<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Lorna Bogue on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Lorna Bogue on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@LornaBogue?source=rss-9197af37f9c5------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Sat, 21 Nov 2026 14:36:17 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@LornaBogue/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Ireland’s unknown abortion rate and why it matters]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@LornaBogue/irelands-unknown-abortion-rate-and-why-it-matters-4a74d8479a26?source=rss-9197af37f9c5------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/4a74d8479a26</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[ireland]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Lorna Bogue]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 15 May 2018 12:23:54 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-05-15T12:23:54.687Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>Nobody knows the true Irish abortion rate. In this post I discuss the lack of data on abortion in Ireland and how the few figures we have are being misused in the referendum debate. My previous post on the Eighth Amendment can be read </em><a href="https://medium.com/@LornaBogue/the-discourse-around-the-eighth-amendment-899e40c4cca8"><em>here</em></a><em>.</em></p><p>Today a leaflet from the No side landed in the office and the number 1 point on it is that ‘The government’s plan will lead to more abortions’, a claim which I feel is worth interrogating. We do not have official figures for Ireland’s abortion rate, however, for reasons that will be become clear later the claims that Ireland has an usually low abortion rate are not quite correct and the claim that a Yes vote will increase our abortion rate is also questionable.</p><p>So firstly, what is the real rate of abortion in Ireland? If we were to believe the <a href="https://prolifecampaign.ie/main/wp-content/uploads/2016/09/ProLifeCampaign_Actuarial_Report_and_Commentary_7September2016.pdf">Pro Life Campaign</a>, the Irish abortion rate is around 1 in 20 (5.2%). However this number, when we take into account the illegality of abortion in Ireland, can best be described as a floor and is unlikely to be anywhere near the true rate. This is important because these estimates are used to claim that <a href="https://prolifecampaign.ie/main/wp-content/uploads/2016/09/ProLifeCampaign_Actuarial_Report_and_Commentary_7September2016.pdf">hundreds of thousands of lives have been saved</a> by the Eighth Amendment in supposed ‘actuarial’ reports (I am curious which actuary is willing to professionally stand by such reports, for reasons that will become more clear later).</p><p>To get a more accurate idea of the true Irish rate we need to talk about at least two major sources of uncertainty which are not taken into account in most of these analyses:</p><ul><li>The illegal usage of the abortion pill (Misoprostol and/or Mifepristone)</li><li>Non-disclosure of Irish addresses in the UK</li></ul><p>Firstly, figures for the illegal usage of the abortion pill vary. This is not surprising given that there is a potential 14 year prison sentence for self-inducing a miscarriage.</p><p>From a study published about <a href="https://liberalarts.utexas.edu/prc/research/research-brief-series/2016-research-briefs/irish-experiences-abortion-telemedicine.php">Women on Web</a>, we can see that between 500–750 abortion pills were shipped per year in the period between 2010 and 2012 by Women on Web alone. While estimates of shipped pills were not available for 2015, during this period the number of consultations doubled from 2012, from around 750 to over 1,500 per year.</p><p>Interestingly, the study on Women On Web and these figures are used in a blog by <a href="https://ionainstitute.ie/what-is-the-irish-abortion-rate/">the Iona Institute</a> which discusses the rate of abortion in Ireland. This blog post is the only record I am aware of from a pro-life organisation that accounts for the abortion pill. Here we are given a ‘very generous estimate’ of 2,000 per year. Coincidentally, this number also corresponds with the estimate given by Professor Sally Sheldon from the Kent Law school <a href="https://kar.kent.ac.uk/61053/1/how%20can%20a%20state%20control%20swallowing.pdf">in this 2016 paper.</a></p><p>Based on this number they give a rate of 5.7 per 1,000 women aged between 19–44. Based on a live birth rate of 65,909 in 2015, this equates to around a 7.7% rate (or around 1 in 13) when the number of abortions is compared to the number of live births. Note that this estimate alone would correspond to a 60% jump over the number that only includes those who officially travel to the UK which is used by most pro-life organisations so already the numbers that are being used are starting to look shaky in calculating an Irish abortion rate.</p><p>We then also must consider that this year a separate organisation, Women Help Women, <a href="https://www.irishtimes.com/news/health/pro-choice-group-calls-for-regulation-of-abortion-pills-1.3458053">gives a figure of 323 people in Ireland accessing pills in the first three months of 2018</a>. If we are to assume a similar rate over the coming year then we are looking at a figure of over 1,200 from this organisation on top of the Women On Web figures outlined above.</p><p>In looking at only the organisations that provide figures for abortion pill use in Ireland, we are already above the 2,000 figure, but there are some important missing variables that should also be factored in. In terms of prescription medication containing these chemicals that were <a href="http://www.thejournal.ie/abortion-pill-use-in-ireland-3892752-Apr2018/">seized the Health Products Regulatory Authority</a> in 2015, we have a figure of 850. This obviously is a greater amount than the study on Women on Web is able to account for between shipping and outcome.</p><p>Based on this fact it is logical to assume that there are other major online providers of these drugs. In any market where there is demand mixed with illegality, less scrupulous sellers will always exist. It is also worth noting that <a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/3122278">Misoprostol is an active ingredient in stomach ulcer medications</a> as well. This method features in some abortion stories.</p><p>The above figures also don’t take into account other methods of inducing miscarriage. Herbal remedies. Misusing hormonal contraception pills. Sitting in boiling water. Excessive alcohol consumption. Drinking bleach. Coat hangers. Blunt physical trauma. These too are the ways that women in Ireland have tried to procure abortions with varying results. Needless to say we have no idea how many have been forced to go to these extremes.</p><p>Taking a holistic approach to how abortions happen illegally in Ireland, the figure of 2,000 upon which most pro-life assessments of the Irish abortion rates is based can be better described as a baseline. Our abortion rate with the 2,000 figure is at least 1 in 13 and examining all the sources of illegal abortions in Ireland, it is very possible that our rate is higher. Ireland&#39;s abortion rate then in actuality may not be significantly different to European countries where abortion is already legal.</p><p>The second factor that is not taken into account when estimating an Irish rate for abortion is Irish women giving UK addresses when they travel. Similarly to the issue of Irish women taking abortion pills, finding an accurate estimate for how many Irish women choose to not disclose an Irish address is extremely difficult. However, we have a handful of reasons which provide an indication that this rate could be higher than what we would intuitively expect.</p><p>For example, many Irish women have national insurance numbers in the UK due to living there for a period. This would allow them to have the cost of an abortion covered by the NHS. Avoiding an unaffordable expense. Another likely factor for providing a UK address is privacy or fear of retribution. As an indication, <a href="https://static.rasset.ie/documents/news/abortion-stats-2016-commentary-with-tables.pdf">520 women (around 1 in 6) who travelled gave their address simply as ‘Ireland’ and deliberately chose not give their county of residence. </a>This wish for privacy can be reasonably assumed to extend to not providing Ireland as an address.</p><p>Most Irish people have family members or friends living in the UK who would be willing to provide their address. Women who have travelled may not wish to discuss their situation and by providing a UK address can avoid further questioning. There is also a demographic of non-Irish women who travel to the UK and other jurisdictions as well. They may not necessarily provide an Irish address.</p><p>If we take into account the effect of the abortion pill and the effect of non-disclosure, what then would be a reasonable estimate for the Irish abortion rate? The honest answer is that I do not have one, but if I have learned anything from this debate about abortion rates, it is that the distance between our intuition and reality can be very significant indeed.</p><p>There is one more important aspect that I would like to talk about. It is the assumption that is often made about what would happen in Ireland if we remove the Eighth Amendment. That is that we would inevitably have abortion rates similar to the UK. There is not strong evidence to support this assumption. It sounds intuitive certainly given our cultural and geographical proximity. The evidence however, would suggest that relying on this intuition can lead to very spurious conclusions.</p><p>When you look at global abortion rates the most striking thing is how difficult it is to explain the variations in abortion rates and how greatly those abortion rates can vary. Legality, socioeconomic factors and lots of other matters seemingly have no causative effect. Looking across western countries where abortion is legal we can see rates ranging from around 10% in countries such as Germany and Switzerland. 15% in Portugal and the Netherlands and 20% in Denmark and the UK. There are no obvious factors that link or differentiate between these clusters.</p><p>To illustrate this further, let us take the example of the Baltic states of Estonia, Latvia and Lithuania. All three have very similar abortion laws and have obvious cultural and social commonalities. Yet, they all have very different abortion rates, ranging from 13% in Lithuania, 20% in Latvia and 26% in Estonia. If these geographically proximate states have such different rates, then asserting that this referendum is about avoiding the UK’s abortion rate in Ireland is a spurious claim that is not backed by evidence.</p><p>In looking at the heads of bill which are often waved around during debates, the obvious comparison is not with UK law. The law in the UK is in fact an outlier in European countries. We are not in fact the first country to have a referendum on legalising abortion, Switzerland had a referendum in 2002 to legalise abortion up to 12 weeks without restriction, with exceptions in cases of rape, incest, fatal foetal abnormality and the life and health of the mother. Sound familiar? <a href="http://www.johnstonsarchive.net/policy/abortion/ab-switzerland.html">The rate of abortion has decreased over time in Switzerland and making abortion legal did not affect this trend</a>. In fact, in observing the table what is there is that the abortion rate was trending upwards until 2002 when the rate stabilised and then decreased over time.</p><p>I hope that I have shown how little we truly know about how many pregnancies in Ireland end in abortion. The numbers that you are likely to see during this referendum are likely at best to be rough estimates and at worst outright propaganda. This lack of information is one of the few things we know for certain that the Eighth Amendment has provided us.</p><p>While so much time is being spent discussing the abortion rate in the UK it seems that the reality of Irish abortion is left to the wayside. No matter what side of the debate you are on everyone agrees that we would like to reduce Irish abortion rates. We deserve to have a proper debate on what that might mean and look like. How can we have this discussion if we don’t even know how many Irish people are having abortions? If we choose to continue to obfuscate the reality by retaining the Eighth amendment we only provide cover to those in our society who would prefer to go back to pretending that Irish abortions do not happen.</p><p>It was interesting that Wendy Grace, a journalist who works for the Irish Catholic and Spirit radio ended the Late Late debate by asking why we are only discussing abortion and not reducing the abortion rate. The answer is that we cannot discuss reducing abortion rates because the illegality of abortion in Ireland has meant that we have very little information about abortion in Ireland. We do not have an accurate abortion rate as a starting point. We cannot measure the impact of policies to reduce the abortion rate without that. Policies that cannot be tested cannot be implemented. Pro-life campaigners in Ireland have not allowed the space for such a conversation and it is their framing of this debate over the last 35 years that has resulted in the current debate that we are having. Retaining the near total ban on abortion means that this conversation will never occur in Ireland. This is something that the pro-life side needs to own, they cannot have it both ways especially if as I’ve previously discussed, they are unwilling to enforce the currently existing criminal punishments for procuring abortion in Ireland. This is the status quo that they are defending and our healthcare system is poorer for it.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=4a74d8479a26" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The discourse around the Eighth Amendment]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@LornaBogue/the-discourse-around-the-eighth-amendment-899e40c4cca8?source=rss-9197af37f9c5------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/899e40c4cca8</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[healthcare]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[repealthe8th]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[civil-discourse]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[referendum]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[debating]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Lorna Bogue]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 21 Mar 2018 18:39:33 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-03-21T18:39:33.876Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Like many people in Ireland I’ve been thinking about the Eighth amendment a lot lately. Not surprising given that at the time of writing we are facing into a referendum on whether to retain or replace the Eighth amendment with wording to give the Oireachtas (our parliament and upper house) the ability to legislate for abortion without constitutional interference.</p><p>So, what is the Eighth amendment?</p><p>The Eighth amendment is what article Article 40.3.3° of the Irish constitution is better known as. It was placed in the Irish Constitution (Bunreacht na hÉireann) in 1983 by referendum. The article itself reads;</p><blockquote><em>The State acknowledges the right to life of the unborn and, with due regard to the equal right to life of the mother, guarantees in its laws to respect, and, as far as practicable, by its laws to defend and vindicate that right.</em></blockquote><p>The wording sounds fairly innocuous, not something that is actively harmful. Unfortunately, in practice this is not the case. The result of this wording is that in medical situations involving pregnancy, where issues can arise extremely quickly; medical practitioners must treat the child the same as the mother. The pregnant mother therefore is not prioritised in the same way as they would be in the health systems of other countries.</p><p>What priority does the mother get then? In Ireland currently a mother has to be in mortal danger before the mother’s right to life is vindicated over that of the child. I am using the word child for a specific reason here. I don’t particularly want to get into arguments about semantics, this wording can be understood by both sides of the debate. Given that the life of the mother must be in mortal peril before they receive medical treatment that would endanger the life of the child this creates an unusual medical situation where the lives of the mother and child are pitted against one another from the moment of conception by our constitution.</p><p>Now, when we have reached a point where emergency medical situations require doctors to act as constitutional lawyers in making medical decisions there is clearly an issue. This I have observed is something that both sides can and do agree on. As a result of issues of this nature coming to light, the government brought in legislation for this specific situation. The Protection of Life during Pregnancy Act 2013. This piece of legislation fitted within the Eighth amendment as it currently stands.</p><p>It has been often said by those who oppose abortion, that perhaps this is enough and that we should go no further. In a medical setting however, at what point does the mother’s life reach mortal peril? We are still left with medical practitioners having to make decisions with an eye to the constitution and having to decide when a mother is ill enough to be close to death. What about situations where the mother’s health is damaged, perhaps permanently? What if the mother has a progressive illness such as cancer which if left untreated will lead to a lethal, but importantly, not immediate progression of the illness and death? These unfortunately are not hypothetical questions. Mothers in Ireland have been denied cancer treatment or <a href="https://www.irishtimes.com/news/state-settled-with-cancer-patient-1.555035">have had their cancer treatment delayed</a> because of this balancing act that medical practitioners are currently forced to perform.</p><p>There still are problems then, and at this point we have reached the limit of what the Eighth amendment will allow. I think that it is reasonable to say that most people would agree that things need to improve beyond our current situation and the Oireachtas is not able to legislate beyond the problematic point of mortal peril that we are currently at.</p><p>This is where the referendum comes in. We cannot have a healthcare system that takes care of mothers until such a time as the Eighth amendment is removed from the constitution. There is no way around this.</p><p>There’s a word that we use a lot in Ireland. Sound. It can be used as a descriptor of a person, or alternately as a way of acknowledging that someone has gone out of their way to help you. Sound.</p><p>The discourse surrounding abortion in Ireland has been unsound in most meanings of the word I would say. If I were to characterise the discourse, ‘strategic’ is the word that I would use. Often it feels like a long drawn out debating society argument. Though there have been mothers who have suffered and died due to our current situation, often the commentary takes place in the realm of the hypothetical. The argumentation we are presented with is tactical and point-scoring. As a former debater (yes, yes, I know) I can see why somebody who is against abortion would tactically decide to try and prevent any change from occurring at all. If we are to view this issue as a zero sum game that one side wins and the other side loses then this strategy makes sense.</p><p>We have a lobby in Ireland that tried to prevent the Protection of Life During Pregnancy act going through. Yes, the one I talked about above that only is used in medical emergencies where the mother is in danger of immediate death. This is a logical thing to do if you are intent on being on the winning side of an argument set around a thought experiment. From the point of view of vindicating the right to life of all people in Ireland however, this does not make sense. We are not in an elite chamber debating a hypothetical.</p><p>I have spoken about the medical situation in Ireland. There is a second important part to the Eighth amendment which is that the right to life of the unborn must be defended by the State. And so the State ‘<em>guarantees in its laws to respect, and, as far as practicable, by its laws to defend and vindicate that right.’</em></p><p>Again, this sounds innocuous. As a philosophical statement we would all like the State to vindicate people’s rights. However, as this is in the constitution we run into an issue. If the State is going to protect the right to life of the ‘unborn’, that is, the child being carried by the mother, then it has to action that. As the child’s life is the same as that of the mother from the point of conception, what this means in practical terms is that, in Ireland, procuring an abortion carries a 14 year prison sentence. Irish people have the right to travel, and the right to information relating to that travel. These rights were inserted into the constitution through referendum in 1992. But they cannot have an abortion in Ireland unless their life is in immediate danger. As the Eighth amendment is written there is no way to remove this element of criminalisation.</p><p>This next part deserves a clickbaity title I feel. So; There Is Something That Both Sides Of The Irish Abortion Debate Agree On And You Will Never Guess What It Is.</p><p>The big, open, secret of the Irish abortion debate is the following; Nobody wants to see people actually being imprisoned for having an abortion in Ireland. <a href="http://www.ronanmullen.ie/wp-content/uploads/2017/12/Joint-Assessment-by-Fitzpatrick-McGrath-and-Mullen-on-the-Committee-of-the-8th-Amendment.pdf">A minority report</a> was compiled by individual members of an Oireachtas committee who wanted to express their views on why no change should be made to the Eighth amendment. In this report, they state the following;</p><blockquote><em>There have been no prosecutions prior to or under the Protection of Life During Pregnancy Act 2013, for either women or doctors</em></blockquote><p>and also;</p><blockquote><em>The retention of a criminal offence in the context of abortion is necessary to deter actions which can hurt individuals and end the life of the unborn child.</em></blockquote><p>So in Ireland we have a situation where those who are against changing the Eighth amendment are arguing that a criminal offence should stay in place on the understanding that this criminal offence wouldn’t actually be enforced. This understanding is not a way to make law, or at least, good law.</p><p>In what other area of law would elected representatives tell people that a criminal offence shouldn’t really be enforced but it should still be defined as a crime?</p><p>The answer that is generally given is that a severe punishment creates deterrence, and that deterrence will prevent the need for enforcement. But is this how other laws are written? Shouldn’t laws also be proportional and fair? More importantly, while these offences remain within the law and are backed up by our constitution they are enforceable. Perhaps we can assume that our current government would not enforce them, but what if we were to get a government that would enforce them? In a time of Trump and Brexit this is not a scenario that is beyond the realm of possibility. Similarly, people have been arrested and imprisoned for procuring abortions in Northern Ireland. This is something that is an ever-present danger while the Eighth amendment still exists.</p><p>The discourse then that we are having is based on hypotheticals and assumptions. Those who are against abortion have tactically adopted the stance of defending the Eighth amendment absolutely. Their argument is that every human life has an absolute and equally weighted value. A life is a life and the life of the unborn child must be brought into independent existence outside of the body of the mother regardless of the suffering or risk of death that the mother is exposed to. Furthermore, as the child’s life is equal to that of the mother’s, the deliberate ending of that life is considered to be murder on the part of the mother. Even if this aspect is not enforced, they argue that abortion should still be legally considered in this way by the State. In framing the discourse in this way we are missing an opportunity for a real discussion about how we as a society value life. We are instead discussing a ban on abortion only and not alternative ways for the State to more effectively value and support life. I wish that those who are most vocally against abortion had not boxed us all into this corner because there are elements that we all can agree with. The life of the mother should be protected, in a real way, informed by best medical practice. People should not be arrested and imprisoned for 14 years for having an abortion in Ireland. We would all like the State to vindicate the rights of everyone.</p><p>We as a society can decide collectively that the Eighth amendment does not fulfil these criteria and introduce legislation that does not have the avoidable deaths of mothers as an inbuilt trade-off. Those against abortion are unwilling to have a discussion on this basis and truly find a way to vindicate life.</p><p>There is a constituency that exists in the hearts and minds of all opinion piece writers and political commentators. I of course speak of The Middle Ground™. The Middle Ground™ fears many things, most of all the Extremes from Both Sides Of The Debate which will make them Turn Off The Debate. I personally have not met someone from the The Middle Ground™. Perhaps they only speak to journalists and I’m missing out here.</p><p>The people I have met instead are, like myself, trapped in this hypothetical debate we are having. I think that we can all agree that our current situation is flawed. However, we are all being done a disservice by the current national discourse. Rather than a national discourse framed around how we can improve our current situation and what active role the State can take in vindicating the rights of all (improved child care, restoring the lone parent allowance, better sexual health and relationship education, reducing instances of rape, funding social services, increasing the number of social workers, better maternal health care and the right to choose birthing services, funding more services and provision for people with additional needs, access to contraception, better parental leave and workplace conditions…. I could go on) we are instead having a debate where those who want things to remain as they are have decided to defend the indefensible, making no concessions whatsoever and relying on muddying the waters to make their points. This does not suprise me. When you are debating on shaky ground, particularly when you are defending the status quo, a common debating tactic is to try and confuse the listener and plant the seeds of doubt in their mind so they dismiss change out of fear. Tactically I understand why this is happening, but it is disappointing to see those who wish to defend life relying on fear to defend a flawed law when there are real and positive changes that can be included in the discourse that we are having.</p><p>Ultimately, the people I have met are sound. The majority of these people won’t have abortions themselves, no matter what comes next. They themselves will decide that. They may not like the idea of abortion, but nobody that I have met would physically stop someone that they know and love from having one when they have made that decision. The Middle Ground™ may not be sound, but the people of Ireland are. I am struck by this in many of the stories that I have heard about abortion. Families and friends are a part of these stories. Men are a part of these stories. Mass-going Mammy or Daddy sometimes feature in these stories, giving money or lifts. Granny and Grandad when they appear have listened with cups of tea. The girls at school and the lads at work have corroborated the “shopping trip” excuses for a flight or ferry to the UK. Husbands and partners and boyfriends have fought against our legal system and despaired silently at bedsides because ‘there’s nothing more that can be done’ and both mother and child are lost. These are all people we know who are just doing their best and helping someone they love in a tough situation.</p><p>This happens everyday in Ireland.</p><p>There are stories I haven’t heard. Some people can’t tell anyone and make the journey alone or they risk 14 years in prison to have an abortion at home. They too are watching this debate and wondering if there is ever a time when they can tell anyone.</p><p>This too happens everyday in Ireland.</p><p>For this referendum what I would say to someone who is unsure is that you may not approve of abortion, and an abortion is not the decision that you would make for yourself. That’s ok. Nobody is asking you to like abortion or to have an abortion. What you are being asked is whether you would stand in someone else’s way when they have made their own decision to have an abortion. I don’t think many people would, and so you are being asked to vote to remove the Eighth amendment from our constitution.</p><p>Sound.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=899e40c4cca8" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>