<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Michael Shalyt on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Michael Shalyt on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@MShalyt?source=rss-992166aad181------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Tue, 17 Nov 2026 02:56:57 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@MShalyt/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Math Of Clash Royale]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@MShalyt/the-math-of-clash-royale-3fb2fcd3247f?source=rss-992166aad181------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/3fb2fcd3247f</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[game-design]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[clash-royale]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[game-analysis]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Michael Shalyt]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 17 Apr 2016 00:00:00 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-04-18T09:10:58.079Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>This is the longest (non-officially-scientific) article/post I’ve ever written so, as is customary in scientific articles, I’ll start with a TL;DR of the main interesting points:</p><ul><li>Is Clash Royale “pay 2 win”? Technically yes. But we’ll derive a rough skill estimation formula — neutralizing (most of) the “wallet size” parameter.</li><li>Turns out the resource that limits players’ ability to upgrade cards in the long run is gold — not amount of card copies. Each chest contains only ~60% of the gold required to use the cards contained in the same chest. Choose wisely which cards to upgrade and which to ignore.</li><li>Don’t buy cards in the shop unless you really need that very specific card.</li><li>Always donate to clan members — it’s in your own best interest<em>.</em></li><li>Almost half the gold income originates from “free” and “crown” chests — which you can get even without winning a single game.</li><li>Supercell used a pseudo-random hard-coded sequence of chest drops that seems to be carefully engineered to feel more random and “fair” than actual random drops, and to dispense “wow” moments at precisely planned time intervals.</li><li>We’ll calculate how much time does a free 2 play player need to reach each level. It’s possible to get level 5 in a few days but reaching level 12 takes <em>years</em>. Literally.</li></ul><h4>Clash Royale who?</h4><p>Even if you are not a gamer, you’ve probably heard of Clash of Clans. After all, not many mobile games can afford a super bowl commercial featuring <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GC2qk2X3fKA">Liam Neeson</a>.</p><p>Don’t let the cartoonish design fool you — in 2015 Clash of Clans produced an estimated 1.5 million dollars in revenue <em>per day</em> for Supercell, the game’s creators. And now the Nordic company released a new blockbuster: Clash Royale.</p><p>The game was globally launched about 1.5 months ago and already has tens of millions of downloads, an active community and user-generated content (Youtube videos, streamers, play guide websites, wiki etc. etc.) — basically every game developer’s dream. Part of the reason for its meteoric success is the popular Clash of Clans brand (Clash Royale uses the same lore, characters and visual design), part is the huge marketing budget Supercell are willing to invest in the game, but perhaps the biggest part is that the game is actually good.</p><p>The game’s combat theory is quite deep so for now I’ll only focus on a few strategic questions and try to provide answers using the power of MATH :).</p><h4>A tale of 2 progression systems</h4><p>I’m usually more of a hardcore strategy gamer, but something in the play-and-counterplay PVP dynamics of Clash got to me. Click <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_hNxfiXmeAE">here</a> for an example of the ~3 minute matches that comprise the “game itself”. The winner of the match gains (and the loser loses) ~30 trophies — the game’s standings system (similar to the <a href="http://lifeinagraph.shalyt.com/2015/10/the-math-of-hearthstone-part-i.html">Hearthstone star system</a>).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/360/0*XrSdjtZmx1vZdL6K.jpg" /></figure><p><em>The battlefield of Clash. Deploy troops and watch them fight autonomously.</em></p><p>This is the first progression system in Clash — basically the “better” you are the more trophies you have (“better” is not necessarily more skilled). Players are matched according to their trophy number — which is basically their MMR (match making rating) — accumulating or losing trophies until they reach a state of equilibrium: ~50% average win rate. The trophy progression system provides a goal for the players, an objective to strive for that supposedly proves their merit and provides bragging rights. Note that this progression scale is reversible: if you play poorly or choose a bad deck to bring into these duels then you will fall back down through the ranks. This is in contrast to the second progression system — a slow grind-like journey of upgrading the quality of your cards and gaining player XP and levels — where you can only progress.<br> <br> As you play Clash, you get chests of various quality — containing cards and gold. You can sacrifice multiple copies of a card to upgrade it — making it 10% better and getting some player XP with each new card level. While the “merit” progress is measured in trophies, “grind” progress is roughly measured by player experience. Each player level makes your towers stronger by 7–8%, in addition to the stronger cards, so getting more chests gradually makes you objectively “better”. <br> [Side note: cards increase their power slightly faster than towers, so on higher levels it’s easier to destroy towers and the natural defender’s advantage of fighting on your side of the map is less pronounced — putting even more emphasis on unit vs. unit combat as the player progresses. A nice design touch.]<br> This process of acquiring and upgrading cards is the main mechanism of pacing long-term game progress.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/640/0*eTE_3FFu2Jk28Xnq.jpg" /></figure><p><em>A sample deck. Note the card levels, the amount of cards needed for the next upgrade, the card rarity (indicated by the blue-orange-purple colors), the player level in the top left and the adorable artwork :)</em></p><p>Unsurprisingly, you can buy chests and gold using real money. This brought about a lot of player backlash — it’s not “fair” facing opponents with objectively stronger cards and towers just because they spent more money on the game — right? Which brings us to the first question:</p><h4>Is Clash Royale “pay to win”?</h4><p>Short answer: yes. You can make your cards and towers strictly stronger by paying money.<br> Longer answer: depends on what you call “winning”.<br> Let’s say I want to know how good am I at the game — what’s my actual skill and competence — what’s my “merit score”. At the time of writing I am yet to spend any money on in game purchases during the 2–3 weeks of almost daily play. I am level 6 (which has nothing to do with my skill) and hang around ~1500 trophies (which does). Is 1500 a lot? Well, the very best players in the world reach ~4000, and anything above 3000 is considered “legendary” status. 1500 is a long way from that — but it’s also a long way from the initial 0. Should I simply say then that my skill level is 1500 trophies? <br> <br> No. My “strength” in a dual is roughly the sum of 3 main factors:</p><p><strong>Power = player level + in-game execution + deck choice</strong></p><p>My <strong>player level</strong> defines my tower strength and is also an approximate indication of my card level. Obviously, the stronger my cards and towers the higher my chance to win. This has nothing to do with my “true skill”.<br><strong>Deck choice</strong> is a vague measure of how good your deck functions together, its various cards complement each other, as well as how good is it against the most popular decks you encounter. Skill does play a role here but sometimes the lack of access to certain cards limits deck building.<br><strong>In-game execution</strong> is the most obviously skill reliant factor — how good am I in piloting my deck and responding to my opponent’s moves. Money can’t buy that.<br> <br>Since I’m at my equilibrium state — I win and lose about the same number of games — my opponents and I have approximately the same <strong>power</strong> score. My opponents’ average level is 6.3–6.4 (about 30–40% are level 7, the rest are 6, with a rare 5 here and there). Since I have a 50% win rate against players with a slightly higher player level than me, from our equation above it follows that my execution and deck building — hence my skill level — is slightly higher than theirs (on average). If my average opponent level was 7 or even more then it would mean I’m a substantially better player than they are — since I manage to overcome my handicap of having worse towers and cards.</p><p>This is a more objective measure of player skill — neutralizing the effects of card quality to the best of our ability. And it has almost nothing to do with the actual number of trophies:</p><p><strong>Skill ~ (Average opponent tower and card level) / (your tower and card level)</strong></p><p>As with all simple models — it’s only an approximation and has many inaccuracies, but gives a more “fair” measure of merit.</p><h4>Should you buy cards?</h4><p>In Clash, the gold that you get from chests is used mostly to pay for card upgrading, but can also be used to directly buy specific cards in the shop.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/643/0*TMPsDR-uwFcGqJ2q.jpg" /></figure><p><em>Cards available for direct purchase. The more you buy, the more expensive they become.</em></p><p>At first glance the question seems silly — if you want the cards and have the money — why not? But the correct approach is to think long term: our goal is to eventually upgrade our cards, which requires both gold and multiple card copies. What is the limiting factor? In the long run will we run out of gold or out of cards first? Let the math commence…<br> <br> Let’s look at common and rare card upgrade quantities and prices:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/506/0*eX--Sz1Z2B2HUUUb.jpg" /></figure><p>Calculating the amount of gold <em>per card</em> needed for upgrade we get the following graphs:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/572/0*piYf6lYxdsgQHhW-.jpg" /></figure><p>Note that the price per card becomes a constant (10) after level 6 for commons and an almost constant (40–50) after level 3 for rares. Aha! Smells like hidden order :)<br>So, if we want to upgrade every card that accumulates the required number of copies, each chest has to contain, on average, about 10 gold per common and about 40 per rare. If the chests contain more gold than that — then we should buy a lot to spend the surplus gold, if they contain less — we can’t upgrade all of our accumulated cards and have to “give up” on our least favorite/used cards.<br> <br>Chest drop statistics in Clash are somewhat complex but fairly well documented on the <a href="http://clashroyale.wikia.com/wiki/Chests">game’s wiki</a> so we’ll use their numbers and guesstimate the data they don’t have. Most of the chests you get are of the “silver” and “free” variations, and they seem to produce approximately the same prizes. The chest content also depends on the number of trophies you had when you received it. Taking my current standings as an example, each chest contains <em>7 common</em> cards — each has ~10% of being upgraded to a rare or epic [Side note: that means each 7 card pack has a roughly <em>50% chance</em> of having at least 1 card better than common] and 46–58 gold (assuming an <em>average of 52 gold</em> per chest for simplicity, even though the real average seems to be slightly lower)<em>.</em><br> Let’s compare the two resources. Using the most dominant gold-per-card numbers and ignoring the very rare occasion of getting an epic card, we can calculate the total gold required for using every card received in the chest:</p><p><strong>Required gold per chest = number of cards * [</strong></p><p><strong>(probability to be a common * gold per card for commons) +</strong></p><p><strong>(probability to be a rare * gold per card for rares)] =</strong></p><p><strong>7 * [0.9 * 10 + 0.1 * 40] = <em>91</em></strong></p><p>It’s important to remember that all of our data and calculations are approximate and might contain 10–20% error, but a 91 gold requirement for upgrades vs 52 received gold per chest is a huge discrepancy. Including epic cards in the calculation only makes matters worse, as their gold-per-card is ~200 — requiring even more gold.<br> “Gold” and “crown” chests are the next tier of chests. At the same trophy level a gold chest contains 161–184 gold (<em>~172 average</em>), 23 cards — 2 of which are guaranteed to be rare or better. Conducting the same calculation will show a requirement of <em>~320 gold</em> — again much more than the amount provided.<br> <br> The situation in the highest rankings is just as bad: a silver chest contains ~85 gold on average and 11 cards — resulting in 143 vs 85: 60% of the required amount.<br> <br> The first apparent conclusion is that <strong>I can upgrade only ~60% of my cards </strong>in the long run (assuming progression through chests alone) — so I should prioritize and think before upgrading every card I can. <br> The second conclusion is that <strong>I shouldn’t buy cards from the shop</strong> unless I really need these very specific cards — the limiting factor is gold, not card quantities. <br> <br> Another meta-game mechanism in Clash Royale is the option to donate cards to the clan. Every 8 hours, each clan member may ask to receive donations of a specific card — if you choose to donate, not only do the cards get transferred to the requesting player but you get some gold and player XP for your trouble. This mechanism is purely beneficial for the players — for example because you and a friend can decide to request the same card and simply donate back and forth between the 2 of you — earning gold and XP for each transaction while not losing any cards. There is a lot to say about the game’s efforts to create social cohesion and incentivise positive player interactions, but I’ll focus on the math side: <strong>you should donate almost every card you can — even for purely selfish reasons</strong>. As we said, the limiting factor is gold, so “selling” unneeded cards is the correct choice — even if you don’t care about helping your clan-mates.</p><h4>How fast is (free 2 play) progression?</h4><p>Almost the first thing you see after installing Clash Royale is a message saying something like “Clash Royale is free to play but you can speed up your progress through in-game purchases”. What is the natural progress speed?<br> Obviously, we are talking about the “grind” part of progression. It’s hard to predict how fast your actual game skill will increase. The natural parameter that measures “grind” progression is XP — so let’s see how fast it’s gained.<br> <br> The main method of getting XP is via upgrading cards. Again ignoring epic cards as they are very rare, we get the following table of XP gains per level:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/522/0*pbO_ilE0Tr5qosUH.jpg" /></figure><p>As we’ve seen in the previous section, the limiting factor in upgrading cards is gold, so we can safely assume we have enough cards for the upgrades — and focus on the “XP yield” of every gold coin. Dividing “XP for upgrade” by “Cost of upgrade” we get:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/546/0*GjZUJ12ZJ_3aGSMP.jpg" /></figure><p>Note that after the first few levels the “XP per gold” conversion rate becomes approximately constant (at 0.05 XP or less per coin). [Side note: the high efficiency in early levels is one of the mechanisms that create the “fast progress” feeling that’s often very important during the first few hours of play]. Since the vast majority of gold is spent on upgrades of higher level cards, we can use the 0.05 conversion rate as a reasonable approximation (instead of taking into account the myriad of possible options).<br> <br> How fast do we acquire gold? Assuming we don’t pay cash and neglecting the donations mechanism for now (which provides both gold and XP in small amounts), we are left only with the 6 types of chests to provide us with gold:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/518/0*nK_3dVMX6cLlidn9.jpg" /></figure><p><em>Gold values for chests received at ~1500 trophies.</em></p><p>What does “Time To Unlock” mean? One of the best design decisions Supercell made in Clash is the chest storage and unlocking mechanism. For every win you get a chest, but you can’t open it and get the rewards inside right away — you first have to unlock it. The process of unlocking a chest takes a varying length of time, depending on its type, and only 1 chest can be unlocking at any given moment. Furthermore, you only have 4 chest storage slots (1 of which will probably be unlocking at any given time) — so if you win a match while your slots are full you’ll get the trophies but no chest. <br> This mechanism not only ties “grind” progression to real time instead of play time, it also encourages players to play in short bursts of a few games each time. Most free 2 play games limit play frequency by some form of energy mechanism — basically preventing you from playing more than X times per Y time (unless you pay some money of course) — which often annoys players and hurts the game’s immersion. Energy systems are not there just to increase monetization (relatively few players pay for energy), but to decrease player burnout. The metaphor that’s usually used is eating too much of a delicious cake — it was very tasty but you ate it all in 1 day and now feel like you never want to see another cake in your life…<br> Clash (like <a href="http://www.falloutshelter.com/">Fallout Shelter</a>) tackles the burnout problem without annoying players with artificial play limits. It makes you feel smart for not playing too much because you want to get chests for your efforts.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/400/0*oz5lHYXCZTQfIkJV.jpg" /></figure><p><em>The chest slot system, while slightly annoying at first, is a great method to keep players coming back to the game several times a day for short play sessions.</em></p><p>The “free” and “crown” chests are obtained differently and don’t need to be unlocked or stored in the 4 slots, so they are a parallel source of gold.<br> <br>The second point that requires clarification is why “random” has quotation marks around it. The type of chest you get after winning a battle might seem random but is actually determined by a hard-coded <a href="https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/152H0sXCMZRwAsnZ1wbFgIwH3jWwtNrXjbe1ToKaycuQ/edit">cycle of 240 chests</a> — containing exactly 180 “silver” chests, 54 “golden” chests, 3 “magic” and 3 “giant” chests each. Assuming the (unrealistic) scenario of optimal efficiency — keeping a chest actively unlocking at every given moment — it would take exactly 1044 hours to unlock the whole cycle, or 43.5 days. <br> Since we know the exact order of the dropped chests, and using the table above, we can plot the rate of gold production per hour from the different chests for the whole 1044 hour cycle:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/499/0*LEHabDW1RLl1CGlB.jpg" /></figure><p><em>Gold from chests per hour. The high spikes are “giant” chests, the medium ones are “magic” and the tiny ones are “golden”.</em></p><p>Note the very constant gold generation rate (about <em>39 gold per hour</em>) most of the time — “silver” and “golden” chests produce almost the same amount of coins per hour because “silver”s unlock much faster, and the “free” and “crown” chests are independent of the cycle. The actual cycle average is closer to <em>43.5 gold per hour </em>— because of the special chests’ contributions. Almost half of the income comes from the “free” and “crown” alternative chests — so don’t underestimate them!<br> <br> [Side note: the timings of the special chests were carefully chosen by the smart designers at Supercell — every drop of an unusual chest is an emotional high point. The first “magic” chest drops very early in the game — to help players get started and hook them in, but then there are ~500 hours (in the impossibly optimal case) — half the cycle — with only 1 “giant” chest. Among other things, it shows Supercell’s confidence in the quality and addictiveness of their core gameplay — since they believe players won’t stop playing during the ~3 “baren” weeks, despite not getting “wow” moments from exotic chest drops. Then during the second half of the cycle the players are “compensated” — perhaps to reignite some of the passion for the game that naturally decays after weeks of daily play.<br> Another possible reason for using a pseudo-random drop cycle instead of actually random probabilities is that sometimes real random doesn’t feel “random enough”. The distribution of “golden” chests vs “silver” ones is carefully chosen so that there are always 1–4 “silver” chests between one “golden” to the next — which “feels” more random and fair than actual random would.]<br> <br>Now that we have an estimate of the flow of gold, let’s multiply by our approximate XP per gold rate and get:</p><p><strong>XP/hour = XP/gold * gold/hour = 0.05 * 43.5 = 2.175 XP/hour = 52.2 XP/day</strong></p><p>Note that it’s quite possible to get ~10–15 XP or even more per day by actively contributing cards to clan members — both by directly earning XP and from the XP that the received gold will eventually turn into. This makes clan contributions even more recommended — as they can speed up leveling by 20–30%.<br> <br>Now let’s compare it to the amount of XP required per level and calculate a rough lower boundary on the time it takes to get to each level. I’ve added 25% to the XP/day rate as an estimate of XP from clan contributions (and achievements):</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/489/0*Rrrh6Bym9QoH6X8g.jpg" /></figure><p><em>An estimation of the number of days required to reach each level, assuming free 2 play and ~1500 trophies. Levels 10–12 are too high to show on the same scale as levels 4–5. <br>Level 10: 270 days, level 11: 700 days, level 12: 1850 days (?!?).</em></p><p>After several days of active play you can reach level 5, but the higher levels seem to require unreasonable lengths of time for a non-paying player. Level 8 requires ~2 months, level 9 ~4 months — even at optimal play speed. Not to mention levels 10–12, which are simply unfeasable.<br>On the other hand, it’s reasonable to assume a player will get more trophies as he plays more and gains levels — so for higher levels it’s perhaps more accurate to take higher trophy counts, which means chests with more gold — meaning more XP/hour. Sadly, this effect speeds up progress only by an additional ~20–25% even if we assume a high trophy count (2000+). Reaching level 12 still takes years…<br> <br>So I guess the most accurate answer to the question “how fast can I level up without paying” is “not fast at all”. Perhaps the goal is to reach level 8 and just be content with that.<br>Even better — perhaps the goal is to reach level 8 and then show those level 10 “wallet warriors” that money can’t buy skill :)<br> <br>Until next time, may you have faith in your abilities, even in the face of “unfair” circumstances.<br> <br> <br> Michael.<br> <br> <br> <strong>This is a repost from my blog: </strong><a href="http://lifeinagraph.shalyt.com/"><strong>lifeinagraph.shalyt.com</strong></a><strong>. Feel free to visit and geek out with me on some mathematical analysis of games, people and other complex but awesome systems.</strong></p><p><em>Originally published at </em><a href="http://lifeinagraph.shalyt.com/2016/04/the-math-of-clash-royale.html"><em>lifeinagraph.shalyt.com</em></a><em> on April 17, 2016.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=3fb2fcd3247f" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[“Why Are Corporate Employees Such Cowards?”]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@MShalyt/why-are-corporate-employees-such-cowards-2288baf160d6?source=rss-992166aad181------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/2288baf160d6</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[corporate-culture]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[job-hunting]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[startup]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Michael Shalyt]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 27 Mar 2016 00:00:00 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-03-27T14:03:51.671Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>IBM used to have an ad that basically said:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/378/0*8cqtRD0l8msg7QTM.png" /></figure><p>Which probably used to be true. For many years IBM was the market standard. Buying IBM hardware was the generally accepted thing to do. When the middle manager making the decision came to his superiors, he didn’t have to fight tooth and nail to defend his choice — saying IBM usually prompted the response “ok, makes sense”. Even though it often wasn’t the optimal choice.</p><p>Unlike popular belief, the majority of middle managers are <em>not</em> intrinsically stupid. Our hypothetical manager knows that the promising little startup company he heard about can probably provide a better product for less money — but what if they can’t? The big bosses will have his head if they’ll think he spent millions of dollars on the wrong hardware. Why should he risk his job just to save the company a million dollars? It’s not his million dollars. Best case scenario maybe he’ll get a promotion. IBM apparently understood this aspect of human mentality — and came up with a unique wording for the “IBM is the right choice” message.<br> Before you dismiss our hardware-buying middle manager as a coward who only cares about covering his own ass — ask yourself “would I act differently?”. Be honest with yourself, would you make a decision that had a 30% chance of getting you fired, 20% chance of landing you a promotion and 50% of being taken for granted?<br> When the organization is risk-averse, allowing very little room for error, so are its employees. Creativity is choked to death in such environments. Instead we get mediocracy generated by average, safe decisions.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/320/0*fSbde9jnceYCRx4L.png" /></figure><p>During the last couple of months I had the pleasure of talking to more than a dozen seasoned entrepreneurs, hearing advice and learning from their experience. One of the recurring observations they shared is best explained by a story (claimed to be real):<br> An Israeli company sold 2 airplanes to an Eastern country. Once the planes were thoroughly examined, a very unhappy customer representative called to complain about the uneven number of bandages in the emergency compartment: one plane had 3 bandages , while the other had 5 — “your planes aren’t standard, please provide exact specifications”. <br> You might chuckle at the eastern “rigidness” or “lack of common sense”, as did I at first, but we would all be wrong. The receiving party representative wants to apply as little decision making as he possibly can — and it’s not his job to decide on the correct number of bandages. If something bad happens, he doesn’t want the responsibility to weigh heavily on his conscious or his career.<br> The Israeli “wing it” attitude is very good at creating early stage products and companies, but poses a substantial hindrance to our ability to grow these ~100 employee successful companies into ~10000 employee successful companies.<br> <br> The same type of risk aversion is clearly visible in the hiring process. One of the main reasons previous employment experience plays such a big role in future employment opportunities is because previous employers basically veted you. If you’ve been doing something for 2 years at a previous company and wasn’t fired — apparently you are capable of doing that something at the new company as well. Oh, you have vast experience doing volunteer/standalone/independent projects? Doesn’t count. Partially because you couldn’t have been fired…<br> The HR representative isn’t willing to risk her own reputation by “taking a chance” and hiring you. If you have the “correct” credentials but subsequently do a crappy job, at least the decision to hire you looks reasonable and defendable. And from her perspective — she’s right.<br> <br> So, whether you’re a young startup looking for early adapters or a talented new addition to the workforce, instead of being frustrated about the lack of enthusiasm for your great new product/skillset — try seeing yourself from their point of view, and then make yourself attractive in their eyes. In the case of large organizations, where blame is personal but profit is company property, that often means becoming the safest, most defendable choice.<br> <br> Until next time, may you see the world through the eyes of others.<br> <br> <br> Michael.<br> <br> <br> <strong>This is a repost from my blog: </strong><a href="http://lifeinagraph.shalyt.com/"><strong>lifeinagraph.shalyt.com</strong></a><strong>. Feel free to visit and geek out with me on some mathematical analysis of games, people and other complex but awesome systems.</strong></p><p><em>Originally published at </em><a href="http://lifeinagraph.shalyt.com/2016/03/why-are-corporate-employees-such-cowards.html"><em>lifeinagraph.shalyt.com</em></a><em> on March 27, 2016.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=2288baf160d6" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[IPhone IS a luxury.]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@MShalyt/iphone-is-a-luxury-e0d45cf3577c?source=rss-992166aad181------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/e0d45cf3577c</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[basic-income]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[luxury]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[progress]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Michael Shalyt]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 10 Mar 2016 00:00:00 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-03-10T15:48:58.828Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Several years ago Israel was swept by the “Social Protest”, hundreds of thousands of people went out of the comfort of their house and attended dozens of demonstrations throughout the country. Since the rallying cries were sometimes approximately “Everything is so F-ing expensive — WTF?!? This really sucks. Let’s do something about it!” — they were easy to relate and united people of various political orientations.</p><p>Disclaimer: even I suspended my normal disbelief in politics and attended a couple — until the harsh reality of how futile it was hit me in the face. You see, one of the major reasons a movement that got ~15% of the population on the streets ended up failing to produce any fundamental changes was that “social justice” means very different things to different people.</p><p>Some were marching because the rent in Tel Aviv was to high for them (it really is very high — but that’s not unusual in Capital/metropolitan cities). Some were thinking about raising the social security handouts to a level slightly above starvation if it was someone’s only income. Some were talking about rotten <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crony_capitalism">crony capitalism</a>. A friend of mine, who’s the head of a communist movement section in Jerusalem, saw it as an opportunity to strengthen the status of the labor class vs. the “ownership class”. Everyone was right in a sense, wrong in a different sense, and most of the crowd’s demands were actually contradictory, despite being very catchy (who wouldn’t want to pay less taxes, get cheaper goods and help those in need — all at the same time? All you have to do is vote for the “social justice” party…).</p><p>I read quite a bit of different views and articles about the whole situation during that time, but the only thing i can clearly recall is a headline: “IPhone is NOT a luxury”. It basically tried to answer some of the criticism that was directed at those demanding lower rents in Tel Aviv and the like. Basically: “if it’s too expensive for you — bugger off and live somewhere else”, “you can’t talk about social security with a smartphone in your pocket” etc. The natural culmination of such arguments seems to be that unless you live in a cave and collect food from the dumpsters you aren’t “entitled” to complain.</p><p>You have to be *this miserable* to ride the “demand rollercoaster”…</p><p>The article tried to say that there is a certain level of living that a “normal, working, educated, middle-class” person should expect — and that level isn’t a “luxury”, and you shouldn’t be embarrassed about “demanding” it.</p><p>Instead of going into a political debate about who’s “right” (no one :) ) or what exactly “middle-class” means — let’s talk about “luxury”. The origin of the word is “luxus” (Latin) — meaning “excess” — but excess only has meaning in comparison to a certain baseline of need: I need 1 screen to use my computer — the second screen exceeds the minimal requirements so it can be thought of as luxury.</p><p>But wait — isn’t the first screen a luxury? Who said I “need” a computer at all? 50 years ago personal computers were basically non-existent so obviously people can survive without them. Come to think about it — any modern electronics didn’t exist 100 years ago and your great-grandparents survived somehow — they didn’t “need” an IPhone — clearly a luxury.</p><p>Ok, but what about “basic needs”? They should be, by definition, something you “need”, something you can’t live without. A common inclusion in such a list is basic healthcare. Even lower class citizens of first world countries can get better medical treatment than kings and nobles just a few centuries ago. Aspirin? Luxury.</p><p>So let’s take the most basic need of all — water. One of the hallmarks of “third-world poverty” is lack of clean running water. We really don’t appreciate enough the miracle we all have in our shower — we turn a nub and water pours out of the wall! Even Moses had to strike the stone to get the same miracle… Anything considered a miracle can’t possibly be a “need” — but today we’re outraged that humanity can’t provide this “basic need” to every single person on Earth.</p><p>You know what? We’re right to be outraged.</p><p>Yes, we used to live in caves. Yes, anything beyond the life of a monkey in a jungle can be considered “luxury”. So what? This is one of the problems with conservatists — they think that if it was good enough for your great-great-great-grandad — it’s good enough for you. Not only does it stifle progress — but it also really isn’t good enough.</p><p>Why shouldn’t we update our expectations? Why shouldn’t we want more for ourselves and for others? Why shouldn’t we strive for more? Why shouldn’t we imagine a future where no one has to do anything unless they want to — and our descendants will look back on us the same way we look at the caveman, thinking “I’m so happy I don’t live in that awful time when you had to work for food and smartphones”…</p><p>Until next time, may you be grateful for what you have, but strive for more nevertheless.</p><p>P.S.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/530/0*D4302VujMDVDHWOG.jpg" /></figure><p>When looking for a fitting caricature, I stumbled upon this picture. It can be interpreted in several ways — depending on your personal attitude and political views — making it “statistically neutral” in a sense. It also reflects best my own views on the subject: I’m not really sure.</p><p>&lt;Personal story&gt;</p><p>I was raised on social welfare handouts. My parents had a very hard time immigrating and rebuilding their life in Israel — despite being very well educated and most of the time busting their ass. If we lived in an extremely libertarian country, chances are I would <em>literally starve</em>. Years past, I got all sorts of education and eventually got to be a high tech employee. Even if I’ll fail to create anything meaningful for the world and become a code monkey for the rest of my life — the income taxes alone will return the government’s investment in me many times over. Even if we ignore morality, keeping me alive was a good financial investment. Stories similar to my family are fairly common — especially among immigrants.</p><p>On the other hand, I am aware of welfare abuse — and the danger of a society that views relying on handouts for a living as a valid strategy and an accepted social norm.</p><p>Unfortunately, I don’t see an easy way to separate the 2. And so I remain undecided.</p><p>&lt;/Personal story&gt;</p><p>Michael</p><p><strong>This is a repost from my blog: </strong><a href="http://lifeinagraph.shalyt.com/"><strong>lifeinagraph.shalyt.com</strong></a><strong>. Feel free to visit and geek out with me on some mathematical analysis of games, people and other complex but awesome systems.</strong></p><p><em>Originally published at </em><a href="http://lifeinagraph.shalyt.com/2016/03/iphone-is-luxury.html"><em>lifeinagraph.shalyt.com</em></a><em> on March 10, 2016.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=e0d45cf3577c" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[“Yes You Can!” — Life Lessons From a Game Jam]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/playwell/yes-you-can-life-lessons-from-a-game-jam-b4322333f2c9?source=rss-992166aad181------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/b4322333f2c9</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[game-design]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[global-game-jam]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[game-development]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Michael Shalyt]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 17 Feb 2016 16:10:01 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-02-17T16:27:01.802Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>During the last weekend of January I’ve been part of the <a href="http://globalgamejam.org/">Global Game Jam 2016</a>–48 hours of work, creativity and crunch time. The stated goal is to create a game, learn new stuff and of course meet new people. What makes GGJ even cooler is that it happens simultaneously all around the world — 36000 jamers from 93 countries. As <a href="https://www.facebook.com/arnold.nesis">Arnold Nesis</a> put it: “My favorite event of the year is basically ‘thousands of people worldwide meet for a 48 hour weekend and… work’.” (really hard).</p><p>We made <a href="http://globalgamejam.org/2016/games/i-have-mouth-and-i-must-clean">“I Have A Mouth And I Must Clean”</a> (5 cookies if you recognize the reference) — but his friends call him “IHAM”. A local multiplayer PVP game about the epic struggle between good and evil — germs Vs. toothbrush, made in Unity (we uploaded the game to Kongregate so everyone can <a href="http://www.kongregate.com/games/MichaelShalyt/i-have-a-mouth-and-i-must-clean?sfa=permalink&amp;referrer=MichaelShalyt">try it out</a>).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/320/0*2kJ6Sk7WF-qS8z5B.jpg" /></figure><p>I believe that, as in every high-intensity situation, there is a lot to learn about life and about yourself at a hackathon. So in this post I’ll do my best to extract even more value from those 2 days — using examples from our own story and extrapolating.</p><h4><strong>Yes you can! (Summon creativity at will):</strong></h4><p>Creativity is a controversial subject. Some are firm believers that inspiration and ideas are somewhat magical beings — they come and go as they please, while others (myself included) hold the opinion that they are a direct result of practice, knowledge, experience, training and hard work. I think the controversy originates from the fact that no one is wrong: inspiration is indeed a random occurrence, but you can <a href="http://lifeinagraph.shalyt.com/2014/02/life-is-not-fair.html">“move” the average</a> quality and quantity of ideas you come up with both by knowing more about the relevant fields and by practicing the art of coming up with ideas.</p><p>In case you’ve never been to GGJ — each year there is a unique theme that’s revealed at the start of the event (this year all games had something to do with “ritual”) — so you can’t prepare a game idea before hand. You can’t wait for the muse to hit you in the proverbial shower. You have to brainstorm an idea with your group that’s simultaneously: doable in 2 days, the team likes and has at least most of the required skills to create, the game doesn’t suck too much. And you have to do it fast — every minute spent brainstorming is a minute not spent on designing and building the actual game.</p><p>I’ve attended together with my partner — <a href="http://natalycreates.com/">Nataly Eliyahu</a> — and we had to do it twice. The first team we “recruited” (on the spot) was both too big and had somewhat conflicting visions of the kind of game we should make — so Nataly and I split off . So we were a couple of hours into the jam and had to brainstorm a completely new “good idea” — which turned out not to be that big of a deal. Both “final” ideas were reasonably good.</p><p>The moral of the story — if you don’t feel creative — try harder :).</p><h4><strong>Yes you can! (Make an actual game):</strong></h4><p>You know — one that actually works and doesn’t bug-out every 5 seconds. This is perhaps the best part of any hackathon — the realization that it is possible to build stuff 10, 20 or even a 100 times faster than large companies do it. Sure, there’s less polish and some bugs/edge cases you blatantly ignored and perhaps worse architecture (but not necessarily — on that later) — but it f-ing works! After that it’s hard to go back and face the abysmal inefficiency of a “normal” 9–5 job — you’re stuck with the gnawing feeling of “I’m wasting my time”. But maybe that’s just me :)</p><p>That being said, you still have to be realistic, cost-efficient and very calculated with how you allocate your limited time.</p><p>The first challenge we faced was being just 2 devs — with no art skill to speak of. So we chose a game that’s light on art requirements (we considered getting a public image of teeth, germs and a brush and drawing the UI ourselves) but heavy on mechanics and balance (asymmetric PVP is tricky to balance well — in retrospect perhaps it’s too complex for a game jam). Luckily, <a href="https://www.facebook.com/jonathan.beytyacov">Jonathan Beyt-yacov</a>, a cool artist and a great guy, heard our brainstorming session and decided to join us — so no Google images were needed — but we were ready to use the skills we have and avoid the skills we don’t.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/400/0*KVKxO2JlxwwS3ASo.jpeg" /></figure><p>Jonathan, me, Nataly and Yaam (who did the sound editing). Nataly is holding our protagonist — the toothbrush.</p><p>Another common mistake at hackathons is to overestimate what you’ll get done in any given period of time — even though it really will be more than you’d get done “normally”. On top of that, people often leave no buffer time for basic QA, bug fixing, polishing, integration challenges and submission. The “solution” is basically to assume you have even less time, and be incredibly brutal when cutting down non-essential features. Continuously ask yourself “is this piece of work absolutely necessary for the game to function well?” — <em>if there is a doubt there is no doubt</em>. Kill the feature with fire.</p><p>A natural result of this strategy is a simpler game — <em>which is a good thing</em>. Choosing a relatively easy game to implement gave us the privilege of playtesting time (and — perhaps even more importantly — time to sleep). We had a working prototype ~16 hours before submission and had several players (who weren’t us) try it out during that time — including the event organizer who (correctly) claimed there was a single heavily favored strategy for one of the sides. That forced us to add a new feature/mechanic to the game ~7 hours before deadline (usually a bad idea), but since there was only sound and UI work left (where I had less value anyway) — it left me free to mess around with the game core and balancing issues.</p><p>The moral of the story — you can do more than you think, but you still have to make the right choices.</p><h4><strong>Yes you can! (Make a fun game):</strong></h4><p>The kind people play for fun — not just to try it out. And when they lose/finish they want to play it again. Now that’s surprisingly hard to accomplish — even if you have more than 48 hours. Luckily, Nataly decided (it was her turn to be the “CEO”) we should focus on making a game with fun and active gameplay, and not an artistic game that’s more focused on telling a story or sending a message — and I’m really glad she did. I’m a big believer that games can be — and some already are — a form of art, but making an “artsy” game in 48 hours that actually makes the player stop and think/feel something is even harder than making it fun and replayable.</p><p>We went for a cartoonish/slightly over the top feel with the art style and sounds (all of which were made with our mouths — I swear!) and a fast, “arcade style”, PVP action game — all in the pursuit of an experience that’s “bite-size” (pun intended) fun. I mean look at it:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/640/0*jTtUie9sPaG8XfMf.jpg" /></figure><p>This is the main game screen. Yes, you’re staring into a mouth the whole game.</p><p>It had to be responsive, it had to “feel good” to both players — even though their mechanics and gameplay are very different. There’s a built-in balancing system — the game is a best of 5, but each time you win <em>your opponent </em>gets a powerup (the bars in the upper corners) — again to make it more back and forth and engaging. And that was our focus — less features, better gameplay.</p><p>We carried this focus even into our final presentation: we were the only group to invite random people from the crowd to play our game live on stage. We knew that we had less shiny graphics and no 3D assets — our best selling points were the cheers and laughter from the crowd during the demo game.</p><p>The moral of the story — focus on the main goal and look through the eyes of the “judges”. For us it was “what would feel funny and fun to the players” — so it’s fairly obvious — but next time you go to a job interview don’t think “what are they going to ask me” but “what kind of person/employee is the interviewer looking for?”.</p><h4><strong>Yes you can! (Invest in infrastructure):</strong></h4><p>Another important decision we made was concentrating the multitude of numbers that controlled all aspects of the game into a single “settings” file. We could change the speed of the brush, germ damage, germ reproduction rate, teeth resilience and many more aspects of the game within seconds — allowing rapid iterations (which we knew we’ll need due to the PVP balance challenge). For an experienced developer that might sound obvious, but in a hackathon atmosphere, where everything feels “one-time-use” and there’s a very tight schedule, software architecture is often the first to be neglected.</p><p>We even went as far as creating all the scripts and dummy functions we assumed we’ll need before writing a single line of actual code. Yes, it took 2–3 hours but we fleshed out the whole architecture and — even more importantly — allowed 2 devs to work on the same small project without stepping on one-another’s toes. I implemented stuff that was further away from Unity specifics since I had no experience working on the platform.</p><p>The moral of the story — even when there seems to be too much work and not enough time, planning ahead and forcing order upon the chaos is worthwhile.</p><h4><strong>“Ok ok — you can. But did it work?”:</strong></h4><p>Well… <a href="http://www.kongregate.com/games/MichaelShalyt/i-have-a-mouth-and-i-must-clean?sfa=permalink&amp;referrer=MichaelShalyt">Judge for yourself</a> (another player required).</p><p>It’s very (very…) far from perfect — but I think it’s worthy of the title “an actual game”. If your response is something like “we played a couple of times but the brush is too strong and always wins” — that’s actually a good sign for me. It means you’ve judged IHAM according to game standards and decided it’s unbalanced — not as a student project that mostly demonstrates the makers’ skills/potential.</p><p>And if you think it sucks — well — I really enjoyed making it so I don’t care :P. Seriously though — if you have constructive criticism then by all means tell me about it. We probably won’t change anything but it will teach me something new.</p><p>Perhaps you’ve noticed my incredibly subtle message of “YES YOU CAN!!!”. In my opinion, that’s perhaps the greatest value of hackathons. The reasoning is as follows: “if I could make ~30% of a playable game in 2 days with no background in Unity — imagine what I could do if I actually knew what I was doing :)”. It’s not necessarily entirely correct (if Nataly wasn’t an expert freelance Unity developer we wouldn’t have a Unity game), but my subconscious finds it very convincing.</p><p>I understand that it’s impossible to work at hackathon throughput, creativity and speed all the time. People need to sleep, rest, eat, drink, take a breath of fresh air, recharge. But wouldn’t it be awesome if we could? :)</p><p>Until next time, Yes You Can!</p><p>Michael.</p><p><strong>This is a repost from my blog: </strong><a href="http://lifeinagraph.shalyt.com/"><strong>lifeinagraph.shalyt.com</strong></a><strong>. Feel free to visit and geek out with me on some mathematical analysis of games, people and other complex but awesome systems.</strong></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=b4322333f2c9" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/playwell/yes-you-can-life-lessons-from-a-game-jam-b4322333f2c9">“Yes You Can!” — Life Lessons From a Game Jam</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/playwell">PlayWell</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>