<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by MarxistHeathen on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by MarxistHeathen on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@MarxistHeathen?source=rss-6ab5a2bc289c------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Tue, 17 Nov 2026 00:01:07 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@MarxistHeathen/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[A Survey of Transfeminists & Transfeminism]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@MarxistHeathen/a-survey-of-transfeminists-transfeminism-56d4c5089253?source=rss-6ab5a2bc289c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/56d4c5089253</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[transfeminismo]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[transfeminismus]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[transfeminism]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[MarxistHeathen]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 06 Nov 2026 22:03:26 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-11-06T22:06:24.847Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Every movement has an understanding of itself. What differs is whether they base their understanding on a concrete investigation of facts or an easy-to-manipulate and difficult-to-challenge “common wisdom.” Every movement and trend starts with the first &amp; the question is whether they ever move to this higher stage of self-understanding. Movements that do are able to consciously develop themselves and grow. Those that aren’t are easy prey for opportunists willing to put their own careers &amp; clout above the aims of the original movement. I’d like transfeminism to take the path of self-knowledge leading into self-development. If you do too, this survey is how we can start.</p><p>Setting aside the pros and cons and all of the high-level, ultra-serious questions about “the collective self development of the movement”… <em>aren’t you just a little curious to know more about us?</em> Like, don’t you want to know who we actually are as a group? Wouldn’t it be fascinating to learn that an author that academia tells is a major transfeminist theorist isn’t actually all that influential among us?</p><p>Hell, don’t you want to be able to find more sources describing transfeminism written <em>by</em> transfeminists? Most descriptions of us are written by outsiders based on one or two books that we may not even be reading. At this point, we can’t really say whether the transfeminism that <em>we</em> engage with is the same as the transfeminism that <em>non-transfeminists</em> in university Queer Studies departments are engaging with. Personally, I’d love for people to be able to learn about what we’re actually seeing rather than what non-transfeminist academics (almost exclusively usually TME) see when they deign to glance our way.</p><h3>The Survey</h3><p>There is a lot of work to be done in terms of investigating the concrete facts about everything we’ve mentioned but the first step to all of it is “ask people.” So, the solution is a comprehensive but exploratory survey that will let us start getting answers to a lot of basic questions.</p><p>The Survey of Transfeminists &amp; Transfeminism will be a survey looking for any and all respondents who identify with any of the following categories, regardless of their level of political education, experience, or activity:</p><ul><li>People who are sympathetic to transfeminism/transfeminists</li><li>People who are supportive of transfeminism/transfeminists</li><li>People who are influenced by transfeminism/transfeminists</li><li>People who identify as transfeminists</li></ul><blockquote>Click <a href="https://forms.gle/8jqBeGTZezLzEwVH6">HERE</a> to access the survey!!</blockquote><p>The survey linked contains a series of ~90 questions broken up into four sections: demographic information, our perceptions of transfeminism, ratings of familiarity/influence with different thinkers, and how transfeminism is showing up in the real world. Some of the questions that this survey will help us begin answering include:</p><ul><li>Who are transfeminists?</li><li>How do we actually define ourselves?</li><li>What do we actually think?</li><li>What theorists and works are actually influencing us right now?</li><li>Where are all the places transfeminism is being discussed?</li><li>In what ways is transfeminism currently impacting or not impacting people’s lives &amp; political practice?</li><li>How are people being exposed to transfeminism in the first place?</li><li>Are there gaps between what we think about ourselves and what is actually true?</li></ul><p>In addition to answering these questions, one major goal is to start building up better awareness among English-speaking transfeminists about the world of transfeminism outside of the US &amp; UK. A larger survey can help us understand the extent to which transfeminism has developed in other places and where we might be able to learn more about it and stay in touch with organization outside of the Anglosphere. Among other examples, American &amp; Canadian transfeminists have much to learn from our Brazilian sisters. Transfeminist education and theory relies heavily on the work of American, Canadian, and British people who exist within or tangential to academia.</p><p>If you are on board with this, please take this survey and share it with others! (It’s linked above!) We are looking for people who identify with transfeminist ideas regardless of how familiar with the work of “canonical” theorists or how politically active you are. The more spaces we can share &amp; promote this survey in, the better off we’ll be. Sharing this on many different websites, to friends and comrades we know “irl,” and to people outside of the monolingual English speaking world will all improve the results of the survey. This first survey is only being conducted in English, so we will mostly be limited to multilingual speakers of other languages. However, getting those responses can help tell us where to spend effort in translating future surveys by myself or others into multiple languages!</p><p>Finally, a word about anonymity &amp; data security. Any publicly released data coming from this survey will involve enough aggregation &amp; other data processing methods to ensure that all responses remain anonymous. Being detailed in your answers will help but please do not share any specific details that could be used to track down any organization that is avoiding online evidence of their existence or any organization that might face legal risks from their activities. Regardless, I will apply my own background as a data professional to take all reasonable steps to ensure safety through anonymity.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=56d4c5089253" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[What is a Social Construct, Anyway?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@MarxistHeathen/what-is-a-social-construct-anyway-ec4edaebd702?source=rss-6ab5a2bc289c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/ec4edaebd702</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[theory]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[transfeminism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[social-construct]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[social-science]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[MarxistHeathen]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 04 Nov 2026 20:48:38 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-11-04T22:20:47.614Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>An Introduction for Transfeminists</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/812/1*Ru6yqdezHZYU7lDWu8-rqQ.png" /></figure><p>Transfeminist discourse, especially when it comes to the question of sex, is often made difficult by the fact that a lot of people do not have a great grasp of what a social construct is. I say this without judgement because this is generally a product of the way that people get exposed to the concept. Many people who object to different things being a social construct do so by advancing an implicit definition where social constructs are things that are entirely imaginary with no actual basis in reality. This overwhelming tide can’t help but convince some people that too much of a material impact or basis in reality means that something <em>isn’t </em>a social construct. This problem is exacerbated by the fact that we are often having these conversations on platforms that make the sort of educational conversations required to correct these mistaken notions very difficult to have.</p><p>This article will be a short introduction to the concept of a “social construct” that can serve as an outside resource to help clarify and correct mistaken views about them. A transfeminist trying to convince someone that sex is a social construct will have limited success in communicating their views if the person they’re talking to isn’t on the same page with what that would even mean. Ideally, this article can help facilitate those conversations so we can resolve our contradictions around this question rather than continue to unwittingly talk past one another.</p><p>The rest of this piece will move along in a discussion that starts from some foundational philosophical concepts you’ll need to understand what a social construct is. Then, we’ll talk a bit about the different “kinds” of things and what makes social constructs unique. Finally, we’ll conclude by going over two important features of social constructs that people often fail to understand, causing them to have mistaken beliefs on the subject.</p><h3>1. Objective Matter &amp; Subjective Consciousness</h3><p>All of the world can be divided into two parts. We have the <strong>objective</strong> world of <strong>matter</strong> that, as a category, exists independently of the human mind. This includes rocks, the wind, the sun, the earth, and the human body. We also have the <strong>subjective</strong> world of <strong>consciousness</strong> or “the ideal” that, as a category, does depend on the human mind to exist. This includes perceptions, ideas, emotions, attitudes, and habits of thought.</p><p>Matter &amp; consciousness have different properties for how they relate to things of the same or other category. There are also differences in how they undergo change and development. Being able to identify which general category that a particular thing belongs to is important to be able to apply our understanding of the general back to the particular. This, in turn, is essential for us to be able to interact with and change the world around us in particular ways.</p><p>For example, if you confuse pure matter for an idea, then you’ll be stuck trying to change reality through willful thinking instead of working around reality itself. If you confuse something subjective for something objective, you may find yourself accepting that nothing can be done about something that is entirely within your power to change.</p><p>Now, there is a complicating factor involved with trying to cleanly identify whether some phenomena is objective or subjective (i.e. whether its dynamics are or aren’t dependent on the human mind). The world isn’t made of discrete, isolated things. The world is made of systems of systems. Some things are systems that are made of systems that are purely objective or that are purely subjective. <em>This</em> doesn’t complicate anything. However, some systems are made of a combination of purely objective systems, purely subjective systems, or other mixed systems. <em>This</em> complicates things.</p><p>Most things that exist do so on either a purely objective or on this mixed basis where some parts are independent of the human mind while others depend on it. Mental constructs that are purely subjective do exist but they are limited to a single human mind. Any shared mental construct or interaction between human minds necessarily involves the material as well as the ideal. So, the question we face is how can we cleanly split the world into two categories of objective things &amp; subjective things when a significant part of the world we need to understand isn’t split cleanly? The answer is <em>we don’t</em>.</p><p>Instead of trying to split every particular thing into three neat categories, we split them into three: natural kinds or objective constructs, mental constructs, and social constructs. The difference between the three lies in whether their basis for existence is purely objective, purely subjective, or a composite mix where some parts are objective and other parts are subjective that we call <strong>intersubjective</strong>.</p><h3>2. Intersubjectivity: The Difference Between a Blink and a Wink</h3><p>The term “intersubjectivity” is a combination of the term “subjectivity” (relating to and depending on the human mind) and the Latin prefix “inter” meaning “between.” Thus, intersubjectivity refers to phenomena that pertain to or occur between more than one human mind. Because consciousness is primarily determined by matter and can only affect the world outside of a particular human mind through willful human activity (i.e. something material), any system that is intersubjective necessarily involves both material and ideal parts.</p><p>When used as a countable noun to refer to particular things (e.g. “an intersubjectivity” or “intersubjectivities”) we are talking about commonalities between multiple subjectivities. Shared understandings, perceptions, beliefs, emotions, and attitudes are different kinds of intersubjectivities. You and I sharing a sense of belonging to a particular group and a belief that liberating that particular group is a good thing are both examples of intersubjectivities existing between us.</p><p>All intersubjectivities are developed through intersubjective processes that involve both ideal/mental elements and material elements. The canonical example of an intersubjective process that develops intersubjectivities between two minds is communication.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*SHv1KjMJjS-hFv48Wt-D4A@2x.jpeg" /><figcaption>One common model of communication, the Schramm Model, depicting the unfolding of a dialectical process of encoding, decoding, and interpretation between two minds and through a physical medium.</figcaption></figure><p>Communication involves subjective things, including the mental construct the sender is trying to communicate and the mental (re)construct the receiver creates in their own mind based on what they think the sender is trying to communicate. It involves material things like the material the sender encodes the message into (e.g. sound waves, ink, electronic data, etc.) and the medium that message gets sent through. It involves subjective processes like articulating an idea or interpreting a message as well as objective processes like transmission.</p><p>A clever way to describe the difference between a truly objective thing and an intersubjective thing is the difference between a blink and a wink. Blinking is a biological action that is not dependent on human consciousness. We do it unconsciously all of the time. It’s such a subconscious process that we hardly notice it with our brains filling in the gaps in our vision it must objectively cause.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/512/1*7eT_3W_EDHjtwP3jdLVOhg@2x.jpeg" /><figcaption>A blink is purely physical while a wink communicates mental content like meaning.</figcaption></figure><p>Now, what’s the difference between a wink and a one-eyed blink? They involve the same physical action, so they sort of are, but you can’t really say they are the same thing. A one-eyed blink doesn’t communicate. A wink does. A wink comes with a social context that gives meaning to body language. It’s this context that lets us intentionally communicate something in a way that a naturalistic bodily movement like a two-eyed blink does not. A wink is a one-eyed blink <em>plus socially constructed context</em>.</p><p>Many intersubjective phenomena are like this, involving a combination of something objective with something intersubjective that come together to produce a larger, intersubjective whole that is greater than the sum of its parts.</p><h3>3. Natural Kinds, Mental Constructs, and Social Constructs</h3><p>We can divide all particular systems (i.e. all particular things) in the world into one of three kinds or constructs: natural kinds, mental constructs, and social constructs. As we’ve hinted, this distinction is based on whether a thing’s existence is on a purely objective basis, purely subjective basis, or mixed intersubjective.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/782/1*hE0Wd1flf7vrhmmu9diL3w.png" /><figcaption>A breakdown of Natural Kinds, Mental Constructs, and Social Constructs</figcaption></figure><p>When systems have a purely objective basis, like chemicals, we call those natural kinds. The internal dynamics of a natural kind are entirely independent of the human mind and the way they interact with the world around them is not primarily shaped by the human mind. There is no amount of willful thinking that can overcome the difference between you sticking your hand in a bucket of water and you sticking your hand in a bucket of sulphuric acid. <em>Those </em>substances are natural kinds with a truly objective basis for their existence.</p><p>Particular mental constructs have a purely subjective basis and are limited to particular human minds. Our individual perceptions, beliefs, attitudes, emotions, and our various cognitive processes are all mental constructs. Their existence is <em>entirely </em>dependent on the human mind. The fact that many of our mental constructs are shared constructs, however, points to the fact that these mental constructs are part of larger, intersubjective systems.</p><p>Finally, we get to social constructs. Social constructs are intersubjective systems that are made up of a combination of natural kinds, mental constructs, and/or other social constructs. Their existence depends on the existence of all of its parts or subsystems, some of which are dependent on the human mind while others are independent. Without <em>all</em> of these parts, it ceases to exist. Virtually all systems making up our society (including society itself) are social constructs. Examples include languages, economies, nations, property, cultures, beauty, borders, marriage, time, ethnicity, citizenship, sexgender, and race.</p><p>People who have been taught that social constructs mean “things that are mostly or entirely imaginary” might balk at some of those examples. It’s rather easy to accept that race and citizenship are social constructs because they are based almost exclusively on social agreements or conventions. We have concrete evidence of time periods before these concepts existed so clearly these things aren’t eternal facts of nature. But, like, time??? Yes, time.</p><h3>4. Time as a Social Construct? More Likely Than You Think…</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/431/1*OoGO5RZmgT0nMkfTEIVxSg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Graffiti saying “Time Doesn’t Exist, Clocks Exist” (not <strong>technically </strong>true but we’ll cover that later!)</figcaption></figure><p>Time being a social construct is an excellent example of what makes all of these social constructs. First, let’s set aside all of the mind-bending research into time in the realm of physics that poses a lot of questions about whether or not it’s real or the several millennia of philosophy doing the same. My point will be clearer if we assume there is an objectively existing flow to the order of events and will apply just as much if there isn’t.</p><p>We cannot separate this objective flow to the order of events from how we divide it (e.g. years, seasons, days, seconds), how we think it flows (e.g., a line, a circle, a spiral), what we connect it to (e.g. the phases of the moon, the traversal of earth around the sun, the oscillation of atoms between energy states, etc.) and the relations to it that we apply to things in the world around us (e.g. what constitutes late/early, arbitrary timing of events and holidays, etc.). Time, as a force that is involved in structuring and shaping our societies, is impossible to separate from all of the arbitrary, culturally-specific conventions we use to understand it.</p><p>Physicists studying the flow of time as a (potential) objective phenomena in physics strip so much cultural context from it that this (potential) natural kind “time” is very distinct from the system we call “Time” that shapes our society.</p><p>Time as we understand it is a social construct because it is a system that has an intersubjective basis involving both objective, material phenomena (that may or may not include time as a natural kind in physics) and mental phenomena like our understandings and beliefs about time. The fact that it has a partly objective basis does not disqualify it from being a social construct but is actually part of what defines it as one.</p><h3>5. Two Features of Social Constructs</h3><p>Now that we’ve gone over what a social construct is, as well as the similarities and differences it has with the other two kinds of things, I want to (re)highlight two specific features of social constructs that directly address mistaken views that people have of them.</p><h4>They Have an Objective Basis</h4><p>As systems defined by intersubjectivity, social constructs necessarily have an objective basis of some kind. They certainly involve mental constructs but they are not purely constructed of them. A lot of confusion about what are and are not social constructs comes from the fact that there are people who, despite correctly identifying some social constructs, fail to identify others because they’re trying to make the distinction on a mistaken basis. This usually is based on some kind of notion that social constructs are “less real” than other things in the world. They’re less stable and more easily changed by human intervention than, say, a law of physics. But they’re still <em>very</em> real.</p><p>Let’s take borders as an example. Many people agree that they’re social constructs but many of those think they are social constructs on the (incorrect) basis that they are purely imaginary things existing in human minds. In other words, they think borders are social constructs because they do not have an objective basis outside the human mind. This is wrong.</p><p>The promise of violence is a social construct and one can even argue that the exercise of violence underlying that promise is a social construct. The physical obstruction and bodily destruction that exercised violence entails, however, is very much a natural kind. Buildings, walls, fences, and inhumane traps exist objectively. The organization of lethal power is socially constructed but contains a very real objective character both in the systematic arrangement of steel, brass, metallic lead, lead styphnate, and nitrocellulose and in the potential objective relations that system can have with soft human flesh.</p><p>Any and all social systems we might mistakenly reduce to “imaginary divides” are almost always backed up in some way by the objective potential to physically separate the objective components of the human body until the only internal forces prompting its movement are escaping gases, settling fluids, and the lingering electricity of a fading nervous system.</p><p>Even systems that do not operate on violence still must have a material basis in the intersubjective process of communication. There is no agreement to abide by a shared fantasy if there’s no communication by way of objective matter to facilitate that agreement.</p><h4>They Are Not Unilaterally Imposed</h4><p>Another mistaken view of social constructs that I’ve seen is the notion that social constructs like identities can be unilaterally imposed. An example would be a trans woman insisting that she had been a man prior to coming out and taking hormones <em>purely on the basis that everyone else saw her as a man</em> (i.e. her gender is synonymous with “the category everyone else sees you as belonging to”). Social constructs certainly can and are imposed. However, the process is never entirely unilateral even when the power imbalance is extreme.</p><p>Social constructs involve the interaction of human minds. The word <em>interaction</em> or “action between” is key (not “action only in one direction!”). Intersubjective processes can be unilateral just as much as the process of finding shared opinions between two people while only knowing, looking into, or even thinking about the opinions of one person. It takes two to tango.</p><p>When it comes to how we fit into a social construct around identity, the label that people consciously apply to us is not the only factor involved. How we consciously label ourselves is another factor but the most important and least recognized factor in this process is the way that all parties (ourselves and others) unconsciously relate to us in ways that are shaped by the social in question (i.e. interacting with us in gendered ways, racialized ways, etc.). This latter factor is extremely important because it not only gets at the heart of an identity by looking at what happens in practice but also because it can contradict conscious labeling!</p><p>It is pretty common for trans women to report contradictions between the conscious labels people apply to us and the gendered ways people actually relate to us throughout our lives. This is worth writing about more later but an example more people will be familiar with is the contradiction between how transphobes will call us “men” but then treat us in extremely gendered ways that line up with how they treat women (e.g. dismissing us as hysterical and overly emotional) and fails to line up with how they treat men (e.g. women transphobes getting physically aggressive with trans women in ways they likely would not with someone they <em>actually </em>saw as a man intent on hurting them).</p><p>Even when a group does not have any choice in what label is applied to them, the decision about what the significance and impact of falling under that label is not entirely up to the imposer. This is common with many systems of race and ethnicity throughout history where “subaltern” populations are forcibly enrolled into a particular position within a system then begin asserting their own views about what it means to belong to that position. Histories of where a people came from before the label was imposed onto them, the cultural survivances from that pre-history, the cultural adaptations made to ensure survival under a system that seeks to erase their existence beyond the designated category, and the legacy of struggle that a people may develop can all come to define what it means to belong to that position just as much as the intent of the imposer.</p><p>Are there situations where people within a particular position would be better off if they abolished the very system defining their group as a group (whether sexgender, race, etc.)? Sure. The abolition of sexgender and race as future desires do not contradict a recognition that resistance is always possible. In fact, they sort of require that recognition. However, the point here is not about whether or not people can find liberation within these systems. It is simply to point out that what many of us see as unilateral processes are actually dialectical ones where autonomy struggles against imposition instead of unconditionally melting away in the face of it.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=ec4edaebd702" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Diamat For Transfeminists]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@MarxistHeathen/diamat-for-transfeminists-ca76ebf35d8c?source=rss-6ab5a2bc289c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/ca76ebf35d8c</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[materialist-dialectic]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[transfeminism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[dialectical-materialism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[marxism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[marxism-leninism]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[MarxistHeathen]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 28 Oct 2026 23:25:13 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-10-29T06:15:48.363Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>A Brief Description of Dialectical Materialism and Materialist Dialectics</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/406/1*CJexiEI1fozpbTtcvLs85A@2x.jpeg" /><figcaption>A diagram relating dialectical materialism and materialist dialectics from a university textbook by Vietnam’s Ministry of Education and Training, translated by Luna Nguyen (link at the end)</figcaption></figure><p>My <a href="https://medium.com/@MarxistHeathen/outlining-the-main-positions-on-sex-gender-4157fd6937a8">most recent article</a> was an attempt to outline the main high-level positions on the question of sex, gender, and their relationship. The underlying problem this was meant to address is the fact that (1) current discourse, in which transfeminists participate, has several different objective positions and (2) these objective positions are mostly undefined, nameless, and do not exist as self-recognized subjective positions. The general idea was that we can begin transforming transfeminist positions within this terrain into self-recognized positions by attempting to map them out. The question posed by the article and the ideas it presents have already generated some discussion, which I feel is a firm step in the right direction… but what does that have to do with dialectical materialism and materialist dialectics?</p><h4>A Confession</h4><p>Now, I do have somewhat of a confession to make. Despite the fact that I did not write that article with an agenda to persuade people to favor one position I describe over the others, I did still have an agenda. The description I presented was objective but my reason for making that description was subjective. The reason I am motivated to lay out a broad map is that I want to describe &amp; demarcate one particular region of the map that is of interest to me.</p><p>There is a place on this map where currents of Black, anti-colonial, scientific socialist, and dialectical materialist thought are colliding into a distinct yet undefined swirl. This nameless vortex is both disorganized and self-organizing. However, at this current moment, it is more disorganized than self-organized. It has neither known boundaries nor clearly understood relationships to other currents of transfeminism. I want to help tip that scale toward self-organization.</p><p>I believe doing this requires a common understanding of which “self” we are speaking of when talking about self-organization. The balance cannot be tipped in favor of “self”-organizing until this “self” is named. We could try to name it right now but that would be fruitless. Trying to name a trend when we aren’t on the same page about what we’re naming is like me telling you the name of someone in a crowd without pointing at who I’m talking about.</p><p>The next problem is that we’re not talking about something we can physically point at. We have to be able to describe this intersection of several currents with words. That task leads to another problem: simply describing it as the place where these currents are intersecting doesn’t do much good for transfeminists who don’t know enough about these currents to recognize them.</p><p>So, we need to name this disorganized swirl before it can become a truly self-organized and self-recognized tendency within transfeminism. We need to describe what thing we are giving a name to before we can name the thing. We need to describe individual currents before we can effectively describe the intersection we hope to name. This series of problems lays out both our path forward and first steps we must take to continue down that path.</p><h4>An Overview</h4><p>To take one of these first steps, I am working on a piece describing a key place where transfeminism and dialectical materialism are currently colliding in a dialectical materialist account of sexgender monism. Because most transfeminists are not truly familiar with dialectical materialism and materialist dialectics, <em>this </em>piece is an introductory foundation to it.</p><p>This article, <em>Diamat for Transfeminists</em>, will give a high-level description of dialectical materialism and materialist dialectics (or “diamat”). The fact that this is a high-level description is worth emphasizing right now. In terms of what this article will and won’t be, this means this article will… (1) be an <em>expository </em>explanation rather than a <em>persuasive </em>piece promoting diamat, (2) be a whirlwind <em>survey </em>of diamat rather than an <em>educational introduction</em> to its fundamentals, (3) sacrifice <em>depth </em>in many areas in favor of covering more <em>breadth </em>than a typical educational introduction. To make up for what I won’t have time and space to do in this article, I will include educational resources at the end. The main body of the article following this introduction will be broken into four sections:</p><ol><li><strong>Defining Diamat:</strong> a short explanation what dialectical materialism and materialist dialectics are</li><li><strong>Dialectical Materialism:</strong> an overview of dialectical materialism’s basic laws</li><li><strong>Materialist Dialectics:</strong> an overview of materialist dialectics’ basic laws and methods</li><li><strong>Educational Resources:</strong> a short list of educational sources for those who want to learn more</li></ol><h4>A Caveat</h4><p>Whether this is the first description of diamat you’ve ever engaged with or if you’ve read plenty of “classic” works on the subject, I should offer a brief word of warning. There are a number of differences between what you will see here and what you will see in traditional explanatory and educational pieces on the subject.</p><p>I am an experienced dialectician. I’m very familiar with the “canon” of the works defining and developing diamat so my non-traditional approach does not come from not knowing what the traditional approach looks like. It also isn’t why I claim to be an experienced dialectician. It comes from years of using diamat as a method of theoretical analysis; using diamat to identify, clarify, communicate, and solve practical problems in group settings; and teaching others about diamat and how to use it, all of which I got continually better at through trial and error until I saw success.</p><p>That experience has made me both very opinionated about and very critical of the ways that diamat is taught and used (i.e. not much at all) by self-proclaimed dialectical materialists. There are a number of mostly unaddressed issues that lead people taught by traditional methods to succumb to a number of different pitfalls intrinsic to that method. This led me toward non-traditional approaches for teaching diamat that build on traditional methods with adjustments made where I think they are necessary to address these different issues.</p><p>So, in addition to things I may be excluding from this high-level summary, I may also use concepts, descriptions, and explanations that most dialectical materialists may not be used to. These are not differences in the substance being taught but differences in the form we’re using to communicate that substance. These changes all result from conscious decisions I have made in the specific places where I believe changes in form are warranted. I have addressed many of these issues elsewhere, so I will not explain them here but I will be open to questions about them or the changes made to address them. Just keep this in mind!</p><h3>Defining Diamat</h3><p>What people refer to as “dialectical materialism” actually refers to two things: dialectical materialism and materialist dialectics (though we often use the former as a shorthand for both). To avoid confusion, this article will stick to “diamat” to refer to both and will only use “dialectical materialism” in the more specific sense. When we use the term “dialectical materialists” (i.e. when we are referring to people), then we are talking about people who believe in, uphold, and/or use diamat as a whole.</p><p>Diamat is a foundational system of knowledge that we use to understand the world through understanding both (a) the relationship between matter and consciousness and (b) the general laws of motion, change, and development for nature, humanity, and thought. Dialectical materialism refers to the subsystem for understanding that first half and materialist dialectics refers to the subsystem for describing the second while both of these subsystems are dependently linked to each other in one larger system.</p><p>Before we break down both dialectical materialism and materialist dialects further in the next two section, there are a few more things worth clearing up: its roots in philosophy’s fundamental questions, what it means for it to be a Marxist philosophy, and why we say it is a liberatory philosophy of the oppressed.</p><h4>Fundamental Questions</h4><p>Diamat, as the name suggests, is not a philosophy that came from nowhere. Marx &amp; Engels developed it as a synthesis of two distinct positions that hadn’t been combined until they combined them: materialism and dialectics. These come from two splits in philosophy: a split between materialism and idealism &amp; a split between dialectics and metaphysics* (used with a narrower meaning than it has today in philosophy). Until they synthesized diamat, all previous materialism was metaphysical and all previous dialectics were idealist. Diamat is materialism that is dialectical and dialectics that are materialist.</p><p>Diamat defines itself as beginning from what its proponents have identified as the most fundamental questions of philosophy. Many introductory texts put forward one question as <em>the</em> fundamental question. The Vietnamese add a second question that is implicitly treated as fundamental. We will cover them in the next section.</p><h4>A Marxist Philosophy</h4><p>Now, diamat is a Marxist philosophy. It was first explicated by Marxists, continues to be mostly developed by Marxists, and it is the foundational philosophy for all Marxist political traditions. That said, this does not mean that all dialectical materialists are Marxists or that you must embrace Marxism to accept diamat. I have subjective opinions on whether or not diamat entails Marxism, but the objective reality is that there are incredibly sharp dialectical materialists who do not identify as Marxists (e.g. <a href="https://theanarchistlibrary.org/category/author/nsambu-za-suekama">NZ Suékama</a>).</p><h4>Diamat: A Weapon of the Oppressed</h4><p>Finally, diamat is a liberatory philosophy of the oppressed. We say this is the case because (1) it is the philosophy that serves our own interests and opposes the philosophies that serve the interests of our oppressors &amp; (2) it is a philosophy that has been developed by oppressed people struggling for their own liberation and developed in the course of that struggle.</p><p>Within class societies, all classes have their own ideas &amp; philosophies that constitute the worldview representing their interests. All systems of ideas &amp; philosophies in a class society bear the stamp of a particular class. Idealism is a go-to belief that ruling classes throughout history use to obscure the material reality of the oppressive systems that benefit them and maintain their rule. Metaphysics, in the Marxist sense of the word, has been their go-to belief for keeping people from making connections between the effects of oppressive systems and their causes. They also rely on metaphysics to keep people under the impression that the way things are now is the way things always have been and always will be.</p><p>The philosophy of materialism serves the interests of the oppressed because it is in our interests to have a clear and accurate understanding of what is actually happening in the world and of the ways we are being oppressed. The method of dialectics serves the interests of the oppressed because it is in our interests to know that all things, including the existence of oppressive systems, can be changed. It is also in our interests, as people who would like to engineer our own liberation, to understand how the general laws of change work and can be made to work in our favor.</p><p>Diamat, as materialism that is dialectical and dialectics that are materialist, is a liberatory philosophy of the oppressed. As the oppressed seeking liberation, it is our philosophy because it is <em>for</em> us and it is <em>by</em> us.</p><h3>Dialectical Materialism</h3><p>Dialectical materialism is philosophy and worldview for understanding the relationship between consciousness and matter. It is based on the two fundamental questions dividing all of philosophy and we can summarize this position as a set of four laws that dialectical materialists hold to be true.</p><p>The main question that some textbooks treat as <em>the</em> fundamental question of all philosophy is the relationship between matter and consciousness. When we speak of matter, we are not referring to the specialized scientific category (i.e. matter vs energy) but to a more general philosophical category that includes all of reality that has an objective existence independent of the human mind.</p><p>All positions on this question can be reduced to variants of one of two positions that have existed in various forms throughout all of human history: idealism and materialism. Idealists believe in the primacy of consciousness over matter or that consciousness precedes and determines matter. Materialists believe in the primacy of matter over consciousness or that matter precedes and determines consciousness.</p><p>This fundamental question is entangled with another fundamental question of whether or not the world around us is actually knowable and additional questions on the specific relationships that matter and consciousness have with each other and themselves. We can summarize the positions that dialectical materialism holds on these questions as four basic laws that dialectical materialism holds to be true.</p><ul><li><strong>Primacy of Matter:</strong> Matter precedes and determines consciousness.</li><li><strong>Motion is the Mode of Matter’s Existence:</strong> All matter is in motion as a basic characteristic of its existence, making change an intrinsic and inescapable aspect of all things.</li><li><strong>Dialectical Relationship of Matter &amp; Consciousness:</strong> Matter is the source &amp; basis of consciousness. Consciousness is the highest product and reflection of matter. Consciousness emerges from and is shaped by matter. Consciousness can impact the world only through willful activity. (e.g. “Problems precede and determine their solutions. Solutions cannot solve problems without implementation.”)</li><li><strong>Intelligibility of the Universe:</strong> The objective universe is knowable to human beings.</li></ul><p>Before moving on, it is worth expanding on the last law. It speaks to the diamat theory of knowledge, or diamat epistemology, which is utterly foundational to all theory and practice. How we know what does and doesn’t work to get us free starts from (usually) unspoken assumptions about how we can know things at all. Essays like “Where Do Correct Ideas Come From” and “On Practice” are excellent sources introducing diamat epistemology but this piece will stick to description and summarize three defining beliefs of diamat epistemology.</p><ul><li><strong>Ultimate Origin of Knowledge:</strong> All knowledge derives from social practice</li><li><strong>Ultimate Criterion of Truth:</strong> Social practice is the ultimate criterion of truth (usually measured in predictive power).</li><li><strong>Ultimate Source of Mastery:</strong> Mastery of praxis comes from the conscious unity of theory and practice</li></ul><h3>Materialist Dialectics</h3><p>Dialectical materialism is a system of ideas and methodologies for understanding the general laws of motion, change, and development for nature, humanity, and knowledge. Everything in the universe can be understood as a system and materialist dialectics lets us understand the dynamics of any system by understanding the dialectical interaction of its parts. We can summarize materialist dialectics in parts: (1) its basic worldview and the law of contradiction and (2) three core methodologies of materialist dialectics.</p><p>All of materialist dialectics follows from its basic worldview that can be called <em>the universality of change and interconnection</em>. All things in the universe are always undergoing some process of change. All things in the universe are connected to all other things in one big network of cause-and-effect interactions. Dialectics as a methodology for understanding the world focuses on contradictions or interactions between interdependent “opposites” (in the sense opposing each other, not logical opposites).</p><p>This worldview is distilled into the most fundamental law of materialist dialectics: <strong>the law of contradiction</strong>. The law of contradiction involves many different elements but we can use the following, simplified description:</p><p>Contradictions exist within all things, throughout the entire course of a thing’s development and within each phase of that development. However, each particular contradiction has its own particular form of motion and is governed by laws specific to that particular form of motion. The development of a thing is primarily determined by these internal contradictions.</p><p>In addition to the law of contradiction, there are three well known “laws of dialectics” formulated by Engels that many later dialecticians have re-organized as distinct aspects and implications of the broader law of contradiction. Nevertheless, they cover important aspects of materialist dialectics &amp; dialectical materialists ought to be familiar with them.</p><p>The problem is that short definitions for two of the laws can be difficult to grasp when presented in traditional language. Presenting them in easier to grasp ways is usually done by adding plain explanations to the traditional language. Stuck with the options of writing lengthier explanations for those two or risking a bunch of people who confuse form for content getting pissy about not using traditional language, I’m opting for presenting them and leaving further explanation to the educational sources in the next section. These laws are:</p><ul><li><strong>Law of Quantitative and Qualitative Change</strong></li><li><strong>Law of the Interpenetration and Unity of Opposites</strong></li><li><strong>Law of The Negation of the Negation (Alt: “Affirmation &amp; Negation,” “Continuity &amp; Negation” or “Continuity &amp; Rupture”)</strong></li></ul><p>Materialist dialectics is not just a system of ideas but a system for understanding. This entails the use of a variety of particular methods to develop and apply our understanding. Among these many methods, we can identify three core methodologies.</p><ul><li><strong>Analysis &amp; Synthesis:</strong> Understanding a thing by breaking it down into its component parts then studying the interaction of those parts and the dynamics emerging from that interaction to understand the whole.</li><li><strong>Causal Closure:</strong> Seeking explanations of natural effects in only natural causes (i.e. causes in the interaction of matter and/or consciousness that is shaped by matter and only becoming a cause through willful activity).</li><li><strong>Dialectical Categories:</strong> The use of specific but universal pairs of dialectical categories to break down particular things and situations in terms category pairs that have known, generalizable laws about applicable relationships (e.g. quantity and quality, form and content, cause and effect, continuity and rupture, etc.)</li></ul><p>Diamat is an incredibly expansive topic. There is much that I can’t cover here and much of what I have covered is simplified. Regardless, I hope that this is still a sufficient high-level overview of what makes someone a dialectical materialist and that unfamiliar transfeminists interested in dialectical materialism are able to use this as a starting point to understand it further.</p><h3>Educational Resources</h3><ul><li><a href="https://dn721608.ca.archive.org/0/items/intro-basic-princ-marx-lenin-part-1-final/IntroBasicPrincMarxLenin_Part_1_Final.pdf">Curriculum of the Basic Principles of Marxism-Leninism: Part 1</a> by Vietnam’s Ministry of Education and Training, translated by Luna Nguyen</li><li><a href="https://www.bannedthought.net/MLM-Theory/Diamat/Intros/Cornforth-MaterialismAndTheDialecticalMethod-4thEd-1978-OCR.pdf">Materialism and the Dialectical Method (4th ed.)</a> by Maurice Cornforth</li><li><a href="https://www.bannedthought.net/MLM-Theory/Diamat/OldDiamatWorks/AnElementaryCourseInPhilosophy-GeorgesPolitzer-1950-OCR-sm.pdf">An Elementary Course in Philosophy</a> by Georges Politzer</li><li><a href="https://www.marxists.org/reference/archive/spirkin/works/dialectical-materialism/index.html">Dialectical Materialism</a> by Alexander Spirkin</li><li><a href="https://foreignlanguages.press/wp-content/uploads/2025/06/S20-Basic-Principles-of-ML-9th-Printing.pdf">Basic Principles of Marxism-Leninism: A Primer</a> by Jose Maria Sison (primarily Chapter 1)</li></ul><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=ca76ebf35d8c" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Outlining The Main Positions on Sex & Gender]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@MarxistHeathen/outlining-the-main-positions-on-sex-gender-4157fd6937a8?source=rss-6ab5a2bc289c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/4157fd6937a8</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[transfeminism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[gender]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[feminism]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[MarxistHeathen]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 26 Oct 2026 21:08:07 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-10-31T23:54:05.813Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Turning the tangle into a taxonomy</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/641/1*ZgN_wj-9twb1CeMF14QDUw.png" /><figcaption>An overview of the main distinct positions on sex, gender, and their relationship.</figcaption></figure><p>There are many different objective positions on the questions of sex, gender, and their relationship in the sense that people have a variety of answers to these questions. However, these generally do not constitute distinct subjective positions that carry identifiable names or definitions that individuals and collectives can use to clarify their specific relationships to the various objective positions. This article seeks to start the process of changing this by demarcating these positions from each other and giving them provisional names that are subject to change.</p><h3>The Lack of Demarcations Is Causing Problems</h3><p>The fact that we do not have clear, subjectively outlined differences between all of these objectively different positions creates problems within queer and feminist discourses. Within our discourses, there is a widespread assumption that “we” have a consensus on these questions that might change over time. For example, someone might hear that “sex is the gendering of the body” and think or say: <em>“I thought we agreed that sex != gender?”</em></p><p>It is often the case that the underlying contradiction within a given feminist or queer discourse is rooted in a difference in positions on sex, gender, and their relationship. The fact that we cannot identify these deeper contradictions means that we cannot label the surface contradiction as stemming from these deeper ones, engage on this deeper basis, and resolve them. This lack of ability to identify different subjective positions also promotes an eclectic development of knowledge where people may end up adopting different ideas or theories about sex, gender, and their relationship that each imply contradictory positions on more fundamental questions.</p><p>The way to begin solving this is to put forward a model of the different positions, organized according to questions and answers. The names that will be given to each position are provisional so remembering a particular name used in this article is not important. What <em>is</em> important is being able to (1) identify and distinguish the various positions from each other and (2) understand how and why they differ from each other.</p><h3>The Different Views of Sex, Gender, and Their Relationship</h3><p>The model below will be mostly structured according to a general principle of identifying a defining question and identifying particular positions according to their answers to those questions. The first question we will look at is actually a combination of two questions, giving us four “top-level” positions. We begin with the two-part question of: <strong><em>are sex and gender both meaningful categories?</em></strong></p><p>Each position is defined by whether it says (a) yes or no to sex being a meaningful category and (b) whether or not it says yes or no to gender being a meaningful category. Note that this is not a question of whether or not each concept is “real” or “socially constructed,” the definitions of which are generally not shared across these categories. Our definition is a bit vague but “meaningful category” comes down to the attitudes each position generally has toward those categories and whether they think they have any social relevance worth entertaining or analyzing.</p><ul><li><strong>Sexgender Nihilism (“No” to Both):</strong> The belief that neither sex nor gender are meaningful categories. This is a possible belief but not a common or politically significant one at this time.</li><li><strong>Gender Denialism (“Yes” Sex; “No” to Gender):</strong> The belief that gender is not a meaningful category distinct from sex-as-anatomical-reality. This is the dominant belief among anti-feminist Christofascists and an increasing number of TERFs.</li><li><strong>Sex Denialism (“No” to Sex; “Yes” to Gender):</strong> The belief that sex is not a meaningful category distinct from gender-as-a-social-construct. This is a popular belief in feminist and queer spaces.</li><li><strong>Sex &amp; Gender Affirming (“Yes” Both):</strong> The belief that sex and gender are meaningful categories.</li></ul><p>The sex &amp; gender affirming position is further broken down into two distinct views based on the secondary question of: <strong><em>is sex socially constructed?</em></strong> Those who understand sex to be an anatomical reality that is not socially constructed can be called either <em>sex realists</em> in relation to that specific question and can overall be referred to as <em>sex-gender dualists</em>. Sex-gender dualists are further divided based on whether or not they think sex is mutable.</p><ul><li><strong>Sex Realism =&gt; Sex-Gender Dualism:</strong> The belief that sex-as-anatomical-reality and gender-as-a-social construct are meaningful categories and that they are distinct and practically separable. Summarized as a belief that <strong><em>sex != gender</em></strong>. This is a popular belief in many queer and trans spaces. It is also a dominant belief among TERFs and a defining belief for Crypto-TERFs.<br> - <strong>Determinism:</strong> Sex-as-anatomical-reality is immutable<br> - <strong>Dynamicism:</strong> Sex-as-anatomical-reality is mutable</li></ul><p>Those who understand sex to be socially constructed can be called <em>sex constructionists</em> on the question of whether sex is constructed and can overall be referred to as <em>sexgender monists</em>. This category is further divided on the question of <em>how </em>sex is constructed, which will be addressed in a later piece.</p><ul><li><strong>Sex Constructionism =&gt; Sexgender Monism:</strong> The belief that sex-as-a-social-construct and gender-as-a-social-construct are meaningful categories and that they are distinct and practically inseparable. Summarized as a belief that holds that (a) <strong><em>sex is the gendering of the body</em></strong><em> </em>and (b) <strong><em>your body does not naturally have a sex; it is weighed against sex</em></strong><em> </em>. This belief can be found in some queer and trans spaces but is almost exclusively a transfeminist position. Note: the belief that sex is a social construct entails that it can be changed, meaning that all consistent sexgender monists are also dynamicist on the question of sex mutability.</li></ul><h3>Review of Positions and Summarizing Slogans</h3><ol><li><strong>Sexgender Nihilism:</strong> The belief that neither sex nor gender are meaningful categories.<br><em> Slogan: “sex and gender don’t matter; we are all people.”</em></li><li><strong>Gender Denialism:</strong> The belief that gender is not a meaningful category distinct from sex-as-anatomical-reality.<br><em> Slogan: “what matters is what’s in your pants not any of this gender shit”.</em></li><li><strong>Sex Denialism:</strong> The belief that sex is not a meaningful category distinct from gender-as-a-social-construct.<br><em> Slogan: “the only thing that matters is how you identify.”</em></li><li><strong>Sex-Gender Dualism (Determinist):</strong> The belief that (1) sex-as-anatomical-reality and gender-as-a-social construct are meaningful categories and that they are distinct and practically separable and (2) sex-as-anatomical-reality is immutable and cannot be changed<br><em> Slogan: “sex != gender and you </em><strong><em>can’t </em></strong><em>change sex.”</em></li><li><strong>Sex-Gender Dualism (Dynamicist):</strong> The belief that (1) sex-as-anatomical-reality and gender-as-a-social construct are meaningful categories and that they are distinct and practically separable and (2) sex-as-anatomical-reality is mutable and can be changed<br><em> Slogan: “sex != gender and you </em><strong><em>can </em></strong><em>change sex.”</em></li><li><strong>Sexgender Monism:</strong> The belief that sex-as-a-social-construct and gender-as-a-social-construct are meaningful categories and that they are distinct and practically inseparable. (<em>Note: all consistent sexgender monists are dynamicist as well</em>)<br> <em>Slogans: “sex is the gendering of the body” and “your body does not naturally have a sex; it is weighed against it.”</em></li></ol><h3>Postscript</h3><p>A point of clarification: the question of whether or not sex and gender are meaingful categories is not the same as whether they are natural, coherent, or worth keeping around. It is simply a question of whether they are meaningful to us on account of being extant categories that do play a role in social interactions that have material impacts on our lives.</p><p>For example, the difference between the position I’m calling “sexgender monism” and the one I’m calling “sex denialism” is not that the latter denies that sex is a natural category. Both positions deny that sex is a thing found in nature. The difference between them is that a sexgender monist acknowledges sex as an extant category that plays a role in social interactions in ways that affect our lives. A sex denialist, on the other hand, does not think that sex is a social construct we should discard but do not acknowledge it as a social construct that is impacting people.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=4157fd6937a8" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[“What’s Wrong with Being a Housewife?”: Tradwives & Fascist Realism]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@MarxistHeathen/whats-wrong-with-being-a-housewife-tradwives-fascist-realism-f1f1090bfce3?source=rss-6ab5a2bc289c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/f1f1090bfce3</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[antifascism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[transfeminism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[feminism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[fascism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[MarxistHeathen]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 25 Oct 2026 02:02:55 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-10-25T02:02:55.462Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/772/1*H04x3XHm-io6QhnCRL49Cg.jpeg" /><figcaption><a href="https://gnet-research.org/2023/05/19/co-opting-cottagecore-pastoral-aesthetics-in-reactionary-and-extremist-movements/">image source</a></figcaption></figure><p>There’s been recent discourse among trans women about the concept of a “tradwife” and the desire to be in a tradwife relationship. When it comes to writing about online discourse, I have a <a href="https://medium.com/@MarxistHeathen/please-stop-talking-about-that-drawing-like-its-real-1c40b67d4ca3">couple rules of thumb</a> I follow for whether or not I think it’s worth writing about. I find it’s worth it when (a) the topic is a persistent discourse reflecting a broader societal conversation and (b) there’s something I think I can provide theoretical clarity on. I have seen discourse talking about the tradwife ideal before, including discourse that frames it in feminist, pro-choice language. The conversation is also a clear reflection of ongoing conversations about gender roles and the “traditional family” we have been having as right wing forces have been calling for an enforced return to “traditional marriage” (e.g. Project 2025 &amp; follow-up plans published by the Heritage Foundation).</p><p>That leaves the question of whether there is anywhere I might be able to add theoretical clarity to. I did find something very interesting in this discourse. In fact, I found it rather quickly after starting to engage in it.</p><p>I am a communist so there is plenty about the ways that our society organizes relationships and reproductive labor that I think we will be better off abolishing in the future. That said, being a communist also entails being a realist and a materialist who knows that many of these structures can’t be abolished until we change underlying economic and social conditions that enable better, alternative structures to flourish. Some communists take any chance to criticize many traditional relationship structures like marriage and the family. I, however, tend to put my own efforts toward other corners of ideological struggle. We all have our roles to play in promoting communist ideas and I just think I’m better off specializing elsewhere.</p><p>All of this is to say: at no point when I was throwing my two cents in about the concept of a tradwife relationship did I <em>ever </em>criticize the desire to be a housewife. In fact, I criticized the tradwife ideal more than once by comparing it to being a housewife as part of an agreement about dividing labor between equal partners within a relationship. The latter doesn’t guarantee an absence of oppressive dynamics. However, being a housewife in a traditional butchfemme relationship or agreeing to do handle the housework in exchange for not having to work in a relationship where that is always subject to renegotiation at any point feel like a far cry from a relationship defined by not just being a housewife but accepting gender-based inequality as a non-negotiable foundation of your relationship.</p><p>What I found interesting is that it didn’t matter how many times I critiqued the tradwife ideal as a specific way to be a housewife that was inferior to other ways of being a housewife. The majority of responses I got still fell into two categories. The first, which I expected, was people insisting on a vulgar choice feminism that functionally denies the validity of any criticism made about any choice a woman makes. The second, which I didn’t at all expect, were all variations of “what’s wrong with being a housewife?” This wasn’t one obstinate rando or a couple of disingenuous trolls saying this. This response came from a wide variety of people who, whether they were responding to me or others, simply were not processing that someone criticizing the tradwife ideal wasn’t also criticizing being a housewife in general.</p><p>Why is that? What is going on in these conversations and how the concept of a “tradwife” is evolving that causes people to struggle to distinguish whether someone criticizing it is also criticizing the desire to be a housewife? It’s easy to just dismiss these people with any number of insults or to resort to ableist explanations assuming there must be some sort of “mental deficiency” behind this but I don’t think this is the case. I think a better explanation of what’s happening here is the result of a phenomena that I suspect is playing a <em>major </em>role in fascist efforts to reshape <em>many</em> different aspects of society, promoting fascist ideas in a way that is both too subtle for many people detect and detached from the political baggage they might associate with fascism. It doesn’t have a name yet but I personally think the best term for it is <strong><em>fascist realism</em></strong>.</p><h3>Capitalist Realism</h3><p>To understand the concept of “fascist realism,” you need to understand the concept behind the term it is inspired by: capitalist realism.</p><p>British thinker Mark Fisher introduced the world to the term in his 2009 book <a href="https://files.libcom.org/files/[Mark_Fisher]_Capitalist_Realism_Is_There_no_Alte(BookZZ.org).pdf"><em>Capitalist Realism: Is There No Alternative?</em></a>. Fisher argued that many things in our society from the world imagined in popular media, to the way governments address major crises like the 2008 Financial Crisis, to a mostly unquestioned consensus that all institutions in society ought to operate on the logic of businesses all reflected the same unconscious worldview. He called this worldview capitalist realism and described it as follows:</p><p>“[W]e are inevitably reminded of the phrase attributed to Fredric Jameson and Slavoj Zizek, that it is easier to imagine the end of the world than it is to imagine the end of capitalism. That slogan captures precisely what I mean by ‘capitalist realism’: the widespread sense that not only is capitalism the only viable political and economic system, but also that it is now impossible even to <em>imagine</em> a coherent alternative to it.”</p><p>This, however, is just the surface of capitalist realism. It’s a description of the final result of an ideological battle already won and not the process by which it went from one perspective among many to what seemed for a time like the only perspective. How capitalist realism operates on its ascent is through the process of depoliticization.</p><h4>Depoliticization</h4><p>Depoliticization starts with something already politicized, like a question with different answers or a problem with different proposed solutions that each depend on what ideological perspective you are coming from. Politicized questions are consciously understood to be primarily clashes between subjective values. The problem with an issue being political is that people can question your ideologically-motivated perspectives of the issue on a political basis and propose their own political solutions to solve it. The way that a ruling class can avoid all of this is to reframe their subjective ideological perspectives in terms of objective “facts” about the natural world.</p><p><em>There’s no point in debating capitalism because it’s the only system that human nature allows us to have. We do need to address how our political economic system causes mental health problems because they are merely chemical imbalances that we should leave to the experts to solve. We don’t need to think whether capitalism is destroying the planet because human beings are naturally greedy and climate change is just a natural cycle outside of our control anyway.</em></p><p>If a ruling class reframes their ideology’s perspective on enough issues from being “a subjective value not everyone agrees with” to being “objective facts all rational people assume are true,” they can easily defang attempts to challenge their dominance. In the paraphrased words of Muhammad Ali: <em>your hands can’t hit what your eyes can’t see.</em></p><h4>Realizing Realism</h4><p>We’ve talked about how capitalist realism takes hold on a sociological level through depoliticization but what does depoliticization look like on the level of individual conversation? Resisting this sort of thing requires us to recognize when it happens but the process is more subtle than someone simply declaring “it’s a fact that I’m right and you’re wrong.” The very acknowledgement that your political position on the question can be wrong is an admission that the issue that you are supposedly wrong about <em>is </em>a political one.</p><p>The first step is to <strong>reproblematize </strong>the underlying issue, redescribing it in a way that shifts the “domain” the issue belongs to from its original, politicized domain to a domain that is currently not politicized by the vast majority. The second step is to <strong>empiricize</strong> your rhetoric or, in other words, stop making subjective judgements and start making claims of objective “facts” (whether or not those claims of fact are true is a separate question). Finally, you need to <strong>delegitimize</strong> your opponent’s rhetoric by insisting that their political answers are not relevant because “we are talking about a non-political question.”</p><p>We see these steps take place when someone tries to reframe their claim that capitalism is the best system to claim that it is the only possible system. First, they might <strong>reproblematize </strong>the underlying question about our economic system from the domain of comparative politics (“what system <em>should</em> we have?”) to the generally depoliticized domain of anthropology (“what systems does human nature make possible?”). Then, they <strong>empiricize</strong> their own rhetoric by shifting from “capitalism is better because of x, y, and z” (a subjective judgement about what constitutes better) to arguments like “any system other than capitalism will fail and revert to capitalism because of human nature.” Finally, they <strong>delegitimize</strong> opposing rhetoric. If you insist that socialism is superior to capitalism, they’ll argue that you are not even making relevant claims because you aren’t acknowledging anthropological “facts” about human nature.</p><h4>Opposition Doesn’t Grant Immunity</h4><p>There is one last observation we need to make about the effect of capitalist realism: <em>socialists became believers</em>. Many organizations retained views that there should be a revolution or of what society ought to look like after said mythical revolution. Practical politics, however, splintered into attempts to reform capitalism (in deed when not in name), utopian efforts seeking the right ideas that will change society if only enough people believed them, floundering attempts at isolated acts of resistance, and projects content with carving out small new worlds inside of the old. Many of these projects have valuable tactics we have built on. However, our movements were hollowed out on the strategic level, leaving us with no coherent theory of change to get us from here, to a revolution, to a society beyond it.</p><p>This hollowing out happened because even the majority of capitalism’s resisters became unwitting believers in capitalist realism. Crucially, the effect did <em>not</em> require them to consciously adopt any pro-capitalist beliefs. In fact, it usually operates by making it difficult to identify the belief in these “objective facts” as a capitalist perspective at all. Our ruling class simply needed enough of us to adopt enough beliefs that, unbeknownst to us, were capitalist perspectives masquerading as consensus of facts of reality.</p><h3>Tradwives and Fascist Realism</h3><p>My conversations with people about tradwives has shown me that capitalism is not the only ideology that benefits from a “realism” sort of strategy that skips direct engagement in order to simply normalize itself.</p><h4>Is a Tradwife Just a Heterosexual Housewife?</h4><p>First, what is a tradwife anyway? The term tradwife was coined as early as 2013 <a href="https://www.prospectmagazine.co.uk/ideas/philosophy/language/70823/the-pernicious-appeal-of-the-tradwife-girlboss-4chan-tiktok">by anti-feminist men on 4chan</a>. This earliest known attestation of the term comes from one man’s solution to the “problem” of feminism enabling women to seek economic independence. The answer he provided relied on exploiting migrant women:</p><p>“You’ll find anything if you pay enough. She’ll pretend to be a tradwife for as long as it takes to get a visa/green card/whatever so you can expect at least a few years of ‘traditional marriage.’”</p><p>Tradwife is a portmanteau of the words “traditional” and “wife” but it is not a mere shorthand. The phrase “traditional wife” can have many different meanings depending on what traditions you refer to. The “trad” part of “tradwife” has not, in either the context in which the term was coined nor in the majority of current usage, been so unspecific about which “traditions” are being referred to. The guiding traditions that have and continue to define the “tradwife” lifestyle as one among many ways to be a housewife are the traditions of the 1950s West. These traditions <a href="https://www.michigandaily.com/arts/digital-culture/the-tradwife-trilogy-part-1-tradwives-mark-the-return-of-the-lobotomized-1950s-housewife/">do</a> <a href="https://www.polisci.uci.edu/files/docs/theses/2025-26/2026_claritza-cisneros.pdf">often</a> <a href="https://www.mediamatters.org/tiktok/study-tradwife-influencers-are-quietly-spreading-far-right-conspiracy-theories">include</a> the traditions of white supremacy and Christian nationalism alongside the uniquely totalitarian patriarchy of the post-war nuclear family.</p><p>What’s important here is that the term “tradwife,” despite its focus on and glorification of the past, is a <em>contemporary </em>term. There was no woman before the 2010s who called herself a tradwife. The labeling of these women as tradwives only occurs when modern-day people apply those labels retroactively on the basis that what they <em>imagine</em> their lives to be like can be shoehorned to fit inside the mythical portrait of women as being largely content with male superiority until feminism came along to brainwash them into thinking we deserve equality. It is an intrinsically modern conception of the housewife because it is defined in opposition to the perceived effects of feminism. The truth is that we would not even have the concept of a tradwife if we didn’t also have the influence of feminism against which we could define it.</p><p>So, regardless of the insistence on a “return to tradition,” the tradwife ideal is (1) a contemporary way of being a housewife, (2) one way of being a housewife among many, and (3) a way of being a housewife where the overwhelming majority of its promoters are fascist promoting it as a central part of their vision for a fascist world free of feminist challenge to male dominance. This makes the tradwife ideal a tough sell for many women who do place at least some value on their autonomy, which includes even many conservative women who oppose their own party on the issue of abortion. The tradwife ideal is an even tougher sell for women who are even more put off by the vision of a fascist future it is associated with, such as trans women.</p><h4>Fascist Realism In Action</h4><p><strong>Fascist realism</strong> is how you make this tough sell to these women. Before starting, you accept that you’re not going to make as much headway as you like if you only try to promote the tradwife ideal alongside every other element of the fascist vision of the future. You need to narrow your pitch to focus on just this one element of the family structure and keep your mouth shut about the larger future this structure is meant to support.</p><p>Then, you engage in depoliticization. You start by allowing some slack in the definition of “tradwife” so it can broaden to include any heterosexual housewife. This lets you <strong>reproblematize </strong>the question of whether or not the fascist vision of a tradwife is good (politicized) to be a question of whether or not women should be allowed to be straight housewives (not currently politicized).</p><p>Doesn’t allowing this slack water down the concept and defeat the purpose of promoting it? Not really. First, this slack doesn’t prevent everyone who comes across the concept and begins to identify with it from being inundated with the specific, original, fascist version of the tradwife ideal. They not only control the information environment around the term. They fucking built it. Second, a woman is only one half of the tradwife relationship. The other half is the man and men who are exposed to the concept are exposed to it almost exclusively in right wing spaces promoting fascist visions of the future. Women who want to be a tradwife but believe in gender equality are a very slim minority among women who want to be a tradwife. Men who are specifically seeking a tradwife relationship but do not believe in gender equality are virtually nonexistent. The nature of the tradwife relationship entails that, if there is a disagreement about the specifics of what it looks like, it is the man’s vision that ultimately defines the box that the woman must conform to out of obedience.</p><p>Having reproblematized the tradwife ideal to simply be the general desire to be a housewife, you move on to your rhetorical adjustments. Fortunately for fascists, this does not require much effort. Reframing the question of the tradwife ideal to be a question of being a housewife of any kind already does this for you. It does this for the people you get to accept that broadened definition as well, whether they even realize the broadening happened.</p><p>Whether or not women can be straight housewives is treated as a question of factual consensus. Rhetoric in favor of the ideal is easily <strong>empiricized</strong> and, where it is brought back into the realm of value questions, can be framed as a question of whether or not women should be allowed to make the same choice women are already allowed to make. Opposing rhetoric is <strong>delegitimized</strong> as a fantastical desire for totalitarian control over women that fails to neglect the reality of women being straight housewives.</p><h4>The Future We Are Facing</h4><p>This is fascist realism. Fascist strategies for bringing about their vision for the world have evolved as the people they need to appeal to have changed. No longer can we expect fascist rhetoric to look like true believers spouting frothing manifestoes meant to drive would-be foot soldiers to “take back their country.” Alongside that rhetoric we will find people, many of whom are not fascists, talking in ways that frame certain elements of the fascist future as factually inevitable.</p><p>Even those who oppose fascism on a conscious level and fear its future will find themselves unwitting believers of key parts just as the socialists in the 80s through the 00s became unconscious believers in the pointlessness of revolution. These women will defend the tradwife ideal not because they are crypto-fascists but because it has become easier to imagine a world in which women are prevented from becoming housewives than it is to imagine a world where housewives are not tradwives.</p><p>This is something we need to be paying attention to. We can see fascist realism at play in discussions about tradwives but that’s because we are looking. I would be beyond shocked if fascists were not promoting fascist realism in many other societal discourses. Beginning to identify where this is happening, developing tactics to combat its spread, and educating others on how to use those tactics in their day-to-day discussions will be critical tasks to ensure fascists do not gain an edge that we cannot come back from.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=f1f1090bfce3" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[War Without Bloodshed: Instruments of Power and Domains of Political Action]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@MarxistHeathen/war-without-bloodshed-instruments-of-power-and-domains-of-political-action-18a15252fb2e?source=rss-6ab5a2bc289c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/18a15252fb2e</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[organizing]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[marxism-leninism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[operational-art]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[community-organizing]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[transfeminism]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[MarxistHeathen]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 20 Oct 2026 00:12:56 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-10-20T00:12:56.013Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>C3E, PIECC, and MDO</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*syO9SP-e-LGtLBhNaQfl_Q.png" /><figcaption>A visual model that relates our model for instruments of power (C3E) to our models for thinking of political operations across the different domains of action (PIECC)</figcaption></figure><p>The last two entries in this series have begun to lay a foundation for us to think about power and the different ways we can exercise it. We developed an operational definition of power but left the question of what kinds of power we can bring to bear in political conflict for “a future article.” This is that future article.</p><p>Our discussion here will cover three different concepts through two different frameworks. First, we will lay out a framework for thinking about the different bases or <em>instruments of power</em> that we can exercise in order to achieve our objectives or prevent our adversaries from achieving theirs. Second, we will introduce a second framework of different <em>domains of action</em> where those different instruments of power get used. Finally, we will go over a third concept to flesh out our operational framework around domains of action to include <em>multi-domain operations</em>.</p><h3>Instruments of Power: C3E</h3><p>When states think about conflict and warfare with other states, they have different mental frameworks for thinking about what their different types or <strong>instruments of power</strong> are. This ensures that all options are on the table for discussion and that everyone who needs to be involved with major questions of interstate conflict have both a <em>shared awareness</em> of what options are on the table and a <em>shared language</em> for discussing how to combine those options.</p><p>The United States has a couple different frameworks but one of the most common is the DIME Model. DIME stands for Diplomatic, Informational, Military, and Economic, with each item standing for one type of source of American state power and each having its own particularities. For the sorts of nonstate organizations we belong to, engaging in political conflicts that are typically not military in nature, we need to adapt our framework to fit our own reality.</p><p>One adapted framework we can use to think about our own instruments or types of power goes by the acronym <strong>C3E </strong>(a shorter version of CCCE). The instruments in this framework are as follows:</p><ul><li><strong>Coercive:</strong> The power to directly compel an adversary to do or cease to do something, often by imposing a strategic dilemma on them.</li><li><strong>Coordinative:</strong> The power to organize, coordinate, consolidate, and mobilize disparate elements around a shared vision into a cohesive force for joint action</li><li><strong>Cognitive:</strong> The power to shape behavior by affecting beliefs, attitudes, decision-making, and other elements of human cognition.</li><li><strong>Economic:</strong> The power to use or restrict the use of resources.</li></ul><p>Equipped with a framework for thinking about the different kinds of power (or types of <a href="https://medium.com/@MarxistHeathen/war-without-bloodshed-power-as-freedom-of-action-771eac1fc6d9">freedom of action</a>) we can generate, we can move onto a discussion about the different “places” we can exercise that power.</p><h3>Domains of Political Operations: PIECC</h3><p>Militaries typically think of their operations as occurring in one or more <strong>domains</strong>. The traditional domains are air, land, and sea. Recent additions have expanded to include other domains like space, cyber, and various human domains. This framework enables us to think about our options for exercising power and the targets we want to apply them to.</p><p>This type of framework can be very valuable to us but cannot be copied directly. A revolutionary transfeminist organization, for example, has little use for thinking about naval operations or air power. I will present an adapted version of this framework below where each domain is collected into an acronym: <strong>PIECC</strong>.</p><ul><li><strong>Physical:</strong> The domain characterized by plainly understood notions of physical space. Its sub-domains include the traditional military domains of land, sea, air, and space. In the vast majority of cases, land is the only relevant domain for political organizers.</li><li><strong>Institutional:</strong> The domain characterized by formal governing institutions with wide acceptance. This includes institutions that are part of a state as well as non-state governing institutions like the World Health Organization (WHO), the Internet Corporation for Assigned Names and Numbers (ICANN), and the International Organization for Standardization (ISO). Common subdomains that are important for political actors include: Electoral, Legislative, Judicial, and Policy-Administrative.</li><li><strong>Economic:</strong> The domain involving resource extraction, production, commerce, finance, and supply chains. Boycotts, strikes, and blockades are all classic examples of political operations that target this domain.</li><li><strong>Cybernetic:</strong> The domain of the organization and flow of information/communication within systems and how that shapes and controls their actions. This is a wide domain that will be covered in greater depth in a future article. Important subdomains include: information, organization, and cognition.</li><li><strong>Cultural:</strong> The domain of culture, defined as systems of shared beliefs, attitudes, tastes, behaviors, habits, and customs that underlie the structure of social groups. This domain tends to be neglected but it is the primary domain within which systems of oppression are maintained and are brought from society-wide cultures into the subcultures of particular spaces and organizations.</li></ul><p>When we execute a course of action to bring our power to bear to transform the world, we are typically doing so in one of these domains. This is far from the only way of breaking down the different domains and, with continued use of this framework and collective discussion, we may come up with a framework that is more specifically honed to help us think about our own activities.</p><p>You may note that there seems to be a bit of overlap between the terms used in the C3E model and the PIECC model that could cause confusion. The most explicit case is that both models use the word “economic.” We’re using the same word but it has a different meaning in each model as one refers to economic <em>power </em>and the other is the economic <em>domain</em>. There is a relationship but they are not restricted to each other. For instance, economic power can be exercised by executing operations in the physical domain (e.g. a blockade) in order to exercise effects on your adversary in the economic domain. You might also leverage economic power in the form of resources in order to put on and provide food at an event you wish to use as an opportunity to organize a community.</p><h3>Multi-Domain Operations</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*syO9SP-e-LGtLBhNaQfl_Q.png" /><figcaption>Bringing back the visualization of our models from earlier.</figcaption></figure><p>Now that we know what the different domains we operate in, I want to briefly discuss two valuable frameworks for thinking about how we wage political conflict across them. The most important development to military theory surrounding domains is the concept of <strong>multi-domain operations</strong> (MDO) where military strategists can think through different, interconnected parts of a larger battle that each operate by different rules rather than thinking of them as entirely distinct battles. Adopting the MDO framework enables us to develop plans that engage multiple domains where actions in one domain cause effects that support operations in other domains.</p><p>Let’s take a look at how we can understand a strike as an example of a multi-domain operation. A picket line blockading a workplace is an operation that is executed in the physical domain but produces effects in the economic domain. Strikes often involve engagement in the institutional domain where companies and unions leverage different institutions (e.g. the National Labor Relations Board and, for capitalists, the local police departments) in order to apply pressure on the adversary. Organizing and disorganizing efforts within the cybernetic domain play a central role. Thinking about our activity through this framework spurs us to think about how our different efforts can mutually support each other as a cohesive whole.</p><h3>Bringing It Together</h3><p>The frameworks we’ve covered: instruments of power (C3I), domains of action (PIECC), and multi-domain operations (MDO), help flesh out a framework for thinking about the concrete exercise of power that will help us develop our operational art. We can easily integrate these frameworks with the previous ones we have discussed around types of operations and freedom of action. As for what that looks like, I will leave it to you to have discussions about how to combine these frameworks with your comrades. You will have a much easier time remembering and connecting these frameworks if you are connecting them into a system in your own heads than you will if I simply gave you a description of how you might do that.</p><p><strong><em>Now go forth and be dangerous.</em></strong></p><p><em>This article is a single installment within War Without Bloodshed, a series of short articles intended for group discussion within political collectives that help teach operational art by introducing operational frameworks taken from the realm of armed conflict that can be usefully applied to unarmed political struggle. The theoretical basis of this is a duality between warfare and politics as particular sub-domains of the more general domain of human conflict. You can find the current articles in this series below:</em></p><p><em>1: </em><a href="https://medium.com/@MarxistHeathen/war-without-bloodshed-a-series-introduction-59d28fb5464d"><em>A Series Introduction</em></a></p><p><em>2: </em><a href="https://medium.com/@MarxistHeathen/war-without-bloodshed-the-trichotomy-of-operation-types-97376fffebd6"><em>The Trichotomy of Operation Types</em></a></p><p><em>3: </em><a href="https://medium.com/@MarxistHeathen/war-without-bloodshed-power-as-freedom-of-action-771eac1fc6d9"><em>Power as “Freedom of Action”</em></a></p><p>4: Instruments of Power and Domains of Political Operations</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=18a15252fb2e" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[War Without Bloodshed: Power as “Freedom of Action”]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@MarxistHeathen/war-without-bloodshed-power-as-freedom-of-action-771eac1fc6d9?source=rss-6ab5a2bc289c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/771eac1fc6d9</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[organizing]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[operational-art]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[transfeminism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[community-organizing]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[marxism-leninism]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[MarxistHeathen]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 14 Oct 2026 20:07:32 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-10-15T00:11:23.687Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Defining Power for Use in Operational Art</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/600/1*23un-Hd9xPp-FhdA1R7-0g.png" /></figure><p>The title of this series points out that, like war, political conflict is ultimately a <em>contest of power</em> between opposing forces. You either have the power to survive and thrive against your enemies or you don’t. Simple as. Power is a central concept in all human conflict. It’s also a central concept in operational art. Within a military context, the goal of strategy and tactics, and therefore the goal of operational art, is to solve problems through generating and arranging combat power. This series is not concerned with the proper arrangement of organized lethality. However, we are <em>very</em> concerned with how to solve problems by generating and properly orchestrating the different sorts of power we do rely on.</p><p>We will discuss the different kinds of power we rely on in unarmed political conflict in a future article but, before we can do that, we need to have a crystal clear understanding of what power is in the first place. Even if it feels like overkill right now, having a concrete and precise definition of power will make it easier to grasp more complex operational frameworks we will discuss later in this series.</p><p>This article will be broken into two parts. For the first, we will create a definition of power that we can use in our operational art going forward. This definition will be centered on a concept called “freedom of action.” The second part will give an example for how we can use this concept in practice by showing how this definition can be combined with a previous entry in this series.</p><h3>Defining Power</h3><p>There are many different definitions of power out there. Most of them are what we call <em>theoretical definitions</em> that describe what power is on a general, abstract level. If we are doing operational art, then we need what are called <em>operational definitions</em> which are concrete, measurable, and able to be used in practical activity. Operational definitions are more restrictive than the theoretical definitions we base them on. However, that’s no problem for us if we just accept that our definition will be specific to political conflicts.</p><p>We could start with any of power’s many theoretical definitions but we’ll stick with one that I personally use. The underlying assumptions about reality fit with most modern ways of thinking about strategy and the pursuit of goals in a competitive environment. For the sake of time, we’ll assume this definition is a good one (additional reasoning behind this theoretical definition can be found in the first two sections of <a href="https://slightlyeastofnew.com/wp-content/uploads/2010/03/destruction_and_creation1.pdf">this paper</a>). This isn’t to say that it’s <em>the </em>correct definition as much as it is to say that it’s <em>a </em>useful definition that will serve our purposes. Our theoretical definition for power will be: the ability of an actor to transform its ecosystem in desired ways.</p><p>We can now <em>operationalize </em>this definition by making it specific to the particular conditions in the types of ecosystems we’ll be in and what having power must look like within those conditions. We’re talking about many different sets of environmental conditions that are all in the future so there is very little we can say about them in advance. The only things we truly know for certain are the following:</p><ol><li>We will have goals that will require us to select an appropriate course of action to transform our ecosystems in order to achieve those goals are</li><li>The ecosystems will be characterized by the presence of volatility, uncertainty, complexity, and ambiguity (<a href="https://www.wpafb.af.mil/News/Article-Display/Article/2847919/how-can-we-thrive-in-a-vuca-environment/">VUCA</a> will likely be a topic for a future article)</li><li>We will be pursuing our goals in a competitive environment (1) where adversaries will be attempting to stop us from achieving our goals and to impose their will on us and (2) where surviving and winning against those adversaries will require the ability to impose our own will on them.</li></ol><p>We could go through a long, drawn-out, super technical process to develop an operational definition from scratch based off of these. Instead, we will base our definition off of an already-common perspective. All major militaries today, accounting for the conditions I mentioned, view power in terms of <strong>freedom of action</strong>, which is the term for an actor’s retention of multiple potential courses of action that are <em>practically exercisable</em> and <em>strategically meaningful</em>.</p><p>Put simply: power is about how many options you have to keep fighting, how many options your adversary has to keep fighting, and how your options stack up against each other. You have power when you have more freedom of action because there are more goals you have a potential course of action to achieve and less problems you lack a viable solution to. You have power over your adversary when you reduce their freedom of action to nothing, giving them no options to achieve their goals (or stop you from achieving yours) other than the ones you see fit to give them.</p><p>So, we’ve got our operational definition: a political actor’s power is defined by their current freedom of action. In a conflict with an adversary, power can be thought of as an actor’s relative freedom of action compared to their adversary. We call this relative relationship between freedom of action between two or more actors the <strong>balance of power</strong>.</p><p>Before moving onto the next section, let’s quickly recap all of the different terms we’ve defined:</p><ul><li><strong>Power (Theoretical Definition):</strong> The ability of an actor to transform its ecosystem in desired ways</li><li><strong>Power (Operational Definition):</strong> An actor’s current freedom of action</li><li><strong>Freedom of Action:</strong> An actor’s retention of multiple potential courses of action that are <em>practically exercisable</em> and <em>strategically meaningful</em></li><li><strong>Balance of Power:</strong> The relative relationship between the freedom of action of two or more actors.</li></ul><h3>Using Our Definition of Power in Political Conflict</h3><p>We’ve got ourselves an operational definition of power that we’re supposed to be able to use. So, how do we use it? We use it by thinking in terms of how different actions shift the balance of power between you and your potential or current adversaries. The way we practically start to think in these terms is by adding five questions to the list of things we think about whenever we’re deciding what courses of action we want to take.</p><ul><li>What courses of action can you practically exercise right now that might help you achieve your goals?</li><li>To what extent does a course of action decrease, preserve, or increase our own freedom of action?</li><li>To what extent does a course of action decrease, preserve, or increase our enemy’s freedom of action?</li><li>In what ways are other actors currently limiting our freedom of action?</li><li>In what ways might other actors limit our freedom of action in the future to take a course of action we might decide on?</li></ul><p>As we learn to turn asking these questions into a habit, we can incorporate them into our broader practice of operational art we are developing. To give an example of what this integration looks like, we will look at how we can build on what we discussed in the previous entry on <a href="https://medium.com/@MarxistHeathen/war-without-bloodshed-the-trichotomy-of-operation-types-97376fffebd6">the Trichotomy of Operation Types</a> and use these concepts together in our practical work.</p><p>We can apply our understanding of power as freedom of action to sustaining operations by thinking about how to balance the short and long term consequences of sustainment decisions. It is easy to jump into the trap of thinking about sustainment in terms of “getting more resources” rather than power, which leads people to compromise their long-term success for short-term gains (a topic covered by critiques of the <a href="https://communitycentricfundraising.org/2020/08/10/nonprofit-industrial-complex-101-a-primer-on-how-it-upholds-inequity-and-flattens-resistance/">non-profit industrial complex</a>).</p><p>Shaping operations are probably the easiest of the three types to think about in terms of freedom of action. They are focused on directly affecting the balance of power to set and preserve the conditions to make your decisive operations possible. Making a decisive operation possible or making sure an enemy can’t render it impossible are both questions that can be answered in terms of power as freedom of action.</p><p>Power as freedom of action is also a useful perspective when thinking about your decisive operation. When deciding what your decisive operation should be to achieve your objective, you need to think about what courses of action you either have the freedom of action to do right now or that you can generate freedom of action for within a reasonable timeframe (with your shaping operations!). You also need to think about what power your enemy has to limit your own freedom of action so you don’t decide on a course of action for your decisive operation that your enemy has the power to stop in its tracks.</p><h3>Next Steps</h3><p>We’ve introduced the concept of freedom of action and used it to define “power” in a way that can be applied in the practice of your operational art. We also talked a little bit about how you can use this perspective on power in a way that builds on the last operational framework we discussed. If you are able to have a collective discussion, I strongly encourage you to spend part of that time talking about concrete examples for how you can think of the relationship that different operation types have with power as freedom of action. <strong><em>Now go forth and be dangerous</em></strong>.</p><p><em>This article is a single installment within War Without Bloodshed, a series of short articles intended for group discussion within political collectives that help teach operational art by introducing operational frameworks taken from the realm of armed conflict that can be usefully applied to unarmed political struggle. The theoretical basis of this is a duality between warfare and politics as particular sub-domains of the more general domain of human conflict. You can find the current articles in this series below:</em></p><p><em>1: </em><a href="https://medium.com/@MarxistHeathen/war-without-bloodshed-a-series-introduction-59d28fb5464d"><em>A Series Introduction</em></a></p><p><em>2: </em><a href="https://medium.com/@MarxistHeathen/war-without-bloodshed-the-trichotomy-of-operation-types-97376fffebd6"><em>The Trichotomy of Operation Types</em></a></p><p><em>3: </em><a href="https://medium.com/@MarxistHeathen/war-without-bloodshed-power-as-freedom-of-action-771eac1fc6d9"><em>Power as “Freedom of Action”</em></a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=771eac1fc6d9" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[War Without Bloodshed: The Trichotomy of Operation Types]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@MarxistHeathen/war-without-bloodshed-the-trichotomy-of-operation-types-97376fffebd6?source=rss-6ab5a2bc289c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/97376fffebd6</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[transfeminism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[marxism-leninism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[organizing]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[community-organizing]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[operational-art]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[MarxistHeathen]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 14 Oct 2026 18:18:49 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-10-15T00:11:59.975Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Decisive, Shaping, and Sustainment Operations to Get The Goods</h4><p><em>Note: This is an abridged version of this </em><a href="https://medium.com/@MarxistHeathen/the-trichotomy-of-operation-types-in-organizing-40d9f086787a"><em>article</em></a><em> that skips over the portions about John Boyd and warfare-politics duality to focus on the operational framework at the center of the article. The purpose of this is (1) to fit it into the series more naturally where the content of this piece is built on by the next piece and (2) to create a more focused piece for a more focused collective discussion by anyone following this series.</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/582/1*mH_IgqUjfOQrVHnX1qlVpQ.png" /></figure><p>One problem we deal with in political organizing is that we have a variety of different approaches yet little in the way of overarching frameworks to think about them with. We do have the general capacity to evaluate whether certain kinds do more harm than good. However, when it comes to the ones we think are generally helpful, it can be difficult to determine how to balance our scarce time, effort, and resources between these forms. We have reached a point where we generally uphold the diversity of tactics but, even among Marxists who opposed “bowing to spontaneity, our approach to the diversity of tactics still relies entirely on spontaneity to fill the gaps.</p><p>A major reason for this is that we lack a framework to think through how these different types of political activity can be related to each other in a specific context. Furthermore, when we’re thinking about the activity of a single organization doing a variety of different things, our lack of a framework makes it difficult to orchestrate these various activities into medium- and long-term strategies. Operational art gives us a framework that fits these needs.</p><p>Practitioners of operational art make a distinction between three types of operations: decisive operations, shaping operations, and sustaining operations. Each type has a generic relationship to the others that operations planners and strategists can leverage to develop clear and easily shareable models for how the different activities within a larger operation relate to each other to enable the success of the larger whole.</p><p>Learning from what the military of the US Empire does may seem counterintuitive or distasteful but the reality is that human conflict, whether war or political organizing, is governed by many of the same laws which means that many of the practices used in the organization and conduct of warfare are easily applicable to our own domain of conflict. (<em>More discussion of the warfare-politics duality that justifies this can be found in the </em><a href="https://medium.com/@MarxistHeathen/the-trichotomy-of-operation-types-in-organizing-40d9f086787a"><em>original version</em></a><em> of this article</em>)</p><p>This article will introduce you to this trichotomy (dichotomy but for 3 things) of operation types. It will be broken into two parts. The first part will introduce you to the trichotomy of operation types. The second will explain how to use it in our specific context of political conflict, giving us some initial direction for how to start thinking about our own activity in terms of this framework.</p><h3>Three Kinds of Action: Decisive-Shaping-Sustaining</h3><p>Planners and strategists in the US military divide all of the different kinds of actions they can take into three kinds: decisive, shaping, and sustaining. Each of these types of operations relate to each other in different ways so that a concert of all three can be orchestrated to accomplish objectives that may require multiple steps to become achievable.</p><p><strong>Decisive operations</strong> are the centerpiece of any operation. These are the operations that directly accomplish the mission or achieve the objective, whatever that may be. Decisive operations are generally the focal point of any given mission. In a military context, these are the operations that <em>decide </em>the outcome of a larger operation, a battle, or campaign. It is most classically the frontal assault meant to destroy an enemy or force a retreat but can be anything depending on what the objective actually is.</p><p>At the start of some conflict, the success of decisive operations to directly achieve an objective are often either too uncertain or certainly impossible. This does not mean the mission is impossible. It means that, before launching the decisive operations, you must <em>set conditions</em> to make their success more certain.</p><p><strong>Shaping operations</strong> are those that create and preserve the conditions for the success of the decisive operation through effects on the adversary or other parts of the broader, external environment. When directly accomplishing the overall objective is impossible, shaping operations set conditions to turn that impossibility into a possibility or, ideally, a near certainty. In a military context, shaping operations may soften up an enemy position through shelling or destroying early warning systems so that a decisive push becomes more likely to succeed.</p><p>Shaping operations, however, only set conditions for the success of the decisive operation by way of effects on things that are <em>external </em>to the fighting force (e.g. the enemy, the terrain, local populations, etc.). The conditions for success depend as much or more on whether the fighting force has internally set conditions. Do they have the personnel and capabilities to execute the required shaping and decisive operations? Do they have the resources to do so for long enough to carry the day?</p><p>Dealing with these sorts of <em>internal</em>issues is the purview of <strong>sustaining operations.</strong> Sustaining operations enables the decisive operation or shaping operations by generating and maintaining the necessary sorts of power. This typically includes issues of logistics and security or force protection. In a military context, this includes supplying combat units and security operations to prevent friendly forces from being surprised and losing combat power before they can wield it.</p><h3>How The Trichotomy Works in Political Organizing</h3><p>So, we’ve talked about the different types of operations in a military context but we have a different context we need to apply them in. Learning to use this framework is something that you must do and make second nature through practice using it. Until then, we can give you a starting place by walking through how we can think of the framework as it applies to a workplace strike.</p><p>We will imagine a hypothetical labor strike and think about the main example of each type of operation that comes together to help the union win a better contract. You can, for a little extra practice, take a second now to try and list three different activities involved and assign each to be either the decisive operation, a shaping operation, or a sustaining operation. Remember: there are multiple correct answers for the latter but only one decisive operation that can be the main thrust of a given operation!</p><p>Let’s start with the decisive operation. This one may have been tricky if you aren’t used to thinking about this framework. Did you guess that the strike itself, the union members putting down their tools to form a picket line, was the decisive operation? In this case, it isn’t because the strike isn’t what directly achieves the objectives. The objective in our hypothetical isn’t to make the boss lose money; it’s to win a better contract for the union! This means that the decisive operation for our strike is the negotiations between the union reps and the company to secure the union’s contract.</p><p>The shaping operation, as you may now guess, is the strike itself! The strike doesn’t secure a better contract. Only the negotiators can do that but the negotiators won’t be able to get the goods if they don’t have leverage. The workers going on strike creates pressure on the company who will get less and less willing to stick to their guns as the shutdown hurts their bottom line more and more.</p><p>There are many different kinds of sustaining operations involved but one good one is fundraising for the union’s strike fund, which starts before they even go on strike. They would have added money to the fund through dues, specific fundraisers, and collecting donations during the strike from allies. The strike fund helps take care of the worker’s needs that they might be unable to meet otherwise when they’re going without a paycheck. This sustaining operation is what allows the strike to go on and the union reps to stay in negotiations despite everyone lacking their usual source of income.</p><p>It’s a simple formula that you’ll be able to use with your comrades to plan your own operations in no time. The <strong>shaping operations</strong> set conditions for the success of the <strong>decisive operation</strong> that directly achieve your objective while your <strong>sustaining operations</strong> enable both of them. <strong><em>Now go forth and be dangerous</em></strong>.</p><p><em>This article is a single installment within War Without Bloodshed, a series of short articles intended for group discussion within political collectives that help teach operational art by introducing operational frameworks taken from the realm of armed conflict that can be usefully applied to unarmed political struggle. The theoretical basis of this is a duality between warfare and politics as particular sub-domains of the more general domain of human conflict. You can find the current articles in this series below:</em></p><p><em>1: </em><a href="https://medium.com/@MarxistHeathen/war-without-bloodshed-a-series-introduction-59d28fb5464d"><em>A Series Introduction</em></a></p><p><em>2: </em><a href="https://medium.com/@MarxistHeathen/war-without-bloodshed-the-trichotomy-of-operation-types-97376fffebd6?sharedUserId=MarxistHeathen"><em>The Trichotomy of Operation Types</em></a></p><p><em>3: </em><a href="https://medium.com/@MarxistHeathen/war-without-bloodshed-power-as-freedom-of-action-771eac1fc6d9"><em>Power as “Freedom of Action”</em></a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=97376fffebd6" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[War Without Bloodshed: A Series Introduction]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@MarxistHeathen/war-without-bloodshed-a-series-introduction-59d28fb5464d?source=rss-6ab5a2bc289c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/59d28fb5464d</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[marxism-leninism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[organizing]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[community-organizing]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[transfeminism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[operational-art]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[MarxistHeathen]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 12 Oct 2026 21:37:09 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-10-15T00:12:15.661Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Operations and Operational Art</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/850/1*xIsuUh5Rga1QJVriOV_HWQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>“We understood that politics is nothing but war without bloodshed and war is nothing but politics with bloodshed.” — Fred Hampton, <a href="https://www.marxists.org/archive/hampton/1969/misc/power-anywhere-where-theres-people.htm">Power Anywhere There’s People</a> (paraphrasing a quotation from Mao Zedong)</figcaption></figure><p>I recently wrote an article about the <a href="https://medium.com/@MarxistHeathen/the-trichotomy-of-operation-types-in-organizing-40d9f086787a">Trichotomy of Operation Types in Organizing</a>, introducing the split between decisive, shaping, and sustaining operations for use by people engaged in unarmed political conflict rather than armed military conflict. I explained in the article how there is a duality between the laws governing warfare and politics. This warfare-politics duality exists on account of the fact that both domains are governed not only by their own particular laws but also by the more general laws of human conflict. This means that not everything that works in armed warfare works when applied to political struggle but that there are many things that do.</p><p>Building on that article, I am starting a new series taking advantage of the duality to introduce individuals and collectives to the praxis of <em>operational art</em> through a series of short articles introducing various conceptual frameworks that we can use to make ourselves more effective in the pursuit of our political goals. Welcome to War Without Bloodshed.</p><p>The series title comes from a popular communist articulation of the warfare-politics duality put forward by Mao Zedong in <a href="https://www.marxists.org/reference/archive/mao/selected-works/volume-2/mswv2_09.htm"><em>On Protracted War</em></a> where he states that “[i]t can therefore be said that politics is war without bloodshed while war is politics with bloodshed.” This is an even more dialectical take on Clausewitz’s <a href="https://www.marxists.org/reference/archive/clausewitz/works/on-war/book1/ch01.htm">famous maxim</a>: “war is a mere continuation of policy by other means.” As stated in the Trichotomy article, John Boyd built on the work of these two theorists and identified that this is the case because both war and politics are two particular domains in the general domain of human conflict.</p><p>The rest of this article will do three things. First, I will give an overview of War Without Bloodshed and how it is meant to be used. Second, we will explain “operations” as the level of conflict lying between strategy and tactics and introduce the concept of operational art. Third, I will present a case for why consciously adopting the praxis of operational art is not only wildly helpful but necessary for our success. Finally, we will end with some brief guidance for what to do if you are convinced of the need to begin learning operational art.</p><h3>Overview of the Series and How to Use It</h3><p>War Without Bloodshed will be an ongoing series of short articles written about frameworks that can be applied to operational art. Each article will typically detail on either a single framework. Sometimes, we may cover two to three simple frameworks that work as a single whole. These frameworks will be either taken directly from a military context like the Trichotomy of Operation Types while others will be adaptations. Most of the articles will be short but this one will be a little longer so I have space to make the case for why this series will be valuable &amp; to lay some foundation for how to think about using what we’ll cover in the series.</p><p>These articles are meant to be read by members of political collectives to learn these frameworks. After reading them, the collective should then discuss the concept as a group and talk about how the concept can be applied to their own activities. None of these concepts are set in stone which means that part of the ongoing discussions about each framework can include changes that a collective may need to make to better fit the framework to their own situation or better align with what they’ve learned from their own experience. This is especially the case with concepts that required more adaptation when being translated from a military context to a political one.</p><p>You can get something out of these articles as an individual and it’s unlikely that any collective will read one of these articles as a group if an individual member didn’t read it on their own. However, the main target audience will be political <em>collectives</em>. That’s where the real learning will happen and it’s the scale where the power of frameworks for operational art will truly shine.</p><h3>Operations and Operational Art</h3><p>Before explaining the technical meaning of “operations” in this context, we need to understand the dichotomy of strategy and tactics. We often use the word “strategy” with a very general definition but, when we speak of <em>both </em>strategy <em>and</em> tactics, it is common practice to use a more specific definition for both.</p><h3>Strategy and Tactics</h3><p>Broadly speaking, strategy starts with some higher-level objective and develops a plan to achieve that goal by selecting some course of action based on what courses of action are practical to execute. A simple formula used for this is that strategy is a balanced combination of ends (what you want done), ways (how you’re going to get it done), and means (what you have to get it done).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/445/1*xCjSYNfITKKTkA4xRqJaaQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>A break down of things that fall under the different prongs of Ends-Ways-Means</figcaption></figure><p>Tactics is below strategy in terms of scale and is concerned with putting the strategy into concrete practice and solving the real-world problems that arise when you try to do so. If strategy is your blueprint and tactics are the tools in your toolbelt.</p><p>The distinction can get messy because there aren’t objective boundaries between the two. What counts as “strategy” and “tactics” is a matter of perspective. To explain what I mean, imagine an organization dedicated to trans rights and liberation.</p><p>The national-level leadership of this organization may adopt a strategy of “combat fascist-promoted laws to eliminate trans people from public life” and one of their tactics may be “pressure city governments to pass laws allowing trans people to use the bathroom that fits their gender identity.” Now, let’s look at this from the perspective of one of this org’s local chapters. Their national leadership chose a tactic of pressuring city governments and this national-level tactic ends up being the <em>strategy</em> for the chapter working on a local scale. on city governments who then selects particular tactics for how to apply that pressure. The difference between strategy and tactics is a difference of scale and what falls into each depends on the scale we’re acting on.</p><h4>The Operational Level of Conflict</h4><p>This flexible framework lets us break down different actions from the pursuit of ultimate political goals down to solving ground-level problems in a fight. However, as militaries began to decentralize “command and control,” distributing it down that hierarchy, this began to raise the question of how you ensure each link of this chain stays connected to the ultimate goal as that chain gets longer. The answer to this question was the concept of the <strong>operational level of conflict</strong> (alternatively: <strong>operations</strong>).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*crWMsdP67Ojh4VfW_pyfpA.jpeg" /><figcaption>The hierarchy of Strategy-Operations-Tactics. Source: <br><a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=k1HGUEI8syA">Tactics vs. Strategy: Levels of War Explained — Military History Handbook</a></figcaption></figure><p>Where strategy and tactics can be thought of as relative versions of the other, the operational level is not a mirror of either. It’s a distinct layer of goal-driven integration that connects each link in the chain between ground-level action and the highest possible political objective. It is concerned with the higher level goals of strategy but relies on the attention to the concrete we associate with tactics. Traditionally, we say that the operational level of conflict is concerned with integrating four essential elements: time, space, means, and purpose.</p><h4>Operational Art</h4><p>The operational level of conflict is a lens for thinking about the relationship between strategy and tactics but thinking isn’t enough. We need to <em>do</em>. So, what do we do about the relationship between those levels? The theory and practice answering that question is what we call <strong>operational art</strong>.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/467/1*juuRW3dsAj_Yk4EOb909lQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Gen. Alexander Andreyevich Svechin, Imperial Russian Army, 1923. (Photo courtesy of Wikimedia Commons)</figcaption></figure><p>Operational art <a href="https://www.armyupress.army.mil/Journals/Military-Review/English-Edition-Archives/November-December-2018/Blythe-Operational-Art/">was first developed</a> as doctrine for the Soviet Union’s Red Army in the 1920s <a href="https://www.militarystrategymagazine.com/article/strategy-and-the-intervening-concept-of-operational-art/">by Alexander Svechin</a>. By the end of the 20th century, the concept had been universally adopted by all major military powers on account of its effectiveness. We can define operational art as <strong><em>the praxis of translating abstract strategic goals into concrete, actionable directions that an someone can execute</em></strong>. Operations, as a level of conflict, involves the arrangement of different tactical efforts in time and space. Operational art ensures (1) that the arrangement of these tactical efforts are not done at random and (2) that what unites the arrangement of tactical actions is <em>always and everywhere</em> the pursuit of strategic objectives and not other factors.</p><p>Now that you are familiar with operations and operational art, we can discuss what’s so valuable about these frameworks. We can start with a discussion of the “other factors” we just mentioned that might unite how someone arranges tactical actions.</p><h3>Why Adopting Operational Art is a Necessity</h3><h4>Operational Art as an Antidote to Widespread Errors</h4><p>There are many different factors and motivations behind how people might try and cobble together tactics in the course of their operations. Out of these, we can identify four main factors that often drive the arrangement of tactical actions other than “the pursuit of strategic objectives.” There are (1) based on habit, doctrine, or dogma, (2) based on “common sense”, (3) based on abstract notions of “what’s right”, and (4) based on what is easiest or is most feasible at the moment. When we look closer at these mistaken principles we can connect each one to a specific political mistake.</p><ul><li><strong>Dogmatism:</strong> An overly strict adherence to written dogma or tradition based on a principle of authority without concern for effectiveness</li><li><strong>Empiricism:</strong> Jumping to conclusions based on superficial observations and ignoring the need for a deeper understanding of all aspects of a situation and their relationships</li><li><strong>Eclecticism:</strong> The adoption of beliefs and practices based on whims about what feels correct rather in contrast to more systematic approaches</li><li><strong>Opportunism:</strong> Sacrificing more difficult, long-term gains in favor of easier, short-term gains that provide more immediate gratification.</li></ul><p>If you’ve spent enough time being politically active, you’ve seen these issues, know they’re widespread, and know how much they hamstring our efforts. Operational art helps us mitigate their damage by making sure there is alignment between tactical actions and strategic goals. This is not only helpful but, I believe, necessary. To illustrate my point, I want to ask you a series of questions about trying to address these problems in other ways.</p><p>Do you know how to identify each of these errors in the wild? Do you know how to explain to a comrade what each is and why they are errors? How to convince others that they are making these errors, explain to them what the alternatives are, and guide them on how to adopt the alternative? If you know how to do this, can you practically do this for <em>everyone</em> in your collective to get everyone on the same page? Can you reliably do this for yourself? Can you do that for everyone despite inevitable personality clashes? How much time will it take you to do it the right way for enough people? Can you do it without taking up too much time from your main activities? Can you do it fast enough to see results before those errors wreak havoc on your collective?</p><p>Now, instead of trying to do <em>that </em>Herculean task, we can just point to all of the clear and proven advantages of adopting operational art over continuing to go up against our better resourced enemies without it. This won’t solve these errors entirely but it will make solving them easier and not having solved them less costly. Personally, I think killing two birds with one stone is the easier sell here.</p><h4>The Functions of an Operational Framework</h4><p>The reality of theory is that “we don’t need theory” is a fantasy belief based on the false assumption that any of us have a choice about using theory. We can only choose whether our theories are explicit. Having explicit frameworks for operational art is a good thing. However, not all frameworks are made equal and we should have a sense of what we expect to get out of them.</p><p>The operational frameworks in this series will have several different functions we can benefit from. I haven’t found a standard list but one would be useful for evaluating particular frameworks. So, I’ve broken down the functions into “5 Cs” that represent different functions operational frameworks serve when adopted by a collective.</p><ol><li><strong>Concentration:</strong> They distill the lessons of history and experience into a potent form that educates planners &amp; strategists and serves as an intellectual starting point for solving problems</li><li><strong>Communication:</strong> They provide a shared language that allows us to communicate quickly and effectively despite different perspectives and to do so in high-stress situations.</li><li><strong>Coordination:</strong> They set out common ways of thinking and doing that allow us to more easily coordinate our actions with each other. This sort of interoperability is critical to be able to scale up our forces.</li><li><strong>Control:</strong> They can contain certain built-in principles and assumptions that help keep us to particular lines of effort and toward specific political/strategic ends.</li><li><strong>Coherency:</strong> They help us create a more coherent force by establishing common frames of reference and assumptions, common situational awareness, and common purpose.</li></ol><p>These different functions make us far more effective at working together to achieve our political goals than we are when we go up against our adversaries without these sorts of things. Moreover, most of these functions are necessary for us to create a more developed “community of practice” where we are all participants in a large, scientific process of figuring out what frameworks do and do not work for us.</p><h3>Learning and Practicing Operational Art</h3><p>Let’s say that you’re convinced that learning operational art is necessary. How do you go about actually learning it? There are two bits of guidance I can give.</p><p>First, operational art gains its effectiveness when put into collective practice &amp; the only way to <em>truly</em> learn it is by having direct experience doing exactly that. The next immediate step if you’re convinced of all this is to make the case to your comrades to convince them of the same. If you aren’t a part of a collective right now, then change that. Either find a collective to join or, failing that, start a study group with a couple comrades where you can discuss these things and learn together. The latter is also a great option if you are already part of a collective but don’t feel like you’re prepared to win people over right now.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/600/1*pqOCPg487u0PUZjw24JCNg.png" /></figure><p>The second piece of guidance I will share is a phase-based framework for learning called <strong>Crawl-Walk-Run</strong>. You can apply this framework to learning anything but we’ll stick with a specific version for how to break up learning any operational framework. You’ll move through the phases as follows:</p><ul><li><strong>Crawl — Learn:</strong> In this phase, you will familiarize yourself with operational frameworks by reading them and encouraging others to engage with the same concepts. Future articles in this series will be designed for this exact purpose but I encourage you to engage with concepts you find in your own research. A good example to start with is reading and sharing the framework found in the article on the <a href="https://medium.com/@MarxistHeathen/the-trichotomy-of-operation-types-in-organizing-40d9f086787a">Trichotomy of Operation Types</a>.</li><li><strong>Walk — Understand:</strong> In this phase, you will deepen your understanding of the operational frameworks you became familiar with in the Crawl phase through discussion and analysis. The discussion can be formal discussions like in a reading group but informal, ongoing discussions are helpful as well. For analysis, you should analyze a relevant example of political activity according to the new framework to see how the pieces fit together. If you can, do this with real world examples you and your collective were involved with. experience with. Failing that, you can use the framework to break down other real-world examples. Multiple repetitions will be beneficial.</li><li><strong>Run — Apply:</strong> In the final phase, you will apply these concepts to your practice. This means using the framework in the discussion and planning of concrete political activity. After or while you are doing this activity, you can then use the framework as a way to break down, understand, and evaluate the different pieces of your operation. This could look like making a plan by naming your decisive operation along with the shaping and sustaining operations you will need to support it. Then you can use this framework to have collective discussions about whether each operation is contributing to the whole as you expect it too and identify problem areas to fix.</li></ul><p>I have some additional writing in the works so you can expect more articles in this series to come out soon. <strong><em>Now go forth and be dangerous</em></strong>.</p><p><em>This article is a single installment within War Without Bloodshed, a series of short articles intended for group discussion within political collectives that help teach operational art by introducing operational frameworks taken from the realm of armed conflict that can be usefully applied to unarmed political struggle. The theoretical basis of this is a duality between warfare and politics as particular sub-domains of the more general domain of human conflict. You can find the current articles in this series below:</em></p><p><em>1: </em><a href="https://medium.com/@MarxistHeathen/war-without-bloodshed-a-series-introduction-59d28fb5464d"><em>A Series Introduction</em></a></p><p><em>2: </em><a href="https://medium.com/@MarxistHeathen/war-without-bloodshed-the-trichotomy-of-operation-types-97376fffebd6?sharedUserId=MarxistHeathen"><em>The Trichotomy of Operation Types</em></a></p><p><em>3: </em><a href="https://medium.com/@MarxistHeathen/war-without-bloodshed-power-as-freedom-of-action-771eac1fc6d9"><em>Power as “Freedom of Action”</em></a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=59d28fb5464d" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Trichotomy of Operation Types in Organizing]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@MarxistHeathen/the-trichotomy-of-operation-types-in-organizing-40d9f086787a?source=rss-6ab5a2bc289c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/40d9f086787a</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[marxism-leninism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[organizing]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[transfeminism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[community-organizing]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[MarxistHeathen]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 09 Oct 2026 00:31:45 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-10-14T18:05:44.245Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Decisive, Shaping, and Sustainment Operations to Get The Goods</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/582/1*mH_IgqUjfOQrVHnX1qlVpQ.png" /></figure><p>One problem we deal with in political organizing is that we have a variety of different approaches yet little in the way of overarching frameworks to think about them with. We do have the general capacity to evaluate whether certain kinds do more harm than good. However, when it comes to the ones we think are generally helpful, it can be difficult to determine how to balance our scarce time, effort, and resources between these forms. We have reached a point where we generally uphold the diversity of tactics but, even among Marxists who opposed “bowing to spontaneity, our approach to the diversity of tactics still relies entirely on spontaneity to fill the gaps.</p><p>A major reason for this is that we lack a framework to think through how these different types of political activity can be related to each other in a specific context. Furthermore, when we’re thinking about the activity of a single organization doing a variety of different things, our lack of a framework makes it difficult to orchestrate these various activities into medium- and long-term strategies.</p><p>There is a framework that fits these needs that we can find in the realm of military strategy (or, more specifically, “operational art”). Practitioners in that realm make a distinction between three <em>types</em> of operations: decisive operations, shaping operations, and sustaining operations. Each type has a generic relationship to the others that operations planners and strategists can leverage to develop clear and easily shareable models for how the different activities within a larger operation relate to each other to enable the success of the larger whole.</p><p>Learning from what the military of the US Empire does may seem counterintuitive or distasteful but the reality is that human conflict, whether war or political organizing, is governed by many of the same laws which means that many of the practices used in the organization and conduct of warfare are easily applicable to our own domain of conflict.</p><p>This article will introduce you to this trichotomy (dichotomy but for 3 things) of operation types. It will be broken into two parts. The first part will take the opportunity to lay the groundwork for this and similar future articles on similar topics. I’ll introduce you to a military strategist we <em>need</em> to be familiar with and explain an important principle for thinking about how theories like this trichotomy of operations types can be applied to political organizing. The second part will describe the framework and give some initial direction for how to start thinking about our own activity in terms of this framework.</p><h3>The John Boyd School of Political Organizing</h3><h4>Why Care?</h4><p>Let’s start with some groundwork that will not just help contextualize this trichotomy of operations types but will lay a foundation for similar pieces I plan to write. I’ll start by explaining the relevance and importance of this tangent, including the most important takeaway from this article. Then, I’ll introduce you to arguably the most important military strategist of the past 50 years who you likely do not know about. Finally, I’ll describe a very important principle that I take from him that underlies why I’m even writing an article like this in the first place.</p><p>So, why am I going to tell you about John Boyd when he’s not even the man who developed the trichotomy of operation types? Is it because you need to understand my personal basis for bringing theories from the domain of warfare into the realm of political organizing to understand this trichotomy? No. You can understand it just fine. Still, I feel this is an important opportunity to exhort you all to embrace the principle of what I call <strong>warfare-politics duality</strong> (explained later in this section) even if you take nothing else at all from this essay. There are three reasons I think this is important:</p><ol><li>I want you to understand that the trichotomy of operation types is not one of the many frameworks from other domains that <em>happens</em> to be useful for organizing but that it is useful because it was developed based on experience with and for use within the domain of human conflict: the general domain that political organizing belongs to.</li><li>I want you to adopt the principle of warfare-politics duality to guide your own research and problem-solving so that all of you can become a part of a larger, scientific conversation that can revolutionize the way we conduct political organizing by finding all of this pre-developed, low-hanging fruit that our enemies have been applying to political organizing for a decade or so now (and maintaining a strategic advantage over us because of it). We will not be the first to do this but <a href="https://maxwilbert.substack.com/p/the-three-types-of-action">those who are already doing this</a> could use more voices in the conversation.</li><li>I want you to understand the principle of warfare-politics duality in order for you to avoid the mistake of seeing the theory and practice of organizing and conducting warfare as only being relevant to armed struggle. Right wing organizations are filled with people who have extensive experience using methods of organizing and structuring practice that they apply to non-lethal, sub-kinetic political organizing all of the time. We are scared to think about military strategy because we think doing so means committing to the use of lethal violence. It does not. Understanding how a tenants union can apply the strategy of defeat-in-detail in their struggle to pressure slumlords for better conditions or organizing complex actions according to battle-tested structuring techniques developed to enable the smooth execution of complex actions do not require anyone to engage in illegal activity. I want you to understand all of this so more of us can stop being gunshy (no pun intended) about scavenging effective organizing methods instead of waiting to spontaneously re-invent the wheel.</li></ol><h4>Col. John “40 Second” Boyd</h4><p>I belong to what I sometimes call the John Boyd School of Organizing. Colonel John Boyd is a former fighter pilot turned military theorist who revolutionized the conduct of war in a way that’s comparable to figures like Sun Tzu and Clausewitz. He was <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2003/03/09/books/40-second-man.html">considered</a> one of the greatest fighter pilots of his time despite limited time spent in active combat or registering a single combat kill. He earned his reputation and the nickname “40 second Boyd” on account of a standing wager that he could best any other pilot in aerial combat in under 40 seconds. In 6 years and over 3000 hours of flight time, he never once had to pay up.</p><p>He had graduated the top of his class in weapons skill and was asked to stay on as an instructor. For the US Air Force, Boyd authored the “Aerial Attack Study” which eventually became the official doctrine for air-to-air combat in the USAF and revolutionized the way fighter pilots around the world thought about aerial combat. In the 1960s, he was tapped by the Pentagon to perform the mathematical analysis that would lead to the F-15’s eventual adoption. He would then go on to develop a revolutionary mathematical model of aircraft performance that was accepted by the USAF and would become the basis for the improvements over the F-15 to create the famed F-16.</p><p>Boyd went from developing personal methods to best opponents in aerial combat and used that experience to develop multiple theories that would change aerial combat forever but he did not stop with a revolution in the specific domain of air-to-air combat. He began to develop experience-based theories that built on what he had and generalized them to the larger domain of warfare, drawing on other sources as wide-ranging as physics, mathematics, cognitive science, cybernetics, and Marxist philosophy.</p><p>These theories started as theories of warfare. However, they approached warfare on such a fundamental level that they became theories of conflict in general, as noted by the titles of his lectures articulating these theories such as <em>Discourse on Winning and Losing</em> and <em>Patterns of Conflict</em>. These theories were built around concepts like the conceptual spiral and his famed OODA Loop.</p><p>In his civilian career, Boyd shared his theories through lectures given to Marine Corps strategists who would wholeheartedly adopt his theories and develop the doctrine of “maneuver warfare.” He is credited with developing much of and the most important parts of the American strategy in the Gulf War, having been pulled out of retirement by Dick Cheney to do so.</p><p>John Boyd died in 1997 but his theories have been transformative in the realm of strategy. He had both direct and indirect influence on the way that warfare is conducted in the modern era, influencing strategists from the US Military to those in the PLA.* His theories, however, did not remain limited to warfare but expanded to influence strategy in a wide-ranging number of domains involving conflict, reshaping the realms of law enforcement tactics, business strategy, litigation practices, cybersecurity, and many more. I keep saying the words “revolutionary” and “revolutionized” but that’s been hard to avoid when the motherfucker kept doing things that fit the bill.</p><p>I consider myself a part of the John Boyd school of organizing for two reasons. The first and most obvious, which I will write more about at some point, are the ways his particular theories have influenced my approach to organizing and organized social conflict.</p><p>The second reason, more subtle and the topic of this article, is that I subscribe to his understanding that warfare is just one type of human conflict. Boyd, as someone directly influenced by Marxist epistemology through Mao’s On Practice, saw warfare as one particular domain in the more general domain of human conflict and, as such, was governed by general laws of human conflict. What this means is that some of the praxis developed for the organization and conduct of kinetic warfare is particular to the domain of warfare while some of it is either general or generalizable to the domain of human conflict.</p><p>In other words: some theory and practice currently found only in the domain of warfare will be directly useful to people engaged in other domains of human conflict such as political organizing. It is up to us to find those and import them directly into our own practice or, when necessary, re-adjust them toward our generally non-lethal and “sub-kinetic” context. There are probably other terms for this principle but I call it the <strong>warfare-politics duality</strong>.</p><p><em>*Although it is hard to prove it from the documents available, I believe it is close to certain that Boyd’s theories played a major role in the development of the PLA’s current doctrines of systems confrontation and systems warfare. If so, it would be a full circle of development that begins with his own central inspirations of Sun Tzu and Mao Zedong.</em></p><h3>The Trichotomy: Decisive-Shaping-Sustaining</h3><h4>Three Kinds of Action</h4><p>Planners and strategists in the US military divide all of the different kinds of actions they can take into three kinds: decisive, shaping, and sustaining. Each of these types of operations relate to each other in different ways so that a concert of all three can be orchestrated to accomplish objectives that may require multiple steps to become achievable.</p><p><strong>Decisive operations</strong> are the centerpiece of any operation. These are the operations that directly accomplish the mission or achieve the objective, whatever that may be. Decisive operations are generally the focal point of any given mission. In a military context, these are the operations that <em>decide</em> the outcome of a larger operation, a battle, or campaign. It is most classically the frontal assault meant to destroy an enemy or force a retreat but can be anything depending on what the objective actually is.</p><p>At the start of some conflict, the success of decisive operations to directly achieve an objective are often either too uncertain or certainly impossible. This does not mean the mission is impossible. It means that, before launching the decisive operations, you must <em>set conditions</em> to make their success more certain.</p><p><strong>Shaping operations</strong> are those that create and preserve the conditions for the success of the decisive operation through effects on the adversary or other parts of the broader, <em>external </em>environment. When directly accomplishing the overall objective is impossible, shaping operations set conditions to turn that impossibility into a possibility or, ideally, a near certainty. In a military context, shaping operations may soften up an enemy position through shelling or destroying early warning systems so that a decisive push becomes more likely to succeed.</p><p>Shaping operations, however, only set conditions for the success of the decisive operation by way of effects on things that are <em>external</em> to the fighting force (e.g. the enemy, the terrain, local populations, etc.). The conditions for success depend as much or more on whether the fighting force has internally set conditions. Do they have the personnel and capabilities to execute the required shaping and decisive operations? Do they have the resources to do so for long enough to carry the day?</p><p>Dealing with these sorts of issues is the purview of <strong>sustaining operations</strong>. Sustaining operations enables the decisive operation or shaping operations by generating and maintaining the necessary sorts of power. This typically includes issues of logistics and security or force protection. In a military context, this includes supplying combat units and security operations to prevent friendly forces from being surprised and losing combat power before they can wield it.</p><h4>How The Trichotomy Works in Political Organizing</h4><p>So, we’ve talked about the different types of operations in a military context but we have a different context we need to apply them in. Learning to use this framework is something that you must do and make second nature through practice using it. Until then, we can give you a starting place by walking through how we can think of the framework as it applies to a workplace strike.</p><p>We will imagine a hypothetical labor strike and think about the main example of each type of operation that comes together to help the union win a better contract. You can, for a little extra practice, take a second now to try and list three different activities involved and assign each to be either the decisive operation, a shaping operation, or a sustaining operation. Remember: there are multiple correct answers for the latter but only one decisive operation that can be the main thrust of a given operation!</p><p>Let’s start with the decisive operation. This one may have been tricky if you aren’t used to thinking about this framework. Did you guess that the strike itself, the union members putting down their tools to form a picket line, was the decisive operation? In this case, it isn’t because the strike isn’t what directly achieves the objectives. The objective in our hypothetical isn’t to make the boss lose money; it’s to win a better contract for the union! This means that the decisive operation for our strike is the negotiations between the union reps and the company to secure the union’s contract.</p><p>The shaping operation, as you may now guess, is the strike itself! The strike doesn’t secure a better contract. Only the negotiators can do that but the negotiators won’t be able to get the goods if they don’t have leverage. The workers going on strike creates pressure on the company who will get less and less willing to stick to their guns as the shutdown hurts their bottom line more and more.</p><p>There are many different kinds of sustaining operations involved but one good one is fundraising for the union’s strike fund, which starts before they even go on strike. They would have added money to the fund through dues, specific fundraisers, and collecting donations during the strike from allies. The strike fund helps take care of the worker’s needs that they might be unable to meet otherwise when they’re going without a paycheck. This sustaining operation is what allows the strike to go on and the union reps to stay in negotiations despite everyone lacking their usual source of income.</p><p>It’s a simple formula that you’ll be able to use with your comrades to plan your own operations in no time. The <strong>shaping operations</strong> <em>set conditions</em> for the success of the <strong>decisive operation</strong> that <em>directly achieve</em> your objective while your <strong>sustaining operations</strong> <em>enable </em>both of them. Now go forth and be dangerous.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=40d9f086787a" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>