<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by CommForum on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by CommForum on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@MITCommForum?source=rss-83297b59b005------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Sat, 21 Nov 2026 03:32:01 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@MITCommForum/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[#BlackInTheIvory: Academia’s Role in Institutional Racism]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/mit-communications-forum/blackintheivory-academias-role-in-institutional-racism-96af14c37f5f?source=rss-83297b59b005------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/96af14c37f5f</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[past-forums]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[CommForum]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 29 Oct 2020 20:42:25 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-12-21T17:20:20.347Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*LQIXTQGney9U-jGtqxUZJg.png" /><figcaption>Left to right: Dr. Shardé M. Davis, Dr. Mareena Robinson Snowden, Dr. James Mickens, and Tanya Ballard Brown</figcaption></figure><p>For many Black scientists and researchers, working in academia means weathering systemic bias, micro-aggressions, and isolation. <strong>Dr. Shardé M. Davis</strong>, a communications researcher at the University of Connecticut, created #BlackInTheIvory this past summer as a platform for discussing the experiences of Black academics. Dr. Davis joins <strong>Dr. Mareena Robinson Snowden</strong>, a nuclear engineer at the Johns Hopkins University Applied Physics Lab, and <strong>Dr. James Mickens</strong>, a computer scientist at Harvard University, to examine academia’s role in perpetuating institutional racism and efforts to change those systems. <strong>Tanya Ballard Brown</strong>, an editor at National Public Radio (NPR), will moderate.</p><p><strong>Thursday, December 3, 2020<br>5:00–6:30 pm<br></strong><a href="https://mit.zoom.us/webinar/register/WN_0GMGQjZ6T0WDu9B_CvqZZg"><strong>Register here</strong></a><strong>: </strong><a href="https://mit.zoom.us/webinar/register/WN_0GMGQjZ6T0WDu9B_CvqZZg"><strong>https://mit.zoom.us/webinar/register/WN_0GMGQjZ6T0WDu9B_CvqZZg</strong></a></p><p><strong>Speakers</strong></p><p><strong>Dr. Shardé M. Davis</strong> is an assistant professor in the Department of Communication at the University of Connecticut and the creator of #BlackInTheIvory. Dr. Davis’s research examines the way Black women leverage communication in the sistah circle to invoke collective identity, erect and fortify the boundaries around their homeplace, and backfill the necessary resources to return to white/male dominant spaces in American society. Dr. Davis also serves as the Immediate Past Chair of the African American Communication and Culture Division (AACCD) of the National Communication Association.</p><p><strong>Dr. James Mickens</strong> is the Gordon McKay Professor of Computer Science at Harvard University, where his research focuses on the performance, security, and robustness of large-scale distributed web services. Prior to his work at Harvard, Dr. Mickens spent six years at Microsoft Research where he worked in the Distributed Systems Group. He is currently on the Board of Directors at the Berkman Klein Center for Internet &amp; Society at Harvard University.</p><p><strong>Dr. Mareena Robinson Snowden</strong> is a senior engineer in the National Security Analysis Department at the Johns Hopkins University Applied Physics Laboratory. Prior to taking on her current role at Johns Hopkins, Dr. Snowden completed fellowships at the National Nuclear Security Administration and the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace Nuclear Policy Program. She is the first black woman to earn a Ph.D. in nuclear engineering from MIT.</p><p>Moderator: <strong>Tanya Ballard Brown</strong> is an editor at National Public Radio (NPR), where she’s worked on stories about families of shooting victims in New Orleans, the aftermath of the Pulse nightclub shooting, and sexual assault against people with disabilities. Ballard Brown was a 2019 Nieman Foundation for Journalism Fellow where she studied how comedic journalism — the intersection of humor, satire, and journalism — can help journalists connect with their audiences and build community. Projects she has edited while at NPR and <em>The Washington Post</em> have been awarded Peabody, Murrow, and Gracie awards, among others.</p><p><em>All Communications Forum events are free and open to the general public. This event is co-sponsored by </em><a href="https://radius.mit.edu/"><em>Radius at MIT</em></a><em> and the </em><a href="https://polisci.mit.edu/research/projects/mit-governance-lab-mit-govlab"><em>MIT Governance Lab</em></a><em>.</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/524/1*FqjizfmT6mLdHD0nG-_ZRQ.jpeg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*5VUsmYjgGcEXxHTBrTN_3g.png" /></figure><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FA9Xg9nz2cE0%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DA9Xg9nz2cE0&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FA9Xg9nz2cE0%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/51ab344c4c8d58894afe4a430cbd1d93/href">https://medium.com/media/51ab344c4c8d58894afe4a430cbd1d93/href</a></iframe><p>Click here for a podcast of this event: <a href="https://soundcloud.com/mit-cmsw/blackintheivory-academias-role-in-institutional-racism">https://soundcloud.com/mit-cmsw/blackintheivory-academias-role-in-institutional-racism</a></p><p><strong>Transcript</strong></p><p><strong>Christina Couch, Coordinator for the MIT Communications Forum: </strong>Okay, it looks like we’re, we’re ready to go here. Panelists, are you all ready to do this?Great! Okay, wonderful. Welcome to all of the attendees who are here. There are quite a few of you. We are thrilled to have you. Welcome to the MIT Communications Forum.</p><p>So this is our first virtual event. We’re really thrilled to be using this format to reach a broader audience, so sincerely, thank you to every single person who’s here for making that happen.</p><p>We have what is bound to be a really fascinating panel tonight. We were so excited that all of our speakers and moderator were available. So I will give everybody a little bit of info about how this event will work. We’re going to have roughly 45 minutes of moderated Q and A followed by about 45 minutes of audience Q and A. I’ll be reading that audience Q and A out loud to our speakers. So if you have a question, do not put it in the chat. Drop it in the Q and A box below. There are a lot more attendees than there are speakers. So we will try to get to as many questions as is humanly possible.</p><p>This event is being recorded. We plan to add some closed captioning and we’re going to post it on our MIT forum, MIT Communications Forum website at Commforum.mit.edu. If you would like to see more events just like this one, please sign up for our mailing list. That is also at Commforum.mit.edu. I will put that link in the chat as soon as this intro is over. I promise you we will not spam you. We only send emails related to our events each year. We only have about six and so you won’t be receiving too much email from us.</p><p>One last thing, we would not be able to make events like this happen without generous support from sponsors. A very special thank you to Radius at MIT, they’ve supported many of our events. They’ve been a phenomenal partner for making events like this happen, and a special thanks to the MIT Governance Lab. We’re working with them for the first time, and we’re thrilled for their support. So without further ado, we have a spectacular lineup.</p><p>I’m excited to introduce our speakers and our moderator. First up, we have <strong>Dr.</strong> <strong>Shardé M. Davis</strong>. She is an assistant professor in the Department of Communication at the University of Connecticut, and she’s the creator of #BlackInTheIvory. Dr Davis’s research examines the way Black women leverage communication in the sister circle to invoke collective identity, erect and fortify the boundaries around their home place, and backfill the necessary resources to return to a white / male dominated spaces in society. Dr. Davis also serves as the Immediate Past Chair of the African American Communication and Culture Division of the National Communications Association. Welcome, Dr. Davis.</p><p><strong>Dr. James Mickens</strong> is the Gordon Mackay Professor of Computer Science at Harvard University. His research focuses on the performance, security, and robustness of large scale distributed web services. Prior to his work at Harvard, Dr Mickens spent six years at Microsoft Research, where he worked in the Distributed Systems Group. He is currently on the board of directors at the Berkman-Klein Center for Internet and Society at Harvard. Welcome, Dr. Mickens.</p><p><strong>Dr. Mareena Robinson Snowden</strong> is one of MIT’s own. She is a senior engineer at the National Security Analysis Department at the Johns Hopkins University Applied Physics Laboratory. Prior to her current role, Dr. Snowden completed fellowships at the National Nuclear Security Administration and the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace Nuclear Policy Program. She was the first Black woman to earn a Ph.D. in nuclear engineering from MIT. Welcome, Dr. Snowden.</p><p>And our moderator tonight is actually somebody I was lucky enough to meet at a Communications Forum event a few years ago.We were thrilled that she agreed to come back. Her name is <strong>Tanya Ballard Brown</strong>. She is an editor at National Public Radio where she’s worked on stories about families of shooting victims in New Orleans, the aftermath of the Pulse nightclub shooting, and sexual assault against people with disabilities. She was a 2019 Nieman Foundation for Journalism Fellow where she studied the intersection of humor, satire, and journalism. Projects she’s edited at NPR and The Washington Post have been awarded Peabody, Murrow, and Gracie awards, among others.</p><p>Thank you so much to all of our speakers. I’m going to pass it off to Tanya right now.</p><p>Tanya Ballard Brown: Thanks everybody for taking time out to come and join us for this conversation this evening. So earlier this year as people were protesting in the streets and demanding an end to racial injustice and calling for solutions to ending systemic racism, that energy spread beyond just policing and beyond the Black Lives Matter slate of policy proposals and into other areas, such as my industry, media, but also into academia. And over the summer that hashtag Black in the Ivory started trending and it gained traction as Black scholars like all these wonderful, really accomplished people that we have here today, shared their experiences confronting and contending with discrimination and alienation and other issues in colleges and universities.</p><p>And so today we want to talk about some of what was shared in the tweet thread and what continues to be shared, as well as best practices, lessons learned, and how to navigate some of these situations that others have been struggling with over the years. And so I want to throw this first to Shardé — I’m going to call people by their first names. I’m Tanya, too. I’m Tanya — who was the main engine behind the hashtag. And just to give us, just talk to us a little bit about why you did this, and what were some of the stories that were shared. What trends or recurring themes did you see shared when you started this conversation and got this conversation going?</p><p>Shardé Davis: Absolutely. Hi, everyone. Good evening. I’m really humbled to be in this space with so many brilliant minds and to able to talk about this really pertinent topic. One that we know has always been around, anti-Black racism in the academy. We also know anti-Black racism is built into the bedrock of the United States. So naturally, it is going to manifest itself in various social institutions. And I think that’s, not I think, but that really is the kind of starting point to how I started to think about this because I was just reeling in over the summer, quarantining because of Covid, and, you know, kind of sitting in what felt like isolation in a rental apartment in California and out protesting, just feeling like I was trying to do something, right? I was trying to somehow make sense of who I am as a Black woman and how this kind of capital C conversation that was happening this summer, this racial reckoning, how that showed up in my own life.</p><p>And because I thankfully, knock on wood, had not had a personal run-ins with the police when it comes to mass incarceration, when it comes to police brutality, it doesn’t mean that anti-Black racism doesn’t manifest in my life. And so I was just sitting there thinking about, what does this mean to me, right? And how does this show up within my own immediate sphere of influence, and immediately just started thinking about the academy and my own experiences, And just an interesting play on words, right? Seemingly so simple, right? Being Black in the Ivory for me felt like a speck in a sea of white, which, growing up in San Diego, going to predominantly white institutions all of my life in terms of secondary education, that’s just the recurring theme.</p><p>I just remember that Sunday when it was trending. And I think it was in the top 20 hashtags across the United States that Sunday. I mean, I was just floored that, you know, for me, it just started, I just was using that as a way to process what was happening around me. And it’s crazy how it, it’s crazy but it’s not how it resonated with so many other Blackademics, right? And in reading the tweets and, I mean talk about all your plans being cancelled that day, because I was just reading. I just couldn’t stop. I wanted to make sure I was reading every single tweet. And in terms of the stories that were surfacing, I don’t know. I think about this phrase, I’ve used this recently, the death by 1,000 paper cuts. So absolutely, that does not mean that many Blackademics around the globe have not experienced overt racism. Some women had talked about sexual assault, right, so thinking about intersectionality and how we cannot untether our racial identity from our gender identity and other identities as well, sexuality and age.</p><p>But it was the micro aggressions, the unwanted touches to someone’s hair for specifically those who were donning their natural kind of kinky curls and other natural hairstyles, being questioned about if they’re the janitor. You know what I mean, when they’re in a lab after hours, being asked for identification when they’re trying to go into the lecture hall to teach by campus police right. So you know these incidences where again, you know, racial micro-aggressions is the psychological warfare, where you’re questioning is it me? This seems racially motivated, but I can’t, I can’t tell. I can’t quite put my finger on it.</p><p>So it was in. I’ll just say this and just to kind of wrap up my answer to your question, but what I found to be the most interesting, one of the most interesting pieces in reading the tweets was how sometimes people were sharing the exact same story. And I mean, down to the minutia. And these are people who are went to grad school at different time periods, who are different generations in terms of like age groups, people who, men and women, different fields, they’re from programs across the United States and saying the exact same story.</p><p>Tanya Ballard Brown: Well, thank you. I think it is interesting that you had, you found that there was so much, not just overlap, but repetition in the stories that people were telling and that segues a little bit into, I want to throw this question to James, Dr. Mickens. Sociologist Tsedale M. Melaku has described the inclusion tax, right. She’s talked about the time spent, the money spent, the emotions spent, the brainpower spent trying to adhere to norms in academic spaces, and I’m curious, and you’ve talked about this a little yourself in other areas, but I’m curious what ways you’ve found to push back against some of that in your career.</p><p>James Mickens: Thanks for the question and I’m glad to be here, glad to see so many people on the call. I think that that question that you asked, I mean it’s a hard one to answer because, in a certain sense, it speaks to the fact that there is this additional burden that scholars of color oftentimes have to face in addition to the other things that scholars already do that makes scholarship hard, you know, publish or perish, being on committees, you know, all this type of stuff.</p><p>And so it’s difficult. You know, I think that one reason why it’s difficult is because it can be hard to tell someone, look I know that you’re busy, but I’m actually probably a little bit busier than you because of the various committees, for example, that I’m asked to be on that you might not be asked to be on, not because you’re a bad person. Just because, you know, people are looking for the diversity unit, you know. And so I think that one of the things that I try to coach young academics on, that I try to be very intentional about my own career is being able to, to be frank and to be polite, but to be open about the fact that there are certain things that I want to do because I want to increase, for example, diversity in professoriate. There are certain things I’m asked to do that perhaps I don’t necessarily want to do, but I feel like I should do as a service. But then that means that there are some things I simply won’t have time to do. And I think that it’s, it’s sort of like more of an art than a science when you need to convey these messages, when you need to tell someone who might be, for example, your chair or your dean or someone like this, your direct manager if you’re an industry, that I would love to do this but, you know, ellipses, I’m doing these other things.</p><p>And so one thing that I found very helpful is that first of all, when you’re having one of these conversations, you need to figure out, am I dealing with someone who’s reasonable or not? I mean, just to put it bluntly, is this a person who you can actually negotiate with, who you can sort of trust to sort of be sympathetic with you even if they don’t immediately understand what your current burdens are?</p><p>Because if the answer is no, if it’s not a reasonable person, that’s like a whole other sort of, you know, path and decision tree as engineers might say. But if it’s someone who is reasonable, then oftentimes I find it very effective and actually very educational for both people to say, “Here’s what my current state of things looks like. I’m on this many committees. I’m, you know, mentoring this many students. You know, this is my teaching load. This is what I’m doing with respect to research. So here’s what I think my priorities are. What do you think my priorities should be?” And, you know, if you phrase that in sort of a polite way, but in sort of an honest way and a direct way, I think that can actually sort of recalibrate how people think sometimes about what the burden of a scholar of color is because I think there’s a large set of people in academia who are well intentioned, but ignorant.</p><p>And just to be clear, that includes me, that includes everyone. We’re all sort of ignorant about something. But I think there’s a large set of people in academia, who, they’re not in the Klan. They’re not, you know, quote-unquote “obvious racists.” They’re not burning crosses in people’s front yard and yet, you know, they’re actually without knowing it, complicit is too strong of a word, but but they don’t understand that, you know, we’re all embedded in sort of this larger social structure and we all play a certain role in making sure that certain things that have inertia either continue or don’t continue. So I’ve actually found that very useful to say, “This is what my next year looks like. So, you know, you’re asking me to do this. Do you think that, you know, how do you think this fits into my overall plan? Do you think I should maybe drop something else?”</p><p>You know, sometimes they say yes. Sometimes they’ll say, yeah, I think you should actually you know do this instead of that, and that’s good feedback for you to hear, perhaps as well. But I think that one of the big challenges I see for scholars of color is that they try to say yes to everything, in part because of a fear of being sort of stereotyped as sort of the the angry person of color or, you know, this is someone, you know, “Well, when I asked Steve to do this, Steve didn’t complain about this,” you know.</p><p>So I think there is a fine line there, but I think that in general, in life, it’s very helpful to be intentional about the things that you do. You know when you want to get some professional or personal goal, think explicitly about what steps you’re going to take to get there. And I think this sort of advice to be intentional is doubly important in academia, in part because there’s so many people who can ask you what to do, right, and try to suggest that you do certain things.</p><p>You know, I used to spend some time in industry and that’s one of the biggest differences I found between industry and academia. In industry, I nominally have one boss, you know? In academia, anyone can send me an email. You know, students can send me an email, people, other professors can send me an email. So it’s really important to be intentional about how you choose what you do.</p><p>Tanya Ballard Brown: I want to throw that same question to Dr. Snowden. Mareena, in terms of how you have learned to manage some of those expectations, some of that additional work, that laborious work that maybe someone not of color is not having to take on</p><p>Mareena Robinson Snowden: Yeah, you know, it’s really, I think that James and Shardé really just hit the nail on the head with so many pieces of their answer, right. So, so, you know, James was talking about this honesty and transparency right and owning the fact that your time, you know, time is the most limited resource, right, and oftentimes we struggle with saying no, right. That is what James is saying, you need to be able to say no. To be intentional is to have to prioritize, right, and one of the hardest things, I think, scholars and practitioners of color have to deal with is prioritizing ourselves because the environment seems so unstable for us, right. Because you are often the only one in the room, so every decision that you make feels so consequential. Even in reality, it may or may not be, right? We recognizes and acknowledge that there is perception and then there’s also reality on both sides of the equation. Right. Um, But I think this, this, this skill and ability, which is something that is built, right, to be able to prioritize yourself and your career and say no is key. Right.</p><p>Now it’s interesting because, for me, you know, I was steeped and raised in the tradition of Historically Black Colleges and Universities. Right. And so much of that, I’m a proud graduate of Florida A&amp;M University. So before I had anything to do with MIT, I was a rattler, okay and the rattler perspective.</p><p>Tanya Ballard Brown: I’m North Carolina A&amp;T</p><p>Mareena Robinson Snowden: Yes, Yes. Come on now, Come on now. Okay. But that, that HBCU perspective is about, to a degree selflessness. Right. It’s about putting yourself in a position to help your culture, right. So there is a balance that has to be struck between being so laser focused on your own success because it is a testament and a data point for your culture about what can happen, and then kind of what I feel as a duty to the culture to contribute to this work, right.</p><p>So, the committee work that James and Shardé talked about, right. Like there, for me, it’s, it’s not, I never feel comfortable because of that sense of duty saying no to everything, right. Like you have to make space for that. And I think that’s, you know, I think James and Shardé would agree. You know, Shardé talked about this, this question of is it me, right? Like they asked, they stopping me? Like am I tripping? Like, did I take that the wrong way?</p><p>When the guy, I was at a holiday party in graduate school and one of the other graduate students walked up to me and just, in a very well intentioned way right James, walked up to me and say, you know, I’m just, you know, I know, I used to live near the inner city and I’m so proud that you were able to make it out of the inner city. Right. And I’m sitting at the holiday party with my little cup of food or to plate of food thinking do I respond to this? Now, what do I say to that, right? Because there’s so many assumptions built into that right. Because I am a Black person in this room, I must have either been the affirmative action hire or admit, or I’ve traversed, you know, crack needles and all kinds of things to get here, right.</p><p>And there are people who live, you know, our, our community is so diverse, right. We have so many different stories, from cultural, right, like we have Jamaicans, we have Haitians, we have people from the African continent, we have people from Canada, like Black people are very diverse and broad right and and to have to come up against the assumptions can be challenging. For me, it was, it was critical while I was at MIT and now that I’m at Johns Hopkins to find community right, because community is the antidote to gaslighting.</p><p>So when you have a community of folks that you can go back to and say, “So this thing happened to me. Am I trippin?” They can say, “No, you’re not tripping,” right. And Shardé’s hashtag was that in the digital space, right. She created community in the digital space so people could acknowledge and corroborate and endorse, right, your experience and say, “No, you are not crazy. This does happen and this is wrong and it exists” to James’s point in this kind of systematic context that matters, right.</p><p>So, you know, James is exactly right. It is a hard question. But I think you know community is essential and learning how to be transparent, not, not necessarily vulnerable. Okay, but how to be honest with your abilities at that moment, and your priorities at that moment is key to kind of staying along the path.</p><p>Tanya Ballard Brown: You say community, are you like, are you telling people to seek out people like yourself instructors who can sort of guide them to other people or, or, or are there resources that should be your university should be compiling and making available. Like, what kind, what, what kinds of ways do people create these communities?</p><p>Mareena Robinson Snowden: Yeah. So the easy answer is all of the above. Right. Um, what I was thinking about was, for me, the most transformative and kind of fortifying force while I was at MIT and now were my peers, right, were my homegirls and my homeboys who I could, you know, W.E.B. Du Bois talks about the mask right. And you could drop the mask and just be yourself and speak in your language and, you know, admit things that you would never admit in the mainstream conversation because of that fear of vulnerability and that stereotype threat, right, that, that you feel like if you admit this, it’s a damnation on your culture. So I think it’s peer community, but you bring up a very key point.</p><p>The best at, one of the best pieces of advice that I got when I was coming up at MIT was, you have to get people to buy into your success. So there are people in power in these institutions, right, whether they’re in the provost’s office, whether they’re in the dean’s office, right, and they need to know that you exist and you ain’t playing. Right, like you serious business. You good at your job, so when the inevitable foolishness starts because it always gonna be some foolishness, you already have the reputation that no, no, no it’s not her or it’s not him. Something else is up here because I know this person is a serious scholar and the quality of their work and the type of their character, right, so they can start to question their own system like something’s wrong here. If she’s having trouble and she’s a stellar student or scholar or professor, we must be dropping the ball somewhere, right, so it’s communities at all levels, Tanya.</p><p>Tanya Ballard Brown: This brings me back to Shardé because earlier this year in an interview, you talked about how white academics have not given weight or attention to systemic racism. And so my question sort of also it builds on what Mareena was just saying is with, you know, white faculty and staff making up like 70% of campuses nationwide, what do you see is their role in helping to dismantle systemic racism? That’s a hard question. This is for Shardé though.</p><p>Shardé Davis: Right. [laughs] Yeah.</p><p>Tanya Ballard Brown: What would you have them do?</p><p>Shardé Davis: They have a lot to do. They have a lot to do. Can I have to just say Mareena’s preaching. Okay. She took this from like a webinar, a forum to some kitchen table talk. I’m here for everything that she that, she said and if I can lean into my research in terms of the communities and peers and the necessity of having, for Black women, for example, a sister circle, right. Thinking about the identities that you hold right and where you sit and your vantage point and finding other individuals who are situated similarly to you. And that can also mean other, for example, other Blackademics and creating a community. They don’t even necessarily have to be Blackademics at your institution but even other Blackademics nationwide, right, because they understand what it means to be one of the only right in in that space, but also thinking about, sometimes you just need to lean on your sister girls. Right and even though they might not necessarily be academics or affiliated with the university, there is a shared understanding about our double jeopardy, right, being both Black and women. And ways in which they might be confronting gendered racism within their own sphere of influence, within their own job that might overlap or read similarly to what we experience so, yeah, I just, I just had to just kind of cosign with what she was what she was preaching on.</p><p>Um, white folks, white academics, what, what is it that they can do? There’s a lot that they can do. One, I’ve been thinking about this a lot and I really think some of them need to have an introspective moment about their own, the seeds that have been planted by their parents, by other socializing agents, by their grandparents, right. I mean, many of us are only one to two generations away from, you know, white communities, other communities of color who have been spewing anti-Black rhetoric and and have been very unabashed, in doing so, right. So, it’s, to think that, you know, someone’s aunt, someone’s grandparents or great grandparents who were a part of those communities, who are part of perpetuating that rhetoric, to think that they have no influence on you, right is, that’s foolish. So I think white individuals need to have an introspective moment about what has been planted inside of them, what beliefs, albeit some maybe deep seated right that are, that are situated, perhaps even in their subconscious, and really interrogating that. Many people are, you know, we talked about therapy, this is also another topic that we should be, white folks especially should be talking about in therapy right. How they might be complicit or how they might be, again, perpetuating this in just their everyday walks of life.</p><p>I also think white folks need to think about not only what their work life looks like, but oftentimes what you do at work is a reflection of your own personal life. How many, look at your own friendship network. Do you only hang around white folks? Think about the books that you read. Is it mainly white authors? Think about the restaurants that you patron. Are they mainly owned by white people? Is it only serving kind of standard American food? Think about the, the, the, your leisure activities, your gym or other classes that you take, fitness classes that you take, thinking about different kinds of seminars or workshops in your community that you attend. Who else is in the room? Who’s teaching it? What are they talking about? That’s a reflection of you and your beliefs, your desires, your ideas right. Again, sometimes it’s subconscious. We’re subconsciously making these decisions, but what we believe is going to guide how we behave.</p><p>So I think that, you know, there needs to be, again, an introspective moment about where someone is situated personally in their own personal life. Um, and I don’t want to say before, but that definitely needs to be working in tandem with the work that they’re doing at the university. I also think that white academics absolutely need to, well I don’t want to say stop, but to stop offloading this work on to Blackademics and even on to other people of color. We all have a role. That could mean making a concerted effort to mentor and advise other Black graduate students. That is not just the responsibility of Black faculty to advise and / or mentor Black graduate students and Black undergraduate students, absolutely not. They have a role in that as well. That could mean sacrificing their privilege, de-centering their privilege and sacrificing, I shouldn’t say sacrificing, but sacrificing their, I guess, comfort. Right. But I mean, white folks benefit from privilege and that then allows them to move up and matriculate the ladder, to maneuver the university in a way that’s much easier. than their Black counterparts. So there’s a way in which they need to sacrifice that. There’s a way in which they need to sacrifice that comfort to create room so that we can start, start to maneuver, so that some of our needs and desires can now be centered.</p><p>Um, there’s a way in which they need to, if they find themselves in, I was talking about this with some faculty of color who I work with at UConn and how there are some open positions for admin in the administrative kind of realm or tier of our university.</p><p>If white folks find themselves getting tapped on the shoulder, perhaps they need to think about some of their Black peers or their Black colleagues who are also more than qualified even to be in that position, and perhaps not go and to take that and to go and suggest someone else’s name, put someone else’s name in the ring, right. There are even just small micro behaviors that folks can do. I learned this theory called shine theory, which is when in meetings, for example, if you hear me say an idea and to go and to repeat that idea because 9 times out of 10, no one’s going to either hear it or they’re not going to give me the acknowledgement. They’re going to maybe like the idea, but not going to attach it to myself and they’re going to go and then take the, basically co op the idea, right. So with shine theory, it’s saying that people in positions of power, to repeat it and to cite it so that not only the idea gets goes forth, but also the individual who owns it. Right. They then are tethered to it.</p><p>So even something as simple as making sure that we’re not getting erased and that we are getting our proper dues. Gosh, I mean, there’s just, I could go on and on. I’m sure we all could kind of collate all these various things that they could do in their personal life and their professional life. Right. And I think you got to do the research, say it again.</p><p>Tanya Ballard Brown: I want to give James and Mareena chance to to share some ideas about what they, what changes they think that white faculty members and other academics might be able to do to help dismantle some of the systemic racism.</p><p>James Mickens: Well, I think, as always, you know, your track record of asking difficult questions continues. I appreciate that you’re keeping us on our feet. We wanted the best, we got the best.</p><p>I think that one of the things which is sort of underlying your question, which I think is interesting, and I’ll just put it out there bluntly. I think one of the big challenges in academia is what do with the case of the white progressive who voted for Obama? Right, there’s like a great scene in <em>Get Out</em> that sort of addresses this very thing. You know, like, you’ll find these people in academia, who, you know, they want to believe they vote the right way. You know, like, oh yeah, I voted for Obama. I totally believe in policies X, Y, and Z.</p><p>But so to get into something that Shardé was saying, it’s like, but are you living a life, you know, sort of academically, in sort of personally, that reflect how you think that you’re voting preferences is sort of, you know, making claims on on on the world. So, for example, like, and this is something, as I mentioned, my some of the other panelists. Not just women and people of color can be on diversity committees. It’s possible that, you know, white men can be on those committees. When you’re looking at, you know, how are we going to manage, you know, a daycare for for professors who have children, it doesn’t just have to be women on that committee. When we’re looking at, to Mareena’s point, looking at, well, how can we increase the diversity of our graduate student admins, it doesn’t just have to be people who have the demographic characteristics that you want to improve being on that committee.</p><p>And so I think that it’s important, and once again, this is another one of those difficult conversations that you, you, you have to sort of midwife with some grace and with some, some charm. But I think it’s important to ask people to basically step up to these things. To say, you know, can you act as an ally, because I think, in many cases, that’s really what’s lacking in in academia. Not just people who say, like, “Yes, I believe in X, Y, and Z,” but it’s like will you actually perform explicit acts of allyship?</p><p>You know, if you see, for example, that, you know, a lot of committee work is being pushed towards people of color, will you be an ally and suggest maybe I’ll do some of that work, or I’ll suggest someone else who is underburdened who should maybe get some of that work? And there are very simple, very practical things that I think that, you know, allies can do. So, for example, when you’re thinking about colloquium speakers. Who should we invite to come talk to our students as exemplars of what academia should look like?</p><p>You know, a very simple question that you can ask in a meeting is, have we consider people of color here? Is there anyone that we’re missing? Are there any women that we’re missing here? You know, there’s anyone with a disability, things like this? And what’s interesting is that when you ask that question, just asking the question, a lot of people will say, oh, right, right, why don’t we invite so and so? And so was just that sort of gentle prodding that was necessary, but someone has to do it. You know, someone has to do it, and you have to sort of set this culture of people being willing to ask those questions.</p><p>And you know, I also want to really sort of emphasize something that Mareena said, which has already been emphasized by Shardé, but particularly if we have a lot of engineers in the audience. Even in engineering, it is a social science. There are plenty of people who are super smart super bright who didn’t build the right network and you don’t hear about those folks. And so I think it’s very important, you know, to build that community and it can’t just be, you know, people of color in the answer. And, you know, why is that? Because there’s not a lot of us out there right now. And so, you know, if you’re just going to hitch your wagon to just a colored star, your wagon might not be going very far at a lot of universities, you know. So I think that if you do have allies, you know, who are white, you should you should allow them to help you because these people do exist out there, you know.</p><p>But I do want to emphasize that point once again that community is so important. Because, you know, when you think about, you know, who gets academic jobs, academia is very small, you know, and as I always tell my students there’s sort of like the long line and the short line, just like get into a club. You know, you always want to be in that short line. Right. And so how do you get on that short line? You get on the short line by knowing people and by your allies knowing people. And so you want to be very intentional regardless of what stage of your career. You could be a grad student. You could be a professor. You can be emeritus. It doesn’t matter. You can be retired, right, there’s still things in your life that you want, and you want to be intentional about building the community that will allow you to achieve those goals.</p><p>Tanya Ballard Brown: I’ll toss this to Mareena, but what you talked about this a little bit about the culture that BIPOC students encounter when they’re coming to universities and they’re not necessarily ready for the campus culture, and just sort of navigating some of these things. What responsibility do institutions have to try to help students, not just get to the school, but get through the school and all of these things that you’re talking about? And what are some of the things that they might be thinking about instituting to help better help students matriculating, graduate, and be successful because our numbers show that we some we can get there sometimes, but we don’t always get finished. We don’t always cross the finish line.</p><p>Mareena Robinson Snowden: Absolutely. You know, I think, to your question, what, what proportion of the responsibility, I say, the vast majority of the responsibility falls on the institution. Right. And the first thing the institution needs to do is know thyself. Right, like one of the biggest errors I see consistently even now in the 30 years of diversity and equity and inclusion being mainstream right, like this is not a new conversation we’re having, and that’s why this is so frustrating, right, because this work, you know, was instigated in like really hardcore in the 90s, and it was the same situation right. And the problem is that institutions, you know, it’s very easy. I see that there’s a lot of different kind of facets to DEI work, right, and, you know, one of the trends. I see is that institutions of higher education, industry, military, regardless, government. Everyone is very comfortable with the recruitment conversation, right. How do we get these shining stars into our institution and once they get through the door, it’s going to be kumbaya cause it’s okay, right.</p><p>Unfortunately, as you said, Tanya the data does not bear that out, right. Students are getting here with all of the vigor and enthusiasm and promise, and for whatever reason they’re leaving with a masters when they applied for a Ph.D. They’re leaving before the tenure track happens or they’re not getting tenure at all. Right. And what I find is a consistent error is that institutions are not tracking this and if they are tracking it, they’re not tracking it in an actionable way. They’re not setting any strategies around these numbers, right. I think the most guarded data in higher ed institutions is your demographic data and it’s guarded because people are embarrassed, because the numbers are not moving in the right direction and they don’t want to be shamed. Right. But we have to move out of this frame of embarrassment and shame and just acknowledge as a collective community under the context of the legacy of slavery and Jim Crow and the transatlantic slave trade, right, like nobody is doing this right. So you’re not uniquely failing in this. We need to get beyond the shame, so that we can share, right, and we can we can strategize together about how to correct these trends specifically with respect to cultural and ethnic diversity, right.</p><p>Because another thing that institutions of higher education are very comfortable with is defining diversity in terms of gender. Right. We are very quick to talk about how we have achieved at our beloved MIT, achieved gender parity in the undergraduate ranks right. We are near 50/50. The proportion of women in STEM is rising, year after year. But as those same people, how many black folks they have in their programs? And what the 10-year trends look like? They’re stagnant, if not reducing right, so we have to hold ourselves accountable to the way that we’re defining these terms, right. You’re defining them in a way that suits you in a way that you’re proud to talk about their data, but if you’re not willing to know thyself and look at yourself, then where are we? We lost before we even started.</p><p>You know, um, I think I, you know, I just, James, you are the MVP talking about this white progressive, my brother. Okay. Because I read something recently that said, it really ties in so well with, it was a Harvard Business Review article or something and they were talking about kind of the other side of, the the other side of the negative diversity corner where you have folks that say, “Listen, we have Asian-Americans. You know, we have a transgender person, a lesbian person, a gay person. We have a, you know, a differently abled person. Like aren’t really diverse enough? Like we did it. We’re here.”</p><p>But, but the question is, where, where are the, where’s the Black person? Like you ain’t done until you have Black people. And the reason why you’re not done until you have Black people there is because you have to frame it in terms of impact right. Diversity and inclusion work is about who is the most marginalized? Who is impacted? It’s not about your intention. I understand what you meant to say, right, but that’s not what’s important here. It’s about how your actions land on communities. Right. And the most effective, still to this day, Covid is bearing it out, day after day, right, if the Black community. From the founding of this country we have been at the bottom of the Totem pole. Okay, it’s the way it was set up. So until you have that group well represented within your organization, you ain’t done. You can have as many as you want in terms of your diversity checkboxes.</p><p>But then, you know, so it’s, it’s a, it’s a very nuanced conversation, but we have to bring these conversations in an institutional way, right, and it can’t just be because another Black man got murdered on camera that now we’re having the Forum. Right. Where is your diversity officer, department head? Provost, right? MIT just released the fact that they want every department now, to have a dedicated diversity officer. That’s, you’re late. This should have been happening. We were talking about this when I was there and I’ve been gone five years now. Right. So we need to invest in these positions so that it’s not only on the students and faculty of color to be the engines of this work right. You need to institutionalize this with positions. When your dean of diversity and inclusion leaves, fill that position. Right, because if it doesn’t get filled, we see where your priorities are and I’m looking at you, my institution. Fill the position so that we can see this work continued to go, year after year.</p><p>But, you know, you asked, what should faculty and the institutions do? These are those things. Know your data. Institutionalize these roles so somebody can own this progress. Have a strategic plan. The same way you have a strategic plan around building your endowment, and you’ve been able to build billion-dollar endowments, right, because you have networks and connections and you set goals and you track those goals, based on year after year data, do the same thing with diversity. Do the same thing with communities of color, and then we will start to see the returns on the investment because right now we’ve done 30 years of investment and have nothing to show for it with respect to Black people. Thank you.</p><p>Tanya Ballard Brown: Do y’all think that Title IX reporting and training are mandatory? Because this again, you just said this, but I’m going to ask you, is mandatory at most campuses, so do you see that the the need for the same kind of codification for diversity, equity, and inclusion training? Is that how we get to someone responsible for the numbers away from the shame that you talked about and more accountability and more action? Shardé. I’ll throw it to Shardé.</p><p>Shardé Davis: [laughs] I don’t think it, I don’t think it hurts. I can put it that way. Um, I don’t think it hurts, as Mareena said, to have dedicated, I see that ia dedicated institutional resourcing right to addressing racism as it, as it exists across the, the university. Certainly, there needs to be some system in place, right, where individuals who encounter these issues and who are assaulted can go to the university and there is a process right by which it will get addressed and evaluated and handled accordingly in a way where the person feels as though the university has responded as they should. Um, yeah. So that could be an officer. I’ve yet to see something like that. I don’t know if this existed other universities, but I’m certainly open to the possibilities of imagining that.</p><p>Tanya Ballard Brown: I think we’re going to shift over to taking questions from the audience now and Christina gave some directions, but I’ll be quiet and let her tell you again, just in case anybody missed how to submit questions.</p><p>Christina Couch: We’ve got some great questions already. If you have additional questions, put them in the Q and A a box below. We’re going to try and get through as many as possible. I’ll just read them out and we’ll pass them on to speakers and kind of go from there.</p><p>The first question I’m going to start out with is non-Black POC exist in a space between whiteness and Blackness and often, it can be difficult to understand your role in helping dismantle anti-Black racism in the academy. Do you think there’s any distinct or particular role that non-Black POC should play in the struggle for justice in academia?</p><p>Mareena Robinson Snowden: Does anybody want to jump in? I’ll just throw out a thought out there real quick. So I think, you know, it’s a wonderful question. And to me, it brings up the idea of coalition building. Right. So, James talked about the fact that unfortunately, the situation right now is, is that there is so few of us, right, and year to year to year, the numbers even fluctuate in that small number, right. So you might have one or two or six and then you’re really celebrating right? So in order for us to make an impact, there has to be coalitions forming between all of the cultural and racial groups in terms of the minority category right. Like the Asian Pacific Islanders need to link up with the Black folks need to link up with the BGSA to link up with the Hispanic professional engineers right like because that’s the only way that we can have that kind of, that kind of power work in terms of numbers.</p><p>What is wonderful about the situation in terms of the coalition is a lot of our needs are similar. Right, a lot of the things that we’re going through in terms of what we’re facing with respect to this within academia. Maybe our origin stories are a little bit different, Right, but the, the systems that were coming up against an academia, oftentimes treat us very similar, right. Now it’s now there are nuances, right, when we talk about, particularly with respect to in engineering, the presence of Asian-Americans versus other minority groups, like there are nuances. I get that. But the idea of getting together and amplifying each other’s needs, amplifying each other’s demands right and, and to Shardé’s point about Shine Theory, right, like, shine. Like if the Hispanic student group or the Hispanic faculty something, like all the minority clubs and, and, and affinity groups need to link up behind because that sends a demand signal to leadership.</p><p>Right. Because also another thing we have to acknowledge in this space right now is we have power. Okay. They don’t want to lose us. They ain’t got but three of us. Okay, so if we all band together, right, and make our demands very, very clear, you know that sends a signal to them to listen. You better listen before all before your diversity walk out the door and go to the next university. Because we are in demand and it’s it’s not something that we have to shy away from. It’s nothing that we created. Okay, but we can leverage that power that we have right now until the system has changed to try to push the system forward.</p><p>Shardé Davis: Yeah. And if I can just say that we kind of are holding, I guess, intention, in a way, but this kind of POC coalition building right and the solidarity that gets invoked, and rightly should be with moments that are focused on particular community. Right. And this is a Black moment. So I, I think for me, we need our non-Black POCS to recognize that to not try and for administrators, not to try to do the broad paint stroke of we’re going to dedicate these dollars for all diverse groups or all kind of groups of color. No. I need dedicated dollars for Black people, Black staff, Black undergraduate students, graduate students, and faculty. I need folks to be bold and to lean into that and for our non-Black POCS to support us in that endeavor. Yeah. We really need to lean into the nuance, right, and that we have specific needs as Black folks that are, that need to be focused on because when we go and try to invoke that kind of all POC or issues, right, Black people, we end up losing and we end up going invisible and unheard.</p><p>James Mickens: Yeah. I would also say the allyship issue is important too, because, you know, although I think there should be sort of like top-down requirements for institutions to think about these issues of race and Blackness, in particular, a lot of times those mandates can seem very artificial and therefore easy for people to ignore if it’s not seen as being something that is also important organically for the community.</p><p>Right. So it’s like, you know, think about like ethics training if you’re a scientist. Most scientists, I mean, they’re like, Yeah, okay. So don’t push people down the stairs. Try not to blow up the lab, like, cool. I’m done. Right, in part because it feels pro forma. It feels like I just have to check this box and then be done with it, you know. So I think that this is one reason why allyship with non-Black POCs is so important because it builds the size of the coalition and it will make the people in power see that it is actually something the community is experiencing and feels is important as opposed to, there was this edict that got passed by, you know, the president or the provost and I just need to check that box and I can keep my job. Instead, it’s like the people who are ostensibly my constituents, whose, you know, care has been entrusted to me, they actually feel this is an important topic.</p><p>Christina Couch: Here’s the next question. Many different diversity, equity, and inclusion committees have sprung up recently students who are Black, indigenous, or people of color disproportionately get asked to be on these committees. The problem is that we are typically the most active and likely to be able to make change. It is a burden to speak up and more of a burden to expect to make the fixes we are pointing out. How do we navigate this issue?</p><p>James Mickens: I’d say, I mean, once again, another hard question just raining, falling down from the sky. So I think that this is one reason why it’s actually important to try to be frank and have honest conversations with the people who are tasking you to do these things. So, you know, sometimes when I get invited to do things, like be on a diversity committee, for example. I will sometimes say, and, you know, I’m tenured now so I’m not worried about getting fired. But I will sometimes say something like, so can you tell me how many other people be on this committee? How many of them will be white? How many of them will be men? How many will be women? Because it’s important for me to not be on a committee that’s, you know, let’s say it’s about, you know, say Black inclusion, that it’s only Black people because yes, you clearly want people at that table when you have that conversation to bring their lived experiences, but it can’t just be the burden of, you know, sort of like the disenfranchised to sort of enfranchise themselves, right. It’s the system, so it takes voices from all across the spectrum.</p><p>And so I think that can be challenging when you’re a student, when you might not feel that you have as much protection there. But if you have allies, for example, either in numbers amongst other students, or if you have other faculty members who you feel comfortable sharing these ideas with, it’s helpful when you have someone who can be external to the direct situation to come in there and vouch for you and the say, well, there’s something, who does not quite right. You know, we’re already not providing enough support for our students of color, and now we’re also asking them to do these extra things in addition to pass their quals and write papers and do lab work and stuff like that. So I think it’s just really important to get to a place where you can have those frank conversations about those things.</p><p>Shardé Davis: Something I did recently, my department started a DEI task force by my very good friend and colleague and I, it was our idea, but I told her pretty frankly, speaking to what James had said, I am not going to be chair. I have no interest being chair of this committee and I will be on it, but more so as a way as a kind of a check and balance because I fear a whole bunch of white folks on a DEI committee, it can go real wrong, real fast. Um, but I essentially kind of worked it out with her in terms of a strategy where she knew, like please do not call me to do everything. I’m probably not going to be on a, on a whole bunch of subcommittees. I have enough to do. This is the role that I want to play. And in a way, also, I also made it clear, which is it’s kind of carping to I was talking about Shine Theory and the ideas that we have and how they can get stolen and co-opted, that when she comes to me, which sometimes she does about certain things that she wants to do with the committee and she wants a sounding board, that she makes sure she gives me credit in the meeting. Because I also find that when we’re sitting on these committees, people do a lot of the picking of your brain and right and wanting to go and to kind of consult with you and then end up taking your ideas and not giving you any to-do for what, for what it is that you’re, right, you’re contributing to the group. So I think, again, the honesty and transparency and also kind of strategy. And if that’s not necessarily with the entire group, then making sure that you’re having that conversation with the, the chair or the member that’s leading it.</p><p>Mareena Robinson Snowden: And if I can just give a quick two-finger on that, you know, in addition to everything that James and Shardé just said, also, as you’re, whatever level you’re at, the person who asked this question, be compassionate with yourself as you build that muscle of prioritization and advocacy for yourself. Right. Because we talked about that tax earlier. And oftentimes, when you have so many demands on your time and things coming in, there can start to become like almost a spectator conversation going on in your head about how you should have done this different or should have done that different. Like you have to forgive yourself if you say yes to one too many things right ,and then use that data to course correct later right. But you know so much of our culture right now is expecting people to arrive at 100%. Like arrive knowing exactly what to do and exactly how to handle situations and it’s just not the reality of the situation. As you have more interactions with these situations, you get better and better at saying no, or I would rather do this or that, or to Shardé’s point, strategizing with people and telling them exactly what you need in that moment, right. So, you know, I wish I would have known that earlier in my career and I would have saved a lot of mental kind of critique of myself, understanding that it’s a process.</p><p>Christina Couch: And the next question is, thank you so much for this wonderful conversation. I resonated so much with everything said as a Black engineering Ph.D. student. I’m on one of the many DEI committees in my university and I’m tired of the lack of self awareness, especially when it comes to understanding the problems BIPOC students face in academia and the simultaneous lack of willingness to spend money for DEI assessments and solutions. How do we demand the resources required to make real institutional change? I’m tired and my patients is waning.</p><p>Mareena Robinson Snowden: So I have a thought. And I’m not sure if it’s a good thought. Okay, well, I’m going to throw it out there. Okay. I remember being a graduate student and just feeling the exact same feelings right, that salt because this was before George Floyd right. I was in graduate school when Trayvon Martin, right, Mike Brown, was happening and it was the same uproar. A little less white people on the protest line. But nonetheless, the same enthusiasm. And one of the things that kept coming up for me was, um, that exact question, right. Like how do I, how do we not let this just be lip service? And I think Shardé has a wonderful example of this, about how being a little more public with your frustration or with your experience right. And there’s a way to do this right, and, and, and we have to acknowledge the risk with being more public, right, writing an article about your experience, sending a tweet about your experience. Like there is a lot of risk to that. So i’m not minimizing or dismissing that, but I think there’s a role for introducing the conversation in a way that is a little bit further than the walls of your institution.</p><p>And maybe the way to approach it if you are in a more risky situation which, let’s say you’re a graduate student and you’re trying to get your Ph.D., you don’t have that yet. Right. Is to always try to frame it in the most collaborative terms possible right. You’re trying to bring the institution along as opposed to convicting them which the frustration makes you feel like you want to do, right. You want to have a kind of “how might we” conversation. How might we bring about this? How might we, right? It’s a we thing, but in a way that brings in stakeholders from beyond your institution in a little bit more public facing way. And I wonder, because you know, at the end of the day, what we have to acknowledge, for good or for bad are these institutions are brands. Right, they’re brands and the biggest threat to their brand is you going public, is you say, is you starting Black in the Ivory. And you best believe Shardé’s university took notice. You know, took notice, probably wanted, Shardé you should speak to this. Probably wanted to talk to you, wanted to get your ideas and your thoughts. Right. So there’s there’s a way to balance and to strategize that risk versus that reward of shining a little bit more of a light on the specific experience that you might be having in your university.</p><p>Shardé Davis: Yes, oh yes risk. Mm hmm. Um, yeah. And that’s a that’s an internal conversation you have to have with yourself about if you can do it, you know. There is something about yeah invoking or kind of, I guess, community. You’re building a coalition nationwide or even global-wide the other Black graduate students who likely are experiencing very similar things or even Black graduate students at your university. Something that comes to mind at UConn is they started on this Instagram page called Black at UConn and it’s anonymous, but students can go and post to the page about whatever it is they’re experiencing Black at UConn and everyone can see the responses, but it’s not attached to an identity. And let me tell you, that has shaken UConn like nobody’s business and I love it. I love it. I think it’s, it was it’s student-created, student ran and the university doesn’t try to, I mean, what can they do? It’s on a third-party social media platform. Um, but I think it’s a really beautiful way of where students really leaned into the power that they have to go and to share their kind of grievances, knowing that the university is taking taking note of it. And they have.</p><p>So I think there’s certainly absolutely power in that and yes I have seen a 180. When I was doing this work before Black in the Ivory popped off, and I mean literally within a month, meeting with the president before and meeting with the president after. Let me tell you, there was a difference. So sometimes you do have to kind of, I don’t say poke the bear cause that’s not what we’re doing. We’re not talking about provoking, but it is about being a bit more forthright and more public with your experiences. And you’re right. It is a brand and they want to protect that brand.</p><p>James Mickens: Yeah, and I would just add that it is important to think about the before and the after there. Because it’s one thing to be able to get the bear’s attention, but now you’re in the bear cave. And so what do you do? And I think there’s certain words that you want to use. You want to be very strategic when you talk to power. Right. So, for example, like one phrase I always use, I say “what are concrete and specific things that we’re going to do to sort of address this issue?” And the reason why concrete and specific is important is because you don’t want the powers that be to issue some very generic statement that say we feel super bad about this. Like clearly they would gussy it up. Like there are so many statements that come out. They just say, “this is shame and really something should be done,” like babushka dolls of passive voice. So you want to say, okay, what are the concrete, specific things that we’re going to do here? And then you also want to say, what are the evaluation metrics?</p><p>So given that you’ve committed to these concrete, specific things, how will we know, and to Mareena’s point, say we. You know, don’t, don’t go in there and it’s like a knife fight, but say how are we going to figure out whether these concrete, specific things worked or not? Because you want to hold people accountable. And I think it’s really important, for example, like when you go into meetings, you know, this is kind of like a Jedi mind trick, but you know going there with a sheet of paper, so people can see how much or how little you’ve written down as a result of what other people have said to you. You know, because if you come into the meeting and you ask the question, like, what are the concrete, specific things we’re going to do? You take the cap off your pen.Get your best smile. Yeah, I’m listening and then you don’t write anything down, that’s a very sort of subtle but like not so subtle message that we haven’t really made progress here. We’re just sort of exchanging platitudes.</p><p>And I think that, you know, that’s one trap that sometimes I see students in particular fall into where they’re very sort of energetic. They’re very enthusiastic. But the thing is, you know, the people in power, they’re there for a reason. They know all these techniques and one of those techniques is to run the clock out. You know, you’ve got an hour long meeting. You spend 45 minutes of it on platitudes. The assistant knocks on the door, 15 more minutes. You look at your agenda, you’ve discussed nothing. Right. So whenever you talk to power you need to be very clear about trying to set the agenda and be polite, but have specific goals that you want for you in terms of what you say, specific asks you want to make of them, and always ask about that evaluation metric thing because if you don’t have evaluation, then it’s very easy for the powers that be to sort of semi-commit to something, but then nothing really gets done.</p><p>Shardé Davis: That’s so good. And in fact, sometimes, or not sometimes, the group I work with, we email them the agenda beforehand. Right, so that they, we all know what it is that we plan to speak about and if I can add just one more thing in terms of strategy and doing this work and the risk is, and you can take this as you will, but when my voice started to become a little bit louder and I started to come a little bit more unabashed in in what I said when my record got stronger. Take it as you will.</p><p>And I’m not saying that this is, you know, necessarily even advice, but I, when I knew, like 10 years is never given by any stretch, but when I knew, like, you know, I, I’ve hit the publication number to where, you know what I mean, where like it’s a lawsuit at this point, I felt a little bit more comfortable. When I knew that, like, you know, my teaching is good. My services is you know, I blow other people out the water in terms of what I’m doing at all levels — university, department, professional, my researchers on point in all aspects, in top-tier journals, then I know that you know in terms of the repercussions that they might come at, you know, that there’s like that might try, they’re going to have to come up, be a little bit more strategic if they even go and try to, if there’s any backlash for me speaking out.</p><p>So I would just consider that as well. I have seen, for example, graduate students where they could probably there, they could probably spend a little bit more time in terms of research and teaching, they don’t necessarily have an established record, but they were very much provoking them there, and it didn’t turn out well for them because of the backlash and they just didn’t have a record to stand on. So take it as you will. But I know that that is a strategy that has very much work for me.</p><p>Christina Couch: And what do you think about the role of tenure and supporting systemic racism in the academy? And if you feel tenure plays a role, what do you think about getting rid of the tenure process?</p><p>Mareena Robinson Snowden: James do you want to go?. I’m not even up for tenure. I’m not even going for it. You have it, so do you want to talk about it?</p><p>James Mickens: The rumors are true. So I recently got tenure last year, thank you. Thank you. I think that tenure is kind of a double edged sword. And this gets back to some of our earlier conversations about what is the additional burden or the additional load that you bear as a person of color, and as a Black person in particular when you have to juggle all of that, you know, with publisher or perish and you have to teach and do all those kinds of things? I think that you know, so tenure is good in a sense that, you know, if you get tenure, then that does give you the freedom to be more outspoken about certain things getting some of Shardé’s points as well. You know, so once you sort of have that credential and just to be frank, it’s a credential. Right. We live in a credentialed society and one reason why it’s hard for grad students to speak up about these things is because you don’t have that credential, which says, Ph.D., I’m a doctor. You’re getting there, but you’re not there yet, you know, and so what you often find is that, you know, if you lack those credentials, that, that sort of puts you in a greater position of danger, if you will, to speak out about these things.</p><p>I think that the, and this is an unfortunate but I think this is a reality of the current academic market, is that as I was mentioning before, even in engineering, it’s a social science. You know, you’ve got to go to conferences.You’ve got to talk to people. You’ve got to do some of that networking, and in fact, you have to do a little bit extra networking because, you know, when I was talking about people thinking about who to invite to a colloquium and, you know, conveniently, you know, Black people don’t get mentioned or women don’t get mentioned, you know, it’s not in many cases because of sort of like quote-unquote big O Overt racism.</p><p>It’s just these systemic problems that are there. And so when you think about tenure, you know, how does that work at most schools, when you go up for tenure, you’ve got to get a ton of letters. Right, you get, other professors in your field have to write these letters that basically say this person deserves tenure. This is like some medieval stuff, man. There’s like trying to get into like a spice guild back in, like, you know, 15th century Italy or something like this. Right. And so you know as an engineer, you think, okay, what’s my work back plan then? So, you know, I need to eventually get, you know, some number of letters, let’s say 10 letters, 15 letters, how do I go about getting those those letters? You know, how do I act intentionally? How do I send preprints to other professors, things like that? How do I go to other schools and give presentations, things like this? So I think that in that sense, there, you know, getting tenure can be more difficult when you’re a person of color. I think if you get it, it’s sort of incumbent upon you to try to use that position of, to be frank, power to advocate for some of these issues.</p><p>Now perhaps the other part of the question is what does it mean when you’ve got these, you know, older people, shall we say, who are tenured who may be not as forward-looking as other people that we might be able to think about? And that’s hard. You know that’s hard. And, and those those folks, you know, as I was mentioning earlier, I like to think about people as sort of like evil and wicked and can’t be reasoned with, and I have a set of strategies for dealing with them and then it’s sort of like incompetent or ignorant. Right. And my advisor told me something that was really, really changed my life. I was angry about something that someone that had done to me and he said, never, never ascribed to malice, what can be explained by incompetence.</p><p>And so this is not to say that they’re not actively evil people out there. But I think if you have that attitude, that actually makes it easier to deal with, for example, some of these older tenured professors who seem like they’re acting just willy nilly, just they’re like Sauron from Lord of the Rings, but really they’re from a different era, perhaps, or maybe they have blind spots that you can help them with. And that, and I realized that when I say that that’s putting a disproportionate burden on the people who are disenfranchised to have to teach people about things. And that’s a real burden.</p><p>So I want to be clear about that, just in the way that Mareena talked about you. You can put yourself in peril by speaking up. It is exhausting to have to explain some of these things to well-intentioned but confused people. But one thing that I’ve seen at least personally my career and when I look at the careers of my friends and other folks is that, you know, Black scholars who’ve been able to, to sort of thread that needle and on the one hand, sort of speak with some of that fire and point out things that are problematic in the ivory tower, but also build coalitions, also create a sense of community, not just amongst other Black scholars, but amongst you know white scholars, amongst not just women, but men as well. Those people tend to be the most effective. And so, you know, I would keep all that in mind in thinking about how it is you want to sort of structure your career. What do you do? What don’t you do?</p><p>Christina Couch: This person asks, I’m curious how the panelists have been able to quantify what I call the invisible tax of being a Black faculty member and / or a doctoral student. I started documenting literally every student mentoring conversation, each token committee assignment, any offensive remark from non-BIPOC colleague, slight from leadership, almost to the point of therapy. How do you recommend we start going beyond simply holding receipts in the review process?</p><p>Mareena Robinson Snowden: So that is a really interesting question, the way that it was framed. Um, when I when you first started reading it, Christina, you know, the idea of receipts. I always think about insurance policies right, and and I think you expect the worst because you want to be ready. You’re, you’re surprised when the amazing things happen, but you want to think about all the potential outcomes. Right. And in my own Ph.D. experience, it got to the point where I also had to keep receipts, right, and had to write minutes after every single advisement meeting so that it was on the record what was understood to James’s point about bringing a paper and writing down concrete and specific expectations.</p><p>But I think there is a, my question would be what is the intention behind the receipts? Right. What is, what is the, what, what, what does the quantification, what end does the quantification serve right? So if you’re trying to have the receipts because your department has a history or a track record of treating students and faculty of color in less than above the board way, and you want to have kind of a record of that if things ever go left, that’s one thing. Right. If you are trying, if you’re keeping receipts as a processing mechanism for yourself, you know, but the goal at the end of it is kind of a healthy outlook on the situation, that’s another thing.</p><p>For me, I think, you know, not all asks on your, on your time are inherently negative, right. There are some people I want to mentor. There’s a lot that I get out of that a relationship or that participation on a task force or being consulted for things right. So I hope that we’re not giving the impression that that work writ large should be shied away from right, but I think if you’re looking for balance sometimes writing it out, can be helpful. Right. That was something that a mentor told me. Write down all the obligations that you have and put it on a whiteboard where you have to see it so that when somebody comes up to you and asked you to do the next thing, you can remember, because this is where I fail, I forget all the other things I’ve committed to right. So then I commit to the next thing, not knowing that something is already in its place right.</p><p>So that’s the intention of the receipt. It can be helpful, but I think just, I mean, I’m curious. I wish this could be a back and forth on what the intention of your detailed receipts are, and understanding if that intention is serving you versus kind of focusing your mind on something that, you know, might, might be keeping you in in a not so helpful place, if that makes sense.</p><p>Christina Couch: The next question is how do we combat seeing Blackness as a monolith if we are often encouraged to code switch and white higher education places.</p><p>James Mickens: The code switching burdens. You can tell by the pregnant pause from everyone, we’re like, oh man, how do we address this one? So, so the code switching burden is real. I think that there’s sort of like a practical reality of, of, of, sort of like how do, once again speak to power, or even people who are your peers or people who are sort of, quote-unquote, you know, junior to you. I think it is important for anyone. Not just white people, for Black people, to anyone, men, women, to be able to understand who their audience is. Right and understand how to phrase things in a way that will help your message resonate with that other person.</p><p>Right, I mean like Barack Obama was a hilarious example of this, right, because you know you can go on Twitter and type in, you know, “Barack Obama speaking like he’s Black” and get a whole set of funny videos you can get an, you know, “Barack Obama speaking like he’s white” and get a whole different set of funny videos.</p><p>So, you know, it’s something that I think a lot of scholars of color struggle with because they want to always be authentic, you know, but in some cases like be speaking in your authentic voice may not be received well by the audience. And I think one of the most important things to understand, like in public speaking and whenever you’re in a situation where you’re trying to be perceived as a person with authority, and that is one of the biggest challenges for scholars of color. Are you perceived as someone with authority? Because you will not automatically be given that authority, and particularly in science. You know, technical authority. That’s a phrase you hear thrown around a lot. You know, this person’s in authority on X. They’re an authority on Y.</p><p>And as a person of color, in particular is a Black person, you will oftentimes not be afforded that automatic authority that might be conferred to a white person who has your same level background, your same publication record. And so I think an unfortunate sort of consequence of that is that you will sometimes have to tweak your, your message a bit or change the way that you talk. And this is sort of just as a practical thing, you know. I think about this as an engineer. Right. So I like telling jokes. I like being funny, but I also know that there are certain career goals I have that are furthered by me first being understood as a technical authority, and then only second being understood as someone you want to hang out with after the talk, or things like that.</p><p>So I think this is a really important example of how you have to know your audience. This is not me you necessarily have to self censor. That’s a different thing. You know, I think that hopefully wherever you are in life, whether you’re a workplace environment or some a personal environment, you should feel comfortable saying that things that are on your mind. But I think from the practical perspective, it is important to try to understand the perspective of the person that you’re talking to and in academia, this is particularly the case because you will oftentimes encounter well intentioned people who don’t get it. And that’s like a big chunk of the resistance that, at least I’ve seen personally, my friends who are scholars of color encounter. It’s not that the person doesn’t want to help. It’s that they don’t fully understand the scope of the problem, or they don’t fully understand why the current mechanisms aren’t good enough. And so, once again, it is a burden to be an educator. It is difficult to have to feel like you need to justify things that you believe are innately true and that you have experienced as personally true. But I mean I think that is something that I see successful Black scholars do, that there is sort of like this, in a sense this extra educational effort they do to try to make people, to allow people to meet them halfway, if you will. To sort of build that rhetorical bridge where both of the people can meet and then they can say, “Okay this is actually a real problem that I understand.”</p><p>Mareena Robinson Snowden: So listen this is such an interesting question. I agree with you, James, and at the same time, I like how you frame it in terms of a practical question and this idea of, you know, I haven’t ever thought about code switching in relation to tailoring for your audience, right. Because that is very well understood, particularly in any kind of scholastic, technical presentations, things like that. Right. Like, you want to tailor your slides to the level of your audience, whether it’s a general audience, you would present it one way or if it’s a very technical audience who knows your narrow field, you would present it a different way. It’s interesting. It’s almost. It’s almost like how you speak in different settings.</p><p>So if you’re in a technical presentation, that’s fine, but I think we have to also leave space for acknowledging that in more general engagement, when I’m at the water cooler or I’m in the break room or something, you know, we should not give the system a pass in making us feel like we must speak in a certain way or use certain vocabulary, right. Like when you when you are not with your engineer hat on and giving a technical talk, you know, and you are just Mareena or Shardé or James, you should be able to speak how you speak, right, and part of that power comes from, my dad says to me all the time, don’t focus on the form, focus on the substance, right. What am I saying? And is what I’m saying correct? Who cares about how I’m saying it in this informal interaction right?</p><p>Now if I’m in a technical talk, that’s a different environment right, but i don’t want our audience to leave without the acknowledgement that you should be able to bring your vernacular, your inflection. Women get told this all the time — Make sure you bring your inflection down. Think about your inflection. Like the amount of thought behind the scenes that has to go into how I’m speaking, how am I gonna have any energy left to focus on the damn nuclear engineering?</p><p>So like we have to leave space for that truth as well. Yes, there is tailoring to your audience and I totally agree with that. I love that framing. And in less formal interactions, you should feel empowered and you should push against the system to not focus on the form, but focus on the substance of what you’re saying.</p><p>Shardé Davis: I’m glad you said that, Mareena. I think you brought up a good point. And as I was listening to the question, and it was something I kind of gleaned from it was kind of a burden that somehow we as Blackademics carry in thinking that our behavior is somehow going to change how what they, our white colleagues view us. So thinking we don’t, I heard how code switching or not and perhaps how that is going to impact our, our white colleagues seeing us as a monolith.</p><p>But unfortunately, we could code switch. We could not code switch. We could use inflections. We could show up in our Ankara or our kente cloth. I could show up with a press and curl, or, you know, my natural kinky curl. Their cognitive processing is their cognitive processing, right, and it’s going to vary from white person to white person and that their own particular journey and where they are at in life. And honestly that’s really doesn’t have much to do with our own behavior, right, because anti-Black racism, it’s systemic. It’s not us, baby. It’s them. Right. And so, I think, and what I’m, you know, hearing from Mareena and from James is that I think we have to really keep that in mind and give ourselves some grace right in allowing us to just be able to show up and spaces in ways that we need to show up, in ways that we deem correct and necessary right and authentic to who we are, um, because yeah there’s not much that we can really say or try to go and change. If a white person is going to see us as a monolithic kind of Black culture, then they’re really not going to change from that unless they go, again, they have their own process and journey to where they are starting to recognize that those are beliefs that they hold and they’re trying to move from that. But it’s not likely going to change from you code switching or not.</p><p>Christina Couch: So this is our last question, thank everybody for being here. The questions have been wonderful. And I’m sorry that we can’t get to all of them. So I’m actually going to kind of combine a few questions here. We’ve had a number of questions along the lines of the structure of academia and how that influences systemic racism. Given systemic racism in academia, how might the structure of a Ph.D. degree be changed to be more equitable. I’m going to kind of broaden that out and say the structure of academia in general.</p><p>Mareena Robinson Snowden: So I’ll take a first stab and then Shardé and James, you guys definitely correct me. So I think one of the things that works against equity in the Ph.D. process, specifically, is all of the opaqueness right, and I understand that there is a purpose, at least in theory that the opaqueness serves but when you’re in the system, it feels more like the opaqueness is to serve as kind of a protection for the department more than it is in service of anything to do with the student. So this idea that, you know, the essence of the Ph.D. is creating new knowledge. Right. And the fact that, it’s similar with a tenure track, you don’t know where that bar is. You know it’s up there, but they’re not going to tell you exactly what you have to do in order to get that next promotion, whether it’s the Ph.D. itself or the actual tenure appointment. Right. But in practice, um, because it isn’t very clear about how this process works, you see, particularly students of color, and particularly Black students falling through the cracks, right, for things that don’t have to be justified because the process is so opaque right. So that’s what I meant by students who applied for a Ph.D., but for whatever reason are leaving with the masters. Right. You talk about the qualifying exam process right.</p><p>We have to look at that system. How does that system affect the attrition rate? And then who in that attrition rate is actually leaving? Because, my hypothesis would be that that is also not equitable. Everybody is not leaving at the same rate, right, and you have to look at that over time. So I think, you know, we need to as an institution or as a field, we need to try where possible, to shed some light and try to put some more formal structure on these points of evaluation. Yes, you may not put a five-point bullet list about exactly what it’s going to take to get a Ph.D., but you need to give people something to hold on to so that when there is that problem, which often is for students of color, they have a ground to stand on right. They have a way to challenge the department. And it’s not just “oh, we got in the room and we decided you’re off the island,” which is like what it feels like. And, and when you look at who is getting thrown off the island, more often than not, you know, it disproportionately affects students of color, and particularly American-born students of color, because that is something that we don’t acknowledge right. When not only do we define diversity with respect to gender, but we often point to our international students as the beacon of our diversity, right, ignoring the historical context of racism in America. Right. And why no American students are able to get into our, our organizations in our institution. So we have to look at those those systems.</p><p>Shardé Davis: Yes, yes, yes, yes. And related to that, I think about the hidden curriculum in academia and in terms of ways to make it a bit more equitable is to acknowledge that there’s a hidden curriculum and to find ways, even at a departmental in terms of the programs and colleges, to find ways to communicate to teach curriculum to your, your BIPOC students.</p><p>For example, I think about writing. The English language is white. It’s white American language, right. It’s created by white folks thinking about Black folks, for example, we are a multilingual people. The English language is not, reading and writing in English is not, does not come easy or it’s not easier. How should I put this? Relative to our white counterparts, we very much struggle as a Black people with our, with that language reading and writing because we’re multilingual individual people. And so because of that, academia really needs to recognize that academic writing is A) technical, so therefore, it needs to be taught about just the basics, the mechanics of academic writing. But then also that there are individuals, for example, who have gone through the pre K through 12 educational system who have not been taught, right, the basics of writing. And so there are assumptions that we have about how Ph.D. students are supposed to show up in the program and how they’re supposed to perform, and again, this kind of curriculum that people are assuming that they know or were taught and they may not have been taught.</p><p>Even thinking about the basics of research, right. Even though individuals may have some research experience coming from coming from let’s say their undergraduate or masters institution, they may not have been sat down and talked kind of the ABCs or the one-beats of research and what it looks like. Again, there can be a disadvantage at play for some of our BIPOC students as they’re moving through the program. So I think we have that, we have to recognize that we’re all not starting out at the same level right, and that there is kind of a hidden network where social capital and information is being transferred among particular groups of people in ways that is different from, again our BIPOC students, and to find a way to make sure that they get that information as well.</p><p>James Mickens: Yeah I think that, I think that what both of you just said was really about the importance of mentorship, too. Because, you know, when you talk about the hidden curriculum or the, this sort of implicit set of skills that people are assumed to have, I mean, it’s not just about the hidden curriculum. It’s also about the fact that, you know, oftentimes the rules are used to punish the people, the people in power want to punish, but these rules are oftentimes not, you know, set in stone, you know. Take quals exams, for example. I know you know many schools, you know, if the department likes you, you can fail your quals and “well, we’ll give you another shot.” If the school doesn’t like you, you fail, half the time and “I don’t like your progress, man. You know, you’re a little bit weak there.” And so we all know examples of this.</p><p>And so that’s one place where mentorship is so important because a mentor who knows how the institution works can set your expectations correctly for, like, this is really a rule that you have to follow. Here’s how you really get evaluated. This is really what, for example, the faculty market looks like. This is what they’re looking for in terms of a resume. So I think a lot of these, these, these issues, a lot of them are related to this issue of mentorship and so I think one of the big things that universities could do to improve the outcomes for Black Ph.D. students and Black faculty as well as make sure there are strong mentoring networks in place to explain some of this hidden knowledge that is so critical for actually succeeding, you know. And like talking about, you know, the extra burdens that you know scholars of color have, you know, which committee memberships can you say no to?</p><p>There are actually many of them, you can say no to and there are no bad effects on you. There are some you should not do that for. Which ones? You know, it’s part of this hidden knowledge. So I think the mentorship aspect is really key to making sure that we have Black scholars succeeding in academia.</p><p>Christina Couch: [Silence]</p><p><strong>Seth Mnookin</strong>: Chris, I think you’ve cut out a little bit.</p><p>Christina Couch: Hi. Sorry. That’s Seth Mnookin, our director. Can you hear me now?</p><p>Seth Mnookin: Yes.</p><p>Christina Couch: Great. Okay. One more time then. Thank you all so much for being here. If you would like to see more events like this sign up for our mailing list at <a href="http://commforum.mit.edu/">commforum.mit.edu</a>. There’s a link in the chat. Thank you to Radius at MIT and the MIT Governance Lab for supporting events like this. This was a really delightful thing, so thank all of our panelists for carving out time today to do this. Thank you so much. Have a nice night, everyone.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=96af14c37f5f" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/mit-communications-forum/blackintheivory-academias-role-in-institutional-racism-96af14c37f5f">#BlackInTheIvory: Academia’s Role in Institutional Racism</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/mit-communications-forum">The Communications Forum at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[POSTPONED — Science Under Attack]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/mit-communications-forum/postponed-science-under-attack-201623442b1c?source=rss-83297b59b005------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/201623442b1c</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[mit]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[upcoming-forums]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mit-communications-forum]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[science-under-attack]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[immigration]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[CommForum]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 09 Mar 2020 15:46:01 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-03-09T15:46:01.920Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>POSTPONED — Science Under Attack</h3><p><strong>All Communications Forum events are postponed until Fall, 2020</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1000/1*3xBdAOP3rMEBgKWB7atPdQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>The anti-immigration rhetoric that is dominating American politics has myriad effects on both scientists and students. <strong>Dr. Ahmed Ghoniem</strong>, Director of MIT’s Reacting Gas Dynamics Laboratory, and <strong>Dr. Sam Sinai</strong>, an MIT alum who is the co- founder of Dyno Therapeutics, discuss the challenges of doing research in the current political climate and how U.S. immigration policy is affecting the country’s ability to attract scientific talent. <strong>Ana Campoy</strong>, a senior reporter at <em>Quartz</em>, will moderate.</p><p><strong>All Communications Forum events are postponed until Fall, 2020</strong></p><p><strong>Speakers</strong></p><p><strong>Dr. Ahmed Ghoniem </strong>is the Ronald C. Crane professor of Mechanical Engineering, the director of the Center for 21st Century Energy at MIT, and the director of MIT’s Reacting Gas Dynamics Laboratory. He holds bachelors and masters degrees in Mechanical Engineering from Cairo University in Egypt and a Ph. D. from the University of California, Berkeley. Since 1983, he has been at MIT where he established the Reacting Gas Dynamics Laboratory. He is a fellow of the American Society of Mechanical Engineers and associate fellow of the American Institute of Aeronautics and Astronautics.</p><p><strong>Dr. Sam Sinai </strong>is the co-founder and lead machine learning scientist at Dyno Therapeutics where he builds machine learning and sampling algorithms for efficient protein design. Starting his education at Tehran University of Medical Sciences, Sinai holds bachelors and masters degrees in Electrical Engineering and Computer Science from MIT and a Ph.D. in Evolutionary Biology from Harvard.</p><p><strong>Ana Campoy </strong>is a senior reporter at <em>Quartz</em> who writes about immigration, trade and Latin America for a global business audience. Previously, she was a reporter for <em>The Wall Street Journal</em>, where she covered stories including the Fort Hood shooting in Texas, the first Ebola infection in the U.S. and the rise of Central American immigration. Her collaboration with Puerto Rico’s Center for Investigative Journalism and the AP on deaths caused by Hurricane Maria won the <a href="https://www.ire.org/awards/philip-meyer-awards/2018-philip-meyer-award-winners">Philip Meyer Award</a>, <a href="https://datajournalismawards.org/projects/hurricane-marias-dead/">the Data Journalism Award for Investigation of the Year</a>, and the Javier Valdez Latin American Prize for Investigative Journalism. Campoy also was part of a team of reporters that won a Gerald Loeb Award for a series of stories on BP’s Deepwater Horizon disaster. As a fellow at the Nieman Foundation for Journalism at Harvard, she is currently studying the backlash against globalization and the social and economic policies that can help address it.</p><p><em>All Communications Forum events are free and open to the general public. Seating is given on a first come, first served basis. There are no tickets. This event is co-sponsored by </em><a href="https://radius.mit.edu/home/"><em>Radius at MIT</em></a><em>.</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/524/1*FqjizfmT6mLdHD0nG-_ZRQ.jpeg" /></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=201623442b1c" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/mit-communications-forum/postponed-science-under-attack-201623442b1c">POSTPONED — Science Under Attack</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/mit-communications-forum">The Communications Forum at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[All Communications Forum Events Postponed Until Fall]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/mit-communications-forum/all-communications-forum-events-postponed-until-fall-7b4604b6810a?source=rss-83297b59b005------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/7b4604b6810a</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[upcoming-forums]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[CommForum]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 09 Mar 2020 15:42:52 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-03-09T15:44:53.932Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3><strong>Due to coronavirus, all MIT Communications Forum events are postponed until Fall, 2020. We will continue to update this page as events get rescheduled. Thank you for your patience.</strong></h3><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=7b4604b6810a" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/mit-communications-forum/all-communications-forum-events-postponed-until-fall-7b4604b6810a">All Communications Forum Events Postponed Until Fall</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/mit-communications-forum">The Communications Forum at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Will MIT Lose Our Immigrant Scientists?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@MITCommForum/will-mit-lose-our-immigrant-scientists-6be036d28332?source=rss-83297b59b005------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/6be036d28332</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[immigration]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mit]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[upcoming-forums]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[brain-drain]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[CommForum]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 07 Mar 2020 16:56:16 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-03-09T15:02:20.894Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>POSTPONED — Science Under Attack</h3><p><strong>All Communications Forum events are postponed until Fall, 2020</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1000/1*3xBdAOP3rMEBgKWB7atPdQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>The anti-immigration rhetoric that is dominating American politics has myriad effects on both scientists and students. <strong>Dr. Ahmed Ghoniem</strong>, Director of MIT’s Reacting Gas Dynamics Laboratory, and <strong>Dr. Sam Sinai</strong>, an MIT alum who is the co- founder of Dyno Therapeutics, discuss the challenges of doing research in the current political climate and how U.S. immigration policy is affecting the country’s ability to attract scientific talent. <strong>Ana Campoy</strong>, a senior reporter at <em>Quartz</em>, will moderate.</p><p><strong>All Communications Forum events are postponed until Fall, 2020</strong></p><p><strong>Speakers</strong></p><p><strong>Dr. Ahmed Ghoniem </strong>is the Ronald C. Crane professor of Mechanical Engineering, the director of the Center for 21st Century Energy at MIT, and the director of MIT’s Reacting Gas Dynamics Laboratory. He holds bachelors and masters degrees in Mechanical Engineering from Cairo University in Egypt and a Ph. D. from the University of California, Berkeley. Since 1983, he has been at MIT where he established the Reacting Gas Dynamics Laboratory. He is a fellow of the American Society of Mechanical Engineers and associate fellow of the American Institute of Aeronautics and Astronautics.</p><p><strong>Dr. Sam Sinai </strong>is the co-founder and lead machine learning scientist at Dyno Therapeutics where he builds machine learning and sampling algorithms for efficient protein design. Starting his education at Tehran University of Medical Sciences, Sinai holds bachelors and masters degrees in Electrical Engineering and Computer Science from MIT and a Ph.D. in Evolutionary Biology from Harvard.</p><p><strong>Ana Campoy </strong>is a senior reporter at <em>Quartz</em> who writes about immigration, trade and Latin America for a global business audience. Previously, she was a reporter for <em>The Wall Street Journal</em>, where she covered stories including the Fort Hood shooting in Texas, the first Ebola infection in the U.S. and the rise of Central American immigration. Her collaboration with Puerto Rico’s Center for Investigative Journalism and the AP on deaths caused by Hurricane Maria won the <a href="https://www.ire.org/awards/philip-meyer-awards/2018-philip-meyer-award-winners">Philip Meyer Award</a>, <a href="https://datajournalismawards.org/projects/hurricane-marias-dead/">the Data Journalism Award for Investigation of the Year</a>, and the Javier Valdez Latin American Prize for Investigative Journalism. Campoy also was part of a team of reporters that won a Gerald Loeb Award for a series of stories on BP’s Deepwater Horizon disaster. As a fellow at the Nieman Foundation for Journalism at Harvard, she is currently studying the backlash against globalization and the social and economic policies that can help address it.</p><p><em>All Communications Forum events are free and open to the general public. Seating is given on a first come, first served basis. There are no tickets. This event is co-sponsored by </em><a href="https://radius.mit.edu/home/"><em>Radius at MIT</em></a><em>.</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/524/1*FqjizfmT6mLdHD0nG-_ZRQ.jpeg" /></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=6be036d28332" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Can Journalists Save the Earth?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/mit-communications-forum/can-journalists-save-the-earth-4f1776a8eeb0?source=rss-83297b59b005------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/4f1776a8eeb0</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[past-forums]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mit-communications-forum]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[propublica]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[climate-change]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[new-york-times]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[CommForum]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 26 Sep 2019 17:44:23 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-12-06T19:45:21.859Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Can Journalists Save the Planet?</h3><p><strong>Thursday, November 21, 2019, 6–8pm, </strong><a href="https://whereis.mit.edu/?go=3"><strong>Room 3–270</strong></a><strong>, MIT</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1000/1*i4vRlmjj-J_RnnR6LqVMQg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Lisa Song (left) and Kendra-Pierre Louis</figcaption></figure><p>The Amazon is burning. Coral reefs are dying. Glaciers are melting, and as Earth gets pushed to its brink, journalists who can translate the impact of climate change and hold the powerful accountable are more needed than ever. Climate reporters <strong>Kendra Pierre-Louis</strong> (<em>New York Times</em>) and <strong>Lisa Song</strong> (ProPublica) head to the MIT Communications Forum to discuss the media’s role in illuminating environmental issues, promoting environmental justice and ethics, and the future of climate journalism. <strong>Beth Daley</strong>, Editor and General Manager for <em>The Conversation</em>, will moderate.</p><p><strong>Thursday, November 21, 2019<br>6:00–8:00 pm<br></strong><a href="https://whereis.mit.edu/?go=3"><strong>Room 3–270</strong></a><strong>, MIT<br>Seating for this event is first come, first served</strong></p><p><strong>Speakers</strong></p><p><a href="https://www.nytimes.com/by/kendra-pierre-louis"><strong>Kendra Pierre-Louis</strong></a><strong> </strong>is a Climate Reporter with the<em> New York Times </em>and author of the book, <a href="https://www.amazon.com/Green-Washed-Why-Cant-Planet/dp/193543943X">Green Washed: Why We Can’t Buy Our Way to a Green Planet</a>. Previously she was a staff writer for <em>Popular Science</em> (PopSci) where she wrote about science, the environment, and, occasionally, mayonnaise. Her writing has also appeared in <em>FiveThirtyEight, The Washington Post, Newsweek, Modern Farmer,</em> and <em>Slate</em>.</p><p><a href="https://www.propublica.org/people/lisa-song"><strong>Lisa Song</strong></a><strong> </strong>is an investigative reporter at ProPublica who covers the environment, energy and climate change. She joined ProPublica in 2017 after six years at <em>InsideClimate News</em>, where she covered climate science and environmental health. She was part of the reporting team that <a href="https://insideclimatenews.org/content/Exxon-The-Road-Not-Taken">revealed Exxon’s shift</a> from conducting global warming research to supporting climate denial, a series that was a finalist for the 2016 Pulitzer Prize for public service. From 2013–2014 she reported extensively on <a href="https://insideclimatenews.org/content/fracking-eagle-ford-shale-big-oil-bad-air-texas-praire">air pollution from Texas’ oil and gas boom</a> as part of a collaboration between several newsrooms. Lisa is a co-author of “<a href="https://insideclimatenews.org/content/dilbit-disaster-inside-biggest-oil-spill-youve-never-heard">The Dilbit Disaster</a>,” which won a Pulitzer for national reporting.</p><p><strong>Beth Daley</strong> is Editor and General Manager of <em>The Conversation</em>. She covered the environment, science, and education for almost two decades at <em>The Boston Globe, </em>was an investigative reporter at the New England Center for Investigative Reporting, and head of strategic development at <em>InsideClimate News</em> before coming to <em>The Conversation</em>. Daley was a finalist for the Pulitzer Prize and has won awards from the Association of Health Care Journalists and the Society of American Business Editors and Writers.</p><p><em>All Communications Forum events are free and open to the general public. Seating is given on a first come, first served basis. There are no tickets. This event is co-sponsored by </em><a href="https://radius.mit.edu/home/"><em>Radius at MIT</em></a><em>, the </em><a href="https://sciwrite.mit.edu/"><em>MIT Graduate Program in Science Writing</em></a><em>, </em><a href="https://www.climatecolab.org/page/about"><em>Climate CoLab</em></a><em>, </em><a href="http://wgs.mit.edu/"><em>Women &amp; Gender Studies at MIT</em></a><em>, the </em><a href="https://cgcs.mit.edu/"><em>MIT Center for Global Change Science</em></a><em>, and the </em><a href="https://nieman.harvard.edu/"><em>Nieman Foundation for Journalism at Harvard</em></a><em>.</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/524/1*U_JNS8JWuODh9CsFKvxGYA.jpeg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/205/1*Kp_OiY9CxVwXh2Fmd9L9Og@2x.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/397/1*bVPFWBHPGuUGD6gv_plYXA.jpeg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/309/1*WOpPI8O_D1TZa-GouNhM3g.jpeg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*3q6_Qx8h8R6D5-Bsj6H-7A.jpeg" /></figure><h3><strong>Can Journalists Save the Earth?</strong></h3><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DbgfnURY1bTQ&amp;src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FbgfnURY1bTQ&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/80d1ffad4f0e1f3c2228d4da7557017a/href">https://medium.com/media/80d1ffad4f0e1f3c2228d4da7557017a/href</a></iframe><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fw.soundcloud.com%2Fplayer%2F%3Furl%3Dhttps%253A%252F%252Fapi.soundcloud.com%252Ftracks%252F721639507%26show_artwork%3Dtrue&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fsoundcloud.com%2Fmit-cmsw%2Fcan-journalists-save-the-planet&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi1.sndcdn.com%2Fartworks-000646103272-wb6iuw-t500x500.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=soundcloud" width="800" height="166" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/076915c2f7cfc19b236b8cad23f8e1a0/href">https://medium.com/media/076915c2f7cfc19b236b8cad23f8e1a0/href</a></iframe><p><strong>Summary</strong></p><p>[This is an edited summary, and not a verbatim transcript.]</p><p><strong>Beth Daley</strong>, Editor and General Manager of <em>The Conversation, </em>opened the Forum by asking the panelists about the beat that they cover.</p><p><strong>Lisa Song</strong>, an investigative reporter at ProPublica, said that her job is to write about climate change and the environment. She has the freedom to pursue any story she wants, which she described as “an incredible luxury.” ProPublica stories can take multiple months to report out. The organization seeks to highlight stories that “create impact” and result in changes to the law or a new solution to the problem the story reveals. The organization at large covers everything from immigration to healthcare to education as well as climate and environment.</p><p><strong>Kendra Pierre-Louis</strong>, a Climate Reporter with the<em> New York Times, </em>said that the <em>NYT</em> has climate reporters in New York, where she works, and in Washington DC. The Washington DC reporters generally cover policy issues whereas the New York reporters cover more science stories. She does a mix of daily reporting of new studies that are coming out and longer form pieces that can take weeks or months to report. She covers what she calls the “natural hazard” beat, which includes issues like tornadoes and extreme weather that have a climate link.</p><p>Daley brought the Forum around to Song’s piece on <a href="https://features.propublica.org/brazil-carbon-offsets/inconvenient-truth-carbon-credits-dont-work-deforestation-redd-acre-cambodia/">the efficacy of carbon offsets</a>, which showed that some offset programs are ineffective. Daley asked Song how she got into that story and the challenges.</p><p>Song said that ProPublica does stories on a calendar year schedule. At the end of 2018, she was looking for her next series of stories and became interested in the United Nations climate negotiations that were happening in Poland. Song started hearing about arguments within the negotiations regarding offsets. Specifically, there were allegations of fraud and opacity regarding verifying that emissions reductions were real. A report came out stating that around 85% of emissions reductions from offset programs were suspicious.</p><p>“This had been the biggest experiment with carbon offsets that the world had ever done and it was basically a complete failure,” Song said.</p><p>Within that context, Song became interested in a specific type of offset called a forest preservation offset, which involves a company paying to preserve trees that would have been cut down otherwise (<a href="https://www.propublica.org/article/these-4-arguments-cant-overcome-the-facts-about-carbon-offsets-for-forest-preservation">more information on that is available here</a>). The United Nations had acknowledged that it is difficult to measure how effective forest preservation offsets are, but there was still a big push to try to start forest preservation offset programs on a large scale. At the time, California was weighing whether to vote on a measure that would encourage these types of offsets. Song had seen debates among activists and environmentalists about the issue and it became obvious that California was basing much of their decision on what was happening in the Brazilian state of Acre, a place that had launched significant forest preservation offset programs. Song decided that she needed to go to Brazil, but she had never done international reporting before and she did not speak Portuguese. ProPublica hired a freelance reporter from Brazil to help Song with the story. The pair went to Brazil for two weeks and interviewed government officials who blatantly said that they care more about getting the money from conservation programs than the efficacy of these programs.</p><p>“When you talk to them and you see how bad deforestation is, it’s completely understandable,” Song said. “They have so little money to track illegal loggers and miners, they need anything they can get to keep the trees standing. They’re sort of making a bet that it’s more important to keep some trees standing than to have suspicious carbon offsets.”</p><p>Song said that this value judgment of whether we should keep the Amazon standing even if it means emitting more CO2 than we’re admitting on paper became a central part of her piece. Song said that she found a project in Cambodia that had passed the highest standards in terms of offsets. ProPublica partnered with a satellite analysis firm, which found that more than half of the trees in that Cambodia project had been cut down one decade after the project began despite the fact that the program was still selling offsets. Offset programs rely on people going into the field every few years and filing a report, but reports for this particular project had not been filed for five years and the project couldn’t be canceled for another ten years after that.</p><p>“We were able to tell them before their actual employees that they might want to take a look, something is very wrong,” Song said.</p><p>Daley asked whether Song’s story had an impact on offset legislation in California.</p><p>Song said that California eventually approved legislation to encourage these offsets, but it passed by one vote. Song said that many people within the California state government read the story and it was discussed before the vote.</p><p>“In general, one thing I found is there’s not a lot of researchers or reporters looking intensely at carbon offsets,” Song said. “They always come from a place of good intentions and I think there can be some reluctance to probe that.”</p><p>Song added that many environmental groups support offset programs.</p><p>Daley asked Pierre-Louis about <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2019/10/24/climate/california-wildfires-climate-change.html?rref=collection/byline/kendra-pierre-louis&amp;action=click&amp;contentCollection=undefined&amp;region=stream&amp;module=stream_unit&amp;version=latest&amp;contentPlacement=7&amp;pgtype=collection">a recent piece she wrote about wildfires</a>. The story explores how the world can (and should) adjust to an environment where wildfires are more likely and less controllable. Daley asked how Pierre-Louis conceived that story and the challenges that came with it.</p><p>Pierre-Louis said that the story was assigned to her while the Amazon was burning and people were still recovering from the previous year’s California wildfires. Originally, Pierre-Louis’ editors wanted a piece about how the world is on fire; however, Pierre-Louis pointed out that wildfires are actually decreasing worldwide due to deforestation and the spread of agriculture. Pierre-Louis said that she could definitively say that the Amazon fires were deliberately set and that the burns were contributing to climate change. Climate change is also exacerbating the wildfire cycles in the western United States and the US government’s policy of nationwide fire suppression is making wildfires worse in certain places. Pierre-Louis said that she had been “low key obsessed” with wildfire for a few years and she did not want the story to portray all fires as bad. She wanted to ensure that fire is portrayed as being context-dependent. Helping people understand the nuance of fires was tremendously important to Pierre-Louis. She said that she felt like she had accomplished that when a fire researcher she had interviewed in the past said that her piece was one of the most well-written and accurate pieces he had seen on the subject.</p><p>Daley asked both speakers how much they think of their audiences when writing these types of stories and who they believes their audience is.</p><p>Pierre-Louis said that she assumes that most people don’t want to read a climate change story, even if they accept the science.</p><p>“When you click on a link about climate change, you’re generally not expecting happy news,” she said.</p><p>She said that she goes into every story with that in mind and with the idea that readers are smart, but uninformed. She said that she tries to explain the science in ways that are easy for them to wrap their heads around. The wildfire story only took Pierre-Louis a day and a half to complete, but behind that was two years of studying wildfire science.</p><p>Daley asked who Pierre-Louis imagines her reader is.</p><p>“Somebody who lives in California, someone who’s freaking out about the Amazon, somebody who is thinking about parking a hot car on grass during a drought,” Pierre-Louis joked.</p><p>She said that she’s fortunate to work with an amazing art director who can add evocative imagery to entice readers. She said that she does not have a specific reader in mind when she writes her stories.</p><p>Song said that she is writing for a general audience who knows what climate change is. She does not expect her readers to know the jargon in that area of study. Song said that it’s hard to get readers to read climate stories for fun. For her carbon offset story, she said that the piece got traction in part because of how counterintuitive it was. The purported upsides of carbon offsets — saving trees, supporting local communities, doing something good for the Earth — give readers hope, but poking holes in that narrative “can sometimes feel not great,” she said. She added that the story also got traction because it came out as California was about to make an important decision regarding supporting offsets. She was told by residents in California that the story was read by many people who were involved in that legislative decision.</p><p>Daley said that language matters in this sphere. She mentioned that this past September, The Guardian began calling the state of the environment a “climate crisis.” She asked how the speakers choose what language they use, what language their organizations allow, and how they balance conveying the urgency of the issue with keeping readers informed about the nuance of the situation.</p><p>Song said that she ProPublica does not have hard and fast rules on language. She tends to use the term climate change because it’s widely recognizable and accurate. She has used the term “climate crisis,” but only in the context of explaining that we are now in an era where in the past couple years, the public has increasingly considered climate change to be an urgent issue. ProPublica does not have blanket rules on what terms to use.</p><p>Pierre-Louis said that the <em>New York Times</em>’ style guide is extensive and they do not use the phrase “climate crisis.” She recently did <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2019/11/13/climate/climate-change-child-health.html">a story on how climate change will make future generations sick</a>. Many other reporters covered the study the story was based on, but Pierre-Louis’ piece did not discuss the impacts in a very scientific way. For example, the study stated that there will be more small particulate pollution as global warming continues. Pierre-Louis asked one expert why children are more susceptible to small particulate pollution and she learned that children’s hearts beat faster and they breathe faster, so they inhale more pollution.</p><p>“Anyone who has ever held a child, you can immediately kind of feel it, which is why I felt it was important, which is why I put it in the piece,” Pierre-Louis said, adding that she felt that those sorts of choices were why her piece had more emotional impact and resonated with readers.</p><p>Pierre-Louis said that this research was happening as the youth climate marches were going on. One of the activists had given congressional testimony and said everyone who came up to her after the testimony and said that she has a bright future was lying because she was committed to a planet that is dying. Pierre-Louis ended the piece with this activist quote, which added a more human angle to the story.</p><p>“I think the problem with phrases like ‘climate crisis’ or ‘climate emergency’ is that you run the risk of them just becoming another thing people say,” Pierre-Louis said. “We have the War on Terrorism. We have the War on Cancer. We have all of these languages, but we haven’t actually solved those problems. Naming things appropriately matters, but it can become too easy, the words become decoupled from the problem.”</p><p>Daley asked how the speakers continue to cover climate change when readers don’t want to read them.</p><p>Song said that she finds stories that are relatable, which is why she went after the offsets story and why they did on-the-ground reporting for it. Offsets are something that many people understand and are familiar with already. Song said that she got a lot of feedback from readers who had bought offsets and were wondering where their money went. Song flew many miles to report on the story and felt at a loss when she realized that she could not by offsets and feel better about the carbon footprint she took on during the reporting process. She hopes to do a story in the future on the best offset projects currently available.</p><p>Daley said that Pierre-Louis had recently written about <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2019/climate/sustainable-clothing.html">how to buy clothing that will last</a>. She asked Pierre-Louis to speak on the solutions angle of covering climate change.</p><p>Pierre-Louis said that the <em>NYT</em> runs a regular column that gives readers a tip on one thing they can do to reduce climate change. Many readers had asked about what they could do in terms of buying clothes, so she wrote the story to find answers. While reporting the piece, she found that many brands advertise that they are eco-friendly, but they often don’t have much transparency about what that means. Patagonia continually comes up as a brand that is genuinely working to limit their carbon footprint, but even the brand recognizes the limits of their accomplishments. The one thing that we know is that consumers can reduce their footprint by buying fewer clothes and by buying clothes that last. The <em>NYT</em> hired a fashion photographer to visualize each of the tips featured in the article and the story included its own Instagram account. Pierre-Louis featured women of color who are working within the slow fashion movement. The tips featured in the story work regardless of price point. All of these things were conscious choices made in order broaden the article’s readership.</p><p>Daley brought the conversation around to environmental justice. She said that she has had difficulty writing about environmental justice and that she has heard the same from other climate reporters. She asked the speakers if they feel the same way and how they approach those types of stories.</p><p>Song said that environmental justice is often one step removed from a pure climate story, but other times it fits in really well and is an angle that needs to be told. For the carbon offsets story, environmental justice plays a central part since one of the appealing aspects of offsets is that they purportedly support needy communities within the global south. In reality, the global north needs to simply be more generous in terms of supporting needy communities within the global south, but that’s not how things currently work. As of now, needy communities financially benefit more from agriculture and from deforestation than from taking conservation dollars. How environmental justice fits into a climate piece largely depends on the central story a reporter is trying to tell.</p><p>Pierre-Louis said that she has done a few strictly environmental justice stories, including <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2018/04/03/climate/mlk-segregation-pollution.html">this piece</a> on how environmental disparities tie in with segregation. Because of the success of that story, Al Gore’s representatives reached out and invited Pierre-Louis to come cover a meeting Gore was having with Reverend Dr. William J. Barber, a minister and activist whose work focuses on issues of poverty, racism, and environmental justice. Pierre-Louis went, toured a community that had been impacted by coal ash, and interviewed victims who had been impacted by the pollution. She called the energy company the victims were blaming.</p><p>“It was the first time I had ever had a straight adversarial interview,” Pierre-Louis said. “It literally ended with the [public relations] person screaming at me and then I hung up the phone very shaken and then the PR person emailed my boss. That was a new experience for me.”</p><p>(<a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2018/08/24/climate/coal-ash-pollution-poverty.html">You can read Pierre-Louis’ piece here</a>.)</p><p>Pierre-Louis also did <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2019/10/21/climate/hawaii-coral-bleaching.html">a story about coral bleaching in Hawaii</a>. When possible, she tries to link stories back to the people who are most impacted. She asked one researcher if they could put her in touch with someone in Hawaii who is directly affected by the bleaching. The researcher connected her with a person who lives in one of the last traditional Hawaiian villages on that particular island.</p><p>“That’s the other way that I think that ecojustice play out,” she said. “There’s a thread in ecojustice movements, which is communities speak for themselves…as a reporter that’s a really valuable thing. Let people speak for themselves.”</p><p>Pierre-Louis said that it’s not always easy to include community voices, but it is necessary.</p><p>Daley said that including community members in the story often isn’t done in journalism. It can change the dynamic of a piece and can make it much richer, but it takes effort and thought. She pointed out that both Pierre-Louis and Song have the luxury of resources and frequently time.</p><p>Pierre-Louis added that two different times she has showed up to report a story and did not realize that there were significant Native American populations that she was previously unaware of. Sources often forget about community members. Pierre-Louis frequently asks sources if they can point her to a source of color or a female source. Having diverse voices is crucial.</p><p>Before opening up the Forum to audience questions, Daley asked how both speakers what angles often aren’t covered in climate journalism.</p><p>Pierre-Louis said that drought often isn’t covered because it’s not visually appealing to shoot and it’s difficult to talk about. Journalists can fall into a trap of saying that drought in a specific area is going to be devastating and then being wrong. One example of that is <a href="https://www.citylab.com/environment/2019/04/cape-town-water-conservation-south-africa-drought/587011/">the coverage of Cape Town’s water crisis</a>.</p><p>Song said that she would love to see more solutions climate journalism that focuses on programs that are working and whether anyone is working to scale those initiatives up. For example, when Song was reporting on the impacts of Hurricane Harvey in Houston, she kept hearing that one of the most successful relocation stories was a town in Illinois called Valmeyer that <a href="https://news.stlpublicradio.org/post/after-great-flood-93-valmeyer-ill-retreated-bluffs-and-found-its-future">was forced to relocate after a flood in 1993</a>. Song called the former mayor of Valmeyer and realized that the town only had a few hundred people.</p><p>“This wonderful success story, which everyone knows about is completely not applicable to the disaster you’re seeing in Houston yet everyone talks about it like we should follow their example,” Song said. “I’m thinking who is actually going to make this work?”</p><p>ProPublica did a story about how backed up Houston’s relocation system was despite that city having the most sophisticated system of its kind. The demand for people who wanted funds to relocate far outpaced the funds they had.</p><p>Daley opened the panel up to audience questions. <strong>An audience member</strong> said that within the past year, there’s been a sharp increase in climate awareness. She asked what benefits and challenges that poses for climate reporters.</p><p>Pierre-Louis said that the benefit is that “people are paying attention.” Print and new media have devoted substantial resources to conveying the magnitude of climate impacts. She said that that’s less true of television news. She said that readers often overestimate the reach of print publications, which often pale in comparison to the millions of viewers who tune into cable news every night. Pierre-Louis also said that she notices that there’s a lot of miscommunication around climate change. The beat has brought in a number of new reporters who are not as familiar with the science as seasoned veterans on the beat. One example was a story that blew up on social media around a small fire that many linked to climate change, though in reality, the fire was not an indication of extreme weather or exacerbating environmental conditions.</p><p>“That drives me nuts because I often feel like you only get one shot and so once people have the wrong idea in their head, it’s really hard to change their minds,” she said.</p><p><strong>An audience member</strong> asked about the resurgence of the climate justice movement. Previously, people believed that science literacy was the solution to climate denialism, but it’s become clear that power literacy — understanding the political and fossil fuel economy — is also crucial. She also asked if their reporting would change if they knew that their audiences were primarily made up of activists.</p><p>Song said that if her primary audience was activist, the biggest change she would make is allowing more jargon to enter her pieces. On the issue of power imbalance, Song said that the idea that the environmental movement is a monolith is false. Often there’s a big split between large, well-funded organizations and smaller, environmental justice groups that are often run by people of color. Song <a href="https://www.propublica.org/article/cap-and-trade-is-supposed-to-solve-climate-change-but-oil-and-gas-company-emissions-are-up">just did a story on cap and trade in California </a>and these two groups were on the polar opposite sides of that issue.</p><p>“You end up finding justice elements that you may not necessarily think of because you also have to think of economic injustice including from people who don’t see themselves as climate activists,” she said.</p><p>While reporting the cap and trade story, Song discovered that there were a lot of flaws in California’s system. During a public regulatory hearing on the issue, groups of minority residents spoke up about how changes to cap and trade could have an economic impact by driving fuel prices up. Song heard a rumor that these residents were somehow being managed by oil and gas interests. Song said that the rumor struck her as strange, so she decided to investigate. She watched a video of the hearings and noticed that a block of Black pastors spoke against the cap and trade changes. She contacted several of them and learned that they were approached by a consulting firm and flown out to Sacramento so they could speak about their economic concerns. Through lobbying records, Song found that the consulting firm was paid by a nonprofit that was funded primarily by oil and gas companies. The pastors, who had a history of advocating against oil and gas drilling in their own neighborhoods, did not know that their trip was funded by oil and gas interests. When Song informed them, they were saddened and shocked.</p><p>“It was a total shock to them that they had been funded by interests that were opposite of what they normally supported,” Song said. “Drilling down to those kinds of power dynamics and revealing them is just a really important thing for all the stories.”</p><p><strong>An audience member</strong> from Germany noted the differences in climate awareness and reporting between Europe and the United States. He asked about the challenges of reporting about climate change to a US audience.</p><p>Pierre-Louis said that one of the biggest differences is that the US has a sustained climate denialist movement, though they’re a clear minority. The overwhelming majority of Americans accept climate science. She pointed to <a href="https://www.merchantsofdoubt.org/">Naomi Oreskes’ work</a> to highlight how oil and gas have facilitated disinformation campaigns throughout the US, Canada, the UK, and Australia. There’s been a large media shift to report from the perspective that climate change is real. Part of the reason why there’s a sustained denialist movement in those four countries is due to private fossil fuel companies having large toeholds in those countries, those nations all have English as the national language, and they all have frontierism mentalities. It’s also worth nothing that climate denialists are in positions of power, which presents an extra challenge to the media. When someone in political power denies climate change, the media has an obligation to report that.</p><p><strong>An audience member </strong>who publishes a newsletter on energy said that he started buying bundles of trees from Heifer International, which has acted as a sort of makeshift carbon offset even though they are not marketed that way. He has asked sci-fi writers to envision positive futures and they have been unable to, but solutions do exist. He asked the panelists how to overcome this lack of imagination about solutions.</p><p>Pierre-Louis pointed to the book <a href="https://www.press.uchicago.edu/ucp/books/book/chicago/G/bo22265507.html"><em>The Great Derangement</em></a>, which touches on how there aren’t a lot of positive futures featured in fiction. Pierre-Louis said that the best example of a positive future she could think of is <em>Black Panther</em>. The city center doesn’t have suburbs or paved roads, and it has an energy solution.</p><p>Daley brought attention to the <a href="https://www.solutionsjournalism.org/">Solutions Journalism Network</a>, a group dedicated to writing about solutions with the same rigor that journalists approach investigative pieces. She asked Song if she considers it to be her job to provide solutions and how does she balance that against the need to report on the news?</p><p>Song said that ProPublica reporters will often spend a year writing about a specific problem and then provide a few solutions at the end of the year. She said that solutions pieces are the not the core of ProPublica, but the group has created user guides on what readers can do to solve problems like preventing maternal mortality and how to avoid getting surprise bills when you’re admitted to a hospital. Song said that those practical guides are important, but she has not had the opportunity to do one thus far. She said that daily and news publications often provide better consumer-oriented advice. For climate change, oftentimes the best thing an individual can do is vote, particularly on a local level.</p><p>Pierre-Louis mentioned the <em>Boston Globe</em>’s <a href="https://apps.bostonglobe.com/metro/investigations/spotlight/2019/11/19/seeing-red/boston-traffic-stuck-politics/?new">recent investigative story on traffic congestion</a> in Boston. We know, for example, that more roads and wider roads leads to more traffic, but the US keeps investing in roads rather than alternative means. Oftentimes, we know the solution but there is not political will to enact it. Mass investment in mass transit is the only thing that reduces traffic, “but we don’t do that in this country,” she said.</p><p>“That’s the other tension with solution stories,” Pierre-Louis added. “Sometimes the solutions are just so obvious and everybody knows what they are, but there’s no movement on them, often for value and socio-political reasons as opposed to for technical reasons.”</p><p><strong>An audience member</strong> who works for <a href="https://www.loe.org/"><em>Living on Earth</em></a> radio, where Lisa Song once interned, asked to what extent covering things like the UNFCCC conferences of the parties climate meetings is important to their audiences and how they go about drawing out the most important parts of that type of high-level diplomacy.</p><p>“I’m going to be honest and say that it’s really boring to go and cover those conferences,” Song said. Unfortunately, oftentimes there isn’t a lot of movement after those conferences. Song covered some of the UN Climate Action Summit events in New York and she came away thinking that nobody is really talking about reducing the use of fossil fuels, which is the most important thing we need to do. There was more discussion of carbon trading and offsets.</p><p>“I complained about it enough that my editor said, ‘Why don’t you just write that story?,’” she said.</p><p>Song wrote <a href="https://www.salon.com/2019/10/05/the-word-nobody-wanted-to-say-at-the-un-climate-action-summit_partner/">a smaller story that focused heavily on one unique slice of those meetings</a> rather than covering it holistically. Pierre-Louis said that she generally does not cover conferences.</p><p><strong>An audience member</strong> asked if the panelists had any advice for scientists and engineers on how to communicate their work to journalists.</p><p>Pierre-Louis said that if your work is very technical, it helps to have an analogy to capture the work. If a scientist is speaking to multiple journalists, have a couple of analogies prepared. Thinking about why the work is important can help journalists as well. When Pierre-Louis worked at <em>Popular Science</em>, she covered the Golden Goose award, a prize given to researchers whose seemingly obscure work has led to significant breakthroughs. Pierre-Louis <a href="https://www.popsci.com/golden-goose-awards-2017/">profiled</a> the scientist who discovered parasitic chytrids in frogs and found that the researcher had an amazing story about quitting science to become a stay-at-home mom, then getting reeled back in later in life and fighting for a position in science. That piece would have been much less rich if the researcher had not opened up to Pierre-Louis. She advocated that scientists not be afraid of opening up personally to journalists.</p><p>Song said that if a scientist has particularly technical research, they should think about how they would explain that work to “their drunk uncle.” She added that there are trainings available to help scientists better communicate with the media. Those events can also provide an overview of journalistic practices and how reporting works.</p><p>Daley said that she used to teach science communication to postdocs. She said that <a href="https://theconversation.com/us"><em>The Conversation</em></a>, where she serves as Editor and General Manager, helps scientists translate their research into public interest journalism that then goes out over the wire.</p><p><strong>An audience member named Betty</strong> asked the panelists if they know of <a href="https://www.yesmagazine.org/"><em>YES! Magazine</em></a>, which focuses on grassroots solutions journalism. She also mentioned publications from The Nature Conservancy and Sierra Club as examples of publications that are producing positive stories. She asked how Song and Pierre-Louis felt about those publications.</p><p>Song said that she reads a lot of climate stories. She normally starts her day by reading a roundup of climate stories from the day before. She reads solutions pieces, but that tends not to be the focus of her particular work.</p><p>Pierre-Louis agreed and said that she also reads <em>Audubon</em>. Pierre-Louis said that she mostly reports on emerging studies, but there aren’t that many positive climate change studies.</p><p><strong>Conor Gearin</strong>, digital and social media specialist at the Whitehead Institute, brought the conversation back to language. Last year during the California fires, Trump began using the phrase “forest management,” which is code for logging. He asked the speakers how they deal with these kinds of Trojan Horse phrases.</p><p>Pierre-Louis said that she tries not to repeat political talking points in general. She said that she tries to avoid phrases like “forest fires,” because many of these fires don’t actually happen in forests.</p><p>Song said that she couldn’t think of any political phrases off the top of her head, but that she does try to avoid jargon in general. For example, instead of using “allowances” with reference to cap and trade, they just use the word permit. If a particular word is generally used in a jargon context in a way that is not commonly understood by average readers, ProPublica reporters try to find an alternative phrase.</p><p>Pierre-Louis said that she tries to avoid the phrase “natural disaster” because a disaster is a hazard that meets a human population.</p><p>“I think that the problem with a natural disaster is it ignores the fact that oftentimes there are systems and processes that put people into harm’s way so it makes it seem inevitable and that’s not true,” she said.</p><p><strong>An environmental journalist from Brazil</strong> said that the climate disinformation campaign went far beyond the four countries that Pierre-Louis mentioned and that it had large implications, especially in developing markets. In Brazil, the government is currently producing a disinformation campaign, especially with regards to fires. The forestation index have proved that the fires in Brazil that happened in August of 2019 are directly connected with deforestation. Brazilian politicians are saying that these fires are natural, but that’s not true.</p><p>Pierre-Louis said that in her story, she wrote that when indigenous people set fires, they do so in a different manner. She said that the did not mean to underestimate the massive political impediments that prevent Amazon conservation.</p><p>The audience member asked her if she felt that journalists are spending too much time discussing climate vocabulary. It is a huge crisis. Journalists have to say what is happening. Instead of talking about vocabulary, journalists should focus on making their work more personal.</p><p>“I think they go together,” Pierre-Louis said. Because she can’t say climate crisis, she is forced to link what’s happening back to communities and let that tell the story, “as opposed to saying we’re all going to die,” she said.</p><p>Daley said that people perceive the risk of climate change wildly differently. She asked the speakers how they think about this.</p><p>Pierre-Louis said that she is most concerned that some people think that they can opt out of the climate crisis. Many believe that climate change is something that’s happening to people far away. Pierre-Louis said that she received an email from someone in California once who said that they didn’t live on the coast and therefore shouldn’t have to care about climate change.</p><p>“I joked for a while that I had a ‘no sea level rise and no coral reefs’ rule,” she said. “Because they’re so visual and it’s so easy, you can go to Louisiana and you can see the areas that are flooding. You can go to Virginia and you can see the areas that are flooding. It becomes an easy crutch to use that as a narrative…The risk that we run into is the people who are going to be horrifically affected in really severe ways don’t know it. Unfortunately, it’s not visual enough.”</p><p>Pierre-Louis <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2018/05/04/climate/bears-not-hibernating.html">wrote a story</a> about how climate change has delayed bear hibernation cycles. That’s one example of an unexpected impact of climate change that affects people and communities.</p><p><strong>Another audience member</strong> who works at <em>Living on Earth</em> said that he often thinks about bias in environmental journalism. It is hard to balance advocacy versus objectivity. He asked the speakers what their perspectives are on balancing these two things and if they consider their respective publications are known for having political bias.</p><p>“I don’t think it’s biased to say the planet should be livable,” Song said. If covering climate change in and of itself counts as bias, that’s a problem. ProPublica starts from the baseline assumption that climate change is real and a serious problem. They also have a “no surprises” rule, which means that every person that will be quoted and mentioned in a story is contacted for a fact check prior to publication. Doing that due diligence helps sources and readers better understand ProPublica’s approach and dedication to accuracy.</p><p>Daley said that it’s known that the media has a liberal bias. She asked Pierre-Louis how she deals with that.</p><p>Pierre-Louis said that neutrality is often viewed as whatever fits within a white male gaze and there is currently a good bit of pushback against that. She mentioned a paper called “<a href="https://www2.psych.ubc.ca/~henrich/pdfs/WeirdPeople.pdf">The Weirdest People in the World?</a>”, which addresses what is considered universal in the field of psychology. Pierre-Louis operates from the perspective that we are all biased. Bias mostly emerges in the stories that a reporter chooses to report she said.</p><p>“I’m constantly consumed with the stories that I’m not telling,” she said. She focuses much more of her attention there over focusing on whether a reader is going to accuse her of political bias.</p><p>Song said that because climate change has become so politicized, oftentimes different standards apply to what people perceive as bias.</p><p>“If you’re an education journalist, it’s pretty much taken for granted that your position is children should have a good education in their school and have adequate resources and not be abused by the staff or the teachers,” she said. “Having that assumption does not make you biased.”</p><p>If we can accept basic truths as not being biased in other beats, there’s no reason that it shouldn’t apply to climate reporters.</p><p>“One of my perpetual frustrations is when you’re watching the debates and there’s some TV reporter interviewing a candidate that is talking about their economic platform, the person interviewing them is a millionaire,” Pierre-Louis said. “That is a bias. They do not have the same economic interests as the vast majority of Americans, but that is somehow fine.”</p><p>If you are a woman or a person of color, it’s implied that you are somehow biased in many forms of journalism, she added.</p><p><strong>An audience member </strong>asked the speakers about what impact they hope their work will have.</p><p>Song said that it can be particularly hard to move the needle on climate change because the topic is so politicized. She said that what has happened in the past couple of years in terms of an increase in public awareness, anger, and urgency has given her hope. Attempts to hold fossil fuel companies accountable have also increased. Ultimately, we are going to need “huge systemic changes” to solve climate changes, which aren’t going to happen through small personal actions.</p><p>Pierre-Louis said that she often thinks about informed consent. We are currently make decisions about the fate of the planet, but we’re often doing it passively. She said that she views helping people making a clear-eyed decision as part of her job.</p><p><strong>An audience member</strong> asked Song about her impressions about where fossil fuel companies stand in terms of accepting responsibility and bolstering solutions.</p><p>Song said that there has been a lot of reporting on exactly how long fossil fuel companies have understood their impacts on climate change. The history of what those companies knew is becoming more clear and there is currently increasing accountability from the public to get these companies to change their business models. Song cited a recent story<em> </em>that tackled what percentage of funding oil and gas companies are spending on clean energy alternatives. Even as companies increase their amount of spending, those funds are still a very small percentage of their overall spending and reflect how little these companies are willing to invest in fossil fuel reduction. People are paying more attention and trying to hold these companies accountable in new ways.</p><p><strong>Phil McKenna</strong>, a reporter at <em>InsideClimate News, </em>asked Song how she keeps momentum when she’s reporting on a single story for several months to one year. He asked Pierre-Louis how she balances short reporting and longer pieces.</p><p>Song said that she frequently checks in with her editor, which helps her stay on track. She also writes summaries, memos, and outlines during the reporting process to ensure that the story is shaping up in a way that makes the time investment worth it.</p><p>“I kind of feel like I’m a chaos monkey,” Pierre-Louis said. “…I basically wait for there to stop being fires or a lull in scientific research and then I hide and squirrel away on the thing I’ve been working on for a longer period of time and then something inevitably pops up and I have to shove it in a dark corner.”</p><p>Daley closed the Forum and thanked the speakers.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=4f1776a8eeb0" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/mit-communications-forum/can-journalists-save-the-earth-4f1776a8eeb0">Can Journalists Save the Earth?</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/mit-communications-forum">The Communications Forum at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Digital Anxieties: A Conversation with Bo Burnham and Jonny Sun]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/mit-communications-forum/digital-anxieties-a-conversation-with-bo-burnham-and-jonny-sun-1287cd03a38f?source=rss-83297b59b005------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/1287cd03a38f</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[jonny-sun]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mit-communications-forum]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[bo-burnham]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[comedy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[past-forums]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[CommForum]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 05 Sep 2019 19:39:21 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-10-11T20:25:07.923Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>Friday, September 27, 2019, 6–8pm, </strong><a href="https://whereis.mit.edu/?go=26"><strong>Room 26–100</strong></a><strong>, MIT</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1000/1*VjN9PjAXS2UiKB6ejlpgig.jpeg" /></figure><p><strong>Bo Burnham</strong> and <strong>Jonny Sun</strong> know that social media can save lives, and it can ruin them. Launching his career in 2006 after comedy videos he filmed in his childhood bedroom went viral on YouTube, Burnham became a nationally headlining comic and writer while growing up in the social media spotlight. Jonny Sun, a screen and TV writer, author, and MIT Ph.D. candidate who has over 500,000 social media followers, has also weathered the benefits and burdens digital fame brings. <em>Eighth Grade</em>, Burnham’s directorial debut feature film, and Sun’s TED Talk both tackle social media’s impact on mental health and the virtues of being vulnerable. Burnham and Sun head to MIT to discuss the hyperconnected love and loneliness of the Internet and staying healthy in the digital age. <strong>Rosalind Picard</strong>, founder and director of the MIT Affective Computing Research Group, will open the event. A free screening of <em>Eighth Grad</em>e will follow.</p><p><strong>Friday, September 27, 2019<br>6:00–8:00 pm<br></strong><a href="https://whereis.mit.edu/?go=26"><strong>Room 26–100</strong></a><strong>, MIT<br>Seating for this event is first come, first served. A free screening of <em>Eighth Grade </em>begins at 8:15pm.</strong></p><p><strong>Speakers</strong></p><p><strong>Bo Burnham</strong> is a comedian, actor, and director whose viral comedy videos have more than 250 million views. He has produced three full-length comedy albums, three stand-up specials, and co-created and starred in the MTV series <em>Zach Stone Is Gonna Be Famous</em>. <em>Eighth Grade</em>, his first feature film as a writer and director, won the Writers Guild of America Award for Original Screenplay, the Directors Guild of America Award for Outstanding Directing on a First-Time Feature Film, and the Independent Spirit Award for Best First Screenplay.</p><p><strong>Jonny Sun</strong> (stylized as “jomny sun”) is the author and illustrator of <em>everyone’s a aliebn when ur a aliebn too </em>(HarperPerennial, 2017) and the illustrator of <em>Gmorning, Gnight!</em> by Lin-Manuel Miranda (Penguin Random House, 2018). He is currently a writer for the animated series <em>BoJack Horseman</em>. His comedic work has appeared in <em>The New Yorker, TIME Magazine, BuzzFeed, Playboy, GQ,</em> and <em>McSweeney’s</em>.</p><p><a href="http://web.media.mit.edu/~picard/"><strong>Rosalind Picard</strong></a> is founder and director of the Affective Computing Research Group at MIT, co-director of the Media Lab’s Advancing Wellbeing Initiative, and faculty chair of MIT’s MindHandHeart Initiative. She co-founded the technology companies Empatica, Inc., which creates wearable sensors and analytics to improve health, and Affectiva, Inc., which delivers technology to help measure and communicate emotion.</p><p><em>All Communications Forum events are free and open to the general public. Seating is given on a first come, first served basis. There are no tickets. This event is co-sponsored by </em><a href="https://mindhandheart.mit.edu/"><em>MindHandHeart at MIT</em></a><em>, </em><a href="https://shass.mit.edu/resources/internal/deflorez"><em>de Florez Fund for Humor</em></a><em>, </em><a href="http://wgs.mit.edu/"><em>Women &amp; Gender Studies at MIT</em></a><em>, </em><a href="https://arts.mit.edu/camit/"><em>Council for the Arts at MIT (CAMIT)</em></a><em>, the MIT </em><a href="https://oge.mit.edu/"><em>Office of Graduate Education</em></a><em>, the MIT Large Event Fund, </em><a href="http://activeminds.mit.edu/"><em>Active Minds at MIT</em></a><em>, </em><a href="https://www.fail-sharing.org/"><em>FAIL!</em></a><em>, </em><a href="http://savetfp.mit.edu/"><em>SaveTFP</em></a><em>, the </em><a href="http://bakerfoundation.mit.edu/"><em>Baker Foundation</em></a><em>, </em><a href="http://lsc.mit.edu/"><em>the MIT Lecture Series Committee</em></a><em>, and the </em><a href="https://studentlife.mit.edu/impact-opportunities/diversity-inclusion/womenmit/margaret-cheney-room"><em>Margaret Cheney Room</em></a><em> / </em><a href="https://studentlife.mit.edu/impact-opportunities/diversity-inclusion/womenmit"><em>Women@MIT</em></a><em>.</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*aSHlF47oimKn4-PXde2lJg.png" /><figcaption>Rosalind Picard (left), Jonny Sun (center) and Bo Burnham, photo credit: Sarah Schwartz</figcaption></figure><p>Though we did not have permission to video record for this event, we got some great photos and a few people wrote about their experiences. Check them out below. We’ve also included some of our photos from the event.</p><p><a href="https://mitadmissions.org/blogs/entry/digital-anxieties-a-conversation-with-bo-burnham-and-jonny-sun/">From the MIT Admissions Blog</a>:</p><p><strong>Digital Anxieties: A Conversation with Bo Burnham and Jonny Sun</strong></p><p><a href="https://mitadmissions.org/blogs/author/camim/"><strong>by Cami M. ‘23</strong></a></p><p><strong>i cried for ten minutes after watching eighth grade. </strong>I have so many things and so little space, but I’ll try my best to communicate it.</p><p>I just walked out of an event called “Digital Anxieties: A Conversation with <a href="https://www.boburnham.com/">Bo Burnham</a> and <a href="https://www.jomnysun.com/">Jonny Sun</a>” and I shit you not when I say it’s probably one of the most influential and life-changing talks I’ve ever sat on.</p><p>As a long-time fan of Bo Burnham, it was absolutely surreal to see him in person. I don’t remember exactly how I stumbled upon him, but I just have strong memories of 7th-grade-Cami curling up on the couch, watching <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ejc5zic4q2A">“what.”</a> for the fifth time in a row. By that point, I had already memorized all the bits and just recited them along. There was something about the crassness of his jokes, paired with his funny, charming, awkward and, most important of all, genuine stage presence that immediately hooked me. I continued to follow all of his stuff after that. I was a bit too shy to go up after the talk to say hi, and I’m sure a small part of myself will always regret that, but regardless, the feeling is still the same. I am utterly in awe of everything he does.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/376/1*HkHDkyx9uq4-zcjlH3xqJg.png" /><figcaption>MIT Communications Forum photo, credit: Sarah Schwartz</figcaption></figure><p>When I read Jonny Sun’s name, nothing quite clicked immediately. After a quick Google search, I was almost vibrating with anticipation for the event, to hear everything he had to say. Jonny is a PhD candidate at MIT and a writer for Bojack Horseman. Bojack Horseman quite literally changed my life. I was in a really dark place when I found the show and I binged what was available on Netflix (seasons 1–4, at the time of my discovery) in about 3 weeks. It made me laugh, made me cry, made me stare at the ceiling at 3am and question my sense of self as a whole, question what impact I wanted to leave on the world. In short: it played a large role in who I am today, and it’s very bittersweet to see it in its final season. I <em>also</em> was too shy to go up to say hi to Jonny and also really needed to pee and by the time I got back the movie had already started. Sorry, Jonny.</p><p>Essentially, the entire talk was just a weird nostalgia trip for me.</p><p>I’m even surprised I’m managing to type this right now because it still doesn’t feel <em>real</em>. But, luckily, I was able to jot down some notes of things discussed and said.</p><p>We had the amazing privilege to submit questions that they could directly answer and discuss, and though my questions weren’t asked, I wrote down some of the questions and answers that really resonated with me and provided a lot of guidance. I’m just gonna list these nuggets of wisdom because I think it’s stuff that everyone needs to hear.</p><p><em>Please note a lot of this is paraphrased, seeing as inner seventh grade Cami was just sobbing uncontrollably and couldn’t focus on typing down coherent and cohesive notes. They are also just snippets of their responses and aren’t everything that they said.</em></p><h3>What do you think it truly means to matter?</h3><blockquote><em>Bo: You might not matter…I got to matter in the spectacular way I wanted to and it wasn’t fulfilling.</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>Jonny: I think a while ago I tweeted something like “the truth is we all achieve greatness. the only difference is the size of our audiences”</em></blockquote><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*__Wmv4NIA84YlsVQJqBNmQ.png" /><figcaption>MIT Communications Forum photo, credit: Sarah Schwartz</figcaption></figure><p>This question got a lot of chuckles, especially after the whole “you might not matter” part and it was strongly reminiscent of that one cheesy scene in The Fault in Our Stars, where Augustus Waters’ greatest fear is not being remembered and then Hazel Grace shits all over that and says that everyone’s going to forget him because in the grand scheme of things he’s nothing and he’s a no one. So it doesn’t matter if he doesn’t matter to everyone because what’s important is that he matters to the people that count. And essentially, that was the Jonny’s conclusion, where at the end of the day all those cliches are, in Bo’s words, “like diamonds — deeply true, true things that have formed from being so true for so long.”</p><p>Cliches like “Live, laugh, love!” or “Family first!” that’ve become so trite to us <em>do </em>hold truth. And while maybe we won’t matter to everyone, what matters is that we matter to the people we matter.⁠<a href="https://mitadmissions.org/blogs/entry/digital-anxieties-a-conversation-with-bo-burnham-and-jonny-sun/#annotation-1">01</a></p><blockquote><em>Bo: Young people live in a post-narrative dissociative world…by the time you get to your first kiss, you’ve watched so many first kisses in movies that you think “This is that part of the movie” and it didn’t feel like that at all. The movie of my life sucks. And we all just want to be watchable. We’re nostalgic for moments that haven’t even happened yet. You’re not a picture of yourself. Your life is not a movie.</em></blockquote><p>I think this topic was talked about for a while and it was something that hit me really, <em>really</em> hard, because I’ve been living my life for this so long. Even now, getting to college, when we’re sitting at an iHop at 2 in the morning I think to myself, “Wow, this is like in those teen movies when…” and I’m living my life in hopes that it’ll be a movie instead of actually living my life like it’s <em>mine</em>.</p><h3>Is there any relief from imposter syndrome?/Do you think it’s good to talk about mental illness openly?/How do you personally take care of yourself?/What self-care things do you do to calm your anxiety?</h3><blockquote><em>Bo: We grow up believing two things — “Everyone goes through this at some point” and “I’m the only one going through this” so we don’t say anything. But I think there’s also an arrogant part of ourselves that don’t want to talk about what we’re going through ’cause we think to ourselves like ‘I struggle with this ’cause I got a g a l a x y brain and then you just go like ‘Oh, I just needed to drink more water.’</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>Jonny: Yeah, I think we get into this mindset of ‘I’m suffering so I must be doing something </em>right<em>.</em></blockquote><p>The galaxy brain quote? Guilty. Abso-f*cking-lutely guilty of that shit. I’ve internalized a lot of my struggles because I somehow came to the idea that my struggles were the only parts of my identity that made me unique and special. Hearing this finally said out loud was like a punch to the gut since it’s something I do <em>so much. </em>Even now I tell myself that it’s okay that I suffered so much in high school because it got me to MIT. And it’s okay if I suffer at my time during MIT because it means bigger and better things are coming. And while there’s a slight truth to the idea that with struggle comes success, the story of our lives shouldn’t solely be a story of struggle. We need to treat ourselves, to take care of ourselves, to realize that suffering does not directly equate to progress.</p><h3>What’s your biggest fear? Mine is bears.</h3><blockquote><em>Bo: Probably my dog dying.</em></blockquote><blockquote>Audience: (awwing)</blockquote><blockquote><em>Jonny: Probably my fiance dying.</em></blockquote><blockquote>Audience: (MORE INTENSE AWWING)</blockquote><blockquote><em>Bo: He’s got a PhD, he’s got a fiance, and what do I got? A f*cking dog.</em></blockquote><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/401/1*0vxhmrMPAF0h2FnkO-QvkA.png" /><figcaption>MIT Communications Forum photo, credit: Sarah Schwartz</figcaption></figure><p>There were definitely more quotable moments, but I just didn’t get the chance to catch them. I would really like to thank Jonny and Bo, as well as MHH and MIT Commforum for coming out and putting on the event. Of course, it didn’t just end there, though.</p><h3>Eighth Grade</h3><p>This is, I guess, my sort of reaction to Bo’s Eighth Grade and why this movie will stick with me forever.</p><p>The movie somehow accurately portrays what it’s like to grow up as a middle schooler or even high schooler in this weird, weird age of social media — teachers trying to awkwardly #relate with those LITTY teens &amp; dab on em, instastalking your crush of yours and trying so hard to not accidentally like that photo from 5 years ago, snapping for thirty minutes trying to get that perfect filter angle.</p><p>But also it was able to capture just how difficult it is to fit in.</p><p>I related with Kayla (our main character) <em>so. f*cking. much.</em> I was the girl in middle school that got pity invites to pool parties and just awkwardly stood off to the side praying for human interaction. I was the girl that did an excited little happy dance whenever someone invited me to hang out with them. I was the girl that thought high school would be so drastically different and that I’d finally get the chance to reinvent myself.</p><p>It was like an almost out-of-body experience watching the movie because it felt like I was watching myself. And I guess this brings us back to that post-narrative lifestyle that Bo was talking about, but the reverse instead. This movie does not give us a reflection of what our life <em>should</em> be, but instead, what our life actually was and is.</p><p>It is not an expectation, but the reality. And it normalizes that reality.</p><p>I could go on and on about Eighth Grade forever, but I should probably leave some unsaid so you can form some opinions on your own.</p><h3>IN CONCLUSION</h3><p>I’ve been having a pretty rough week, having gotten a D on my first ever MIT test, my 18.01A midterm, and it’s kind of been taking a toll on my confidence in being here and belonging here. But this talk managed to turn that all around. It basically came in my time of need and I’m very grateful to have had the opportunity to listen to all the nuggets of wisdom Jonny and Bo offered unto us. It also really inspired me to get more in touch with my creative side, making me not only write this blogpost so I don’t ever forget this night, but just write and read more. In fact, I’m going to buy<a href="https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/0062569023/ref=as_li_tl?ie=UTF8&amp;tag=jonnysun-20&amp;camp=1789&amp;creative=9325&amp;linkCode=as2&amp;creativeASIN=0062569023&amp;linkId=1dd578650b04514e807e8085899288c0"> Jonny’s book right now ;) shameless plug</a> and also probably rewatch what. and make happy and just think about Eighth Grade.</p><p>I recommend you do the same.</p><p>**************************************************</p><p><a href="https://www.thecrimson.com/article/2019/10/1/bo-burnham-jonny-sun-talk/">From <em>The Harvard Crimson</em></a>:</p><h3>Bo Burnham and Jonny Sun Discuss Mental Health and the Internet at MIT</h3><p>By: <a href="https://www.thecrimson.com/writer/1215356/Emerson_J._Monks/">Emerson J. Monks</a></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*yvb2U8KNiBreOfDSeO1t0g.png" /><figcaption>MIT Communications Forum photo, credit: Sarah Schwartz</figcaption></figure><p>An hour before “Digital Anxieties: a Conversation with Bo Burnham and Jonny Sun,” a line had already formed down the hallways of the Compton Laboratories at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology. On Sept. 27, students from universities in the Boston area gathered to watch comedian and director Bo Burnham and writer and illustrator Jonny Sun discuss mental health in the age of technology.</p><p>Burnham and Sun gathered onstage to discuss isolation and community in an over-publicized era, examining how social media can make mental health both better and worse — and how we can all encourage a healthier use of the internet.</p><p>“You are not alone in your loneliness,” Sun said.</p><p>In 2006, Burnham began uploading videos of himself singing on YouTube that went viral. He has since enjoyed a successful career in stand-up comedy, and has produced the shows “Words, Words, Words,” “what.,” and “Make Happy.” Most recently, he wrote and directed his first feature film, “Eighth Grade,” which received numerous awards.</p><p>Sun is the author and illustrator of the book “everyone’s a aliebn when you’re a aliebn too” and the illustrator of the New York Times best-selling “Gmorning, Gnight!” by Lin Manuel Miranda. He is a writer for the sixth season of “BoJack Horseman,” a Ph.D candidate at MIT, and a creative researcher at the Harvard metaLAB, where he studies virtual communities created by social media.</p><p>Both Burnham and Sun’s professional backgrounds equipped them to address mental health issues, especially within the context of social media. Both initially found success through online platforms — Burnham through YouTube, Sun largely through Twitter — and both have had to deal with their own struggles in the publicized social media sphere. Sun has struggled with depression, and Burnham often had panic attacks while performing stand-up. Sun currently studies online societies, while Burnham’s “Eighth Grade” addressed coming-of-age in a self-broadcasted era.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/895/1*xziKOzyuJNLSLE1Yzmng0A.png" /><figcaption>MIT Communications Forum photo, credit: Sarah Schwartz</figcaption></figure><p>“I’ve had probably 20 panic attacks in my life, 19 of which have been onstage,” Burnham said.</p><p>Burnham and Sun began the discussion by talking about social media usage in their own daily lives. Burnham argued that many contemporary artists engage their audience too much in their creative process, dispersing fragments of information and asking for continuous feedback.</p><p>“You can’t be creative. You’re constantly in a dialogue with your audience,” Burnham said.</p><p>Sun also contended that the internet had an element of exhibitionism. “Everyone is performing to each other all the time,” he said. He cited reaction videos and a constant, rapid-fire exchange of ideas, which Burnham named a kind of “cultural cacophony.”</p><p>After the initial discussion, Burnham and Sun engaged in a question-and-answer session with the audience. One audience member asked a question about mental illnesses, to which Sun confessed that he created a bot that sent him notifications every hour or so to do something small to improve his mental health. When asked about the validity of virtual friendships, Sun said that connection is connection, “no matter where we find it.”</p><p>“[Burnham’s] comedy I think is something that provides a sense of light within darker times,” audience member Dillon Powell said. “When you’re going through a harder time he’s somebody that both relates to you and is still very human.”</p><p>Other members of the audience felt similarly. “When they were talking about finding greatness and being great to one specific person as opposed to a whole audience of people, I felt like that really resonated with me,” Nadine A. Jackson ’23 said.</p><p>When the discussion came to an end, the stage flooded with students clamoring for selfies, autographs, or a chance for brief conversation. The Internet is, after all, an inescapable phenomenon that resonates with a generation that has never known a world without it.</p><p>“I wake up on it, I go to bed with it,” Burnham said.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=1287cd03a38f" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/mit-communications-forum/digital-anxieties-a-conversation-with-bo-burnham-and-jonny-sun-1287cd03a38f">Digital Anxieties: A Conversation with Bo Burnham and Jonny Sun</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/mit-communications-forum">The Communications Forum at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[An Evening with Comedienne Cameron Esposito: March 14]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/mit-communications-forum/an-evening-with-comedienne-cameron-esposito-march-14-528c7e412ed1?source=rss-83297b59b005------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/528c7e412ed1</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[stand-up-comedy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mit-communications-forum]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[past-forums]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[comedy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[cameron-esposito]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[CommForum]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 25 Feb 2019 16:13:20 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-04-03T16:22:27.745Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>An Evening with Comedienne Cameron Esposito: March 14, 2019</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*TLhD0udH6yPYggbopXokQg.jpeg" /></figure><p>Comedienne Cameron Esposito delights audiences with a short comedy set followed by Q&amp;A about <em>Rape Jokes</em>, her standup comedy special about sexual assault from a survivor’s perspective.</p><p><strong>Thursday, March 14, 2019<br>6:00–8:00 pm<br></strong><a href="https://whereis.mit.edu/?go=W16"><strong>Kresge Little Theater (W16–035)</strong></a><strong>, MIT<br>Seating for this event is first come, first served. The event will also be livestreamed to </strong><a href="https://whereis.mit.edu/?go=1"><strong>room 1–190</strong></a><strong>.</strong></p><p><strong>Cameron Esposito</strong> is a nationally headlining comic who has garnered glowing praise from <em>The New York Times</em>, <em>Vanity Fair</em>, <em>Variety</em>, and <em>The Guardian</em>. She’s also a sexual assault survivor. In 2018, Esposito released <em>Rape Jokes</em>, a standup comedy special about sexual assault from a survivor’s perspective. Esposito heads to MIT for a short standup performance followed by Q&amp;A with the audience.</p><p><strong>Speaker:</strong></p><p><a href="https://www.cameronesposito.com/"><strong>Cameron Esposito</strong></a><strong> </strong>is a comedienne who co-created and co-starred in the sitcom, <em>Take My Wife. </em>Esposito’s critically-acclaimed performances have been lauded by <em>The New York Times</em>, <em>Variety</em>, <em>The Guardian</em>, <em>LA Weekly</em>, <em>Time Out Los Angeles</em>,<em> </em>and <em>Los Angeles Magazin</em>e. Her sophomore album, <a href="https://cameronesposito.bandcamp.com/album/same-sex-symbol"><em>Same Sex Symbol</em></a>, debuted at number one on the iTunes comedy charts and was named one of <em>The AV Club</em>’s best comedy albums of 2014<em>. Rape Jokes</em>, her standup special, tackles sexual assault from a survivor’s perspective and raised more than $85,000 for the Rape, Abuse &amp; Incest National Network.</p><p><em>All Communications Forum events are free and open to the general public. Seating is given on a first come, first served basis. There are no tickets. The event will also be livestreamed to </em><a href="https://whereis.mit.edu/?go=1"><em>room 1–190</em></a><em>.</em><strong> </strong><em>This event is co-sponsored by the </em><a href="https://shass.mit.edu/resources/internal/deflorez"><em>de Florez Fund for Humor</em></a><em>, </em><a href="http://wgs.mit.edu/"><em>Women &amp; Gender Studies at MIT</em></a><em>, and </em><a href="https://mindhandheart.mit.edu/innovation-fund"><em>The MindHandHeart Innovation Fund</em></a><em>.</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/800/1*d1QZJV8pXXkPi-BevyZA5A.jpeg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/318/1*Mjz-rvrz8RYhTsPuKnUcsA.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/800/1*WewqExTtVsGFt46tRRTaQg.png" /></figure><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FdsIbb3UEvnY%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;url=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DdsIbb3UEvnY&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FdsIbb3UEvnY%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/be06ef85ca727a08bea34a1e2863ddcd/href">https://medium.com/media/be06ef85ca727a08bea34a1e2863ddcd/href</a></iframe><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fw.soundcloud.com%2Fplayer%2F%3Furl%3Dhttps%253A%252F%252Fapi.soundcloud.com%252Ftracks%252F600356349%26show_artwork%3Dtrue&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fsoundcloud.com%2Fmit-cmsw%2Fan-evening-with-comedienne-cameron-esposito&amp;image=http%3A%2F%2Fi1.sndcdn.com%2Fartworks-000514476318-5z91zb-t500x500.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=soundcloud" width="800" height="166" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/3faa0d03259329c841c63180c610d6c5/href">https://medium.com/media/3faa0d03259329c841c63180c610d6c5/href</a></iframe><p>Summary</p><p>Photos by Greg Peverill-Conti</p><p>[This is an edited summary, and not a verbatim transcript.]</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*6JDPlEnXBpPWevc8nPvtAg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Seth Mnookin and Cameron Esposito</figcaption></figure><p><strong>Cameron Esposito</strong> performed a 45-minute standup set. The event then transitioned into the moderated discussion portion of the evening.</p><p><strong>Seth Mnookin</strong>, director of the MIT Communications Forum, began by thanking the evening’s sponsors — the De Florez Fund for Humor, Women and Gender Studies at MIT, and the MindHandHeart Innovation Fund. Mnookin also gave a trigger warning regarding material that might come up in the course of the conversation. He also provided information about the MIT Violence Prevention and Response office. Mnookin then began the moderated discussion portion of the evening.</p><p>Cameron Esposito joked that the microphone, which was positioned on a small table stand by her chair, was adorable and “the world’s most ineffective boom mic.”</p><p>Mnookin opened the conversation by asking Esposito about why she created her standup special, <a href="https://www.cameronesposito.com/"><em>Rape Jokes</em></a><em>, </em>which addressed sexual assault from a survivor’s perspective.</p><p>Esposito said that the special was distributed for free through her website. There is an option for viewers to donate and viewers have thus far chosen to donate $95,000, all of which went to the Rape, Abuse &amp; Incest National Network (RAINN).</p><p>“That gives me a lot of hope. I really love that,” she said.</p><p>Esposito has joined the RAINN advisory council since. Esposito said that she woke up in the middle of the night with the title of the special in her head.</p><p>“Rape jokes, it’s one of those things that’s been debated for as long as I’ve been doing comedy,” she said. “ ‘Are there certain topics that are off limits?’ It just strikes me as utter silliness because when people are talking about something like sexual assault, first of all there always seems to be this implied difference that men feel differently about sexual assault and I find in my anecdotal experience, that is not true.”</p><p>Esposito added that she knows a lot of men who are either survivors themselves or have been affected by sexual assault. She said that she believes that most people are on the side of justice and good communication.</p><p>“One of our biggest problems in this country is that we don’t have sex ed, so how can you know whether or not you’re doing something consensual,” she said.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*-Y7EDXqSgCrNcizZ17xsSg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Cameron Esposito</figcaption></figure><p>Esposito said that she frequently sees comics go on stage and say something deliberately offensive or obtuse, then get upset when an audience wants more from them.</p><p>“If you’re a comic and somebody tells you, ‘be more careful with this thing that has affected real people,’ that you should want to be a good enough artist to make better jokes,” she said.</p><p>Esposito also said that she always assumes that there are survivors in the room because she is a survivor. Sexual assault is a topic that’s often discussed as if it only affects people outside of the room, which statistically is not true. Esposito created her standup special to shift that opinion.</p><p>Mnookin asked what the experience of talking to people after that show been like with audiences.</p><p>Esposito said that she only did that material in small rooms because she didn’t feel like she could go into large venues, bring up this topic, and then leave. She only performed <em>Rape Jokes</em> material in rooms with capacities of 100 or less. Oftentimes after performances, audience members would come up to her and out themselves as survivors. She felt like there was “some aftercare required.” Esposito typically plays bigger rooms, which makes it difficult to spend time with individual audience members.</p><p>Mnookin asked if Esposito plans to continue to perform this material in smaller rooms.</p><p>Esposito said that she will never do that material again as a whole. She said that <em>Rape Jokes </em>was a special project, in part because people who worked on the show donated their time to make the show happen.</p><p>“I just feel like I captured exactly what I wanted to capture and I’m very proud of it and it exists and I feel like now I can move on a little bit,” she said. “I said my piece and that’s more than most people get to do.”</p><p>Mnookin asked Esposito what got her into improv.</p><p>Esposito said that Boston College, her alma mater, has the oldest collegiate improv group in the country. It’s called <a href="http://www.mymothersfleabag.com/">My Mother’s Fleabag</a>. Amy Poehler was in the group ten years before Esposito. When Esposito was at Boston College, Poehler was just breaking out on <em>Saturday Night Live</em>.</p><p>“There was this feeling that oh you just act like a banana in the cafeteria for like three nights a month or whatever and you get to be a famous person,” Esposito said.</p><p>Esposito got her first professional comedy job the day after she graduated from college.</p><p>Mnookin asked her if she always knew that she wanted to perform.</p><p>Esposito said no. She said that she was a jock, a three-sport athlete in high school. She was also on student council and involved in setting up for school events. At Boston College, she played rugby. Esposito said that she really didn’t know that comedy could be a full-time job, even after she was doing it professionally. She applied for graduate school to get her masters in social work. While in Boston, she worked with children with several physical special needs while she did comedy at night. She thought that comedy would be her passion, but not her career.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*fkmK4mQX9d0WDcHpOveX_g.jpeg" /><figcaption>Seth Mnookin</figcaption></figure><p>Mnookin said that we now live in a culture where the world at large feel like they have a right to interact with anyone who is even remotely famous in any way they like. He asked what that experience has been like for Esposito, adding that not all of the comments she gets are fully supportive.</p><p>Esposito said that she has a new approach to social media. She really isn’t on any major platforms and therefore doesn’t see as many comments, positive or negative. During the first ten years of her career, she only got discouragement through social media channels. Other comics and improv performers were sometimes kind to her, but much of the other feedback was negative.</p><p>Esposito added that she is part of the first generation of comics that could start out of the closet. Ellen DeGeneres was well into her career and had her own television show when she came out. DeGeneres was blacklisted and had to rebuild her career after coming out. Tig Notaro didn’t start talking about her personal life until later in her career. Some comedians, such as Lea DeLaria, did come out of the closet very early in their careers, but these comedians didn’t gain mainstream success until much later in life. Esposito is part of the first generation who had the ability to be openly gay from the beginning of their careers. For the first ten years of her career, people asked Esposito why she had to talk about being gay in her act.</p><p>Mnookin quipped that straight male comedians never talk about their sex lives.</p><p>“Do they have sex? I don’t know,” Esposito said.</p><p>Mnookin asked Esposito if now, the years into her career, if she sees that as being the same for men and women within the LGBTQI community.</p><p>Esposito said that she is now 15 years into her career. The first ten years were very hard and in the last five years, she’s been getting rewarded for being an unusual voice in comedy.</p><p>“I almost don’t trust it,” she said.</p><p>Esposito said that there has never been openly gay male megastar in the standup world. There also hasn’t been a trans or nonbinary megastar.</p><p>“There are a lot of lesbians who do standup because we don’t care what men think of us,” she said. “Well we do. I still do because I’m cultured female. Of course I care what men think about me. Accept me! Think I’m beautiful! I don’t want you at all, but could you please validate me? It’s very confusing.”</p><p>Laughter is a submissive behavior. The person on stage is a leader and that can feel really nice “to be held in that way,” Esposito added. “I think sometimes for men, if that’s a woman, she’s a straight woman, her life is going to be hard. She’s going to have a difficult time dating. She’s going to have a difficult time figuring out how to find a partner because her partner is cultured to be threatened by her. I think that same thing then extends to gay men where it’s like homophobia against gay men is actually really misogyny…”</p><p>Esposito said that gay men are often reduced to penetrative sex acts. These gender and sexual orientation dynamics play out in standup comedy in many of the same ways they play out in the rest of the world.</p><p>“I can’t wait to see who the first gay male megastar is,” Esposito said, adding that it could be Jaboukie Young-White, who is currently on <em>The Daily Show</em>, or Joel Kim Booster.</p><p>Mnookin brought up Basketball Shorts Guy, a nameless person who once quietly stepped between Esposito and the person who sexually assaulted her. Mnookin said that the character is interesting because he showcased what an ordinary person can do to combat sexual assault.</p><p>Esposito said that Basketball Shorts Guy “absolutely changed my life.” She said that she is grateful that this person chose to intervene when he could have just walked by. She said that that kind of intervention is what she’s trying to do by offering her standup special for free.</p><p>“I’m trying to interrupt this system that we live in,” she said.</p><p>Esposito said that she was trying to do the same thing with her television show, <em>Take My Wife</em>. The show was low budget, but had high levels of diversity and featured an all-female writer’s room that was 40% people of color and more than 50% out LGBT actors. When the show was canceled when the network went defunct, they released those numbers. <em>Take My Wife</em> operated on a budget that was about one-tenth of what a budget might be for an HBO series, but despite not having the ability to pay actors, writers, and producers in the same way as larger networks, they were able to attract a broad spectrum of talent. When their diversity numbers were released, the information trended on Twitter and was picked up by several media outlets.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*G12jaJ984s5EXaDw6hKocQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Cameron Esposito</figcaption></figure><p>“Being able to release those numbers felt, again to me, it’s like these little moments to disrupt the system, put a challenge out to people who are in a position to hire folks,” she said. “Here’s what I was able to do. Improve on this.”</p><p>Esposito said that that kind of disruption is what she’s done in her career and what she hopes to continue to do.</p><p>Mnookin said that after Seeso streaming service shut down, <em>Take My Wife</em> was picked up by Starz. Mnookin also said that viewers don’t need to sign up for anything in order to watch the <em>Rape Jokes</em> special. They can simply watch it on Esposito’s site. He asked what else Esposito is currently working on.</p><p>Esposito said that she just turned in the second draft of a book and that she’s trying to sell a new television show. She’s also currently on the road testing out new material.</p><p>Mnookin asked her if she enjoys being on the road.</p><p>“Oh it is so lonely,” Esposito said. She said that she sometimes wishes she could go home and see her dog, a nine-pound chihuahua.</p><p>Mnookin then opened up the forum to the audience for questions.</p><p>An engineer in the audience said that she is also a poet who is just beginning to perform her work. She said that she saw <em>Rape Jokes</em> and enjoyed it. She asked Esposito how she walks the line between talking about difficult experiences and things that aren’t talked about enough while keeping in mind that the audience might be affected and have feelings about the material.</p><p>Esposito said that she tries to be a conscientious as she can be about her material. One thing that helps is making sure that you’re investigating your own experience and speaking only for yourself. Esposito said that that’s why she felt like she could do a special like <em>Rape Jokes</em> — because the material only speaks to her individual experiences and not to rape culture as a whole. The more specific and the more personal she was, the more that speaks to rape culture.</p><p>“I find that that is how we do the best work, is when we only speak for ourselves,” she said.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*0paBYxATLjJHSCHRnfy0aA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Cameron Esposito signs an autograph</figcaption></figure><p>An audience member said that every gay person has their journey to figuring out that they’re gay. The audience member said that there was a time in her life when she didn’t know that she could be gay, but that changed after watching BuzzFeed’s <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=W_N36YpApQA"><em>Ask a Lesbian</em></a> web series, which featured Esposito. The audience member said that was a turning point in her life. She asked for an autograph, which Esposito granted.</p><p>“That’s the whole goal,” Esposito said.</p><p>“Convert lesbians,” Mnookin quipped.</p><p>Esposito said that she didn’t have a lesbian role model growing up. When she was at Boston College, Esposito used to take the train with her girlfriend to go to Diesel Cafe, “where there’s just haircuts.” That trip is a two-hour trip. “I don’t think we ever ordered. We would just walk in and go, ‘ooooh,’ ” she said.</p><p>Mnookin joked that the <em>Ask a Lesbian</em> series taught him how lesbians use condoms (<a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Av2PU3wLGio">in this episode</a>).</p><p>“You lay them on the windowsill to dry. You make a dreamcatcher,” Esposito joked.</p><p>An audience member from Wellesley College said that she is the adopted daughter of lesbians and she is also queer herself. She brought up an episode of <em>Take My Wife</em> wherein Esposito discusses adoption. She asked if Esposito could elaborate on the story behind how that episode was created.</p><p>Esposito thanked the audience member for making the trip all the way from Wellesley College. She said that the show was made with her wife, Rhea Butcher, and that the show gave her the opportunity to talk about real issues for the queer community — issues like how expensive adoption is and how to make decisions about whether to use one partner’s eggs for in-vitro fertilization. Some of the writers were queer; others weren’t. Esposito’s team would bring in members of the queer community who were not associated with the show and do a special table reading of each episode to make sure that the material really rang true to that community. They also tried to hire out LGBT actors so that the show was as authentic to the queer community as possible.</p><p>“So often when queer characters pop up in shows, it’s like a random room of straight writers trying to address a topic and that’s when you get weird jokes about closets and you’re like what?,” she said.</p><p>Take My Wife was really about “trying to make something really honest,” Esposito added.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*fspALbHagF-7HOb8-bdkFA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Cameron Esposito</figcaption></figure><p>The audience member said that the show was “really life-changing.” She saw it in high school when she was unsure if she was gay. She thought that she couldn’t be gay because her parents were.</p><p>An audience member named Sam thanked Esposito for championing the message the diversity is what makes this country good. Sam said that he is part of an allies group for men within the Sloan School of Management.</p><p>“That’s amazing that that even exists,” Esposito said. “The business school allies group? We are literally there? That it’s that’s specific? That’s fucking awesome!”</p><p>Sam asked Esposito how his group could encourage more people to be allies and recognize the need to take action.</p><p>Esposito said that was a great question. For her, the only solution that has ever worked is telling people why something matters to her.</p><p>“I really feel like we’re in this moment where it feels like the inclination is to address a massive social issue, but I find that that can turn people off or even overwhelm people,” she said. “It’s literally why I think standup is a valuable art, because you’re on stage talking about here’s my experience, here’s my experience. It’s not constructive. It’s not like here’s what you should do.”</p><p>Esposito said that simply talking about allyship and why it’s important amongst friends can provide an opening for other people to join the cause. Attraction works better than evangelization in that context.</p><p>An audience member said that she was a longtime fan of Esposito, in part because of her older sister, who is also gay. The audience member said that she grew up Catholic and had what sounds like a similar upbringing to Esposito. The audience member said that she recently stood up in front of a crowd and discussed two instances of sexual assault that happened to her. Those instances were perpetrated by a woman. The audience member said that talking about the experience in front of an audience was “really powerful.” She’s graduating in spring and isn’t sure what she should do in the future. She said that she wanted to spread awareness about LGBT issues as well as sexual assault. She asked Esposito about what the best way to make a difference is.</p><p>Esposito expressed condolences that the sexual assaults happened and she thanked the audience member for sharing her story. Esposito said that the audience member is at an age where she doesn’t need to know exactly how she’s going to make an impact on the world.</p><p>“Investigation and information is so helpful,” Esposito said.</p><p>Esposito said that she remembers feeling overwhelmed as a college student. Knowing what’s going to be the right thing ten years down the road is tough, but an easier question to answer is what is the first step you can take? For example, the first step to take if you want to become a standup comic is to perform at an open mic night. The first step to take if you want to be a politician is to take the LSAT. Activists can also go to a single meeting of a new activist group and evaluate how that feels.</p><p>“I know that there’s all this pressure and it feels like you have to know the answer but, like I said, I didn’t start doing standup full-time or comedy full-time as my job until I was 27,” she said.</p><p>She spent five years doing comedy alongside several other jobs to figure out what the right thing for her was.</p><p>“That’s ok, too,” Esposito said. “The advice is to take the first step, see if you like it, then take the second step and not worry about changing the world, but worry about what you like.”</p><p>An MIT senior said that she’s a longtime fan of Esposito.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*_rM3fJsxM_1wVpLNK2YlCw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Cameron Esposito</figcaption></figure><p>“I specifically have a question for you because at some point in your life, you’ve been very Catholic and now you’re very gay,” the audience member said, adding that the same was true for her. The audience member said that she is from Italy and was raised Catholic.</p><p>She said that she did not see any issues with being gay and Catholic in Italy because there, she did not feel as much homophobia as she does in the United States.</p><p>“When I came to the US as a college freshman, that’s the first moment in which I realized, ‘oh wait, there are people who have problems with me being gay and Catholic at the same time,’” she said. She said that in the United States she felt rejected by the Catholic community and that she felt uncomfortable presenting herself as both gay and Catholic. She asked for Esposito’s take.</p><p>Esposito said that she grew up thinking that the Catholic Church was centered around community and trust and “doing the right thing in the world.” Esposito said that she will always consider herself “ethnically Catholic,” but in college, the thing that first made her push away from the Church wasn’t her sexual identity; it was reading about the Church’s take on the role of women.</p><p>“I read about being a vessel and why I couldn’t be a priest and it made me so sad,” she said.</p><p>Women comprise more than 50% of world’s population. The Catholic Church is one of the world’s wealthiest organizations and one of the largest land owners across the globe.</p><p>“There’s so much money and there’s so much opportunity to do good work and instead, the more I investigated, the more I was like ‘oh my faith went to Mexico and built churches on indigenous land, or took space that had been occupied by somebody else and killed the people in there and put a cross on it,’” she said.</p><p>Esposito was at Boston College when the Catholic Church sex abuse scandal came to national attention in the 2000s.</p><p>“BC bought a parcel of land from the archdiocese that is butting up against the university and that money from that was then given to survivors of sex abuse,” she said. “They openly did this. It wasn’t even a weird back door deal…my college tuition went to offset abuse. I don’t know that I think that anybody has to make any particular decision about whether you believe in certain things or whether you go to mass. I’m just somebody who thinks that we have to look at things conscientiously and this organization that I was born into, I feel an enormous responsibility to be honest about in the public realm. Just because we have good football teams doesn’t mean we’re good people.”</p><p>Esposito said that if Catholicism feels helpful and beautiful and if it feels like a framework from which somebody can do good work, that’s great. It should just come with honesty about the organization itself.</p><p>Mnookin brought the conversation around to an earlier comedy bit wherein Esposito described a meal during which her young niece repeatedly asked each individual at dinner table if they were pooping. He said that he hoped that her niece will one day be able to ask someone if they’re pooping and the answer is yes.</p><p>“I want that for her too,” Esposito said.</p><p>An audience member asked if, at the time, the niece was pooping.</p><p>“Great follow-up question, she was not pooping,” Esposito said. “That’s how we all assumed she was covering for it.”</p><p>Mnookin ended the event by thanking the audience, the event sponsors, and the MIT Violence Prevention and Response Office.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=528c7e412ed1" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/mit-communications-forum/an-evening-with-comedienne-cameron-esposito-march-14-528c7e412ed1">An Evening with Comedienne Cameron Esposito: March 14</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/mit-communications-forum">The Communications Forum at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Dispatches From the Golden Age of Audio: February 21, 2019]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/mit-communications-forum/dispatches-from-the-golden-age-of-audio-february-21-2019-2a3dcb5224d?source=rss-83297b59b005------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/2a3dcb5224d</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[podcasting]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[npr]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mit]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[podcast]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[past-forums]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[CommForum]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 31 Jan 2019 17:55:59 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-03-08T08:18:18.792Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*GZK52uH2537c88nJlMB_UA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Cynthia Graber and Al Letson</figcaption></figure><p>Thursday, February 21, 2019<br>6:00 — 8:00 pm<br>Room <a href="https://whereis.mit.edu/?go=4">4–163</a>, MIT</p><p>Podcasting has given rise to new voices and new, highly personal ways to tell stories. But as the medium expands, it struggles to create gold standards for building shows that will be popular and financially sustainable. Cynthia Graber, co-host and co-creator of <a href="https://gastropod.com/"><em>Gastropod</em></a>, about the science and history of food, joins Al Letson, host of the investigative reporting show <a href="https://www.revealnews.org/"><em>Reveal</em></a><em> </em>and <a href="https://www.radiotopia.fm/showcase/errthang/"><em>Errthang</em></a><em>, </em>his own personal “mixtape of delight,” to dive into the secrets of successful podcasting and what the future might hold for this intimate form of media.</p><p><strong>Speakers:</strong></p><p><strong>Cynthia Graber </strong>is an award-winning radio producer and print reporter who’s covered science, technology, food, agriculture, and any other stories that catch her fancy for more than 15 years. Her work has been featured in magazines and radio shows including <em>Fast Company</em>, <em>BBC Future</em>, <em>Slate</em>, the <em>Boston Globe</em>, Studio 360, PRI’s <em>The World</em>, <em>Living on Earth</em>, and many others. She’s a regular contributor to the podcast <em>Scientific American</em>’s <a href="https://www.scientificamerican.com/podcast/60-second-science/"><em>60-Second Science</em></a><em> </em>and in 2014, she co-founded the <a href="https://gastropod.com/"><em>Gastropod</em></a> food science podcast alongside author Nicola Twilley. Cynthia’s radio and print awards include those from the American Association for the Advancement of Science, the Society of Environmental Journalists, and the international Institute of Physics.</p><p><strong>Al Letson </strong>has received national recognition and built a devoted fan base with soul-stirring, interdisciplinary work. He established himself early in his career as a heavyweight in the Poetry Slam Movement, which garnered artistic credibility and renown. Performing on a number of national, regional and local stages, including HBO’s <em>Def Poetry Jam</em>, CBS’s <em>Final Four PreGame Show </em>and commercial projects for Sony, the <em>Florida Times Union</em>, Adobe Software, and the Doorpost Film Project. After winning the Public Radio Talent Quest, Al received a grant from the Corporation for Public Broadcasting to create three episodes of his public radio show concept <em>State of the Re:Union</em>. His company finished their first grant in August of 2009, and has just been awarded one of the largest public radio grants ever given to a single project to produce a full season of shows.</p><p><em>All Communications Forum events are free and open to the general public. Seating is given on a first come, first served basis.</em></p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FKHz69AyzxJI%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;url=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DKHz69AyzxJI&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FKHz69AyzxJI%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/ff13929a6c3ef7d8762a7227ab6b33a9/href">https://medium.com/media/ff13929a6c3ef7d8762a7227ab6b33a9/href</a></iframe><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*QxQ_oveADE64s24mqxJ1iQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Cynthia Graber and Al Letson.</figcaption></figure><p><strong>Summary</strong></p><p>[This is an edited summary, and not a verbatim transcript.]</p><p>By: Kelsey Tsipis, Photos by Greg Peverill-Conti</p><p><strong>Cynthia Graber</strong> is an award-winning radio producer and journalist, whose work appears in <em>Slate</em>, the <em>Boston Globe</em>, <em>Wired</em>, and <em>Scientific American</em>, among others. In 2014, she co-founded <em>Gastropod</em> — a podcast about food, science, and history. <em>Gastropod</em> has won a Regional Edward R. Murrow Award and an International Association of Culinary Professionals Award. In 2016, it was named “Boston’s Best Podcast” by <em>Improper Bostonian</em>. Cynthia was a MIT Knight Science Journalism Fellow, and she currently teaches the radio journalism segment for the MIT Graduate Program in Science Writing.</p><p><strong>Al Letson </strong>is a<strong> </strong>Peabody and Emmy award-winning radio host, performance artist, and playwright. He currently hosts <a href="https://www.revealnews.org/"><em>Reveal</em></a>, a public radio show created by the Center for Investigative Reporting and PRX which is now in its fourth season. <em>Reveal</em> has received international acclaim for its in-depth investigative journalism on issues such as inmate abuse, white nationalism, immigrant detention camps, and much more. <em>The Atlantic</em> says: “the experience of each episode is akin to a spoonful of sugar, even when it’s telling a story about Richard Spencer’s cotton farms or a man’s final days as a heroin addict.” Before <em>Reveal</em>, Al spent years on the road telling the story of America one community at a time as the host of the public radio show, <em>State of the Re:Union. </em>He<em> </em>also co-hosts the culture podcast, <a href="https://www.radiotopia.fm/showcase/errthang"><em>Errthang</em></a>.</p><p>Graber opened the forum by thanking everyone for being there and saying that talking about podcasting is one of her favorite things in the world and that she’s a big fan of Letson’s work. She asked Letson how he got into audio.</p><p>“I used to think that saying that I got into radio was kind of an unorthodox path, but I think everybody kind of takes an unorthodox path to podcasting,” said Letson.</p><p>Letson went on to explain his own unconventional career path into podcasting, which started in 2007. He was watching <em>American Idol</em> with his daughter and afterwards went online to see how the contestant he liked had fared. Instead of the popular network TV singing competition, he found the Public Radio Talent Quest organized by the Public Radio Exchange (PRX) and the Corporation for Public Broadcasting (CPB), which was a nationwide search for new public radio talent.</p><p>At the time, Letson explained, he was a flight attendant and performing artist, flying to different cities and performing slam poetry during his off-work hours. He felt his experience gave him a unique perspective into life in America.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*K-jQrg8CccFlk9QY8DlTtA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Al Letson</figcaption></figure><p>“Because I had seen the country from the bottom up, hanging out with poets and activists, I had this idea for what I thought America looked like and felt that so much of the media wasn’t talking about it,” he said.</p><p>Letson pitched his idea for a podcast, which he named <a href="http://stateofthereunion.com/"><em>State of the Re:Union</em></a><em> </em>on a whim, to the<em> </em>competition. He ended up as one of the contest’s three winners, along with Glynn Washington, who went on to make <a href="https://snapjudgment.org/podcast"><em>Snap Judgement</em></a><em>,</em> and Majora Carter, who went on to make <em>The Promised Land</em>.</p><p>“Glynn and I took really different paths to make radio,” said Letson. “Glynn wanted to get people who didn’t make radio before to come in and do it, and I had a sound that I was trying to achieve, so I did it the opposite way. I went out and found a lot of great audio producers who were kind of young in their career but also had a lot of potential.”</p><p>Letson said that when hiring people for <em>State of the Re:Union</em>, his number one requirement was that they exhibit passion for the idea behind the show.</p><p>“Passion for the idea that America is such a rich and diverse place, and we don’t talk about that enough in our news, in our storytelling, especially at the time,” Letson said. “Also, this is right around the time when Obama first got in office, so we were filled with hope.”</p><p>As far as how he transitioned from radio to podcasting, Letson told a story of meeting a hippie named Steve at a party who told him that “podcasting was the future.”</p><p>“I was like ‘Come on, Steve, you’ve had too much to drink,’ ” said Letson. “You mean my iPod? What do I do, cast it? What is that? I didn’t even know what he was talking about. And here I am, so Steve was 100 percent right.”</p><p>Graber then recounted her own unconventional path into podcasting. She wasn’t a fan of radio journalism or NPR growing up. However, in 1998, she went to Boston University to get a master’s degree in science journalism and ended up taking a radio class. She had a background in theater and had decided to take the class because she “liked microphones,” she joked. Afterwards, she was hired as an intern at <em>Living on Earth</em>, an NPR show, and offered a full-time position 2 weeks later. After <em>Living on Earth</em>, Graber worked at <em>World Vision Report </em>for 7 years.</p><p>Podcasting was becoming popular around this time, and Graber was podcasting for <em>Scientific American</em> and guest hosting some other science podcasts. During her year as a Knight Science Journalism Fellow at MIT, she began to think that she wanted to do her own thing.</p><p>“I kept thinking, I’m ready to be my own boss,” said Graber. “I’m ready to come up with my own idea.”</p><p>Her original idea was a podcast about women in science.</p><p>“I was like ‘I’m not going to ask them any of the stupid questions women always get asked,’ ” said Graber. “I’m not going to ask them how they deal with childcare. I’m not going to ask them anything you wouldn’t ask a guy. I’m just going to find out what they’re passionate about and what’s exciting about their work.”</p><p>The topic seemed too broad though, so Graber tried to narrow it down by thinking about a topic she was “obsessed” with.</p><p>“It’s this intersection of food, science, and history,” said Graber. “So I started doing some market research. I’m like, okay, no one’s doing this. There’s cooking shows. There might be some cooking with science shows, but there’s nothing that was marrying my own obsessions in the radio world, in the podcasting world.”</p><p>Graber had also just met Nicola Twilley, who had a blog called <a href="http://www.ediblegeography.com/"><em>Edible Geography</em></a>. Graber sent her the proposal for the podcast idea, and “like two seconds later” Twilley offered to co-host.</p><p>Graber said at the time Twilley “had no idea what she was signing up for.” She didn’t have a background in radio and had a separate full-time job. Graber had to show her the ropes of the audio world. Graber said it’s common that people underestimate how much time it takes to make something of quality.</p><p>Graber asked Letson about his process in creating <em>Errthang</em>.</p><p>“It’s beautifully produced, and it’s really fascinating and really compelling and this is your kind of artistic baby,” said Graber. “Where did that come from?”</p><p>Letson said his roles in <em>State of the Re:Union </em>and <em>Reveal</em> are very clearly defined and don’t leave a lot of room for him “to stretch out and be me.”</p><p>“What <em>State of the Re:Union </em>needed from me was vision and hosting,” said Letson. “I worked with such amazing journalists. As long as I had vision, they came along, and they found great stories, and we just made something really great together.”</p><p>With <em>Reveal</em>, Letson explained, his role is strictly to host and, at times, play the voice of authority, asking open questions and keeping people accountable.</p><p>“But I’m a performer,” said Letson. “I’m a middle kid. I’m addicted to clap cocaine. I need people to clap for me.”</p><p>Letson said he was growing frustrated that he didn’t have a creative outlet.</p><p>“So <em>Errthang</em> came out of this desire to … like I had something to say and I wanted to play a little bit,” said Letson. “Also, I love cutting tape. It’s one of my favorite things in the world. When you cut a story and you score it just right, the thrill of all of it coming together is such a rush. That’s how <em>Errthang</em> came about. It was just me needing to stretch my artistic wings, so to speak.”</p><p>Graber said this is where her and Letson’s approaches to podcasting diverge a bit. Her and Twilley’s approach from day one was that Gastropod was a business. They modeled it after start-ups, even not paying themselves for a year. They created a logo, website, story ideas, and list of people to feature, said Graber. They also created a media plan, reaching out to contacts on social media to generate excitement.</p><p>It worked, Graber said. Their first episode had 8,000 to 10,000 listens. They decided to do full episodes every two weeks, instead of once a month with little “bite-sized episodes” in between.</p><p>“We are now paying ourselves a full-time salary as a journalistic, highly produced podcast, which makes us kind of unicorns in that part of the world,” said Graber.</p><p>Graber asked Letson if in creating <em>Errthang</em> he ever thought of these things: his audience, when he planned to launch, media plans, etc.</p><p>Letson said no; he didn’t think about any of those things.</p><p>“This is probably the worst advice to give anybody that’s going into podcasting, like the absolute worst advice,” said Letson. “Well, okay, it’s the worst advice to give anybody that’s going into podcasting with the idea of making money. I have no desire to make any money off of <em>Errthang</em>. I just really want <em>Errthang</em> to pay for itself.”</p><p>Letson got a grant to start <em>Errthang</em> from a local philanthropist in Jacksonville, Florida, which covered production costs for the first season. That grant allowed him to pay his co-host Willie Evans Jr. and his business manager. Then, for the second season, they partnered with Radiotopia, which “was amazing, because Radiotopia did give us a good bit of money, which allowed me to be a lot more ambitious,” said Letson. For the third season, Letson said, he’s talking to people about coming in and funding it, “because I have really ambitious plans for what I want to do in the third season, like really ambitious plans.”</p><p>Graber pointed out that the reason for their different approaches could be that Letson already has a full-time job with <em>Reveal</em>.</p><p>“Exactly,” said Letson. “That’s why I don’t need <em>Errthang</em> to make me money.”</p><p>Letson breaks other podcasting “golden rules” with <em>Errthang</em>, he said.</p><p>“I don’t think about how often I need to come out, I just come out when I’m ready,” said Letson. “With <em>Reveal</em>, if we did that, we would lose all of our numbers. We would not be in people’s ear. It is not a good strategy, because what happens is every season, I’m helping people re-find us again.”</p><p>But, Letson said, he makes <em>Errthang</em> for “the love of it,” and would do it even if nobody listened to it.</p><p>“I had no game plan, neither financially nor how to get the word out or anything,” said Letson. “All I really wanted to do was to make something that I’d really be proud of.”</p><p>Graber asked how often Letson checked his listener numbers for <em>Errthang</em>. Letson said he doesn’t look for <em>Errthang</em>.</p><p>“I haven’t even looked at them for season two,” said Letson. “I love season two, because I felt like in season one, I was just figuring out what it was I was trying to say. In season two, I knew exactly what I wanted to say, and I crafted that whole season with that thought process in mind.”</p><p>For <em>Reveal</em>, Letson said, the listener numbers are a lot more important, but there is a whole team apart from Letson who are looking into how to attract new listeners. One new way they’re aiming to attract new audiences is with a serial story — a murder mystery set in the Deep South.</p><p>“Everybody’s doing murder mysteries now, and there’s some things that drive me crazy about murder mysteries,” said Letson. “So what I’m doing is guiding our serial away from all those things that drive me crazy. Like one thing that I hate … Being a Southerner, one thing that I hate is how podcasts will come to the South and they’ll take a story away and not quite understand the context. And not leave the community with anything, you know? Yes, I’m talking about <em>S-Town</em>.”</p><p>Letson said it’s important to him that their serial story be done in a way that is accountable to the community the story it is set in and thinks about how it will portray the people in the community, many of whom don’t listen to podcasts.</p><p>“I mean, the lead character has passed on, but the lead character’s sister is my point of contact with the family, and her phone number changes at least every 3 months,” said Letson. “She still has a plan where she runs out of minutes and data usage. That’s real for her life. She’s not listening to podcasts. So how do I tell the story that’s relevant to her, that’s about her, and let her reflect in a way with media that she actually can engage in? So we’re thinking about how to do that type of stuff, because … I’m constantly trying to think about how I can bring more people into the room.”</p><p>Graber asked Letson how they plan to get the word out about the podcast, other than the obvious sharing of information via their public radio platform.</p><p>“First and foremost, it’s like if you really want to go get new listeners, you’ve got to have a really smart PR campaign to go out and get it, which is another reason why I don’t do it [for] <em>Errthang</em>, because I don’t have money to do a PR campaign, right? But you really do,” said Letson. “There’s so many podcasts out there now that if you don’t figure out a way to make yourself stand out and get attention and get people writing about you and talking about you, you’re at a loss already.”</p><p>Letson said they are thinking about “how to meet people where they are.” One way they’re doing this, said Letson, is by reaching out to cultural influencers in the area, in this case, hip hop artists.</p><p>“Because this has to do with a young black man being killed by police, we’re reaching out to a bunch of hip hop artists in that part of the world and telling the story and seeing if any of them want to make a song to go on their album that we don’t own at all,” said Letson. “It’s their song. We’d give them audio bites from the show and have them mix it into the music.”</p><p>Graber said this concept of “finding listeners where they are” is something she thinks about a lot for <em>Gastropod</em> as well, particularly lately.</p><p>“There was a big shakeup in Apple a year ago, and Apple changed how they do their metrics, and everybody lost about 40 percent of what their podcast downloads were,” said Graber. “I’m telling you this now. Nobody wants to talk about it. No podcasts would admit how much they lost from that, but it was probably about 40 percent, mostly across the board.”</p><p>Graber says one way they are exploring getting their numbers back up is finding listeners via cross-promotions with other podcasts.</p><p>“We think our audience is everyone, like everybody eats, right?” said Graber. “But there are people who naturally are obsessed with these topics, and they’ll say, ‘How have you been around for four and a half years and I’ve never heard of you?’”</p><p>Graber said she hasn’t found print articles especially helpful for promotion, with one exception: being mentioned in <em>Wired</em> magazine as one of their favorite scripted podcasts. “<em>Wired</em> readers are podcast listeners,” said Graber.</p><p>Graber then asked Letson his thoughts on the state of the podcasting world.</p><p>“Honestly, I think we’re in a bubble, and I think that bubble’s going to pop really soon,” said Letson. “I think we began to see the decline of organizations that want to put money into podcasts.”</p><p>Letson cited the recent layoffs at BuzzFeed, which removed their entire podcasting department. He gave a couple more examples, saying it looks like the industry is contracting a little bit. Graber and Letson both agreed that the silver lining of this trend could be that poorly produced podcasts also go away.</p><p>“Some people should not do podcasts,” said Letson.</p><p>“Not everybody can do podcasts,” said Graber.</p><p>“Listen, there are things that I would love to do that I should not do,” said Letson. “Like I should not be an Olympic swimmer. I should not. I would drown. I should not go to MIT. I would not do well here. I couldn’t find the damn building.”</p><p>Graber agreed that there’s a bubble in the sense that the market is oversaturated. Everybody wants to do a podcast, and everybody thinks they can do a podcast, and everybody thinks it’s easy to do, she said.</p><p>“I think what most people don’t realize is that it’s actually really hard work,” said Graber. “And it takes a long time to do it well.”</p><p>Letson agreed.</p><p>“It takes a really long time,” he said. “I mean, I cannot listen to season one and season two of <em>State of the Re:Union</em>, because I sound horrible. Horrible. I just don’t even know how they let me on the air with that. It took years for me to figure out exactly where my voice should be. It took me a long time to figure out the, like … “</p><p>“How to write for your own voice,” said Graber.</p><p>“How to write for the voice, right,” said Letson. “I think that I’ve learned how … I know my sweet spot. I know when I’m telling a story, what exactly I’m working for, because I know I do that really well, but it took me a long time to figure those type of things out. I think, yeah, people tend to think that it’s easy.”</p><p>Graber said that while she agrees there’s a bubble in the number of podcasts out there, she thinks there’s still room for growth in podcasting.</p><p>“I think that the research shows that it’s still a fairly small percentage of Americans who listen to podcasting regularly, and it’s growing, so there’s still a huge potential audience out there,” said Graber.</p><p>Graber said that as for advertising, online ads for <em>Gastropod</em> are much more effective because people shy away from fast forwarding through them. <em>Gastropod</em>’s numbers on people who listen through until the end is also high, around 80 to 90 percent, said Graber.</p><p>“So I think there’s still a lot of room for growth in the industry,” said Graber. “I am hoping, though, that it … not that it shakes out in a bad way like what happened with BuzzFeed. I mean, I don’t know, because I don’t work there, but I think maybe people don’t realize how much of a financial and time investment podcasting is, and so they don’t realize how much they’re actually going to have to pay people to do it well.”</p><p>Letson agreed and also noted that part of the problem is that Facebook touted video as the new medium to invest in.</p><p>Graber agreed, then asked Letson how he decides what level of personhood and vulnerability to reveal on <em>Errthang</em>.</p><p>“I believe that to tell great stories you have to be vulnerable, especially if you’re telling stories about yourself,” said Letson. “If you’re not willing the be vulnerable then why do it? Like, it’s boring.”</p><p>It’s a delicate balance though, said Letson, adding that he does think about how to protect himself. He said that on season three of <em>Errthang</em>, there’s a story that he hasn’t told for years because he wasn’t ready. He added that it’s important that you control how you want private things to become public.</p><p>“I have a daughter that passed away, and I told a story on <em>The Moth</em> about it,” said Letson. “I told that story strictly because I always say my other kids’ names out loud, but I never say her name out loud. I wanted to say Lauren’s name in front of an audience, like she was here; she mattered. But that was my only thought. I didn’t even let <em>The Moth</em> pay me for it, I just needed to do it for my own purposes.”</p><p>Letson said that, for him, storytelling is a deliberate, thoughtful choice that he views as a hugely important practice in shaping self-perception, both on a societal and individual level.</p><p>“I tell stories because I believe storytelling is probably the most powerful force in the universe,” said Letson. “If you think about it, everything that we all know about anything, we all learned from story.”</p><p>Letson said that he tries to harness that power for good to make the world a better place.</p><p>“When I’m thinking about how I’m trying to make the world a better place, I’m doing it through story,” said Letson. “If the best way I can do that is through my vulnerability, then I’m gonna use that.”</p><p>“The thing I tell friends of mine all the time is that, I can’t speak for anybody else’s life, but I can tell you that my life is full of magic, like magic shit happens,” said Letson. “I mean, I won a contest and I got my own NPR show. When I got my first NPR show, literally 200 people in the NPR building wanted to stab me, because they’d been working in that industry for years and didn’t get that opportunity, right?”</p><p>But magic has a cost, said Letson.</p><p>“You don’t get to do magic and not pay for it,” said Letson. “Everything has a cost. So the hard stuff, the vulnerability, is that cost. But out of that cost is where the magic springs out. So I’m thinking about all of those things and how I engage with storytelling, and what I’m willing to give, and what I’m holding for myself.”</p><p>Graber then said that, for her, connection to the audience and including bits of her personality is also really important, even though <em>Gastropod</em> is not personal storytelling like Letson’s. It’s a journalism storytelling show, she said, that’s driven by a lot of history, so it was important to her to include personal narratives to build the show’s “characters.”</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*c3xDe74tzWA1L3GpALBlPg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Cynthia Graber</figcaption></figure><p>“The only reason that people are going to want to come back every two weeks to spend time with us is us,” Graber recalled telling Twilley when they first started making <em>Gastropod</em>. “They have to feel connected to us … I wanted people to really feel connected to us, to trust us, to trust that we’re gonna hold their hand and take them through something super cool, really fascinating, but also that we had to occasionally reveal things about ourselves.”</p><p>Those things can be small, like her hatred of cilantro, or bigger things like the fact that her great-grandparents were communists. Opening up parts of their personal lives makes listeners feel like they are friends, said Graber.</p><p>Letson said that he does the same thing on <em>Reveal</em>.</p><p>“With <em>Reveal</em>, I am constantly thinking about the persona of Al that people are hearing and what I want the persona of Al to be,” said Letson. “…I just want people to feel like I’m their cool friend that we can have a coffee with. I’m telling them something and I also listen to them. But I don’t wanna sound like a newsman, so to not sound like a newsman, you have to drop bits of yourself here and there.”</p><p>Letson gave an example of when he felt like he knew someone based off their audio work. He had listened to Melissa Block, an NPR reporter, cover the earthquake in China. At one point, she got choked up explaining how families were excavating rubble and frantically searching for loved ones.</p><p>“I sat in my car and wept,” said Letson. “Then when I met her for the first time, I hugged her so hard. She was like, ‘I don’t know you.’ But it totally was like that moment of … it is such an intimate art form that I am sitting in my car, at wherever I was going, in a park, just listening and weeping, and I felt like I had this moment with Melissa.”</p><p>Graber agreed, noting that when teaching she often tells her students that audio is the most intimate medium.</p><p>“You’re in people’s ears, you’re in their bedrooms. You’re going with them on a run. You’re hanging out with them as they cook,” said Graber. “And when you use the word ‘you,’ they feel like you’re talking to them.”</p><p>“Right, absolutely, ’cause you are,” said Leston.</p><p>“Every time that I am doing any kind of recording, I’m always thinking about that one person that’s listening to me,” said Letson. “I’m not thinking about a whole lot of people. If I thought about how many listeners <em>Reveal</em> has every time that I did it, I think it would freak me out. So instead I think about the one listener <em>Reveal</em> has, the one person that I’m just trying to tell the story to, and whoever’s listening to it is that one person.”</p><p>The talk was then opened up to audience questions. One attendee asked for the speakers’ thoughts about Spotify recently buying the podcasting startup Gimlet, and what that says about the future of podcasting and access.</p><p>Graber said that the <em>Gastropod</em> team has worried about staying independent with this kind of big money trying to centralize things. People are questioning whether things will start going behind a paywall, Graber said, though it’s too early to say right now. As far as whether it will affect access and diversity, Graber said that has been a longstanding issue in radio. She mentioned that Spotify just put out a show called <a href="https://www.dopelabspodcast.com/"><em>Dope Labs</em></a>—a science show hosted by two young African-American women—that everyone should check out.</p><p>Letson said that he also worries about journalism outlets maintaining revenue streams amid changes like these. The diversity issue is a bit more actionable.</p><p>“What’s interesting about the idea about diversity now is that in a lot of ways we can now shame companies in a way that we couldn’t before, and make them pay attention to things that they didn’t care about before,” said Letson. “Some companies will never listen, but some … I think a good majority of them will pay attention, and so there is now the opportunity for people to speak up and be heard and can make change.”</p><p><strong>Tom Levenson</strong>, a professor of science writing at MIT, asked the next question.</p><p>“I have kind of interconnected questions,” said Levenson. “What kind of radio is podcasting? Or when you say radio and you say podcasting, do you guys mean somewhat different things, or slightly different things?”</p><p>Letson said he uses the terms radio and podcast interchangeably. <em>Reveal</em> is both radio and a podcast.</p><p>“I think there’s space for doing things a little differently,” said Graber. “You don’t have to adhere to the public radio hour in the same way that you when you’re on radio.”</p><p>Both Letson and Graber agreed that podcasting allows for more flexibility, in tone, voice, content, and episode length. A lot of what we think of as “new” in podcasting today is really just re-mixed original radio format, said Graber. The <a href="https://serialpodcast.org/"><em>Serial</em> podcast</a> is one example.</p><p>“When <em>Serial</em> came out, everyone was like, ‘This is breaking the mold,’ ” said Graber, “and I was like, ‘Okay, this is serialized storytelling about crime. This is radio, the early days of radio. People would turn on their radios and listen to serialized storytelling about crime.’ It happens to be a podcast, spun out of <em>This American Life</em>, done in a different way, but it’s not new. It’s old.”</p><p><strong>Emily Pontecorvo</strong>, a student in the MIT Graduate Program in Science Writing, asked Letson what making <em>State of the Re:Union </em>was like with no prior journalism or radio experience.</p><p>“I think one of my greatest strengths is that I recognize that I need people,” said Letson. “And in this area, I think in other areas maybe not so much, but in this area I’m really good at putting my ego aside and saying, ‘I need your help.’”</p><p>Letson said he surrounded himself with people who complemented his lack of experience. He hired <a href="https://www.revealnews.org/author/takitelonidis/">Taki Telonidis</a>, who was experienced in radio and knew enough that “he would tell me no.” He hired his best friend, “the most honest person I’ve ever met,” to run the business side of things, and then looked for journalists who had a passion for the mission of <em>State of the Re:Union.</em></p><p>Another audience member asked Letson and Graber what they like to listen to.</p><p>Graber said it’s hard for her to listen to podcasts and not edit them in her head. She mainly listens to public radio shows, like <a href="https://www.npr.org/programs/wait-wait-dont-tell-me/"><em>Wait, Wait, Don’t Tell Me</em></a>. She also praised the interview show <a href="https://www.npr.org/podcasts/399954056/nerdette-podcast"><em>Nerdette</em></a><em>,</em> which is centered around young feminists interviewing cool people.</p><p>Letson said that he also has trouble listening to podcasts because he works in the industry now. Letson said that he tends to listen to audio books. He said that he listened to <a href="https://www.apmreports.org/in-the-dark"><em>In the Dark</em></a>, season two, which he thought was “a revelation of a podcast.” He loved that it<em> </em>was active in the community they were reporting on and had figured out that the best way to communicate with the community was though Facebook.</p><p>“I love the holistic approach, that journalism has a responsibility, not just to tell the truth, but has a responsibility to the people that they are actually telling the story about,” said Letson. “Like we owe them something, you know? They gave us something, and we need to give them something back. So, I can’t recommend that podcast enough.”</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*GZK52uH2537c88nJlMB_UA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Cynthia Graber and Al Letson</figcaption></figure><p><strong>Andrew Whitacre</strong>, the director of communication for the Comparative Media Studies department at MIT, asked the speakers whether they keep audiences in mind who seek out podcasts that don’t have a narrative structure.</p><p>Letson said when he went to the Podcast Movement conference, he was blown away by the number of different podcasts out there and how small the narrative section was. It is something he deals with at <em>Reveal</em> because certain stories they have to tell don’t always translate to the audience it’s meant to reach. For <em>Errthang</em>, Letson said that he is also is trying to bridge the gap between narrative structure and the talkie format that a lot of African-American podcasts follow. One way is to engage with podcast hosts that follow those formats, basically making a podcast about a podcast.</p><p>Tom Levenson asked whether the Letson and Graber could speak more on the craft process of building a podcast.</p><p>Letson said when he lays out a story for <em>Errthang,</em> he prioritizes sound design. He imagines the story unfolding the way a musician thinks about composing a song, with highs and lows to keep the audience hooked. Letson said that he usually edits alone in the studio, with just his computer, the script, and the mic in front of him. He records his voice recordings before he starts scoring a piece. He said that the best advice he has received in radio is that podcasting is the most visual medium there is because people close their eyes and build the world around them. So you have to give listeners the tools to do that.</p><p>Conversely, Graber said that music isn’t where her skillset lies and doesn’t fit as well with the topic of <em>Gastropod</em>. She still uses rhythm to edit when audio clips come in, which is important because both podcast hosts record remotely. Most of their sound also comes from field reporting, so crafting scenes is a complex process that includes layering audio, cutting cross conversations, tightening quotes, clipping out laughter, and more. In thinking about episode topics, they look for diverse people to showcase, do prep interviews, read books, do research, write up questions, transcribe interviews, highlight quotes they think they want, write a script, clean it up, pull cuts, do a read-through, mix it, edit it again, record it in their closets twice, and listen and mix until it’s perfect.</p><p>“I’m out of breath just telling you all,” said Graber. “It’s a lot.”</p><p>“It’s a lot,” said Letson. “But if you love audio production, it’s hugely rewarding.”</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=2a3dcb5224d" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/mit-communications-forum/dispatches-from-the-golden-age-of-audio-february-21-2019-2a3dcb5224d">Dispatches From the Golden Age of Audio: February 21, 2019</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/mit-communications-forum">The Communications Forum at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Consequences of America’s Miracle Machine: November 8, 2018]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/mit-communications-forum/november-8-2018-is-america-losing-its-miracle-machine-6846113ef0c5?source=rss-83297b59b005------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/6846113ef0c5</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[maria-zuber]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[eric-lander]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[past-forums]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[science]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mit-communications-forum]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[CommForum]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 07 Sep 2018 21:19:18 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-11-17T16:35:39.833Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1000/1*kwO75qxdXLRGql22qs8beA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Dr. Eric Lander and Dr. Maria Zuber</figcaption></figure><p>Thursday, November 8, 2018<br>6:00–8:00 pm<br>Room <a href="https://whereis.mit.edu/?go=3">3–270</a>, MIT</p><p>In the 20th century, America led the world in scientific and technological innovation, with federally funded basic research leading to breakthroughs ranging from the Internet to the Human Genome Project, with many positive impacts on society.</p><p>More recently, possibilities ranging from autonomous weapons to eugenic application of genetic editing tools have made it clear that the rate of discoveries has outpaced our ability to predict their moral and ethical consequences. How the scientific community addresses these essential questions could mean the difference between societal benefit and dystopia.</p><p><strong>Eric Lander</strong>, president and founding director of the Broad Institute of MIT and Harvard and a principal leader of the Human Genome Project, and <strong>Maria Zuber</strong>, MIT Vice President for Research and the E. A. Griswold Professor of Geophysics, will be joined by Communications Forum director <strong>Seth Mnookin</strong> for a wide-ranging discussion on the ethical issues entangled in innovation and the real, and sometimes devastating, effects of invention without culpability.</p><p><strong>Speakers:</strong></p><p><a href="https://www.broadinstitute.org/bios/eric-s-lander"><strong>Dr. Eric Lander</strong></a> is the president and founding director of the Broad Institute of MIT and Harvard. A geneticist, molecular biologist, and mathematician, he has played a pioneering role in the reading, understanding, and biomedical application of the human genome and was a principal leader of the Human Genome Project.</p><p><a href="https://eapsweb.mit.edu/people/zuber"><strong>Dr. Maria Zuber</strong></a><strong> </strong>is the MIT Vice President for Research and the E. A. Griswold Professor of Geophysics. Dr. Zuber was principal investigator for the Gravity Recovery and Interior Laboratory (GRAIL), the first woman to lead a NASA spacecraft mission, and the first woman to lead a science department at MIT. In her role as Vice President for Research, Dr. Zuber oversees research administration and policy for more than a dozen interdisciplinary research laboratories and centers.</p><p>Moderator: <a href="http://sethmnookin.com/"><strong>Seth Mnookin</strong></a> is the director of the MIT Communications Forum and director of MIT’s Graduate Program in Science Writing. His most recent book, <a href="http://sethmnookin.com/the-panic-virus/"><em>The Panic Virus: The True Story Behind the Vaccine-Autism Controversy</em></a><em>, </em>won the “Science in Society” award from the National Association of Science Writers.</p><p><em>All Communications Forum events are free and open to the general public. Seating is given on a first come, first served basis. There are no tickets. This event is co-sponsored by </em><a href="https://radius.mit.edu/home/"><em>Radius at MIT</em></a><em>.</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/524/1*CpsoySwu2xJ2GAUEbur5Dg.jpeg" /></figure><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FUB3Y5--3jhw%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;url=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DUB3Y5--3jhw&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FUB3Y5--3jhw%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/941116b79bb73ab65bb503e0525cc52d/href">https://medium.com/media/941116b79bb73ab65bb503e0525cc52d/href</a></iframe><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fw.soundcloud.com%2Fplayer%2F%3Furl%3Dhttps%253A%252F%252Fapi.soundcloud.com%252Ftracks%252F529420920%26show_artwork%3Dtrue&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fsoundcloud.com%2Fmit-cmsw%2Fconsequences-americas-miracle-machine-eric-lander-maria-zuber&amp;image=http%3A%2F%2Fi1.sndcdn.com%2Fartworks-000439446513-6edxok-t500x500.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=soundcloud" width="800" height="166" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/f7d2b87c61e5ab85c188b1bf6cf940a5/href">https://medium.com/media/f7d2b87c61e5ab85c188b1bf6cf940a5/href</a></iframe><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*VRaoip4LWi2SeB_8hHgy4g.jpeg" /><figcaption>Seth Mnookin, Dr. Eric Lander, and Dr. Maria Zuber</figcaption></figure><p><strong>Summary</strong></p><p>Summary by <a href="https://cmsw.mit.edu/profile/madeleine-turner/">Madeleine Turner</a>, Photos by Greg Peverill-Conti</p><p>[This is an edited summary, and not a verbatim transcript.]</p><p><strong>Seth Mnookin</strong>, director of the MIT Communications Forum, began by introducing the night’s panel.</p><p><strong>Dr. Eric Lander</strong> is the president and founding director of the Broad Institute, a professor of biology at MIT, and a professor of systems biology at the Harvard Medical School. He was a principle leader of the Human Genome Project. From 2009 to 2017, he served as co-chair on the President’s Council of Advisors on Science and Technology (PCAST) under Barack Obama.</p><p><strong>Dr. Maria Zuber</strong> is the MIT Vice-President for Research and the E.A. Griswold Professor of Geophysics. She has been involved in more than half a dozen NASA planetary missions and is the principle investigator of the Gravity Recovery and Interior Laboratory (GRAIL). She was the first woman to lead a NASA spacecraft mission. In 2016, she was elected chair of the National Science Board, a governing body of the National Science Foundation.</p><p>Mnookin opened the Forum by asking Lander and Zuber when they knew they wanted to become scientists.</p><p>“Science chose me,” Zuber said. According to family lore, Zuber jumped up and down in her playpen as rockets launched in the ’60s. “I wanted to be a scientist forever,” she said. She began building telescopes at the age of six. Eventually she was teaching herself optics and grinding her own lenses.</p><p>Lander did his undergraduate and Ph.D. in mathematics, after he “fell in love with math” in high school. Through his high school program, he took the train up to Columbia on the weekends and learned about <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Galois_theory">Galois theory</a>. After receiving his Ph.D., he realized that he loved math, but didn’t want to do it as a career. Math is very “monastic,” Lander said. After “casting about for a number of years,” he fell in love with genetics.</p><p>Mnookin asked Lander and Zuber if they missed bench science — the day-to-day of overseeing their own experiments.</p><p>Although other responsibilities cut into his time, Lander said that he has never given up on research.</p><p>Zuber agreed. She does, however, have more postdocs, graduate, and undergraduate students in her lab. “After running six space missions, I want to have more impact than I had before,” she said. Today, she wants to “help people create things, and make things happen.”</p><p>“I get a lot of satisfaction out of creating opportunities to allow others to achieve their dreams,” she says. “It’s a rush.”</p><p>Lander agreed.</p><p>“At a place like MIT, you have all these amazing people and projects. You have less time for your own research, but you’re mentoring,” he said. “There’s a satisfaction and joy in that.”</p><p>Mnookin asked Lander and Zuber how they define the “Miracle Machine” — what were its ingredients, and what led the United States to become a leader in technology in the twenty-first century?</p><p>Behind the Miracle Machine, Lander said, is the basic idea that research is “powerful at producing useful things that aren’t obvious.” Research doesn’t need to be focused on finding an application in order to be useful.</p><p>Lander said that the military engineer and inventor <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vannevar_Bush">Vannevar Bush</a> did not want research to be done in government laboratories. Instead, Bush thought it should be done at universities.</p><p>“The first real ingredient of the Miracle Machine is to engage in ideas all around the country,” Lander said.</p><p>Decentralizing research had another, indirect benefit: with students working alongside researchers, you get a “freshness” of ideas. You train people on the bench. Those students go on to work in government and industry.</p><p>“We take it for granted, but it’s a very odd system,” Lander said.</p><p>Other countries jumped on board eventually.</p><p>“The United States was, and in many cases, still is, the best attractor of talent in the world,” Zuber added.</p><p>Mnookin asked Zuber to describe the interplay between “basic research on a decentralized level” and “applied science projects” at NASA.</p><p>Zuber got her Ph.D. when Reagan was president and the United States invested space-based “Star Wars” lasers for ballistic missile defense. It was new technology, but based on fundamental physics.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*aYhxAbZWRtrLZmH_w7x0Kg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Dr. Maria Zuber</figcaption></figure><p>“They were moving to solid-state lasers, as opposed to older designs, which use flash lamps,” Zuber said. “I said to myself, if we’re investing hundreds of millions of dollars in laser technology, I bet you it’s something I can do science with.”</p><p>Zuber got security clearance to learn the laser technology. The energy of the laser, as well as its precision, determined its classification.</p><p>“We just took all those specs and dialed them down until they were unclassified,” Zuber said.</p><p>NASA planned to launch a mission to Mars on the Challenger Space Shuttle, but the Challenger exploded. When they opened a competition for a new altimeter, Zuber and some friends applied by proposing a new laser system. She attributed her success in the competition to her background doing fundamental research on solid-state lasers.</p><p>“What are some of the inventions that we use everyday that came out of basic research?,” Mnookin asked.</p><p>“GPS and cell phones,” Lander said. We can trace GPS back to when Sputnik was launched. Researchers were “trying to figure out how to locate it.” Lander said. “They ad hoc came up with a way of positioning in the way of having multiple signals.”</p><p>Another example is the Internet. The government invested in Internet infrastructure before it was obviously useful.</p><p>The third example of “practical fruitfulness” coming from government-sponsored research is the work of Nobel prize-winning microbiologist Salvador Lurie, Lander said. Lurie worked on a special “restriction” enzyme found in bacteria that helps protect against viruses. The work led to advances in gene editing.</p><p>“If anybody had said, ‘Please build the following for us,’ in a top-down fashion, we never would have gotten these things,” Lander said. At the same time, the discoveries were “no accident.” They “emerged from fundamental curiosity.”</p><p>Space is unforgiving, and you must have every calculation and measurement correct, said Zuber. Not all people who go through training wind up staying in the field.</p><p>“We obviously had the detonation of the atomic bomb in World War II, but our general view was that science is an unalloyed source for good, something that was going to lead us into the future,” Mnookin said. He asked Lander and Zuber if that was truly the zeitgeist.</p><p>Zuber agreed. “We were going to explore and discover,” she said.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*e77Vnn7ez64_biOAS1TReA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Dr. Eric Lander</figcaption></figure><p>Lander said he was brought up on <em>Star Trek</em>. He watched the crew, which included Russians, Americans, and aliens like Spock. It showed him an optimistic view of the future. The message was clear: technology would bring people closer together.</p><p>“Now we’re a couple decades into the twenty-first century, and I think there’s more concern about whether inventions and progress will be used for good,” Mnookin said. We can develop autonomous cars, but also autonomous weapons. Social media connects us, but it also disseminates hate speech.</p><p>“Has a need to pay attention to the implications of science and research cropped up more recently?” Mnookin asked.</p><p>“Science just got incredibly useful,” Lander said. “I think we have a sophisticated understanding that all technologies require responsible behavior.”</p><p>Lander pointed to biotechnologies and genome editing. Gene drives might get rid of malaria, or “they might screw up our environments completely.” Both can be true.</p><p>Zuber pointed out the tension between creating new artificial intelligence technologies and putting people out of jobs. The MIT ethos is to “make a better world; we want to help people,” she said. Zuber added that a “huge amount of effort” is going on at MIT to “think the issues through” and to deal with “ethical considerations in parallel with discovery.”</p><p>Lander said that he notices a cultural difference between the East and West coast. Californians exhibit techno-optimism — the notion that tech will solve all our problems. On the East Coast, the community shows a greater sense of responsibility for seeing that technology won’t get misused.</p><p>Mnookin asked if the notion of “parallel ethical responsibility” has become more pronounced recently. He compared the situation in the tech sector to what’s currently happening in journalism. In the past, Mnookin says, “our job was to put out information, let people decide.” Journalists have realized over several decades that this isn’t enough. Journalists are grappling with a need to have ethical guidelines. Could the same be true for scientists?</p><p>Zuber said that she has seen more discussions on ethics lately.</p><p>“Students come in…and whatever they work on, they’re really committed to leaving this world a better place,” she said.</p><p>Zuber partially attributes the do-good attitude to community service requirements in elementary school. She mentioned a fusion startup that began at MIT. They worked with high field superconducting magnets, hoping to make a fusion power plant the size of a room instead of a football field.</p><p>“They don’t want to be billionaires or to win the Nobel prize,” Zuber said. “They started doing this because they are really concerned about climate change.”</p><p>Mnookin wondered why we see a difference, in terms of service and a sense of responsibility, between current and earlier generations. Do young people sense “the precariousness of our situation,” or is it the effect of community service built into the curriculum at an early age?</p><p>Earlier generations never saw people in other parts of the world, where people might be living in poverty, Zuber said. She added that the view of Earth from Apollo 8 also changed people’s thinking. Zuber grew up in a coal mining town in Pennsylvania. Her father was a policeman, and he had one of the highest paying jobs in town.</p><p>“I didn’t think I was poor, because everyone was kind of the same [where she lived],” she said.</p><p>Mnookin asked Lander to explain his East Coast-West Coast theory. Does the difference stem from an “accumulation of wealth” in the tech sector?</p><p>Lander said he’s “not a cultural anthropologist.” But at West Coast dinner parties, he sees a higher proportion of people who think technology will “work it all out.” People on the West Coast are still “grappling with the idea that social media doesn’t happily unite everybody.” He noted that institutions on the East Coast are older and “more rooted in the humanities.”</p><p>“Things need to be done by the society, not in the interest of a company,” Lander said, adding that he wants to see more discussion about the role that government plays and its responsibilities.</p><p>“A lot of the country is left out of the tech revolution entirely.” Lander said. “This can’t be a good thing for the country in the long run.”</p><p>Zuber said we need to think about how people who are displaced from their jobs can benefit from the new economy. Otherwise, our society will become unstable.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*8KZJeZ-BLK1kvgXNWP4aFQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Dr. Eric Lander</figcaption></figure><p>Lander added that it’s also important to look at the distribution of income. People saw incomes rise in the nineties, but that was only on average. The overall distribution of income showed a less promising picture, with a smaller group of people benefiting.</p><p>Mnookin said that it appears as if we are inching towards instability. “Can the technology sector engage in ways that can help us move past that?,” he asked.</p><p>Zuber recently reviewed <a href="https://climate.mit.edu/users/mit-climate-action">MIT’s Climate Action Plan</a>, which includes information on reaching populations who might not be interested in climate change otherwise.</p><p>“It has been important to avoid preaching to the choir,” she said. “It’s great if people understand climate change, but if we only speak to them, we’re not helping. Let’s figure out who the messenger ought to be.”</p><p>A good messenger could be someone’s child, or maybe a local religious leader.</p><p>Lander brought the conversation around to city-wide climate change initiatives. For example, when Pittsburgh had extremely bad air pollution, “they invented the air quality index,” he said. Suddenly, the problem became less abstract. By making pollution measurable, people became motivated to clean up the air. In contrast, “don’t talk about what might happen two hundred years from now,” he said. It doesn’t engage people.</p><p>“What keeps you up at night, in terms of areas of science where we’re not grappling with the implications?,” Mnookin asked.</p><p>Zuber said that she’s concerned about the federal budget for basic science. In terms of buying power, the budget is down.</p><p>“I worry about the level of investment that the US is making relative to other parts of the world,” she said. “Other countries have read our playbook and realize that investment in science means you’re getting educated people who can start companies.”</p><p>Today, the United States shares a smaller share of the pie in terms of discovery, but we can also “benefit from discovery in other places,” Zuber said.</p><p>Zuber also expressed particular concern with the biotech industry. The United States has limits to the kind of data we collect, while the Chinese government “takes all those data,” she said. “If we think about personalized medicine and treatments, that leads to a mismatch.”</p><p>Lander said that the inability to share data in biotech and medicine isn’t so much a question of privacy as much as it is a technical problem. We “haven’t forced the healthcare system to be a learning system,” he said. Most people think that we are sharing data and learning from it, he said. “In fact, [patients] want us to have a medical system where we’re sharing data.”</p><p>Zuber also said that she worries about STEM education in the United States. Robotics competitions in our country fill high school gyms, while in China, they “fill stadiums.” The implication is that United States should step up immigration “of talented people from abroad,” Zuber said.</p><p>Mnookin asked if Zuber and Lander have any “meta-concerns” — areas where ethical considerations might be overlooked.</p><p>Lander mentioned geoengineering to combat climate change. Some friends think that geoengineering is a viable climate change solution, while others view it as potentially catastrophic and therefore unethical.</p><p>“There is no bright line that separates bioengineering from bioweapons,” he said.</p><p>Along similar lines, we could use artificial intelligence to predict suicide risk, or we could misuse AI to decide who should be serving longer terms in jail.</p><p>“We aren’t struggling with [these issues] enough,” Lander said. “They’re daunting problems” and we need students from a range of disciplines to be excited to tackle the world’s problems.</p><p>Mnookin asked what can we do to incentivize scientists to change culture.</p><p>Panels such as this one are helpful, Lander said, adding that this discussion would not be happening five years ago.</p><p>Zuber said that faculty also need to be aware of ethical issues in their fields.</p><p>Mnookin asked if it be helpful to have some sort of requirement that whenever a faculty member does research, maybe their proposal should include an ethical component?</p><p>“You’re going to get boilerplate statements,” Zuber said.</p><p>Lander agreed. Once you make an ethical statement is a requirement, it becomes something to check off a box. That’s not enough. It needs to be more “vibrant,” Lander said. You need people “arguing about this stuff.”</p><p>Mnookin asked if there was a way to make ethical considerations more organic. How do you promote discussion instead of “waiting for awareness to bubble up in the culture?”</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*XM74ugH6PXKHSeed6uwLsw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Dr. Maria Zuber</figcaption></figure><p>Zuber said that leaders have a responsibility to raise issues. At the same time, “things work a lot better if they bubble up.”</p><p>Lander brought up the introductory biology course he teaches at MIT. One session of that class is devoted to biology and society. He would like to see ethical questions permeating beyond that one class.</p><p>“We need to do it well, to challenge people to think freshly about it,” he said.</p><p>Mnookin then opened the forum to the audience for questions.</p><p><strong>Josh</strong>, a fourth-year MIT undergrad, asked if the panelists were confident that the basic research they’ve engaged in throughout their careers “will leave the world better than how you found it?”</p><p>If we could predict which research was net-bad, we’d shut it down, Lander said. But we don’t know where research leads, and it could lead to something good. People who developed nuclear energy have a lifelong responsibility to make sure it’s not used for destruction. Lander believes his own work results in “unbalanced-good” because he’s an optimist. “But I don’t think it happens without a tremendous amount of work.”</p><p>Zuber said that looking after discoveries and “making sure they get used well” is part of the reason why she and Lander spend less time in the lab. She said that she participates in advisory councils “to ponder these things and put out thoughtful reports.”</p><p><strong>One audience member</strong> said that she is taking a bioethics class and mentioned a specific case about institutional review boards. She asked about how a consensus be formed when people on review boards represent “diverse and different” viewpoints.</p><p>The MIT institutional review board currently sits under Zuber’s office. Recently, they added a humanist to the board, since they found it important to “get those voices into the discussion,” she said.</p><p>Lander said that he sees two possible outcomes. We can yell and “harden” differences, or we can say, “I’ve got to understand what you’re thinking,” he said. “It bothers me to no end that social discourse goes in this fashion of polarization. There is no good outcome to polarization.”</p><p>Mnookin asked Zuber if there was something in particular that sparked the addition of a social scientist to the review board.</p><p>Zuber said that the move to add a social scientist was motivated by an increasing number of discussions within the scientific community about these issues.</p><p>Mnookin asked if having a social scientist is common on review boards.</p><p>The panelists both said that it is common in medicine, but not in other areas of science.</p><p><strong>A project coordinator who works at the Broad Institute</strong> asked if ethical responsibility will always be put on the individual. What kinds of groups can be involved with ethical questions and the Miracle Machine?</p><p>Zuber said that she hopes many people are involved in the ethical questions. She “frankly expects” the government to get involved, but questioned the right way for that to happen, adding that “there has to be a sufficient number of voices involved in this to keep a rational decision.”</p><p>Lander said that people often take initiative to create their own groups, citing the <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pugwash_Conferences_on_Science_and_World_Affairs">Pugwash Conferences on Science and World Affairs</a> in the 1950s as one example of a group that organized in response to ethical questions in science.</p><p>Mnookin brought the conversation around to what should be done with countries that do not adhere to ethical norms. China, for example, has frequently bucked Western traditions when it comes to ethical standards.</p><p>China has learned a lot from us, Zuber said, and we have learned from China in certain ways, too.</p><p>“We’ve got to get everyone to play by a set of established rules, and if we do that, we can all learn from each other and continue to collaborate,” she said, adding that scientific journals and diplomacy have roles to play in this issue.</p><p>Mnookin asked what happens if countries don’t comply.</p><p>“Things are going to change in terms of access” to research and data, Zuber said.</p><p>Currently, we’re seeing a migration from a rule-based international order, Lander said, to countries exerting power because they can. For China, the best defense in the long run may be “entanglement.”</p><p>“Countries that actually benefit from each other tend not to go to war with each other,” he said.</p><p><strong>Jason Dearen</strong>, a Knight Science Journalism fellow at MIT, said he lived in San Francisco for twenty-three years and witnessed the local government giving away public resources to tech companies. Now “firemen, policemen and teachers can’t afford to live there.” He pointed out that similar changes are happening in the Cambridge area, one example being the construction of the new life science buildings at MIT. Dearen asked if MIT is eyeing mistakes made on the West coast and considering ways to develop Cambridge responsibility.</p><p>Zuber said that MIT would not build in Kendall Square if the plan wasn’t approved by Cambridge City Council.</p><p>“Lots of people are spending lots of time on that,” she said. “We have to live here.”</p><p>Lander said that responsibility falls to the city government. Maybe there is a formula that funnels corporate real estate taxes into affordable housing to promote economic diversity. Thus far, finding this kind of sustainable formula has not be found. Community organizations and journalists could play a vital role in pushing for finding the correct mix.</p><p>Mnookin asked Zuber if the development includes funding for affordable housing. She said that it does.</p><p><strong>A third-year computer science undergrad</strong> said that billions of dollars invested in the biological technology industry but organizations aimed at keeping the general public safe from bioweapons are often critically underfunded. She asked how we can balance investment in creating new technologies while also investing in preparedness.</p><p>Zuber said discussions like these are going on constantly. Compared to “building the next big plane or the next big ship,” the Pentagon has less expertise on bioterror hazards. Former Secretary of Defense <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ash_Carter">Ash Carter</a> and a team from the Pentagon spent time at MIT and the Broad Institute, educating themselves on what these risks were, so the Pentagon could better plan for them. Zuber said that there are lots of people involved in defense who are interested in these conversations. She believes that we will see more work being done in areas of prevention.</p><p>Lander said that to become good at defeating bioweapons, “we’re going to have to practice on natural disease” by using technology in an offensive, rather than defensive, manner.</p><p><strong>A Ph.D. student in computer science</strong> asked about changing the research culture. She wondered if current scientific disciplines appreciate interdisciplinary research. “The norms and ways to benchmark accomplishments are baked into established fields” and might not reward interdisciplinary work.</p><p>To have MIT’s new <a href="http://news.mit.edu/2018/mit-reshapes-itself-stephen-schwarzman-college-of-computing-1015">College of Computing</a> succeed, “we’ll have to what you just said,” Zuber said. In general, to support interdisciplinary work, “you have to be really smart about how you do your assessment,” Zuber said, adding that if MIT goes by “traditional stovepipes” of faculty evaluation, that interdisciplinary component will not be realized. Having people with diverse experience serving on committees that make decisions is the only way to facilitate interdisciplinary work on a granular level.</p><p>Lander said that some of the most exciting research happens in the boundaries of research fields, though these pioneering efforts are often not valued in the short term. He encouraged the audience member to keep pursuing research at those edges. “The story usually works out ok, you just have to be more stubborn,” he said.</p><p>Catherine Clark, an associate professor of French Studies at MIT, asked why the Institute doesn’t have an ethics requirement for MIT undergraduates.</p><p>Zuber said an ethics requirements has been discussed along with project-based learning, statistics, diversity, and climate change course requirements. She said that she thinks the best option is to incorporate ethics into courses that are already offered.</p><p>Lander agreed. A standalone ethics class might be less effective; everyone would feel like they need to “take their caster oil.” But if every course had embedded ethics, people would say, “ethics is not a separate thing. It’s part of the thing,” Lander said.</p><p>Zuber said that Stephen Schwarzman, the donor for the new College of Computing, made it clear that ethics would be an important part of the curriculum. She said that she believes that ethics will increasingly permeate other MIT courses.</p><p><strong>Michael Simon</strong>, a former MIT employee, asked if Lander, Zuber, and Mnookin took inspiration and found value from outside areas like poetry, literature, and nature.</p><p>Although Zuber was focused on being a space scientist from an early age, she did have a fellowship at Radcliffe. “That year, I read every book on the <em>New York Times</em> bestseller list,” she said. “You had to, or else, if you went to lunch, you had nothing to say.” She said a liberal arts education made her a better scientist. She learned how communicate her work to people who aren’t scientists. “It helped me immensely,” she said.</p><p>Lander said that his mother took him to the 1965 World’s Fair in New York that his mother took him to see it 13 times. “Boy, it opened my eyes to the fact that there was a world out there, which in my corner of Brooklyn, you might not have known,” he said. He also took John McPhee’s nonfiction writing class at Princeton, which still influences Lander’s writing to this day.</p><p>“When I write scientific papers, I still have McPhee’s editorial voice in my head,” he said.</p><p>Lander also credited a Renaissance architecture course he took as providing him with a sense of how art tells a story over time.</p><p>Mnookin said that his entire career is based on exposure to things, then getting having he freedom to get obsessed with them until moving on. He said that he was heavily influenced by essays by biologist <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lewis_Thomas">Lewis Thomas</a>. Mnookin also did stints as a music critic and sports writer before turning to science writing.</p><p>“I think journalism is the best career anyone could ever have,” he said, adding that the most exciting thing about it is, “it gives one the freedom to find something that’s exciting, then go the best people in that area and say ‘Spend a lot of time with me and teach me everything you know.’”</p><p>Mnookin then thanked the panelists and the Forum’s co-sponsor, Radius at MIT.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=6846113ef0c5" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/mit-communications-forum/november-8-2018-is-america-losing-its-miracle-machine-6846113ef0c5">The Consequences of America’s Miracle Machine: November 8, 2018</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/mit-communications-forum">The Communications Forum at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[What’s So Funny About Oppressive Regimes? October 18, 2018]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/mit-communications-forum/october-18-2018-whats-so-funny-about-oppressive-regimes-474134b2fa98?source=rss-83297b59b005------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/474134b2fa98</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[mit-communications-forum]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[past-forums]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[comedy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[sara-taksler]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[tickling-giants]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[CommForum]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 07 Sep 2018 21:06:17 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-10-25T19:54:49.850Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/750/1*pznO0g_VFqeGIZvjOVJOIw.jpeg" /></figure><p>A senior producer on <em>The Daily Show </em>meets the Egyptian Jon Stewart and documents his fight for comedy and free speech.</p><p>Thursday, October 18, 2018<br>6:00–8:00 pm<br>Room <a href="https://whereis.mit.edu/?go=3">3–270</a>, MIT</p><p>As a senior producer on <em>The Daily Show </em>with Jon Stewart and Trevor Noah, <strong>Sara Taksler</strong> has spent her career taking comedic pot shots at politicians. When she met Dr. Bassem Youssef, an Egyptian satirist who uses comedy to criticize Middle Eastern politics, Taksler witnessed first-hand how laughter thrives, even in terrifying circumstances. <a href="http://www.ticklinggiants.com/"><em>Tickling Giants</em></a>, Taksler’s documentary about Youssef, is a hilarious story about finding comedy in unexpected places. Taksler joins <strong>Amber Day</strong>, author of <a href="https://www.amazon.com/Satire-Dissent-Interventions-Contemporary-Political/dp/0253222818"><em>Satire and Dissent: Interventions in Contemporary Political Debate</em></a>, to discuss the power of free speech and what’s so funny about oppressive regimes. A screening of <em>Tickling Giants</em> will be held at MIT in Room 26–100 on Friday, October 19th at 7pm.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FNImW9pJ1_8E%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;url=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DNImW9pJ1_8E&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FNImW9pJ1_8E%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/bb470ac88c6481f14ed922ce6c486abf/href">https://medium.com/media/bb470ac88c6481f14ed922ce6c486abf/href</a></iframe><p><strong>Speaker:</strong></p><p><strong>Sara Taksler</strong> is a senior producer on <em>The Daily Show </em>with Trevor Noah and creator of the documentaries <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=B504NyWMg68"><em>TWISTED: A Balloonamentary</em></a><em> </em>and<em> Stop the Ignorance: The Beauty That Is New Jersey. </em>Her latest documentary, <em>Tickling Giants</em>, premiered at the 2016 Tribeca Film Festival.</p><p><strong>Amber Day</strong> is a professor in the English and Cultural Studies department at Bryant University who studies the intersections of art and political speech, including satire and irony, political performance and activism, and public debate. She is also the author of <a href="https://www.amazon.com/Satire-Dissent-Interventions-Contemporary-Political/dp/0253222818"><em>Satire and Dissent: Interventions in Contemporary Political Debate</em></a><em>.</em></p><p><em>All Communications Forum events are free and open to the general public. Seating is given on a first come, first served basis. There are no tickets. This event is co-sponsored by MIT Political Science and the de Florez Fund for Humor.</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*3HDqx1nOAxMA5tHyYG1xFg.jpeg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*uXllEeuE9c2zEMgku9ugvQ.jpeg" /></figure><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fw.soundcloud.com%2Fplayer%2F%3Furl%3Dhttps%253A%252F%252Fapi.soundcloud.com%252Ftracks%252F516765108%26show_artwork%3Dtrue&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fsoundcloud.com%2Fmit-cmsw%2Fwhats-so-funny-about-oppressive-regimes&amp;image=http%3A%2F%2Fi1.sndcdn.com%2Fartworks-000424183317-0z6fed-t500x500.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=soundcloud" width="800" height="166" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/33004d4ecedde557abd71304a0c5bf75/href">https://medium.com/media/33004d4ecedde557abd71304a0c5bf75/href</a></iframe><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2F3f3XX4ars8w%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;url=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3D3f3XX4ars8w&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2F3f3XX4ars8w%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/edb442809ad6e458105253793e1a2a44/href">https://medium.com/media/edb442809ad6e458105253793e1a2a44/href</a></iframe><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*vJRGf5_tKwd5r0VBS3MD5Q.jpeg" /><figcaption>Amber Day (left) and Sara Taksler</figcaption></figure><p><strong>Summary</strong></p><p>By: Christina Couch, Photos by Greg Peverill-Conti</p><p>[This is an edited summary, and not a verbatim transcript.]</p><p><strong>Seth Mnookin</strong>, director of the MIT Communications Forum introduced the speakers, then screened <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2w3PTW58fSE">the trailer</a> for <em>Tickling Giants</em>.</p><p><strong>Amber Day, </strong>author of<em> </em><a href="https://www.amazon.com/Satire-Dissent-Interventions-Contemporary-Political/dp/0253222818"><em>Satire and Dissent: Interventions in Contemporary Political Debate</em></a>, opened the Forum by asking documentary film producer <strong>Sara Taksler </strong>what made her want to follow Bassem Youssef and create this film. Tickling Giants was a strict departure from Taksler’s earlier work on <em>The Daily Show</em>.</p><p>Taksler said that she met Youssef at <em>The Daily Show</em>. Youssef asked if he could observe how <em>The Daily Show</em> operated, which was something no one had done at the show before. Taksler said that she was particularly interested in the fact that Youssef was a heart surgeon at the time.</p><p>“I couldn’t imagine Jon Stewart doing heart surgery during the day and then hosting <em>The Daily Show</em> at night,” she said.</p><p>Taksler had also wanted to follow a late night show in the year leading up to an election and was inspired by <em>The War Room</em>, a film wherein the most famous person featured plays a very small role and the focus is more on the surrounding staff. When she met Bassem, “I thought this is that story with much, much higher stakes,” she said.</p><p>Taksler noticed that among the people Youssef brought to observe <em>The Daily Show,</em> half were women. Curious about what the life of her late night counterpart in Egypt might look like, Taksler impulsively asked Youssef if she could make a movie about him and he said yes.</p><p>Day asked how long Taksler filmed in Egypt.</p><p>Taksler said that she met Youssef in 2012, but the story of <em>Tickling Giants</em> begins in 2011. They filmed until 2014 in Egypt, then later in the United States. Taksler said that late night shows typically have 10 “dark weeks” wherein the staff is off. She used those breaks to work on the film.</p><p>Day said that Youssef is described as “Egypt’s Jon Stewart,” but at the height of his popularity, Youssef’s audience was much, much larger than <em>Daily Show</em> audiences.</p><p>“Unlike anything we’ve ever had here,” Taksler said. Youssef got between 30 and 40 million viewers per episode. Stewart got around two million per episode at the peak of <em>The Daily Show</em>’s popularity. Taksler compared Youssef’s show to “the Super Bowl, but it was every week.”</p><p>One reason for Youssef’s popularity was that political humor wasn’t allowed in Egypt, especially humor at the expense of those in power. There were comedy shows, but they predominantly centered around poking fun at more mundane topics such as traffic or the weather.</p><p>“Some people were tuning in because they loved watching it and some people were tuning in because they hated him,” she said.</p><p>Taksler said that Youssef started comparing himself to Jon Stewart. When he came to observe <em>The Daily Show</em>, Youssef charmed the staff and was eventually asked to come on the show as a guest. At the time, most people in Egypt were not watching <em>The Daily Show</em>.</p><p>The <em>Tickling Giants</em> trailer features Jon Stewart visiting Youssef’s set in Egypt. Day asked if Taksler was instrumental in setting that up.</p><p>Taksler said that Youssef really wanted Stewart to visit. While directing <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rosewater_(film)"><em>Rosewater</em></a> in the Middle East, Stewart offered to come visit Youssef’s set.</p><p>By the time Taksler began filming in Egypt, she already had several years of experience at <em>The Daily Show</em>. Day asked how Youssef’s show operated in comparison.</p><p>Taksler said, “big picture, very similar. Detail-wise, very different.” When Taksler arrived, she noticed that “everyone kind of looked and acted like the people I worked with at home, but there were Akmeds instead of Adams.” Taksler said that the atmospheres of both shows were very similar, but there were significant differences in terms of staff make-up. On Youssef’s show, very few people had a television background. Many were attorneys, architects, or recent college graduates who did not have any broadcast experience. She added that <em>The Daily Show</em> also had greater resources for quickly finding clips for the show whereas Youssef’s staff had to manually go through every political show, create their own transcriptions, and pull clips.</p><p>Day asked if Youssef’s staff also worked other jobs.</p><p>Taksler said that everyone was full-time, though there were a few interns who were still in school.</p><p>Day said that the trailer shows how Youssef and his staff were in danger while doing their jobs. She asked if Taksler also felt like she was in danger.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*FQTNzsZsc68vNQQBJT9-ig.jpeg" /><figcaption>Sara Taksler</figcaption></figure><p>Taksler said that the level of danger came as a surprise and, at the time, she didn’t realize how much of a “lightening rod” Youssef was. Even today, when Youssef walks down the street in the United States, he still encounters both fans and aggressive critics. When Taksler was making the film, one of her camera people got beaten up and his footage was stolen. She made it a point to keep a low profile while filming in Egypt.</p><p>At one point while filming, a series of protests outside of Youssef’s building caused concern that the building might be firebombed. Taksler was filming outside the building and was asked to go inside in order to draw less attention. At the time, there were rumors that Youssef was a CIA operative and people were afraid that Taksler’s presence as a non-Egyptian might convince others that the rumor was true. During a different protest at a later date, someone on Youssef’s staff advised Taksler not to come film.</p><p>“I talked to Bassem and he was like, ‘I think you should come because I’m going to be there and worst case scenario, you get blown up and if you do, a <em>Daily Show</em> producer got blown up at my show and that’s great publicity,’ ” Taksler quipped.</p><p><em>60 Minutes</em> also happened to be shooting a profile on Youssef at the time. The security detail for <em>60 Minutes</em> showed Taksler the escape route they had planned in case anything went awry. Fortunately, things were ok that day.</p><p>Taksler said that there were also times when she didn’t know if she was in danger. For instance, there were rumors that staff at her hotel had turned in Al Jazeera journalists to the Egyptian police. Another time, Taksler noticed a man staring at her at her hotel. Taksler told Youssef what was happening and Youssef told her the man was flirting with her. The next morning, Taksler told women in Youssef’s office what happened and they confirmed that it was a flirtation and not a dangerous situation.</p><p>Day asked if the film screened in Egypt.</p><p>Taksler said that the film is available through Netflix outside of the United States, including Egypt. There was one public screening at a university in Cairo. A Skype interview was set up with Youssef, but the day before the event, the university requested that Youssef pull out. The government would not allow the screening to take place if the interview with Youssef went through, but authorities also did not want to look bad for shutting the interview down. Youssef pulled out of the interview, but the screening did go forward.</p><p>Day asked Taksler if, at the time during filming, she had a sense that Youssef’s show was going to be so controversial.</p><p>Taksler said that when she started filming, the story that interested her was really about the term “tickling giants.” That phrase came from a cartoon drawn by a member of Youssef’s staff. The cartoon features Youssef holding a giant feather tickling the foot of a giant. The phrase came to refer to an individual finding a creative, non-violent way to draw attention to an abuse of power. Taksler thought that her story was about the fact that Youssef was a regular person who found the spotlight through finding non-violent, humorous ways to point out political issues.</p><p>“Most of us aren’t going to start a comedy show and become one of the most famous comedians in the world probably, but everyone has a thing they could do and that’s what was interesting,” she said.</p><p>Taksler did not believe that Youssef’s life would become as complicated as it did during the course of filming.</p><p>Day asked what Youssef is doing now.</p><p>Taksler said that Yousself lives in Los Angeles and is currently trying to make it as a performer and writer. He hopes to one day land a Netflix special or a politically-themed show of his own. While he’s reinventing himself in the United States, he appears at <em>Tickling Giants</em> screenings and he has a one-man show in New York.</p><p>Day asked if Youssef has traveled back to Egypt since his show was shut down there.</p><p>Taksler said no. Due to legal issues, Youssef has avoided returning.</p><p>Day asked Taksler what she thinks Youssef’s legacy is in Egypt.</p><p>Taksler said that while editing the film, they talked about whether or not Youssef has a legacy of hope. Several Egyptians working on film said that the movie shouldn’t feel too hopeful because then viewers will walk away believing that the problems are solved. They also believed that the film shouldn’t feel too devastating because it might discourage viewers from trying to fix problems. Taksler said that she aimed to leave the audience with a feeling that was “somewhere in the middle.” Taksler believes that Youssef’s legacy is a hope that political satire and free speech can exist within Egypt, but that’s not the reality yet. Youssef is often quick to point out that revolutions do not happen overnight. Taksler said that she hopes that his story will inspire people to do more. Comedians within Egypt are still attempting to bring political satire and the ability to openly criticize government to the country.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*EAHd33cZsaRosc1J_C9x0w.jpeg" /><figcaption>Amber Day</figcaption></figure><p>Day said that <em>Tickling Giants</em> has a strong call to action, which is unusual for a documentary. She asked Taksler to talk about her thinking behind that.</p><p>Taksler said that the call to action is that each person should find their own way to tickle giants. Taksler pointed to MIT’s <a href="https://www.makethebreastpumpnotsuck.com/">Make the Breast Pump Not Suck hackathon</a> as a good example of people using their specific talents to knock down barriers that currently exist for nursing mothers. Liron Lavi Turkenich,<a href="https://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/middle-east/israeli-woman-new-typeface-aravit-arabic-hebrew-co-existence-palestinian-muslim-world-a7768646.html"> a typeface designer who created a font that combines Hebrew and Arabic</a> in an effort to promote co-existence between those who speak either language, is another example of someone using their specific talents to solve problems. Taksler added that there are several ways to find your method of tickling giants. If you can’t find the exact right way you should tickle giants, she advocated helping someone else get their project off the ground.</p><p>Though <em>Tickling Giants</em> was made prior to the 2016 Presidential election, Taksler has said that experiencing it now in the current political climate often feels different for viewers. Some have asked if she has updated the film. Day asked what Taksler believes viewers are now seeing anew.</p><p>Taksler said that even the editor of the film, the last person who touched it, recently asked her when she changed the film. Taksler said that she also felt different after watching the film following the election. She said that she believes that viewers originally saw the film as a story that took place somewhere else, whereas now they view it more as something that could possibly happen in the United States. Taksler said that certain things were not included in the film because they weren’t realities in the US, but now they are. The idea of fake news, for example, wasn’t included in the film because that was not a conversation topic in the US at the time. The idea of paid protestors is another example. Donald Trump’s insistence on going after comedians and the press on Twitter has also added to the feeling that the events in <em>Tickling Giants</em> could happen here.</p><p>Shortly after the 2016 election, Taksler emailed a political cartoonist on Youssef’s staff and asked what one should do when your country changes in a negative way. The cartoonist said that the first step is to recognize that the country didn’t change; you just might not have recognized what it was the whole time. From there, you keep going and try to stay motivated and active, he said.</p><p>Day said that Trump has a thin skin and weighs in on comedians in way that previous presidents haven’t. Day asked if Taksler is tempted to try to get a reaction from him.</p><p>Taksler said no.</p><p>“It’s pathetic when a president engages in a fight like that,” she said.</p><p>Making jokes about situations that are already so absurd is a far more difficult challenge.</p><p>Day segued into the late night comedy world. Late night has historically been dominated by white men. She asked if Taksler found particular challenges working in that industry as a woman.</p><p>Taksler said that when filming, she was shocked that the vast majority of Youssef’s staff were women. Taksler assumed that it would be tougher for women to break into late night there, but that was not the case. Within the US, there is more gender parity within the late night world, but there are still significant problems. She credited Trevor Noah for his efforts to diversify his staff. The more diverse late night hosts are, the more diverse staff will be. Taksler also noted that there needs to be more diversity among entry-level staff positions, but the situation has changed substantially since she first began in the industry. Her first year working as a producer, she would frequently find herself in the writer’s room and among 30 people, only two were women.</p><p>“It became a running joke that I would pitch these kind of dark stories, but really it was just pitching stories about women’s issues and I think people were a little less comfortable doing that,” she said.</p><p>That situation as “dramatically changed,” she said. Men now feel more comfortable pitching issues around historically women’s issues, such as sexual harassment and campus rape.</p><p>Day said that she is currently doing research on feminist comedians, specifically how the rise of feminist comedians has brought out both new stories centered around women’s issues as well as vitriolic trolling leveraged more heavily at women than men. Two prime examples of the type of trolling and criticism that result from feminist jokes include the backlash Michelle Wolf experienced after performing at the White House Correspondents’ Dinner and the criticism Samantha Bee took after calling Ivanka Trump an expletive. Day asked Taksler what that level of vitriol feels like from the inside.</p><p>Taksler said that with regard to Michelle Wolf’s backlash, that criticism was a direct result of Wolf being a woman.</p><p>“She didn’t do anything that lots of guys haven’t done in that same room before her and she was funnier than a lot of them,” Taksler said.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*gWd8r7tjURVmGAMRFhIvdw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Sara Taksler</figcaption></figure><p>Taksler said that everyone should have stood up for Wolf. With Youssef’s story, he was the only person doing political satire within Egypt, so it was easy for people to lob criticism directly at him. Likewise, since there are fewer women in comedy within the US, it’s easier for those few to bear the brunt of criticism for things that male comedians have done for years.</p><p>Day noted that even the tweet that ignited criticism of Michelle Wolf portrayed Sarah Sanders as a wife and mother who shouldn’t be made fun of, rather than a public figure within the Trump administration.</p><p>Taksler said that some version of this scenario of women being punished disproportionately plays out in all sorts of contexts and is not exclusive to the comedy world.</p><p>Day brought the conversation around to Jordan Klepper’s now canceled series, <a href="http://www.cc.com/shows/the-opposition-with-jordan-klepper"><em>The Opposition</em></a>. She asked if Taksler believes that it’s becoming harder for these types of political shows to distinguish themselves.</p><p>Taksler said that <em>The Opposition</em> was a character show, which is often harder to pull off than a straight satire show. Unlike Stephen Colbert, who had already portrayed his <em>Colbert Show</em> character while on <em>The Daily Show</em>, Klepper had not done that character previously. Taksler said that the landscape for comedy could shift again and there might be space for a show like <em>The Opposition</em> in the future.</p><p>Day asked if Taksler knows what her next project will be.</p><p>Taksler said that she’s throwing around a few ideas for a late night-style show focusing on stories relating to women and minorities. She said that she’s also taking some time to do talks on college campuses.</p><p>Day opened up the Forum to audience questions.</p><p><strong>Tanya Ballard Brown,</strong> an editor at NPR and a fellow at the Nieman Foundation, asked Taksler what she learned watching Youssef’s show being produced and brought back to the US.</p><p>Taksler said that Youssef’s show often featured big song and dance numbers that weren’t often the type of material presented on <em>The Daily Show</em>. She said that she was very struck by how motivated Youssef’s staff was by <em>The Daily Show</em> and she felt a greater appreciation for free speech within the US and the ability to make politically poignant comedy.</p><p><strong>Seth Mnookin</strong>, director of the MIT Communications Forum, asked Taksler what effect <em>The Daily Show</em> has in the current political climate, and if the role that comedy plays is different within truly oppressive regimes versus wannabe oppressive regimes.</p><p>Taksler said that there are several <em>Daily Show</em>-type shows that have sprung up worldwide. She believes the impact depends on what the audience does with it. Within the US, many people share comedy segments, but the effect is limited. Like prayer, which doesn’t change things in and of itself but does change people who in turn take action, comedy changes people but does not have an effect in and of itself.</p><p>Youssef’s experience inspired people, in part because he used multiple clips to showcase politicians being hypocritical rather than simply making jokes at their expense. Taksler pointed to research by Sophia McClennen, founding director of Penn State’s Center for Global Studies, which found that people who just watch news aren’t likely to be politically active, but people who watch political satire are likely to take action.</p><p>Day said that journalists often interview her for stories about political humor, and she’s noticed that the media has an unfortunately superficial way of talking about satire. She is often asked if a single comedy sketch will change the course of an election or have a strong impact on a politician’s career.</p><p>“It’s such a strange way to measure efficacy because it’s like very little in human history actually operates that way where one thing will suddenly change everyone’s mind and one thing brings down a wall,” she said. “That’s just not how stuff happens.”</p><p>Satire, instead, slowly shifts conversation and can introduce new terms into a debate. Shifting that conversation in small ways has a significant impact and has an influence over larger cultural change. Often sharing comedic clips is dismissed as preaching to the converted, but there is a reason why people who agree with each other come together to have a shared sense of community, Day added.</p><p>Taksler agreed. She said that one thing she’s been surprised by is how politically diverse fans of the film are. On to the way to one screening, Taksler received a call from someone who told her that Ted Cruz was a fan of the film. She later learned that Glenn Beck was a fan. She was also asked to screen the film at a function for the Koch family, which later turned into multiple screenings. The first screening was held the weekend that Trump’s travel ban on Muslims was announced. During the question and answer portion of the event, Taksler said that Youssef is a perfect example of a Muslim coming to the United States because it was not safe for him at home.</p><p>“We had a good conversation and the next day, the Kochs issued a statement condemning the Muslim ban,” she said, adding that she has no way of knowing if that choice was related to her statements, but the reaction did make her feel hopeful.</p><p>Free speech is an issue that both liberals and conservatives deeply care about, though they often focus on individual iterations of how they view free speech as being under attack.</p><p><strong>Julie Fox</strong>, a member of the general public, asked Taksler if, given the level of intimidation many journalists feel in the current political climate, there has been a greater emphasis on censorship within writers rooms.</p><p>Taksler said that it might be the most dangerous time in history to be a journalist. There are frequent conversations about what should be said on late night shows, but these typically don’t revolve around censorship. Instead, they often center around whether a particular joke is offensive. Topics about things like the children of public figures are often viewed as off limits. There are also lots of conversations about how to handle heavy topics, such as school shootings, and whether those issues should be addressed at all. At a late show, when a devastating crisis happens, the morning meeting often starts by viewing clips of the event and trying to carve out some sort of poignant angle from there.</p><p>“You start the meeting with something that feels unthinkable and an hour later there’s usually at least one thread that feels kind of cathartic and you work on that for the rest of the day,” she said. “…Those are my favorite pieces, the ones where you don’t think there’s any way you could possibly do it in the morning and then you find a way.”</p><p>Especially in the current political climate, it’s especially important to have that kind of accountability. Throughout history, even in the worst of circumstances, people have made jokes and found hints of levity. It’s simply a question of finding the right angle and the right joke.</p><p><strong>A former Al Jazeera journalist</strong> asked Taksler about research showing that political satire shows are often more relied upon than traditional journalism.</p><p>Taksler said that there are always reports stating that more young people get their news from <em>The Daily Show</em> than from traditional news outlets, and she never believes them. Young people may get their televised news from <em>The Daily Show</em>, but they are also likely to be getting news from other places such as online resources or social media. Typically, <em>Daily Show</em> writers think more about being funny and less about providing audiences with a well-rounded account of everything that’s happening in the news.</p><p>Taksler added that during her time at <em>The Daily Show</em>, she would often find a particularly juicy clip and was shocked that traditional news outlets hadn’t covered it. <em>TDS</em> had a strong emphasis on getting stories right whereas traditional journalists have more pressure to get the story out first.</p><p>The journalist said that shows like <em>Last Week Tonight with John Oliver “</em>aren’t confined to the conventions of journalism, but they’re doing journalism.” He asked Taksler what happens when satire shows get things wrong. How can success be measured when the take is wrong? The journalist specifically pointed to <a href="http://www.cc.com/video-clips/g46wwe/the-daily-show-with-trevor-noah-pakistan-gets-its-own-version-of-donald-trump">a segment Trevor Noah did </a>that compared Trump to Pakistan prime minister Imran Khan. “The idea that these two characters could be the same and using these very flimsy kind of comparisons fell into tropes about Pakistan,” the journalist said, acknowledging that the segment was funny, but wrong. He asked Taksler if changes are made when that type of blowback happens.</p><p>Taksler said that she has not seen that particular clip, but she would guess that, given her experience with the process of writing segments like that, people who know a lot about that subject wrote the piece. She also said that Noah probably stands by the segment unless he has issued an apology. It is not clear to her that Noah would perceive that as a mistake. Taksler said that there is a genuine desire to get things right on the show, but that segments often inspire criticism.</p><p><strong>An MIT student</strong> asked Taksler where she goes if she needs to laugh.</p><p>Taksler joked that she doesn’t like to laugh. She said that she feels burnt out by the news and tries to limit her news consumption to material she can read. She said that she sometimes goes to see stand-up and live improv. She also hangs out with funny friends, but often finds herself burnt out on satire. Sometimes she will seek out a specific John Oliver or Samantha Bee segment, but she’s not a consistent viewer. She asked the audience member what she does to laugh.</p><p>The MIT student said that she doesn’t do enough to laugh, but she find solace in funny writers.</p><p><strong>Adam</strong> <strong>Zand </strong>asked if Taksler had thought about doing short-form projects.</p><p>Taksler said that just a few hours prior, she found out that a friend of hers wrote a parody of <em>My So-Called Life</em> that she’s trying to get Funny or Die to produce. Taksler has agreed to direct or produce the project if it gets the green light. She said that she’s also interested in doing some funny videos for organizations like gun control and women’s rights nonprofits.</p><p>While she was making <em>Tickling Giants</em>, she was also working at <em>The Daily Show</em>, which meant working double shifts to get keep both projects moving. While filming <em>Tickling Giants</em>, Taksler avoided doing any sort of promotional work in order to avoid unwanted attention. As soon as the film was done, Taksler needed to fundraise so she set up an IndieGogo campaign. The campaign eventually made it to the inbox of a woman who happened to be married to the CEO of Technicolor who was looking for a project that could celebrate the 100th anniversary of the company. He liked the idea of supporting a filmmaker who was trying to tell the story of an ordinary person supporting free speech in the Middle East.</p><p>“When they called to tell me, I totally thought it was a prank,” Taksler said.</p><p>The news of the Technicolor support happened the day after Jon Stewart announced that he was leaving <em>The Daily Show</em>. Taksler had a staff of 12 for the film and worked nonstop for a year to get the project off the ground. She said that she’s happy to have some time off.</p><p><strong>An MIT staffer</strong> brought up <a href="https://www.theverge.com/2018/9/28/17915990/pulp-fiction-brett-kavanaugh-mashup-meme-samuel-l-jackson">a viral clip</a> that mixed Brett Kavanaugh’s testimony with scenes from <em>Pulp Fiction</em>. He asked Taksler if that type of media is a good approach for doing parody online.</p><p>Taksler said that the <em>Pulp Fiction</em> clip was “the first time I laughed that week.” She added that she did not think that the clip would change minds, but that it still had value and was a perfect example of a short clip that a lot of people found joy in during a time of pain. She said that Twitter, by design, is self-indulgent and is not a must-have for society. That said, there are good things that come out of the medium. During the Arab Spring, that platform was vital for helping like-minded people connect. For late night shows, every joke has already been made on Twitter. Writers seek to add more value and to find a deeper insight.</p><p><strong>Kenneth Cox</strong>, an MIT student, circled back to the Penn State research, which showed that people who view political satire are more likely to be politically active. He asked if there are also negative consequences of satire and if it contributes to political polarization in the US.</p><p>Taksler said that she believes it’s possible. She said that the way around that is to try to hold whomever is in power accountable and to not just do it selectively. In <em>Tickling Giants</em>, the same people who loved Youssef for criticizing one politician hated him for criticizing another. She added that she does not think that we are as divided as we seem. For example, while putting together one segment on gay rodeos, Taksler went through three dozen cowboys to find one who was homophobic and wanted to go on camera to talk about it. She was heartened that most people did not agree with that stance. She also advised the audience to never get all of their information from a single source.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*2hPtdInv8fLvX9G82eJEoQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Amber Day</figcaption></figure><p>Day said that there has not yet been done a study looking at whether satire exacerbates polarization. Day has done a lot of work on irony and activism. Irony is a great way to attract attention to a particular cause or group, but irony generally doesn’t convince people on the other side of the issue.</p><p>“It’s not a bridge-builder,” she said, but building bridges often isn’t the aim.</p><p>Taksler said that she is currently less interested in convincing people she disagrees with and she’s more interested in convincing people she agrees with to be more active.</p><p><strong>Greg Peverill-Conti</strong> asked if there are examples of conservative satire.</p><p>Taksler cited <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Red_Eye_(talk_show)"><em>Red Eye</em></a> on Fox as one example.</p><p>Peverill-Conti asked if conservatives are less funny.</p><p>Taksler said no. There are generally more liberal people in entertainment, so there’s a bigger pool to draw comedians from. Also, “punching down is way less funny than punching up,” she said. “I don’t want to watch someone who’s already been victimized get made fun of.”</p><p>Day said that there is also research coming out now which indicates that liberals tend to be more comfortable with irony in general, which may lend itself to an increased interest in satire and comedy.</p><p><strong>Jason Adams</strong>, Co-Founder of Tap Inspect, asked Taksler how she knew she was finished with the film, as opposed to taking a break and seeing what else develops in the next six months.</p><p>Taksler said that figuring out an ending is “maddening.” Filmmakers are often done when they run out of money. In other cases, filmmakers build out several different stories and then choose the most interesting ones. With <em>Tickling Giants</em>, the vision Taksler originally had for the film wound up being very different than how the film turned out. The best advice she got was for the filmmaker to ask themselves who is the audience and what do they want the audience to feel. Taksler decided that she wanted to appeal to a younger, Western audience, and she wanted them to leave the film feeling “frustrated but hopeful.” Material that did not fit those parameters was left on the cutting room floor.</p><p>Taksler debated ending the film when Youssef’s show got shut down, but then shortly after the entire staff lost their jobs, they continued to rehearse for a song and dance number. Taksler said that during that rehearsal, the energy was wild and one staffer looked directly into her camera and repeatedly said, “we will not be stopped.” She extended the film to continue after Youssef’s show was shut down in order to include that scene.</p><p>Greg Peverill-Conti asked Taksler if she had ever considered having the film remastered in order to use some of the footage that didn’t make it into the original cut.</p><p>Taksler said no. Several extras pertaining to the film <a href="http://www.ticklinggiants.com/">were released online</a>. Most of the rest probably won’t be seen. Youssef is currently doing a one-man show, so it’s possible that some of the footage will be used there, but it’s unclear.</p><p>Seth Mnookin wrapped up the Forum and thanked the audience.</p><p>Taksler added that <em>Tickling Giants </em>is currently available on iTunes or through the <a href="http://www.ticklinggiants.com/watch-now/">Tickling Giants website</a>. She encouraged the audience to share any creative, non-violent acts they’ve done to showcase abuses of power with the #Tickling Giants hashtag.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=474134b2fa98" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/mit-communications-forum/october-18-2018-whats-so-funny-about-oppressive-regimes-474134b2fa98">What’s So Funny About Oppressive Regimes? October 18, 2018</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/mit-communications-forum">The Communications Forum at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>