<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Leverage Research on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Leverage Research on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@LeverageResearch?source=rss-a1da96f80887------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Tue, 17 Nov 2026 14:04:39 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@LeverageResearch/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[June 2023 Public Strategy Update]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@LeverageResearch/june-2023-public-strategy-update-1c2d116ee3d9?source=rss-a1da96f80887------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/1c2d116ee3d9</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[history-of-science]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[strategy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[progress]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[artificial-intelligence]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Leverage Research]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 11 Jul 2023 20:21:15 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-07-11T20:21:15.156Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>The following are Executive Director Geoff Anders’ prepared remarks for Leverage’s June 2023 public strategy update, which was held on Friday, June 23 at the Leverage online office. Audio of actual remarks and Q&amp;A is linked just below; actual remarks followed written remarks fairly closely.</em></p><p><em>Leverage’s strategy presentations are meant to inform the public about the institute’s perspective on strategic issues of public relevant pertaining to science and technology. For more information, please see our collection of </em><a href="http://leverage.institute/resources"><em>strategy-related resources</em></a><em> on the Leverage </em><a href="http://leverage.institute/"><em>website</em></a><em>.</em></p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fw.soundcloud.com%2Fplayer%2F%3Furl%3Dhttps%253A%252F%252Fapi.soundcloud.com%252Ftracks%252F1548336793%26show_artwork%3Dtrue&amp;display_name=SoundCloud&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fsoundcloud.com%2Fcontact-us-69745589%2Fstrategy-presentation-6-23-23%3Fsi%253D00f7a0ee77d74ff38f82dada29df4b35%2526utm_source%253Dclipboard%2526utm_medium%253Dtext%2526utm_campaign%253Dsocial_sharing%26sa%3DD%26source%3Ddocs%26ust%3D1689108085194850%26usg%3DAOvVaw02ky0fHC02S3f6NvrKFMpe&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fsoundcloud.com%2Fimages%2Ffb_placeholder.png&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=soundcloud" width="800" height="166" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/7302e02156e36dd4f8b26eb2e6d61b15/href">https://medium.com/media/7302e02156e36dd4f8b26eb2e6d61b15/href</a></iframe><h3>Introductory Remarks</h3><p>Hello everyone, welcome to Leverage Research’s first public strategy update in 2023, and third overall. Our first two strategy updates focused on laying out some part of our overall strategic picture. We covered lots of topics, and for people interested, we have some links available, including text and audio from previous updates, as well as some internal documents we decided to release. <em>(Links: Jun ’22—</em><a href="https://medium.com/@LeverageResearch/june-2022-public-strategy-update-ce50a172c677"><em>remarks</em></a><em>, </em><a href="https://make.headliner.app/download/f76d1bcd-c115-4f02-8b43-dadd834ae1f6?source=user-export-email&amp;_branch_match_id=970698573950414375&amp;utm_source=email&amp;utm_medium=video-detail&amp;_branch_referrer=H4sIAAAAAAAAAw3LUQ6DIBAFwBOtSEUlTZqeZWEfgcQWsqDp8ev8Tx6j9acxPbNiymA5yhc6cWvmKoJKgsHlMGnfxIYoFK1dyaX5QT64hYRF/OIYNm3vXk%2BNeJ0dSvi1qoPwufcfIw7ma2YAAAA%3D"><em>audio</em></a><em>, </em><a href="https://docs.google.com/document/d/1H4uKqjNlAc7l35kTb5F4BQv1_ORPbpcmvgpEu1pjAh4/edit"><em>internal doc</em></a><em>; Dec ’22—</em><a href="https://medium.com/@LeverageResearch/december-2022-public-strategy-update-226aad5333b"><em>remarks</em></a><em>, </em><a href="https://soundcloud.com/contact-us-69745589/leverage-strategy-update-audio-recording-dec-16-2022?utm_source=cdn.embedly.com&amp;utm_campaign=wtshare&amp;utm_medium=widget&amp;utm_content=https%253A%252F%252Fsoundcloud.com%252Fcontact-us-69745589%252Fleverage-strategy-update-audio-recording-dec-16-2022"><em>audio</em></a><em>, </em><a href="https://docs.google.com/document/d/1c8PlNUaG_OMk6BRj5vKxuNct-MVMQg8MUFPqfEal_cM/edit#"><em>internal</em></a><em>)</em></p><p>In this update, we’re going to talk about the basic question of whether strategic thinking is needed in the domains of science and technology, and also with respect to public engagement. It’s a strange idea — usually when people think of strategy, they think of war or business, and maps or business plans, or else heroes and villains battling each other, where in popular culture it’s more often the villains who have strategies.</p><p>Our perspective, as we will explain, is that strategic thinking is necessary and useful in the domains of science, technology, and public engagement. That’s why we have strategies and why we’re doing public strategy updates. It’s important for us to convey why we have this focus, since it involves important questions that people need to think about.</p><p>Today’s presentation will have two parts. In this first part, I’ll talk about Leverage’s perspective of strategy, which will include thinking about the topic of strategy in a very abstract way. Then I’ll give two concrete illustrations of the importance of strategy, focusing on domains in which Leverage works, namely (1) history of science research, and (2) public communication about artificial intelligence.</p><p>This part will take thirty minutes. I’ll pause now and then for questions, so if you have questions relevant to what I’m saying, you are very much invited to ask. After that part, we’ll then move on to the second part, which will be a more open discussion and conversation about the topics discussed. We have a number of guests here today which I’m happy to welcome, in particular Samo Burja, CEO and founder of Bismarck Analysis, a global consultancy that focuses on institutional adequacy, player analysis, and civilizational prospects, and Nevin Freeman, CEO and founder of Reserve, a cryptocurrency project that is aiming to create a stable decentralized currency — the original vision of crypto.</p><p>We’re looking forward to hearing everyone’s thoughts and opinions on the topics being discussed.</p><p>For anyone who is interested in continuing the conversation after the hour, you’re invited to join us in our Discord for informal conversation after the public update.</p><h3>Strategy in Theory</h3><p>We’re going to start off abstractly. I mentioned war and business and maps and heroes and the like. What actually is strategy? And why does it matter, especially in the context of an institute that studies and communicates about early stage science?</p><p>Let’s take these questions in turn.</p><h4>What is Strategic Thinking?</h4><p>If you search Wikipedia or Google, you’ll find people defining “strategy” in terms of plans, objectives, and uncertainty, and also war or military operations. People talk about business or “evolutionary strategy.” Midjourney produced a pretty hilarious image, basically a big mashup of chess pieces and castles.</p><p>Our perspective is that strategy is about navigating a landscape. You can think about landscapes literally or metaphorically, as in, figuring out how to cross over a mountain or navigating the “business landscape.”</p><p>Strategy comes in when landscapes are difficult in certain ways. It’s not just that a landscape is hard to pass through. You might imagine going uphill against the wind and there’s no real strategy needed, just “keep going.”</p><p>Rather, strategy becomes necessary when you can’t trust your natural instincts or impulses. If you’re crossing a swamp, and you can’t tell where you can step or where you’ll sink in, you may need a strategy to figure out how to cross.</p><p>The need for strategic thinking sometimes comes from the environment, as with the swamp. Sometimes it comes from oneself, though, or rather, how one expects oneself to interact with the environment. A good example here is Odysseus, who tied himself to the mast so he could hear the siren’s song without getting drawn in. That’s a strategy — his natural impulses would be wrong, so he took steps to ensure he could still successfully navigate the landscape.</p><p>One type of case where it’s wrong to trust one’s impulses in when the landscape is <em>treacherous</em>. When we say something is “treacherous,” we mean that it is apt to betray you. People can be treacherous, but so can a mountain cliff, where a cliff might be treacherous if it appears safe in ways in which it is not.</p><p>This explains why strategy is often associated with war and business, or with villains rather than heroes. In adversarial circumstances, where people are trying to mislead one another, strategy may be necessary in order to not be misled or to prevail over an opponent.</p><p>Our preference is for heroes rather than villains, perhaps unsurprisingly. And that’s how strategy can be deployed for good — when either a landscape is treacherous, or when your own impulses are wrong, or when you’re defending against people who are trying to trick or mislead you.</p><h4>Why Does Strategy Matter?</h4><p>Given this explanation of strategy, it may seem obvious why strategy matters. Lots of landscapes are tricky. Our natural impulses are sometimes wrong. There are, unfortunately, also many circumstances where people are trying to trick each other — or at least aren’t doing their absolute best to communicate the truth.</p><p>Nevertheless, people don’t focus on strategy and strategic thinking nearly as much as they could. Why is that?</p><p>Here’s one reason. Thinking about strategy involves (1) thinking about danger, but (2) thinking constructively about how dangers will be handled. This is hard to do. It’s easy to be an optimist and not focus on the dangers. It’s easy to be a pessimist and not focus on constructive solutions. It’s hard to get the right mix of optimism and pessimism to let you both take the measure of dangers and also figure out how to overcome them.</p><p>This is a partial explanation. But it’s not a complete one. People have become quite good at thinking about the dangers from chemistry, for instance, or with operating heavy machinery. But people are less good at thinking about dangers from people, especially the ways that otherwise friendly or well-meaning people can work together to create illusions.</p><p>Strategic thinking is easiest when one has a clear opponent, an enemy. This happens in war. Something similar can happen in business. The fact that people’s goals are opposed, and obviously opposed, makes it easy to identify that the landscape is treacherous, that there are dangers one might not be seeing.</p><p>But think about a phenomenon as simple as <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Groupthink">groupthink</a>. Groupthink is a deadly phenomenon. When projects fail, groupthink is a common cause. If your group is succumbing to groupthink, sound the alarm, take evasive action immediately.</p><p>Groupthink is a well known, common, and high-stakes problem. Why then do people still fall victim to it? The answer is that it can be hard to identify ways that good people — including oneself — can work together to create highly misleading illusions.</p><p>This helps to explain why strategic thinking is important. There <em>are</em> dangers, even in friendly, seemingly non-political environments. That’s not to say that <em>every</em> environment is dangerous or that one needs to have one’s strategy hat on all the time. But it’s important to recognize that it’s not just war, it’s not just business, it’s not just treacherous mountain paths. It’s <em>people</em>, and frequently it’s <em>ourselves</em>. If we don’t take account of the real dangers, we won’t recognize when we need to think strategically, and things might go wrong.</p><p>The stakes are also quite high, as we’ll see. It could be possible to sink hundreds of person-years of effort into studying the history of science and still get wrong answers. It might be possible to spend years working on getting good outcomes with respect to AI and have no impact — or worse, produce the opposite of the intended effect.</p><p>The stakes are high, and there are dangers, but the dangers are, in our view, ultimately tractable. That’s why strategic thinking is important. If you’re on the relevant sort of landscape and you’re not thinking strategically, it’s really hard to ensure you’ll get a good outcome. But if strategic thought <em>is</em> necessary, frequently reality is not so complicated as to foreclose a solution.</p><p>There are dangers, and strategy is a way to meet some of them.</p><h4>Brief Q&amp;A</h4><p>— — — <em>break for Q&amp;A</em> — — —</p><h3>Strategy in Practice</h3><h4>Why Does Leverage Engage in Strategic Planning?</h4><p>It may now be clear why Leverage engages in strategic planning. For the past decade, Leverage has worked in the areas of science and technology. More recently, the institute has expanded to include public communication. Each of these areas contain important dangers, some of which can be addressed by thinking strategically.</p><p>I’ll note three important dangers, each of which calls for advance planning. These are hype, unintended consequences, and overreliance on institutions.</p><p><em>Hype. </em>There’s a lot of hype in science and technology. This is well-known — just look at the “science news” from a few years ago and see whether everything they were talking about has actually happened. Or you could go back earlier, and see the 1950s advertisements for flying cars. We’re still waiting.</p><p>Hype is a serious danger, because some very popular things don’t have substance, and some very unpopular things are actually quite promising. You may have heard that introspection as a research method doesn’t work. Turns out that’s wrong — an important and misleading piece of hype.</p><p>The most dangerous circumstance for hype, however, comes when there is <em>some</em> substance and <em>some</em> misconception. Those together can yield what <em>seem</em> like promising projects and avenues forward that will ultimately just waste a lot of people’s time.</p><p><em>Unintended consequences.</em> Science and technology also sometimes yield unintended consequences. Gain-of-function research was never meant to be a public danger. The pursuit of nuclear energy also yielded the atom bomb. Dynamite, the Internet, the mobile phone — these things have enhanced our lives and also caused harm.</p><p>The problem with unintended consequences is, quite simply, that they are frequently the opposite of what we want. When people set out to invent new science and technology, they are frequently doing so with the intention of benefiting the world and benefiting themselves. The scientist whose work is then used for military purposes they did not intend, or who is killed by their own invention, are now clichés. [add links]</p><p>It may seem completely infeasible to predict the effects of new science and technology, especially hundreds of years in advance. Nevertheless, our natural impulses, which frequently are simply to discover and invent, are also misleading. “[Y]our scientists were so preoccupied with whether or not they could that they didn’t stop to think if they should.” (That’s from Jurassic Park.) Planning in advance is necessary, even if it seems incredibly difficult.</p><p><em>Overreliance on institutions.</em> A third major danger in the realm of science and technology is the overreliance on institutions. This can come in many forms. People may expect that the top journals in a field represent the actual state of the art. People may think that scientists are devoting their resources to the most important problems. More deeply, people may believe that their understanding of science, itself derived from institutions, is an accurate characterization of this special form of knowledge and social institution.</p><p>Unfortunately, we live in a time when institutions are less reliable than people think. In some cases, there are promising research avenues, or even entire new fields or subfields, that are not being explored or given institutional support. There are even misconceptions about the aspects of the scientific process — from randomized control trials to the relation between academia and the scientific enterprise — that institutions are not taking careful steps to correct.</p><p>Happily, it is part of the story of science that it is self-correcting, including by enterprising people who act from the outside. Acting outside of present institutions, and seeking to create new ones, is a challenging path. It calls for strategy. But we believe it is possible, in both idea and concrete reality.</p><h4>Brief Q&amp;A</h4><p>— — — <em>break for Q&amp;A</em> — —</p><h4>Studying the History of Science: Dangers and Strategies</h4><p>Now let’s look at some specific areas. We’ll first look at the history of science, where Leverage has its History of Science program, and then artificial intelligence, where Leverage is launching a new initiative aimed at public communication about AI.</p><p>Leverage’s History of Science program is studying science, with the idea that a better understanding of how science was done in the past will help do better science today. In particular, we’re doing case studies on how the major discoveries in the history of successful sciences were made.</p><p>There are a number of challenges here, including raising money for the research and helping people understand why the history of science is important. In terms of problems that require strategic thought, however, the main problem we expect to encounter is bias, or rather, the difficulty identifying and challenging our own assumptions.</p><p>When you imagine researchers studying the history of science, what is the main thing you imagine going wrong? The researchers go in with assumptions that they fail to identify, these assumptions shape which evidence they examine, and as a result they end up reaching the wrong conclusions. That’s the primary danger that we need to avoid.</p><p>In broad terms, our solution to this problem is to have our researchers’ biases cancel each other out. In a single word, it’s <strong>multidisciplinarity</strong>. It may sound trite, but you really can do a lot to overcome bias by having people with different perspectives work together on something.</p><p>The main challenge then is which disciplines ought to work together to study the history of science. History of science is a natural choice. Historians, however, are not naturally trained to identify assumptions, make careful conceptual distinctions, and so forth. (In fact, people in general are not normally trained to do this.) That’s something philosophers do. So we decided to balance history of science with the philosophy of science.</p><p>As it turns out, there is already a small discipline, the History and Philosophy of Science (HPS) that already exists, and so that’s perfect. The philosophers can help to identify assumptions and think clearly about what science is, balancing the historians. The philosophers on their own would likely be too abstract and fail to agree about things. So, the philosophers can be balanced by the historians, who can keep things focused on determining concretely what happened in history.</p><p>This solution worried me, though, because I could imagine history of science and philosophy of science people getting into the wrong sort of pattern. So we decided to balance them with social science. Many social sciences are not fully functional, but there are still social sciences that can help people have different valuable perspectives. If you imagine having a linguist or an economist on the team, you imagine them paying attention to very different types of evidence.</p><p>Concretely, and this is where you can see a specific attempted solution to a strategic challenge, we are aiming to hire researchers who have expertise in at least two of the three areas: history, philosophy, and social science. We’re not fully sure it will work, but there are a lot of ways to see how well it is going, and we’ve thought of a variety of solutions in case this doesn’t address the danger of bias.</p><h4>Communicating about AI: Dangers and Strategies</h4><p>Let’s now turn to artificial intelligence. As many of you will know, there have been a lot of developments in AI over the last few years, and now discourse about AI has spilled onto the public scene. Leverage is now planning to launch an initiative pertaining to AI which will focus on public communication and have the goal of helping to ensure positive outcomes with respect to the new technology.</p><p>As we’ve started preparing for this, one thing we’ve been working on is identifying the different dangers of the initiative. So far, we’ve identified three. This means that by comparison, the AI communication area is much more strategically difficult than history of science research, for instance, which has only one.</p><p>The first danger is understanding how to cause the right outcomes. The AI situation is extraordinarily complex. There are many different parties involved, and society itself is poorly understood. (Social science is an early stage science, which we strongly support!) We expect most people’s projects in this area to have no effect, and of those that do, many to have effects that are the opposite of what is intended.</p><p>The second danger, or challenge, I should say, is getting people to work together. There are communities that have been thinking about AI for more than a decade, and there are still big disagreements about what is dangerous, and how dangerous, and on what timeframes. Having people work together when they disagree about important things is very difficult, and many of people’s natural impulses for how to do this will be mistaken.</p><p>The third difficulty is getting stuck in narratives around AI, including pessimistic ones. I spoke about hype. There is a lot of hype in this area, and many of the possibilities being considered are quite alarming. Even if one gets people to be able to work together despite disagreement, there’s the danger that people will tilt too negatively overall. It can be hard to think clearly about very dangerous possibilities.</p><p>I will briefly sketch the solutions we’re considering to handle these problems. With respect to the first danger, at least part of our strategy will be to <strong>study the history</strong>. This is what happens when people get serious about causing an effect: they study relevant parts of history. Here, there are a number of examples of how society’s reaction to technology and risk have been shaped through deliberate effort.</p><p>Regarding working together, one important idea we’re exploring is that of <strong>decentralization</strong>. The term “decentralization” may be misleading, because there is a certain amount of centralized structure needed to enable decentralized coordination. There may need to be shared goals or principles; even open source projects have many shared centralized resources they use. Our hope is that there will be some way to reach agreement on enough things that it will be possible to have people coordinate in a less centralized way, even despite disagreement.</p><p>With respect to not getting drawn in by misleading narratives, one thing the institute is doing is making sure we <strong>devote enough of our effort to other things</strong>. We’re never planning to spend more than half of our time on AI; in all likelihood it will be much less. That can help with dealing with potentially misleading narratives or overall pessimism — it’s harder to get sucked in when you’re spending less of your time on it.</p><h3>General Q&amp;A</h3><p>Alright, those are my remarks. Let’s open for general discussion!</p><p><em>— — — break for Q&amp;A — — —</em></p><p><em>To learn more about Leverage, visit our </em><a href="http://leverage.institute/"><em>website</em></a><em>, read our </em><a href="https://medium.com/@LeverageResearch/introduction-to-leverage-research-f3b9bdae983f"><em>Introduction to Leverage series</em></a><em>, or see our </em><a href="https://docs.google.com/document/d/1TrbB28SLWDTutCLhOA7gNmRteIsFUCcdA_1SHV-dFP8/edit#"><em>FAQ</em></a><em>. To contribute to our thinking on strategic topics, join the discussion in our </em><a href="https://t.co/8WWrJ0NHpo"><em>Discord community</em></a><em>.</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*GadHrvia3VNOqjE9.png" /></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=1c2d116ee3d9" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[December 2022 Public Strategy Update]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@LeverageResearch/december-2022-public-strategy-update-226aad5333b?source=rss-a1da96f80887------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/226aad5333b</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[future-technology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[progress]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ideology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[silicon-valley]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[social-movements]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Leverage Research]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 21 Dec 2022 22:29:09 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-12-27T14:43:51.166Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>The following are Executive Director Geoff Anders’ prepared remarks for Leverage’s December 2022 public strategy update, which was held on Friday, December 16 at the Leverage online office. Audio of actual remarks and Q&amp;A is linked just below; actual remarks followed prepared remarks pretty closely.</em></p><p><em>Leverage’s strategy presentations are about the institute’s perspective on the current events and societal forces that impact our work. For readers interested in a general introduction to Leverage Research, please see our </em><a href="https://medium.com/@LeverageResearch/introduction-to-leverage-research-f3b9bdae983f"><em>Introduction to Leverage Research</em></a><em> essay, our </em><a href="http://www.leverageresearch.org/"><em>website</em></a><em>, and a description of our </em><a href="https://www.leverageresearch.org/research"><em>programs</em></a><em>.</em></p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fw.soundcloud.com%2Fplayer%2F%3Furl%3Dhttps%253A%252F%252Fapi.soundcloud.com%252Ftracks%252F1406845399%26show_artwork%3Dtrue&amp;display_name=SoundCloud&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fsoundcloud.com%2Fcontact-us-69745589%2Fleverage-strategy-update-audio-recording-dec-16-2022%3Fsi%3De06854bce5e9418f8bcc74c1739d560d%26utm_source%3Dclipboard%26utm_medium%3Dtext%26utm_campaign%3Dsocial_sharing&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi1.sndcdn.com%2Fartworks-LZxzDc5sl00qXZ5p-Ylpx8g-t500x500.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=soundcloud" width="800" height="166" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/795abf7f59fdc03423a41a290c57ae7e/href">https://medium.com/media/795abf7f59fdc03423a41a290c57ae7e/href</a></iframe><h3>Introductory Remarks</h3><p>Welcome to Leverage Research’s second public strategy update. This update will build on the previous update, which was given in June of this year. If you’d like to review the material from that, we have an <a href="https://docs.google.com/document/d/1H4uKqjNlAc7l35kTb5F4BQv1_ORPbpcmvgpEu1pjAh4/edit#">internal strategy document</a> which we have made available, as well as the text of my <a href="https://medium.com/@LeverageResearch/june-2022-public-strategy-update-ce50a172c677">prepared remarks</a> for the public presentation, as well as <a href="https://make.headliner.app/download/f76d1bcd-c115-4f02-8b43-dadd834ae1f6?source=user-export-email&amp;_branch_match_id=970698573950414375&amp;utm_source=email&amp;utm_medium=video-detail&amp;_branch_referrer=H4sIAAAAAAAAAw3LUQ6DIBAFwBOtSEUlTZqeZWEfgcQWsqDp8ev8Tx6j9acxPbNiymA5yhc6cWvmKoJKgsHlMGnfxIYoFK1dyaX5QT64hYRF/OIYNm3vXk%2BNeJ0dSvi1qoPwufcfIw7ma2YAAAA%3D">audio of the presentation</a> itself. <em>(Editor’s note: These links are for the June 2022 public strategy update.)</em></p><p>If you weren’t there, or haven’t read up on Leverage’s strategy previously, don’t worry — I will summarize some of the ideas from last time and also there will be a Q&amp;A after this presentation.</p><p>We have one hour for today’s presentation. I expect to spend about thirty minutes presenting, with interspersed Q&amp;A. I’ll then open up for general Q&amp;A, which will take another thirty minutes. For those interested in further, less formal discussion, I invite all of you to join me in the Leverage Discord after the general Q&amp;A, for another thirty minutes of informal discussion.</p><p>With respect to the Q&amp;A, we very much want people to understand Leverage’s perspective and approach to positive impact. As a result, please feel free to ask anything that relates to Leverage that you think will help you understand the institute’s perspective better. If your questions pertain to what I’ve just presented, then feel free to raise those when I pause for questions. If your questions or comments are more general, those are also welcome, though I would ask that you keep those for the general Q&amp;A.</p><p>We’re going to be recording the presentation and the interspersed Q&amp;A sections, as well as the general Q&amp;A. If you have questions that you would prefer to not have recorded, we invite you to raise those during the informal Discord discussion afterwards, which will not be recorded.</p><p>In terms of how to use Gather, you can press 6 to raise your hand. People can keep their mics muted unless speaking, in which case unmute. You can also ask questions in the chat, where you should make sure it’s set to “Everyone” so everyone can see the question you ask.</p><h3>General Strategy</h3><h4>Understanding Human Nature</h4><p>In our first update, I talked about Leverage’s original plan and the idea of <strong>differential technological progress</strong>.</p><p>The essence of this idea is that <strong>when</strong> different areas of science and technology are developed can depend on the actions of individuals and small groups. As a result, it is possible for individuals and small groups to affect humanity’s overall trajectory by helping to determine the <strong>order</strong> in which technologies are developed.</p><p>Leverage’s first foundational research program, into psychology and human nature, was based on this idea. It is often observed that humanity’s power has grown more quickly than its wisdom. It was our aim, through that research project, to understand human nature better so as to understand how humanity’s wisdom could be increased and its power safely amplified. With greater wisdom, our idea was that humanity would be better equipped to handle the scientific and technological power it has acquired and the new power it will acquire in the future.</p><h4>Recognizing Human Goodness</h4><p>This original research project yielded a number of important insights that have shaped our subsequent efforts.</p><p>First among these is the claim that humanity is good. This may seem like a surprising claim, for a number of reasons. First, it is a very blunt claim on a very large topic. It may seem difficult to be able to make claims like this. Second, it sounds like it is an evaluative claim. Research is often thought to aim at making positive claims, i.e., claims about how things are, rather than evaluative claims, i.e., claims about whether things are good or bad.</p><p>With respect to the latter, the idea that humanity is good breaks down into a number of more basic ideas. The first pertains to human goals. Humanity is often thought of as selfish or self-motivated, greedy or profit-motivated, hateful or petty, or worse, sinful and corrupt. Through our research, we found that people have instrumental goals which chain down to basic goals. Those basic goals, as far as we could see, were the same or similar, and were what one might commonsensically think of as “good” or “neutral” — and also compatible with one another.</p><p>Rather than status or power or a jumble of automated reflexes, we found that people were aiming, at the most basic level, at flourishing, connection, and acceptance. In some cases this manifested locally, in the pursuit of loving and connected human relationships and friendships. In some cases this manifested globally, in the pursuit of universal flourishing and interconnection. Our researchers differed on the details of what the basic goals were, but all of the views supported the idea that humanity’s goals are basically fine.</p><p>Of course, humankind is selfish and greedy, hateful and petty, and possibly much, much worse, at least at times. What we found was that the problems in human nature pertained not the goals that people had, but to how people expected to achieve those goals.</p><p>With respect to people’s plans, and how they expected to achieve their goals, we found a shocking degree of human dysfunction. It would not be an exaggeration to say that it was traumatic for our researchers to see stark representations of mental structures, where you could see where people did not care about each other, where they were planning to hurt each other, and where their minds were tangled in horrible knots of irrational fear and self-justification.</p><p>Nevertheless, despite the difficulty of looking at these mental structures, we found, to our great relief, that the problematic mental structures were shiftable, that people could change, and that what appeared to be problems in human nature could be addressed, if approached correctly.</p><p>With good or neutral goals, and a great degree of improvability and correctability, it remained to assess the overall situation of humanity to determine whether people are likely to be an instrument in the creation of their own positive future, or if human nature is turned against itself in a way that means that humanity is best factored out.</p><p>It is difficult to make a judgment on this last point, but from everything we have seen we are optimistic. Thus the idea that humanity is good amounts to this: that humans have good or neutral goals, that these goals are compatible, that the problems arise from how those goals are expected to be achieved, that these expectations and plans can be modified, that humanity can thus be improved if approached properly, and that there are great prospects for humanity to play a central and positive role in the creation of a future good for itself.</p><h4>Increasing Human Wisdom</h4><p>A second important conclusion we reached pertained to the value of public engagement. After the dissolution of the first project, Leverage reformed, now with a much greater focus on public engagement and communication.</p><p>The value of public engagement was first recognized in the spring of 2019, prior to dissolution. This lesson was reinforced after dissolution, both by feedback we received and by our own experiences starting to communicate with the public.</p><p>This lesson, however, is not complete. In recent times we have come to believe that beyond mere engagement, one of the essential means by which humanity will come to have greater wisdom is through communication and discussion, in both public and private contexts, about important issues — including how to guide our own technological future.</p><p>Thus we have reached at length what may seem like a very natural conclusion, which is that humanity’s wisdom might be increased through public and private discussion and engagement. This <em>is</em> a natural conclusion, though it is certainly not believed by everyone.</p><p>Hence, we expect that Leverage’s strategy going forward will include not only clear communication, but the attempt to educate and inform individuals and the public in a way that conduces to their greater wisdom. We expect this aim to be greatly served by our Exploratory Psychology research program, where we have began open-sourcing the mental tools and techniques we developed, and inviting people to join an external community of researchers interested in exploring and studying the mind.</p><p>If anyone here is interested in learning more about our psychology research or being part of our external research community, please speak to Kerry Vaughan, who is in charge of our <a href="https://www.leverageresearch.org/exploratory-psychology">Exploratory Psychology</a> program. We have recently released a bunch of material pertaining to our psychology research, including the first step for new researchers, which is to learn about an introspective method called belief reporting.</p><h4>The Role of Supporting Projects</h4><p>In addition to <strong>increasing public understanding</strong> in order to increase its wisdom, Leverage has also, since its inception, recognized the value of <strong>supporting projects</strong>. Research does not happen on its own, or at least, it does not always. When it happens, research is also not automatically distributed to the right people or organizations. Thus much research that should happen does not, and much research that should have an impact only does so much more slowly than we would want.</p><p>As part of this, Leverage has found it valuable to run supporting projects, aimed at communicating some truth, or developing some resource, or causing some other relevant change. The primary example of this thus far in the institute’s history is its decision to support the early growth of the Effective Altruism movement. We expect that there will be other examples in the institute’s future.</p><h4>Summary of General Strategy</h4><p>From our June strategy update and this one, we can say that Leverage’s strategy for impact includes:</p><ul><li><strong>increasing public understanding</strong>, so as to increase humanity’s wisdom overall</li><li><strong>causing differential progress</strong> in scientific and technological areas, so that humanity gets develops knowledge and power in a sequence that better accords with its wisdom, and</li><li><strong>running supporting projects</strong>, in order to make sure that research that is done ends up having the impact it should.</li></ul><p>Now is a good time to break for the first Q&amp;A.</p><h4>Brief Q&amp;A</h4><p><em>— — — break for Q&amp;A — — —</em></p><h3>The Strategic Landscape</h3><p>I described part of the strategic landscape, as we see it, in the last strategy presentation. For today, I’m going to cover some additions to that picture. When we get to time for questions, please feel free to ask about anything from that picture or what I talk about today.</p><p>We also have a <a href="https://docs.google.com/document/d/1c8PlNUaG_OMk6BRj5vKxuNct-MVMQg8MUFPqfEal_cM/edit">new internal strategy document</a> available. <em>(Editor’s note: This link is for the December 2022 public strategy update.)</em></p><h4>Overarching Narratives</h4><p>One part of the strategic landscape that I did not talk about last time is the narrative landscape. We live in a memetic environment composed of many narratives. These narratives overlap and criss-cross in a variety of ways.</p><p>I think it’s important to be even-handed on the topic of narratives: narratives often simplify and mislead, but on the other hand, without narratives it can be very hard to understand anything at all.</p><p>For this update, we discussed two narratives which are likely to be familiar to people in Silicon Valley and the surrounding diaspora. The first pertains to progress, the second to the future.</p><p>With respect to progress, the standard narrative is that humanity has made substantial scientific and technological progress over the last several centuries, that this progress has been extremely good, that we need more progress of this type, that people oppose progress much more than they should, and that they oppose progress because they don’t understand how important or good the progress has been.</p><p>We think this narrative is true on some counts, but incorrect or inaccurate on others. It is true that humanity has made substantial scientific and technological progress over the last several centuries. It is true this has been extremely good in a number of ways, and also that we need more progress. However, we think that scientific and technological progress has also been bad in a number of ways and that people know this. People are, in our view, much more pro-technology, pro-science, and pro-progress than is commonly recognized. But they also understand ways in which science and technology has caused problems, and they don’t like being misled. Developers and proponents of new science and technology are rarely honest and straightforward about the harms and potential downsides of new developments, and we think this leads to a lot of resistance.</p><p>With respect to the future, the standard narrative, at least in Silicon Valley, is that a robot future is coming. We may merge with machines, or plug into the Metaverse, or upload ourselves to the Internet, or turn the world over to a superhuman AI. The narrative is that this future is coming, that it is inevitable, that it is good, and that the people building the future are happy about it.</p><p>We now suspect that this narrative is false on almost every count. The key observation here is that these visions are essentially <em>escapist</em>: we’re getting rid of our messy biological brains, or leaving our fragile bodies behind, or replacing ourselves with AIs, or literally getting in a spaceship and leaving the Earth.</p><p>Escapism can be fun and has its place. But it’s a bad foundation for science and technology projects. This helps to explain why many of the more future-oriented science and technology projects end up not working: it’s hard to think realistically about the technologies you’re developing if you really don’t want to be in the circumstance you’re in.</p><p>Our view is that the Silicon Valley-style future is actually pessimistic, rather than optimistic, that it’s not inevitable, that the people who are supposed to be creating it are frequently demotivated, precisely because the future isn’t a good one, and that the best prospects for a science and technology-enhanced future lie elsewhere.</p><h4>Nearby Ideologies</h4><p>Another aspect of the strategic landscape are the ideologies that occupy it. Ideologies are a particular thing, a particular mental and social technology, and a lot can be said about them. For now, I’ll just talk about four of the ideologies and what we think is happening with them.</p><p><em>Mathematical Scientism.</em> There is an ideology that I have been tracking for a number of years now. It pertains to atomization, the legitimization of impersonal authority, the delegitimization of personal authority, and the predominance of a particular form of knowledge — mathematical scientific <em>episteme</em>. For now, I am calling it “Mathematical Scientism,” though you’ll get much of the idea if you think of the name “Science™.”</p><p>There’s a long history here and this is quite difficult to describe, but the primary update is that I now think that this ideology has lost a lot of its motive force, that the general trends powering it have burned out, and that what is left is just momentum from before.</p><p>Since this is a different and unusual topic, I’d be happy to answer questions about it in the Q&amp;A.</p><p><em>Social Justice.</em> With social justice, we need to distinguish the idea itself from the ideology. With regard to the idea, the idea is that groups, including those that have been defined by race and gender, have been treated badly historically, continue to be treated badly now, and that this should be addressed, thereby bringing about greater social justice. The ideology surrounding this, which has been popular over the last several years, is characterized by the more forceful push for progress on topics of social justice.</p><p>Overall, the read here is that social justice as an ideology made some advances, including getting much broader acceptance for the concept of structural racism, but that now its proponents have radicalized in a way that has alienated a lot of the larger population. As far as I can tell, the power and reach of this ideology is now on the decline.</p><p><em>Effective Altruism.</em> Many members of the audience here will be familiar with Effective Altruism, which has been in the spotlight recently, so I won’t rehash the details. The main developments here have been the public debut of EA, which took place with the EA Time Magazine cover and the profile of Will MacAskill in the New Yorker, and then the FTX collapse and disgrace of EA mega-donor Sam Bankman-Fried.</p><p>EA is now in a very tough spot. There is very strong competition among ideologies to be accepted into society, and now that EA has a severe and visible weakness, there will be substantial attempts to push it out. We’re basically seeing this with all of the commentary tying Sam Bankman-Fried to EA and using this to showcase EA’s flaws.</p><p>The main choice here is whether EA mounts a good defense. EA’s strength has been moral authority. This is a resource it has developed over many years. That moral authority is called into question by the FTX debacle and by leaders’ lack of response to it. EA leaders will either give a convincing response soon, or the EA movement will end, with the EA community contracting. The EA community would then continue to exist but go into slow decline, and the same will be true of the EA ideology.</p><p><em>LessWrong Rationalism.</em> Some but not all will be familiar with the LessWrong community, and with LessWrong Rationalism in particular. This is essentially a group of people who are interested in improving their ways of thinking, especially modeling their cognition after imagined ideal agents, for the purpose of being able to deal with the potential risk of near-term artificial superintelligence.</p><p>The big update is short timelines. For some reason, which hasn’t become totally clear, a number of the key people in the LessWrong Rationalist set came to believe that the world will be destroyed by artificial general intelligence soon. We don’t think that’s true, and it would be good if the people involved would display their reasoning on the matter. In the meantime, we think the doom mentality has negative effects on people inside and outside the group, including researchers, and has negative effects overall on the field of AI safety.</p><h4>Brief Q&amp;A</h4><p>— — — break for Q&amp;A — — —</p><h3>Expected Developments &amp; New Challenges</h3><p>We like to make predictions. Energy for movements not going into EA, will go into new movements. There’s a general pessimism that people seem to have about the future, manifested most clearly in the lack of optimistic, realistic science fiction.</p><p>We expect this pessimism will be overcome, and that one of the important vehicles for this will be a new movement.</p><p>I’ll leave the rest for the general Q&amp;A.</p><h3>General Q&amp;A</h3><p>— — — break for Q&amp;A — — —</p><p><em>If you want to learn more about Leverage Research’s perspective, you can find notes, internal documents, and audio recordings of all of our strategy updates </em><a href="https://leverage-research.notion.site/LR-Strategic-Landscape-Updates-d6eae1393f0145f18879b7f20d49c7d1"><em>here</em></a><em>.</em></p><p><em>If you’ve found the topics discussed in this post interesting and would like to contribute to our thinking, join the discussion in our </em><a href="https://t.co/8WWrJ0NHpo"><em>Discord community</em></a><em>.</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*sBtiOhJ9fzTM100KCVSRsw.png" /><figcaption>Screenshot of Leverage December 2022 Public Strategy Update in our Gather office</figcaption></figure><figure><a href="http://leverageresearch.org/"><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*0eX6scQE36RBvlKEcOYSdQ.png" /></a></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=226aad5333b" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Publications and Background Information]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@LeverageResearch/publications-and-background-information-560917742abd?source=rss-a1da96f80887------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/560917742abd</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[leverage-research]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Leverage Research]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 13 Aug 2022 21:39:03 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-11-30T00:54:35.202Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>Leverage Research — reference series</em></p><h3>Learn About Leverage Research</h3><p>This page is a repository of links to Leverage Research’s published research, institute communications, and related materials. If there is something missing from this page, please <a href="https://docs.google.com/forms/d/e/1FAIpQLSe91ddQAh33Rj9W9C35au6u3jKSvmzXs-g3zv07S4zNLC4-_Q/viewform">let us know</a>.</p><h4>Available Research</h4><p><em>History of Science</em></p><ul><li>General Information<br> — <a href="https://www.leverageresearch.org/_files/ugd/1f8f94_dd8bfb4d70bf43e6a6c536c8dcc832f9.pdf">Program Introduction</a></li><li>Gilbert and the Discovery of ‘Electricks’<br> — <a href="https://www.leverageresearch.org/_files/ugd/51c82b_2608b0accce645a380432170e96e156b.pdf">Case Study</a><br> — <a href="https://www.leverageresearch.org/_files/ugd/51c82b_4a0a06e23299489fb4415c6413c03cd1.pdf">Research Highlights</a></li><li>Franklinian Theory<br> — <a href="https://www.leverageresearch.org/_files/ugd/51c82b_0308802b14504a4ea7ce3e245bae92f0.pdf">Case Study</a><br> — <a href="https://www.leverageresearch.org/_files/ugd/51c82b_5f918f707fb944e18e92a60fa142610d.pdf">Research Highlights</a></li><li>The Leyden Jar<br> — <a href="https://www.leverageresearch.org/_files/ugd/51c82b_fa2f2bde9b6d48e7a6b9edc4d1128591.pdf">Case Study</a><br> — <a href="https://static.wixstatic.com/media/51c82b_89326f673fab43f1a4018a9d538e261a~mv2.png/v1/fill/w_125,h_161,al_c,q_85,usm_0.66_1.00_0.01,enc_auto/Leyden%20Jar%20Highlights%20First%20Page%20Image_p.png">Research Highlights</a><br> — <a href="https://www.leverageresearch.org/_files/ugd/51c82b_afa220f527f24791bc94b34f655e023a.pdf">Translation of Kleist Letters</a></li><li>Volta and the Electrophorus<br> — <a href="https://www.leverageresearch.org/research-voltas-electrophorus">Case Study</a><br> — <a href="https://www.leverageresearch.org/_files/ugd/51c82b_4ed464040c8c4501b59a8e336e2e5eb7.pdf">Research Highlights</a></li><li>Ørsted and Electromagnetism<br> — <a href="https://www.leverageresearch.org/research-electromagnetism">Case Study</a><br> — <a href="https://www.leverageresearch.org/_files/ugd/51c82b_dd9bf581e3fe4ff58e9e137563ae39e8.pdf">Research Highlights</a></li></ul><p><em>Exploratory Psychology</em></p><ul><li>General Information<br> — <a href="https://www.leverageresearch.org/exploratory-psychology">Program Overview</a></li><li>Open-source Introspection Tools<br> — <a href="https://www.leverageresearch.org/exploratory-psychology-introspection-safety">Introspection Safety for Researchers</a><br> — <a href="https://www.leverageresearch.org/exploratory-psychology-belief-reporting">Introduction to Belief Reporting</a><br>— <a href="https://www.leverageresearch.org/chart-logic">Chart Logic &amp; Core Mechanics</a></li><li>Nonverbal Information<br> — <a href="https://www.leverageresearch.org/_files/ugd/51c82b_b0866b2594954a7aadc1863d511ea1dd.pdf">On Intention Research</a><br> — <a href="https://www.leverageresearch.org/_files/ugd/51c82b_8c470a93a70e4ab987b1e6f2f769b069.pdf">The Muscle-Readers, a Historical Sketch</a> <em>— also under review at Seeds of Science</em></li></ul><p><em>Bottlenecks in Science and Technology</em></p><ul><li>Bottlenecks 2021<br> — <a href="https://docs.google.com/document/d/1vuvg9hhUiYJBprlSRv9BOzdEAMZD79n0O77l90UaS9c/">Summary and Review</a><br> — <a href="https://nintil.com/bottlenecks-workshop">Co-organizer write-up</a><br> — <a href="https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCDa-ljRkT2wSnC7himKyV7Q">Bottlenecks Presentations</a> (YouTube Channel)</li></ul><p><em>Other Research</em></p><ul><li>Consensus Research<br> — <a href="https://docs.google.com/document/d/1nR1kIyanifMhPoiYMtNwFxZui6PJdXiYt2IdWsrQp-k/edit?usp=sharing">Argument Mapping</a><br> — <a href="https://docs.google.com/document/d/1Ca-HUwiH7Q-yRfcDUCc8uPUNtcbrqxlsG2u0XZNVjbM/edit#heading=h.yqoi0yqc61n0">Intellectual Practice Examination</a><br> — <a href="https://docs.google.com/document/d/1TCOWf9jOzPd0h4tcD1emGsltDPgnHVWL6arUdcUlkcA/edit?usp=sharing">Enhanced Discourse Norms: Intellectual Processes</a></li><li>Intelligence Amplification Research<br> — <a href="https://docs.google.com/document/d/1vwBhkKNvAJ8z4ogrqIX-AtfpV89Uu9-5MXw9AilDFfE/edit?usp=sharing">Intelligence Amplification Map</a></li></ul><h4>Institute Communication</h4><p><em>Basics</em></p><ul><li>Programs (on website)<br> — <a href="https://www.leverageresearch.org/history-of-science">History of Science</a> — program description and research<br> — <a href="https://www.leverageresearch.org/exploratory-psychology">Exploratory Psychology</a> — program description, research, and history<br> — <a href="https://www.leverageresearch.org/bottlenecks">Bottlenecks in Science and Technology</a> — program description</li><li>Introduction to Leverage Medium Series<br> — <a href="https://medium.com/@LeverageResearch/introduction-to-leverage-research-f3b9bdae983f">Introduction to Leverage Research</a><br> — <a href="https://medium.com/@LeverageResearch/our-current-programs-11c423f8987b">Our Current Programs</a><br> — <a href="https://medium.com/@LeverageResearch/challenges-we-face-91e9c3ef2daa">Challenges We Face</a></li></ul><p><em>Strategy</em></p><ul><li>Public Strategy Update, June 2022<br> — <a href="https://medium.com/@LeverageResearch/june-2022-public-strategy-update-ce50a172c677">Public update prepared remarks</a><br> — <a href="https://make.headliner.app/download/f76d1bcd-c115-4f02-8b43-dadd834ae1f6?source=user-export-email&amp;_branch_match_id=970698573950414375&amp;utm_source=email&amp;utm_medium=video-detail&amp;_branch_referrer=H4sIAAAAAAAAAw3LUQ6DIBAFwBOtSEUlTZqeZWEfgcQWsqDp8ev8Tx6j9acxPbNiymA5yhc6cWvmKoJKgsHlMGnfxIYoFK1dyaX5QT64hYRF/OIYNm3vXk%2BNeJ0dSvi1qoPwufcfIw7ma2YAAAA%3D">Public update audio</a><br> — <a href="https://docs.google.com/document/d/1H4uKqjNlAc7l35kTb5F4BQv1_ORPbpcmvgpEu1pjAh4/edit">Internal strategy document</a></li></ul><p><em>Inquiries</em></p><ul><li><a href="https://www.leverageresearch.org/inquiry-report-april-2022">Experiences Inquiry</a> — results of an independent inquiry in 2021 into the experiences of former team members as part of the Leverage research collaboration (2011–2019)</li></ul><p><em>Messages from Executive Director</em></p><ul><li><a href="https://mailchi.mp/leverageresearch/2021-year-in-review">Dec 2021–2021 Year in Review</a></li><li><a href="https://mailchi.mp/leverageresearch/2021-thanksgiving-message">Nov 2021 — Thanksgiving Message</a></li><li><a href="https://www.leverageresearch.org/_files/ugd/51c82b_d6106e56d3024fbc9d196773318cf4a8.pdf">Nov 2021 — Reports of Negative Experiences</a></li></ul><p><em>Newsletters and Updates</em></p><ul><li>2022<br>— <a href="https://mailchi.mp/leverageresearch/newsletter-giving-tuesday-2022">Giving Tuesday Message 2022</a><br>— <a href="http://eepurl.com/idO93j">Q3 2022 Newsletter</a><br> — <a href="https://mailchi.mp/leverageresearch/newsletter-q2-2022">Q2 2022 Newsletter</a><br> — <a href="https://mailchi.mp/leverageresearch/strategy-presentation-june-2022">June 2022 – Public Strategy Presentation Update</a><br> — <a href="https://mailchi.mp/leverageresearch/newsletter-q1-2022">Q1 2022 Newsletter</a><br> — <a href="https://mailchi.mp/leverageresearch/inquiry-report-and-intention-research-update-april-2022">April 2022 — Inquiry Report and Intention Research Update</a></li><li><em>2021<br> </em>— <a href="https://mailchi.mp/leverageresearch/newsletter-q4-2021">Q4 2021 Newsletter</a><br> — <a href="https://mailchi.mp/leverageresearch/2021-winter-holiday-message">December 2021 — Happy Holidays from Leverage Research</a><br> — <a href="https://mailchi.mp/leverageresearch/giving-tuesday-2021-winter-fundraiser">November 2021 — Giving Tuesday</a><br> — <a href="https://mailchi.mp/leverageresearch/newsletter-q3-2021">Q3 2021 Newsletter</a><br> — <a href="https://mailchi.mp/leverageresearch/newsletter-q3-10567197">October 2021 — AMA at Leverage Virtual Office</a><br> — <a href="https://mailchi.mp/leverageresearch/newsletter-q3-10319093">Q2 2021 Newsletter</a><br> — <a href="https://mailchi.mp/leverageresearch/newsletter-q3-10137453">Q1 2021 Newsletter</a></li><li><em>2020<br> — </em><a href="https://mailchi.mp/leverageresearch/newsletter-q3-9516053">Q4 2020 Newsletter</a><br> — <a href="https://mailchi.mp/leverageresearch/newsletter-q3-2020">Q3 2020 Newsletter</a></li></ul><p><em>Inside Leverage Research</em></p><ul><li><a href="https://leverageresearch.substack.com/">Inside Leverage Substack</a></li><li><a href="https://discord.com/invite/6VZRdq8HrN">Leverage Discord community</a></li></ul><p><em>Social Media</em></p><ul><li><a href="https://twitter.com/leverageres">Twitter</a></li><li><a href="https://www.facebook.com/LeverageResearch/">Facebook</a></li><li><a href="https://www.linkedin.com/company/leverage-research">LinkedIn</a></li><li><a href="https://medium.com/@LeverageResearch">Medium</a></li></ul><p><em>Community Relations</em></p><ul><li>Leverage and Effective Altruism — <a href="https://forum.effectivealtruism.org/posts/hkAYutkaMkqg4ooo4/updates-from-leverage-research-history-mistakes-and-new">Updates from Leverage Research: history, mistakes, and new focus</a></li><li>Leverage and Rationality — <a href="https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/3GgoJ2nCj8PiD4FSi/updates-from-leverage-research-history-and-recent-progress">Updates from Leverage Research: History and Recent Progress</a>, <a href="https://www.dropbox.com/s/p0nah8ulohypexe/1.%20Leverage%20History%20%231%20-%202021-10-23%20-%20Rationality%20Community%20-%20with%20Anna%20Salamon.m4a?dl=0">Conversation with Geoff Anders and Anna Salamon</a></li></ul><p><em>Annual Reports</em></p><ul><li><a href="https://www.leverageresearch.org/annual-report-2019-2020">Annual Report 2019–2020</a></li><li><a href="https://www.leverageresearch.org/annual-report-2021">Annual Report 2021</a></li></ul><h4>Related Media and Essays</h4><p><em>Podcasts</em></p><ul><li>Geoff Anders<br> — <a href="https://podcasts.apple.com/gb/podcast/geoff-anders-technological-breakthroughs-ai-tomorrow/id1594759881?i=1000545191261">Technological Breakthroughs</a> — <em>AI Tomorrow<br> </em>— <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cV0mUqhfrio">Knowledge and its Role in Society</a> — <em>Futurati<br> </em>— <a href="https://narrativespodcast.com/2021/04/20/38-research-knowledge-and-decay-with-geoff-anders/">Research, Knowledge, and Decay</a> — <em>Narratives Podcast<br> </em>— <a href="https://clearerthinkingpodcast.com/?ep=018">Scientific Progress and the Replication Crisis</a> — <em>Clearer Thinking<br> </em>— <a href="https://pattersoninpursuit.libsyn.com/ep-102-scientific-progress-and-intellectual-schelling-points-dr-geoff-anders">Scientific Progress and Intellectual Schelling Points</a> — <em>Patterson in Pursuit</em></li><li>Kerry Vaughan<br> — <a href="https://radiopublic.com/the-knowledge-archives-WDVPA9/s1!67e7b">An Inventor’s Tale: The History of Electricity</a> — <em>The Knowledge Archive<br> </em>— <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iMZzCPRrtQ8">The History of Science and Building Intellectual Generative Communities</a> — <em>Futurati</em></li></ul><p><em>Essays</em></p><ul><li>Geoff Anders<br> — Research and Knowledge Accumulation essay series:<br> - <a href="https://geoffanders.medium.com/a-problem-with-research-60e48506a9f7">Part 1: A Problem With Research?</a><br> - <a href="https://geoffanders.medium.com/how-to-understand-research-productivity-dc526a6a8b3e">Part 2: How to Understand Research Productivity</a><br> - <a href="https://geoffanders.medium.com/knowledge-preservation-and-decay-b82530991b71">Part 3: Knowledge Preservation and Decay</a><br> - <a href="https://geoffanders.medium.com/intellectual-schelling-points-bb25c993a82a">Part 4: Intellectual Schelling Points</a><br> - <a href="https://geoffanders.medium.com/the-endurance-of-research-programs-b85513b5c08f">Part 5: The Endurance of Research Programs</a></li></ul><p><em>Experiences of Our Previous Research Collaboration (2011–2019)</em></p><ul><li>Cathleen — <a href="https://cathleensdiscoveries.com/LivingLifeWell/in-defense-of-attempting-hard-things"><em>In Defense of Attempting Hard Things</em></a>, the most extensive and accurate account of Leverage Research published thus far, covering 2012–2019</li><li>Jonathan — <a href="https://www.facebook.com/jonathan.wallis.714/posts/1802447699947196"><em>Leverage Research: Context, Analysis, and Takeaway</em></a>, another account of Leverage Research, covering 2017–2019 and extending into 2020</li><li>Zoe — <a href="https://medium.com/@zoecurzi/my-experience-with-leverage-research-17e96a8e540b"><em>My Experience with Geoff Anders and Leverage Research</em></a>, the initial account which sparked the Experiences Inquiry, covering 2017–2019; while we believe the author had genuine negative experiences, the institute disputes this account on much of the substance and implication</li></ul><h3>In the Works</h3><p>In addition to the above materials, Leverage Research also has other publications and public presentations of information pending.</p><p><em>History of Science</em></p><ul><li>Case studies<br> — Electric Light and Fire <em>(in development)</em></li><li>Publications<br> — “Closing the Loop: Ewald von Kleist and the Origins of the Leyden Jar” <em>(forthcoming in Isis)<br> </em>— “Three Letters on the Discovery of the Leyden Jar” <em>(forthcoming in Lias)</em></li></ul><p><em>Exploratory Psychology</em></p><ul><li>Introspection Safety for Researchers <em>(in development)</em></li></ul><p><em>Institute Communications</em></p><ul><li><a href="https://docs.google.com/document/d/1TrbB28SLWDTutCLhOA7gNmRteIsFUCcdA_1SHV-dFP8/edit#">Leverage FAQ</a> <em>(draft) </em>— Frequently Asked Questions on the institute, past and present.</li></ul><h3>Learn More</h3><p>Read more about the institute through our Introduction to Leverage Research essay series:</p><ul><li><a href="https://medium.com/p/f3b9bdae983f/">Introduction to Leverage Research</a></li><li><a href="https://medium.com/@LeverageResearch/our-current-programs-11c423f8987b">Our Current Programs</a></li><li><a href="https://medium.com/@LeverageResearch/challenges-we-face-91e9c3ef2daa">Challenges We Face</a></li></ul><p><em>More essays coming soon:</em></p><ul><li>Our Strategy for Impact</li><li>Join the Team!</li></ul><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=560917742abd" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Challenges We Face]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@LeverageResearch/challenges-we-face-91e9c3ef2daa?source=rss-a1da96f80887------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/91e9c3ef2daa</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[leverage-research]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Leverage Research]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 13 Aug 2022 21:11:18 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-08-13T21:11:18.938Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>An essay in the Leverage Introduction series</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*PF7mfVLe6NpuuVfb" /></figure><h3><strong>Understanding the Obstacles</strong></h3><p>In its work, Leverage Research faces surprising obstacles and difficult challenges. To meet these challenges, we have developed an internal culture and set of attitudes that thus far has proven valuable.</p><p>While difficulties and challenges are often unique, there are three broad classifications that we find useful in thinking about what we need to do in order to succeed, whether that be in our research or public communication efforts. These broad classes include <em>complicated puzzles</em>, <em>difficult unifications</em>, and dealing with <em>steadfast opposition</em>.</p><h4>Complicated Puzzles</h4><p>The puzzles and problems we work on frequently involve many factors, each of which is important and needs to be understood thoroughly. Below we describe a few examples.</p><p><em>Counterfactual causal pictures.</em> In our <a href="https://www.leverageresearch.org/history-of-science">history of science</a> case studies, our primary aim is to determine what led to a particular breakthrough or discovery in the history of science. This picture needs to be accurate and ideally has counterfactual significance, i.e., it tells us something about how things could have gone differently. Producing an accurate and potentially counterfactually informative picture, however, can involve thinking about a large number of elements, including physical, economic, social, psychological, and conceptual factors. We do not take an approach where we assume <em>a priori</em> that one or another type of factor broadly dominates; our Ørsted study found a role for Kantian philosophy, while our current study on electric light and fire is finding a role for the printing press, economic development underpinning the rise of craft traditions, and the special physical properties of glass.</p><p><em>Public introspective research.</em> Through our <a href="https://www.leverageresearch.org/exploratory-psychology">Exploratory Psychology program</a>, we are now creating an external community of researchers who will engage in introspective research using some of the tools and practices from our previous research. We expect this to be a complex challenge. Researchers will need to speak with one another in order to cross-check results. Introspective research, however, can frequently produce surprising data, and researchers may reasonably prefer to keep some results private. This yields a challenge: how can we safeguard researcher comfort and privacy while enabling adequate information to be shared? Furthermore, we expect some amount of data will need to be shared publicly, which complicates the equation further. We thus expect that success in this program will involve carefully understanding, balancing, and navigating a large number of factors.</p><p><em>Coordination challenges.</em> We believe that ambitious research projects often depend on many parties in order to succeed, including researchers, funders, research program designers, and other groups as well. The events in our <a href="https://www.leverageresearch.org/bottlenecks">Bottlenecks program</a> reflect this, where we bring together an audience with a variety of perspectives, backgrounds, skill sets, and intellectual commitments to discuss related and overlapping aims. This is another example of a complicated puzzle, where both events and research projects go better if relevant parties’ different perspectives and interests can be effectively coordinated.</p><p>These complex problems are illustrative, though certainly do not exhaust or cover the full range of challenges the institute has faced or expects to face in the future. Underlying problems like these, however, there is a common thread, which is the challenge of combining hard-to-unify characteristics and skill sets.</p><h4>Difficult Unifications</h4><p>Solving complicated puzzles, especially of the sort above, involves a type of generalism or interdisciplinarity. Understanding economics <em>and</em> philosophy <em>and </em>material science; balancing privacy/comfort <em>and </em>research productivity <em>and </em>public legibility; working with funders <em>and </em>researchers<em> and </em>institution designers; interacting with both the hard sciences <em>and</em> the soft sciences.</p><p>Since more is frequently better, one might wonder why everyone doesn’t become a generalist or “specialize” in many different things. One answer is that specialization enables greater focus and hence a higher level of achievement. We think this is sometimes the case, but in practice we have found that there are frequently enormous benefits from developing skills in related domains; someone who can think well about economics and philosophy often does better in both. Hence, on a strictly payoff-related basis, we think there is often a strong case for generalism or adding new specialties.</p><p>This leaves a quandary about why interdisciplinary skill sets and approaches are frequently rare. Our answer is that different specialties often involve <em>opposing tendencies</em>. Opposing tendencies are not strictly incompatible, they’re just hard to unify — whether in a single person or a single team.</p><p>Good history of science, for instance, involves both history and philosophy. Historians tend to be more concrete and focus on the facts; philosophers tend to be more abstract and focus on the general ideas. Concreteness and abstractness aren’t incompatible — you can do both — but the things that give people an inclination towards concreteness also often give them a disinclination towards abstractness and vice versa.</p><p>These opposing tendencies show up in many places: people versus things, intellectual versus social, abstract versus concrete. Great interdisciplinary work requires taking steps to overcome these oppositions and unify difficult-to-unify focuses, attitudes, and tendencies of thought. This can take place within an individual who masters multiple specialties or a team that effectively combines individuals with different skill sets.</p><h4>Persistent Opposition</h4><p>If the challenges of our research and communication efforts weren’t enough, the institute also faces opposition. Early in its history, the institute sought collaboration with organizations and individuals in two ideological communities, Effective Altruism and LessWrong. These efforts ultimately failed, and left rivalries that have become increasingly toxic over time.</p><p>The impact on the institute from these rivalries is threefold. The rivalries themselves appear to be ideological in nature, stemming from opposing views of how to improve the world (Effective Altruism) or think and act effectively (LessWrong). Specific conflicts seem to center around competition over talent (Effective Altruism) and funding sources (LessWrong). This then impacts our ability to hire and raise money, and serves as an intermittent (and at times, distressing) distraction.</p><p>During the first many years of the institute’s existence, we took different approaches to opposition and rivalry. At times we have tried to reason with relevant individuals, presuming that differences were superficial and that it was possible to resolve issues of contention through discussion. At other times, we tried broader community outreach, inviting members of the communities and aggrieved individuals to our events. At still other times we have tried disengagement (“haters gonna hate”), and giving the opposition a collective shrug.</p><p>Historically, we have not detected much impact from opposing individuals’ efforts on our hiring and fundraising. In some ways, opposition has made hiring and fundraising more difficult. But in other ways, opposition has fueled notoriety and made it easier for us to raise money and hire talented people. Our first <a href="https://www.leverageresearch.org/2021-winter-fundraiser">public fundraiser</a>, for instance, was successfully completed right after a substantial degree of public drama.</p><p>Nevertheless, opposition has led to negative experiences for our employees. We learned this especially as a result of a <a href="https://www.leverageresearch.org/inquiry-report-april-2022">recent inquiry</a> we did into experiences working on our 2011–2019 research collaboration (see especially p. 20, §9). We have thus resolved to reduce external opposition and support our employees in meeting this opposition as best we can; hence, this is one of the challenges we face.</p><h3>And How To Overcome Them</h3><p>To face these challenges and others like them, the institute has developed a culture suited to the execution of complex, long-term, ambitious projects. This culture combines a variety of virtues, including thoughtfulness, patience, energy, and ambition. Each of these virtues helps us to deal with complicated problems or complex unifications, or help us avoid standard failure modes.</p><p>In addition to virtues, LR has also developed a variety of analytical tools and practices for approaching difficult problems, including conceptual models and problem-solving methods.</p><p>Most of all, however, the institute depends on its people. We expect our people to be strong, resilient, thoughtful, ambitious and, above all, motivated to seek common understanding and make the world better.</p><p>LR’s culture is a work in progress and we’re always seeking to add to our problem-solving repertoire and our understanding of people and the world. We expect to expand on many of our approaches to overcoming difficult challenges as part of future essays.</p><h3>Learn More</h3><p>Please check out the other essays in our Introduction to Leverage Research series:</p><ul><li><a href="https://medium.com/p/f3b9bdae983f/">Introduction to Leverage Research</a></li><li><a href="https://medium.com/@LeverageResearch/our-current-programs-11c423f8987b">Our Current Programs</a></li><li>Challenges We Face <em>(current essay)</em></li></ul><p><em>More essays coming soon:</em></p><ul><li>Our Strategy for Impact</li><li>Join the Team!</li></ul><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=91e9c3ef2daa" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[June 2022 Public Strategy Update]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@LeverageResearch/june-2022-public-strategy-update-ce50a172c677?source=rss-a1da96f80887------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/ce50a172c677</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[positive-impact]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[leverage-research]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[strategy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[science]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Leverage Research]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 01 Jul 2022 20:11:15 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-12-27T14:20:16.212Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>The following are the prepared remarks on Leverage Research’s strategy for positive impact, made by Executive Director Geoff Anders, presented at Leverage’s June 2022 Public Strategy Update on Wednesday, June 29 at the Leverage online office. An audio recording of actual remarks, including initial Q&amp;A sections, is available </em><a href="https://t.co/BMsGQsMT5J"><em>here</em></a>; <em>actual remarks followed prepared remarks fairly closely.</em></p><h3>Introductory Remarks</h3><p>Welcome to Leverage Research’s first public strategy update. We’re looking forward to sharing more and more of our perspective over time. One part of that will be sharing how we think about the world and the strategies we think will be effective in causing positive change.</p><p>We have two hours blocked out for today, though of course we may not end up using the whole time. I’ll start by outlining Leverage’s general strategy for impact and the rationale behind it. I’ll then take questions. Next, I’ll give what will ideally be a short presentation on our overall strategic picture, then brief Q&amp;A again. Finally, I’ll state some concrete expectations about the future, and then talk about some of the challenges we face and how we expect to address those. Then we’ll open up for a general Q&amp;A.</p><p>As far as topics, anything related to Leverage is within bounds, though of course I’d like us to stay pretty close to the topics at hand. We’re going to do an audio recording for the main parts of the presentation. So that people feel free asking whatever questions they would like, we’re not planning to record the general Q&amp;A.</p><p>Since this is the first public strategy presentation I’m giving, it’s possible that some parts may be too long or too short, or not explained well enough. Please feel free to ask questions, including questions like: “Why do you believe X?” or “Could you say X in a different way?” We believe that discussion and argument are often valuable means of reaching the truth, so please also feel free to voice disagreement. For people new to Gather, there’s a button to raise your hand, it’s the emoji button, or you can type questions into the chat. For the chat, make sure it is set to “Everyone” so everyone sees the question you ask.</p><p>We’re providing access to the internal Leverage strategy document this presentation is based on. There’s a link posted in the Gather chat as well as one posted on Twitter. This was not originally written for public presentation, but ended up sufficiently polished that we felt that giving access to it was appropriate. I’ll describe many of the same themes in my presentation, though in a different order and sometimes with different language.</p><h3>General Strategy</h3><h4>The Plan</h4><p>As some will know, Leverage was founded in 2011. At that time, we had a big plan which you can still find on the internet. People generally referred to it as “The Plan.” Essentially it was a description of a research program for making progress in the social sciences, speculation on the potential applications of breakthroughs in the social sciences, and an analysis of the components necessary to make the world much better than it is now.</p><h4>Differential Technological Progress</h4><p>More generally, however, that plan was based on the idea of <strong>differential technological progress</strong>. Over the course of centuries or millennia, we expect humanity to make technological progress. Civilizations rise and fall. The technological height of one era is not necessarily preserved as we move to the next. So we do not believe in monotonic or “linear” technological growth.</p><p>However, as a general pattern in human history, it does appear that new technologies are developed over time, and with them greater understanding of the world in which we live. Sometimes that understanding is called “natural philosophy.” Sometimes it is called “science.”</p><p>There is then a question of whether individual humans, or small groups, can make choices that affect the overall trajectory of technological development. I think the answer is <em>yes</em>. Advances in science and technology are very frequently made by small groups and individuals, and in some cases it is plausible that the advances made are such that without those specific individuals or those specific groups, they would not have occurred otherwise for some number of years.</p><p>An example from our recent study of the history of science is the discovery of electromagnetism. By 1802, there were current-carrying wires with sufficient amperage that if you brought a magnetized needle nearby and ran current through the wire, the current would deflect the magnetic needle and you would have discovered electromagnetism. Electromagnetism was in fact discovered in 1820 by Hans Christian Ørsted, who was investigating hypotheses related to the unity of forces, and saw that when he ran current through a wire, a nearby magnetized needle was disturbed.</p><p>It seems inevitable that once we have batteries, once we have wires with sufficient current, someone somewhere will put a magnetized needle close to a current-carrying wire. It is then surprising and notable that in this case it took 18 years for that to happen.</p><p>Why it took 18 years, what led Ørsted in particular to make the discovery, and some information about why it was not discovered earlier are covered in our <a href="https://www.leverageresearch.org/research-electromagnetism">case study</a> on the discovery of electromagnetism, which is published on the Leverage website.</p><p>This is one simple example where we can imagine that a concerted effort might have led to faster technological progress. Had someone discovered electromagnetism earlier, the entire timeline might have been shifted forward.</p><p>Of course, that’s not necessarily true. It’s quite possible that there were other factors bottlenecking future developments. This is something we hope to ascertain through our <a href="https://www.leverageresearch.org/history-of-science">History of Science</a> program. But the idea should be clear enough: there may be advances, in science or technology, that can be made by small groups or individuals, which can change overall timelines.</p><p>If that is true, then there is a question about which technologies should be developed at which times. It may be beyond the reach of an individual or small group to prevent a technology from being developed at all — that may be the province of humanity as a whole. But it <em>is</em> within reach for individuals and small groups to take steps which change relative timelines.</p><h4>Wisdom and Power</h4><p>From 2011 through 2019, Leverage’s focus was on the social sciences. It is commonly remarked that humanity’s power has grown more quickly than its wisdom, and that this presents us with an increasingly dangerous circumstance over time. Motivated by this thought — and others — we spent substantial time investigating topics in the social sciences, including many aspects of human nature.</p><p>Our hope was that by advancing knowledge of the human mind, of people, individuals and groups, and how they function in societies and social arrangements, that we would be able to benefit the world. This idea — differential technological progress in the social sciences — encapsulates the original Leverage strategy.</p><p>Of course, people often do not think about the social sciences like psychology and sociology as pertaining to <em>technology</em>. “Technology” is often thought to be synonymous with “material technology,” like cars and planes, or “information technology,” like computers. We even use the light bulb to symbolize having an idea. But if we understand technology to refer to the concrete instantiation of <em>techne</em>, or of technical knowledge, then we can imagine mental and social technologies as well.</p><p>The most obvious examples of mental technologies include techniques, like mnemonics for remembering or study skills from skill. The most obvious examples of social technologies include simple social forms, like the handshake; money is another potential example. Effective therapeutic techniques might be mental technologies or mental/social hybrids. The point is that we certainly can think in terms of mental and social technologies, at which point it makes sense to think about differential technological progress in the social sciences.</p><p>On the research dimension, we were exceedingly happy with the results of our research into the social sciences. It is now the work of our <a href="https://www.leverageresearch.org/exploratory-psychology">Exploratory Psychology</a> program to distribute to external researchers the information they need to validate, test, replicate, and ideally extend the results we reached.</p><p>The idea here is that through a better understanding of people, it may be possible for humanity to become wiser, and through increased wisdom better chart a course through the future, making considered choices about which technologies to develop, and how.</p><h4>Science and the Future</h4><p>Leverage reorganized in 2019. At this point we adopted a new focus: <em>early stage science</em>. More generally, we now expect to be focused on questions pertaining to science and the future. Just as there is a fundamental question about humanity’s wisdom to wield its power, there is another important question about how humanity should choose to navigate the technological future.</p><p>Technology is sometimes seen as an inevitable force. Similarly, advances in science can seem like they happen automatically. However, this is not necessarily the case. The history of science shows its contingency, at least with respect to timing and order, and it may be substantially better if humanity chooses to make some advances sooner, others later. In fact, if we can equip humanity to think properly about science, technology, and the future, and make good decisions, it’s quite possible that the future we expect, borne of technology and knowledge, can be a brighter one for all.</p><h4>Science and the Public</h4><p>We expect that a bright future, borne of science, technology, and wise human agency, will involve a better understanding of science, a better understanding of ourselves, and further progress in many fields. We also suspect that it will involve tackling the question of who exactly should be making decisions about progress. This is something we look forward to contributing to in the months and years ahead.</p><p>This means that we expect to continue our focus on <strong>differential technological progress</strong>, now with an added focus on public engagement. We live — and here I say what may be for some the most controversial part of this presentation — in a democracy, and as a result we believe these questions should be hashed out at least partially in public.</p><p>There is of course a question about how to engage in public discourse on difficult and contentious topics, especially in an era of great political division and in the context of social media, the impacts of which are still being absorbed. Our current hypothesis is that many communication challenges, and much of the misunderstanding in the public, is downstream of a failure to communicate clearly and empathetically. And so <strong>clear communication</strong>, especially to the public, but also to many other audiences, is a new part of our general strategy.</p><h4>Brief Q&amp;A</h4><p><em>— — — break for Q&amp;A — — —</em></p><h3>The Strategic Landscape</h3><p>I’m now going to describe some of the strategic landscape, as we see it. By “strategic landscape,” this is essentially the environment that we’re operating within. It includes global trends, risks, opportunities, and challenges.</p><p>I am now going to cover material that is included in the <a href="https://docs.google.com/document/d/1H4uKqjNlAc7l35kTb5F4BQv1_ORPbpcmvgpEu1pjAh4/edit">internal strategy update</a> document. So if you’d like to read about this while I’m speaking, or would like more information, please check out that document.</p><h4>Global Trends</h4><p>One part of the strategic landscape is: global trends. Here, we look at what is happening in the world as a whole, trying to determine how things will change. We then focus especially on trends that are relevant to our work.</p><p>With respect to global trends, the main relevant trend we have identified is the <em>tension between democracy and technocracy</em>. Essentially, there is a big question about who should be in charge of what. Advocates of democracy think “the people” should be in charge. Advocates of technocracy think “the experts” should be in charge. Questions of who should be in charge are especially important with respect to science and technology development. You can imagine a system where scientists decide, or where the public decides. Of course, there are other options, and questions about the role of individuals and the market.</p><p>With respect to this trend, it appears the gap between “the public” and “the experts” is widening in some places (e.g., US politics), but closing in others (e.g., on Twitter).</p><h4>Global Risks</h4><p>A second part of the strategic landscape is: global risks. Here, we try to identify what the largest and most likely sources of risk are, in terms of what might cause substantial harm to large numbers of people.</p><p>There are different ways to divide up risks. We divide them into <em>acute</em>, <em>chronic</em>, and <em>prospective</em>. Acute risks may happen soon. Chronic risks may issue in harm over the long term. Prospective risks are ones that involve more substantial unknowns.</p><p>Under acute risks, we identified <em>nuclear war</em>, <em>pandemics</em>, and <em>large-scale conventional war</em> as the most concerning. Under chronic risks, we found <em>environmental degradation</em> as the primary risk. Under prospective risks, we identified <em>civilizational decline</em>, <em>hostile human-level artificial intelligence</em>, and <em>global totalitarianism</em> as the top issues. Some authors and thinkers have proposed speculative technologies as important risks, like atomically precise manufacturing (aka “nanotechnology”), artificial superintelligence, or the possibility that we’re in a simulation which then gets shut off. We do not at present think that these are central risks.</p><p>There’s obviously a lot to say about each of those, so I’ll leave discussion about that to Q&amp;A.</p><h4>Institutions</h4><p>Another part of the strategic landscape pertains to institutions. In thinking about institutions, we try to understand how they work, both ideally and actually, and what role we expect them to play in the future.</p><p>I’ll remark on three institutions: academia, science, and the public. We don’t have a full assessment of any of these, and of course it may seem strange to call “the public” an institution. It’s possible that our classification of these will change over time.</p><p>With respect to academia, our present perspective is that academia is semi-functional. This is a middle road between people who oppose academia or people who uncritically accept it. Essentially, academia is enormous. Many of the researchers are good, as is some of the research. However, various causes — in particular, in our view, the mass expansion of academia after World War II — has led many academic fields to become decidedly less functional. The most pertinent example is the field of psychology which, as many of you will know, has been mired in a replication crisis for the past decade.</p><p>With respect to science, we have all heard narratives of amazing progress (“singularity”) and the total lack thereof (“stagnation”). We ourselves are unsure. This is where our third program, <a href="https://www.leverageresearch.org/bottlenecks">Bottlenecks in Science and Technology</a>, comes in. Through that program we hope to get researchers and thinkers to help determine how much progress is actually being made in a wide variety of scientific and technological fields and then, ideally, help us figure out how to make more.</p><p>With respect to the public, our view is, perhaps controversially, that the public is much better constituted and has a much better understanding that is often recognized, especially in technocratic circles. There are surveys, of course, which reveal a shocking lack of understanding of science on the part of the public. But if you look at movies, which are commercially successful and designed to be understood by the public, it seems that there is a broad and surprisingly accurate understanding of the role of science and technology in society.</p><h4>Research Areas</h4><p>With respect to differential technological development, we are always on the lookout for areas of research that are particularly promising. This both allows us to try to predict what will happen in the future (as advances are made or fail to be made) and to make good choices when we ourselves select a field to study.</p><p>I will briefly remark on a few research areas. In the future, especially as a result of our Bottlenecks work, I expect we will end up with assessments of many different fields and subfields.</p><p>Social science — We believe that the social sciences are highly promising, but that they are often mistaken for late stage sciences rather than early stage sciences. This leads many researchers to investigate in those fields using methods that are not well-suited to making discoveries.</p><p>History of science — We also think that the history of science is highly promising. In particular, we believe that the data set for successful science <em>is</em> the history of science, and thus that people interested in making science better ought to be very interested in the history. Of course, the history of science, and more specifically how the major discoveries in the history of science were made, has been studied to a degree. But we believe that it is possible to discover more that is of direct relevance, and have been very pleased by the initial results of our History of Science work.</p><p>Psychology — Perhaps unsurprisingly, we continue to think psychology is a highly promising field of study, especially introspective psychology. The mind exists, is studiable, exhibits many discernible patterns, and is apt to be described in many ways. We studied the mind especially in terms of understanding mental structures and in the context of psychological self-improvement, but we believe there are other ways to study it as well.</p><p>Coordination studies — This is our provisional name for what we believe should be or become a field. It would include startups, teams, political organization, and a wide variety of other topics. Of course many fields touch on these things, though we expect there to be a special advantage from focusing specifically on coordination and forms of coordination as the object of study.</p><p>Artificial general intelligence — There is a lot of hype right now about artificial general intelligence. As I prepared this strategy update the primary focus was understanding the degree to which the hype was justified. Our short answer is that while there have been some advances in AI, including the Transformer architecture from Google Brain in 2017, and large language models, like used by GPT-3 and DALL-E, we do not currently believe that we are close to human-level artificial intelligence or appreciable artificial general intelligence. Of course, it is hard to assess these things without a theory of intelligence or general intelligence.</p><p>In the process of preparing the update, however, I realized that artificial intelligence may be an early stage science, and that there may be room for valuable work here, either supported or conducted by the institute. Such work would not be conducted on a fast timescale, and would prioritize understanding how artificially intelligent systems might do what we want rather than something very different.</p><p>Early stage science — Lastly, our focus since 2019 has been <em>early stage science</em>. Early stage science refers to the idea that science is not conducted in the same way at all stages in the development of fields, and that the world done early in a field’s life is importantly different than after the field matures. We believe there are many fields that will benefit from looking at things from an early stage science perspective. In future updates we hope to assemble a list of such fields.</p><h4>Brief Q&amp;A</h4><p><em>— — — break for Q&amp;A — — —</em></p><h3>Expected Developments</h3><p>It is useful to make predictions, partially to ensure that one is looking at the future, partially to incentivize oneself to think concretely and realistically. In our case, I would not say we are so confident as to make predictions; we are willing, however, to record some expectations about the future. Here are two; each rounds the expectation to the nearest 5 or 10 year mark.</p><h4>Anticipation #1: Backlash against life sciences — 30 year time frame</h4><p>First, we currently expect that without careful intervention in the meantime, there may be a broad backlash against the life sciences. It is hard to estimate timeframes, but we put our current anticipation at 30 years.</p><p>The model is this: Doctors in Nazi Germany engaged in horrifying practices before and during World War II. After World War II, during the Nazi doctor trial, the idea of unethical experimentation came into the public view and safeguard policies were adopted in the US. These policies, however, lacked teeth. Twenty-five years later, there was a new precipitating cause: the infamous Tuskegee Syphilis study, where US government agencies allowed Black men with syphilis to go untreated in order to learn about the negative effects of the disease. This led to a large public backlash, then regulation and the creation of IRBs. IRBs successfully curbed unethical research, but also limited ethical research as well.</p><p>We think something similar might happen with the life sciences. We have just had a global pandemic, with millions dead, widespread suffering, and substantial economic loss. This occurs in the context of risky research, including gain-of-function research, and a worrying track record of lab leaks. We are concerned that in response to the pandemic, new policies that lack teeth will be adopted; then, after generational turnover, there may be some other sort of precipitating event (a lab spill, or some other accident), followed by the broad regulation of life science. This is concerning for a number of reasons; dangerous research should be halted earlier, and in a way that does not unnecessarily limit ethical research.</p><h4>Anticipation #2: End of artificial general intelligence bubble — 5 year time frame</h4><p>Second, we believe there is presently an artificial general intelligence bubble. There is a lot of enthusiasm and some real advance, but expectations have become unmoored from reality and the cost of training larger and larger models is high. We then expect the bubble will pop, with the result being a general de-emphasis of artificial general intelligence. We put our current anticipation on this at 5 years, though a more conservative estimate would be 10 years.</p><h3>Challenges and Approaches</h3><p>Last, I’ll talk about some of the challenges we face and how we expect to approach those challenges.</p><h4>Communicating the relevance of history</h4><p>One of our big challenges will be communicating the relevance of history. People like science and they like major discoveries, but this sentiment has not yet extended itself to history. We think that there is a link between the past and the present, and that clear communication and patience will eventually bridge the gap.</p><h4>Navigating public unease about psychology</h4><p>Another large challenge relates to psychology. People are uneasy about the mind, and justifiably so. Nevertheless, it is an important topic. Thus it is essential to figure out how to navigate the fears, concerns, and misgivings people have with respect to an understanding of the mind, and psychology, and themselves. Here too we expect that clear communication, and especially listening, will help us to bridge the gap.</p><p>One note about communication is that we expect that we will end up splitting our resources between research and communication, rather than focusing almost exclusively on research like we did in the past. Another is that we will focus on communicating both about current issues as well as fundamental questions and confusions. We hypothesize that in some cases, the most efficient way to bridge distance between perspectives is to try to speak about the most basic questions at issue.</p><h4>Combating public misinformation</h4><p>There has been, as many of you know, a large amount of misinformation both posted online and passed around in private about the institute. This is stressful, because we’re trying to do something good, and because misinformation can confuse people and make it harder to succeed. Our plan here is to release more public information and seek to correct existing misinformation by going through relevant official channels. We also will seek private resolution of disagreements but, where that fails, subject bad behavior to public scrutiny.</p><p>We really would prefer to not have to focus on this, but it keeps coming up, and so we believe it deserves (some) continued attention.</p><h4>Addressing lack of civic knowledge</h4><p>One issue that we have encountered in a number of contexts is people seeming to not understand why we are engaging with the public in the way we are, or taking other relevant actions. We chalk this up to a decline in civic knowledge; our plan to address it is to discuss relevant issues publicly.</p><h4>Navigating hype around artificial intelligence</h4><p>With respect to artificial intelligence, there is both hype and opportunity. In general, our plan is to form our views in a way that allows us to navigate around the hype and identify where there are genuine opportunities.</p><h3>General Q&amp;A</h3><p><em>— — — break for Q&amp;A — — —</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=ce50a172c677" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Our Current Programs]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@LeverageResearch/our-current-programs-11c423f8987b?source=rss-a1da96f80887------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/11c423f8987b</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Leverage Research]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 24 Jun 2022 22:35:17 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-08-13T21:12:11.589Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>An essay in the Leverage Introduction series</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*bnUxbFpR8yQIylFR_2R8yQ.png" /><figcaption>History of Science Program—Exploratory Psychology Program—Bottlenecks Program</figcaption></figure><h3>Ambitious Efforts</h3><p>The bulk of Leverage Research’s efforts go into our <a href="https://www.leverageresearch.org/research">three central programs</a>: History of Science, Exploratory Psychology, and Bottlenecks in Science and Technology. Each of these programs was selected because we believe there is a special opportunity available to contribute to progress in nascent and struggling fields and thereby substantially improve the world.</p><h4><strong>History of Science Program</strong></h4><p>Through our <a href="https://www.leverageresearch.org/history-of-science">History of Science program</a>, we are conducting case studies on the major discoveries in the history of successful sciences in order to determine how those discoveries were made. To what degree has scientific advance depended on theory? Or experiment? Or the development of new instruments? We hypothesize that patterns in the history of science are <em>identifiable</em> and <em>transferable</em>. That is to say, we believe that the actual causes of scientific discovery can be determined to an important degree, and that knowledge of these causes can be applied to make present-day scientific research faster and more effective.</p><p>Our efforts thus far have focused on the history of electricity. There appear to be approximately thirteen important discoveries in the early history of the field, from Gilbert’s isolation of static electric attraction in 1600 to Maxwell’s statement of the equations governing electromagnetism in 1865. We have conducted mid-depth case studies on nearly half of these discoveries, with encouraging results: in each case we have been able to reach a plausible account of how the discovery was made, and every case study so far has yielded new lessons.</p><p>In terms of the total scope of the project, we estimate that each case study takes 6–9 months on average to complete and that there are between 200–400 important discoveries in the early histories of successful sciences. This yields 100–300 person years of effort, which will be supplemented by further analytical studies of various types. This quantity of effort may be daunting to lone researchers, but is entirely within reach for a dedicated team with a long-term research program.</p><p>The eventual outcome of this program, if successful, will be the early history of science rendered accessible, with it now being easy to examine the data set of discoveries from the history of successful sciences and draw conclusions about the early scientific process. It is then our expectation that this will yield insights that improve how research is done today.</p><h4>Exploratory Psychology Program</h4><p>From 2012–2019, researchers at Leverage Research engaged in an extensive exploration of the mind using introspective methods. During this time we tested a variety of introspective methods, developed our own techniques and practices, and sought to map out the conscious and unconscious mind.</p><p>Our <a href="https://www.leverageresearch.org/exploratory-psychology">Exploratory Psychology program</a> marks the next phase of this research. We are now working to teach external researchers to use our research methods and engage in introspective research themselves. We expect a responsibly managed external community of researchers will both confirm many of our previous findings and discover new things themselves. We also expect that where we made errors in our own research, external researchers will be likely to identify and help us correct those errors.</p><p>The first techniques we are working to release are belief reporting, which we believe helps people introspect on their underlying beliefs more reliably, and charting, a method for organizing introspective reports into diagrams that display the relations between beliefs, actions, and goals.</p><p>For the purposes of our program, a thriving community of 100–200 external researchers is likely sufficient. We then expect to publish results. In the ideal case, this leads to the development of a fruitful new sub-field of psychological study, one whose methods are inexpensive enough to encourage routine and widespread replication.</p><h4>Bottlenecks in Science and Technology Program</h4><p>Over the past decade, we’ve heard narratives of extreme technological progress and the absence thereof — singularity or stagnation. The reality is likely somewhere in the middle and also dependent on choices individuals make.</p><p>Through our <a href="https://www.leverageresearch.org/bottlenecks">Bottlenecks program</a>, we are aiming to convene researchers, funders, institution designers, and creative thinkers to help determine how much progress is being made in different fields in science and technology, what the bottlenecks are to future progress, and to create the conditions for new ambitious projects that will break those bottlenecks.</p><p>We launched this program in the summer of 2021 with an <a href="https://bit.ly/2021-bottlenecks-write-up">inaugural workshop</a>, “Bottlenecks in Science and Technology” (aka “Bottlenecks 2021”), hosted at the headquarters of supersonic flight company Boom Supersonic. Researchers presented on the bottlenecks in more than ten different fields, including supersonic flight, energy (fusion, fission, and geothermal), metagenomic sequencing, life extension, telerobotics, psychology, and neuropsychiatry. The workshop was very well-received, sparking conversations that led to the creation of a new aging research grant program and a carbon dioxide removal initiative.</p><p>The institute received a generous <a href="https://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2021/09/emergent-ventures-winners-sixteenth-cohort.html">Emergent Ventures grant</a> for its work on bottlenecks, and interest for follow-on workshops has been strong. We expect to run further events, organize researchers to write careful analyses of bottlenecks in different fields, and otherwise contribute to the creation and successful execution of ambitious projects that will drive responsible scientific and technological progress.</p><h3>Other Projects</h3><p>In addition to the above programs, the institute also has a few smaller projects. Of these, two worth highlighting are:</p><ul><li><strong>Coordination Research.</strong> Since 2011, the institute has studied, both experimentally and theoretically, how people can work together effectively and well. At present, we are learning about how defining the institute better and communicating more publicly contribute to internal and external coordination.</li><li><strong>Research Archive.</strong> Much of our research from 2011–2019 has not been written up. We periodically put effort into writing up this research and publishing it <a href="https://www.geoffanders.com/">online</a>. Previous research reports have covered topics such as consensus and intelligence amplification; future reports will cover other topics as well.</li></ul><p>We frequently have ideas for other programs and projects, though with our current ones we more than have our hands full.</p><h3>Learn More</h3><p>To learn more about our programs, see the information on our <a href="http://leverageresearch.org/">website</a>. For other information about LR, you can also read other essays in this series:</p><ul><li><a href="https://medium.com/p/f3b9bdae983f/">Introduction to Leverage Research</a></li><li>Our Current Programs <em>(current essay)</em></li><li><a href="https://medium.com/@LeverageResearch/challenges-we-face-91e9c3ef2daa">Challenges We Face</a></li></ul><p><em>More essays coming soon:</em></p><ul><li>Our Strategy for Impact</li><li>Join the Team!</li></ul><figure><a href="http://leverageresearch.org/"><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*0eX6scQE36RBvlKEcOYSdQ.png" /></a></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=11c423f8987b" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Introduction to Leverage Research]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@LeverageResearch/introduction-to-leverage-research-f3b9bdae983f?source=rss-a1da96f80887------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/f3b9bdae983f</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[positive-impact]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[science]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[leverage-research]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[technology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[research]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Leverage Research]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 24 Jun 2022 22:34:22 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-08-23T19:52:19.208Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>An essay in the Leverage Introduction series</em></p><figure><a href="http://leverageresearch.org/"><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*m9Zmc51fClNBMzLykZL1Fg.png" /></a></figure><h3><strong>An Opportunity for Impact</strong></h3><p>Despite the vast number of researchers and enormous amount of money spent on research, there are still many domains that are importantly understudied.</p><p>These domains are overlooked for a variety of reasons. In some cases, the research itself requires a new approach, often by an interdisciplinary team which can be hard to assemble. In other cases, topics are controversial or unpopular, making it hard to find talented researchers or raise money.</p><p>This is where Leverage Research sees an opportunity for positive impact. Over the past decade, we have developed the capacity to identify promising but neglected areas of study, design novel research approaches, locate and hire researchers with a wide variety of talents, and raise funds — even for projects in areas that are unusual or outside current fashions.</p><p>Of course, creating these research projects is just the first step. Ambitious research projects, including in neglected or undeveloped areas, can be difficult to run, take many years, and meet with surprising challenges along the way.</p><p>To create the best conditions for the success of its projects, Leverage Research has needed to develop its own perspective on many issues, as well as a unique culture, set of values, and institutional practices. We have also chosen to focus on <em>early stage science</em>, where our current programs involve studying, conducting, and supporting research in fields we believe have the potential to become successful sciences.</p><p>In this essay series, we hope to introduce both prospective collaborators and readers with a passing interest to our work. Below are some topics we hope to cover. More generally, we’d like to invite people to come on our journey with us and help contribute to our success.</p><h3>Topics to Explore</h3><p><em>Our Strategy for Impact</em> — The history of science and technology teaches a number of lessons. Some lessons are positive: small teams can make rapid research progress; progress in unanticipated areas can transform the world. Other lessons are cautionary: ambitious projects often fail, new science and technology are not always beneficial. LR’s strategy for positive impact incorporates these observations as part of an attempt to make responsible scientific progress. <em>[Coming Soon]</em></p><p><em>Central Focus: Early-Stage Science</em> — There are many opportunities for high-leverage research; as such, in our own work we periodically select majors areas of focus. Starting in 2019, we began to focus on <em>early-stage science</em>, that is, areas we believe have the potential to become successful sciences. Our focus on early-stage science includes studying the history and philosophy of science to understand science better and trying to help nascent and underdeveloped fields advance towards maturity. <em>[Coming Soon]</em></p><p><em>Our Current Programs</em> — The majority of our work falls within one of our <a href="https://www.leverageresearch.org/research">three main programs</a>. Each of these programs contributes in some way to our efforts to understand and support early stage science. (<a href="https://medium.com/@LeverageResearch/our-current-programs-11c423f8987b">Read More</a>)</p><ul><li><em>History of Science program</em> — In our <a href="https://www.leverageresearch.org/research">History of Science program</a>, researchers produce in-depth case studies of important scientific discoveries in order to make the history of science more accessible and build a picture of what scientific advance looks like in its early stages.</li><li><em>Exploratory Psychology program</em> — Our <a href="https://www.leverageresearch.org/research-exploratory-psychology">Exploratory Psychology program</a> aims to disseminate the findings from our previous introspective research (conducted during 2011–2019), especially by helping external researchers engage in early-stage introspective research using our methods.</li><li><em>Bottlenecks in Science and Technology program</em> — Through our <a href="https://www.leverageresearch.org/bottlenecks">Bottlenecks program</a>, we help support others running their own ambitious research projects by bringing together the people, resources, and knowledge needed to identify and overcome the most important bottlenecks to progress.</li></ul><p><em>Challenges We Face</em> — Ambitious research projects face a variety of challenges; this is especially true for ones conducted by interdisciplinary teams studying neglected areas. By understanding the challenges, we can take steps to ensure that we meet them. <em>[Coming Soon]</em></p><p><em>Join the Team!</em> — Leverage Research is hiring. Join a small but ambitious team aiming to have an impact in the mid-to-long run by helping to shape and contribute to the scientific enterprise. We have a number of positions open and expect to grow substantially over the next several years. <em>[Read about our open positions on our </em><a href="https://www.leverageresearch.org/jobs"><em>Jobs page</em></a><em>]</em></p><h3>More Information</h3><p>Learn more about Leverage Research by visiting our website, reading our research, or skimming any of the Medium essays in this series:</p><ul><li>Introduction to Leverage Research <em>(this essay)</em></li><li><a href="https://medium.com/p/11c423f8987b/">Our Current Programs</a></li><li><a href="https://medium.com/@LeverageResearch/challenges-we-face-91e9c3ef2daa">Challenges We Face</a></li></ul><p><em>More essays coming soon:</em></p><ul><li>Our Strategy for Impact</li><li>Join the Team!</li></ul><p>Please also feel free to reach out directly (contact@leverageresearch.org). We are always looking for talented people to join the team and potential collaborators.</p><figure><a href="http://leverageresearch.org/"><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*0eX6scQE36RBvlKEcOYSdQ.png" /></a></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=f3b9bdae983f" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Studying Early Stage Science: Research Program Introduction]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@LeverageResearch/early-stage-science-research-program-introduction-cb52b7c5d6f1?source=rss-a1da96f80887------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/cb52b7c5d6f1</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[early-stage-science]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[meta-science]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[scientific-progress]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[history-of-science]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Leverage Research]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 14 Jan 2020 05:45:08 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-01-14T05:45:08.230Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Introduction</h3><p>Scientific progress is responsible for some of the most amazing developments in human history. It has enabled us to cure diseases, increase agricultural yields, and travel quickly and safely across the globe. As such, the opportunity to enable progress in science can be very valuable.</p><p>Having studied examples from the history of science, we at <a href="https://www.leverageresearch.org/">Leverage Research</a> believe it is possible to describe how early discoveries led to the creation of impressive and sophisticated scientific disciplines. By understanding the methodologies used by the researchers at key points in the past, as well as the social and institutional contexts that enabled them to make progress, we believe it may be possible to help modern researchers make progress in new or stagnating fields.</p><p>In this paper, we outline a research program designed to investigate this hypothesis. We describe three important examples from the history of science, identify a phenomenon worth studying, state a specific formulation of our hypothesis, and describe our research methodology¹. With this paper and the work that follows it, we hope to set the stage for the study of early stage science.</p><p>You can read more about early stage science on <a href="https://www.leverageresearch.org/research">our website</a>.</p><h3>Three Historical Cases</h3><h4>Galvani, Volta, and the Invention of the Battery</h4><p>In 1780, an Italian physician and biologist named Luigi Galvani announced the discovery of a new electrical phenomenon, which he called “animal electricity.”</p><p>For some time, Galvani had been performing experiments using dissected frogs to investigate how electricity interacted with animal bodies. In his most famous experiment, he found that he could make dissected frog legs twitch by hanging them on iron hooks and probing them with a piece of metal. He concluded on the basis of his investigations that an electrical charge was being generated by the frog leg itself, and that this “animal electricity” was generated by an electrical fluid in the frogs (Cajavilca, Varon, and Sternbach 2009, 160).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/232/1*NdFm7_3ZTE_-F4eWMonZzg.jpeg" /><figcaption><em>Figure 1: Galvani experimenting on frogs</em></figcaption></figure><p>Galvani’s research attracted others to investigate animal electricity. In particular, it drew the attention of an Italian physicist and chemist by the name of Alessandro Volta.</p><p>Volta began to suspect that electricity was being generated from a source other than the frog itself. Volta’s hypothesis was that the electrical charge was instead created by Galvani’s use of different metals to mount and probe the frog leg, and further that certain metals were naturally disposed to pass an electric charge given the presence of a conductor.</p><p>To test his hypothesis, Volta needed some way to detect the presence of an electric charge. In the days before the invention of precise instruments for measuring electricity, this was no small challenge. Others had used the creation of visible sparks or the physical sensation of getting an electric shock as a way of detecting electricity, but these effects tended to require a strong current and Volta suspected that the current involved in the frog leg experiment was relatively small.</p><p>He needed a more sensitive instrument. So, he used his tongue.</p><p>He reasoned that if a frog leg would conduct electricity, his tongue probably would too. And, Volta knew from previous experiments that an electric charge applied to the tongue could create a bitter sensation. This let him conduct an experiment: he touched either side of his tongue with combinations of metals and used the presence or absence of the bitter sensation to detect an electrical charge. He found that some combinations of metals did cause the bitter sensation, leading him to conclude that it was in fact the metals that passed a current through his tongue, rather than his tongue generating its own “animal electricity” (Cajavilca, Varon, and Sternbach 2009, 162; Shock and Awe: The Story of Electricity 2011).</p><p>Subsequent investigations led Volta to make further breakthroughs in understanding the ability of metals to transmit an electric charge. He eventually discovered that he could generate a strong and consistent electrical charge by stacking zinc and copper on top of one another in an alternating pattern with brine-soaked cloth or cardboard in between.</p><p>Volta’s invention was dubbed the Voltaic pile, and was the precursor to the modern battery.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/858/1*Jh-3swfS4LBsNVVOEMxozg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Figure 2: Volta’s experiment and the Voltaic Pile</figcaption></figure><p>The debate between Galvani and Volta over animal electricity and related topics would result not only in the Voltaic pile, but also in the early development of the fields of electrophysiology, electromagnetism, and electrochemistry (Cajavilca, Varon, and Sternbach 2009, 159).</p><p>While the two had deep theoretical disagreements, Galvani’s creative experiments identified a phenomenon — frogs twitching when touching two pieces of metal — which Volta was able to study with a unique method of his own, using his tongue instead of a frog. Galvani’s theory of animal electricity was wrong, but his work enabled further research that led to the creation of the voltaic pile and the foundations of our modern understanding of electricity.</p><p>Volta and Galvani both had to develop many of their own theories in the absence of an accepted paradigm for electricity, and both had to design their own experimental tools and methods. The trajectory of their respective research programs, and of their research efforts combined, would have been hard to predict in advance. They tried anyway, and their work helped turn the study of electrical phenomenon into a fully developed scientific discipline.</p><h4>Galileo and the Development of Telescopic Astronomy</h4><p>The history of science includes a number of cases of scientific progress that share some of the notable features of Galvani and Volta’s research. Another example is the story of Galileo and the early development of telescopic astronomy.</p><p>Galileo Galilei pioneered the use of the telescope to observe celestial objects. He observed Jupiter’s moons, the phases of Venus, Saturn, the existence of sunspots and more. Initially, though, Galileo had trouble convincing others of the reliability and usefulness of the telescope. When Galileo visited Bologna in 1610 to demonstrate his telescope:</p><blockquote>In the presence of a number of learned men, Galileo showed his telescope and let others observe earthly and celestial things through it. They agreed that for earthly objects the instruments performed as promised but that in the heavens it was not reliable. Although Galileo’s notes show that on the first night two and on the second night all four of the satellites were visible, none of the gentlemen present were able to see satellites around Jupiter. (Van Helden 1994, 11)</blockquote><p>The learned men were skeptical of Galileo’s device for understandable reasons. The optical principles behind the device were not well understood at the time and some of Galileo’s claims about the heavens contravened established wisdom on the topic. Furthermore, Galileo’s telescope was not a very powerful or easy-to-use instrument. His telescope was capable of no more than 20x magnification and a field of view of around 15 feet, whereas one can purchase a modern amateur telescope today for around 100 USD that is capable of 10 times greater magnification (200x) and a field of view 34 times larger (516 feet) (<a href="https://telescopicwatch.com/galileo-telescope/">Sky and Telescope 2017; Telescopic Watch 2019</a>).</p><p>To illustrate the difficulties this posed, compare the image of Ely Cathedral viewed with a modern telescope at the same zoom as Galileo’s telescope (20x) with the field of view available to modern telescopes (Figure 3, top picture), with the image of the same object at the same distance with a replica of one of Galileo’s telescopes (Figure 3, bottom picture).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/738/1*2jM_xpV_18zHyIfogyadPQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Figure 3: Top picture — modern telescope at 20x zoom; Bottom picture — replica of Galileo’s telescope, also at 20x zoom (<a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nzXnnwxJmSg">Astronomy and Nature TV 2010</a>)</figcaption></figure><p>The small circle in the middle of the bottom picture is the field of view available through the replica telescope. The light colored area shows the visible portion of the cathedral.</p><p>In addition to the small field of view, Galileo lacked modern equipment for mounting and stabilizing his telescope. This meant that even if Galileo could find the relevant astronomical object in the small field of view, ensuring that the telescope remained fixed on that object for repeated observations was a significant challenge.</p><p>Finally, even under optimal circumstances, it is not uncommon for a user of Galileo’s telescope to fail to see what they are meant to see. The instrument takes a certain amount of getting used to as the eye and brain become accustomed to interpreting the image and not everyone has sufficiently good eyesight to use the device properly (Van Helden 1994, 11). As one historian of science notes:</p><blockquote>On several occasions I have taken a group of my students to look for Jupiter’s satellites through a replica of one of Galileo’s telescopes — students who were convinced the moons were really there — and the results were always mixed. Some saw all that were visible, some saw one or two, and some saw none at all. No matter how public the occasion, the actual observing remains an individual and private act. (Van Helden 1994, 12)</blockquote><p>Indeed, the private nature of telescopic observations created difficulties in settling scientific disputes. For example, in 1643, Antonius Rheita published a book announcing the discovery of new satellites around Jupiter and Saturn. While others reported not seeing the satellites, Rheita claimed the satellites could only be seen with the new, more powerful telescope he had invented. All telescopes at the time were hand-made and thus differed in clarity and magnification, and so scientists could not simply use their own instruments to confirm or disconfirm each others’ claims as their failure to replicate results could be the consequence of inferior equipment. Scientists eventually reached agreement on this question in 1647, when Hevelius (who claimed to have built a still more powerful telescope), was able to convince scientists that the supposed satellites were actually fixed stars behind the planets (Van Helden 1994, 8–20).</p><p>The telescope was initially an unreliable, poorly understood tool. It did not produce directly shareable or replicable results and in practice often created scientific disputes that were difficult to resolve. Yet despite the challenges it posed, the telescope did sometimes allow early telescopic astronomers to make observations that were more detailed than those available to the naked eye. This modest improvement was enough to attract a small number of early scientists who began working with the device. Over time, they learned more about the optical principles involved, improved at grinding lenses for new telescopes, and developed more effective ways of communicating their findings to other astronomers and the public.</p><h4>Black, Lavoisier, and the Chemical Revolution</h4><p>In 1756, Joseph Black published his Experiments Upon Magnesia Alba in which he described experiments he performed on an unusual substance which he called “fixed air.” Black originally discovered the substance² through experiments on magnesia alba — now called magnesium carbonate — and chalk (calcium carbonate). Black observed that when magnesia alba was heated or combined with an acid it began to bubble and left behind a residue. Black was able to use an analytical balance that he invented to precisely weigh the residue and note that it lost a noticeable amount of weight. Black hypothesized that the bubbling and weight loss was caused by the liberation of a gas that had been “fixed” in the magnesia alba (hence the name, fixed air).</p><p>Black was curious about the properties of this fixed air and so began to devise ways to experiment with the substance.</p><p>He noticed that it had an unusual effect on fire, noting that:</p><blockquote>I mixed together some chalk and vitriolic acid. . . The strong effervescence produced an air or vapour, which, flowing out at the top of the glass, extinguished a candle that stood close to it; and a piece of burning paper immersed in it, was put out as effectually as if it had been dipped in water. (West 2014, L1059)</blockquote><p>This indicated that fixed air was not the same as atmospheric air. There were other unusual properties as well. He investigated the effect of fixed air on animals and found that it was remarkably toxic when inhaled — he noted that “sparrows died in it in ten or eleven seconds” (Robinson 1803).</p><p>The toxicity of fixed air when inhaled led Black to suspect that fixed air might be the air expelled as part of the respiration process itself. He designed several experiments to test this hypothesis. In one he blew bubbles into a solution of limewater (calcium hydroxide) and noted that a precipitate of chalk was leftover indicating that he had succeeded in fixing the air back into the chalk. He repeated this experiment on a larger scale by placing limewater soaked in rags in an air duct in the ceiling of a church and observing a chalk residue as the lime soaked up the fixed air from the congregation’s respiration (West 2014, L1059).</p><p>He made several other discoveries about the substance and explained various observed phenomena. For instance, there was an observed unusual effect at the Grotto del Cano in Italy, where animals that visited the Grotto died, but humans could visit unharmed. Black explained this phenomenon by proposing that fixed air was heavier than atmospheric air and thus sank closer to the ground, poisoning animals but not humans. He also discovered that fixed air was emitted during the fermentation process (West 2014, L1059).</p><p>We now know “fixed air” as carbon dioxide, and Black’s work isolating and describing the properties of carbon dioxide represented the first demonstration that gases can be weighable constituents of solid bodies, the first demonstration that gases are unique chemical substances and not atmospheric air in different states of purity, and the first demonstration that respiration involves the transformation of gases. In the 18 years after the publication of Black’s work all the respiratory gases were isolated and characterized with Henry Cavendish discovering hydrogen in 1766, Daniel Rutherford isolating nitrogen in 1772, and Joseph Priestly isolating oxygen in 1774 (West 2014, L1059).</p><p>Joseph Black’s work in isolating and describing carbon dioxide contributed significantly to scientific progress in chemistry. In much the same fashion as Galvani and Volta, Black discovered a new phenomenon and developed unusual and creative methods to study the phenomenon. In particular, his insight that carbon dioxide was connected to respiration allowed for rapid progress in isolating the other gases involved in respiration. As other scientists investigated new gases they attempted to explain them in terms of ultimately incorrect, yet sometimes useful theories. Indeed, even Black’s theory that the air was “fixed” in the solids is somewhat different than the modern understanding of the phenomenon. In modern nomenclature, Magnesia Alba is MgCO3, and by heating it MgCO3 becomes MgO + CO2. We might say that carbon dioxide can be liberated from Magnesia Alba but in modern terms, we probably wouldn’t describe carbon dioxide as being “fixed” in the Magnesia Alba. While Black’s theory of carbon dioxide may not match our modern understanding, he nevertheless contributed significantly to scientific progress by isolating and cleverly studying a new phenomenon.</p><p>As additional gases were isolated and described, there was considerable disagreement about what the gasses were and scientists advanced a number of competing theories to explain their properties. For example, Rutherford and Priestly’s discoveries were both explained in terms of the then popular phlogiston theory of combustion which posited that an element called phlogiston was released from materials as they combusted and combustion would continue until either all the phlogiston had been released or the air was saturated with phlogiston such that it could not contain more. On this theory nitrogen was labeled “phlogisticated air” and oxygen was labeled “dephlogisticated air.”³</p><p>The debate over the nature of these newly discovered airs culminated in the work of Antoine-Laurent de Lavoisier and what is often called the chemical revolution. Between 1775 and 1789, Lavoisier is credited with discovering the law of conservation of mass and a new theory of combustion, which explained combustion and acidic corrosion in terms of oxygen⁴ and eventually replaced the phlogiston theory. Lavoisier’s approach to chemistry built on Black’s approach through its focus on weight, but utilized much more sophisticated and elaborate equipment to investigate the properties of the newly discovered airs (West 2014, L1060).</p><h3>Identifying a Phenomenon</h3><p>The research efforts of Volta and Galvani, Galileo, and Black appear to have a number of attributes in common.</p><p>They feature a relative absence of established theories and well-understood instruments in the area of investigation, the appearance of strange or unexplained phenomena, and lack of theoretical and practical consensus among researchers. Progress seems to occur despite (and sometimes enabled by) flawed theories, individual researchers use imprecise measurement tools that are frequently new and difficult to share, and there exists a bi-directional cycle of improvement between increasingly sophisticated theories and increasingly precise measurement tools.</p><p>For example, consider Black’s study of fixed air. He began with an unexplained phenomenon: certain substances losing weight when heated. His approach to studying that phenomenon involved a wide range of methods, such as blowing bubbles into limewater and leaving limewater-soaked rags in the air duct of a church. This led to a larger study of new gases, where there were many theoretical disagreements between researchers, and where flawed theories (e.g., the theories of phlogisticated and dephlogisticated air) seemed to aid the process of discovery. Finally, improvements in measuring the weight of substances allowed for better theories and refinements to the researchers’ instruments.</p><p>These examples gesture at the potential existence of a recognizable cluster of discovery-related attributes (“Attribute Cluster 1”) that plausibly play an important role in scientific progress. This is striking, because this is different from another attribute cluster (“Attribute Cluster 2”) that is more familiar and more commonly referred to, that appears throughout the history of science. That second cluster includes large groups of scientists working together, a foundation of largely accepted theory, precise and well-understood instruments, researcher consensus on the quality of these instruments, and many small discoveries that tend to build iteratively on one-another and cohere with previous theory.</p><p>This raises a number of questions: Are the attributes in Attribute Cluster 1 actually present in cases described above? Do those attributes appear in a special set of cases in the history of science? More generally, is there a natural cluster of discovery-related attributes in the conceptual vicinity of Attribute Cluster 1 that appear in important cases of scientific discovery, like those described above? What can we learn from investigating the cases that are the most natural candidates for exemplifying attributes from Attribute Cluster 1? Is the distinction between Attribute Cluster 1 and Attribute Cluster 2 useful in the context of describing the progress of science?</p><p>The pattern suggested by the cases described above, and those like them, is noteworthy. If there is in fact a recognizable cluster of discovery-related attributes that plausibly play a role in scientific progress other than Attribute Cluster 2, this could be important for understanding when and how new fields make scientific progress. We believe this possibility is rendered at least somewhat plausible by the cases above and deserves further study.</p><h3>Hypothesis</h3><p>The cases of Volta and Galvani, Galileo, and Black illustrate a hypothesized pattern in the development of fields of science which we call “early stage science.”</p><p>We hypothesize that:</p><ol><li>Some scientific fields develop from initial investigations in nascent fields to highly functional knowledge acquisition programs.</li><li>The histories of the development of these highly functional knowledge acquisition programs are characterized by a similar, describable pattern.</li><li>As part of this pattern, the relevant scientific fields have different attributes at different points in their development. More specifically, earlier in the development of the relevant scientific fields, the fields have an attribute cluster in the conceptual vicinity of Attribute Cluster 1, as suggested by numerous examples. Some of those fields later have an attribute cluster in the conceptual vicinity of Attribute Cluster 2. The fact of these attribute clusters implies the existence of phases of scientific development.</li><li>These phases of scientific development arise from the facts about how people figure things out about the world. This includes how inference, experimentation, observation, theory development, tool development, and other aspects of how people can seek to understand the world around them lead researchers to be able to improve their understanding of a given phenomenon.</li><li>In accordance with this, researchers need to use different tools and practices depending on their starting state of knowledge. We expect to find that there is a coherent logic to the meta-practices that lead to the development and advancement of research programs under different starting conditions.</li><li>More specifically, a model of early stage scientific practice will explain how researchers overcome the difficulties that arise when attempting to gain knowledge when dealing with substantially unknown phenomena, poor tools, and so forth. When stated, this model will be both prima facie plausible and verifiable by checking against the research activities that led to important discoveries in practice.</li></ol><p>It is consistent with the above hypothesis that many of the attributes specifically identified in the historical cases above are not actually constitutive of early stage science, so long as conceptually similar attributes can be identified which are.</p><h3>Methodology</h3><p>The current methodology of our investigation primarily focuses on analyzing historical case studies of scientific discovery in new fields. In this section, we cover how we plan to select and analyze specific cases.</p><h4>Selecting Cases</h4><p>To select cases, we will attempt to identify functional modern and historical scientific research programs and identify the initial discoveries integral to their development. By starting with functional scientific research programs and working back, we are aiming to ensure that the cases of early stage research we study are success cases. The pattern that we hypothesize to exist is not meant to be a pattern that occurs in all early stage research, but rather effective early stage research. Since the effectiveness of early stage research can be difficult to assess, we believe the safest set of cases to examine are cases where the relevant field developed into a full-fledged functional research program.</p><p>To identify functional modern and historical scientific research programs, we will look for fields where there are large groups of researchers studying similar phenomena, using very similar methods, with a corpus of shared theory, and substantial predictive power. This is our initial hypothesis of signs that will enable us to identify a sufficient set of functional scientific research programs. If we encounter reasons to change our criteria, we will do so, especially if doing so will help us to better identify successful early stage research cases. It is open to us, for instance, that we would be better served by looking at Kuhnian paradigms or broad scientific consensus, rather than looking for the attributes above.</p><p>Once we identify functional scientific research programs and identify the initial discoveries integral to their development, we will then analyze how researchers made those discoveries.</p><p>For example, consider modern astronomy. As part of doing their research, large groups of modern astronomers use highly advanced telescopes and highly advanced analytical methods to find, see, and study intergalactic objects at an incredible degree of precision. Astronomers have a shared body of theory, make the same observations with different telescopes, and are able to predict with high precision what they and others will observe when they look through telescopes at different points in the sky. These attributes indicate that modern astronomy is plausibly a highly functional scientific research program.</p><p>Having selected astronomy as a plausible success case for scientific development, we can then investigate the beginnings of the field to find plausibly important and formative discoveries. In this case, Galileo and others’ work with early telescopes significantly changed how we both observe and think about objects in space. As a result, Galileo plausibly represents a case where successful early research methods might be visible and thus is fruitful to study.</p><h4>Analyzing Cases</h4><p>In analyzing the historical cases, we will be trying to build a coherent model of how researchers make scientific progress in the early stages of the development of scientific fields. We expect to approach this from many angles, looking at similarities and differences between cases, building causal models of the cases, and trying to state plausible general obstacles early stage researchers might encounter. By cross-checking the cases and the general model 11 against each other, we hope to improve our models of individual cases as well as our general model.</p><p>This may or may not lead to convergence on a single, intelligible general model that fits the cases and also is plausible abstractly. If it does, we will consider this evidence in favor of our hypothesis. If it does not, either because plausible general models do not fit the cases or because the general models contain attributes that are not intelligibly related to the logic of discovery in the early stages of a field, we will consider this evidence against our hypothesis.</p><p>If we reach an adequately plausible general model, we will then investigate whether it can be used to generate recommendations for present-day scientists seeking to make progress in fields operating under early stage research conditions. If a particular model relies heavily on factors local to the particular historical case, researcher, or era, it may not serve as a good template for recommendations for present-day scientists or a general theory of scientific methodology. On the other hand, if a model tends to feature potentially generalizable methodological elements with mechanistic relations (e.g., a particular model for how instrument development works at different levels of theoretical uncertainty), we can see whether the model can generate recommendations for current researchers.</p><h3>Conclusion</h3><p>Following the methodology above, we believe we will be able to select and analyze cases of discovery that have led to the development of highly functional scientific research programs. We expect our analysis to help confirm or disconfirm the existence of early stage science as a unique phase of science with a unique and understandable methodology. It is our hope that investigating this hypothesis will shed light on what methods should be used to make scientific progress in new or underdeveloped fields, and thereby help push science forward.</p><h4>Footnotes</h4><ol><li>A later paper will situate our investigation in the surrounding literature, including describing our relation to Kuhn, Popper, Lakatos, historicism, methodologism, natural epistemology, and complementary science.</li><li>Black was likely not the original discoverer of the substance. It had been briefly described around 100 years prior by Jan Baptist van Helmont who called it gas sylvestre although Black was likely the first to describe its properties in detail.</li><li>Rutherford’s initial name for nitrogen was “noxious air.” Labeling it phlogisticated air is often attributed to Priestly.</li><li>Indeed, the name “oxygen” comes from the greek roots (oxys) meaning “acid” and (-gen¯es) meaning “producer.”</li></ol><p>This paper was originally posted on <a href="https://www.leverageresearch.org/research">our website</a>.</p><h4>References</h4><ul><li>Bartlett, Richard J. 2019. “Galileo’s Telescope — The What, When and How.” Telescopic Watch. Last modified May 16, 2019. <a href="https://telescopicwatch.com/galileo-telescope/">https://telescopicwatch.com/galileo-telescope/.</a></li><li>Cajavilca, Christian, Joseph Varon, and George L. Sternbach. 2009. “Luigi Galvani and the Foundations of Electrophysiology.” Resuscitation 80 (2): 159–62. doi:10.1016/j.resuscitation.2008.09.020.</li><li>Dalby, Robert. 2010. “Looking through Galileo’s Telescope — Practical Comparison.” Astronomy and Nature TV. Last modified September 27, 2019. 12 <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nzXnnwxJmSg.">https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nzXnnwxJmSg.</a></li><li>Quinn, Jim. 2017. “Stargazing with Early Astronomer Galileo Galilei.” Sky Telescope. Last modified May 9, 2019. <a href="https://www.skyandtelescope.com/astronomy-resources/stargazing-with-galileo/">https://www.skyandtelescope.com/astronomy-resources/stargazing-with-galileo/.</a></li><li>Robison, John. 1803. Lectures on the elements of chemistry by the late Joseph Black. Edinburgh: W. Creech.</li><li>“Spark.” 2011. Shock and Awe: The Story of Electricity. BBC Four. Van Helden, Albert. 1994. “Telescopes and Authority from Galileo to Cassini.” Osiris 9: 8–29. doi:10.1086/368727.</li><li>West, John B. 2014. “Joseph Black, Carbon Dioxide, Latent Heat, and the Beginnings of the Discovery of the Respiratory Gases.” American Journal of Physiology-Lunch Cellular and Molecular Physiology 306 (12): L1057–63.</li></ul><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=cb52b7c5d6f1" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>