<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Liz Hagelthorn on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Liz Hagelthorn on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@LizHagelthorn?source=rss-8a49df8dda2a------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Tue, 17 Nov 2026 15:03:17 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@LizHagelthorn/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Creative Revolution: AI, Copyright Law, and the New Era of Digital Artistry]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@LizHagelthorn/creative-revolution-ai-copyright-law-and-the-new-era-of-digital-artistry-e857afa8bde3?source=rss-8a49df8dda2a------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/e857afa8bde3</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[copyright]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[licensing]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[social-media]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ai]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ip]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Liz Hagelthorn]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 01 Feb 2024 06:19:54 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-02-01T06:19:54.953Z</atom:updated>
            <cc:license>https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nd/4.0/</cc:license>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>This article navigates the transformative impact of AI on the creative industry, examining the evolving legal landscapes and the new challenges and opportunities they present for digital artistry.</em></p><p><em>In this article, I share my insights as a meme maker and founder of </em><a href="http://smarterlicense.com/"><em>SmarterLicense</em></a><em>, exploring the intersection of creativity, commerce, and technology with a focus on AI’s impact in these realms. I reflect on my experiences and learnings from the Copyright Society Midwinter 2024 Meeting, where I gained valuable perspectives on copyright, artistry, and AI. This piece delves into the challenges and opportunities presented by AI in the digital world, emphasizing the importance of proactive digital rights management on social media and the evolving legal landscape. I discuss the critical role of AI in shaping content creation and highlight the necessity of innovative platforms like </em><a href="http://smarterlicense.com/"><em>SmarterLicense</em></a><em> for managing and monetizing creative works. Additionally, I explore the emerging significance of datasets in AI development, underscoring how they are becoming the new canvas for creatives and the need for solutions that protect their rights and ensure proper usage.</em></p><p><em>Learn more about SmarterLicense at </em><a href="http://smarterlicense.com/"><em>SmarterLicense.com</em></a></p><p>For the better part of my career, and indeed much of my life, I have found myself at the vibrant crossroads where creativity, commerce, and technology converge. As a meme maker, I’ve reveled in the art of remixing and setting the stage for others to re-imagine content, adding their unique twist to my creative meme formats.</p><p>My creative pursuits are my livelihood, where virality gives value, but unfortunately virality doesn’t pay bills. My work requires balancing the act of freely sharing ideas with the necessity of making a living. My deep-seated experience in social media has afforded me a unique vantage point to observe and participate in this ever-evolving space.</p><p>My platform, <a href="http://smarterlicense.com/">SmarterLicense</a>, is a manifestation of this balance, a platform where monetization, licensing and creative works are the cornerstone of innovative tools that work with our existing web. The inception of <a href="http://smarterlicense.com/">SmarterLicense</a> embodies my dedication to navigating the complexities introduced by digital and social media advancements. I’m blessed to work on technological innovations that represent a holistic approach to reshaping the exchange, utilization, and monetization of creative works in the digital realm.</p><p>From viral growth strategies to leading creative for pseudonymous networks, my journey has been one of constant learning and adaptation. As AI becomes an increasingly integral part of our digital ecosystem, I’ve dedicated my focus to addressing the challenges it presents, especially in studying the incentives and identifying the next creative frontiers.</p><h3>Insights from the Copyright Society Midwinter Meeting</h3><p>Recently, I attended the <a href="https://copyrightsociety.org/event/2024-midwinter-meeting/?event=7489">Copyright Society Midwinter 2024</a> Meeting. This gathering was a convergence of some of the most brilliant legal minds grappling with the intertwined realms of copyright, artistry, and artificial intelligence (AI).</p><p>Although I found the weekend incredibly valuable and informative, I discovered that there are many existing problems in this space. My startup, <a href="http://smarterlicense.com/">SmarterLicense</a>, has become my medium for solving these problems. In this piece, I want to explain some of what I learned, outstanding issues that remain unaddressed, and the ways that code can solve some of the thorniest difficulties regarding content creation, IP rights, and AI.</p><p>Among the highlights was my artwork, “Wizard of Palm Springs,” created using my original photo and Adobe Firefly, won the AI Art Contest! I created this piece to pose the question: “In an age where AI and open-source tools are used with an original photograph I took, where do the boundaries of infringement lie?”</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/510/0*xrFrcJAYlm6qWZWI.jpeg" /></figure><p><em>“Wizard of Palm Springs” by Liz Hagelthorn</em></p><p><em>To license this piece, simply visit my </em><a href="https://smarterlicense.com/post/7e2e841f-8b62-4ff9-a748-13ad339eb360"><em>SmarterLicense listing</em></a><em>.</em></p><p>The event was an enlightening melting pot of ideas at the intersection of art, technology, and law. Key discussions included panels like “Navigating the Legal Pitfalls of Social Media,” featuring experts Shannon Green, Global General Counsel, Anomaly, Hannah E. Taylor, Partner, Frankfurt Kurnit Klein &amp; Selz and Maddy Batliboi, Global Head of Music Legal, Meta. They delved into the evolving challenges their clients face on social media and highlighted the critical need for adaptable, informed strategies in our rapidly shifting technological landscape. My takeaway from their talk is that a lot of these patterns are the same ones that we see in trying to solve the problems raised by AI and media.</p><p>Here are some of the takeaways and common legal risks I see brands and buyers get in trouble legally and financially:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/474/0*eIcgg8fwC1nlwk8l.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/474/0*pE6MJ-KmfvxFuZHi.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/474/0*_S6Tv5m926FayvJ_.png" /></figure><p>During the conference, these slides served as visual anchors for the rich discussions, providing attendees with tangible takeaways to apply in their practices.</p><p>As I reflect on the panels and the exchanges of ideas around social media, there’s a lot of practical wisdom for navigating the copyright terrain in a new AI-driven world.</p><h3>Enhancing Digital Rights Management: The Need for Proactive Search Tools from Social Media Platforms</h3><p>As highlighted in the panel, the management and protection of intellectual property (IP) on social media platforms are paramount. The discussions at the Copyright Society Midwinter Meeting, particularly with Meta’s presence on the panel, highlighted a glaring omission in the current digital rights management (DRM) ecosystem despite having tools like CrowdTangle already built. Specifically, to allow rights holders and their legal teams to efficiently search for their marks across platforms such as Instagram and Facebook. This deficiency underscores a critical need for social media giants to either harness the potential of existing tools more effectively or innovate new solutions tailored to meet the unique requirements of rights holders.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/750/0*IBVIdzwPO2CojxBx.jpeg" /></figure><p><a href="https://i.vimeocdn.com/video/906417256-f5b4958a505a66178e425a02681b9eeeb6a3d1431f5495daa9c0f9c1a0fde578-d_750x421.875?q=60">source: CrowdTangle Screenshot</a></p><p><strong>The Critical Gap in Current DRM Practices</strong></p><p>The absence of a recommended, dedicated system for IP search and management significantly hinders rights holders’ ability to safeguard their intellectual property. This challenge leaves rights holders in a reactive stance, scrambling to identify and address infringements after they’ve occurred rather than preventing them proactively.</p><p><strong>The Urgent Need for a Proactive DRM Approach</strong></p><p>The digital era demands a DRM strategy from major social media and content platforms that is both proactive and automated, offering rights holders the tools necessary to monitor their IP comprehensively and take swift action against potential infringements.</p><p>This approach should ideally include:</p><ul><li>Automated Monitoring: Utilizing advanced algorithms and machine learning to scan social media platforms for specific trademarks, logos, and copyrighted materials, providing real-time alerts to rightsholders.</li><li>Efficient IP Search and Management: A feature within social media ecosystems that allows for efficient search and export of intellectual property marks, facilitating easier tracking and enforcement.</li><li>Collaborative DRM Solutions: Encouraging collaboration between social media platforms and IP management solutions to create a more integrated and effective DRM system that is interoperable across each platform.</li></ul><p><strong>A Call for Innovation and Collaboration</strong></p><p>By developing and implementing systems that allow for efficient IP search and management, social media and content distribution platforms can significantly enhance the ability of rights holders to protect their intellectual property, fostering a digital environment that respects and upholds the rights of creators and innovators. Rights Holders and their legal teams must continue to demand this. After all, without content, platforms are empty. Creators should use their leverage to require platforms to support their rights.</p><h3>Navigating Copyright Law vs. Platform Tools Empowering Massive Infringement</h3><p>The less ownership you have in a file, the higher the risk and the greater the need for a proper license, regardless of the type of creative work involved or the distribution method. This principle has been a cornerstone of copyright law, which has evolved to offer solutions for various media types through the development of technology and platforms.</p><p><strong>A crucial point underscored by the speakers was the divergence between copyright law, which governs usage, and the platforms’ terms, products, and features that sometimes facilitate mass infringement. A prime example of this is the use of “embeddings” on social media platforms.</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*yaXIeI2UtCkzZvRh.png" /></figure><h4>Case Example: Justin Goldman v. Breibart News Network, LLC et. al.</h4><p>A famous instance highlighting the “Twitter embed” issue is the 2016 case of <em>Justin Goldman v. Breitbart News Network</em>.</p><ul><li>Background: Goldman took a photograph of Tom Brady and Danny Ainge, which he posted on Snapchat. The image quickly went viral including across Twitter/X.</li><li>Infringement Issue: Several online publications, including Breibart and The Boston Globe embedded tweets containing Goldman’s photo in their news stories without his permission.</li><li>Court’s Ruling: The judge ruled in Goldman’s favor based on two important points:</li><li>The substantial nature of Goldman’s picture that had been taken.</li><li>The failure of the publications to license the image through standard copyright methods.</li></ul><p>The case highlights the complexities of copyright law vs. platform tools. Platforms have embedding or “share to story” features that actively enable widespread copyright infringement. In addition to the Goldman case where infringement happened via Twitter’s embedding feature, each platform has their own copyright landmines. <a href="https://www.womblebonddickinson.com/sites/default/files/2023-11/Complaint_OFRA_Cosmetics.pdf">There are countless cases where</a> on Instagram, brands share creator content to their stories featuring commercial music overlays and get sued. There is a gap between the legal framework governing copyright and the mechanisms provided by social media platforms do not align with traditional copyright norms. It’s very difficult to bring claims against platforms for any of this and it’s up to users and advertisers to protect themselves.</p><h3>Re-examining “Commercial Use” in the age of AI and Social Media</h3><p>In the realm of social media, ‘commerciality’ carries weighty legal implications, exemplified by the recent Midwinter Meeting’s focus on copyright law. The discussions were punctuated by the Supreme Court’s decision in <em>Andy Warhol Foundation for the Visual Arts, Inc. v. Goldsmith</em>, a case that probes the boundaries of copyright and fair use in the context of artistic transformation and commercial intent.</p><p>Here are the critical takeaways from the ruling:</p><ul><li>Infringement of Copyright: The Supreme Court’s decision confirms that one of Warhol’s works, derived from Lynn Goldsmith’s photograph of Prince, was not protected under “fair use” because it infringed upon Goldsmith’s copyright.</li><li>Commercial Purpose: Justice Sonia Sotomayor’s majority opinion highlighted that both Goldman’s photograph and Warhol’s variation served commercial purposes in portraying Prince, which aligns them more with copyright infringement than fair use.</li><li>Purpose and Character: The ruling suggests that if the secondary work’s purpose and character had been distinctly different from the original, the decision might have come out differently, indicating that visual variation alone does not exempt a work from copyright concerns if it fulfills a similar commercial function.</li><li>Impact on Artistic Expression: Justice Elena Kagan’s dissent cautions that this interpretation of fair use could inhibit artistic creativity, as it narrows the scope for artists to draw from existing works without seeking permission.</li></ul><p>The Supreme Court’s <em>Warhol</em> opinion seems miles away from the very real problems raised by internet content and the growth of AI. The isolated one-to-one comparison conducted by the Court assumes a business model that allows for a single image to be featured on the cover of a magazine, or as a page accompanying an article inside. The economic context of online creators bears little–if any–resemblance to this. It is extraordinarily difficult to use <em>Warhol</em> as a source of usable rules to govern online infringement because its perspective is founded on a business model that appears long ago and far away.</p><h3>Commercial Interests in the Creator Economy</h3><p>First, the concept of a static image for editorial use as a point of comparison is nonsensical in the so-called Creator Economy. Each creator operates as a source of content over time operating within a reputation economy that builds up an engaged audience. The commercial realm in the virtual space is entirely different. For example, a creator who posts ten times per day provides a mix of sponsored and non-sponsored posts. The balance of ads vs. organic content is the same as the platforms themselves. Generally, nonsponsored posts have no monetization attached. Sponsored posts do, sometimes because they are paid for by a brand or the creator has found another way to monetize the posts on the platform. In the vast majority of cases, nonsponsored posts have highly engaging content and are usually the reasons that subscribers engage. At the same time, a timeline of completely sponsored posts quickly dies. No one wants to see 100% ads.</p><p>Once content creators learn which of their posts get the most views, they tailor later posts to match those algorithmic preferences to maximize reach, subscribers, and income. If a platform’s algorithm is prioritizing a particular type of sound, look, provocative language, or the like, creators pick up on those preferences and follow suit. In this way, the content creator’s conduct is inherently commercial because it is heavily influenced by the platform’s preferences. These considerations are entirely absent from the economic underpinning in the <em>Warhol</em> case.</p><p>In addition, the pure demand of volume of content required by platforms is impossible for a single content creator to meet day by day and grow a sustainable business from. To meet the posting standards of dominant social media platforms, users will inevitably infringe in the way they engage with, react to or create from copyrighted works that may be trending at any given time.</p><p>The successful creator, one who is building their audience in a reputation economy– monetizes their account by providing a mix of both sponsored and nonsponsored posts, balancing the two to maximize their reach. Thus, it makes little sense to say that a nonsponsored post is noncommercial. At the end of the day, all of the creator’s posts are commercial.<em> All </em>posts generated by a creator who wishes to earn are commercial.</p><p>Second, this underscores the symbiotic relationship between content creators and platforms. Platforms are, by their nature, commercial entities. They earn money in various ways, some pay out money to creators like YouTube’s AdSense program. Platforms dictate the pace and type of content that will be prioritized to viewers. Platforms themselves are profiting from both types of content, sponsored and non-sponsored, using organic user generated content to offset advertisements run through their platform. In a similar way a creator may monetize their page, platforms are monetizing their platform by serving advertisements within the organic “non-monetized” content without cutting in any creator.</p><p>Platforms are directly monetizing any infringement that’s happening on their platform. The idea of fair use goes out the door because platforms are monetizing this content and if we take the <em>Warhol</em> judgment seriously, this is extremely problematic for the platforms since they are making commerce from any infringement that happens on them. However, platforms have protection under the DMCA and if the infringed rightsholder files a complaint, platforms have to follow a take-down process. However, rightsholders must find the infringement first because nobody can file on their behalf with the platforms.</p><p>Given this, I propose the following points should be under consideration in the era of social media:</p><ul><li>Platforms as Enablers of Monetization: Social media platforms have evolved from mere conduits to active enablers of monetization, suggesting that any activity on these platforms is implicitly commercial.</li><li>The ‘Creator’ Economy: The term ‘Creator’ blurs the lines between personal expression and commercial enterprise, propelling users to exploit their content and followers for financial gain within this economy.</li><li>Off-Platform Economic Impact: The value attributed to followers and reputation on social media bestows an economic dimension to interactions, hinting at an inherent commercial motive behind such engagements.</li><li>Legal Ambiguity and the Creator Economy: The burgeoning Creator Economy necessitates a reevaluation of the current copyright law, seeking clarity and certainty while personal and commercial content creation increasingly converge.</li></ul><p>The legal ecosystem must evolve alongside the digital environment, especially as the creator economy reshapes the landscape of copyright. Creators, platforms, and legal professionals must work together to navigate this intricate terrain, ensuring that copyright laws remain relevant and accommodating in the age of AI and the expanding creator economy.</p><h3>Implementing Solutions</h3><p>Reflecting on these discussions, it becomes evident how SmarterLicense will play a transformative role in addressing these copyright challenges. SmarterLicense’s modular licensing agreements, which allow for customizable terms and adaptable grants and restrictions, provide a much-needed flexible framework in an environment where creative works are extensively used in AI and machine learning.</p><h3>SmarterLicense: Revolutionizing IP Management with Modular Licensing Agreements</h3><p>At the core of SmarterLicense’s innovation is the development of modular licensing agreements. This groundbreaking approach provides the flexibility required to navigate the complex and dynamic nature of digital content creation and usage in an AI-driven world. Modular licensing agreements allow creators and rightsholders to tailor the terms of their licenses to specific use cases, ensuring that the value of their creative work is accurately reflected across different contexts and applications.</p><p><strong>The benefits of modular licensing are multidimensional:</strong></p><ul><li><strong>Customizable Terms</strong>: Rights Holders and/or buyers can adjust the terms of a license according to specific scenarios, offering a personalized approach to IP management.</li><li><strong>Adaptable Grants and Restrictions</strong>: The flexibility to modify rights within a license caters to the evolving needs of digital content usage, particularly in AI applications.</li><li><strong>Dynamic Pricing Models</strong>: Pricing can be varied based on the scope of use, duration, or the profile of the licensee, ensuring fair compensation for creators.</li><li><strong>Licenses in Machine-Readable Formats</strong>: A pioneering feature that integrates licensing terms directly into code, facilitating legal compliance and ethical use of creative works as a wrapper in AI and generative tools.</li><li><strong>Retroactive Licensing Capability</strong>: Recognizing the vast expanse of content already available (and stolen) online, SmarterLicense introduces retroactive licensing. This is critical for content that pre-dates the advent of new technologies and for which rights holders seek to secure appropriate licensing arrangements after the fact. It allows for the retrospective alignment of content with current copyright laws and ethical standards, ensuring rights holders can recover due compensation and control over their past works.</li></ul><p>Complementing this, our tool “SmarterLinks” pioneered a streaming-first model for digital asset management. My platform transforms the way digital assets are shared, accessed, and managed, embodying the convenience and efficiency of streaming services. It marks a pivotal shift towards more cost saving file management, seamless digital interactions, and unmatched control over assets.</p><p>SmarterLicense allows for real-time management, access revocation, and detailed usage tracking, making it a game-changer in IP management.</p><h4>Use Cases: Bringing the Concepts to Life</h4><p>To illustrate how these innovations can be applied in real-world scenarios, consider the following use cases:</p><ol><li>Agency Campaign for Celebrity “Barbi”: In a digital campaign for Barbi, a marketing agency utilizes SmarterLinks to share her digital content securely and manage it with flexibility. They create unique pointers for each digital asset, integrated directly into the campaign’s infrastructure. This allows real-time content updates and ensures fans always have access to the latest materials. After the campaign, Barbi can instantly revoke the pointers, withdrawing access to her content and preventing further use.</li><li>AI Model Training: The marketing agency develops an AI model tailored to enhance Barbi’s digital engagement, using her digital assets for training. Upon the campaign’s conclusion, Barbi revokes access to her content, effectively stopping the AI model from using her assets for further learning or development.</li></ol><p>These use cases demonstrate how SmarterLicense and SmarterLinks can be instrumental in modern digital asset management, offering unprecedented control and flexibility. They showcase the platforms’ ability to adapt to the evolving needs of digital campaigns while ensuring that creative rights are preserved in an increasingly AI-integrated world.</p><p><a href="https://www.smarterlicense.com/">Learn more about SmarterLicense</a></p><h3>The Future of AI and Intellectual Property — Pioneering with Modular Licensing Agreements and Dataset Creation</h3><p>Most recently, SmarterLicense has added an AI license to protect both buyers and sellers to our platform. Users can now list properties or send offers on content for the use of AI. Simply select “AI License” when utilizing one of our many tools.</p><h3>Utilizing SmarterLicense’s AI Licensing Feature: Practical Scenarios</h3><p>Content Owners Licensing for AI Use:</p><ol><li>Scenario: A photographer owns a collection of unique wildlife photographs. They want to make these available for AI training purposes, ensuring their intellectual property rights are protected.</li><li>Process: Using SmarterLicense, the photographer selects the ‘AI License’ option to specify the terms, attribution and price under which their photographs can be used for AI training.</li><li>Outcome: Companies or individuals interested in using these photographs for AI training can license the photographers images and dataset quickly and easily.</li></ol><p>Scenario: AI Developers Generating Offers for Website Content</p><ol><li>Context: An AI development team is working on a natural language processing project and identifies a website with extensive articles and resources that would be valuable for their AI training. They require legal permission to use this content.</li><li>Using SmarterLicense for Quick Offer Generation:</li><li>Step 1: Identify Content: The AI developers identify the specific website content that aligns with their project requirements.</li><li>Step 2: Generate Offer: Through SmarterLicense, the developers create an offer for the website content. They specify the scope of AI usage, duration, and any compensation or attribution terms.</li><li>Step 3: Send Offer: The offer is directly sent to the website owner.</li><li>Outcome:</li><li>Website Owner’s Review: The website owner receives the offer and reviews the proposed terms for AI usage of their content.</li><li>Negotiation and Agreement: If the website owner agrees to the terms, they accept the offer through SmarterLicense, add payout information and upload any additional files for distribution upon approval.</li></ol><h3>Dataset Creation: The New Frontier for Non-Technical Creatives</h3><p>AI thrives on datasets and a clear gap in existing models like OpenAI and other open source models on sites like HuggingFace is the existence of private, high quality, interoperable, proprietary datasets around underlying IP.</p><p>I’ve been studying and building AI tools for creatives over the past year and a half. Based on my experience, the way forward is in the creation of datasets as a new canvas for creatives, especially those who may not have a technical background. This emerging domain is where creativity meets technology, and SmarterLicense is leading the charge in empowering creatives to contribute to AI development through safe dataset creation. This enables creators to use AI in a focused and propriety way to fuel their creativity without opening their sources and their final work product to appropriation.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*EjOpExSal-ncBJ_I.png" /></figure><p>The Diagram (above), explained:</p><ol><li>Underlying AI Model: At the base, we have an AI model (like those from OpenAI or Llama that can be found on HuggingFace), symbolized by the green base plate. This is the foundational technology upon which everything else is built and fine tuned to generate new AI tools.</li><li>Other Datasets: Around the AI Builder, there are other datasets, depicted by various animal figures. These represent publicly available or generic datasets that are typically used to “tune” AI models.</li><li>AI Builder: The character holding a wooden piece represents an AI Builder who adds datasets to enhance the AI tool, in this case, an Animal Kingdom AI tool. This symbolizes the customization and refinement of AI models using additional data.</li><li>Rightsholder: The rightsholder, symbolized by the figure in a suit, holds the key to proprietary datasets and source IP. They are the custodians of unique, high-quality datasets that have significant communicative value and cultural impact.</li><li>SmarterLicense: This represents a platform that facilitates the transformation of traditional content and IP into datasets that AI can use effectively. It ensures that rightsholders are protected and that their creative intent and IP integrity are maintained.</li><li>Rightsholder Dataset and Source IP: The lions and associated images within the rightsholder’s area signify the proprietary datasets. These are exclusive and high-quality datasets that are interoperable with the underlying AI model. They contain the rightsholder’s source IP, which is valuable for training AI in specific, niche, or culturally significant contexts.</li><li>Derivative Works and Code: The transition from rightsholder datasets to AI models involves converting IP into a form that AI can understand — code. This process is akin to creating derivative works that maintain the essence of the original IP but in a format suitable for AI training and application.</li></ol><p>The diagram and its breakdown illustrate that private, high-quality datasets based on rightsholders’ IP are the new frontier for creatives. Platforms like SmarterLicense are crucial for ensuring these assets are correctly transformed into code for AI use while protecting rightsholders’ interests and fostering a future where trust in online content and IP management is restored.</p><p>I believe that creatives and rightsholders are not currently protected and will get taken advantage of through the next few years. AI companies, who mis-describe the methods of training models and their uses, are incentivize to actively lead us astray because they have no experience in use cases they build for. Fueled by billions in investment, the AI tech ecosystem has severely underestimated the communicative value of talent, fan bases and globally-recognized IP. Their vision for the future doesn’t account for a time when trust is completely broken online.</p><h3>Derivative Works and Code</h3><p>For existing content and IP, datasets serve as instructional code akin to derivative works of the underlying IP on which models are trained on. However, for AI to effectively use these assets, they must be converted into code. SmarterLicense is working on solutions that facilitate this transformation, ensuring that creative intent and IP integrity are maintained.</p><p>AI’s potential is unlocked when the datasets it learns from are rich with the nuances that only creatives can provide. It’s these subtleties and intricacies from artists, writers, and musicians that infuse AI tools with the depth and relatability needed to truly resonate with audiences.</p><p>Without this creative input, datasets become mere shells, lacking the fidelity to mirror the human experience and failing to earn the trust of the users they’re designed to serve. Without this interoperability and input from creatives, AI tools risk becoming detached from the cultural context and fail to resonate with users. The tech industry must prioritize building datasets that are not only technically compatible across various models but are also embedded with the creative essence that gives technology its soul and appeal.</p><p>By promoting interoperability and control, we advocate for a future where AI tools and platforms serve the creative community, not exploit it. Tech builders can code day in and day out, but without the nuance and predictability provided in accompanying datasets, their tech may remain unused, sitting in digital silence.</p><h3>Conclusion: A Vision for the Future</h3><p>As we navigate the copyright landscape reshaped by AI and the creator economy, integrating solutions like SmarterLicense is crucial. Existing mechanisms have not kept up. These tools not only offer practical ways to manage digital assets but also inspire a more balanced approach that respects both creative freedom and copyright law in the age of digital transformation.</p><p>If you would like to discuss integrating SmarterLicense into your existing technology or to support your IP portfolios, please reach out <a href="/service/mailto:liz@smarterlicense.com">liz@smarterlicense.com</a>.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=e857afa8bde3" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Twitter (X) Made It’s Algorithm Public — Here’s what you need to know…]]></title>
            <description><![CDATA[<div class="medium-feed-item"><p class="medium-feed-image"><a href="https://medium.com/@LizHagelthorn/twitter-x-made-its-algorithm-public-here-s-what-you-need-to-know-f65f56368bf5?source=rss-8a49df8dda2a------2"><img src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1456/0*OLM17FONPDwguo59.jpeg" width="1456"></a></p><p class="medium-feed-snippet">If you are a brand, business, publisher or creator and looking to use this post on your blog, newsletter, website, social media or other&#x2026;</p><p class="medium-feed-link"><a href="https://medium.com/@LizHagelthorn/twitter-x-made-its-algorithm-public-here-s-what-you-need-to-know-f65f56368bf5?source=rss-8a49df8dda2a------2">Continue reading on Medium »</a></p></div>]]></description>
            <link>https://medium.com/@LizHagelthorn/twitter-x-made-its-algorithm-public-here-s-what-you-need-to-know-f65f56368bf5?source=rss-8a49df8dda2a------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/f65f56368bf5</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Liz Hagelthorn]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 01 Feb 2024 06:07:36 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-02-01T06:07:36.038Z</atom:updated>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Social Strategy Deep Dive: The Kardashian’s Instagram activity since 2015 to present day]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@LizHagelthorn/social-strategy-deep-dive-the-kardashians-instagram-activity-since-2015-to-present-day-773c8254677d?source=rss-8a49df8dda2a------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/773c8254677d</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[digital-marketing]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[social-media]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[kardashian]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Liz Hagelthorn]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 27 Feb 2023 22:24:49 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-02-27T22:25:28.039Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>What creators and brands can learn from the world’s most followed family on Instagram.</h3><h4>*this article was originally posted on my Substack where I post about memes, organic virality, digital culture and social media. Subscribe here: <a href="http://lizh.substack.com/">lizh.substack.com</a></h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*qaMK3ZtRrjugQZUO.jpeg" /></figure><p><em>In this article, I discusses the incredible growth and popularity of the Kardashian/Jenner family on Instagram from January 2015 to January 2023. In the last year alone, their followers increased by 314.97 million, or 24.33%. The article emphasizes the importance of the comments/likes ratio and consistency in posting. The article also examines the top-performing posts, which are determined by Instagram’s overperformance score. The article highlights the importance of focusing on the people who work behind the scenes of any business and who can create personal connections with audiences. Additionally, I discusse a post by Kim Kardashian’s SKIMS Instagram account that featured actresses Simona Tabasco and Bea Granno from HBO’s White Lotus season 2. The article concludes by emphasizing the importance of active comment sections in creating cultural zeitgeist and growth opportunities for brands.</em></p><p>Ummm hi hello! How are you? I’m good except I dove deep into the Instagram posts of Kim, Kourtney, Kris, Kourtney, Kylie and Kendall since 2015! Do I have the time to do this? Absolutely not! Are there tons of learnings I thought you’d find interesting? You bet!</p><p>I should preface this by saying that not everyone is part of the most famous family in the world. You can have all of the Instagram followers in the world but you are always competing with someone. And when you’re comparing and competing, you’re miserable. Be happy with the following you have. Connect with people in your life. The comparison journey is a race to some pretty bad feelings. Unless you’re Kylie Jenner. Then you are absolutely crushing everyone. And there’s lots to learn by digging into their stats.</p><p>Let’s begin….</p><p>This data covers the period of 1/1/2015 to 1/26/2023. Please note this does *not* include Reels. The software I’m using does not allow me to pull Reels data without doing it by hand (no thanks!). So here you go!</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*HQUuK4iFd9wIwu2E.jpeg" /></figure><p>Here’s the overview– the Kardashian/Jenner women have 1.55B followers in total. From January 2022 to January 2023, this number grew 314.97M in total, or 24.33%. That’s astonishing growth– for those who post most actively and engage meaningfully with their followers, growth between 1.69% and 2%-6% is considered very high. Not to mention, the more followers you have after 1m+, the harder it is to grow. Kylie has the most followers with 379.74M. Khloe’s follower growth was the highest at over 33%.</p><p>In the next sections, I will highlight the importance comments/likes ratio, how many times the women are posting per day, the top performing posts and what we can learn from it all.</p><h3>At-A-Glance: Kylie Leads in Total Interactions (Comments + Likes)</h3><p>Maybe I am biased because I am obsessed with SKIMS or her net worth is the highest at $1.7b, but I had assumed Kim is the most followed. I was completely shocked to see Kylie has such a lead in total interactions. Her numbers alone are pretty wild.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*aCqqfZJjHHHrgzxg.jpeg" /></figure><p>To put these interactions into context, the <a href="https://www.sportsmediawatch.com/super-bowl-ratings-historical-viewership-chart-cbs-nbc-fox-abc/">total views of the Superbowl</a> since 1967 is 4.67b. This means that 5x more people have either liked or commented on one of the Kardashian women’s Instagram posts in the last 8 years than have watched the Superbowl in the last 55 years. In other words, this family owns more audience numbers than almost anyone else can imagine reaching. This does not include Reels, view counts or their numbers from other social media platforms, let alone viewers of their popular reality television show which has gone 10+ seasons.</p><p>Another stat to blow your mind, their family’s total interactions are 28.23B but there are only 8B people in the world. This is 3.5x the world’s population. <strong><em>Kylie’s Instagram likes in the past 8 years alone (13.23B) are approx 1.5x the entire world population</em></strong>.</p><h3>The Importance of Your Comment Section</h3><p>Their comment section is as important as the posts themselves. The posts act as mirrors for our lives and the comment section is where we discuss our own perspectives with each other. Generally, they cover a plethora of topics and conversations related to the themes of the posts.</p><p>Kendall, despite having almost ~700M less likes than her sisters Kourtney and Khloe, has over 15M and 8M more comments, respectively. Yay for her. But these numbers raise a red flag for me. They could be a signal that there’s negativity or fighting in her comment section. Kendall is hearing a lot more in the comment section than the ratio of her “likes” compared to her famous sisters. Comments are not always positive, especially when they outnumber averages of “likes”. I imagine this can be a lot to deal with. Kendall famously discusses her struggles with her mental health.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*mpLY7s11B5OYv1il.jpeg" /></figure><ul><li>Consistency is key. The family has posted 1–2x per day over the years.</li><li>Per the diagram on the bottom left side, the family has posted fewer individual posts through the years and have focused on carousel posts aka “albums”. People spend more time on posts they have to swipe through and read long captions for. When people spend more time on your posts, Instagram continues to serve your posts to more people. Hence the high performance. Everyone should be posting carousel posts.</li><li>This chart does not include posts that have been archived or removed.</li></ul><h3>Which side of posts performed better?</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*X21U2u7leL400HzB.jpeg" /></figure><h3>Which posts had a higher performing score?</h3><p>Can you guess? Keep scrolling for the answer…</p><h3>Top Posts &amp; Methodology</h3><p>The methodology for the top posts among the Kardashian/Jenner women is the same methodology that Instagram uses, which is by an “over performance score.” This score weighs comments 1:1 with likes. This means comment/like ratios are weighted and higher when the first initial people see the post, then interact with it by liking or commenting. The more people who saw the post in the beginning hours of its time on Instagram, the more Instagram showed the post(s) to people. This is the key for growth of accounts no matter your follower numbers. If I covered the top posts solely by interactions (likes + comments), Kylie’s posts would outrank everyone because of how many more followers and interactions (likes + comments) she has. So I’m going to do my analysis by looking at posts that overperform how they “should” do based on those factors alone.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*HPjxmurvPA3pMxhQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>Did you guess the right side above? If so, congratulations my lil social media genius. You’re hired.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*cMpwB8BVogVy8hbE.jpeg" /></figure><p><strong>Top Posts: Everyone should get their mom on Instagram</strong></p><ul><li>As far as overperforming scores go, Kris Jenner leads the way in performance of posts. Despite having the lowest followers, Kris has the most potential for the fastest growth. Kris also posts double (avg 2x per day) than the rest of the Kardashian/Jenner women.</li><li>Based on these, everyone should get their mom on Instagram and have them post about your birthdays, weddings and major moments in your life. Kris’ posts that do the best feature her children and grandkids.</li><li>Kris’s top performing posts all include Kylie (the highest performing and most followed of the Kardashian women). So if you have a super popular, influential friend or product, focus on posting hype moments around that. Kris should post more of North. People on Instagram love Northie.</li><li>Speaking of hyping your friends and loved ones up, Kris is the perfect hype woman. Performance is higher when Kris posts her support of others rather than celebrating herself.</li><li>Kris has mastered the “through the years” and contextual posts aggregating all of the Kardashian happenings and people into a single frame. If you notice, her top posts have multiple pictures within one frame either of people through the years or in a contextual context or of ALL the kids, ALL of the sisters, ALL of the baby daddys in one frame. Another is Queen Elizabeth (through the generations) in one frame.</li><li>Kris supporting the men in the Kardashian/Jenner women’s lives is also notable. If she were my client I’d recommend she continue to do so. Whether it’s Travis Scott’s birthday or the unfortunate loss of Tristan’s mom, these are just a few examples of her posts of “support.” that bring significant follower interactions</li><li>Black and white pictures also perform better. It adds a sense of sentimentality to the life moments.</li></ul><h3>We like big butts we cannot lie… or do we?</h3><p>One thing not pictured as high performing on this slide: body, booty and sexy selfies. People are not drawn to the aspirational lifestyle and images as they were during social media’s past. I also have a theory here that most of their followers are women so they are looking for connection and intimate moments. That’s not what’s keeping people hooked and works to grow careers. It is the uniqueness to our stories and our relationships with each other which is bringing the biggest response here. In fact some of their lowest performing posts are Kylie on a yacht that feel extremely staged. People want the BTS, the journey and the raw footage. People want to see the inside of your closet, KIM (me).</p><p>To look at Kim specifically, even from Instagram’s early days in 2015 and especially into 2018/2019, Kim’s children were always her top performing posts by 5x+ which is extremely significant. On average, most of her posts perform 1.5x better than the others. Here are all of her top performing posts since 2015.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*i-aU8PCwrQcUlY96.jpeg" /></figure><p>It’s always been about her kids and family. Have you been paying attention? The decline of posts of sexy photos feels inevitable when you look at the numbers this way, doesn’t it?</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*OOBHDojmXIRBhCjK.jpeg" /></figure><p>The transition of Kim from sexy to savvy is a great example of how anyone can learn and start implementing long term strategies for their life (and social media posts). It is time that people stopped wasting their time scrolling, posting and consuming and started envisioning their dreams and what the steps are to get there. I talk about this at length <a href="https://lizh.substack.com/p/state-of-social-media-2023-goodbye">here</a>.</p><p>Kim didn’t speak at Harvard overnight. This was a long term dream and she is showing the steps of what it took to get there. In order to understand how your brand will perform in the future, you need to look at what performs best for you and how you can up-level and magnify the sides of yourself that lead to growth and long term development. A picture of yourself outside of a class you just spoke to at Harvard is the new museum of ice cream. What are your gifts, how do you want to take accountability for them? What does that look like when you get there?</p><p>One of Kim’s last sexy top performing posts is very TikTok, pre-TikTok. 1–3 seconds to hook you with her voice and a black screen with a question, “Can you guys see what’s going on here”, and then 1–2 second stills of her and her sisters. To read more about TikTok hacks, please read <a href="https://lizh.substack.com/p/how-to-go-viral-on-tiktok-and-other">my piece on TikTok</a> hacks.</p><p><a href="https://instagram.com/kimkardashian">kimkardashian</a></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/640/0*LSx4NaofgS8hJ8yp.jpg" /></figure><p>A post shared by Kim Kardashian (<a href="https://instagram.com/kimkardashian">@kimkardashian</a>)</p><h3>Sentimentality and Connection</h3><p>People see the imperfections of the Kardashians and relate to them. The families aren’t nuclear ones, they’re forging their own path. It’s easy to minimize their relevance, but I think people seek out more about them than just their beauty and wealth.</p><p>Public audiences want to see an “authentic” family, throwbacks and sentimental moments of the Kardashian/Jenner women especially. Public sentiment around them using their bodies or sex appeal to attract audiences are missing the larger picture.</p><h3>What We Can Learn</h3><p>If you are a brand or a business, your employees are not your family and there’s only one Kardasian/Jenner family. But one lesson is that you should focus on highlighting the people who run your accounts, who work behind the scenes of your business, and who can create personal connections with audiences. These types of posts would overperform to the rest of your metrics. People want to connect and relate to other people. Supporting and uplifting others always wins.</p><p>We can also learn that we should be empowering individuality through dialogue. Digital technology and emotional storytelling are not mutually exclusive (but are always treated this way). Social media means facilitating dialogue between consumers and brands. <strong>Without emotional connection, no amount of technology will inspire attention, purchases or loyalty</strong>. Brands must empower dialogue around issues that its demographic cares about. Championing values in sophisticated ways works, not forcing perceived relevance.</p><p>Another thing we can learn is how to tap into the value of sentimentality to provide exhausted, troubled consumers with emotional escapism. There is a facility of nostalgia with experiential and visual ways to update existing norms. This is seen in the visual power of Kris Jenner’s contextual / historical timelines of the people in their family.</p><h3>Where should the Kardashians take this?</h3><p>Kim’s top performing posts used to do 5–6x the others. Since 2022 and 2023, they’ve done about 1.5–2x better than her other posts. What I’d love to see the Kardashian/Jenner women discuss: One or more of the sisters really discussing the struggles around the way we talk to ourselves. One thing I don’t see discussed a lot is how we are often our own worst critic and that most of what people say about us doesn’t compare to the things we say to ourselves. <strong>How we talk to ourselves really matters</strong>. Dealing with this struggle is an incredibly hard pattern to break but I think discussing mental health at length and how we can crawl out of dark holes could be really healing for the multiple generations of people who now spend the majority of their time online. Particularly now, there’s a lot of trauma.</p><p>Having one of the most “perceived” and viewed internet families discuss this struggle could be a really important for emotional connection among audiences. As mentioned above, the families’ comment section is as important as the posts themselves. Representing a plethora of topics and conversations related to the themes of the posts. The posts act as mirrors for our lives and the comment section is where we discuss with each other. There is no doubt these ladies have mastered dealing with being in the public eye and some of those darker themes can be very relatable for their fandoms as an opportunity to bring strangers–who are their “communities–in closer dialogue and connection. <strong>Being methodical and responsible about the conversations we create in the cultural zeitgeist via active comment sections is one of the greatest social strategies one can have.</strong> This is one of the biggest opportunities for growth. To get people talking <em>about “the right things”. </em>I wish more publications and brands understood the power of this. Celebrities and creators, please show them how it’s done!</p><h3>Integrating Product Content</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*56dEys1DC_HHMiio.jpeg" /></figure><p>Here are some of their lowest performing posts. If simple product shots don’t work for the Kardashian/Jenners, then it’s not going to work for your CPG brand either. Sorry.</p><h3>One Post Deep Dive: White Lotus / Kim Kardashian’s SKIMS; Product Content That Works</h3><p>Last thing, I’d like to cherry pick one post and break down why it caught our attention. One of the most popular posts by Kim Kardashian’s SKIMS Instagram account (@skims), is the valentines day collection featuring Simona Tabasco and Bea Granno from HBO’s popular series, <a href="https://www.hbo.com/the-white-lotus/season-2">White Lotus</a> season 2 as the brand’s ambassadors and models. The comment section praises SKIMS for the marketing and perfect collaboration.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*Y3jb20v7lJExmM2J.png" /></figure><p>I’d like to discuss why this campaign worked and what made it resonate so heavily with audiences. For one, it was an incredible example of culturally relevant timing. The campaign was announced on Jan 23, 2022 and followed the season 2 finale on Dec 11, 2022. A little more than a month since the finale, White Lotus wasn’t exactly still in our heads but it was something we felt that we had started to move on from. A month is a short time to pull this off, don’t get me wrong, but it wasn’t the instant, next-day craze we’ve been accustomed to with social media and fast fashion. This is why I think there’s something more going on here.</p><p>On White Lotus, actresses Simona and Bea (pictured) play two local prostitutes who spent their days at the ultra luxurious White Lotus Hotel in Italy. Their scenes followed the girls around the hotel, using their looks and sex as they daydreamed about following their real dreams of being a singer (and performing at the hotel) and owning a clothing store. The women used their bodies and proximity to powerful men in the fancy White Lotus hotel to get what they want: money and opportunity. In the meantime, we watched as the older pianist promise Bea a stepping stone/opportunity to reach her dream of singing at the hotel (to ultimately leave prostitution).</p><p>The men in the show didn’t pay up right after they had sex. Instead, the women had to chase the men around the hotel, prepared to hustle, negotiate, and do what it takes in order to get the money they are owed. The show and these two characters remind us that ultimately most relationships are transactional. Life is about going after what we want. The two women who were most upfront with this, and how power always plays a role every dynamic, “won” big.</p><p>Not pictured in the SKIMS campaign but felt in the collaboration with the White Lotus characters is that we resonate with them, and Kim, because this experience is one universally felt by women. That we can only be taken seriously, or become powerful enough because of our proximity or co-sign of powerful men. Mostly through intimate relationships but also in our career as our bosses and mentors. Kim and her sisters, and their proximity to powerful men, including Kanye West, had power that ultimately eclipsed the attention and proximity to the men in their lives, including Kanye. Given the platform, like Bea’s beautiful performance in the season finale of White Lotus once she was given the chance, eclipsed the man who promised her introductions after sleeping with her but ultimately never made good on his promise. Given the platform, especially in achieving our dreams and in business, women can and will outshine the men before us. It’s interesting and remarkable Kim chose these girls, of all the characters who include the elegant and much more local, Jennifer Coolidge.</p><p>The soul crushing reality and experience for women everywhere, that we are just one really rich guy away from being taken seriously is something my friends and I discuss but I wish it was talked about in the public square more. What if we found out Britney Spears and Jeff Bezos are dating? Would it change the way you saw her? Or that you were dating Jeff Bezos? or Lebon James? Do you think people’s perception of you would change? This is what I’m talking about. This is felt at such deep levels by women about most powerful, wealthy men. Not just Jeff Bezos and Lebron James. Until we have our own money and power, we are stuck fighting for the upper hand with people we’d rather not even speak to. Put a different way, for my millennials, it’s like how many asses do you have to kiss to just own your own home? Can we just be open about this transaction? There is something in this campaign that speaks to the power of a well written storyline being amplified by a real world example of its main archetype.</p><p>I don’t normally write pieces like this but if you enjoyed pop culture breakdowns, please let me know. I treated this piece as if I was going to start to look into the data as if the Kardashian/Jenner’s were potential new social clients but I’ve barely scratched the surface. This piece is a way for brands and creators to learn from and how to look at the broader trends and themes for their own social posts to set the strategy for their future. This would be my preliminary research before an initial phone call. Kris needs to give me her Instagram password, because I would grow that sh*t to the moon. Hope that helps provide context. Thanks for reading.</p><h4>*this article was originally posted on my Substack where I post about memes, organic virality, digital culture and social media. Subscribe here: <a href="http://lizh.substack.com/">lizh.substack.com</a></h4><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=773c8254677d" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Memes & Monetization: Can You Make Money from Memes?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@LizHagelthorn/memes-monetization-can-you-make-money-from-memes-93737f7184f8?source=rss-8a49df8dda2a------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/93737f7184f8</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[creator-economy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[viral-marketing]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[social-media]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[memes]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[monetization]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Liz Hagelthorn]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 16 Dec 2022 07:35:17 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-12-16T07:50:08.138Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*J3fCVe5-zrkDU9k2nEmNkA.jpeg" /></figure><p>In this piece, I will highlight the current landscape for viral organic content, map the key players and describes the financial side of meme creation. The slides pose a series of questions around the future of monetization on the Internet. These issues lead to a description of the dark reality for creators, meme maker success strategies based on building network effects, and ways to protect creatives who are under pressure from the content churn required by big social media platforms. These slides are for anyone with a social media account who enjoys sending memes to their friends.</p><p><em>The below materials are meant to be presented with voiceover and are from my keynote at </em><a href="https://www.gather.se/speakers/liz-hagelthorn"><em>Gather — Stockholm 2022</em></a><em>. The slides have been reformatted with my notes. If you enjoy this piece, please like, comment, share and tag me @lizhagelthorn across social media.</em></p><p>Table of Contents</p><ol><li>What are Memes?</li><li>Why are Memes Important?</li><li>Meme Industry &amp; Market Size</li><li>Origin of Internet Memes</li><li>What Platforms Do Memes Come From?</li><li>How To Create a Great Meme</li><li>How Memes Make Money</li><li>The Current State of Monetization for Memes</li><li>What Happens Next…</li></ol><p>Making and sharing memes is one of the most popular activities on social media.</p><p>But what is a meme?</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*hz2HqwaQa7HJNnFsIjfYGg.jpeg" /></figure><ul><li>In greek, meme translates to “to imitate” , in french the translation is “same”</li><li>If you can understand the science of memes, you can understand the larger cultural phenomena, communities and issues for our world.</li><li>Memes come in many different shapes and sizes but ultimately memes are reflections of cultural artifacts, stories, emotions and communities found across the internet.</li><li>The official definition of a meme points to memes as central to communication across the internet. To make a meme means to transform and remix units of culture.</li><li>Memes are the paradigm of a new, flourishing creativity. Not only are these captioned images one of the most pervasive and important forms of online creativity, but they also upend many of copyright law’s fundamental assumptions about creativity, commercialization, and distribution.</li><li>There are two central attributes of Internet memes: <strong>creative reproduction of materials</strong> and <strong>intertextuality</strong>.</li></ul><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*5nsbhvGU-H5KyvOQE6YH6A.jpeg" /></figure><ul><li>If you can understand the science of memes, you can understand the larger cultural phenomena, communities and issues for our world.</li><li>In the same way emojis can easily and quickly communicate our emotions in a way that words can’t, memes do the same for messages, ideas and allow us to provide subtext for the world around us in a way that regular speech cannot.</li><li>The digital age (2000s+) has ushered in a new “attention economy” in which it is no longer speech that is scarce, but rather listeners’ attention. Communicating by meme is a hack that gives individual speakers a fighting chance to be heard in our attention-scarce world.</li></ul><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*ev6aU9MZK1DzWaEmyIXktw.jpeg" /></figure><ul><li>Just like a song, memes provide the format for others to put their stories and messages within. How a songwriter writes a melody or a rapper writes a bar, people fit their stories in the format of trending internet memes.</li></ul><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*gzREOLJbrZUm3xOr_H9vWw.jpeg" /></figure><ul><li>When we look at a meme on the internet, we resonate with different jokes, images or “in-groups” pictured in the memes, because we see those parts within ourselves.</li></ul><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*qkRro8g6Ea74p5jP7KLgoA.jpeg" /></figure><ul><li>Representing a growth rate of 21.6% compared to a 13% growth rate across global digital content</li></ul><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*_UjrnWPWHnYNw-dmqpyxRA.jpeg" /></figure><ul><li>According to Instagram, this figure is up from 500k in 2018.</li><li>With the global pandemic, people were experiencing the effects of a cultural phenomenon at a scale like never before.</li><li>The <a href="https://www.apa.org/monitor/2022/04/inbrief-memes-research">American Psychological Association </a>did a study and found funny memes helped people cope with the stress of the COVID-19 pandemic, making viewers feel calmer and more content just by looking at 3 memes.</li><li>The researchers found that people who viewed memes compared with other types of media reported higher levels of humor and more positive emotions, which was indirectly related to a decrease in stress about the COVID-19 pandemic.</li></ul><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*k0dk_ZAjpxbVzwcqBfe0Hw.jpeg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*8XsaBYRSrMn76-gt0Y5RHQ.jpeg" /></figure><ul><li>When it comes to the average type of marketing assets across the internet (branded content, promotions, etc.), memes outperforms them all with 60% of consumers saying they are more likely to buy something from a brand that uses memes.</li></ul><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*LYgyF0wRiEjS6muXEYAyaQ.jpeg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*40rQje9BPBbKQusE4AJ53Q.jpeg" /></figure><ul><li>The term “meme” first appeared in the 1976 book by evolutionary biologist Richard Dawkins.</li><li>Dawkins defined “memes” as a unit of cultural transmission such as slang, fashion trends, behaviors, religion.</li><li>The popularity of a meme is what ensured its survival.</li><li>Memes battle for survival with attention, with the best memes suiting different contexts or becoming timeless.</li><li>The more popular memes survive..Analogues to natural selection.</li><li>Later in life, Dawkins clarified that instead of mutating by random change like a gene, internet memes mutate based on human creativity.</li><li>The modern study of Memetics gained traction in the 90s but ultimately failed as most scientists saw it more as an obscure philosophy and not a renewed science.</li></ul><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*qz8PcKN9-C0bKz93NjThvw.jpeg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*gOeCaqdfMdxLbjR95dlKmA.jpeg" /></figure><ul><li>As the internet evolved, so did memes. One thing that remained the same from 2005–present day: all memes originate from two types of online platforms (one video and one text or forum-based with the ability to share photos).</li><li>When YouTube was released in 2005, video memes became popular with “Rick Rolling” or the Harlem Shake.</li><li>By 2010, almost 35% of memes came from YouTube and 30% came from 4chan.</li><li>By, 2011 Reddit and Tumblr held 12–14% of memes respectively.</li><li>2010, Instagram was founded.</li><li>In 2012, Vine was founded and generated about 7% of all internet memes.</li><li>By 2014+, 25–50% of memes came from Twitter.</li><li>By 2020, TikTok started gaining 30%+ of all meme content on the internet.</li><li>In 2022, TikTok owns 45% of the meme conversation on the internet.</li><li>In 2022, Twitter owns 30% of the meme conversation.</li></ul><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*IpeNjL1Y6pE0_lEGMlH8Pw.jpeg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*V2djzs2NDAywEC9_IVrYrw.jpeg" /></figure><p>There are 3 things that make a meme:</p><ul><li>Format: what type of meme is it (3 soda slots pouring into one cup).</li><li>Content: The actual image or video. Often owned by a record label, television network or movie studio and needs to be remixed. In this slide, it is the underlying picture of a soda machine.</li><li>Message: What is the meme saying, to who and what is the perspective of the meme. Here I am messaging to you what the contents of a great meme are.</li></ul><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*gkrV8e3swZFQ2pHbKv548Q.jpeg" /></figure><ul><li>Here is my “Matrix for High Performing Memes”. This slide is much better with a voiceover, but at a high level the quadrants are labeled as follows:</li></ul><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Tv4hnOxFEBYbt3jhnHmAJA.jpeg" /></figure><ul><li>Easy template to remix: does the underlying photo, image, video or song allow for easy remixing</li><li>Universal experience / emotion: can someone else relate to this experience? Is the experience timeless?</li><li>Point of view / intertextual analysis: are there multiple parties in the meme? Is it clear the perspective of the creator of the meme and are there other characters within the meme that others can relate to or are the intended audience?</li><li>Relevance to culture: is it quick to recognize? How big is the audience around the specific content? Will people get it?</li></ul><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*EaEmy0EoI9ToR6OSC9NSjw.jpeg" /></figure><ul><li>Shoutout to my friend <a href="https://twitter.com/NickWK">Nick Kaufman</a> who showed this to me: If you haven’t seen the video of the dancing man at<a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GA8z7f7a2Pk"> Sasquatch Music Festival</a> from 2009 (23m views on YouTube), it’s a great insight into how the algorithms work and how memes spread on the internet. The first few people who started dancing with the guy, made it OK for others to join in which had a snowballing network effect.</li></ul><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*lXt7oU8-inh7g-KH6DY9UA.jpeg" /></figure><p>I go more into this topic in my piece “<a href="https://magic.mirror.xyz/YwDbQVr_Uz1zT2zT3YCbeourFL7p6GvuzTj3xdQmZ0g">What Does Ownership on the Internet Mean?</a>” but a few key points:</p><ul><li>Currently, the power of the internet is in the hands of the social media companies that write and control social media algorithms.</li><li>They determine the spread of information and create the distribution channels.</li><li>Along the way, they extract $134 billion in advertising revenue per year from content that users provide for them at no cost.</li><li>the current Internet ownership structure allows a few central players to exploit our digital lives, content, and connections for profit while gatekeeping the type of content we make.</li></ul><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*akwZ3WKnndimE8094sxkcw.jpeg" /></figure><ul><li>The creators making a living online are at the mercy of these platforms; if the platforms change their rules or algorithms, creators are forced to course correct on the spot and follow new rules, which are more likely to serve the platform’s interests than the creators.</li><li>Advertising-based business models do not help artists or creativity flourish; quite the opposite.</li><li>Have you ever heard the saying “life imitates art”? What happens when most of the art we see is actually subtle advertising?</li></ul><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*AzyPBxtJkie7SPGb1JfTjA.jpeg" /></figure><ul><li>The internet is about novelty — creating the new and seeking the new. Researchers argue that taste is an essentially human capacity; we know if we like something before we understand why.</li><li>This effect is principally founded on surprise. Algorithms are designed to pleasantly surprise you through relevant and timely recommendations, yet we are never quite surprised because algorithmic-driven content speaks to the masses, leading to a lack of originality and the production of almost identical products.</li><li>When you think of social media and the differences of opinion people could learn from, algorithms actually expose us to similar things that we’ve interacted with before. This creates echo chambers based on similar formatted content and messages across the internet and a lack of connection to each other.</li></ul><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*h30IIZFgGFJWcSti8UmQ8w.jpeg" /></figure><ul><li>In addition to unoriginal products and services, the constant creative content churn required by dominant social media platforms is a fast-track to burnout and social media fatigue for content creators.</li><li>After surveying 127 Instagram accounts totaling 300 million followers between 2019 and 2021, researchers learned that that an account with 1 million followers needs to post 7x times per day to continue growing a substantial following.</li><li>Adobe, released a <a href="https://news.adobe.com/news/news-details/2022/Adobe-Future-of-Creativity-Study-165M-Creators-Joined-Creator-Economy-Since-2020/default.aspx">report</a> that recommended creators and brands post 110x per week across social media platforms. This is unsustainable.</li></ul><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*o2BmN1tWfbKbYDzBIKKUiA.jpeg" /></figure><ul><li>It’s very hard to make money from commissioning memes directly. What meme makers and networks are selling are impressions and eyeballs of their hard-won audiences.</li></ul><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Nnca2_Hq54hOg8WHEeYq1Q.jpeg" /></figure><ul><li>Meme pages calculate an average impression per post by posting a consistent number of times per day so that they can calculate a total number of impressions per month. The average impressions per month needs to be maintained and grown in order to grow their followers. By posting consistently, they are also able to take the average expected impression per post and sell sponsored posts in between their organic posts.</li><li>This is how meme creators like @FuckJerry are able to charge and justify <a href="https://www.vulture.com/2020/02/fuckjerry-bloomberg-sponsored-meme-instagram-posts.html">$30,000 per post</a>.</li></ul><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*1G0AHtbRi_qAavxTTLhQVg.jpeg" /></figure><ul><li>All branded posts come at a cost to your audience. You have to be careful how many sponsored posts that you do and make sure you’re creating organic content to outweigh sponsorships.</li><li>The Internet’s unwritten rules are changing. Because that’s what the Internet does, It’s constantly changing.</li></ul><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*6CAIRuAthpnBbhYg5-gMSw.jpeg" /></figure><ul><li>The new rules, if implemented correctly, could mean expansive new ways to earn a living from it.</li><li>Creators have more power than they realize.</li></ul><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*IUCdMfDyuDDDcRlsL0e3uw.jpeg" /></figure><ul><li>In their NYU Law Review article <a href="https://www.nyulawreview.org/issues/volume-97-number-2/memes-on-memes-and-the-new-creativity/">“Memes on Memes and the New Creativity,”</a> Emily Kempin Professor of Law <a href="https://its.law.nyu.edu/facultyprofiles/index.cfm?fuseaction=profile.overview&amp;personid=19731">Amy Adler</a> and Professor <a href="https://its.law.nyu.edu/facultyprofiles/index.cfm?fuseaction=profile.overview&amp;personid=27961">Jeanne Fromer</a> argue that the highly speculative market for non-fungible tokens (NFTs) stems from an urge to privatize widely available meme images: “an attempt to cling to the concepts of uniqueness, originality, and authenticity in a world where those concepts no longer make sense.</li></ul><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*HO8yBkxVYCK5Lc-1xkV6ng.jpeg" /></figure><ul><li>The reality of “Web3”, which has been filled with bad actors, scams, hacks and rug-pulls, has left a lot to be desired. Will it fulfill its promise of a better, creative world? Time will tell.</li><li>One thing is clear: the new evolution of decentralized social media is among us. Interoperability of our data, content and audiences is a required first step. It’s time we have the ability to port our content, data and audiences (our power) from Big Tech platforms and advertising-based business models to a decentralized online ecosystem owned by each of us. We can talk about this during my next keynote.</li></ul><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*n5bKg7MqB6njuRX4LTXpTg.jpeg" /></figure><p>If you’re interested to read more on how we can avoid big tech centralization, you can read my piece on the topic below:</p><p><a href="https://magic.mirror.xyz/YwDbQVr_Uz1zT2zT3YCbeourFL7p6GvuzTj3xdQmZ0g">What does Ownership on the Internet Mean? by Liz Hagelthorn</a></p><p><em>Liz Hagelthorn is a social-first storyteller and meme-maker with a diverse background in meme culture, technology, and organic virality. Liz is best known for leading creative for the largest pseudonymous meme network on Instagram, overseeing creative strategy across 100+ accounts with 300M followers and reaching 1.2B people per month. Most notably, Liz was the face and creator behind the @girl account. She led the network’s acquisition in under two years.</em></p><p><em>Liz has held positions at Google and Twitter, and works with high-profile startups and celebrities to develop viral organic growth strategies, In 2021, Liz led a web3 artist and developer collective to create the first Ethereum gas tool for NFT artists and collectors to better understand platform fees. She is also the creator and host of</em><a href="http://girlgoneviral.xyz/"><em> Girl Gone Viral</em></a><em>, a podcast featuring interviews with creative entrepreneurs, online community builders, and academics about how storytelling on the internet really works.</em></p><p><em>Liz graduated with a Bachelor of Arts from the University of California, Berkeley. Follow her on Twitter</em><a href="http://twitter.com/lizhagelthorn"><em> @lizhagelthorn</em></a><em>.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=93737f7184f8" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[What Does “Ownership” on the Internet Mean?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@LizHagelthorn/what-does-ownership-on-the-internet-mean-170de28c0303?source=rss-8a49df8dda2a------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/170de28c0303</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[memes]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[content]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[web3]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[social-media]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[advertising]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Liz Hagelthorn]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 23 Aug 2022 14:38:30 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-08-26T02:52:45.766Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*CzrZ6WAshBd8jVxvleuLUg.jpeg" /></figure><p><em>How We Can Avoid Big Tech Centralization All Over Again</em></p><p><em>Liz Hagelthorn is a social-first storyteller and meme-maker with a diverse background in meme culture, technology, and organic virality. Liz is best known for leading creative for the largest pseudonymous meme network on Instagram, overseeing creative strategy across 100+ accounts with 300M followers and reaching 1.2B people per month. Most notably, Liz was the face and creator behind the @girl account. She led the network’s acquisition in under two years.</em></p><p><em>Liz has held positions at Google and Twitter, and works with high-profile startups and celebrities to develop viral organic growth strategies, In 2021, Liz led a web3 artist and developer collective to create the first Ethereum gas tool for NFT artists and collectors to better understand platform fees. She is also the creator and host of </em><a href="http://girlgoneviral.xyz/"><em>Girl Gone Viral</em></a><em>, a podcast featuring interviews with creative entrepreneurs, online community builders, and academics about how storytelling on the internet really works.</em></p><p><em>Liz is currently Director of Social &amp; Content at Coil, a service that provides additional methods for content creators to monetize their work online. Liz graduated with a Bachelor of Arts from the University of California, Berkeley. Follow her on Twitter </em><a href="http://twitter.com/lizhagelthorn"><em>@lizhagelthorn</em></a><em>.</em></p><p><strong>The Internet’s unwritten rules are changing</strong>. The new rules, <em>if implemented correctly, </em>could mean expansive new ways to earn a living from it.</p><p>The products and services that define the internet are evolving into a new phase, commonly known as web3. Web3 potentiates ownership of digital assets, products, and services using blockchain technology. It represents a new evolution of the internet that shifts power from Big Tech platforms and advertising-based business models to a decentralized online ecosystem owned by its users.</p><p>For creators, web3 offers an incredible opportunity to build, grow, and monetize audiences on a decentralized platform. But how do we prevent moving from one big platform, such as Instagram or Twitter, to another, such as OpenSea or Discord, only to experience the same centralization problems?</p><blockquote><em>“The playbook is still being written, but one thing is certain: ownership is becoming a keystone of new experiences across all categories of software products.”</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>- </em><a href="https://variant.fund/articles/the-ownership-economy-2022/"><em>The Ownership Economy</em></a></blockquote><p>Everybody? Online? Making money? That is the dream.</p><h3><strong>A Global Creativity Crisis</strong></h3><p><em>How the centralization of social media platforms created a creativity crisis and what we can learn from it.</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/404/0*o_ESHcWbdJeZl5Lx" /><figcaption>source: Liz Hagelthorn</figcaption></figure><p>The current model of digital ownership is in direct conflict with our ability to create meaningful aesthetic work and communicate with each other. It hinders the innovation necessary to drive a healthy economy; it creates algorithmic-driven content churn that leads to social fatigue and stunted creativity; and it creates advertiser monopolization of creator energy and audiences. Web3 skeptic or not, the current centralization of the internet is preventing innovation and the development of a more equitable, creative online world.</p><p>Currently, the power of the internet is in the hands of the social media companies that write and control social media algorithms. They determine the spread of information and create the distribution channels. Along the way, they extract $134 billion in advertising revenue per year from content that users provide for them at no cost.</p><p>In other words, the current Internet ownership structure allows a few central players to exploit our digital lives, content, and connections for profit while gatekeeping the type of content we make. The creators making a living online are at the mercy of these platforms; if the platforms change their rules or algorithms, creators are forced to course correct on the spot and follow new rules, which are more likely to serve the platform’s interests than the creator’s.</p><p><strong>Innovation, Interoperability and Data Portability</strong></p><p>Web2 (aka 2004 to present day), marked the Internet’s transformation from “read-only” to “read-write”. When social media platforms, like MySpace, Facebook, and Twitter, created spaces for user-generated content, it was no longer just corporations creating digital content for others to see.</p><p>However, unlike corporations, the content creators building audiences on these platforms have very little ownership over their work. They can’t export their own content or collect contact information from their hard-won audiences, but they’re forced to stay on these platforms if they want to continue to reach people. Meanwhile, the social media platforms receive massive growth and profits powered by user content. For example, Facebook launched in 2004, and by 2018, it had more than <a href="https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/users-by-social-media-platform?time=2008..2019&amp;country=Facebook">2.26 billion users</a>.</p><p>In June 2019, the Committee on the Judiciary <a href="https://judiciary.house.gov/uploadedfiles/competition_in_digital_markets.pdf">initiated a bipartisan investigation</a> into the state of competition online, finding that the rise of market power has materially weakened innovation and entrepreneurship in the U.S. economy. Some venture capitalists, for example, report that there is an innovation “kill zone” that insulates dominant platforms from competitive pressure simply because investors do not view new entrants as worthwhile investments.</p><p>Not only do web2 social media platforms stifle innovation, but users don’t receive compensation from platforms for creating the content that drives people to them. Worse, platforms like YouTube and Instagram have algorithms that incentivize users to post more and more content per day if they want to generate engagement. This allows platforms to sell more and more advertisements that can be served against that content and keep people on their platforms longer. But it only serves to burn out creators.</p><p><strong>Algorithmic-Driven Creativity &amp; Fatigue</strong></p><p>Creativity and storytelling happen through the art of the process; not the intended result.</p><p>To preserve authentic communication, content, and control over our digital lives, we need to change our current concept of online ownership. The internet is where many of us work and live, which allows algorithmic-driven products and apps to take complete control over our digital lives.​​ These interferences hinder our ability to form authentic connections, create original content, and develop innovative products and services.</p><p>In his book <em>Taste</em>, Giorgio Agamben discusses the relationship between algorithms and what drives human desire to discover things we like. Agamben argues that taste is an essentially human capacity; we know if we like something before we understand why.</p><p>This effect is principally founded on surprise. Algorithms are designed to pleasantly surprise you through relevant and timely recommendations, yet we are never quite surprised because algorithmic-driven content speaks to the masses, leading to a lack of originality and the production of almost identical products.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/625/0*4esst6IekYP-lKrB" /><figcaption>source: Liz Hagelthorn</figcaption></figure><p>In addition to unoriginal products and services, the constant creative content churn required by dominant social media platforms is a fast-track to burnout and <a href="https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0736585321001350">social media fatigue</a> for content creators. After surveying 127 Instagram accounts totaling 300 million followers between 2019 and 2021, researchers learned that that an account with 1 million followers needs to post seven times per day to continue growing a substantial following.</p><p>Online platforms do not pay creators to post this many times per day. However, if you want to make a living from artistic work hosted on a dominant platform, you need high followings and engagement to negotiate brand deals.</p><p>Alternative business models for the web could not come at a more necessary time. The most recent generations are burned out, poor, and lonely. <strong>Although dubbed the Creator Economy, one has to question whether a creator might have ever envisioned <em>this</em> economy.</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*4h7-K-W_ZFCZJeCt" /><figcaption>source: Liz Hagelthorn</figcaption></figure><p><strong>Advertiser Monopolization of Creativity and Perspective</strong></p><p>Advertising-based business models do not help artists or creativity flourish; quite the opposite. Have you ever heard the saying “life imitates art”? What happens when most of the art we see is actually subtle advertising?</p><p><a href="https://www.redcrowmarketing.com/2015/09/10/many-ads-see-one-day/">Digital marketing experts estimate</a> that most Americans are exposed to around 4,000 to 10,000 advertisements each day. Opening Instagram, Twitter, LinkedIn or any other social media app is like seeing an advertisement of every person you know.</p><p>As a collective, we have internalized ad-based storytelling, and we use it to tell and sell our own stories through highlight reels of the very best moments of our lives. The internet is a hall of mirrors, and if what we find interesting, who we follow, and what we relate to are grounded in advertisements, we inevitably become advertisements ourselves.</p><p>We want to sell ourselves so badly that we use apps like FaceTune to look more presentable, more sellable, like the celebrities we see in magazines and movies. But what happens when <a href="https://www.cosmopolitan.com/uk/entertainment/g9608870/celebrity-photoshop-fails/">celebrities are the ones removing their own insecurities to the point they no longer look human</a>? The cycle continues. We come to “social media” to be social, to connect, but how can you feel connected to someone promoting themselves in a highly un-relatable way for likes? Everyone ends up feeling more alone and depressed. This cycle is not healthy or sustainable for the creator or the consumer.</p><p>With the rise of the Creator Economy and web3, creators are empowered to own their audiences without needing to cater to brands or rely on the norms established by dominant social media platforms.</p><p>Currently, in web2, there are 50 million “creators” and 2 million can earn a full-time living creating content. Of the 2 million full-time creators, <a href="https://influencermarketinghub.com/ebooks/Creator_Economy_-_Creator%20Earnings_Benchmark_2021.pdf">approximately 75% of their income comes from brand deals</a>. This means that creators need to find sponsors, write contracts, and create sponsored content, aka advertisements, just to pay bills. But imagine how creativity can flourish when creators aren’t forced to focus on promotional brand content to make a living.</p><p>Web3 business models and tools are massive opportunities for creators to start shifting their content strategy to one that better benefits them and their audiences. Web3 also offers the opportunity for platforms to create tools and features that usher in the new era of the decentralized Internet. It’s an era that can be owned by users and shift the labor paradigm to allow for multiple streams of income for content creators’ time, money, and creative assets.</p><h3><strong>Internet Ownership of Assets Manifesto</strong></h3><p>As we imagine the future of the internet, various possibilities emerge. This exploration can include various design options both on- and off-chain that create environments conducive to creativity, communication, technological innovation, and payments. This is a critical moment to reconceptualize online ownership.</p><p>The following 13 recommendations can help to define <em>ownership</em> on the web. These are meant to inspire builders and storytellers who want to create web2 and web3 products and services that lead to a user-owned Internet.</p><p><strong>1.Ownership should include the ability to buy, trade, license, and sell digital assets easily across the globe. </strong>Platforms and marketplaces should allow owners of individual NFTs, digital assets, and goods to:</p><p><em>Set prices, Decide sale mechanisms (direct, auction, open to offers), List for sale, License market participation, Fractionalize sales, Commission incentives and architecture for curators to earn, Split profits, Initiate trades, Facilitate account transfers and username sales, Accept tips.</em></p><p><strong>2. Ownership should include the ability to download digital assets in the file type, size, and resolution chosen by the original creator and made explicit before the purchase. </strong>Platforms should provide the original creator with the option to choose<em> </em>what format, aspect ratios, or files they want to make downloadable</p><p><strong>3. Ownership should include the ability to link out to an external URL. </strong>Platforms and marketplaces should allow owners of individual NFTs, digital assets, and goods to add their own:</p><p><em>Website links, Social media profiles, Discord channels, Podcasts, Songs and streaming services, Forms and other questionnaires for visitors, Decentraland, Sandbox or other Metaverse land where a character lives, Press articles, Other NFTs and profiles.</em></p><p>Web3 is a massive opportunity for people to create brands, storylines, characters and social networks just from owning one digital asset or good, including NFTs. For example, California-based restaurateur and Bored Ape Yacht Club (BAYC) #6184 Andy Nguyen <a href="https://www.businessinsider.com/bored-apes-apecoin-crypto-token-metaverse-otherside-volatility-yuga-labs-2022-5">opened Bored and Hungry, a burger restaurant in Long Beach, California</a>. If ones looks at BAYC #6184 on OpenSea, it would be nice to see the website or press articles associated with the asset.</p><p><strong>4. Ownership should include the ability to add captions and change the context and/or descriptions of creator assets.</strong></p><p>Platforms and marketplaces should allow owners of individual NFTs, digital goods, and assets to write their own captions, descriptions, and messages.</p><p>If a marketplace creates this feature off-chain and the piece is sold to another wallet, the caption should disappear.</p><p><strong>5. If marketplaces and platforms allow for commenting by other users, ownership should include the ability to moderate any comments</strong></p><p>Platforms and marketplaces should allow owners of individual NFTs, digital goods, and assets to:</p><p><em>Turn comments on/off, Delete comments, Block users and wallets from commenting, Block certain phrases and terms used in comments, Report comments and wallets who engage in abuse, harassment, or spam, Add links in comments, Like or pin comments to the top of the discussion, Add images, videos, and other owned media in comments</em></p><h3>cr0ss.eth on Twitter: &quot;This has been my Coinbase NFT experience so far... pic.twitter.com/Fx5tVeZzPA / Twitter&quot;</h3><p>This has been my Coinbase NFT experience so far... pic.twitter.com/Fx5tVeZzPA</p><p>This is not great.</p><p><strong>6. Ownership should include the ability to gate access to creator assets.</strong></p><p>Platforms and marketplaces should allow owners of individual NFTs, digital goods, and assets to:</p><p><em>Control access to buy or trade, Limit views and edit access to chosen audiences, Control visibility of revealed assets (for example, the public may be able to see that you have an asset in your wallet, but not which one)</em></p><p><strong>7. Ownership should include creator asset analytics</strong></p><p>Platforms and marketplaces should compensate owners of individual NFTs, digital goods, and assets for:</p><p><em>Any analytics the platform or marketplace collects, such as views, devices, traffic sources, and other audience data</em></p><p><em>Analytics obtained from links or spaces where the asset is publicly shared via custom links (the red arrow line, below) that host the content</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*SR0p9s9Za4Xm2fmB" /><figcaption>source: CrowdTangle</figcaption></figure><p><em>Information obtained from the platform’s search function</em></p><p><em>Ability to download analytics into raw data (.csv file or similar)</em></p><p><strong>8. Ownership should include the ability to track asset sales and postings across the internet</strong></p><p>Platforms and marketplaces should provide owners of individual NFTs, digital goods, and assets access to the full purchase history of an asset.</p><p>A future technology could allow owners to view and track where their assets are posted. For example, if you make a meme and post it to Twitter and Instagram, there should be a dashboard tied to the meme that shows you those two posts, along with posts from anyone who screenshot or took that meme for their own use or modification. This technology could be similar to song detection for DMCA takedowns, but used for all digital assets. This would be the foundation of a thriving licensing market on the Internet, providing a fair incentive for meme makers everywhere.</p><p><strong>9. Ownership should include rights that are defined prior to transaction for the purposes of empowering the owner, such as the right to:</strong></p><p><em>Post across socials, Use as profile pictures, Photoshop or manipulate, Create animations from the original, Merchandise, License, Earn revenue from being displayed or distributed by the creator (for example: if you buy a .0001% of a Taylor Swift song, you can earn revenue from streams)</em></p><p><strong>10. Ownership should include the ability to add, split, or delegate other ownership parties to an individual asset</strong></p><p><em>Co-post with another account/wallet/user/fill in the blank, Split earnings, Delegate administrative rights to another user or wallet</em></p><p><strong>10. Ownership should include the ability to build a following, collect subscribers, gather email addresses, and/or implement a notification or messaging system that alerts interested users to the activity of an individual NFT, digital good, or asset</strong></p><p>Alternatives include: <em>Asset based audiences (building an audience or community around one asset), Ownership based (building an audience or community who splits ownership of an asset), Wallet based (building an audience or community around a certain on-chain wallet)</em></p><p><strong>11. Ownership should include the ability to quantify or present value upgrades, additional media, or other material purchased or sold with an individual NFT, digital good, or asset</strong></p><p>Individual asset owners have been massively successful in creating and growing loyal followings as the identity of their NFT. For example, on Twitter, <a href="https://opensea.io/assets/ethereum/0xb47e3cd837ddf8e4c57f05d70ab865de6e193bbb/6529">Cryptopunk #6529</a> has gained almost <a href="https://twitter.com/punk6529">400,000 followers</a> and established themselves as a leading voice within the crypto and NFT space despite nobody knowing their true identity.</p><p>In this way, each asset has the ability to translate into an identity that accrues social and economic capital. This allows an owner to create value independent of their identity. Ultimately, that goodwill can be transferred with the asset in subsequent transactions.</p><p>Marketplaces should allow owners to quantify or present any value upgrades. Any assets created that are associated with the digital asset, such as a Twitter handle, should be sellable along with the media.</p><p><strong>12. Ownership should include the ability for creators to earn advertising revenue related to the storage of their asset across the internet</strong></p><p>To the extent that the asset’s host, such as a platform or marketplace, earns ad revenue from particular assets, the host should have a mechanism to share that revenue with the asset’s creator. For example, if OpenSea sells advertisement slots, such as banner ads, then owners of assets featured on the page where the banner appears should receive most of the revenue.</p><p>If you are investing in the meme and content space or are interested in this topic, I’d love to talk to you. My Twitter DMs are open <a href="http://twitter.com/lizhagelthorn">@lizhagelthorn</a>.</p><p><em>If you want to understand how the desire for online ownership is driving changes to the digital economy, </em><a href="https://li.substack.com/p/the-ownership-economy-2022"><em>Variant Fund’s “The Ownership Economy 2022”</em></a><em> offers a useful primer on the importance and potential of web3, including the vision and market opportunity discussed in this piece.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=170de28c0303" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>