<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Jon Gregory on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Jon Gregory on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@JMan240?source=rss-1b4d96a49c92------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Fri, 20 Nov 2026 20:01:52 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@JMan240/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Sports Media’s Battle to Understand Kareem Hunt, Labor Rights, and Their Own Hypocrisy]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@JMan240/sports-medias-battle-to-understand-kareem-hunt-labor-rights-and-their-own-hypocrisy-a6245899603?source=rss-1b4d96a49c92------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/a6245899603</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[sb-nation]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[kareem-hunt]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[nfl]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[sports]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jon Gregory]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 01 Dec 2018 18:09:18 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-12-01T18:09:18.686Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/770/1*8Tk6JnI72DNQTA1DiiG4Ng.jpeg" /></figure><p>In February, Kareem Hunt, possibly the best running back in the NFL, pushed and kicked a woman in a Cleveland, Ohio hotel, and then attempted to lie his way out of punishment for doing so. On the verge of a December run to the playoffs, and presented with irrefutable and public evidence of his guilt, Hunt’s team released him and the NFL handed him what is essentially an indefinite suspension.</p><p>A few hours after video of Hunt’s actions was released, SB Nation, a publication that <a href="https://deadspin.com/sb-nation-is-still-exploiting-workers-but-in-a-kinder-1825928891">has as bad a grasp of sound labor policy</a> as any other site on the internet, <a href="https://www.sbnation.com/nfl/2018/11/30/18120089/kareem-hunt-chiefs-hotel-assault-nfl-suspension-released-updates">ran a story</a> that included the following: “The NFL doesn’t need legal charges to decide whether to suspend a player. It shouldn’t need video proof either.”</p><p>It’s an assertion that should be familiar to anyone who follows sports. One that demands sports leagues develop an extralegal ability to obtain information, or act without it. After all, <a href="https://www.theringer.com/nfl/2018/12/1/18120220/kareem-hunt-kansas-city-chiefs-nfl-league-office">as The Ringer suggests</a>, how could the NFL fail to collect information when they have so much money to spend? Surely simply showing up, as a massive corporation who stands to make millions off the product produced by the person being accused, and attempting to cut a check should be enough right?</p><p>No one who is completely incompetent, like Rodger Goodell, gets paid a bunch of money by the NFL to be bad at their job, so clearly just flashing some cash should resolve the issue. There are definitely no laws barring discussion of cases. No legal counsel for those involved. No fear on the part of accusers or authorities that the NFL, one of the country’s largest corporations, might be more interested in burying or mitigating the damage to the league’s leading rusher instead of punishing him. No one with privileged access to case information that might find it more effective to tell literally anyone other than a group of rich white men who employ serial abusers about what happened that night in that hotel. At least none that the NFL’s monetary heft shouldn’t be able to circumvent, right?</p><p>It’s a suggestion that creeps ever closer to a blanket call for punishment of players, in every sport, based entirely on hearsay. Though, it should be noted, that this sentiment is largely avoided with problematic female sports stars. SB Nation, and basically every other major sports outlet, <a href="https://www.sbnation.com/soccer/2016/8/24/12634768/us-soccer-terminates-hope-solos-contract-suspends-her-for-6-months">had nothing bad to say about the US Women’s National Team</a>, or MLS, after years of enabling goalie Hope Solo’s obvious alcoholism and widely reported abuse finally ended in Solo’s forced departure.</p><p>I’m not a red pilled MAGA chud who’s going to start droning on about how that’s reverse sexism, but there’s valid questions to be asked about the obvious disparity between someone having very similar problems during a time when the NFL was very publicly confronting the same issues within its own building; and how that reflects on whether or not the media actually cares about the conduct of athletes and the severity with which they are punished beyond that punishment being able to generate interest. With every incident, sports media walks closer and closer to advocating that athletes, particularly visible ones, are punished first and questions asked, based on their desire to report the news most of these incidents revolve around, never.</p><p>They want the meat of the Kareem Hunt story, the comeuppance for the vile abuser and the story of the NFL’s ineptitude, on their plate without the side of bland frozen green beans that is accepting a massive corporation shouldn’t be able to put its foot to the throat of its workers’ livelihood because someone <em>said</em> they did something; nor have the ability to compel victims of their employees’ crimes to testify to, and relive, them for the purpose of meting out what will likely be symbolic punishment. They want things simplified into “bad guy does bad thing and gets punished” and don’t care what else is eroded in the process so long as the retribution is delivered expediently — because for some reason they’ve conflated expedience with justice, and deluded themselves into believing that a corporation is capable of giving a shit about anything other than its profit.</p><p>This push for corporate power and brutality to match that of its producers is also a bone chilling assertion to see coming from the writer’s room of a publication currently <a href="https://www.courthousenews.com/judge-advances-class-action-by-vox-sports-bloggers/">battling a class action lawsuit for abusing its many employees</a>. Despite regularly writing articles about how <a href="https://www.sbnation.com/2018/11/14/18092708/nfl-practice-squad-money-reality-jaydon-mickens-michael-thomas">sports leagues take advantage of their most vulnerable</a>, and chiding them for not considering the health of their players, for some reason the right to be treated fairly should be waived on a suspicion and the corporation inflicting this new abuse applauded for their willingness to take a stand on something they don’t actually care about. Suddenly the NFL is wrong for not jettisoning players at the first sign of trouble, for not firing its workers on the spot. The Ringer even goes so far as to suggest that the accused should be punished for simply being accused. “For all the league’s assurances since 2014 about having stronger enforcement and more robust investigative powers, a team once again took decisive action against a player accused of violence only because of a video released by TMZ.”</p><p>Now, obviously, the internet being what it is, my argument requires a caveat. Kareem Hunt earned the outcome of this (at the very least because he apparently tried to worm his way out of taking responsibility for his actions), and I don’t believe for a second that the NFL didn’t have enough proof to act earlier. There’s enough information in the original reporting, done by people who actually care, to satisfy their rules for handing out a suspension of some kind — even if not initially under the NFL’s policies regarding assault. I also stand on the side of accusers, but accepting the validity of an accuser and supporting their right to make an accusation without being harassed or discredited via ad hominem is not the same as, and should not be treated as, having enough information to support corporate dickheads’ right to act with impunity. Rodger Goodell is a greedy, spiteful corporate troll, and no one should be in a hurry to subject the athletes his league employs to the collective wrath of his cadre of hyper-wealthy assholes. Not even Kareem Hunt.</p><p>Hunt deserves the protections provided by his union, and deserves to not be treated like a PR chip to be played into the pot — something the media seems anxious to have him turn into — because he’s a person. Arguing to waive his right to humane treatment, to lust for a world in which he is more swiftly judged at the hands of a corporation that is always going to be slow and cruel by its very nature, is arguing against our own self interests as human beings. In a league where injuries just move practice a few feet over and where players with scrambled brains have to fight for a pittance of restitution, there’s only one reasonable conclusion to come to.</p><p>The NFL doesn’t care about Hunt, or about Abigail Ottinger, and it certainly doesn’t care about justice, so arguing that they act more harshly is an absurd call for infliction of hollow retribution. Arguing it from the halls of a corporate news outlet that is seeking to avoid paying its contributors <em>minimum</em> wage, and in many cases pays them no wage at all, is fucking vile.</p><p>SB Nation, and other sports media, are justified in taking the NFL to task for its many failures on this front in years past. Kevin Clark of The Ringer hammers home that point with a fervor in his article (linked earlier). The problem with that sentiment isn’t its moral sensibility, but rather the places those moral sensibilities are projected from.</p><p>If it’s a problem that the NFL only acted when presented with a video from TMZ, then it’s also a problem that the whole of sports media did the same.</p><p>If you follow SB Nation for sports news, you probably didn’t know Kareem Hunt did anything bad at all. Their coverage of the initial accusation of Hunt’s assault was relegated to quotes from local news posted without further comment on The Chiefs’ sweatshop team blog. It didn’t sniff the main site or even its main NFL landing page. The accusations were similarly absent from ESPN’s main NFL hub. The Ringer ran nothing about it, and as an avid follower of their podcast until the complete implosion of my Panthers every year, I can say with certainty they never gave it much attention there, if they even mentioned it at all. Deadspin’s flexible site layout and extreme amount of content makes it hard to tell definitively if they covered the story originally, but the lack of evidence in internet archives and links to previous stories in their current coverage of Hunt suggests they did not.</p><p>ESPN and Deadspin are two of the most read sports publications in the world. The Ringer and SB Nation have already published long condemnations of the NFL’s lack of action prior to this point, despite doing nothing to highlight Hunt’s offenses. Of the sports sites with accessible archives from February of this year, only Sports Illustrated, a publication more notorious for images of scantily clad women, got a report about the assault onto the front page — which included all the information that The Ringer, ESPN, Deadspin, SB Nation, et all are quick to point out now, and more. Bleacher Report, for their part as an aggregator, at least managed to get something up on their NFL landing page.</p><p>With all this in mind, the question becomes even simpler. If the NFL says they want to be better, and the media wants the NFL to be better, why did none of them give a fuck about Kareem Hunt’s assault until TMZ released a video of it?</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=a6245899603" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Reactionary Anarchism]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@JMan240/reactionary-anarchism-5b53635298b?source=rss-1b4d96a49c92------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/5b53635298b</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[games]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[watch-dogs]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[socialism]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jon Gregory]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 26 Feb 2018 16:46:08 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-02-26T16:46:08.560Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>There’s a lot to be said, and that has been said, about <em>Watch Dogs 2</em> and its salvaging of a franchise that was over-sold and then dragged through the mud. It’s a genuinely fun world, with a lot of smart writing and a heaping helping of system improvements. It’s also a world of intellectual theft, but not of the variety you might assume.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*2sjl3uV9SfVCPYtl436nUg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Watching dogs isn’t always what you might expect in Watch Dogs 2.</figcaption></figure><p>My version of Marcus Holloway, <em>Watch Dogs 2</em>’s young, likable replacement for its predecessor’s insufferable, brooding murder machine wore a CCCP jacket towards the end of my time with the game. It never quite fit. Not because of its size, mind you, but because of the game’s politics; or more specifically, its hamfisted use of Anarchism, Socialism, and other leftist ideologies in a game that doesn’t give a flying fuck about them as anything other than window dressings.</p><p>And I’m talking about a deeper level than the fact that it’s a game made by a corporation that’s structure is inherently designed to funnel money upwards. No, deeper down, at its core, <em>Watch Dogs 2</em> is staunchly reactionary. Its focus is not on how to live in a world where technology watches you all the time, how to fight the forces that abuse connectivity and build a better system in which to operate. Instead, in all of its details, Ubisoft’s open-world hacking epic pines to repair something old that has been broken.</p><p>Nothing exemplifies this more than Marcus; you know, the dude wearing the Soviet jacket and ostensibly doing so because he’s a fan of the Russian revolution — or at the very least deferential to its ideals; but Marcus can’t be, at least not in any critical, thoughtful fashion. Although he possesses all the relevant life experiences to end up at the very least a democratic socialist, he only comes to the hacker cell DedSec to help himself. His concern is less with systemic injustice and more with systemic injustice that has been inflicted specifically upon him.</p><p>The problem for Marcus isn’t that ctOS, the <em>Minority-Report</em>-styled citywide surveillance system of the <em>Watch Dogs</em> world, inflicts upon every citizen rank oppression at the hands of the wealthy and powerful — it’s that Marcus fell into their crosshairs. This attitude cascades down from those opening moments and through the rest of the game. His friends join him, making it clear that despite their tattoos and railing against the corporations and institutions, they are only nominally left of center. Their problem isn’t that the system itself it’s oppressive, it’s that they don’t have control of it.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*V0HGI5c0gtF_ShkjGoUKDQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>We’re meant to believe that Sitara, though her parents were wealthy, has somehow completely abandoned that element of her life and pulled herself up entirely by her own bootstraps (oh, and somehow simultaneously built a mysterious revenue source capable of funding the acquisition of property and dissemination of propaganda). Wrench, the “crazy anarchist” of the group, seems to fail to understand the principals of Anarchism at all; instead fulfilling the classical misunderstanding, and erring on the side of just fucking shit up regardless of what it is as opposed to… oh, maybe, I don’t know, arguing that a compulsory system itself is inherently oppressive by nature and thus ripe for abolition. I’m not even sure if Wrench consciously recognizes the systems he interacts with, except for, as with Marcus, when they oppress him or his friends directly, and the crew have to get to work to mete out retribution to the abusive party or set things back to the way they should be.</p><p>Around this core is built layers upon layers of outwardly Socialist, potentially even Revolutionary Socialist or outright Anarchist cruft. Little chunks of mostly inoffensive liberal identity politics dot the landscape, but in a vacuum one might easily assume that the game is, in fact, what it purports to be. The team takes on massive corporations, the Oakland PD, and even the FBI in an attempt to expose corruption and better society by returning some semblance of power back to the people of the greater Bay Area. Back on that bottom layer, though, DedSec rarely takes actions of their own volition. They react to the changes around them, attempt to take petty vengeance or act upon and exploit the system for their own gain.</p><p>Further out on the fringes it frays again, away from the political culture elements it pilfers from in almost every element. Ignore, for a moment, the series’ continuing strange obsession with the identification of trans people as trans, or this game’s rather annoying positioning of a hefty, slightly heavy-handedly written, lesbian as a primary antagonist. While those have been touched on as tone deaf elements, along with others, they distract from the larger picture of what <em>Watch Dogs 2</em> fails at. Set the personal politics aside for your own, personal use, and consider the larger social implications of the game’s structure. DedSec thrives by theft, but not from the people a Revolutionary Socialist or traditional Marxist might suggest are deserving of it when the shit hits the fan.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Pe1Py1xghvBPc6lQVqMnag.jpeg" /></figure><p>Yes, DedSec does occasionally take from the rich. Yes, they reclaim money, left to rot on the ground, and even occasionally from the territory of those that work to oppress them. They also take it from the accounts of those who desperately need it, if the player so chooses, and the game is all too happy to get said player there. The predictive software Marcus uses to identify the people with the highest priority accounts for pilfering is just as likely to single out wealthy banker douchebags as homeless relapsed addicts sleeping on cardboard in the rain. Marcus gains the ability to steal cars from normal people without detection early. Crossfire and pedestrian casualties are nearly impossible to avoid.</p><p>Similarly, the game is built around acquisition and materialism over most everything else. One can work for the game’s Uber allegory, and then get jumped by a gang of taxi drivers; suggesting fairly outright that labor organizers are bloodthirsty bad guys while outright refusing, during dialogue, to take any kind of nuanced stance on the topic. There are expensive cars to strive for, fancy clothes to sport, high-end weaponry and gadgets to 3D print and so forth and so on. DedSec, in genius bit of most likely unintentional irony, sports a DedSec brand clothing vending machine in its hideouts — a machine its most core members must still pay to use.</p><p>Anything is justifiable in furtherance of the cause. If DedSec cares about bettering the lives of the people when it does not also better the lives of its members, then it never chooses to show it. Even as the later portions of the game flourish into ripe territory for examination of the system that has enabled all of its chaos, it boils itself right back down into a mush focused on individual actors over that which supports them. <em>Watch Dogs 2</em> often comes tantalizingly close to actually providing salient counter commentary to late Capitalism. It brings itself up for air, if only for a moment, and something it hits on blossoms into an outwardly sincere consideration of the things it steals from. These moments are, unfortunately, agonizingly short-lived and often paired with regression in minutes, if not moments.</p><p>At the end of the day, <em>Watch Dogs 2</em> is still a thief, and in the process of fencing its ill-gotten gains, creates a strange, reactionary Frankenstein’s monster of Anarchism, Socialism, and anything left of the space it actually feels comfortable existing in.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=5b53635298b" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Skin Deep]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@JMan240/skin-deep-8a5c24bf2404?source=rss-1b4d96a49c92------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/8a5c24bf2404</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[review]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[final-fantasy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[videogames]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[criticism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[final-fantasy-xv]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jon Gregory]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 17 Feb 2018 02:52:32 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-02-17T14:05:53.399Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*8TyW8I3DbdBrHXURQ6PT1Q.jpeg" /></figure><p><em>Final Fantasy XV</em> is as superficial as its main characters, an outwardly pleasant looking thing that crumbles to ash when you attempt to grasp it. It is the worst Final Fantasy I have ever played, and one of the worst games I’ve ever completed.</p><p>It’s often too easy to, in the moment, say something is the worst game you’ve ever played. In most cases, like the finer details of <em>Final Fantasy XV</em>’s world, the games don’t stick with you. They lack the impact, the truly rancid notes necessary to really earn that title absent the bias of recency. <em>Final Fantasy XV</em> (<em>FFXV</em>), though, fails on a profound level, almost beyond comprehension, and to the point that beginning to dig into, and make sense of, the pile of slop is nearly as daunting as the prospect of finishing the game itself.</p><p>The easiest place to begin is also the least impactful, but perhaps also the most useful for setting a stage. Few games manage to fill tens of hours with so little meaningful interaction. Shallow alone doesn’t begin to describe the mechanical problems present in <em>FFXV</em>. It’d be hard to argue that the series’ main entries have enjoyed rich interactive experiences in the past, yet something about this game feels even more vacant.</p><p>At the boring end of the spectrum lies combat; an amorphous — but somewhat pleasantly flashy — slurry of <em>Final Fantasy XII</em> party management and <em>Final Fantasy XIII</em>’s active time battles. Any good present in the system is fundamentally betrayed, however, by paper thin underpinnings. Equipment has been boiled down to the most basic weapons and accessories. Magic is reduced to three elements and, even if it were diverse enough to be pleasant or useful to engage with, is tied up in tedious resource gathering. Summons decide when to aid you, which is almost never and rarely when you actually could have used their help. Party members occasionally team up with you or are allowed to perform mostly ineffective, highly repetitive, signature moves. None of these systems seem like they were thought about for more than the length of a coffee break.</p><p>Perhaps this wouldn’t matter if fighting itself was a simple but mostly enjoyable and functional action pastiche in the vein of later <em>Kingdom Hearts</em> entries. Instead, button prompts often fail to trigger, and enemies focus player character Noctis to a fault; devolving combat into a mind-numbing charade of spamming healing items in the absence of healing magic and sitting through their overlong animations. To make matters worse, the game is fond of air-dropping it faceless “imperial” soldiers onto your head, further breaking encounters and ensuring that any semblance of an enjoyable experience is sucked from fights by incomprehensible chaos.</p><p>This same theme of sluggish, unresponsive, surface-deep interaction snakes its tendrils out into the only nominally interactive world. Attempting to engage with anything in the environment, a button press shared with the action of jumping, results consistently in Noctis flailing wildly as he leaps into the air. The crown prince is fond of going airborne when attempting to enter his car, pick up an item, interact with an objective, speak to other people and everything in between. Ironically, movement is often so mind-meltingly slow that I found myself jumping all the time just to alleviate the anxiety it imposed upon me.</p><p>Control over the game’s central vehicle is locked away, frustratingly, for hours. Customization of the Regalia is shallow and gated behind mindless resource gathering. Chocobos can whisk you places more reliably, but function on an inane rental system that exists only to suppress your ability to engage with anything financial in the world — not that they’d have anywhere to take you if they were worth the trouble anyways. Party members grab you regularly, preventing you from entering battle while they impart a “strategy” that often boils down to, quite literally, “do X amount of damage”. So regularly does the game wrench control from you to give report cards during battles or stare at Noctis after the completion of a side-quest while he stares lifelessly into the distance, that I found my self audibly admonishing it.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*XbAvxMUyWGtODGSFtXRThA.jpeg" /></figure><p>While it would like to trick you into thinking it shares the complexity of the series it steals its name from, <em>FFXV</em> has the mechanical depth — both in combat and its larger world — of something like <em>Firewatch</em> or <em>Life is Strange</em>. You get to do what it tells you to do, when it tells you to do it, and nothing else. That it attempts to conceal this instead of embracing it, that it attempts to deceive its players rather than dare to do what it actually wants to do, that it wastes its audience’s time fabricating a series of mechanical illusions, is insulting.</p><p>The physical world surrounding Insomnia, the soulless city at the heart of our squad of pretty boys’ adventure, should similarly be a source of derision. At its core, the rolling hills and small, oddly placed desert, are the same deception the game engages in elsewhere. It’s filled with people, who seemingly live nowhere — West-Worldesque robotic husks that exist to trick you into a sense of life. Boring quest dispensers that all too regularly sport an offensively common antebellum American southern accent, and yap away in desperation to build excuses for quest designs that would have been dated half a decade ago.</p><p>That the spaces between the handful of unique locations are a vapid combination of clashing architecture, seemingly lifted from one of a dozen photos, and slightly rotated, exceptionally overused prefab buildings. The much lauded dungeons are little more than empty corridors, trading on an illusion of complexity created by fights and maze-like design in an attempt to hide how stark they really are. I should care more, as a person that loves world design, but it’s just so boring I can’t be bothered to devote more to tearing it apart.</p><p>Where the game really falls to pieces, where effort is actually warranted in the pursuit of dismantlement, is in the tragedy of its narrative. The larger <em>Final Fantasy</em> series has long been a bastion for inscrutable lore dumps and taxing characters. It’s often overwhelming to the point of seeming nonsensical but rarely actually loses its thread completely — even when it makes bad, and sometimes laughable decisions. It has produced some excellent narratives, inspiring worlds, and at the very least, even at its lowest points, managed to surface redeeming characters and moments.</p><p><em>Final Fantasy XV</em>, meanwhile, is unrepentant gibberish; highlighted by both the series’ most wasted villain to date, and a cast of unimaginative characters, wrapped around a lazy, imperialist fantasy. A fantasy in which the throne is all that matters and there are no subjects to gum up the works, no one to dissent against the powers that trade their lives like currency. It pales in comparison to the recently re-released <em>Final Fantasy XII</em>, a sprawling political drama that has a sense of heart and care for the places and people in it. Little in <em>FFXV</em> suggests its writers even considered something beyond the script they penned. Despite inhabiting the skin of a lore heavy series, the world of Eos and its people might as well have not existed at all a week before the gang’s car runs out of gas in the desert.</p><p>Though the game, and its fans, would have you believe that it’s tale of camaraderie — of pretty boys being pretty boys — the reality is that most of your time will be spent listening to NPCs drone about stuff that is completely immaterial to the grander narrative, and completely devoid of any meaningful characterization of Lucis. You’ll perform menial tasks, ignoring your larger goal to eek out a few levels. The vast majority of these NPCs will dump their same identical, mindless quests upon you over and over, until you long for the days when the series’ linear roots would incidentally whisk you past at least a temporary point of no return.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*XV9cpC1BdVmmt26VYwG54w.png" /></figure><p>It doesn’t help that, of your party of good friends, only two actually seem to be friends at all. They all talk like they are, but only Prompto and Noctis possess any actual chemistry. A heartfelt conversation between the two atop one of the game’s hotels, during which Prompto opens up about feeling like he doesn’t belong, serves as one of the few bright spots, and the only moment of greater character exploration in the entire game. This moment is bolstered later by the somewhat flat, but still interesting revelation that Prompto is one of manufactured human weapons that the empire flings at you in droves. Noctis, while far from the series’ most interesting protagonist, is perfectly serviceable in his role, while Ignis could easily pass for little more than an indifferent chauffeur.</p><p>Gladiolus, on the other hand, is a plague. He’s introduced as being along because he’s duty bound to be there, and though he returns again and again, shows little actual affection for anyone. For the most part he’s a hulking monument to toxic masculinity, disappearing to deal with dangerous stuff alone and cold shouldering the rest of the party when he disagrees with them. He mercilessly ridicules both Prompto and Noctis on multiple occasions. Most notably guilt tripping Noctis after the death of his bride to be, Lunafreya, insisting that men don’t handle such an event by outwardly grieving. Similarly, he constantly singles out Prompto for not holding his own in combat, going out of his way to make sure someone who doesn’t feel like he fits in <em>knows</em> he doesn’t.</p><p>It’s suggested that Gladio is loyal to Noctis, and loyalty in the absence of emotion is a sign of true friendship. Friends aren’t the only ones that come back though, and the hulking monument to the quintessential male fallacy resembles a persistent abuser more than he does a firm-footed companion. Combine Ignis’ indifferent stoicism and Gladio’s abusive personality with a game that seems to care little about expanding the narratives surrounding its characters, and you end up with a story that actively combats its own core narrative concept. <em>Final Fantasy XV</em> posits that party is as tight as family, but gives you a bunch of people that can’t be bothered to worry about anyone but themselves, and who refuse to ask for help when they clearly need it.</p><p>The rest of the narrative is similarly frustrating, carving obvious chunks out of itself to entice players to pay more to find out what’s actually going on. Ardyn, perhaps the best presented villain the series has had in two decades, turns from an intriguing, mysterious trickster with ties to an enigmatic empire into a grudge holding, one note super villain with no explanation. One minute he’s playfully hounding you, the next he’s making good on some perceived slight that just never happens or gets explained on screen. The subsequent sequences devolve into an incomprehensible mess of a back half , with characters that are cast aside without warning or introduced as if you’ve known them all your life. One might as well be given one of every ten pages in a Dan Brown novel and asked to piece together something from the conspiratorial lunacy.</p><p>This absurd approach expands beyond the moment to moment character interactions. If the citizens of Lucis are in any way oppressed by Niflheim, or interested in seeing their “rightful king” return to the throne, this sentiment is nowhere to be found. There are hardly any “Nif” soldiers anywhere, and they very rarely even inhabit the same space as anyone other than the party. Absent their magically spawning dropships and unguarded, mostly empty concrete bases, you’d be hard pressed to find any signs of a military occupation. The city of Insomnia itself, the crown jewel you’re striving to reclaim, serves little purpose other than as a setting for mass destruction; constantly empty and without any discernible concern for their missing prince or murdered king. The empire, Ardyn excluded, pursues Noctis, a potential threat to their very existence, with all the urgency of a SWAT team to a j-walker.</p><p>At its core <em>FFXV</em> asks you to care about a royal pissing match, to invest yourself in a bunch of shitheads vying for power over a vacant, heartless city literally devoid of life or liveliness. It’s the<em> Entourage</em> of the <em>Final Fantasy</em> world, but with a side of repugnant apathy towards the human cost of wars and resistance.</p><p>With some effort <em>FFXV</em> could have formed the basis for a truly groundbreaking narrative direction for the series; an exploration of its past glorification of colonialism and the wars that surround it, through the eyes of those at the tip of its spear. But it doesn’t give a fuck about anything. It doesn’t care if the game you’re engaging with is in any way meaningful or even vaguely enjoyable. It doesn’t care about introducing its characters or the story its telling. It damn well doesn’t care about the legacy of <em>Final Fantasy</em>.</p><p><em>Final Fantasy XV</em> cares about turning a disaster into $75+ of the most cynical, deceptive content Square Enix has ever created. It’s a game about earnings calls and investment meetings, not pretty princes and their pretty friends. It’s a sandwich so desperate to sell you the meat and the cheese separately, that it forgets the damn bread.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=8a5c24bf2404" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[If the NFL is as Boring as The Ringer Thinks it is, They Have Only Themselves to Blame]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@JMan240/if-the-nfl-is-as-boring-as-the-ringer-thinks-it-is-they-have-only-themselves-to-blame-5a53ccba3389?source=rss-1b4d96a49c92------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/5a53ccba3389</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[college-football]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[quarterbacks]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[the-ringer]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[nfl]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[offensive-line]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jon Gregory]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 20 Sep 2017 16:26:13 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-09-20T16:33:57.799Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*P2xKTCWx7jFQ_rK1_kvUOQ.jpeg" /></figure><p><em>The Ringer</em> <a href="https://www.theringer.com/nfl/2017/9/19/16332762/watchability-fun-football-boring-quality-of-play">thinks the NFL is boring now</a>.</p><p>It’s their modus operandi this season, their running theme of the year. It’s on the site, it’s in their podcasts and their social media feeds. <a href="https://medium.com/@JMan240/lets-talk-about-the-weirdly-off-base-world-of-nfl-analysis-43b5c88a9255">As I’ve written about before</a>, for whatever reason NFL analysts and reporters are loath to move on from something they think they’ve hit on; and, like an overly conservative coach, they’ll keep ramming it down your throat for a whole season hoping it takes off for a week or two before Gronk spikes a football into the back of a Browns player’s head following a TD and that’s all anyone can talk about for the next month.</p><h3>Shake4ndbake on Twitter</h3><p>BRUHHHH 😂😂😂https://t.co/VxNvPZQZqT</p><p>They’ll assume the Seahawks are still a good team, even after they barely top a terrible 49ers team that slung itself in desperation at the line to gain on 4th downs in week one, failing to even put up a fight against a team whose QB had shoulder surgery and a single drive of preseason play. They’ll need the Patriots to go 0–5 to start a season before they even question a battered roster’s ability to compete. And so forth and so on.</p><p>There’s a couple problems with the “NFL is bad now” train of thought, though.</p><p>Problem number 1?</p><h3>No One can Come Up with a Convincing Explanation</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*WtUcg8XOaJSTHn_SWj8o_A.jpeg" /></figure><p>At the end of the day, no one can really come up with a good reason why the NFL is actually as nearly unwatchable as a small handful of people think it is. <em>The Ringer</em> trotted out a GM, and some analysts, and they pointed the finger at bad offensive lines and changing offensive styles and said it was all terrible without explaining why any of that actually made the games terrible to watch.</p><p>In particular, <em>The Ringer</em> seems to love pointing to TV ratings, as if the publication itself doesn’t exist entirely online and streaming services either don’t exist or haven’t been eroding the value of those figures for nearly a decade. Hell, even they admit that viewership isn’t actually down, and all they mustered in support of their theory was a tweet… from a year ago, about a <em>Wall Street Journal</em> article that suggested viewing time was down through the first quarter of the 2016 season.</p><p>Frankly, I turned off Falcons vs Packers this weekend not because the football was bad, but because I had to choose between watching it on <em>NBC</em>’s trash streaming service, with its persistent banner ad shrinking the picture, or my over-priced (now) Charter-Spectrum cable service with its shit picture quality. If football, or, hell, major networks, were as easy to get to and provided programming parity between online and dedicated services, I probably wouldn’t have tuned out at all. I know I’d have watched more football during week one if an early game had been aired in my market prior to the Panthers’ 4:25 kickoff in San Francisco, or if a game hadn’t started at 10:30pm on a Monday. And this week if the NFL itself hadn’t cannibalized its <em>Thursday Night Football</em> programming to try to drive people to subscribe to their terrible TV package.</p><p><em>The Ringer</em> writer ends up pining for a league of old, when things were supposedly more spectacular and fun, and bat their eyelashes longingly at some mythical soccer philosophy of playing a prettier game as if that’s a thing that’s even applicable in a sport where half the players on the field are engaged directly in throwing their bodies like missiles at other humans every play.</p><p><em>The Washington Post</em> chose instead to trot out stat after stat, but was forced to make concessions at every turn. They note that teams are relatively on-par to last year rushing the ball in the red zone through two games. They note that teams are similarly as successful in red zone scoring, that young QBs have a harder time, and that bad teams are bad. Their wild revelation that offensive lines are worse isn’t actually new, and they paired it with a clip of Joe Thomas, perhaps the best LT in the history of the game, getting beat by TJ Watt. Not what I’d have chosen, but I guess that’s just me.</p><p><em>WaPo</em>’s stats are, at best, paired with a “lowest since 2005” caveat, which, frankly, isn’t that long ago and doesn’t suggest a terribly significant shift in parity. To put that in perspective, Brady already had his first 3 Super Bowls, Roethlisberger was about to snag his first, the Panthers were still the most volatile team in the league, and the Browns were still trash. About the only noteworthy difference between then and now is that the Jaguars weren’t quite the disaster that they are now — although functionally they just traded places with the Raiders so its basically a wash. There’s an underlying theme in the <em>WaPo</em> article that suggests quarterback play has dropped off significantly.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/380/1*pU9CmFI9hWMDrwzGjAOwfA.jpeg" /><figcaption>No one put the Brown in Browns quite as efficiently as Kelly Holcomb.</figcaption></figure><p>Meanwhile back in 2005, since we’ve already stopped in… the Browns started Trent Dilfer and Charlie Frye. Josh McCown (weird right?) started almost half the season for the Cardinals. The Ravens were rolling with Kyle Boller and Anthony Wright. The Bills had Kelly Holcomb and J.P. Losman. The 49ers played Ken Dorsey, Cody Pickett, and Tim Rattay in addition to Alex Smith. Brooks Bollinger started more games for the Jets than Chad Pennigton. Ryan Fitzpatrick (oh look, another one) started games for the Rams. The Saints were still in the Aaron Brooks era. The Lions were withering away under the command of Joey Harrington and an ancient Jeff Garcia. Rounding out the low end were primary Miami starter Gus Ferrotte, and the elder Carr at the helm of the withering Houston Texans.</p><p>Oh, and Jake Delhomme, Rex Grossman, (old man) Mark Brunell, Byron Leftwich, and Chris Simms all started playoff games that year. Not exactly a breathtaking example of quarterbacking prowess. The idea that the NFL’s QB pool has become somehow significantly worse is absurd, despite people floating it around a lot recently, as is the notion that the striking longevity of Brady, Brees, and Roethlisberger dragging the average age of starting QBs in the NFL upwards is a sign of a sudden dearth of talent at the position. If you think Brooks Bollinger was meaningfully better than Jared Goff, I’ve Goff some bad news for you.</p><p>As for the old days being pillars of fun, and beauty, that may have been true; if you were a fan of the 49ers or Cowboys — who collectively accounted for a over a third of all Super Bowl victories between 1980 and 1999. Just ask Buffalo fans how fun the ‘90s were, though. Or how beautiful football was for the 16 teams that wallowed in collective mediocrity, and the half dozen that were even worse, over the course of the ‘80s; separating themselves from their competition over that decade by no more than 20 wins in a league that ground games out to a fault. Or, perhaps, the ‘00s were fun and beautiful by comparison to recent NFL years, because there certainly wasn’t nearly a lockout or various levels of tumultuous, ugly play and terrible QBs. *cough cough* Jimmy Clausen and JaMarcus Russell *cough cough*</p><p>We’re two games into a season, and the fact that this is even a discussion is patently absurd. If there’s a shittier sample size to make such a gargantuan assertion based on, I certainly haven’t seen it in the sports world.</p><p>Problem number 2?</p><h3>It’s Their Fault</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/980/1*2RHk8u4wZfVZtip6E8Qz_A.jpeg" /></figure><p>Maybe not specifically <em>The Ringer</em>, its a bit too young of a publication despite being the one fiendishly waving the flag and shouting the same thing over and over, like the drunk guy at the bar who is convinced a certain play is terrible, and loses his fucking mind every time it’s run regardless of its effectiveness. Certainly some of its writers though.</p><p>Sports media, in general, has its fingerprints all over the NFL quality of play debate, and on the wrong side of it, <em>The Ringer</em> included.</p><p>Speaking of which, <em>The Ringer</em> is a great place to start, because they represent the same fascination with the NFL’s relatively terrible stats and making snap judgments based off them that created this supposed mess. In their decrying of the NFL’s quality, they take shots at high-completion passing attacks, and a lack of explosiveness paired with a trend towards conservative play-calling designed to prevent turnovers. They speak to analysts who suggest that style of play is boring, and yet they themselves have been harping on TD to INT ratio and completion percentages as markers of quality for years, along with the rest of the sports world; ragging on teams that have stuck with the deep ball, and been inconsistent in the process.</p><p>They’ve pushed a narrative that paints a player who does more outside of those stats — your Cam Newtons and Marcus Mariotas — as somehow significantly worse than his compatriots. Why? Well, his completion percentage, as Robert Mays might put it, “just isn’t there”. He’s “too careless with the football”, he’s “just not as mechanically skilled” as the other guys. Whether or not that’s actually the case, or how lacking in other skills the rest of the players are, doesn’t seem to matter; but, the narrative does, because the narrative is what young players hear, and subsequently what they think they need to strive for.</p><p>The narrative that a shorter, higher efficiency passing attack is the right way to go isn’t just fueled by the media’s obsession with bad stats, but by their obsession with offenses they purport to hate. <em>The Ringer</em> penned an article this off-season calling the Patriots <a href="https://www.theringer.com/nfl/2017/8/7/16107814/2007-new-england-patriots-tom-brady-randy-moss-wes-welker">The Perfect Team</a>, highlighting their 2007 16–0 season; a season that would ultimately end with a Super Bowl loss and an identity shift that paved the way, backed by continuous praise, to the short passing attacks that define the league today.</p><p>Since the Moss-era Patriots dispersed to the wind, Boston’s darlings have been built entirely around making things easier for an aging Brady. They thrive on the same quick passing plays that are now being derided as boring. They dink and dunk their way down the field with a passing attack that, most of the time, resembles a running game in terms of rhythm — and often features running backs to boot. Brady’s obscenely quick release is universally praised, and the Patriots have become the most competitive team in the history of the NFL in the span of a single man’s career.</p><p>They’re also, indeed, boring as molasses in a freezer, and have been for the better part of the last decade. And yet the praise continues, and though it is not undue it is hypocritical. The Patriots are the poster children of hyper-efficiency, and everything the quality-of-play debaters should hate. Their teams seem to survive any injury or suspension, because they thrive on a highly precise brand of conservative play-calling. Never doing more than they have to, never more quickly than is necessary, but always exactly as much as is needed.</p><p>Their ability to eat up the clock with long drives often bails out a patchwork defense. Their offensive line hasn’t had a healthy high-caliber player in at least half a decade, choosing instead to lean on a quick-fire passing attack, good schematic blocking concepts, and a savvy approach to change of pace that allows them to mask, and even gain an advantage with, an offensive line full of players most people can’t name. Swapped with any other team in the league, the Patriots line would most certainly be equally as porous as their peers.</p><p>Compounding the NFL’s very real offensive line problems, are the sports networks themselves, particularly <em>ESPN</em>, who have turned college football from stepping stone to the NFL into its own mammoth industry. You want an explanation for the lack of quality offensive lineman? Well, look no further than <em>College Football Live</em>, and the rise of the CFB money-machine.</p><p>The entirety of college football has defaulted to easier offenses, with easier reads, because its easier to win with them in a situation where the entire roster turns over top to bottom every 4–5 years. They run the Spread Option offense, they call plays with giant pictures and hand signals from the sideline. Offensive lineman never put their hand in the dirt. Receivers and running backs rarely block, QBs take snaps from under center once in a blue moon. Why? Because it’s easier to just tell someone to go stand there and look at the sideline to know what to do every play. It’s easier to just put the QB in the shotgun, as far from the defense as possible, and hope that the offensive line slows the D down a bit just by being there. It’s easier to hand the ball off on a sweep or toss it on an option than it is to coordinate a pulling guard and a lead-blocking fullback.</p><p>It’s hard to imagine major college programs care about getting their players to the NFL beyond the point that it makes it easier for them to recruit new players and subsequently stay competitive. There’s no incentive for competitive schools to care about their players’ preparedness, no reason to run a more complex pro-style offense, no need to teach technique when the system that requires the least amount of effort is naturally also going to be the most consistently effective.</p><p>Meanwhile the coaches get paid millions, the sports networks rake in advertising money, the different conferences sign massive TV deals, the games suck, and no one seems to care.</p><p>The answer to the NFL’s quality of play problem, if indeed there is one outside of the offensive line, is simple, and it’s been simple since I first really started caring about football in middle school. Dump college football, stop televising the vast majority of its trash games, stop signing massive TV deals, stop debating the merits of a level of sport where even the best teams are invariably trash. Stop lauding coaches and schools that leach off what are often vulnerable, disadvantaged young people. Cap spending by college programs, punish untoward recruiting schemes harshly, and impose heavy taxes on earnings from the performances of unpaid collegiate athletes.</p><p>That, is the only responsible way to approach the NFL’s growing problems, the only reasonable stance for a publication that purports to care about the quality of the sports it watches, the only way to stop the bigger machine from cannibalizing its smaller sibling.</p><p>The only way to stop college football from devouring the NFL.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=5a53ccba3389" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Lets Talk About The Weirdly Off-Base World Of NFL Analysis]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@JMan240/lets-talk-about-the-weirdly-off-base-world-of-nfl-analysis-43b5c88a9255?source=rss-1b4d96a49c92------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/43b5c88a9255</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[espn]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[nfl]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[cam-newton]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[analysis]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jon Gregory]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 27 Aug 2017 19:27:38 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-08-27T19:27:38.684Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*mVvSWOf5JeVJR0d7f8jSsQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>Coverage of the NFL is weird, relying more than any other sport on resilient, season-long narratives that seem to persist until the moment they are violently cast off their pedestal, only to be resurrected the second they seem even remotely reasonable again. Most fans tune-in because they want to see their team talked about, then roll their eyes when the pro NFL analysts whiff on easily available information.</p><p>The world of the NFL analyst is so resistant to change it begs questioning if they research their topics ahead of time at all. Take ESPN’s Matthew Berry this week, knocking Cam Newton’s fantasy value. That’s fine, he doesn’t have to like Cam as a Fantasy QB and there are good reasons not to — uncertainty about his ability to transition to a new offense with limited preseason time, uncertainty about the productivity around him, uncertainty about his long-term health. I’m not here to attack the man for his opinions, just his blatant disregard for, well, everything else that’s been discussed around Newton this off-season.</p><p>To illustrate this we have to dig into counter analysis. Berry asserts that Cam’s value as a fantasy QB is limited by the Panthers’ decision to not run him as much, suggesting that Cam lacks the ability to pass his way to relevance in a more suitable scheme. Meanwhile his two most productive seasons rushing and passing (ignoring TD to INT ratio and focusing on net yardage), years one and two, were when the offense was run by Rob Chudzinski and Cam ran a more varied passing attack while escaping the pocket more. That last bit is important, because it’s something Cam has done less of thanks to the design of the offense in recent years.</p><p>Chudzinski’s offense while in Carolina might be best described as a bog-standard NFL passing attack with Zone Read concepts frankensteined into it. The Chud era Panthers just plain passed more, with Newton logging career highs in attempts, completions, average yards per attempt, and average yards per completion in his rookie season. More importantly, however, the offense simplified Newton’s reads, allowing a younger and less experienced QB the opportunity to make plays with his legs when coverage won the downfield fights. None of this information is secret, and arguably it should be easier for analysts with massive stores of information and exceptional resources to recognize — and yet this information appears only sparingly in coverage of the NFL and its teams.</p><p>Chudzinski’s evolution of the Panthers offense netted him an ill-fated stint as head coach of the Browns and thus entered Mike Shula, and Air Coryell–a devilishly complex passing attack focused on forcing the ball deep down the field. With Air Coryell came the “Inaccurate Cam” narrative, the idea that Newton, while physically talented, just lacks the passing skill necessary to be a great QB without running. While much can be said about Air Coryell, <a href="http://presnapreads.com/2017/06/28/cam-newton-is-as-inaccurate-as-steph-curry/">it’s best point of comparison in the sporting world is Steph Curry’s Golden State Warriors</a>. It’s the type of offense that, when played well and by the right combination of players, produces MVP level results; and that falls to pieces the second it catches a thread on anything. The 2015 Panthers nearly went undefeated, the 2016 Panthers imploded like a nuclear reactor.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*C0zL5J6Jrow5d2-v2BuNrw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Newton left the pocket less in 2016 than ever before, but his rate of contact continued to be exceptionally high.</figcaption></figure><p>The problem for the 2016 Panthers, however, wasn’t that Newton was less accurate. While as a baseline he was less accurate both with and without pressure than anyone else in the league, that doesn’t tell the tale of the gargantuan QB in the context of the offense he runs or the state of his team. All that information is out there, though, and should be used as a lens when examining Newton — or any other passer.</p><p>Air Coryell asks a QB to essentially shoot three-pointers for the whole game, completing high degree-of-difficulty downfield throws in an attempt to overwhelm an opposing defense. It’s the epitome of go big or go home. The routes are slow to develop, but hit hard and go for big gains. Because of the length of the routes however, a significant portion of Newton’s game has been eliminated as the Panthers have transitioned from mixed concept offense to a more traditional Air Coryell passing attack. Newton has had to stay in the pocket, because the scheme combined with Carolina’s behemoth wide receivers is slow, and Newton stuck in the pocket loses a dimension. His runs become more predictable, they’re planned instead of improvised, and he’s under threat of becoming a tackling dummy if all the pieces don’t work.</p><p>Last season, behind a ravaged offensive line that struggled to block long enough to support Air Coryell’s deep drops and bracketed by receivers that struggled to gain separation, the wheels came off–and Cam’s numbers reflected the fact that he was asked not to escape his deflating pockets in favor of forcing the ball to receivers that had less than a yard of separation <a href="http://www.nfl.com/news/story/0ap3000000769130/article/cam-newton-leads-nfls-top10-most-aggressive-qbs">a whopping 25 percent of the time</a>. Cam was basically asked to run a pick-and-pop, long-ball offense with a hand in his face all season. No one else was even close.</p><p>More than two-thirds of Newton’s passes traveled five yards or more through the air, a stat that already heavily outpaces the rest of the league and seems outright galling considering the Panthers’ offensive line was so injured that they started a guy who had been mowing lawns at Center for most of the year, and literally ran out of Tackles to put on the field. Considering how terrible Newton’s line was, and the offense asking him to ignore one of his most valuable traits, it would be easy to write Newton off as simply put in a bad spot during his terrible passing performance last year, but even that falls short of painting the whole picture.</p><p>Despite receivers that couldn’t operate in the short game and a line that couldn’t block for the deep game, Newton still excelled in all the ranges where his receivers weren’t at an extreme disadvantage — or where the team simply didn’t operate. The Panthers barely threw behind the line at all, and logged less passes to all RBs — the players most likely to catch the ball in that space — last year than rookie Christian McCaffrey alone had in his best year of college ball. In the two passing categories beyond five yards and at or below 20, Newton ranked in the top five passers in the league in terms of accuracy. Even behind a terrible offensive line, and playing nearly a quarter of the season with badly injured shoulder, Newton still ranked in the top 10 when asked to throw the ball more than 20 yards down field.</p><p>More in-depth anaylsis simply doesn’t support Cam being a sub-par passer in terms of capability, instead pointing to a deadly cocktail of receivers that lack elite skills and a scheme that was vulnerable to poor offensive line play. Couple that information with the team’s plan to move to a quicker passing attack that is likely to offer Newton more opportunities to escape the pocket, and it stands to reason that less designed runs for Cam doesn’t mean he’ll be commensurately less productive as a runner. Berry’s line of reasoning for avoiding Cam just doesn’t make sense by any decent measure.</p><p>This type of sticky narrative isn’t limited to Newton by any means; statistical simplicity has a habit of burying many a good player in the NFL these days, and elevating many a mediocre one. The problem largely boils down to the NFL world’s depth of stat keeping not maintaining pace with a sports viewership that demands immediate, definitive answers to who or what is better rather than discussion of the merits of the game’s various elements.</p><p>The NFL has remained exceptionally insular to the hawkish stat examination other sports enjoy. Even the NFL’s own statisticians have relegated detailed stats to blurbs made to fill the downtime during live games and as fodder for two to three minute segments used to prop up coverage, founded on snap judgments, of a league that operates, in any meaningful capacity, for just half of the year. It reeks of a, frankly, lazy approach to analysis. One that’s willing to consistently accept and posit theories based on simple, generalized information.</p><p>Stats are a great tool for fighting sport’s biggest addiction, cliche. Analysis of the NFL, and evaluations of the men who play in it, has, however, remained largely the same since I learned what stats were in the first place. Trapped in a “First Take” addled world of boring hot takes that feeds on the average fan’s inbred narcissism. It’s a shame that almost no one who is paid to dig around in the NFL’s numbers seems to care about going more than surface deep, because that’s the only way any of this stops.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=43b5c88a9255" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Strange Multi-person Perspectives of Video Games]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@JMan240/the-strange-multi-person-perspectives-of-video-games-6fd1b42e6d0a?source=rss-1b4d96a49c92------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/6fd1b42e6d0a</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jon Gregory]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 23 Apr 2014 04:16:45 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2014-04-23T04:16:45.148Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Video games have a weird habit of doing something no other medium can, because they are interactive in a way previous mediums are not. They play with perspective, and how players interact with the worlds they explore. The result is stories told, or at least experienced, from multiple perspectives.</p><p>Popular trends in blockbuster-scale games have created a weird combination between every possible perspective. In some cases the first-person storytelling perspective of a player-controlled character narrating events pops up. Though outright first-person narration is rather rare, narration of thought by the thinker is a distinctly first-person characteristic and fairly common in third-person games. The third-person visual perspective also creates a flipped second-person interaction between the players and the actors they control. In the context of a game like “Uncharted,” the player is filling the role of something like a choice prompt in a choose-your-own-adventure novel — they are the narrator of actions telling Nathan Drake what he does next.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/258/1*KaqCB5TbipXZdeGef5R6Fg.png" /></figure><p>At the same time games’ objective systems — a favorite guiding tool of games aimed at a larger audience — play a second-person role for actor and player; in this case, the objectives are dictating the goals of the player and subsequently influencing the actions of Nate. The same storytelling perspective is present in the glowing ledges of “Uncharted,” which even more directly dictate what both the player and Nate do. Finally, the standard third-person storytelling perspective is present in cutscenes.</p><p>First-person games are no less guilty of mixing perspectives than their coattail-ridding counterparts. In games like “The Elder Scrolls” every objective is dictated to the player-controlled character, who is incapable of giving a first-person account, but then carried out in first-person through the direct actions of players. “Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare” gives players the first-person perspective of Soap McTavish, who simply acts as a vehicle for the third-person tale of Captain Price. In general, most noteworthy first-person games tell third-person stories. If the character being controlled is presented as the main character the story is usually lacking any of the introspection inherent in first-person storytelling — Soap never stops to tell players what he thinks about Price or the war he’s fighting, he’s just a camera with legs and a gun that insane people occasionally address as a human being.</p><p>So, what exactly prompted me sit back and pick apart the messy perspectives of my favorite medium? “Fire Emblem: Awakening.”</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/213/1*5NhkWuYh80wkaZLKVWvYuw.png" /></figure><p>Over the past week or so I’ve been picking away at “Fire Emblem,” which I bought with my 3DS but chose not to touch because it didn’t grab me immediately. I created my character Alessa, and she got hitched to Lon’qu as part of the marriage freight-train of a relationship system and I didn’t care; or rather, I didn’t care as much about Alessa and Lon’qu because there’s no way I could possibly mistake them for the main characters simply due to my creation of one and her relationship with the other. “Fire Emblem” is Chrom’s story, everything else is tangential and I’ve enjoyed the tale more for it.</p><p>The separation of gameplay and story, and the positioning of Chrom as the main character, prevent the perspective issues of most games from occurring. Since I’m never in direct control of Alessa, I’m never interfering with her independence as a character. She’s free to play a secondary role, while my only contribution is as the mysterious force of nature building her previously established tactical brilliance. With Chrom as the main character, even if I was given the option to make Alessa sound like a madwoman it wouldn’t matter because she is a spectator.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*z_9uCq7MrLVteoCTc2UQiA.jpeg" /></figure><p>My realization got me thinking about what I like in some of my other favorite games. I don’t give a damn about Commander Shepard, I care about Tali, Garrus and everyone else on the Normandy first. I don’t care about The Warden or Hawke, I care about Varric, Merrill and Leliana — and okay, maybe I cared a bit about Alistair even if it wasn’t enough to bother saving him. I don’t care about my “Fallout” or “Elder Scrolls” characters, I care about everyone they bump into. When I play a game I usually find myself caring about someone other than the main character when asked to take control of their actions; if I don’t find myself caring about someone other than the main character in that situation, I usually don’t finish the game.</p><p>As much as people like to talk down on ideas like ludonarrative dissonance, there are real issues with the way storytelling is handled in a lot of games. Almost exclusively those issues are created by putting players in the shoes of a story’s protagonist and then unleashing them on the world. Am I really supposed to believe my master assassin flung himself to death from a rooftop? Or that my highly trained soldier threw a grenade off a wall and killed himself? Maybe it’s secretly normal for the heroes of “Oblivion” to spend days of in-game time jumping off rocks to train their athleticism, who knows? The only time putting players in the shoes of a protagonist seems to work though, is when games like “Saints Row” embrace the inherent stupidity of trying to build a character that matches what players end up doing.</p><p>What I’d like to see is more big games taking a step back to write a really tight narrative about someone else. Let players be a random shoehorned-in soldier. Let players be just another guy, but write a great character for them to hang out with. Giving players a consistent person, who they can never change their perspective of, is the only way to improve what games are already doing. Pairing them with someone whose role is just as big should be the least any game does.</p><p>I’ve had enough of games trying to convince me that the gun-toting camera rigs I’m playing are the most important people around, despite only spouting a handful of lines over the course of an entire tale. I’ve also had enough of games trying to convince me that characters like Nathan Drake are anything other than the ruthless cypher for my test of hand-eye coordination. Players don’t need to be the baddest-badass in the galaxy all the time, sometimes playing second-fiddle to that person is more enjoyable.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=6fd1b42e6d0a" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>