engagement out of possession also makes better use of his transitional qualities, he’s higher and therefore closer to the valuable space- that in behind running and empathetic passing can be funnelled into actions of greater value.</p><p>Havertz being in the first line of the press also helps with the mental side of things, he’s still pretty low on confidence and is largely unwilling to abandon his defensive or deep phase duties in favour of potentially more valuable actions due to that. Kai at RCM is still plagued by midfield responsibilities to an extent, but he feels far less bound to deeper areas and therefore spends a lot more of his time in the box. He is far more willing to make general movements and perform actions outside of his “zone” due to the reduction in deeper responsibilities. Kai is best when he’s got a level of freedom and he’s not going to interpret a role freely that has restrictions on it due to his lack of confidence, that freedom has to be thrust upon him to an extent (as it can be to an extent at RCM).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*CMnfZ286WaFDX8Dz.jpg" /></figure><p>The existence of Gabriel Jesus up front is also helpful for Havertz at RCM, his consistent dropping into the second phase to act as a plus one gives Havertz the opportunity to operate in more central areas- due to him picking up the occupying responsibilities, re: the centre halves. There’s also the possibility of Jesus dragging centre halves out of the defensive line through his dropping movements, giving Kai space to exploit in behind if he’s willing to make the run.</p><p>The Arsenal right hand side is also still functional despite Kai Havertz’s movements. Kai Havertz tends to “abandon” the half space when Bukayo Saka receives the ball via moving into the box (he does this as well when Gabriel Martinelli receives via moving into the far post area). While this gives Saka an option to cross to in the area, it could lead to him being isolated and therefore stuck in difficult 1v1 positions (ideally the interior would overlap or at least drag defenders away from the winger in order to isolate the full back).</p><p>However, this problem isn’t really debilitating due to the dynamism that Ben White provides. His overlapping threat enables Saka to move inside (which enables him to make more decisive actions- central zones are King after all) or use his gravity to get Ben White the ball at the by-line (which increases the chances of reaping the rewards of Havertz’s box occupation on the right as he can attack the front post).</p><p>He’s also able to reap the rewards of having a good far post crosser on the left in Martinelli, the Brazilian tends to take his man on down the outside so when he cuts in, he usually is afforded more time on the ball than a Saka is ( important to note that there’s different levels of doubling up on Martinelli compared to Bukayo). This greatly aids in his delivery levels and 6&quot;4 Havertz at the back post is a great target to aim at.</p><p>It’s also a good solution for Arsenal’s 4–2–4 build up, the high occupation of the right channel allows Havertz to act as a target man from midfield (same goes for his current usage at LCM to be fair) which is crucial in combating man to man presses. Without Havertz, Arsenal struggle to consistently progress if they become technically insecure- with the German however, there’s a little more leeway. Height is the press killer and the ability for Arsenal to bypass the build up phase by playing it direct to Havertz (who’s a top facilitator once he receives the ball) presents a large part of his value to the club (especially at RCM which enables him to stay high in these phases given the system). It ain’t revolutionary, but it’s useful.</p><p><em>Negatives:</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*4unR0v6SCg-4VtVH.jpg" /></figure><p>First and foremost, Kai Havertz is not the best RCM in the squad. As a pure player in that role all of Ødegaard, Smith Rowe and Vieira are superior options and when considering Saka as the staple right winger (rather than a pure outside winger who could functionally work with Martin Ødegaard), the latter two still remain more useful than the German. Smith Rowe’s a better enabler of Bukayo due to his movements outside (as well as him being superior to Havertz as a box crashing threat due to his cleaner ball striking when coming on to the ball), Ødegaard is a better pocket player as well as being another player who works better as a box crasher from that role and Fabio Vieira has devastating passing quality in that right half space which facilitates others (including Havertz in his optimal role), while having the highest creative ceiling in the squad.</p><p>While there are some benefits for Havertz himself when having Saka specifically as a partner, Saka isn’t so lucky in this partnership (aside from the lack of occupation of similar channels and Kai being somebody to cross the ball too). Bukayo is forced to be responsible for both tilting (through a high volume of touches) and exploiting (through crossing and other forms of remote access) the block from the right hand side.</p><p>While Havertz genuinely does do some stretching of the block duties from RCM, he doesn’t manipulate the block via moving defenders around/ increasing the concentration of defenders ballside, which rtherefore educes the ability to access the left hand side in good areas as the block isn’t forced to tilt towards the right (aside from doubling up on Saka but that can usually be done without adverse effects on the left- an interior is needed to have some sort of ball dominance or gravitating actions outside the box in order for the block to truly be scared enough to congregate on the right).</p><p>There’s also a serious waste of many of his good facilitating qualities in a midfield role, by having him operate predominantly on the right, he isn’t able to reliably interact with Martinelli (who needs a facilitator next to him to truly thrive out wide due to his direct nature and in behind threat) or with Declan Rice who has the capabilities to be a genuinely high level box crashing interior if he’s got the correct environment (which includes a strong facilitating central presence like Havertz). In short, Havertz at RCM in this regard hurts his ability to enable production from others due to not having him function in entirely central areas.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*uJSqDsfalXF_sMO-.jpg" /></figure><p>He’s also forced to perform actions in that RCM that he’s not particularly comfortable in doing, occupying the pockets is simply not something that Kai Havertz is great at. The tight areas and need to create separation from his marker in those spaces doesn’t suit his frame in the slightest. He’s also not particularly impressive doing general half space jobs, he’s got a fine delivery on him but that delivery isn’t best used in congested areas (note that there’s also nobody for him to cross the ball to in the box due to a lack of a certain somebody in there), but aside from that he’s only ever going to do jobs on the ball to a fine standard. His passes are empathetic, his carries are safe but he’s not going to be the difference maker in those areas to really break down a block.</p><p>He’s not suited to the style of box crashing that a midfield role entails either, he’s awkward when coming onto the ball which usually leads to him not striking through it cleanly. He’s a drifter rather than a crasher, a crasher needs to penetrate into the box and perform actions while doing that penetration, that just isn’t something that the German is effective at. The incompatible thing here is that the RCM needs a box crasher of some sorts, there needs to be penetration into the area rather than mere movement otherwise there’s nobody to properly push the block back on the right (Kai does an alright job of it but there’s wiggle room) or facilitate Saka’s creative threat. The drifter (Kai) is far more suited to doing that drifting entirely <strong><em>within </em></strong>the confines of the box, rather than transitioning from<em> </em><strong><em>out to in</em></strong> and therefore not doing jobs that are required from somebody who’s outside the area for a fair bit of time to the wanted standard. This is as well as not always being in valuable positions due to those jobs (which is their entire job!). Time spent outside of the area for Kai in settled play is largely time wasted, that truth is simply incompatible with using him in that RCM role functionally.</p><h4>So is it viable?</h4><p>Sorta? It’s a solution that emphasises a lot of what he’s good at, he’s allowed to drift into areas, win second balls and occupy the box. He will fulfil the base function that Kai Havertz has to consistently bring to the side in order for this Arsenal to properly work in big games- namely the ability to play over the press using him as a target man. However, it really isn’t (fully) ideal in that regard either, due to him being the primary receiver when going long he can’t really be a primary penetrating force to be facilitated for and while that can be mitigated (Martinelli at CF), it doesn’t make best use of his abilities as an in behind threat.</p><p>There’s also a psychological issue with him at RCM, it’s a role that emphasises his non-ball dominating attributes, his raumdeuter tendencies if you will. He will already do all of that off the ball stuff in a position that doesn’t emphasise those attributes (such as CF), all that emphasising those attributes does is take away from his facilitating qualities in volume. He needs to have his on the ball work emphasised through having the team play through him (or at least bounce off of him) to a certain degree in order to be useful in that regard- he doesn’t need his off the ball stuff emphasised, his arm doesn’t need to be twisted into doing that stuff in the same manner that his arm needs to be twisted into being an <strong>on the ball</strong> presence.</p><p>RCM just isn’t central enough to allow that, he’s definitely not a bad ghost, but he can be more than that if play is funnelled through that. Another issue is that his lack of assertiveness is only further exacerbated in the role, his confidence issues are clear to see and that same issue of ghosting crops up as a result of that. He’s not going to take the game by the scruff of the neck, you’ve more so got to hand it to him- that just doesn’t happen at RCM. He is far too tentative to make that role work and it plays into a lot of the issues he has psychologically via allowing him to drift in and out of games.</p><p>Overall, it’s fine- Kai Havertz at RCM isn’t fundamentally flawed as an idea in the same way that Kai Havertz at 8 is, there’s some arguments that it makes use of his qualities in a way that isn’t possible anywhere else. Havertz is very good at <strong>his </strong>interpretation of RCM, it’s just that, that interpretation isn’t necessarily optimal for the team nor is it how you get the most value out of him. He isn’t going to influence a game to the level you’d expect of a 65 million pound signing at RCM, his output isn’t going to be anywhere near the level that he’s capable of and even the dynamics that he’s surrounded by don’t make best use of his ability to make the team better. It is not <strong>the</strong> solution, if this was his best role then I’d definitively disagree with the allotment of funds towards the German. Luckily, it’s not and I don’t.</p><h3>Kai Havertz at Centre Forward.</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/615/0*TjkyVbeK_w1-utKQ.jpg" /></figure><p>Kai Havertz is often touted as position-less, he’s either believed to be “versatile” or he “doesn’t know his best position” depending on what end of the Kai Havertz spectrum you’re on. I believe that to be untrue. He does have a wide ranging skillset, but that doesn’t mean that skillset overlaps well in most positions. He’s a limited midfielder, a limited winger, a limited full back (Nagelsmann?) but that certainly isn’t the case up top. He is frankly, one of the most complete centre forward’s in world football.</p><h4>The hook</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1002/0*hLq5tjGm5Jcg2JgH" /></figure><p>The Enganche is a player that’s deified in Argentina, they’re the “hook” between the midfield lines and the attacking lines. The centre of space, the interpreter of the tempo of the team and undoubtedly the most important tool for progression in the side. I am not claiming Kai Havertz to be anything of the sort, what he can be though is the “hook” between the attacking lines and the space in behind. The ability to access that space through positional discipline and high level timing of release to wide outlets allows him to be a transitional force not only off the ball but on it as well.</p><p><em>Why is it important?</em></p><p>His function as the hook is fundamental to Arsenal’s transitional value. His ability to hold up the ball and acts as a middle man between the bottom of the pitch and Arsenal’s wide outlets allows for quick progression and more importantly dangerous access of in behind spaces. The ability for Arsenal to bypass the build up lottery and not rely on having to play *through* the press by being able to play *over* it is vital in this era of man to man presses and that ability is only accentuating by having him down the middle. Not only does he keep the ball fantastically well when it’s hit long to him (his first touch and use of his body with his back to man is truly top tier), he is fantastic at bringing others in to play once he’s brought it down. Having Gabriel Martinelli and Emile Smith Rowe (two space eaters and clinical finishers) close to Kai Havertz when he’s acting as “the hook” is a chance creation machine.</p><p>The out to in runs that commonly occur from a lot of Arsenal’s players simply can’t be accessed without a facilitator next to them. It’s something that distinguishes Havertz from Gabriel Jesus at centre forward, not only is the German a far more reasonable outlet to have as the first contact to a long ball, he’s also far more comfortable bringing others into play as his first thought and it’s imperative in these situations that the first thought is the one executed due to the time constraints on transitions. He completely changes the transitional outlook of the team and he’s almost a necessity to have next to Emile Smith Rowe and Gabriel Martinelli if you want to maximise their output and abilities as some of the coolest finishers in the squad.</p><h4>The penetrator</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1002/0*TbnjV-TIJJXvNSfF" /></figure><p>Kai Havertz is a phenomenal in behind threat. His runs are intelligent, he’s quick and he’s fantastic at attacking the most valuable space available. His ability to attack space is definitely one of his greatest strengths however, from deep and from the flanks the space he’s invading isn’t extraordinarily valuable- that isn’t the case up front. His exploitation of in behind space when starting high dwarfs his deeper exploitation in efficiency, when he makes runs from the 9 he is far more likely to score from them simply due to the fact that those runs are in behind the backline rather than from the midfield line to just in front of a stretched backline (as he would be doing in a so-called “raumdeuter” role).</p><p>The environment also suits this ability well, Ben White and Bukayo Saka are great at passing into exploitable space and the latter&#39;s gravity in particular eases the runs that Havertz has to make. While he is a definitive off ball threat in transition due to his in behind threat (and a cool finisher 1v1 when he’s confident- more on that later), that isn’t the only situation where his penetrative abilities come to the fore- they are also fantastically useful in settled play.</p><p>The threat he poses forces the defensive line to sag when in settled situations, his consistency in off-ball runs opens up the space in front- not for himself, but for others crashing the box such as an Emile Smith Rowe or a Martin Ødegaard. All the best centre forwards fulfil this function, a certain gravity and fear that they strike into their opponents through their assertive threat allows for others to benefit from their presence even without touching the ball.</p><p>Kai Havertz isn’t just a facilitator for other penetrators, he is that himself- a high level transitional threat that no centre-half wants to see running in behind. That’s what City get out of Haaland up front, a guy to play over the press and a devastating outlet in behind- but Havertz is more than that, he’s a credible link man as well. Outside of the area as a centre forward Kai Havertz has the ability to do the jobs that you buy both a Harry Kane *and* an Erling Haaland to do- irrespective of the standard that he does those jobs to (obviously not at the level of either in their respective fields), the fact that you can ask him to do both speaks to his utter completeness as a centre forward at his best and it speaks to why Arsenal signed him.</p><h4>The finisher</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*P0H4csy29PbBe2xw" /></figure><p>Contrary to popular belief Kai Havertz is not a bad finisher, he’s had bad finishing <a href="https://twitter.com/xGPhilosophy/status/1665323106959867906"><em>years</em></a><em> </em>but he’s not a bad finisher. There are reasons behind his finishing issues over the years, the growth spurt, confidence and the <em>Chelsea factor</em><strong>™. </strong>Now, this may seem unsubstantiated, so here’s my evidence.</p><p>Firstly, Kai’s shot prep is top notch- he creates separation efficiently (through both using his large frame and getting it out of his feet well) and the positive first touches that he has when he’s on it are incredibly effective at giving him the space to shoot. He’s also generally pretty good at knowing when to shoot, you’ll rarely see a shot taken by Kai Havertz that shouldn’t be and it’s just as unlikely that you’ll see a geniune opportunity for him to shoot be passed up on.</p><p>The main thing that I like with Kai Havertz’s actual finishing is how intuitive it is, with a great example of this being his goal against RC Lens in the Champions League group stage (where he improvised based on the bounce of the ball being too high for his initial planned finish and managed to use his foot to poke it just underneath Brice Samba’s arm). He is no “system” finisher, only taking the type of chances that the manager has laid out for him as being a possibility, he’s instinctive and that’s a great strength to have.</p><p>As mentioned previously he’s good in the air, as a back post arrive there’s few better than Kai Havertz simply due to his height- you can swing the ball without that much precision and he’ll likely be able to get it (especially as he’s usually attacking a shorter full back rather than a centre half). He’s good at the front post as well, his flick on game is impressive and has only improved as he’s gotten older.</p><p>He’s also been shown to be adept as a pure striker of the football with his goal against England in the Nations League being an example of this. Kai Havertz is no devastating striker of the football in the Erling Haaland mould, but when he has time he tends to strike the ball fairly cleanly from long range and that’ll likely only improve as he gets more comfortable with his body post-growth spurt (with his volleying in particular taking a sizeable dip in quality after his move from Leverkusen).</p><p>Out of everything though, my main belief in Kai Havertz as a good finisher is his mental approach to the game and the juxtaposition of it to Gabriel Jesus presents a wonderful case study for why it’s a good thing for Kai.</p><p>Kai’s calm, Jesus is decidedly not so. Gabriel Jesus has a history of letting missed chances get to him, making a mountain out of a molehill when things don’t drop how he wants them to. Don’t get me wrong, I love how emotional Gabriel Jesus is, he takes matters into his own hands like few others- he wouldn’t be the beautiful footballer we see every week (with depressing 4–6 week breaks every 3 months) without that emotion. However, it isn’t particularly conducive to a great finisher- being bothered isn’t how you finish the next chance.</p><p>This just isn’t an issue for Kai, while often his lackadaisical demeanour is criticised when things aren’t going well, it’s largely a net positive for him on the pitch- calling him a cool head in general is a step too far but in front of goal? There’s no doubt. When he’s in behind, 1 on 1 with the goalkeeper I expect Kai Havertz to score- his inevitability isn’t something that’s appreciated yet (largely because he isn’t inevitable-<strong> yet</strong>), but once it is it’ll be impossible to miss and he’ll go from being seen as a poor finisher to being one of the best around.</p><h3>The fit</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*NtwFYC1HvRPYKv7R" /></figure><p>It’s all well and good waxing lyrical about how good he *might* be as a centre forward in isolation, it’s all well and good theorising about what he *might* be able to do but the most important thing in all of this is what he’d *actually* be able to do in this Arsenal side at centre forward. Lucky for us, the general “fit” is the thing that I’m most excited about with Kai Havertz.</p><p>Firstly, it’s important to state that there’s invariably going to be differences in how Kai Havertz fits into the side based upon who he’s playing with- does he fit as well with Martin Ødegaard in comparison to Emile Smith Rowe? No, he doesn’t and that’s important to acknowledge and delve into. So that’s exactly what I’m going to do.</p><p><strong>Right Central Midfield</strong></p><p><em>The Martin Ødegaard “fit”.</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/640/0*bKbNvCv3E0hCdv09" /></figure><p>The “fit” is a bit of a mixed bag, there’s a theoretical agreement in their relationship. Kai Havertz’s off the ball movement when settled is fairly inventive and nobody is as inventive on the ball in the squad (league, world?) as Martin Ødegaard. Kai’s weak foot isn’t poor, those balls we see Martin sneak past the defensive line weekly wouldn’t necessarily be wasted on Kai. Martin’s also not a bad crosser of the ball, while the back post drifting is certainly not exclusive to the centre forward role for Kai- there are fruits to be found with Martin in this number 9 context.</p><p>Martin’s also pretty meh as a transitional passer (on the right that is), a transitional 1–2 punch ala Kevin De Bruyne and Erling Haaland is not what we have on our hands here. In essence, they are both pretty malleable and intelligent players- it’s nothing to write home about but it’s functional in possession.</p><p>Out of possession however, the Martin Ødegaard/ Kai Havertz relationship truly blossoms. We’ve already seen a level of compatibility in this regard, the hybrid press instituted in the Man United game earlier in the season saw both put in some of the best out of possession performances of the season (especially taking into account Kai was functioning in an unfamiliar deeper role). The blocking of space and understanding of triggers that both have in their locker was on full display, they are probably the two most intelligent pressing minds in the squad (excluding Rice but like, that’s OOP Jesus we’re talking about) and having those two leading the press is such as useful tool to have. The flexibility that those two would give Mikel Arteta and his coaching staff is something that is tough to value but is certainly appreciated.</p><p><em>The Fabio Vieira “fit”.</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*0tA4R7BwW9aIVgBX.jpg" /></figure><p>Fabio Vieira is the best passer in the squad, I mentioned the lack of a Haaland- De Bruyne transitional 1–2 punch with the Ødegaard relationship, well here you go. There are very, very few footballers who are able to find runners as well as Fabio Vieira, at the risk of sounding cliché- this boy has got an absolute wand of a left foot and he bloody well knows it.</p><p>That threat isn’t just transitional, Fabio’s the best crosser in the squad and there’s nobody else you want serving up balls for the German to attack. He’s also got a certain level of that Martin Ødegaard intuitive bag, he understands the football pretty well on both feet and feeding Kai in the box on the half turn is something that he’ll do nearly as well as the Norwegian. Whilst it applies to all 3 possible RCM candidates, lay offs into space outside the area (with Kai’s gravity creating that space) are something that Fabio will definitively benefit from. He’s can hit them from range and having a sort of backboard spitting out 30 of those a season can only increase his output in comparison to the current striker options who don’t have the same gravity (Eddie) or instinct (Jesus).</p><p><em>The Emile Smith Rowe “fit”.</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/624/0*Ira5w8fKu1Zow_vO.jpg" /></figure><p>The Kai Havertz/ Emile Smith Rowe partnership may seem to the naked eye one of overlapping similarities and therefore inefficiencies however, Kai’s completeness means that whilst similar they are still balanced.</p><p>In transition, Emile Smith Rowe is a high level outlet to be facilitated for, with the 4–2–4 build up allowing that facilitation via having Kai and Emile in close proximity. Would I say that their partnership in transition is directly as compatible as Fabio/Kai? No, but it’s functional, Smith Rowe is no big space passer but his enabling qualities and his individualist abilities (largely his exceptional carrying) mean that there’s no issue to speak of. They facilitate each other to an acceptable degree and that’s all that’s required, neither really need to be aided in transition.</p><p>In settled play there’s not much to speak of, Emile will crash the box and Kai will help enable that with his gravity and lay offs. What Smith Rowe largely brings in settled play is enabling qualities for Bukayo Saka, the ability to get his mate inside via overlapping runs and dragging players on the underlap is something that *will* benefit Kai Havertz. Having one of the best passers in the squad (Saka) in that right half space can only help Havertz’s output and accessing the back post through a Saka cross is something we’ve seen countless times already this season. Emile enables that and Kai benefits from it- the partnership works and it’s a good fit.</p><p><strong>Left Central Midfield.</strong></p><p>It’s important to note that there’s a lesser importance to the relationship between the LCM and the CF in comparison to the RCM/ CF relationship just largely based on the lack of proximity, in a 4–2–4 the interactions between the CF and the LCM aren’t particularly important in a macro sense due to them being less in number, but in settled play there’s is still a “fit” that needs to be examined.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/678/0*iGp2ooouey325X3T.jpeg" /></figure><p>The important thing at that LCM spot is for the player to be a high tier passer, the ideal is that they can feed runs in behind for Kai in transition and whip balls in for him to attack at the back post in settled play (as well as generally feeding him on the half turn in the box).</p><p>Declan Rice fits the bill, with him also having a box crashing threat which fits well with Kai, Martin Ødegaard also checks out- with the reduction in available angles to him tending to have the effect of making him more direct in transition and I’d expect the partnership to be better as a result. The adequate LCM options available at the club (Rice, Ødegaard, Lokonga, Patino and Trossard) all fit the bill with Havertz, if they don’t fit in with Kai (in regards to being a passer that threatens in transition and manipulates a block to a good standard), then they likely don’t fit in the with the side at all.</p><p><strong>Left wing.</strong></p><p>There’s a little more leeway in regards to how his usage would differ on the basis of who play’s on the left, the squad has some very different profiles who can operate out wide and again as a testament to Havertz’s malleability, he has the ability to operate well with all of them.</p><p><em>Reiss Nelson</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*3gKJwuP1mSRXU8sn.jpg" /></figure><p>Reiss is not some sort of wide outlet, he’s not somebody who’s going to be running in behind and therefore for a team to function with him out wide you’ll likely need a penetrative threat up top. Somebody is going to need to run the channels for Reiss to let him get inside his fullback and while some of that can come from midfield in settled play, ideally the centre forward will be there for slip passes inside.</p><p>He’s not anything to write home about in transition either, there’s nothing expansive about Reiss Nelson’s game and whilst that is largely fine for what he is in the squad, it does mean that the centre forward has to do a lot of the leg work in this regard.</p><p>Luckily Kai Havertz can do these jobs, he’s the type of centre forward that can accommodate a Reiss Nelson, he’s a threat in behind and at his best is a willing runner- they’re a partnership that isn’t going to necessarily rock the boat but it’s usable as a dynamic. Havertz up front enables a consistent usage of Nelson, which considering the latter’s proficiency at breaking down a low block, is a massive tick in Kai’s column.</p><p><em>Gabriel Martinelli</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/615/0*vyIr6iXfFK0pJiLC.jpg" /></figure><p>I mentioned some potential fruits of this partnership beforehand in the midfield section with regards to Havertz being a target for Martinelli’s back post crossing but there’s a lot more to it than that. Simply put, this relationship has the ability to be the most directly valuable in the team and it’s a relationship that right now is entirely dysfunctional.</p><p>The main difference between how the relationship functions with Martinelli at LW and Havertz at CF in comparison to Havertz in the LCM role is the “middle man” of that passer LCM profile that’d exist with Kai out of the role. They’ve both got somebody trying to find their runs and the lack of complete proximity means that those runs don’t necessarily have to be the same runs.</p><p>Confusion and fear (as well as just, scoring) are the main goals of running in behind, when defenders are scared they naturally drop towards their goal and this relationship performs that function well. This penetrative threat is crucial in transitional games, having two top tier outlets who are also incredibly cool under the cosh is something that is entirely required for the biggest of nights- you don’t win unless you are prepared to suffer and that suffering has to be broken up somehow.</p><p>When settled, Havertz also has a tendency to drift towards the right and therefore away from Martinelli which is largely a good thing, their relationship when in settled play isn’t ideal. It largely manifests itself when they are in close proximity as Martinelli receiving on the touchline and looking for Kai’s runs or taking his man on from a standing start which is isn’t how you want to use him- he should be making runs as well as Kai rather than him facilitating Kai’s runs. However, when in central areas things are a little different- Kai’s low-touch facilitation is very useful to have close to Martinelli in the box. Gabriel Martinelli is the player that you want taking the most shots in the side and having a centre forward who’s first thought is giving it to somebody else can only be a good thing in fulfilling that goal.</p><p><strong>Right wing</strong></p><p>In an attempt to keep this piece under 40,000 words I’m not going to repeat myself in regards to his balance with Bukayo Saka, it’s largely the same as with him at RCM just without a lot of the 1v1 deficiencies that occur based on his isolation- simply put, a high level runner and header near a high level crosser and passer is going to lead to output.</p><p><em>Gabriel Jesus</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*W9aoeLW31o1TKy0r" /></figure><p>While much has been made of their relationship with Kai starting deeper and Jesus dropping in leaving exploitable space in behind (as well as how their movements have been linked in the box with Kai feeding off of second balls from Gabi for two of his goals for the club thus far), there’s been understandably less talk surrounding possibilities in how they’d function in different roles.</p><p>I’m a huge fan of Gabriel Jesus as a right winger and his tendency to go outside is a bonus to have with a big centre forward occupying the box, the front post runs that Kai Havertz likes to make aren’t just something that can bring about goal scoring opportunities for himself- they are a chance creation machine on their own.</p><p>A gambling Gabriel Martinelli taking advantage of a Kai Havertz front post runs is something we’ve already seen against Luton Town this season and is something we’ll likely see again. Whilst Jesus doesn’t necessarily cross enough when he’s on the wing (which is part of a wider issue with him in regards to inefficiency and a lack of facilitation), it is something that we’ll still likely see more of and having somebody with that box presence is such a good mechanism for dragging defenders away and opening up space for the plethora of box crashers that we have in the side.</p><h4><strong>Summary</strong></h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*pNYWWn99xWehllgF" /></figure><p>It’s important for me to stress that Kai Havertz isn’t and will never be the perfect centre forward, his completeness is something that I’ve highlighted and praised but that completeness isn’t fully combined with raw quality. He does a lot of things to a good, even great standard, but he does a lot less to a truly top tier standard and that does mean that there’s better players around. However, he is of the standard required to lead a side to Champions League glory in the role, Kai Havertz can be Arsenal’s number 9 if we want him to be long term and in regards to squad planning (and the possible incoming of a superstar this coming summer), I believe that it would work out best if he is in fact that.</p><h3><strong>Concluding thoughts</strong></h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*LQWYa1g-olNa089K.jpg" /></figure><p>I haven’t really felt the need to argue over the validity of Kai Havertz as a player in this piece ajd for good reason. Whilst in the time between me starting this article and it’s publishing Kai’s public perception has improved (as his output has increased). My view on the player hasn’t, the “Kai Havertz conundrum” was never really about quality- it was about usage. IN my opinion, we’ve got it wrong so far. His influence must be increased, his instincts of drifting to the background and only doing what’s most valuable must be suppressed if we are to get value for money on Kai Havertz. He most definitely can be the focal point in this Arsenal side, not only that I’d wager that he’s only of value if he *is* the focal point in this Arsenal side and with that (at least in my mind) I’d like to settle the Kai Havertz conundrum.</p><p>He’s been gifted with the power to settle the biggest of matches, he’s been gifted with the ability to facilitate and influence on a level befitting the starting number 9 of one of the biggest clubs in Europe. That gift cannot be thrown away based on his whims and thus the answer to the Kai Havertz conundrum is this- if that gift is harnessed then he will be one of the bargains of the summer, if it’s not, if Arsenal allow for Kai Havertz to play into the stereotype of Kai Havertz, then the recruitment team did in fact make a rare mistake.</p><p>Either the financial outlay was wasted (if he’s restricted to a midfield role, a superstar number 9 comes in and he’s rightfully dropped for Emile Smith Rowe or Fabio Vieira in that RCM role/ a new number 8 or Declan Rice in that LCM role), or Arsenal are a worse team for persisting with him in midfield. The Kai Havertz conundrum is a statement but it also poses a question, one which we haven’t got the answer to yet. Whether it be injuries or environment, we simply don’t know what the club’s true view of Kai Havertz is, until then- the Kai Havertz conundrum remains unsolved.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=d1f38583a2f0" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Martin Ødegaard-problem or solution?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@HBM_afc/martin-%C3%B8degaard-problem-or-solution-3eac18c4d0b8?source=rss-9def112d885c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/3eac18c4d0b8</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[football]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[arsenal]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[HBM]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 18 Oct 2023 17:39:14 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-10-18T18:06:14.889Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>I’d like to preface this whole thing by saying that I absolutely love Martin Ødegaard; he’s one of my favourite stories, and his ability to change in function is truly astounding. He’s a fantastic captain, a leader by more than just example and in the simplest of terms, the best pocket player in world football.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/615/1*QpgVFoKp4G-LElxmd1MTMA.jpeg" /></figure><p>However, not all is well at Arsenal and frankly not all is well with Martin Ødegaard (or at least with his usage).</p><h4>A short (re)introduction.</h4><p>A lot of pressure was put on Martin Ødegaard from a young age, a truly prodigious talent that was pursued by nearly all the giants of Europe, we can glean a lot about Martin Ødegaard the 24 year old from how Martin Ødegaard the 15 year old played. This extract from an <a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20150924051445/http://www.fotball.no/Landslag_og_toppfotball/spillerutvikling/2015/Grottland-Unyansert-kommentar-fra-Morten-P/">article</a> written in 2015 by the now head of player and coach development at the Nowegian football federation Håkon Grøttland presents a lot of the stuff that you’ll see in his game now. His extraordinary pocket play was clearly already developed and the lack of “rules” imposed on him at that age speaks to his current inventiveness on the ball, the scooped passes and small space genius that you’ll often see from him likely derives from this initial freedom and encouragement from coaches to be inventive.</p><p>“He therefore had no “rules” to deal with in the attacking game. He was allowed to let loose and try what he thought was most appropriate then and there. Guidance from the trainers was limited to positive reinforcement and an occasional call to try even harder at what he was good at; namely to identify spaces ahead in the lane.” This passage encapsulates what a young Martin Ødegaard was faced with- a genius of a footballer who’s main job was to exploit that genius through specialisation of what he was good at namely finding spaces and exploiting it through reception or identification of a pass.</p><p>Even more impressive than any creativity he has on the ball is his creativity with the ball, the environment he was placed in has produced that and therefore has produced a player who has an innate feel for the workings of the ball which allows him to manipulate it so well.</p><p>Another factor is the type of pitch that Martin Ødegaard played on as a youth player, as the coach who prompted Ødegaard’s breakthrough into the first 11 of Strømsgodset (the club that Real Madrid signed him from) David Nielsen said before Arsenal’s trip to FK Bodø/Glimt in the 22/23 Europa league group stage “The problem Bodo/Glimt will have is that Martin is the No 1 player in the world on artificial grass.” Ødegaard is a player that thrives in the small spaces and that partly comes from playing in these environments, forced to thrive when the pitch was small rather than attempt to expand it (as a Bruno Fernandes, Kevin De Bruyne or a Fabio Vieira would).</p><p>Small spaces, fantastic spatial intelligence, undersized (as was mentioned in the aforementioned article with him having to play as a LB due to the worry that he’d be muscled off the ball in central areas playing 2–3 years above his age group as an 11 year old). That’s the basis of Martin Ødegaard and while he’s built on that fantastically (absurd outside the box shooting and a great ability to adjust his volume of touches when receiving deeper), fundamentally those are his overarching strengths and asking him to do anything wildly outside of those strengths will likely result in him doing those jobs to a sub-elite standard.</p><h3>Small spaces, big spaces, Bukayo Saka; the issue with the right hand side.</h3><p>“Can be challenged on the use of remote space.” That was the sole criticism of a 13 year old Martin Ødegaard after his first “national initiative” at the Statoil talent camp (again from the same article which I’d very much suggest anyone with an interest in Ødegaard should read) and that really does sum up his issues at Arsenal over 11 years later perfectly- the positives of “Good skills in relation to close range (1st touch, taking off pressure, leading/dribbling, combination play)” seem to sum up his value for the club pretty accurately as well.</p><p>So why does “remote space” matter? Well, it all comes down to the simplest of ideas in football, something we’re all told growing up- make the pitch big when attacking and small when defending. Most of this stuff is done for rather than by a player of Martin Odegaard’s ilk (as it is for a player such as Fabio Vieira as well), players with express pace tend to stretch the opposition block due to fear of being caught in behind (increasing the pitch vertically) and the rest is largely done via player instruction (wingers hugging the touchline in order to increase the pitch horizontally and consistent occupation of the 5/6 channels in order to pin the block so therefore increase the pitch vertically.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/615/1*IhrKOb7Xk-5IzXP2qOj-bg.jpeg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*43sVxg5T1z3qcdf7oRHAOg.jpeg" /></figure><p>Where Martin Ødegaard comes in (or more aptly doesn’t come in) is exploiting that increased pitch via finding those “remote spaces”. Martin Ødegaard largely attempts to find solution within the right hand side, he takes a lot of touches (which is a large reason why he retains the ball so well) and due to the open angles he operates in he’s rarely forced into playing outside of his comfort zone (which I’ll touch on later). This tends to reduce the isolations that occur on the left hand side due to him not directly accessing whoever is holding width, as well as leading to teams being able to more confidently tilt their block towards the right (as seen often with how many players always seem to be surrounding Bukayo Saka when he receives the ball)- if he doesn’t consistently attempt to access the left then the right can be clogged up more as immediate danger isn’t neccessarily present. As Pep Guardiola put it “In all team sports, the secret is to overload one side of the pitch so that the opponent must tilt its own defence to cope.” The issue with Ødegaard is that he’s really good at making the defence tilt towards the right but he’s not so good at punishing the defence for their tilting and therefore he is no longer forcing the defence to tilt- it’s entirely deliberate on their part. That’s the main problem with how the right half space is used, here (in my opinion) are the solutions.</p><h4>Fabio Vieira- the plug and play solution.</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*F20yJbElxfs2KdEfpyDVRA.jpeg" /></figure><p>Fabio Vieira is a big spaces player- his best attribute is his ability to access wherever you want him to access on the pitch with one action. He strikes the ball incredibly cleanly and crosses to a high level (something that’s been missing in this Arsenal side in terms of volume). While he’s not quite as good as Ødegaard at tilting the block (although he’s more than adept at it and it really isn’t that important a skill to have considering Saka’s gravity), where he far exceeds the Norwegian is his ability to exploit that tilted block especially from the right. This is an issue I have with his usage so far, you cut off Vieira’s angles and he is the same passer just with less options (due to already being very direct in nature), you cut off Ødegaard’s angles and he becomes a completely different passer in value (increase in directness largely leads to passes that are more valuable- just look at Martinelli’s <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NJIITj3m2tg">goal</a> against Brighton (1:22 on the video)). That’s not to say that Ødegaard is a better player off the left (I’ll again get to that later) it’s just to say that Fabio Vieira is a considerably worse one. It’s all about weighing up the options here, would the interplay on the right hand side be considerably worse (especially with an overlapper like White)? Not really, but would the access of the left hand side in both settled play and transition improve drastically? There’s no doubt in my mind.</p><p>This left hand side access is not the only thing that Fabio Vieira would bring to that zone over Martin Ødegaard, as I’ve previously stated Fabio is an excellent crosser and unlike Martin, is two footed in that regard. This means that he’s excellent from the left and the right but regardless this is a particular area of focus due to a clear improvement that can be made in the area.</p><p>Half space crossing was a clear area of issuein the 22/23 season and presented a deficiency in Arsenal’s repertoire of chance creation. Arsenal were far less likely to cross from the half spaces than a team such as Manchester City, this is partly due to a lack of a target man to aim at in the area (an issue that’s been addressed by the summer signing of Kai Havertz- an excellent header of the football who’s 6&quot;4 frame acts as a point of gravity for those types of crosses) however, an arguably even more prominent reason was the lack of willingness for our half space occupiers to cross. With Fabio Vieira in the side this is less likely to be an issue, he crosses well and he crosses often (he averages 1.5 crosses more per 90 in the Premier League than Ødegaard). This crossing issue is especially prominent considering the issues with central access Arsenal have been experiencing this season, there’s been a low level of zone 14 occupation and partly as a symptom of this- a low level of chance creation. With the addition of regular half space crossing, the central access issue becomes patched up to a degree and a lot of the open play chance creation deficiencies seen this season will likely be solved (to an extent). The benefits of an increased volume of crossing even within the current side can be seen with Saka’s goal against Bournemouth- the one open play cross attempted by Martin Ødegaard that game led to Arsenal’s only open play goal. Ødegaard’s reluctance to access this “remote space” through crossing leads to an increased creative burden being put on more complicated chance creation methods as well as giving the brunt of the crossing duty to a sometimes overlapping full back (Ben White/Takehiro Tomiyasu) who a) is a weaker crosser than an interior likely would be (and definitely a weaker one than Fabio Vieira) and b) leads to a weakening of the rest defence as the full back has to be high and wide for a fair portion of the game instead of the 3–2 base. This is in addition to the simple increase in fatigue that the full back faces when needing to consistently overlap, as a possession based team running needlessly is a clear flaw and one which is always present when the majority burden for overlaps is put upon a deep player.</p><p>Overall, Fabio provides more value than any other option in the right half space, his transitional qualities are excellent, his associative play is certainly up to scratch and he opens a new avenue for a consistent chance creation method which would aid the new big money signing of Kai Havertz (who’s currently devoid of confidence and is definitively not getting enough service without crossing situations being consistent). Fabio is a far better option to occupy that zone than Ødegaard in my eyes, however he’s not the only option and the other one provides similar solutions while simultaneously being a better match for the profile of Arsenal’s best offensive player- Bukayo Saka.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*ede1SphIAE1t3vwijTYYGw.jpeg" /></figure><h4>Emile Smith Rowe- unlocking Bukayo Saka.</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*hpUCRCqj82Z4a7Tu-qJb_g.jpeg" /></figure><p>While the Fabio Vieira solution was about improving the value of action from the RCM in the right half space, this solution is more so about improving the fluidity of the right hand side while still maintaining the value of actions in the right half space (with the “passer” no longer being the interior but Saka instead).</p><p>There’s been a drastic profile mismatch on the right hand side for the past couple of years and it’s really simple, Bukayo Saka for all his merits is far better suited having the ball played largely into his feet (although his unwavering will to help the team has led to him being a perfectly fine in behind threat when asked to run there). Martin Ødegaard is not a player that fits well with this archetype of player. Firstly, he doesn’t exploit Bukayo Saka’s gravity anywhere near often enough, it ends up being Ben White who does the exploiting through overlaps- something Ødegaard’s one footedness almost completely prohibits him from doing. While the rest defence issue is prominent, even more important is the fact that Ben White is not the best player to have doing that overlap in terms of effectiveness- you simply would rather your attacking midfielder in those areas than your faux centre back (important to note that his ceiling as an overlapper is genuinely pretty high, however, he’s not the complete article there and likely will never reach the levels of an Emile Smith Rowe in terms of value on the touchline).</p><p>Secondly, Ødegaard doesn’t fully emphasise Bukayo Saka’s strengths, the Englishman has a fantastic creative passing range that is currently heavily underused. The volume of slip balls to the inside channel needs to increase in order to maximise Saka’s talents, with the volume of low blocks that Arsenal face, cutbacks from Arsenal’s interiors need to increase (especially considering the box crashing prowess of a Declan Rice or even a Thomas Partey). When the block is pushed back the space right in front of the defence is the most valuable and also some of the easiest to exploit (just look at how many goals Rodri scores for City from that zone), this chance creation method is another that is underused by Arsenal and as much as I’d like to say that Martin Ødegaard is the man for the job he simply isn’t dynamic enough/two footed enough to provide that underlapping threat. That’s where Emile Smith Rowe comes in.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*2piId5pvn_W-_y5BTh1k-A.jpeg" /></figure><p>Like Fabio Vieira, Emile Smith Rowe is a big spaces player. While, the former as previously stated is a player that exploits large spaces, Emile Smith Rowe creates them. A dynamic runner, his in-behind threat stretches the defence and leaves space in front of it as the block is forced to drop. He’s also got fantastic running power and his excellent ball carrying is a top tool to have in transition. This changes the dynamic on the right hand side in transition, the added penetration increases the options when on the break as space in behind is more likely to be used than if you have a Vieira or an Ødegaard in that role. This dynamic running is also very useful in settled play, the ability for Smith Rowe to consistently overlap frees White of this duty and therefore allows him to sit in the base 3 more often therefore adding more security to the rest defence as there isn’t space to exploit in behind him (although Saliba is usually fantastic at cleaning up any of these messes in the channels.)</p><p>Perhaps more important is the flexibility Smith Rowe provides for that right hand side through his ability to occupy the touchline. Bukayo Saka is one of the best receivers between the lines in the world and he rarely gets the opportunity to use that ability as he’s too often holding the width, the ability for him to sit inside at times is crucial in getting more output out of him. Smith Rowe width holding capabilities also allows Saka to cut inside more freely, again getting himself closer to the goal where he’s becoming so dangerous (just look at his goal against Nottingham Forest). There’s also the matter of Smith Rowe’s gravity when carrying the football, too often Saka is asked to face up 2–3 players after receiving a pass from deep areas, Smith Rowe’s ability to carry tends to attract players and also improves the type of 1v1’s Saka takes, lay offs after a carry allow for Saka to already be moving when he squares up his man rather than receiving onto his back foot and having to create separation on his own. Ball-carries create fear in a block and lead to defenders having to gamble- the runner (Smith Rowe) creates the fear, the passer (Saka) exploits that fear. Saka will have the option to cross the ball more (and his angle for half space crosses is actually better than an interiors would be as he’s coming inside and whipping the ball rather than having to open himself up) while Smith Rowe’s willingness to run in a straight line into the box will also increase the volume of the aforementioned slip balls that Bukayo will be able to play.</p><p>All of these factors aren’t even taking into consideration the actual humans at play, they’ve been in the academy together for nearly all of their footballing lives and thus their understanding of each other and associative play is top notch. This largely refutes any issues about how Arsenal will tilt the pitch to the right without a ball dominant player like Ødegaard, these two have the capabilities to replicate that simply through the dynamism (and therefore fear) they provide.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*KMHOwRy0_cc6bfdQAKESJg.jpeg" /></figure><p>It simply comes down to a runner-passer dynamic and where that dynamic occurs. In regards to that, there really is no player more suited to making Bukayo Saka’s life easier than Emile Smith Rowe.</p><h4>So why is Martin Ødegaard still playing RCM?</h4><p>Well, the answer I’d have given you last season was Thomas Partey- the Ghanaian’s overambitious passing and tendency to go with the flow of games meant that without Ødegaard, Arsenal tended to lack control. Without the 6 bringing control to the side it was necessary for both interior’s to be secure in possession and Ødegaard’s ball retentive qualities were arguably entirely necessary in that RCM role last season. However, with the departure of Granit Xhaka (a deep lying playmaker shunted into a box to box role and therefore lacking in final third threat) and the arrival of Declan Rice and Kai Havertz, the dynamics of the midfield changed and Ødegaard’s ball retentive qualities no longer are quite as valuable.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*1OcEm9eNF4Z5Uq-6vwID6w.jpeg" /><figcaption>Graph illustrating the attacking inefficiencies of Granit Xhaka at LCM</figcaption></figure><p>I’ll start with Declan Rice, while he’s technically the first choice LCM in our squad (as Partey wasn’t sold in the summer) the Ghanaian’s absence through injury has led to him primarily playing at 6 throughout his first few months at the club (which is his best position). Declan Rice has none of the same issues that Partey has as a number 6, his conservative nature when passing and ability to (largely) transcend the flow of the game in order to serve as a place of metaphorical refuge in the swirling storm of chaos that is so often what the average premier league match devolves into means that Martin Ødegaard’s ability to retain the ball is no longer quite as necessary (especially considering Rice’s improvement of Arsenal’s rest defence and therefore transition control through conservatism in possession is no longer needed to the same extent ). This therefore largely negates last season’s reasoning as to why Ødegaard is playing RCM, in order to examine why he’s playing RCM this season we have to take a look at the other big money signing of the summer- Kai Havertz.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*3Zmxdp-NR2DMjzg7Gx0Akw.jpeg" /></figure><p>Kai Havertz is a centre forward in my eyes and I’m completely convinced that he’ll end up playing there consistently for Arsenal, however due to the current composition of the squad, the German has rarely played up top (game time being needed for Gabriel Jesus and the ever excellent Eddie Nketiah), instead he’s been shunted into being the left sided 8. While last season it was the job of the left sided 8 (Granit Xhaka) to bind his movement to the inverting left back (Oleksandr Zinchenko) therefore occasionally dropping into the pivot of the 3–2 structure when the Ukrainian was wide, that really isn’t possible with Kai Havertz. Whilst at the start of the season Mikel Arteta attempted (without much success) to maintain the dynamics of that left hand side via having Havertz involved in deep play, instances of that happening have petered out. The German tended to just be an extra body in build up, not quick enough to progress when passing and lacking the fluidness in the turn to evade the press through carries. Therefore, Martin Ødegaard’s role has been altered slightly this season (more so in the past month) which presents a reasonable explanation as to why he’s still playing in the RCM role despite unfavourable attacking dynamics.</p><p>The Norwegian’s role in build up has been flipped in recent weeks with him dropping in next to Rice to act as a +1 in addition and Havertz staying high. While this does leave the formation slightly asymmetrical as the right channel is left vacant, this isn’t particularly worrying as Havertz is the outlet for long balls when the press can’t be broken and Saka is as capable a receiver as you’re going to get when the full back is on his back (as often happens when the press is broken on the right).</p><p>Ødegaard in build up is a very interesting proposition, especially on the right. He’s fluid in the turn and has the technical dribbling to escape immediate danger when being pressed, he’s also forced into not taking too many touches due to the limits of the situation as he’s being pressured, this is in addition to his undeniable intelligence in coordinating his movement with pivot- a lot of the times he drops in is when Arsenal escape the press as he picks his moments to receive well. The open nature of dropping in from the right also aides a player of his ilk, he’s got access to most of the first third just with his left foot and any passes he has to play to his left (usually would be done with the right foot when facing the goal) are short and don’t highlight his one-footedness (he can even just use the outside of the boot as he does often).</p><p>So is the answer to the question of why he’s still at RCM proficiency in build up? Could it also be his willingness in the press and ability to lead it? Sure, that’s likely the reason why he’s still there (as well as the relationships and understanding he’s built on the right hand side especially in regards to the Ødegaard-Saka-White triangle) but it doesn’t neccessarily justify his inclusion in that role. Fabio Vieira and Emile Smith Rowe cannot perform these specific jobs as well as Martin Ødegaard can but there’s no reason they should have to- I’d even go as far to say that it’s detrimental for the RCM to be consistently involved in build up.</p><p>Note: Ødegaard’s ability to lead the press is a totally fair point to bring up when discussing whether to move him, it’s just part of the pro’s and cons of the decision and I think the former outweigh the latter.</p><h4>Saka vs Martinelli and why the LCM should be deep (as long as they are Arsenal’s wingers).</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/700/1*bXrxdSizCq8Ppmmb-KbLyg.jpeg" /></figure><p>Bukayo Saka has the feet and mind of an interior with the engine of a wide powerhouse, he thrives with bodies surrounding him to interchange with and play through. Therefore, isolating him 40–50 yards from the goal just isn’t ideal- he’s not got the express pace to breeze past players and create a transition nor does he neccessarily want to be that direct. While he carries fantastically up the pitch it’s not the best use of a situation where the press is broken, when the opposition has holes in it it’s not the time to consolidate- it’s the time to penetrate and that’s what Gabriel Martinelli can do. While Bukayo Saka is hindered by the abandonment and therefore isolation high up the pitch, Gabriel Martinelli thrives <strong>because of</strong> it.</p><p>Martinelli is a true wide outlet, he thrives in behind and attacks the goal directly. Where he currently struggles as a winger is where he receives with little space and has to square up his man- this isn’t an issue after receiving from a build up situation as he has space to run into (or a ball to run onto). Sure, clogging up the space surrounding Martinelli is fine (he combines with players in close proximity well enough) but he’s at his best when there’s space surrounding him and nobody in his way to hinder him exploiting it.</p><p>This represents the opposite of Saka’s requirements when build up is occuring, while the Englishman is hindered by the lack of somebody occupying the right half space, his Brazilian counterpart almost requires that vacation of the adjacent half space in order to function to his fullest extent (especially considering he’s an inside forward at heart and works best drifting into central areas). By flipping the current dynamics of having the RCM dropping in to help build play and the LCM staying high, both winger’s preferences are satisfied (as are Kai Havertz’s who is far more comfortable receiving on the right if he is playing in a midfield role). Saka’s has the potential to be a big space passer but is largely not that as a runner (at least to an elite level- he still runs in behind with a regularity that you’d expect of one of the most complete wingers on the planet) while Gabriel Martinelli is a big space runner and certainly wouldn’t be categorised as a big space passer, therefore, for the left dynamics to work he needs to be paired with one (or something close to one- I’ll get onto that in a second).</p><p>Having the LCM deep also makes more sense when only considering the base 7 involved due to the inverting of a full back from the left. What makes an inverted full back so useful is the difficulty that the opposition has when pressing it due to it’s fluidity. While the number 6 is intended to be a fixed point in build up, not moving too much or rotating too often with others so that they are a consistent passing option, the inverted full back functions very differently.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*YNVKsPRzNDukpnVZwQ4t4w.jpeg" /></figure><p>Using Arsenal as a case study, Zinchenko usually starts in a conventional left back position in a 4–1 or a 4–2 build up shape (either the single pivot is receiving or it’s the single pivot and Ødegaard). This In a man to man pressing scheme the winger just follows Zinchenko inside when he inverts (therefore creating a clear passing angle for Gabriel to the winger), however in a hybrid scheme (which is getting more and more common) the winger has to choose whether to follow and allow the space to be vacated (and their fullback to be left 1v1 with the winger) or sit and occupy that space and allow for a numerical overload (in the hope that whatever central players they have can block off the passing lanes into the newly formed pivot). The fluidity of this is what makes it a decision to the team out of possession, if the fullback is always tucked in then there’s no “inertia” period where they are a free option or space is opened up, same goes for if the fullback is always wide.</p><p>Note: Martin Ødegaard dropping into the pivot isn’t necessarily a set structure that’s employed yet, he doesn’t drop into the pivot every game (and almost certainly won’t when it’s Rice in the 8 and Jorginho/Partey/Elneny in the 6). However, I’d expect that if he continues to play in the role, the tendency of him to drop in as we’ve seen will become more common and crucially more set in as a structure, especially when the other interior is more a 10 than an 8 (Havertz, Vieira, Smith Rowe).</p><p><em>So what does this have to do with LCM role?</em></p><p>As previously mentioned, it’s vital for the health of a build up phase for the 6 to be rigid, having an inverted full back right next to the 6’s position isn’t particularly in agreement with that. The 6 is impacted as they’re forced to move across when the full back inverts and the full back is impacted as they no longer have “carte blanche” over when to invert (which is especially impactful to a Zinchenko type who’s role is partly having ability to recognise when to invert, subsequently acting as a sort of first phase general via tampering with the flow of the build up and recognising the triggers that allow for space to open up in behind the first line of the press). However, when a full back is inverting towards the side where an interior is positioned it allows for more stability in build up, the 6 is still a constant but the 8 and the LB are more able to change their positioning in order to find solutions. This is what happened with Granit Xhaka last year with him occupying the 2 in a 3–2 sometimes, but also occupying the left half space in a front five. With the way Arsenal build up it’s simply more efficient to have the LCM dropping into the pivot to build rather than the RCM (with a prime example of this inefficiency being the increased occupation of the right side of the pivot by Zinchenko which forces him to cover more ground when Arsenal goes back into it’s defensive block as well as not allowing him to be as aggressive in the counter press as he has defensive responsibilities on the opposite side of the pitch.</p><p><em>What about when Arsenal invert from the right?</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*kRmgPVMtFUoqwWqDCZvw1A.jpeg" /></figure><p>There isn’t much evidence on how Arsenal build up in regards to which interior drops into the pivot when a player inverts from the right (although it was Granit Xhaka last season for the last two games of the 22/23 season when Thomas Partey inverted) as Ødegaard hadn’t started consistently helping in build up before Zinchenko returned from injury and Arsenal started inverting from the left again. Therefore, without clear evidence to the contrary, shouldn’t the opposite logic be true for inverting from the right than from the left- shouldn’t an RCM be a better fit in build up when inverting from the right?</p><p>In theory, yes. All the benefits of an LCM dropping deep when the left back is inverting apply identically to an RCM dropping deep when the right back is inverting. However, football isn’t played (much to my dismay) on a tactics board and the profile of the man inverting from the right has to come into play. Jurriën Timber is a very different profile of player in possession and as a result, has different requirements and possibilities of usage. The Dutchman is not Oleksandr Zinchenko, he’s far more rangy than the Ukrainian and moves a lot more both on and off the ball. His ball carrying is one of his best attributes and he’s perfectly adept at progressing the play both inside the pivot or out on the touchline. Zinchenko is far more refined and controlled, more inclined to progress play from inside than outside and a better receiver in the pivot than Timber. He’s at his best when confined to lateral movements off the ball whereas Timber is far better played next to an unmoving presence than being that presence. The freedom for Timber to receive both outside and in the pivot is essential in using him to his fullest capabilities, he’s not a first phase general and while Zinchenko’s best role is fluid <strong>within</strong> the context of using an inverted full back, Jurriën’s role is fluid <strong>via</strong> the standard of an inverted full back.</p><p><em>So what does that have to do with which interior is involved in build up?</em></p><p>Well, it all comes down to balance. The rigidity of the 6 balances well with the roaming nature of Timber, he’s equally adept at operating on the right side of the 4 as he is at operating on the right side of the 2 in build up. This means it’s less impactful on Jurriën’s effectiveness in build up to bind his movements to the 6 rather than an interior as he’ll be able to spend more time on the outside of the pivot. With an interior next to him rather than the 6 he’ll be restricted in where he can go, more time spent in the pivot as the interior moves high just isn’t the best usage of Jurriën Timber. The same isn’t true for Zinchenko, he’s rigid enough where his movement is better bound to a more fluid interior (especially considering his lesser usefulness on the touchline)- Jurriën’s is better bound to a more rigid 6 (as he moves in the 6 moves left).</p><p>Note: It’s a completely fair point to make that surely the initial logic of the left sided inversion should apply to Timber when he inverts from the left (as he did in the Community Shield win over Manchester City). However, the angles on the left side are much more favourable for inside proggression for the Dutchman as well as less favourable for outside progression (right footer on the left touchline usually struggles to pass as well down the line due to the way the ball is coming in to the receiver- out to in rather than in to out). There’s also the argument that Declan Rice favours the left hand side of the pivot (as it has better angles to progress and it’s easier to carry the ball from as a right footer). Whilst he does favour the left the Rice clearly doesn’t have major issues on the right- a notch against the LCM dropping in (as he’ll have to occupy the right side of the pivot while the full back is in conventional areas) for sure, but it isn’t something worth changing the build up shape to accommodate.</p><p>This all brings me to my main solution for Martin Ødegaard and what I believe is the cure for his usage issues.</p><h3>Martin Ødegaard at LCM; the good, the bad and why it’s necessary.</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*IKYFrvVgzSJXdxB6eZ61ug.jpeg" /></figure><p>The fundamental issue with Ødegaard at RCM is that his value in advanced areas is just too little to have him solely operate there. His zone of influence on a game needs to be larger in order to deserve the sizeable contract he’s been handed, Ødegaard at LCM (especially with that LCM being a deeper role) does just that. The forced directness that is a by-product of his angles being cut off (left footer on the left side) as well as the increase in areas of reception that would occur with him consistently operating deeper would increase both the volume of actions that would occur as well as increasing the quality of those actions. Too often Ødegaard lets games slip away from him, too little responsibility in tandem with too much influence- if Arsenal’s ability to play well is going to be influenced by Ødegaard’s ability to influence the game then he needs to have more responsibilities to match that influence and given what he can do, that responsibilities has to come in the form of an increased role in deeper phases.</p><p>If Martin Ødegaard isn’t utilised in a different manner to how he is currently, then not only will he be shackled to a role that doesn’t maximise his usefulness but Arsenal will be shackling itself to an imperfect solution- it’ll be at the mercy of the whims of one footballer who like every other footballer can have his off days and even when he’s as on it as can be, will still not provide the best of the best production. That why he needs to be used differently, that’s why he needs to be moved deeper.</p><p><em>In possession.</em></p><p>Martin Ødegaard has a heavy angle bias, he’s one footed and this clearly affects how he receives the ball as well as the passes that are available to him once he has it. While when he’s on the right hand side of the pivot with his back facing a presser he has a large portion of the pitch available to him on his left boot, when on the left hand side he’s far more limited. He’ll also likely be less secure when on the left, when turning to his left (which is likely to happen as that’s where most of the space is when receiving on the left hand side), he’s more likely to show the ball to the defender as his body isn’t between it (has to use the outside of the boot to push the ball left). When turning right using his left foot his body is between man and ball which is a safer turn. Ødegaard knows this and it’ll likely just lead to missed opportunities to progress rather than turnovers but it does bring forth inefficiency in deep build up. The limits that his angle bias puts upon him would likely lead to somebody who’s inefficient in build up on the left hand side, reliant on risky outside of the boot passes and bounce passes into deeper players (therefore shirking progressive responsibility). Therefore resulting in enforced safety when being progressed to by a centre half.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*2Kge29njk29gbZxdlkvfJQ.jpeg" /></figure><p><em>Out of possession.</em></p><p>He’s also got issues out of possession that would come with a deeper role. Whilst one of his main positive attributes in a higher role is his exceptional pressing and leading of the line, he’s likely far less suited to blocking space in the pivot. He’s also not a fantastic defensive dueller, his slight frame isn’t suited to going into tackles and he isn’t particularly adept at nicking the ball before a duel is necessary (lack of burst/ defensive experience). Is he robust enough physically to play in a pivot out of possession? Is he disciplined enough defensively to block more valuable space consistently? Does he have a good awareness for interceptions? Is he competent enough in the air for a deeper role? There’s a lot of unanswered questions there and it presents a fairly compelling case as to why Mikel Arteta hasn’t deployed him in a deeper role.</p><h4>The good.</h4><p>Martin Ødegaard made his international debut at the age of 15, within 7 years he was captain. He made his debut for Arsenal on the 30th of January 2021, within 18 months he was captain. If there’s one thing that I could say about Martin Ødegaard it would be that he’s an exemplary employee for Arsenal football club. A leader by example, a hard worker and incredibly adaptable. An early criticism of the Norwegian at the beginning of his spell at Arsenal was that he didn’t shoot enough, he now (joint) holds the record for non penalty goals by a midfielder in a Premier League campaign. There were questions over how he’d be off the ball as a number 10, that’s now nearly universally viewed as one of his strengths. His character is arguably his greatest strength and it’s the main reason why I believe that Martin Ødegaard has a successful future at Arsenal.</p><p>I see no reason why his angle bias has to be a part of his game moving forward, if he’s asked to improve his weak foot (note that if this happens his reception issues will largely fall away due to an increased confidence in using his right), I have full confidence that he’ll manage to do it. He’s also an incredibly smart footballer, I’d be very surprised if his defensive brain isn’t at the level required and as he naturally progresses as a footballer most of his physical deficiencies in terms of robustness should become less of a worry. He’s managed to adapt his game within the confines of a position, I see no reason why he can’t adapt his game to a new one.</p><p>There’s also simple positives with moving him to the left that require no level of work or adaptation. Firstly, as previously mentioned the balance between him and Martinelli is great, his creative numbers would spike as he’s afforded a runner and with his angles being cut off he’d become more of a threat transitionally due to forced directness. This directness would also translate to his half space crossing, less time to think and less touches in the final third would force him to produce that action more often (which is especially beneficial considering Kai Havertz’s likely CF conversion and his preference to drift to the right hand side). His temperament already presents him as a better option in the role than anyone in the squad aside from Declan Rice and if he can iron out his in possession deficiencies (build up) there is simply no reason why he can’t start the biggest of games in the role. There’s also the matter of his exceptional finishing ability when shooting across his body, a large issue with his shooting comes from his struggles when opening up, this wouldn’t be an issue on the left as the angles for his favoured drilled shot to the bottom left hand corner of the goal are more favourable. His offensive movement will not be affected either, he will still be one of the best box crashing midfielders in world football- just with better angles to get his shot off. He’ll also be a far more effective runner, while not a dynamic over lapper, he’d certainly be a threat on the underlap (something Arsenal have sorely missed since Granit Xhaka’s departure), further increasing his creative output.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*hNbIjauwCHQ_xG-jk4lktQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>The best pocket player in world football, an output monster, an enabler for offensive runs by the guy that Jürgen Klopp called the “talent of the century” and the club captain of <strong>The Arsenal</strong>. Martin Ødegaard has the potential to culturally define this iteration of the football club, all of the ingredients are there for that to be from LCM, but there’s a touch more to it than that.</p><h3>My dream for Martin Ødegaard (and why that contract doesn’t have to be a costly mistake).</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*UXSu55Yqi7hEOo8c2vkdfQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>Martin Ødegaard the all conquering, era defining LCM is not likely to happen, potential isn’t a promise. Just because the ingredients are there doesn’t mean that they’ll necessarily come out of the oven exactly how you wanted them too.</p><p>I’d love to be able to tell you that every ill plaguing the game of Martin Ødegaard can be rectified through hard work, I’d love to be able to say that X leads to Y because of Z is a rational way of looking at football- but it’s not. With Charlie Patino coming through the ranks and the existence of Declan Rice as an option in the role (as well as the possibility of a new signing there) Martin Ødegaard probably will never be the first option in the role. It ain’t all bad though, what he can become is one of the most valuable squad pieces on the planet, who’s minutes come from his versatility rather than his inherent game breaking quality. In essence, I believe Martin Ødegaard can become Bernardo Silva and <strong>here’s why.</strong></p><p>Martin Ødegaard’s traits are some of the most transferrable around, he’s always a force of retention and his technical base will mean that he’s always a guy who’s hard to press. He’s also shown a level of defensive application which further presents the idea of Martin Ødegaard as a floor raiser. My dream for Martin Ødegaard is for him to be a sure thing, a guarantee of technical stability and off the ball application that can play on the biggest of nights when those two attributes are needed most- when the inevitable chaos descends and the standards are highest being able to keep the ball as well as being committed when the ball isn’t yours are the two fundamental pillars of winning. Martin can provide that. There’s one issue right now (outside of his angle bias) and it pertains to the former fundamental rather than the latter, Martin Ødegaard’s body doesn’t hold up the best in contact- it’s the thing stopping the Bernardo Silva-fication of Martin Ødegaard to come into full effect. His body simply isn’t robust enough to hold up against the rigours of playing out wide, a core principle of usage is that you put your “piano pushers” out wide and your “piano players” in the centre. The physicality monsters parole the touchline while the artists craft inside. It’s a different world out there and Martin Ødegaard simply isn’t ready for it. Not all is doom and gloom though, there’s real cause to believe that the Martin Ødegaard of the future will be able to survive out there and it all comes down to the development that we’ve seen from him off the ball in the past season or so.</p><p>While a certain portion of his pressing acumen has to be attributed to his mind- he leads the press fantastically well and implements the instructions to a tee. The main thing that has improved out of possession in the last year is his physical robustness, his ability to perform high intensity sprints and subsequently partake in duels to a high standard has come on leaps and bounds. Sometimes with how long he’s been around we forget that the Norwegian is still only 24 years old, the underdeveloped tag that’s been attributed to him his whole life still hasn’t been fully shed. If he becomes more robust, more able to take contact, there’s no reason that he won’t be able to survive out on the touchline. Will he ever be a two way threat, routinely taking on his man down the outside and whipping balls in on his weaker foot? No, nothing close to that but what he can be is a force of retention and calm while also having a solid level of attacking returns if he’s surrounded by dynamic runners.</p><p>The value that he has the potential to provide through doing the basics well and allowing our “moments players” (the ones with true game breaking quality- your Vieira’s, your Martinelli’s and dare I say your Havertz’s) to shine is incredibly high. The potential of Martin Ødegaard if he can become a technical assurer across the pitch is simply this- Bernardo Silva with more output. Bernardo Silva with more output is worth that contract, the risk of that contract is not that the Martin Ødegaard of the future doesn’t deserve the money, it’s that we won’t ever see the Martin Ødegaard of the future.</p><h3>Concluding thoughts.</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*ljxoTpwVo0ASMKTqsTp_Pw.jpeg" /></figure><p>The sad truth is, Martin Ødegaard in his current form does not deserve a starting place at Arsenal, the fit is all wrong and it’s part of the reason why Arsenal’s attack in open play has been so poor this season (only 10xG in 8 games). I’ve talked about his usage a fair bit and that is an important issue, it’s a disservice to Martin Ødegaard to expect him to be something that he isn’t- to expect the attack to flow through him in the same way that Manchester City’s attack flows through Kevin De Bruyne and Manchester United’s flows through Bruno Fernandes (when he isn’t shunted out to the right wing). But we are also doing a disservice to Mikel Arteta by expecting him to take a risk on the Martin Ødegaard of today, moving him to the left presents many issues and when the stakes are as high as they are, we can’t expect risks to be taken- especially when the risks are in regards to potential issues in build up (look at the differences in impact that the loss of Gabriel Jesus had to the side compared to the loss of William Saliba). It’s why I’d rubbish any talk of Ødegaard being switched to a deeper left sided role mid game, unless it’s been heavily worked on in training and he’s gotten used to how the left side works then there’s no way that he’ll be risked there.</p><p>While I’ll espouse rhetoric about what should happen, I simply don’t know what’s going on in training but, what I can definitively say on the situation is that a discussion needs to be had, Ødegaard at RCM doesn’t make sense as a first option and we are at the point where either change in the player has to occur or change in playing time has to occur. Yet, amidst the seemingly gloomy nature of the situation hope persists. There is absolutely no reason why it has to be the playing time that changes long term. The idea that a player with the work ethic of Martin Ødegaard is unable to improve his right foot is an absurd concept, we all have a habit of looking at a players flaws as set in stone and a players strengths as just as rigid. Are we really suggesting that if both he and the coaching staff are willing to make an effort to rectify his angle bias that they couldn’t do it? Are we suggesting that the improvement of a weak foot is beyond the grasp of a footballer who captains both club and country at the highest level? I’d suggest that the question isn’t whether he can change it’s whether he (and the club in general) wants to change.</p><p>So that’s where the optimistic tone of this article comes from, I myself believe that Martin Ødegaard has the ability to reach his unquestionable potential as an all phases technical assurer. Inaction is the enemy here, risks must be taken. What would’ve been of the treble winning season at Manchester City had an 18 year old Rico Lewis not been plucked from the academy and put into the first team- was he any less of a risk than Martin Ødegaard at LCM? I have faith in Mikel Arteta to come face to face with his pragmatism and take a leap of faith- sure, the frying pan may lead to a fire but that’s not the point. Martin Ødegaard deserves for that risk to be taken on in, constricting a player to where they are comfortable is one of the worst things a coach can do to them, I’m sure Martin Ødegaard wants to be the best version of Martin Ødegaard and that simply won’t happen if the status quo is maintained.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*uN-aVeGeD06QeOh1CzntHw.jpeg" /></figure><p>It was a definite risk making Martin Ødegaard the highest paid player at the club, it strips the club of an out if things don’t change and potentially blocks the pathway for more impactful players in his role. Would I have given that contract to him? The answer is probably no, is it a lost cause though? The answer I’d give is the same. His qualities being as guarenteed as they are means that there’s never going to be a footballing world where Martin Ødegaard doesn’t matter and there’s the possibility of a world where Martin Ødegaard matters more than nearly any other footballer on the planet. Football the game will always have space for those who understand the ball to the level Martin Ødegaard does and football the profession will always have space for those who understand the work that needs to be put in. That’s why Martin Ødegaard will never go out of fashion and a footballer like that is always worth having at the football club.</p><p>With that inherent value in mind if he’s not influencing the entire pitch within 18 months something has clearly gone horribly wrong, when the foundations are this good you can put the player anywhere and he’ll succeed- so don’t be surprised when the lightbulb turns on and it all clicks into place. That’s the most likely outcome right now, the one that makes the most sense.</p><p>Only through arrogance will Martin Ødegaard’s usage continue to be an issue, and if arrogance is present in the management of the football club than the Norwegian will be the least of it’s worries.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=3eac18c4d0b8" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Inverted Full backs, inverted centre backs and why they’re good news for young midfielders.]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@HBM_afc/inverted-full-backs-inverted-centre-backs-and-why-theyre-good-news-for-young-midfielders-c11474bd975c?source=rss-9def112d885c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/c11474bd975c</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[football]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[HBM]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 02 Sep 2023 02:05:06 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-09-02T02:05:06.294Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/225/1*CGThg3qo_JPczdpQ0Hfm8A.jpeg" /></figure><p>I don’t need to tell you the origins of the inverted defender, any example I could cite as the first instance of its usage would undoubtedly be predated by somebody far more knowledgeable than I am on the subject. What I’d rather talk about is what they require, who can play there and how the role differs with different tactical set- ups.</p><h3>The inverted full back in the box</h3><p>The box really came to prominence in this last season (22/23) in the public eye, a 3–2–2–3 that saw Manchester City win the treble and saw Arsenal run them pretty damn close to one of those trophies. While we saw inverted full backs at City first, I’m going to take Arsenal and Oleksandr Zinchenko as a case study here, why he works inverting from the left and perhaps in something more pertinent to the future of the role, why he doesn’t.</p><h4>The “Zinchenko role”</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/300/1*bYBgA_ePKwVPuQwXSyU4FA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Oleksandr Zinchenko</figcaption></figure><p>The 26 year old Ukrainian international started his career as an attacking midfielder (and still plays in midfield for his country) but was converted into a full back by Pep Guardiola upon his arrival in England. Converted midfielders are common among inverted full backs, after all, their in possession duties are far more similar to a deep lying midfielder than any conventional full back.</p><p><em>What he’s good at.</em></p><p>Zinchenko has an incredible turning radius which allows him to effectively receive the ball and progress despite often being embedded within the second line of the press. His compact frame means that when pressured he effectively keeps the ball (this frame is common amongst good inverted full backs) . He disguises his passes fantastically when progressing the ball further into his interiors, with those passes usually being crisp and empathetic (correct foot to receive on/not too much spin). Top tier close quarter dribbling allowing for consistent ball retention. A willingness to sit in the pivot rather than roam keeping the rest defence in tact while simultaneously being crucial for recycling. He’s also a tactically intelligent player, with the tactically flexible nature of the inverted full back role (especially with the rise of the 4–2–4 build up) knowing when to invert based on where the defensive cohort is on the pitch. He also meets the demands of the role in the more complex tactical aspects, his recognition on when the press requires a 3–1 structure (staying wide) or when it requires a 3–2 (inverting into the pivot) is near flawless. This comes from a really intuitive understanding that Zinchenko has, many players wouldn’t be able to recognise when the 1,2,3 players pressing in the first line are successfully blocking his passing lane and therefore making him redundant as consistently as Zinchenko does. The flexibility of the inverted full back is what makes it so difficult to press (especially when not going man2man).</p><p><em>What he’s not so good at.</em></p><p>He’s not a fantastic ball carrier, his strides don’t have the power to breeze past players especially in central areas (which is completely fine considering that central ball carrying is most useful in transition where he mostly finds himself on the left flank anyway). Zinchenko is also not anything special as a crosser of the football which means that in the occasions he finds himself wide left he often doesn’t take full advantage of it, another issue with him occupying the wide left channels links back to his ball carrying, he isn’t fantastic 1v1 in the same way a Kieran Tierney is (which to be fair isn’t a huge shame considering his poor crossing). His in possession deficiency’s are minor in general though, his issues mostly come from the less glamourous part of the game. Don’t get me wrong Zinchenko isn’t horrible out of possession he doesn’t harken back attacker in defenders clothing Andre Santos who’d frequently have bouts of simply forgetting that he wasn’t playing in an attack vs defence drill during the Emirates formative years. He’s not exactly a liability off the ball, any accusations of poor defensive positioning are usually overblown, the space he leaves in the left channel tends to be a necessary evil of having a full back tuck in. However, nobody would claim that he’s remotely elite. He does have a tendency to be unaware defensively (no surprise as a natural midfielder), he doesn’t cover ground exceptionally well (again not uncommon among those with that compact inverted full back frame), his lack of running power doesn’t help in defensive 1v1’s either , his lack of lateral quickness as a consequence of that running power deficiency can often lead to him getting beaten to the by-line. He’s also got a tendency to get twisted up far too easily again allowing for easy box access and while he’s perfectly fine in readjusting his body orientation it’s often too late. He’s not an exceptional duellist either, his stocky legs aren’t exceptionally adept at nicking the ball and he has a slight tendency to go into duels half-heartedly (again likely a product of his early days as an attacking midfielder).</p><p><em>If he’s so bad defensively why does he play?</em></p><p>It’s a bit of a false hypothesis, but what it comes down to is that Arteta sees him as a net positive despite his out of possession deficiencies. It really isn’t a huge issue for teams such as Arsenal or Manchester City, they usually have enough of the ball where a player’s in possession value far outweighs the importance of their out of possession value (or lack thereof). This idea is even more pertinent when going up against low-blocks, where the ball is more likely to be in the hands of the Arsenal’s and City’s of the world for large, large stretches of time. However, against teams that have the technical quality to hold the ball for portions of time and/or has exceptional outlets that can exploit sub-par elements of a rest defence/ settled block. The margins are smaller and in Pep Guardiola’s quest for Champions League glory the Cancelo’s and Zinchenko’s of the world just wouldn’t do, when chaos is guaranteed, Pep just wasn’t willing to have players who wouldn’t thrive in it.</p><h4>Rico Lewis, John Stones and the rise of the inverted centre back.</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/225/1*wBTxhx9J4gJci74NyBvkHA.jpeg" /><figcaption>John Stones</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/183/1*K2pCvOGc3g0dxmOmWbVWGg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Rico Lewis</figcaption></figure><p>It’s January 2023 and Pep Guardiola isn’t happy, his team has just won 4–2 at home to a frankly dire Tottenham Hotspur side that would proceed to follow up their best start in Premier League history by imploding completely beyond my (as an Arsenal fan’s) wildest dreams. Pep, then proceeds to go on a post-match <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bX_71nAo4ug"><em>rant </em></a>calling out his player’s passion and will to win. That was partly true, there was a sense of numbness at the Etihad that clearly came from the extraordinary success that had preceded the now famed 2022/23 season, but there was a deeper issue. Pep hadn’t quite cracked the code and Manchester City’s superstar full back Joao Cancelo wasn’t helping.</p><p>The Portuguese international had been widely regarded as the best full back in the league the 2021/22 season (although I’d like to have words on behalf of a certain Merseyside-based generational deep creator) however his defensive deficiencies were all too clear, he had/has a tendency to wander into the half spaces leaving Rodri with far too much ground to cover. His 1v1 defending also leaves a lot to be desired, as shown most prominently in a humiliation courtesy of Mohamed Salah at Anfield in a tight 1–0 defeat which left City 4 points behind an Arsenal side that had just had a drama filled 1–0 win at Elland Road (the match was delayed due to issues with the Hawkeye system that enables VAR, there was a missed penalty, and a red card/ penalty was overturned in the last minute) which left the unfancied Gunners in a position of belief. These issues were further compounded by attitude issues that arose, seemingly due to a lack of game time. All of this culminated in the player (who’d been included in the PFA team of the season a year prior) being loaned out to Bayern Munich in the January window.</p><p>A large reason for that lack of game time was the 18 year old Rico Lewis’s fantastic performances in the inverted full back role, while a midfielder in the academy, his defensive qualities (good running power, top positioning and generally impressive 1v1 defending) are more akin to a natural defender, this in combination with his incredible turning radius, willingness to sit in the pivot and progressive passing qualities makes him an example of the future of the role. Very little weaknesses and not a compromise in the same way that a Zinchenko is. However, as an 18 year old there was and still is a rawness about him so it&#39;s no surprise that Pep didn’t fully trust him for Champions league nights, there was no way Pep was willing to risk him getting caught up in the occasion. In came John Stones and a major basis of why I’m writing this piece.</p><h4>John Stones</h4><p>Arriving at Manchester City in the summer of 2016 for an initial fee of £47.5 million from Everton there was a lot of pressure on the then 22-year-old and while throughout his first 5 or so years at the club he’d shown glimpses of the player he’d become, a combination of injuries and stiff competition meant that he was by no means a guaranteed starter coming into the 22/23 season. Nowadays, when he’s fit, he’s one of the first names on the team sheet.</p><p><em>What he’s good at.</em></p><p>Stones is more than competent at switching the play which is a huge bonus when in settled attacking phases as it allows City to quickly make use of the underloaded side when the defensive block overcommits on their gravity players (Haaland, KDB etc). He also uses his body very well receiving the ball from the defence, his size helps with this but his extensive scanning before reception allows for him to orientate his body so that there isn’t a necessity to perform half turns that are likely a step too far from somebody who’s more natural behind the ball. He temporizes play very well, rarely gets caught up in the flow of the game often recycling the ball when a lesser pivot player would attempt to progress it needlessly (I’m looking at you Thomas). He also covers ground at a respectable rate which allows his movements out of midfield into the defensive block to be without issue most of the time. This also comes into play with the help he hands to Manchester City’s rest defence, able to move vertically and counter press well or laterally move and hold players up to a high level, his out of possession qualities when in midfield are truly a huge factor in Manchester City’s ability to sustain pressure at a high level. He’s a good channel defender, a superior alternative to Zinchenko in that regard as well as being an impressive duellist. His long legs allow him to take the ball from places that he shouldn’t necessarily be able to and there is a level of commitment to that action which isn’t as present in the Ukrainian&#39;s game. John Stones is also an impressive box defender, aerially sound, adept at blocking shots and good at tracking runners. Stones is also an imperious ball carrier as shown in the champions league final, with his strides eating up ground quickly while also having the ability to make micro adjustments on the ball that you’d expect of someone far closer to the ground. He has a similar tactical intelligence to Zinchenko, adept at knowing when to step into midfield, with his ball carrying helping in that regard as he’s often allowed to carry there and simply sits. His passing is also crisp and the breadth of his backswing is incredibly useful when manipulating blocks as he can easily deceive those attempting to block passing lanes by convincingly feigning to one option and then closing himself off at the last minute and fizzing the ball into a different teammate.</p><p><em>What he’s not so good at.</em></p><p>John Stones doesn’t have a truly elite turning radius, while he makes up for it by being clever with his body, it would be unwise to consistently ask him to receive on the half turn in the same way that you could ask a Zinchenko to. This can often lead to an isolated Rodri as, Stones isn’t fully comfortable stepping in as early as Zinchenko would, if you want to play through a press with John Stones as an inverted centre back, you’d be smart to have a secondary controller to drop in to the first/second phases in order to take some of the ahead of the ball build up responsibilities off Stones. He isn’t a Ruben Dias level box defender either, there’s not an air of invincibility around him in the duel, he’s good, but he’s not exceptional (not that it matters too much considering his role).</p><p><em>Is the inverted centre back an inherently better solution?</em></p><p>No of course it isn’t, it’s got it’s advantages and disadvantages same as the inverted full back, really as tactics always do it comes down to the players, but I’ll get to that in a minute.</p><h3>The inverted centre back vs the inverted full back</h3><h4>The functional qualities of the inverted centre back</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*bpMWSktxj68Il79YviNm-Q.png" /><figcaption>4–2–4 from goal kick, pre-Stones inversion</figcaption></figure><p>Before the inversion, the inverted CB is still responsible for similar build up duties to what a conventional CB would be required to fulfil. It requires composure to be able to pick out the spare man, an understanding of the risk of passing short into central areas and the confidence to do so when that risk has been assessed.</p><p><em>Understanding of when to invert.</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*gJZr8RUzgVdXdFIj-nEo9Q.png" /></figure><p>It is crucial when inverting from deep areas to be safe in that manner, it does require a shifting of the backline and the zone vacated is far more dangerous than that of an inverting full back. This can lead to a tendency for players to invert later from a central position simply due to a fear of the value of the zone vacated. However, this issue can be slightly reduced depending on the skillset of the inverter. If an excellent ball carrier (which should be one of the main qualities looked for when hoping to use a player in the role) is in the position, then the ability to carry the ball into the second line and sit reduces the chances of the ball being lost when the zone is vacated. Stones certainly fits the bill, as does a player such as Frenkie De Jong, who’s an example of a midfielder that could move back, similar to the path of most inverted full backs rather than a defender moving forwards as seen with Stones.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*r2kPpE5ix0Qs0yKRyYnqIQ.png" /><figcaption>Out of possession movements of an inverted centre back.</figcaption></figure><p>The lack of requirement of lateral movement and lack of channel defending makes the role more suited to player’s with less running power (who tend to be taller as a function of where they defend). Better duellists would likely find their home here which would be useful in the vertical movements that are succeeded by a duel in counter pressing situations.</p><h4>The functional qualities of the inverted full back</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*_6msn6ZPA35ClsZo5gLOtQ.png" /><figcaption>Arsenal 4–2–4 build up with M2M press, pre-Zinchenko inversion. (Arsenal don’t always use this shape, but have recently used it in build up especially in pre-season)</figcaption></figure><p>The role of the inverted full back largely mirrors that of the full back that would tuck into the last line of defence later on(White). A large part of the initial responsibility is wide progression, the scenario of a pass from the centre back to one of the double pivot who then turns it around the corner to the wide full back is not uncommon. Unlike the inverted centre back, the inverted full back is often the spare man, so there is a larger onus to make more ambitious passing in deeper areas. If the usual deep build up plan doesn’t work (out-in-out/out-in-line break) then it can also be the responsibility of the inverted full back to receive a pass from the centre back with a presser on their back, the subsequent sequence of play requires good decision making (calmness on the ball not to go long, ability to recognize whether ball side pivot is open, choice between wall pass to ball side CB or pass into GK), two footedness (ability to make early pass inside as reception would likely be with the right foot in order to block off the opportunity for the presser (Silva in this case) to immediately intercept.), physical robustness (in order to absorb initial contact from presser), turning radius/close quarter dribbling (in order to retain and progress/spin presser if they over commit. The back to play qualities that an inverted full back should hold usually makes them a very useful build up tool due to the ability for them to receive in higher areas under pressure rather than just as the free man (as is often the case for traditional full backs/centre back converted full backs).</p><p><em>Understanding of when to invert.</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*ulLyV--LqvNok2ucusxSEA.png" /><figcaption>Man marking press, with Zinchenko wide just before possible inversion.</figcaption></figure><p>Unlike an inverted CB, the zone that is vacated doesn’t immediately have to be filled, it’s good if it is filled to an extent (deeper positioning of LCB compared to wide LB) but if it isn’t, all that is left is a possible passing lane to the winger. However, there are issues with it being left entirely vacated as that passing lane is sub-optimal when accessed by the LCB from more central areas due to the fact that there is the possibility of the full back getting touch tight and then the winger receiving at a poor angle. If the LCB does occupy the bottom of the zone then, it does require a general shifting of the backline to not leave the high value zone that the LCB was occupying completely open. When the inversion occurs, the pivot is required to shift right, so an important aspect of inverting is to do so when the pivot isn’t on the left which would lead to over congestion and subsequently you’d lose any spare man advantages that could crop up. There is also the requirement of the LCM in the channels to shift slightly wider, it is nearly always sub-optimal to have two players in the same vertical lane (poor angles to receive in/less ability to a) run on to the ball (creates separation for cross or carry) or b) take it on the half turn (part of those poor angles is the likelihood of having to station the body entirely towards the passer due to a defender likely being on their back when in those lanes. Unlike the inverted CB, carrying the ball into central zones isn’t as much of an option, horizontal carrying in deep areas is always risky due to the access it allows for defenders and while vertical space is often present for deep players, horizontal space beyond/within the first line of engagement often is not. More flexibility in inversions, but maybe less in type of inversion.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*aXeqvYAg7-J0kYc_IM7XZg.png" /><figcaption>Out of possession movements of an inverted full back</figcaption></figure><p>There’s a larger requirement for lateral movement, but also a greater license to roam and “hunt” when ball winning (why a Caicedo type is such a useful player in the role). In the 4–4–2 block the inverted full back is required to be a good 1v1 defender which speaks to that running power (something many of the inverted full backs that have cropped up struggle with due to their starts in midfield). This is a generalisation of the role though, and I’d like to talk about a specific example of the inverted full back that presents why we might have to wait some time to see (near) flawless interpretations of the role.</p><h3>Trent Alexander-Arnold</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/300/1*R8Z0RWH8tA9x80QG8rB_Yw.jpeg" /></figure><p>Jurgen Klopp’s famed 4–3–3, heavy metal football had brought a Premier League title and a Champions league to Merseyside, ending their 30 year drought in the former. High intensity, full backs high and wide, inside forwards, false nine, conservative eight’s that would run for days and a lighthouse 6 in Fabinho. Nobody was more important to their success than Trent Alexander-Arnold, the most creative passer in the league. In deep, wide positions nobody in world football is as adept as Trent at finding his man. He is an alright defender, he covers space well enough, his defensive positioning is nothing special, he doesn’t necessarily excel in 1v1’s nor is he a liability. In 21/22 Liverpool were two games off of an unprecedented quadruple, then the culmination of a lack of care with squad building and a steady physical decline of some star players came to the fore.</p><p>The 22/23 season was rotten from the start, a league that was far too good to be out muscled and a team that was nowhere near physical enough to out muscle teams like they used to. Liverpool simply ran too much, played too much for a decline not to happen, they were direct to a fault, they no longer could press like they used to and as they lost the ball, they lost control and the spaces appeared.</p><p>There’s a fundamental issue with having full backs high, it leaves space behind them. That’s fine if you suffocate the opposition, if they never get the chance to use that space. That’s fine if you have the most imperious centre half that we’ve seen. Liverpool by 2023 had neither. Trent was wrongfully scapegoated, deemed a terrible defender for the spaces that he was asked to vacate, the spaces that used to be covered, the spaces that used to have no danger. The profiles weren’t there anymore, you could argue that the football wasn’t possible any more.</p><p>Klopp had seen the success of the inverted full back, he’d seen the midfield superiorities that it brought. He understood that it could hide the newly mortal Virgil Van Dijk’s deficiencies, he knew that it could promote Ibrahima Konate’s strengths. So he changed things up, a promising performance on the 9th of April against top of the league Arsenal showed promising signs and proceeded to go unbeaten in their last 9 games of the season. Trent Alexander-Arnold’s creative output improved, all seemed well, the tweak had worked. They were title contenders once more.</p><p>Not quite.</p><p><em>Why the inverted full back isn’t plug and play.</em></p><p>Let me start by stating what Trent’s flaws aren’t. He is a no worse defender than Zinchenko who thrives in the role, that’s always the thing that people try to get at Trent with and that’s not going to happen here. No, Trent’s real issues are in possession.</p><ol><li>Trent Alexander-Arnold is a very direct footballer. He can pass wherever he wants, so he does. He is not a good temporizer of play and in a pivot that’s kind of essential. In order to work in settled play he needs to be surrounded by cautious profiles, which he isn’t. That’s not Klopp’s philosophy, the shape may mirror Pep’s but that doesn’t mean he craves control in the same way. The naturally direct profiles surrounding Trent and including Trent lead to Liverpool being sucked into transitional games, which is exactly what the inverted full back is supposed to prevent.</li><li>Trent is not fantastic ahead of the ball. He is nothing special on the half turn, doesn’t show in build up nearly enough. It really isn’t his game he doesn’t have the mentality of a midfielder and he sure doesn’t have the body of a pivot (not quite compact enough for my liking). That being said, I wouldn’t have it any other way.</li><li>Unless very, very specific circumstances are met, you are wasting Trent Alexander-Arnold. Trent needs, an RCM that is a)comfortable taking the majority of build up responsibilities (Trent stays wide) b) comfortable dropping into the pivot so that Trent can rotate wide (where he’s best) and Salah can come off the touchline (where he’s best) c) Has the temperament to counteract these two direct profiles. Even then, the rest defence is weaker as Trent still takes up wide positions, it’s worth it due to his creative upside being something that we haven’t seen from anybody else, but in this current Liverpool teams those criteria aren’t being met leading to Klopp’s men being sucked into transitional games and conceding goals like the second <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_11PMQTzlnM">clip</a> here (mostly Van Dijk’s fault but it’s not an uncommon sight). In short, you can’t just put a player into the role, you’ve got to be creating player driven-systems if you don’t have system-driven players (which very few do).</li></ol><p>However, when roles are brought forward football has an uncanny ability to create profiles that fit those roles, even separate from those actually using it.</p><h3>Ivan Fresneda</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/300/1*ojCKb8Unt2VU2EfKihXjLA.jpeg" /></figure><p>There’s no transfer that hurt me as an Arsenal fan quite like Ivan Fresneda’s move from Real Vallodolid to Sporting. Originally of Real Madrid’s academy, the 18 year old had a breakout 22/23 season, making 22 La Liga appearances and impressing in many of them. The most <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MxOxwYIFZoM">eye-catching</a> performance may’ve been his fantastic defensive display against Real Madrid against the mercurial Vinicius Junior.</p><p><em>What makes him so unique?</em></p><p>Ivan Fresneda stands at 6&quot;0 tall, he’s got an unusually broad chest, rangy legs and flexible hips. So what does this mean? It makes him absurd when defending 1v1’s. His broadness makes it hard for the winger to move him and therefore find an opportunity to move past, his flexible hips mean that if he is moved he is quick to correct himself, meaning that he’s rarely fully beaten. In addition to this, his rangy legs mean that once the winger gets into his range, he’s fantastic at nicking it off them. Not only has he got the physical attributes to be a top tier 1v1 defender, he’s a technically good 1v1 player as well.</p><p>He’s almost goading the winger to the touchline, barely side on, he matches their step count and his eyes are always on the ball. He’s never completely closed off though, always ready to adjust, but his smart positioning means that those adjustments are usually small and easy rather than big and time-consuming (I’m looking at you Ben White).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*SaWC85IkTQa5_inE8fM_pA.jpeg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*SEgdXne8i-fSc_oS5e0MaQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>He also covers space incredibly well, those rangy legs cover ground very quickly, both laterally and vertically, which is something essential for the inverted full back role in counter-pressing situations and when holding up play in the channels to buy time for the block to re-organize.</p><p>He’s also got fantastic in possession qualities that make him suitable for the role. He’s a fantastic ball carrier- manipulates his step count well while having long, powerful strides. He takes in contact very well largely due to his broad frame, he uses that frame well in reception similar to a Stones. This is in addition to turning fantastically well which is largely down to the flexibility he has in his hips. He is a calm presence on the ball, not overly direct and has shown flashes of being able to temporize play. His passing is crisp and his touch is rarely loose. While he does have a tendency to drift that’s normal at his age and could easily be coached out of him. If that’s not enough he’s got a fantastic delivery, is a dynamic presence on the overlap and has a good brain for interceptions, not too aggressive unlike many young players. He can be Kyle Walker, he can be Andy Robertson but most importantly he is Ivan Fresneda and that’s something we’ve never seen before, a defender who can naturally invert, a new breed as such who will rival (and exceed) Rico Lewis, who (if he stays at left back) will rival Valentin Barco as the new breed of full back.</p><h3>Why it’s good for young midfielders.</h3><p>“Nobody wants to grow up and be a Gary Neville” Jamie Carragher may’ve been joking when he said that but it’s indicative of a larger point. The full back position in it’s most basic attacking form (in the first line and wide of two centre backs) is the least valuable position on the pitch (unless you’re Trent). The lack of use in these zones is a large reason why you rarely see elite teams use a back 4 in possession anymore, it’s all back 3’s. In the quest for midfield superiority the box and diamond has been introduced, the 3 in settled play has become 4 as the 4 at the back becomes 3. The closest thing we see to a traditional full back is the outside centre half of the back 3 on the opposite side of the inverted player ala Ben White or Nathan Ake and yet they are still more centre back than full back.</p><p><em>So why is this good?</em></p><p>In general, the rise of inverted defenders increases those operating in midfield areas in possession and as the teams that usually use them generally have the ball, it creates an extra spot in the starting 11 for somebody that has midfield qualities. No longer are full backs failed midfielders forced to perform actions that they don’t wish to and are unsuited to, not physically robust for the flanks and too good technically to be misused there, instead they operate in the areas they wish to.</p><p><em>So what specifically about each role helps young midfielders?</em></p><p>Firstly, I’m going to go through some generalised attributes of each role which need to have a general overlap with a players’ qualities in order to be a general fit for the role (important to note that deficiencies can be covered up, but that would likely only happen if their other qualities were exceptional enough).</p><p>Inverted full back:</p><p>Running power, Half turn reception, technical dribbling, deception on passes(block manipulation), temperament to transcend game state, ability to cover grounds, good 1v1 technique, half turn reception, good awareness (scanning before reception), tactical intelligence to know when to invert, good aggression on interceptions, generally fine box defending, good duelling capacity</p><p>An inverted centre back is similar with less emphasis on 1v1 defending, more emphasis on vertical movement rather than lateral, a greater emphasis on box defending, greater emphasis on ball carrying and a more cautious mentality in regards to inversions.</p><p>Most midfielders who’ve been converted to inverted defenders were 8’s, I believe that it’s far smarter to convert 6 types (or at least 6 adjacent) as they operate in similar areas of the pitch and their temperament has to therefore be similar (if slightly more aggressive).</p><p>The cropping up of different types of inversions has only broadened the volume of midfielders who can play in the role. While once a midfielder such as Manuel Locatelli would be wasted as an inverted midfielder, now he could invert from centre back without being found out in the channels, with his lateral movement no longer being a key part of the equation. As the explosion in talent continues in world football, the increase in specificity of roles increases the possible usages of profiles. As stated previously this doesn’t just go for 8’s as well.</p><p>Discourse around Manchester City midfielder Rodrigo Hernandez would make you believe he’s an infallible 6, they pay no mind to the compact spaces of Guardiola’s system, the duelling monsters he’s surrounded with to make up for his out of possession weaknesses. There are few in world football who could eventually be helped by the inverted centre back role more than Rodri. Already often played at centre half for the Spanish national team, the reduced distances to cover and the lesser responsibilities in duelling (in comparison to a lighthouse 6) the inverted centre back role would perfectly hide his deficiencies (which are only going to become more pronounced as he eventually declines physically). This isn’t just him specifically, the inverted centre back role will likely provide a home for many 6’s whose powers have waned in regards to their movement, who no longer are quite so powerful, so fluid.</p><p>A midfielder such as Charlie Patino could become a low block solution in the role, tall and languid, he doesn’t have the power for the channels, however I’d have no such qualms about seeing him inverting from the middle. This is similarly true of many of his type. With the rise of low blocks, box defending becomes less and less imperative, therefore options are increased. This is particularly important as schedules become more packed, increasing the quality of supposedly makeshift solutions is how to preserve the true difference makers when the margins are slimmer. When a team controls the ball, it becomes far less important what deep players do in the first 40 yards, the next 20 is what truly matters.</p><p><em>Closing thoughts:</em></p><p>With the footballing schedule becoming ever more saturated and the margins ever slimming at the top, non-elite fits such as players operating in zones that they don’t wish to becomes a less viable option. The increased prominence of both the inverted full back and inverted centre back gives a wider array of body types and qualities the opportunity to prosper in zones that are suited to them. Lighthouse 6’s that are athletically declining can be converted into inverted centre backs that don’t have to cover as much space, defensively strong, compact 8’s that aren’t penetrative enough to be an elite interior can invert from both sides, centre backs who are maybe sub-elite in the channels but turn really well can step into midfield, midfielders who carry the ball incredibly well but don’t have the space to do it higher up the pitch can make the most of that attribute. It represents another path into the elites, it broadens the scope in a world where it only seems to be narrowing, as the role becomes more normalised the volume of overlapping profiles will increase. Both roles represent a sort of death of the traditional full back, an imperfect hybrid- a half position that operates in areas that are fairly innocuous or pick up positions that leave too much space. It’s a step towards perfection, tactical security and maximising valuable profiles, hiding their weaknesses and accentuating the strengths of players with valuable qualities. It’s a step towards specialisation, the system allowing for versatility rather than a player being able to operate in multiple areas to a fine standard within a fixed system. The extremity of quality in solutions provided is more valuable than the volume of solutions provided, these roles allow for an increased usage of those who provide that extremity and signifies the downfall of those who only provide volume.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=c11474bd975c" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>