<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Justin Smith on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Justin Smith on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@JustinusSmithus?source=rss-2049c41b82de------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Wed, 18 Nov 2026 12:21:10 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@JustinusSmithus/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Can the Senate Regain the Founders’ Vision?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@JustinusSmithus/can-the-senate-regain-the-founders-vision-6bf37cfc279?source=rss-2049c41b82de------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/6bf37cfc279</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[founders]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[united-states]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[reason]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[senate]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Justin Smith]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 14 Oct 2017 13:07:52 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-10-14T13:07:52.003Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Ygw2UImI0qwDIoK_X1UZzw.jpeg" /></figure><h4>There exists the pervasive national myth that our bicameral legislature houses two almost sacred chambers of reasoned debate in which are birthed the bills that are sent to the president to become law. However many times we, as children, had watched Schoolhouse Rock special on how bills become laws we ascribe the process to a sort of mystical treatment and, thus, oversimplify the process. It is, therefore, taken for granted that the two chambers of the legislature, that of the House and of the Senate, are supposed to be chambers of reasoned debate; more so in the Senate with the addition of arcane rules and procedures designed to engender an air of compromise.</h4><p>Throughout my adult life I have not witnessed much of the senatorial compromise that I had learned, from my public education, should exist. Any statement contending that the last ten years have seen in congress polarizing speeches, debates, and actions expressed by those on both sides of the political spectrum across every imaginable form of media, whether social or traditional, would, with great likelihood, have reached an almost unanimous consensus among the general population. I felt that I was a part of this consensus after witnessing the lack of expected compromise through speech, debate, or action from a body revered for its ability to painstakingly work through deeply entrenched differences to bring forth legislative action that it ensures is in the best interest of every citizen, the United States Senate.</p><p>I now feel as if the Senate has hope to function, once again, as it was meant to as described to the people of New York by Publius so long ago. This change was brought about by the exhortations of John McCain to his colleagues in the Senate on July 25th where he lamented the practice of legislating behind closed doors, the lack of willingness to compromise, and, also, the often harsh words that aids an unwillingness even to discuss policy differences that even he has admitted to uttering. He stated to the Senate, in that floor speech, that “Our founders envisioned the Senate as the more deliberative, careful body that operates at a greater distance than the other body from the public passions of the hour.” Is Senator John McCain trying to bring the modern Senate back to the chamber of reasoned debate and compromise that our Founders had envisioned?</p><blockquote><strong><em>“This place is important. The work we do is important. Our strange rules and seemingly eccentric practices that slow our proceedings and insist on our cooperation are important.” -Senator John McCain, July 25, 2017 Floor Speech</em></strong></blockquote><p>This is what Senator McCain stated in his floor speech on July 25th. His invocation of the founder’s spirit is supported by a source long held with the utmost respect regarding how our Constitution applies to the function of our federal government, the Federalist Papers. Just why should the Senate have any of the rules or practices that would slow any proceedings and insist on cooperation that Senator McCain alluded to? Publius, either Alexander Hamilton or James Madison, stated in Federalist №63 that “such an institution may be sometimes necessary as a defense to the people against their own temporary errors and delusions.”<strong> </strong>This sounds pretty insulting when taken apart from this next description of a political reality with which we are all too familiar in the highly polarized political environment we live in today:</p><blockquote><strong><em>“As the cool and deliberate sense of the community ought, in all governments, and actually will, in all free governments, ultimately prevail over the views of its rulers; so there are particular moments in public affairs when the people, stimulated by some irregular passion, or some illicit advantage, or misled by the artful misrepresentations of interested men, may call for measures which they themselves will afterwards be the most ready to lament and condemn. In these critical moments, how salutary will be the interference of some temperate and respectable body of citizens, in order to check the misguided career, and to suspend the blow meditated by the people against themselves, until reason, justice, and truth can regain their authority over the public mind?” -Federalist №63</em></strong></blockquote><p>Judging from the inference of the founders own statements, the following of arcane rules and practices that embody the “regular order” that Senator McCain has so often referred to when highly controversial issues come before the Senate are integral to the basic function of the Senate that the founders envisioned. If passions were to rule such a body that was meant to operate with “cool and deliberate sense” then the instability of such a body, from administration to administration, would engender very little confidence in the legislation that passes through its chamber. Publius, again either Alexander Hamilton or James Madison, embody this sentiment in the following passage from Federalist №62:</p><blockquote><strong><em>“What prudent merchant will hazard his fortunes in any new branch of commerce when he knows not but that his plans may be rendered unlawful before they can be executed? What farmer or manufacturer will lay himself out for the encouragement given to any particular cultivation or establishment, when he can have no assurance that his preparatory labors and advances will not render him a victim to an inconstant government? In a word, no great improvement or laudable enterprise can go forward which requires the auspices of a steady system of national policy.” -Federalist №62</em></strong></blockquote><p>Thus, the abandonment of Regular Order renders nearly any legislation that passes the Senate impotent because such an abandonment has caused a severe loss in confidence that such legislation that becomes law will retain any sense of permanence due to the inability of our Senators to compromise, to actually set aside their passions and deliberate. I firmly believe that the Senate needs to regain the confidence of the People by performing their roles as the founders envisioned. There is already a wing of congress designed to reflect the passions of the people, maybe if the Senate embodied the calm, reasoning, deliberative body envisioned by our Founders confidence in our government will finally be restored, along with a boost in Congress’ approval rating.</p><p><strong>Below are links to Senator McCain’s Floor Speech and the quoted Federalist Papers.</strong></p><p><a href="https://www.mccain.senate.gov/public/index.cfm/2017/7/mccain-on-senate-floor-today"><strong>https://www.mccain.senate.gov/public/index.cfm/2017/7/mccain-on-senate-floor-today</strong></a></p><p><a href="https://www.congress.gov/resources/display/content/The+Federalist+Papers#TheFederalistPapers-62"><strong>https://www.congress.gov/resources/display/content/The+Federalist+Papers#TheFederalistPapers-62</strong></a></p><p><a href="https://www.congress.gov/resources/display/content/The+Federalist+Papers#TheFederalistPapers-63"><strong>https://www.congress.gov/resources/display/content/The+Federalist+Papers#TheFederalistPapers-63</strong></a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=6bf37cfc279" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Christianity in Government]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@JustinusSmithus/christianity-in-government-dd37deb8b14c?source=rss-2049c41b82de------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/dd37deb8b14c</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[welfare-reform]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[justice]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[christianity]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[religion]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Justin Smith]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 11 Feb 2017 13:34:41 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-02-11T13:34:41.986Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>The Christian in today’s society often finds him/herself in a political environment that often seems hostile as it becomes, seemingly, more and more secular. It is important to understand that there exists a rather important link between Christianity and government that the Christian must be mindful of; that Christians must be able to understand that Christian concepts do have a place in the domestic and international political realms and that they know that there are Christian answers to the fundamental questions concerning these concepts and their place in political life.</p><p><strong><em>Do Christian concepts such as truth, morality, love, order, justice and sin have a place in the domestic political realm?</em></strong></p><p>Community is one of the most basic building blocks of a political society, for within it one finds the social ties that bind individuals together and it provides a focus towards which these individuals move together. Dietrich Bonhoeffer gave a few reasons why Christians are to help build community in the Church. One is to realize that we Christians are brought together into the Christian community through Jesus Christ alone, not in any other way, and that in this way is our brotherhood formed to where we can join together in Christian community. The other way to help build community in the Church is to realize that we must show brotherly love to other Christians, for we are all brothers and sisters in Christ. We must love each other here because we are going to all be together for eternity in the eternal Christian community when Christ comes again. What was most impactful to me was the community aspect of Brotherly Love. Considering the capacity of love that Christ had for dying on the cross for all of the brothers and sisters in Christ, it will help us all be able to sing praises and worshipping Christ throughout eternity.1</p><p>Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr. spent the greater part of his life striving for the equality of the black community through civil disobedience. His faith in this program rested upon the Christian concepts of truth, morality, love, order, justice, and sin in their ability to help us interpret human law by the standard of God’s law, in order that we might determine what laws man creates are just and what laws are not just. The way in which Dr. King defines the just and unjust laws is by comparing them to moral laws, or God’s Laws. There were several standards that he used by which to test a law as just or unjust. One such standard was whether or not the law applied equally to the majority that enacted the law and the minority that had no say in the making of the law. If the law applied equally to both then it was just if not, then it was unjust. Another standard tested whether or not the law lived up to the moral laws of God. For legalists, it was perfectly legal to obey the laws of the Nazis, but it was immoral to do so because of the immorality of their laws.2</p><p>Furthermore, Dr. King’s understanding of just law and the moral laws are not concepts new to Christianity, it is an understanding of what is right and wrong that is within all of mankind, for as the Apostle Paul states:</p><blockquote>“…the work of the law is written in their hearts, their conscience also bearing witness, and their thoughts the meanwhile accusing or else excusing one another.”3</blockquote><p>This law “written in their hearts” is Natural Law, an understanding of the moral laws of God that is instilled in each of us, as we are made in His image so are His laws our laws in our natural state. What Paul is saying here is that what is morally wrong and what is morally righteous is something that we inherently know and that we are bound so to the witness of our conscience that we cannot deny its internal proclamations. The understanding of these Natural Laws, which no man can deny, is the cornerstone of civil law. The understanding of God’s law that is imprinted in our mind and soul is what makes civil law binding to us. We know by these natural laws that we shouldn’t steal, we shouldn’t disobey our parents, and that we also shouldn’t murder, to name a few. The civil laws that protect a person’s life, liberty, property are based upon these inalienable rights, inalienable because they are of God, given to the the Jews upon tablets of stone but written upon the hearts of all Gentiles also by the very finger of God. Our current government is based upon the security of these Natural Laws of God that protect these Natural Rights of Man.</p><p>During the time in which he was leading this movement, Dr. King viewed the Church with disappointment during his time because they, with few isolated exceptions, did not live up to the expectations that he felt Christians Churches shouldn’t have had any problem fulfilling, concerning the application of basic Christian concepts in guiding the actions of the church during this civil rights movement. Many of the Churches in the South, most especially the White Church leadership, either admonished Dr. King’s civil disobedience because it disrupted the status quo, because they felt the defiance of the law was un-christian, or because some actually supported, through their silence, segregation by not speaking out against it. Dr. King listed many concerns for the Church, including that the Church was forgetting its early Christian roots in that Christians should be upholding the moral laws of God, at the risk of themselves, rather than uplifting the laws of man. He hoped that the church during his time would remember their early Christian heritage and remember their call in being followers of Christ.4</p><p>Carrying Dr. King’s views further concerning issues that we are dealing with today,with the issue of abortion cropping up in the news very frequently, Dr. King would still be concerned for the most part with the Church in its semi-reluctance to get off the sidelines with a few exceptions, including the Catholic Church. The fact that this is still an issue, the condoning of murder under the guise of a “convenient medical procedure,” is incredibly sad in that the Church, with its collective voice has not done more in opposition of the issue.5</p><p><strong><em>How about when it comes to international issues of war, peace, and security?</em></strong></p><p>A great and informative work on how the precepts of Christianity can inform our understanding of civil law and foreign policy is titled <em>War, Peace, and Christianity</em>, by J. Daryl Charles and Timothy J. Demy. In it the first important point made by the authors that impacted my understanding of the subject was that just-war moral reasoning has always existed as the basic moral knowledge propagated by natural law for as long as humans existed. The book states that “all people prior to the giving of the law on Mount Sinai knew it as well, including those who formalized the Hammurabi Code in the eighteenth century B.C.”5 This was impactful to me because this basic moral understanding provides common ground in understanding the basic civil law of any country in existence as these are based on the moral code inherent in Natural Law. The second impactful point made by the authors was that “Peace is <em>not</em> to be understood as the absence of conflict; it is rather the <em>fruit of by-product</em> of a justly ordered society.”6 This greatly impacted me because, as I formerly understood the lessons learned in my high school history class, there was always peace once the fighting ended. I lost sight of the fact that the conflict ended only once the peace treaty was concluded. These treaties that I so often neglected to notice where the instrument in which society was ordered justly so that peace might be attained because if peace was dependent upon the mere absence of conflict then will every society contain tensions that would, time and time again, tear it apart with conflict. Another impactful point made by the book was the author’s’ point that terrorists are fundamentally distinct from freedom fighters, as the oft quoted phrase “One person’s terrorists is another person’s freedom fighter.”7 This distinction is drawn in the book, which says that “it thereby show itself as a moral abomination through its total disregard for human dignity and personhood. Furthermore, it operates in defiance of legitimate authority by military organisms…that are neither governments…nor subject to governments.”8 The impact on my understanding was great, as I hear this phrase quoted a lot by others in an attempt to garner sympathy for these people by stating that they are just fighting for a cause they believe in, but the way that they do it is highly immoral and highly unjust.</p><p>It must be understood that it is morally just to intervene when genocide and human rights violations occur, as <em>War, Peace, and Christianity</em> states, that antipathy towards these actions will make the human community morally culpable at several levels. The only argument against this that I could possibly understand and agree with would be the West’s argument of ignorance. If a country is truly ignorant of a human rights violation or genocide, it is understandable for there to be inaction as one cannot act upon what one does not know about. The agreement, however, ceases to be valid once the knowledge is there; the claim to ignorance is an abdication of moral responsibility. I agree with the text wholeheartedly when it states that “not only are these unspeakable acts crimes that are committed by specific and direct perpetrators; they also implicate those people groups, societies, or communities that either sanction or tolerate and stand by as the crimes are being committed. Moreover, the implicate neighboring nations or people groups that might have the wherewithal to prevent them.”9</p><p>On the subject of humanitarian aid and military intervention, the only criteria necessary to be considered would be to determine whether either would be needed, based upon the precepts of just war theory, and the logistics of either action. In such a case, if we have the wherewithal to intervene, I believe we should we should. As for the pacifist’s argument against intervention, the Lord stated: “A new commandment I give unto you, That ye love one another; as I have loved you, that ye also love one another.”10 The pacifist might use this for the advocation of non-violence, but is it really loving others who are suffering from human rights violations or genocide to turn a blind eye and leave them to their death? I am always ready to defend and fight for the people that I love rather than to stand by and let them suffer, that same should be said of our reaction to this suffering of other nations or people groups.</p><p>An indirect result of the threat that terrorism places upon us Americans, a threat not felt much before 9/11, is that we are much more likely to accept what previously would have constituted an infringement upon our civil liberties in order to avert another terrorist attack. One such program is the encouragement by the federal and state governments to report any odd goings on as they could indicate a potential terrorist plot. The modern day premise that everyday people should serve as informants on each other is much reminiscent of a certain totalitarian state in which several characters I remember from 1984, were brainwashed to always report any anomalies, or abnormal behavior, in their fellow members. This also reminds me of the campaign initiated after the boston bombings that was designed to encourage anyone who sees anything suspicious to report that incident. How long will it take until the government suggests that things subversive to the agenda of the government be reported too. This happened in most every totalitarian state early in their regimes and it is just a step away from this protective policy we have taken to prevent terrorists from killing innocent civilians. There is a fine line there, we need people informing on others if it is in the interest of public safety, such as preventing terrorists from killing innocent civilians, but we also need to prevent the government using these people willing to inform on each other for uses that may infringe upon the rights of the people. One answer is to encourage a watchdog developed to keep an eye on the spheres of authority. We have that in the press and various civil liberty organizations whose mission is to act as a watchdog against a government overstepping its boundaries of power drawn by the Constitution.</p><p>According to the text, the Just-War Tradition does allow for the United States’ current “War on Terrorism.” The just war theory “has been utilized and developed over the centuries such that it can address any type of warfare. The United States’ “war on terror” “has been carried out as a deliberate response to the attacks of 9/11 and to a perceived threat of international terrorism that is ideologically rooted in militant Islamic jihadism. The fact that we have continued to sustain terrorist attacks, and also prevented many attacks, rooted in militant Islamic Jihadism says much in support of the War on Terror instigated by the U.S. Within the text is a question asked by Paul Ramsey: “Can counter-insurgency abide by the distinction between legitimate and illegitimate military objectives while insurgency deliberately does not?”11 This question on insurgency, according to the text, provides a corollary to question of terrorism and counter-terrorist operations. Furthermore, this corollary is important as “counter-insurgency has been recognized as a valid response, even though difficult, within the tradition.”12 As the text said: the response to terrorism is difficult, my concern is that we are not active enough in the war on terrorism when it comes to the threat of ISIS, we have the wherewithal to end their militant threat to both middle-eastern governments and the innocent civilian population. Their persecutions of Christians, Jews, and moderate Muslims warrants a more direct response from the U.S. than air-strikes alone. The same goes for other organizations of militant Islamic Jihadism whose views of Christians and Jews, and pretty much anyone that does not subscribe to their brand of Islam, are similar.</p><p><em>War, Peace, and Christianity</em> did not necessarily change my views so much as it helped me to understand further the actions that the United States had taken concerning wars I have read about in history class and lived through, as in the case of the war in Iraq. For example, as far as ISIS is concerned, given the violent nature of the threat and that they have threatened the U.S. with attacks, we should commit ourselves more to the conflict. I believe that we have just cause to enter deeper into the conflict both militarily and in a humanitarian fashion. Not only is ISIS a military threat to the United States, through their efforts to inspire domestic terrorists within the U.S. and their threats against our ally Israel, but also they are a humanitarian threat to all in their conquered territory who are not their brand of Muslim, either being of another sect, Christian, or connected to the West. Those who fit these categories are often beaten, tortured, raped, or executed. Facing this reality, we who have the wherewithal to contribute substantially more to the war effort have only offered air support in a conflict that is going to require an armed ground force, instead entrusting this very important task to local rebels rather than committing our own professionally trained soldiers to do what only their extensive training can accomplish. With troops on the ground, in addition to air support, we can win this conflict, following it up with an extended U.S. military presence in an effort to prevent another ISIS from becoming a threat again, unlike what we did when we pulled all U.S. Personnel out of Iraq not too long ago, creating the power vacuum that became the catalyst for this current conflict.13</p><p><strong><em>How have Western Christians answered these fundamental questions about religion and political life?</em></strong></p><p>Roger Williams, founder of the state of Rhode Island, wrote two documents, The Bloody Tenent of Persecution and his Letter to the Town of Providence, that were fundamental to an early understanding of the concept of a separation between the Church and the state. He uses both of the works, selected, to advance the idea of separation of church and state. First, in the Bloody Tenent of Persecution, Williams speaks of the religious authority and the civil authority being held, not together, but each by a separate bodies, with neither holding any sort of overlapping power over the other body’s authority. This is to ensure that the civil authority would not interfere with the free exercise of religion, and that the religious authority would not dictate the functions of the state. This is to ensure both political and religious freedom.14</p><p>This narrative is further continued by Roger Williams’ Letter to the Town of Providence. In this, Roger Williams likens government to a ship of sea, thus the old adage of a ‘ship of state’ in action. The passengers on board are all of different religious persuasions, and are thus likened to the citizens of a city, while the Captain and crew are considered the Civil authority and the enforcers of that authority, respectively. Roger williams continues the letter by stating that just as a ship captain must deftly steer the ship on the best course, so must the civil authority of ‘ship of state’ govern in a way that benefits all constituents. The captain must not interfere with the right of each passenger to pray or practice their own religion, but should these passenger’s infringe upon the right of the others to practice their religion, then must the civil authority step in enforce their individual rights and interfere with their persecutions.15</p><p>Marvin Olasky, in his The Tragedy of American Compassion, brought to the forefront the issue of Christian love and compassion in the context of the Great Society social welfare programs that came about during the 1960’s through to today’s Entitlement Programs. I believe that the current state of American Compassion can be summarized by hugely bloated forms of the Great Society programs that exist in what is known today as Entitlement Programs. The views expressed in Olasky’s book line up with my own views, especially in the the line: “schools for all and work for all.”16 The problem with many Entitlement Programs are that many people today believe that it is their right to be provided food, housing, healthcare, and even cell phones without feeling the need to change their situation to where they do not need these services provided to them. I was in the grocery store the other day, listening to a store salesperson offering store-sponsored credit cards as a way to build credit while also saving on groceries, I remember one person in particular respond to her offer by stating: “I don’t need credit, I got free food stamps,” this being said with an air of pride. I was floored listening to this, I have always thought of these programs as a bridge between a bad situation and a better future, or a hand up. Instead many people see these as nothing more than a handout. In my view, I can honestly say that our society has gone further towards allowing many to expect the government to take care of their every want and need, from cradle to grave. Food, raiment, housing, healthcare, and even cell phones are subsidized by the government with very little oversight as to how many of the “entitled” are still in these programs. We need to get back in the mentality that these services come with the condition that those who need them must work their way out of needing them.17</p><p>This is not to say that our society must pick and choose who needs help and who does not, a core component of Social Darwinism. Social Darwinism, in its most basic form, is the application of the Evolutionist mantra, “survival of the fittest”, to to the societal forms of gender, wealth, class, race, and age. The premise of this theory is that government or charitable aid should not be given to the weaker groups on the spectrum of these societal forms as they are burdening society as a whole by their very existence. The principal supporters that I found for Social Darwinism are Francis Galton, Herbert Mathus, and Simon Newcomb. The result of this movement was that proponents founded charities that operated on the notion that only certain people deserved help and classified those who needed help as either deserving or undeserving. Problems that many Christians found with this was that there was no compassion for the needy and the fact that many of these new charities were pointedly secular. I find myself more closely aligning my views of compassion with that of the Christians that, as Jesus said:</p><blockquote>“Give to him that asketh thee, and from him that would borrow of thee turn not thou away.”18</blockquote><p>In my opinion, we need to show compassion when dealing with those in need, but we also need to carefully figure just how we can best help those in need. The social Darwinist idea of these groups being a burden on society has in it a practical argument when we dismiss the idea of leaving these groups to fend for themselves and die. I believe that we need to help those in need, these elements of society that Social Darwinists want to exclude from their charities, in a way that helps them out of their situation that got them in a state of needfulness in the first place. This approach can be summed up in the idea of giving these groups a “Hand-Up, instead of a Hand-Out.” This provides a more practical approach when considering the best way to help those in need without excluding anyone.19 This also was the approach taken by the Apostle Paul, and his fellow Apostles, which can be found in Second Thessalonians, 3:10–15:</p><blockquote>“10 For even when we were with you, this we commanded you, that if any would not work, neither should he eat. 11 For we hear that there are some which walk among you disorderly, working not at all, but are busybodies. 12 Now them that are such we command and exhort by our Lord Jesus Christ, that with quietness they work, and eat their own bread. 13 But ye, brethren, be not weary in well doing. 14 And if any man obey not our word by this epistle, note that man, and have no company with him, that he may be ashamed. 15 Yet count him not as an enemy, but admonish him as a brother.”</blockquote><p>Reinhold Niebuhr’s contribution to Christian political thought provided us a window with which to view the morality of differing political systems by looking at the end goals and the means to achieve these goals in the differing political systems. His views concentrate on two distinct groups, the children of light and the children of darkness. In the children of light, Niebuhr gives to them the characteristic of an excessively optimistic view regarding the nature of man, this optimism pertaining to the idea that through use of reason and morality, and the forward marching of progress man will be able to overcome the natural instinct to act for himself and come to regard the interest of the greater good, the interest of collective humankind. In contrasting the children of light, Niebuhr gives to the children of darkness the characteristic of the ruthless pursuit of self interest, regardless of natural or moral law. The example of this shown in Dean Patterson’s <em>Christianity and Power Politics</em> is of Neville Chamberlain as the Child of Light, believing that through reason and morality Hitler could be negotiated with to end his ruthless conquest, while Hitler, the example of the Child of Dark, was willing to go to any means, subvert or overt, to achieve his goals.20</p><h3>Conclusion</h3><p>While these two examples were promoted as the extremes of his light/dark theory, Niebuhr advocated democracy as being the balance of these two distinctly different ideals. He treated the democracy of the United States in particular as needing role in leading the international community in order to combat against international threats from those in the realm of darkness, while recognizing that we are not the children of light, we have our own failures, we are not perfect. I find myself agreeing with this Christian Realism, because as Christians living in this world, we must deal with the world while not being of the world. In a democracy we can be the leader representing the best of the light while still having the ability to successfully combat the Children of Darkness. There can be no compromise with them, so I believe that this is the only way on this earth.</p><p>After studying diligently in this course, I conclude that truth, morality, love, order, justice, and sin have a place in the domestic political realm. I believe that these concepts are fundamental to the domestic political realm because they are fundamental to life as we know it in general. Each of these concepts are present in the everyday interactions between individuals and groups in society, providing the basic framework in which we interact everyday. Given this, to believe that these concepts have a place in the domestic political realm, the arena in which individuals and groups in society interact to determine how they will be governed, is easy to understand because these concepts are necessary for existence of our domestic political realm. Without these concepts there would be no way for individuals and groups to interact with each other.</p><p>When it comes to international issues of war, peace, and security I must reiterate that these Christian concepts apply to interactions between different countries as it applies also between individuals and between groups in society within and individual nation. These concepts govern the actions that take place between these countries in regards to war, peace, and security. It is understood that if a country is found to be in violation of these Christian concepts, the international relationship between that country and others would be in danger of falling out of a peaceful relationship, thus providing a concern for the security of the individual nations because of the violating nation. In this state of affairs, war may easily ensue. Just as the Christian concepts of truth, morality, love, order, justice, and sin govern the relationships between individuals and groups and their government, so also do they govern the relationships between nations.</p><p>Through the centuries since Christ’s death and resurrection, a long succession of Western Christians, from Augustine to John Locke to William Rogers to Dr. Martin Luther King, jr., have striven to answer these fundamental question about religion and political life. Augustine’s concept of the cities of man and God provided us the concept that earthly government should use the city of God as its guiding light in its goals and policies. John Locke’s concept of natural law being created by God, written on our hearts by Him, and applicable to everyone by Him provided one of the building blocks of our American Government. William Rogers’ works on the separation of Church and State provided an environment in which individual belief and the Church as a whole would not be constrained by the will of the government. Dr. Martin Luther King, jr.’s civil rights movement strove to hold the laws of man up to the standard of the moral laws of God and that it is by this standard that we can determine the justness of man-made law.</p><h3>Endnotes</h3><ol><li>King, Martin Luther. A Letter from a Birmingham Jail. Andover, MA: 1968.</li><li>King, Martin Luther. A Letter from a Birmingham Jail. Andover, MA: 1968.</li><li>Romans 2:15, KJV</li><li>King, Martin Luther. A Letter from a Birmingham Jail. Andover, MA: 1968.</li><li>Charles, J. Daryl, and Timothy J. Demy. War, Peace, and Christianity: Questions and Answers from a Just-war Perspective. Wheaton, IL: Crossway Books, 2010. Pg. 35</li><li>Charles, J. Daryl, and Timothy J. Demy. War, Peace, and Christianity: Questions and Answers from a Just-war Perspective. Wheaton, IL: Crossway Books, 2010. Pg. 159</li><li>Charles, J. Daryl, and Timothy J. Demy. War, Peace, and Christianity: Questions and Answers from a Just-war Perspective. Wheaton, IL: Crossway Books, 2010. Pg. 228</li><li>Charles, J. Daryl, and Timothy J. Demy. War, Peace, and Christianity: Questions and Answers from a Just-war Perspective. Wheaton, IL: Crossway Books, 2010. Pg. 229</li><li>Charles, J. Daryl, and Timothy J. Demy. War, Peace, and Christianity: Questions and Answers from a Just-war Perspective. Wheaton, IL: Crossway Books, 2010. Pg. 188</li><li>John 13:34 KJV</li><li>Charles, J. Daryl, and Timothy J. Demy. War, Peace, and Christianity: Questions and Answers from a Just-war Perspective. Wheaton, IL: Crossway Books, 2010. Pg. 212</li><li>Charles, J. Daryl, and Timothy J. Demy. War, Peace, and Christianity: Questions and Answers from a Just-war Perspective. Wheaton, IL: Crossway Books, 2010. Pg. 212</li><li>Charles, J. Daryl, and Timothy J. Demy. War, Peace, and Christianity: Questions and Answers from a Just-war Perspective. Wheaton, IL: Crossway Books, 2010. Pgs. 211–12</li><li>WILLIAMS, Roger, and Samuel Lunt. CALDWELL. The Bloudy Tenant of Persecution. Edited by S. L. Caldwell. 1867.</li><li>“Letter to the Town of Providence.” Homestead. January 1, 1655. Accessed December 6, 2014. <a href="http://corematerials.homestead.com/13_letter_to_the_town_of_providence.pdf.">http://corematerials.homestead.com/13_letter_to_the_town_of_providence.pdf.</a></li><li>Olasky, Marvin N. The Tragedy of American Compassion. Washington, D.C.: Regnery Gateway, 1992.</li><li>Olasky, Marvin N. The Tragedy of American Compassion. Washington, D.C.: Regnery Gateway, 1992.</li><li>Matthew 5:42 KJV</li><li>Leonard, Thomas C. “Origins of the Myth of Social Darwinism: The Ambiguous Legacy of Richard Hofstadter’s Social Darwinism in American Thought.” Princeton. November 8, 2007. Accessed December 6, 2014. <a href="http://www.princeton.edu/~tleonard/papers/myth.pdf.">http://www.princeton.edu/~tleonard/papers/myth.pdf.</a></li><li>Patterson, Eric. Christianity and Power Politics Today: Christian Realism and Contemporary Political Dilemmas. New York: Palgrave Macmillan, 2008.</li></ol><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=dd37deb8b14c" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Freedom of Religion, not “From”]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@JustinusSmithus/freedom-of-religion-not-from-3f9ac674e0af?source=rss-2049c41b82de------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/3f9ac674e0af</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[history]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[religious-freedom]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[government]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[supreme-court]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Justin Smith]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 02 Feb 2017 03:19:41 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-02-03T03:48:08.384Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<blockquote>“Believing with you that religion is a matter which lies solely between Man &amp; his God, that he owes account to none other for his faith or his worship, that the legitimate powers of government reach actions only, &amp; not opinions, I contemplate with sovereign reverence that act of the whole American people which declared that their legislature should “make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof,” thus building a wall of separation between Church &amp; State. Adhering to this expression of the supreme will of the nation in behalf of the rights of conscience, I shall see with sincere satisfaction the progress of those sentiments which tend to restore to man all his natural rights, convinced he has no natural right in opposition to his social duties.</blockquote><blockquote>— Thomas Jefferson, from Letter to the Danbury Baptists</blockquote><p>The phrase “wall of separation”, first coined by Thomas Jefferson, has been used to contort the meaning of the first amendment to disastrous consequences for our freedom of religious expression. I will to show, here, the original intent in Mr. Jefferson’s use of that phrase in his letter to the Danbury Baptists and shall explore the effect of its misuse on Establishment Clause jurisprudence through the number of Supreme Court cases this phrase has been used in, in addition to other contemporary research into the topic.</p><p>Mr. Jefferson’s use of the oft quoted phrase “a wall of separation between Church &amp; State” in his Letter to the Danbury Baptists soon after his inauguration has had a large impact upon Religious Establishment jurisprudence in the time since that letter was first penned. Whether or not the impact has been a negative one depends upon the view those who interpret Mr. Jefferson’s meaning when he wrote the letter. Professor Daniel Dreisbach, of New York University, asserts that the common interpretation of the phrase, that this “wall” is erected between religion and all civil government, is incorrect. The correct interpretation, according to the professor, is one in which it is the national government that is to be subject to separation from religion, and vice versa; the phrase, he asserts, does not imply a separation between state and local government and religion. In this vein, he asks the question: “How can one reconcile Jefferson’s record on religious proclamations in Virginia with the position he took in the Danbury letter?”1</p><p>Douglas G. Smith, in Thomas Jefferson’s Retrospective on the Establishment Clause, asserts that, “according to Dreisbach, Jefferson was merely attempting to convey his view that there was a wall of separation between the federal,”2 between the national government and the state and local government’s. Whereas in his letter to the Danbury Baptists Mr. Jefferson was explained why, according to the First Amendment, he had proclaimed any days of Thanksgiving or prayer as President of the United States he had, upon attaining elected positions in the General Assembly and the Governorship of Virginia, no qualms about proposing bills for days of prayer and Thanksgiving while in the Assembly nor signing such bill as Governor, even after penning his draft of the Virginia Statute for Religious Freedom.3 The significance of this timing shows that Mr. Jefferson believed when he wrote that letter that, after advocating in his Statute what many recognize as the foundational idea of a separation between church and state, “he believed, as a matter of federalism, that the national government had no jurisdiction in religious matters, whereas state governments were authorized to accommodate and even prescribe religious exercises.”4</p><p>. This phrase was not incorporated into establishment clause jurisprudence until 1878, when the Supreme Court heard the case of Reynolds v. United States. Mr. Chief Justice Waite, in his opinion, quotes the portion of Mr. Jefferson’s Letter after pointing out that he was not a member of the Constitutional Convention, being a minister in France at the time of both the convention and the ratification of the Constitution. Though recognizing that, though Mr. Jefferson played no personal part in the drafting of the constitution nor the original debates on the wording of the first ten amendments, Mr. Chief Justice Waite still incorporated another part of the famous Letter5 to argue the point that the United States could not argue the dictates of Conscience, it could regulate man’s religious actions so far as they are “in opposition to his social duties”6</p><p>The phrase famously appeared once again in the Supreme Court Case Everson v. Board of Education (1947). In this case, Justice Hugo Black delivered the opinion of the court where he substantially expanded the importance of the “wall” metaphor by, not only incorporating it as a doctrinal metaphor7 but also subscribing its application to the states through the Fourteenth Amendment, stating that “neither a state nor the Federal Government can set up a Church.”8 Not only was the metaphor incorrectly applied, as Jefferson’s meaning behind the metaphor had already been explained by his political actions and private correspondence to others as applying only to the national government’s establishment of religion, but Justice Black’s statement is totally ignorant of the fact that the States instituted legal religious establishments decades after the ratification of the Constitution.9</p><p>Mr. Chief Justice Warren delivered in his opinion over two decades later, in Flast v. Cohen (1968), a revival of the original intent of the first amendment by pointing out that “the Establishment Clause was designed as a specific bulwark against such potential abuses of governmental power, and that clause of the First Amendment [Footnote 25] operates as a specific constitutional limitation upon the exercise by Congress of the taxing and spending power conferred by Art. I, § 8.”10. Several years later, in Lemon v. Kurtzman (1971), the “wall” phrase is seen as inspiration for a legal test, known as the lemon test. This judicial test in Establishment Clause jurisprudence was designed to determine whether government actions constituted excessive religious entanglement. This being impermissible the court gave the test three prongs: The court must “examine the character and purposes of the institutions that are benefited, the nature of the aid that the State provides, and the resulting relationship between the government and the religious authority.”11 This test was to provide a way for the “wall” to remain impregnable.</p><p>The doctrine in question, the Lemon Test, being based upon the phrase “a wall of separation between church and state”, that is attributed to Thomas Jefferson in his Letter to the Danbury Baptists, is what has supported this separation doctrine since, as noted earlier, Reynolds v. United States (1879). Justice Rehnquist contends, based upon historical evidence surrounding Jefferson’s letter and the Amendments Debates in the First Congress, that the separation phrased coined by Jefferson in his letter does not accurately represent the intent behind the first amendment’s Religion Clauses regarding Religious Establishment and Free Exercise. Justice Rehnquist states that: “James Madison was undoubtedly the most important architect among the Members of the House of the Amendments which became the Bill of Rights, but it was James Madison speaking as an advocate of sensible legislative compromise, not as an advocate of incorporating the Virginia Statute of Religious Liberty into the United States Constitution. During the ratification debate in the Virginia Convention, Madison had actually opposed the idea of any Bill of Rights.”12 He states this in order to minimize the importance of Jefferson, and his letter, in their interpretive role of the Religion Clauses of the First Amendment. Justice Rehnquist further mentions the subject of Mr. Jefferson’s separation from the Constitutional Convention and the Amendment Debates in the First Congress.13</p><p>With the importance of James Madison’s contributions to the Bill of Rights established over Mr. Jefferson, Rehnquist cites records of the First Congress, which was responsible for forming the language of what would be our Bill of Rights. In this debate particular focus is placed upon the evolution of the wording of the clauses that became the Religion Clauses of the First Amendment, particularly Madison’s role in its evolution.14</p><p>This phrase written by Mr. Thomas Jefferson, “a wall of separation between Church &amp; State”, has consistently been used to contort the meaning of the first amendment to disastrous consequences for our freedom of religious expression. The historical evidence showing the connection between the phrase and Mr. Jefferson’s intent that it is for the national government to be separate from church establishment has been recognized by legal historians as well as some justices on the Supreme Court. Yet, the mistaken interpretation of this phrase by early Supreme Court Justices, have affected subsequent Establishment Clause jurisprudence in such a way as to continue to give this mistaken interpretation of Mr. Jefferson’s doctrinal metaphor seemingly the status of law, as many American citizens today are more likely to know this phrase, written 14 years after the First Amendment, than the Religious Clause of the First Amendment itself. It is to be hoped that further historical, legal inquiry into Mr. Jefferson’s famous metaphor will do much to correct this gross misunderstanding.</p><p>Endnotes</p><p>1 Daniel Dreisbach, Thomas Jefferson and the wall of separation between church and state. pg 58</p><p>2 Dreisbach claims that “[a] careful review of Jefferson’s actions throughout his public career suggests that he believed, as a matter of federalism, that the national government had no jurisdiction in religious matters, whereas state governments were authorized to accommodate and even prescribe religious exercises.”( n20 ) Accordingly, through both words and deeds Jefferson seemed to recognize that the state governments could properly have some role in religious matters.” (Douglas Smith, Thomas Jefferson’s retrospective on the establishment clause. pg. 6)</p><p>3 “Jefferson voiced similar notions in March, 1805, in his Second Inaugural Address: ‘In matters of religion, I have considered that its free exercise is placed by the constitution independent of the powers of the general [federal] government. I have therefore undertaken, on no occasion, to prescribe the religious exercises suited to it; but have left them, as the constitution found them, under the direction and discipline of state or church authorities acknowledged by the several religious societies.’” Joseph Hemmer jr, Jefferson’s “Wall of Separation”: How Jurisprudential Interpretation Shaped a Secular Polity. pg. 29</p><p>4 “The “wall” metaphor was not offered as a general pronouncement on the prudential relationship between religion and all civil government; rather, it was, more specifically, a statement delineating the legitimate constitutional jurisdictions of the federal and state governments on matters pertaining to religion. It arguably had less to do with the separation between church and all civil government than with the separation between the federal and state governments. Jefferson’s “wall,” strictly speaking, was gloss on the First Amendment. As a figurative device to illuminate the First Amendment, the “wall” cannot,as a constitutional construct, exceed the scope and function of the First Amendment.” Daniel Dreisbach, Thomas Jefferson and the wall of separation between church and state. pg 59</p><p>5. “Adhering to this expression of the supreme will of the nation in behalf of the rights of conscience, I shall see with sincere satisfaction the progress of those sentiments which tend to restore man to all his natural rights, convinced he has no natural right in opposition to his social duties.” Reynolds v. United States, pg. 164</p><p>6. “Coming as this does from an acknowledged leader of the advocates of the measure, it may be accepted almost as an authoritative declaration of the scope and effect of the amendment thus secured. Congress was deprived of all legislative power over mere opinion, but was left free to reach actions which were in violation of social duties or subversive of good order.” Ibid</p><p>7. “The potential problem with doctrinal metaphors is that they can reduce a complex concept, like church-state relations, to a metaphor, and metaphor is not capable of capturing all the nuances, complexities, and dimensions of the original concept. “ This is one common criticism about the “wall of separation” metaphor. The United States Supreme Court admitted, “Candor compels acknowledgment, moreover, that we can only dimly perceive the lines of demarcation in this extraordinarily sensitive area of constitutional law.”” Julie Oseid, The Power of Metaphor: Thomas Jefferson’s Wall of Separation between Church &amp; State. pg. 123</p><p>8. “The “establishment of religion” clause of the First Amendment means at least this: neither a state nor the Federal Government can set up a church. Neither can pass laws which aid one religion, aid all religions, or prefer one religion over another. Neither can force nor influence a person to go to or to remain away from church against his will or force him to profess a belief or disbelief in any religion. No person can be punished for entertaining [p16] or professing religious beliefs or disbeliefs, for church attendance or non-attendance. No tax in any amount, large or small, can be levied to support any religious activities or institutions, whatever they may be called, or whatever form they may adopt to teach or practice religion. Neither a state nor the Federal Government can, openly or secretly, participate in the affairs of any religious organizations or groups, and vice versa. In the words of Jefferson, the clause against establishment of religion by law was intended to erect “a wall of separation between church and State.” Reynolds v. United States, supra, at 164.” Everson v. Board of Education, pg. 16</p><p>9. “Specifically addressing religious liberty in the Constitution, the Supreme Court ruled unanimously, in Permoli v. Municipality (1845), that ‘[t]he Constitution makes no provision for protecting the citizens of the respective States in their religious liberties; this is left to the state constitutions and laws: nor is there any inhibition imposed by the Constitution of the United States in this respect on the states.’34 Justice Joseph Story concurred, in his authoritative Commentaries on the Constitution of the United States (1833). The purpose of the First Amendment, he wrote, was ‘to exclude from the national government all power to act upon the subject [of religion].”35 He further opined that “the whole power over the subject of religion is left exclusively to the state governments, to be acted upon according to their own sense of justice, and the state constitutions.’” Daniel Dreisbach, Thomas Jefferson and the wall of separation between church and state. pg. 62</p><p>10. ““James Madison, who is generally recognized as the leading architect of the religion clauses of the First Amendment, observed in his famous Memorial and Remonstrance Against Religious Assessments that “the same authority which can force a citizen to contribute three pence only of his property for the support of any one establishment may force him to conform to any other establishment in all cases whatsoever.” The concern of Madison and his supporters was quite clearly that religious liberty ultimately would be the victim if government could employ its taxing and spending powers to aid one religion over another or to aid religion in general. [Footnote 24] The Establishment Clause was designed as a specific bulwark against such potential abuses of governmental power, and that clause of the First Amendment [Footnote 25] operates as a specific constitutional limitation upon the exercise by Congress of the taxing and spending power conferred by Art. I, § 8.” Flast v. Cohen, pg 103–104</p><p>11. “In order to determine whether the government entanglement with religion is excessive, we must examine the character and purposes of the institutions that are benefited, the nature of the aid that the State provides, and the resulting relationship between the government and the religious authority. MR. JUSTICE HARLAN, in a separate opinion in Walz, supra, echoed the classic warning as to “programs, whose very nature is apt to entangle the state in details of administration. . . .” Id. at 397 U. S. 695. Here we find that both statutes foster an impermissible degree of entanglement.” Lemon v. Kurtzman, pg 615</p><p>12. Wallace v. Jaffree, 472 U.S.97–98</p><p>13. “Thomas Jefferson was, of course, in France at the time the constitutional Amendments known as the Bill of Rights were passed by Congress and ratified by the States. His letter to the Danbury Baptist Association was a short note of courtesy, written 14 years after the Amendments were passed by Congress. He would seem to any detached observer as a less than ideal source of contemporary history as to the meaning of the Religion Clauses of the First Amendment.”ibid, pg. 92</p><p>14. “His original language “nor shall any national religion be established” obviously does not conform to the “wall of separation” between church and State idea which latter-day commentators have ascribed to him. His explanation on the floor of the meaning of his language — “that Congress should not establish a religion, and enforce the legal observation of it by law” — is of the same ilk. When he replied to Huntington in the debate over the proposal which came from the Select Committee of the House, he urged that the language “no religion shall be established by law” should be amended by inserting the word “national” in front of the word “religion.” It seems indisputable from these glimpses of Madison’s thinking, as reflected by actions on the floor of the House in 1789, that he saw the Amendment as designed to prohibit the establishment of a national religion, and perhaps to prevent discrimination among sects. He did not see it as requiring neutrality on the part of government between religion and irreligion. Thus the Court’s opinion in Everson — while correct in bracketing Madison and Jefferson together in their exertions in their home State leading to the enactment of the Virginia Statute of Religious Liberty — is totally incorrect in suggesting that Madison carried these views onto the floor of the United States House of Representatives when he proposed the language which would ultimately become the Bill of Rights.” ibid. pgs. 98–99</p><p><strong>Bibliography</strong></p><p>Dreisbach, Daniel. Thomas Jefferson and the wall of separation between church and state. NYU Press, 2002.</p><p>Everson v. Board of Education, 330 U.S. 1 (1947)</p><p>Flast v. Cohen, 392 U.S. 83 (1968)</p><p>Hemmer Jr, Joseph J. “Jefferson’s “Wall of Separation”: How Jurisprudential Interpretation Shaped a Secular Polity.” Free Speech Yearbook 44, no. 1 (2009): 27–39.</p><p>Lemon v. Kurtzman, 403 U.S. 602 (1971)</p><p>Jefferson, Thomas. “Jefferson’s letter to the Danbury Baptists.” In Library of Congress. 1802.</p><p>Oseid, Julie A. “Power of Metaphor: Thomas Jefferson’s Wall of Separation between Church &amp; State, The.” J. Ass’n Legal Writing Directors 7 (2010): 123.</p><p>Smith, Douglas G. “Thomas Jefferson’s retrospective on the establishment clause.”Harvard Journal of Law and Public Policy 25 (2003): 369.</p><p>Wallace v. Jaffree, 472 U.S. 38</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=3f9ac674e0af" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Why Tax the Rich?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@JustinusSmithus/why-tax-the-rich-f6e8a75e98fb?source=rss-2049c41b82de------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/f6e8a75e98fb</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[inequality]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[economics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[government]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[history]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Justin Smith]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 01 Feb 2017 03:02:42 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-02-01T03:03:27.762Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>There is a much asked question in this country on whether or not it would be beneficial to the U.S. economy to increase taxes on the high incomes. The two sides to the issue speak of the vast number of programs that could benefit those in poverty, as well as the great number of improvements to our nation’s infrastructure that could be made, if we were to increase taxes on the wealthy. Also much heard is the argument that to increase taxes on the wealthy would serve to stagnate investment in key industries that would serve to seriously, negatively, affect the U.S. Economy. This issue needs to be explored so as to gain a better understanding as to the consequences of either action and also their benefits by looking at some of the reasons for questions of taxing the rich exists as well as some of the relationships between taxes on the rich, the various socio-economic classes, and the government that would implement such taxes.</p><p><strong>Why are the rich perceived as needing to be taxed more now?</strong></p><p>In recent time, “the past thirty years,” attitudes regarding the topic of economic inequality, regarding “political and social consequences” of it, have been the subject of much discussion and argument. Defined as unequal dispersion of income, the amount of income, in the United States, has decreased in flow towards “families in the bottom 40 percent of the income distribution from about 17.4 to 13.9 percent between the years 1973 and 2001. Between 1970 and 1998, however, the income earned by the top 1 percent has quadrupled.1 These figures just mentioned outline the great concern, mainly voiced by those not contained within the top one percent of income earners, with the rising inequality in income distribution.</p><p>While the disparity between the incomes of the richest and the poorest in today’s political debates has not been the first time most Americans today have encountered the subject as many young, and even not so young, Americans have been inundated with classic rags to riches animated Disney stories such as Robin Hood and Cinderella. Despite this nearly subconscious education in income inequality for many young Americans within the last century, the United States has been relatively lax in “mitigating income inequality through government action,” when compared to the actions of European governments in this arena.2 Why have Americans supported, or at least showed no great concern about, income inequality in the last century?</p><blockquote>“One common hypothesis is that they do so because they embrace an American ideology of opportunity in which economic inequality is natural and unobjectionable. Samuelson’s explanation for the fact that we are not ‘demonstrating in the streets’ is that, ‘On the whole, Americans care less about inequality — the precise gap between the rich and the poor — than about opportunity and achievement: are people getting ahead?’”3</blockquote><p>Despite the general support of, or at least apathy on, the growing gap between the highest income earners and the lowest by Americans mentioned earlier, there has been a proven connection between the growth of poverty in the United States and this growing gap between the highest and the lowest income earners here in this country. It has been shown that:</p><blockquote>“if the proportion of the income received by the rich increases, poverty is more than likely to increase as well. Honohan (2004), in fact, finds a positive relationship between the income share of the highest 10 per cent of the population and the share of the population living below the poverty line, controlling for the mean income of the lowest 90 per cent of the population.”4</blockquote><p><strong>How Have the Rich Been Taxed?</strong></p><p>Due to the increased amount of literature, and probably because of increased news coverage on the subject, the narrative of why there is such a large gap between the richest and the poorest has changed into a narrative on how to make income earning more equitable, or how to reduce this income gap discussed thus far. One of the most used methods of reducing this income disparity is the government action of taxation. Within the broad realm of taxation, one particular kind of tax has been associated with income equity the longest, the progressive tax.</p><p>It has been assumed that concerns with income inequality, at least as having the people require some action of the government, first surfaced when the United States was faced with the need for mass mobilization of an army for Word War I in Europe. What made this case unique was that, for the first time in United States history, conscription on such a massive scale was required for battle on foreign soil. It has been show that, despite the implementation of universal conscription in the United States in mobilizing for WWI, there was not an equitable distribution among socioeconomic classes among those conscripted for military service, or at least among those conscripted for the most dangerous duties.5. Also prominent among the many arguments made by the conscripted was that, despite military service, “individuals with invested wealth have possibilities to earn financial profits out of a war because of increased demand for certain goods and services,”6 leading to idea that this “income is thought to be gained as a result of the sacrifices of others.”7 It is with this in mind that Kenneth Scheve and David Stasavage argue that:</p><blockquote>“Thus, mobilization for mass warfare, with and without conscription, creates a situation in which governments are asking tremendous sacrifices on the part of some of their citizens, while others not only benefit from those sacrifices but actually gain financially from the war. Fairness concerns are central to all debates about taxation and war mobilization only accentuates these considerations, increasing demands for progressive taxation so that the sacrifices in the war effort are more evenly distributed throughout society.”8</blockquote><p>The progressive tax, central to the argument previously posted, was called for, with great support, by those who were at the center of the war effort. This was mainly due to those sacrificing their lives, the conscripted, seeing the individuals and business concerns poised to profit greatly from the war as on the edge of the conflict. This inequality of income was seen, by those conscripted, as the coinciding with an inequality of sacrifice for the first time in modern warfare. This perception led to a greater demand for the greater progressivity of the tax system in place, placing the burden of financing the war, and later paying off the war debt, on the rich by increasing their tax burden, relative to those who earn lower incomes, to pay these debts at the same time that the burden of fighting the war falls mainly on those within the lower socioeconomic classes. 9</p><p><strong>How do the rich respond to being taxed more?</strong></p><p>In the quest to find out why there is a perception that the rich need to be taxed more and how this perception came about, the next question that needs asking is one of how do the rich respond to having a larger share of the tax burden placed upon them relative to the other socioeconomic classes. The news is regularly inundated with stories of tax-havens and other tax law loopholes used by the rich in order to avoid having a large percentage of their annual income taken to constitute a large percentage of the federal revenue. Do increases in taxes on the rich increase the likelihood that they will use some of these mentioned methods to decrease their own tax burden? In what way will a tax increase actually decrease the amount of tax revenues received from the rich?</p><p>In one attempt to answer these question, it has been suggested by Austan Goolsbee that:</p><blockquote>“almost all of the estimated responsiveness of taxable wage and salary income to marginal rates from 1991 to 1995 was the result of shifts in the timing of compensation, in the spirit of Slemrod (1995), not permanent shifts in the form of compensation.” What this means is that the wealthiest executives tend not to convert their compensation to nontaxable forms in order to avoid it being taxed altogether. Instead, this means that the wealthiest executives are changing the timing of their existing forms of compensation so that they may be affected by a lower tax rate in anticipation to a future tax increase. This is accomplished by cashing in certain types of stock options that result in the income from such being taxed on the day of exercise and the option strike price is treated as ordinary wage income to the individual….” 10</blockquote><p>Despite these shifts in the timing of compensation in order that higher taxes on the strike price of these stock options may be avoided, this is only a short term phenomena. When this shift in compensation timing is over, the loss in taxable income as revenue to the federal government due to tax increases, deadweight loss, is found to be only modest in addition to only a minor change in overall taxable income from these wealthiest executives due to the compensation timing shifts. In essence, the rich seek to mitigate the proportionally large tax burden placed upon them through a myriad of methods although, as shown in the example about the shift in compensation timing practiced by the wealthiest executives, these methods do not significantly reduce their overall tax burden in the long run.11</p><p><strong>Conclusion</strong></p><p>In exploring the much asked question in this country of whether or not it would be beneficial to the U.S. economy to increase taxes on the high incomes, we have looked at why many perceive the need to tax the rich, how these taxes on the rich have grown more progressive, and whether attempts by the rich to avoid their proportionately large tax burden affects the overall effectiveness of tax increases upon their income. Through the lens of lower and middle classes, such as comprised the bulk of conscripted men during WWI, and through actions of the rich, such as high-income executives, in trying to mitigate their tax burdens one can acquire a better understanding of what it means to call for higher taxes for the rich, how such a call originated, and how the rich may respond to such calls to place a greater share of the tax burden upon their shoulders.</p><p>Endnotes</p><p>1. “The share of national income going to families in the bottom 40 percent of the income distribution declined by about one-fifth, from 17.4 percent in 1973 to 13.9 percent in 2001, while the share going to families in the top 5 percent increased by more than one-third, from 15.5 percent to 21.0. percent. Meanwhile, the share of income going to the top one-tenth of one percent quadrupled between 1970 and 1998, leaving the 13,000 richest families in America with almost as much income as the 20 million poorest families.” (Bartels, 2005 pg. 16)</p><p>2. Nathan Glazer has argued that “Americans, unlike the citizens of other prosperous democracies, not to mention those of poor countries, do not seem to care much about inequality.” (Bartels, 2005 pg. 17)</p><p>3. Bartels, 2005 pg. 16</p><p>4. Apergis, Oguzhan, and Payne 2011 pg. 135</p><p>5. “Even after the adoption of universal conscription in the advanced industrial countries, individuals were conscripted on the basis of characteristics correlated with income and wealth. The most important of these is age, than younger individuals. The existence of deferment policies for educational or other reasons can also produce a de facto bias whereby those higher up the income distribution were less likely to be required to fight in the front lines.” (Scheve and Stasavage, 2010 pg. 534)</p><p>6. “Irrespective of whether they serve in the armed forces, perceptions may arise that individuals with invested wealth have possibilities to earn financial profits out of a war because of increased demand for certain goods and services. It has long been recognized that attitudes toward income inequality and redistribution depend on beliefs about the process through which inequality was generated.”(Scheve and Stasavage, 2010 pg. 535)</p><p>7. “It has long been recognized that attitudes toward income inequality and redistribution depend on beliefs about the process through which inequality was generated. In the context we consider, attitudes regarding progressivity are likely to depend on whether income is thought to be gained as a result of the sacrifices of others.”(Scheve and Stasavage, 2010 pg. 535)</p><p>8. Scheve and Stasavage, 2010 pg. 535</p><p>9. “We have argued that mobilization for mass warfare produces demands for progressive taxation as a means of ensuring greater equality of sacrifice in the war effort. There is substantial evidence consistent with this hypothesis. Focusing attention on World War I, we find a significant upward shift in top tax rates in those countries that participated and mobilized for the war. Further, we find a substantial positive war-mobilization effect based on difference-in-differences estimates that compare changes in top rates from 1900 to 1930 in participant and nonparticipant countries. This effect is not limited to top tax rates but reflects changes in other measures of progressivity as well. This article also reports several forms of additional evidence to support our argument. First, the timing and political rhetoric of war financing debates during World War I is consistent with our claim that progressive taxation was a response to demands for equalizing war-time sacrifice.”(Scheve and Stasavage, 2010 pg. 538)</p><p>10. “Nonqualified stock options (NQOs) are not considered income until exercised, at which time the difference between the stock executive compensation price on the day of exercise and the option strike price is treated as ordinary wage income to the individual.”(Goolsbee, 2000 pg. 360–361)</p><p>11. “Such changes may allow many to avoid taxation for a short period of time and may wreak havoc on contemporaneous revenue estimates. But after the shifting is done, the total changes in taxable income, at least in this sample, seem to be more limited and the deadweight loss of progressivity more modest than previous work has suggested.”(Goolsbee, 2000 pg. 375)</p><p><strong>Bibliography</strong></p><p>Apergis, Nicholas, Oguzhan Dincer, and James E. Payne. “On The Dynamics of Poverty and Income Inequality in US States.” Journal Of Economic Studies 38, no. 2 (2011): 132 — 43. doi:10.1108/01443581111128370.</p><p>Bartels, Larry M. “Homer Gets a Tax Cut: Inequality And Public Policy in the American Mind.” Perspectives On Politics 3, no. 01 (2005). doi:10.1017/S1537592705050036.</p><p>Goolsbee, Austan. “What Happens When You Tax The Rich? Evidence from Executive Compensation.” Journal Of Political Economy 108, no. 2 (2000): 352. doi:10.1086/262122.</p><p>Scheve, Kenneth, and David Stasavage. “The Conscription Of Wealth: Mass Warfare and the Demand for Progressive Taxation.” International Organization 64, no. 04 (2010): 529 — 61. doi:10.1017/S0020818310000226.</p><p>Williamson, John B. “Beliefs About The Rich, the Poor and the Taxes They Pay.” American Journal Of Economics and Sociology 35, no. 1 (1976): 9 — 30.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=f6e8a75e98fb" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Positions of the Federalists and the Anti-Federalists in the Debate on the Ratification of the…]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@JustinusSmithus/positions-of-the-federalists-and-the-anti-federalists-in-the-debate-on-the-ratification-of-the-1241d5a74949?source=rss-2049c41b82de------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/1241d5a74949</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[history]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[federalism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[government]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Justin Smith]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 31 Jan 2017 04:21:09 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-01-31T04:21:09.800Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Positions of the Federalists and the Anti-Federalists in the Debate on the Ratification of the Constitution</h3><p>During the time between the final session of the Constitutional Convention and the ratification of the Constitution of the United States there were a number of issues that those who opposed the Constitution, known as the Anti-federalists, had with our long-lasting frame of government. These issue included the assumption of state debt from the war, the exclusion of a bill of rights from the Constitution, the emittance of paper currency, and even the issue of standing armies. During this time of intense debate both the Federalists, those in favor of ratification, and the Anti-federalists, those opposed, had written many letters, pamphlets, and newspaper articles in an attempt to make their opinions heard in the marketplace of ideas and to influence the debate on the continuance of one government or the formation of a kind of government completely new.</p><p><strong>A Bill of Rights</strong></p><blockquote><em>Among the many issues contested in the debates on ratification was the lack of a Bill of Rights in the finished product of the Constitutional Convention. Antifederalists, concerned with the lack of an included Bill of Rights, similar to the one they held so dear when subjects of Great Britain, expressed several fears they felt would surface into reality if this lack of said Bill was not rectified.</em></blockquote><p>There were many Anti-federalists, like George Mason of Virginia, who felt that the Constitution would create a government that “would ‘commence in a moderate Aristocracy’ and would probably degenerate into an ‘oppressive Aristocracy.’”1 This concern seems especially prudent considering that, originally, neither the Senate nor the President were to be elected popularly.2 This fear of a possible aristocracy borne not of land, but of power, would greatly endanger the hard-won liberties that had cost the lives of many during the war. It was, again, George Mason who had felt that if too great an amount of power were apportioned to “any group of men” they would then “seek aggrandizement and elevate their own interests above those of society.” Mason’s answer to this problem involved “a more effective system of checks on government and a written bill of rights to protect individual liberty.”3 It light of this, it was the sentiment of many Anti-federalists that, if they were to be governed “by people superior, more learned, and more deliberative than they,” who were fundamentally different from the common farmer or townsman, “than individual rights needed specific protection.”4</p><p>In response to these common-sense concerns James Madison, as Publius, tries to calm those worried about the safety of their liberties that they fought for, and that many fellow Americans had died for. He makes his case by drawing from their current frame of government, the Articles of Confederation, so that he may make the claim that a Bill of Rights is not “essential to liberty,” as there is no Bill of Rights under the Confederation government.5 It is by citing this fact, among other deficiencies of the Confederation government, that Madison asks his readers how could “sensible citizens…resist ratification,” seeing as the concerns that they have with the proposed government “lie with tenfold weight against the existing Confederation.”6</p><p><strong>The Assumption of State Debts</strong></p><p>One of the key weaknesses of the Articles of Confederation was the inability for the Congress to impose taxes for any reason at all, it was instead funded by money requested of the individual state government’s. The Congress simply did not receive the money needed to service the massive national debt accrued during the War. In addition to this, the assumption of state debt from the Revolutionary was a critical issue during the debate for ratification. The Antifederalists saw in this assumption of debt several dangers, such as the federal government gaining too much influence into the affairs of the states. The Federalists, however, saw the effects of the continuing debt from the war on the states and its crippling effect on their economies. Additional, the Federalists saw for a way for the U.S. to gain a positive credit report with Europe by the creation of a funded national debt.</p><p>The problems, as seen by the antifederalists, with this proposal of a funded national debt incited anxiety and frustration with many who saw it as the potential creation of another aristocracy as soon as they fought to be free of a monarchy. On such Antifederalists, writing under the pseudonym of The Federal Farmer, wrote that the newly written Constitution came about as a result of “the conflict between leveling debtors ‘who want a share of the property of others’” and men he called “aristocrats” as they were attempting to “grasp at all power and property.”7 This was a very popular view of the proposed funded debt by Antifederalists, seeing it as a way for the proposed Federal government to wedge itself into the business of the state governments and use it as“an instrument of influence and corruption”8 The anonymous Antifederalist writer, Calca, charged that a “public revenue naturally begets influence…that bane of all free government’s.” He arrived at this conclusion in his writings by comparing this funded debt proposal to the historical instance of Great Britain’s establishment of a public debt after the Glorious Revolution, saying the “the national debt had been the ‘parent of corruption’ in Britain.9 In addition to the voice of Calca in New York, “the Lees in virginia charged that the ‘impost was designed for no other purpose than to give Congress an undue Influence in the States’”10</p><p>In response to these fears of aristocracy, corruption and influence Publius relates that a massive debt, and a crippled economy as a result, would soon leave the country bankrupt and vulnerable. Based upon this assessment, Publius sought to make the appeal that the current form of government is ill-equipped to deal with the debt and that the new government would be the only suitable manager of the owed money. In particular, “the central government’s inability to impose taxes”11 that left it unable to deal with its own national debt, let alone the debt accrued by the individual states during the war. In response to the outcry against the proposal to assume the debt of the states, out of fear of undue influence in the state government’s, the question was whether the individual states could handle the debt themselves, being “a loosely organized collection of autonomous states”. The answer was a resounding no, as Madison stated that “there is nothing men differ so readily about as the payment of money.”12 Speaking further on the subject, Madison admitted that, while there was no specific language within the constitution that dealt with the question of debt owed to the central government by the states, he did condemn the notion that “the government would DARE…to remit the debts justly due the public.” In judging this statement in context with his early misgivings about the individual states ability to deal with the national debt from the war, Madison was expressing great confidence in the new government’s ability to deal with the massive amount of debt accumulated during the Revolutionary War.13</p><p><strong>Standing Armies</strong></p><p>Nearly as iconic as the Colonial hatred of ‘taxation without representation’ was their dislike, and distrust, of standing armies. During the aftermath of the French and Indian War it was quite common to see, at least in the port cities of the eastern coast of the colonies, British regular infantry, garrisoned in the colonies at the expense of the Colonies, meaning at the expense of the colonists themselves. While the government in Britain felt it a necessary measure in order to protect against a possible French, or Indian, invasion of British Territory after the peace of 1763, the colonists saw it as an ever present danger their civil liberties, and felt as well that it was an unneeded expense upon the colonies in general. It is by understanding these established misgivings about standing armies before the revolution that we can, therefore, understand the general doubts of the Antifederalists on the subject of standing armies after the war as well as their preference for state-controlled militias.</p><p>When confronted with the possibility of federal control over the mobilizing of state militias, many antifederalists “Skeptics worried, for example, that a federal power to mobilize local militias would lead the central government to overwhelm American liberties.”14 The America envisioned by the antifederalists was “wedded to a republican civic ideal,” in America that Samuel Adams had called “a Christian Sparta.”15 I was through these civic ideals that professional armies were always seen “as evil incarnate, undermining the citizen’s self-sacrificial participation in the defense of the public realm, which was the premise of the militia.” Thus it was the argument of many Antifederalists against uniting under one federal government because such a large territory was seen as incompatible with the existence of “a free elective government.”16 This was mainly due to the recognized inability to govern a realm of such size without forming a professional army.</p><p>Many of the Antifederalists, on the other hand, were still wedded to a republican civic ideal, to the making of America into what Samuel Adams called “a Christian Sparta.” The very feature of pluralist diversity in the new constitutional order that Madison saw as its great virtue, the Antifederalists saw as its major defect. For the Antifederalist “Brutus” it was absurd that the legislature “would be composed of such heteroge- neous and discordant principles, as would constantly be contending with each other.” A chorus of Antifederalists insisted that virtuous republican government required a small area and a homogeneous population. Patrick Henry noted that a republican form of government extending across the continent “contradicts all the experience of the world.” Richard Henry Lee argued that “a free elective government cannot be extended over large territories.” Robert Yates of New York saw liberty</p><p>If the antifederalists were concerned with the incompatibility between professional armies and the republic civic ideals of a liberty minded citizenry, the Federalists were more concerned about the security from the invasion of the fledgling nation as well as the industrial pursuits of its citizenry. Acknowledging an “eclipse of older civic ideas of self-sacrifice and participatory citizenship in commercial America”, Hamilton noted that the habits of the people, being involved on a daily basis with the “pursuit of gain and devoted to the improvements of agriculture and commerce,” are not compatible with being “a nation of soldiers,” as they would be under the militia system. He argued in Federalist №24 that the citizens that would comprise a militia “would not long, if at all, submit to be dragged from their occupations and families.” The down-side to this system, if it prevails, would include a “loss of labor” and would throw into disorder the “industrious pursuits of individuals,” causing the economic well-being of both the average citizen as well as that of the nation as a whole to suffer.17</p><p><strong>The Emittance of Paper Currency</strong></p><p>Also prominent in the debate on ratification was the issue concerning the emittance of paper currency.18 Central to this issue was the conflict between creditors who owned the debt from the Revolutionary War, being either original purchaser of the war bonds that financed the colonial war effort or by buying those bonds off of the original purchasers at a reduced price, and the debtors, who were those regular citizens who were taxed burdensomely so that the states could be able to pay off those who owned the debt. Those who were owed payment for their bonds were in favor of higher taxes so that the respective states may be able to pay them their money owed while the ‘debtors’ were in favor of policies that would provide for debtor-relief, such as lower taxes and the emittance of paper currency so the debts could be more easily paid at the face value of the currency rather than in the value of gold or silver specie.</p><p>Though he was prominent among the Antifederalists, George Mason was not in favor of the payment of debts in paper money, as he was a creditor. Despite this Mason argued the case for the states to have the authority to interfere with private contracts when it might be necessary to do so. He also felt that Congress should not be prohibited from emitting paper currency because, “he had a mortal hatred to paper money, yet as he could not foresee all emergences, he was unwilling to tie the hands of the Legislature.”19 Differing from George Mason in his status as a creditor, many other Antifederalists much more sympathetic with the plight of the debtor, were of the opinion that “states be permitted to retain in circulation paper money that had already been emitted.”20</p><p>In response to the Antifederalist arguments, the Federalists advocated for the “exclusive federal regulation of the currency,” which “found support in ‘the pestilen effects of paper money” emitted by the states.21 One such example of “the pestilent effects of paper money” can be found in the actions of Rhode Island, in which a pro debtor-relief party had gained control of the legislature and proceeded to pass aggressive reforms that included the printing of paper currency in vast quantities, meaning to use this new paper money to force-pay creditors, being required to take the currency at face value.22</p><p><strong>Conclusion</strong></p><p>As evidenced by the intense dialogue between Antifederalists and Federalists, the debate on the future of the United States government after the close of the Constitutional Convention was not to be likened to the easy exchange of ideas that we imagine took place in the Salons of Paris. These debates that took place in newspapers, pamphlets, books, and public forums and private homes involved many of the most polarizing issues of the day. The issue of the assumption of state debt, the question of a bill of rights, the emittance of paper currency, and even the issue of a professional army had intense public support on both sides of all of these issues. Despite the fact that we know what the final decision was after these debates, it is very interesting to see both sides of these debated issues, the outcome of which the fate of the fledgeling nation’s future rested upon.</p><h3>Endnotes</h3><ol><li>“Anti-Federalists like Virginia’s George Mason feared that the government created by the Constitution would “commence in a moderate Aristocracy” and would probably degenerate into an “oppressive Aristocracy.””(Cornel, 1168)</li><li>“It is important to remember that neither the Senate nor the president was to be popularly elected under the original document.”(Lee, 1085)</li><li>“What worried Mason was the traditional republican fear of corruption. In his mind, any group of men who were given too much power would seek aggrandizement and elevate their own interests above those of society. The solution to Mason’s objections was a more effective system of checks on government and a written bill of rights to protect individual liberty.”(Cornel, 1168)</li><li>“If, after all, government was to be run from some city hundreds of miles away, by people superior, more learned, and more deliberative than they, by people with whom they had little in common, than individual rights needed specific protection.” (Kramnick, 12)</li><li>“Is a bill of rights essential to liberty? The Confederation has no Bill of Rights.”(Coenen, 507)</li><li>“Citing these points, Madison asked how sensible citizens could resist ratification when “most of the capital objections urged against the new system, lie with tenfold weight against the existing Confederation.””(Coenen, 507)</li><li>“The Federal Farmer saw the new Constitution resulting from the conflict between leveling debtors “who want a share of the property of others” and men “called aristocrats” who “grasp at all power and property.”(Kramnick, 21)</li><li>The funded debt supported by the impost proposed by the nationalists in 1781 and 1783 was repeatedly attacked, in vintage Country vitriol, as an instrument of influence and corruption. In every case where critics can be identified they were men who later became Antifederalists.(Hutson 362)</li><li>“public revenue naturally begets influence … that bane of all free governments.” “Calca,” writing in the New York Packet of February 26, 1784, compared the nationalists’ impost for funding the war debt “to the public debt established by the Court in Great Britain after the Glorious Revolution.” The national debt had been the “parent of corruption” in Britain, “Calca” asserted, “the powerful and prevailing instrument of pernicious influence, in the supreme executive power. What security have we, what security can we have, that the same baneful effects will not attend it here?”(Hutson, 362)</li><li>The Lees in Virginia charged that the “impost was designed for no other purpose than to give Congress an undue Influence in the States,”(Hutson, 362)</li><li>“Problems related to commerce also plagued the Confederation. The central government’s inability to impose taxes left it hard-pressed to deal with an ever-mounting debt that had grown out of the Revolution.”(Coenen, 482)</li><li>“Could a loosely organized collection of autonomous states properly manage the national debt? No, because “there is nothing men differ so readily about as the payment of money.”(Coenen, 504)</li><li>“The Constitution, Madison acknowledged, did not specify in terms that obligations owed to the federal government would survive ratification. But ‘no real danger can exist that the government would DARE … to remit the debts justly due to the public, on the pretext here condemned.’”(Coenen, 504)</li><li>“Skeptics worried, for example, that a federal power to mobilize local militias would lead the central government to overwhelm American liberties.” (Coenen, 503)</li><li>“Many of the Antifederalists, on the other hand, were still wedded to a republican civic ideal, to the making of America into what Samuel Adams called “a Christian Sparta.”</li><li>Many of the Antifederalists, on the other hand, were still wedded to a republican civic ideal, to the making of America into what Samuel Adams called “a Christian Sparta.” The very feature of pluralist diversity in the new constitutional order that Madison saw as its great virtue, the Antifederalists saw as its major defect. For the Antifederalist “Brutus” it was absurd that the legislature “would be composed of such heteroge- neous and discordant principles, as would constantly be contending with each other.” A chorus of Antifederalists insisted that virtuous republican government required a small area and a homogeneous population. Patrick Henry noted that a republican form of government extending across the continent “contradicts all the experience of the world.” Richard Henry Lee argued that “a free elective government cannot be extended over large territories.” Robert Yates of New York saw liberty “swallowed up” because the new republic was too large.”(Kramnick, 9)</li><li>“He was writing of manning garrisons involved in protecting the frontiers: ‘And if they could be prevailed upon or compelled to do it, the increased expense of a frequent rotation of service, and the loss of labor and disconcertation of the industrious pursuits of individuals, would form conclusive objections to the scheme. It would be as burdensome and injurious to the public as ruinous to private citizens.’”(Kramnick, 9)</li><li>“Other issues also lent themselves to reasoned discussion and debate. Among them were whether…Congress should have authority to emit paper money.” (Nelson, 473)</li><li>“George Mason, a creditor who favored enforcement of contracts and payment of debts in specie rather than in inflated paper money. Yet, in the midst of the debate on the contract clause, he argued that states should be left free to interfere with private contracts since “cases will happen that can not be foreseen, where some kind of interference will be proper, &amp; essential.” Similarly, he cautioned against preventing Congress from emitting paper money: although “he had a mortal hatred to paper money, yet as he could not foresee all emergences, he was unwilling to tie the hands of the Legislature.”(Nelson, 474)</li><li>“North Carolina joined Pennsylvania’s Antifederalists in the latter request and further proposed that states be permitted to retain in circulation paper money that had already been emitted.” (Nelson, 480)</li><li>Arguments from state practice drew in part on the experiences of dysfunctional institutions. Exclusive federal regulation of the currency, for example, found support in “the pestilent effects of paper money” circulated by states whose “guilt . . . can be expiated [not] otherwise than by a voluntary sacrifice on the altar of justice, of the power which has been the instrument of it.”(Coenen, 498)</li><li>“In Rhode Island, however, a “debtor party” captured the statehouse and proceeded to implement aggressive reforms. In particular, the legislature permitted the printing of vast amounts of new currency — more dollars per person than in any other state — and then it forced creditors to take the currency in payment of past debts at face value.”(Coenen, 484)</li></ol><p><strong>Bibliography</strong></p><p>Coenen, Dan T. “A Rhetoric for Ratification: The Argument of “The Federalist” and Its Impact on Constitutional Interpretation” Duke Law Journal 56, №2. 469–543</p><p>Cornell, Saul. “Aristocracy Assailed: The Ideology of Backcountry Anti-Federalism” The Journal of American History 26, no. 4. 1148–1172</p><p>Estes, Todd. “The Voices of Publius and the Strategies of Persuasion in <em>The Federalist</em>.” <em>Journal of the Early Republic</em> 28, no. 4 (12 2008): 523–58. doi:10.1353/jer.0.0034.</p><p>Holton, Woody. “An Excess of Democracy — Or a Shortage?: The Federalists’ Earliest Adversaries.” <em>Journal of the Early Republic</em> 25, no. 3 (12 2005): 339–82. doi:10.1353/jer.2005.0054.</p><p>Hutson, James A. <em>“Country, Court, and Constitution: Anti Federalism and the Historians” </em>William and Mary Quarterly 38, №3. 337–368.</p><p>Johnson, Joel A. “Disposed to Seek Their True Interests: Representation and Responsibility in Anti-Federalist Thought.” <em>The Review of Politics</em> 66, no. 04 (12 2004): 649. doi:10.1017/S0034670500039929.</p><p>Kramnick, Isaac. “The “Great National Discussion”: The Discourse of Politics in 1787” The William and Mary Quarterly 45, no.1. 3–32</p><p>Lee, Emery G. “Representation, Virtue, and Political Jealousy in the Brutus–Publius Dialogue.” <em>The Journal of Politics</em> 59, no. 04 (12 1997): 1073. doi:10.2307/2998593.</p><p>Nelson, William E. “Reason and Compromise in the Establishment of the Federal Constitution, 1787–1801.”The William and Mary Quarterly 44, no. 3 (12 1987): 458. doi:10.2307/1939766.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=1241d5a74949" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>