<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Hugo on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Hugo on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@HugoYuwono?source=rss-d98ffc7faf45------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Fri, 20 Nov 2026 19:35:19 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@HugoYuwono/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Absurdity of Garbage Discourse and Drama in MUN]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@HugoYuwono/the-absurdity-of-garbage-discourse-and-drama-in-mun-8ff47cd2aa53?source=rss-d98ffc7faf45------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/8ff47cd2aa53</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[mun]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Hugo]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 01 Sep 2026 14:58:20 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-09-01T15:15:47.774Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>This whole thing could have been solved with a conversation, better public relations, and maybe grown adults doing something else.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/235/0*ZXOW-IGT8Mow3xcp.jpeg" /></figure><h3>A Long List of Unnecessary Drama</h3><p>Since 2020s, The Circuit has evolved in ways that previously were untold in a pre-pandemic circuit. From exponential growth in conferences between 2020–2022 (with a later surge post-Bhinneka MUN in 2024), multiple firms offering training services, the rise of regional conferences and clubs across many provinces, and an explosion of participation in what had previously been a Jakarta-centric activity. Yet, if there’s anything that has remained consistent (which is saying a lot), it’s that the circuit likes to accommodate and platform trash moments of conflicts.</p><p>From a campaign for an award promotion after the end of the conference, to plagiarism accusations leading to doxing. Things have gotten crazy. The last two, being caused by disgruntled individuals who were very trigger happy (and aren’t busy enough) to engaging in extreme theatrics over the perception of seeking justice. To that end, it is astonishing that the circuit never really collapsed over any of the major crises that arose through the years. Attributed to the pacifism and reluctance of stakeholders (including fossils) to really take any of them seriously (with the exception of harassment) since accommodating fire with fire has never worked ever. Both in simulation and in real life. Unfortunately, this also leads to a lack of accountability, partly due to legitimate inaction that could have addressed the issues that occurred.</p><p>Taking an example of the 2023 scoring case in Yogyakarta, the whole thing would have been over from the beginning if people knew the parameters that surrounded the scoring process and the expectations of the council. That being said, the rules and policies of said conference was extensive enough that it prevented someone from being hexed over comments that clearly was light-hearted, and was not an indicator nor reasoning to force a promotion of a delegate from honmen to most outstanding. On the other end, the plaintiffs knowingly elevated and created a conflict from thin air to try to push an award promotion, and was too worked up and lacked the humanity that comes from accepting what is itself an achievement.</p><p><strong>A delegate of their delegation winning an award on their second-ever conference.</strong></p><p>The shenanigans that followed, which caused a conference to be disrupted and the collapse of an entire MUN club, could have been mitigated if the plaintiff of the case above was held liable. To this end, they were never held liable. Thanks in part to a circuit that rewards loyalty above objective facts. To which the faction that supported the plaintiff would itself collapse within a year. Unsurprising for a bunch of people who spent too much time larping as historical figures who betray each other for the primary goal.</p><h3>Last Week’s Discourse</h3><p>To say the whole debate was unnecessary and deeply flawed, is an understatement. For one thing, misinformation was spread on the notion that chairs knowingly created high standards that automatically eliminates the designation of a Best Delegate award under supposed unsatisfactory opinion of the chair. Going as far as to claim that it is a policy, which is deeply misleading. While the Crisis Council certainly has its deep problems, this whole argument is deeply and dangerously misleading. From my own experiences, some Chairs can be quite strict with how they score, going so far as to claim their own standards. That being said, the concept of no Best Delegate being given applies at a case-by-case level. As there is a chunk of Chairs who very much still give this award, coupled with asterisk feedback on the performance of the council.</p><p>They aren’t the chunk of Chairs who diminish their delegates over unanswered QARMAS and topics. Rather, they are representative of an old pre-pandemic circuit that knows how deeply wrong such a decision is. Now made worse with a universal, non-data driven claim that suggest the general practice is not to give the full awards. To the credit of the CSTD council I took part in, they were able to give a detail explanation to my university on why the award wasn’t given. While I personally disagree with their decision, more so after I chaired myself and not conduct such decision, their ability to explain the logic in place of closed-door metrics serves as a model for other chairs. My opinion on this matter remains the same on my <a href="https://medium.com/@HugoYuwono/the-problems-of-the-indonesian-mun-circuit-part-two-de7133776674">MUN Problem Part Two Article</a>, which sums up my opinion on this particular matter.</p><p>To this end, I must state what needs to be desperately stated. The Circuit should not accommodate utter garbage discourse, designed to get a reaction. Yall need to understand that we are either in school, university, or in some cases in the workplace. Itself, a reminder that we live in the real world, not a fake one. Engage in dialogue, create well-crafted arguments that don’t needlessly spin, and embrace the real world at the same time. The concept of people duking it out over something this miniscule is just, awful and low. Then again, my articles have been said to be useless so I digress.</p><h3>The Next Step</h3><p>The circuit is better off having meaningful dialogue on matters of policy in the backdrop of real life. The rising costs, confusing award parameters, the social gap between chairs and delegates, and the big ego in all are legitimate issues that needs addressing. At the same time, many of us are very much going through high school, university, and the job market. Unsurprisingly, its <strong>VERY IMPORTANT</strong> compared to having debates on something that isn’t even reality.</p><p>The gift of knowledge of the Circuit and the wider Model United Nations community is best utilized not at taking down each other, but rather at creating meaningful contributions in this world. From Academic Papers, Opinion Pieces, Historical Comparative Studies, to general discourse on a struggling country. The potential is very much and always there. It shouldn’t be relegated to who has what award and how many titles and positions they have in the circuit. A deeply misguided mentality that creates the social construct that MUN is everything when really, it’s a supplemental study activity.</p><p>To paraphrase project IMMUNE:</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=8ff47cd2aa53" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[A Year of Writing, Commemorating 365 days of Medium Presence]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@HugoYuwono/a-year-of-writing-commemorating-365-days-of-medium-presence-bba65f9e21cc?source=rss-d98ffc7faf45------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/bba65f9e21cc</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[commemoration]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[anniversary]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[reflections]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Hugo]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 20 Mar 2026 15:45:00 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-07-20T01:02:03.567Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>A lot to celebrate, and remember</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*ZcWkMT_9YTENdrXhY6j8sQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Self-Gallery, Taken at the Le Meridien Hotel</figcaption></figure><p>A year ago, I made a decision that would alter much of how I would see myself by publishing an article I had considered keeping to myself. Titled Redefining What It Means to Be a MUNer, the article wasn’t originally meant for public consumption. Rather, it was meant to remind myself why I was doing the activity at that time, in the face of an environment that then and now continues to be toxic. Filled with problematic, misguided individuals who continue to see themselves as prophets and guardians of a circuit they see as a religion.</p><p>But as time went on, the article evolved into a deep dive into what I think should be the best kind of personal values and paradigm for doing the activity. With the goal of ensuring that anyone participating in this activity would come out as strong ethical leaders who are resilient to challenges in this unforgiving world. One that had been simulated by a bunch of problematic, over-stimulated teens and young adults who surely enjoy causing suffering to others. But I digress.</p><p>Ultimately, the article kick-started a much-needed discussion in the circuit. Later, complemented with an article that existed out of frustration with the Verbal Commendation award, a reflection on the worthiness of the Best Delegate title, a problematic interaction, the press council, and the two-part article discussing what I had assessed as problems in the circuit. Culminating in hundreds of views, some responses, and one person getting hung up over scoring matrix transparency.</p><p>At the end of the day, I started writing because I was lost in the circuit. At the time I wrote the first one in late 2024, I had recalibrated the reasoning why I continued. After everything that went down with my then-club, and the degrading and toxic behaviour of high-level MUNers who had no shame in committing character assassination the year prior. But much like the world, I too had to move on from countless hours of ruminating. The article was my way out, not some blind delegating one-upmanship. I am glad I chose the former.</p><p>If there’s a sentence that represents what I continue to go through (though interpreted by someone else), it is a comment left in my first article by a senior of mine on campus that read:</p><blockquote>“I hope you can find peace in the “dynamic and unpredictable” landscape of the Indonesian MUN circuit and reach a harmonious resolution to those who have violated your boundaries and abused your trust. Finding peace is a wonderful thing when we’ve discovered the way to do so. Peace is not for others, but it’s for ourselves.”</blockquote><blockquote>— Ria Dara, writer of Pipeline Era</blockquote><p>An ongoing mission that I continue to pursue to this day. Regardless of the loudest critics and naysayers.</p><p>I am grateful to readers of my page for their inputs over the last year, and the real impact this page had on my first-ever chairing role. This year, I look forward to broadening my horizon beyond MUN and transitioning towards International Relations and pop culture. The latter has been trialed as a topic for <a href="https://www.instagram.com/p/DUI2wHpD8B9/?img_index=1">Diskurasi</a>.</p><p>Thank you for the feedback and reactions. Stay tuned, more to come.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=bba65f9e21cc" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[An Updated Opinion on the Scoring Matrix]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@HugoYuwono/an-updated-opinion-on-the-scoring-matrix-3f7e3375f735?source=rss-d98ffc7faf45------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/3f7e3375f735</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[retraction]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mun]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Hugo]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 19 Mar 2026 19:41:53 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-03-19T19:41:53.862Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Since last September, I have reflected on my remarks in the aftermath of my last two articles on what I believe to be ongoing problems in the circuit. In the section discussing the scoring matrix, I had argued that improved transparency and some form of standardization would allow a delegate to formulate an improved diplomatic strategy. Whilst at the same time, some form of standardization would alleviate much confusion regarding how the substance is used and scored, with improved outputs to the expectation of both the delegates and the chairs of the council. Looking back, the statement was flawed.</p><p><strong>I want to clarify that in no way was there an intention to oversimplify the issue.</strong> Though it certainly didn’t help that it looked like it. In the aftermath of its initial release, some deliberations were made on the tone of that article section, with particular regard to a line in the scoring matrix section which had read:</p><blockquote><em>The solution here is simple:</em></blockquote><blockquote><strong><em>The Committee must disclose the scoring matrix at the end of the conference to the delegates and give it to them.</em></strong></blockquote><blockquote><em>Make it an obligatory practice, starting now. Why? because the delegates deserve to have tools at their disposal to substantively improve upon their performance, especially given the high costs of admission.</em></blockquote><p>Looking back, those comments on making transparency obligatory were deeply flawed and emotionally charged. By the end of a conversation with a crisis source, I realized that I had inadvertently made a generic suggestion that had not considered the challenge a council like Crisis would have for such transparency. Given the different method it uses to collectively score directive outcomes and the front room/backroom dynamics. As such, edits have been made to the article.</p><p>That being said, I would like to make it clear that in no way did I intend to insinuate a generalized standard for all councils. Rather, such moves can be done in the aftermath of transparency efforts on how scoring works at the behest of the circuit and its organizers. According to agreements between multiple stakeholders, as mutually agreed upon.</p><p><a href="https://medium.com/@HugoYuwono/the-problems-of-the-indonesian-mun-circuit-part-one-b49d0cc57500?source=friends_link&amp;sk=e7ca71dba39eebe9ede26b372ccbee4e"><strong>Edited Article with revised remarks on the 19th of March 2026</strong></a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=3f7e3375f735" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Problems of the Indonesian MUN Circuit: Part Two]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@HugoYuwono/the-problems-of-the-indonesian-mun-circuit-part-two-de7133776674?source=rss-d98ffc7faf45------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/de7133776674</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[mun]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[model-united-nations]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Hugo]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 26 Sep 2025 15:52:09 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-09-26T15:52:09.365Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Because part one wasn’t enough.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*LgI6UsGljNWXELN7-xdP3g.jpeg" /><figcaption>Source: Author’s Gallery from JMUN 2025</figcaption></figure><h3>Lack of Transparency</h3><p>An argumentation touched upon in sections discussing politics, criticism, and substance within MUN, transparency as a concept is hard to come by, to my knowledge. Looking at the concept broadly, and based on my observation, transparency only exists when something horrible occurs in the circuit. That happened in September of 2023 and June of 2024 in the MUN circuit.</p><blockquote>With that in mind, what would be the primary reason behind the lack of transparency?</blockquote><p>Be it discourse, substance issues such as the scoring matrix, or the mere general explanatory discussions of MUN Politics. It harkens back to the individuals and groups themselves. While many reasons have been made to justify this secretive world, one could argue that a person’s goals within MUN are the primary reason. To my knowledge, that is the case. For some, achieving a “career” in MUN means being compliant with the establishment. Perhaps, the expectation here is for a person to have significant influence over an organization and its people and turn it into a personal playground. A phenomenon I have personally observed in some people who believe that they are never wrong.</p><p>As such, establishing transparency at its core requires one important principle, and that is <em>Legowo,</em> which means sincerity. The ability to separate personal interest in favor of the greater good, and the understanding that while ideas have room to grow, so does criticism. A circuit that encourages ideas and discussion for the better future of MUN in Indonesia. That is what I believe MUN should be.</p><h3>Nepotism</h3><p>Early in my journey, I was of the belief that chairing a council is a natural progression of delegating. Not that as a career, as some would put it nowadays, but that of a journey. A way to cement the education aspect of this extracurricular activity. Unfortunately, looking at current circumstances, it is nothing but a pipe dream.</p><p>From my experience and observation, the supposed path to becoming a chair was not what I had expected. From my observation, if you want to be a chair, you don’t need to have many awards, to the point that you can chair in a council that you never delegated in the first place. Why? Because, from my observation, a person can become a chair through connections more than awards, this “culture” is known as nepotism. Connections, which can be achieved through personal favors, internal referrals, and resource-based lobbying by those who can afford to create a conference or to utilize a mun company to assist in their journey, free of hindrance. Hence, individuals with the resources (monetary and/or connections) can rise to the top of the circuit instantly. It just doesn’t seem right to me that some MUNers who have done their best and achieved several awards in MUN have a hard time being recognized as a suitable chair in a conference. This is not to say it applies to most MUNers, but from my observation, it happens nonetheless.</p><p><strong><em>With that in mind, I ask this of the circuit:</em></strong></p><blockquote>Should a MUNer be solely accepted as a Chair because they know someone in a club/conference? Or should a MUNer be solely accepted because of meritocracy, where experience and awards matter more than connections? That is up to the circuit to decide.</blockquote><h3>The High Price of Admission</h3><p>Around 2019, the pricing of an MUN conference at the high school level was already quite steep for someone starting. For 300k Rupiah, there’s a lot that can be spent with that kind of money, much less the 1 million starting price for most varsity-level conferences these days. With that in mind, one thing does bug me about that starting price.</p><blockquote><strong>How can a non-accommodation admission be as high as 1,8 million Rupiah these days?</strong></blockquote><p>The question, for me at least, showed up in a conference early this year. Where a varsity-level conference in February, held by a varsity mun club, became one of the very few offline conferences to offer a price of around 400k Rupiah. For that price point, it was able to offer the quality of a varsity conference for a fraction of the price. Similarly, within the same month of February, a conference with a 750k Rupiah price was able to do a conference in a hotel. Despite the venue changing on both days, it was able to offer a similar experience to a big four conference with half the cost of an early bird non-accommodation pricing. This begs the question:</p><blockquote><strong>Does a conference need to be expensive for it to be worth joining?</strong></blockquote><p>As someone looking from the outside, knowing the lowest was at one point was 1,3 million Rupiah, function is everything. A conference can consider offsetting the cost for delegates. This can be done through cutting down the grandeur and council options whilst retaining the resources needed to retain a well-organized conference with high-quality debate.</p><p>At the end of the day, the option goes back to the respective clubs and committees. Particularly, the committee that selects the venue and does the cost-benefit analysis of the options they have. That being said, stable pricing, particularly for a non-accommodation admission, would be greatly appreciated in our ever-difficult economy. A hybrid-style conference does not resolve the pricing problem; if anything, the high barrier of entry for those longing for the experience of an offline conference remains. Which in the past could generally be had below 1 million Rupiah.</p><h3>The Decline of Varsity Delegates</h3><p>If there is anything to note with the current landscape we have today, it’s that there has been a significant decline of varsity MUNers, especially in the Big Four conference. So why is that the case? Well, it harkens back to several sections in this article.</p><p>From my personal view, several factors come into play. The first factor is the price of admission. When I was applying for a double-delegate council this year, the costs of the conference’s non-accommodation were, to my double-delegate candidate, considered too expensive. As such, they pulled out, and I received a replacement decided by the committee. So, it makes sense to recognize that pricing has gotten too high for a varsity-level MUNer.</p><p>The second factor is the increased presence of high school MUNers in varsity conferences. Which goes without saying brings a certain feeling of being obsolete to older, varsity delegates. Particularly in how some behave and act in debate. Though I would be remiss if I didn’t recognize how some were highly competitive and mature delegates. The same, however, can’t be said of varsity delegates being chaired by a high school MUNer. Which, from what I have heard, brings a certain feeling of awkwardness and ire by varsity MUNers who felt that they should have been chaired by fellow varsity MUNers, not high school MUNers.</p><blockquote><strong>The solution here would be a reduction of price admissions, and the prioritization of varsity-level MUNers to be a chair in a varsity-level conference with the head chair and one of the co-chairs from the varsity-level, if feasible, all three chairs are from the varsity-level.</strong></blockquote><h3>Conclusive Statement</h3><p>I hope both articles can help MUNers understand the problems we face within the circuit, and to know that discussion and criticism are necessary. There is still time to improve the circuit for the better. My hope is for the circuit to be much greater for the next generation of MUNers.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=de7133776674" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Problems of the Indonesian MUN Circuit: Part One]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@HugoYuwono/the-problems-of-the-indonesian-mun-circuit-part-one-b49d0cc57500?source=rss-d98ffc7faf45------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/b49d0cc57500</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[model-united-nations]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[indonesia-circuit]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mun]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Hugo]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 13 Sep 2025 15:44:04 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-03-18T23:24:56.641Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>Should these issues remain unaddressed for the foreseeable future, disinterest and eventual cessation of mun can only be attributed to the very stakeholders who refuse to confront legitimate concerns.</em></p><p><strong>Previous remarks suggesting the mandatory disclosure of the scoring matrix have been revised after reflecting that the remarks at the time of release were deeply flawed (19/3/2026)</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*LgI6UsGljNWXELN7-xdP3g.jpeg" /><figcaption>Source: Author’s Gallery from JMUN 2025</figcaption></figure><p>For better or for worse, the circuit has drastically evolved since the dawn of the 2010s. Much of it includes the increased growth of conferences in the last decade. With the backdrop of problems looming behind it. Problems were seen as a far cry prior to the pandemic. With all the post-pandemic growth that has occurred, the following is my personal take on the circuit’s problems. The first chapter, that is.</p><h3>Power Politics</h3><p>For much of the circuit’s existence in the late 2000s, there wasn’t much of a present political atmosphere, with the politics that had occurred being limited in scale and niche enough that they didn’t degrade the experience. Conversely, at present, much of what occurs in the circuit has gotten into the inter-personal realm. With individuals systematically and surgically targeted over perceived hindrance to an interest group&#39;s goals of award dominance, committee influence, and a difference in style. Such treatment, from personal observation, has been directed towards those from opposing interest groups and the executive board over a variety of reasons. Be it interpersonal dynamics, policy differences in scoring and operations, contentious conference bidding, and club dynamics.</p><p>Taking into consideration what has occurred in the last two years, what is clear is that politics in MUN is an inalienable reality. One that must be recognized in its truest form, not shunned and swept beneath the rug. An undeniable reality that has occurred far too many times, one that creates a mountain of problems and unresolved puzzles that eventually erupt, no matter how tight attempts are made to cover for it. When it does erupt, not much is done to resolve it, and instead, it is devolved into a needless and dangerous blame game.</p><p>Besides cover-up attempts and unaddressed policy, operations, and preference differences, another critical part of MUN Politics is the power relations between individuals and groups. Wherein people who hold on to the executive board tend to be dismissive of delegates and anyone externally with their opinions. Instead of actively listening or creating dispute settlements that are transparent, several individuals, to my personal observations, tend to be more focused on the optics of their position at all costs, and push aside the problem. Opening the door for issues to pile on, and a brutal blame game to occur, which will inevitably hurt someone.</p><p>In resolving MUN Politics, a considerate move would be to create conflict resolution mechanisms that emphasize not only that of fair results but also that of transparency. While it certainly will bring a certain level of PR nightmare, a just and transparent conflict resolution will build trust in a conference towards delegates and their faculty advisors. Providing peace of mind and building trust with the committee in other conferences moving forward. Additionally, a hands-on approach and attempts at removing bias will ensure fair treatment of any and all entities within the circuit with no exemptions. That being said, probable bias and favours will still be present even if some mechanisms are there to prevent them, given the lack of governance and regulations within the circuit on operations and rights of delegates. Leaving room for loopholes open for exploitation.</p><h3>Anti-Criticism</h3><blockquote>“Raise your voice, Raise Diplomacy”</blockquote><blockquote>-HSMUN, 2019</blockquote><p>In a post-Reformasi world, the assumption is to have discourse in every section of life. One that extends to competitions and how it operates. The MUN circuit surely is one that does democracy justice. The conference slogans always emphasized the creation of an ideal world through discourse and discussion. The unfortunate reality paints a different picture. For the most part, criticism within the circuit has been limited only to that of conference feedback, with no further checks and updates made on the supposed changes made accordingly to the delegate’s complaints. Furthermore, much of the discourse that exists outside has been limited to that of calling out people in certain circumstances, but not much aimed at criticizing other MUNers and how they operate conferences, and related business.</p><p>With several exemptions in September of 2023 and June of 2024, the circuit rarely engages in any form of discourse critical of the circuit and stakeholders. While seemingly not important on the surface level, criticism is practically the foundation that MUN strives to build upon and enhance among its participants. Much like its founding course, which is International Relations, MUN bridges policy debates coupled with criticism. Something that is lacking in practice and seemingly is only reserved for the simulated debates.</p><p>The lack of criticism in many ways can be attributed to the social relations within MUN itself, with existing social cliques and the feeling of great discomfort from criticizing friends and colleagues within this world. With supposed “criticisms” only existing (to date) due to a certain mob mentality toward whatever is unpopular and not from the content itself. The circuit’s reaction to the mere notion of creating a marketplace for allocation is one example, yet one will hardly find even the mildest of criticism on the concept of mun mentoring.</p><p>Making matters worse, to my knowledge, people within the circuit are more inclined to keep things appearing stable on the surface to the point that even the smallest inquiries about things that occur are declined. The culture of resolving things internally has historically exacerbated conflicts within the circuit and has diminished the need for an objective and necessary criticism in creating a sustainable environment for all actors involved. As such, for the most part so far, attempts at public criticism have been largely dismissed, with at least one individual referring to the author’s articles as nonsense and a waste of time.</p><p>The only way for the circuit to start, even the most minuscule steps in fixing itself, comes from encouraging varying opinions critical of how the circuit ideally can operate and exist. Not purely from a market or delegating perspective, but also that of personal takes that will be valuable to committees and their leaders in shaping a coherent, nurturing, and democratic environment. One that puts their delegates and chairs first, not PR points in the circuit.</p><p>As such, on a personal note, I highly encourage anyone, regardless of the varsity or high school, to engage in discourse. A lack of discourse will only encourage the worst kind of silence. The kind that leads towards disaster.</p><h3>Substantive “Standard”</h3><p>An overlooked aspect that is often forgotten despite its importance is substance in MUN. A word used to refer to the supposed “academic” aspect of the debate, encompassing speech, diplomacy, and negotiation. Yet despite its wide net, something is quite clear yet remains unaddressed. What really is the standard? It’s a legitimate point of contention. When that gets asked, the answer can vary drastically from one conference to another, much less from one chair to another. Most of the time, they will only give you such a broad and general note that you can’t really figure it out yourself. Effectively leaves the delegates to pick up the pieces of inconsistent feedback and for them to try creating a coherent strategy out of it for the next conference. One chair says the speech structure is a ramble, while the other says it&#39;s adequately structured. There is no surefire answer, and for some reason, it’s been that way for almost two decades.</p><p>As if the chair&#39;s feedback wasn’t confusing enough, the lack of a coherent and clear substantive “standard” is made worse by zero disclosure of the scoring matrix after the conference. With the primary customary reasoning being that of “Chair&#39;s discretion,” and as such, any form of disclosure of the matrix and its formula (which itself varies accordingly) is not something that delegates should be privy to. This is not to say the scoring system hasn’t been somewhat disclosed. Some conferences are still willing to disclose the scoring weight variables and their percentage. Unfortunately, the lack of a disclosure of how that comes into play after the conference, coupled with discretion-based feedback according to the chair&#39;s own preferences, leaves any delegate hoping to fix their performance in total confusion. One delegate would surmise they got a Most Outstanding because they lacked diplomacy, according to one chair’s statement, yet at the same time, another chair would say it&#39;s because they portrayed their country well.</p><p>The problem doesn’t stop with zero disclosure, as the very formula used and scoring logic is too. The grading system of a conference can vary drastically, with some conferences using a 10–100 scale coupled with a conference-specific percentage for each performance variable (Diplomacy, Substance, Role Fulfilment, etc). On the other hand, a conference may employ an instinct and personalized system according to each chair. Something made clear in the interview process, wherein a conference asks a candidate how they would judge what makes for a Best Delegate, Most Outstanding, and Honourable Mention. Effectively leaving the supposed “standards” that are the point of discussion to the imagination of the candidate, with the open-endedness of F1’s Grill the Grid. Either way, the more depressing reality is that delegates, for the most part, aren’t even aware of the various versions of the scoring matrix (and its logic) that exist out there. Given the lack of initiative from actors to voluntarily disclose the information by longtime stakeholders of the circuit, who always find a reason not to.</p><p><strong>(The following is a revised paragraph in place of the original iteration)</strong></p><p>One solution could include disclosing the scoring matrix to delegates after the conference, to ensure that participants know their room for improvement for the next conference, whilst also getting their price of admission cost worth the feedback. At the same time, such a disclosure could benefit chairs by cutting back on post-conference feedback requests.</p><p>Should that happen, the circuit could start formulating a cohesive and generally accepted form of standards and logic in the hopes that delegates can then use those fixed variables to truly improve upon their performance more coherently and create tailored strategies that liven up the debate, not weaken it. I would be remiss to mention that non-traditional councils, such as Press, Crisis, DPR, etc., have different methodologies of scoring that may not be as straightforward as regular councils. As such, room for policy changes regarding a transparent and clear substantive framework is subject to the councils and their limitations. Unable to be given the same weight as a regular council.</p><p>With that being said,</p><h3><strong>Is the circuit ready for transparency?</strong></h3><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=b49d0cc57500" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Inside the Press Council]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@HugoYuwono/inside-the-press-council-86783b6e6d58?source=rss-d98ffc7faf45------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/86783b6e6d58</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[press]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[unca]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mun]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Hugo]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 12 Aug 2025 14:50:36 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-08-28T19:07:53.967Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>Despite transcending time periods and council dynamics, the press council is often overlooked due to a lack of placard raising. Despite that, it continues to bring a unique niche that, much like a crisis council, makes it unrivalled in its output.</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*s13prbw6k4LcPcHyYloH2Q.jpeg" /><figcaption>Courtesy of the Indonesiamun committee</figcaption></figure><p>For much of its existence, the Press Council was seen as a niche council even before the pandemic. It was small, mobile, and opinionated. It had no direct impact on any council, given that news updates are made by the academic team; yet their presence was felt in their sudden press conferences. Bringing a sense of urgency and injecting ideas indirectly that one could take as an improvement of their stance and solution. That was what I thought of for quite some time.</p><h3>More than a Rapporteur</h3><p>Embarking on the press council for the first time wasn’t in any of my plans beforehand. At the height of doing high-pol councils, I simply saw the council as a glorified observer pass. Much to my sentiments at the time, I was thankfully proven wrong; given how, despite not fitting in with the proceedings, I still had a great time and enjoyed the work. Granted, the pacing, deadline, and physical mobility were very demanding, but it was still an experience in and of itself. Going in, my expectations were accurately described as confused, as I had not taken part in this council in any of the previous eleven conferences I had attended. That being said, I somewhat told myself to enjoy the council and to do my best despite knowing the expected performance of a beginner.</p><p>Proceeding-wise, I certainly didn’t expect the communal tone of the council despite the looming deadlines for the mandatory article and video. A far cry from anything I have seen up to that point. Being the writers that we are, the Press council (also known as IPI and UNCA) is tasked with noting down the arguments that occur during debate, and to procure in its place the product of an article (and in the case of Indonesiamun, a video report). The article type includes the opinion piece and news report; the latter being objective (but is suggested to include a soft bias).</p><p>Much of the brunt work, as expected, came from the high mobility between councils, and managing the time, which was exacerbated by the comically long hallway the venue had. Going into the noting section of the proceedings, I simply decided to wing it, given it was the first ever time I was doing the council; something that even one of the co-editors would recognize as an unexpected appearance. That being said, much like real news reporters, the task came in the form of noting the developments and procuring the mandatory product. A challenge to anyone doing it for the first time.</p><h3>Through the gaps</h3><p>As a reporter, much of the assignment isn’t purely to observe, but also that understand the flow of debate with the assistance of the internet and a complete library of study guides. That being said, something I had not thought of was the fact that debate itself can truly make or break the article. Something that occurred in this instance. The council I covered, namely the WHO, was marketed to beginner delegates. Yet, the unfortunate circumstance was that the study guide felt something akin to UNSC, or any intermediate council, to that matter. Emphasizing various subtopics on global health, Gray’s Anatomy, and Non-state actor distribution. To put it simply, it was a sensory overload for the delegates to debate upon, much less the reporters covering it.</p><p>It hit me, the press council isn’t just reporting the scene; it’s also about looking through the tiniest of gaps. Not only in the debate, but also on the substance side of things. Effectively making it a great opportunity for any future delegate, dais, and committee to understand the receiving end of how a delegate can try to understand a topic and what not to do when given the chance.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*cXcKc0nx0Q5Fyq0WfbzKXw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Cover image made for the council</figcaption></figure><h3>The verdict</h3><p>While the council may not be fit for someone akin to traditional formats, the press council provides an alternate and insightful perspective into the substance world of MUN, while importantly providing a way to hone skills in writing and conceptualizing, which itself is an important tool in such a competitive world of ideas. Though the pacing and allure are something that one must experience themselves, truly a radical departure from highpol yet an equally tight pacing.</p><p>Like a crisis council, the press council is something to experience, not to observe. We all need a change of scenery here and there. The press council is truly a perfect fit for those who want something that doesn’t involve long, never-ending COTWs. That and maybe yelling and screaming is a bit too much when done consecutively.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=86783b6e6d58" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[FOMO in MUN]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@HugoYuwono/fomo-in-mun-e1b6790747f3?source=rss-d98ffc7faf45------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/e1b6790747f3</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Hugo]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 11 Jul 2025 15:29:21 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-07-11T15:45:42.700Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>If there is anything I have recognized in all my years in the circuit, much less in life, it’s that validation is an important part of a person’s existence. It gives us purpose and function, yet at the same time, too much of it can lead to absolute abomination.</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*TWTf8w9SJc-8Hqe9k_OH5A.jpeg" /></figure><h3>Future Aspirations</h3><p>When I first came into the circuit, the allure that brought me in wasn’t the formal dresses or the good speeches, but the idea that debate can simulate critical thinking, whilst bringing a piece of “leadership” into the fold. It was great, engaging, and riveting. So much so that for some time, I genuinely considered pursuing roles actively, albeit naively to in the ground situations. The premise was itself promising, dedicate time to the circuit, and lead by example. I mean, who wouldn’t want that kind of stuff in their life? It gives a sense of purpose to one’s time in the circuit. Like youth organizations and their idealist promises, it was something. Though as time went on, it became nothing but a facade for a floating and totalitarian leadership.</p><p>From where I am from at the time, mechanisms for equitable process in the creation of social roles are non-existent compared to their nearest equivalent. The equivalent, also a prominent club in the mun circuit, had been known for their rigorous bureaucratic bidding and fit/proper test mechanism, with additional elaborative mechanisms on the direction of the club, its goals, program, and yearly evaluation. On the other hand, the place I had known had none of those mechanisms, effectively a mini monarchy that prevents a proper social structure that truly takes into consideration its members. Yet, one thing was clear to me: everyone was vying for attention, desperately.</p><p>In all my time in the circuit, I haven’t had such deep desires for such a position until the prospect of it became clear with time. But the conditions that I had faced made me realize that to be recognized in the moment required excessive lobbying and vying, in a rather inappropriate and unethical manner that is. What was once seen by me as an opportunity to be seen in the circuit quickly devolved into an ethics test. Be a good boy and get promoted, or stand your ground and lose everything. The latter was what I did.</p><p>In what I thought was a way to be seen as a critical member of the club and to be recognized as an experienced MUNer with an opinion, I quickly delved into the darkest moment of my time in the circuit. What started as criticism of club policy didn’t result in some recognition; rather, it resulted in alienation, whilst those who stood by were elevated to cabinet positions in the middle of the night despite not holding such a position beforehand, all while being handpicked by the self-declared Secretary General and the Head of training.</p><p>Suffice it to say, the feeling of helplessness and lack of being seen as a serious “MUNer” by their standards was more than enough to discourage me from pursuing other avenues to be a person that matters in society. What followed was a soft power removal of any dissent, and I eventually left at my own will after recognizing that whilst appeasement results in short-term gains, it brings with it a degradation of human character.</p><h3>The Price of Missing Out</h3><p>In the direct aftermath of my voluntary departure, driven by the senseless bandwagoning by several individuals in seeking active positions within the organization, I remembered feeling like I just left a huge opportunity in the dust. Though, as time went on, it was clear that warnings about what that kind of power does to people only became evident as the months and years went by. Granted, like any person in the circuit, much less life, I did feel like I was letting go of such a huge opportunity to contribute “hugely” to the circuit. Though the reality was that even if I stayed, I probably would have been nothing but an unused spare tire, left rotting in the boot of the car, in contrast to my current standing as a self-declared “Independent” MUNer, which allowed me to grow on my accords. It wasn’t clear to me at the time, and I remember blaming myself every time I saw them “succeed” and get chairing gigs in a rather unfair and unpleasant manner myself. To make matters worse, the closest comparisons were themselves part of their respective communities, and as such, I couldn’t fairly compare myself to others and the “privilege” they got.</p><p>In that past-tense, I was in essence blaming myself for missing out, for not being a loyalist, much less obedient to the “Cabinet Director” themselves. Though, in retrospect, I am glad I don’t have such a visible stain on my reputation given what happened on the sidelines of their first delegation win, which had detrimental and irreversible precedent on how bad mun politics could be, even over Honorable Mention. Thankfully, I was able to proceed with my decision to return by mid-2024, a decision that was made and calculated carefully with the state of the circuit and its political stability, much less a new refreshed paradigm that focuses explicitly on learning, not a Best Delegate title, much less a Secretary General one at that.</p><h3>(Not) a Deal with the Devil?</h3><p>Armed with a new paradigm, I proceeded to continue my mun journey after a brief observation of a conference in June of 2024. It felt surreal starting completely from zero again, particularly in such a prominent conference that year. That being said, the difficult council and topic choice eventually drove me to win an Honourable Mention later that year, and a rather unexpected Best Delegate award, as I have elaborated in my previous article. That being said, it wasn’t without its challenges. Unfortunate circumstances surrounding my health had adversely impacted my performance early this year, within two weeks, wherein I pushed to have substantive chops whilst dealing with voice box issues. Whilst the first endeavour didn’t merit any awards, the second one within the same month did, albeit a Verbal Commendation. Though, in retrospect, it’s a miraculous circumstance that such designation meant being placed in the same category of people who otherwise had better health and bloc roles; as such I still consider it as a personal achievement even if in the eyes of some it’s just a “lucky” award with no merit.</p><p>The challenges faced within those two conferences eventually materialized into the survival mode I had days ago within the Security Council, where unfortunate circumstances surrounding prep time and less than favourable double-delegate dynamics had rendered me lacking compared to other delegations. That being said, getting a Verbal Commendation was once again a personal miracle given the conditions. Though in the end, the chairs had emphasized that my consistency, calm, and collected nature was enough for such designation, whilst also emphasizing the need to take a bolder stance and to insinuate more on points.</p><p>It was a great day, until an offhand conversation with a MUNer had led to an unsolicited Mephisto-like offer by midnight. It wasn’t supposed to be something very serious, given the impromptu nature of the conversation. But, what followed was a lecture about how me winning Verbal Commendations consecutively would be fault for not improving, in the process throwing their friend under the bus to make a point, and a lecture about how my articles are a waste of time that overthink what the circuit is. They got worked up over a simple conversation, and divulged into the often-inevitable cotw yap session any MUNer has faced. It was a lot. However, one thing was clear in that conversation: I had no problem with them. Though the unsolicited nature of certain remarks made was unwarranted, and sounded more like a person using their opportunity to lecture on things and to make claims that seemed overblown.</p><p>It was supposed to end there. Yet, nearing midnight, my phone rang.</p><blockquote>“We have an offer for you. Tomorrow, we will let you know.”</blockquote><p>What followed was a passive-aggressive back-and-forth about how the offer was not a “deal with the devil type” and that I shouldn’t be worried. Only to be followed by a personal inquiry about whether I am continuing my mun journey, complete with the most unconvincing projection and unsolicited suggestion that the offer will be to advise on how I should proceed in the circuit. Taken aback by how unsolicited and suspicious the offer was, much less the “meet in an undisclosed location” part, I rejected it right there and then. Only for the individual to truly reveal what the offer was. That the offer was training meant to achieve an ideal output of a best delegate award, and that it included telling me about the dramas that led to this point.</p><p>Reading that sentence, I was baffled. Why go to extreme lengths to hide their true intentions in the first place? What’s with all the secrecy? And why do people genuinely think I do this for the highest award? Even a “floating delegate” who skimmed through my first article will understand that, in the aftermath of my journey, it was never my intention whatsoever. The conversation was later closed with what can only be described as a low, insecure, and projection sentence I have ever heard.</p><blockquote>“But honestly, if you really think this lowly of me, then maybe this offer would be best suited to someone else”</blockquote><p>As if I ever thought of them in the first place. The sentence in closing the conversation made it clear what the intention was. They both thought that my desire for power was so high that I was willing to relinquish my independence like a country entering the European Union. It set a bad precedent.</p><p>Suffice to say, it was the worst mouthful projection piece of insecurity on display. It was in many ways the lowest thing I have ever seen stated towards me, and the most ignorant one at that. As if dealing with narcissistic and Machiavellian types wasn’t worse, opportunistic types like this get added to the list. A low blow for a person known for their directive, clearly it failed in this instance.</p><h3>Vested Interests and Proliferation</h3><p>What was clear from that interaction was this: I had value. The way I use it, however, must be done in an orderly, wise, and considerate manner. While opportunists only see me purely from an awards perspective, I see myself as valuable enough to pass on my lessons to others and contribute to creating the necessary and critical discourse the circuit is desperately needing. Not as a wannabe king and a demeaning person.</p><p>Amidst the landscape of people wanting to be Secretary General and Chairs by all means necessary, incidents like this remind me of my self-worth and the fact that I deserve to be more than someone else’s offshore bandwagoning tool in their desperate post-power syndrome perception that the circuit is theirs to rule.</p><p>I am an Independent, and I will always be that way.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=e1b6790747f3" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Prudent Delegate]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@HugoYuwono/the-prudent-delegate-7b14423f19d1?source=rss-d98ffc7faf45------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/7b14423f19d1</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[mun]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Hugo]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 24 May 2025 16:02:20 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-08-12T10:15:00.939Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>For every small progress, it builds up towards the future</em></p><p>Was this the right moment? Did I deserve this? Is it the highest point of my mun journey?</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*ltaZcV_mPey-R-G8zK-Gtg.jpeg" /><figcaption>We all go through our shortcomings, with perseverance</figcaption></figure><p>Those were the questions I had when both my friend and I received the Best Delegate award designation at a short diplomatic course event. Granted, he feels ecstatic as anyone should in such an extraordinary situation. Yet, I seem not to have been able to wrap my head around it, though it seems the personal climb has something to do with it.</p><h3>Average Joe</h3><p>I will admit, I am not extraordinary compared to most MUNers in the circuit. Some only need a matter of months to rise to the top, whilst others seemingly find themselves in that kind of opportunity luck that miraculously puts them on top of the circuit, navigating with precision and eventually overstaying their welcome given how quickly they rose the “ranks” in the circuit. Compared to them, I was just doing this for the sake of enjoyment; a mindset that grew naturally since my first conference in 2019. Things reached their highest point several years later, when I received a Most Outstanding award, something I had seen as a natural progression given how the award before was an Honorable Mention award. That being said, I remembered telling myself and vowing that I would never dedicate excessively to the title of Best Delegate, given that reaching an M.O before graduating high school is itself an achievement. A promise held on upon my return to the circuit in early 2023, with a delegating capacity by 2024. At the same however, it was clear to me that the overall atmosphere had shifted upon my return to the circuit; to the point it blurred my promises.</p><p>As I walked my way into the circuit and joined a community, it was made clear to me that, unlike my last time in the circuit, something very different was bound to happen. This time, I must contend with dealing with things not of my doing, with the consequence of a new perspective on the circuit too big for me to handle.</p><h3>Crisis Update</h3><p>A natural progression of anyone’s time in the circuit is to take part in more collective groups related to MUN and try to gain something out of it. However, by the end, the lesson wasn’t in speech structures or anything related to the typical 101s of doing MUN; rather, it came from the tough lesson of what happens when I chose to say no in a wave of yes. I wouldn’t have imagined that saying “no” to a series of decisions would have great consequences, considering it had worked in other normal settings. Yet, in this case, it led me down a rabbit hole deeper than everything I had ever known about the circuit. A rabbit hole, I would admit, had ruined every precedent I had known about the circuit prior. This caused me to be excessively pragmatic and isolationist upon engaging with the stakeholders within the circuit.</p><p>At the end of the day, I chose not to blame myself for acting that way, given how the circuit has become more toxic with time and has gotten more dangerous because of it. Something as simple as policy criticisms, due process outcomes of awards, and assessment viability of delegating performance can turn into a toxic point of contention.</p><p>Such toxic behaviour would later morph into the kind of clandestine directives that come with actual consequences, and in the process hurt individuals and entire groups. To this day, I still reflect on dealing with such directives. To the point, pragmatic and isolationist thought becomes the basis of the decisions I make in the circuit and the required prudence that goes hand in hand with it. Particularly in such a precarious world where everything can happen in the blink of an eye. All simply because of disputes relating to conference operations, academic discretion, and personal preferences. Though that last one unfortunately seems to be the most common and dangerous.</p><h3>Crossroads</h3><p>Tackling a dilemma relating to my existence and sustainability in the circuit wasn’t something I had in mind when I first joined; that being said, such a concept became reality upon my arrival at the varsity level. It became obvious straight away to me that I was at a crossroads; nothing in the last several years would prepare me. The signal was clear: be a servant, or get lost; that was how I saw it. A mindset that to this day bugs the hell out of me, given how such demands (and blind loyalty) have only led to what I would personally call a “placard arms race” between competing entities and groups. Subjects whose sole purpose in the circuit isn’t to educate, but rather to build unparalleled dominance in the circuit by all means necessary. Even at the great cost of the very values that make up humanity, if any remained to begin with.</p><p>When faced with the option, I made the choice not to take part in such a thing. Not because it wasn’t lucrative, but rather because I felt that having such a mentality would severely exhaust me and drive me to burnout to the point my physical health would be adversely impacted. Additionally, I had made it clear that such an arms race mentality would only drive the worst instincts and lead towards an unproductive and forced growth that would backfire.</p><p>What I hadn’t known at the time was that such opinion would lead to retaliation; yet not surprising coming from the same collection of people who believe such an arms race is required for their twisted definition of the Best Delegate. One that isn’t defined by a piece of paper, much less to share knowledge for the great development of society. But rather one defined by a world where everything is predictable and controllable at all costs, all justified under a falsely implanted idea of diplomacy.</p><p>In the aftermath of not choosing, I felt the full brunt of disguised distaste towards me. Such distaste morphed into what I see as a retaliatory series of decisions that led me towards a breaking point where I questioned whether or not my life had a meaning. Such a case caused me to be so disillusioned to the point that I became an isolationist towards any attempt at returning. Thankfully, I did find the strength to return by my own accord to this day, but not without having flashbacks and having a sense of being an inferior delegate despite the elapsing time.</p><h3>Vindication</h3><p>To be in a position of doing things on my own accord meant doing things from the ground up without the fanciest tools and resources a MUNer can get in achieving the highest designation. That being said, whilst I retain complex feelings relating to my Best Delegate designation, I still see this as a milestone in a journey six years in the making. For much of my time in the circuit, I have dealt with all sorts of people. The condescending chair, the dominating delegate, and the high echelons who treat others the way an absolute monarch treats its citizens. It’s a lot to put it mildly, but to be treated in a way I personally see as harsh, it’s a miracle I was able to get back on my feet to begin with. Something I hope will be the acceleration of my goal to contribute to the circuit in all capacities, without toxic behavior and a dog-eat-dog mentality. A challenge I chose to accept when I decided to embrace the circuit once more after a harsh reality check.</p><p>For what it&#39;s worth, this award has given me the space I need to turn off the repeating naysayers in my head. Those who doubted me and shut me off for choosing not to go disciple over mun. A decision that allowed me to do things on my terms, without fear and a bloated sense of being inferior.</p><p>This endeavour is not for those who play it safe; it’s for those who choose to embrace the world as it is. The kind that can become toxic and childish, to the point that individuals and groups are put into jeopardy over the smallest of variables. As a circuit, we have the work to do in making this world more equitable and safe, and to do so without throwing the blame and instigating conflicts over perceived “justice” and actionable behaviour. It remains to be said what comes next, but I hope this designation will remind me that with great power indeed comes great responsibility. To be the person that matters is to be one who contributes to growth, not burns down the pillars, and to have a foothold on others.</p><p>May the circuit find its light and confront the truth.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=7b14423f19d1" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Curious Case of Verbal Commendation]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@HugoYuwono/the-curious-case-of-verbal-commendation-67b03e1e4e00?source=rss-d98ffc7faf45------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/67b03e1e4e00</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[indonesian-circuit]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mun]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Hugo]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 14 Apr 2025 14:19:39 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-08-28T19:06:00.637Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>Five years on and I have no clue what’s the definitive point is with this award, much less why the policy of this award is contradictory from one place to another</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*BOGEudiy9RbPImuxaL_89w.jpeg" /><figcaption>Source: Personal Gallery</figcaption></figure><p><strong>Disclaimer: The following article is an interpretation of Verbal Commendation by the author and the contributors of the article and may not reflect official policies and decisions of committees, chairs, and academic staff.</strong></p><p>It’s confusing, an excuse for existence, and a waste of time? That is how I would describe Verbal Commendation (Verbcom). An appreciation of hardworking delegates and yet not really a real award. The policy, which previously was only a standing ovation has morphed into the policy of certificates akin to Diplomatic Commendation by some interpretations, which in its implementation is both experimental and contradictory.</p><p>In turn, this contradiction has left me wondered if the meaning of Verbal Commendation itself is flexible or not. Something that remains a mystery given the unstandardized and often secretive scoring system.</p><h3>What It Ment Then</h3><p>Verbal Commendation, as the name suggest is a commendation of your speaking capacity. A designation that works to recognize the work of delegates, who in the context of the debate were in the shortlist of contending recipients of Honorable Mention, the lowest denomination and the third rank of the overall awards given in a council. A designation, which by <a href="https://dictionary.cambridge.org/dictionary/english/consolation-prize">Cambridge Dictionary standards fall under the category of the Consolation Prize</a>. Personally, I was of the opinion that verbcom was just a necessity designed to encourage first timers to go ahead and instigate the delegate inside of them. An “Award” that shows them that they were designated for the main prizes and as such with encouragement of the words “Verbal Commendation” they may embark on a fulfilling journey towards becoming the Best Delegate and succeed in their “Career” in the circuit. Though, I am not personally a fan of the “Career” part, I sure do agree from experience that the designation helps with the post-conference processing and evaluation on overall performance and providing motivation in real way. Even if it’s just words on the projected screen and standing up (Or going to stage and holding a certificate for some conferences).</p><p>I understood this when I received my first verbcom at the 2020 edition of HSMUN, where I received it in my second conference. It came as a shock to be honest, seeing that I received such designation without extensive mentorship much less intensive delegation training. Upon receiving the award, I felt the impact of the designation immediately. Some congratulations were in order, the school posted it, and the dopamine was more than enough for me to receive an honorable mention by my next conference. Granted, in the grand scheme of things it’s not as impressive with what people my age at the time could do in the present. Where conferences at the high school level occur bi-monthly and nowadays had somewhat on par chair and substantive capacity of newer post-pandemic conference provide the opportunity quicker than the few that stood during the pandemic. That being said, personally I still feel that the designation still felt as a prerequisite dopamine to those who strive to succeed in the circuit by their own preferences and paradigm.</p><p>In the grand scheme of things, Verbal Commendation gets the job done. Though ensuring it conforms to a more complex debate environment and giving it some worth is something that is worth considering given how the Verbcom I knew then has changed in recent times.</p><h3>Current Condition</h3><p>In the current context (at least to my own experience) the way Verbal Commendation is seen by some committees has changed ever since I got my first one several years ago. For one thing, the designation itself has had a more public presence, being displayed for the public profile of incoming chairs for a conference. Something that had not occurred in the past. That being said, it is worth noting why that is the case.</p><p>For starters, more and more councils these days can have some strict chairs with strict scoring matrixes. As such, this results in the capping of awards to Most Outstanding and Honorable Mention, with Verbal Commendation now being more present than ever before. From my personal observations, Verbcom are interpreted not as a purely “complimentary” award to those who dared to speak the most and has a somewhat good stance, but now applies to delegates who contribute greatly to the debate, had their solutions and mechanisms, a proper and consistent stance. Yet, as per usual didn’t make the cut for the top three awards.</p><p>While this may seem like a great step in properly and inclusively recognizing the work of delegates and not purely from fancy speech structures as it seemed to appear in the past, it does bring into question why despite the function shift and the changing debate landscape that impacts it, why it hasn’t received much of a real appreciation in the form of a certificate more broadly, with it being remaining awkwardly standing in your spot, or in some cases standing next to the real awardees on stage. Both situation resulting in the same outcome, nothing but bragging rights and an empty hand comparative to those who didn’t even get the designation.</p><h3>A Gray Area</h3><p>In its supposed capacity as an award, various interpretations of Verbal Commendations exist to a degree. Though, the most apparent sign comes from whether or not a conference chooses to handover the certificate for it. Something that to my knowledge rarely occurs, and when it does, I can’t help but feel something is off when winning verbcom and not getting one whilst losing verbcom in another conference where they do give the certificate. The contradiction that occurs unsurprisingly can cause quite a headache, particularly if an organizer contradicts its own policy on this supposed award. The consolation prize in question can be weirdly recognized by one conference and not recognized by another conference’s mere weeks apart.</p><p>Difference in viewpoints regarding the designation (which seemed like an agreeable definition) was present when I viewed a council awarding in one of the conferences I had attended, where delegates with this designation had been awkwardly called to stage and to stand with nothing in hand after a back and forth from the chair of the council and the organizing committee that was too visible by my own admission. Speaking to an individual about whether a verbcom recipient is deserving of a certificate or not, I would recall the individual speaking to the effect of:</p><blockquote>“No serious conference in the circuit gives out certificates for verbcom”</blockquote><blockquote>— A now retired senior official in the mun world.</blockquote><p>Upon hearing this statement, I couldn’t help feel sorry to the delegates and feel confused at the same time. Thinking what a waste of time it is for people to stand on a stage despite getting nothing in the end other than a picture. It bothered me that for what is supposed to be an “award” for some parts of the circuit, the implementation of it has been nothing but polarizing and unstandardized.</p><h3>Policy of Verbal Commendation</h3><p>Looking at it broadly, Verbal Commendation remains at its core as a consolation prize. However, I would personally argue that newer policies by some conferences to handover a certificate seem to suggest a diverse interpretation of the award as an actual thing and not just a recognized designation. As mentioned before, the decision to have or not a certificate is contradictory in nature from one to another conference. Causing the inevitable confusion about whether or not Verbal Commendation is an actual award or not, seeing that in this instance a certificate-backed Verbal Commendation is more akin to Diplomatic Commendation that exists in circuits outside of Indonesia.</p><p>The decision to have a certificate ultimately comes down to the organizing committee itself. Though, it is worth pointing out the decision to have Verbcom as a certificate is not explicitly mentioned and only the designation itself. Looking at it from a substantive perspective, personally I am of the understanding that the award functions as a motivating consolation prize and not much after it. Though having it as a certificate without much advertising sure gives me the misleading and confusing signal whether or not the meaning of the award is flexible towards the context of the debate particularly delegates who become sponsors. Though, I certainly am willing to correct myself it has been this way for a while or if it indeed has changed in meaning because of the policies of some chairs to restrict the top three awards to Most Outstanding or Honorable Mention being the highest and the weight being placed on Verbal Commendation.</p><h3>Perspectives from The Circuit</h3><p>In shaping a more objective opinion on such a topic as Verbal Commendation, I reached out to several individuals. Multiple individuals were both passive to the inquiry or declined to comment on the issue. That being said, two individuals were willing to be quoted. With one going on the record and another commenting under the condition of anonymity. The following is the interaction:</p><p><strong>Q1: In your time as a delegate, have you received a verbal commendation? If so, how did it make you feel and influence your post-conference evaluation?</strong></p><blockquote>“On my time as a delegate, I have received a couple of Verbal Commendations and having one as the first award got me further into MUNs. I didn’t actually realize whether my substance was appreciated if any by the chairs, and getting a standing ovation at the ballroom in (Location) was not something I had expected when I was a high schooler amongst varsity students. So that was like almost something to me, it gives you the sense of appreciation to keeps you going and again its not a formal-formal awards because I didn’t get a certificate for it because I didn’t believe I didn’t deserve it in the first place, but my post conference evaluation felt like I was being appreciated for being there, felt like generally being appreciated for expressing the right things.”</blockquote><blockquote>— A Varsity-level MUNer who wishes to remain anonymous.</blockquote><blockquote>“I’ve received 4 verbcoms throughout my mun journey and every single time I received the award I felt satisfied with myself because it showed that I performed well enough to be recognized by the chairs as a top performer. I never felt jealous or displeased because every single time I got verbcom, I knew there were other delegates who did way better and deserves higher awards. this helped me evaluate on what I could do in future MUNs so I could receive a higher award.”</blockquote><blockquote>— Fadil, a high school MUNer</blockquote><p><strong>Q2: Seeing the contradictive policies of conferences who give and not give a certificate for verbal commendation, what should a delegate expect in finding meaning for verbal commendation? particularly after a contentious debate where sponsor who contribute greatly receive it.</strong></p><blockquote>“I don’t know how delegates should feel about VCs, its not a formal award, I believe its just a standing ovation of sorts. I don’t know, I am not sure. I feel like credit should be given where credit is due and one of that is giving people Verbal Commendations. I generally feel VCs are a way to appreciate people who you really wish to be in the formal awards but they are like very close to the formal award. VCs is a nice thing to have, but I believe it should be capped just so it still has exclusivity.”</blockquote><blockquote>— A Varsity-level MUNer who wishes to remain anonymous.</blockquote><blockquote>The individual would later elaborate that they have given the award to a sponsor delegate that were exceptionally leading but they broke stance. They would later be reminded of the mission of mun in representing the country properly and accurately and as such the Verbal Commendation award requires nuance.</blockquote><blockquote>“I believe that a delegate should look at verbcom as an award that highlights their performance as good but can be improved on in the future. as for sponsors that receive, it serves as a reflection period of what was done right and wrong throughout the comses and identify what chairs grade the most on.”</blockquote><blockquote>— Fadil, a high school MUNer</blockquote><p><strong>Q3: Seeing that the award has on some occasion be used to bring about some individual’s rise to the chairing world, how should the circuit treat this award moving forward?</strong></p><blockquote>“I am not sure about this, receiving Verbal Commendation is an achievement at the personal level. It depends on the committees how they evaluate Verbal Commendations, I don’t think the circuit needs to make something up about this, but I feel like we have agreed to what we need to agree upon which is saying that Verbal Commendation is just Verbal Commendation and I feel that VCs are a standing ovation award especially in the Indonesian Circuit. But I know for a fact if you got to Harvard World MUN it is a big deal, because it is.”</blockquote><blockquote>– A Varsity-level MUNer who wishes to remain anonymous.</blockquote><blockquote>“I believe verbcom should be seen as an award because at the end of the day, it really depends on what mun you received verbcom at because different MUNs hold different levels in my opinion. So, for example a verbcom in Jakarta mun is worth more than a verbcom at a high school level mun for example. The amount of people in the council also matters as more people = more competition for influence and recognition from chairs. The quality of the council also varies where some councils can be loaded with good delegates and some with below par standards.”</blockquote><blockquote>— Fadil, a high school MUNer</blockquote><p><strong>Q4: As a consolation prize, Verbal Commendation acted as encouragement for new to experience delegates to keep improving. That being said in this hypercompetitive and at times toxic debate has the meaning of the award changed? and how do organizers and chair recruiters view individuals who are willing to recognize the Verbal Commendation they receive?</strong></p><blockquote>“Has the meaning of the award changed? I don’t know I haven’t chaired in a while. But me from the perspective of the chair feel that Verbal Commendation is a Verbal Commendation it is a standing ovation, it is still in an essence a form of appreciation from the chairs to the delegates albeit it may be just a non-formal award you can just mention someone get a VC, just like in the Singaporean Circuit for example you don’t get called to stage and take a picture with the rest of the awardees, it’s a different level in that sense.”</blockquote><blockquote>- A Varsity-level MUNer who wishes to remain anonymous.</blockquote><blockquote>“Again, it depends on what mun and the context of how the achieved the verbcom award. So prestige of mun, amount of people joined, and quality of the council.”</blockquote><blockquote>— Fadil, a high school MUNer</blockquote><h3>Conclusion</h3><p>If there’s any takeaway in all of this is that as an award, Verbal Commendation remains as a consolation award. With interpretation whether or not it deserves a certificate as a selective policy of some conference. That being said, with or without it the award continues to serve as a form of appreciation albeit in informal means. Though, the most surprising thing that came with this article was the reluctance of individuals to comment on something as simple as Verbal Commendation even if they retain their anonymity. I suppose people feel the circuit isn’t ready for any dissent, and to those people I hope our circuit can be a safe environment for the raising of voices and not just as fancy taglines for conference advertisements.</p><p><strong>That being said, should I get the facts wrong I apologize in advance. Seeing that not much has been talked about this award, much less the definitive rationale and policies pertaining to the process of Verbal Commendation. Thank you for reading, I look forward to the circuit’s many takes and feedback.</strong></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=67b03e1e4e00" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Redefining What It Means To Be A MUNer]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@HugoYuwono/redefining-what-it-means-to-be-a-muner-f82bff5f0ed8?source=rss-d98ffc7faf45------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/f82bff5f0ed8</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[mun]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[model-united-nations]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Hugo]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 20 Mar 2025 14:17:12 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-04-04T15:46:51.822Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>In a time of uncertainty, we need to remember the values we hold and how they truly define us to be the MUNer the circuit can depend on.</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*yaXZBM9T8Bq4PgWmAiS5eQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>An average scene of a committee session</figcaption></figure><p>When I started doing MUN six years ago, I did it because I realized this extracurricular activity’s potential. I was in tenth grade back then and I was seeking an interesting and unique activity that wasn’t mundane, yet fit the profile of someone who desperately needed a way to practice their lack of communication skills, and that is why MUN caught my attention at the extracurricular expo.</p><p>Despite the display of awards at the extracurricular booth expo, not one person there ever excessively pushed its competitiveness aspect. Instead, they emphasized that while it would be nice to get an award, no one ever gets it on their first try, and that self-development at the end of the day is more important than any award in the conference. This a sentiment that heavily remains true to this day, contrary to those who frame MUN as a religious object, much less a political arena.</p><p>As a concept, self-development in Model UN isn’t necessarily a new or foreign idea. It was discussed extensively by Rohil Deshpande in his <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_dXvDyIqQN4&amp;list=TLPQMjkwMjIwMjTqbIx0Xms2RQ&amp;index=2">TEDx Talk</a> entitled “Model United Nations in India”, in which he discussed the importance of the educational aspect of Model UN and how a conference can easily be ruined by among things the wrong mindset, a bloated sense of achievement, petty statistics, and poorly organized conferences.</p><p>Despite knowing prior that MUN was originally designed to promote the <a href="https://www.wisemee.com/history-of-the-first-mun/">workings of the U.N and the diplomatic aspect of state and non-state actor interaction</a>, nothing would ever prepare me in witnessing things that happen at the varsity world. What I saw was nothing but a polarized environment, where complex realpolitik occurs at every level. Seemingly with no end in sight and needlessly continuing every month.</p><p>The political aspect of Model UN along with its blowback can be seen in a <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2013/08/04/education/edlife/a-new-student-run-breed-crisis-oriented-and-fiercely-competitive.html">New York Times article by Anjli Parrin</a>, in which the article discussed the rowdiness, politicking, and petty tactics that happen in Model UN conferences in the United States. The article highlighted the issue of MUN becoming an environment of politicking and petty tactics, one further exasperated by rank-motivated competition. The article not only discusses the impact of MUN turning into a hypercompetitive landscape but also touches upon the powers of their chairs and the impact they have on the proceedings of the committee.</p><p>While MUN Politics is an unavoidable reality these days, it should encourage us to be ourselves in creating an ideal environment of self-development. One where debate exists accordingly and everyone recognizes the mission behind why they are in the circuit.</p><h3>The Paradigm</h3><p>When I think of doing Model UN, I think of what purpose it serves in my life. In my view, the purpose is that of practice-based learning for the further development of my writing, public speaking, and research capabilities. Yet, I still can’t wrap my head around those who feel that this hobby is so much more than it is, treating it as a place of personal gain and conquest. This mentality appeared despite Model UN being widely known simply as a social construct in the form of simulations designed to teach the art of diplomacy and the functions of the United Nations (and other international organizations) with additional soft skill development.</p><p>As such, the outcome of a conference particularly at the personal level is defined by the intellectual approach that comes before every conference, Wherein the moral question of whether or not we are doing it for ourselves or the interests of others. Additionally, upholding ethics and morality is critical to not only the value of each participation in a conference but also that of having a positive and sustainable impact on the community. Frankly, having considerate, sensible, and ethical reasoning behind every conference isn’t just key to success later in life on other affairs but also will significantly reduce the impact of those who seek to use these conferences for personal gain. Something we don’t need in a time where people appreciate and value themselves going to conferences to connect with others and achieve better self-development.</p><p>Additionally, having the proper paradigm when it comes to Model UN can greatly and positively result in a real and meaningful debate during the conference while also preventing any undesirable outcomes that come from putting personal interests at the forefront of these conferences.</p><h3>Objective</h3><p>When participating in a conference, a MUNer may choose to interpret their participation into several options. Whether it’s doing it for the glory of the wins, having fun, self-development, or perhaps a healthy mix of all of that. That being said, it is important that besides having a proper paradigm, the goal of participating in the conference itself must take into consideration sustainable self-development whilst getting the award. A concept that prevents the mere thought of circuit dominance and power into the picture.</p><p>The concept of having a measured goal that isn’t going to be self-destructive anytime soon isn’t necessarily a new idea. Nadim Sungkar, a well-known MUNer introduced a concept regarding participation in MUN called “DEWAT” in his <a href="https://l.instagram.com/?u=https%3A%2F%2Fbit.ly%2FNADIMMUNBOOK%3Ffbclid%3DPAZXh0bgNhZW0CMTEAAabjh0p6tONgDwwRwOTBWfCR_XRzS7GKyPhZkZMP0H8LwykyaiwyPu5gPSY_aem_-0VNM54affuqYe6DLq1JgQ&amp;e=AT0ejtqau2DoK6PaNdIw3O2xvKcJFVh2DNa5_t_FlksHTifpmb_2EeZrUzx6nPc6n4ODESy8owopxVhYVrbNx4SgDUApLBV1VFDkBQ">MUN book</a>.</p><blockquote>The “Don’t Expect to Win All the Time (DEWAT)” Mentality: To Keep the Ego in Check</blockquote><blockquote>The what? Well, the “Don’t Expect to Win All the Time (DEWAT)” mentality is something that I use during my time in MUN as delegate. I want to win award in MUN and I believe that I can win award in MUN, but at the same time, I don’t want to expect that I will going to win award all the time in MUN. Some people may think that it’s some sort of insecurity. For me? It’s not insecurity at all; it’s to make sure that my ego is not growing into a form of arrogance. Ego is something that are very good for your MUN journey. Ego means your desires to win.</blockquote><blockquote>However, too much ego (believing that you will always going to win all the time in MUN) is something dangerous and could hurt you very bad someday. When someone expect themselves to win an award all the time, if they successfully win, their ego will grew bigger and bigger, and it will be dangerous someday. If they failed to win, they will be strucked by that failure, because the bigger the ego grew, the painful the failure will be. The “DEWAT” mentality in MUN helps me a lot on keeping my ego in check. By keeping it in check, my ego is still there, but not too much. Too much ego will makes you think you’re unbeatable, and that is dangerous. Believing that you’re unbeatable will ended up be your greatest weakness.</blockquote><blockquote>Unfortunately, when I retired from competing as delegate in MUN last year and moving to more of a mentor or coach kind of role in MUN, I forgot my very own “DEWAT” mentality. There’s two particular cases where I forgot the “DEWAT” mentality during that time; when I oversaw Rousseau Jordan in PadMUN 2020 and Rafliansyah in FPCI UNPAD MUN 2020. In both of those particular cases, I expect that they will going to win either Best Delegate award, Most Outstanding Delegate award, Honorable Mention award, or Best Position Paper award, because they really are a great MUNer. And when they won the Verbal Commendation award, I’m totally shocked, and I also feel disappointed towards myself for not helping them more.</blockquote><blockquote>I remember that after the Closing Ceremony of PadMUN 2020, Jordan and I were supposed to meet (via Zoom) to talk about what happened in the PadMUN 2020. The meeting is basically a “Post-MUN Evaluation” stuff. I cancelled the meeting after the announcement of the Verbal Commendation award, because I’m totally surprised with the result and a part of me somehow feel guilty for not helping him more. Same thing with Rafli in the FPCI UNPAD MUN 2020, and although the “Post-MUN Evaluation” meeting (via Zoom) after the closing ceremony of FPCI UNPAD MUN 2020 happened, I didn’t talk a lot during that meeting. Again, for the same reason as before; I’m totally surprised by the result. Still, I believe they’re both a great MUNer. It is therefore important to remember to always have the “DEWAT” mentality in MUN, whether as a delegate or as a mentor or a coach, because we never know what’s going to happen in MUN. Not expecting to win an award all the time is a key to win an award in MUN. You will win an award, but try not to expect it will happen all the time. Good thing takes time.</blockquote><p>Nadim Sungkar in <a href="https://l.instagram.com/?u=https%3A%2F%2Fbit.ly%2FNADIMMUNBOOK%3Ffbclid%3DPAZXh0bgNhZW0CMTEAAabjh0p6tONgDwwRwOTBWfCR_XRzS7GKyPhZkZMP0H8LwykyaiwyPu5gPSY_aem_-0VNM54affuqYe6DLq1JgQ&amp;e=AT0ejtqau2DoK6PaNdIw3O2xvKcJFVh2DNa5_t_FlksHTifpmb_2EeZrUzx6nPc6n4ODESy8owopxVhYVrbNx4SgDUApLBV1VFDkBQ">Nadim: A MUNer History (Page.43)</a></p><p>The concept, which stands for “Don’t Expect to Win All the Time” argues that a MUNer should have a reasonable ego regarding the desire to win and the general expectation of the conference itself. The concept focuses on the importance of keeping the ego to a healthy parameter that will ensure a sensible and controlled expectation of an award.</p><p>In my personal experience, controlling my ego as it relates to an unraveling debate allowed for a reasonable and logical assessment of the flow of debate and opens the door for substance improvement and development. Such nuance allows for a humble and measured thought that prevents unrealistic expectations and in turn prevents unfavorable actions should a conference not go well debate-wise. At the same time, it mitigates any thought of hyper-participation in desperation for awards and in turn keeps my character in check should social temptations of feeling validated appear.</p><h3>Boundaries</h3><p>When redefining what it truly means to be a MUNer, one important concept that correlates with the paradigm and objective aspect is boundaries. A critical requirement in the conduct of MUN is designed to prevent friction and needless issues in conferences and group settings. Whilst it has the benefit of instigating the will to thrive and succeed, one must ask oneself the question of where the boundary exists. I am bringing this up because it seems there have been many times where the red line either has been set but not followed or perhaps violated by other individuals for their petty interests.</p><p>The boundary aspect of MUN in this regard has always been about ensuring full control of the actions and practice of diplomacy by our own will, free from intervention from parties that may weaponize the mere act of pretend diplomacy for some sketchy and laughable “political goals” which in retrospect stems from a lack of grace from longstanding achievements and contribution within the circuit. Setting a redline between ourselves and what we do in the circuit not only locks out complicated issues from happening but also ensures that our character within the circuit is not defined by anyone but ourselves. Something that is under threat by interest groups that engage in mun politics and are looking for their next partner in their endeavor that at its core is very selfish and needlessly dangerous.</p><h3>Humility</h3><p>As an aspect that is often neglected in favor of the appearance of capability, humility is something that is supposed to be a universally accepted code. Unfortunately, in several cases, some members of the circuit showed that such “humility” only existed in a plain of convenience. Instead, such expected behavior was replaced with condescending behavior that isn’t always based on professional conduct during and after the conference. Often it becomes too much to bear that it causes a stereotypical image that MUNers are by nature disrespectful towards members of the community and are too selfish to create a productive environment to learn from each other.</p><p>Though, in retrospect humility as a concept is such a wide issue in the circuit that it requires a very delicate approach. One that takes into consideration the often undermined process behind MUN (be it organizing, running, or delegating) is critical in shaping the required self-decency in action. One that if not present, could cause irreparable damage to public image or at worse undermine the process orientation of the debate that occurs and minimize it into an unfair comparison of one person to another.</p><h3>An Epilogue</h3><p>With the dynamic and unpredictable nature of MUN in mind, I couldn’t help but wonder why something so hobbyist and educational in nature could at times turn into something deeply unbearable and at times downright toxic despite the limitations that come with simulating the United Nations. That being said, the lack of people constantly reminding themselves of what brought them here and keeps them coupled with numerous examples of outbursts and gaslighting has led to this moment in the nearly two decades of MUN in Indonesia where people have to be somewhat reminded of the real things that need to be considered while they are engaged in this world in fostering an environment of self-development and not societal regression.</p><p>As such, we must rethink the values and norms we uphold in order to create a circuit that nourishes thoughtful and measured debate which cannot under any circumstance be sidelined because of the mere notion it undermines contested debate, much less relations within the circuit which once deteriorated could potentially create a never-ending cycle of conflict that undermine entire institutions, conferences, clubs, and individual. Setting the path of destruction that causes distrust in the very mission of Model United Nations, to educate on global cooperation in achieving collective sustainable goals in the face of global issues. All whilst simultaneously increasing awareness of world issues, and learning of history and its adverse impacts. In light of the last two years, I can only wish us all the best of luck given the things that have been and will continue to occur. I hope we start treating each other humanely as before, for it is the key to the existence of Model United Nations and its noble education goal.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=f82bff5f0ed8" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>